AB 382: Integrated regional water management plans: grant funding: upper watershed health.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-05
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (March 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Referred to Com. on W., P., & W. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 8. |
| Feb 5, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 12, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Water, Parks, and Wildlife |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 20, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 382
Author:(Mathis) – As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2019
Policy Committee: | Water, Parks and Wildlife | Vote: | 14-0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to include a priority preference for regional water management groups undertaking projects to improve upper watershed health upstream and outside the geographic area covered by the groups’ Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) plan when applying for funding under the IRWM grant program. Additionally, this bill:
- Allows a regional water management group to contribute a lower amount of matching funds for projects eligible under this bill if consistent with the general obligation bond providing the funding.
- Applies to grant funding authorized on or after January 1, 2020.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown increased cost pressures to provide future state general obligation bonds, likely in the range of $50 million to $100 million or more in the near term, to allow lower state matching requirements (less than the 50% requirement in Proposition 1) for grants to improve upper watershed health for grants authorized on or after January 1, 2020.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, “In order to further efforts to direct funding towards the maintenance and overall health of our watersheds, incentives must be created that benefit downstream users.” This bill prioritizes investing in forest health and source watersheds to improve California’s water infrastructure.
- Background. SB 1672 (Costa), Chapter 767, Statutes 0f 2002, established the Regional Water Management Planning Act to authorize regional water management groups to prepare and adopt regional plans to address water supply, water quality, flood protection and other water resource issues.
Since then, various general obligation bond acts have provided over $1.5 billion in state funding to support and advance integrated, multi-benefit regional projects through the IRWM program. There are currently 48 regional water management groups, covering 87% of the state geographically and 99% of its population.
- LAO Recommends Incentivizing Upper Watershed Projects Through the IRWM Program. In its April 2018 report on “Improving California’s Forest and Watershed Management,” the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) recommends, among other things, directing DWR to include incentives for watershed health projects in the IRWMP grant application process. According to the LAO:
We recommend that the Legislature require DWR to structure future IRWM grant programs such that regions that opt to undertake projects improving upper watershed health (1) are awarded additional points in the scoring of competitive grants applications and/or (2) face lower local cost‑share requirements (for example, 30 percent rather than 50 percent). These incentives would encourage IRWM regions to invest in projects that benefit their water supply and quality even if they are implemented upstream and outside of their region. These new grant conditions could be imposed for IRWM grants from future bonds.
This bill is consistent with this LAO recommendation.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 12, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON WATER, PARKS, AND WILDLIFE
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 382 (
Author:Mathis) – As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2019
SUBJECT: Integrated regional water management plans: grant funding: upper watershed health
SUMMARY: This bill would prioritize forest watershed health projects within the Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) Process. Specifically, this bill:
- Would make changes to the criteria for granting funds under the IRWM process for projects authorized starting January 1, 2020.
- Would require the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to include in the criteria for project awards preference for projects that improve the upper watershed health (upstream). This may include projects outside a regional water group’s geographic area.
- Requires the bill to be consistent with existing bond acts.
- Would, if consistent with existing general obligation bond acts, lower the local cost share for projects that improve upper watershed health (upstream) and outside the regional water group’s geographic area.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Integrated Regional Water Planning Act of 2002 that authorizes, but does not require, the preparation and adoption of an integrated regional water management plan (IRWMP). (Water Code §10530)
- Provides parameters for the development of an integrated regional water plan, including preparation and adoption of the plan, guidelines, and public notices. Defines a regional water management group as three or more local agencies, at least two of which have statutory authority over water supply or water management, plus those other persons who may be necessary to develop and implement an IRWMP. Much, but not all, of the state is covered by one or more IRWMPs.
- Allows IRWMPs to include regional projects or programs that accomplish any of the following:
- Reduce water demand through agricultural and urban water use efficiency.
- Increase water supplies through, groundwater storage and conjunctive water management, desalination, precipitation enhancement, water recycling, regional and local surface storage, water-use efficiency, and stormwater management.
- Improve operational efficiency and water supply reliability, through conveyance facilities, system reoperation, and water transfers.
- Improve water quality, through improved drinking water treatment and distribution, groundwater and aquifer remediation, matching water quality to water use, wastewater treatment, water pollution prevention, and management of urban and agricultural runoff.
- Improve resource stewardship, through agricultural lands stewardship, ecosystem restoration, flood plain management, recharge area protection, urban land use management, groundwater management, water-dependent recreation, fishery restoration, including fish passage improvement, and watershed management.
- Improve flood management through structural and nonstructural means, or by any other means.
- Propositions 50 and 84, the 2009 water bond, and most current bond proposals require that projects and programs be included in an IRWMP in order to be fundable from the bonds’ Integrated Regional Water Management programs.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
Summary and Purpose: This bill would require the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to include incentives for regional water management groups to undertake projects that promote upper watershed health by prioritizing those projects in the Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) process.
