AB 2717: Motor vehicles: unattended children: liability.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 352, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 30, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 5343.). |
| Aug 27, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 27, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 30. Noes 0. Page 4353.). |
| Aug 20, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2020 | From Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 14, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 13, 2020 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jul 31, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 23, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 9, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 8, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 76. Noes 0. Page 4728.) |
| Jun 3, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (June 2). |
| May 12, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 16, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 12, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | AB 2717 Chau Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2717 Chau By Wieckowski | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 30, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 8, 2020 | AB 2717 Chau Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2020 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 11, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2717
Author:(Chau)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides immunity from liability to a person who rescues an unattended and endangered child from a vehicle, subject to certain conditions.
Major Provisions
- Permits a person to take reasonable steps necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child's safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. Provides further that a person who removes a child from a vehicle under these circumstances is not criminally liable for actions taken reasonably and in good faith if the person does all of the following:
- Determines the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle.
- Has a good faith belief that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary because the child is in imminent danger of suffering harm if not immediately removed from the vehicle, and, based upon the circumstances known to the person at the time, the belief is a reasonable one.
- Has contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department, or the "911" emergency service prior to forcibly entering the vehicle.
- Remains with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until a peace officer or another emergency responder arrives.
- Used no more force to enter the vehicle and remove the child from the vehicle than was necessary under the circumstances.
- Immediately turns the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder who responds to the scene.
- Specifies that a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency medical technician (EMT) personnel who removes a child shall arrange for treatment or transportation, as specified.
- Provides that a person shall not be civilly liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing a child in accordance with the criteria prescribed in 1) above.
- Defines "child" for purposes of the above to mean a child six years of age or younger.
The Senate Amendments:
Specify that a peace officer, firefighter, or other EMT who removes a child from a car shall arrange for treatment or transport of the child, as specified.
COMMENTS:
Existing law makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other responsible person to leave a child of six years or younger in a motor vehicle, under circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child's health or safety, unless the child is supervised by another person at least twelve years of age. Notwithstanding this law, some parents, legal guardians, and others apparently still leave children unattended in vehicles. According to studies provided by the author, there are still a surprising number of children who suffer "pediatric heatstroke" and related problems as a result of parents leaving them in parked vehicles. This bill would grant criminal and civil immunity to any person who rescues a child from a vehicle, so long as the rescuer reasonably believes that the child is in danger, does no more damage to the vehicle than is necessary, contacts law enforcement or emergency personnel, and waits with the child until police officers or emergency personnel arrive on the scene.
"Good Samaritan" Immunity in Existing Law. California generally follows the common law "no duty to rescue" rule. This means that absent some "special relationship" (e.g. parent-child, teacher-student, etc.) we have no legal duty to come to the aid of others, even if we could do so with minimal risk or effort. California, like most other states, has countered this rather antisocial common law rule by enacting so-called "Good Samaritan" laws, which provide immunity from liability to persons who voluntarily come to the aid of others, should their intervention result in an unintended injury to person or property. Some advocates claim that Good Samaritan laws encourage potentially life-saving intervention by removing the fear of liability. This reasoning assumes, however, that a person who would otherwise act honorably to save another would be deterred by fear of a lawsuit. Whether or not a would-be rescuer would stop and think about a lawsuit in the heat of the moment is debatable, but there is perhaps a better and simpler justification for offering qualified immunity: it seems inherently unfair to punish people who potentially risk their lives by voluntarily coming to the aid of others.
Existing immunity protects medical and non-medical interventions. Prior to AB 83 (Feuer) Chapter 77, Statutes of 2009, California law only provided qualified immunity to persons who rendered emergency "medical care" at the scene of an emergency. AB 83 was enacted in response to the California Supreme Court's decision in Van Horn v. Watson (2008) 45 Cal. 4th 322. In that case, the driver of a vehicle that had crashed pulled an unconscious passenger from the car, apparently fearing that the car might catch on fire or even explode. However, in pulling the passenger from the car, the driver unintentionally may have worsened the injuries. The passenger pulled from the vehicle subsequently sued the driver for those added injuries. The Supreme Court narrowly interpreted then-existing law as only granting immunity to persons who render "medical" aid at the "scene of an emergency," and determined that pulling the person from the vehicle was not, according to the Court, a medical intervention. In response to this decision, AB 83 amended the law to clarify that laypersons who render medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency are immune from liability, so long as their conduct does not constitute "gross negligence" or willful or wanton conduct. One could argue, therefore, that rescuing a child from a vehicle, where the rescuer reasonably believes that there is a significant risk to the health and safety of the child, is nonmedical assistance in an emergency and therefore already immune from liability under existing law. However, this bill would remove any ambiguity as to whether encountering an unattended child in a vehicle constitutes being at the "scene of an emergency" under existing law by expressly granted immunity to any person who reasonably rescues an endangered child from a vehicle.
