AB 286: Taxation: cannabis.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-03
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 16. Noes 1.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on REV. & TAX. and B. & P. |
| Jan 29, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 28. |
| Jan 28, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Apr 8, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Business and Professions] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 286
Author:(Bonta) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 10 - 1 |
Business and Professions | 16 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill temporarily reduces, from 15% to 11%, the excise tax on sales of cannabis and cannabis products and temporarily suspends the cannabis cultivation tax.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Annual revenue loss in the range of $227 million in 2019-20, $313 million, and $365 million in 2021-22. This revenue loss includes:
- Annual cultivation tax revenue loss in the range of $75 million in 2019-20, $107 million in 2020-21 and $127 million in 2021-22.
- Annual excise tax revenue loss in the range of $130 million in 2019-20, $175 million in 2020-21 and $204 million in 2021-22.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (AUMA), enacted when voters approved Proposition 64 in 2016, created the statutory framework for the state to regulate cannabis and impose taxes on the sale of both medical and commercial cannabis. As of January 1, 2018, state law imposes a 15% excise tax on the gross receipts of any retail sale of marijuana and imposes a cultivation tax of $9.25 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis flowers and $2.75 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis leaves.
- Future amendments. During the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions hearing on this bill, the author pledged to narrow the scope of this bill to leave the excise tax as is and to suspend the cannabis cultivation tax for a set period of time.
- Report requirement. Proposition 64 mandates, by January 1, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) must include in a report recommendations for adjustments to the tax rate to achieve the goals of undercutting illicit market prices and ensuring sufficient revenues are generated.
- Staff comments. AB 286 aims to combat the illicit cannabis market by suspending or temporarily reducing cannabis taxes. Supporters argue this will allow legal businesses to offer more competitive prices in order to bring in customers currently buying from illicit market operations.
In light of the pending LAO report exploring the issue of cannabis taxation, the committee may wish to consider whether this bill is premature given that the legal industry has been operating for just a few years. Additional issues to consider include:
- State taxes are not the only reason why legal cannabis businesses are at a disadvantage. Cannabis businesses and industry advocates point to a number of challenges: local tax policies, licensing requirements, banking restrictions and lab testing requirements all make the process of running a legal cannabis business more cumbersome and more costly. Absent cannabis taxes, legal businesses still would be at a significant disadvantage relative to illicit market operators.
- The legal commercial cannabis industry is growing. Supporters correctly note that tax revenue has thus far failed to meet expectations. If cannabis tax revenue continue to grow at the 2018 Q4 rate (2%), then FY 2018-19 revenue will be roughly $270 million, compared to DOF’s projected $355 million. However, both LAO and DOF routinely stress that these projections are subject to significant uncertainty.
Given the uncertainty of these projections and the general volatility associated with an industry in transition, it is more helpful to look at average, long-term trends. Even with the many challenges affecting the nascent legal industry, the commercial cannabis industry is still growing. In 2018, collections grew at an average quarterly rate of 22%, and collections in 2018-19 were substantially higher than any quarter in 2017-18.
- Local taxes can fill the gap. California has no cap on taxes imposed on commercial cannabis by local governments. Because legal cannabis operations are expanding, many local governments see legal cannabis as a unique revenue-generating opportunity. Local governments may look at any reduction in statewide taxes as an opportunity to further raise local rates.
- There will likely be a court challenge. Finally, it is unclear whether the Legislature can amend the AUMA for this purpose. As the policy committee analysis notes, these changes will likely be subject to legal challenges.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 286
Author:(Bonta) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2019
SUBJECT: Taxation: cannabis.
SUMMARY: Reduces the excise tax on sales of cannabis and cannabis products from 15% to 11%, and suspends the tax on cannabis cultivation, until July 1, 2022, and requires the state’s cannabis licensing authorities to provide reports to the Legislature that demonstrate the success of the changes to the tax structure through certain specified metrics.
EXISTING LAW:
- Enacts the Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act to provide for a comprehensive regulatory framework for the cultivation, distribution, transport, storage, manufacturing, processing, and sale of medicinal and adult-use cannabis. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 26000 et al.)
- Defines an “A-license” as a state license issued for cannabis or cannabis products intended for adults 21 years of age and older and “M-license” as a state license for commercial cannabis activity involving medicinal cannabis. (BPC § 26001)
- Provides for twenty total types of cannabis licenses including subtypes for cultivation, manufacturing, testing, retail, distribution, and microbusiness; requires each licensee except for testing laboratories to clearly designate whether their license is for adult-use or medicinal cannabis. (BPC § 26050)
- Establishes the Bureau of Cannabis Control (BCC) within the Department of Consumer Affairs, previously named the Bureau of Marijuana Control, the Bureau of Medical Cannabis Regulation, and the Bureau of Medical Marijuana Regulation, for purposes of regulating microbusinesses, transportation, storage, distribution, testing, and sale of cannabis and cannabis products within the state. (BPC § 26010)
- Requires the BCC to convene an advisory committee to advise state licensing authorities on the development of standards and regulations for legal cannabis, including best practices and guidelines that protect public health and safety while ensuring a regulated environment for commercial cannabis activity that does not impose such barriers so as to perpetuate, rather than reduce and eliminate, the illicit market for cannabis. (BPC § 26014)
- Provides the Department of Food and Agriculture (CDFA) with responsibility for regulating cannabis cultivators. (BPC § 26060)
- Provides the Department of Public Health (CDPH) with responsibility for regulating cannabis manufacturers. (BPC § 26130)
- Establishes grounds for disciplinary action against cannabis licensees, including failures to comply with state licensing requirements as well as local laws and ordinances. (BPC § 26030)
- Subjects cannabis businesses operating without a license to civil penalties of up to three times the amount of the license fee for each violation in addition to any criminal penalties. (BPC § 26038)
- Expresses that state cannabis laws shall not be interpreted to supersede or limit the authority of a local jurisdiction to adopt and enforce local ordinances to regulate cannabis businesses. (BPC § 26200)
- Imposes a 15% excise tax upon purchasers of cannabis or cannabis products sold in this state in addition to the sales and use tax imposed by the state and local governments. (Revenue and Tax Code (RTC) § 34011)
- Imposes a cultivation tax on all harvested cannabis that enters the commercial market at a rate of $9.25 per dry-weight ounce for cannabis flowers and $2.75 per dry-weight ounce for cannabis leaves. (RTC § 34012)
- Provides the Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) with responsibility for administering and collecting taxes on cannabis businesses. (RTC § 34013)
- Establishes the California Cannabis Tax Fund (Tax Fund) in the State Treasury wherein cannabis tax revenues are deposited. (RTC § 34018)
- Specifies that money in the Tax Fund shall be disbursed by the Controller in the following order of funding priority:
- Funds sufficient to reimburse departments for any reasonable costs incurred through the implementation of the state’s cannabis laws that are not otherwise reimbursed.
