AB 2271: Electricity: research programs: peer review.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-02
Existing law provides the Public Utilities Commission with broad authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. Existing law requires the commission to convene, or continue, until August 26, 2025, an independent peer review panel to conduct an independent review of enhanced seismic studies and surveys of a certain nuclear powerplant.
This bill would require the commission to establish a procedure for an independent peer review of certain research programs proposed by an electrical corporation for approval by the commission. The bill would require the independent peer review of a proposed research program to be conducted upon the commissions receipt of the proposed program. The bill would require the commission to make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon approval of the program.
Existing law provides the Public Utilities Commission with broad authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. Existing law requires the commission to convene, or continue, until August 26, 2025, an independent peer review panel to conduct an independent review of enhanced seismic studies and surveys of a certain nuclear powerplant.
This bill would require the commission to establish a procedure for an independent peer review of certain research programs proposed by an electrical corporation for approval by the commission. The bill would require the independent peer review of a proposed research program to be conducted upon the commissions receipt of the proposed program. The bill would require the commission to make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon approval of the program.
Existing law provides the Public Utilities Commission with broad authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. Existing law requires the commission to convene, or continue, until August 26, 2025, an independent peer review panel to conduct an independent review of enhanced seismic studies and surveys of a certain nuclear powerplant.
This bill would require the commission to establish a procedure for an independent peer review of certain research programs proposed by an electrical corporation for approval by the commission. The bill would require the independent peer review of a proposed research program to be conducted upon the commissions receipt of the proposed program. The bill would require the commission to make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon approval of the program.
Existing law authorizes any state agency to enter into an energy savings contract with a qualified energy service company for the purchase or exchange of thermal or electrical energy or water, or to acquire energy efficiency services, water conservation services, or both, for a term not exceeding 35 years, at those rates and upon those terms that are approved by the agency.
This bill would make nonsubstantive revisions to this authorization.
Existing law authorizes any state agency to enter into an energy savings contract with a qualified energy service company for the purchase or exchange of thermal or electrical energy or water, or to acquire energy efficiency services, water conservation services, or both, for a term not exceeding 35 years, at those rates and upon those terms that are approved by the agency.
This bill would make nonsubstantive revisions to this authorization.
(a)For purposes of this section, research programs means programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the commission and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations. Research programs do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (Chapter 7.1 (commencing with Section 25620) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code) or the Electric Program Investment Charge program developed pursuant to Section 25711.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)The commission shall establish a procedure for the independent peer review of a research program proposed by an electrical corporation, to be followed if the research program will cost fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) one million dollars ($1,000,000) or more. The independent peer review shall be conducted in accordance with the procedure upon the commissions receipt of the proposed research program.
(c)This section does not apply to a research program that is directly reviewed and approved by the commission.
(c)
(d)The commission shall make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon the approval of the research program.
(a)For purposes of this section, research programs means programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the commission and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations. Research programs do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (Chapter 7.1 (commencing with Section 25620) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code) or the Electric Program Investment Charge program developed pursuant to Section 25711.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)The commission shall establish a procedure for the independent peer review of research programs a research program proposed by an electrical corporation. corporation, to be followed if the research program will cost fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) or more. The independent peer review shall be conducted in accordance with the procedure upon the commissions receipt of a the proposed research program.
(c)The commission shall make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon the approval of the research program.
(a)For purposes of this section, research programs means programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the commission and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations. Research programs do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (Chapter 7.1 (commencing with Section 25620) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code) or the Electric Program Investment Charge program developed pursuant to Section 25711.5 of the Public Resources Code.
(b)The commission shall establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation. The independent peer review shall be conducted in accordance with the procedure upon the commissions receipt of a proposed research program.
(c)The commission shall make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon the approval of the research program.
SECTION 1.Section 388 of the Public Utilities Code is amended to read:388.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a state agency may enter into an energy savings contract with a qualified energy service company for the purchase or exchange of thermal or electrical energy or water, or to acquire energy efficiency services, water conservation services, or both, for a term not exceeding 35 years, at those rates and upon those terms that are approved by the agency.
(b)The Department of General Services or any other state or local agency intending to enter into an energy savings contract may establish a pool of qualified energy service companies based on qualifications, experience, pricing, or other pertinent factors. Energy service contracts for individual projects undertaken by any state or local agency may be awarded through a competitive selection process to individuals or firms identified in such a pool. The pool of qualified energy service companies and contractors shall be reestablished at least every two years or shall expire.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Energy savings means a measured and verified reduction in fuel, energy, or water consumption when compared to an established baseline of consumption.
