AB 310: California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-06-26
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 3, 2020 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Jul 2, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and JUD. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 16. Noes 1.) (May 16). |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. (Ayes 10. Noes 2.) (March 19). |
| Mar 11, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and PUB. S. |
| Jan 30, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 1. |
| Jan 29, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 310 Santiago Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Mar 19, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Public Safety] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 310 | Hearing Date: | 8/3/20 |
Author: | Santiago | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/26/20 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell & Peterson | ||
California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank
Creates a depository bank in the I-Bank, requires the Treasurer to deposit specified percentages of state funds into the I-Bank over time and target an investment of 10% of the Pooled Money Investment Account’s average daily balance in I-Bank, as well as moves I-Bank out of GO-Biz.
Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic and the unprecedented nature of the 2020 Legislative Session, all Senate Policy Committees are working under a compressed timeline. This timeline does not allow this bill to be referred and heard by more than one committee as a typical timeline would allow. In order to fully vet the contents of this measure for the benefit of Senators and the public, this analysis includes information from the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee.
Background
State Treasurer. Elected every four years, the State Treasurer is the State's lead asset manager, banker, and financier. As part of this role, the Treasurer manages several programs, including the Pooled Money Investment Account (PMIA), which invests monies on behalf of state government and local jurisdictions to help manage their fiscal affairs. While the Pooled Money Investment Board, consisting of the Treasurer as Chair, the Controller, and Director of Finance, sets investment policy consistent with state law, the Treasurer manages PMIA’s day to day operations. Cash attributable to both the General Fund and Special Funds flow into PMIA as the state receives tax and fee payments, then flows out to meet state obligations as authorized by law or the Budget Act, such as allocating funds to schools, or paying vendors or other contractors, among other purposes. Because PMIA is a cash management account for temporarily idle funds, its primary investment objectives are safety, liquidity and yield.
The Treasurer can invest PMIA funds in securities, limited by state law to government securities, securities of federally-sponsored agencies, domestic corporate bonds, prime-rated commercial paper, and repurchase and reverse repurchase agreements. The Treasurer can also use PMIA funds to make interest-bearing time deposits in California banks, savings and loan associations and credit unions, as well as national banks, banks located in other states, or any California branch office of a bank headquartered in another state, as well as state or federally chartered savings and loan associations or credit unions that are located in this state. Before the Treasurer makes a cash deposit, the bank or other financial institution must provide sufficient collateral consisting of approved securities with a market value of at least 110% of the deposits, or with approved promissory notes secured by mortgages or deeds of trust with a market value of at least 150% of the deposit. In 2018-19, daily investments in time deposits averaged $4.8 billion daily.
The Local Agency Investment Fund (LAIF) allows cities, counties and special districts to place its temporarily idle funds in the Treasurer’s custody, who deposits and invests them as part of PMIA. Participating agencies can withdraw their funds from the LAIF at any time. At the end of June 2020, the LAIF had 2,362 participating agencies and a balance of $32.1 billion, slightly less than one-third of PMIA’s current $100 billion portfolio.
In 2018-19, slightly more than half of PMIA’s average daily portfolio was held in U.S. Treasuries, 18.5% in agency coupon securities or discount notes, 16.3% in negotiable certificates of deposit, and 7% in commercial paper. The average investment life is 191 days, with an effective yield of 1.21%. Because state cash flows fluctuate, expenses necessary for the state to respond to events such as wildfires and COVID-19 pandemic response can occur quickly and unexpectedly, and participants in LAIF can withdraw funds at any time, PMIA invests in highly liquid securities that can be quickly and easily sold without risk of principal loss.
State Controller. Elected every four years, the State Controller is the state’s chief fiscal officer. The Controller issues warrants and electronic fund transfers from the State Treasury, audits all funds disbursed from the state, and pays all of the state’s claims, including payments to schools and local governments as well as payroll expenses. The Controller manages state cash flow by either borrowing externally or internally. External borrowing consists of the Controller requesting the Treasurer to issue revenue anticipation notes, where investors provide immediate cash and subsequently repaid by the end of each fiscal year. The Controller borrows internally from certain funds allowed by statute, including PMIA, to cover any cash flow shortages. However, state law prohibits the Controller from borrowing from other funds, including LAIF.
The Department of Finance indicated in its July, 2020, Finance Bulletin that the state’s cash receipts for the entire 2019-20 fiscal year are more than one billion above the 2020-21 forecast of $123.395 billion, or almost 1%. However, earlier this year the Legislative Analyst’s Office indicated in its Spring Fiscal Outlook for the 2020-21 fiscal year, that the state’s cash position “will change dramatically in the coming months:”
“When normal (income tax) collections resume, the state’s cash position could improve, but a variety of factors will continue to limit the state’s available cash. This includes: depressed economic activity which will lead to lower revenues, the use of the state’s General Fund and special fund reserves to pay for currently authorized services, and higher costs as the state responds to COVID‑19. As such, cash management is likely to become a more prominent feature in legislative deliberations and decision‑making in this budget process and future budgets.”
The California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank. The California Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank (I-Bank) supports economic development through its authority to issue bonds, make loans, and provide credit enhancements. The I-Bank's activities are organized into the following direct loan and conduit financing programs:
- The Infrastructure State Revolving Fund Program, which provides low-cost loan financing to local agencies for public infrastructure projects.
- The California Lending for Energy and Environmental Need, which directly funds energy efficiency and street lighting for municipalities, schools, universities, and hospitals.
- The Jump Start Loan Program, which provides microloans, technical assistance and financial literacy training.
- The Small Business Loan Guarantee Program, which guarantees repayments to lenders that provide financing to small businesses that experience capital access barriers.
- The Farm Loan Program, which supports direct loans to smaller farms for purchase, operating costs, and other expenses.
- The Industrial Development Revenue Bond Program, which provides tax-exempt revenue bond financing for eligible manufacturing companies.
- The 501(c)(3) Revenue Bond Program, which offers tax-exempt revenue bond financing for certain nonprofit, public benefit corporations.
- The Public Agency Revenue Bond Program, which provides tax-exempt revenue bond financing for governmental entities.
- The Exempt Facilities Program, which allows for tax-exempt conduit bond finance for projects that are government-owned or consist of private improvements within publicly-owned facilities, such as private airline improvements at publicly-owned airport.
Additionally, the 2020-21 Budget Act includes $25 million General Fund for I-Bank to provide capital to Community Development Financial Institutions (CDFI) and other mission based lenders to enable the origination of more loans in underbanked communities. I-Bank works with the CDFI network to serve economically disadvantaged small businesses, including the underbanked and unbanked, to increase liquidity and available capital in these areas.
I-Bank is governed by a Board of Directors consisting of the Director of Finance, the Treasurer, the Director of the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) who serves as Chair, and the Secretary of Transportation, or their designees. Additionally, statute bars the I-Bank from accepting deposits of money for time or demand deposits.
In 2012, the Legislature codified GO-Biz in law as the lead entity for economic strategy and the marketing of California on issues relating to business development, private sector investment, and economic growth (AB 29, Perez, 2012). Under Governor Brown’s Governor’s Reorganization Plan #2 (GRP#2), GO-Biz now houses the I-Bank, the California Film Commission, the California Tourism Commission, Small Business Development Centers, and the Small Business Loan Guarantee Program, effective July 1, 2013. The now-defunct Business, Transportation, and Housing Agency housed I-Bank prior to GRP#2.
Local agency investments. Since 1913, state law has authorized local officials to invest a portion of local agencies’ temporarily idle funds in a variety of financial instruments. Originally, state law limited the instruments to government bonds, but over time the laws governing local agency investments have been amended to keep pace with changing investment opportunities and current market offerings. California law allows local officials to deposit money in state or national banks, savings associations, federal associations, credit unions, or federally insured industrial loan companies in the State of California. When investing, reinvesting, purchasing, acquiring, exchanging, selling, or managing public funds, state law outlines local agencies’ investment objectives, also known as the prudent investor standard. The primary objective is to safeguard the principal of the funds under its control. The secondary objective is to meet the liquidity needs of the depositor. The final objective is to achieve a return on the funds under its control. State law limits the percentage that local agencies can invest in many types of investments. This encourages local agencies to diversify their investment portfolios, which limits the risk to the local agency if any investment does not have the expected return. Local agencies make investments with different maturity dates, which refer to the date when the borrower must make the final payment due on an investment. Local agencies work with community and national banks to help manage these deposits.
The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly affected local agencies’ investment practices. Local agencies have seen their revenues decrease because of decreased economic activity and stay-at-home orders intended to decrease their residents’ exposure to the virus. Making matters worse, local agencies also face increased public health costs to respond to the unprecedented public health emergency. Both factors reduce the amount of funds local agencies have to invest in longer-term investments or projects, and require local agencies to focus their efforts on short-term cash management to maintain core services. For example, local agencies issued $2.4 billion in debt in May 2020, $1.2 billion less compared to May 2019, which may indicate local agencies’ reluctance to add any additional fiscal obligations and to maintain a higher level of liquidity in their cash portfolio.
Chartering banks. The Financial Code regulates the businesses of commercial and industrial banking in California, administered by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO).
The Commissioner of Business Oversight must make or cause to be made a careful investigation and examination of the following items when an organization files an application to organize and establish a corporation to engage in the banking business:
- The character, reputation, and financial standing of the organizers and their motives in seeking to organize the proposed bank.
- The need for banking facilities or additional banking facilities, giving particular consideration to the adequacy of existing banking facilities.
- The character, financial responsibility, banking experience, and business qualifications of the proposed officers of the bank.
- The character, financial responsibility, business experience, and standing of the proposed stockholders and directors.
State law prohibits the Commissioner from approving an application to form a bank in California until the commissioner has ascertained all of the following to their satisfaction:
- That the public convenience and advantage will be promoted by the establishment of the proposed bank.
- That the proposed bank will have a reasonable promise of successful operation.
- That the bank is being formed for no other purpose than the legitimate objects contemplated by the Banking Law.
- That the proposed capital structure is adequate.
- That the proposed officers and directors have sufficient banking or trust experience, ability, and standing to afford reasonable promise of successful operation.
Public Banking. Public banking in the United States is more than 100 years old. The nation’s only public bank operating at scale, the Bank of North Dakota (BND), was founded in 1919 by the state Legislature to support the state’s farmers. BND is the exclusive depository institution for state government funds and also serves local governments, which can voluntarily elect to deposit funds in the bank. Importantly, BND does not compete with private financial institutions. Rather, it partners with local banks and credit unions. The initial underwriting, risk assessment, and credit approval decision are made by the private sector banks. These private financial institutions then originate the loans, apply to participate in one of BND’s programs, and BND provides capital to participate in the loan with the private financial institution.
Except for public ownership, public banking proposals vary in the scope of services provided, level of regulation, and capital structure. Proponents generally argue that public banks will benefit the public by:
- Investing public funds in a way that reflects the values of the electorate,
- Divesting public funds from commercial banks that provide financing to industries and firms, or engage in behavior inconsistent with those values,
- Providing capital at a lower cost than the private sector for preferred uses, such as public infrastructure projects, affordable housing, small businesses, and offering banking services to those who lack them, and
- Reducing costs to the government for banking services.
Renewed interest in public banking has resulted in legislation or feasibility studies in state and local governments around the country in the years following the financial crisis and the economic recession it caused. Feasibility studies often find significant start-up costs and high levels of financial and operational risk associated with public banks. For example, in March, 2019, the San Francisco Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector issued a Municipal Bank Feasibility Task Force Report to “research the viability and advisability of a municipal bank as well as other opportunities to leverage the City’s banking and investment practices to promote community goals.” This feasibility study examined three financial models: a non-depository reinvestment entity that focuses on affordable housing and small business lending to achieve community goals (Model One); a depository institution that allows the City to divest from banks that perform the City’s cash management (Model Two); and a combination of the two models (Model Three). The below table summarizes the results of the three models studied:
Model One: Reinvest | Model Two: Divest | Model Three: Combination | |
Break Even Details | |||
Years to Break Even | 10 | 31 | 56 |
Size at Breakeven[1] | $1.1 billion | $3.1 billion | $10.4 billion |
Estimated Appropriation Required to Break Even | |||
Start-Up Costs | $6 million | $119 million | $119 million |
Operational Subsidy | $13 million | $990 million | $2.2 billion |
Capital Investment | $165 million | $460 million | $1.6 billion |
TOTAL | $184 million | $1.6 billion | $3.9 billion |
As shown above, both of the models that envision taking deposits (Models Two and Three) are considerably more expensive to establish than the model that envisions lending without also taking deposits. The task force study did not recommend one model over either of the others; instead, the report was intended to provide information for use by the Board of Supervisors and Mayor when deciding whether, and, if so, how, to move forward. Regardless of which option is chosen, any a public bank will need significant financial resources to capitalize it.
Last year, the Legislature enacted AB 857 (Chiu), which created a process for a local agency to apply for a public bank license from DBO. The bill required the local agency to meet the same general requirements and approval criteria as private sector applicants, including deposit insurance provided by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, as well as routine supervision and examinations to evaluate the nature of the bank's operations, the adequacy of the bank's internal controls and its internal audit function, and the bank's compliance with laws and regulations. If weaknesses are identified, the bill permits regulators to correct deficiencies in the bank's risk management practices and address weaknesses in the bank's operations.
The Public Banking Alliance wants to create a depository bank in the I-Bank, require the Treasurer to deposit specified percentages of state funds into the I-Bank over time and target an investment of 10% of PMIA’s average daily balance in I-Bank, as well as moving I-Bank out of GO-Biz and place it under the management of a newly-formed Commission.