- $10 million to a public university in California annually to research and evaluate the implementation and effect of the state’s cannabis laws, including the impact of legal cannabis on public health; the public safety implications of legal cannabis; the effectiveness of certain drug treatment programs; whether additional antitrust protections are needed in the recreational cannabis market; the economic impacts of the state’s cannabis laws; and how to best tax cannabis based on potency, and the structure and function of licensed cannabis businesses; among other topics of study.
- $3 million to the Department of the California Highway Patrol annually to establish and adopt protocols to determine whether a driver is operating a vehicle while impaired by the use of cannabis.
- $10 million beginning with the 2018-19 fiscal year, then increasing by $10 million each year until reaching $50 million annually, to the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development to award community reinvestments grants to local health departments and at least 50% to qualified community-based nonprofit organizations to support job placement, mental health treatment, substance use disorder treatment, system navigation services, legal services to address barriers to reentry, and linkages to medical care for communities disproportionately affected by past federal and state drug policies.
- $2 million annually to the University of California San Diego Center for Medicinal Cannabis Research to further its objectives.
- Remaining funds deposited into sub-trust accounts as follows:
- 60% into the Youth Education, Prevention, Early Intervention and Treatment Account, disbursed to the Department of Health Care Services for programs for youth that are designed to educate about and to prevent substance use disorders and to prevent harm from substance use. The programs shall emphasize accurate education, effective prevention, early intervention, school retention, and timely treatment services for youth, their families, and their caregivers.
- 20% into the Environmental Restoration and Protection Account, disbursed to the Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation to fund activities related to the natural resources and wildlife implications of legal cannabis.
- 20% into the State and Local Government Law Enforcement Account, disbursed to the California Highway Patrol to fund education regarding cannabis-impaired driving and to the Board of State and Community Corrections to award grants to local law enforcement to address the public health and safety implications of locally legalized cannabis.
(RTC § 34019)
- Prohibits the Legislature from changing the cannabis tax revenue funding allocations before July 1, 2028. (RTC § 34019(h))
- Requires the Controller to periodically audit the Tax Fund to ensure that funds are used and accounted for in a manner consistent with what is required by law. (RTC § 34020)
- States that cannabis taxes shall be in addition to any other tax imposed by a local government. (RTC § 34021)
- Permits a county to impose a tax on the privilege of cultivating, manufacturing, producing, processing, preparing, storing, providing, donating, selling, or distributing cannabis or cannabis products. (RTC § 34021.5)
- Authorizes the Legislature to enact laws to implement the state’s regulatory scheme for cannabis, provided those laws are consistent with the purposes and intent of the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (Proposition 64). (BPC § 26000)
THIS BILL:
- Makes various findings and declarations about the voters’ intent in passing Proposition 64 to replace black market cannabis sales with sales by lawful, regulated businesses, and states that the bill’s intent is to further that goal by ensuring the legal market can compete with illicit sellers.
- Lowers the cannabis excise tax from 15% to 11% for sales beginning on the operative date of the bill and ending on July 1, 2022.
- Suspends the cannabis cultivation tax beginning on the operative date of the bill and ending on July 1, 2022.
- Provides that the bill’s operative date is on the first day of the first calendar quarter commencing more than 30 days after the bill is signed.
- Requires cannabis licensing authorities to report to the Legislature by August 1, 2022 the following metrics for purposes of determining the success of the tax reduction:
- The number of businesses that applied for licenses from the BCC and the CDFA annually.
- The number of businesses that were issued licenses by the BCC and the CDFA annually.
- A comparison of the above metrics listed in paragraph as follows:
- The number of businesses that applied for licenses from the BCC and the CDFA in the years 2018 and 2019 against those applied for in the years 2020 and 2021.
- The number of businesses that were issued licenses by the BCC and the CDFA in the years 2018 and 2019 against those issued in the years 2020 and 2021.
- Requires the CDTFA to report to the Legislature by August 1, 2022 the following metrics for purposes of determining the success of the tax reduction:
- The annual amount of total sales of cannabis and cannabis products by licensed retailers for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years.
- The quarterly amount of total sales of cannabis and cannabis products by licensed retailers for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years.
- The annual amount of state tax revenue from the cannabis cultivation and excise taxes for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years.
- The quarterly amounts of state tax revenue from the cannabis cultivation and excise taxes for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years.
- The comparative growth rates of sales and revenue from before and after the effective date of the act adding this section.
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature that if the revenues collected from the reduced excise tax on cannabis are projected to be insufficient to adequately fund the reasonable regulatory costs as well as the program funding allocations outlined in Proposition 64, the Legislature will consider enacting subsequent legislation restoring the rate of the excise tax to the rate that existed before the bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by California State Treasurer Fiona Ma.
Background.
Early History of Cannabis Regulation in California. Consumption of cannabis was first made lawful in California in 1996 when voters approved Proposition 215, or the Compassionate Use Act. Proposition 215 protected qualified patients and caregivers from prosecution relating to the possession and cultivation of cannabis for medicinal purposes, if recommended by a physician. The initiative prohibited physicians from being punished or denied any right or privilege for making a medicinal cannabis recommendation to a patient. Proposition 215 also included findings and declarations encouraging the federal and state governments to implement a plan to provide for the safe and affordable distribution of cannabis to patients with medical needs.
The regulatory scheme for medicinal cannabis was further refined by SB 420 (Vasconcellos) in 2003, which established the state’s Medical Marijuana Program (MMP.) Under the MMP, qualified patients were eligible to obtain a voluntary medical marijuana patient card, which could be used to verify that the patient or a caregiver had authorization to cultivate, possess, transport, or use medicinal cannabis. The MPP’s identification cards were intended to help law enforcement officers identify and verify that cardholders were allowed to cultivate, possess, or transport limited amounts of cannabis without being subject to arrest. The MMP also created protections for qualified patients and primary caregivers from prosecution for the formation of collectives and cooperatives for medicinal cannabis cultivation.
Without the adoption of a formal framework to provide for state licensure and regulation of medicinal cannabis, a proliferation of informally regulated cannabis collectives and cooperatives were largely left to the enforcement of local governments. As a result, a patchwork of local regulations was created with little statewide involvement. More restrictive laws and ordinances by cities and counties were ultimately upheld by the California Supreme Court in City of Riverside v. Inland Empire Patients (2013) 56 Cal. 4th 729, which held that state law did not expressly or implicitly limit the inherent authority of a local jurisdiction, by its own ordinances, to regulate the use of its land, including the authority to provide that facilities for the distribution of medicinal cannabis be prohibited from operating within its borders.
