AB 2244: Court fees: electronic filing.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-09-22
Existing law authorizes the electronic service of documents in accordance with uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified. Upon Judicial Council adoption of the uniform rules, existing law authorizes a superior court, by local rule, to require mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in accordance with certain requirements including a requirement that any fees charged by the court do not exceed the actual cost of electronic filing and service of documents.
This bill would add the additional requirement that a fee to process a payment that is charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider, does not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing the payment. The bill would require waiver of fees to process a payment if the court deems waiver appropriate.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For purposes of this provision, the bill would deem an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a filing fee or other court fee to complete an electronic filing transaction to be an agent of the court solely for that purpose, except as otherwise specified. The bill would require an agent of the court to report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer, as specified, and would require the agent to provide the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, with access to examine the records and documents of the agency for purposes of verifying report accuracy and compliance with certain requirements. The bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees but would still require the electronic filing service provider to complete the filing. The bill would require a court, or certain electronic file managers, to accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider, as specified.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover fees for the electronic filing or service of documents, or fees for the hosting of electronic documents, charged by an electronic filing service provider, if the court orders or requires electronic filing, service, or hosting of documents.
Existing law authorizes the electronic service of documents in accordance with uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified. Upon Judicial Council adoption of the uniform rules, existing law authorizes a superior court, by local rule, to require mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in accordance with certain requirements including a requirement that any fees charged by the court do not exceed the actual cost of electronic filing and service of documents.
This bill would add the additional requirement that a fee to process a payment that is charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider, does not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing the payment. The bill would require waiver of fees to process a payment if the court deems waiver appropriate.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For purposes of this provision, the bill would deem an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a filing fee or other court fee to complete an electronic filing transaction to be an agent of the court solely for that purpose, except as otherwise specified. The bill would require an agent of the court to report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer, as specified, and would require the agent to provide the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, with access to examine the records and documents of the agency for purposes of verifying report accuracy and compliance with certain requirements. The bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees but would still require the electronic filing service provider to complete the filing. The bill would require a court, or certain electronic file managers, to accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider, as specified.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover fees for the electronic filing or service of documents, or fees for the hosting of electronic documents, charged by an electronic filing service provider, if the court orders or requires electronic filing, service, or hosting of documents.
Existing law authorizes the electronic service of documents in accordance with uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified. Upon Judicial Council adoption of the uniform rules, existing law authorizes a superior court, by local rule, to require mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in accordance with certain requirements including a requirement that any fees charged by the court do not exceed the actual cost of electronic filing and service of documents.
This bill would add the additional requirement that fees a fee to process a payment that is charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider, does not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing the payment. The bill would require waiver of fees to process a payment if the court deems waiver appropriate.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For purposes of this provision, the bill would deem an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order a filing fee or other court fee to complete an electronic filing transaction to be an agent of the court. court solely for that purpose, except as otherwise specified. The bill would require an agent of the court to report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer, as specified, and would require the agent to provide the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, with access to examine the records and documents of the agency for purposes of verifying report accuracy and compliance with certain requirements. The bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider from colleting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees but would still require the electronic filing service provider to complete the filing. The bill would also prohibit a court or specified entities contracting with a court from requiring an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment, as specified. require a court, or certain electronic file managers, to accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider, as specified.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider and electronic filing service provider hosting fees as costs, as specified. fees for the electronic filing or service of documents, or fees for the hosting of electronic documents, charged by an electronic filing service provider, if the court orders or requires electronic filing, service, or hosting of documents.
Existing law authorizes the electronic service of documents in accordance with uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified. Upon Judicial Council adoption of the uniform rules, existing law authorizes a superior court, by local rule, to require mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in accordance with certain requirements including a requirement that any fees charged by the court do not exceed the actual cost of electronic filing and service of documents.
This bill would add the additional requirement that fees to process a payment that is charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider, not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing the payment. The bill would require waiver of fees to process a payment if the court deems waiver appropriate.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For purposes of this provision, the bill would deem an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction to be an agent of the court. The bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider from colleting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees but would still require the electronic filing service provider to complete the filing. The bill would also prohibit a court or specified entities contracting with a court from requiring an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment, as specified.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider and electronic filing service provider hosting fees as costs, as specified.
Existing law authorizes the electronic service of documents in accordance with uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified. Upon Judicial Council adoption of the uniform rules, existing law authorizes a superior court, by local rule, to require mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in accordance with certain requirements including a requirement that any fees charged by the court do not exceed the actual cost of electronic filing and service of documents.
This bill would add the additional requirement that fees to process a payment that is charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider, not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing the payment. The bill would require waiver of fees to process a payment if the court deems waiver appropriate.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For purposes of this provision, the bill would deem an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction to be an agent of the court. The bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider from colleting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees but would still require the electronic filing service provider to complete the filing. The bill would also prohibit a court or specified entities contracting with a court from requiring an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment, as specified.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider fees as costs, as specified.
Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to accept a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer in payment of designated obligations, including filing fees and other court costs. Existing law authorizes a court, subject to Judicial Council approval, to impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
This bill would additionally authorize an agent of the court to impose a fee, subject to Judicial Council approval, for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the court in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer.
Existing law also enumerates costs that a prevailing party may recover in a civil action.
This bill would authorize a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider fees as costs, as specified.
(a)A document may be served electronically in an action filed with the court as provided in this section, in accordance with rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e).
(1)For purposes of this section:
(A)Electronic service means service of a document, on a party or other person, by either electronic transmission or electronic notification. Electronic service may be performed directly by a party, by an agent of a party, including the partys attorney, or through an electronic filing service provider.
(B)Electronic transmission means the transmission of a document by electronic means to the electronic service address at or through which a party or other person has authorized electronic service.
(C)Electronic notification means the notification of the party or other person that a document is served by sending an electronic message to the electronic address at or through which the party or other person has authorized electronic service, specifying the exact name of the document served, and providing a hyperlink at which the served document may be viewed and downloaded.
(2)If a document may be served by mail, express mail, overnight delivery, or facsimile transmission, electronic service of the document is authorized when a party has agreed to accept service electronically in that action.
(3)In any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service under paragraph (2), or in which the court has ordered electronic service under subdivision (c) or (d), the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. The electronic service of documents by the court shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided in paragraph (4).
(4)(A)Electronic service of a document is complete at the time of the electronic transmission of the document or at the time that the electronic notification of service of the document is sent. However, any period of notice, or any right or duty to do any act or make any response within any period or on a date certain after the service of the document, which time period or date is prescribed by statute or rule of court, shall be extended after service by electronic means by two court days, but the extension shall not apply to extend the time for filing any of the following:
(i)A notice of intention to move for new trial.
(ii)A notice of intention to move to vacate judgment under Section 663a.
(iii)A notice of appeal.
(B)This extension applies in the absence of a specific exception provided by any other statute or rule of court.
(b)A trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) and the following conditions:
(1)A document that is filed electronically shall have the same legal effect as an original paper document.
(2)(A)When a document to be filed requires the signature, not under penalty of perjury, of an attorney or a self-represented party, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that attorney or self-represented party if filed electronically.
(B)When a document to be filed requires the signature, under penalty of perjury, of any person, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that person if filed electronically and if a printed form of the document has been signed by that person before or on the same day as, the date of filing. The attorney or person filing the document represents, by the act of filing, that the declarant has complied with this section. The attorney or person filing the document shall maintain the printed form of the document bearing the original signature and make it available for review and copying upon the request of the court or any party to the action or proceeding in which it is filed.
(3)Any document that is electronically filed with the court after the close of business on any day shall be deemed to have been filed on the next court day. Close of business, as used in this paragraph, means 5 p.m. or the time at which the court will not accept filing at the courts filing counter, whichever is earlier.
(4)The court receiving a document filed electronically shall issue a confirmation that the document has been received and filed. The confirmation shall serve as proof that the document has been filed.
(5)Upon electronic filing of a complaint, petition, or other document that must be served with a summons, a trial court, upon request of the party filing the action, shall issue a summons with the court seal and the case number. The court shall keep the summons in its records and may electronically transmit a copy of the summons to the requesting party. Personal service of a printed form of the electronic summons shall have the same legal effect as personal service of an original summons. If a trial court plans to electronically transmit a summons to the party filing a complaint, the court shall immediately, upon receipt of the complaint, notify the attorney or party that a summons will be electronically transmitted to the electronic address given by the person filing the complaint.
(6)The court shall permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document. The court shall consider and determine the application in accordance with Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code and shall not require the party or attorney to submit any documentation other than that set forth in Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code. Nothing in this section shall require the court to waive a filing fee that is not otherwise waivable.
(7)A fee, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred in processing the payment.
(c)If a trial court adopts rules conforming to subdivision (b), it may provide by order that all parties to an action file and serve documents electronically in a class action, a consolidated action, a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial courts order does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Orange County Superior Court may, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the requirements set forth in paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b), rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e), and the following conditions:
(A)The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
(B)The court and the parties shall have access to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court or to electronic filing access directly through the court. The court may charge fees of no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable. The court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems a waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
(C)The court shall have a procedure for the filing of nonelectronic documents in order to prevent the program from causing undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action, including, but not limited to, unrepresented parties.
(D)A court that elects to require electronic filing pursuant to this subdivision may permit documents to be filed electronically until 12 a.m. of the day after the court date that the filing is due, and the filing shall be considered timely. However, if same day service of a document is required, the document shall be electronically filed by 5 p.m. on the court date that the filing is due. Ex parte documents shall be electronically filed on the same date and within the same time period as would be required for the filing of a hard copy of the ex parte documents at the clerks window in the participating county. Documents filed on or after 12 a.m., or filed upon a noncourt day, will be deemed filed on the soonest court day following the filing.
(2)If a pilot project is established pursuant to paragraph (1), the Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report to the Legislature, on or before December 31, 2013, on the results of the evaluation. The evaluation shall review, among other things, the cost of the program to participants, cost-effectiveness for the court, effect on unrepresented parties and parties with fee waivers, and ease of use for participants.
(e)The Judicial Council shall adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(f)The Judicial Council shall, on or before July 1, 2014, adopt uniform rules to permit the mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, which shall be informed by any study performed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(g)(1)Upon the adoption of uniform rules by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, as specified in subdivision (f), a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to paragraph (2).
(2)A superior court that elects to adopt mandatory electronic filing shall do so pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including, but not limited to, paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), and (7) of subdivision (b), and subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), and pursuant to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified in subdivision (f).
SEC. 2.Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1033.5.(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, or a pro bono attorney, as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an electronic filing service provider if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service of documents.
(15)Fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider. This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
(16)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)(A)If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). A claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (i) upon a noticed motion, (ii) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (iii) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (iv) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
(B)Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 3.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged an administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of a county board of supervisors, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, if the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation that constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency or agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court. Unless otherwise specified, the electronic filing service provider is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) for an electronic filing transaction.
(3)A court shall not be held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under this subdivision.
(4)An agent of the court shall report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer. These reports shall be issued pursuant to guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council. For purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this subdivision, the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, shall have the right to access and examine the records and documents of an agent of the court. The agent of the court shall provide the Judicial Council with all relevant information requested, and shall permit access to its premises at reasonable times for purposes of interviewing employees, and inspecting and copying any relevant records. The agent of the court shall maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed, or until the verification process is completed, whichever occurs later.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for before any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
(k)An electronic filing service provider, as described in subdivision (h), shall not collect or attempt to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing fee or other court fee, or a fee charged by the electronic filing service provider for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider shall complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
(l)A court, or an electronic filing manager that provides a court, pursuant to a contract, with a system for accepting electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees, shall accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h). The court shall determine the methods of payment that will be accepted by the court and the electronic filing manager. The methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH), and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
(a)A document may be served electronically in an action filed with the court as provided in this section, in accordance with rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e).
(1)For purposes of this section:
(A)Electronic service means service of a document, on a party or other person, by either electronic transmission or electronic notification. Electronic service may be performed directly by a party, by an agent of a party, including the partys attorney, or through an electronic filing service provider.
(B)Electronic transmission means the transmission of a document by electronic means to the electronic service address at or through which a party or other person has authorized electronic service.
(C)Electronic notification means the notification of the party or other person that a document is served by sending an electronic message to the electronic address at or through which the party or other person has authorized electronic service, specifying the exact name of the document served, and providing a hyperlink at which the served document may be viewed and downloaded.
(2)If a document may be served by mail, express mail, overnight delivery, or facsimile transmission, electronic service of the document is authorized when a party has agreed to accept service electronically in that action.
(3)In any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service under paragraph (2), or in which the court has ordered electronic service under subdivision (c) or (d), the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. The electronic service of documents by the court shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided in paragraph (4).
(4)(A)Electronic service of a document is complete at the time of the electronic transmission of the document or at the time that the electronic notification of service of the document is sent. However, any period of notice, or any right or duty to do any act or make any response within any period or on a date certain after the service of the document, which time period or date is prescribed by statute or rule of court, shall be extended after service by electronic means by two court days, but the extension shall not apply to extend the time for filing any of the following:
(i)A notice of intention to move for new trial.
(ii)A notice of intention to move to vacate judgment under Section 663a.
(iii)A notice of appeal.
(B)This extension applies in the absence of a specific exception provided by any other statute or rule of court.
(b)A trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) and the following conditions:
(1)A document that is filed electronically shall have the same legal effect as an original paper document.
(2)(A)When a document to be filed requires the signature, not under penalty of perjury, of an attorney or a self-represented party, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that attorney or self-represented party if filed electronically.
(B)When a document to be filed requires the signature, under penalty of perjury, of any person, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that person if filed electronically and if a printed form of the document has been signed by that person before or on the same day as, the date of filing. The attorney or person filing the document represents, by the act of filing, that the declarant has complied with this section. The attorney or person filing the document shall maintain the printed form of the document bearing the original signature and make it available for review and copying upon the request of the court or any party to the action or proceeding in which it is filed.
(3)Any document that is electronically filed with the court after the close of business on any day shall be deemed to have been filed on the next court day. Close of business, as used in this paragraph, means 5 p.m. or the time at which the court will not accept filing at the courts filing counter, whichever is earlier.
(4)The court receiving a document filed electronically shall issue a confirmation that the document has been received and filed. The confirmation shall serve as proof that the document has been filed.
