AB 2991: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011: leadership project certification.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-05-19
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 2, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 20, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 19, 2020 | Read second time and amended. |
| May 18, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (May 13). |
| May 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| May 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 24, 2020 | Read first time. |
| Feb 22, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 23. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 13, 2020 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2991
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:May 19, 2020
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends for two years the AB 900 expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for “environmental leadership development projects” (ELDPs). This bill also allows a project alternative to be certified under the conditions applicable at the time the original project was certified. Additionally, this bill:
- Modifies the ELDP requirements as follows:
- Replaces the current GHG neutrality requirement with a requirement there will be no net additional GHG emissions from employee transportation.
- Requires the applicant to reduce GHG emissions in the project area and the neighboring community. Requires 50% of the reductions to be direct reductions (not offsets).
- Allows ARB to adopt an applicant fee.
- Replaces the 15% transportation efficiency requirement with a 20% reduction in vehicle miles traveled requirement as determined by the Office of Planning and Research (OPR).
- Requires the applicant to pay superior and Appeals court costs.
- Deletes JLBC concurrence requirements.
- Provides an ELDP is subject to the AB 900 rules in place on the date the Governor certified the ELDP.
- Authorizes the Governor, before a lead agency’s approval of an ELDP, to certify a project alternative if the alternative also complies with AB 900’s statutory conditions at the time of the Governor’s original certification.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Potential unknown one-time cost-increases, likely in the $100,000 to $120,000 range, for OPR to update its practices to comply with the new ELDP requirements (GF).
COMMENTS:
- According to the Author:
California is in a housing crisis and we must use all available tools to speed up desperately needed housing projects and other developments that will provide high-wage, stable jobs for Californians. AB 2991 will ensure that environmentally friendly developments that accomplish these goals are completed as quickly as possible by simply extending a program that has proven to yield results.
- Background. In 2011, AB 900 (Buchanan) and SB 292 (Padilla), Chapters 353 and 354, Statutes of 2011, established expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for a limited number of projects. For AB 900, it was large-scale projects meeting extraordinary environmental standards and providing significant jobs and investment. For SB 292, it was a proposed downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center project achieving specified traffic and air quality mitigations.
For the eligible projects, the bills provided for original jurisdiction by the Court of Appeal and a compressed schedule requiring the court to render a decision on any lawsuit within 175 days. This promised to reduce the existing judicial review timeline by 100 days or more, while creating new burdens for the courts and litigants to meet the compressed schedule.
AB 900's provision granting original jurisdiction to the Court of Appeal was invalidated in 2013 by a decision in Alameda Superior Court in “Planning and Conservation League v. State of California.” AB 900 was subsequently revised to restore jurisdiction to superior courts and require resolution of lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible.
To date, 17 projects have been certified under AB 900.
- Related Legislation. SB 995 (Atkins) extends the AB 900 program for four years, with a sunset of January 1, 2025, and expands the program to include certain housing projects meeting specified standards. SB 995 is pending in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 13, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2991 (
Author:Santiago) – As Amended Ver:May 4, 2020
SUBJECT: Environmental quality: Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011
SUMMARY: Extends for five years the expedited California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) judicial review procedures established by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act [AB 900 (Buchanan), Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011] for “environmental leadership development projects” (ELDPs). Allows a project alternative to be certified under the conditions applicable at the time the original project was certified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to CEQA, requires a lead agency with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to evaluate the environmental effects of its action and prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR). If an initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR. CEQA authorizes judicial review of the agency's decision to carry out or approve the project. Challenges alleging improper determination that a project may have a significant effect on the environment, or alleging an EIR does not comply with CEQA, must be filed in the superior court within 30 days of filing of the notice of approval. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions.
- Pursuant to AB 900, establishes procedures for expedited judicial review (i.e., requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible) for ELDPs certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions, including LEED gold-certified infill site projects, clean renewable energy projects, and clean energy manufacturing projects.
