AB 2573: Trusts: notifications.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-03-04
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 23, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 27, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 26, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 4602.) |
| May 13, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 12, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 11). |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 2, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 26, 2020 | AB 2573 Obernolte Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2020 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2573
Author:(Obernolte) – As Amended Ver:March 4, 2020
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Trusts: notifications
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO ENSURE THERE IS FINALITY, AND TRUST BENEFICIARIES DO NOT HAVE MULTIPLE opportunities TO CONTEST A TRUST, SHOULD THE LAW BE CLARIFIED TO LIMIT CONTESTS of a trust TO A CERTAIN NUMBER OF DAYS AFTER THE BENEFICIARY (OR HEIR) IS GIVEN NOTICE THAT THE TRUST HAS BECOME IRREVOCABLE?
SYNOPSIS
As part of estate planning, a person may elect to create a trust into which that person transfers specified property. Trusts are commonly used to avoid probate and obtain certain tax advantages. There are two types of trust estate plans: a testamentary trust, which is written into a will and becomes effective upon death; and a living or inter vivos trust, which is created in a separate document. There are two types of living trusts, revocable and irrevocable, although living revocable trusts generally become irrevocable trusts upon the death of the person creating the trust (in California, the settlor). Unlike a revocable trust, an irrevocable trust does not permit the settlor to revoke or change the trust without the consent of the beneficiaries of the trust and/or the court.
The trustee of a trust is required to notify the trust’s beneficiaries, and the heirs of the deceased settlor, of the existence of the trust when certain events occur. That notification starts the clock ticking on when the beneficiaries or heirs may begin an action to contest the trust. However, the ability to bring a suit now applies too broadly, such as when there is a change of trustees, potentially giving beneficiaries multiple times to contest the same trust. This bill, sponsored by the Trusts & Estates Section of the California Lawyers Association, limits when an action to contest a trust can occur to only those instances when a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, has become irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or when the express terms of the trust so provide.
SUMMARY: Limits when a beneficiary of a trust or heir of the settlor may bring an action to contest a trust to within 120 days from when a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, has become irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a person who has received the required notice from a trustee that a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, has become irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust from bringing an action to contest the trust more than 120 days from the date the notification by the trustee is served upon that person, or 60 days from the date on which a copy of the terms of the trust is delivered to that person, as provided, during that 120-day period, whichever is later.
- Excludes, from limitation on when an action to contest a trust can be brought under 1), instances of notification based on a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust or a power of appointment retained by the settlor that either becomes effective or lapses.
EXISTING LAW:
- Governs the creation, validation, modification, termination, and administration of trusts, and provides for the adjudication of disputes relating to trusts. Provides for the rights and responsibilities of all parties to a trust, i.e., the settlor (the creator of the trust), trustee, beneficiary, heir, and a third party, such as a creditor. (Probate Code Section 15000 et seq. All further statutory references are to the Probate Code unless stated otherwise.)
- Requires a trustee to serve notification, within 60 days of the event requiring the notification, to each beneficiary of an irrevocable trust and each heir of the deceased settlor, as provided, when one of the following events occur:
- When a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, becomes irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust;
- Whenever there is a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust; and
- Whenever a power of appointment retained by the settlor is effective or lapses, as provided. (Section 16061.7 (a), (b).)
- Requires the notification in 2), if served because the trust became irrevocable based on the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust, to contain the following warning, set out in a separate paragraph in not less than 10-point boldface type: “You may not bring an action to contest the trust more than 120 days from the date this notification by the trustee is served upon you or 60 days from the date on which a copy of the terms of the trust is delivered to you during that 120-day period, whichever is later.” (Section 16061.7 (h).)
- Prohibits a person upon whom the notification by the trustee is served pursuant to 2), whether the notice is served within or after the required time period, from bringing an action to contest the trust more than 120 days from the date the notification by the trustee is served upon that person, or 60 days from the date on which a copy of the terms of the trust is delivered to that person during that 120-day period, whichever is later. (Section 16061.8.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: As part of estate planning, a person may elect to create a trust into which that person transfers specified property. Trusts are commonly used to avoid probate and may provide certain tax advantages. There are two types of trust estate plans; a testamentary trust, which is written into a will and becomes effective upon death, and a living or inter vivos trust, which is created in a separate document. There are two types of living trusts, revocable and irrevocable trusts, although living revocable trusts generally become irrevocable trusts upon the death of the person creating the trust (in California, the settlor). Unlike a revocable trust, an irrevocable trust does not permit the settlor to revoke or change the trust without the consent of the beneficiaries of the trust and/or the court.
The trustee of a trust is required to notify the trust’s beneficiaries, and the heirs of the deceased settlor, of the existence of the trust when certain events occur. That notification starts the clock ticking on when the beneficiaries or heirs may bring an action to contest the trust. However, the ability to bring a suit now applies too broadly, such as when there is a change of trustees, potentially giving beneficiaries multiple times to contest the same trust. This bill limits when an action to contest a trust can occur to only those instances when a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, has become irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or when the express terms of the trust so provide.
In support of the bill, the author states:
Probate Code Section 16061.8 limits the time for contesting a trust to 120 days after the service of the trustee notification prescribed by Probate Code section 16061.7. This code section provides for three different “triggering” events that require this notification: 1) Whenever a revocable trust or a portion of a trust becomes irrevocable because of the death of the settlor or settlors, 2) Whenever there is a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust, and 3) Whenever a power of appointment retained by a settlor over an otherwise irrevocable trust lapses upon death. This legislative proposal would clarify section 16061.8 to provide that the 120-day limitation period applies only when the notification is required by reason of the death of the settlor. A new limitation period would not be created or revived if notification is required upon the change of trustee of an existing irrevocable trust, as the trust has already been deemed just that - “irrevocable.” The proposed change would clarify an ambiguity in current law and further the existing statutory purpose of providing finality in post-death trust administration.
