AB 253: Remote court reporting.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 419, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 24, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | From committee: That the Senate amendments be concurred in. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (September 11). |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 11 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 21, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 13, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HIGHER ED. and P. & C.P. |
| Jan 24, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 23. |
| Jan 23, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 12, 2019 | AB 253 Mark Stone Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2019 | With recommendation: That Senate amendments be concurred in. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB253 Mark Stone By Beall | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | AB 253 Mark Stone Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA2 Bill Id:AB 253
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Authorizes a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting.
The Senate Amendments:
Delete the Assembly version of this bill, and instead:
- Define "remote court reporting" as the use of a stenographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to produce a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Provide that notwithstanding 6), below, the Santa Clara Superior Court is authorized to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. Provides that the pilot project must comply with all of the following requirements:
- The remote court reporting must be performed only by full-time official reporters of employed by the Santa Clara Superior Court who have at least five years of courtroom experience;
- The official reporters must be physically located in Santa Clara Superior Court facilities while performing the remote court reporting. After 180 days of meaningful remote court reporting testing, the Santa Clara Superior Court and the exclusive representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court may, by mutual agreement, agree to include an additional offsite location to test remote court reporting;
- A maximum of two courtrooms may be equipped to participate in the pilot project;
- Remote court reporting may be used only to report proceedings in limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases; and
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting as part of the pilot project may be used whenever a transcript of court proceedings is required. The fees of the official reporter and costs of transcript preparation for remote court reporting must be the same as when an official reporter is present in the courtroom.
- Provide that the presiding judge of the Santa Clara Superior Court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project. The committee is to include at least two judicial officers who participated in the pilot project, at least two official reporters chosen by the exclusive bargaining representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court, and at least two attorneys who regularly practice in the Santa Clara Superior Court.
- Provide that the required report pursuant to 3) is to be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- Provide that the pilot project must conclude no later than December 31, 2020 unless the Santa Clara Superior Court determines that the use of remote court reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, in which case the pilot should be terminated immediately.
- Prohibit the use of remote court reporting to make the record of any proceeding outside the scope of the pilot program described in 2), above, and prohibits the courts from expending any funds to purchase equipment or software to facilitate the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
COMMENTS:
Recognizing the growing need to deploy more court reporters to California courtrooms, as well as the need to entice new court reporters into the field, this measure proposes a modest pilot program to begin testing remote court reporting technology. Remote court reporting technology, essentially a two-way live feed between the courtroom and another court facility, would enable a court reporter to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings without requiring the reporter to be physically present in the courtroom. If the technology proves successful, it will assist county courts by permitting reporters in a primary courthouse to cover proceedings in more remote locations without the need to travel. Additionally, should the pilot prove successful, and courts agree with associated labor representatives, the technology may eventually permit a court reporter to work from home or another location away from the courthouse.
According to the Author:
"By piloting remote court reporting in a limited manner, AB 253 ensures that the technology can be properly tested before the Legislature even contemplates expanding its use."
Arguments in Support:
SEIU California, on behalf of its court reporter members, states:
The preparation of official verbatim records by individuals not physically present in the courtroom who cannot easily observe the proceeding or who may not be able to hear all speakers or easily discern whose speaking or to interrupt a speaker, as well as equipment failure raise similar issues to the use of electronic recording equipment to make the official verbatim record. There is no similar statutory authorization for remote court reporting to make the official verbatim record using an audio or audiovisual connection. It is important to determine in a pilot project whether remote reporting can work for litigants and trial courts. It is critical to ensure these new technologies actually work for litigants before being implemented and causing the expenditure of hundreds of thousands of dollars just to find it does not create a verbatim record and therefore undermines our system of justice.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Judicial Council indicates unknown costs, potentially over $200,000 annually, to the courts related to the prohibition on the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
VOTES:
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: Vote not relevant
YES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: Vote not relevant
YES:
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Vote not relevant
YES:
ABS, ABST OR NV:
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie‑Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002346
Date of Hearing: September 11, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 253
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
FOR CONCURRENCE
SUBJECT: Remote court reporting: SANTA CLARA COUNTY PILOT PROGRAM
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD A PILOT PROGRAM BE CREATED IN THE SANTA CLARA COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT TO TEST AND EVALUATE THE MERITS OF USING REMOTE COURT REPORTING TECHNOLOGY IN CALIFORNIA?
SYNOPSIS
A complete and accurate transcript of court proceedings is a vital component of the court record used to appeal litigation. Without a properly recorded transcript of court proceedings, it is nearly impossible for an appellate court to review a lower court’s actions to determine if potentially harmful errors prejudiced one litigant over another. The strongest court records are produced by certified court reporters taking down a real-time record of proceedings in the courtroom. However, due to budgetary decisions of some courts and California’s skyrocketing cost of living, courts are struggling to recruit and retain qualified court reporters. This problem is especially acute in California’s higher-cost coastal counties.
Advances in technology and data streaming present new opportunities for recording court proceedings. Utilizing live-feed audiovisual technology a court reporter may be able to develop a transcript of a proceeding without needing to be physically present in a courtroom. Such technology may enable courts to better allocate staff resources and cover proceedings at satellite courthouses in the event a certified court reporter cannot be physically present. However, these new technologies also carry risks. Due to the integral role that a court record plays in the justice system, any efforts to expand the use of remote court reporting technology must be conducted in a measured and responsible manner to ensure the technology works appropriately. Accordingly, this bill proposes a modest pilot program to begin testing remote court reporting technology in the Santa Clara County Superior Court in an accountable and controlled manner. Should this pilot program prove successful, the Legislature may work with the courts to expand the pilot program and the use of remote court reporting technology in the future in a reasonable and thoughtful manner.
This measure is sponsored by SEIU California on behalf of their court reporter members in Santa Clara County. This is the first bill related to remote court reporting technology to win the support of the court reporters themselves. Although several concerns about the scope of the pilot project have been raised to the Committee, there is no formal opposition to the bill.
SUMMARY: Enacts a pilot program in the Santa Clara County Superior Court to study the use and effectiveness of remote court reporting technology in California courts. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “remote court reporting” as the use of a stenographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to produce a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Provides that notwithstanding 6), the Santa Clara Superior Court is authorized to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. Provides that the pilot project must comply with all of the following requirements:
- The remote court reporting must be performed only by full-time official reporters employed by the Santa Clara Superior Court who have at least five years of courtroom experience;
- The official reporters must be physically located in Santa Clara Superior Court facilities while performing the remote court reporting. After 180 days of meaningful remote court reporting testing, the Santa Clara Superior Court and the exclusive representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court may, by mutual agreement, agree to include an additional offsite location to test remote court reporting;
- A maximum of two courtrooms may be equipped to participate in the pilot project;
- Remote court reporting may be used only to report proceedings in limited civil, child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases; and
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting as part of the pilot project may be used whenever a transcript of court proceedings is required. The fees of the official reporter and costs of transcript preparation for remote court reporting must be the same as when an official reporter is present in the courtroom.
- Provides that the presiding judge of the Santa Clara Superior Court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project. The committee is to include at least two judicial officers who participated in the pilot project, at least two official reporters chosen by the exclusive bargaining representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court, and at least two attorneys who regularly practice in the Santa Clara Superior Court.
- Provides that the report required pursuant to 3) is to be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- Provides that the pilot project must conclude no later than December 31, 2020 unless the Santa Clara Superior Court determines that the use of remote court reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, in which case the pilot must be terminated immediately.
- Prohibits the use of remote court reporting to make the record of any proceeding outside the scope of the pilot program described in 2) and prohibits the courts from expending any funds to purchase equipment or software to facilitate the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
- Eliminates the authority for the pilot program on January 1, 2022.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that a superior court may appoint as many competent phonographic reporters, to be known as official reporters of such court, and such official reporters pro tempore as are deemed necessary for the performance of the duties and the exercise of the powers conferred by law upon the court and its members. (Government Code Section 69941.)
- Prohibits a person from being appointed to the position of official reporter of any court unless the person has first obtained a license to practice as a certified shorthand reporter from the Court Reporters Board. (Government Code Section 69942.)
- Permits that when needed in order for the judicial business of the superior court to be diligently carried on and a particular matter may proceed to trial or hearing without delay, a pro tempore official reporter may be appointed to perform the duties of a phonographic reporter in that matter, or until a regular official reporter becomes available for that service, and requires a pro tempore official reporter who is present in the courtroom providing that service to be appointed by the presiding judge of the court or the judge presiding in the department where the reporter will serve. (Government Code Section 70044.)
