AB 376: Student loan servicing.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-25
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 25, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 154, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 25, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 8, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 57. Noes 15. Page 5351.). |
| Aug 28, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 28, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 29. Noes 9. Page 4404.). |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 20). |
| Aug 6, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 19). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F.I. and JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 28, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 8. |
| Feb 5, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | AB 376 Mark Stone Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB376 Mark Stone et al. By Mitchell | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2019 | AB 376 Mark Stone Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 376
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:August 20, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits specified acts and establishes specified requirements related to the servicing of student loans in a manner intended to protect student loan borrowers.
The Senate Amendments:
- Exempt federally chartered credit unions from this bill.
- Move substantive servicer requirements and prohibited acts from the Student Loan Servicing Act (SLSA) in the Financial Code to a new title in the Civil Code.
- Exempt guaranty agencies from the servicing requirements and enforcement provisions of the bill (but not from the requirement to respond to requests for information from the Student Loan Ombudsman and Department of Business Oversight (DBO)).
- Make technical and clarifying changes.
COMMENTS:
Student debt – how much is owed and how it is repaid – has a profound effect on the state economy and the financial well-being of California families. After mortgages, student debt is the second largest category of consumer debt with over $1.5 trillion outstanding nationwide as of December 31, 2019, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York. In California alone, more than 4 million borrowers owe $147 billion. This debt places a substantial burden on the monthly budgets of California borrowers, crowding out investments that families would otherwise make in housing, small business development, and other household spending.
California has an interest in alleviating the debt service burden of student loans, the reduction of which would benefit individual borrowers and local economies. The vast majority of student loan debt is owed to the federal government, meaning repayment, or the lack thereof, of interest and principal does not cycle through the private credit markets. Instead, these payments offset accounting entries in a ledger of the federal government, which is running aggregate annual deficits that exceed $2 trillion. While California cannot cancel or forgive outstanding student loans, the state can regulate the behavior of student loan servicers in a manner that helps borrowers reduce their student loan payments over time. Keeping more income in these consumers' pockets will boost their spending on goods and services, which will create jobs and benefit the state economy.
Proponents of regulating student loan servicers identify misaligned incentives that may cause servicers to behave in a manner contrary to the interests of borrowers. Servicers are often paid a fee based on the number of borrowers in their portfolio, which provides an incentive to keep borrowers indebted over time. Servicers may also face incentives to steer borrowers into forbearance, rather than income-driven repayment plans or other lower-cost options, because it takes fewer servicing resources to enroll a borrower in forbearance.
Without regulation by states, servicers face few incentives to comply with federal regulations. An inspector general report issued last year found that the federal entity responsible for overseeing servicers "had not established policies and procedures that provided reasonable assurance that the risk of servicer noncompliance with requirements for servicing federally held student loans was mitigated."[1] The report also warned that the lack of federal oversight "did not provide servicers with an incentive to take actions to mitigate the risk of continued servicer noncompliance that could harm students."
This bill proposes a robust set of standards with which student loan servicers must comply when dealing with California borrowers. The bill prohibits servicers from engaging in activities that mislead borrowers, engaging in unfair or deceptive practices toward borrowers, and failing to accurately apply payments or accurately report payment performance to credit reporting agencies. The bill also requires servicers to meet minimum standards related to processing payments in a timely manner, maintaining accurate records, and processing questions or complaints from borrowers. The borrower protections in this bill can be enforced through a private right of action, ensuring that borrowers have pathways to appropriate remedies regardless of whether their servicer is licensed under existing state law or whether the state Attorney General has sufficient resources to bring an action.
According to the Author:
AB 376 establishes the Student Borrower Bill of Rights, ensuring that individuals with student loan debt are given reliable information, quality customer service, and meaningful access to repayment and forgiveness programs. This groundbreaking legislation will make California the first in the nation to offer student loan borrowers the same comprehensive protections that consumers with mortgages and credit cards take for granted.
After a student loan is taken out, loan servicing companies are the ones that communicate with borrowers about payments, account information, refinancing options, and other issues surrounding their loans. Despite a mountain of evidence that demonstrates rampant predatory actors, it is very clear that the federal government has deliberately stepped back from its duties to protect student borrowers and, in order to protect its consumers California must take action.
With 3,780,000 student loan borrowers across California owing $134.3 billion, it is imperative that California take a strong stance to protect borrowers against bad actors. AB 376 will ensure that California borrowers are protected and can take action if servicers violate these basic protections.
Arguments in Support:
An extensive coalition of consumer advocacy and legal aid organizations, student associations, and organized labor writes in support of the bill:
This bill would make California the first state in the nation to create a comprehensive set of rights for people holding student debt, by requiring student loan companies to treat borrowers fairly and giving borrowers the right to hold these companies accountable when they fail to meet basic servicing standards...Unlike mortgages or credit cards, there is not industry-wide framework at the federal level to regulate the student loan industry...AB 376 would create enforceable industry-wide standards for loan servicing companies. The bill would: ban "abusive" student loan servicing practices that take unreasonable advantage of borrowers' confusion over loan repayment options; create minimum servicing standards related to application of payments, paperwork retention and specialized staff training; establish a Student Borrower Advocate within the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) responsible for reviewing complaints, gathering data and coordinating with related state agencies; and grant DBO additional "market monitoring" authorities, to better collect data about the student loan servicing industry.
Arguments in Opposition:
Opposition raises several concerns with the bill. Many opponents dislike the consumer enforcement mechanism and want it removed from the bill or at least changed to mirror existing class action requirements under California law. Opponents believe that certain provisions of the bill are preempted under the National Bank Act or Higher Education Act.
The Student Loan Servicing Alliance is a trade association whose members service about 95% of all outstanding federal and private student loans. They appreciate amendments made by the author to this bill's right to cure but continue to oppose the bill on several grounds.
Servicers strongly support oversight by appropriate regulators that assesses our compliance with existing law and helps us improve. However, this legislation would encourage costly litigation on regulations even when a regulator has found no factual basis for action against student loan servicers. While the right to cure amendment helps reduce the potential costs meaningfully, servicers will still have to face the expense of defending against the inevitable incorrect allegations, that while perhaps well-intentioned, will be rooted in a lack of understanding of student loan servicing or the complicated regulations which are applicable.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in unknown, but likely significant ongoing costs to DBO (Financial Institutions Fund) and estimated costs of up to $1 million to the Department of Justice's Consumer Protection Section for an increase in workload due to additional referrals from the Student Loan Ombudsman to investigate complaints and assist the Ombudsman in complying with specified reporting requirements (General Fund).
VOTES:
ASM BANKING AND FINANCE: 9-0-3
YES: Limón, Bauer-Kahan, Burke, Cervantes, Gabriel, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Choi, Melendez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-15-6
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones‑Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Fong, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Patterson, Ting
SENATE FLOOR: 29-9-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Grove, Melendez, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chang, Jones
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 20, 2020
CONSULTANT: Michael Burdick / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081 FN: 0003493
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 376 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 376
Author: Mark Stone (D), et al.
Amended: 8/20/20 in Senate
SENATE BANKING & F.I. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/19/19
AYES: Bradford, Durazo, Hueso, Portantino
NOES: Dahle
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chang, Caballero
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-15, 5/28/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Student loan servicing
SOURCE: California Federation of Teachers
Consumer Reports
NexGen California
Student Borrower Protection Center
Student Debt Crisis
Young Invincibles
DIGEST:
This bill imposes new requirements on student loan servicers doing business in this state and places responsibility with the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) for administering these requirements; provides judicial enforcement mechanisms for violations of the aforementioned requirements by student loan servicers; requires DBO to collect information about and report on the activities of student loan servicers in this state; and requires DBO to designate a Student Loan Ombudsman, as specified.
Existing law:
- Provides for the Student Loan Servicing Act (SLSA; Division 12.5 of the Financial Code, Financial Code Section 28100 et seq.), administered by the DBO. The SLSA prohibits any person from engaging in student loan servicing in this state, as defined, without first obtaining a license pursuant to Division 12.5, but does not apply to any of the following (Financial Code Section 28102):
- State- or federally-chartered depository institutions or industrial loan companies.
- A public postsecondary educational institution (e.g., University of California) or a private nonprofit postsecondary educational institution (e.g., Stanford University) servicing a student loan it extended to a borrower.
- A nonprofit community service organization, as specified (generally speaking, nonprofits that engage in credit counseling, debt settlement, or debt management activities on behalf of consumers at no or very low cost; see Financial Code Section 12104).
- A state or nonprofit private institution or organization that has an agreement with the United States Secretary of Education, as specified, in connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion.
- A debt collector, as defined, whose student loan debt collection business involves collecting or attempting to collect on defaulted student loans, as defined.
- Imposes a series of requirements on licensed student loan servicers and prohibited acts in which student loan servicers may not engage, as specified.
This bill:
- Contains findings and declarations regarding the challenges of student loan debtors, the predatory practices of some student loan servicers, failure of the federal government to take necessary action to halt widespread abuses, and the resulting need for California to take steps to do all of the following: promote meaningful access to affordable repayment and loan forgiveness benefits; ensure that California borrowers can rely on information provided to them by their student loan servicers; and build on California’s SLSA to protect California borrowers from predatory student loan industry practices.
- Moves several definitions and virtually all substantive provisions contained in the SLSA out of the Financial Code and into the Civil Code.
- Defines the term “student loan servicer” in a broader manner than this term is defined in the SLSA. For purposes of this bill, “student loan servicer” means any person engaged in the business of servicing student loans in this state, but while the SLSA contains exemptions for debt collectors, guaranty agencies, depository institutions, certain postsecondary educational institutions, and certain nonprofit community service organizations, as defined, this bill exempts only federally-chartered credit unions, debt collectors, and guaranty agencies from its requirements.
- Defines term “qualified request” as any inbound telephone call made by a borrower to a student loan servicer, in which the borrower either requests specific information from the student loan servicer or reports what the borrower believes to be an error regarding the borrower’s account, and which cannot be resolved in a single phone call. Also adds definitions for the terms “military borrower,” “borrower working in public service,” “older borrower,” and “borrower with disabilities.”
- Prohibits any person from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan in this state, as specified.
- Prohibits a student loan servicer from employing a scheme, device, or artifice to defraud of mislead a borrower; engage in an unfair or deceptive practice toward a borrower, as specified; misrepresent or omit material information in connection with the servicing of a student loan; misapply payments made by a borrower to the outstanding balance of a student loan; fail to accurately report each borrower’s payment performance to at least one consumer reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis, as specified; refuse to communicate with an authorized representative of the borrower who provides a written authorization signed by the borrower, as specified; or negligently or intentionally make a false statement or knowingly and willfully make an omission of a material fact in connection with information or reports filed with DBO or another government agency.
- Requires a person engaged in student loan servicing in this state to do all of the following, except to the extent that a requirement is inconsistent with any provision of federal law or regulation, and then only to the extent of the inconsistency:
- Post and process student loan payments in a timely manner, as specified.