(5)Upon electronic filing of a complaint, petition, or other document that must be served with a summons, a trial court, upon request of the party filing the action, shall issue a summons with the court seal and the case number. The court shall keep the summons in its records and may electronically transmit a copy of the summons to the requesting party. Personal service of a printed form of the electronic summons shall have the same legal effect as personal service of an original summons. If a trial court plans to electronically transmit a summons to the party filing a complaint, the court shall immediately, upon receipt of the complaint, notify the attorney or party that a summons will be electronically transmitted to the electronic address given by the person filing the complaint.
(6)The court shall permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document. The court shall consider and determine the application in accordance with Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code and shall not require the party or attorney to submit any documentation other than that set forth in Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code. Nothing in this section shall require the court to waive a filing fee that is not otherwise waivable.
(7)A fee, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred in processing the payment.
(c)If a trial court adopts rules conforming to subdivision (b), it may provide by order that all parties to an action file and serve documents electronically in a class action, a consolidated action, a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial courts order does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Orange County Superior Court may, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the requirements set forth in paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b), rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e), and the following conditions:
(A)The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
(B)The court and the parties shall have access to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court or to electronic filing access directly through the court. The court may charge fees of no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable. The court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems a waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
(C)The court shall have a procedure for the filing of nonelectronic documents in order to prevent the program from causing undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action, including, but not limited to, unrepresented parties.
(D)A court that elects to require electronic filing pursuant to this subdivision may permit documents to be filed electronically until 12 a.m. of the day after the court date that the filing is due, and the filing shall be considered timely. However, if same day service of a document is required, the document shall be electronically filed by 5 p.m. on the court date that the filing is due. Ex parte documents shall be electronically filed on the same date and within the same time period as would be required for the filing of a hard copy of the ex parte documents at the clerks window in the participating county. Documents filed on or after 12 a.m., or filed upon a noncourt day, will be deemed filed on the soonest court day following the filing.
(2)If a pilot project is established pursuant to paragraph (1), the Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report to the Legislature, on or before December 31, 2013, on the results of the evaluation. The evaluation shall review, among other things, the cost of the program to participants, cost-effectiveness for the court, effect on unrepresented parties and parties with fee waivers, and ease of use for participants.
(e)The Judicial Council shall adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(f)The Judicial Council shall, on or before July 1, 2014, adopt uniform rules to permit the mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, which shall be informed by any study performed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(g)(1)Upon the adoption of uniform rules by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, as specified in subdivision (f), a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to paragraph (2).
(2)A superior court that elects to adopt mandatory electronic filing shall do so pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including, but not limited to, paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), (6), and (7) of subdivision (b), and subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), and pursuant to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified in subdivision (f).
SEC. 2.Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1033.5.(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, or a pro bono attorney, as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an electronic filing service provider if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service of documents.
(15)Fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider. This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
(16)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)(A)If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). A claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (i) upon a noticed motion, (ii) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (iii) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (iv) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
(B)Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 3.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged an administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of a county board of supervisors, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, if the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation that constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency or agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court. Unless otherwise specified, the electronic filing service provider is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) for an electronic filing transaction.
(3)A court shall not be held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under this subdivision.
(4)An agent of the court shall report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer. These reports shall be issued pursuant to guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council. For purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this subdivision, the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, shall have the right to access and examine the records and documents of an agent of the court. The agent of the court shall provide the Judicial Council with all relevant information requested, and shall permit access to its premises at reasonable times for purposes of interviewing employees, and inspecting and copying any relevant records. The agent of the court shall maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed, or until the verification process is completed, whichever occurs later.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for before any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
(k)An electronic filing service provider, as described in subdivision (h), shall not collect or attempt to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing fee or other court fee, or a fee charged by the electronic filing service provider for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider shall complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
(l)A court, or an electronic filing manager that provides a court, pursuant to a contract, with a system for accepting electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees, shall accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h). The court shall determine the methods of payment that will be accepted by the court and the electronic filing manager. The methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH), and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
(a)A document may be served electronically in an action filed with the court as provided in this section, in accordance with rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e).
(1)For purposes of this section:
(A)Electronic service means service of a document, on a party or other person, by either electronic transmission or electronic notification. Electronic service may be performed directly by a party, by an agent of a party, including the partys attorney, or through an electronic filing service provider.
(B)Electronic transmission means the transmission of a document by electronic means to the electronic service address at or through which a party or other person has authorized electronic service.
(C)Electronic notification means the notification of the party or other person that a document is served by sending an electronic message to the electronic address at or through which the party or other person has authorized electronic service, specifying the exact name of the document served, and providing a hyperlink at which the served document may be viewed and downloaded.
(2)If a document may be served by mail, express mail, overnight delivery, or facsimile transmission, electronic service of the document is authorized when a party has agreed to accept service electronically in that action.
(3)In any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service under paragraph (2), or in which the court has ordered electronic service under subdivision (c) or (d), the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. The electronic service of documents by the court shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided in paragraph (4).
(4)(A)Electronic service of a document is complete at the time of the electronic transmission of the document or at the time that the electronic notification of service of the document is sent. However, any period of notice, or any right or duty to do any act or make any response within any period or on a date certain after the service of the document, which time period or date is prescribed by statute or rule of court, shall be extended after service by electronic means by two court days, but the extension shall not apply to extend the time for filing any of the following:
(i)A notice of intention to move for new trial.
(ii)A notice of intention to move to vacate judgment under Section 663a.
(iii)A notice of appeal.
(B)This extension applies in the absence of a specific exception provided by any other statute or rule of court.
(b)A trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) and the following conditions:
(1)A document that is filed electronically shall have the same legal effect as an original paper document.
(2)(A)When a document to be filed requires the signature, not under penalty of perjury, of an attorney or a self-represented party, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that attorney or self-represented party if filed electronically.
(B)When a document to be filed requires the signature, under penalty of perjury, of any person, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that person if filed electronically and if a printed form of the document has been signed by that person before or on the same day as, the date of filing. The attorney or person filing the document represents, by the act of filing, that the declarant has complied with this section. The attorney or person filing the document shall maintain the printed form of the document bearing the original signature and make it available for review and copying upon the request of the court or any party to the action or proceeding in which it is filed.
(3)Any document that is electronically filed with the court after the close of business on any day shall be deemed to have been filed on the next court day. Close of business, as used in this paragraph, means 5 p.m. or the time at which the court will not accept filing at the courts filing counter, whichever is earlier.
(4)The court receiving a document filed electronically shall issue a confirmation that the document has been received and filed. The confirmation shall serve as proof that the document has been filed.
(5)Upon electronic filing of a complaint, petition, or other document that must be served with a summons, a trial court, upon request of the party filing the action, shall issue a summons with the court seal and the case number. The court shall keep the summons in its records and may electronically transmit a copy of the summons to the requesting party. Personal service of a printed form of the electronic summons shall have the same legal effect as personal service of an original summons. If a trial court plans to electronically transmit a summons to the party filing a complaint, the court shall immediately immediately, upon receipt of the complaint complaint, notify the attorney or party that a summons will be electronically transmitted to the electronic address given by the person filing the complaint.
(6)The court shall permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document. The court shall consider and determine the application in accordance with Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code and shall not require the party or attorney to submit any documentation other than that set forth in Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code. Nothing in this section shall require the court to waive a filing fee that is not otherwise waivable.
(7)A fee, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred in processing the payment.
(c)If a trial court adopts rules conforming to subdivision (b), it may provide by order that all parties to an action file and serve documents electronically in a class action, a consolidated action, a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial courts order does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Orange County Superior Court may, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the requirements set forth in paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b), rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e), and the following conditions:
(A)The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
(B)The court and the parties shall have access to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court or to electronic filing access directly through the court. The court may charge fees of no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable. Fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing. The court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems a waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
(C)The court shall have a procedure for the filing of nonelectronic documents in order to prevent the program from causing undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action, including, but not limited to, unrepresented parties.
(D)A court that elects to require electronic filing pursuant to this subdivision may permit documents to be filed electronically until 12 a.m. of the day after the court date that the filing is due, and the filing shall be considered timely. However, if same day service of a document is required, the document shall be electronically filed by 5 p.m. on the court date that the filing is due. Ex parte documents shall be electronically filed on the same date and within the same time period as would be required for the filing of a hard copy of the ex parte documents at the clerks window in the participating county. Documents filed on or after 12 a.m., or filed upon a noncourt day, will be deemed filed on the soonest court day following the filing.
(2)If a pilot project is established pursuant to paragraph (1), the Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report to the Legislature, on or before December 31, 2013, on the results of the evaluation. The evaluation shall review, among other things, the cost of the program to participants, cost-effectiveness for the court, effect on unrepresented parties and parties with fee waivers, and ease of use for participants.
(e)The Judicial Council shall adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(f)The Judicial Council shall, on or before July 1, 2014, adopt uniform rules to permit the mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, which shall be informed by any study performed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(g)(1)Upon the adoption of uniform rules by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, as specified in subdivision (f), a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to paragraph (2).
(2)A superior court that elects to adopt mandatory electronic filing shall do so pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including, but not limited to, paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) (6), and (7) of subdivision (b), and subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), and pursuant to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified in subdivision (f).
SEC. 2.Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1033.5.(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, or a pro bono attorney, as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Electronic filing service provider fees. If a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to electronically file and serve documents through an electronic filing service provider.
(14)Fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an electronic filing service provider if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service of documents.
(15)Electronic filing service provider hosting fees. If Fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to host documents through an electronic filing service provider. This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
(16)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)(A)If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). A claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (A) (i) upon a noticed motion, (B) (ii) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (C) (iii) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (D) (iv) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
(B)Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 3.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged an administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of a county board of supervisors, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, if the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation that constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency or agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court. Unless otherwise specified, the electronic filing service provider is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting a payment described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) for an electronic filing transaction.
(3)A court shall not be held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under this subdivision.
(4)An agent of the court shall report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer. These reports shall be issued pursuant to guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council. For purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this subdivision, the Judicial Council, or its authorized representative, shall have the right to access and examine the records and documents of an agent of the court. The agent of the court shall provide the Judicial Council with all relevant information requested, and shall permit access to its premises at reasonable times for purposes of interviewing employees, and inspecting and copying any relevant records. The agent of the court shall maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed, or until the verification process is completed, whichever occurs later.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for before any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
(k)An electronic filing service provider, as described in subdivision (h), shall not collect or attempt to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing fee or other court fee, or a fee charged by the electronic filing service provider for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider shall complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
(l)A court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated fees shall not require an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment but shall instead offer a menu of payment options that court, or an electronic filing manager that provides a court, pursuant to a contract, with a system for accepting electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees, shall accept more than one method of payment from an electronic filing service provider described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h). The court shall determine the methods of payment that will be accepted by the court and the electronic filing manager. The methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH) (ACH), and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
(a)A document may be served electronically in an action filed with the court as provided in this section, in accordance with rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e).
(1)For purposes of this section:
(A)Electronic service means service of a document, on a party or other person, by either electronic transmission or electronic notification. Electronic service may be performed directly by a party, by an agent of a party, including the partys attorney, or through an electronic filing service provider.
(B)Electronic transmission means the transmission of a document by electronic means to the electronic service address at or through which a party or other person has authorized electronic service.
(C)Electronic notification means the notification of the party or other person that a document is served by sending an electronic message to the electronic address at or through which the party or other person has authorized electronic service, specifying the exact name of the document served, and providing a hyperlink at which the served document may be viewed and downloaded.
(2)If a document may be served by mail, express mail, overnight delivery, or facsimile transmission, electronic service of the document is authorized when a party has agreed to accept service electronically in that action.
(3)In any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service under paragraph (2), or in which the court has ordered electronic service under subdivision (c) or (d), the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. The electronic service of documents by the court shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided in paragraph (4).
(4)(A)Electronic service of a document is complete at the time of the electronic transmission of the document or at the time that the electronic notification of service of the document is sent. However, any period of notice, or any right or duty to do any act or make any response within any period or on a date certain after the service of the document, which time period or date is prescribed by statute or rule of court, shall be extended after service by electronic means by two court days, but the extension shall not apply to extend the time for filing any of the following:
(i)A notice of intention to move for new trial.
(ii)A notice of intention to move to vacate judgment under Section 663a.
(iii)A notice of appeal.
(B)This extension applies in the absence of a specific exception provided by any other statute or rule of court.
(b)A trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) and the following conditions:
(1)A document that is filed electronically shall have the same legal effect as an original paper document.
(2)(A)When a document to be filed requires the signature, not under penalty of perjury, of an attorney or a self-represented party, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that attorney or self-represented party if filed electronically.
(B)When a document to be filed requires the signature, under penalty of perjury, of any person, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that person if filed electronically and if a printed form of the document has been signed by that person before or on the same day as, the date of filing. The attorney or person filing the document represents, by the act of filing, that the declarant has complied with this section. The attorney or person filing the document shall maintain the printed form of the document bearing the original signature and make it available for review and copying upon the request of the court or any party to the action or proceeding in which it is filed.
(3)Any document that is electronically filed with the court after the close of business on any day shall be deemed to have been filed on the next court day. Close of business, as used in this paragraph, means 5 p.m. or the time at which the court will not accept filing at the courts filing counter, whichever is earlier.
(4)The court receiving a document filed electronically shall issue a confirmation that the document has been received and filed. The confirmation shall serve as proof that the document has been filed.
(5)Upon electronic filing of a complaint, petition, or other document that must be served with a summons, a trial court, upon request of the party filing the action, shall issue a summons with the court seal and the case number. The court shall keep the summons in its records and may electronically transmit a copy of the summons to the requesting party. Personal service of a printed form of the electronic summons shall have the same legal effect as personal service of an original summons. If a trial court plans to electronically transmit a summons to the party filing a complaint, the court shall immediately upon receipt of the complaint notify the attorney or party that a summons will be electronically transmitted to the electronic address given by the person filing the complaint.
(6)The court shall permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document. The court shall consider and determine the application in accordance with Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code and shall not require the party or attorney to submit any documentation other than that set forth in Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code. Nothing in this section shall require the court to waive a filing fee that is not otherwise waivable.
(c)If a trial court adopts rules conforming to subdivision (b), it may provide by order that all parties to an action file and serve documents electronically in a class action, a consolidated action, a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial courts order does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Orange County Superior Court may, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the requirements set forth in paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b), rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e), and the following conditions:
(A)The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
(B)The court and the parties shall have access to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court or to electronic filing access directly through the court. The court may charge fees of no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable. Fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing. The court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
(C)The court shall have a procedure for the filing of nonelectronic documents in order to prevent the program from causing undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action, including, but not limited to, unrepresented parties.