- Provides that if an official reporter or an official reporter pro tempore is unavailable to report an action or proceeding, the court may order that, in a limited civil case, or a misdemeanor or infraction case, the action or proceeding be electronically recorded, including all the testimony, the objections made, the ruling of the court, the exceptions taken, all arraignments, pleas, and sentences of defendants in criminal cases, the arguments of the attorneys to the jury, and all statements and remarks made and oral instructions given by the judge. (Government Code Section 69957 (a).)
- Provides that a transcript derived from an electronic recording may be utilized whenever a transcript of court proceedings is required. Stipulates that transcripts derived from electronic recordings must include a designation of “inaudible” or “unintelligible” for those portions of the recording that contain no audible sound or are not discernible. (Government Code Section 68857 (a).)
- Requires the Judicial Council to provide a semiannual report to the Legislature detailing all purchases and leases of electronic recording equipment used in superior court. (Government Code Section 69958.)
- Defines the practice of shorthand reporting as the making, by means of written symbols or abbreviations in shorthand or machine shorthand writing, of a verbatim record of any oral court proceeding, deposition, court ordered hearing or arbitration, or proceeding before any grand jury, referee, or court commissioner and the accurate transcription thereof. (Business & Professions Code Section 8017.)
- Permits a minor to testify in a preliminary hearing or trial utilizing closed-circuit television under specified circumstances. (Penal Code Section 1347.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a one-year pilot project to study the use of remote court reporting to make the official record of certain court proceedings. In support of this measure, the author states:
Nothing ensures an accurate and high-quality transcript of court proceedings like an in-person court reporter. However, technology is making remote court reporting possible. Although this technology is promising, the Legislature must ensure that maintaining the accuracy and integrity of court records is at the forefront of any authorization of remote court reporting technology. Accordingly, any efforts to broaden the use of remote court reporters in California must be undertaken in a methodical manner that protects litigants and the integrity of court records above all other concerns. AB 253 does just that by proposing a modest pilot program that begins to test the feasibility of remote court reporting. If the pilot is successful, it may provide a model for remote court reporting programs that can be adopted in all county courts.
Accurate court transcripts are critical to protect access to justice and court reporters are critical to providing accurate transcripts. Without the official record of what transpired at a court proceeding, litigants may be unable to draft orders effectively and will generally not be able to appeal decisions. For example, when issuing a judgment in a contested family law matter, the judge often requires one of the parties to prepare a written judgment memorializing the orders of the court. Without a transcript, preparation of a judgment, and therefore enforcing the orders made by the judge, may be all but impossible. Similarly, if a litigant seeks to modify a judgment based on a change of circumstances, it is often necessary to understand, and communicate to the court, the circumstances the court initially took into account in making a custody or support order, for example. Absent a transcript, this too may be very difficult.
If no court reporter is present at a court proceeding, no transcript can be available; and, unfortunately, many courts in California today no longer provide court reporters in civil and family law matters. Thus, for most of these matters, unless parties bring their own court reporter to court, there is at best limited access to justice and an increase in the transcript fee is not relevant since there is no record of the court proceeding to transcribe. As a result of the recession and the state budget crisis, trial courts budgets were reduced, and, among other service reductions, many courts reduced or eliminated court reporters unless their services were mandated by statute. In order to better understand the impacts of budget reductions on the trial courts, this Committee independently surveyed the 58 trial courts in 2013 to assess what measures the courts had taken to address the cuts, including any reduction in court reporters. Of the 55 (out of 58) courts to respond, six had reduced expenditures for court reporters, and fully 30 courts reported that they had ceased providing court reporters for civil, family, and probate proceedings. Despite significant increases in court funding, court reporter services have not been fully restored and are not guaranteed by any means.
To offset the lack of official court reporters supplied by the courts, some parties have retained outside reporters and sought their appointment as a court reporter pro tempore. While this is a reliable alternative for affluent parties, court reporters pro tempore do little to assist lower income litigants. A recent appellate court decision summarized the problems of access to justice for lower income litigants in a dissolution case in which the appellant was unable to provide an accurate transcript of the proceedings because there had not been a court reporter present at the trial court. The appellate court wrote, in a footnote:
We are deeply troubled by the trial court's policy of conducting all family law matters without a reporter unless a reporter is engaged by one or both parties at their own expense. This policy is actually codified in a local rule stating, "The family court does not provide a court reporter in family law matters, except when possible a reporter will be provided for DCSS and restraining order matters. If you would like to have a court reporter present you will need to hire and pay all costs associated with the reporter." (Super. Ct. Santa Cruz County, Local Rules, rule 3.7.01.) As illustrated by this case, the absence of a verbatim record can preclude effective appellate review, cloaking the trial court's actions in an impregnable presumption of correctness regardless of what may have actually transpired. Such a regime can raise grave issues of due process as well as equal protection in light of its disparate impact on litigants with limited financial means. The practice becomes all the more troubling when viewed in combination with the statewide prohibition against privately recording court proceedings "for any purpose other than as personal notes." (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 1.150(d).) Perhaps the time has come at last for California to enter the 20th century and permit parties to record proceedings electronically in lieu of the far less reliable method of human stenography and transcription. Until that day, however, we believe the right to effective appellate review cannot be permitted to depend entirely on the means of the parties. (In re Marriage of Obrecht (2016) 206 Cal. App. Lexis 138, 11, footnote 3.)
A court reporter present in the courtroom generates the “gold standard” of official records. Court reports are extensively trained and licensed to take down a shorthand recording of a proceeding that is subsequently turned into the transcript. Unlike a recording device, a court reporter in a courtroom is able to stop the proceeding should parties begin to talk over one another, ask parties to repeat mumbled or otherwise inaudible statements, and ensure that a final record is readable and devoid of the noises associated with hesitation that inevitably occur in live court. Even video recording is susceptible to parties talking over one another. Thus, because of the court reporter’s ability to ensure that every statement is captured, their transcripts are considered the best record of a proceeding.
The California Supreme Court recent reaffirmed the value of court reporters in the courtroom holding, “the absence of a court reporter at trial court proceedings and the resulting lack of a verbatim record of such proceedings will frequently be fatal to a litigant's ability to have his or her claims of trial court error resolved on the merits by an appellate court. This is so because it is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that justifies reversal of the judgment.” (Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608-609.) The court in the Jameson case held that court reporters provide such a vital service that they must be provided by the courts in cases in which a civil litigant is afforded a fee waiver.
Cost pressures in the courts and California’s high cost of living is making providing court reporters in every court difficult. As noted above, in the wake of the state’s budget crisis of the early 2010’s, court budgets were decimated and many courts sought to absorb budget cuts by eliminating services and staff. One county’s superior court went so far as to eliminate all court reporters from their payroll and hire an outside court reporting service in a misguided attempt to lower costs. While the courts’ budgets have increased substantially in recent years, too many courts have chosen not to bring back their court reporters. In the wake of the Jameson decision, the pressure for courts to provide court reporters will only increase. Although every judgeship comes with sufficient funding to provide a full complement of support staff, include a court reporter, the reality in far too many California courts is that missing court reporters are hurting litigants.
As California’s budget, and overall economy, recovered from the Great Recession, the cost-of-living in many counties skyrocketed. Santa Clara County, the home of Silicon Valley has experienced one of the most dramatic increases in housing costs of any county in the state. High housing costs, in turn, are hampering courts ability to attract court reporting talent. In Santa Clara County a certified court reporter can earn between $91,927 and $106,414 annually. Although this pay places a court reporter well into the middle class, this salary is woefully insufficient to afford most housing in Santa Clara County where the median home value is approximately $1.2 million. Without additional enticements, some courts will continue to struggle to recruit quality court reporters.
This bill. Recognizing the growing need to deploy more court reporters to California courtrooms, as well as the need to entice new court reporters into the field, this measure proposes a modest pilot program to begin testing remote court reporting technology. Remote court reporting technology, essentially a two-way live feed between the courtroom and another court facility, would enable a court reporter to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings without requiring the reporter to be physically present in the courtroom. If the technology proves successful, it will assist county courts by permitting reporters in a primary courthouse to cover proceedings in more remote locations without the need to travel. Additionally, should the pilot prove successful, and courts agree with associated labor representatives, the technology may eventually permit a court reporter to work from home or another location away from the courthouse.
This pilot program would enable two departments within the Santa Clara County Superior Court to conduct a one-year pilot program to test the technology. The bill would require the presiding judge of the Santa Clara County Superior Court to convene a working group of attorneys, judges, and court reporters to report on the success and failure of the pilot. Although the bill would only permit remote court reporting to occur within the scope of the pilot program, it should be noted that nothing in this bill would preclude the Legislature from considering expanding the pilot program, or remote court reporting generally, should the pilot program be deemed a success.