It is important to note the limited nature of the immunity provided by this bill. First, the bill only provides immunity for damage or trespass to property; it would not provide immunity if the rescuer caused injury to the child. Second, the immunity only applies where the rescuer acted upon "reasonable" belief that the child was in danger and that the rescuer follows prescribed steps, including not doing more damage to the vehicle than is necessary, contacts law enforcement or emergency personnel, and waits with the child until police officers or emergency personnel arrive on the scene.
Lastly, this bill seems more than reasonable in light of AB 797 (Steinorth) Chapter 554, Statutes of 2016, which offers immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles, so long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and then follows prescribed steps. This bill is almost identical in content and structure to AB 797. Surely, if we grant immunity to people who rescue animals from vehicles, we should afford the same immunity to people who rescue young children.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "California has laws to exempt Good Samaritans from criminal or civil liability in the rescue animals left unattended in vehicles, but no such laws in the rescue of children. AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal."
Arguments in Support:
The California Professional Firefighters write that, "AB 2717 would extend existing Good Samaritan protections to those who act in in good faith to render emergency assistance from liability to individuals who take action to rescue a child younger than six years old from a motor vehicle. When there is so little time to prevent the injury or death of a young child, individuals who are on the scene and able to respond immediately should not be punished for property damage caused to the vehicle during the rescue. California's firefighters are often the first on the scene when these horrific accidents occur, and know firsthand the devastation that comes with these tragic incidents."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-0-1
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kalra
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, McCarty, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0-3
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Low, Muratsuchi, Quirk
SENATE FLOOR: 30-0-10
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Melendez, Moorlach, Morrell, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 19, 2020
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003469
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2717 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2717
Author: Chau (D)
Amended: 8/19/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/30/20
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Melendez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/8/20 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Motor vehicles: unattended children: liability
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill exempts from civil and criminal liability a person who takes any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, so long as the person complies with certain requirements.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/19/20 clarify that a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle, or who takes possession of a child who has been removed from a motor vehicle is to arrange for treatment and transport of the child according to the medical control policies of the local EMS agency.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another, but if a person decides to assist another then that person must act with reasonable care. (Artiglio v. Corning Inc. (1998) 18 Cal.4th 604; Williams v. State of California (1983) 34 Cal.3d 18.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability who, in good faith and not for compensation, renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. (Hlth. & Saf. Code § 1799.102.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing a confined and unattended animal from the vehicle, if the person reasonably believes that rescue is necessary to prevent the unnecessary suffering, disability, or death of the animal. (Civ.C. § 43.100.)
- Makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other person responsible for a child six years of age or younger to leave that child inside a motor vehicle, unless the child is supervised by a person at least 12 years of age, under any circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety. (Veh.C. § 15620.)
This bill:
- Permits a person to take any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. A child is defined as a child who is six years of age or younger.
- Provides that a person who removes a child under these circumstances is not criminally liable for actions taken reasonably and in good faith if the person does all of the following:
- Determines the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle.
- Has a good faith belief that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary because the child is in imminent danger of suffering harm if not immediately removed from the vehicle, and, based upon the circumstances known to the person at the time, the belief is a reasonable one.
- Has contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department, or the “911” emergency service prior to forcibly entering the vehicle.
- Remains with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until a peace officer or another emergency responder arrives.
- Used no more force to enter the vehicle and remove the child from the vehicle than was necessary under the circumstances.
- Immediately turns the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder who responds to the scene.
- Provides that these provisions do not prevent a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder from removing a child from a motor vehicle if the child’s safety appears to be in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle, or who takes possession of a child who has been removed from a motor vehicle, to arrange for the treatment and transport of the child according to the medical control policies of the local EMS agency. The parent of a child removed from a vehicle may be required to pay for charges that may accrue for the care or medical treatment of the child.
- Authorizes a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder to take all steps that are reasonably necessary for the removal of a child from a motor vehicle, including, but not limited to, breaking into the motor vehicle, after a reasonable effort is made to locate the owner or other person responsible.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle or who receives a child rescued from a vehicle from another person to, in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle, leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child will be treated.
- Provides that a person shall not be civilly liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing a child in accordance with these provisions.
Comments
California generally follows the traditional principles of common law that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another except for special relationships (like a parent and child). Like many other states, California provides for so-called “Good Samaritan” laws that provide immunity from liability if a person does assist another and during that assistance an unintended injury to person or property occurs. In order to receive immunity from liability, the person offering assistance has a duty to exercise reasonable care, and if that person’s actions fall below this standard of care and causes harm, then the Good Samaritan may be held liable.
Immunity provisions are generally disfavored because they, by their nature, prevent an injured party from seeking a particular type of recovery. The Legislature has, in limited scenarios, approved limited immunity from liability (as opposed to blanket immunities) to promote other policy goals that benefit the public. For example, existing California law provides immunity from civil liability to a person who in good faith and not for compensation renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. In 2016, the Legislature approved AB 797 (Steinorth, Chapter 554, Statutes of 2016), which provided a person is not civilly or criminally liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing an animal in accordance with certain provisions in the Penal Code.