A trustee required to provide notice of the trust to the trust beneficiaries and the heirs of a deceased settlor on the occurrence of certain events. Under existing law, a trustee is required to serve notification to each beneficiary of an irrevocable trust and each heir of the deceased settlor, as provided, when one of the following events occur:
- When a revocable trust, or any portion thereof, becomes irrevocable because of the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust;
- Whenever there is a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust; and
- Whenever a power of appointment retained by the settlor is effective or lapses, as provided. (Section 16061.7 (a), (b).)
The notification is required to be provided within 60 days of the triggering event requiring the notification or within 60 days of the trustee becoming aware of a person who is entitled to receive the notice. (Section 16061.7 (f).) The notice must contain the following information:
- The identity of the settlor or settlors and the date of execution of the trust instrument.
- The name, address, and telephone number of each trustee;
- The address of the physical location where the principal place of administration of the trust is located;
- Any additional information that may be expressly required by the terms of the trust instrument; and
- A notification that the recipient is entitled, upon reasonable request to the trustee, to receive from the trustee a true and complete copy of the terms of the trust. (Section 16061.7 (g).)
The notification limits when an action can be brought contesting the trust. The notice limits when a beneficiary or heir, in certain situations, can contest a trust. In particular, the required notice, if served because the trust became irrevocable based on the death of one or more settlors or because of the express terms of the trust, must contain the following warning, set out in a separate paragraph in not less than 10-point boldface type:
You may not bring an action to contest the trust more than 120 days from the date this notification by the trustee is served upon you or 60 days from the date on which a copy of the terms of the trust is delivered to you during that 120-day period, whichever is later. (Section 16061.7 (h).)
The notice of limitation on bringing an action is not sent in the event of one of the other triggering events for notice: either a change of trustees of an irrevocable trust or a power of appointment becomes effective or lapses. That is appropriate because those events do not trigger the need to challenge the trust. However a trust becoming irrevocable does. A time limitation for bringing suit in that instance promotes the efficient administration of a trust after the death of a settlor or other event making the trust irrevocable, and all interested parties are alerted to the short limitation period available to contest the validity of the trust instrument. If they want to contest the trust during that time period, they can. Once the time period expires with no contest brought, the trustee can confidently administer the trust instrument according to its terms and without fear of a later contest. The notification, statutory warning, and limitation period helps bring potential contests to a head and settle them with finality.
This bill appropriately limits the time period for bringing an action to contest a trust to one time. The provision limiting when an action can be brought to challenge a trust, which is set out in Section 16016.8, is broader than those instances where the trustee is required to send the warning under Section 16016.7. Although notice must be sent to the beneficiaries and heirs in three instances, only one of those instances – when a settlor has died or the trust becomes irrevocable – requires the warning language and necessitates the beginning of the clock for filing an action to contest the trust. The other two instances – a change of trustees of an irrevocable trust or a power of appointment becoming effective or lapsing – do not change the underlying trust and thus do not require a second bite of the apple with a second opportunity to challenge the trust. The author provides an example of why these additional periods for possibly challenging a trust are not only confusing, but could lead to unintended results:
More than one triggering event may occur during a trust administration. For example, assume that the settlor of a trust dies in 2012, and the trust becomes irrevocable. A first successor trustee is appointed and properly gives the statutory notification. That first appointed successor trustee becomes incapacitated in 2016. A second successor trustee is appointed in 2017 requiring another statutory notification because of the change in the trustee of an irrevocable trust. The second notification would be sent only to the current trust beneficiaries because they are the interested parties. Section 16061.7(h) does not require the inclusion of the statutory warning for this second notification. Do the trust beneficiaries have an additional 120 days from the mailing of the second notification to contest the trust?
While it may be appropriate for beneficiaries to be able to challenge the appointment of an incorrect trustee, that is fundamentally different than challenging the trust itself. Only one period – the initial notification period in the above example – is necessary to allow interested parties to challenge the trust and then provide finality.
This bill clarifies that is indeed the case by providing that the 120-day limitation to bring an action to challenge a trust applies only to those instances when the settlor dies or the trust otherwise becomes irrevocable. In these instances, the time period to challenge the trust arises. However, under the bill, the time period no longer arises either when there is a change of trustee of an irrevocable trust or when a power of appointment retained by the settlor becomes effective or lapses. In these instances, the beneficiaries will still get notice of the change, but they would no longer be able to contest the trust itself.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, the sponsor, the Trusts & Estates Section of the California Lawyers Association, writes:
The statutory notification promotes the efficient administration of a trust after the death of a settlor because it alerts all interested parties to the short 120-day limitation period available to contest the trust instrument. The trustee serves the notification, commonly with a copy of the relevant terms of the trust, on all interested parties. If the applicable limitation period expires with no action by the interested parties, the trustee can confidently administer the trust according to its terms and without fear of a pending contest. If one or more interested parties file a contest within the 120-day period, the trustee can bring all contests to a head and settle them with finality.
More than one event may occur during a trust administration that triggers notification under Section 16061.7. For example, 1) death of the settlor in year 1 would trigger notification; and 2) change of the trustee in year 3 would trigger a second notification. Under current law, it is not clear if the beneficiaries have a new 120-day period to contest the trust following the second notification sent in year 3. Yet there would be no reason to allow trust contests following change of the trustee and to do so would be contrary to the goal of finality, established following the initial statutory notification that is provided after death of the settlor.
AB 2573 clarifies that the 120-day limitation period for contesting a trust, after the trustee notification required under Probate Code Section 16061.7, applies only when the notification is required by reason of the death of a settlor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Lawyers Association, Trusts & Estates Section (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):