(D)A court that elects to require electronic filing pursuant to this subdivision may permit documents to be filed electronically until 12 a.m. of the day after the court date that the filing is due, and the filing shall be considered timely. However, if same day service of a document is required, the document shall be electronically filed by 5 p.m. on the court date that the filing is due. Ex parte documents shall be electronically filed on the same date and within the same time period as would be required for the filing of a hard copy of the ex parte documents at the clerks window in the participating county. Documents filed on or after 12 a.m., or filed upon a noncourt day, will be deemed filed on the soonest court day following the filing.
(2)If a pilot project is established pursuant to paragraph (1), the Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report to the Legislature, on or before December 31, 2013, on the results of the evaluation. The evaluation shall review, among other things, the cost of the program to participants, cost-effectiveness for the court, effect on unrepresented parties and parties with fee waivers, and ease of use for participants.
(e)The Judicial Council shall adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(f)The Judicial Council shall, on or before July 1, 2014, adopt uniform rules to permit the mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, which shall be informed by any study performed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(g)(1)Upon the adoption of uniform rules by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, as specified in subdivision (f), a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to paragraph (2).
(2)A superior court that elects to adopt mandatory electronic filing shall do so pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including, but not limited to, paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b), and subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), and pursuant to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified in subdivision (f).
SEC. 2.Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1033.5.(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code, or a pro bono attorney, as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Electronic filing service provider fees. If a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to electronically file, serve, and host file and serve documents through an electronic filing service provider.
(15)Electronic filing service provider hosting fees. If a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to host documents through an electronic filing service provider. This paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
(15)
(16)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). A claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (A) upon a noticed motion, (B) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (C) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (D) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 3.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged an administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of a county board of supervisors, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, if the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation that constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for before any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
(k)An electronic filing service provider, as described in subdivision (h), shall not collect or attempt to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider shall complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
(l)A court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated fees shall not require an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment but shall instead offer a menu of payment options that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH), or (ACH) and payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
(a)A document may be served electronically in an action filed with the court as provided in this section, in accordance with rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e).
(1)For purposes of this section:
(A)Electronic service means service of a document, on a party or other person, by either electronic transmission or electronic notification. Electronic service may be performed directly by a party, by an agent of a party, including the partys attorney, or through an electronic filing service provider.
(B)Electronic transmission means the transmission of a document by electronic means to the electronic service address at or through which a party or other person has authorized electronic service.
(C)Electronic notification means the notification of the party or other person that a document is served by sending an electronic message to the electronic address at or through which the party or other person has authorized electronic service, specifying the exact name of the document served, and providing a hyperlink at which the served document may be viewed and downloaded.
(2)If a document may be served by mail, express mail, overnight delivery, or facsimile transmission, electronic service of the document is authorized when a party has agreed to accept service electronically in that action.
(3)In any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service under paragraph (2), or in which the court has ordered electronic service under subdivision (c) or (d), the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. The electronic service of documents by the court shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided in paragraph (4).
(4)(A)Electronic service of a document is complete at the time of the electronic transmission of the document or at the time that the electronic notification of service of the document is sent. However, any period of notice, or any right or duty to do any act or make any response within any period or on a date certain after the service of the document, which time period or date is prescribed by statute or rule of court, shall be extended after service by electronic means by two court days, but the extension shall not apply to extend the time for filing any of the following:
(A)
(i)A notice of intention to move for new trial.
(B)
(ii)A notice of intention to move to vacate judgment under Section 663a.
(C)
(iii)A notice of appeal.
This
(B)This extension applies in the absence of a specific exception provided by any other statute or rule of court.
(b)A trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) and the following conditions:
(1)A document that is filed electronically shall have the same legal effect as an original paper document.
(2)(A)When a document to be filed requires the signature, not under penalty of perjury, of an attorney or a self-represented party, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that attorney or self-represented party if filed electronically.
(B)When a document to be filed requires the signature, under penalty of perjury, of any person, the document shall be deemed to have been signed by that person if filed electronically and if a printed form of the document has been signed by that person prior to, before or on the same day as, the date of filing. The attorney or person filing the document represents, by the act of filing, that the declarant has complied with this section. The attorney or person filing the document shall maintain the printed form of the document bearing the original signature and make it available for review and copying upon the request of the court or any party to the action or proceeding in which it is filed.
(3)Any document that is electronically filed with the court after the close of business on any day shall be deemed to have been filed on the next court day. Close of business, as used in this paragraph, shall mean means 5 p.m. or the time at which the court would will not accept filing at the courts filing counter, whichever is earlier.
(4)The court receiving a document filed electronically shall issue a confirmation that the document has been received and filed. The confirmation shall serve as proof that the document has been filed.
(5)Upon electronic filing of a complaint, petition, or other document that must be served with a summons, a trial court, upon request of the party filing the action, shall issue a summons with the court seal and the case number. The court shall keep the summons in its records and may electronically transmit a copy of the summons to the requesting party. Personal service of a printed form of the electronic summons shall have the same legal effect as personal service of an original summons. If a trial court plans to electronically transmit a summons to the party filing a complaint, the court shall immediately upon receipt of the complaint notify the attorney or party that a summons will be electronically transmitted to the electronic address given by the person filing the complaint.
(6)The court shall permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document. The court shall consider and determine the application in accordance with Sections 68630 to 68641, inclusive, Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code and shall not require the party or attorney to submit any documentation other than that set forth in Sections 68630 to 68641, inclusive, Article 6 (commencing with Section 68630) of Chapter 2 of Title 8 of the Government Code. Nothing in this section shall require the court to waive a filing fee that is not otherwise waivable.
(c)If a trial court adopts rules conforming to subdivision (b), it may provide by order that all parties to an action file and serve documents electronically in a class action, a consolidated action, or a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial courts order does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
(d)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Orange County Superior Court may, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the requirements set forth in paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b) and (b), rules adopted pursuant to subdivision (e) (e), and the following conditions:
(A)The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
(B)The court and the parties shall have access either to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court, court or to electronic filing access directly through the court. Any fees charged by the court shall be for The court may charge fees of no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents, and shall be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including, but not limited to, for any party who has received a fee waiver. documents. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable and shall be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including, but not limited to, for any party who has received a fee waiver. reasonable. Fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing. The court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
(C)The court shall have a procedure for the filing of nonelectronic documents in order to prevent the program from causing undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action, including, but not limited to, unrepresented parties.
(D)A court that elects to require electronic filing pursuant to this subdivision may permit documents to be filed electronically until 12 a.m. of the day after the court date that the filing is due, and the filing shall be considered timely. However, if same day service of a document is required, the document shall be electronically filed by 5 p.m. on the court date that the filing is due. Ex parte documents shall be electronically filed on the same date and within the same time period as would be required for the filing of a hard copy of the ex parte documents at the clerks window in the participating county. Documents filed on or after 12 a.m., or filed upon a noncourt day, will be deemed filed on the soonest court day following the filing.
(2)If a pilot project is established pursuant to paragraph (1), the Judicial Council shall conduct an evaluation of the pilot project and report to the Legislature, on or before December 31, 2013, on the results of the evaluation. The evaluation shall review, among other things, the cost of the program to participants, cost-effectiveness for the court, effect on unrepresented parties and parties with fee waivers, and ease of use for participants.
(e)The Judicial Council shall adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(f)The Judicial Council shall, on or before July 1, 2014, adopt uniform rules to permit the mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, which shall be informed by any study performed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) and which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. These rules shall conform to the conditions set forth in this section, as amended from time to time.
(g)(1)Upon the adoption of uniform rules by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified civil actions in the trial courts of the state, as specified in subdivision (f), a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to paragraph (2) of this subdivision. (2).
(2)Any A superior court that elects to adopt mandatory electronic filing shall do so pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including, but not limited to, paragraphs (1), (2), (4), (5), and (6) of subdivision (b) of this section, (b), and subparagraphs (A), (B), and (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (d), and pursuant to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council, as specified in subdivision (f).
SECTION 1.SEC. 2.Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure is amended to read:1033.5.(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code Code, or a pro bono attorney attorney, as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Electronic filing service provider fees. If a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to electronically file, serve, and host documents through a certified an electronic filing service provider.
(15)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). Any A claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (A) upon a noticed motion, (B) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (C) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (D) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged a an administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of the a county board of supervisors of a county, supervisors, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) hereof constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, provided if the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation which that constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)(1)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for prior to before any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
(k)An electronic filing service provider, as described in subdivision (h), shall not collect or attempt to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider shall complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
(l)A court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated fees shall not require an electronic filing service provider to use any single method of payment but shall instead offer a menu of payment options that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH), or payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
(a)The following items are allowable as costs under Section 1032:
(1)Filing, motion, and jury fees.
(2)Juror food and lodging while they are kept together during trial and after the jury retires for deliberation.
(3)(A)Taking, video recording, and transcribing necessary depositions, including an original and one copy of those taken by the claimant and one copy of depositions taken by the party against whom costs are allowed.
(B)Fees of a certified or registered interpreter for the deposition of a party or witness who does not proficiently speak or understand the English language.
(C)Travel expenses to attend depositions.
(4)Service of process by a public officer, registered process server, or other means, as follows:
(A)When service is by a public officer, the recoverable cost is the fee authorized by law at the time of service.
(B)If service is by a process server registered pursuant to Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 22350) of Division 8 of the Business and Professions Code, the recoverable cost is the amount actually incurred in effecting service, including, but not limited to, a stakeout or other means employed in locating the person to be served, unless those charges are successfully challenged by a party to the action.
(C)When service is by publication, the recoverable cost is the sum actually incurred in effecting service.
(D)When service is by a means other than that set forth in subparagraph (A), (B), or (C), the recoverable cost is the lesser of the sum actually incurred, or the amount allowed to a public officer in this state for that service, except that the court may allow the sum actually incurred in effecting service upon application pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (c).
(5)Expenses of attachment including keepers fees.
(6)Premiums on necessary surety bonds.
(7)Ordinary witness fees pursuant to Section 68093 of the Government Code.
(8)Fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court.
(9)Transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court.
(10)Attorneys fees, when authorized by any of the following:
(A)Contract.
(B)Statute.
(C)Law.
(11)Court reporter fees as established by statute.
(12)Court interpreter fees for a qualified court interpreter authorized by the court for an indigent person represented by a qualified legal services project, as defined in Section 6213 of the Business and Professions Code or a pro bono attorney as defined in Section 8030.4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(13)Models and enlargements of exhibits and photocopies of exhibits may be allowed if they were reasonably helpful to aid the trier of fact.
(14)Electronic filing service provider fees. If a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to electronically file, serve, and host documents through a certified electronic filing service provider.
(14)
(15)Any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
(b)The following items are not allowable as costs, except when expressly authorized by law:
(1)Fees of experts not ordered by the court.
(2)Investigation expenses in preparing the case for trial.
(3)Postage, telephone, and photocopying charges, except for exhibits.
(4)Costs in investigation of jurors or in preparation for voir dire.
(5)Transcripts of court proceedings not ordered by the court.
(c)Any An award of costs shall be subject to the following:
(1)Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
(2)Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
(3)Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
(4)Items not mentioned in this section and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the courts discretion.
(5)When any If a statute of this state refers to the award of costs and attorneys fees, attorneys fees are an item and component of the costs to be awarded and are allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a). Any claim not based upon the courts established schedule of attorneys fees for actions on a contract shall bear the burden of proof. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) may be fixed as follows: (A) upon a noticed motion, (B) at the time a statement of decision is rendered, (C) upon application supported by affidavit made concurrently with a claim for other costs, or (D) upon entry of default judgment. Attorneys fees allowable as costs pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (C) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a) shall be fixed either upon a noticed motion or upon entry of a default judgment, unless otherwise provided by stipulation of the parties.
Attorneys fees awarded pursuant to Section 1717 of the Civil Code are allowable costs under Section 1032 of this code as authorized by subparagraph (A) of paragraph (10) of subdivision (a).
SEC. 2.Section 6159 of the Government Code is amended to read:6159.(a)The following definitions apply for purposes of this section:
(1)Credit card means any a card, plate, coupon book, or other credit device existing for the purpose of being used from time to time upon presentation to obtain money, property, labor, or services on credit.
(2)Card issuer means any a person, or his or her agent, who issues a credit card and purchases credit card drafts.
(3)Cardholder means any a person to whom a credit card is issued or any person who has agreed with the card issuer to pay obligations arising from the issuance of a credit card to another person.
(4)Debit card means a card or other means of access to a debit card cardholders account that may be used to initiate electronic funds transfers from that account.
(5)Draft purchaser means any a person who purchases credit card drafts.
(6)Electronic funds transfer means any a method by which a person permits electronic access to, and transfer of, money held in an account by that person.
(b)Subject to subdivisions (c) and (d), a court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency may authorize the acceptance of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer for any of the following:
(1)The payment for the deposit of bail for any offense not declared to be a felony or for any a court-ordered fee, fine, forfeiture, penalty, assessment, or restitution. Use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph may include a requirement that the defendant be charged any a administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction.
(2)The payment of a filing fee or other court fee.
(3)The payment of any towage or storage costs for a vehicle that has been removed from a highway, or from public or private property, as a result of parking violations.
(4)The payment of child, family, or spousal support, including reimbursement of public assistance, related fees, costs, or penalties, with the authorization of the cardholder or accountholder.
(5)The payment for services rendered by any a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(6)The payment of any a fee, charge, or tax due a city, county, city and county, or other public agency.
(7)The payment of any moneys payable to the sheriff pursuant to a levy under a writ of attachment or writ of execution. If the use of a card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to this paragraph includes any administrative fee charged by the company issuing the card or processing the account for the cost of the transaction, that fee shall be paid by the person who pays the money to the sheriff pursuant to the levy.
(8)The payment of a donation, gift, bequest, or devise made to or in favor of a county, or to or in favor of the board of supervisors of a county, pursuant to Section 25355.
(c)A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. A city desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of its city council. Any other public agency desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) shall obtain the approval of the governing body that has fiscal responsibility for that agency.
(d)After approval is obtained, a contract may be executed with one or more credit card issuers, debit card issuers, electronic funds transfer processors, or draft purchasers. The contract shall provide for the following matters:
(1)The respective rights and duties of the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency and card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser regarding the presentment, acceptability, and payment of credit and debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests.
(2)The establishment of a reasonable means by which to facilitate payment settlements.
(3)The payment to the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser of a reasonable fee or discount.