This bill seeks to now provide Good Samaritans who act reasonably to save the life of a child who is six years of age or younger with immunity from criminal and civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the property damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing the child. This bill also establishes procedures that apply to a peace officer or emergency responder under those circumstances, including, requiring transportation of the child to a hospital for diagnosis and treatment and requiring that they leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child was taken to be treated in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle.
This bill’s provisions create civil and criminal immunity to encourage Good Samaritans to act when it becomes clear that it is necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. Existing law already makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or other responsible person to leave a child under six years of age in a vehicle unattended; however, 39 children die each year on average in the Unites States from heatstroke after being left in a vehicle, with California having 52 such deaths since 1998.[1] This bill’s provisions appear to base the immunity narrowly on a person’s reasonable and good faith belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger necessitating forcible entry into the vehicle as long as the Good Samaritan takes specific actions before forcible entry. These actions include: determining the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle; contacting local law enforcement, the fire department, or 911 emergency services; remaining with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until an officer or emergency responder arrives; and immediately turning the child over to a representative from law enforcement or other emergency responder at the scene. The immunity is further narrowly tailored in that it limits the civil immunity to property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle. In light of the fact that the Legislature granted immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles, so long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and follows specified steps, it seems eminently reasonable to offer similar immunity to persons who rescue young children in similar circumstances.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah
Auto Club of Southern California
California Professional Firefighters
Emergency Medical Services Administrators Association of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
California has laws to exempt Good Samaritans from criminal or civil liability in the rescue of animals left unattended in vehicles, but no such laws in the rescue of children. AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal.
Prior to forcibly entering a vehicle, a person must have contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department or called “911”if they hold reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation or other circumstances. In addition, the person has also determined that the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle and in good faith believes that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary. The person must remain near the vehicle at a safe location until an emergency responder arrives and immediately turn the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder at the scene.
The California Professional Firefighters write in support, stating:
Each year as summer approaches and the weather begins to get warmer, news stories begin to increase regarding the devastating consequences of leaving an unattended child in a locked car. While forgetting a child in the back seat of their car is every parent’s worst nightmare, the numbers of children who have been injured or died as a result of pediatric vehicular heatstroke (PVH) have increased since they were first recorded in the 1990’s. In fact the deadliest year on record for PVH was 2018 when 53 cases were recorded nationwide, three of which occurred in California […]
AB 2717 would extend existing Good Samaritan protections to those who act in in good faith to render emergency assistance from liability to individuals who take action to rescue a child younger than six years old from a motor vehicle. When there is so little time to prevent the injury or death of a young child, individuals who are on the scene and able to respond immediately should not be punished for property damage caused to the vehicle during the rescue. California’s firefighters are often the first on the scene when these horrific accidents occur, and know firsthand the devastation that comes with these tragic incidents. For these reasons and more, we urge your support for AB 2717. [emphasis in original]
The AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah and Auto Club of Southern California (AAA Clubs) jointly write in support:
A child dies from a heatstroke about once every 10 days from being left alone in a hot vehicle. In fact, heatstroke is the leading cause of non-crash vehicle fatality for kids 14 and younger according to AAA research. In 90-degree weather, the inside of cars can reach 133 degrees when in direct sunlight. Even mild weather can be dangerous for young people because their bodies can heat up five times faster than adults. There are too many tragic fatalities and even more “close calls” because of incidents involving children trapped inside cars.
More than 1 in 5 of the 50 million AAA members nationwide reside in California. The AAA Clubs regularly use our communication reach to remind all motorist not to leave kids in hot cars every summer. Unfortunately, educational campaigns are not enough given the deadly consequences at risk. Accordingly, the AAA Clubs encourage a yes vote on AB 2717. No one should have to think twice about liability issues before saving the life of a child trapped in a hot car.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/8/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Low, Muratsuchi, Quirk
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/21/20 18:16:33
**** END ****
Motor Vehicle Safety Issues: Hot Car Deaths, National Safety Council (2020) available at https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/motor-vehicle-safety-issues/hotcars/ (as of Jul. 7, 2020). ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2717 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 2717
Author: Chau (D)
Amended: 3/12/20 in Assembly
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/30/20
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Melendez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/8/20 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Motor vehicles: unattended children: liability
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill exempts from civil and criminal liability a person who takes any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, so long as the person complies with certain requirements.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another, but if a person decides to assist another then that person must act with reasonable care. (Artiglio v. Corning Inc. (1998) 18 Cal.4th 604; Williams v. State of California (1983) 34 Cal.3d 18.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability who, in good faith and not for compensation, renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. (Hlth. & Saf. Code § 1799.102.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing a confined and unattended animal from the vehicle, if the person reasonably believes that rescue is necessary to prevent the unnecessary suffering, disability, or death of the animal. (Civ.C. § 43.100.)
- Makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other person responsible for a child six years of age or younger to leave that child inside a motor vehicle, unless the child is supervised by a person at least 12 years of age, under any circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety. (Veh.C. § 15620.)
This bill:
- Permits a person to take any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. A child is defined as a child who is six years of age or younger.