Prior introductions of new technology to the courts required Legislative authorization. Remote court reporting would not be the first use of technology in the courts. For decades, judges have utilized technology to improve efficiency and protect parties to litigation. Indeed, the courts have held that rooted in the judicial branch’s constitutional authorization rests, “inherent powers which enable them to carry out their duties and ensure the orderly administration of justice.” (In re Amber S. (1993) 15 Cal. App. 4th 1260, 1264.) Accordingly, it has been suggested to this Committee that a pilot program is not necessary to study remote court reporting and that judges already possess the power to utilize this technology.
However, this interpretation of the courts power appears to run counter to both the statutory history of the authorization for court reporters and the Legislature’s prior precedent for authorizing the use of technology in the courtroom. The statute permitting courts to appoint official court reporters, Government Code Section 69941, was first adopted in 1953 (AB 1908 (Caldecott) Chap. 206, Stats. 1953) and subsequently amended in 1957 (AB 1907 (McMillan) Chap. 1259, Stats. 1957) and 2002 (SB 1316 (Committee on Judiciary) Chap. 784, Stats. 2002). The 2002 amendments were nonsubstantive and designed to implement the unification of the municipal and superior courts. Thus the last meaningful amendment to the section was 1957. Given that television was in its infancy in 1957, it is difficult to believe the Legislature contemplated granting the authority for remote court reporting when it adopted the statute. Although it may arguably be true that pursuant to existing law courts possess some limited discretion to use remote court reporting in very narrow instances, for example this Committee has heard antidotal evidence that one county used remote reporting during a severe snow storm on one occasion, the broader adoption of remote court reporting was certainly not ordained by the Legislature.
Similar legislative histories have guided the Legislature’s formal codification of other technologies in the courts. Although technology has been used to advance the interest of justice in isolated cases (see, e.g., In re Amber S., supra, at p. 1266), legislative authority is typically granted prior to the widespread adoption by California courts. For example, Legislative authority underpins the courts use of closed-caption television to enable remote witness testimony (Penal Code Section 1347) and electronic recording of court proceedings (Government Code Section 68857 (a)). Although it appears that isolated uses of these technologies may have occurred prior to Legislative authorization, these practices were not widely used in the courts until codified by the Legislature.
Protecting the integrity of court records necessitates a methodical approach to deploying remote court reporting technology. As noted above, the accuracy of an official transcript of a court proceeding is a critical component of the justice system. In deploying remote court reporting technology it is vital that the accuracy of these records is maintained. The pilot program envisioned by this bill will determine if a court reporter located outside of the courtroom is able to properly interject and stop the proceeding in order to clarify points when, for example, parties speak simultaneously, garble or mumble their statements, or otherwise speak in a manner that is difficult to decipher. Additionally, the pilot will determine if the remote reporting technology and associated data connections are sufficiently reliable to permit the reporter to take down a transcript without undue delays caused by faulty live-feed connections.
Beyond the pure analytical aspect of the pilot program, this bill also requires input from judges, court reporters, and attorneys. Accordingly, even if the technology proves reliable, the Legislature can evaluate the day-to-day experiences of court users to determine if expanding the technology is justified.
It has been suggested to this Committee that the scope of the pilot is too narrow, and that more counties, perhaps even all 58 counties, should be added to the pilot program. First, a 58-county pilot program would less resemble a pilot program than a statewide programmatic authorization. Second, although modest, this pilot represents the first step toward adopting remote court reporting technology. Nothing in this bill would preclude the Legislature from considering expanding the pilot program in the future so long as future expansions protect the integrity of the court system, official litigation records, and the employment rights of court reporters.
This bill will not impact remote witness testimony, video appearances, or court calls. It has also been suggested to this Committee that the bill may impact the courts ability to utilize remote appearances in motion practice, remote testimony, or remote interpretation services. Although this bill prohibits the use of remote reporting technology outside of the scope of the pilot program this bill does not impact the court’s existing programs. In accordance with existing law, a court reporter should be present in the courtroom during remote testimony and other remote appearances. This bill would not impact such an appearance. Similarly, this bill would not impact video depositions for incarcerated defendants, as presumably the court reporter is in the courtroom with the judge and not in the jail facility. Additionally, this bill does not impact court call conferencing technology for law and motion hearings. The bill is simply a narrow program focused on remote court reporting and will not impact the current practices utilized by the court to permit parties to appear remotely.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is sponsored by the court reporters represented by SEIU California. In support of the pilot program they state:
The preparation of official verbatim records by individuals not physically present in the courtroom who cannot easily observe the proceeding or who may not be able to hear all speakers or easily discern whose speaking or to interrupt a speaker, as well as equipment failure raise similar issues to the use of electronic recording equipment to make the official verbatim record. There is no similar statutory authorization for remote court reporting to make the official verbatim record using an audio or audiovisual connection. It is important to determine in a pilot project whether remote reporting can work for litigants and trial courts. It is critical to ensure these new technologies actually work for litigants before being implemented and causing the expenditure of hundreds of thousands of dollars just to find it does not create a verbatim record and therefore undermines our system of justice.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
SEIU California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 253
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Authorizes a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting.
The Senate Amendments:
Delete the Assembly version of this bill, and instead:
- Defines "remote court reporting" as the use of a stenographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to produce a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Provides that notwithstanding 6), the Santa Clara Superior Court is authorized to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. Provides that the pilot project must comply with all of the following requirements:
- The remote court reporting must be performed only by full-time official reporters of employed by the Santa Clara Superior Court who have at least five years of courtroom experience;
- The official reporters must be physically located in Santa Clara Superior Court facilities while performing the remote court reporting. After 180 days of meaningful remote court reporting testing, the Santa Clara Superior Court and the exclusive representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court may, by mutual agreement, agree to include an additional offsite location to test remote court reporting;
- A maximum of two courtrooms may be equipped to participate in the pilot project;
- Remote court reporting may be used only to report proceedings in limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases; and
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting as part of the pilot project may be used whenever a transcript of court proceedings is required. The fees of the official reporter and costs of transcript preparation for remote court reporting must be the same as when an official reporter is present in the courtroom.
- Provides that the presiding judge of the Santa Clara Superior Court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project. The committee is to include at least two judicial officers who participated in the pilot project, at least two official reporters chosen by the exclusive bargaining representative of the official reporters of the Santa Clara Superior Court, and at least two attorneys who regularly practice in the Santa Clara Superior Court.
- Provides that the required report pursuant to 3) is to be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- Provides that the pilot project must conclude no later than December 31, 2020 unless the Santa Clara Superior Court determines that the use of remote court reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, in which case the pilot should be terminated immediately.
- Prohibits the use of remote court reporting to make the record of any proceeding outside the scope of the pilot program described in 2) and prohibits the courts from expending any funds to purchase equipment or software to facilitate the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
COMMENTS:
California does not mandate the use of court reporters in certain civil actions, and budget cuts have resulted in increasingly shallow pools of official court reporters. This scarcity forces parties to choose between the undesirable alternatives of shouldering the costs of a private court reporter or altogether forgoing the use of a court reporter, thereby forfeiting the benefits and protections that an official transcript can provide. Accurate transcripts of proceedings are vital to the administration of justice for a variety of reasons, including: establishing a record in order to subject errant rulings to the scrutiny of higher courts; enabling counsel to impeach a witness by showing that the witness made prior inconsistent statements while under oath; prosecuting a person for perjury; and ensuring that court orders accurately reflect the judge's ruling on nuanced issues such as visitation rights or division of property. Finally, a lack of transcripts of court proceedings deprives the general public of a means to independently evaluate what transpires in courts. Accurate, authoritative transcripts of proceedings are thus critical to ensuring judicial accountability, due process, equal protection, and access to justice. Although existing law allows for electronic recordings to create transcriptions in limited circumstances, such recordings can be unreliable, susceptible to manipulation, or contain gaps in information.
According to the Author:
"By piloting remote court reporting in a limited manner, AB 253 ensures that the technology can be properly tested before the Legislature even contemplates expanding its use."
Arguments in Support:
None on file
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Judicial Council indicates unknown costs, potentially over $200,000 annually, to the courts related to the prohibition on the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
VOTES:
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 12-0-0
YES: Medina, Choi, Jones-Sawyer, Bloom, Gabriel, Irwin, Kiley, Levine, Low, Patterson, Santiago, Weber
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 11-0-0
YES: Chau, Kiley, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Gallagher, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith, Wicks
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0-4
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Chen, Dahle, Voepel
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001885
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 253 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 253
Amended: 9/3/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Remote court reporting
SOURCE: Service Employees International Union
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a one-year pilot project to study the use of remote court reporting.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/3/19 move this bill’s prohibition on court reporting to a section that is not subject to the bill’s 2022 sunset date, thereby continuing that prohibition indefinitely.