Author’s Statement:
In order to further efforts to direct funding towards the maintenance and overall health of our watersheds, incentives must be created that benefit downstream users. AB 382 creates these incentives by requiring that DWR offer IRWM grant funding preferences for a regional water management group which undertakes projects to improve watershed health upstream and outside of their geographical area. Through proactive and statewide participation in upper watershed health, this measure can ensure that all Californians are able to reap the benefits of a clean and healthy watershed.
Background: According to the author, the majority of the state’s developed water supply originates in its forested source watersheds, and that supply is threatened by overly dense forest conditions and wildfire risk. Recent legislation, Chapter 695 of 2016 (AB 2480, Bloom), defines source watersheds as “integral components of California’s water infrastructure.” Yet despite the inherent interest in maintaining forest health this creates for downstream water users, few of those users are investing in maintaining the health of their source watersheds. While comprehensive statewide data is not available, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) found only a few examples of water or hydropower agencies that are opting to spend their local funds on projects to maintain or improve forest health. Instead, the bulk of funding for forest health programs comes either from state or federal agencies. This ultimately puts our watersheds at risk as cooperation between downstream water management groups and government agencies is crucial in maintaining the health of our watersheds.
Integrated Regional Water Management. Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) is a collaborative effort to identify and implement water management solutions on a regional scale that increase regional self-reliance, reduce conflict, and manage water to concurrently achieve social, environmental, and economic objectives. This approach delivers higher value for investments by considering all interests, providing multiple benefits, and working across jurisdictional boundaries. Examples of multiple benefits include improved water quality, better flood management, restored and enhanced ecosystems, and more reliable surface and groundwater supplies.
The IRWM began in 2002 when the Regional Water Management Planning Act (Chapter 767, SB 1672, Costa) was passed by the Legislature. Since then, various bond acts approved by California voters have provided over $1.5 billion in state funding to support and advance integrated, multi-benefit regional projects. The local match on the state resources has been impressive; often on the order of four to one. Cities, counties, water districts, community/environmental groups, Tribes and others across the state have worked collaboratively to organize and establish 48 regional water management groups, covering over 87 percent of the state's area and 99 percent of its population.
LAO Report on Improving California’s Forest and Watershed Management. The LAO published its report on watershed management in April of 2018. In this report, as detailed below, the LAO made three specific recommendations to take steps to generate additional investments from downstream beneficiaries by (1) requiring the State Water Project to make an annual spending contribution to maintain the health of the Feather River watershed, (2) appropriating $2 million for pilot projects for local water and hydropower agencies to conduct wildfire cost‑avoidance and cost‑benefit studies, and (3) modifying grant criteria for the Integrated Regional Water Management program to encourage spending on watershed health projects. This bill addresses the third of these recommendations. The report is available at LAO.ca.gov.
Relevant sections of the LAO report:
Roughly one‑third of California is forested, including the majority of the watersheds that serve as the key originating water source for millions of people across the state. These forests also provide critical air, wildlife, climate, and recreational benefits. However, a combination of factors have resulted in poor conditions across these forests and watersheds, including excessive vegetation density and an overabundance of small trees and brush. Such conditions have contributed to more prevalent and severe wildfires and unprecedented tree mortality in recent years, and experts are concerned these trends will continue if steps are not taken to significantly improve the health of the state’s forests.
Most of California’s rivers and streams originate in its forests, providing a substantial portion of the water used for drinking and agricultural production. For example, runoff from snow and rain that falls in the Sierra Nevada forestlands ultimately provides about 60 percent of the water supplies used by people across the state.
Forest Management Involves Proactive Activities. “Forest management” is generally defined as the process of planning and implementing practices for the stewardship and use of forests to meet specific environmental, economic, social, and cultural objectives. Activities forest managers employ include timber harvesting (typically for commercial purposes), vegetation thinning (clearing out small trees and brush, often through mechanical means or prescribed burns), and reforestation (planting new trees). As discussed later, research has shown that these are the types of activities that are most effective at preserving and restoring the natural functions and processes of forests, and thereby maximizing the natural benefits that they can provide. Efforts to extinguish active wildfires are not generally considered to be forest management activities, as they are more responsive than proactive.
Threats to Water Supply and Quality, Hydropower Generation. Scientists have identified several ways in which forest density can reduce the amount of water that runs off from source watersheds into rivers and streams for downstream uses. For example, if the forest canopy is too thick, snow will collect on the tops of the trees and be exposed to direct sunlight, causing it to more quickly evaporate rather than collecting on the ground and slowly melting into runoff. A greater volume of trees also means more water may be lost to evapotranspiration—consumption by the trees in order to grow—also leaving less available for runoff. Additionally, mountain meadows that have become overgrown with trees are less able to play their traditional role of “sponges” that store and gradually release snow and water.
Poor forest conditions can also affect water supplies when they contribute to severe fires. After such fires, burned and denuded hillsides are prone to discharging large amounts of sedimentation into streams, rivers, and reservoirs during storms. Downstream, these sediments can affect both water quality (by introducing soils, nutrients, and pollutants into water sources) and water supply (by displacing capacity in reservoirs). Excessive sedimentation in rivers and reservoirs can also impair the ability to generate hydropower when it clogs intakes, turbines, and other components of hydroelectric facilities.