- Provides that a person who removes a child under these circumstances is not criminally liable for actions taken reasonably and in good faith if the person does all of the following:
- Determines the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle.
- Has a good faith belief that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary because the child is in imminent danger of suffering harm if not immediately removed from the vehicle, and, based upon the circumstances known to the person at the time, the belief is a reasonable one.
- Has contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department, or the “911” emergency service prior to forcibly entering the vehicle.
- Remains with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until a peace officer or another emergency responder arrives.
- Used no more force to enter the vehicle and remove the child from the vehicle than was necessary under the circumstances.
- Immediately turns the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder who responds to the scene.
- Provides that these provisions do not prevent a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder from removing a child from a motor vehicle if the child’s safety appears to be in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle, or who takes possession of a child who has been removed from a motor vehicle, to take the child to a hospital for diagnosis and treatment. The parent of a child removed from a vehicle may be required to pay for charges that may accrue for the care or medical treatment of the child.
- Authorizes a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder to take all steps that are reasonably necessary for the removal of a child from a motor vehicle, including, but not limited to, breaking into the motor vehicle, after a reasonable effort is made to locate the owner or other person responsible.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle or who receives a child rescued from a vehicle from another person to, in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle, leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child will be treated.
- Provides that a person shall not be civilly liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing a child in accordance with these provisions.
Comments
California generally follows the traditional principles of common law that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another except for special relationships (like a parent and child). Like many other states, California provides for so-called “Good Samaritan” laws that provide immunity from liability if a person does assist another and during that assistance an unintended injury to person or property occurs. In order to receive immunity from liability, the person offering assistance has a duty to exercise reasonable care, and if that person’s actions fall below this standard of care and causes harm, then the Good Samaritan may be held liable.
Immunity provisions are generally disfavored because they, by their nature, prevent an injured party from seeking a particular type of recovery. The Legislature has, in limited scenarios, approved limited immunity from liability (as opposed to blanket immunities) to promote other policy goals that benefit the public. For example, existing California law provides immunity from civil liability to a person who in good faith and not for compensation renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. In 2016, the Legislature approved AB 797 (Steinorth, Chapter 554, Statutes of 2016), which provided a person is not civilly or criminally liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing an animal in accordance with certain provisions in the Penal Code.
This bill seeks to now provide Good Samaritans who act reasonably to save the life of a child who is six years of age or younger with immunity from criminal and civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the property damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing the child. This bill also establishes procedures that apply to a peace officer or emergency responder under those circumstances, including, requiring transportation of the child to a hospital for diagnosis and treatment and requiring that they leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child was taken to be treated in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle.
This bill’s provisions create civil and criminal immunity to encourage Good Samaritans to act when it becomes clear that it is necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. Existing law already makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or other responsible person to leave a child under six years of age in a vehicle unattended; however, 39 children die each year on average in the Unites States from heatstroke after being left in a vehicle, with California having 52 such deaths since 1998.[1] This bill’s provisions appear to base the immunity narrowly on a person’s reasonable and good faith belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger necessitating forcible entry into the vehicle as long as the Good Samaritan takes specific actions before forcible entry. These actions include: determining the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle; contacting local law enforcement, the fire department, or 911 emergency services; remaining with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until an officer or emergency responder arrives, and immediately turning the child over to a representative from law enforcement or other emergency responder at the scene. The immunity is further narrowly tailored in that it limits the civil immunity to property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle. In light of the fact that the Legislature granted immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles, so long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and follows specified steps, it seems eminently reasonable to offer similar immunity to persons who rescue young children in similar circumstances.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/13/20)
AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah
Auto Club of Southern California
California Professional Firefighters
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/13/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author writes:
California has laws to exempt Good Samaritans from criminal or civil liability in the rescue of animals left unattended in vehicles, but no such laws in the rescue of children. AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal.
Prior to forcibly entering a vehicle, a person must have contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department or called “911”if they hold reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation or other circumstances. In addition, the person has also determined that the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle and in good faith believes that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary. The person must remain near the vehicle at a safe location until an emergency responder arrives and immediately turn the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder at the scene.
The California Professional Firefighters write in support, stating:
Each year as summer approaches and the weather begins to get warmer, news stories begin to increase regarding the devastating consequences of leaving an unattended child in a locked car. While forgetting a child in the back seat of their car is every parent’s worst nightmare, the numbers of children who have been injured or died as a result of pediatric vehicular heatstroke (PVH) have increased since they were first recorded in the 1990’s. In fact the deadliest year on record for PVH was 2018 when 53 cases were recorded nationwide, three of which occurred in California […]
AB 2717 would extend existing Good Samaritan protections to those who act in in good faith to render emergency assistance from liability to individuals who take action to rescue a child younger than six years old from a motor vehicle. When there is so little time to prevent the injury or death of a young child, individuals who are on the scene and able to respond immediately should not be punished for property damage caused to the vehicle during the rescue. California’s firefighters are often the first on the scene when these horrific accidents occur, and know firsthand the devastation that comes with these tragic incidents. For these reasons and more, we urge your support for AB 2717. [emphasis in original]
The AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah and Auto Club of Southern California (AAA Clubs) jointly write in support:
A child dies from a heatstroke about once every 10 days from being left alone in a hot vehicle. In fact, heatstroke is the leading cause of non-crash vehicle fatality for kids 14 and younger according to AAA research. In 90-degree weather, the inside of cars can reach 133 degrees when in direct sunlight. Even mild weather can be dangerous for young people because their bodies can heat up five times faster than adults. There are too many tragic fatalities and even more “close calls” because of incidents involving children trapped inside cars.