Proposed Law
AB 310 enacts several changes to create a depository bank in the I-Bank, requires the Treasurer to deposit specified percentages of state funds into the I-Bank over time and target an investment of 10% of PMIA’s average daily balance in I-Bank equity, loans, debt securities, bond anticipation notes, or other obligations. The measure also moves I-Bank out of GO-Biz and place it under the management of the newly-formed Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank Commission, and changes the composition of I-Bank’s current board.
State Treasurer. AB 310 requires the State Treasurer to target an investment of 10% of PMIA’s average daily balance into I-Bank equity, loans, debt securities, bond anticipation notes, or other obligations. The measure adds I-Bank equity, loans, debt securities, bond anticipation notes, or other obligations on to the list of investments the Treasurer can make using surplus funds. The bill also adds the I-Bank onto the list of banks in which the Treasurer can make deposits of state funds. The bill exempts the I-Bank from the security and collateral requirements that apply to other banks must maintain to receive and retain time deposits.
I-Bank as Depository Bank. AB 310 requires DBO to charter the I-Bank as a depository institution for the purpose of accepting deposits from the Treasurer, a state officer or employee having control over state money, a local agency, or a quasi-public nonprofit entity as defined. The bill directs DBO to adopt or amend any rule or regulation that facilitates organizing I-Bank as a depository. AB 310 allows the Treasurer, a state officer or employee having control over money belonging to or in the custody of the state, including PMIA and LAIF, or a local agency to establish a deposit account with the bank, under the terms and conditions established by I-Bank. The measure also permits I-Bank to accept deposits from quasi-public nonprofit entities upon approval by the Board, which is detailed below. The measure prohibits deposits from being used for specified purposes, or being impounded or seized by the state. The bill also bars the Bank from prohibited high-risk activities, as defined.
The bill makes conforming changes to state law to authorize the State Treasurer, as well as local agencies and quasi-public nonprofit agencies, to deposit funds with I-Bank. Additionally, the measure allows I-Bank to collaborate with the Treasurer and the Governor to seek loan guarantees under the Municipal Liquidity Facility authorized by the recent federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act. AB 310 also allows I-Bank to consolidate any of the debt purchased by the bank into securities for resale on a secondary market for the purpose of creating liquidity for the bank and participant lenders and seek any necessary securities registrations or permits.
AB 310 requires the I-Bank to seek to become a state member bank of the Federal Reserve System, and a member of the Federal Home Loan Bank System. The bill also directs I-Bank to seek to open a master account with a Federal Reserve Bank, primarily to use for short-term loan transactions to balance the accounts of the bank. The measure requires I-Bank to employ experienced staff sufficient to carry out the fiduciary duties of a depository bank and for the purpose of evaluating and generating financing activity. The bill allocates I-Bank profits to the following purposes in order:
- Payment of interest on deposits in all deposit accounts.
- Retention for use as capital reserves to expand the financing activities of the bank.
- Reversion to the General Fund.
AB 310 allows I-Bank to charge transaction fees, including origination and issuance fees, for its services, so long as the amount of the fee does not exceed the reasonable cost to the bank of performing the service, and are less than comparable fees charged by a private commercial bank. The measure allows, but does not require, the I-Bank to procure FDIC insurance. The bill also makes conforming changes to I-Bank annual reporting requirements regarding its activities to include certain information regarding its depository activities, and to ensure that the Commission receives both the annual report regarding its activities and a separate report regarding its expansion fund, and trust fund financial product activity of each of its corporations.
Other I-Bank Services. The bill requires the Board to establish lending and credit support programs with participating lenders by continuing or expanding programs within the Small Business Finance Center to include:
- Loan guarantees under the Small Business Loan Guarantee Program.
- Issuing lines and letters of credit.
- Securitization.
- Bundling.
- Insurance.
- Conducting participation lending and wholesale lending.
- Offering subordinated debt on more favorable terms than comparable commercial debt with maturities of at least 15 years, or full or partial loan repurchases, so long as participating lenders are Community Development Financial Institutions serving low-income communities, community development credit unions, and public banks.
AB 310 provides that at least 60% of the small business loan guarantees must be applied to loans made to “target borrowers.” The bill requires I-Bank to guarantee 100% of a small business loan that:
- Has a maturity period of less than six years.
- Is in an amount not greater than is either less than $100,000, or six months of the borrower’s current expenses.
- Has a fixed interest rate that is less than the prime rate plus 1%.
- Where payments on the loan are deferred for at least 12 months.
- Where a minimum credit score is not required to obtain the loan.
- Does not require a personal guarantee.
- Need not be secured by collateral.
- Where the borrower’s annual revenue was less than $2.5 million at the time the loan was originated.
- Where the borrower was not required to provide a social security number to complete the loan application.
- The borrower is a target borrower, defined as either a firm that meets two of the following criteria:
- Is a microbusiness (an entity with less than 50 employees or less than $2.5 million in revenue),
- Is located in a disadvantaged community, identified according to references in the Health and Safety Code used to allocate Greenhouse Gas Reduction Funds, a rural area, or a tribal area.
- The borrower is a business of which at least 51% is owned by persons who lack social security numbers; live in disadvantaged communities as defined, or are low-income, women, indigenous, minority, immigrants, or formerly incarcerated.
The bill requires the I-Bank Board to establish minimum standards for all participating lenders to ensure that no lender uses I-Bank’s programs for exclusionary, predatory, or extractive products, and approve participating lenders. The standard must include an annual review of participating lenders subject to public comment. The bank board must also set allowable fees, loan spreads, and annual percentage rates for participating lenders.
AB 310 also requires I-Bank to study developing and offering, directly or in partnership with participating lenders, additional products such as:
- Universal deferred payment bonds or “baby bonds.”
- Pension investments into green jobs, climate change mitigation and resilience, or renewable energy infrastructure.
- Investment accounts and products that facilitate impact investing by private investors and institutions, including pension funds, into unbanked and underbanked communities.
- Low-to-no-cost banking and payment services, either directly or in partnership with participating lenders, directed toward unbanked and underbanked communities.
- Alternative to payday or car title loans, either directly or in partnership with participating lenders, in the form of short-term secured and unsecured credit products.
- Other financial services to meet an identified community need to be suggested by community input process, conducted annually, and presented at a public meeting of the I-Bank Board. The community input process must include surveys of the community, participating lenders, target borrowers, and local agencies; a public report that includes a summary of findings and a plan to address the stated needs of the community; and a period of public comment on the plan, including hearings and a written response from the bank one year after the bank receives its depository authority.
AB 310 also creates a local government financing program that allows I-Bank to purchase bond anticipation notes of local agencies and tribal governments, including purchasing, underwriting, and acting as a broker-dealer for the placement of revenue bonds or general obligation bonds for local agencies and tribal governments. The program must prioritize bonds issued for the purposes of funding affordable housing, school districts, social services, and publicly-owned infrastructure. The measure allows I-Bank to directly lend and extend credit on more favorable terms than comparable commercial or public debt to a local agency or tribal government, or public bank as authorized by AB 857. The bill also requires I-Bank to create a bridge loan program for local agencies serving disadvantaged communities by March 1, 2021.
The bill further requires I-Bank to engage in the following activities to local public banks as authorized by AB 857:
- Provide technical assistance to local agency organizers to develop viability studies, business plans, and charter applications.
- Develop loan facilities, extend credit, and provide financial services.
- Liaise with the Federal Reserve, federal Small Business Administration, and other federal agencies.
- Develop a plan to create a network of public banks to pool risk, insurance, technology, compliance, and administrative capacity.
AB 310 requires I-Bank to solicit feedback from local agencies and tribal governments to better address their needs. AB 310 also makes conforming changes to definitions in current I-Bank law to implement its expanded lending programs.
I-Bank Governance. AB 310 transfers the authority to supervise the I-Bank from GO-Biz to the Infrastructure and Economic Development Bank Commission, created by the bill, consisting of the Governor, the Controller, and the Treasurer, or their designees. The Governor can fill any vacancy on the Commission. All three members must be present to constitute a quorum for the Commission.
The bill changes the current composition of the I-Bank Board from its current five members consisting of the Director of Finance, the Treasurer, the Director of GO-Biz, an appointee of the Governor, and the Secretary for Transportation, or their designees, to a board of nine voting and two non-voting members. The bill provides that the two non-voting members are the Director of Finance and the Director of GO-Biz, or their designees. Voting members are the Lieutenant Governor, and eight other individuals appointed by the Commission consisting of:
- Three banking professionals, all of whom must have experience in community development finance or at a local financial institution,
- One county treasurer, and,
- Four experts in affordable housing financing or policy, organized labor, environmental justice, racial justice, climate change mitigation, microenterprise lending, or employee-owned business.
The measure requires staggered four-year terms for its voting members, and further provides that five members constitute a quorum. AB 310 replaces the authority of the Governor to appoint the I-Bank’s Director subject to Senate confirmation by instead directing the Commission to appoint the Director without being subject to Senate confirmation. Instead of serving at the pleasure of the Governor, the measure provides that the Director serves at the pleasure of the Commission. The bill prohibits a member of the Board of Directors from participating in any bank action, or attempting to influence any decision or recommendation by any employee of or consultant to the bank that involves a sponsor of which:
- The member is a representative, or
- In which the member or the immediate family of the member has a personal financial interest, as defined.
The bill contains several provisions transferring the Bank from GO-Biz to the Commission, including to:
- Require GO-Biz’s executive director and I-Bank board members that were serving on the bill’s operative date to remain in those positions, and serve under the Commission.
- Provide that the Commission maintains all duties, powers, purposes, responsibilities, and jurisdiction that existed when supervised by GO-Biz.
- State that I-Bank maintains all records, papers, offices, equipment, supplies, or other property, held for the benefit or use by the bank when supervised by GO-Biz.
- Transfer all civil service employees who performed duties for the I-Bank to the Commission with the same status, position, and rights, except for exempt employees.
- Provide that the Commission succeeds to all of the rights and property of GO-Biz conferred by this division.
- Shift the property of any office, agency, or other entity of state government related to functions provided to the Commission to the Commission. The Department of General Services must determine the disposition of any property if doubt arises.
- Transfer from GO-Biz to the Commission all unencumbered balances of appropriations and other funds that were previously available for use in connection with any function or the administration of I-Bank, so long as the Commission maintains the same use and purpose for which the appropriation was originally made or funds made available. The Department of Finance must determine the disposition of any balances or funds if doubt arises.
- Provide that the Commission succeeds all of GO-Biz’s debts and liabilities as if the I-Bank had incurred them.
- State that any reference in law to GO-Biz in the division of law which authorizes the I-Bank instead refers to the Commission.
The bill requires I-Bank’s executive director to prepare a proposed projected five-year budget detailing projected costs due to the transfer of the bank from GO-Biz to the Commission by January 1, 2021. The executive director must submit the budget to the Board of Directors, and if approved by the Board, to the Legislature and each of its fiscal committees.
By January 1, 2022, the Director must also:
- Develop the same projected budget required above,
- Develop a standard form to be used to apply for a deposit account,
- Seek to have the bank become a state member bank of the Federal Reserve System, and
- Develop a handbook for internal use by I-Bank staff regarding the responsibilities and requirements applicable to the bank, including any applicable regulations and fiduciary rules, in its capacity as a state member bank of the Federal Reserve System.
The bill also allows the executive director to employ professional staff or consultants with expertise in the regulatory and other policy practices of the Federal Reserve System as necessary for assistance.
Local Agency Investments. AB 310 adds I-Bank equity, loans, debt securities, bond anticipation notes, or other obligations onto the list of authorized local government investments. The measure also adds I-Bank to the list of banks eligible for local agency deposits. The bill also exempts the I-Bank from the requirement in current law that any local agency deposit cannot exceed a bank’s equity.
The measure defines several terms, and makes legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, "COVID-19 has blindsided our economy. People have lost their jobs, small businesses have permanently closed, and millions are struggling under financial hardship. AB 310 provides a real people-centered solution. By establishing a state bank, we keep our local dollars in the community and reinvest money where people need it the most. As the world's fifth largest economy, we cannot let our taxpayers bear the brunt of Wall Street's predatory banking practices. AB 310 would stimulate economic recovery and empower our local communities with sustainable, tangible relief."
2. PMIA as bank capital. Creating a public bank in state government requires significant resources. Without these resources, the benefits of a public bank cannot be realized. The San Francisco Treasurer-Tax Collector’s report captures these tradeoffs, which apply to the state when contemplating AB 310’s merits:
“A municipal bank presents an opportunity to achieve community goals, such as divestment and reinvestment, in a sustainable and creative fashion. However, it is also a time-intensive and expensive endeavor. Pursuing a municipal bank has significant short term costs, in terms of money, time and energy. It also has a significant, but uncertain, payout in the long-term. Creating a public bank necessarily involves making difficult decisions around trade-offs about how the City should prioritize projects and allocate its money.”