- Defines ELDP as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Requires that these projects be located on an infill site.
- Requires a project that is within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy (SCS) or alternative planning strategy (APS) is in effect, to be consistent with specified policies in either the SCS or APS.
- A clean renewable energy project that generates electricity exclusively through wind or solar, but not including waste incineration or conversion.
- A clean energy manufacturing project that manufactures products, equipment, or components used for renewable energy generation, energy efficiency, or for the production of clean alternative fuel vehicles.
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Allows a person proposing to construct an ELDP to apply to the Governor for certification that the ELDP is eligible for streamlining. Requires the person to supply evidence and materials that the Governor deems necessary to make a decision on the application. Requires any evidence or materials be made available to the public at least 15 days before the Governor certifies a project pursuant to AB 900.
- Authorizes the Governor to certify an ELDP if the Governor finds the project meets all of the following conditions:
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- The project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages, provides construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment.
- Requires contractors and subcontractors to pay to all construction workers employed in the execution of the project at least the general prevailing rate of per diem wages.
- Provides that this obligation may be enforced by the Labor Commissioner through the issuance of a civil wage and penalty assessment pursuant to relevant provisions of the Labor Code, unless all contractors and subcontractors performing work on the project are subject to a project labor agreement that requires the payment of prevailing wages and provides for enforcement through an arbitration procedure.
- The project does not result in any net additional greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, including emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the Air Resources Board (ARB) pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006.
- A multifamily residential project provides unbundled parking, such that private vehicle parking spaces are priced and rented or purchased separately from dwelling units, except for units subject to affordability restrictions in law that prescribe rent or sale prices, where the cost of parking spaces cannot be unbundled from the cost of dwelling units.
- The project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required under CEQA shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case, including payment of the costs for the appointment of a special master if deemed appropriate by the court, in a form and manner specified by the Judicial Council.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the administrative record for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to CEQA, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project.
- Requires the Governor, prior to certifying a project, to make a determination that each of the conditions specified above has been met. These findings are not subject to judicial review.
- If the Governor determines that an ELDP is eligible for streamlining, requires the Governor to submit that determination, and any supporting information, to the Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) for review and concurrence or non-concurrence.
- Requires the JLBC to concur or non-concur in writing within 30 days of receiving the Governor's determination.
- Deems the ELDP certified if the JLBC fails to concur or non-concur on a determination by the Governor within 30 days of the submittal.
- Authorizes the Governor to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects pursuant to AB 900. These guidelines are not subject to the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures that require resolution, to the extent feasible, within 270 days, including any appeals, of a lawsuit challenging the certification of the EIR or any project approvals for a certified ELDP.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to an ELDP if the applicant fails to notify a lead agency prior to the release of the draft EIR for public comment.
- Requires the draft and final EIR to include a specified notice in no less than 12-point type regarding the draft and final EIR being subject to AB 900.
- Provides that provisions of AB 900 are severable.
- Provides that nothing in AB 900 affects the duty of any party to comply with CEQA, except as otherwise provided in AB 900.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to a project if the Governor does not certify the project prior to January 1, 2020.
- Provides that certification of the ELDP expires and is no longer valid if the lead agency fails to approve the project prior to January 1, 2021.
- Sunsets January 1, 2021.
- Defines ELDP as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
THIS BILL:
- Extends AB 900’s certification deadlines and sunset for five years, as follows:
- ELDP must be certified by the Governor before January 1, 2025.
- ELDP must be approved by the lead agency before January 1, 2026.
- AB 900 chapter sunsets January 1, 2026.
- Provides that an ELDP is subject to the AB 900 rules in place on the date the Governor certified the ELDP.
- Authorizes the Governor, before a lead agency’s approval of a ELDP, to certify a project alternative if the alternative also complies with AB 900’s statutory conditions at the time of the Governor’s original certification.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
California is in a housing crisis and we must use all available tools to speed up desperately needed housing projects and other developments that will provide high-wage, stable jobs for Californians. AB 2991 will ensure that environmentally friendly developments that accomplish these goals are completed as quickly as possible by simply extending a program that has proven to yield results.