More than 1 in 5 of the 50 million AAA members nationwide reside in California. The AAA Clubs regularly use our communication reach to remind all motorist not to leave kids in hot cars every summer. Unfortunately, educational campaigns are not enough given the deadly consequences at risk. Accordingly, the AAA Clubs encourage a yes vote on AB 2717. No one should have to think twice about liability issues before saving the life of a child trapped in a hot car.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 6/8/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Low, Muratsuchi, Quirk
Prepared by: Amanda Mattson / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/14/20 12:36:37
**** END ****
Motor Vehicle Safety Issues: Hot Car Deaths, National Safety Council (2020) available at https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/motor-vehicle-safety-issues/hotcars/ (as of Jul. 7, 2020). ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2717 (Author:Chau)
Version: March 12, 2020
Hearing Date: July 30, 2020
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
AMConsultant:
SUBJECT
Motor vehicles: unattended children: liability
DIGEST
This bill exempts from civil and criminal liability a person who takes any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, so long as the person complies with certain requirements.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Even though existing law makes it an infraction for a parent or any other person responsible for a young child to leave a child inside a vehicle under circumstances that pose a risk to the child’s health or safety, children are still left unattended in vehicles sometimes resulting in horrific consequences. This bill grants civil and criminal immunity to a person who rescues a child six years of age or younger from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger and follows certain steps, such as doing no more damage to the vehicle than necessary, contacting emergency personnel, and waiting with the child until police emergency personnel arrive. This bill is similar to existing provisions of law that grants immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles as long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and follows specified steps.
The bill is supported by AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah, Auto Club of Southern California, and the California Professional Firefighters. There is no known opposition
Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic and the unprecedented nature of the 2020 Legislative Session, all Senate Policy Committees are working under a compressed timeline. This timeline does not allow this bill to be referred and heard by more than one committee, as a typical timeline would allow. In order to vet the contents of this measure for the benefit of Senators and the public, this analysis includes information from the Senate Public Safety Committee.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another, but if a person decides to assist another then that person must act with reasonable care. (Artiglio v. Corning Inc. (1998) 18 Cal.4th 604; Williams v. State of California (1983) 34 Cal.3d 18.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability who, in good faith and not for compensation, renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. (Hlth. & Saf. Code § 1799.102.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing a confined and unattended animal from the vehicle, if the person reasonably believes that rescue is necessary to prevent the unnecessary suffering, disability, or death of the animal. (Civ.C. § 43.100.)
- Makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other person responsible for a child six years of age or younger to leave that child inside a motor vehicle, unless the child is supervised by a person at least twelve years of age, under any circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety. (Veh.C. § 15620.)
This bill:
- Permits a person to take any reasonable steps that are necessary to remove a child from a vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. A child is defined as a child who is six years of age or younger.
- Provides that a person who removes a child under these circumstances is not criminally liable for actions taken reasonably and in good faith if the person does all of the following:
- Determines the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle.
- Has a good faith belief that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary because the child is in imminent danger of suffering harm if not immediately removed from the vehicle, and, based upon the circumstances known to the person at the time, the belief is a reasonable one.
- Has contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department, or the “911” emergency service prior to forcibly entering the vehicle.
- Remains with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until a peace officer or another emergency responder arrives.
- Used no more force to enter the vehicle and remove the child from the vehicle than was necessary under the circumstances.
- Immediately turns the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder who responds to the scene.
- Provides that these provisions do not prevent a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder from removing a child from a motor vehicle if the child’s safety appears to be in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle, or who takes possession of a child who has been removed from a motor vehicle, to take the child to a hospital for diagnosis and treatment. The parent of a child removed from a vehicle may be required to pay for charges that may accrue for the care or medical treatment of the child.
- Authorizes a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder to take all steps that are reasonably necessary for the removal of a child from a motor vehicle, including, but not limited to, breaking into the motor vehicle, after a reasonable effort is made to locate the owner or other person responsible.
- Requires a peace officer, firefighter, or other emergency responder who removes a child from a motor vehicle or who receives a child rescued from a vehicle from another person to, in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle, leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child will be treated.
- Provides that a person shall not be civilly liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing a child in accordance with these provisions.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
California has laws to exempt Good Samaritans from criminal or civil liability in the rescue of animals left unattended in vehicles, but no such laws in the rescue of children. AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal.
Prior to forcibly entering a vehicle, a person must have contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department or called “911”if they hold reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation or other circumstances. In addition, the person has also determined that the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle and in good faith believes that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary. The person must remain near the vehicle at a safe location until an emergency responder arrives and immediately turn the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder at the scene.
