AB 2973: Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency: the Office of Immigration and Refugee Affairs.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-02-21
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 3, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 12, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (May 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 24, 2020 | Read first time. |
| Feb 22, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 23. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 11, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2973
Author:(Santiago) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2020
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 8 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill creates an agency within state government called the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency (IRAA).
- Creates the Immigrant and Refugee Integration Fund within the State Treasury.
- Renames the Director of the Statewide Immigrant Integration the Director of Statewide Immigrant and Refugee Integration and places that office under the authority of the Secretary of the IRAA.
- Transfers to the IRAA any property of any office, agency or department that relates to functions transferred to the IRAA from other departments.
- Provides that the Agency is headed by a Secretary, who is appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation.
- States the Secretary may appoint two Chief Deputy Secretaries, subject to Senate confirmation.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown, but possible costs (GF) may be between three and eight million dollars annually for staff and infrastructure and to the extent the IRAA offers immigrant-related services and engages with other state and local agencies to coordinate those services. The IRAA appears similar in scope to the Workforce Development Agency. The 2019-20 GF budget allocation for the WDA was approximately $5.5 million dollars.
Additionally, this bill provides that, where appropriate, funds allocated for other immigrant-related services will be transferred to IRAA. This may result in additional GF costs to backfill other departmental funds re-directed to IRAA given that this bill does not eliminate immigration-related duties performed by, for example, the Department of Social Services (DSS) Immigration Services Unit and Refugee Programs Bureau. The 2019-2020 Budget Act allocated approximately $75 million dollars from the GF to various state agencies for immigration-related services. The 2020-21 proposed budget allocated $65 million dollars to DSS for immigration services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose and Background. According to the author:
In order to wholly welcome immigrants to California and achieve full integration, the state must be bold and proactive in its approach to offering direct services while addressing rapid policy changes impacting immigrants and refugees.
SB 84 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 25, Statutes of 2015, implemented the Statewide Director of Immigration Integration to serve as lead on planning and coordination of immigration and policies in California. Additionally, the Department of Social Services operates the Immigration Services Unit and the Refugee Programs Bureau aimed at providing legal services, outreach and other integration efforts. This bill would transfer DSS resources to the IRAA.
- Spending Restrictions. The COVID-19 pandemic has pushed California into a recession that is likely to last several years. According to the Governor’s May Revise, California is facing a revenue deficit of $54 million dollars in the 2019-2020 FY.
On April 30, 2020, the Department of Finance advised all state departments to reduce costs and spending arguing that “reduced economic activity is expected to result in a recession.” All state departments were instructed to reduce certain employee benefits and are prohibited from entering into any new service contracts or modifying existing contracts. This bill creates the IRAA and transfers immigration services provided by other departments to the IRAA. That would likely require re-negotiation of existing agreements and create significant costs. - Related Legislation. AB 1113 (Chiu) would have created an agency in state government called the Office of Immigrant and Refugee Affairs (OIRA). AB 1113 was held on this Committee’s Suspense file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2973
Author:(Santiago) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2020
SUBJECT: Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency: the Office of Immigration and Refugee Affairs
KEY ISSUE: WOULD THE POWERS EXERCISED BY A CABINET-LEVEL STATE AGENCY TASKED WITH COORDINATING AND IMPROVING EXISTING AND FUTURE PROGRAMS TO ASSIST IMMIGRANTS AND REFUGEES BE PREEMPTED BY THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT’S PLENARY POWERS IN THE AREAS OF IMMIGRATION AND FOREIGN RELATIONS?
SYNOPSIS
This bill, sponsored by the Coalition for Humane Immigration Rights, would establish a new Cabinet-level agency in state government, entitled the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency. The agency’s responsibilities would include coordinating immigrant and refugee services among state agencies; assisting state agencies in evaluating the effectiveness and reach of their services; making policy recommendations to the Governor and Legislature; and coordinating with local immigrant affairs offices to maximize the impact of the services they provide.
In our system of federalism, state governments are generally free to exercise their powers in support of the health, safety, and welfare of their residents, unless the federal government has reserved such an area to itself, has regulated that area so pervasively that there is no room for state action in the area, or has rendered it impossible to comply with both state and federal mandates in the area, or if state law would create an obstacle to the achievement of the federal government’s objectives. Here, the powers to be exercised by the proposed agency are meant to enhance the welfare of immigrants and refugees in California and thus fall squarely within the scope of California’s authority. As a result, there appears to be no basis for arguing that the proposed agency’s powers are preempted by the federal government’s supreme authority in the areas of immigration and foreign relations. This well-intentioned bill is supported by immigrant rights advocacy organizations and has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Establishes the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency as a new Cabinet-level agency in state government. Specifically, this bill:
- Creates an agency in state government, entitled the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency (Agency).