(2)Qualified energy service company means a company with a demonstrated ability to provide or arrange for building or facility energy auditors, selection and design of appropriate energy savings measures, project financing, implementation of these measures, and maintenance and ongoing measurement of these measures as to ensure and verify energy savings.
(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any a state agency may enter into an energy savings contract with a qualified energy service company for the purchase or exchange of thermal or electrical energy or water, or to acquire energy efficiency and/or services, water conservation services, or both, for a term not exceeding 35 years, at those rates and upon those terms that are approved by the agency.
(b)The Department of General Services or any other state or local agency intending to enter into an energy savings contract may establish a pool of qualified energy service companies based on qualifications, experience, pricing pricing, or other pertinent factors. Energy service contracts for individual projects undertaken by any state or local agency may be awarded through a competitive selection process to individuals or firms identified in such a pool. The pool of qualified energy service companies and contractors shall be reestablished at least every two years or shall expire.
(c)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Energy savings means a measured and verified reduction in fuel, energy energy, or water consumption when compared to an established baseline of consumption.
(2)Qualified energy service company means a company with a demonstrated ability to provide or arrange for building or facility energy auditors, selection and design of appropriate energy savings measures, project financing, implementation of these measures, and maintenance and ongoing measurement of these measures as to ensure and verify energy savings.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2016 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 8, 2016 | Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 2, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 1, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (June 27). |
| Jun 20, 2016 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 13, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E., U., & C. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on E., U., & C. |
| Jun 1, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0. Page 5032.) |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 80. Noes 0.) |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (May 27). |
| May 18, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 21, 2016 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (April 20). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on U. & C. |
| Mar 17, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on U. & C. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 17, 2016 | Referred to Com. on U. & C. |
| Feb 19, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 20. |
| Feb 18, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 8, 2016 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2016 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2016 | AB 2271 QUIRK Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2016 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 20, 2016 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Commerce |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular Session
AB 2271 (Quirk) - Electricity: research programs: peer review
Version: June 13, 2016 | Policy Vote: E., U., & C. 6 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 8, 2016 | Consultant: Narisha Bonakdar |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
- AB 2271 requires the CPUC to establish a procedure for the independent peer review of a research program if the program will cost one million dollars or more, and requires that the independent peer review is conducted in accordance with the procedure.
Fiscal Impact:
- Approximately $361,000 (Utilities Reimbursement Account) for staff positions to draft, release, and administer contracts with independent research entities to continually provide reviews of proposed research.
- Approximately $250,000 per year on average, varying year to year, for peer review contracts.
Background:
- CPUC-regulated electrical corporations conduct and administer research. These research programs are often included in CPUC rate cases to recover costs through rates. The CPUC may allow electrical corporations to use ratepayer funds if it determines investments made with those funds will be in the public interest and are just and reasonable. Between 2009 and 2014, the CPUC approved about $400 million in ratepayer funds for research and development. The majority of these funds were approved without review by experts in the field of research being funded, because the CPUC does not have such a process in place. Some funds have been awarded to sole-source projects.
The CPUC does not require peer review of ratepayer-funded research proposals. As evidence of the need for such review, the author relays the story of the CPUC decision, in 2012, to authorize ratepayer funding of research at Lawrence Livermore National Lab (LLNL).
In 2012, the CPUC authorized the investor-owned electric utilities (IOUs – PG&E, SCE, SDG&E) to enter into a five-year research and development agreement with LLNL. The CPUC authorized ratepayer funding of the 21st Century Energy Systems (CES-21) program at costs of $30 million per year to be collected by the IOUs and transferred to LLNL. The Utility Reform Network and the then-named Division of Ratepayer Advocates (DRA) both opposed the decision.
The CPUC identified that LLNL has expertise in supercomputing facilities and analysis, which will be central to conducting the research. In response to an inquiry from DRA, the utilities stated that even though they were aware of other supercomputing facilities within California, they had not contacted or evaluated those facilities to determine if they would be appropriate or cost-effective for the CES-21 program. However, they also stated that such an evaluation would be made for specific proposals to be funded by CES-21 by the CES-21 Board of Directors.