It would also establish procedures that apply to a peace officer or emergency responder under those circumstances, including, but not limited to, requiring transportation of the child to a hospital for treatment.
2. “Good Samaritan” laws and qualified immunity
California generally follows the traditional principles of common law that a person has no duty to come to the aid of another except for special relationships (like a parent and child). Like many other states, California provides for so-called “Good Samaritan” laws that provide immunity from liability if a person does assist another and during that assistance an unintended injury to person or property occurs. In order to receive immunity from liability, the person offering assistance has a duty to exercise reasonable care, and if that person’s actions fall below this standard of care and causes harm, then the Good Samaritan may be held liable.
Immunity provisions are generally disfavored because they, by their nature, prevent an injured party from seeking a particular type of recovery. The Legislature has, in limited scenarios, approved limited immunity from liability (as opposed to blanket immunities) to promote other policy goals that benefit the public. For example, existing California law provides immunity from civil liability to a person who in good faith and not for compensation renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. In 2016, the Legislature approved AB 797 (Steinorth, Ch. 554, Stats. 2016), which provided a person is not civilly or criminally liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing an animal in accordance with certain provisions in the Penal Code.
This bill seeks to now provide Good Samaritans who act reasonably to save the life of a child who is six years of age or younger with immunity from criminal and civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the property damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing the child. The bill also establishes procedures that apply to a peace officer or emergency responder under those circumstances, including, requiring transportation of the child to a hospital for diagnosis and treatment and requiring that they leave written notice bearing their name and office and the address of the location where the child was taken to be treated in a secure and conspicuous location on or within the motor vehicle.
3. Bill appears to craft a narrow immunity for the reasonable actions of a Good Samaritan to rescue a child whose safety is in immediate danger
The bill’s provisions create civil and criminal immunity to encourage Good Samaritans to act when it becomes clear that it is necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. Existing law already makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or other responsible person to leave a child under six years of age in a vehicle unattended; however, 39 children die each year on average in the Unites States from heatstroke after being left in a vehicle, with California having 52 such deaths since 1998.[1] The bill’s provisions appear to base the immunity narrowly on a person’s reasonable and good faith belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger necessitating forcible entry into the vehicle as long as the Good Samaritan takes specific actions before forcible entry. These actions include: determining the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle; contacting local law enforcement, the fire department, or 911 emergency services; remaining with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until an officer or emergency responder arrives, and immediately turning the child over to a representative from law enforcement or other emergency responder at the scene. The immunity is further narrowly tailored in that it limits the civil immunity to property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle. In light of the fact that the Legislature granted immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles, so long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and follows specified steps, it seems eminently reasonable to offer similar immunity to persons who rescue young children in similar circumstances.
4. Statements in Support
The California Professional Firefighters write in support, stating:
Each year as summer approaches and the weather begins to get warmer, news stories begin to increase regarding the devastating consequences of leaving an unattended child in a locked car. While forgetting a child in the back seat of their car is every parent’s worst nightmare, the numbers of children who have been injured or died as a result of pediatric vehicular heatstroke (PVH) have increased since they were first recorded in the 1990’s. In fact the deadliest year on record for PVH was 2018 when 53 cases were recorded nationwide, three of which occurred in California […]
AB 2717 would extend existing Good Samaritan protections to those who act in in good faith to render emergency assistance from liability to individuals who take action to rescue a child younger than six years old from a motor vehicle. When there is so little time to prevent the injury or death of a young child, individuals who are on the scene and able to respond immediately should not be punished for property damage caused to the vehicle during the rescue. California’s firefighters are often the first on the scene when these horrific accidents occur, and know firsthand the devastation that comes with these tragic incidents. For these reasons and more, we urge your support for AB 2717. [emphasis in original]
The AAA Clubs write in support jointly:
A child dies from a heatstroke about once every 10 days from being left alone in a hot vehicle. In fact, heatstroke is the leading cause of non-crash vehicle fatality for kids 14 and younger according to AAA research. In 90-degree weather, the inside of cars can reach 133 degrees when in direct sunlight. Even mild weather can be dangerous for young people because their bodies can heat up five times faster than adults. There are too many tragic fatalities and even more “close calls” because of incidents involving children trapped inside cars.
More than 1 in 5 of the 50 million AAA members nationwide reside in California. The AAA Clubs regularly use our communication reach to remind all motorist not to leave kids in hot cars every summer. Unfortunately, educational campaigns are not enough given the deadly consequences at risk. Accordingly, the AAA Clubs encourage a yes vote on AB 2717. No one should have to think twice about liability issues before saving the life of a child trapped in a hot car.