(4)Any other matters appropriately included in contracts with respect to the purchase of credit and debit card drafts and processing of electronic funds transfer requests as may be agreed upon by the parties to the contract.
(e)The honoring of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer pursuant to subdivision (b) hereof constitutes payment of the amount owing to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency as of the date the credit or debit card is honored or the electronic funds transfer is processed, provided the credit or debit card draft is paid following its due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or the electronic funds transfer is completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer.
(f)If any a credit or debit card draft is not paid following due presentment to a card issuer or draft purchaser or is charged back to the court, city, county, city and county, or other public agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the court, city, or other public agency honoring the credit or debit card shall be void. If any an electronic funds transfer request is not completed with transfer to the agency requesting the transfer or is charged back to the agency for any reason, any record of payment made by the agency processing the electronic funds transfer shall be void. Any A receipt issued in acknowledgment of payment shall also be void. The obligation of the cardholder or accountholder shall continue as an outstanding obligation as if no payment had been attempted.
(g)If a credit card, debit card draft, electronic funds transfer, or other payment offered in payment is returned without payment, for any reason, a reasonable charge for the charge back or return, not to exceed the actual costs incurred by the public agency, may be imposed to recover the public agencys processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to, and become part of, any underlying obligation other than an obligation which constitutes a lien on real property, and a different method of payment for that payment and future payments by this person may be prescribed.
(h)Notwithstanding Title 1.3 (commencing with Section 1747) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, a court or agent of the court, city, county, city and county, or any other public agency may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts as specified in paragraph (3) of subdivision (d). Any A fee imposed by a court or agent of the court pursuant to this subdivision shall be approved by the Judicial Council. Any A fee imposed by any other public agency pursuant to this subdivision for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer shall be approved by the governing body responsible for the fiscal decisions of the public agency.
(i)Fees or discounts provided for under paragraph (3) of subdivision (d) shall be deducted or accounted for prior to any statutory or other distribution of funds received from the card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser to the extent not recovered from the cardholder or accountholder pursuant to subdivision (h).
(j)The Judicial Council may enter into a master agreement with one or more credit or debit card issuers, funds processors, or draft purchasers for the acceptance and payment of credit or debit card drafts and electronic funds transfer requests received by the courts. Any A court may join in any of these master agreements or may enter into a separate agreement with a credit or debit card issuer, funds processor, or draft purchaser.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 6113.). |
| Aug 23, 2016 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 36. Noes 1. Page 5031.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 36. Noes 1.). |
| Aug 16, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 18 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 16, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 15, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 11, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Aug 1, 2016 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 22, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 21). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 19, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 4787.) |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0.) |
| May 12, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 12, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 5, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 4, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (May 4). |
| Apr 14, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 13, 2016 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 12, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 12). |
| Apr 6, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 5, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 3, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 23, 2016 | AB 2244 GATTO Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 16, 2016 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2244 Gatto | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2016 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 1, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 21, 2016 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2016 | AB 2244 GATTO Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 4, 2016 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 12, 2016 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2244
Author:(Gatto)
As Amended Ver:June 13, 2016
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: | 78-0 | (May 12, 2016) | SENATE: | 36-1 | (August 16, 2016) |
Original Committee Reference: JUD.
SUMMARY: Prohibits electronic filing vendors from charging a payment method convenience fee that exceeds the cost incurred to provide the processing. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an agent of the court may impose a fee for the use of a credit card or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for that payment method. Provides that fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing.
- Requires the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to waive processing payment fees if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
- Requires a court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents to provide a menu of payment options that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions, and payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
- Allows a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider fees as costs.
- Allows a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider hosting fees as cost until January 1, 2022.
The Senate amendments:
- Specify that an electronic filing service provider as defined is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting electronic court filing fees.
- Provide that the court is not liable for the actions of an agent of the court in imposing fees for the use of a credit or debit card, or electronic funds transfer as a method of payment.
- Require an agent of the court, as provided, to issue a report on the agent's costs in providing various payment options, and to maintain relevant records for inspection by the Judicial Council.
- Make technical and clarifying changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes courts to allow parties to electronically file court documents in accordance to rules established by the Judicial Council, and as provided by state law. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1010.6 (b). Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.)
- Provides that rules adopted by the Judicial Council relating to mandatory electronic filing and service of documents in trial courts shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and the integrity of electronic service. (Section 1010.6 (f).)
- Sets forth the rules adopted by the Judicial Council regarding electronic filing and serving of court documents. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rules 2.250-2.261.)
- Requires the court to permit a party or an attorney to file an application for a fee waiver as part of the electronic filing process. (Section 1010.6 (b)(6).)
- Authorizes a court and other specified public agencies to accept credit card, debit card, or electronic fund transfers for the payment of specified government services and fees. Provides that when a court or other specified public agencies authorizes one of the payment methods, the public agency may impose a fee for the use of a debit card, or electronic fund transfer not to exceed the costs incurred by the public agency in providing for payment. If a court is imposing the fee, the fee shall be approved by the Judicial Council. (Government Code Section 6159.)
- Provides that a prevailing party is entitled as a matter of right to recover costs in any action or proceeding, as provided. (Section 1032.)
- Provides specified items that are allowable recoverable costs and others that are not allowable recoverable costs. (Section 1033.5)
- Provides that any award of costs shall be subject to the following:
- Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
- Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
- Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
- Items not specifically mentioned and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the court's discretion. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriation Committee:
- Fee restrictions: Potentially significant costs to electronic filing service providers (EFSPs) and electronic filing managers (EFMs) for processing costs that are unrecoverable due to fee exemptions/waivers. To the extent a court serves as the EFSP and/or EFM for low-income and self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers, these processing costs would be absorbed by the court's operating budget (General Fund*). Alternatively, to the extent courts enter into vendor contracts for EFSP/EFM services, these unrecoverable costs could be built into the costs of the contracts (General Fund*).
- EFSP verification process: Potential future increase in workload (General Fund*) to the Judicial Council to conduct the verification process described in this measure which would include interviewing EFSP employees, as well as accessing, inspecting, and copying relevant records of fees/costs for auditing purposes. To the extent this process is already in place and operating, any impact to the Judicial Council would be absorbable.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
COMMENTS: California's court system is one of the largest in the world, with more than 2,000 judicial officers and approximately 19,000 judicial branch employees statewide who assist in the court's management of cases every year. (2015 Courts Statistics Report: Statewide Caseload Trends, Judicial Council of California (2015).) During the 2013-14 fiscal year, there were 7.5 million cases filed statewide in the superior courts. (Ibid.)
Given the high volume of filings in California's courts each year, a party's ability to file and serve documents electronically significantly improves the court's capacity to process filings. Ideally, parties could file their legal documents electronically directly to the court through a statewide case management system at no additional cost (aside from the court filing fee). But given the reality of the courts not having such a system, trial courts are doing the best they can to facilitate electronic filing with county systems that rely upon fees for service.
How Does Electronic Filing Work? According to a recent staff report from the Judicial Council, an electronic filing system requires both an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) and an electronic filing manager (EFM). Generally, the litigant files the legal document with the EFSP which translates the information, and sends it to the EFM, which delivers and communicates that information to the court's case management system. (The Critical Role of the State Judiciary in Increasing Access for Self-Represented Litigants: Self-Help Access 360˚, Judicial Council, July 2015.)
If Electronic Filing Is Not Managed Correctly, It May Create Barriers to Justice for Self-Represented and Low-Income Litigants. In that same report, concerns about electronic filing and access to justice were raised:
Early experiences with e-filing, both in California and in other states, suggest that many private vendor EFSPs are not focused on serving the market segment of self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers. The access community believes that the exclusion of self-represented litigants from electronic filing "has the potential to enlarge the access to justice gap in the long run." Electronic filing is an area in which a slight tip of the balance means that the technology tool is no longer used to achieve greater access; rather, it becomes a barrier. The California judicial branch has the opportunity to "place a finger on the scale" in favor of low-income and self-represented litigants by developing the capacity to serve as the EFSP and EFM for all self-represented litigants in the state.
To date, thirteen trial courts have adopted some form of mandatory electronic filing system. Although mandatory electronic filing may be an attractive option for trial courts because of the significant efficiencies to courts, electronic filing has not been perfect. To some extent, this bill addresses several of the issues confronting electronic filing.
Consistent with Existing Law, this Bill Prevents Electronic Filing Vendors from Charging a Payment Method Convenience Fee that Exceeds the Cost to Vendors of that Payment Transaction. Government entities may accept credit cards, debit cards, or electronic funds transfers for the payment of certain government services, including court filings. Although current law allows a government entity, including a court, to impose a convenience fee for those transactions, the government entity may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds its costs for providing that payment method.
Consistent with current law, this bill sensibly provides that an electronic filing service provider, who remits funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction, acts as an agent of the court, and may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds the provider's cost to provide that service. In order to further protect litigants and provide greater clarity about convenience costs associated with processing payment methods, this bill also requires that when a trial court adopts rules for mandatory electronic filing, the fees (if any) that are charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred by the court, manager, or provider.
This Bill Makes Electronic Filing More Accessible to Indigent Litigants and Litigants with Fee Waivers, Consistent with California's Goals of Promoting Access to Justice. To ensure that litigants with fee waivers have true access to electronic filing without fees, this bill does two important things. First, it prohibits those litigants from being required to pay transaction processing fees. Second, it clarifies existing law to require an electronic filing service provider to electronically file a fee-waiver-litigant's documents if that is the litigant's preferred method.
In order to protect litigants who may not have access to credit or debit cards, this bill also sensibly requires electronic filing managers to accept alternative forms of payment beyond credit cards for the payment of filing fees and e-filing transaction costs. Specifically, this bill requires the court (or the electronic filing manager) to offer a menu of payment options, including but not limited to, credit cards or debit cards, electronic fund transfers, Automated Clearing House, and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost, such as an electronic check.
Given That Some Courts Mandate Electronic Filing, this Bill Would Allow Costs Associated With Electronic Filing to Be Recoverable Litigation Costs. Throughout litigation, parties pay for costs associated with the legal proceeding, such as filing fees, expert-witness fees, and attorney's fees. In addition to any judgment award, current law allows the prevailing party to recover specific litigation costs from the unsuccessful party. Current law specifically provides which items are allowable or not allowable as recoverable costs. Given that some courts have mandated electronic filing, this bill reasonably adds electronic filing service provider fees to the list of allowable recoverable costs when a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court. This bill also limits those costs to costs that are actually incurred.
Recovering Hosting Costs. In some matters, courts will order parties to have their documents "hosted" by an electronic filing service provider. This often occurs in complex cases when certain documents are never lodged with the court, and courts lack the infrastructure to hold these out-of-court documents. Although this bill still allows parties to recover these hosting costs, the bill includes a five-year sunset which allows the Legislature to determine whether it is appropriate for these responsibilities to be shifted to third-party vendors.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004197
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2244
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/21/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/11/16
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Hill, McGuire, Mendoza, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/12/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill ensures that if any trial court permits or mandates electronic filing and service of documents, any fees charged by the court, an electronic filing manager (EFM), or an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred. This bill further ensures that if a trial court mandates e-filing: (1) a court or an EFM contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated fees accept more than one method of payment to an EFSP, as specified; and (2) clarifies that an EFSP is an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting specified payments and any fees set by an EFSP must, consistent with existing law, be approved by the Judicial Council. This bill also allows for prevailing parties to recover fees associated with electronic filing and service through an EFSP, as specified.
Existing law:
- Provides that except as otherwise provided by statute, a prevailing party, as defined, is entitled as a matter of right to recover costs in any action or proceeding. Existing law enumerates the items allowable as costs under the above provision, including, among other things:
- filing, motion, and jury fees;
- any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal.
- Provides that any award of costs is subject to the following, among other things:
- allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation; and
- allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
- Authorizes a court and other specified public entities to accept credit card, debit card, or electronic fund transfers for the payment of certain government services and fees, including the payment of a filing fee or other court fee. A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer must first obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. Provides that, notwithstanding specified law, a court may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. The Judicial Council must approve any such fee imposed.
- Provides that in any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service or in which the court has ordered electronic service, as specified, the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. Provides that electronic service shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided.
- Provides that a trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing (e-filing) of documents, subject to Rules of Court adopted as specified and subject to specified conditions. These include conditions relating to electronic signatures and fee waivers, among other things. Requires the court to permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the e-filing of a document, as specified.
- Permits a court to require electronic filing of documents in complex civil litigation cases, as specified, provided that it does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of the electronic service. Requires these rules to conform to the conditions set in the Code of Civil Procedure, as specified.
- Sets forth, under Rules of Court, uniform rules regarding e-filing and serving of documents. (Cal. Rules of Court 2.250-2.261.)
- Provides authority for the Orange County Superior Court, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, to establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to specified requirements and rules adopted by Judicial Council, and certain additional statutory conditions. Those additional conditions include that the court and the parties either have access to more than one electronic service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court, or have e-filing access directly through the court. Any fees charged by the court must be for no more than the actual cost of e-filing and service of the documents, whereas any fees charged by the electronic service provider must be reasonable. In both instances, fees must be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including for any party who has received a fee waiver.
- Requires the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2014, to adopt uniform rules for mandatory e-filing and service of documents for specified actions in the state’s trial courts, which are to be informed by the pilot project, above, and are to include statewide policies on various items, including, among other things, privacy, unrepresented parties, fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to e-filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. Upon adoption of those rules, a superior court may, by local rule, mandate e-filing, pursuant to specified statutory requirements and conditions, including several of the conditions that were specified for the mandatory e-filing pilot project, above.
This bill:
- Adds a new condition to the list of conditions that courts must meet when electing to permit, or otherwise mandating, e-filing and service of documents. Specifically, a fee, if any, charged by a court, an EFM, or an EFSP to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred.
- Specifies, consistent with existing law, that the court, an EFM, or an EFSP shall waive any fees charged if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
- Prohibits an EFSP, as described, from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing or other court fee, or a fee charged by the EFSP for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the EFSP must complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
- Requires a court or an EFM that provides a court, pursuant to contract, a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees accept more than one method of payment to an EFSP who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing or other court as an agent of the court, as specified, below. Requires the court to determine which methods of payment shall be accepted by the court and the EFM, and specifies that the methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House and other methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
- Authorizes an “agent of the court” to impose a fee for use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. For these purposes, an EFSP who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing fee or other court fee, as specified, to complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court, and, unless specified otherwise, the EFSP is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting such payments for an electronic filing transaction. Further ensures that, consistent with a specified requirement under existing law, that any such fees charged by the court or the EFSP be approved by the Judicial Council.