Subsequent to the funding decision, the CPUC developed a set of criteria that each funded project must adhere to, called the Cooperative Research and Development Agreement. While the criteria do not include “peer review” of proposals explicitly, it is required that each proposal has the support of a majority of the Board of Directors. The Board of Directors consists of six members: three from academia or research institutions and three from the utilities.
The author contends the LLNL research funding proposal would have benefitted from peer review and serves as justification for the need to require peer review of research proposals. In addition to the 2012 LLNL proposal, the CPUC approves tens of million in ratepayer-funded research annually.
Proposed Law:
This bill:
Defines “research programs” as a program for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the CPUC and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations.
Specifies that Research programs do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program.
Requires the CPUC to establish a procedure for the independent peer review of a research program proposed by an electrical corporation that will cost one million dollars or more.
Requires the independent peer review to be conducted in accordance with the CPUC’s procedures.
Specifies that eth bill does not apply to research program that is directly reviewed and approved by the CPUC.
Requires the CPUC to make the review available on its website.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 2271 Hearing Date: 6/27/2016
Author: | Quirk | ||
Version: | 6/13/2016 As Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jay Dickenson | ||
SUBJECT: Electricity: research programs: peer review
DIGEST: This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes the CPUC to regulate private corporations that own, operate, control, or manage a line, plant, or system for the transportation or the production, generation, transmission, or furnishing of heat, power, or storage directly or indirectly to or for the public; and to fix rates, establish rules, examine records, issue subpoenas, administer oaths, take testimony, punish for contempt, and prescribe a uniform system of accounts for all public utilities, including electrical and gas corporations, subject to its jurisdiction. (Article 12 of the California Constitution)
- Requires that all charges demanded or received by any public utility for any product, commodity or service be just and reasonable, and that every unjust or unreasonable charge is unlawful. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Authorizes the CPUC to allow recovery of expenses for research and development within rates to be charged by electrical, gas, heat, or telephone corporations and establishes guidelines for evaluating research, development, and demonstration programs proposed by electrical and gas corporations. (Public Utilities Code §§740-740.1)
- Establishes the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (PIER Program) – a research, development, and demonstration program intended to advance science and technology in the fields of energy efficiency, renewable energy, advanced electricity technologies, energy-related environmental protection, transmission and distribution, and transportation technologies. (Public Resources Code §25620 et seq.)
- Establishes the Electric Program Investment Charge (EPIC) program, a utility-funded, California Energy Commission (CEC)-administered program of applied research and development, technology demonstration and deployment, and market facilitation for clean energy technologies and approaches for the benefit of ratepayers. (Public Utilities Code §25711.5)
This bill:
- Requires the CPUC to establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation, to be conducted in accordance with the procedure upon the CPUC’s receipt of a proposed research program.
- Defines a “research programs” as programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the commission and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations.
- Specifies that “research programs” do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the PIER Program or the EPIC program.
Background
Independent peer review. Generally stated, research peer review is an independent, expert third-party assessment of a project. Such a review is meant to identify problems with a proposal that, ideally, can be fixed in subsequent iterations of the proposal.
The competitive process incorporating peer review of proposals is the standard among many granting institutions. Major federal agencies that incorporate peer review for grant funding include the Department of Agriculture, the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, the Environmental Protection Agency, the National Institute of Standards and Technology, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and the National Aeronautics and Space Administration.[1]
Peer review not standard requirement for ratepayer-funded research. The CPUC does not require peer review of ratepayer-funded research proposals. As evidence of the need for such review, the author relays the story of the CPUC decision, in 2012, to authorize ratepayer funding of research at Lawrence Livermore National Lab (LLNL).
In 2012, the CPUC authorized the investor-owned electric utilities (IOUs – PG&E, SCE, SDG&E) to enter into a five-year research and development agreement with LLNL.[2] The CPUC authorized ratepayer funding of the 21st Century Energy Systems (CES-21) program at costs of $30 million per year to be collected by the IOUs and transferred to LLNL. The Utility Reform Network and the then-named Division of Ratepayer Advocates (DRA) both opposed the decision.