- Inquire of a borrower how to apply an overpayment to a student loan. Follow the borrower’s wishes regarding overpayments, if the borrower provides direction, or apply any overpayment in a manner that is in the best financial interest of the borrowers, as defined, if the borrower does not provide direction.
- Apply a partial payment, as defined, in a manner that minimizes late fees and negative credit reporting, unless a borrower provides alternate instructions, as specified.
- Ensure that any late fee imposed on a borrower for a past due student loan payment is reasonable and proportional to the total costs incurred as a result of the late payment, and in no case exceeds 6% of the amount past due.
- Diligently oversee its service providers, as specified.
- Timely process its paperwork, consistent with existing federal requirements, as specified.
- Maintain records about a borrower’s account and retain these records while the servicer services the loan and for a minimum of three years after the loan has been paid in full, assigned to collection, or transferred to a different servicer.
- Treat a qualified request in the same manner as a qualified written request.
- Maintain policies and procedures permitting a borrower who is dissatisfied with the outcome of an initial qualified request to escalate the borrower’s concern to a supervisor.
- Protect borrowers from any negative consequences, as defined, which are directly related to an issue identified in a borrower’s qualified request or qualified written request, until that request has been resolved. Notwithstanding this requirement, servicers are prohibited from furnishing information to a consumer reporting agency for 60 days regarding a payment that is subject to a qualified request or qualified written request.
- Protect borrowers from any negative consequences, as defined, stemming from a sale, assignment, transfer of a student loan, system conversion, or any payment made by a borrower to an original student loan servicer consistent with the original student loan servicer’s policy.
- Notify a borrower in writing at least 15 days before the borrower is required to send payments to a new student loan servicer, if the sale, assignment, or other transfer of the borrower’s student loan results in a change in the identity of the party to whom the borrower is required to send payments or direct communications regarding their student loan.
- Ensure that all necessary information, as defined, regarding a borrower, a borrower’s account, and a borrower’s student loan accompanies a loan when it transfers to a new student loan servicer within 45 calendar days of the effective date of the sale, assignment, or transfer of the student loan, as specified.
- Provide specialized training for any customer service personnel that advise military borrowers, borrowers working in public service, older borrowers, or borrowers with disabilities about student loan repayment benefits and protections, as specified.
- Respond within 10 business days to communications from the Student Loan Ombudsman, or within a shorter, reasonable time as the Student Loan Ombudsman may request in their communication.
- Respond to a qualified written request by acknowledging receipt of the request within 10 business days, and provide additional information, as specified and if applicable, within 30 business days, regarding action the servicer will take related to the request.
- Requires student loan servicers to comply with the requirements of this bill and with all applicable federal laws relating to student loan servicing, as they are amended from time to time, and the regulations promulgated pursuant to those federal laws, and requires DBO to administer this bill.
- Imposes joint and several liability on student loan servicers for the conduct of their third party service providers.
- Provides that any consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a person engaged in student loan servicing to comply with this bill, applicable federal law, or applicable federal regulations, may bring an action on their own behalf and on behalf a similarly situated class of consumers to recover or obtain any of the following: actual damages of at least $500 per plaintiff, per violation; an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices; restitution of property; punitive damages; attorney’s fees; any other relief the court deems proper.
- Provides that, in addition to any other remedies described above or provided elsewhere in law, whenever it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a student loan servicer has engaged in conduct that substantially interferes with a borrower’s right to an alternative payment arrangement; loan forgiveness, cancellation, or discharge; or any other financial benefit, as specified, the court must award treble actual damages to the plaintiff. Provides that in no case may a total damage award be less than $1,500 per plaintiff, per violation.
- Provides servicers with a right to cure alleged violations before an action for damages may be brought against them. The right to cure applicable to actions for damages is as follows:
- At least 45 days before a consumer may bring an action for damages or injunctive relief, the consumer must provide written notice, as specified, to the person alleged to have engaged in the violations regarding the nature of the alleged violations and demand that the person correct and remedy the method, acts, or practices that are the subject of the notice.
- An action for damages brought by a consumer on his or her own behalf may not be maintained, if the person who is issued the demand provides the consumer with an appropriate correction and remedy within 30 days after receiving written notice of the violation or agrees, within 30 days after receiving written notice of the violation, to provide the consumer with an appropriate correction and remedy within a reasonable time.
- An action for damages brought by a consumer on the consumer’s behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers may not be maintained, if the person who is issued the demand shows that all of the following are true:
- All similarly situated consumers have been identified, or a reasonable effort to identify those consumers has been made.
- All identified consumers have been notified that, upon their request, the person alleged to have engaged in the violation(s) will make the appropriate correction and remedy.
- The correction and remedy requested by the consumers has been or will be given in a reasonable time.
- The person who is issued the demand has ceased engaging in or will cease engaging in the violation(s) within a reasonable time.
- Provides that, notwithstanding the remedies in 10) and 11) above and the right to cure described in 12) above, an award of damages may not be given in connection with a violation of this bill, applicable federal law, or applicable federal regulations, if the person alleged to have engaged in the violations does both of the following:
- Proves by a preponderance of the evidence that the violation was not intentional and resulted from a bona fide error, despite the use of reasonable procedures adopted to avoid that error.
- Makes an appropriate correction, repair, replacement, or other remedy, as specified.
- Authorizes, effective July 1, 2021, and subject to enactment of a Budget Act appropriation, the Commissioner of DBO (commissioner) to monitor for risks to consumers in the provision of student loan servicing in this state, by compiling and analyzing data, as specified. Includes guaranty agencies within the definition of the term “student loan servicer” for purposes of this provision.
- Requires, effective July 1, 2021, and subject to enactment of a Budget Act appropriation, the commissioner to designate a Student Loan Ombudsman within the department, with specified duties related to tracking, compiling, and analyzing student loan complaints; monitoring the development and implementation of federal and state laws and rules relating to student loan borrowers; and disseminating information about the ability of specified state and federal departments and agencies to accept complaints from student loan borrowers. Requires the Student Loan Ombudsman to submit an annual report to the Legislature, beginning January 1, 2023, regarding its activities. Includes guaranty agencies within the definition of the term “student loan servicer” for purposes of this provision.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in unknown, but likely significant ongoing costs to DBO (Financial Institutions Fund) and estimated costs of up to $1 million to the Department of Justice’s Consumer Protection Section for an increase in workload due to additional referrals from the Student Loan Ombudsman to investigate complaints and assist the Ombudsman in complying with specified reporting requirements (General Fund).
California Federation of Teachers (co-source)
Consumer Reports (co-source)
NexGen California (co-source)
Student Borrower Protection Center (co-source)
Student Debt Crisis (co-source)
Young Invincibles (co-source)
Attorney General Xavier Becerra
Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara
Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Secretary of State Alex Padilla
AARP
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Americans for Financial Reform
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
Association of Young Americans
Beneficial State Foundation
Building the California Dream Alliance
California Asset Building Coalition
California Association of Nonprofits
California Association of Realtors
California Community Colleges Chancellor’s Office
California Council of Community Behavior Health Agencies
California Dental Association
California Dream Network
California Economic Justice
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
California LULAC
California Optometric Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Reinvestment Coalition
California Student Aid Commission
California Women’s Law Center
Californians for Economic Justice
CalPIRG
Centro Legal de la Raza
City and County of San Francisco
City of Stockton
Clean Water Action
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights
Common Sense Kids Action
Community Water Center
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
County Welfare Directors Association of California
Courage Campaign
East Bay Community Law Center
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Generation Progress
Housing & Economic Rights Advocates
Improve Your Tomorrow
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
Mi Familia Vota
Mission Asset Fund
National Student Loan Defense Network
New Economics for Women
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
San Diego State College Democrats
San Francisco Treasurer & Tax Collector Jose Cisneros
Service Employees International Union
Stockton Mayor Michael Tubbs
Student Senate for California Community Colleges
The Institute for College Access & Success
UnidosUS
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
University of California Student Association
Veterans Education Success
Western Center in Law and Poverty
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Bankers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Bankers Association
Student Loan Servicing Alliance
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Student Borrower Protection Center, one of this bill’s sponsors, is a nonprofit organization founded by former senior regulators at the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. “Our team led the first government-wide effort at the federal level to halt abuses by the student loan industry and create new consumer protections to ensure 44 million Americans with student debt were no longer preyed upon by an industry looking to get rich off of our nation’s student debt crisis. However, the Trump Administration and Betsy DeVos have rolled back much of this progress, siding with the largest student loan companies over the rights of student borrowers....AB 376 picks up where past federal efforts to reform the student loan system have fallen short.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Consumer Bankers Association and California Bankers Association believe that the exemption for state- and federally-chartered banks and credit unions that is contained in the SLSA should be added to the Civil Code provisions of AB 376 and that the requirements of AB 376 should be applied only to those entities required to be licensed under the SLSA.
The Student Loan Servicing Alliance is a trade association whose members service about 95% of all outstanding federal and private student loans. They appreciate amendments made by the author to this bill’s right to cure but continue to oppose the bill on several grounds. “Servicers strongly support oversight by appropriate regulators that assesses our compliance with existing law and helps us improve. However, this legislation would encourage costly litigation on regulations even when a regulator has found no factual basis for action against student loan servicers. While the right to cure amendment helps reduce the potential costs meaningfully, servicers will still have to face the expense of defending against the inevitable incorrect allegations, that while perhaps well-intentioned, will be rooted in a lack of understanding of student loan servicing or the complicated regulations which are applicable.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 59-15, 5/28/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Fong, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Patterson, Ting
Prepared by: Eileen Newhall / B. & F.I. /
8/25/20 8:55:06
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 376 (Mark Stone) - Student loan servicing
Version: August 6, 2020 | Policy Vote: B. & F.I. 4 - 1, JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 20, 2020 | Consultant: Janelle Miyashiro |
Bill Summary:
AB 376 would create the “Student Borrower Bill of Rights” and impose new requirements on student loan servicers.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 20, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, but likely significant ongoing costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) (Financial Institutions Fund).
- Estimated costs of up to $1 million to the Department of Justice’s Consumer Protection Section for an increase in workload due to additional referrals from the Student Loan Ombudsman to investigate complaints and assist the Ombudsman in complying with specified reporting requirements (General Fund).
Author Amendments:
- Provide an exemption for federally chartered credit unions.
- Add coauthors.
- Make other technical and clarifying changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 376 (Mark Stone) - Student loan servicing
Version: June 20, 2019 | Policy Vote: B. & F.I. 4 - 1, JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Debra Cooper |
Bill Summary:
AB 376 would create the “Student Borrower Bill of Rights” and impose new requirements on student loan servicers.