- Prohibits a court from being held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under the above provisions and requires that an agent report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, as specified. Requires that the Judicial Council or its authorized representative have access to and the right to examine the records and documents of an agent for purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this reporting requirement. The agent must, among other things provide the Judicial Council all relevant information requested and maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs, as specified.
- Adds to the list of recoverable costs by prevailing parties:
- fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an EFSP if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service; and
- until January 1, 2022, fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an EFSP.
- Makes other technical, clarifying or non-substantive changes.
Background
The federal courts, have long allowed for electronic filing of court documents. (See Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. rule 5(d)(3), which provides that a court may, by local rule, allow papers to be filed, signed, or verified by electronic means that are consistent with any technical standards established by the Judicial Conference of the United States, and may require e- filing only if reasonable exceptions are allowed.) The federal rules also, however, prohibit a court clerk from refusing to accept paper filings – even if a local court rule mandates e- filing. (Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 5(d)(4); see also Klemm v. Astrue (9th Cir. 2008) 543 F.3d 1139, 1143.)
E-filing proponents argue that it creates substantial efficiencies and cost savings for both litigants and the courts: it saves in time, labor, postage, supplies, storage, and travel; creates easier and timelier access to records and documents by the courts and the public; engenders more efficient use of staff time; allows for remote access to court records by lawyers and the public over the Internet; grants attorneys the flexibility to file documents after hours when courts are closed; and gives multiple parties the ability to view the same documents, at the same time. At the same time, however, this state has been cautious of the hardships that e-filing might cause for some courts or litigants—particularly low income or unrepresented litigants—given that access to electronic communications are still widely disparate among different cities and counties within this state, and even from home to home in the same neighborhoods based on one’s economic means. Some might not be able to even afford the technology needed for e-filing, or have access to broadband or Internet services, even if they do have the technology (i.e. computers.) Thus, while it has been long anticipated that e-filing and e-service will become the norm, and not the exception, it has been with the understanding that public policy ultimately dictates that, when it comes to our courts, access – and uniform access at that – is imperative. This is not to state that the competing interests in efficiencies and access cannot coexist or help advance one another (indeed, allowing e-filing can grant litigants remote access to their courts, saving them valuable time that would otherwise be spent standing in line and away from work –which can be particularly difficult for low-wage and self-represented litigants); it is merely to acknowledge that any rules adopted in this state for e-filing need to be cognizant of the very real concerns related to access so as to not compromise them in the name of technological advancement and efficiency.
Accordingly, for years, California has authorized limited e-filing under Section 1010.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In 1999, SB 367 (Dunn, Chapter 514, Statutes of 1999), among other things, enacted Section 1010.6 to allow trial courts to adopt local rules permitting e-filing and service of documents, and to require the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules for the e-filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, as specified. SB 367 also reflected the legislative intent to: (1) provide for the eventual standardization of e-filing and service procedures on a statewide level; and (2) to provide that a court shall not adopt an e-filing procedure that requires a litigant or attorney to possess specialized, cumbersome, or expensive equipment or software to utilize the e-filing system. Subsequently, in 2010, SB 1274 (Committee on Judiciary, Chapter 156, Statutes of 2010) authorized parties to consent to, or the court to order, electronic service of documents that are not required to be personally served. SB 1274 also required the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules relating to the integrity of e-filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, and redefined “electronic service” to include both electronic notification and electronic transmission, as specified.
Most recently, in 2012, this state enacted additional legislation to authorize a pilot program in Orange County’s Superior Court that would allow for mandated e-filing in specified cases, as long as certain enumerated conditions were met. (AB 2073, Silva, Chapter 320, Statutes of 2012.) Recognizing that other courts may subsequently wish to move toward mandatory e-filing as well, AB 2073 also allowed for that possibility, on the condition that any future courts must also meet requirements of Section 1010.6 and any additional uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council for the filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state based upon its study of the Orange County pilot program. Indeed, in 2013, the Judicial Council approved a proposal, effective July 1, 2013, to allow superior courts to require that parties electronically file and serve documents in civil cases. Notably, those new rules exempt self-represented parties from any mandatory e-filing and service requirements adopted by participating courts, but also include language that encourages these parties to participate voluntarily. To the extent feasible, courts and other entities are encouraged to assist self-represented parties to electronically file and serve documents. (See California Courts Press Release, Judicial Council Allows Superior Courts to Require E-filing in Civil Cases (Jun. 28, 2013) <http://www.courts.ca.gov/22655.htm [as of Jun. 5, 2016].)
This bill updates various statutory rules and conditions surrounding mandatory e-filing, in particular relating to processing fees charged for e-filing payments, payment options, and the ability of prevailing parties to recover e-filing fees.
Comments
As stated by the author:
The Judicial Council’s Court Case Management System (CCMS), an ambitious court technology project to provide all 58 superior courts with a long-needed uniform, linked case management system would have, among other things, made it easier for parties to file their legal documents electronically with the courts. Since its demise in the heights of the Great Recession, California courts have moved to upgrade their information technology systems with local contracts with various vendors. These contracts typically provide for case management systems, electronic filing of documents, and more. Usually the third party vendor acts as an “electronic filing manager” (EFM) in creating the portals through which “electronic filing service providers” (EFSPs) actually file documents on behalf of law firms and other users of court services.
Increasingly, courts are moving to require the filing of documents electronically. In some counties, certain case types must be filed electronically, and often complex civil cases require e-filing. In some counties, EFSPs must pay court filing fees and e-filing transaction costs with credit cards, and pay convenience fees to electronic filing managers for the use of credit cards. While electronic filing represents a major benefit to the courts and public, how the systems are implemented can raise policy questions of fair access to the judicial system. In addition, present law contains a number of ambiguities which should be resolved as these systems are being implemented. AB 2244 is intended to address these ambiguities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Fee restrictions: Potentially significant costs to EFSPs and EFMs for processing costs that are unrecoverable due to fee exemptions/waivers. To the extent a court serves as the EFSP and/or EFM for low-income and self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers, these processing costs would be absorbed by the court’s operating budget (General Fund*). Alternatively, to the extent courts enter into vendor contracts for EFSP/EFM services, these unrecoverable costs could be built into the costs of the contracts (General Fund*).
- EFSP verification process: Potential future increase in workload (General Fund*) to the Judicial Council to conduct the verification process described in this bill which would include interviewing EFSP employees, as well as accessing, inspecting, and copying relevant records of fees/costs for auditing purposes. To the extent this process is already in place and operating, any impact to the Judicial Council would be absorbable.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Coalition for Improving Court Access
Judicial Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/12/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Burke, Jones-Sawyer
8/15/16 20:22:16
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2244 (Gatto) - Court fees: electronic filing
Version: June 13, 2016 | Policy Vote: JUD. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 1, 2016 | Consultant: Jolie Onodera |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 2244 would prescribe specified limits on the fees charged by the courts, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider associated with the electronic filing of court documents, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Fee restrictions: Potentially significant costs to electronic filing service providers (EFSPs) and electronic filing managers (EFMs) for processing costs that are unrecoverable due to fee exemptions/waivers. To the extent a court serves as the EFSP and/or EFM for low-income and self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers, these processing costs would be absorbed by the court’s operating budget (General Fund*). Alternatively, to the extent courts enter into vendor contracts for EFSP/EFM services, these unrecoverable costs could be built into the costs of the contracts (General Fund*).
- EFSP verification process: Potential future increase in workload (General Fund*) to the Judicial Council to conduct the verification process described in this measure which would include interviewing EFSP employees, as well as accessing, inspecting, and copying relevant records of fees/costs for auditing purposes. To the extent this process is already in place and operating, any impact to the Judicial Council would be absorbable.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Existing law authorizes a court and other specified public entities to accept credit card, debit card, or electronic fund transfers for the payment of certain government services and fees, including the payment of a filing fee or other court fee. A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer must first obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. Existing law provides that, notwithstanding specified law, a court may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. Any such fee imposed by a court must be approved by the Judicial Council. (Government Code § 6159(b), (c), (h).)
Existing law provides that a trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to Rules of Court adopted as specified and subject to specified conditions. (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) § 1010.6(b)(1)-(6).) Existing law requires the court to permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document, as specified. (CCP § 1010.6(b)(6).)
Existing law permits a court to require electronic filing of documents in complex civil litigation cases, as specified, provided that it does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action. The Judicial Council is required to adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of the electronic service. Existing law requires these rules to conform to the conditions set in Section 1010.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as amended from time to time. (CCP § 1010.6(c), (e).)
Existing Rules of Court set forth uniform rules regarding electronic filing and serving of documents. (California Rules of Court, rules 2.250-2.261.)
Existing law also requires the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2014, to adopt uniform rules for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified actions in the state’s trial courts, which are to be informed by the pilot project, above, and are to include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. Existing law provides that upon the adoption of those rules, a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including several of the conditions that must be met by any court allowing e-filing of documents and several of the requirements specified for the mandatory e-filing pilot project, above. (CCP § 1010.6(f), (g).)
While the practice of electronic filing may create substantial efficiencies and cost savings for both litigants and the courts, the state has been cautious of the hardships that electronic filing might cause for some courts or litigants, particularly low income or unrepresented litigants, given that access to electronic communications are still widely disparate among different cities and counties within this state, and even from home to home in the same neighborhoods based on one’s economic means. Some might not be able to afford the technology needed to electronically file, or have access to broadband or internet services. Thus, while it has been long anticipated that electronic filing will be adopted widely, it has been with the understanding that public policy ultimately dictates that uniform access to justice in the courts is imperative.
This bill would update specified statutory rules and conditions surrounding mandatory electronic filing, in particular relating to processing fees charged for electronic filing payments, payment options, and the ability of prevailing parties to recover electronic filing fees.
Proposed Law:
This bill would prescribe the following specified limits on fees associated with the electronic filing of court documents:
- Adds a new condition to the list of conditions that would have to be met both by courts that elect to permit, and courts that otherwise mandate, e-filing and service of documents. Specifically, it would provide that a fee, if any, charged by a court, an electronic filing manager (EFM), or an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred.
- Consistent with existing law, specifies that the court, an EFM, or an EFSP shall waive any fees charged if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
- Prohibits an EFSP, as described, from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing or other court fee, or a fee charged by the EFSP for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the EFSP must complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
- Further requires a court or an EFM that provides a court, pursuant to contract, a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees accept more than one method of payment to an EFSP who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing or other court as an agent of the court, as specified, below. The bill would require the court to determine which methods of payment shall be accepted by the court and the electronic filing manager, and specifies that the methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
- Authorizes an “agent of the court” to impose a fee for use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. This bill would provide for these purposes, that an EFSP who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing fee or other court fee, as specified, complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court, and, unless specified otherwise, the electronic filing service provider is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting such payments for an electronic filing transaction. This bill would further ensure that, consistent with the existing requirement under Section 6159 of the Government Code, above, that any such fees charged by the court be approved by the Judicial Council, that any fees charged by the EFSP be approved by the Judicial Council.
- Prohibits a court from being held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under the above provisions and would require that an agent of the court report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to Judicial Council guidelines.
- Requires the Judicial Council or its authorized representative to have access to and the right to examine the records and documents of an agent of the court for purposes of verifying the accuracy of the fee and cost reports to be issued pursuant to guidelines adopted by the Judicial Council and to verify compliance with this reporting requirement. The agent of the court must: (1) provide the Judicial Council all relevant information requested; (2) permit access to its premises at reasonable times, for the purposes of interviewing employees and inspecting and copying any relevant records; and (3) maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed or until the verification process is complete, whichever is later.
- Adds to the list of recoverable costs by prevailing parties:
- Fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an EFSP if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service.
- Fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an EFSP. This bill provides that this paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
- Makes other technical, clarifying and non-substantive changes.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2073 (Silva) Chapter 320/2012 authorized the Orange County Superior Court to establish a pilot project mandating that parties electronically file documents in specified civil cases, and required the Judicial Council to adopt a rule on mandatory electronic filing before July 1, 2014.
Staff Comments:
The Judicial Council has indicated the provisions of this measure are consistent with ongoing internal efforts to promote the use and fairness of electronic filing.
Staff notes that due to the restrictions placed on charging fees for persons subject to fee exemptions/waivers, this bill could result in ongoing operating costs to the entities responsible for the processing costs, which could be the vendor EFSP, the EFM, or the court. To the extent a court serves as the EFSP and/or EFM for low-income and self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers, these processing costs would be absorbed by the court’s operating budget. Alternatively, to the extent courts enter into vendor contracts for EFSP/EFM services, these unrecoverable costs could be built into the costs of the vendor contracts, which would also be a state cost. The magnitude of these costs would be dependent on the unit processing cost and the volume of transactions subject to the processing fee waiver annually, which is unknown but potentially significant. As reported by the Judicial Council:
A fully functioning e-filing system (as opposed to “e-delivery,” which allows for documents to be delivered to a court email address or other electronic drop box, but does not integrate those documents into the court’s case management system) requires both an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) to receive the filing, and an electronic filing manager (EFM), to serve as a “translator” of the information received on the forms from the EFSPs and deliver that information into an individual court’s case management system. In California, local courts that are pursuing e-filing are working with their case management system vendors to determine a certification process for e-filing service providers (EFSPs) and an appropriate number of EFSPs for certification. They will also be contracting with a vendor for the development of an EFM to communicate with their case management systems, in order to deliver the benefits of truly paperless filing.
Early experiences with e-filing, both in California and in other states, suggest that many private vendor EFSPs are not focused on serving the market segment of self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers. The access community believes that the exclusion of self-represented litigants from electronic filing “has the potential to enlarge the access to justice gap in the long run.” Electronic filing is an area in which a slight tip of the balance means that the technology tool is no longer used to achieve greater access; rather, it becomes a barrier. The California judicial branch has the opportunity to “place a finger on the scale” in favor of low-income and self-represented litigants by developing the capacity to serve as the EFSP and EFM for all self-represented litigants in the state.