Even after several years of allowable cannabis cultivation and consumption under state law, a lack of a uniform regulatory framework led to persistent problems across the state. Cannabis’s continued illegality under the federal Controlled Substances Act, which classifies cannabis as a Schedule I drug ineligible for prescription, generated periodic enforcement activities by the United States Department of Justice. The constant threat of action by the federal government created apprehension among California’s cannabis community.
A document issued by the United States Attorney General in 2013 known as the “Cole memorandum” indicated that the existence of a strong and effective state regulatory system, and a cannabis operation’s compliance with such a system, could allay the threat of federal enforcement interests. Federal prosecutors were urged under the memo to review cannabis cases on a case-by-case basis and consider whether a cannabis operation was in compliance with a strong and effective state regulatory system prior to prosecution. The memo was followed by Congress’s passage of the Rohrabacher-Farr amendment, which prohibits the United States Department of Justice from interceding in state efforts to implement medicinal cannabis.
MCRSA. After several attempts to improve the state’s regulation of cannabis, the Legislature passed the Medical Marijuana Regulation and Safety Act—subsequently retitled the Medical Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act (MCRSA)—in 2015. MCRSA consisted of a package of legislation: AB 243 (Wood); AB 266 (Bonta, Cooley, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, and Wood); and SB 643 (McGuire). MCRSA established, for the first time, a comprehensive statewide licensing and regulatory framework for the cultivation, manufacture, transportation, testing, distribution, and sale of medicinal cannabis to be administered by the newly established BCC within the Department of Consumer Affairs, the CDPH, and the CDFA, with implementation relying on each agency’s area of expertise.
MCRSA vested authority for:
- The BCC to license and regulate dispensaries, distributors, transporters, and (subsequently) testing laboratories, and to provide oversight for the state’s regulatory framework;
- The CDPH to license and regulate manufacturers; and
- The CDFA to license and regulate cultivators.
While entrusting state agencies to promulgate extensive regulations governing the implementation of the state’s cannabis laws, MCRSA fully preserved local control. Under MCRSA, local governments may establish their own ordinances to regulate medicinal cannabis activity. Local jurisdictions may also choose to ban cannabis establishments altogether.
AUMA. Not long after the Legislature enacted MCRSA, California voters passed Proposition 64, the Adult Use of Marijuana Act (AUMA). The passage of the AUMA legalized cannabis for non-medicinal adult use in a private home or licensed business; allowed adults 21 and over to possess and give away up to approximately one ounce of cannabis and up to eight grams of concentrate; and permitted the personal cultivation of up to six plants. The law retained prohibitions against smoking in or operating a vehicle while under the effects of cannabis, possessing cannabis at a school or other child oriented facility while kids are present, growing in an unlocked or public place, and providing cannabis to minors.
The proponents of the AUMA sought to make use of much of the regulatory framework and authorities set out by MCRSA while making a few notable changes to the structure still being implemented. In addition, the AUMA approved by the voters adopted the January 1, 2018 deadline for state implementation of non-medicinal cannabis in addition to the regulations required in MCRSA that were scheduled to take effect on the same date. The same agencies given authority under MCRSA remained responsible for implementing regulations for adult use.
Under the AUMA, the BCC within the Department of Consumer Affairs continues to serve as the lead regulatory agency for all cannabis, both medicinal and non-medicinal. The AUMA includes 19 different license types compared to the original 17 in MCRSA, and provides the Department of Consumer Affairs (and the BCC) with exclusive authority to license and regulate the transportation of cannabis. The AUMA also authorizes vertical integration models which allows for the holding of multiple license types, as previously prohibited under MCRSA. Additionally, while MCRSA required both a state and local license to operate, the AUMA only stipulated a state license; however, the state is also directed not to issue a license to an applicant if it would “violate the provisions of any local ordinance or regulation.”
The language of the AUMA allows for legislative modifications that “implement” or “give practical effect” to the law by a majority vote. However, what constitutes “implementing” has been interpreted to be limited. Consequently, proposed changes to the voters’ intent in the AUMA require a two-thirds vote and of those, some may be deemed to require voter approval.
MAUCRSA. In the spring of 2017, SB 94 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review) was introduced to reconcile the distinct systems for the regulation, licensing, and enforcement of legal cannabis that had been established under the respective authorities of MCRSA and the AUMA. The single consolidated system established by the bill—known as the Medicinal and Adult-Use Cannabis Regulation and Safety Act (MAUCRSA)—created a unified series of cannabis laws and deleted redundant code sections no longer necessary due to the combination of the two systems. MAUCRSA also clarified a number of components, including but not limited to licensing, local control, taxation, testing, and edibles.
Regulations. On January 16, 2019, the state’s three cannabis licensing authorities—the BCC, the CDPH, and the CDFA—officially announced that the Office of Administrative Law had approved final cannabis regulations promulgated by the three agencies respectively. These final regulations replaced emergency regulations that had previously been in place, and made various changes to earlier requirements following the public rulemaking process. The adoption of final rules provided a sense of finality to the state’s long history in providing for the regulation of lawful cannabis sale and use.
Tax Revenue Allocations. Under MAUCRSA, a 15% excise tax is imposed on sales of cannabis and a tax on cannabis cultivation is imposed at a rate of $9.25 per dry-weight ounce of cannabis flowers and $2.75 per dry-weight ounce of cannabis leaves that are harvested and brought to market. These taxes are distinct from state sales and use taxes, which apply to recreational cannabis, as well as any taxes imposed by local governments. Excise tax and cultivation tax revenues are deposited into a special fund referred to as the California Cannabis Tax Fund and are then allocated for a variety of purposes in order of priority.
First, expenditures incurred by state agencies responsible for implementing cannabis laws are to be paid for through the Tax Fund. This includes reasonable costs incurred by the CDTFA for administering and collecting the taxes, not to exceed 4% revenue; reasonable costs incurred by the BCC, DCA, CDFA, and CDPH for licensing and enforcement programs; reasonable costs incurred by the Department of Fish and Wildlife, the State Water Resources Control Board, and the Department of Pesticide Regulation for carrying out their environmental protection duties under the state’s cannabis laws; and other state agencies. Allocations to reimburse these state entities shall only be made to the extent the entities are not otherwise reimbursed for their costs—e.g., the BCC, CDFA, and CDPH are largely reimbursed for their costs through the collection of cannabis license fees. (However, these fees are currently not being collected for temporary licenses.)
After state agency cost reimbursement, Tax Fund revenue is next allocated to fund a series of specific programs designated under Proposition 64. These programs are to be provided with precise amounts of funding totaling $25 million and are to be appropriated annually until the 2028-29 fiscal year. In order of priority, the disbursements are as follows:
- $10 million to a public university in California selected by the BCC to research and evaluate the implementation and effect of legal cannabis and make recommendations to the Legislature and Governor regarding possible changes to the law. Universities receiving these funds shall publicly report on their findings at least every two years. The research topics may include but are not limited to:
- Impacts on public health, including health costs associated with cannabis use, as well as whether cannabis use is associated with an increase or decrease in use of alcohol or other drugs.