The CPUC identified that LLNL has expertise in supercomputing facilities and analysis, which will be central to conducting the research. In response to an inquiry from DRA, the utilities stated that even though they were aware of other supercomputing facilities within California, they had not contacted or evaluated those facilities to determine if they would be appropriate or cost-effective for the CES-21 program. However, they also stated that such an evaluation would be made for specific proposals to be funded by CES-21 by the CES-21 Board of Directors.[3]
Subsequent to the funding decision, the CPUC developed a set of criteria that each funded project must adhere to, called the Cooperative Research and Development Agreement. While the criteria do not include “peer review” of proposals explicitly, it is required that each proposal has the support of a majority of the Board of Directors. The Board of Directors consists of six members: three from academia or research institutions and three from the utilities.
The author contends the LLNL research funding proposal would have benefitted from peer review and serves as justification for the need to require peer review of research proposals. In addition to the 2012 LLNL proposal, the CPUC approves tens of million in ratepayer-funded research annually.
Good for the goose, but not good for PIER or EPIC. The CEC administers two IOU-ratepayer-funded research, design and development programs – PIER and EPIC.
PIER is designed to advance the fields of energy efficiency, renewable energy, advanced electricity technologies, energy-related environmental protection, transmission and distribution, and transportation technologies. The CEC administers PIER, granting funds through an open project solicitation process. The program invested more than $700 million over the past decade.[4] However, the program is now ramping down as it failed to win legislative reauthorization several years ago.
EPIC provides public interest investments in applied research and development, technology demonstration and deployment, market support, and market facilitation, of clean energy technologies and approaches for the benefit of electricity ratepayers of the three major investor-owned utilities (IOUs).[5] EPIC is administered by the CEC and the IOUs. Funds are administered under the oversight and control of the CPUC, with $162 million in annual funding approved from 2013 to 2020. The funds are administered 80 percent by the CEC and 20 percent by the IOUs, with the IOU role limited to technology demonstration and deployment. A public proceeding is conducted every three years to consider investment plans.
Neither PIER nor EPIC uses independent peer review for every proposal. As described by the CEC, it uses state employees with area expertise and, when necessary, outside experts to review research proposals for these programs according to published criteria, using published results. The CEC notes that its reviewers have no financial interest in the research in question. While the author reports not being overly familiar with the details of the review procedures applicable to these two programs, he contends the review processes to be adequate and therefore exempts them from the requirements of this bill.
But what is a “research program?” Helpfully, this bill provides a definition of research program:
Programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the commission and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations.
Clear enough, it would seem. However, many parties – the Energy Efficiency Council (EEIC), IOUs, and the CPUC – contend the meaning, despite the definition is not clear, or at least open to varying interpretations. The EEIC and PG&E fear this bill could be applied very widely – and the CPUC notes their interpretations do not seem unreasonable – and delay research and innovation.
One partial remedy is to increase the dollar threshold provided in this bill. Currently, this bill’s requirements apply to any research program proposed by an IOU if the program will cost $50,000 or more. Few research proposals fall below that dollar amount. If the threshold were to be raised significantly – the author has suggested a threshold of $1 million – then only financially substantial research programs, whatever that term entails, would be subject to the requirements of this bill.
Another way to limit the scope of this bill is to apply it only to those research programs not subject to CPUC staff review. The EEIC notes that certain projects are reviewed and filed with the staff of the CPUC’s Energy Division.
Given the ambiguity around the term “research program,” the author may wish to amend this bill to limit its applicability to research programs that 1) will cost more than $1 million and 2) are not subject to direct, published review and approval by the staff of the CPUC.
In any case, this bill provides authority to the CPUC to develop the peer review procedures. The CPUC, in implementing this bill, will have discretion to establish parameters and definitions, including parameters and definitions regarding what is meant by “research program,” that make the procedures practicable.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 48 (Hill, 2014) would have required the CPUC to conduct an independent expert review, as specified, to inform findings supporting any inclusion of research and development expenses in electricity rates by CPUC-regulated utilities. The bill passed the Senate 35-0 but failed in the Assembly Committee on Utilities and Commerce.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT:
None received
OPPOSITION:
California Energy Efficiency Industry Council
Pacific Gas and Electric Company, unless amended
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
In the case of the LLNL funding proposal, an independent third-party review of the application may have revealed issues with the proposed research, increased the quality of research performed, and provided additional credibility to the research and funding process. Further transparency would have been added to the process if the results of the review were published to an Internet Web site upon the approval of the program.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The EEIC and PG&E similarly argue that this bill’s applicability is difficult to determine and may lead to unnecessary, bureaucratic and time-consuming review of projects, thereby discouraging and delaying important innovations and insights.