In other states, the judicial branch serves as either a sole EFSP or sole EFM for all forms of electronic filing (or manages contracts with outside vendors for these services) on behalf of all courts throughout the state. In California, the Judicial Council can ensure that electronic filing is available to all court users by serving as a one-stop EFSP and EFM for self-represented litigants. (Judicial Council, The Critical Role of the State Judiciary in Increasing Access for Self-Represented Litigants: Self-Help Access 360° (Jul. 2015)
This bill requires the Judicial Council or its authorized representative to have access to and the right to examine the records and documents of an EFSP for purposes of verifying the accuracy of its fee and cost reports issued, and to verify the EFSP’s compliance with the bill’s provisions. Additionally, the bill requires EFSPs to maintain records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed, or until the verification process is completed, whichever is later. This requirement would imply that the verification process must be conducted, although it does not impose a strict timeline within which the process must be completed. As a result, the Judicial Council could potentially incur additional workload to conduct the verification process described in this measure which would include interviewing EFSP employees, as well as accessing, inspecting, and copying relevant records of fees/costs for auditing purposes. To the extent this process is already in place and operating, any impact to the Judicial Council would be absorbable.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2244 (Author:Gatto)
Version: June 13, 2016
Hearing Date: June 21, 2016
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: RD
SUBJECT
Court fees: electronic filing
DESCRIPTION
This bill would ensure that if any trial court permits or mandates electronic filing and service of documents, any fees charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred. This bill would further ensure that if a trial court mandates e-filing: (1) a court or an electronic filing manager contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated fees accept more than one method of payment to an electronic filing service provider, to be determined by the court, that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH) and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost; and (2) clarify that an EFSP is an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting specified payments and any fees set by an EFSP must, consistent with existing law, be approved by the Judicial Council.
This bill would also allow for prevailing parties to recover fees associated with electronic filing and service through an EFSP, as specified. Lastly, the bill requires agents of the court (EFSPs) to report their costs to the Judicial Council and requires that the Judicial Council or its authorized representative have access to and the right to examine the records and documents of agents of the court for purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this reporting requirement, as specified.
BACKGROUND
The federal courts, have long allowed for electronic filing of court documents. (See Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. rule 5(d)(3), which provides that a court may, by local rule, allow papers to be filed, signed, or verified by electronic means that are consistent with any technical standards established by the Judicial Conference of the United States, and may require electronic filing only if reasonable exceptions are allowed.) The federal rules also, however, prohibit a court clerk from refusing to accept paper filings – even if a local court rule mandates electronic filing. (Fed. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 5(d)(4); see also Klemm v. Astrue (9th Cir. 2008) 543 F.3d 1139, 1143: “Under this rule, the Clerk was obligated to accept Klemm’s notice of appeal for filing, despite Klemm's failure to comply with the local electronic filing rules. [Footnote omitted.] In any event, the Clerk's failure formally to file Klemm's notice of appeal is of no import because the paper was deemed filed when it ‘arrived in the hands of the Clerk within the statutory period.’ [Citation omitted.] Thus, Klemm's notice of appeal was timely even though it was mailed to the Clerk, rather than filed electronically, as the local rules require.”)
E-filing proponents argue that it creates substantial efficiencies and cost savings for both litigants and the courts: it saves in time, labor, postage, supplies, storage, and travel; creates easier and timelier access to records and documents by the courts and the public; engenders more efficient use of staff time; allows for remote access to court records by lawyers and the public over the Internet; grants attorneys the flexibility to file documents after hours when courts are closed; and gives multiple parties the ability to view the same documents, at the same time. At the same time, however, this state has been cautious of the hardships that e-filing might cause for some courts or litigants—particularly low income or unrepresented litigants—given that access to electronic communications are still widely disparate among different cities and counties within this state, and even from home to home in the same neighborhoods based on one’s economic means. Some might not be able to even afford the technology needed for e-filing, or have access to broadband or Internet services, even if they do have the technology (i.e. computers.) Thus, while it has been long anticipated that e-filing and e-service will become the norm, and not the exception, it has been with the understanding that public policy ultimately dictates that, when it comes to our courts, access (and uniform access at that) is imperative. This is not to state that the competing interests in efficiencies and access cannot coexist or help advance one another[1]; it is merely to acknowledge that any rules adopted in this state for e-filing need to be cognizant of the very real concerns related to access so as to not compromise them in the name of technological advancement and efficiency.
Accordingly, for years, California has authorized limited electronic filing under Section 1010.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure. In 1999, SB 367 (Dunn, Ch. 514, Stats. 1999), among other things, enacted Section 1010.6, to allow trial courts to adopt local rules permitting e-filing and service of documents, and to require the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, as specified. SB 367 also reflected the legislative intent to: (1) provide for the eventual standardization of electronic filing and service procedures on a statewide level; and (2) to provide that a court shall not adopt an electronic filing procedure that requires a litigant or attorney to possess specialized, cumbersome, or expensive equipment or software to utilize the electronic filing system. Subsequently, in 2010, SB 1274 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 156, Stats. 2010) authorized parties to consent to, or the court to order, electronic service of documents that are not required to be personally served. Among other things, SB 1274 also required the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules relating to the integrity of electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, and redefined “electronic service” to include both electronic notification and electronic transmission, as specified.
Most recently, in 2012, this state enacted additional legislation to authorize a pilot program in Orange County’s Superior Court that would allow for mandated e-filing in specified cases, as long as certain enumerated conditions were met. (See AB 2073, (Silva, Ch. 320, Stats. 2012).) Recognizing that other courts may subsequently wish to move toward mandatory e-filing as well, AB 2073 also allowed for that possibility, on the condition that any future courts must also meet requirements of Section 1010.6 and any additional uniform rules adopted by the Judicial Council for the filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state based upon its study of the Orange County court’s pilot program. Indeed, in 2013, the Judicial Council approved a proposal, effective July 1, 2013, to allow superior courts to require that parties electronically file and serve documents in civil cases. Notably, those new rules exempt self-represented parties from any mandatory e-filing and service requirements adopted by participating courts, but also include language that encourages these parties to participate voluntarily. To the extent feasible, courts and other entities are encouraged to assist self-represented parties to electronically file and serve documents. (See California Courts Press Release, Judicial Council Allows Superior Courts to Require E-filing in Civil Cases (Jun. 28, 2013) <http://www.courts.ca.gov/22655.htm> [as of Jun. 5, 2016].)
This bill would update some of the statutory rules and conditions surrounding mandatory e-filing, in particular relating to processing fees charged for e-filing payments, payment options, and the ability of prevailing parties to recover e-filing fees.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that except as otherwise provided by statute, a prevailing party, as defined, is entitled as a matter of right to recover costs in any action or proceeding. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1032(a)(5).)
Existing law enumerates the items allowable as costs under the above provision, including, among other things:
- filing, motion, and jury fees;
- transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court;
- court reporter fees as established by statute;
- court interpreter fees, as specified; and
- any other item that is required to be awarded to the prevailing party pursuant to statute as an incident to prevailing in the action at trial or on appeal. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1033.5(a).)
Existing law provides that any award of costs is subject to the following, among other things:
- allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation; and
- allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1033.5(c).)
Existing law authorizes a court and other specified public entities to accept credit card, debit card, or electronic fund transfers for the payment of certain government services and fees, including the payment of a filing fee or other court fee. A court desiring to authorize the use of a credit card, debit card, or electronic funds transfer must first obtain the approval of the Judicial Council. Existing law provides that, notwithstanding specified law, a court may impose a fee for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agency in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. These costs may include, but shall not be limited to, the payment of fees or discounts to the card issuer, funds process, or draft purchaser. Any such fee imposed by a court must be approved by the Judicial Council. (Gov. Code Sec. 6159(b), (c), (h).)
Existing law provides that in any action in which a party has agreed to accept electronic service or in which the court has ordered electronic service, as specified, the court may electronically serve any document issued by the court that is not required to be personally served in the same manner that parties electronically serve documents. Existing law provides that electronic service shall have the same legal effect as service by mail, except as provided. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(a)(3).)
Existing law provides that a trial court may adopt local rules permitting electronic filing of documents, subject to Rules of Court adopted as specified and subject to specified conditions. These include conditions relating to electronic signatures and fee waivers, among other things. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(b)(1)-(6).) Existing law requires the court to permit a party or attorney to file an application for waiver of court fees and costs, in lieu of requiring the payment of the filing fee, as part of the process involving the electronic filing of a document, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(b)(6).)
Existing law permits a court to require electronic filing of documents in complex civil litigation cases, as specified, provided that it does not cause undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(c).)
Existing law requires the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules for the electronic filing and service of documents in the trial courts of the state, which shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, and access to public records, and rules relating to the integrity of the electronic service. Existing law requires these rules to conform to the conditions set in Section 1010.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as amended from time to time. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(e).)
Existing Rules of Court set forth uniform rules regarding electronic filing and serving of documents. (California Rules of Court, rules 2.250-2.261.)
Existing law provides authority for the Orange County Superior Court, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, to establish a pilot project to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to specified requirements and rules adopted by Judicial Council, and certain additional conditions. Those additional conditions include that the court and the parties either have access to more than one electronic service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court, or to electronic filing access directly through the court. Any fees charged by the court must be for no more than the actual cost of electronic filing and service of the documents, whereas any fees charged by the electronic service provider must be reasonable. In both instances, fees must be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including for any party who has received a fee waiver. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(d).)
Existing law also requires the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2014, to adopt uniform rules for mandatory electronic filing and service of documents for specified actions in the state’s trial courts, which are to be informed by the pilot project, above, and are to include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and rules relating to the integrity of electronic service. Existing law provides that upon the adoption of those rules, a superior court may, by local rule, require mandatory electronic filing, pursuant to the requirements and conditions set forth in this section, including several of the conditions that must be met by any court allowing e-filing of documents and several of the requirements specified for the mandatory e-filing pilot project, above. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(f), (g).)
This bill would add a new condition to the list of conditions that would have to be met both by courts that elect to permit, and courts that otherwise mandate, e-filing and service of documents. Specifically, it would provide that a fee, if any, charged by a court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment for filing fees and other court fees shall not exceed the costs incurred.
This bill would, consistent with existing law, specify that the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider shall waive any fees charged if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
This bill would prohibit an electronic filing service provider, as described, from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an electronic filing transaction, including a fee to process a payment, a filing or other court fee, or a fee charged by the electronic filing service provider for electronically filing documents, from a party who is exempt from paying fees; provided, however, that the electronic filing service provider must complete the filing notwithstanding the fee exemption.
This bill would further require a court or an electronic filing manager that provides a court, pursuant to contract, a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents and associated filing and other court fees accept more than one method of payment to an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing or other court as an agent of the court, as specified, below. The bill would require the court to determine which methods of payment shall be accepted by the court and the electronic filing manager, and specifies that the methods of payment may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH) and other payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
This bill would authorize an “agent of the court” to impose a fee for use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer. This bill would provide for these purposes, that an electronic filing service provider who is required to collect and remit a payment of a filing fee or other court fee, as specified, complete an electronic filing transaction is deemed an agent of the court, and, unless specified otherwise, the electronic filing service provider is deemed an agent of the court for the sole purpose of collecting and remitting such payments for an electronic filing transaction. This bill would further ensure that, consistent with the existing requirement under Section 6159 of the Government Code, above, that any such fees charged by the court be approved by the Judicial Council, that any fees charged by the electronic filing service provider be approved by the Judicial Council.
This bill would prohibit a court from being held liable for the actions of an agent of the court under the above provisions and would require that an agent of the court report its costs in providing for payment by credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer pursuant to Judicial Council guidelines. This bill would require that the Judicial Council or its authorized representative have access to and the right to examine the records and documents of an agent of the court for purposes of verifying the accuracy of these reports and compliance with this reporting requirement. The agent of the court must: (1) provide the Judicial Council all relevant information requested; (2) permit access to its premises at reasonable times, for the purposes of interviewing employees and inspecting and copying any relevant records; and (3) maintain all records and documents relating to its fees and costs for a minimum of four years from the date the fee is imposed or until the verification process is complete, whichever is later.
This bill would add to the list of recoverable costs by prevailing parties:
- fees for the electronic filing or service of documents through an electronic filing service provider if a court requires or orders electronic filing or service; and
- fees for the hosting of electronic documents if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider. This bill provides that this paragraph shall become inoperative on January 1, 2022.
This bill would make other technical, clarifying or non-substantive changes.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
The Judicial Council’s Court Case Management System (CCMS), an ambitious court technology project to provide all 58 superior courts with a long-needed uniform, linked case management system would have, among other things, made it easier for parties to file their legal documents electronically with the courts. Since its demise in the heights of the Great Recession, California courts have moved to upgrade their information technology systems with local contracts with various vendors. These contracts typically provide for case management systems, electronic filing of documents, and more. Usually the third party vendor acts as an “electronic filing manager” (EFM) in creating the portals through which “electronic filing service providers” (EFSPs) actually file documents on behalf of law firms and other users of court services.
Increasingly, courts are moving to require the filing of documents electronically. In some counties, certain case types must be filed electronically, and often complex civil cases require e-filing. In some counties, EFSPs must pay court filing fees and e-filing transaction costs with credit cards, and pay convenience fees to electronic filing managers for the use of credit cards.
While electronic filing represents a major benefit to the courts and public, how the systems are implemented can raise policy questions of fair access to the judicial system. In addition, present law contains a number of ambiguities which should be resolved as these systems are being implemented. AB 2244 is intended to address these ambiguities.
In support, the Coalition for Improving Court Access, adds:
The use of electronic filing is expanding rapidly in California courts, and courts throughout the country. Rather than create and maintain electronic filing systems directly, most courts have turned to contracts with private companies to provide the services. In simple terms, the entities which create and maintain the electronic filing portals into courts are known as “electronic filing managers” (EFMs), while companies which interact with law firms and other filers to transmit documents to courts through these portals are known as “electronic filing service providers” (EFSPs).
Courts increasingly are mandating the electronic filing of documents in particular case types, as we move towards “paperless” systems. There are tremendous benefits to litigants and courts which can result from properly designed and supervised electronic filing systems. [ . . . ] Taken together, [the proposed changes in AB 2244] resolve ambiguities and help establish the statutory framework to support the growth of electronic filing in California courts.
2. Relevant terminology, explained
This bill uses terminology such as “electronic filing managers” and “electronic filing service providers,” and, as does existing law, recognizes that e-filing can be provided directly by the courts or by electronic filing service providers. As explained in a recent report by the Judicial Council:
A fully functioning e-filing system (as opposed to “e-delivery,” which allows for documents to be delivered to a court email address or other electronic drop box, but does not integrate those documents into the court’s case management system) requires both an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) to receive the filing, and an electronic filing manager (EFM), to serve as a “translator” of the information received on the forms from the EFSPs and deliver that information into an individual court’s case management system. In California, local courts that are pursuing e-filing are working with their case management system vendors to determine a certification process for e-filing service providers (EFSPs) and an appropriate number of EFSPs for certification. They will also be contracting with a vendor for the development of an EFM to communicate with their case management systems, in order to deliver the benefits of truly paperless filing.