- The impact of treatment for maladaptive cannabis use and the effectiveness of different treatment programs.
- Public safety issues related to cannabis use, including studying the effectiveness of the packaging and labeling requirements and advertising and marketing restrictions contained in the act at preventing underage access to and use of cannabis and cannabis products, and studying the health-related effects among users of varying potency levels of cannabis and cannabis products.
- Cannabis use rates, maladaptive use rates for adults and youth, and diagnosis rates of cannabis-related substance use disorders.
- Cannabis market prices, illicit market prices, tax structures and rates, including an evaluation of how to best tax cannabis based on potency, and the structure and function of licensed cannabis businesses.
- Whether additional protections are needed to prevent unlawful monopolies or anti-competitive behavior from occurring in the adult-use cannabis industry and, if so, recommendations as to the most effective measures for preventing such behavior.
- The economic impacts in the private and public sectors, including, but not necessarily limited to, job creation, workplace safety, revenues, taxes generated for state and local budgets, and criminal justice impacts, including, but not necessarily limited to, impacts on law enforcement and public resources, short and long term consequences of involvement in the criminal justice system, and state and local government agency administrative costs and revenue.
- Whether the regulatory agencies tasked with implementing and enforcing the state’s cannabis laws are doing so consistent with the purposes of Proposition 64, and whether different agencies might do so more effectively.
- Environmental issues related to cannabis production and the criminal prohibition of cannabis production.
- The geographic location, structure, and function of licensed cannabis businesses, and demographic data, including race, ethnicity, and gender, of license holders.
- The outcomes achieved by the changes in criminal penalties made under Proposition 64 for cannabis-related offenses, and the outcomes of the juvenile justice system, in particular, probation-based treatments and the frequency of up-charging illegal possession of cannabis or cannabis products to a more serious offense.
- $3 million to the California Highway Patrol (CHP) to establish and adopt protocols to determine whether a driver is operating a vehicle while impaired, including impairment by the use of cannabis or cannabis products, and to establish and adopt protocols setting forth best practices to assist law enforcement agencies. The CHP may hire personnel to establish the protocols specified in this subdivision. In addition, the CHP may make grants to public and private research institutions for the purpose of developing technology for determining when a driver is operating a vehicle while impaired, including impairment by the use of cannabis or cannabis products.
- $10 million to the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz), which subsequently increases by an additional $10 million each fiscal year until reaching a total disbursement of $50 million annually beginning in the 2022-23 fiscal year. GO-Biz is instructed to use this money to, in consultation with the Labor and Workforce Development Agency and the State Department of Social Services, administer a community reinvestments grants program to local health departments and at least 50% to qualified community-based nonprofit organizations to support job placement, mental health treatment, substance use disorder treatment, system navigation services, legal services to address barriers to reentry, and linkages to medical care for communities disproportionately affected by past federal and state drug policies. GO-Biz is required to solicit input from community-based job skills, job placement, and legal service providers with relevant expertise as to the administration of the grants program. In addition, GO-Biz is required to periodically evaluate the programs it is funding to determine the effectiveness of the programs, shall not spend more than 4% for administrative costs related to implementation, evaluation, and oversight of the programs, and shall award grants annually, beginning no later than January 1, 2020.
- $2 million to the University of California San Diego Center for Medicinal Cannabis Research to further the objectives of the center, including the enhanced understanding of the efficacy and adverse effects of cannabis as a pharmacological agent.
After each of the above allocations have been made in sequential order, totaling $25 million, any remaining revenue in the Tax Fund is divided into sub-trust accounts according to a percentage outlined by Proposition 64. The division is as follows:
- 60% of the remaining revenue is deposited in the Youth Education, Prevention, Early Intervention and Treatment Account, and disbursed by the Controller to the Department of Health Care Services for programs for youth that are designed to educate about and to prevent substance use disorders and to prevent harm from substance use.
- 20% of the remaining revenue is deposited in the Environmental Restoration and Protection Account, and disbursed by the Controller as follows:
- To the Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation for the cleanup, remediation, and restoration of environmental damage in watersheds affected by cannabis cultivation and related activities including, but not limited to, damage that occurred prior to enactment of Proposition 64, and to support local partnerships for this purpose. The Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation may distribute a portion of the funds they receive from the Environmental Restoration and Protection Account through grants.
- To the Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation for the stewardship and operation of state-owned wildlife habitat areas and state park units in a manner that discourages and prevents the illegal cultivation, production, sale, and use of cannabis and cannabis products on public lands, and to facilitate the investigation, enforcement, and prosecution of illegal cultivation, production, sale, and use of cannabis or cannabis products on public lands.
- To the Department of Fish and Wildlife to assist in funding the watershed enforcement program and multiagency taskforce to facilitate the investigation, enforcement, and prosecution of these offenses and to ensure the reduction of adverse impacts of cannabis cultivation, production, sale, and use on fish and wildlife habitats throughout the state.
- To the Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation for the cleanup, remediation, and restoration of environmental damage in watersheds affected by cannabis cultivation and related activities including, but not limited to, damage that occurred prior to enactment of Proposition 64, and to support local partnerships for this purpose. The Department of Fish and Wildlife and the Department of Parks and Recreation may distribute a portion of the funds they receive from the Environmental Restoration and Protection Account through grants.
- 20% of the remaining revenue is deposited in the State and Local Government Law Enforcement Account and disbursed by the Controller as follows:
- To the CHP for conducting training programs for detecting, testing and enforcing laws against driving under the influence of alcohol and other drugs, including driving under the influence of cannabis.
- To the CHP to fund internal programs and grants to qualified nonprofit organizations and local governments for education, prevention, and enforcement of laws related to driving under the influence of alcohol and other drugs, including cannabis; programs that help enforce traffic laws, educate the public in traffic safety, provide varied and effective means of reducing fatalities, injuries, and economic losses from collisions; and for the purchase of equipment related to enforcement of laws related to driving under the influence of alcohol and other drugs, including cannabis.
- To the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC) for making grants to local governments to assist with law enforcement, fire protection, or other local programs addressing public health and safety associated with the implementation of Proposition 64. The BSCC shall not make any grants to local governments which have banned the cultivation, including personal cultivation or retail sale of cannabis.
- The Department of Finance shall determine the allocation of revenues between the agencies; provided, however, beginning in the 2022–23 fiscal year the amount allocated to CHP for training programs shall not be less than $10 million annually and the amount allocated to the CHP for grants shall not be less than $40 million.