- Background. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
CEQA actions taken by public agencies can be challenged in superior court once the agency approves or determines to carry out the project. CEQA appeals are subject to unusually short statutes of limitations. Under current law, court challenges of CEQA decisions generally must be filed within 30 to 35 days, depending on the type of decision. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. The petitioner must request a hearing within 90 days of filing the petition and, generally, briefing must be completed within 90 days of the request for hearing. There is no deadline specified for the court to render a decision.
In 2011, AB 900 and SB 292 (Padilla), Chapter 353, Statutes of 2011, established expedited CEQA judicial review procedures for a limited number of projects. For AB 900, it was large-scale projects meeting extraordinary environmental standards and providing significant jobs and investment. For SB 292, it was a proposed downtown Los Angeles football stadium and convention center project achieving specified traffic and air quality mitigations. For these eligible projects, the bills provided for original jurisdiction by the Court of Appeal and a compressed schedule requiring the court to render a decision on any lawsuit within 175 days. This promised to reduce the existing judicial review timeline by 100 days or more, while creating new burdens for the courts and litigants to meet the compressed schedule. AB 900's provision granting original jurisdiction to the Court of Appeal was invalidated in 2013 by a decision in Alameda Superior Court in Planning and Conservation League v. State of California. AB 900 was subsequently revised to restore jurisdiction to superior courts and require resolution of lawsuits within 270 days, to the extent feasible.
To date, 17 projects have been certified under AB 900:
- McCoy Solar Energy Project in Riverside County.
- Apple Campus 2 in Cupertino.
- Soitec Solar Energy Project in San Diego County.
- 8150 Sunset Boulevard, a mixed-use commercial and residential project in Hollywood.
- Event Center and Mixed-Use Development at Mission Bay Blocks (i.e., Warriors arena) in San Francisco.
- Qualcomm Stadium Reconstruction Project in San Diego.
- 6701 Sunset/Crossroads, a mixed-use residential, hotel, and commercial project in Hollywood.
- Yucca-Argyle Project, a mixed-use residential, hotel, and commercial project in Hollywood.
- 10 Van Ness Avenue, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in San Francisco.
- 1045 Olive Street Project, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in downtown Los Angeles.
- Hollywood Center Project, a mixed-use project in Hollywood.
- Potrero Power Station Mixed-use Project in San Francisco.
- 3333 California Street Project, a mixed-use commercial/residential redevelopment project in San Francisco.
- Hollywood & Wilcox Mixed-Use Project, a residential/retail/office project in Hollywood.
- Balboa Reservoir, a mixed-income housing/retail project in San Francisco.
- Downtown West Mixed Use Plan, an office/retail/hotel/events/housing/utility project in San Jose.
- California Northstate University Medical Center Project, a hospital/medical office project in Elk Grove.
- Senate review of ELDPs. In April 2019, the Senate Office of Research (SOR) published a review of ELDPs certified under AB 900 (https://sor.senate.ca.gov/environmentalquality).
One key finding from the report is that the benefits of achieving zero-net additional GHG emissions and the transportation efficiency requirements, as well as the benefits from jobs and housing creation, are largely unknown and uncertain. The unknown benefits from jobs and housing creation are simply due to not having any requirements for the project developers to report these statistics. However, the uncertainty from the GHG emissions and transportation efficiency requirements is primarily due to the problematic use of a baseline to measure current existing conditions. The report found that ELDPs appear to have much discretion in choosing various assumptions to determine their baselines and a lack of guidance and ambiguity presents verification challenges during the certification process. To resolve this issue, the SOR report provided recommendations for the Legislature to consider that would eliminate the use of a baseline and provide more robust upfront and locally-specific environmental benefits. These options included requiring upfront traffic and air pollution impact fees, a vehicle miles traveled threshold, and site-specific clean energy requirements.