Fiscal Impact:
- Significant, ongoing costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) of $1.6 million in the first year and $1.2 million annually thereafter for the new position of Student Borrower Advocate, support staff for the Student Borrower Advocate, and additional examiners and legal staff. (Financial Institutions Fund)
- Unknown, potentially significant costs for DBO to contract with an economist to monitor for risks to consumers, as this is not a task that DBO currently engages in. (Financial Institutions Fund)
- Potential costs to the Department of Justice of $289,000 in FY 2019-20 and $501,000 ongoing, for additional personnel to investigate complaints and assist the Student Borrower Advocate in complying with the reporting requirements. (GF)
Background:
The Student Loan Servicing Act (SLSA) established in 2018 (AB 2251 (Stone, 2016)) prohibits any person from engaging in student loan servicing in this state without first obtaining a license from DBO. In order to protect student loan borrowers, the SLSA imposes requirements on student loan servicers and prohibits certain practices and acts. The SLSA places oversight of these provisions with the Commissioner of DBO. These provisions do not apply to state- or federally-chartered depository institutions or industrial loan companies, a public postsecondary education institution or a private nonprofit postsecondary educational institution servicing a student loan that it extended to a borrower, a nonprofit community service organization, or a state or nonprofit private institution or organization that has an agreement with the U.S. Secretary of Education in connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion.
Proposed Law:
This bill would create the “Student Borrower Bill of Rights” and impose new requirements on student loan servicers. Specifically, it would:
- Prohibit a person from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan in this state, as provided;
- Specify the actions that a student loan servicer is prohibited from doing;
- Specify the actions that a student loan servicer is required to do, except to the extent these provisions are inconsistent with federal law;
- Establish the position of the Student Borrower Advocate to receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers, as specified;
- Authorize any consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a student loan servicer to comply with these provisions or federal law to bring an action on that consumer’s behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers against that student loan servicer to recover or specified remedies;
- Require the Commissioner of DBO to designate a Student Borrower Advocate within the department to provide timely assistance to any student loan borrower with any student loan, to receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers, and would require The Student Borrower Advocate to hire additional staff as necessary;
- Require complaints regarding student loan servicers not subject to licensing under the Student Loan Servicing Act to be referred to the Department of Justice (DOJ). DOJ would be authorizes to investigate complaints regarding student loan servicers referred by the Student Borrower Advocate, and from the public, who may also submit complaints directly to DOJ;
- Require the Student Borrower Advocate to confer with DOJ and the Office of Student Assistance and Relief regarding the student loan servicing complaints, the proper referral processes for those complaints, and the reporting requirements of the Student Borrower Advocate;
- Specify the duties of the Student Borrower Advocate including but not limited to compiling and analyzing data; assisting student loan borrowers; monitoring federal, state, and local laws, rules, regulations, and policies; and producing an annual report submitted to the appropriate committees of the Legislature having jurisdiction over higher education and financial institutions, as specified;
- Require DBO to monitor for risks to consumers in the provision of student loan servicing, including developments in the market for those services, and to administer these provisions, as specified;
- Require the Commissioner, on a quarterly basis, to develop and publicize metrics based on data collected, as specified.
Related Legislation:
AB 38 (Stone, Chapter 379, Statutes of 2018) was a clean-up bill to AB 2251, which made several technical changes and added exemptions from the SLSA for guaranty agencies and debt collectors, as specified.
AB 2251 (Stone, Chapter 824, Statutes of 2016), enacted the SLSA, operative July 1, 2018, which requires persons servicing student loans in this state, as defined, to become licensed by DBO, comply with specified requirements, and refrain from engaging in specified prohibited acts.
Staff Comments:
Through the Student Loan Servicing Office, DBO recently began licensing and regulating student loan servicers engaged in business in California. DBO’s oversight includes fielding complaints from borrowers and enforcing violations. This bill would build on this new program by establishing a “Bill of Rights” for borrowers by adding to the rules contained in the SLSA, applying new rules to a broader set of entities than those required to be licensed under SLSA, adding a private right of action, allowing DBO and the Attorney General to enforce violations of federal law, establishing a student borrow advocate, and instituting marketing monitoring.
Student loan servicers are not an original lender or loan holder. Instead, servicers contract with lenders to manage loans and process payment plans and respond to borrower questions. These servicers enter into contracts with loan providers, including the federal government, and earn commission on the loans they service. A borrower generally has no control over which company services a loan, and federal rules governing these companies are weak and inconsistent.
While the Student Loan Servicing Office is fairly new, DBO has already engaged with noncompliant servicers. In July 2018, DBO sent letters to 12 servicers that did not properly register with DBO.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 376 (Author:Mark Stone)
Version: June 20, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Student loan servicing
DIGEST
This bill imposes new requirements on student loan servicers doing business in this state, and requires the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) to oversee these provisions. The bill establishes the position of the Student Borrower Advocate to receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers, as provided. The bill also provides for a consumer enforcement mechanism by allowing a consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a student loan servicer to comply with these provisions or any applicable federal laws relating to student loan servicing to bring an action on the consumer’s behalf and on behalf of any similarly situated class of consumers against that student loan borrower.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Student loan debt is a pressing issue of the time, with more than one million Americans defaulting on student loans nationwide in 2017, which is three times the number who lost homes to foreclosure over this period. In California alone, more than 3.7 million borrowers owe nearly $125 billion in student loan debt. There have been several document reports of systemic abusive practices by student loan borrowers, and yet the federal government seems to be taking deliberate action to undermine protections for student loan borrowers. In response, this bill seeks to bolster existing protections for student loan borrowers by, among other things enacting the Student Loan Borrower Bill of Rights, establishing the position of a Student Borrower Advocate, and provides for a consumer enforcement mechanism.
The bill is sponsored by NextGen California, Consumer Reports, Student Borrower Protection Center, Student Debt Crisis, and Young Invincible. The bill is supported by a broad coalition, including labor organizations, business associations, consumer protection organizations, and human rights organizations. The bill is opposed by various associations representing banks, credit unions, and student loan servicers, as well as the Civil Justice Association of California. The bill passed out of the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee on a vote of 5-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Prohibits, pursuant to the Student Loan Servicing Act (SLSA), any person from engaging in student loan servicing in this state, as defined, without first obtaining a license and places oversight of these provisions with the Commissioner of Business Oversight within the DBO. These provisions do not apply to any of the following: (Fin. Code §§ 28100 et. seq.)
- State- or federally-chartered depository institutions or industrial loan companies.
- A public postsecondary educational institution or a private nonprofit postsecondary educational institution servicing a student loan it extended to a borrower.
- A nonprofit community service organization, as specified.
- A state or nonprofit private institution or organization that has an agreement with the United States Secretary of Education, as specified, in connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion. (Fin. Code § 28102.)
- Imposes requirements on student loan servicers and prohibits certain practices and acts, including the following:
- Licensees must provide, free of charge on their internet web site, information or links to information regarding repayment and loan forgiveness options that may be available to those borrowers and provide this information or these links to borrowers in writing at least once per calendar year. (Fin. Code § 28130(f).)
- Licensees must respond to a qualified written request, as defined, by acknowledging written receipt within 10 business days and provide information relating to the request and, if applicable, the action the licensee will take to correct the account within 30 business days. (Fin. Code § 28130(g).)
- After receiving a qualified written request from a borrower related to a dispute over a borrower’s payment, a licensee may not furnish adverse information to any consumer reporting agency for 60 days regarding any payment that is the subject of the qualified written request. (Fin. Code § 28130(g).)
- Licensees must ask borrowers how to apply overpayments, as defined, on outstanding student loans, except as provided in federal law or required by a student loan servicing agreement. (Fin. Code § 28130(h).)
- When a sale, assignment, or other transfer of the servicing in a student loan results in a change in the identity of the party to whom the borrower is required to send payments or direct communications, licensees must notify borrowers in writing at least 15 days before the payment is due to the new party, providing specified relevant information about the loan and the new servicer, and must transfer all information regarding a borrower, that borrower’s account, and that borrower’s student loan to the new licensee servicing the student loan within 45 calendar days of the effective date of the sale, assignment, or transfer. (Fin. Code § 28134.)
- Licensees must also retain records of servicing a borrower’s student loan for a minimum of three years after the student loan is sold, assigned, transferred, or paid in full, except where prohibited by federal law. (Fin. Code § 28138.)
- Licensees are prohibited from defrauding or misleading a borrower, engaging in any unfair or deceptive practice toward any borrower, misapplying payments made by a borrower, failing to accurately report each borrower’s payment performance to at least one nationwide consumer reporting agency, refusing to communicate with an authorized representative of the borrower, or making any false statement or omitting any material fact in connection with any information or reports submitted to DBO or another governmental agency. (Fin. Code § 28136.)
This bill:
- Establishes the Student Borrower Bill of Rights, which prohibits a person from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan in this state, as provided.
- Prohibits a student loan servicer from engaging in other specified acts, including:
- Directly or indirectly employing a scheme, device, or artifice to defraud or mislead a borrower.
- Engaging in an unfair or deceptive practice toward borrowers or misrepresenting or omitting material information in connection with the servicing of a student loan, as specified.
- Misapplying payments made by a borrower to the outstanding balance of a student loan.
- Failing to accurately report each borrower’s payment performance to any consumer reporting agency, as provided.
- Refusing to communicate with an authorized representative of the borrower who provides a written authorization signed by the borrower.
- Negligently or intentionally making a false statement or knowingly and willfully making an omission of a material fact in connection with information or reports filed with the DBO or another governmental agency.
- Requires a student loan servicer to do certain things, except to the extent these provisions are inconsistent with federal law, including:
- Posting, processing, and crediting student loan payments in a timely manner.
- Imposing reasonable and proportional fees for a late payment, as specified.
- Diligently overseeing its service providers.
- Processing paperwork in a timely manner.
- Maintaining accurate records about a borrower’s account for the life of the loan.
- Maintain policies and procedures permitting a borrower who is dissatisfied with the outcome of an initial qualified request to escalate the borrower’s concern to a supervisor.
- Protecting borrowers from any negative consequences that are directly related to the issue identified in a borrower’s qualified request or qualified written request until that request has been resolved.
- Protecting borrowers from any negative consequences stemming from a sale, assignment, transfer, system conversion, or payment made by the borrower to the original student loan servicer consistent with the original student loan servicer’s policy.
- Establishes the position of the Student Borrower Advocate to receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers, as provided.
- Authorizes any consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a student loan servicer to comply with these provisions or federal law to bring an action on that consumer’s behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers against that student loan servicer to recover or obtain any of the following remedies:
- actual damages, but in no case shall the award be less than $500;
- an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices;
- punitive damages;
- attorney’s fees; and
- any other relief the court deems proper.
- In addition to any other remedies, whenever it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a student loan servicer has engaged in conduct that substantially interferes with a borrower’s right to an alternative payment arrangement; loan forgiveness, cancellation, or discharge; or any other financial benefit as established under the terms of a borrower’s promissory note or under the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1070a et seq.), as from time to time amended, and the regulations promulgated thereunder, the court is to award treble actual damages to the plaintiff, but in no case should the award be less than $1,500.
- Requires the DBO to monitor for risks to consumers in the provision of student loan servicing, including developments in the market for those services, and to administer these provisions, as provided.
- Defines various terms for these purposes, as provided.
- Defines student loan servicer to mean any person engaged in the business of servicing student loans in this state.