Existing law:
- Requires court reporters in death penalty proceedings, juvenile court proceedings, hearings on a motion to withdraw consent to a step-parent adoption, or in any felony or civil case when ordered by the court or requested by a party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 269; Fam. Code § 9005(d); Pen. Code § 190.9; Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 347 & 677.)
- Defines the practice of shorthand reporting as the making, by means of written symbols or abbreviations in shorthand or machine shorthand writing, of a verbatim record of any oral court proceeding, deposition, court ordered hearing or arbitration, or proceeding before any grand jury, referee, or court commissioner and the accurate transcription thereof. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 8017.)
- Provides that a superior court may appoint as many competent phonographic reporters, to be known as official reporters of such court, and such official reporters pro tempore, as are deemed necessary for the performance of the duties and the exercise of the powers conferred by law upon the court and its members. (Gov. Code § 69941.)
- Prohibits a person from being appointed to the position of official reporter of any court unless the person has first obtained a license to practice as a certified shorthand reporter from the Court Reporters Board. (Gov. Code § 69942.)
- Prescribes the fees for reporting testimony and proceedings at $55 a day, or any fractional part thereof, and sets varying levels of compensation for court reporters based on the county in which the reporting occurs. (Gov. Code § 69948.)
- Authorizes fees for transcripts and copies thereof as follows:
- for the original copy: $0.85 per 100 words;
- for a copy purchased at the same time as the original: $0.15 per 100 words; and
- for a first copy not purchased at the same time as the original: $0.20 per 100 words, and $0.15 for each additional copy purchased at the same time. (Gov. Code § 69950.)
- Provides that for transcription in civil cases, the reporter may charge an additional 50 percent for special daily copy service. (Gov. Code § 69951.)
- Provides that when there is no official reporter in attendance and a reporter pro tempore is appointed, the reporter’s reasonable expenses for traveling and detention must be fixed and allowed by the court and paid in like manner. (Gov. Code § 69952.)
- Allows a court, if an official court reporter or an official reporter pro tempore is unavailable, to use electronic recording equipment only in a limited civil case, a misdemeanor or infraction case, or for the internal purpose of monitoring the performance of subordinate judicial officers, hearing officers and temporary judges. (Gov. Code § 69957(a)-(b).)
- Requires each court to obtain advance approval from the Judicial Council of California for purchases or leasing of electronic recording technology. Requires each superior court to report semiannually to the Judicial Council, and the Judicial Council to report semiannually to the Legislature, regarding all purchases and leases of electronic recording equipment that will be used to record superior court proceedings. (Gov. Code §§ 69957(c), 69958.)
This bill:
- Defines “remote court reporting” as the use of a stenographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. If the court opts to do so, all of the following apply:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by full-time official reporters employed by the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, provides for offsite reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, or infraction cases.
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project will be recognized as official transcripts.
- Existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting.
- The presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- The pilot project must terminate by December 31, 2020, or earlier if the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice.
- Sunsets 1) and 2), above, January 1, 2022.
- Prohibits, expressly, remote court reporting or the use of court funds therefor, except as provided in 2), above.
Comments
- The importance of transcripts of proceedings. California does not mandate the use of court reporters in certain civil actions, and budget cuts have resulted in increasingly shallow pools of official court reporters. This scarcity forces parties to choose between the undesirable alternatives of shouldering the costs of a private court reporter or altogether forgoing the use of a court reporter, thereby forfeiting the benefits and protections that an official transcript can provide.
As a matter of public policy, accurate transcripts of proceedings are vital to the administration of justice for a variety of reasons, including: establishing a record in order to subject errant rulings to the scrutiny of higher courts; enabling counsel to impeach a witness by showing that the witness made prior inconsistent statements while under oath; prosecuting a person for perjury; and ensuring that court orders accurately reflect the judge’s ruling on nuanced issues such as visitation rights or division of property. If the parties later disagree on a ruling, they may be forced to re-litigate the case—a considerable burden on the parties and courts. Moreover, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court has written that:
[…]the absence of a court reporter at trial court proceedings and the resulting lack of a verbatim record of such proceedings will frequently be fatal to a litigant's ability to have his or her claims of trial court error resolved on the merits by an appellate court. This is so because it is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that justifies reversal of the judgment.
(Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608-609.) Finally, a lack of transcripts of court proceedings deprives the general public of a means to independently evaluate what transpires in courts. Accurate, authoritative transcripts of proceedings are thus critical to ensuring judicial accountability, due process, equal protection, and access to justice.
Although existing law allows for the use of electronic recordings to create transcriptions in limited circumstances, such recordings can be unreliable, susceptible to manipulation, or may contain gaps in information. Court reporters are trained to capture important nuances that recordings cannot provide, including narrative explanations of inaudible actions and translations of legal terminology. Reporters can also interject and stop the proceeding in order to clarify points when, for example, parties speak simultaneously, garble or mumble their statements, or otherwise speak in a manner that is difficult to decipher.
- Pilot project to study remote court reporting in limited, controlled circumstances. This bill seeks to test and evaluate the feasibility and reliability of remote court reporting—defined in the bill as the use of a phonographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter—in a closely controlled set of circumstances. The bill would authorize the Santa Clara Superior Court, between the period of January 1, 2020 and December 31, 2020 to conduct the pilot project to study the potential use of court reporting. The bill imposes the following safeguards and limitations on the pilot project:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by full-time official reporters employed by the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, the bill would provide for off-site reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement, as specified.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases.
- If the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, the project must terminate earlier than December 31, 2020.
Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project would be recognized as official transcripts. Additionally, this bill provides that existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting. Finally, this bill requires that the presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
3) Expressly prohibits remote court reporting in conditions other than those
specified in the bill
This bill expressly prohibits remote court reporting unless it is carried out under the bill’s provisions. Thsi bill was recently amended to ensure that this prohibition would continue indefinitely after the remainder of the bill’s provisions sunset.
Disagreement has arisen as to whether this prohibition amounts to a substantive change or a mere clarification of the law. While existing law does not expressly forbid remote court reporting, some provisions appear to assume that a court reporter’s presence in the courtroom continues, as it has been for thousands of years, to be an essential facet of the profession. In particular, statutes governing the appointment of reporters pro tempore provide that if an official reporter is not “in attendance” (Gov. Code § 69952(b)), then the reporter pro tempore must be “present in the courtroom” (Gov. Code §§ 68086(d) & 70044(a), (b)). Rule of Court 2.956(c) similarly states that a reporter pro tempore may be appointed when there is no official reporter in “attendance.” The rule defines “official reporter” as a court reporter “whose fee for attending and reporting proceedings is paid for by the court or the county, and who attends court sessions as directed by the court….” (Id. at (e)(2); emphasis added.) Finally, existing law sets varying levels of compensation for court reporters based on the county in which the reporting occurs. (Gov. Code § 69948.) If a remote court reporter in Butte County, where the daily fee is $75, remotely reports for a trial in Colusa County, where the fee is $125, which rate does the reporter receive?
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee: “The Judicial Council indicates unknown costs, potentially over $200,000 annually, to the courts related to the prohibition on the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program. (General Fund)”
Service Employees International Union (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
Ensuring the financial stability of the court reporting industry is essential given that without an official record of what transpired at a court proceeding, litigants may be unable to draft orders effectively and will generally not be able to appeal decisions, and those attempting to recount what actually happened during proceedings will be unable to so with any degree of accuracy. However, high housing costs in Silicon Valley make it nearly impossible for these civil servants to afford to live in the areas they serve. The median home cost in Santa Clara County is well over $1.2 million, well out of the reach of a middle class court reporter. These costs are forcing Santa Clara court reporters to live further and further away from their workplace.
In order to reduce the burden that high housing costs place on court reporters in Silicon Valley, AB 253 proposes a modest pilot program to study the effectiveness of remote, audiovisual based court reporting in Santa Clara County. This bill would require the County to submit a report to the Legislature and would be limited to only certain types of civil cases. If successful, the type of reporting envisioned by AB 253 may ease the burden of high housing costs on court reporters in the Bay Area.
The sponsor, Service Employees International Union, writes:
In the past two years, with some modest budget reinvestments and as a result of Jameson v. Desta, courts have begun to prioritize the hiring and usage of court reporters. However, some courts are now facing recruitment issues for a variety reasons. These reasons range from poor management policies that make the court undesirable to work in, allocation methodologies (WAFM) that fund some courts at greater rates than others, to low pay and high cost of living in certain counties. This is compounded by the fact that court reporter transcript rates are extremely outdated and have only been increased once in 105 years with the last being in 1990.