To date, two ELDPs, the Warriors arena and 8150 Sunset Boulevard projects (as well as Sacramento’s Golden One Center project subject to similar procedures), have been challenged in court and received expedited judicial review. Although the shortened judicial review timeline of 270 days was not always met for these projects, the SOR report found that these projects have moved through the litigation process much faster than normal timelines. The ELDPs have likely received a significant streamlining benefit largely due to the concurrent preparation of the administrative record, as well as the judges’ deference to meeting the timeline and establishing streamlined court procedures. Additionally, the report found that all of the petitioners for the three ELDP CEQA cases stated that the shortened judicial review timeline did not adversely affect their ability to present their issues before the court. Recommendations from the SOR report related to the expedited judicial review process includes extending and clarifying the 270-day timeline and reducing adverse impacts on lead agencies when concurrently preparing the administrative record by extending some requirements.
- Is AB 900 keeping pace with environmental leadership on GHG mitigation and clean air? Following the enactment of AB 32 in 2006, SB 97 was enacted in 2007 to confirm the requirement to address environmental impacts of GHG emissions under CEQA and require the adoption of CEQA Guidelines for the mitigation of GHG emissions or the effects of GHG emissions, including effects associated with transportation or energy consumption. SB 97 requires the CEQA Guidelines to be periodically updated to incorporate new information or criteria established by ARB pursuant to AB 32.
Under CEQA Guidelines adopted pursuant to SB 97, a project’s GHG emissions can be reduced by “off-site measures, including offsets that are not otherwise required” and “measures that sequester greenhouse gases.” The CEQA Guidelines allow projects to reduce GHG emissions by relying on voluntary market offsets that are not otherwise required as well as other offsite and sequestration measures that result in GHG reductions.
When it was enacted in 2011, AB 900 required projects to achieve GHG neutrality, without specifying how. In practice, the AB 900 projects have relied heavily on voluntary offsets. Meanwhile, California's climate policy has focused increasingly on achieving local clean air co-benefits and reducing the reliance on offsets. In 2017, the Legislature's extension of the cap-and-trade program, AB 398, included a reduction in total amount of offsets that may be used for compliance, coupled with a requirement that at least half of offsets result in environmental benefits within California. A companion measure, AB 617, focused on improving local air quality by updating pollution controls at large industrial facilities in the cap-and-trade program and implementing community-based emission reduction programs in the most pollution-burdened communities.
Over the same time period, CEQA practice has demonstrated the feasibility of GHG mitigation plans that incorporate significant on-site and local direct GHG reduction measures, rather than relying entirely on offsets to mitigate projects' GHG emissions. For example, Newhall Ranch, a large project of over 20,000 homes and related development in Los Angeles County near Santa Clarita, was approved in 2017 with the developer’s commitment to "achieve zero net GHG emissions using feasible and reliable emission-reduction actions related to the land development project, the implementation of direct measures to reduce GHG emissions offsite, and the procurement of GHG offsets." To achieve net zero GHG, 13 mitigation measures were adopted for Newhall Ranch, including on-site, off-site and offsets. In total, approximately 55% of the GHG reductions are from on-site and local direct reduction measures, with the balance from offset projects, including some located in California.
In 2018, the Legislature passed AB 734 (Bonta) and AB 987 (Kamlager) to provide expedited judicial review for the Oakland A’s and Los Angeles Clippers projects respectively. AB 734 and AB 987 required at least 50% of GHG mitigation from on-site and local direct GHG reduction measures, and limited the use of offsets to 50% of GHG mitigation.
- Review of ELDP’s real world GHG performance. In support of the proposition that AB 900 is an engine for housing production, supporters identify 17,597 residential units associated with certified ELDP projects. These are projects that have been certified under AB 900, but not built. In fact, of the 17 projects certified in eight years of AB 900, only two projects have been built to date, and neither includes housing.