- Provides a student loan servicer does not include either:
- A debt collector, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1788.2 of the Civil Code, whose student loan debt collection business, and business operations, involve collecting, or attempting to collect, on defaulted student loans, that is, federal student loans for which no payment has been received for 270 days or more, or private student loans, in default, according to the terms of the loan documents. However, debt collectors who also service nondefaulted student loans as part of their business and business operations are student loan servicers.
- In connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion, a state or nonprofit private institution or organization having an agreement with the U. S. Secretary of Education under the Higher Education Act of 1965 (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1078(b)).
- Makes various legislative findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill:
The author writes:
AB 376 establishes the Student Borrower Bill of Rights, ensuring that individuals with student loan debt are given reliable information, quality customer service, and meaningful access to repayment and forgiveness programs. This groundbreaking legislation will make California the first in the nation to offer student loan borrowers the same comprehensive protections that consumers with mortgages and credit cards take for granted.
After a student loan is taken out, loan servicing companies are the ones that communicate with borrowers about payments, account information, refinancing options, and other issues surrounding their loans. Despite a mountain of evidence that demonstrates rampant predatory actors, it is very clear that the federal government has deliberately stepped back from its duties to protect student borrowers and in order to protect its consumers, California must take action.
With 3,780,000 student loan borrowers across California owing $134.3 billion, it is imperative that California take a strong stance to protect borrowers against bad actors. AB 376 will ensure that California borrowers are protected and can take action if servicers violate these basic protections.
2. Protections for student loan borrowers
a. Evidence of abuse and misleading practices
There have been several documented instances of systemic abuse and misleading practices regarding student loan servicers. In 2017, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) sued Navient for “systematically and illegally failing borrowers at every stage of repayment” [1] and reported that as of April 1, 2017, the CFPB had received roughly 1.1 million complaints regarding student loan servicers.[2] In 2018, the California Attorney General filed a lawsuit against Navient for unlawful business practices.[3]
b. Federal actions undermine protection for student borrowers
Unfortunately, the federal government has taken several actions that undermine and thwart protections for student borrowers. For example, Education Secretary Betsy DeVos reversed course on Obama Administration policies that were designed to create new federal protections for student loan borrowers by withdrawing “a series of policy memos issued by the Obama Administration to strengthen consumer protections for student loan borrowers” in 2017.[4] Other reports indicated that the Department of Education was preventing the CFPB from regulating student loan servicers by issuing guidance to them to not comply with requests from the CFPB for information.[5] In May of 2018, the CFPB shut down the only unit solely dedicated to overseeing student loan borrowers and was instead folded in to the CFPB’s consumer information unit.[6]
c. Enhanced protection for student borrowers
This bill seeks to bolster existing provisions of state law for student borrowers by placing new requirements on student loan servicers and establishing the position of the Student Borrower Advocate within the DBO. There are specific protection for borrowers who are military borrowers, older borrowers, borrowers with disabilities, and borrowers working in public service to ensure these borrowers are able to take advantage of specific programs they may qualify for under federal law. A key component of the bill is prohibiting abusive acts or practices when a person is servicing a student loan. These provisions emulate the same protections contained in the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank; Public Law 111-203). The recent actions of the federal government demonstrate why these protections need to be enacted into state law. If California does not protect student borrowers, no one will.
A major difference in this bill from the existing provisions of the SLSA is that these provisions also apply to state- and federally-chartered banks and credit unions, which the SLSA does not. The provisions of the bill do not apply to a debt collector whose student loan debt collection business, and business operations, involve collecting, or attempting to collect, on defaulted student loans, however, the bill does apply its provisions to debt collectors who also service nondefaulted student loans as part of their business and business operations. The other entities exempted from the bill’s provisions are state or nonprofit private institutions or organizations having an agreement with the United States Secretary of Education under the Higher Education Act of 1965 (HEA) (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1078(b)) in connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion. According to FinAid:
Guarantee agencies insure student loans against default. The 1% default fee (previously "guarantee fee") that is collected from each disbursement on a federal education loan is paid to the designated guarantee agency to cover the costs of insuring the loan. (Some guarantee agencies have built up enough of a reserve that they are able to waive or reduce the default fee.) If the borrower defaults, dies or becomes totally and permanently disabled, the guarantee agency reimburses the lender for the balance remaining on the loan […] The Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 ended the federally-guaranteed student loan program — the Federal Family Education Loan Program (FFELP) — effective June 30, 2010. All new federal education loans since July 1, 2010 have been made through the Direct Loan program. Despite the end of FFELP, the 35 guarantee agencies are still involved in guaranteeing the existing FFELP loan portfolios against default and will continue in this role until the last FFELP loan is paid in full. Nevertheless, many of the state guarantee agencies are diversifying into other areas, such as managing state grant and non-federal student loan programs, developing financial literacy training programs, and servicing federal education loans made through the Direct Loan program.[7] [mphasis added]
The author may wish to explore amending the bill to apply these provisions to guaranty agencies to the extent they are servicing student loan debt not in default in a similar manner to a debt collector.
3. Protecting student borrowers’ rights
a. Enforcement
This bill strengthens protections for student borrowers by providing a strong enforcement mechanism that empowers student borrowers to hold student loan servicers accountable for their abusive practices or acts and violations of state and federal law. As documented above, the federal government has been actively undermining protections for student borrowers leaving the states to fill the vacuum. The bill provides any consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a student loan servicer to comply with these provisions or any applicable federal laws relating to student loan servicing to bring an action on the consumer’s behalf and on behalf of any similarly situated class of consumers against that student loan borrower. Remedies authorized under this action include actual damages; an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices; restitution of property; punitive damages; attorney’s fees; or any other relief the court deems proper. In addition, whenever it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a student loan servicer engaged in conduct that substantially interferes with a student borrower’s right to an alternative payment arrangement; loan forgiveness, cancellation, or discharge; or any other financial benefit as established under the terms of a borrower’s promissory note or under the HEA (20 U.S.C. §§ 1070 et. seq.), the court is to award treble actual damages to the plaintiff, but not less than $1,500 per plaintiff.
b. Federal preemption
Some opponents of the bill have argued that its provisions are preempted by federal law, specifically the HEA. Recently, on June 27, 2018, the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit held that the HEA contains several express provisions of exemption, such as lenders and loan servicers are not subject to disclosure requirements imposed by state law. (20 U.S.C. § 1098g.) However, the court held in that the express preemption of Section 1098g of Title 20 of the United States Code does not entirely bar attempts to assert consumer protection or tort law claims against a student loan servicer, and that field preemption does not apply, stating:
Field preemption is confined to only a few areas of the law, such as the National Labor Relations Act […] Courts have consistently held that field preemption does not apply to the HEA, and we do as well.[8]
4. Statements in support
This bill is sponsored by NextGen California, Consumer Reports, Student Borrower Protection Center, Student Debt Crisis, and Young Invincibles. The bill is supported by numerous labor organizations, business associations, and consumer protection organizations, and California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara.
Student Debt Crisis, a co-sponsor of the bill, writes:
California would lead the nation by becoming the first state to create a comprehensive set of rights for people holding student debt. This bill requires student loan companies to treat borrowers fairly and gives borrowers the right to hold these companies accountable when they fail to meet basic servicing standards, mislead borrowers, or commit illegal business practices.
NextGen, a co-sponsor of the bill, writes:
The current statutory environment surrounding student loans does not provide much in the way of consumer protections, subjecting borrowers to an unregulated world of private lenders, debt collectors, and student loan servicers who are more focused on the bottom line than assisting borrowers. This leads to high default and delinquency rates. When student loan borrowers become delinquent or default, they can have their professional licenses revoked, their wages garnished, and their Social Security payments seized, causing these individuals to struggle with everyday financial choices while billion-dollar companies increase their profit margins.
5. Statements in opposition
The bill is opposed by the California Bankers Association, California Credit Union League, Civil Justice Association of California, Consumer Bankers Association, and the
Student Loan Servicing Alliance.
Opposition raises several concerns with the bill. Many opponents dislike the consumer enforcement mechanism and want it removed from the bill or at least changed to mirror existing class action requirements under California law. Opponent believe that certain provisions of the bill as the bill are preempted under the National Bank Act or Higher Education Act. In addition, opponents believe the affirmative duty to act in the best interest of the student borrower is unworkable and is an attempt to create a fiduciary duty that does not existing under current law.
The Civil Justice Association of California, an association of businesses including Dow Chemical Company, PG&E, Monsanto, and Shell Oil Company, writes in opposition to the bill stating:
While CJAC does not take a position on the merits of the regulatory provisions laid out in AB 376, we fear that allowing enforcement by individual lawsuit with quasi-class action feature, liquidated damages of $500 or $1,500, and attorney’s fees, could lead to unjustified lawsuits that are more about attorney’s fees than about justice.
SUPPORT
NexGen California (co-sponsor)
Consumer Reports (co-sponsor)
Student Borrower Protection Center (co-sponsor)
Student Debt Crisis (co-sponsor)
Young Invincibles (co-sponsor)
AARP California
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Americans for Financial Reform
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
Association of Young Americans
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra
Beneficial State Foundation
California Asset Building Coalition
California Association of Nonprofits
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Veteran Service Agencies
California Dental Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Insurance Commissioner Ricardo Lara
California Labor Federation
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
California LULAC
California Reinvestment Coalition
California Secretary of State Alex Padilla
California Women’s Law Center
Californians for Economic Justice
CalPIRG
City and County of San Francisco
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights
Common Sense Kids Action
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
County Welfare Directors Association of California
Courage Campaign
East Bay Community Law Center
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Generation Progress
Hildreth Institute
Housing & Economic Rights Advocates
Improve Your Tomorrow
National Student Loan Defense Network
New Economics for Women
Public Law Center
PolicyLink
San Francisco Treasurer & Tax Collector Jose Cisneros
Service Employees International Union California
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Student Borrower Protection Center
Student Senate for California Community Colleges
The Institute for College Access & Success
UnidosUS
University of California Student Association
Veterans Education Success
OPPOSITION
California Bankers Association
California Credit Union League
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Bankers Association
Student Loan Servicing Alliance
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
AB 38 (Stone, Ch. 379, Stats. 2018) was a clean-up bill to AB 2251, which made several technical changes and added exemptions from the SLSA for guaranty agencies and debt collectors, as specified.