AB 310’s sole source of capitalizing its expanded program and depository activities is directing I-Bank to sell debt securities to PMIA, which the bill directs the Treasurer to target for purchase. I-Bank would then use the proceeds from the sale of these securities to finance the bill’s expanded loan and financing programs. However, PMIA funds are not idle surplus capital the state can invest in long-term lending programs without significant risk; PMIA is a cash management fund that invests local agency funds as well as state moneys that have been appropriated but not yet disbursed in highly liquid assets that can be sold to meet funding needs at a moment’s notice. If PMIA investments result in loss of principal, less funds exist to pay the state’s legal obligations. While I-Bank is a highly-rated issuer of revenue and conduit bonds, the debt obligations created by AB 310 do not currently exist, and requiring PMIA to purchase them may jeopardize its liquidity to the extent it is required to buy something it cannot subsequently sell. A market for AB 310’s I-Bank debt securities could exist in the future; however, the state would risk loss of principal if it could not sell these securities to other investors at a price comparable to the one paid to I-Bank. The Federal Reserve is providing extraordinary assistance to debt markets generally in response to the COVID-19 pandemic; however, investors generally assess and price risk by looking at the revenues derived or assets pledged by any specific debt obligation, and the quality of the assets and repayment risk of the securities backed by AB 310’s expanded loan programs is currently unknown. This risk becomes more acute if the economic effects of the COVID-19 pandemic negatively affect the state’s cash position. In her letter, the State Treasurer argues:
“Establishing a state bank as specified by this bill would jeopardize the safety and liquidity of moneys held by my office on behalf of thousands of local agencies in this state as well as the state’s General Fund; and, it fails to properly meet the liquidity requirements imposed on any bank selected by my office to receive state funds.”
The Committee may wish to consider whether the amount of risk AB 310 places on state funds is worth its potential benefits.
3. I-Bank as depository. I-Bank does not currently, or have the financial, human, or technology resources to, provide traditional bank depository services or issue the kinds of securities contemplated by AB 310. As stated by the State Controller, “I-Bank is a bank in name only, and can more accurately be described as a financing authority. It was established to provide financing for public infrastructure and private development.” AB 310 would add a depository into I-Bank into which the Treasurer must deposit 20% of state funds within one year of the bill’s effective date, and 100% within five years. When depositing state funds with banks and other financial institutions, current law require collateralization that exceeds the amount of the deposit to ensure the safety of these deposits. AB 310 both exempts the I-Bank from these collateral requirements as well as any requirement to apply for a bank charter from DBO or be subject to any ongoing form of traditional regulation beyond the I-Bank Board and the Commission created by the bill. The Committee may wish to consider whether AB 310’s structure for I-Bank’s depository functions is safe enough to merit deposit of state cash.
4. Resources needed. As noted by the San Francisco Office of the Treasurer and Tax Collector’s Municipal Bank Feasibility Task Force Report, establishing a public bank is a time-intensive and expensive endeavor with significant short-term costs of money, time and energy. I-Bank would need to hire individuals with expertise operating a depository institution and issuing debt securities that differ from its current products to implement the bill, and these individuals would likely demand higher salaries that other state agency employees. Additionally, I-Bank would need to hire these individuals quickly; the bill directs DBO to grant it a bank charter on the bill’s effective date, and the Treasurer to deposit 20% of state funds into I-Bank one year after that. However, AB 310 provides no direct appropriation or authority for a General Fund loan to fund these increased costs. While the initial legislation creating I-Bank in 1995 allowed it to borrow money as needed for the purposes of meeting the necessary expenses of initial organization and operation from PMIA, it is unclear how and when PMIA would pay these costs given the state’s other obligations. Additionally, the continuing economic effects of the COVID-19 pandemic are expected to negatively affect the state’s fiscal situation. The Committee may wish to consider whether I-Bank can successfully implement AB 310, and whether allocating the necessary resources to do so are a superior use of finite state funds.
5. Also brought to you by… According to the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee, “this bill requires the Commissioner of Business Oversight (commissioner) to charter the I-Bank as a depository bank for the purpose of accepting deposits of public funds, as specified; would, on or before January 1, 2022, require the commissioner to adopt or amend any rule or regulation necessary to facilitate the organization of the I-Bank bank as a depository; and would provide that the I-Bank may, but need not, obtain FDIC insurance. All three of these provisions raise significant concerns from the perspective of the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee. This bill would remove the commissioner’s discretion to review the I-Bank’s application for a charter and undermine the commissioner’s authority by requiring the commissioner to approve the I-Bank as a depository, regardless of whether the commissioner would have done so absent the provisions of this bill. This bill also requires the commissioner to adopt or amend any rule or regulation necessary to facilitate the organization of the I-Bank as a depository. In essence, this requirement places the commissioner in the position of proposing the regulations necessary to undermine his or her authority to regulate the I-Bank in the same manner as other state-chartered depositories. This bill would further undermine the commissioner’s regulatory authority by making optional the requirement that the I-Bank obtain FDIC insurance. One of the primary responsibilities of a banking regulator is to ensure the safety and soundness of the depository institutions under that regulator’s jurisdiction. By making FDIC insurance optional, and by failing to require that the bank obtain other insurance acceptable to the commissioner if the bank fails to obtain FDIC insurance, this bill prevents the commissioner from upholding his or her responsibilities as a safety and soundness regulator. Given the extent to which this bill undermines the commissioner’s authority and prevents DBO from acting to ensure the safety and soundness of the I-Bank, it is unclear why DBO is involved at all. As the bill is currently drafted, DBO’s only role appears to be legitimizing the I-Bank as a state depository. Unlike other state-chartered depositories, the I-Bank will not be required to comply with the key requirements of the Banking Law, nor will it be subject to regulatory oversight by an empowered commissioner.”
6. What about me? In 2018-19, interest-bearing time deposits were held by 51 commercial banks, 15 credit unions and three savings and loans in California. PMIA holdings in time deposits had an average yield of 2.3%. Under AB 310, banks and other financial institutions who meet the necessary requirements to participate in the time deposit program would only be eligible for 80% of deposits one year after the bill’s effective date, and entirely ineligible five years after the bill’s effective date when the Treasurer must make all deposits into I-Bank. The Committee may wish to consider whether ending time deposits with other banks is merited, especially when AB 310 exempts I-Bank from collateral requirements and state regulation.
7. Who oversees? As mentioned above, AB 310 directs the Commissioner of DBO to grant I-Bank a bank charter, rendering it exempt from any traditional banking regulation. This charter does not have an expiration date, so the Legislature would not have an effective oversight mechanism over I-Bank’s depository activities. AB 310 would also strip the Senate’s power to confirm I-Bank’s director, instead providing that the executive director serve at the pleasure of the board, whose members are appointed by a Commission consisting only of the Governor, the Controller, and the Treasurer. The Committee may wish to consider whether AB 310 allows for sufficient legislative oversight of I-Bank’s expanded operations. Additionally, Governor Brown moved I-Bank under GO-Biz in 2013, and away from the Business, Transportation, and Housing Agency under a larger plan to restructure state agencies. To the extent that I-Bank is viable as a depository institution, is a newly-formed commission a better way of supervising it than GO-Biz? The Committee may wish to assess GO-Biz’s record supervising I-Bank’s current functions and duties before moving it under a new and untested entity.
Assembly Actions
Not relevant to this version of the bill.
Support and Opposition
(7/31/20)
Support: California Public Banking Alliance (Sponsor); Malia Cohen, Member, California State Board of Equalization; Robert Garcia, Mayor, City of Long Beach; Sam Hindi, Councilmember, Foster City; Stephen Young; Councilmember, City of Benicia; 350 Bay Area; Abundant Housing LA; Active San Gabriel Valley; Alliance for Just Recovery; Alliance for Community Transit Los Angeles (ACT-LA); American Federation of Teachers Guild, Local 1931; Asian Pacific Environmental Network (APEN); Asian Pacific Islander Small Business Program; Beneficial State Foundation; Brilliant Corners; California Alliance for Community Energy; California Community Economic Development Association (CCEDA); California Environmental Justice Alliance (CEJA); California Progressive Alliance; California Public Banking Alliance; California Reinvestment Coalition (Co-Sponsor); City of Berkeley; City and County of San Francisco; Coastal Commons Land Trust; Committee for Better Banks; Communities for a Better Environment; Communities United for Health and Justice; Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS); Corporation Humboldt; Democracy Collaborative; Democratic Socialists of American-San Diego; East Los Angeles Community Corporation; Esperanza Community Housing Corporation; Feel the Bern/San Fernando Valley Democratic Club; Fossil Free California; Friends of the Earth; Friends of Public Banking Santa Rosa; Green Party of California; Green Party of Monterey County; Green Party of Santa Clara County; Haven Neighborhood Services; Inclusive Action for the City; Indivisible California-StateStrong; Indivisible Green Team; LA Ford; Lawyers Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (LCCR-SF); Local Clean Energy Alliance; Los Angeles County Federation of Labor (AFL-CIO); McGee-Spaulding Neighbors in Action; Mission Economic Development Agency; Mission Street Neighbors; Monterey County Democratic Central Committee; North Bay Jobs with Justice; North Bay Labor Council; North Coast People’s Alliance; Oakmont Democratic Club; People for Public Banking; PODER; PODER San Francisco; PolicyLink; Praxis Peace Institute; Public Bank East Bay; Public Bank Long Beach; Public Bank Los Angeles; Public Bank San Diego; Public Bank Santa Barbara; Public Bank SGV; Public Banking Institute; Public Law Center; Richmond LAND; Romero Institute; San Francisco Public Bank Coalition; San Francisco Rising; Santa Barbara County Board of Supervisors; Santa Cruz Climate Action Network; Santa Cruz County Democratic Central Committee; SEIU California; Sonoma County GO LOCAL; South Bay Progressive Alliance; Sunrise Movement; Sustainvest Asset Management; The Greenlining Institute; United Educators of San Francisco (UESF); UFCW Local 5; UFCW Local 770; United Food and Commercial Workers (UFCW) Western States Council (Co-Sponsor); Windsor Democratic Club; YIMBY Democrats of San Diego County; 486 individuals.
Opposition: State Controller Betty Yee, State Treasurer Fiona Ma (unless amended), California Association of County Treasurer-Tax Collectors, California Bankers Association, California Chamber of Commerce, California Community Banking Network, California Credit Union League, California Taxpayers Association.
-- END --
As used by the authors of the SF report, the “size” of a bank refers to its outstanding loans plus its cash and securities on hand. For a depository, this sum should equal the bank’s deposits plus capital. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 310 Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Author: | Santiago | ||
Version: | May 16, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Trial Jury Selection and Management Act
HISTORY
Source: Chief Probation Officers of California
State Coalition of Probation Officers
Prior Legislation: AB 2240 (Grayson) Vetoed 2018 (Parole, Probation and Correctional officers)
SB 428 (Hall) Failed Senate Judiciary 2015 (peace officers)
SB 1133 (Anderson) Failed Senate Judiciary 2014 (Fish and Game officers)
AB 1708 (Alejo) not heard Senate Public Safety 2014(parole officers, CDCR officers, state hospital officers etc.)
AB 1993 (Nakanishi) not heard Senate Judiciary 2005-06 (nurses)
AB 270 (Bates) Failed Senate Public Safety 2003(harbor and port police)
AB 1978 (Haynes) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2003 (single parents)
AB 2253 (Mountjoy) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2004 (75 years or older)
AB 2271 (Parra) Failed Senate Public Safety 2004 (CDCR officers
AB 1660 (Negrete McLeod) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2002
AB 1970 (Matthews) - not heard in Senate 2001-02 (Parole, Probation
and Correctional officers)
AB 303 (Torlakson) Chapter 55, Stats. 2001 (Bart officers)
AB 1814 (Lempert) - Chapter 266, Stats. 2000 (Breastfeeding moms)
SB 801 (Poochigian) Failed Senate Judiciary 1999 (Judges)
AB 2608 (Wildman) - held Senate Approps. 1997-98 (Firefighters)
AB 316 (Morrissey) - held Senate Judiciary 1997-98 (LA County Park
Rangers, Safety Police and Security Officers)
SB 2066 (Rogers) - Chapter 742, Stats. 1994 (UC and CSU Police)
AB 2577 (Wright) - Chapter 324, Stats. 1992 (Peace Officers and CHP)
Support: The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME, AFL-CIO; California Correctional Peace Officers Association; California Statewide Law Enforcement Association; California Probation, Parole and Correctional Association; California Public Defenders Association; Fraternal Order of Police, Northern California Probation; Fresno County Probation Officer’s Association; Los Angeles County Probation Officers Union; Madera Probation Peace Officers Association; Sacramento County Probation Association; San Joaquin County Probation Officers Association; Ventura County Professional Peace Officers Association; a number of individual probation officers
Opposition: California Judges Association; Judicial Council of California
Assembly Floor Vote: 72 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to exempt probation officers from jury service in criminal trials.
Existing law provides a right to a jury trial in felony and misdemeanor cases. (Cal. Const., art I § 16.)
Existing law states the policy of California is that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random from the population of the area served by the court; that all qualified persons have an equal opportunity to be considered for jury service in the State; that all qualified persons have an obligation to serve as jurors when summoned; and that it is the responsibility of jury commissioners to manage all jury systems in an efficient, equitable, and cost-effective manner. (Code Civil Procedure (CCP) § 191.)
Existing law provides that persons who are not residents of the jurisdiction where the trial is held are not eligible to be jurors. (Civil Code § 203 (a)(4).)
Existing law states that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random, from sources that include a representative cross section of the population of the area served by the court. (CCP § 197.)
Existing law states that no person shall be excluded from eligibility for jury service in California unless they:
- Are not citizens of the United States;
- Are under 18 years of age;
- Are not domiciliaries of the State of California, or residents of the jurisdiction wherein they are summoned to serve;
- Have been convicted of malfeasance in office or a felony, and whose civil rights have not been restored;
- Do not hold sufficient knowledge of the English language;
- Currently serve as a grand or trial juror in any court of this state; or
- Are currently in conservatorship. (CCP § 203.)