This recruitment issue is particularly acute in Santa Clara Superior Court. Under the WAFM model, Santa Clara Superior is considered a donor court and has not equally benefitted from state budget reinvestments, as a result their budget has essentially become flat. This has led to Santa Clara Superior Court’s inability to offer competitive wages. Coupled with this, Santa Clara County is among the most expensive counties to live in California.
Additionally, Santa Clara Superior has experienced a large number of reporters retiring or resigning to work in other courts or in the private sector. Between 2011 and 2018, 27 court reporters retired from service and 10 resigned. During this same period, the court was able to recruit and hire18 reporters. To put this into context, there are currently approximately 82 judicial officers and 53 court reporters in Santa Clara Superior Court.
AB 253 would allow Santa Clara Superior Court and their court reporters who have been working in good faith to address their recruitment problem to responsibly and discreetly test the use of remote reporting to determine whether it provides a viable potential alternative to creating the verbatim record to ensure to litigants will have access to a transcript.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Chen, Dahle, Voepel
Prepared by: Josh Tosney / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/4/19 19:22:29
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 253 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 253
Amended: 6/21/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Remote court reporting
SOURCE: Service Employees International Union
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a one-year pilot project to study the use of remote court reporting.
Existing law:
- Requires court reporters in death penalty proceedings, juvenile court proceedings, hearings on a motion to withdraw consent to a step-parent adoption, or in any felony or civil case when ordered by the court or requested by a party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 269; Fam. Code § 9005(d); Pen. Code § 190.9; Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 347 & 677.)
- Defines the practice of shorthand reporting as the making, by means of written symbols or abbreviations in shorthand or machine shorthand writing, of a verbatim record of any oral court proceeding, deposition, court ordered hearing or arbitration, or proceeding before any grand jury, referee, or court commissioner and the accurate transcription thereof. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 8017.)
- Provides that a superior court may appoint as many competent phonographic reporters, to be known as official reporters of such court, and such official reporters pro tempore, as are deemed necessary for the performance of the duties and the exercise of the powers conferred by law upon the court and its members. (Gov. Code § 69941.)
- Prohibits a person from being appointed to the position of official reporter of any court unless the person has first obtained a license to practice as a certified shorthand reporter from the Court Reporters Board. (Gov. Code § 69942.)
- Prescribes the fees for reporting testimony and proceedings at $55 a day, or any fractional part thereof, and sets varying levels of compensation for court reporters based on the county in which the reporting occurs. (Gov. Code § 69948.)
- Authorizes fees for transcripts and copies thereof as follows:
- for the original copy: $0.85 per 100 words;
- for a copy purchased at the same time as the original: $0.15 per 100 words; and
- for a first copy not purchased at the same time as the original: $0.20 per 100 words, and $0.15 for each additional copy purchased at the same time. (Gov. Code § 69950.)
- Provides that for transcription in civil cases, the reporter may charge an additional 50 percent for special daily copy service. (Gov. Code § 69951.)
- Provides that when there is no official reporter in attendance and a reporter pro tempore is appointed, the reporter’s reasonable expenses for traveling and detention must be fixed and allowed by the court and paid in like manner. (Gov. Code § 69952.)
- Allows a court, if an official court reporter or an official reporter pro tempore is unavailable, to use electronic recording equipment only in a limited civil case, a misdemeanor or infraction case, or for the internal purpose of monitoring the performance of subordinate judicial officers, hearing officers and temporary judges. (Gov. Code § 69957(a)-(b).)
- Requires each court to obtain advance approval from the Judicial Council of California for purchases or leasing of electronic recording technology. Requires each superior court to report semiannually to the Judicial Council, and the Judicial Council to report semiannually to the Legislature, regarding all purchases and leases of electronic recording equipment that will be used to record superior court proceedings. (Gov. Code §§ 69957(c), 69958.)
This bill:
- Defines “remote court reporting” as the use of a phonographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. If the court opts to do so, all of the following apply:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by official reporters of the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, provides for offsite reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, or infraction cases.
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project will be recognized as official transcripts.
- Existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting.
- The presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- The pilot project must terminate by December 31, 2020, or earlier if the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice.
- Prohibits, expressly, remote court reporting or the use of court funds therefor, except as provided in 2), above.
- Sunsets January 1, 2022.
Comments
- The importance of transcripts of proceedings. California does not mandate the use of court reporters in certain civil actions, and budget cuts have resulted in increasingly shallow pools of official court reporters. This scarcity forces parties to choose between the undesirable alternatives of shouldering the costs of a private court reporter or altogether forgoing the use of a court reporter, thereby forfeiting the benefits and protections that an official transcript can provide.
As a matter of public policy, accurate transcripts of proceedings are vital to the administration of justice for a variety of reasons, including: establishing a record in order to subject errant rulings to the scrutiny of higher courts; enabling counsel to impeach a witness by showing that the witness made prior inconsistent statements while under oath; prosecuting a person for perjury; and ensuring that court orders accurately reflect the judge’s ruling on nuanced issues such as visitation rights or division of property. If the parties later disagree on a ruling, they may be forced to re-litigate the case—a considerable burden on the parties and courts. Moreover, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court has written that:
[…]the absence of a court reporter at trial court proceedings and the resulting lack of a verbatim record of such proceedings will frequently be fatal to a litigant's ability to have his or her claims of trial court error resolved on the merits by an appellate court. This is so because it is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that justifies reversal of the judgment.
(Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608-609.) Finally, a lack of transcripts of court proceedings deprives the general public of a means to independently evaluate what transpires in courts. Accurate, authoritative transcripts of proceedings are thus critical to ensuring judicial accountability, due process, equal protection, and access to justice.
Although existing law allows for the use of electronic recordings to create transcriptions in limited circumstances, such recordings can be unreliable, susceptible to manipulation, or may contain gaps in information. Court reporters are trained to capture important nuances that recordings cannot provide, including narrative explanations of inaudible actions and translations of legal terminology. Reporters can also interject and stop the proceeding in order to clarify points when, for example, parties speak simultaneously, garble or mumble their statements, or otherwise speak in a manner that is difficult to decipher.
- Pilot project to study remote court reporting in limited, controlled circumstances. This bill seeks to test and evaluate the feasibility and reliability of remote court reporting—defined in the bill as the use of a phonographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter—in a closely controlled set of circumstances. The bill would authorize the Santa Clara Superior Court, between the period of January 1, 2020 and December 31, 2020 to conduct the pilot project to study the potential use of court reporting. The bill imposes the following safeguards and limitations on the pilot project:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by official reporters of the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, the bill would provide for off-site reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement, as specified.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases.
- If the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, the project must terminate earlier than December 31, 2020.
Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project would be recognized as official transcripts. Additionally, this bill provides that existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting. Finally, this bill requires that the presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
The Judicial Council indicates unknown costs, potentially over $200,000 annually, to the courts related to the prohibition on the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program. (General Fund)
Service Employees International Union (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
Ensuring the financial stability of the court reporting industry is essential given that without an official record of what transpired at a court proceeding, litigants may be unable to draft orders effectively and will generally not be able to appeal decisions, and those attempting to recount what actually happened during proceedings will be unable to so with any degree of accuracy. However, high housing costs in Silicon Valley make it nearly impossible for these civil servants to afford to live in the areas they serve. The median home cost in Santa Clara County is well over $1.2 million, well out of the reach of a middle class court reporter. These costs are forcing Santa Clara court reporters to live further and further away from their workplace.
In order to reduce the burden that high housing costs place on court reporters in Silicon Valley, AB 253 proposes a modest pilot program to study the effectiveness of remote, audiovisual based court reporting in Santa Clara County. This bill would require the County to submit a report to the Legislature and would be limited to only certain types of civil cases. If successful, the type of reporting envisioned by AB 253 may ease the burden of high housing costs on court reporters in the Bay Area.
The sponsor, Service Employees International Union, writes:
In the past two years, with some modest budget reinvestments and as a result of Jameson v. Desta, courts have begun to prioritize the hiring and usage of court reporters. However, some courts are now facing recruitment issues for a variety reasons. These reasons range from poor management policies that make the court undesirable to work in, allocation methodologies (WAFM) that fund some courts at greater rates than others, to low pay and high cost of living in certain counties. This is compounded by the fact that court reporter transcript rates are extremely outdated and have only been increased once in 105 years with the last being in 1990.
This recruitment issue is particularly acute in Santa Clara Superior Court. Under the WAFM model, Santa Clara Superior is considered a donor court and has not equally benefitted from state budget reinvestments, as a result their budget has essentially become flat. This has led to Santa Clara Superior Court’s inability to offer competitive wages. Coupled with this, Santa Clara County is among the most expensive counties to live in California.