AB 2251 (Stone, Ch. 824, Stats. 2016), enacted the SLSA, operative July 1, 2018, which requires persons servicing student loans in this state, as defined, to become licensed by DBO, comply with specified requirements, and refrain from engaging in specified prohibited acts.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 59, Noes 15)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 4)
Assembly Banking and Finance Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
CFPD Sues Nation’s Largest Student Loan Company Navient for failing Borrowers at Every State of Repayment, CFPB (Jan. 18, 2017), available at https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/cfpb-sues-nations-largest-student-loan-company-navient-failing-borrowers-every-stage-repayment/ (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
CFPB Monthly Snapshot Spotlights Student Loan Complaints, CFPB (Apr. 25, 2017), https://www.consumerfinance.gov/about-us/newsroom/cfpb-monthly-snapshot-spotlights-student-loan-complaints/ (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
Friedman, What This Navient Lawsuit Means For Your Student Loans, Forbes (Jul. 9, 2018), available at https://www.forbes.com/sites/zackfriedman/2018/07/09/student-loans-navient-lawsuit/#4e280b3d2777 ↑
Douglas-Gabriel, Betsy DeVos undoes Obama’s student loan protections, Chicago Tribune (Apr. 11, 2017), available at https://www.chicagotribune.com/business/ct-betsy-devos-student-loan-protections-20170411-story.html (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
CFPB Chief Says Education Department Is Blocking Student Loan Oversight, NPR (May 16, 2019), available at https://www.npr.org/2019/05/16/723568597/cfpb-chief-says-education-department-is-blocking-student-loan-oversight (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
Thursh & Cowley, Mulvaney Downgrades Student Loan Unit in Consumer Bureau Reshuffle, New York Times (May 9, 2018), available at https://www.nytimes.com/2018/05/09/us/student-loans-consumer-financial-protection-bureau-cfpb.html (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
Guarantee Agencies, FinAid, available at http://www.finaid.org/loans/guaranteeagencies.phtml (as of Jun. 20, 2019). ↑
Nelson v. Great Lakes Educational Loan Services, Inc. (7th Cir. Jun. 27, 2019, No. 18-1831) pp. 3, 22, 24. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BANKING AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 376 Hearing Date: June 19, 2019
Author: | Mark Stone | ||
Version: | May 16, 2019 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eileen Newhall | ||
Subject: Student loan servicing.
SUMMARY
This bill imposes new requirements on student loan servicers doing business in this state and places responsibility with the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) for administering these requirements; provides judicial enforcement mechanisms for violations of the aforementioned requirements by student loan servicers; requires DBO to collect information about and report on the activities of student loan servicers in this state; and requires DBO to designate a Student Borrower Advocate, as specified.
EXISTING LAW
- Provides for the Student Loan Servicing Act (SLSA; Division 12.5 of the Financial Code, Financial Code Section 28100 et seq.), administered by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) The SLSA prohibits any person from engaging in student loan servicing in this state, as defined, without first obtaining a license pursuant to Division 12.5, but does not apply to any of the following (Financial Code Section 28102):
- State- or federally-chartered depository institutions or industrial loan companies.
- A public postsecondary educational institution (e.g., University of California) or a private nonprofit postsecondary educational institution (e.g., Stanford University) servicing a student loan it extended to a borrower.
- A nonprofit community service organization, as specified (generally speaking, nonprofits that engage in credit counseling, debt settlement, or debt management activities on behalf of consumers at no or very low cost; see Financial Code Section 12104).
- A state or nonprofit private institution or organization that has an agreement with the United States Secretary of Education, as specified, in connection with its responsibilities as a guaranty agency engaged in default aversion.
- A debt collector, as defined, whose student loan debt collection business involves collecting or attempting to collect on defaulted student loans, as defined.
- State- or federally-chartered depository institutions or industrial loan companies.
- Imposes a series of requirements on licensed student loan servicers and prohibited acts in which student loan servicers may not engage, the most substantive of which include the following:
- Licensees must provide, free of charge on their internet web site, information or links to information regarding repayment and loan forgiveness options that may be available to those borrowers and provide this information or these links to borrowers in writing at least once per calendar year (Financial Code Section 28130(f)).
- Licensees must respond to a qualified written request, as defined, by acknowledging written receipt within 10 business days and provide information relating to the request and, if applicable, the action the licensee will take to correct the account within 30 business days (Financial Code Section 28130(g)).
- After receiving a qualified written request from a borrower related to a dispute over a borrower’s payment, a licensee may not furnish adverse information to any consumer reporting agency for 60 days regarding any payment that is the subject of the qualified written request (Financial Code Section 28130(g)).
- Licensees must ask borrowers how to apply overpayments, as defined, on outstanding student loans, except as provided in federal law or required by a student loan servicing agreement (Financial Code Section 28130(h)).
- When a sale, assignment, or other transfer of the servicing in a student loan results in a change in the identity of the party to whom the borrower is required to send payments or direct communications, licensees must notify borrowers in writing at least 15 days before the payment is due to the new party, providing specified relevant information about the loan and the new servicer, and must transfer all information regarding a borrower, that borrower’s account, and that borrower’s student loan to the new licensee servicing the student loan within 45 calendar days of the effective date of the sale, assignment, or transfer (Financial Code Section 28134).
- Licensees must also retain records of servicing a borrower’s student loan for a minimum of three years after the student loan is sold, assigned, transferred, or paid in full, except where prohibited by federal law (Financial Code Section 28138).
- Licensees are prohibited from defrauding or misleading a borrower, engaging in any unfair or deceptive practice toward any borrower, misapplying payments made by a borrower, failing to accurately report each borrower’s payment performance to at least one nationwide consumer reporting agency, refusing to communicate with an authorized representative of the borrower, or making any false statement or omitting any material fact in connection with any information or reports submitted to DBO or another governmental agency (Financial Code Section 28136).
- Licensees must provide, free of charge on their internet web site, information or links to information regarding repayment and loan forgiveness options that may be available to those borrowers and provide this information or these links to borrowers in writing at least once per calendar year (Financial Code Section 28130(f)).
THIS BILL
- Contains findings and declarations regarding the challenges of student loan debtors, the predatory practices of some student loan servicers, failure of the federal government to take necessary action to halt widespread abuses, and the resulting need for California to take steps to do all of the following: promote meaningful access to affordable repayment and loan forgiveness benefits; ensure that California borrowers can rely on information provided to them by their student loan servicers; and build on California’s SLSA to protect California borrowers from predatory student loan industry practices.
- Defines the terms “borrower,” “commissioner,” “department,” “engage in the business,” “in this state,” “student loan,” and “student loan servicer” as those terms are defined in the SLSA and adds a new definition for the term “qualified request,” which is defined as any inbound inquiry or complaint to a student loan servicer that cannot be completed in a single phone call.
- Prohibits any person from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan in this state. Provides that an abusive act or practice in connection with the servicing of a student loan includes, but is not limited to one that:
- Materially interferes with a borrower’s ability to understand a term or condition of a student loan.
- Takes unreasonable advantage of any of the following:
- A borrower’s lack of understanding of the material risks, costs, or conditions of the student loan.
- A borrower’s inability to protect his or her interests in selecting or using a student loan or a feature, term, or condition of a student loan.
- A borrower’s reasonable reliance on a student loan servicer to act in the interests of the borrower.
- A borrower’s lack of understanding of the material risks, costs, or conditions of the student loan.
- Materially interferes with a borrower’s ability to understand a term or condition of a student loan.
- Prohibits any person from engaging in any unfair or deceptive practice toward any military borrower, borrower working in public service, or borrower with disabilities, or from misrepresenting or omitting any material information in connection with the servicing of a student loan owed by a military borrower, borrower working in public service, or a borrower with disabilities. For purposes of these prohibitions, misrepresenting or omitting any material information is defined as misrepresenting or omitting any of the following:
- The availability of any program or protection specific to or applicable to military borrowers, borrowers working in public service, or borrowers with disabilities.
- The amount, nature, or terms of any fee or payment due or claimed to be due on a student loan.
- The terms and conditions of the student loan agreement.
- The borrower’s obligations under the student loan.
- The availability of any program or protection specific to or applicable to military borrowers, borrowers working in public service, or borrowers with disabilities.
- Prohibits any person from engaging in any unfair or deceptive practice toward any older borrower or cosigner or misrepresenting or omitting any material information in connection with the servicing of a student loan owed or cosigned by an older borrower. For purposes of these prohibitions, misrepresenting or omitting any material information is defined as misrepresenting or omitting any of the following:
- The availability of any program or protection specific to older borrowers or cosigners or applicable to older borrowers or cosigners.
- The amount, nature, or terms of any fee or payment due or claimed to be due on a student loan.
- The terms and conditions of the student loan agreement.
- The borrower’s or cosigner’s obligations under the student loan.
- The availability of any program or protection specific to older borrowers or cosigners or applicable to older borrowers or cosigners.
- Requires a person engaged in student loan servicing in this state to do all of the following, except to the extent that a requirement is inconsistent with any provision of federal law or regulation, and then only to the extent of the inconsistency:
- Post, process, and credit student loan payments in a timely manner, as specified.
- Apply an overpayment on a loan, as defined, in a manner that is in the best financial interest of a student borrower, unless a borrower provides instructions to the contrary, as specified.
- Apply partial payments, as defined, in a manner that minimizes late fees and negative credit reporting, as specified.
- Ensure that any late fee imposed on a borrower for a past due student loan payment is reasonable and proportional to the total costs incurred as a result of the late payment, and in no case exceeds 6% of the amount past due.
- Diligently oversee its service providers, as specified.
- Timely process its paperwork, consistent with existing federal requirements, as specified.
- Maintain accurate records about borrowers’ accounts and retain these records for the life of a student loan, as specified.
- Treat any inbound inquiry or complaint that cannot be completed in a single phone call as a qualified request subject to the same requirements and protections established for qualified written requests under the SLSA.
- Maintain policies and procedures permitting borrowers to escalate a complaint or inquiry to a senior representative if the borrower is dissatisfied with the outcome of the initial qualified request.
- Protect borrowers from any negative consequences that are related to the issue identified in a borrower’s qualified request or qualified written request. For purposes of this requirement, negative consequences include, but are not limited to, negative credit reporting, lost eligibility for a borrower benefit, late fees, interest capitalization, or other financial injury.
- Protect borrowers from any negative consequences stemming from a sale, assignment, or transfer of a student loan or from a system conversion. For purposes of this requirement, negative consequences include, but are not limited to, negative credit reporting, the imposition of late fees, or loss of or denial of eligibility for any benefit or protection established under federal law or included in a loan contract.
- Ensure that all necessary information, as defined, regarding a borrower, a borrower’s account, and a borrower’s student loan accompanies a loan when it transfers to a new student loan servicer, as specified.
- Provide specialized training for any customer service personnel that advise military borrowers, borrowers working in public service, older borrowers, or borrowers with disabilities about student loan repayment benefits and protections, as specified.
- Respond within 15 calendar days to communications from the Student Borrower Advocate, or within a shorter, reasonable time as the Student Borrower Advocate may request in their communication.
- Comply with specified provisions of the SLSA.
- Post, process, and credit student loan payments in a timely manner, as specified.
- Requires a person engaged in student loan servicing to comply with the requirements of this bill and with all applicable federal laws relating to student loan servicing, as they are amended from time to time, and the regulations promulgated pursuant to those federal laws.
- Provides that any consumer who suffers damage as a result of the failure of a person engaged in student loan servicing to comply with this bill, applicable federal law, or applicable federal regulations may bring an action on their own behalf and on behalf a similarly situated class of consumers to recover or obtain any of the following:
- Actual damages, although in no case may a total award of damages be less than $500.