-- END --
US General Accounting Office, “Federal Research: Peer Review Practices at Federal Science Agencies Vary.” GAO/RCED-99-99. March, 1999. ↑
CPUC D12-12-031, December 20, 2012 ↑
LawrenceLivermoreNationalLaboratoryPartnership_DR_DRA_004-Q29 ↑
http://www.energy.ca.gov/2014publications/CEC-500-2014-035/CEC-500-2014-035-CMF.pdf ↑
http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/FINAL_DECISION/167664.pdf ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2271
Author:(Quirk)
As Amended Ver:March 17, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Utilities | 14-0 | Gatto, Patterson, Burke, Chávez, Dahle, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Hadley, Roger Hernández, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Williams | |
Appropriations | 20-0 | Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Calderon, Chang, Daly, Eggman, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Roger Hernández, Holden, Jones, Obernolte, Quirk, Santiago, Wagner, Weber, Wood |
|
SUMMARY: Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to establish a procedure for the independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the CPUC to establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation to be conducted upon the CPUC's receipt of a proposed research program.
- Requires the CPUC to make the results of the review, upon approval of the research program, available to the public on its website.
- Specifies research programs do not include programs funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program or the Electric Program Investment Charge program.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- The CPUC will require additional permanent staff, at the cost of about $390,000 per year, to identify proposals, administer contracts with independent research entities, and ensure researchers do not have conflicts of interest. Additionally, the CPUC estimates expert review contract costs to be $250,000 per year for five years.
- California Energy Commission and the Air Resources Board costs are minor and absorbable.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose: According to the author, it is essential to have the proper evaluation of the scientific and technical merits of the research the CPUC approves. This bill will require an independent peer review to be conducted once the CPUC receives a proposed program. This bill will also require the results of the review to be posted on the CPUC's Web site.
Research proposals likely subject to this requirement are those conducted pursuant to many proceedings, including those addressing electric vehicles, demand response, distribution resource planning, and long term procurement planning.
- Background: CPUC-regulated electrical corporations conduct and administer research. These research programs are often included in CPUC rate cases to recover costs through rates. The CPUC may allow electrical corporations to use ratepayer funds if it determines investments made with those funds will be in the public interest and are just and reasonable. Between 2009 and 2014, the CPUC approved about $400 million in ratepayer funds for research and development. The majority of these funds were approved without review by experts in the field of research being funded, because the CPUC does not have such a process in place. Some funds have been awarded to sole-source projects.
By requiring an independent third-party review, this bill will increase the quality of research performed, and provide additional credibility to the research and funding process. Further transparency will be added by publishing the results of the review.
Analysis Prepared by: Darion Johnston / U. & C. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0003221
Date of Hearing: May 18, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2271
Author:(Quirk) – As Amended Ver:March 17, 2016
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Commerce | Vote: | 14 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to establish a procedure for the independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the PUC to establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation to be conducted upon the PUC's receipt of a proposed research program.
- Requires the PUC to make the results of the review, upon approval of the research program, available to the public on its website.
- Specifies research programs do not include programs funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (PIER) or the Electric Program Investment Charge program (EPIC).
FISCAL EFFECT:
The PUC will require additional permanent staff, at the cost of about $390,000 per year, to identify proposals, administer contracts with independent research entities, and ensure researchers do not have conflicts of interest. Additionally, the PUC estimates expert review contract costs to be $250,000 per year for five years.
CEC and ARB costs are minor and absorbable.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, it is essential to have the proper evaluation of the scientific and technical merits of the research the PUC approves. This bill will require an independent peer review to be conducted once the PUC receives a proposed program. This bill will also require the results of the review to be posted on the PUC 's website.
Research proposals likely subject to this requirement are those conducted pursuant to many proceedings, including those addressing electric vehicles, demand response, distribution resource planning, and long term procurement planning.
- Background. PUC-regulated electrical corporations conduct and administer research. These research programs are often included in PUC rate cases to recover costs through rates. The PUC may allow electrical corporations to use ratepayer funds if it determines investments made with those funds will be in the public interest and are just and reasonable. Between 2009 and 2014, the PUC approved about $400 million in ratepayer funds for research and development. The majority of these funds were approved without review by experts in the field of research being funded, because the PUC does not have such a process in place. Some funds have been awarded to sole-source projects.