Additionally, Santa Clara Superior has experienced a large number of reporters retiring or resigning to work in other courts or in the private sector. Between 2011 and 2018, 27 court reporters retired from service and 10 resigned. During this same period, the court was able to recruit and hire18 reporters. To put this into context, there are currently approximately 82 judicial officers and 53 court reporters in Santa Clara Superior Court.
AB 253 would allow Santa Clara Superior Court and their court reporters who have been working in good faith to address their recruitment problem to responsibly and discreetly test the use of remote reporting to determine whether it provides a viable potential alternative to creating the verbatim record to ensure to litigants will have access to a transcript.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Chen, Dahle, Voepel
Prepared by: Josh Tosney / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/1/19 14:03:35
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 253 (Mark Stone) - Remote court reporting
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 253 would allow the Superior Court in Santa Clara County to conduct a one-year pilot program to study the use of remote court reporting, as specified, and would prohibit the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program.
Fiscal Impact:
The Judicial Council indicates unknown costs, potentially over $200,000 annually, to the courts related to the prohibition on the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot program. (General Fund*)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Shorthand reporting is the practice of making, by means of written symbols or abbreviations in shorthand or machine shorthand writing, a verbatim record of an oral court proceeding, deposition, court-ordered hearing or arbitration or of a proceeding before a grand jury, referee, or court commissioner and the accurate transcription thereof. Existing law requires court reporting in death penalty proceedings, juvenile court proceedings, hearings on a motion to withdraw consent to a step-parent adoption, and in any felony or civil case when ordered by the court or requested by a party.
Official court reporters must be licensed by the Court Reporters Board to practice as a certified shorthand reporter. The fees that court reporters, including private reporters, may charge for transcripts are set by statute. Currently, the fee for an original printed copy of a transcript is $0.85 per 100 words, with a copy of the original that is purchased at the same time as the original is $0.15 per 100 words. A first copy of the transcript purchased at a time other than with the original is $0.20 per 100 words and $0.15 for each additional copy thereafter. Notwithstanding the above fee schedule, if a trial court had established transcription fees in effect on January 1, 2012, based on an estimate as to the number of words or folios on a typical transcript page, those transcription fees must be the transcription fees for proceedings in those courts, and the policy or practice for determining transcription fees in those courts cannot be changed unilaterally. In addition to being able to charge the courts and other interested parties for transcripts, some court reporters are employed by the courts and receive wages and benefits.
Proposed Law:
This bill would allow the Superior Court in Santa Clara County to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting, as defined, to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. This pilot project would extend until January 1, 2022. If the court chooses to participate in the project, the remote court reporting must be performed only by official reporters of the Superior Court in Santa Clara County who have at least five years of courtroom experience and only in certain types of cases, including child support and misdemeanor cases. Additionally, the presiding judge would be required to appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, with the report being presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
Lastly, AB 253 would prohibit, until January 1, 2022, the use of remote court reporting or the expenditure of funds by the courts to purchase equipment or software to facilitate the use of remote court reporting outside of the pilot project.
Related Legislation:
AB 1385 (Santiago, 2019) would increase the per-page fees paid to court reporters for official transcripts. AB 1385 is pending in this Committee.
AB 1520 (Low, 2019) would, in part, expand the use of voice recognition technology in court reporting. AB 1520 is pending in this Committee.
Staff Comments:
It does not appear that statutory authorization is required for a court to implement a remote court reporting pilot project. Indeed, some courts currently have a memorandum of understanding (MOU) with the local union representing court reporters to allow such a use. This bill would render those aspects of the MOUs nugatory.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 253 (Author:Mark Stone)
Version: June 21, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Remote court reporting
DIGEST
This bill authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a one-year pilot project to study the use of remote court reporting to make the official record of certain court proceedings.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Court reporters, who serve a vital role in the administration of justice by developing verbatim records of judicial proceedings, are civil servants whose salaries can top out at just over $100,000. While this may be enough for a comfortable middle-class lifestyle in many parts of the state, in some counties it is not sufficient to keep up with skyrocketing housing prices. One such county is Santa Clara, where the median home price is over $1.2 million.
This bill would authorize a one-year pilot program in that county with the aim of
testing a way of making the profession of court reporting more financially sustainable. Specifically, the bill would authorize, in limited, controlled circumstances, court reporting to be done remotely using audiovisual equipment. The bill would require a court committee to provide a report to the Legislature within six months after the pilot project concludes. The bill is sponsored by Service Employees International Union (SEIU) and has no known opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires court reporters in death penalty proceedings, juvenile court proceedings, hearings on a motion to withdraw consent to a step-parent adoption, or in any felony or civil case when ordered by the court or requested by a party. (Code Civ. Proc. § 269; Fam. Code § 9005(d); Pen. Code § 190.9; Welf. & Inst. Code §§ 347 & 677.)
- Defines the practice of shorthand reporting as the making, by means of written symbols or abbreviations in shorthand or machine shorthand writing, of a verbatim record of any oral court proceeding, deposition, court ordered hearing or arbitration, or proceeding before any grand jury, referee, or court commissioner and the accurate transcription thereof. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 8017.)
- Provides that a superior court may appoint as many competent phonographic reporters, to be known as official reporters of such court, and such official reporters pro tempore, as are deemed necessary for the performance of the duties and the exercise of the powers conferred by law upon the court and its members. (Gov. Code § 69941.)
- Prohibits a person from being appointed to the position of official reporter of any court unless the person has first obtained a license to practice as a certified shorthand reporter from the Court Reporters Board. (Gov. Code § 69942.)
- Prescribes the fees for reporting testimony and proceedings at $55 a day, or any fractional part thereof, and sets varying levels of compensation for court reporters based on the county in which the reporting occurs. (Gov. Code § 69948.)
- Authorizes fees for transcripts and copies thereof as follows:
- for the original copy: $0.85 per 100 words;
- for a copy purchased at the same time as the original: $0.15 per 100 words; and
- for a first copy not purchased at the same time as the original: $0.20 per 100 words, and $0.15 for each additional copy purchased at the same time. (Gov. Code § 69950.)
- Provides that for transcription in civil cases, the reporter may charge an additional 50 percent for special daily copy service. (Gov. Code § 69951.)
- Provides that when there is no official reporter in attendance and a reporter pro tempore is appointed, the reporter’s reasonable expenses for traveling and detention must be fixed and allowed by the court and paid in like manner. (Gov. Code § 69952.)
- Allows a court, if an official court reporter or an official reporter pro tempore is unavailable, to use electronic recording equipment only in a limited civil case, a misdemeanor or infraction case, or for the internal purpose of monitoring the performance of subordinate judicial officers, hearing officers and temporary judges. (Gov. Code § 69957(a)-(b).)
- Requires each court to obtain advance approval from the Judicial Council of California for purchases or leasing of electronic recording technology. Requires each superior court to report semiannually to the Judicial Council, and the Judicial Council to report semiannually to the Legislature, regarding all purchases and leases of electronic recording equipment that will be used to record superior court proceedings. (Gov. Code §§ 69957(c), 69958.)
This bill:
- Defines “remote court reporting” as the use of a phonographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter.
- Authorizes the Santa Clara Superior Court to conduct a pilot project to study the potential use of remote court reporting to make the verbatim record of certain court proceedings. If the court opts to do so, all of the following apply:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by official reporters of the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, provides for offsite reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, or infraction cases.
- Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project will be recognized as official transcripts.
- Existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting.
- The presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
- The pilot project must terminate by December 31, 2020, or earlier if the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice.
- Expressly prohibits remote court reporting or the use of court funds therefor, except as provided in 2), above.
- Sunsets January 1, 2022.
COMMENTS
1. The importance of transcripts of proceedings
California does not mandate the use of court reporters in certain civil actions, and budget cuts have resulted in increasingly shallow pools of official court reporters. This scarcity forces parties to choose between the undesirable alternatives of shouldering the costs of a private court reporter or altogether forgoing the use of a court reporter, thereby forfeiting the benefits and protections that an official transcript can provide.
As a matter of public policy, accurate transcripts of proceedings are vital to the administration of justice for a variety of reasons, including: establishing a record in order to subject errant rulings to the scrutiny of higher courts; enabling counsel to impeach a witness by showing that the witness made prior inconsistent statements while under oath; prosecuting a person for perjury; and ensuring that court orders accurately reflect the judge’s ruling on nuanced issues such as visitation rights or division of property. If the parties later disagree on a ruling, they may be forced to re-litigate the case—a considerable burden on the parties and courts. Moreover, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court has written that:
[…]the absence of a court reporter at trial court proceedings and the resulting lack of a verbatim record of such proceedings will frequently be fatal to a litigant's ability to have his or her claims of trial court error resolved on the merits by an appellate court. This is so because it is a fundamental principle of appellate procedure that a trial court judgment is ordinarily presumed to be correct and the burden is on an appellant to demonstrate, on the basis of the record presented to the appellate court, that the trial court committed an error that justifies reversal of the judgment.