Existing law states that no eligible person shall be exempt from jury service as a trial juror by reason of occupation. (CCP § 204 subd. (b).)
Existing law requires the jury commissioner to randomly select jurors for jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. (CCP § 219 (a).)
Existing law excludes the following peace officers from random selection to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire civil and criminal matters:
- Any sheriff, undersheriff, or deputy sheriff employed in the capacity by a county government;
- Any chief of police, of a city, or a chief, a director, or a chief executive officer of a municipal public safety agency, and any police officer appointed by one of these individuals;
- Any police officers or port wardens employed by the San Diego Unified Port District Police or the Harbor District of the City of Los Angeles;
- Any marshal or deputy marshal of a superior court or county;
- The Attorney General of California;
- All special agents and investigators of the Department of Justice;
- Any chief, assistant chief, deputy chief, deputy director, and division director of the Department of Justice designated as a peace officer by the Attorney General;
- Any deputy sheriff from 32 counties, as specified, employed to perform duties related to custodial responsibilities at any county custodial facility;
- Any member of the Department of the Highway Patrol provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law or the protection of state officers, state properties, and the occupants of state properties; and,
- A member of the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Police Department provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law in or about the property owned by the District. (CCP § 219 (b)(1).)
Existing law excludes the following peace officers from random selection to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire in criminal matters:
- A member of the University of California Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a University of California campus or property owned and administered by the University of California; and
- A member of the California State University Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a California State University campus. (CCP § 219 (b)(2).)
Existing law allows an eligible person to be excused from jury duty in cases of undue hardship, upon the person or the public, as defined by Judicial Council. (CCP § 204 (b).)
Existing law provides that it is an undue hardship for a prospective juror whose services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, if it is not feasible to make alternative arrangements to relieve the person of those responsibilities during the period of service as a juror without substantially reducing essential public services. (California Rule of Court 2.1008 (d)(6).)
Existing law requires Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court, requiring the trial courts to establish procedures for jury service that gives peace officers scheduling accommodations when necessary. (CCP § 219.5.)
This bill would exempt parole officers from being selected for voir dire in a criminal matter.
This bill would require Judicial Council to submit a report addressing the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service on the courts.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Federal law requires all persons, with some exceptions, to serve jury duty. The exceptions include, but are not limited to, persons who are not U.S. citizens and those who are under 18 years of age (Title 28 U.S. Code § 1861). In addition to excusing ineligible individuals from jury duty, state law also exempts specified sworn peace officers, including city police officers, country sheriffs, University of California officers, and California Highway Patrol, from jury duty (Code of Civil Procedure § 219). These officers are exempt based on the general notion that they provide a valuable public service that should not be interrupted by required jury service.
Despite also being sworn peace officers, probation officers are not exempt from jury duty. These officers’ duties include supervising offenders on post release supervision and probation. As a result, an officer may be familiar with the facts of a particular criminal case and therefore should not be involved in that defendant’s court proceedings to ensure the defendant’s constitutional right to a fair and unbiased trial (U.S. Const., 6th and 14th Amends.; Cal. Const., art. I, section 16; Irvin v. Dowd (1961) 366 U.S. 717, 722; In re Hitchings (1993) 6 Cal.4th 97, 110).
In 2018, the Legislature passed SB 10 which replaces cash bail with “risk assessments” of individuals and non-monetary conditions of release. These risk assessments are conducted by probation officers and as a result these officers are subject to facts of the case that other potential jurors are not, which, again, creates potential bias against the defendant. In addition, they are in positions where the defendant in a criminal trial could potentially be under their jurisdiction in the future. This conflict can create a public safety risk to these officers by requiring their personal information to be shared during the course of the jury selection and/or a trial. To address these issues, AB 310 would add probation officers to the section of state law that prohibits other specified peace officers from selection for duty.
2. Jury Service Exemptions
Prior to the 1980's, jury service exemptions were provided for legislators, congressmen, military personnel, peace officers, local office holders, attorneys, clergy, teachers, doctors, dentists, merchant seamen, telephone and telegraph operators, firefighters, and railroad employees. However, because those exemptions limited the available jury pool, the Legislature subsequently repealed jury service exemptions. The view of the Legislature at that time was that adding specific exemptions for jury service was a "slippery slope," especially considering the difficulties in having members of the public serve the court.
However, the Legislature has reinstated the existing exemptions for certain peace officers. The rationale for re-establishing these jury service exemptions was that these particular peace officers perform critical public safety functions and are constantly needed on the job to protect the public. It was not as the sponsor alleges because there was an “inherent danger that police officers and deputy sheriffs are exposed to through their interactions with potential criminals.” Many law enforcement peace officers, including those who work for the Departments of Fish and Game, Parks and Recreation, Forestry and Fire Protection, Alcoholic Beverages, Motor Vehicles, and State Fire Marshals, as well as the community college and school district police departments, are still not exempt from jury duty.
In the early 1990's, the Legislature recommenced the creation of new "carve outs" from jury service for specified peace officers. An exemption for specified peace officers and CHP officers from civil and criminal matters was created in 1992 and an exemption for University of California police officers and members of the Department of Corrections Law Enforcement Liaison Unit was added in 1994. In 2001, SB 303 (Torlakson), Chapter 55, Statutes of 2001, created a new public safety officer "carve out" that exempts San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District police from jury service in both civil and criminal matters. In 2002, AB 1970 (Mathews) attempted to add probation and parole officers to the jury duty exemptions and it was never heard in Senate Public Safety after it was clear it would not have the votes.
3. Exemption from criminal trials
This bill would exempt probation officers from criminal trials only. Since jury pools are not called separately for criminal or civil trials this bill should not keep a probation officer from showing up for a jury.
The sponsor argues that “as an arm of the court, probation officers have pre-conviction responsibilities such as operating pretrial programs and conduction risk assessments as well as preparing probation reports and making recommendations to the bench on suitability and eligibility for probation which may involve interviewing the defendant and witnesses and reviewing information on the circumstances of the offense.” While this is true, a probation officer who worked on a particular case or had contact with the defendant or witnesses would be immediately dismissed for cause just as any juror would. A probation officer may also not live in the jurisdiction in which he or she serves so thus may not have professional contact with a defendant in the jurisdiction in which he or she works. In addition others, including attorneys, spouses of attorneys, judges, social workers etc. may have contacts with the attorneys involved or the judge or may come in contact with the case during the trial or appellate phase and they still have to appear for jury duty. In fact when he was Chief Justice, Ronald George showed up for jury duty as do many lower court judges throughout the state. (http://articles.latimes.com/2003/may/16/local/me-onthelaw16)
4. Argument in Support
The State Coalition of Probation Organizations support this bill stating:
AB 310 seeks to extend [the jury service exemption] to probation peace officers. Given the enhanced role probation peace officers play today in criminal proceedings, and the more dangerous population they work with, extending the exemption to jury duty is a matter of probation peace officer safety.
5. Argument in Opposition
The California Judges Association opposes this bill stating:
AB 310 seeks to expand categorical exemptions to jury service to include additional designated parole and correctional officers, as specified, as exempt from voir dire in civil and criminal matters.
CJA’s opposition to AB 310 is consistent with its general opposition to exemptions from jury service. Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations.
Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable. Creating further categorical exemptions harms the diversity of the jury pool and increases the burden on the remaining prospective-juror community.
6. Veto of AB 2240 (Grayson)
Governor Brown vetoed AB 2240 (Grayson) stating:
I am returning Assembly Bill 2240 without my signature.
This bill would exempt probation, parole and correctional officers from jury service in criminal trials.
Jury service is a fundamental obligation of citizenship. I am not inclined to expand the list of those exempt simply because of their occupation.
-- END –
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 310 Hearing Date: June 25, 2019
Author: | Santiago | ||
Version: | May 16, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Trial Jury Selection and Management Act
HISTORY
Source: Chief Probation Officers of California
State Coalition of Probation Officers
Prior Legislation: AB 2240 (Grayson) Vetoed 2018 (Parole, Probation and Correctional officers)
SB 428 (Hall) Failed Senate Judiciary 2015 (peace officers)
SB 1133 (Anderson) Failed Senate Judiciary 2014 (Fish and Game officers)
AB 1708 (Alejo) not heard Senate Public Safety 2014(parole officers, CDCR officers, state hospital officers etc.)
AB 1993 (Nakanishi) not heard Senate Judiciary 2005-06 (nurses)
AB 270 (Bates) Failed Senate Public Safety 2003(harbor and port police)
AB 1978 (Haynes) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2003 (single parents)
AB 2253 (Mountjoy) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2004 (75 years or older)
AB 2271 (Parra) Failed Senate Public Safety 2004 (CDCR officers
AB 1660 (Negrete McLeod) Failed Assembly Judiciary 2002
AB 1970 (Matthews) - not heard in Senate 2001-02 (Parole, Probation
and Correctional officers)
AB 303 (Torlakson) Chapter 55, Stats. 2001 (Bart officers)
AB 1814 (Lempert) - Chapter 266, Stats. 2000 (Breastfeeding moms)
SB 801 (Poochigian) Failed Senate Judiciary 1999 (Judges)
AB 2608 (Wildman) - held Senate Approps. 1997-98 (Firefighters)
AB 316 (Morrissey) - held Senate Judiciary 1997-98 (LA County Park
Rangers, Safety Police and Security Officers)
SB 2066 (Rogers) - Chapter 742, Stats. 1994 (UC and CSU Police)
AB 2577 (Wright) - Chapter 324, Stats. 1992 (Peace Officers and CHP)
Support: The American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME, AFL-CIO; California Correctional Peace Officers Association; California Statewide Law Enforcement Association; California Probation, Parole and Correctional Association; California Public Defenders Association; Fraternal Order of Police, Northern California Probation; Fresno County Probation Officer’s Association; Los Angeles County Probation Officers Union; Madera Probation Peace Officers Association; Sacramento County Probation Association; San Joaquin County Probation Officers Association; Ventura County Professional Peace Officers Association; a number of individual probation officers
Opposition: California Judges Association; Judicial Council of California
Assembly Floor Vote: 72 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to exempt probation officers from jury service in criminal trials.
Existing law provides a right to a jury trial in felony and misdemeanor cases. (Cal. Const., art I § 16.)
Existing law states the policy of California is that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random from the population of the area served by the court; that all qualified persons have an equal opportunity to be considered for jury service in the State; that all qualified persons have an obligation to serve as jurors when summoned; and that it is the responsibility of jury commissioners to manage all jury systems in an efficient, equitable, and cost-effective manner. (Code Civil Procedure (CCP) § 191.)
Existing law provides that persons who are not residents of the jurisdiction where the trial is held are not eligible to be jurors. (Civil Code § 203 (a)(4).)
Existing law states that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random, from sources that include a representative cross section of the population of the area served by the court. (CCP § 197.)
Existing law states that no person shall be excluded from eligibility for jury service in California unless they:
- Are not citizens of the United States;
- Are under 18 years of age;
- Are not domiciliaries of the State of California, or residents of the jurisdiction wherein they are summoned to serve;
- Have been convicted of malfeasance in office or a felony, and whose civil rights have not been restored;
- Do not hold sufficient knowledge of the English language;
- Currently serve as a grand or trial juror in any court of this state; or
- Are currently in conservatorship. (CCP § 203.)
Existing law states that no eligible person shall be exempt from jury service as a trial juror by reason of occupation. (CCP § 204 subd. (b).)
Existing law requires the jury commissioner to randomly select jurors for jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. (CCP § 219 (a).)
Existing law excludes the following peace officers from random selection to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire civil and criminal matters:
- Any sheriff, undersheriff, or deputy sheriff employed in the capacity by a county government;
- Any chief of police, of a city, or a chief, a director, or a chief executive officer of a municipal public safety agency, and any police officer appointed by one of these individuals;
- Any police officers or port wardens employed by the San Diego Unified Port District Police or the Harbor District of the City of Los Angeles;
- Any marshal or deputy marshal of a superior court or county;
- The Attorney General of California;
- All special agents and investigators of the Department of Justice;
- Any chief, assistant chief, deputy chief, deputy director, and division director of the Department of Justice designated as a peace officer by the Attorney General;
- Any deputy sheriff from 32 counties, as specified, employed to perform duties related to custodial responsibilities at any county custodial facility;
- Any member of the Department of the Highway Patrol provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law or the protection of state officers, state properties, and the occupants of state properties; and,
- A member of the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Police Department provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law in or about the property owned by the District. (CCP § 219 (b)(1).)
Existing law excludes the following peace officers from random selection to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire in criminal matters:
- A member of the University of California Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a University of California campus or property owned and administered by the University of California; and
- A member of the California State University Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a California State University campus. (CCP § 219 (b)(2).)
Existing law allows an eligible person to be excused from jury duty in cases of undue hardship, upon the person or the public, as defined by Judicial Council. (CCP § 204 (b).)
Existing law provides that it is an undue hardship for a prospective juror whose services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, if it is not feasible to make alternative arrangements to relieve the person of those responsibilities during the period of service as a juror without substantially reducing essential public services. (California Rule of Court 2.1008 (d)(6).)
Existing law requires Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court, requiring the trial courts to establish procedures for jury service that gives peace officers scheduling accommodations when necessary. (CCP § 219.5.)
This bill would exempt parole officers from being selected for voir dire in a criminal matter.