Early experiences with e-filing, both in California and in other states, suggest that many private vendor EFSPs are not focused on serving the market segment of self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers. The access community believes that the exclusion of self-represented litigants from electronic filing “has the potential to enlarge the access to justice gap in the long run.” Electronic filing is an area in which a slight tip of the balance means that the technology tool is no longer used to achieve greater access; rather, it becomes a barrier. The California judicial branch has the opportunity to “place a finger on the scale” in favor of low-income and self-represented litigants by developing the capacity to serve as the EFSP and EFM for all self-represented litigants in the state.
In other states, the judicial branch serves as either a sole EFSP or sole EFM for all forms of electronic filing (or manages contracts with outside vendors for these services) on behalf of all courts throughout the state. In California, the Judicial Council can ensure that electronic filing is available to all court users by serving as a one-stop EFSP and EFM for self-represented litigants. This function is the culmination of the work currently being undertaken to apply user-centered design concepts to the information currently available on the statewide self-help website and is the final link in providing full and equal access to the courts for self-represented litigants. (Judicial Council, The Critical Role of the State Judiciary in Increasing Access for Self-Represented Litigants: Self-Help Access 360° (Jul. 2015) <http://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/ctac-20150710-report-addendum.pdf> [as of Jun. 5, 2016] (Footnote omitted).)
3. Bill would enhance consumer protections for purposes of mandatory e-filing fees
Existing law allows for courts to adopt local rules allowing parties to electronically serve specified documents, consistent with certain statutory requirements and conditions and applicable Rules of Court. In 2012, AB 2073 (Silva, Ch. 320, Stats. 2012) was enacted to authorize a temporary pilot project in the Orange County Superior Court to require parties to specified civil actions to electronically file and serve documents, subject to the rules adopted by the Judicial Council and other specified conditions. That bill also required the Judicial Council to adopt uniform rules for mandatory electronic filing (or e-filing) and service of documents for specified civil actions in the state’s trial courts, and ensured that any subsequent trial courts that seek to mandate electronic filing adopt the conditions required by the Orange County Superior Court pilot and the applicable Rules of Court issued by the Judicial Council, as well as certain statutory conditions that would apply in the context of voluntary e-filing courts. As noted in the Background, the Judicial Council has since adopted rules allowing for courts to mandate e-filing in civil actions, having declared the pilot project a success which, overall “resulted in significant cost savings for the court and was generally less or equally expensive for litigants” and “demonstrated the project’s relative ease of use and convenience for represented and self-represented litigants.” (Judicial Council, Report on the Superior Court of Orange County’s Mandatory E-Filing Pilot Project: Report to the Legislature as Required by Code of Civil Procedure Section 1010.6(d)(2) (Sept. 2014) <http://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/lr-SC-of-Orange-e-file-pilot-proj.pdf > [as of Jun. 5, 2016].)
This bill now seeks to make various updates to the statutory conditions and requirements that relate to e-filing payments, including processing fees. Most relevant to this bill, if a superior court desires to mandate e-filing, existing law dictates, among other things, that the court and the parties either have access to more than one electronic filing service provider (ESFP) capable of electronically filing documents with the court, or to electronic filing access directly through the court. Any fees charged by the court must be for no more than the actual cost of electronic filing and service of the documents and shall be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including, but not limited to, for any party who has received a fee waiver. In contrast, any fees charged by an ESFP are required to be “reasonable,” and, must also be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including for any party who has received a fee waiver. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1010.6(d)(1)(B).)
This bill would now expressly prohibit a court, electronic filing manager (EFM), or EFSP from charging processing fees for filing fees and other court fees shall in excess of the actual costs incurred. Notably, this prohibition would apply not only in courts that mandate e-filing, but also those that allow it on a voluntary basis. Additionally, consistent with existing law, this bill would continue to ensure that the court, an EFM, or an EFSP waive any fees charged if the court deems a waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver. Such fees, as reflected in the bill, include a fee to process a payment, a filing or other court fee, or a fee charged by the EFSP for electronically filing documents. Moreover, the bill ensures that any fees for the use of a credit or debit card or electronic funds transfer that are set by the EFSP, as an agent of the court, who is required to collect and remit funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction, would also have to first be approved by the Judicial Council. (See Gov. Code Sec. 6159(h), which requires any such fees, when set by a court, be approved by the Judicial Council.)
Thus, as a practical matter, under this bill, any fees charged to litigants for e-filing payments that they make by way of credit card are restricted to the actual amount incurred for processing the credit card payment, and no more—which is particularly important when parties have no alternatives to e-filing in certain actions. Moreover, the bill would further ensure that the court or the contracted entity providing the system for acceptance of e-documents and associated fees not require an EFSP to use any single method of payment. The court or contracted EFM would, instead, have to allow for more than one form of payment, to be selected by the court, which may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions such as Automated Clearing House (ACH) and – notably – payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost. Moreover, consistent with the existing requirement that fees be waived for parties who have received fee waivers from the court (e.g., indigent parties), this bill would expressly prohibit EFSPs from collecting or attempting to collect a fee to complete an e-filing transaction from a party who is exempt from paying fees.
As a matter of public policy, as discussed in the Background, while it is encouraging to see this state’s courts incrementally move toward mandatory e-filing, it is important to balance the desire for innovation and efficiencies against access and potential hardships to litigants, particularly for low-income individuals. By adding such consumer protections into the law surrounding the conditions which must be met before e-filing can be mandated by any California trial court, this bill would appear to recognize the concerns related to access and help ensure that those concerns are not compromised in the name of technological advancement and efficiency.
4. Recovery of electronic filing service provider and EFSP hosting fees
California allows prevailing parties to recover certain fees. For these purposes, Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure lists various categories of costs that a prevailing party may currently recover, to which this bill would add electronic filing service provider (EFSP) fees as well as EFSP hosting fees. Specifically, this bill provides that if a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court, the party may recover fees for the electronic filing or service of the documents through an EFSP (which are otherwise limited by the bill to the actual costs incurred). Similarly, if a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an ESFP, the prevailing party may recover those fees, though only until January 1, 2022.
Notably, Section 1033.5 already permits the recovery of filing fees. Indeed, when this Committee considered AB 2073 in 2012 to allow for an Orange County pilot program (see Comment 2, above) a question was raised as to the recovery of e-filing fees:
Interested parties have raised a question of whether the cost of e-filing, in a county in which e-filing is made mandatory, is a form of recoverable fees under Section 1033.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure. That section lists costs that are generally recoverable, in the court’s discretion, by a prevailing party, including, “[f]iling, motion, and jury fees.” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1033.5(a)(1).) Staff notes that where e-filing is made mandatory pursuant to this pilot project, the direct cost of using the designated e-filing systems to file documents is arguably among those filing fees that can be recoverable under that section under the plain meaning of the term, “filing fees.” (Sen. Judiciary Com. analysis of AB 2073 (2011-2012 Reg. Session) Jun. 10, 2012, p. 10.)
This bill would now make that presumption explicit. Ultimately, allowable costs must be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation and must be reasonable in amount. (See Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1033.5(c).) In support, the Judicial Council writes that this bill “will result in a more consistent electronic filing universe for both the public and the courts, while also providing clarity for ESFPs in planning their operations under the improved laws.”
Support: Coalition for Improving Court Access; Judicial Council
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: AB 2073 (Silva, Ch. 320, Stats. 2012) See Background; Comments 2 and 3.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 78, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 20, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Indeed, allowing e-filing can grant litigants access (remote access) to their courts, saving them valuable time that would otherwise be spent standing in line and away from work—which can be particularly difficult for low-wage and self-represented litigants. ↑
Date of Hearing: May 4, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2244
Author:(Gatto) – As Amended Ver:April 13, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prescribes certain limits on fees associated with electronic filing of court documents. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a fee imposed by an agent of the court for the use of a credit card or debit card or for an electronic funds transfer, may not exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for that payment method, and that fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment may not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing.
- Requires the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to waive processing payment fees if the court deems the waiver to be appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
- Requires a court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents to provide a menu of payment options that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions, and payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Negligible fiscal impact on the courts.
COMMENTS:
- Background. During the 2013-14, 7.5 million cases were filed statewide in the superior courts. Given the high volume of filings in California’s courts each year, a party’s ability to file and serve documents electronically significantly improves the court’s capacity to process filings. The Judicial Council’s Court Case Management System (CCMS), among other things, would have made it easier for parties to file their legal documents electronically with the courts in all 58 counties.
Due to cost overruns an inadequate project oversight, in March 2012, the Judicial Council terminated the project, which left many trial courts with failing case management systems. As a result, counties have turned to various private vendors to provide technology systems to their courts. Generally, these private technology systems allow for the electronic filing of documents.
- Purpose. According to the author, "In some counties, EFSPs [electronic filing service providers] must pay court filing fees and e-filing transaction costs with credit cards, and pay convenience fees to electronic filing managers for the use of credit cards. While electronic filing represents a major benefit to the courts and public, how the systems are implemented can raise policy questions of fair access to the judicial system. In addition, present law contains a number of ambiguities which should be resolved as these systems are being implemented. AB 2244 is intended to address some of these ambiguities."
Under current law, government entities may accept credit cards, debit cards, or electronic funds transfers for the payment of certain government services, including court filings. Although current law allows a government entity, including a court, to impose a convenience fee for those transactions, the government entity may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds its costs for providing that payment method.
Consistent with current law, this bill provides that an electronic filing service provider, who remits funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction and acts as an agent of the court, may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds the provider’s cost to provide that service. In order to further protect litigants and provide greater clarity about convenience costs associated with processing payment methods, this bill also requires that when a trial court adopts rules for mandatory electronic filing, the fees (if any) that are charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment may not exceed the actual costs incurred by the court, manager, or provider.
In addition, to ensure that litigants with fee waivers have true access to electronic filing without fees, this bill prohibits those litigants from being required to pay transaction processing fees and clarifies existing law to require an electronic filing service provider to electronically file a fee-waiver-litigant’s documents if that is the litigant’s preferred method. Finally, in order to protect litigants who may not have access to credit or debit cards, this bill also requires electronic filing managers to accept alternative forms of payment.
Analysis Prepared by: Chuck Nicol / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 12, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2244
Author:(Gatto) – As Amended Ver:April 5, 2016
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: COURT FEES: ELECTRONIC FILING
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO REDUCE COSTS FOR LITIGANTS AND TO PROMOTE ACCESS TO JUSTICE FOR INDIGENT PARTIES, SHOULD ELECTRONIC FILING VENDORS BE PROHIBITED FROM CHARGING A PAYMENT TRANSACTION COST THAT EXCEEDS THE ACTUAL COST, AND BE REQUIRED TO PROVIDE A VARIETY OF PAYMENT METHODS, INCLUDING METHODS THAT DO NOT CHARGE A TRANSACTION COST?
SYNOPSIS
During the 2013-14 fiscal year, there were nearly 7.5 million cases filed in our trial courts statewide. Given the high volume of filings, a party’s ability to file and serve documents electronically significantly improves the court’s capacity to process filings. The now-defunct statewide Court Case Management System (CCMS) would have made it easier for courts to accept electronic filings. As a result of CCMS’s termination, trial courts have looked toward private vendors to provide electronic filing services.
It seems safe to say that electronic filing has dramatically improved over the years and this technological improvement has helped improve access to courts. But of course, the electronic filing system isn’t perfect. Indeed, courts need to ensure that any electronic filing system protects low-income and indigent litigants and reduces costs for all parties by promoting competition among vendors.
Consistent with these goals, this bill reduces costs for litigants and promotes access to justice for indigent litigants. First, this bill prohibits electronic filing vendors from charging a credit card convenience fee that exceeds the cost incurred by vendors in providing that transaction, consistent with existing law. Second, this bill prohibits electronic filing vendors from charging indigent litigants a payment processing fee and clarifies existing law so that indigent litigants may more easily file electronically without being charged. Third, this bill requires the court or the electronic filing manager to provide a menu of alternative forms of payment, including payments methods that do not charge transaction fees. Lastly, this bill allows parties to recover electronic service fees as allowable recoverable costs in courts that require mandatory electronic filing. This author-sponsored bill is supported by the Coalition for Improving Court Access, a coalition of electronic filing service providers and others who support the growth of electronic filing in California courts, and has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Prohibits electronic filing vendors from charging a payment method convenience fee that exceeds the cost incurred to provide the processing. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that an agent of the court may impose a fee for the use of a credit card or debit card or electronic funds transfer, not to exceed the costs incurred by the agent in providing for that payment method. Provides that fees, if any, charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred for processing.
- Requires the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to waive processing payment fees if the court deems waiver appropriate, including in instances where a party has received a fee waiver.
- Requires a court or an entity contracted with a court to provide a system for acceptance of electronically transmitted documents to provide a menu of payment options that may include credit or debit cards, electronic funds transfers, electronic networks for financial transactions, and payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost.
- Allows a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider fees as costs.
- Allows a prevailing party to recover electronic filing service provider hosting fees as cost until January 1, 2022.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes courts to allow parties to electronically file court documents in accordance to rules established by the Judicial Council, and as provided by state law. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1010.6(b). Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure.)
- Authorizes courts to require parties to electronically file documents in a class action, a consolidated action, or a group of actions, a coordinated action, or an action that is deemed complex under Judicial Council rules, provided that the trial court’s order does not cause undue hardship or significance prejudice to any party to the action. (Section 1010.6 (c).)
- Authorized the Orange County Superior Court, by local rule and until July 1, 2014, to establish a pilot project to require parties to electronically file and serve documents in specified civil actions subject to specified conditions, including:
- The court shall have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required.
- The court and the parties shall have access either to more than one electronic filing service provider capable of electronically filing documents with the court, or to electronic filing access directly through the court.
- Any fees charged by the court shall be for no more than the actual cost of the electronic filing and service of the documents, and shall be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including, but not limited to, for any party who has received a fee waiver. Any fees charged by an electronic filing service provider shall be reasonable and shall be waived when deemed appropriate by the court, including, but not limited to, for any party who has received a fee waiver. (Section 1010.6 (d).)
- Authorizes trial courts to require parties to electronically file and serve documents, provided that the trial court follows the rules adopted by the Judicial Council for mandatory electronic filing, and meets the conditions specified under the Orange County Superior Court pilot, as provided above in #3. (Section 1010.6 (g).)