- An order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices.
- Restitution of property.
- Punitive damages.
- Attorney’s fees.
- Any other relief the court deems proper.
- Actual damages, although in no case may a total award of damages be less than $500.
- Imposes joint and several liability on student loan servicers for the conduct of their third party service providers.
- In addition to any other remedies described above or provided elsewhere in law, provides that whenever it is proven by a preponderance of the evidence that a person engaged in student loan servicing has engaged in conduct that substantially interferes with a borrower’s right to an alternative payment arrangement, loan forgiveness, cancellation, or discharge, or any other financial benefit established under the terms of a borrower’s promissory note or the Higher Education Act of 1965, as it is amended from time to time, and the regulations promulgated pursuant to that law, the court must award treble actual damages to the plaintiff. Provides that in no case may a total damage award be less than $1,500 per plaintiff, per violation.
- Requires the DBO to administer the provisions of this bill and to do all of the following:
- Monitor for risks to consumers in the provision of student loan servicing, including developments in the market for those services.
- Not later than 180 days following the operative date of the bill, designate a Student Borrower Advocate within the department to receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers and provide timely assistance to student loan borrowers, as described in more detail below.
- Not later than 180 days following the operative date of the bill, gather and compile information from persons engaged in student loan servicing to assemble data substantially similar to the data collection proposed in the “Student Loan Market Monitoring” initiative described by the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau in Federal Register No 171, Page 11440, dated September 6, 2017.
- On a quarterly basis, develop and publicize metrics that identify each person engaged in student loan servicing and provide relevant metrics related to the performance of student loan servicing by each of these persons.
- Monitor for risks to consumers in the provision of student loan servicing, including developments in the market for those services.
- Requires the Student Borrower Advocate to do all of the following:
- Receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers and refer these complaints, as follows:
- Complaints regarding a student loan servicer licensed under the SLSA must be referred to the appropriate unit within DBO.
- Complaints regarding a student loan servicer that is not subject to licensure under the SLSA must be referred to the California Department of Justice.
- Complaints regarding a private postsecondary educational institution licensed by the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education must be referred to that Bureau’s Office of Student Assistance and Relief.
- Complaints regarding a student loan servicer licensed under the SLSA must be referred to the appropriate unit within DBO.
- Compile and analyze data on student loan borrower complaints received and referred to DBO and DOJ.
- Help student loan borrowers understand their rights and responsibilities under the terms of student loans.
- Provide information to the public, agencies, legislators, and others regarding the problems and concerns of student loan borrowers and make recommendations to resolve those problems and concerns.
- Analyze and monitor the development and implementation of federal, state, and local laws, rules, regulations, and policies relating to student loan borrowers and recommend any changes the advocate deems necessary.
- Assess the number of residents with federal student loans who have applied for, received, or are awaiting a decision on forgiveness or discharge of a student loan, as specified.
- Disseminate information about the availability of the Student Borrower Advocate to help student loan borrowers, potential student loan borrowers, institutions of higher education, student loan servicers, and any other participant in student loan lending with any student loan concerns.
- Take any action reasonably calculated or intended to assist student loan borrowers, including providing assistance applying for forgiveness or discharge of a student loan and communicating with a student loan servicer to resolve a complaint received by the advocate from a student loan borrower.
- Request and compile data provided by any student loan servicer if the advocate reasonably determines that data to be necessary to effectuate his or her duties. If the Student Borrower Advocate determines that it is necessary to compel the production of that data via examination or subpoena, DBO is required to coordinate with the Student Borrower Advocate to effectuate the production of the data.
- Submit a report, as specified, to the appropriate committees of the legislature having jurisdiction over higher education and financial institutions, as specified, not later than 18 months after enactment of the bill and at least once annually thereafter.
- Receive and review complaints from student loan borrowers and refer these complaints, as follows:
COMMENTS
- Purpose: This bill is co-sponsored by the Student Borrower Protection Center, Next Gen California, Consumer Reports, Student Debt Crisis, and the Young Invincibles to improve student loan borrower outcomes. The bill is intended to build on California’s existing SLSA and fill gaps that exist following the Trump Administration’s decision to dismantle the student loan servicing oversight arm of the CFPB.
- The Author Will Offer Extensive Amendments: AB 376 is double-referred to this Committee and the Senate Judiciary Committee and is subject to the fiscal deadline. Because there was insufficient time to amend the bill before this Committee’s policy hearing on the measure, amendments will be offered by the author in Committee to do all of the following:
- Amend the SLSA (whose provisions are in the Financial Code) to delete substantive servicer requirements and prohibited acts. Amend the code sections that this bill adds to the Civil Code to incorporate the servicer requirements and prohibited acts previously contained in the SLSA. These changes have the effect of stripping the SLSA down to a licensing framework and ensuring that the substantive rules applicable to the act of servicing a student loan in this state are contained in the Civil Code.
- Exempt guaranty agencies from the servicing requirements and enforcement provisions of the bill (but not from the requirement to respond to requests for information from the Student Borrower Advocate and DBO).
- Add definitions for the terms “military borrower,” “borrower engaged in public service,” “older borrower,” and “borrower with disabilities,” and clarify/correct the definitions of “qualified request” and “qualified written request.” Clarify that a qualified request must be treated in the same manner as a qualified written request.
- Reorganize the Civil Code provisions to group prohibited acts together. As the bill is currently drafted, prohibited acts are spread throughout the Civil Code language and, in certain places, are lumped in with required acts, making it difficult to distinguish affirmative responsibilities from prohibitions.
- Clarify that the minimum actual damages, which may be awarded by a court to a borrower following a lawsuit, equal $500 per plaintiff, per violation.
- Revise the rule, currently contained in the Financial Code but being moved to the Civil Code, which prohibits servicers from reporting any adverse information to a credit reporting agency for sixty days following receipt of a qualified written request from a borrower. Once revised, this provision will institute a 60-day pause on credit reporting by prohibiting servicers from reporting any information to a credit reporting agency about a payment that is the subject of a qualified written request.
- Amend the SLSA (whose provisions are in the Financial Code) to delete substantive servicer requirements and prohibited acts. Amend the code sections that this bill adds to the Civil Code to incorporate the servicer requirements and prohibited acts previously contained in the SLSA. These changes have the effect of stripping the SLSA down to a licensing framework and ensuring that the substantive rules applicable to the act of servicing a student loan in this state are contained in the Civil Code.
- Once the Bill is Amended, How Will All of This Work? California adopted the SLSA, effective July 1, 2018, joining a handful of other states and the District of Columbia in requiring entities that service federal or private student loans in this state to be licensed. California’s SLSA, like the licensing laws of other jurisdictions, was an attempt to address extensive student loan borrower complaints about treatment by their student loan servicers and reports of systemic problems within the student loan servicing industry, which were documented in several reports issued by the CFPB.
This bill is intended to add to the required and prohibited actions contained in the SLSA, apply those expanded rules to a broader group of entities than those required to be licensed under the SLSA, enforce those expanded rules using a combination of DBO and AG oversight and private rights of action, place DBO in the role of Student Borrower Advocate, and institute market monitoring of the student loan servicing industry. Each of these components is discussed in more detail immediately below.
Add to the Rules Contained in the SLSA. One of the key provisions of AB 376 is its addition of an “abusive acts and practices” standard to California law. The “abusive practices” language of AB 376 mirrors federal protections contained in the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (Dodd-Frank; Public Law 111-203). According to representatives of the Student Borrower Protection Center (SBPC), codifying the “abusive” standard in California law will preserve broad future enforcement authority for both the California Attorney General and DBO and allow individuals to hold industry directly accountable using the private right of action in this bill.
Other rules being added to California law by AB 376 represent an attempt to “fill the gaps” in borrower protection that remain following enactment of the SLSA. Per the SBPC, although the SLSA “included some limited new protections for borrowers, it did not offer the kind of comprehensive, transparent and enforceable standards in place in other regulated consumer financial markets” like the credit card and mortgage lending industries.
SBPC also believes that the new rules being added to California law will withstand pre-emption challenges. ”In the past, state policymakers have been reluctant to set broad standards, in part, out of concern [that] preemption provisions in the Higher Education Act could render a state law inapplicable to the servicing of federal student loans, which are more than 90% of all outstanding loans. This view incorrectly treated the Higher Education Act as if it preempted all state regulation. However, the opposite is true --- aside from a single, narrow provision expressly preempting certain state ‘disclosure’ requirements, federal higher education law is silent as to the role of states when setting standards for the servicing of student loans.”
Apply the New Rules to a Broader Set of Entities Than Those Required to be Licensed under the SLSA. California’s SLSA includes several exemptions, some of which are mirrored in AB 376, and some of which are not. The most notable group exempt from the SLSA but subject to AB 376 includes state- and federally-chartered banks and credit unions.
Add A Private Right of Action and Allow DBO and the AG to Enforce Violations of Federal Law. This bill makes it a violation of state law for any person engaged in student loan servicing in this state to fail to comply with the requirements of AB 376 or to fail to comply with “all applicable federal laws relating to student loan servicing, as from time to time amended, and the regulations promulgated thereunder.” It gives DBO the right to enforce violations of AB 376 and the federal laws and regulations it incorporates by reference as violations of the SLSA.
This bill also authorizes any consumer who suffers damage due to the failure of an entity engaged in student loan servicing in this state to comply with the requirements of AB 376 or the federal laws and regulations it incorporates to bring an action on their own behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers against the person who has committed the violation or violations giving rise to the damage.
According to the SBPC, “The Higher Education Act does not include a private right of action or any mechanism to permit state law enforcement officials or state regulators to enforce borrowers’ rights to a wide range of federal consumer protections and benefits...Recent actions by the Trump Administration have drastically reduced federal oversight and enforcement efforts on behalf of borrowers. For example, in August 2017, the U.S. Department of Education revoked information sharing agreements that once permitted the CFPB to supervise and handle consumer complaints about the largest student loan servicers. This action marked the start of a series of increasingly hostile moves by the Trump Administration, including the Education Department’s 2018 ‘reinterpretation’ of preemption under the HEA, the shuttering of CFPB’s Office for Students, and the widespread misuse of the federal Privacy Act to obstruct state oversight. California has the opportunity to provide borrowers with a first-of-its kind means to enforce their federal rights to affordable student loan payments and loan forgiveness and demand significant penalties from the student loan industry when these rights are violated.”
Establish a Student Borrower Advocate. This bill attempts to replicate on a state level what the CFPB used to offer at a federal level. The SBPC states, “Until 2018, the CFPB was the only agency in the federal government with a dedicated unit that could assist borrowers with both federal and private student loans. The Trump Administration shuttered this office, following action by the Department of Education to limit coordination between these agencies on student loan complaints...No state has provided a borrower advocate with the resources, legal tools, and independence necessary to replicate the successful model built by the CFPB.” AB 376 gives the Student Borrower Advocate (a position within DBO) authority to refer suspected violations of law to the AG and DBO; compile and analyze borrower complaints; and make independent recommendations to the Governor, the AG, and the Legislature.