By requiring an independent third-party review, this bill will increase the quality of research performed, and provide additional credibility to the research and funding process. Further transparency will be added by publishing the results of the review.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 20, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND COMMERCE
Mike Gatto, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2271 (
Author:Quirk) – As Amended Ver:March 17, 2016
SUBJECT: Electricity: research programs: peer review
SUMMARY: Requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to conduct an independent peer review, as specified, of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the CPUC to establish a procedure for independent peer review of research programs proposed by an electrical corporation upon the CPUC's receipt of a proposed research program.
- Requires the CPUC to make available to the public on its Internet Web site the results of the review upon the approval of the research program.
- Defines research programs to mean programs for the development of novel and innovative processes that are proposed by electrical corporations for approval by the CPUC and that would be funded through the rates of ratepayers of the electrical corporations. Research programs do not include programs that are funded pursuant to the Public Interest Energy Research, Demonstration, and Development Program (Chapter 7.1 (commencing with Section 25620) of Division 15 of the Public Resources Code) or the Electric Program Investment Charge program developed pursuant to Public Resources Code Section 25711.5.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes that public utilities are subject to control by the Legislature. (California Constitution, Article XII, Section 3)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix rates, establish rules, examine records, issue subpoenas, administer oaths, take testimony, punish for contempt, and prescribe a uniform system of accounts for all public utilities subject to its jurisdiction. (California Constitution, Article XII, Section 6)
- Authorizes the CPUC to adopt rules for public utilities regarding a showing of information to be made in support of proposed rate changes and allowing opportunities to protest those rate changes. (Public Utilities Code Section 454)
- Authorizes the CPUC to allow an electrical corporation, gas corporation, heat corporation, or telephone corporation to include expenses for research and development in rates. (Public Utilities Code Section 740)
- Requires the CPUC to consider specified guidelines in evaluating the research, development, and demonstration programs proposed by electrical and gas corporations. (Public Utilities Code Section 740.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: "There is a need for more visibility in the interactions between Commissioners and regulated utilities. AB 2271 creates a transparent process for projects that have been approved by the CPUC without any checks and balances. It is essential to have a proper evaluation of the scientific and technical merits of the research that the CPUC approves. AB 2271 would require an independent peer review to be conducted once the [CPUC] receives a proposed program. This bill will also require the results of the review to be posted to the CPUC website. The public has a right to know what it's paying for."
- Independent Peer Review: The goal of independent peer is to obtain an independent, third-party review of a scientific/technical work product from experts who have not substantially contributed to its development.[1] This review is intended to uncover problems or unresolved issues in a preliminary (or draft) work product, and facilitates revision of the draft product into a final product that reflects sound technical information and analyses. This review typically enhances a scientific/technical work product so the decision or position taken on the work product has a sound, credible basis. The National Research Council states:
When peer [independent] review results are used to improve the quality of a decision process (e.g. selection of proposals, prioritization of projects for funding), it also enhances the credibility of the decisions. Use of peer [independent] review therefore provides observers some confidence that decisions are made with the best available scientific and technical information.[2]
An independent peer review process is used by many granting institutions, including but not limited to federal agencies such as the Department of Agriculture, National Science Foundation, National Institutes of Health, Environmental Protection Agency, National Institute of Standards and Technology, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, and National Aeronautics and Space Administration.[3] As an example, the United States Department of Energy awarded an Energy Hub grant of $120 million over five years to Argonne National Laboratory for energy storage research, and did so "through an open national competition with a rigorous merit review process that relied on outside expert reviewers." The California Energy Commission (CEC) conducts a peer review of applications for Public Interest Energy Research (PIER) funding, and the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine requires peer review of all grant applications.
Although peer input, public comment, and stakeholder input add value to the work product, they do not substitute for independent expert review.[4] Peer input refers to the contributions made by an open exchange of data, insights, and ideas during development of a work product. However, when one has a material stake in the project or participated substantially in the development (such as a workgroup member), reviews by those individuals may not qualify as unbiased, independent review. One cannot argue that an independent expert review is not necessary if a major work product has received "enough" peer input. Public comment similarly does not always result in the in-depth analyses expected of an independent review process. Finally, stakeholder involvement also does not substitute for independent expert review, as it typically involves external interest groups with a stake in the work product outcome or regulatory position.