This bill would require Judicial Council to submit a report addressing the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service on the courts.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Federal law requires all persons, with some exceptions, to serve jury duty. The exceptions include, but are not limited to, persons who are not U.S. citizens and those who are under 18 years of age (Title 28 U.S. Code § 1861). In addition to excusing ineligible individuals from jury duty, state law also exempts specified sworn peace officers, including city police officers, country sheriffs, University of California officers, and California Highway Patrol, from jury duty (Code of Civil Procedure § 219). These officers are exempt based on the general notion that they provide a valuable public service that should not be interrupted by required jury service.
Despite also being sworn peace officers, probation officers are not exempt from jury duty. These officers’ duties include supervising offenders on post release supervision and probation. As a result, an officer may be familiar with the facts of a particular criminal case and therefore should not be involved in that defendant’s court proceedings to ensure the defendant’s constitutional right to a fair and unbiased trial (U.S. Const., 6th and 14th Amends.; Cal. Const., art. I, section 16; Irvin v. Dowd (1961) 366 U.S. 717, 722; In re Hitchings (1993) 6 Cal.4th 97, 110).
In 2018, the Legislature passed SB 10 which replaces cash bail with “risk assessments” of individuals and non-monetary conditions of release. These risk assessments are conducted by probation officers and as a result these officers are subject to facts of the case that other potential jurors are not, which, again, creates potential bias against the defendant. In addition, they are in positions where the defendant in a criminal trial could potentially be under their jurisdiction in the future. This conflict can create a public safety risk to these officers by requiring their personal information to be shared during the course of the jury selection and/or a trial. To address these issues, AB 310 would add probation officers to the section of state law that prohibits other specified peace officers from selection for duty.
2. Jury Service Exemptions
Prior to the 1980's, jury service exemptions were provided for legislators, congressmen, military personnel, peace officers, local office holders, attorneys, clergy, teachers, doctors, dentists, merchant seamen, telephone and telegraph operators, firefighters, and railroad employees. However, because those exemptions limited the available jury pool, the Legislature subsequently repealed jury service exemptions. The view of the Legislature at that time was that adding specific exemptions for jury service was a "slippery slope," especially considering the difficulties in having members of the public serve the court.
However, the Legislature has reinstated the existing exemptions for certain peace officers. The rationale for re-establishing these jury service exemptions was that these particular peace officers perform critical public safety functions and are constantly needed on the job to protect the public. It was not as the sponsor alleges because there was an “inherent danger that police officers and deputy sheriffs are exposed to through their interactions with potential criminals.” Many law enforcement peace officers, including those who work for the Departments of Fish and Game, Parks and Recreation, Forestry and Fire Protection, Alcoholic Beverages, Motor Vehicles, and State Fire Marshals, as well as the community college and school district police departments, are still not exempt from jury duty.
In the early 1990's, the Legislature recommenced the creation of new "carve outs" from jury service for specified peace officers. An exemption for specified peace officers and CHP officers from civil and criminal matters was created in 1992 and an exemption for University of California police officers and members of the Department of Corrections Law Enforcement Liaison Unit was added in 1994. In 2001, SB 303 (Torlakson), Chapter 55, Statutes of 2001, created a new public safety officer "carve out" that exempts San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District police from jury service in both civil and criminal matters. In 2002, AB 1970 (Mathews) attempted to add probation and parole officers to the jury duty exemptions and it was never heard in Senate Public Safety after it was clear it would not have the votes.
3. Exemption from criminal trials
This bill would exempt probation officers from criminal trials only. Since jury pools are not called separately for criminal or civil trials this bill should not keep a probation officer from showing up for a jury.
The sponsor argues that “as an arm of the court, probation officers have pre-conviction responsibilities such as operating pretrial programs and conduction risk assessments as well as preparing probation reports and making recommendations to the bench on suitability and eligibility for probation which may involve interviewing the defendant and witnesses and reviewing information on the circumstances of the offense.” While this is true, a probation officer who worked on a particular case or had contact with the defendant or witnesses would be immediately dismissed for cause just as any juror would. A probation officer may also not live in the jurisdiction in which he or she serves so thus may not have professional contact with a defendant in the jurisdiction in which he or she works. In addition others, including attorneys, spouses of attorneys, judges, social workers etc. may have contacts with the attorneys involved or the judge or may come in contact with the case during the trial or appellate phase and they still have to appear for jury duty. In fact when he was Chief Justice, Ronald George showed up for jury duty as do many lower court judges throughout the state. (http://articles.latimes.com/2003/may/16/local/me-onthelaw16)
4. Argument in Support
The State Coalition of Probation Organizations support this bill stating:
AB 310 seeks to extend [the jury service exemption] to probation peace officers. Given the enhanced role probation peace officers play today in criminal proceedings, and the more dangerous population they work with, extending the exemption to jury duty is a matter of probation peace officer safety.
5. Argument in Opposition
The California Judges Association opposes this bill stating:
AB 310 seeks to expand categorical exemptions to jury service to include additional designated parole and correctional officers, as specified, as exempt from voir dire in civil and criminal matters.
CJA’s opposition to AB 310 is consistent with its general opposition to exemptions from jury service. Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations.
Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable. Creating further categorical exemptions harms the diversity of the jury pool and increases the burden on the remaining prospective-juror community.
6. Veto of AB 2240 (Grayson)
Governor Brown vetoed AB 2240 (Grayson) stating:
I am returning Assembly Bill 2240 without my signature.
This bill would exempt probation, parole and correctional officers from jury service in criminal trials.
Jury service is a fundamental obligation of citizenship. I am not inclined to expand the list of those exempt simply because of their occupation.
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 310
Author:(Santiago)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides that probation officers that are deemed peace officers are categorically exempted from jury duty in criminal matters until January 1, 2024. Requires the Judicial Council of California to submit a report regarding the impact of jury service exemptions to the justice system.
Major Provisions
- Provides that peace officers employed by a probation department shall not be selected for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters until January 1, 2024 and that the exemption is repealed as of that date.
- Requires the Judicial Council of California, on or before January 1, 2023, to submit to the Legislature a report on the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service, including the exemptions for peace officers. The report shall specifically address the following:
- Impacts to court administration created by exemptions from jury service.
- Impacts to the diversity, including cultural and professional backgrounds, of the jury pool created by exemptions from jury service.
- Impacts on the overall access to justice created by exemptions from jury service, including delays in trial scheduling and dismissals of last-day criminal trials.
COMMENTS:
California law has long held that a broad pool of potential jurors is needed to ensure the fairness of the legal process. In 1975, AB 681 (Siegler), Chapter 593, replaced the remaining jury duty exemptions with a generic provision allowing any person to be excused from jury duty for undue hardship to themselves or the public. In the years since 1975, several categories of front-line peace officers have been exempted from jury service based on the notion that they were rarely chosen for jury service, and frequently had potential conflicts. Nonetheless, most participants in the criminal justice process, including attorneys and judges, remained eligible for jury service, reflecting the widely held belief that making the full scope of the citizenry eligible for jury service is imperative to a functioning democracy.
Recognizing the unique role that many peace officers play in the justice system, the California Rules of Court already provide significant flexibility when these officers are called to jury service. The California Rules of Court specifically note that "inconvenience to a prospective juror or an employer is not an adequate reason to be excused from jury duty, although it may be considered a ground for deferral." (California Rules of Court, Rule 2.1008.) However, to address the needs of peace officers and other first responders, the rules state that if "the prospective juror's services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, and it is not feasible to make alternative arrangements to relieve the person," a juror may be excused from jury duty during the voir dire process. (Ibid.) Since 2000, there have been at least eight measures introduced in the Legislature seeking to exempt a class of persons from jury service. Frequently, these measure present rational, yet anecdotal, justifications for exempting a class of individuals or professionals from jury service that on a stand-alone basis would merit such an exemption. To ensure that the Legislature is no longer required to evaluate seemingly legitimate jury service exemptions in a vacuum this bill would also require the Judicial Council of California to provide a report detailing the impact of categorical exemptions to the justice system and on the diversity of the jury pool.
According to the Author:
It is important that probation officers be exempt from jury duty to avoid potential conflicts of interest within our justice system and to keep officers safe. These officers' duties include supervising offenders on probation. As a result, their duties provide them with knowledge that may create a possible conflict of interest regarding court proceedings involving an inmate, parolee, etc. that they may have supervised.
Arguments in Support:
Representative of the coalition the bill's co-sponsor, the State Coalition of Probation Organizations, argue:
AB 310 seeks to extend [the jury service exemption] to probation peace officers. Given the enhanced role probation peace officers play today in criminal proceedings, and the more dangerous population they work with, extending the exemption to jury duty is a matter of probation peace officer safety.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Judges Association contends:
Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations. Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, this bill imposes one-time costs (Trial Court Trust Fund/GF) of $250,000 for Judicial Council staff to analyze the impact of exemptions on the justice system and submit a report to the Legislature.
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-2-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 7-0-1
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Kamlager-Dove, Santiago, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Quirk
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 16-1-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000567
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 310
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2019
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 10 - 2 |
Public Safety | 7 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill exempts certain corrections, probation and parole officers from criminal trial jury service until January 1, 2024, and requires Judicial Council to submit a report to the Legislature detailing the impact of categorical exemptions on the justice system.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time costs (Trial Court Trust Fund/GF) of approximately $1.6 million dollars for the trial courts to implement an exemption process for corrections, probation and parole officers. Judicial Council estimates this bill will remove approximately 30,000 corrections officers and 14,000 probation and parole officers from the jury pool.
- One-time costs (Trial Court Trust Fund/GF) of $250,000 for Judicial Council staff to analyze the impact of exemptions on the justice system and submit a report to the Legislature.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
It is important that parole, probation, and correctional officers be exempt from jury duty to avoid potential conflicts of interest within our justice system. … [T]heir duties provide them with knowledge that may create a possible conflict of interest regarding court proceedings involving an inmate, parolee, etc. that they may have supervised.
- Support. According to the California Public Defenders Association:
In most, but not all cases, the credibility of a fellow officer will be a critical issue in deciding guilt or innocence, and it would be difficult to set aside the natural inclination to side with that officer. Also, many of the investigative issues in such a case may resemble the personal specialized knowledge of the juror-officer in his own job, thereby risking the introduction of extraneous evidence into the jury room.
- Opposition. According to the California Judges Association:
Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations. Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
Counsel: Nikki Moore
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 310
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:March 20, 2019
SUMMARY:
Exempts from criminal trial jury service 13 new categories of corrections, probation and parole officers until January 1, 2024. Requires the Judicial Council of California to submit a report to the Legislature detailing the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service on the justice system. Specifically, this bill:
- Exempts that the following classifications of peace officers employed by the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), as designated by Penal Code Section 830.5, from voir dire for jury service in criminal matters:
- A parole officer employed by CDCR;
- A parole officer employed by CDCR’s Division of Juvenile Parole Operations (Division);
- A board coordinating parole agent with the Juvenile Parole Board;
- A correctional officer employed by CDCR;
- A correctional officer employed by the Division;
- Any correctional counselor series employee of CDCR;
- Any medical technical assistant series employee designated by the Secretary of CDCR or employed by the Department of State Hospitals;
- Any employee of the Board of Parole Hearings designated by the Secretary of CDCR as a peace officer; and,
- Any other employee designated as a peace officer by the Secretary of CDCR;
- Provides that the following classifications of local peace officers as designated by Penal Code Section 830.5, shall not be selected for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters:
- Probation Officers;
- Deputy Probation Officers;
- Any superintendent, supervisor, or employee of an institution operated by a probation department with custodial responsibilities; and,
- Any transportation officer of a probation department.
- Sunsets the specified jury exemptions in January 1, 2024.
- Requires the Judicial Council of California, on or before January 1, 2023, to submit to the Legislature a report on the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service, including the existing and proposed exemptions for peace officers. The report shall specifically address the following:
- Impacts to court administration created by exemptions from jury service;
- Impacts to the diversity, including cultural and professional backgrounds, of the jury pool created by exemptions from jury service; and,
- Impacts on the overall access to justice created by exemptions from jury service, including delays in trial scheduling and dismissals of last-day criminal trials.
- Permits Judicial Council to utilize representative surveys to generate data for the report.
EXISTING LAW:
- States that the policy of the State of California is that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random from the population of the area served by the court; that all qualified persons have an equal opportunity to be considered for jury service in the State; that all qualified persons have an obligation to serve as jurors when summoned; and that it is the responsibility of jury commissioners to manage all jury systems in an efficient, equitable, and cost-effective manner. (Code Civ. Proc., § 191.)
- Requires that all persons selected for jury service be selected at random, from sources that include a representative cross section of the population of the area served by the court. (Code Civ. Proc., § 197.)
- Provides a method for selecting a fair and impartial jury in a criminal jury trial, wherein counsel for the parties has a right to engage in a liberal and probing examination calculated to discover bias or prejudice with regard to the circumstances of the particular case or the parties before the court. (Code Civ. Proc., § 223.)
- Presumes a person is eligible for jury service unless they:
- Are not citizens of the United States;
- Are under 18 years of age;
- Are not domiciliaries of the State of California, or residents of the jurisdiction wherein they are summoned to serve;
- Have been convicted of malfeasance in office or a felony, and whose civil rights have not been restored;
- Do not hold sufficient knowledge of the English language;
- Currently serve as a grand or trial juror in any court of this state; or
- Are currently in conservatorship. (Code Civ. Proc., § 203.)
- Provides that the jury commissioner shall randomly select jurors for jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. (Code Civ. Proc., § 219 (a).)