- Provides that the Agency is headed by a Secretary, who is appointed by the Governor, subject to Senate confirmation, and that the Secretary serves at the pleasure of the Governor.
- Provides that the Secretary may appoint two Chief Deputy Secretaries, subject to Senate confirmation, and that these Chief Deputy Secretaries hold office at the pleasure of the Secretary.
- Amends existing law establishing a Statewide Director of Immigrant Integration, a position already filled by gubernatorial appointment, to add refugee services to the position’s portfolio. Renames the position the “Statewide Director of Immigrant and Refugee Integration” (Director).
- Establishes, within the Agency, the Office of Immigrant and Refugee Affairs (Office), to be headed by the Director.
- States that it is the Legislature’s goal, in enacting this bill, to both incorporate existing programs to assist immigrants and refugees within the Office and to place future such programs within the Office.
- Transfers to the Office all property of any office, agency, or department that relates to functions concerning immigrant and refugee affairs.
- Delegates to the Department of General Services the responsibility of determining whether a transfer of property to the Office should be made, if there is doubt over the question.
- Establishes the Immigrant and Refugee Integration Fund in the State Treasury, the moneys in which are available to the Secretary, upon appropriation by the Legislature, for the Office to expend to defray its expenses.
- Transfers to the Fund the balance of any appropriation and any other funds available for use in connection with any function, or the administration of any law, that is assigned to the Office, so long as the transferred funds are used for the purpose for which they were originally made available.
- Delegates to the Department of Finance the responsibility of determining whether a transfer of funds to the Office should be made, if there is doubt over the question.
- Transfers to the Office every officer and employee of any office, agency, or department who is performing a function transferred to the Office. Preserves the status, position, and rights of any such officer or employee, unless the position is exempt from the State Civil Service Act.
- Sets forth the following duties for the Director:
- Developing a mission statement, strategic plan, and matrix of success for the Office.
- Establishing a permanent structure within the State to serve immigrants and refugees.
- Assisting other state agencies in evaluating their programs for accessibility and effectiveness in providing services to immigrants and refugees.
- Coordinating integration efforts among state agencies and recommending policy and budget mechanisms for meeting immigrant and refugee integration goals.
- Engaging stakeholders inside and outside of government to identify key integration opportunities and challenges, and to communicate the critical importance of immigrant and refugee integration for the success of immigrants, refugees, their children, the communities in which they settle, and of the nation as a whole.
- Developing and executing grant programs that directly support capacity building and training among state agencies and state and local communities through technical assistance, training, organizing, and other programs.
- Identifying effective practices and successful modes of delivering services to immigrant and refugee communities.
- Evaluating the need for improvements in the implementation and coordination of public policies relating to immigrant and refugee communities.
- Coordinating with local immigrant affairs offices to streamline services and maximize their impact.
- Creating a clearinghouse of information and referral systems for services available to immigrants.
- Monitoring the implementation of statewide legislation and regulation relating to, or intended to serve, immigrants and refugees.
- Engaging the federal government and federal agencies, when appropriate, to maximize effectiveness of services provided to immigrants and refugees.
- Making policy recommendations to the Governor and Legislature, with express authorization provided to the Office to (1) inform the Legislature of its position on any legislative proposal pending before the Legislature and to urge the introduction of legislative proposals, and (2) state its position and viewpoint on issues developed in the performance of its specified duties and responsibilities.
- Requires the Director to report to the Legislature on a biannual basis regarding successes and challenges in meeting immigrant and refugee integration goals.
- Changes the date on which the Director must provide a comprehensive report regarding (1) programs and services that serve immigrants, and (2) a plan for better implementation and coordination of immigrant and refugee assistance policies and programs, from January 10, 2017 to January 1, 2021.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the position of Statewide Director of Immigrant Integration, appointed by the Governor, to serve as the statewide lead for the planning and coordination of immigrant services and policies in California. (Government Code Section 65050.)
- Requires the Director to develop a comprehensive statewide report on programs and services that serve immigrants, develop an online clearinghouse of immigrant services, resources, and programs, and monitor the implementation of statewide laws and regulations that service immigrants. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, sponsored by the Coalition for Humane Immigration Rights, would establish a new Cabinet-level agency in state government entitled the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency. The agency’s proposed responsibilities include coordinating immigrant and refugee services among state agencies; assisting state agencies in evaluating the effectiveness and reach of their services; making policy recommendations to the Governor and Legislature; and coordinating with local immigrant affairs offices to maximize the impact of the services they provide.
Background and justification for this bill. California state government agencies currently administer a number of programs directed at securing the welfare of immigrant and refugees in the State. The theory underlying this bill is that creating a new Cabinet-level agency to coordinate these disparate programs would enhance their overall effectiveness.