(Jameson v. Desta (2018) 5 Cal.5th 594, 608-609.) Finally, a lack of transcripts of court proceedings deprives the general public of a means to independently evaluate what transpires in courts. Accurate, authoritative transcripts of proceedings are thus critical to ensuring judicial accountability, due process, equal protection, and access to justice.
Although existing law allows for electronic recordings to create transcriptions in limited circumstances, such recordings can be unreliable, susceptible to manipulation, or contain gaps in information. Court reporters are trained to capture important nuances that recordings cannot provide, including narrative explanations of inaudible actions and translations of legal terminology. Reporters can also interject and stop the proceeding in order to clarify points when, for example, parties speak simultaneously, garble or mumble their statements, or otherwise speak in a manner that is difficult to decipher.
2. Pilot project to study remote court reporting in limited, controlled circumstances
This bill seeks to test and evaluate the feasibility and reliability of remote court reporting—defined in the bill as the use of a phonographic reporter who is not present in the courtroom to take down a verbatim record of court proceedings that are transmitted by audiovisual means to the reporter—in a closely controlled set of circumstances. The bill would authorize the Santa Clara Superior Court, between the period of January 1, 2020 and December 31, 2020 to conduct the pilot project to study the potential use of court reporting. The bill imposes the following safeguards and limitations on the pilot project:
- The remote reporting must be performed only by official reporters of the court who have at least five years of courtroom experience.
- The reporter must be physically located in court facilities while performing the remote reporting. After 180 days of meaningful testing, the bill would provide for off-site reporting, if the court and the reporters’ representative enter into a mutual agreement, as specified.
- No more than two courtrooms may participate in the pilot project.
- Remote reporting may only be used for limited civil cases and child support, misdemeanor, and infraction cases.
- If the court finds that remote reporting is prejudicing the rights of litigants or the interests of justice, the project must terminate earlier than December 31, 2020.
Transcripts created through remote court reporting under this pilot project would be recognized as official transcripts. Additionally, the bill provides that existing fees for transcript preparation applicable to courtroom reporting are the same for remote reporting. Finally, the bill would require that the presiding judge of the court must appoint a committee to prepare a report to the Legislature on the results of the pilot project, as specified. The report must be presented to the Legislature within six months of the conclusion of the pilot project.
3. Remote court reporting could make the profession of court reporting more financially sustainable
Like many professions, court reporter salaries have stagnated while the cost of living has increased. This problem is especially acute in areas of California with high housing prices. This bill creates a pilot program to test remote court reporting in Santa Clara, where the median price of housing makes a middle class lifestyle virtually unobtainable on a court reporter’s salary. As past legislative efforts to increase reporter fees have failed,[1] this bill seeks to test a possible means of making the profession of court reporting more alluring by enabling it to be it to be done remotely, thereby making it accessible to people who live in areas with lower costs of living.
The author writes:
Ensuring the financial stability of the court reporting industry is essential given that without an official record of what transpired at a court proceeding, litigants may be unable to draft orders effectively and will generally not be able to appeal decisions, and those attempting to recount what actually happened during proceedings will be unable to so with any degree of accuracy. However, high housing costs in Silicon Valley make it nearly impossible for these civil servants to afford to live in the areas they serve. The median home cost in Santa Clara County is well over $1.2 million, well out of the reach of a middle class court reporter. These costs are forcing Santa Clara court reporters to live further and further away from their workplace.
In order to reduce the burden that high housing costs place on court reporters in Silicon Valley, AB 253 proposes a modest pilot program to study the effectiveness of remote, audiovisual based court reporting in Santa Clara County. This bill would require the County to submit a report to the Legislature and would be limited to only certain types of civil cases. If successful, the type of reporting envisioned by AB 253 may ease the burden of high housing costs on court reporters in the Bay Area.
The sponsor, SEIU, writes:
In the past two years, with some modest budget reinvestments and as a result of Jameson v. Desta, courts have begun to prioritize the hiring and usage of court reporters. However, some courts are now facing recruitment issues for a variety reasons. These reasons range from poor management policies that make the court undesirable to work in, allocation methodologies (WAFM) that fund some courts at greater rates than others, to low pay and high cost of living in certain counties. This is compounded by the fact that court reporter transcript rates are extremely outdated and have only been increased once in 105 years with the last being in 1990.
This recruitment issue is particularly acute in Santa Clara Superior Court. Under the WAFM model, Santa Clara Superior is considered a donor court and has not equally benefitted from state budget reinvestments, as a result their budget has essentially become flat. This has led to Santa Clara Superior Court’s inability to offer competitive wages. Coupled with this, Santa Clara County is among the most expensive counties to live in California.
Additionally, Santa Clara Superior has experienced a large number of reporters retiring or resigning to work in other courts or in the private sector. Between 2011 and 2018, 27 court reporters retired from service and 10 resigned. During this same period, the court was able to recruit and hire18 reporters. To put this into context, there are currently approximately 82 judicial officers and 53 court reporters in Santa Clara Superior Court.
AB 253 would allow Santa Clara Superior Court and their court reporters who have been working in good faith to address their recruitment problem to responsibly and discreetly test the use of remote reporting to determine whether it provides a viable potential alternative to creating the verbatim record to ensure to litigants will have access to a transcript.
SUPPORT
Service Employees International Union (sponsor)
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 1385 (Santiago, 2019) seeks to increase the per-page fees paid to court reporters for official transcripts. That bill will be heard in the same hearing as this one.
Prior Legislation: See Comment 3, footnote 1.
AB 1834 (Wagner, 2015) would have permitted a court to use electronic recording equipment in a family law case if an official reporter or an official reporter pro tempore was unavailable. The bill was held in Assembly Judiciary.
AB 365 (Mullin, 2013) would have clarified that only proceedings transcribed by an official court reporter or reporter pro tempore can be considered prima facie evidence of testimony in a proceeding. The bill was gutted and amended in the Senate.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 0)
Assembly Higher Education Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
**************
Transcript fees have not been raised since 1991. (SB 2376; Presley, Ch. 505, Stats. 1990). Several subsequent attempts to increase the fees have failed, including AB 2305 (Klehs, 2006), AB 582 (Evans, 2007), AB 2305 (Klehs, 2006), AB 2629 (Hernández, 2016) and, most recently, AB 2757 (Reyes, 2018). ↑
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 253 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2019
SUBJECT: Postsecondary education: social security numbers: task force: reporting
SUMMARY: This bill would remove an obsolete provision in the Education Code which otherwise requires the College and University Social Security Number Task Force within the Office of Privacy Protection (OPP) to produce a specified report by July 1, 2010. Specifically, this bill would:
- Repeal a statutory requirement that, on or before July 1, 2010, the task force submit a final report of its findings and recommendations to the OPP, and to the Assembly and Senate committees on Judiciary.
- Repeal related provisions that provided: (1) that the final report must include a list of the existing uses of social security numbers (SSN) common among colleges and universities for routine operations and compliance with state and federal laws; and, (2) that the findings and recommendations of the task force are informational only and shall not be binding on any college or university.
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes, various restrictions on the use of SSNs and specifically prohibits a person or entity from doing any of the following:
- Publicly posting or displaying an individual’s SSN.
- Printing an individual’s SSN on any card that he or she must use to access products or services.
- Requiring an individual to transmit his or her SSN over the internet, unless the connection is secure or the SSN is encrypted.
- Requiring an individual to use his or her SSN to access an internet website, unless specified security measures are also required to access the website.
- Printing an individual’s SSN on any materials mailed to him or her unless required by state or federal law.
- Selling, advertising for sale, or offering to sell an individual’s SSN, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.85(a).)
- Provides that, unless required to do so by state or federal law, no person, entity, or government agency shall present for recording or filing with a county recorder a document that is required law to be open to the public if that record displays more than the last four digits of an SSN. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.89(a).)
- Establishes the Social Security Number Truncation Program (Truncation Program) in state government, which requires the county recorder of each county to establish a SSN truncation program in order to create a public record version of each official record, as specified, and generally requires that the public record version of an official record be used for responses to public records act requests, among other things. (Gov. Code Sec. 27300 et seq.)