- CPUC and CEC energy-related research programs and funds: To meet the state's energy needs, the CPUC and CEC have proposed a focus on research, development, and demonstrations related to bioenergy, energy efficiency, renewable energy, transportation fuels and vehicles, and carbon capture and storage.[5] However, independent review is not always utilized. The following are examples of energy-related research programs involving the CPUC and/or CEC:
- PIER program: PIER is a research, development, and demonstration program intended to advance the fields of energy efficiency, renewable energy, advanced electricity technologies, energy-related environmental protection, transmission and distribution, and transportation technologies. The CEC administers PIER, granting funds through an open project solicitation process. The program invested more than $700 million over the past decade.[6] As of June 2013, PIER is not funding new projects (funding has been depleted), but the CEC managed projects through 2015.
- The Electric Program Investment Charge (EPIC): Established in 2012 by the CPUC, EPIC provides public interest investments in applied research and development, technology demonstration and deployment, market support, and market facilitation, of clean energy technologies and approaches for the benefit of electricity ratepayers of the three major investor-owned utilities (IOUs) Pacific Gas and Electric, San Diego Gas and Electric, and Southern California Edison.[7] EPIC is administered by the CEC and the IOUs. Funds are administered under the oversight and control of the CPUC, with $162 million in annual funding approved from 2013 to 2020. The funds are administered 80% by the CEC and 20% by the IOUs, with the IOU role limited to technology demonstration and deployment. A public proceeding is conducted every three years to consider investment plans.
Independent of these programs, CPUC-regulated IOUs conduct and administer research. These research programs are often included in CPUC rate cases to recover costs through rates. The CPUC may allow IOUs to use ratepayer funds if it determines investments made with those funds will be in the public interest and are just and reasonable. Between 2009 and 2014, the CPUC approved about $400 million in ratepayer funds for research and development. The majority of these funds were approved without review by experts in the field of research being funded, because the CPUC does not have such a process in place. Some funds have been awarded to sole-source projects.
- Lawrence Livermore National Lab (LLNL) Funding Issue: One example of funded research that may have benefited from independent review involves the CPUC, the IOUs, and LLNL. In 2012, the CPUC authorized the electric IOUs to enter into a five-year energy research and development agreement with LLNL. The CPUC authorized ratepayer funding of $30 million per year from the 21st Century Energy Systems (CES-21) program, collected by the IOUs and transferred to LLNL.
The Utility Reform Network (TURN) and the CPUC Office of Ratepayer Advocates (ORA) both opposed the decision. TURN objected to the grant being made without competitive solicitation, as the CPUC identified LLNL as having expertise in supercomputing facilities and analysis, which were central to the research, without examining other options. In response to ORA, the IOUs also stated that even though they were aware of other supercomputing facilities within California, they had not contacted or evaluated those facilities to determine if they would be appropriate or cost-effective.
In this case, an independent third-party review of the application may have revealed issues with the proposed research, increased the quality of research performed, and provided additional credibility to the research and funding process. Further transparency would have been added to the process if the results of the review were published to an Internet Web site upon the approval of the program.
- Potential policy gaps: Currently, this bill does not address two potential policy gaps:
- Funding Cap: According to current bill language, every project funded by ratepayers, as specified, will be subject to independent review, as the bill currently does not contain a cost cap in regards to the review. For example, would the Legislature consider independent review of a $1000 ratepayer funded project to be efficient and cost-effective?
- Timeline: Independent review is most useful when conducted in a timely manner. However, a timeline or parameters for review has not been established in the bill.
- Prior Legislation:
SB 48 (Hill) of the 2013-14 Regular Session: Required the CPUC to conduct an independent expert review, as specified, to inform findings supporting any inclusion of research and development expenses in electricity rates by CPUC-regulated utilities. Died in the Assembly Utilities and Commerce Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Darion Johnston / U. & C. / (916) 319-2083
NRC, Peer Review in the Department of Energy-Office of Science and Technology, 1997. ↑
http://www.energy.ca.gov/2008publications/CEC-100-2008-001/CEC-100-2008-001.PDF ↑
http://www.energy.ca.gov/2014publications/CEC-500-2014-035/CEC-500-2014-035-CMF.pdf ↑
http://docs.cpuc.ca.gov/word_pdf/FINAL_DECISION/167664.pdf ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Commerce
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):