SUPPORT
AAA Northern California, Nevada and Utah
Auto Club of Southern California
California Professional Firefighters
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
AB 797 (Steinorth, Ch. 554, Stats. 2016), provided immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles if they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and take certain steps.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 18, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Motor Vehicle Safety Issues: Hot Car Deaths, National Safety Council (2020) available at https://injuryfacts.nsc.org/motor-vehicle/motor-vehicle-safety-issues/hotcars/ (as of Jul. 7, 2020). ↑
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2717
Author:(Chau) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2020
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill exempts a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing a child 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability or death to the child.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Possible minor cost savings to the trial courts (GF/Trial Court Trust Fund) in that this bill may reduce the number of civil cases and criminal prosecutions against defendants for trespass or vandalism when the facts support immunity. Existing law likely already creates immunity in these cases pursuant to California’s Good Samaritan Law, however, this bill expressly grants immunity for damage caused as a result of rescuing a child.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal.
- Good Samaritan Law. The Good Samaritan Law provides immunity from liability to people who voluntarily come to the aid of others, if their intervention results in an unintended injury assuming the absence of gross negligence. Rescuing a child from a vehicle, where the rescuer reasonably believes that there is a significant risk to the health and safety of the child, is likely already immune under existing law. However, this bill would remove any ambiguity as to whether encountering an unattended child in a vehicle constitutes being at the “scene of an emergency” under existing law by expressly granting immunity to any person who reasonably rescues an endangered child from a vehicle.
- Prior Legislation. AB 797 (Steinorth), Chapter 554, Statutes of 2016, exempted a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the property damage or trespass occurred while the person was rescuing an animal.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2717
Author:(Chau) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2020
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Motor vehicles: unattended children: liability
KEY ISSUE: SHould a person who rescues an unattended child from a VEHICLE BE immune from liability for damages or trespass to that vehicle, so long as the person reasonably believed that the child was in danger and took specified steps in response to the perceived danger?
SYNOPSIS
Existing law makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other person responsible for a child to leave a child who is six years of age or younger in a motor vehicle under circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety, unless the child is supervised by another person who is at least twelve years of age. Notwithstanding this law, some people still leave children unattended in vehicles under circumstances that could place the children in danger. This bill would grant criminal and civil immunity to any person who rescues a child from a vehicle, so long as the rescuer reasonably believes that the child is in danger, does no more damage to the vehicle than is necessary, contacts law enforcement or emergency personnel, and waits with the child until police officers or emergency personnel arrive on the scene. The bill is similar in structure and intent to AB 797 (Ch. 554, Stats. 2016), which granted similar immunity to persons who rescued endangered animals from vehicles. Arguably, a person who, reasonably and in good faith, rescues an endangered child from a vehicle already has immunity from civil liability under the state’s so-called “Good Samaritan” law, which grants immunity to persons that render medical or non-medical assistance at the scene of an emergency, so long as they do not commit acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. However, this bill would remove any ambiguity as to whether rescuing an endangered and unattended child from a vehicle constitutes rendering assistance at the “scene of an emergency.” The bill is supported by the California Professional Firefighters. There is no known opposition to the bill.
SUMMARY: Provides immunity from liability to a person who rescues an unattended and endangered child from a vehicle, subject to certain conditions. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits a person to take reasonable steps necessary to remove a child from a motor vehicle if the person holds a reasonable belief that the child’s safety is in immediate danger from heat, cold, lack of adequate ventilation, or other circumstances that could reasonably be expected to cause suffering, disability, or death to the child. Provides further that a person who removes a child from a vehicle under these circumstances is not criminally liable for actions taken reasonably and in good faith if the person does all of the following:
- Determines the vehicle is locked or there is otherwise no reasonable manner for the child to be removed from the vehicle.
- Has a good faith belief that forcible entry into the vehicle is necessary because the child is in imminent danger of suffering harm if not immediately removed from the vehicle, and, based upon the circumstances known to the person at the time, the belief is a reasonable one.
- Has contacted a local law enforcement agency, the fire department, or the “911” emergency service prior to forcibly entering the vehicle.
- Remains with the child in a safe location, out of the elements but reasonably close to the vehicle, until a peace officer or another emergency responder arrives.
- Used no more force to enter the vehicle and remove the child from the vehicle than was necessary under the circumstances.
- Immediately turns the child over to a representative from law enforcement or another emergency responder who responds to the scene.
- Provides that a person shall not be civilly liable for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage was caused while the person was rescuing a child in accordance with the criteria prescribed in 1) above.
- Defines “child” for purposes of the above to mean a child six years of age or younger.
EXISTING LAW:
- Makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other person responsible for a child six years of age or younger to leave that child inside a motor vehicle, unless the child is supervised by a person at least twelve years of age, under any circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety. (Vehicle Code Section 15620.)
- Makes it a crime to willfully cause or permit a child to suffer, or inflict unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering, or willfully place a child in a situation where the child’s health is endangered. (Penal Code Section 273a.)
- Exempts from civil liability a person who in good faith, and not for compensation, renders emergency or non-emergency medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency unless the person commits acts or omissions that constitute gross negligence or willful or wanton conduct. (Health & Safety Code Section 1799.102.)