Institute Market Monitoring. This provision places DBO into a role that the CFPB tried to fill, but was unable to before the Trump Administration prevented the Bureau from moving forward. In 2017, the CFPB issued a proposal to enact a “Student Loan Market Monitoring” initiative (Federal Register No 171, Page 11440, September 6, 2017). According to the SBPC, “By requiring student loan companies to compile and produce summary data about their performance, California will be able to develop a ‘report card’ for the student loan industry – identifying the companies and practices that are failing borrowers and informing state and federal policymakers seeking to drive reforms across the student loan market.”
- Student Loan Servicing Practices and New State Laws Have Prompted Extensive Litigation But Settled Few Questions: The question of whether and to what extent states may regulate the activities of entities that service federal student loans is one that has been considered by many courts of law. Litigation over this issue intensified following states’ decisions to enact student loan servicing licensing laws applicable federal and private student loan servicers. The courts have also presided over extensive litigation regarding what duties student loan servicers have to the borrowers whose loans they service. To date, courts’ rulings have been mixed. None of the cases that could inform the Legislature regarding the extent to which the provisions of AB 376 will hold up to legal challenge have been fully settled.
- This Bill Is Likely to Add to the Litigation: At a minimum, this bill’s private right of action is likely to generate both individual and class action litigation against student loan servicers alleged to have violated the new rules being added by AB 376 or federal law, or both. However, the provisions of this bill also provide ample fodder for servicers subject to its provisions to file suit against the state, seeking to invalidate certain provisions of the bill. For example, federally-regulated banks allege that this bill contains provisions which are pre-empted under the National Bank Act (see Opposition arguments, below). Banks could wait to be sued and raise these arguments when defending plaintiffs’ lawsuits, or they could strike first and bring an action against the state, seeking to invalidate those portions of the bill they believe are pre-empted, to discourage future plaintiffs’ suits against them.
This bill also applies several of its requirements, “except to the extent that a requirement is inconsistent with any provision of federal law or regulation, and then only to the extent of the inconsistency.” Language of this sort is an invitation for regulators, plaintiffs’ attorneys, and servicers to argue about where states’ authority stops in the case of federal student loans and federally-regulated servicers.
This bill also includes at least one provision that has been directly challenged by student loan servicers in litigation brought against them by others. For example, this bill defines an abusive act or practice as, among other things, a servicer failing act in the interests of a borrower whose loan that servicer is servicing. The question of whether a servicer has an affirmative duty to act in the best interests of borrowers is an unsettled matter of law, which is currently being litigated as part of lawsuits brought against Navient by both the CFPB and California’s AG. AB 376 takes the view that this unsettled matter of law will be decided in favor of the CFPB and California AG. If it is not, DBO will be required to enforce this provision, until an appellate court strikes it down. - Support:
- The Student Borrower Protection Center (SBPC), one of this bill’s sponsors, is a nonprofit organization founded by former senior regulators at the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. “Our team led the first government-wide effort at the federal level to halt abuses by the student loan industry and create new consumer protections to ensure 44 million Americans with student debt were no longer preyed upon by an industry looking to get rich off of our nation’s student debt crisis. However, the Trump Administration and Betsy DeVos have rolled back much of this progress, siding with the largest student loan companies over the rights of student borrowers....AB 376 picks up where past federal efforts to reform the student loan system have fallen short.”
- An extensive coalition of consumer advocacy and legal aid organizations, student associations, and organized labor writes, “This bill would make California the first state in the nation to create a comprehensive set of rights for people holding student debt, by requiring student loan companies to treat borrowers fairly and giving borrowers the right to hold these companies accountable when they fail to meet basic servicing standards...Unlike mortgages or credit cards, there is not industry-wide framework at the federal level to regulate the student loan industry...AB 376 would create enforceable industry-wide standards for loan servicing companies. The bill would: ban “abusive” student loan servicing practices that take unreasonable advantage of borrowers’ confusion over loan repayment options; create minimum servicing standards related to application of payments, paperwork retention and specialized staff training; establish a Student Borrower Advocate within the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) responsible for reviewing complaints, gathering data and coordinating with related state agencies; and grant DBO additional “market monitoring” authorities, to better collect data about the student loan servicing industry.”
- The Student Borrower Protection Center (SBPC), one of this bill’s sponsors, is a nonprofit organization founded by former senior regulators at the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. “Our team led the first government-wide effort at the federal level to halt abuses by the student loan industry and create new consumer protections to ensure 44 million Americans with student debt were no longer preyed upon by an industry looking to get rich off of our nation’s student debt crisis. However, the Trump Administration and Betsy DeVos have rolled back much of this progress, siding with the largest student loan companies over the rights of student borrowers....AB 376 picks up where past federal efforts to reform the student loan system have fallen short.”
- Opposition:
- The Student Loan Servicing Alliance is a trade association whose members service about 95% of all outstanding federal and private student loans. The trade association is seeking three sets of amendments, which, if taken by the author, would remove the association’s opposition. Those amendments include striking the private right of action, striking the market monitoring requirements this bill imposes on the Student Borrower Advocate and DBO, and modifying the provisions of the bill that require servicers to credit borrower payments in a manner that is “in the best interest of the borrower.” The association would prefer to require servicers to disclose their payment allocation methodologies to borrowers and allow borrowers to provide custom directions if they prefer a different desired allocation that is permissible within the servicing contract or law.
- The Civil Justice Association of California also seeks to see this bill’s private right of action removed. “Chapter 3, Section 1788.103(b) allows an individual lawsuit on behalf of themselves ‘and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers’ which creates a statutory minimum amount of damages of $500. This representative action feature, a quasi-class action, would allow one person to represent others without having to fulfill the requirements of a class action lawsuit. Although California has some of the most liberal class action lawsuit requirements in the country (see William R. Shafton, California’s Uncommon Common Law Class Action Litigation, 41 Loy. L.A.L. Rev 783 (2008), California does impose some limits on class certification....This bill would allow a borrower to sue on behalf of others similarly situated, without any of the traditional requirements of a representative action.”
- The Consumer Bankers Association, California Bankers Association, and California Credit Union League believe that the exemption for state- and federally-chartered banks and credit unions that is contained in the SLSA should be added to the Civil Code provisions of AB 376 and that the requirements of AB 376 should be applied only to those entities required to be licensed under the SLSA. If AB 376 is applied to banks, the Consumer Bankers Association argues that the bill would create insurmountable conflicts for federally regulated financial institutions. “Several provisions of the bill would place State of California representatives, including the Student Borrower Advocate, in the position of exercising ‘visitorial powers’ over banks in violation of federal law...Any requirement in the bill that would give the State the right to investigate the student loan operations of a National Bank, and/or examine or require the production of the books, accounts, records, and files of a National Bank that services student loans, constitutes an impermissible exercise of visitorial authority...Likewise, any requirement that banks must submit reports (annual or otherwise) or produce proprietary business data or written complaint responses would violate national bank preemption principles that give exclusive visitorial authority (e.g., the right to audit, inspect, examine and supervise the operations and books/records of a national bank) to the federal prudential regulators.”
- The Student Loan Servicing Alliance is a trade association whose members service about 95% of all outstanding federal and private student loans. The trade association is seeking three sets of amendments, which, if taken by the author, would remove the association’s opposition. Those amendments include striking the private right of action, striking the market monitoring requirements this bill imposes on the Student Borrower Advocate and DBO, and modifying the provisions of the bill that require servicers to credit borrower payments in a manner that is “in the best interest of the borrower.” The association would prefer to require servicers to disclose their payment allocation methodologies to borrowers and allow borrowers to provide custom directions if they prefer a different desired allocation that is permissible within the servicing contract or law.
- Amendments: See “Comments Number 2,” above.
- Prior and Related Legislation:
- AB 2251 (Stone), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2016, enacted the SLSA, operative July 1, 2018, which requires persons servicing student loans in this state, as defined, to become licensed by DBO, comply with specified requirements, and refrain from engaging in specified prohibited acts.
- AB 38 (Stone), Chapter 379, Statutes of 2018 was a clean-up bill to AB 2251, which made several technical changes and added exemptions from the SLSA for guaranty agencies and debt collectors, as specified.
- AB 2251 (Stone), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2016, enacted the SLSA, operative July 1, 2018, which requires persons servicing student loans in this state, as defined, to become licensed by DBO, comply with specified requirements, and refrain from engaging in specified prohibited acts.
LIST OF REGISTERED SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Support
NexGen California (co-sponsor)
Consumer Reports (co-sponsor)
Student Borrower Protection Center (co-sponsor)
Student Debt Crisis (co-sponsor)
Young Invincibles (co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
Americans for Financial Reform
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
Association of Young Americans
Attorney General Xavier Becerra
Beneficial State Foundation
California Asset Building Coalition
California Association of Nonprofits
California Association of Realtors
California Federation of Teachers
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
California LULAC
California Women’s Law Center
Californians for Economic Justice
CalPIRG
City and County of San Francisco
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights
Common Sense Kids Action
Consumer Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
County Welfare Directors Association of California
Courage Campaign
East Bay Community Law Center
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Generation Progress
Housing & Economic Rights Advocates
National Student Loan Defense Network
New Economics for Women
Public Law Center
San Francisco Treasurer & Tax Collector Jose Cisneros
Service Employees International Union
Student Senate for California Community Colleges
The Institute for College Access & Success
UnidosUS
University of California Student Association
Opposition
California Bankers Association
California Credit Union League
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Bankers Association
Student Loan Servicing Alliance
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 376
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Creates the Student Borrower Bill Of Rights (the Act) imposing new requirements on persons engaged in student loan servicing within California, as specified.
Major Provisions
Chapter 1. Student Borrower Bill Of Rights:
- Prohibits a student loan servicer, as defined, from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan within California.
- Defines an act or practice as abusive if it does either of the following:
- Provides appropriate definitions to facilitate the Act, including, but not limited to:
Chapter 2. Rules of the Road:
Establishes standards for student loan servicers in California, requiring them to:
- Post and process student loan payments in a timely manner.
- Apply overpayments in a manner that is in the best financial interest of the borrower.
- Apply partial payments in a manner that minimizes negative impacts to borrowers.
- Ensure past dues fees are reasonable and proportional to the total costs of the loan, as specified.
Chapter 3. Enforcement:
- Requires anyone engaged in servicing a student loan comply with state and federal laws, including the provisions of the Act.
- Provides that any consumer who suffers damage because of the failure of a person engaged in student loan servicing, as defined by the Act, may bring an action on their own behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers against that person to recover or obtain damages, as specified, and as defined by the court.
Chapter 4. California Student Borrower Advocate:
Creates the Student Borrower Advocate and gives the advocate responsibilities that include reciving complaints, reviewing complaints, analyzing data, assisting borrowers, providing public information, analyzing and monitoring the development and implementation of laws and rules, as specified.
Chapter 5. Spotlight on Industry Practices:
Requires the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) monitor for risks to consumers in the student loan servicing industry. It describes the information the Commisoner may gather to complete these tasks including gathering information from servicers and reporting the data publically.