- Provides that if a jury commissioner requires a person to complete a questionnaire, the questionnaire shall ask only questions related to juror identification, qualification, and ability to serve as a prospective juror. (Code Civ. Proc., § 205 (a).)
- Provides that a court may require a prospective juror to complete such additional questionnaires as may be deemed relevant and necessary for assisting in the voir dire process or to ascertain whether a fair cross section of the population is represented as required by law, if such procedures are established by local court rule. (Code Civ. Proc., § 205 (c).)
- Prohibits from selection for voir dire for jury service in civil and criminal matters the following peace officers:
- Any sheriff, undersheriff, or deputy sheriff employed in the capacity by a county government;
- Any chief of police, of a city, or a chief, a director, or a chief executive officer of a municipal public safety agency;
- A police officer appointed by a person designated in b);
- Any police officers or port wardens employed by the San Diego Unified Port District Police or the Harbor District of the City of Los Angeles;
- Any marshal or deputy marshal of a superior court or county;
- The Attorney General of California;
- All special agents and investigators of the Department of Justice;
- Any chief, assistant chief, deputy chief, deputy director, and division director of the Department of Justice designated as a peace officer by the Attorney General;
- Any deputy sheriff from 32 counties, as specified, employed to perform duties related to custodial responsibilities at any county custodial facility;
- Any member of the Department of the Highway Patrol provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law or the protection of state officers, state properties, and the occupants of state properties; and,
- A member of the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Police Department provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law in or about the property owned by the District. (Code Civ. Proc., § 219 (a).)
- Prohibits from selection for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters the following peace officers:
- A member of the University of California Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a University of California campus or property owned and administered by the University of California; and
- A member of the California State University Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a California State University campus or property owned and administered by the California State University. (Code Civ. Proc., § 219 (b).)
- Provides that the courts must establish pretrial assessment services, and provides that services may be performed by court employees or the court may contract for those services with a qualified local public agency with relevant experience. (Pen. Code, § 1320.26 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “It is important that parole, probation, and correctional officers be exempt from jury duty to avoid potential conflicts of interest within our justice system. These officers’ duties include supervising offenders on post release supervision, mandatory supervision, probation, parole, and monitoring people serving time inside a local or state detention facility. As a result, their duties provide them with knowledge that may create a possible conflict of interest regarding court proceedings involving an inmate, parolee, etc. that they may have supervised.
“In addition, pulling these peace officers from duty can significantly impact their respective agencies’ ability to effectively manage and administer programs and supervision and can also put officers in danger. Probation, parole and correctional officers are in positions in which the defendant in a criminal trial could potentially be under their jurisdiction in the future, which puts these officers at risk when their private information is released. While there may be concern surrounding this bill of creating a ‘slippery slope’ in which any person of a certain profession may be exempt from jury service, it is imperative that probation, parole and correctional officers be exempt from jury duty to uphold the integrity of California’s court system and preserve the safety of officers.”
- Potential Conflicts, Bias, and Impartiality: Both the U.S. and state constitution guarantee defendants accused of a crime the right to a trial by unbiased, impartial jurors. (U.S. Const., 6th and 14th Amends.; Cal. Const., art. I, section 16; Irvin v. Dowd (1961) 366 U.S. 717, 722; In re Hitchings (1993) 6 Cal.4th 97, 110.) An impartial juror is someone capable and willing to decide the case solely on the evidence presented at trial. (Smith v. Phillips (1982) 455 U.S. 209, 217.) A sitting juror’s bias renders him unable to perform his duty and thus the juror could be challenged for cause and subject to discharge and substitution. (People v. Keenan (1988) 46 Cal.3d 478, 532; People v. Lomax (2010) 49 Cal.4th 530, 589.)
Whether a juror is impartial is discovered through the voir dire process. During voir dire the parties and the judge question prospective jurors in order to learn information about them. The most common and most important questions asked during voir dire is whether the prospective juror knows any of the people associated with the case, including the parties, their witnesses, the attorneys, the judge, and the court staff. In order to ensure a fair and impartial jury is selected in a criminal jury trial, counsel for the parties have a right to engage in a liberal and probing examination calculated to discover bias or prejudice with regard to the circumstances of the particular case or the parties before the court. Attitudes about law enforcement, the police, the courts, or the criminal justice system are common areas of questioning and fertile ground for learning information that may support a challenge for cause to eliminate a potential juror.
The theory behind this bill is that the position and views of peace officers, and any one serving a similar function, make those people unconditionally unable to serve on criminal juries without need for examination, a sentiment shared by representatives for peace officers and defendants alike. Justification for existing exemptions from jury service for peace officers, and for the propose exemption for parole and probation officers in this bill, center on the sentiment that an officer may already know a repeat offender or may end up supervising a defendant after trial, making it wholly inappropriate for such person to be on the jury of that individual. Requiring an officer to appear for voir doir is seen as a waste of resources and time, since the officer will likely be dismissed from service in any event due to inherent conflicts.
Impartiality and conflict concerns are at the root of the voir dire process; preemptory and “for cause” challenges are the remedy. The parties’ right to an impartial jury is paramount, and it is inherent in the process that a person with a conflict will be eliminated from the jury pool whether categorical exemptions exist or not. This bill raises the question whether categorical exemptions for peace officers deprive a person engage in law enforcement who is on criminal trial of the opportunity to seat a jury of their peers.
This bill would require the Judicial Council to create a report to determine the impact of exempting categories of professions from jury service, generally. This report will help the Legislature understand the propriety of carving out entire sections of the population from jury service. The justification for categorical exemptions for law enforcement officials are easily stretched to justify exempting criminal attorneys, public defenders, prosecutors, paralegals, and court reporters, expert witnesses, or any court employee and criminal justice professional for that matter, from serving on a criminal jury. However, as the California Judges Association notes, it may be harmful to winnow the jury pool based on broad-sweeping exemptions, and generally, these exemptions should be resisted. In the future, this Legislature may even wish to revert back to the case-by-case examination of all potential jurors and eliminate categorical exemptions from jury service. The report mandated by this bill of Judicial Council to investigate the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service will likely illuminate which approach is more appropriate.
Similar measures to this bill have also attempted to exempt parole and probation officers from civil jury service. This bill would only exempt specified officers from criminal cases, where the justification for this bill are greater. While some impartiality and conflict concerns may arise in civil cases, there is a much broader range of activity in the civil courts that would not implicate these concerns.
- The Constitutional Problem of Categorically Excluding from Jury Duty Certain Occupations: The Legislature should exercise extreme caution when deciding whether to continue down the path of excluding certain categories of people from jury service.
“The constitutional rule requiring a representative jury bars not only the exclusion of a group, but disproportionate reduction in its members; if some persons with a particular life experience are barred from the jury, others cannot properly represent the perspective of those excluded because the number of persons with that perspective will be disproportionately small.” (People v. Harris (1984) 36 Cal. 3d 36, 51.)
It is a fundamental tenet of the U.S. Constitution that a criminal defendant is entitled to trial by an impartial jury drawn from a representative cross-section of the community. (Taylor v. Louisiana (1975) 419 U.S. 522, 530; 16; People v. Wheeler (1978) 22 Cal.3d 258, 272; see also Cal. Const. art. I, §16.) As the Supreme Court stated, “in our heterogeneous society jurors will inevitably belong to diverse and often overlapping groups defined by race, religion, ethnic or national origin, sex, age, education, occupation, economic condition, place of residence, and political affiliation; that it is unrealistic to expect jurors to be devoid of opinions, preconceptions, or even deep-rooted biases derived from their life experiences in such groups; and hence that the only practical way to achieve an overall impartiality is to encourage the representation of a variety of such groups on the jury so that the respective biases of their members, to the extent they are antagonistic, will tend to cancel each other out.” (Wheeler at pp. 276.) The Court held, “the exclusion of prospective jurors solely on the ground of group bias violates the right to trial by a jury drawn from a representative cross-section of the community.” (Id. at. pp.276-77.) emphasis added.)
A defendant may challenge a jury conviction for a violation of the fair-cross-section requirement. To do so the defendant must show (1) that the group alleged to be excluded is a distinctive group in the community; (2) that the representation of this group in venires from which juries are selected is not fair and reasonable in relation to the number of such persons in the community; and (3) that this underrepresentation is due to systematic exclusion of the group in the jury-selection process.” (Duren v. Missouri (1979) 439 U.S. 357, 364.) No litigant has the right to a jury that mirrors the demographic composition of the population, or necessarily includes members of his own group, or is composed of any particular individuals. (Id. at 762.) This is because prospective jurors are subject to for cause and peremptory challenges on grounds of specific bias; but, as the Court warned “we cannot countenance the decimation of the surviving jurors” on the ground of group bias. (Id.) In Sixth Amendment fair-cross-section cases, systematic disproportion itself demonstrates an infringement of the defendant’s interest in a jury chosen from a fair community cross section, no showing of intent to discriminate, for example on the bases of a group’s perceived bias, is required. (Id.)
In California the jury commissioner is required to randomly select qualified prospective jurors for jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. The names are selected from various source lists including records from the DMV and registrar of voters. The jury commissioner may send a questionnaire to potential jurors from the source lists only to determine if the potential juror is qualified. The jury commissioner must summon prospective jurors and hear the excuses of jurors summoned. It is left to the discretion of the jury commissioner to accept an excuse without a personal appearance. Unless excused by reason of undue hardship, the summoned prospective jurors shall be available to appear for service. (Code Civ. Proc., § 213.) The Civil Code specifies that it is an undue hardship for a prospective juror, whose services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, including correctional, probation, and parole officers.
Once summoned, jurors appear for jury duty, and the jury commissioner selects, at random, jurors to be on jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. (Code Civ. Proc., § 219.) The only category of people who are excluded from being randomly selected on a jury panel to be sent to a court room for voir dire are sheriffs, police, and highway patrol officers in criminal and civil trials, and UC and CSU police in criminal trials. (Code Civ. Proc., § 219.) This is the law despite the fact that this group of individuals may be excused, without a personal appearance, if jury service is an undue hardship because their services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, and members of this group can also be dismissed for cause during voir dire, if needed.
This bill raises the questions of whether eliminating peace officers from the jury pool deprives the public of a fair cross section of the community being represented in a criminal trial. It could ultimately raise challenges to cases where a person, including a peace officer, may allege that their constitutional right to an impartial jury is diminished due to the categorical exemption of certain occupations.
This bill would add additional occupations, including parole, corrections, and probation officers, to the list of occupations already categorically excluded from jury duty in criminal cases. Proponents of this bill claim that pulling these officers away from their duties can significantly impact the agency’s ability to effectively manage and administer programs and supervision. The persuasiveness of the argument is suspect because a peace officer who is not already statutorily specifically exempt may request to be excused from jury duty on the basis of undue hardship because he or she is immediately needed in a critical public safety function, on a case by case basis. Furthermore, while post-conviction and post-release supervisory officers are an important part of the public safety system, it is unclear if each and every peace officer employed as a probation officer, parole officer, or correctional officer is continuously needed to fulfill a critical public safety function that would justify a blanket exemption from jury duty.
Moreover, a categorical exclusion based on occupation would prohibit individuals who desire to fulfil their civic duty of serving on a jury the opportunity to do so.
- Argument in Support: According to the California Public Defenders Association, “AB 310 would enact a modest, but wholly appropriate, change to Code Civ. Proc., § 219, having to do with selection of potential trial jurors. Under subdivision (c) of that section most categories of peace officers are excluded from voir dire in criminal cases. The reasons for this are fairly obvious. In most, but not all cases, the credibility of a fellow officer will be a critical issue in deciding guilt or innocence, and it would be difficult to set aside the natural inclination to side with that officer. Also, many of the investigative issues in such a case may resemble the personal specialized knowledge of the juror-officer in his own job, thereby risking the introduction of extraneous evidence into the jury room.
“Finally, most, if not all, such officers would probably be excused from service in criminal cases anyway, either for cause or peremptorily, and therefore it would be more economical of court time and resources, as well as, of the officers’ time, to not put them through the process in the first place. AB 310 would simply expand the categories of peace officers already excluded from voir dire in criminal cases to include parole officers and correctional officers. The foregoing rationale for excluding peace officers of other categories from criminal voir dire applies with equal force to them. In addition, their direct and almost constant contact with individuals who have been convicted of criminal offenses raises a legitimate risk that they may have a difficult time entertaining the presumption of innocence for those who are merely accused.” - Argument in Opposition:
- According to the California Judges Association (CJA), “AB 310 seeks to expand categorical exemptions to jury service to include additional designated parole and correctional officers, as specified, as exempt from voir dire in civil and criminal matters.
“CJA’s opposition to AB 310 is consistent with its general opposition to exemptions from jury service. Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations.
“Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable. Creating further categorical exemptions harms the diversity of the jury pool and increases the burden on the remaining prospective-juror community.” - According to the Judicial Council, “The council has a longstanding policy of opposing categorical exemptions from jury service and has continually found that statutorily exempting specific categories of persons from jury duty reduces the number of available jurors, makes it more difficult to select representative juries, and unfairly increases the burden of jury service on other segments of the population. The courts have a constitutional obligation to ensure that jury pools are representative of the community and that there are enough prospective jurors in the courthouse each day to avoid having to dismiss last-day criminal trials for lack of jurors.
“Furthermore, existing law and California Rules of Court make categorical exceptions unnecessary, as both authorize courts to grant a hardship excuse in appropriate circumstances and to make scheduling accommodations without requiring a court appearance. Hardships noted in the promotion of bills like AB 310, including lack of transportation, personal obligation to provide care for another, and that the prospective juror’s services ‘are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety,’ would all be grounds constituting undue hardship under California Rules of Court, rule 2.1008.