- Provides that rules adopted by the Judicial Council relating to mandatory electronic filing and service of documents in trial courts shall include statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and the integrity of electronic service. (Section 1010.6 (f).)
- Sets forth the rules adopted by the Judicial Council regarding electronic filing and serving of court documents. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rules 2.250-2.261.)
- Pursuant to the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a court may, by local rule, allow papers to be filed, signed, or verified by electronic means as provided. A local rule may require electronic filing only if reasonable exceptions are allowed. The clerk must not refuse to file a paper solely because it is not in the form prescribed by a local rule or practice. (Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., rule 5(d), 28 U.S.C.)
- Requires the court to permit a party or an attorney to file an application for a fee waiver as part of the electronic filing process. (Section 1010.6 (b)(6).)
- Authorizes a court and other specified public agencies to accept credit card, debit card, or electronic fund transfers for the payment of specified government services and fees. Provides that when a court or other specified public agencies authorizes one of the payment methods, the public agency may impose a fee for the use of a debit card, or electronic fund transfer not to exceed the costs incurred by the public agency in providing for payment. If a court is imposing the fee, the fee shall be approved by the Judicial Council. (Government Code Section 6159.)
- Provides that a prevailing party is entitled as a matter of right to recover costs in any action or proceeding, as provided. (Section 1032.)
- Provides specified items that are allowable recoverable costs and others that are not allowable recoverable costs. (Section 1033.5)
- Provides that any award of costs shall be subject to the following:
- Costs are allowable if incurred, whether or not paid.
- Allowable costs shall be reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation rather than merely convenient or beneficial to its preparation.
- Allowable costs shall be reasonable in amount.
- Items not specifically mentioned and items assessed upon application may be allowed or denied in the court’s discretion. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: California’s court system is one of the largest in the world, with more than 2,000 judicial officers and approximately 19,000 judicial branch employees statewide who assist in the court’s management of cases every year. (2015 Courts Statistics Report: Statewide Caseload Trends, Judicial Council of California (2015).) During the 2013-14 fiscal year, there were 7.5 million cases filed statewide in the superior courts. (Ibid.)
Given the high volume of filings in California’s courts each year, a party’s ability to file and serve documents electronically significantly improves the court’s capacity to process filings. Ideally, parties could file their legal documents electronically directly to the court through a statewide case management system at no additional cost (aside from the court filing fee). But given the reality of the courts not having such a system, trial courts are doing the best they can to facilitate electronic filing with county systems that rely upon fees for service.
The Failure of a Statewide Court Case Management System (Which Would Have Allowed Parties to File Electronically) Has Forced Trial Courts to Look Elsewhere for Technological Improvements. The Judicial Council’s Court Case Management System (CCMS), an ambitious court technology project to provide all 58 superior courts with a long-needed uniform, linked case management system would have, among other things, made it easier for parties to file their legal documents electronically with the courts.
In February 2011, the California State Auditor issued a report roundly criticizing the Judicial Council's lack of proper management and oversight of the project. In its report, the Auditor concluded that, among other criticisms of the project, the Judicial Council did not ensure adequate independent oversight of CCMS, as would be expected of a project of similar size and complexity. Concern about the computer project continued, resulting in internal and independent reviews, legislative hearings, and proposed legislation. In March of 2012, the Legislature concluded the project must be halted and denied any further funding to CCMS. Later that month, the Judicial Council terminated the project. The termination of CCMS, after the expenditure of more than half a billion dollars, not only depleted the courts’ increasingly scarce resources, but also left many trial courts with failing case management systems. As a result, counties have turned to various private vendors to provide technology systems to their courts. Generally, these private technology systems allow for the electronic filing of documents.
In support of the bill, the author writes that electronic filing represents the future in California courts and benefits the courts, litigants, lawyers and the public generally:
Since the demise of the Judicial Council’s proposed California Case Management System (CCMS) in the heights of the Great Recession, California courts have moved to upgrade their information technology systems with local contracts with various vendors. These contracts typically provide for case management systems, electronic filing of documents, and more. Usually the third party vendor acts as an “electronic filing managers” (EFMs) in creating the portals through which “electronic filing service providers” (EFSPs) actually file documents on behalf of law firms and other users of court services.
Increasingly, courts are moving to require the filing of documents electronically. In some counties, certain case types must be filed electronically, and often complex civil cases require e-filing. In some counties, EFSPs must pay court filing fees and e-filing transaction costs with credit cards, and pay convenience fees to electronic filing managers for the use of credit cards.
While electronic filing represents a major benefit to the courts and public, how the systems are implemented can raise policy questions of fair access to the judicial system. In addition, present law contains a number of ambiguities which should be resolved as these systems are being implemented. AB 2244 is intended to address some of these ambiguities.
Background on Electronic Filing. Many state courts throughout the country have electronic filing capabilities. Some of these courts allow electronic filing, while others mandate it. Likewise, federal rules allow federal courts to accept documents via electronic filing, if they so choose and allow federal courts to require electronic filing “only if reasonable exceptions are allowed.” (Fed. Rules Civ.Proc., rule 5(d), 28 U.S.C.) Generally, under the federal approach, only attorneys are mandated to participate in electronic filling. However, the federal courts have a rule that prohibits a court clerk from refusing to accept paper filings – even if a local court rule mandates electronic filing. (Ibid.)
How Does Electronic Filing Work? According to a recent staff report from the Judicial Council, an electronic filing system requires both an electronic filing service provider (EFSP) and an electronic filing manager (EFM). Generally, the litigant files the legal document with the EFSP which translates the information, and sends it to the EFM, which delivers and communicates that information to the court’s case management system. (The Critical Role of the State Judiciary in Increasing Access for Self-Represented Litigants: Self-Help Access 360˚, Judicial Council, July 2015.)
If Electronic Filing Is Not Managed Correctly, It May Create Barriers to Justice for Self-Represented and Low-Income Litigants. In that same report, concerns about electronic filing and access to justice were raised:
Early experiences with e-filing, both in California and in other states, suggest that many private vendor EFSPs are not focused on serving the market segment of self-represented litigants, many of whom are indigent and qualify for fee waivers. The access community believes that the exclusion of self-represented litigants from electronic filing “has the potential to enlarge the access to justice gap in the long run.” Electronic filing is an area in which a slight tip of the balance means that the technology tool is no longer used to achieve greater access; rather, it becomes a barrier. The California judicial branch has the opportunity to “place a finger on the scale” in favor of low-income and self-represented litigants by developing the capacity to serve as the EFSP and EFM for all self-represented litigants in the state.
In other states, the judicial branch serves as either a sole EFSP or sole EFM for all forms of electronic filing on behalf of all courts throughout the state. In California, the Judicial Council can ensure that electronic filing is available to all court users by serving as a one-stop EFSP and EFM for self-represented litigants. This function is the culmination of the work currently being undertaken to apply user-centered design concepts to the information currently available on the statewide self-help website and is the final link in providing full and equal access to the courts for self-represented litigants. (The Critical Role of the State Judiciary in Increasing Access for Self-Represented Litigants: Self-Help Access 360˚, supra.)
Electronic Filing is Not New to California. California initially authorized electronic filing in 1999 under SB 367 (Dunn, Chap. 514, Stats. 1999). In 2012, the Legislature authorized a pilot program to allow the Orange County Superior Court to require parties to file their legal documents electronically under AB 2073 (Silva, Chap. 320, Stats. 2012). Among other things, the AB 2073 pilot required the following: (1) the court to have the ability to maintain the official court record in electronic format for all cases where electronic filing is required; (2) the court and the parties to have access either to more than one EFSP capable of electronically filing documents, or to electronically file directly through the court; and (3) the court to have a procedure for the filing of non-electronic documents in order to prevent undue hardship or significant prejudice to any party in an action.
Assuming that other trial courts would eventually want mandatory electronic filing, AB 2073 required the Judicial Council to adopt rules for trial courts. Those rules required a consideration of statewide policies on vendor contracts, privacy, access to public records, unrepresented parties, parties with fee waivers, hardships, reasonable exceptions to electronic filing, and the integrity of electronic service. Trial courts that choose mandatory electronic filing must also follow the conditions required under the Orange County Superior Court pilot.
In 2014, the Judicial Council reported that the Orange County pilot “was a success”:
Mandatory electronic filing resulted in significant cost savings for the court and was generally less expensive for represented and self-represented litigants. Electronic filing also offered ease of use and convenience for litigants. And when issues arose, the court responded to address those issues. Similarly, changes to the California Rules of Court ameliorated any latent access issues by exempting SRLs [self-represented litigants] from the mandatory electronic filing requirement. (Report on the Superior Court of Orange County’s Mandatory E-Filing Pilot Project, Judicial Council of California, September 30, 2014.)
To date, 13 trial courts have adopted some form of mandatory electronic filing system. Although mandatory electronic filing may be an attractive option for trial courts because of the significant efficiencies to courts, electronic filing has not been perfect. Indeed, as more and more courts implement electronic filing systems, this Committee discovers new issues, such as how the current process has affected indigent litigants; competition among vendors; and the high cost of electronic filing. To some extent at least, this bill addresses several of those issues.
Consistent with Existing Law, this Bill Prevents Electronic Filing Vendors from Charging a Payment Method Convenience Fee that Exceeds the Cost to Vendors of that Payment Transaction. Government entities may accept credit cards, debit cards, or electronic funds transfers for the payment of certain government services, including court filings. Although current law allows a government entity, including a court, to impose a convenience fee for those transactions, the government entity may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds its costs for providing that payment method.
When it comes to electronic filing, vendors who apply a convenience fee for the use of credit cards, debit cards, or electronic funds transfer are not bound by the same rules described above. For example, this Committee has learned that some vendors charge a credit card transaction fee at a percentage of a filing service fee (for example, a 2.5 percent credit card fee for $1,435 complex civil filing fee, which amounts to an additional $35.86 charge).
Consistent with current law, this bill sensibly provides that an electronic filing service provider, who remits funds in order to complete an electronic filing transaction, acts as an agent of the court, and may not charge a convenience fee that exceeds the provider’s cost to provide that service. In order to further protect litigants and provide greater clarity about convenience costs associated with processing payment methods, this bill also requires that when a trial court adopts rules for mandatory electronic filing, the fees (if any) that are charged by the court, an electronic filing manager, or an electronic filing service provider to process a payment shall not exceed the actual costs incurred by the court, manager, or provider.
This Bill Makes Electronic Filing More Accessible to Indigent Litigants and Litigants with Fee Waivers, Consistent with California’s Goals of Promoting Access to Justice. As previously mentioned, trial courts that mandate electronic filing must adopt the conditions required by the Orange County Superior Court pilot and the applicable Rules of Court issued by the Judicial Council. Under Rules of Court 2.253, a party who has a fee waiver is exempt from all electronic filing fees.
To ensure that litigants with fee waivers have true access to electronic filing without fees, this bill does two important things. First, it prohibits those litigants from being required to pay transaction processing fees. Second, it clarifies existing law to require an electronic filing service provider to electronically file a fee-waiver-litigant’s documents if that is the litigant’s preferred method.
In order to protect litigants who may not have access to credit or debit cards, this bill also sensibly requires electronic filing managers to accept alternative forms of payment beyond credit cards for the payment of filing fees and e-filing transaction costs. Specifically, this bill requires the court (or the electronic filing manager) to offer a menu of payment options, including but not limited to, credit cards or debit cards, electronic fund transfers, Automated Clearing House, and payment methods that do not charge a transaction cost, such as an electronic check.
Given That Some Courts Mandate Electronic Filing, this Bill Would Allow Costs Associated With Electronic Filing to Be Recoverable Litigation Costs. Throughout litigation, parties pay for costs associated with the legal proceeding, such as filing fees, expert-witness fees, and attorney’s fees. In addition to any judgment award, current law allows the prevailing party to recover specific litigation costs from the unsuccessful party. Current law specifically provides which items are allowable or not allowable as recoverable costs. For example, transcripts of court proceedings ordered by the court are allowable, while costs for the investigation of jurors during voir dire are not allowable. Additionally, costs must be reasonable in amount and reasonably necessary to the conduct of the litigation; if certain costs are not mentioned in statute, a court may use its discretion to allow or deny a cost.
Given that some courts have mandated electronic filing, this bill reasonably adds electronic filing service provider fees to the list of allowable recoverable costs when a court requires or orders a party to file and serve documents electronically with the court. This bill also limits those costs to costs that are actually incurred.
Recovering Hosting Costs. This Committee has learned that, sometimes, courts will order parties to have their documents “hosted” by an electronic filing service provider. This often occurs in complex cases when certain documents are never lodged with the court, and courts lack the infrastructure to hold these out-of-court documents.
Although this bill still allows parties to recover these hosting costs, the bill, as proposed to be amended, includes a five-year sunset. On a certain level, it seems that certain depository responsibilities belong to the court, and not third party vendors. Additionally, this Committee has learned that some courts may soon acquire the technology to become the depository in complex cases.
In order for this Committee to assess whether trial courts should acquire hosting technology, or whether it is more appropriate for electronic filing service providers to host documents, the author proposes to make the following amendments:
On page 8, line 39, after file, insert “and”.
On page 8, line 39, delete the first comma and “, and host”
On page 8, line 40, after the period, insert “(15) Electronic filing service provider hosting fees. If a court requires or orders a party to have documents hosted by an electronic filing service provider, the recoverable costs are those actually incurred to host documents through an electronic filing service provider. This paragraph shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends that date.”
On page 9, line 1, delete (15) and insert (16)
On page 14, line 1, delete “or” and insert “and”
Although this Bill Does Not Specifically Address the Issues of Vendor Competition, this Bill Highlights the Need for the Legislature’s Oversight in the Courts’ Progress in Mandating Electronic Filing. When AB 2073 moved through the Legislature, this Committee raised several concerns about how trial courts would implement mandatory e-filing. First and foremost, this Committee signaled that indigent litigants should not be required to file electronically. (Indeed, this bill takes significant steps to help achieve that goal.) Second, this Committee signaled that “[l]itigants should not be forced to use only one vendor, but should have the ability to either directly file with the court or have a choice of multiple vendors to use.” (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 2073; April 24, 2012.) Indeed, in order to promote access to justice, there should be robust competition to keep electronic filing costs low, and to prevent a de facto increase in California’s civil filing fees.
As this bill was being analyzed, this Committee learned that the Judicial Council is considering a recommendation to encourage courts to have multiple electronic filing managers. While this policy is consistent with this Committee’s goals of promoting robust competition among vendors, the Legislature should continue to actively monitor how our courts’ are implementing electronic filing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Coalition for Improving Court Access
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):