The author writes:
California openly welcomes immigrants and refugees by providing needed support for immigrants to successfully integrate and establish themselves into our state. California is home to approximately 10.7 million immigrants and refugees, comprising nearly one quarter of the state’s population and 34 percent of the labor force.
According to a recent report produced by the University of Southern California titled “Getting to Know California’s Eligible-to-Naturalize Adult Population,” California is home to over 2.2 million immigrants who are legal permanent residents (LPR), with the largest populations residing in Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino and San Diego counties. However, despite this significant amount of LPRs who are eligible to become naturalized citizens, significant gaps remain in the number of eligible immigrants becoming naturalized. This can be attributed to a lack of programs that assist in promoting naturalization in certain regions, a lack of culturally competent organizations to serve newer and more diverse immigrant populations and a lack of innovative partnerships to support the promotion of citizenship.
California currently has a Statewide Director of Immigrant Integration, which is tasked with continually assessing the challenges faced by immigrants and refugees in our state. In addition, CDSS provides refugee social services and the California Department of Justice hosts the Office of Immigrant Assistance. However, the Office of Immigrant Assistance is a purely informational resource and does not offer any direct services.
Despite these efforts, California lacks a centralized agency dedicated to integrating immigrants and refugees, which leads to confusion, fragmentation of services and a lack of awareness of the resources available to immigrants and refugees. In order to wholly welcome immigrants to California and achieve full integration, the state must be bold and proactive in its approach to offering direct services while addressing rapid policy changes impacting immigrants and refugees.
The only aspect of this bill that lies within the jurisdiction of this Committee is the relation between state and federal immigration law, and therefore, that issue is the only aspect of the bill analyzed herein.
The Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency would exercise powers within the State’s traditional police powers. California state agencies provide numerous services, both direct and indirect, for immigrants and refugees. To take only a few examples:
- The Immigration Services Unit of the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) “ensures the effective development and implementation of programs and funding initiatives necessary to support legal services, outreach, community education, and other immigrant integration efforts…includ[ing] services to increase access to Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA), Other Immigration Remedies (OIR), naturalization, removal defense, and immigration protection for Unaccompanied Undocumented Minors (UUMs).” (See https://www.cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/Immigration)
- The Refugee Programs Bureau, also part of CDSS, “oversees culturally-sensitive and linguistically-appropriate services that helps [refugees] attain the skills needed to achieve self-sufficiency and a successful integration… by partnering with counties, resettlement agencies, school districts, and community based organizations.” (See http://www.cdss.ca.gov/inforesources/Refugees)
- The “California Dream Act” enables undocumented immigrants who are eligible for in-state tuition to obtain financial aid to attend the California Community Colleges, the California State University, and the University of California. (Education Code Sections 66021.6, 66021.7, 69508.5, 76300.5.)
- The Secretary of State requires immigration consultants to register with it; these consultants are regulated by the Department of Consumer Affairs. (Business and Professions Code Sections 22440 et seq.)
All of these services fall squarely within California’s police powers. “[T]he structure and limitations of federalism . . . allow the States great latitude under their police powers to legislate as to the protection of the lives, limbs, health, comfort, and quiet of all persons.” (Gonzales v. Oregon (2006) 546 U.S. 243, 270 (internal quotation marks omitted).) “[Police] regulations may validly be imposed if they constitute a reasonable exertion of governmental authority for the public good.” (In re Fuller (1940) 15 Cal. 2d 425, 428.) The successful integration of immigrants and refugees into California communities, the provision of higher education to immigrant populations, and the supervision of professionals who provide immigration-related services are all legitimate ends to which the state’s police powers may be exercised. As this bill proposes to centralize the coordination and management of such programs in order to increase the state’s effectiveness in providing services to immigrants and refugees, the bill would appear to also be a valid exercise of the state’s police power.
The powers delegated to the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency appear not to be preempted by federal law. There is nevertheless the issue of whether California’s power to create an Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency is preempted by the federal government’s power over immigration and foreign policy. The federal government has power under the United States Constitution to “establish a Uniform Rule of Naturalization[.]” (United States Constitution, Article I, Section 8, Clause 4). The federal government also has inherent authority as a sovereign to conduct relations with foreign nations. (United States v. Curtiss-Wright Export Corp. (1936) 299 U.S. 304, 318 [“The powers to declare and wage war, to conclude peace, to make treaties, to maintain diplomatic relations with other sovereignties, if they had never been mentioned in the Constitution, would have vested in the federal government as necessary concomitants of nationality.”].)