“Many changes in recent years designed specifically to lessen the burden of jury duty on citizens also render categorical exemptions unnecessary. Such changes include creation of a one day/one trial system statewide, improving the summons process to allow requests for excuses to be made, and adoption of a rule of court to ensure that jurors can request scheduling accommodations without appearing in court.
“Courts must constantly balance the need to ensure access to the justice system with the need to respect jurors’ time. However, while jury service requires sacrifice on the part of citizens, exempting certain classes of individuals based on the burden it might put on them unfairly increases the burden on the others.”
- According to the California Judges Association (CJA), “AB 310 seeks to expand categorical exemptions to jury service to include additional designated parole and correctional officers, as specified, as exempt from voir dire in civil and criminal matters.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 2240 (Grayson), 2018, was identical to the introduced version of this measure. Governor Brown vetoed the bill.
- AB 1541 (Kiley), Chapter 302, Statutes of 2017, permits each party’s counsel be calculating to discover bias and prejudice in jury selection, in accord with the circumstances of a particular case or the parties before the court.
- AB 1708 (Alejo), 2014, was nearly identical to the introduced version of this bill. AB 1708 was held in this committee.
- SB 1133 (Anderson), 2014, would have exempted from jury service fish and game wardens who were sworn peace officers. AB 1133 failed in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Chief Probation Officers of California (Sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Correctional Peace Officers Association
California Probation Parole and Correctional Association
California Public Defenders Association
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Chief Probation Officers of California
Los Angeles County Probation Officers Union, AFSCME Local 685
State Coalition of Probation Organizations
Oppose
California Judges Association
Judicial Council of California
Analysis Prepared by:
Nikki Moore / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Date of Hearing: March 19, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 310
Author:(Santiago) – As Introduced Ver:January 29, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Trial Jury Selection and Management Act
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD corrections, probation, and parole officers BE GIVEN A TEMPORARY CATEGORICAL EXEMPTION FROM SERVING ON JURIES IN CRIMINAL MATTERS?
- SHOULD THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL OF CALIFORNIA BE REQUIRED TO SUBMIT TO THE LEGISLATURE A REPORT DETAILING THE IMPACTS OF JURY SERVICE EXEMPTIONS ON THE JUSTICE SYSTEM AND THE DIVERSITY OF THE JURY POOL?
SYNOPSIS
This measure is the third bill to be introduced since 2014 that seeks to exempt corrections, parole, and probation officers that qualify as peace officers from being summoned for voir dire in jury service. Last year’s Assembly Bill 2240 (Grayson, 2018), which was identical to the introduced version of this measure, cleared the Legislature but was vetoed by Governor Brown. In vetoing that measure, Governor Brown noted, “Jury service is a fundamental obligation of citizenship,” and stated that he was not inclined to provide an exemption. This Committee raised similar concerns to those expressed by Governor Brown in its analysis of that measure, stating that, “Since 1975, California law has, generally, required all citizens to serve as potential jurors regardless of a person’s occupation or life experience. The State’s policy reflects the belief that a truly democratic and impartial jury is best obtained when a diverse spectrum of citizens, with broad life experiences and backgrounds, are eligible for jury service.” (Assem. Jud. Com., analysis of AB No. 2240 (2017*2018 Reg. Sess.) As Introduced Feb. 13, 2018 at p. 1.) To ensure that the Legislature is no longer required to evaluate specific jury service exemptions without a stronger understanding of the impact of such exemptions on the jury pool overall, as proposed to be amended, this bill would require the Judicial Council of California to report to the Legislature on the impact of categorical exemptions to the justice system and the diversity of the jury pool. Additionally, proposed amendments would make the exemption from jury service for corrections, parole, and probation officers temporary, pending the outcome of the Judicial Council’s report.
This measure is jointly sponsored by the Chief Probation Officers of California and the State Coalition of Probation Organizations who contend that their membership should be granted an exemption from criminal jury service due to their role in the criminal justice process. This measure is opposed by the California Judges Association who, like Governor Brown, argue that jury service is a fundamental obligation of citizenship. They also note that every categorical exemption from jury service poses significant challenges to the courts, which already struggle to find an adequate number of eligible jurors to hear cases.
SUMMARY: Provides that thirteen individual classifications of corrections, probation, and parole officers, that are deemed peace officers under existing law, are categorically exempted from jury duty in criminal matters until January 1, 2024. Requires the Judicial Council of California to submit a report regarding the impact of jury service exemptions to the justice system. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that the following classifications of peace officers employed by the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR), as designated by Penal Code Section 830.5, shall not be selected for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters:
- A parole officer employed by CDCR;
- A parole officer employed by CDCR’s Division of Juvenile Parole Operations (Division);
- A board coordinating parole agent with the Juvenile Parole Board;
- A correctional officer employed by CDCR;
- A correctional officer employed by the Division;
- Any correctional counselor series employee of CDCR;
- Any medical technical assistant series employee designated by the Secretary of CDCR or employed by the Department of State Hospitals;
- Any employee of the Board of Parole Hearings designated by the Secretary of CDCR as a peace officer; and
- Any other employee designated as a peace officer by the Secretary of CDCR;
- Provides that the following classifications of local peace officers as designated by Penal Code Section 830.5, shall not be selected for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters:
- Probation Officers;
- Deputy Probation Officers;
- Any superintendent, supervisor, or employee of an institution operated by a probation department with custodial responsibilities; and
- Any transportation officer of a probation department.
- Provides that the provisions of 1) and 2) shall remain in effect until January 1, 2024 and are repealed as of that date.
- Requires the Judicial Council of California, on or before January 1, 2023, to submit to the Legislature a report on the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service, including the exemptions for peace officers. The report shall specifically address the following:
- Impacts to court administration created by exemptions from jury service.
- Impacts to the diversity, including cultural and professional backgrounds, of the jury pool created by exemptions from jury service.
- Impacts on the overall access to justice created by exemptions from jury service, including delays in trial scheduling and dismissals of last-day criminal trials.
- Provides that the Judicial Council may utilize representative surveys to generate any data necessary for the report required pursuant to 4).
EXISTING LAW:
- States that the policy of the State of California is that all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random from the population of the area served by the court; that all qualified persons have an equal opportunity to be considered for jury service in the State; that all qualified persons have an obligation to serve as jurors when summoned; and that it is the responsibility of jury commissioners to manage all jury systems in an efficient, equitable, and cost-effective manner. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 191.)
- Requires all persons selected for jury service shall be selected at random, from sources that include a representative cross section of the population of the area served by the court. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 197.)
- Presumes a person is eligible for jury service unless they:
- Are not citizens of the United States;
- Are under 18 years of age;
- Are not domiciliaries of the State of California, or residents of the jurisdiction wherein they are summoned to serve;
- Have been convicted of malfeasance in office or a felony, and whose civil rights have not been restored;
- Do not hold sufficient knowledge of the English language;
- Currently serve as a grand or trial juror in any court of this state; or
- Are currently in conservatorship. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 203.)
- Provides that the jury commissioner shall randomly select jurors for jury panels to be sent to courtrooms for voir dire. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 219 (a).)
- Provides that if a jury commissioner requires a person to complete a questionnaire, the questionnaire shall ask only questions related to juror identification, qualification, and ability to serve as a prospective juror. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 205 (a).)
- Provides that a court may require a prospective juror to complete such additional questionnaires as may be deemed relevant and necessary for assisting in the voir dire process or to ascertain whether a fair cross section of the population is represented as required by law, if such procedures are established by local court rule. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 205 (c).)
- Prohibits from selection for voir dire for jury service in civil and criminal matters the following peace officers:
- Any sheriff, undersheriff, or deputy sheriff employed in the capacity by a county government;
- Any chief of police, of a city, or a chief, a director, or a chief executive officer of a municipal public safety agency;
- A police officer appointed by a person designated in b);
- Any police officers or port wardens employed by the San Diego Unified Port District Police or the Harbor District of the City of Los Angeles;
- Any marshal or deputy marshal of a superior court or county;
- The Attorney General of California;
- All special agents and investigators of the Department of Justice;
- Any chief, assistant chief, deputy chief, deputy director, and division director of the Department of Justice designated as a peace officer by the Attorney General;
- Any deputy sheriff from 32 counties, as specified, employed to perform duties related to custodial responsibilities at any county custodial facility;
- Any member of the Department of the Highway Patrol provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law or the protection of state officers, state properties, and the occupants of state properties; and
- A member of the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District Police Department provided that their duty is the enforcement of the law in or about the property owned by the District. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 219 (a).)
- Prohibits from selection for voir dire for jury service in criminal matters the following peace officers:
- A member of the University of California Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a University of California campus or property owned and administered by the University of California; and
- A member of the California State University Police Department provided that the officer is assigned to the enforcement of the law within one mile of a California State University campus or property owned and administered by the California State University. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 219 (b).)
- Provides that the courts must establish pretrial assessment services, and provides that services may be performed by court employees or the court may contract for those services with a qualified local public agency with relevant experience. (Penal Code Section 1320.26 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to temporarily exempt corrections, parole, and probation officers that qualify as peace officers from being summoned for voir dire for jury service in any criminal matter, despite the State’s general policy that all eligible persons should have an equal opportunity to serve on a jury. To ensure that the Legislature is no longer required to evaluate seemingly legitimate jury service exemptions in a vacuum, as proposed to be amended, this bill would also require the Judicial Council of California to provide a report detailing the impact of categorical exemptions to the justice system and on the diversity of the jury pool.
Diverse trial juries are an essential tool for a functioning democracy. Although the United States Constitution was the first document to formally codify the right of a criminal defendant to a trial by jury, the use of panels compromised of members of the public to adjudicate legal matters long predates the founding of the United States. While the earliest evidence of the use of juries can be traced to the ancient Greeks, the American tradition of trial juries has roots in early Nordic influences on the English Common Law. Norway long utilized courts comprised of “laugrettomadr,” or lawmen, who were citizens nominated from various districts to hear cases of national importance. During the Norman Conquest, these traditions took hold in England. However, as the English legal scholar Blackstone noted, trial by jury in England is a privilege, not a right. Nonetheless, the use of jury trials became an established practice in the American colonies.
Seeking to maintain royal order in North America, colonial juries were frequently made up of loyalists to the English monarch. However, as the interests of the American colonists and the English monarch began to diverge in the mid-1700s, colonial attorneys who were loyal to the crown sought to exclude persons perceived as bias from juries. Following the widely publicized trial of John Peter Zenger for seditious libel in 1735, the legislature of the Massachusetts Bay Colony passed the America’s first jury selection law removing the monarch’s control of the jury selection process and granting sole control of jury selection to the courts. The Massachusetts courts then developed a system to select jury pools encompassing all land-owning men within the colony in order to diversify the jury pool and further limit the crown’s influence in the judicial process. Believing that the Massachusetts law provided too much control over the questioning and selection of jurors to the people, the English Parliament subsequently passed a law restoring full control of jury selection in the colonies to the crown. (Hans, Valerie P., and Neil Vidmar. Judging the Jury. Perseus, 2001.)
The pro-monarch juries of the pre-Revolutionary period convinced early Americans of the need for unbiased juries to handle legal matters as a check on unrestrained government power. To protect these beliefs, the jury process was codified in the Fifth, Sixth, and Seventh Amendments to the United States Constitution, enshrining the American notion that democratic deliberation, “by jurors of different backgrounds and perspectives, to reach consensus through debate and discussion” was a right guaranteed to all Americans. (Robert P. Burns, The History and Theory of the American Jury, 83 Cal. L.Rev. 1477 (1995).) The right to trial by a jury of one’s peers remains one of the most fundamental rights given to Americans.
Throughout American history, jury participation has been expanded to better reflect the community as a whole. Unlike England, which dramatically scaled back the use of juries due to the lack of men available for jury service during World War I, the United States has significantly broadened the pool of potential jurors throughout its history. While early American juries were limited to white, land-owning men, as civil and voting rights expanded so too did eligibility for jury service, albeit slowly. Not until the passage of the Federal Civil Rights Act of 1875 (now codified at 18 USC § 243) did Congress formally require African Americans to be included in the jury pool for federal cases. The first record of women serving on a trial jury was in the Wyoming Territory in 1870, although that right was removed upon the Territory’s obtaining statehood. As late as 1961, the U.S. Supreme Court held that a “woman is still regarded as the center of home and family life. We cannot say that it is constitutionally impermissible for a State... to conclude that a woman should be relieved from the civic duty of jury service unless she herself determines that such service is consistent with her own special responsibilities.” (Hoyt v. Florida, 368 U.S. 57 (1961).) The Hoyt decision was not formally overturned until 1975. However, generally, American law has favored broad jury pools and disfavored attempts to curtail a person’s eligibility for jury service.
California law has long held that a broad pool of potential jurors is needed to ensure the fairness of the legal process. California expanded jury service faster than the nation as a whole such that by 1975, the only groups exempt from jury duty were those that the Legislature believed worked in occupations that provided a valuable public service that should not be interrupted by a requirement of jury service. Those occupations included the legislators themselves, members of Congress, military personnel, peace officers, local office holders, attorneys, clergy, teachers, doctors, dentists, merchant seamen, telephone and telegraph operators, firefighters, railroad employees, faith healers, and cloister monks and nuns. In 1975, AB 681 (Siegler, Chap. 593, Stats. 1975) replaced the remaining jury duty exemptions with a generic provision allowing any person to be excused from jury duty for undue hardship to themselves or the public. In the years since 1975, several categories of front-line peace officers have been exempted from jury service based on the notion that they were rarely chosen for jury service, and frequently had potential conflicts. Nonetheless, most participants in the criminal justice process, including attorneys and judges, remained eligible for jury service, reflecting the widely held belief that making the full scope of the citizenry eligible for jury service is imperative to a functioning democracy.