- Exempts a person from civil liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle if the damage or trespass occurs while the person is rescuing a confined and unattended animal from the vehicle, if the person reasonably believes that rescue is necessary to prevent the unnecessary suffering, disability, or death of the animal. (Civil Code Section 43.100.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Existing law makes it an infraction for a parent, legal guardian, or any other responsible person to leave a child of six years or younger in a motor vehicle, under circumstances that would pose a significant risk to the child’s health or safety, unless the child is supervised by another person at least twelve years of age. Notwithstanding this law, some parents, legal guardians, and others apparently still leave children unattended in vehicles. According to studies provided to the Committee by the author, there are still a surprising number of children who suffer “pediatric heatstroke” and related problems as a result of parents leaving them in parked vehicles. This bill would grant criminal and civil immunity to any person who rescues a child from a vehicle, so long as the rescuer reasonably believes that the child is in danger, does no more damage to the vehicle than is necessary, contacts law enforcement or emergency personnel, and waits with the child until police officers or emergency personnel arrive on the scene.
“Good Samaritan” Immunity in Existing Law. California generally follows the common law “no duty to rescue” rule. This means that absent some “special relationship” (e.g. parent-child, teacher-student, etc.) we have no legal duty to come to the aid of others, even if we could do so with minimal risk or effort. California, like most other states, has countered this rather antisocial common law rule by enacting so-called “Good Samaritan” laws, which provide immunity from liability to persons who voluntarily come to the aid of others, should their intervention result in an unintended injury to person or property. Some advocates claim that Good Samaritan laws encourage potentially life-saving intervention by removing the fear of liability. This reasoning assumes, however, that a person who would otherwise act honorably to save another would be deterred by fear of a lawsuit. Whether or not a would-be rescuer would stop and think about a lawsuit in the heat of the moment is debatable, but there is perhaps a better and simpler justification for offering qualified immunity: it seems inherently unfair to punish people who potentially risk their lives by voluntarily coming to the aid of others.
Existing immunity protects medical and non-medical interventions. Prior to AB 83 (Ch. 77, Stats. 2009), California law only provided qualified immunity to persons who rendered emergency “medical care” at the scene of an emergency. AB 83 was enacted in response to the California Supreme Court’s decision in Van Horn v. Watson (2008) 45 Cal. 4th 322. In that case, the driver of a vehicle that had crashed pulled an unconscious passenger from the car, apparently fearing that the car might catch on fire or even explode. However, in pulling the passenger from the car, the driver unintentionally may have worsened the injuries. The passenger pulled from the vehicle subsequently sued the driver for those added injuries. The Supreme Court narrowly interpreted then-existing law as only granting immunity to persons who render “medical” aid at the “scene of an emergency,” and determined that pulling the person from the vehicle was not, according to the Court, a medical intervention. In response to this decision, AB 83 amended the law to clarify that laypersons who render medical or nonmedical care or assistance at the scene of an emergency are immune from liability, so long as their conduct does not constitute “gross negligence” or willful or wanton conduct. One could argue, therefore, that rescuing a child from a vehicle, where the rescuer reasonably believes that there is a significant risk to the health and safety of the child, is nonmedical assistance in an emergency and therefore already immune from liability under existing law. However, this bill would remove any ambiguity as to whether encountering an unattended child in a vehicle constitutes being at the “scene of an emergency” under existing law by expressly granted immunity to any person who reasonably rescues an endangered child from a vehicle.
It is important to note the limited nature of the immunity provided by this bill. First, the bill only provides immunity for damage or trespass to property; it would not provide immunity if the rescuer caused injury to the child. Second, the immunity only applies where the rescuer acted upon “reasonable” belief that the child was in danger and that the rescuer follows prescribed steps, including not doing more damage to the vehicle than is necessary, contacts law enforcement or emergency personnel, and waits with the child until police officers or emergency personnel arrive on the scene.
Lastly, this bill seems more than reasonable in light of AB 797 (Ch. 554, Stats. 2016), which offers immunity to persons who rescue unattended animals from vehicles, so long as they reasonably believe that the animal is in danger and then follows prescribed steps. This bill is almost identical in content and structure to AB 797. Surely, if we grant immunity to people who rescue animals from vehicles, we should afford the same immunity to people who rescue young children.
According to the author, “California has laws to exempt Good Samaritans from criminal or civil liability in the rescue animals left unattended in vehicles, but no such laws in the rescue of children. AB 2717 would exempt a person from civil and criminal liability for property damage or trespass to a motor vehicle, if it occurs while the person is rescuing a child who is 6 years of age or younger under circumstances that reasonably could cause suffering, disability, or death to the child, and they take certain steps during the removal.”
Arguments in Support: The California Professional Firefighters write that, “AB 2717 would extend existing Good Samaritan protections to those who act in in good faith to render emergency assistance from liability to individuals who take action to rescue a child younger than six years old from a motor vehicle. When there is so little time to prevent the injury or death of a young child, individuals who are on the scene and able to respond immediately should not be punished for property damage caused to the vehicle during the rescue. California’s firefighters are often the first on the scene when these horrific accidents occur, and know firsthand the devastation that comes with these tragic incidents.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Professional Firefighters
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):