Courts have generally recognized three forms of federal preemption of state law: express preemption, field preemption, and conflict preemption. Express preemption occurs when a federal statute contains a provision that explicitly “withdraw[s] specified powers from the States.” (Arizona v. United States (2012) 567 U.S. 387, 399.) Field preemption occurs when the “intent to displace state law altogether can be inferred from a framework of [federal] regulation so pervasive […] that Congress left no room for the States to supplement it or where there is a federal interest […] so dominant that the federal system will be assumed to preclude enforcement of state laws on the same subject.” (Ibid., internal quotations omitted.) Conflict preemption generally occurs in situations where it is physically impossible to comply with both federal and state regulations, or where state law “stands as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress.” (Ibid.)
This bill does not appear to run afoul of any of these three forms of preemption. There is no express federal preemption of the types of immigration and refugee services that the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency would coordinate. While the Supreme Court has long held that immigration policy is the exclusive domain of the federal government (Chy Lung v. Freeman (1876) 92 U.S. 275), this bill does not contemplate regulating immigration or setting up any legal framework in which federal immigration law cannot be complied with. As a result, neither field preemption, nor conflict preemption appear to be implicated. The bill also appears not to infringe on the United States’ power to conduct relations with other nations.
Moreover, the Supreme Court has recognized that “[t]he pervasiveness of federal regulation does not diminish the importance of immigration policy to the States.” (Arizona, supra, 567 U.S. at 397.) It is critically important for California to successfully integrate immigrants and refugees, and to give these populations the tools they need to enhance their well-being. The benefits of California doing so inure not only to these groups, but to the state as a whole. (See, e.g., Assembly Joint Resolution No. 1 (Daly, Chap. 8, Stats. 2019.) [“Vietnamese Americans have enhanced California’s culture through the establishment of vibrant Little Saigon communities throughout the state that … allow all Californians to be immersed in the richness of Vietnamese culture[.]”]).
The Supreme Court has made it clear that “[f]ederalism, central to the constitutional design, adopts the principle that both the National and State Governments have elements of sovereignty the other is bound to respect.” (Arizona, supra, 567 U.S. at 398.) Based on the legal principles outlined above, and the fact that none of the services that would be coordinated by the contemplated Agency have been found to be preempted, it appears sufficiently clear that the powers that the Agency would exercise are squarely within the California’s sovereignty and do not run afoul of the federal government’s plenary power over immigration and foreign affairs.
To sum, enactment of the Immigrant and Refugee Affairs Agency under this bill does not present federal preemption concerns.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Coalition for Humane Immigration Rights writes as follows in support of the bill:
In recent years California has experienced several crises that have had tremendous impacts on communities including recent wildfires and the COVID 19 pandemic. In these instances, immigrant communities experienced significant delays in being provided adequate responses from the state to better assist them to access available resources or relay critical information that was pertinent to their health and safety to them. Additionally, the rapid changes to immigration policy and aggressive enforcement actions by the Trump Administration have significantly changed the lives of millions of Californian and will continue to have impact on immigrant communities long after this administration. The state has a responsibility as the home to the largest immigrant population in the nation to build up its infrastructure to provide adequate and timely responses to immigrant communities.
Similarly, the California Immigrant Policy Center observes:
The creation of an Immigrant and Refugee Agency would provide the Administration the opportunity to dedicate capacity specifically towards comprehensive approaches to integrate our immigrant and refugee families by creating, updating, and implementing policies and programs. AB 2973 would establish a central agency that would be tasked with ensuring effective policies for immigrant and refugee integration in California. This bill would go beyond the existing standard and provide many Californians, regardless of immigration status, with access to adequate resources and methods for safeguarding their well-being.
Prior Related Legislation: AB 1113 (Chiu, 2019) would have established the Office of Immigrant and Refugee Affairs as a new Cabinet-level agency in state government. The bill passed out of this Committee, but was placed on the suspense file by the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 84 (Budget and Fiscal Review, Chap. 25, Stats. 2015) established a Statewide Director of Immigrant Integration to serve as the statewide lead for the planning and coordination of immigrant services and policies in California.
SB 10 (Lara, Chap. 22, Stats. 2015), as introduced, would have established the California Office of New Americans to create a centralized office to lead and assess challenges and opportunities to coordinate the implementation of immigrant integration legislation. The bill was later amended to authorize the State to apply for a waiver from federal authorities in order to permit individuals previously ineligible because of their immigration status to obtain health coverage through the California Health Benefit Exchange.
SB 1 (Cedillo, 2007), as introduced, would have created the Office of Immigrant Affairs within the Department of Community Services & Development in order to ensure the integration and civic participation of new citizens in the State. The bill was later amended to address financial aid for higher education. In that form, it passed the Legislature, only to be vetoed by then-Governor Schwarzenegger.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (sponsor)
California Immigrant Policy Center
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Jith Meganathan / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):