The two completed projects are the Apple Campus in Cupertino and the Golden State Warriors arena (Chase Center) in San Francisco. These two projects took different approaches to “environmental leadership” and mitigating project GHG emissions.
The Apple project, a large, ring-shaped office building, was designed and built consistent with Apple’s corporate sustainability goals. The zero-net-energy building reduced GHG compared to the prior office buildings. Apple further committed to extraordinary measures to encourage employees to use bicycles, transit, and electric vehicles. Construction emissions were offset by committing to purchase 100% renewable energy.
The Warriors project deducted the baseline GHG emissions from its prior arena in Oakland to reduce its GHG mitigation obligation, then committed to mitigate remaining GHG emissions by purchasing voluntary offsets. (This is consistent with the approach proposed by many other AB 900 projects.)
Though the Chase Center was certified by the Governor in 2015 and opened in August 2019, the Warriors first offset purchase was not executed until March 26, 2020. To offset its construction emissions, the Warriors purchased offsets sourced from the Hernando County Landfill in Florida at a cost of $3.50/ton. The total cost of offsetting construction emissions for the $1.4 billion Chase Center was $39,869. The cost of a single courtside season ticket in the 18,064-seat Chase Center is $52,800.
- Suggested amendments. The author and the committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Replace current GHG neutrality requirement – subdivision (c) of Section 21183 – with the following:
(c)(1)The project does not result in any net additional emissions of greenhouse gases, including greenhouse gas emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code. The baseline for this determination shall be limited to greenhouse gas emissions occurring on the project site no more than 60 days before the application is submitted.
(2) To maximize public health, environmental, and employment benefits, the applicant shall reduce the emissions of greenhouse gases in the project area and in the neighboring communities of the project. Not less than 50% of the greenhouse gas emissions reductions necessary to achieve the requirements of this subdivision, excluding the greenhouse gas emissions from residential uses of the project, shall be from local, direct greenhouse gas emissions reduction measures that give consideration to criteria air pollutant and toxic air contaminant emissions reductions, including, but not limited to, any of the following:
(A) Project design features or onsite reduction measures, or both design features and onsite reduction measures, including up to 50% of emissions reductions attributable to design features necessary to meet the LEED gold certification requirement.
(B) Off-site reduction measures in the neighboring communities.
(3) The applicant may obtain offset credits for up to 50% of the greenhouse gas emissions reductions necessary to achieve the requirement of this subdivision. The applicant shall, to the extent feasible, place the highest priority on the purchase of offset credits that produce emission reductions within the city or air district where the project is located. Any offset credits shall be verified by a third party accredited by the State Air Resources Board. In no event shall offset credits be used from a project located outside the United States.
(4) The State Air Resources Board may adopt an applicant fee sufficient to cover its costs of making this determination.
- Replace 15% transportation efficiency requirement – in subdivision (b) of Section 21180 – with the following:
21183 (h). The project achieves a 20% reduction in vehicle miles traveled per capita compared to existing development, as determined by the Governor’s Office of Planning and Research.
(1) For projects that are at least two-thirds residential uses by square footage, the project shall not generate vehicle travel per capita more than 80% of vehicle miles traveled per capita in the city or region where the project is located.
(2) For commercial projects, the project shall not attract vehicle travel per employee more than 80% of the existing vehicle miles traveled per employee for the region.
- Amend subdivision (f) of Section 21183 to require the applicant to pay costs of the superior court, as well as the Court of Appeal, in hearing and deciding any case.
- Amend subdivision (b) of Section 21184 to eliminate JLBC concurrence.
- Replace 2026 sunset with 2023 sunset.
- Related legislation. SB 995 (Atkins), pending in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, extends AB 900 for four years, with a sunset of January 1, 2025.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Central City Association
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Opposition
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California League of Conservation Voters (unless amended)
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Communities for A Better Environment
Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability
Natural Resources Defense Council (unless amended)
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Sierra Club California
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):