- To the CHP for conducting training programs for detecting, testing and enforcing laws against driving under the influence of alcohol and other drugs, including driving under the influence of cannabis.
Cannabis Tax Revenues. One of the principal arguments made by the proponents of Proposition 64 was that legalizing cannabis would result in significant tax revenue for use by state and local governments. In its analysis of Proposition 64, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) stated that the initiative’s fiscal effects were “subject to significant uncertainty.” However, the LAO suggested in the Proposition 64 voter guide that over time, the legal sale of legalized cannabis could result in state and local tax revenues the LAO said “could eventually range from the high hundreds of millions of dollars to over $1 billion annually.”
However, actual tax revenues collected so far have come in well below what early projections indicated. The Governor’s Budget Summary for the 2018-19 fiscal year stated that “cannabis excise taxes are expected to generate $175 million in 2017-18 and $643 million in 2018-19.” The January 10, 2019 release of the Governor’s Proposed Budget predicts that approximately $355 million in excise tax revenue would be collected by the end of the fiscal year – nearly half of what was originally anticipated. This situation is not unique to California; for example, Massachusetts officials projected $63 million in tax revenue for the first year of that state’s cannabis legalization, but as of March 1, the state had collected only $5.9 million.
Given that fewer businesses have entered into the newly licensed cannabis industry than anticipated and many jurisdictions still currently ban cannabis locally, the black market continues to widely operate. Supporters of this bill argue that because the high tax rate on cannabis businesses is a leading cause for this slow industry growth, the tax levy would ultimately lead to a larger scale of taxable activity and thus greater revenue. Supporters point to how when the State of Washington first legalized cannabis, it initially had higher tax rates; when that state lowered their rate and simplified their system, the state eventually began generating greater revenue. New Frontier Data provided estimates for an earlier iteration of this bill that “a 4% reduction in the state excise tax would expect to see an increase in legal participation by 119,000 consumers, generating an estimated additional $278 million in retail revenue.” The following chart from New Frontier Data is sometimes used to support this claim:
However, the State of Washington is not a perfect allegory for California. Originally, Initiative 502 levied a 25% tax on cannabis at three separate points in the supply chain: a 25% tax on producer sales to processors, another 25% tax on processor sales to retailers, and a third 25% tax on retailer sales to customers. The change made in Washington was to replace this three-tiered system of taxation with a single 37% tax on final sales of cannabis. Not only was this a much more significant reform to the state’s legal scheme for cannabis, but both the resulting excise tax rate of 37% remains much higher than California’s 15% rate.
It is also worth noting that state-level taxes on the cultivation and sale of cannabis represent only a portion of the overall effective tax rate for any given cannabis operation. Under Proposition 64 and MAUCRSA, local governments are permitted to levy their own taxes on a cannabis business, and many jurisdictions have imposed additional taxes that greatly exceed the assessments adjusted by this bill. For example, the County of Monterey imposes its own cultivation tax of $15 per square foot. The City of Berkeley cut its local excise tax on cannabis sales from 10% to 5%. In 2017, the City of Campbell approved a measure to impose an initial tax of 7% on cannabis businesses that could be raised through local ordinance to a tax rate as high as 15%.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 3157 (Lackey) was substantially similar to this bill. This bill was held under submission on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
California State Treasurer Fiona Ma is sponsor of the bill. Treasurer Ma argues that “given that we now have seen a year of severe under-collection of expected tax revenue and that the black market still exists, it is understood that excessive taxation is an obstacle to establish a fully viable legal market. Compliant businesses are at a significant disadvantage, and this high tax rate incentivizes businesses to stay underground.” Treasurer Ma characterizes the bill as “imperative to temporarily lessen California’s total tax on cannabis, and give these businesses and the State enough time to fully implement Prop 64.”
The California Association of County Treasurers and Tax Collectors (CACTTC) supports the bill. The CACTTC states that “the taxes imposed by Proposition 64 were substantial, and they have disincentivized cannabis consumers and operators from engaging with the legal market. This significant tax burden has made it difficult for California to establish a robust legal and regulated cannabis market while also making it difficult for compliant businesses to compete with the illegal market that is willing to operate outside the state’s regulatory framework.” The CACTTC believes that lowering the state tax rate “will lead to more individuals and businesses engaging in the state’s legal cannabis market and reduce participation in the illicit cannabis market.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The County Behavioral Health Directors Association of California (CBHDA) opposes this bill. According to the CBHDA, “60 percent of the remaining tax on cannabis and cannabis products, after regulation, research and community reinvestment funds are allocated, would be directed toward youth substance use disorder prevention and treatment. With the passage of AB 286, the generated funds from the excise tax would be significantly reduced.” The CBHDA is concerned that “with a reduction in funding, at-risk youth in California will not access vital substance use disorder services and could experience adverse lifetime outcomes.”
The California Society of Addiction Medicine (CSAM) also opposes the bill. CSAM states that “there is no empirical evidence that the suspension of the cultivation tax and the reduction of the excise tax would increase sales of cannabis products. However, these changes in taxes would take away valuable resources needed for substance abuse education, early intervention, and addiction treatment. A critical reason Californians voted for Proposition 64 was the promise that California would finally fund education, prevention, early intervention and treatment services for youth. AB 286 would break that promise.”
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
Impact on State’s Ability to Fund Regulatory Obligations and Proposition 64 Programs. In order to fund the state’s regulatory scheme for cannabis prior to the collection of license fees and taxes, the State of California transferred $135 million in General Fund loans to the Cannabis Control Fund. These loans must be paid back. While much of the state agency regulatory costs are intended to be reimbursed through license fees, these fees are not currently being collected from businesses still operating with temporary licenses. It is anticipated that the language regarding cannabis excise taxes making state agency reimbursement a priority for the Tax Fund will be relied upon for these obligations. A total of $200.6 million in costs was anticipated for regulatory agencies in the 2018/19 fiscal year in the January 10, 2019 Governor’s proposed budget, as well as $2.9 million for the CDTFA’s cannabis tax enforcement program. The Governor’s budget summary states that “the Administration is deferring allocations for Proposition 64 programs until the May Revision, when more updated revenue data will be available.”
Following the reimbursement of reasonable costs incurred by regulatory entities, Proposition 64 was passed by the voters with the promise that new programs would receive specified amounts of funding. As previously discussed, a total of $25 million is allocated for research, education, substance use disorder treatment, and public safety programs. If cannabis tax revenues are insufficient to fund this $25 million, it could be argued that the intent of the voters in favor of Proposition 64 is not being fulfilled. This is not including the funding intended for additional programs funded through revenue in excess of the $25 million in specified allocations.