COMMENTS:
Student loan debt has climbed to become the second largest type of household debt in America. Only mortgage debt, which is generally secured by real estate, is larger. Amid ongoing discussions about the negative impacts that this level of debt has on younger student borrowers, new concerns about the negative impacts on the nation's economy have emerged. Large student debt burdens can prevent home ownership, retirement savings, entrepreneurship, an interest in careers that require extra school, or an ability to return to rural areas after graduation.
According to the Author:
With 3,780,000 student loan borrowers across California owing $134.3 billion, it is imperative that California take a strong stance to protect borrowers against bad actors. AB 376 will ensure that California borrowers are protected and can take action if servicers violate these basic protections.
Arguments in Support:
AB 376 establishes the Student Borrower Bill of Rights, ensuring that individuals with student loan debt are given reliable information, quality customer service, and meaningful access to repayment and forgiveness programs. This groundbreaking legislation will make California the first in the nation to offer student loan borrowers the same comprehensive protections that consumers with mortgages and credit cards take for granted.
Arguments in Opposition:
The Student Loan Servicing Alliance states, "this legislation as drafted, both creates potential for more borrower confusion, would potentially increase the cost of student loans for California residents, and most importantly, does not address the real challenges that student loan borrowers face. Our members work on behalf of borrowers to enroll them into the right payment plan for their individual circumstance, while helping them avoid delinquency and default. This is best achieved in a clear and consistent regulatory environment. We would point out that California has recently passed broad legislation that is now being implemented and whose impacts are now being assessed."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, significant special fund costs to DBO in excess of $1 million in the first year and in excess of $790,000 ongoing. These costs include personnel, which this committee assumes to be the Student Borrower Advocate as well as support staff and an additional attorney, as well as one-time administrative costs during initial implementation.
VOTES:
ASM BANKING AND FINANCE: 9-0-3
YES: Limón, Bauer-Kahan, Burke, Cervantes, Gabriel, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Choi, Melendez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: William Herms / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081 FN: 0000918
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 376
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
Policy Committee: | Banking and Finance | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill creates the “Student Borrower Bill of Rights” and imposes new requirements on student loan servicers. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a servicer from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan and establishes new standards and requirements for a servicer, such as that a servicer post and process student loan payments in timely manner and ensure past dues fees are reasonable and proportional to the total costs of the loan.
- Creates a new “Student Borrower Advocate” position within the Department of Business Oversight (DBO), who is responsible for receiving and reviewing complaints and assisting borrowers, among other specified duties.
- Enables a consumer who suffers damage as a result of a loan servicer violating this bill or any other applicable federal law related to student loan servicing to bring an action on their own or on behalf of a similarly situated class.
- Requires DBO to monitor risks for consumers in the student loan servicing industry, which must including developing and publicizing relevant metrics on the performance of student loan servicers.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Significant special fund costs to DBO in excess of $1 million in the first year and in excess of $790,000 ongoing. These costs include personnel, which this committee assumes to be the Student Borrower Advocate as well as support staff and an additional attorney, as well as one-time administrative costs during initial implementation.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. DBO, through the Student Loan Servicing Office, recently began licensing and regulating student loan servicers engaged in business in California. DBO’s oversight includes fielding complaints from borrowers and enforcing violations. DBO’s student loan servicing program was created by AB 2251 (Stone), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2016.
AB 376 builds on this new program by establishing a “Bill of Rights” for borrowers and allowing borrowers to sue servicers if they suffer damages when servicers violate new standards and rules. The author argues that AB 376 will ensure borrowers are provided reliable information and meaningful access to repayment and forgiveness programs.
- How do student loan servicers work? Student loan servicers are not an original lender or loan holder. Instead, servicers contract with lenders to manage loans and process payment plans and respond to borrower questions. These servicers enter into contracts with loan providers, including the federal government, and earn commission on the loans they service. A borrower generally has no control over which company services a loan, and federal rules governing these companies are weak and inconsistent.
- Enforcement actions thus far. While the Student Loan Servicing Office is fairly new, DBO has already engaged with noncompliant servicers. In July 2018, DBO sent letters to 12 servicers that did not properly register with DBO.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Monique Limón, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 376 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
SUBJECT: Student loan servicing
SUMMARY: Creates the Student Borrower Bill Of Rights (the Act) imposing new requirements on persons engaged in student loan servicing within California, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
Chapter 1. Student Borrower Bill Of Rights:
- Prohibits a student loan servicer, as defined, from engaging in abusive acts or practices when servicing a student loan within California.
- Defines an act or practice as abusive if it does either of the following:
- Materially interferes with the ability of a borrower to understand a term or condition of a student loan.
- Takes unreasonable advantage of any student borrower, as specified.
- Provides appropriate definitions to facilitate the Act, including, but not limited to:
- Defines “borrower” as person who has received or agreed to pay a student loan, or a person who shares in the responsibility for repaying a student loan, as specified.
- Defines “Student loan servicer” as any person engaged in the business of servicing student loans, as specified, excluding debt collectors, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 1788.2 of the Civil Code.
Chapter 2. Rules of the Road:
Establishes standards for student loan servicers in California, requiring them to:
- Post and process student loan payments in a timely manner.
- Apply overpayments in a manner that is in the best financial interest of the borrower.
- Apply partial payments in a manner that minimizes negative impacts to borrowers.
- Ensure past dues fees are reasonable and proportional to the total costs of the loan, as specified.
- Diligently oversee its service providers, including third-party service providers, as specified.
- Timely process student loan paperwork, including appropriate training for servicers and access to applications for income-driven repayment plans, as specified.
- Maintain accurate records about borrower’s accounts and that these records be retained for the life of the student loan, unless otherwise prohibited by law.
- Have policies and procedures in place allowing borrowers to escalate a complaint or inquiry to a senior representative if the borrower’s inquiry cannot be handled in a single phone call or the borrower is dissatisfied with the initial qualified request, as defined.
- Protect borrowers from negative consequences related to a borrower’s inquiry, as specified.
- Defines “negative consequence” for purposes of the subdivision as including, but not limited to, negative credit reporting, lost eligibility for a borrower benefit, late fees, interest capitalization or other financial injury.
- Protect borrowers from negative consequences from a sale, assignment, transfer, system conversion, or any other payment made by the transferor service, as specified.
- Ensure all necessary information, as specified, regarding a borrower, a borrower’s account, and a borrower’s student loan accompanies a loan when it transfer to a new person engaged in servicing the student loan within 45 days, as specified.
- Provide for specialized training for any customer service personnel that advises military borrowers, borrowers working in public service, older borrowers, or borrowers with disabilities about student loan repayment benefits and protections.
Chapter 3. Enforcement:
- Requires anyone engaged in servicing a student loan comply with state and federal laws, including the provisions of the Act.
- Provides that any consumer who suffers damage because of the failure of a person engaged in student loan servicing, as defined by the Act, may bring an action on their own behalf and on behalf of a similarly situated class of consumers against that person to recover or obtain damages, as specified, and as defined by the court.
Chapter 4. California Student Borrower Advocate:
Creates the Student Borrower Advocate and gives the advocate responsibilities that include reciving complaints, reviewing complaints, analyzing data, assisting borrowers, providing public information, analyzing and monitoring the development and implementation of laws and rules, as specified.
Chapter 5. Spotlight on Industry Practices:
Requires DBO monitor for risks to consumers in the student loan servicing industry. It describes the information the Commisoner may gather to complete these tasks including gathering information from servicers and reporting the data publically.
EXISTING LAW:
AB 2251 (Stone), Chapter 824, Statutes of 2016: Enacts the Student Loan Servicing Act, operative July 1, 2018, establishing a new licensing law applicable to student loan servicers, administered by DBO, as specified.
AB 38 (Stone) Chapter 379, Statutes of 2018: Changes the Student Loan Servicing Act authorizing the Commissioner of DBO to implement licensee requirements under the Act, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: In the late 1960’s, a political debate took place in California asking the question whether students should be paying a larger share of the cost for the states’ four-year colleges. This began a nearly half-century run on increases to student fees and tuition in California that has resulted in taking California’s four-year state colleges from what was then nearly free to currently over $14,000 for tuition and fees at a UC.
This increase in tuition and fees accompanied an ever-increasing cost of housing, meals, books and supplies. In order to manage the cost of college, significant numbers of students turned to student loans to achieve their college education goals. The federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) reports that today there is over $1.3 trillion in student loan debt nationwide, with over $134 billion in California alone.
The author states:
AB 376 establishes the Student Borrower Bill of Rights, ensuring that individuals with student loan debt are given reliable information, quality customer service, and meaningful access to repayment and forgiveness programs. This groundbreaking legislation will make California the first in the nation to offer student loan borrowers the same comprehensive protections that consumers with mortgages and credit cards take for granted.
After a student loan is taken out, loan servicing companies are the ones that communicate with borrowers about payments, account information, refinancing options, and other issues surrounding their loans. Despite a mountain of evidence that demonstrates rampant predatory actors, it is very clear that the federal government has deliberately stepped back from its duties to protect student borrowers and, in order to protect its consumers California must take action.
With 3,780,000 student loan borrowers across California owing $134.3 billion, it is imperative that California take a strong stance to protect borrowers against bad actors. AB 376 will ensure that California borrowers are protected and can take action if servicers violate these basic protections.
Student loan debt has climbed to become the second largest type of household debt in America. Only mortgage debt, which is generally secured by real estate, is larger. Amid ongoing discussions about the negative impacts that this level of debt has on younger student borrowers, new concerns about the negative impacts on the nation’s economy have emerged. Large student debt burdens can prevent home ownership, retirement savings, entrepreneurship, an interest in careers that require extra school, or an ability to return to rural areas after graduation.
When students take out student loans and inevitably engage with student loan servicers for the scheduling and repayment of those loans it can be stressful and difficult, even when the system works properly. However, to date the CFPB has received over one million student borrower complaints.
This bill contains a provision enabling the student borrower to sue their servicer if the student suffers damages as a result of a servicer’s failure to comply with the provisions of the Act. A student borrower may bring an action for actual damages, injunctive relief, restitution, punitive damages, attorney’s fees, and other relief, including treble damages in certain circumstances.
In 2017, the CFPB filed a lawsuit against several large student loan servicers claiming they systematically and illegally failed borrowers. The Attorney General of California joined three other states in suing Navient, one of the nation’s largest servicers, for failing and misleading borrowers.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Nextgen California (Sponsor)
Americans For Financial Reform
California Asset Building Coalition
California Association Of Nonprofits
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Californians For Economic Justice
Calpirg, California Public Interest Research Group
Coalition For Humane Immigrant Rights
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation Of California
Consumer Reports
East Bay Community Law Center
Housing And Economic Rights Advocates
New Economics For Women
Public Law Center
Student Borrower Protection Center
Student Debt Crisis
The Institute For College Access & Success
Unidosus
Opposition
Student Loan Servicing Alliance
Analysis Prepared by: William Herms / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):