Despite the need for a robust jury pool, proponents of this measure argue that probation, parole, and correctional officers are sufficiently involved in the criminal justice system to merit a categorical exemption from criminal jury service. The author and the co-sponsors of this bill offer two primary justifications for this measure. The proponents contend that the existing voir dire process places peace officers at risk by forcing them to submit to questioning in the presence of defendants, and that probation officers are playing a growing role in the criminal justice process and may be subject to bias, thus justifying the exception. In support of this measure the author notes the following:
It is important that parole, probation, and correctional officers be exempt from jury duty to avoid potential conflicts of interest within our justice system and to keep officers safe. These officers’ duties include supervising offenders on post release supervision, mandatory supervision, probation, parole, and monitoring people serving time inside a local or state detention facility. As a result, their duties provide them with knowledge that may create a possible conflict of interest regarding court proceedings involving an inmate, parolee, etc. that they may have supervised.
In addition, probation peace officers are in positions in which the defendant in a criminal trial could potentially be under their jurisdiction in the future, which puts these officers at risk when their private information is released. Their activities include mandatory supervision of individuals released from jails and prisons, which often bring probation officers into contact with very dangerous individuals. To address these issues, AB 310 would add probation, parole and correctional officers to the section of state law that prohibits other specified peace officers from selection for jury duty.
Supporters of this measure contend that probation, parole, and correctional officers are entitled to protections not afforded to other officials in the criminal justice process, or the public at large. In support of this bill, the State Coalition of Probation Organizations argues that the vior dire process is unnecessarily intrusive for peace officers who may be required to disclose potentially personal information in court, in front of defendants. The State Coalition of Probation Organizations additionally (and erroneously) claim that while it would be unthinkable that a, “public defender or district attorney would serve on a jury during a criminal trial, probation peace officers today serve on such juries. It is time to recognize the enhanced duties and dangers for probation peace officers as a result of ‘realignment’ and extend the jury duty exemption.” This argument rests on a faulty premise. Under existing law, public defenders and district attorneys are subject to voir dire in criminal jury trials and do serve on juries. Although the State Coalition of Probation Organizations may be correct in stating that most public defenders and district attorneys (as well other none-exempt parties who work around the justice system, including judges) are frequently dismissed from a criminal jury during the voir dire process for many of the same reasons most probation officers are likely to be dismissed from service, these groups are not afforded a categorical exemption from being in the jury pool. Accordingly, these criminal attorneys must share the very same personal information in front of defendants that the probation officers claim would put them at risk if shared, and yet these attorneys are not provided a categorical exemptions from jury service in this bill. Additionally, this bill provides no protections to members of the general public who must disclose personal information in front of criminal defendants on a daily basis as a part of the functioning trial jury system. It is difficult to believe that members of the public would be any less fearful of sharing personal information than a highly trained member of law enforcement, like a probation officer. Finally, despite anecdotal claims of fear being voiced by members of the State Coalition of Probation Organizations, no evidence has been provided to this Committee that criminals are utilizing information disclosed during voir dire to target probation officers, or any other class of potential jurors, such as criminal defense attorneys or prosecutors.
The growing role of probation officers in all aspects of the criminal justice process may justify an exemption from jury service, but insufficient information exists to evaluate this theory. Recognizing the unique role that many post-conviction peace officers play in the justice system, the California Rules of Court already provide significant flexibility when these officers are called to jury service. The California Rules of Court specifically note that “inconvenience to a prospective juror or an employer is not an adequate reason to be excused from jury duty, although it may be considered a ground for deferral.” (California Rules of Court, Rule 2.1008.) However, to address the needs of peace officers and other first responders, the rules state that if “the prospective juror’s services are immediately needed for the protection of the public health and safety, and it is not feasible to make alternative arrangements to relieve the person,” a juror may be excused from jury duty during the voir dire process. (Ibid.) This provision applies to the service of peace officers on both civil and criminal juries. Additionally, courts generally permit jurors to reschedule service, occasionally repeatedly, so long as the potential juror is willing to communicate their needs to the courts. Nonetheless, this bill’s co-sponsor, the Chief Probation Officers of California have argued that probation officers are taking on a growing role in pre-trial criminal justice processes and that the existing procedures are no longer sufficient to handle potential conflicts.
Probation officers currently prepare probation reports and make recommendations to the bench. Additionally, recent changes to California’s cash bail laws may enhance the role of probation officers in the court process. After the Legislature enacted SB 10 (Hertzberg) Chap. 244, Stats. 2018, California courts are moving away from a cash bail system and instead focusing on conducting a risk assessments of defendants when determining a defendant’s eligibility for pretrial release. While currently on-hold and subject to a referendum vote, the existing law provides that risk assessments may be conducted by a qualified local public agency with relevant experience. In some jurisdictions a court could decide to vest this power with an existing probation department. The author argues that this role is incompatible with rendering an impartial jury decision, especially if the officer is exposed to information subsequently disallowed from trial by a judge. While these potential conflicts should be exposed during the voir dire process, and a peace officer could be dismissed via a preemptory challenge, the Legislature recently enacted SB 843 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chap. 33, Stats. 2016) that reduced the number of preemptory challenges from ten to six in many criminal matters. In instances in which a clear potential for bias exists, for example if a probation officer possessed information that would have to be excluded from presentation at trial, the judge would retain the ability to dismiss the juror for cause. However, for the purpose of judicial efficiency a categorical exemption may be justified.
At this point, the full impact of bail reform on the courts is unknown. Accordingly, as proposed to be amended, this bill would permit the jury service exemption for corrections, parole, and probation officers on a temporary basis until January 1, 2024. The proposed sunset provision ensures that the Legislature can revisit the jury service exemption once the impact of bail reform is better understood, and the Judicial Council can better study the impact of the exemption. This provision would create a new paragraph 3 in subdivision (b) of Section 219 of the Code of Civil Procedure to read:
(3) Notwithstanding subdivision (a) a peace officer, as defined in subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 830.5 of the Penal Code shall not be selected for voir dire in criminal matters. This paragraph shall remain in effect until January 1, 2024, and as of that date is repealed.
Jury service exemptions pose significant logistical hurdles for the courts. California’s courts are constitutionally obligated to ensure that jury pools are reflective of the community at large and categorical jury service exemptions pose significant logistical challenges for the courts. Selecting the proper number of jurors to call for service on a given day is a logistical challenge that requires the court to balance the need for jurors to hear the cases pending with the number of persons available. The fewer prospective jurors available for a jury pool, the greater the risks that a court may be forced to dismiss the last-day criminal trials for failure to obtain enough jurors. This problem is especially acute for smaller county courts.
For example, according to the Los Angeles County Probation Department, two-thirds of their staff of 6,500 are sworn officers who would be rendered exempt from jury service if this measure passes. In a county of 10.6 million, the loss of approximately 4,300 potential jurors may not significantly impact the Los Angeles County Superior Court’s efforts to summon enough jurors to conduct court. However, in smaller counties that maintain probation departments and are home to large correctional facilities, the impacts of this bill may be more significant. Del Norte County, with a population of approximately 30,000, maintains a far smaller probation department when compared to Los Angeles County. However, the number of officers in the county represent a larger percentage of the potential juror pool. In the event this bill is enacted, and also exempts from the jury pool all of the corrections officers at the Pelican Bay State Prison, meaning a large quantity of potential jurors would no longer be eligible for service in Del Norte County. Such reductions in the size of local jury pools may challenge the court’s ability to generate sufficient panels for voir dire and place additional burdens on other county residents, who will be summoned for jury service more frequently to offset the reduction in the jury pool.
The Legislature is frequently called upon to weigh the merits of jury service exemptions without data to justify the diminishing the diversity of the jury pool. Since 2000, there have been at least eight measures introduced in the Legislature seeking to exempt a class of persons from jury service. The majority of these measures have failed, and yet these bills continue to be introduced nearly every other year. Frequently, these measure present rational, yet anecdotal, justifications for exempting a class of individuals or professionals from jury service that on a stand-alone basis would merit such an exemption. Nonetheless, should every group who presents a broad-based need to be exempted from jury service be granted such an exemption, the diverse and representative nature of the jury pool in California would be quickly undermined. This problem is exacerbated when Legislature is asked to weigh these individual measures with little information regarding the total number of persons who would receive an exemption, or how such exemptions would impact the diversity or availability of potential jurors. Accordingly, these bills ask the Legislature to make a judgment call without fully understanding the impact such decisions would have on the justice system.
Reflecting the need for concrete information regarding the impact to the courts created by jury service exemptions, the Legislature would be well served by having more information regarding the issues posed by jury service exemptions and the potential impacts to the fairness of the judicial system. Accordingly, as proposed to be amended, this bill will now include the following provisions authorizing the Judicial Council of California to study the impacts of categorical exemptions from jury service on the justice system:
Section 219.1 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure to read as follows:
(a) On or before January 1, 2023, the Judicial Council shall submit a report to the Legislature on the impact of categorical exemptions to jury service, including the exemptions provided in subdivision (b) of section 219. The report shall include the following:
(1) Impacts to court administration created by exemptions from jury service.
(2) Impacts to the diversity, including cultural and professional backgrounds, of the jury pool created by exemptions from jury service.
(3) Impacts on the overall access to justice created by exemptions from jury service, including delays in trial scheduling and dismissals of last-day criminal trials.
(b) The Judicial Council may utilize representative surveys to generate any data necessary for the report required pursuant to subdivision (a).
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is backed by a coalition of law enforcement organizations, most notably state and local probation organizations. Representative of the coalition the bill’s co-sponsor, the State Coalition of Probation Organizations, argue:
AB 310 seeks to extend [the jury service exemption] to probation peace officers. Given the enhanced role probation peace officers play today in criminal proceedings, and the more dangerous population they work with, extending the exemption to jury duty is a matter of probation peace officer safety.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this measure, the California Judges Association, argue that jury service exemptions harm the criminal justice system and the fairness of the legal process. The California Judges Association contends:
Many courts already struggle with the challenges of having enough jurors available for prospective jury service, and the expansion of further exemptions will further complicate this. This is particularly true in counties with smaller populations.
Existing law and the voir dire process provide adequate opportunity for excuse where allowable. Creating further categorical exemptions harms the diversity of the jury pool and increases the burden on the remaining prospective-juror community.
Prior Related Legislation: AB 2240 (Grayson), 2018, was identical to the introduced version of this measure. That bill passed the Legislature but was ultimately vetoed by Governor Brown on the grounds that jury service is fundamental to a functioning justice system and profession-based exemptions are improper.
AB 1541 (Kiley), Chap. 302, Stats. 2017, permitted counsel for each party to conduct a jury examination that is calculated to discover bias or prejudice with regard to the circumstances of a particular case or the parties before the court.
AB 1708 (Alejo), 2014, was nearly identical to the introduced version of this bill. That bill passed this Committee and was held in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
SB 1133 (Anderson), 2014, would have exempted fish and game wardens who were sworn peace officers from jury service. This measure failed in Senate Judiciary.
AB 1993 (Nakanishi), 2006, would have exempted active nurses who work at least 20 hours per week in directed patient care services from jury service in criminal and civil matters. The bill was held in this Committee.
AB 1978 (Haynes), 2004, would have provided that an eligible person who is a single parent or guardian and has sole custody of a minor child under 6 years of age or is a parent in a 2-parent household who remains at home to care for a minor child under 6 years of age may be excused from jury service. The bill was held in this Committee.
AB 2253 (Mountjoy), 2004, would have permitted the exclusion of a prospective juror who is 75 years of age or older, if that person wishes to be excused. The bill failed passage in this Committee.
AB 270 (Bates), 2003, would have exempted harbor and port police from jury service in criminal and civil matters. The bill failed passage in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
AB 513 (Matthews), Chap.353, Stats. 2003, required the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court establishing jury service procedures that provide Penal Code 830.5 peace officers - correctional officers, parole agents and probation officers - scheduling accommodations when necessary. These procedures are now reflected in Rule 2.1008 of the California Rules of Court.
SB 303 (Torlakson), Chap. 353, Stats. 2001, exempted the San Francisco Bay Area Rapid Transit District police from voir dire in criminal and civil matters.
SB 2066 (Rogers), Chap. 742, Stats. 1994, exempted the California State University campus police from civil jury service.
AB 2577 (Wright), Chap. 324, Stats. 1992, exempted the Officers of the Department of the Highway Patrol from jury service.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Chief Probation Officers of California (co-sponsor)
State Coalition of Probation Organizations (co-sponsor)
California Correctional Peace Officers Association
California Public Defenders Association
Fraternal Order of Police-Lodge 52
Fraternal Order of Police- Northern California Probation- Lodge #19
Fraternal Order of Police- Southern California Probation- Lodge #702
Fresno County Deputy Probation Officer’s Association
Los Angeles County Probation Officers Union, AFSCME Local 685
Madera Probation Peace Officers Association
Sacramento County Probation Association
San Joaquin County Probation Officers Association
Senior Deputy Probation Officer Noah Arnold, San Luis Obispo County
Supervising Probation Officer Christopher Henn, Merced County Probation Department
Ventura County Professional Peace Officers Association
Opposition
California Judges Association
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):