In the short term, it is overwhelmingly likely that lowering state-level taxes on cannabis will result in even lower overall revenue to the state. This bill would make an arguably risky investment in the legal market by sacrificing additional revenue over the next several years in hopes of stimulating a languid lawful industry. While there is significant support for that approach to combating the black market, the bill may nevertheless be further jeopardizing one of the key reasons that California voters were given for supporting Proposition 64.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California State Treasurer Fiona Ma (Sponsor)
CalAsian Chamber of Commerce
California Association of County Treasurers & Tax Collectors
California Cannabis Industry Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
City of Emeryville
Conference of California Bar Associations
Continuum Distribution
Eaze Solutions, Inc.
Humboldt County Growers Alliance
Monterey County Cannabis Industry Association
Osiris Ventures DBA VMCM
Santa Cruz County
Southern California Coalition
United Cannabis Business Association
United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
California Society of Addiction Medicine
County Behavioral Health Directors Association
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Date of Hearing: April 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 286 (
Author:Bonta) – As amended Ver:April 3, 2019
FOR VOTE ONLY
2/3rds vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Taxation: cannabis
SUMMARY: Reduces the excise tax rate on cannabis and cannabis products from 15% to 11%, and suspends the imposition of the cultivation tax, on or after the operative date of this bill and before June 1, 2022. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes findings and declarations that the provisions of this bill further the purpose and intent of the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (AUMA), and comply with the requirements of Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41.
- Reduces, on and after the effective date of this bill, and before July 1, 2022, the excise tax from 15% to 11% of the average market price of any retail sale by a cannabis retailer. The excise tax rate reverts back to 15% on and after July 1, 2022.
- Suspends the cultivation tax, on and after the effective date of this bill, and before July 1, 2022. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (DTF) may adjust the cultivation tax rates for inflation, which apply to the excise tax on flowers and leaves, on or after January 1, 2020.
- Requires the following to be reported to the Legislature by August 1, 2022:
- The number of businesses that applied for licenses from the bureau and the Department of Food and Agriculture annually for the years 2018 through 2021;
- The number of businesses that were issued licenses by the bureau and the Department of Food and Agriculture annually for the years 2018 through 2021;
- The number of businesses that applied for licenses from the bureau and the Department of Food and Agriculture in the years 2018 and 2019 against those applied for in the years 2020 and 2021; and,
- The number of businesses that were issued licenses by the bureau and the Department of Food and Agriculture in the years 2018 and 2019 against those issued in the years 2020 and 2021.
- Requires the following to be reported to the Legislature by August 1, 2022:
- The annual amount of total sales of cannabis and cannabis products by licensed retailers for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years;
- The quarterly amount of total sales of cannabis and cannabis products by licensed retailers for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years;
- The annual amount of state tax revenue from the cannabis cultivation and excise taxes for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years;
- The quarterly amounts of state tax revenue from the cannabis cultivation and excise taxes for the 2017–18, 2018–19, 2019–20, and 2020–21 fiscal years; and,
- The comparative growth rates of sales and revenue from before and after the effective date of the act adding this section.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy. However, this bill shall become operative on the first day of the first calendar quarter commencing more than 30 days after the effective date of this date.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the consumption of recreational cannabis by individuals over 21 years of age, referred to as adult-use cannabis, under AUMA.
- Authorizes the Legislature to amend AUMA to further the purposes and intent of the act with a 2/3 vote of the Legislature, except as provided.
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling tangible personal property (TPP), absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in California.
- Imposes a complementary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of TPP purchased from any retailer. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser, and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to a retailer registered to collect the California use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax, unless the use is exempted. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the DTF.
- Imposes a cannabis excise tax upon purchasers of cannabis or cannabis products sold in this state at the rate of 15% of the average market price of any retail sale by a cannabis retailer.
- Imposes a cultivation tax on all harvested cannabis that enters the commercial market upon all cultivators. The tax is imposed at the following rates:
- $9.25 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis flower;
- $2.75 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis leaves; and,
- $1.29 per ounce on a fresh cannabis plant.
FISCAL EFFECT: It is estimated that this bill will result in revenue losses of $227 million in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, $313 million in FY 2020-21, and $365 million in FY 2021-22[1].
COMMENTS:
- The author's office has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
The primary goal of AB 286 is to reduce the size of the state's black market for cannabis. The black market continues to undercut businesses that are complying with state regulations and doing things the right way. In the first year of collecting cannabis taxes, the state fell short by over $100 million in projected tax revenue.
AB 286 will temporarily reduce the tax burden on these licensed operators to keep customers at licensed businesses and help ensure the regulated market survives and thrives. This very strategy has been shown to actually increase overall tax revenue in other states. Once the legal marketplace has established its roots, the tax rates will return to the prescribed levels set in Prop 64.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: In November 2016, California voters approved Proposition 64, the AUMA, which legalized the recreational use of cannabis. AUMA created a statutory framework for the state to regulate recreational cannabis and imposed taxes on the sale of both medical and recreational cannabis. Specifically, beginning on or after January 1, 2018, a 15% excise tax is imposed upon purchasers of cannabis and cannabis products, and a cultivation tax is imposed upon cannabis cultivators on all harvested cannabis that enters the commercial market. The cultivation tax is set at $9.25 per dry ounce of cannabis flowers, $2.75 per dry ounce of cannabis leaves, and $1.29 per ounce of fresh cannabis plant. Immature plants, including clones and seeds, are excluded from the cultivation tax. Additionally, beginning on November 9, 2016, medical cannabis, which was subject to the sales tax, is now exempt from the sales tax if a patient furnishes a valid Medical Marijuana Identification Card.
- California's cannabis market: According to a report recently published by Arcview Market Research, California cultivators produced about 13.5 million pounds of cannabis in 2016, but California only consumed about 2.5 million pounds[2]. The remaining 11 million pounds is believed to have been shipped to illicit markets elsewhere. It is estimated that California consumers will spend about $9.2 billion on cannabis products in 2018, but only an estimated $3.7 billion will be spent on legal cannabis products. Clearly, most of the California cannabis market is still illegal; California has the largest and the most developed illicit market in the nation. This could create problems as California attempts to bring the black market under regulation. According to the report, a significant problem facing the legalization of the market is the high tax burden on cannabis products and the complex regulatory scheme. It is believed that these two factors will disadvantage legal sellers by as much as 77% on pricing compared to well- established black market sellers.
- Consumer sensitivity: If a consumer's behavior changes significantly with a change in price, the demand for that product is considered to be elastic. If a consumer's demand changes little when prices change, the demand for that product is considered inelastic. It has been assumed that the demand for cannabis is inelastic, and in fact studies have shown that cannabis is inelastic when compared to other substitutes[3]. However, when comparing the regulated cannabis market to the illicit cannabis market, a report by Whitney Economics shows that consumers are extremely sensitive to prices[4]. Consumers will go to great lengths to purchase cannabis products from the illicit market if the price difference between the regulated and illicit markets begins to diverge, even slightly. In fact, Whitney Economics found that a 5% increase in price will decrease demand in the regulated market by 11.2% to 12.0%[5].