- Requires, as part of this Truncation Program, that the County Recorders Association of California, no later than January 1, 2009, and annually thereafter, shall submit to the chairpersons of the Assembly Committee on Judiciary and of the Senate Committee on Judiciary, and to the OPP, or any successor agency, a report on the progress each county recorder has made in complying with this article, to assist the Legislature in monitoring the progress of each county recorder’s SSN truncation program. Provides, that this report shall no longer be required upon the OPP making a determination that all counties have completed the component of the program with respect to each official record recorded between January 1, 1980, and December 31, 2008. (Gov. Code Sec. 27305.)
- Requires the OPP in the Department of Consumer Affairs to establish the “College and University Social Security Number Task Force,” as specified, to conduct a review of the use by all colleges and universities of SSNs in order to recommend practices to minimize the collection, use, storage, and retention of SSNs in relation to academic and operational needs and applicable legal requirements. (Ed. Code Sec. 66018.55(a)-(c).)
- Requires that the task force review and make recommendations to minimize the collection, use, storage, and retention of SSNs by California colleges and universities, which shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
- A survey of best practices at colleges and universities and the costs of implementing those best practices.
- The necessary use and protection of SSNs for all of the following: research purposes; academic purposes, as specified; operational uses by academic medical centers, including, but not limited to, patient identification, tracking, and care; business purposes, including, but not limited to, the provision of employee benefits, tax purposes, loan programs, and other requirements imposed by current state and federal statutes and regulations; another operational need of the college or university.
- Current personal privacy protections provided to students, applicants, staff, and faculty of colleges and universities.
- Existing state and federal legal requirements, including regulatory requirements, mandating the use of SSNs at colleges and universities.
- The possible use of personal identifiers or other substitutes for SSNs that protect personal information and meet the operational needs of colleges and universities.
- The cost of funding any recommendations presented by the task force, including those that are of minimal cost and can be implemented immediately and those that require additional funding or time to implement. (Ed. Code Sec. 66018.55(e).)
- Requires that, on or before July 1, 2010, the task force submit a final report of its findings and recommendations to the OPP, and to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary and the Senate Committee on Judiciary. (Ed. Code Sec. 66018.55(g)(1).)
- Requires that the final report also include a list of the existing uses of SSNs common among colleges and universities for routine operations and compliance with state and federal laws. (Ed. Code Sec. 66018.55(g)(2).)
- Provides that the findings and recommendations of the task force are informational only and shall not be binding on any college or university. (Ed. Code Sec. 66018.55(g)(3).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to repeal an outdated reporting deadline that passed nearly 10 years ago. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s statement: According to the author:
AB 253 eliminates an outdated reporting requirement that was created when the Office of Privacy Protection in the Department of Consumer Affairs was required by law to create a task force to review best practices for the use of social security numbers in college and universities in the state.
The report was due to the Office of Privacy Protection and to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary and the Senate Committee on Judiciary on or before July 1, 2010. Since the creation of this statute, the Office of Legislative Counsel began adding sunset dates to reporting requirements as a matter of practice. However, without legislative action, outdated reporting requirements such as the one in this statute will remain on the books.
- Background: The underlying statute that this bill seeks to amend, was part of a larger legislative effort in 2007, AB 1168 (Jones, Ch. 627, Stats. 2007), to abate identity theft by restricting access to one of the most critical tools of identity theft: SSNs.
As noted in the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis at the time, although identity thieves obtain the SSNs of other persons in a variety of ways, studies suggest that quite often these numbers are harvested from official records and legal documents accessible to the public. Accordingly, AB 1168 sought to require the truncation (meaning the redaction of the first five digits) of any SSNs accessible to public viewing. The bill, in particular, created additional truncation requirements in three particularly vulnerable areas, one of which is now the subject of this bill: colleges and universities that, for operational reasons, must retain substantial amounts of personal information on students and staff. Two other vulnerable areas identified by AB 1168 were local agencies that are required to make many records publicly accessible under the California Public Records Act, and the state Franchise Tax Board, which creates lien abstracts and other legal documents that become public records.
With respect to colleges and universities, specifically, the author of AB 1168 noted that in 2006, American universities and colleges reported 52 breaches of personal information. According to the Assembly policy committee’s analysis at the time:
For a variety of reasons, institutions of higher education collect and maintain a great deal of personal information on students and employees. For example, colleges and universities must maintain student records for several years in order to respond to requests for grade transcripts. A social security number helps to ensure that transcripts are in fact those of the requesting student, since many students may have common names. However, this vast amount of personal information – whether it is maintained in on-campus computer databases or code-accessible websites – is subject to “hacking” or can otherwise fall into the hands of unauthorized persons. For example, in December of 2006 UCLA reported a security breach that resulted in unauthorized access to the personal information of 800,000 current and former students and employees, and even student applicants who had never attended the university.
UCLA was not alone. A list of security breaches maintained and frequently updated by the Privacy Rights Clearinghouse contains a disproportionate number of colleges and universities. Indeed, as this analysis was being drafted, the University of California at San Francisco announced a security breach that may have compromised the personal information, including social security numbers, of 46,000 students, faculty, and staff.
In light of the peculiar vulnerability of institutions of higher learning, this bill would require all colleges and universities located within the state to implement policies and procedures regarding the retention of social security numbers in electronic records that are accessible through the Internet. At a minimum, these policies and procedures must provide for the redaction of social security numbers unless it is necessary for operational reasons to have the full number. In addition, the bill would require that the college or university discard records and applications after a reasonable period of time if those records contain social security numbers along with other pieces of personally identifiable information.
Eventually, those requirements, as they pertained to colleges and universities, were removed and, in their place, was a requirement to establish the College and University Social Security Number Task Force. The task force was charged with: (1) making recommendations to minimize the collection, use, storage, and retention of SSNs by California colleges and universities; and, (2) providing a specified report to the Legislature, which is now the subject of this bill. (See amendments to AB 1168, June 1, 2007.)
- Additional reporting requirement: AB 1168, the original bill enacting the reporting requirement that is the subject of this bill, actually contained two reporting requirements. In addition to the July 1, 2010 report mandated from the College and University Social Security Number Task Force in the Education Code, a second reporting requirement was added to the county recorders’ Truncation Program that AB 1168 established within the Government Code (commencing at Government Code Section 22301).
Specifically, AB 1168 established a reporting requirement in the Truncation Program that required the County Recorders Association of California, no later than January 1, 2009, and annually thereafter, to submit to the chairpersons of the Assembly and Senate committees on Judiciary, and to the Office of Privacy Protection, or any successor agency, a report on the progress that each county recorder has made in complying with this program, in order to assist the Legislature in monitoring the program’s progress. While this report is technically required annually, it was not envisioned to exist in perpetuity. The statute specifically states that once the OPP makes a determination that all counties have completed the component of the program with respect to each official record recorded between January 1, 1980, and December 31, 2008, the report would no longer be required thereafter. (See Gov. Code Sec. 27305.) The author also has a bill that was heard and approved by this Committee earlier this year, which would require this particular report to, hereinafter, be submitted to this Committee (instead of the Assembly Judiciary Committee), since it does not appear that the need for that particular report is yet obsolete. (See AB 1472 (Stone). That bill is currently on the Assembly Floor.)
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 253 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Introduced Ver:January 23, 2019
[Note: This bill is doubled referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection and will be heard by that Committee as it relates to issues under its jurisdiction.]
SUBJECT: Postsecondary education: social security numbers: task force: reporting
SUMMARY: Repeals an obsolete reporting requirement regarding the collection, use, storage, and retention of social security numbers.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, and the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges, and private, independent institutions of higher education as the four segments of postsecondary education in this state. (Education Code (EDC) Section 66010, et seq.)
- Requires the Office of Privacy Protection in the Department of Consumer Affairs to establish a task force, with specified members, to conduct a review of the use by all public and private colleges and universities in this state of social security numbers in order to recommend practices to minimize the collection, use, storage, and retention of social security numbers, and requires the task force to submit a report of its findings and recommendations to the Office of Privacy Protection and to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary and the Senate Committee on Judiciary, on or before July 1, 2010. (EDC Section 66018.55)
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill was keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: Need for the bill. According to the author, AB 253 eliminates an outdated reporting requirement that was created when the Office of Privacy Protection in the Department of Consumer Affairs was required by law to create a task force to review best practices for the use of social security numbers in college and universities in the state.
The report was due to the Office of Privacy Protection and to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary and the Senate Committee on Judiciary on or before July 1, 2010. Since the creation of this statute, the Office of Legislative Counsel began adding sunset dates to reporting requirements as a matter of practice. However, without legislative action, outdated reporting requirements such as the one in this statute will remain on the books.
This bill removes a reference to an outdated reporting requirement for which the deadline has already passed.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):