The Sacramento Bee recently reported that California is not meeting revenue projections for commercial cannabis[6]. In the first two months of legalization, Californians bought $339 million worth of cannabis products, about 13% less than expected. Many in the industry are blaming high taxes, regulation, and the ease with which consumers can buy products from the gray market. According to Kristi Knoblich, board president of the California Cannabis Industry Association and co-founder of Kiva Confections, a manufacturer of edible cannabis products, "Sales are happening but they're not happening in the regulated market.[7]" As an example of how large the illicit market is, the Sacramento Bee reported that in February of 2018, 6,000 dispensaries and delivery services were listed on Weed Maps[8], but the state had only issued licenses for 580 dispensaries and delivery services at that time.
- What does this bill do? This bill suspends the cultivation tax and reduces the excise tax from 15% to 11% for a period of about three years. The goal, as stated by the author, is to allow time for cannabis businesses and consumers to transition from the black market into the regulated market. The elasticity of cannabis suggests that such a reduction could have a positive effect in encouraging more consumers to purchase from regulated dispensaries since the price difference between the illicit and regulated markets would be smaller as a result of this bill. However, as noted in Arcview Market's research, California's tax is in line with other states allowing for the use of cannabis. However, a big factor in the 77% premium on legal cannabis is the cost of regulatory compliance. If the goal is to encourage broader regulation of the market, the author may also wish to consider making changes to the regulatory scheme.
- Furthering the purpose of AUMA? To properly amend the AUMA, changes require a 2/3rds vote of the Legislature and the amendments must further the purpose and intent of the AUMA. Despite having findings and declarations that the changes made by this bill further the AUMA's purpose, it is not clear that suspending the cultivation tax and reducing the excise tax, even for a specified period of time, is in line with the intent of the voters to tax and regulate recreational use of cannabis. As such, the changes made by this bill may be subject to legal challenges.
- Committee's Tax Expenditure Policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added R&TC Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure proposals comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements. This bill, as currently drafted, complies with R&TC Section 41.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to the new policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean ten years. This bill provides a rate reduction for about three years.
- Previous legislation: AB 3157 (Lackey), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 3157 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's Suspense File.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
This revenue estimate assumes that the price elasticity of demand for cannabis is -.025, which seems appropriate when comparing cannabis to other substitutes. However, this bill appears to encourage consumers to shift from the illicit market to the regulated market. At least one study has shown that the price elasticity between these two markets is between -2.24 to -2.4 (Whitney Economics, Taxation and the Effects on the Illicit Cannabis Market, 2016). The revenue estimates may be substantially different if one assumes the latter figures. ↑
Arcview Market Research, California: The Golden Opportunity? ↑
Davis, A., and Nichols, M. The Price Elasticity of Marijuana Demand, University of Nevada, Reno ↑
Supra, Taxation and the Effects on the Illicit Cannabis Market ↑
Id. ↑
http://www.sacbee.com/news/state/california/california-weed/article208196024.html. ↑
Id. ↑
Weedmaps is an online legal cannabis community that allows users to review and discuss cannabis strains and local dispensaries. Weedmaps provides listing services for medical canncabis dispensaries, doctors' offices and delivery services throughout the United States. The site accepts reviews from any patient in medical cannabis states. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 286 (
Author:Bonta) – As Introduced Ver:January 28, 2019
TESTIMONY ONLY
2/3rds vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Taxation: cannabis
SUMMARY: Reduces the excise tax rate on cannabis and cannabis products from 15% to 11%, and suspends the imposition of the cultivation tax, on or after the operative date of this bill and before June 1, 2022. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes findings and declarations that the provisions of this bill further the purpose and intent of the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (AUMA).
- Reduces, on and after the effective date of this bill, and before June 1, 2022, the excise tax from 15% to 11% of the average market price of any retail sale by a cannabis retailer. The excise tax rate reverts back to 15% on and after June 1, 2022.
- Suspends the cultivation tax, on and after the effective date of this bill, and before June 1, 2022. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (DTF) may adjust the cultivation tax rates for inflation, which apply to the excise tax on flowers and leaves, on or after January 1, 2020.
- Takes effect immediately as a tax levy. However, this bill shall become operative on the first day of the first calendar quarter commencing more than 30 days after the effective date of this date.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the consumption of recreational cannabis by individuals over 21 years of age, referred to as adult-use cannabis, under AUMA.
- Authorizes the Legislature to amend AUMA to further the purposes and intent of the act with a 2/3 vote of the Legislature, except as provided.
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling tangible personal property (TPP), absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in California.
- Imposes a complementary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of TPP purchased from any retailer. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser, and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to a retailer registered to collect the California use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax, unless the use is exempted. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the DTF.
- Imposes a cannabis excise tax upon purchasers of cannabis or cannabis products sold in this state at the rate of 15% of the average market price of any retail sale by a cannabis retailer.
- Imposes a cultivation tax on all harvested cannabis that enters the commercial market upon all cultivators. The tax is imposed at the following rates:
- $9.25 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis flower;
- $2.75 per dry-weight ounce on cannabis leaves; and,
- $1.29 per ounce on a fresh cannabis plant.
FISCAL EFFECT: It is estimated that this bill will result in revenue losses of $227 million in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, $313 million in FY 2020-21, and $365 million in FY 2021-22[1].
COMMENTS:
- The author's office has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
The primary goal of AB 286 is to reduce the size of the state's black market for cannabis. The black market continues to undercut businesses that are complying with state regulations and doing things the right way. In the first year of collecting cannabis taxes, the state fell short by over $100 million in projected tax revenue.
AB 286 will temporarily reduce the tax burden on these licensed operators to keep customers at licensed businesses and help ensure the regulated market survives and thrives. This very strategy has been shown to actually increase overall tax revenue in other states. Once the legal marketplace has established its roots, the tax rates will return to the prescribed levels set in Prop 64.
- Supporters of this bill state that "[e]ver since voters passed Proposition 64 in November 2016, the now-legal cannabis industry has faced a bevy of regulatory questions that relate to every aspect of the industry. Currently, one of the largest issues that this new industry is facing is black market operators. California's current tax rate on cannabis related production is often listed as one of the reasons why a legitimate business has a hard time competing with black market sources. Not only does this harm small businesses in California, it also poses a risk to consumers as the black market sources cannot be regulated for safety."
- Opponents state that "[t]here is no empirical evidence that the suspension of the cultivation tax and the reduction of the excise tax would increase sales of cannabis products. However, these changes in taxes would take away valuable resources needed for substance abuse education, early intervention, and addiction treatment. A critical reason Californians voted for Proposition 64 was the promise that California would finally fund education, prevention, early intervention and treatment services for youth. AB 286 would break that promise."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: In November 2016, California voters approved Proposition 64, the AUMA, which legalized the recreational use of cannabis. AUMA created a statutory framework for the state to regulate recreational cannabis and imposed taxes on the sale of both medical and recreational cannabis. Specifically, beginning on or after January 1, 2018, a 15% excise tax is imposed upon purchasers of cannabis and cannabis products, and a cultivation tax is imposed upon cannabis cultivators on all harvested cannabis that enters the commercial market. The cultivation tax is set at $9.25 per dry ounce of cannabis flowers, $2.75 per dry ounce of cannabis leaves, and $1.29 per ounce of fresh cannabis plant. Immature plants, including clones and seeds, are excluded from the cultivation tax. Additionally, beginning on November 9, 2016, medical cannabis, which was subject to the sales tax, is now exempt from the sales tax if a patient furnishes a valid Medical Marijuana Identification Card.
- California's cannabis market: According to a report recently published by Arcview Market Research, California cultivators produced about 13.5 million pounds of cannabis in 2016, but California only consumed about 2.5 million pounds[2]. The remaining 11 million pounds is believed to have been shipped to illicit markets elsewhere. It is estimated that California consumers will spend about $9.2 billion on cannabis products in 2018, but only an estimated $3.7 billion will be spent on legal cannabis products. Clearly, most of the California cannabis market is still illegal; California has the largest and the most developed illicit market in the nation. This could create problems as California attempts to bring the black market under regulation. According to the report, a significant problem facing the legalization of the market is the high tax burden on cannabis products and the complex regulatory scheme. It is believed that these two factors will disadvantage legal sellers by as much as 77% on pricing compared to well- established black market sellers.
- Consumer sensitivity: If a consumer's behavior changes significantly with a change in price, the demand for that product is considered to be elastic. If a consumer's demand changes little when prices change, the demand for that product is considered inelastic. It has been assumed that the demand for cannabis is inelastic, and in fact studies have shown that cannabis is inelastic when compared to other substitutes[3]. However, when comparing the regulated cannabis market to the illicit cannabis market, a report by Whitney Economics shows that consumers are extremely sensitive to prices[4]. Consumers will go to great lengths to purchase cannabis products from the illicit market if the price difference between the regulated and illicit markets begins to diverge, even slightly. In fact, Whitney Economics found that a 5% increase in price will decrease demand in the regulated market by 11.2% to 12.0%[5].
The Sacramento Bee recently reported that California is not meeting revenue projections for commercial cannabis[6]. In the first two months of legalization, Californians bought $339 million worth of cannabis products, about 13% less than expected. Many in the industry are blaming high taxes, regulation, and the ease with which consumers can buy products from the gray market. According to Kristi Knoblich, board president of the California Cannabis Industry Association and co-founder of Kiva Confections, a manufacturer of edible cannabis products, "Sales are happening but they're not happening in the regulated market.[7]" As an example of how large the illicit market is, the Sacramento Bee reported that in February of 2018, 6,000 dispensaries and delivery services were listed on Weed Maps[8], but the state had only issued licenses for 580 dispensaries and delivery services at that time.
- What does this bill do? This bill suspends the cultivation tax and reduces the excise tax from 15% to 11% for a period of about three years. The goal, as stated by the author, is to allow time for cannabis businesses and consumers to transition from the black market into the regulated market. The elasticity of cannabis suggests that such a reduction could have a positive effect in encouraging more consumers to purchase from regulated dispensaries since the price difference between the illicit and regulated markets would be smaller as a result of this bill. However, as noted in Arcview Market's research, California's tax is in line with other states allowing for the use of cannabis. However, a big factor in the 77% premium on legal cannabis is the cost of regulatory compliance. If the goal is to encourage broader regulation of the market, the author may also wish to consider making changes to the regulatory scheme.
- Administrative concerns: Having two tax rates in the same quarterly reporting period results in reporting errors and increases costs to update computer programs and to develop a tax return that includes multiple tax rates. As such, the author may want to modify the inoperative date from June 1, 2022 to the first day of the next quarter – July 1, 2022.
- Furthering the purpose of AUMA? To properly amend the AUMA, changes require a 2/3rds vote of the Legislature and the amendments must further the purpose and intent of the AUMA. Despite having findings and declarations that the changes made by this bill further the AUMA's purpose, it is not clear that suspending the cultivation tax and reducing the excise tax, even for a specified period of time, is in line with the intent of the voters to tax and regulate recreational use of cannabis. As such, the changes made by this bill may be subject to legal challenges.
- Committee's Tax Expenditure Policy: SB 1335 (Leno), Chapter 845, Statutes of 2014, added R&TC Section 41, which recognized that the Legislature should apply the same level of review used for government spending programs to tax credits introduced on or after January 1, 2015. This Committee has recently adopted a new policy, requiring that all new tax expenditure proposals comply with the requirements of R&TC Section 41. A tax expenditure proposal must outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements. This bill does not currently contain clear goals, purposes, or objectives that this expenditure is intended to achieve, nor does it contain performance measurement indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring the success of this tax expenditure.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to the new policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean ten years. This bill provides a rate reduction for about three years.
- Previous legislation: AB 3157 (Lackey), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 3157 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's Suspense File.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
State Treasurer, Fiona Ma (Sponsor)
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Cannabis Industry Association
City of San Leandro
CMG/Caliva
Continuum Distribution
Critical Mind
CURA, Cannabis Solutions
Humboldt County Growers Alliance
National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws, California
Nor Cal Cannabis Company
Southern California Coalition
United Cannabis Business Association
Opposition
California Society of Addiction Medicine
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
This revenue estimate assumes that the price elasticity of demand for cannabis is -.025, which seems appropriate when comparing cannabis to other substitutes. However, this bill appears to encourage consumers to shift from the illicit market to the regulated market. At least one study has shown that the price elasticity between these two markets is between -2.24 to -2.4 (Whitney Economics, Taxation and the Effects on the Illicit Cannabis Market, 2016). The revenue estimates may be substantially different if one assumes the latter figures. ↑
Arcview Market Research, California: The Golden Opportunity? ↑
Davis, A., and Nichols, M. The Price Elasticity of Marijuana Demand, University of Nevada, Reno ↑
Supra, Taxation and the Effects on the Illicit Cannabis Market ↑
Id. ↑
http://www.sacbee.com/news/state/california/california-weed/article208196024.html. ↑
Id. ↑
Weedmaps is an online legal cannabis community that allows users to review and discuss cannabis strains and local dispensaries. Weedmaps provides listing services for medical canncabis dispensaries, doctors' offices and delivery services throughout the United States. The site accepts reviews from any patient in medical cannabis states. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):