The risk of wildfires also threatens the system that supplies water for millions of downstream water users. Of particular concern for millions of Californians is the risk to the Feather River watershed, which drains into Oroville Lake—the primary water source for the State Water Project (SWP). The SWP, which is operated by the state’s Department of Water Resources (DWR), is a water storage and delivery system that transports water from Northern California to supply 25 million people—two‑thirds of the state’s population—living across the state, as well as 750,000 acres of irrigated farmland mostly in the Central Valley.
The high potential for a fire is also a threat for the Central Valley Project (CVP), a separate water storage and delivery system owned and operated by the federal government. The CVP collects mountain runoff into reservoirs and then delivers it through canals to irrigate about one‑third of all agricultural land in the state, as well as to provide municipal water for close to 1 million households. Fires affecting any of the multiple Cascade and Sierra Nevada watersheds whose runoff feeds reservoirs for the CVP water delivery system would have major implications—in particular for the Pit and McCloud watersheds, which drain into Shasta Lake.
Local Governments Also Spend Money on Forest Health Activities. Counties, cities, special districts, and other local governments also invest in forest health activities within their respective jurisdictions. Examples include Community Wildfire Protection Plans, which some communities develop to identify forest fuel reduction priorities and other preventative measures. These plans are particularly common and encouraged by the federal and state governments in communities located adjacent to forestlands. Some limited examples also exist of mountain regions opting to undertake forest restoration projects intended to preserve local water quality, and using local dollars to match state bond funds from the Integrated Regional Water Management (IRWM) program. (The IRWM program provides bond funding—which must be paired with local funds—for regional groups to implement locally determined water resource projects.) For example, the Madera County IRWM group paired $1.5 million in local funds with an equal amount of state bond funds to reduce fuels in the Sierra National Forest in order to reduce wildfire risk and, in the words of its IRWM grant application, to help “meet long‑term water supply needs, [protect] water quality, and augment/restore environmental conditions.” Investments by local agencies and governments in discretionary forest management programs can be significantly limited in many rural forested areas of the state, however, due to small tax bases and—in many cases—economically disadvantaged populations.
Downstream Beneficiaries Not Contributing Much to Forest Health Activities. As discussed, the majority of the state’s developed water supply originates in its forested source watersheds, and that supply is threatened by overly dense forest conditions and wildfire risk. Yet despite the inherent interest in maintaining forest health this creates for downstream water users, few of those users are investing in maintaining the health of their source watersheds. While comprehensive statewide data are not available, our review found only a few examples of water or hydropower agencies that are opting to spend their local funds on projects to maintain or improve forest health. Instead, as discussed earlier, the bulk of funding for forest health programs comes either from the state or federal agencies.
The limited examples we found of local investments in forest health generally were from agencies receiving water and hydropower directly from nearby forests. These include the Upper Mokelumne River Watershed Authority (a joint powers authority made up of six water agencies) and the Placer County Water Agency. These groups are partnering with other agencies (such as USFS) to improve the health of their watersheds, including undertaking forest thinning and restoration projects. Additionally, a few other groups have paired local funds with state bond funds through the IRWM program to conduct water quality and restoration projects in nearby forested upper watersheds. In contrast, we found few examples of forest investments from agencies located further downstream from source watersheds—that is, those that depend on snowmelt runoff that travels longer distances through the state’s rivers and canals, such as agencies in the Central Valley or Southern California. For example, entities that contract to receive water from the federal Central Valley Project and those from the SWP have not made significant financial contributions to maintaining or improving the health of the forested watersheds above Shasta Dam and Oroville Dam, the originating sources of the water supply upon which they depend.
The connection between watershed health and water supply has received some additional attention from downstream water users in recent years, likely due in part to the increased prevalence of severe wildfires. In 2014, a coalition of five statewide groups—representing the water, forestry, rural, environmental, and agricultural sectors—formed the California Forest Watershed Alliance to advocate for increasing the pace and scale of forest restoration practices to “promote healthier, more resilient forests across California.” Additionally, in 2015 the Association of California Water Agencies issued a report recommending increased investments in improving the resiliency of California’s water sources. These initiatives, however, have stopped short of calling for downstream beneficiaries to invest their own funding in upper watershed health projects. Rather, they primarily call for increased action on the part of the state and federal governments.
Recent legislation, Chapter 695 of 2016 (AB 2480, Bloom), defines source watersheds as “integral components of California’s water infrastructure” and states that forest and ecosystem repair in those watersheds may be funded in similar ways to the maintenance and repair of other water infrastructure. The vast majority of water infrastructure projects are funded through local funds (such as revenues from water user fees), with state and federal funds typically making up a much smaller comparative share. Most local agencies have not yet begun to consider actions to improve watershed health as typical water infrastructure projects.
LAO Recommendation. Incentivize Upper Watershed Projects Through IRWM Program. We recommend encouraging local entities to use local funds (paired with state IRWM grants) for watershed health projects by directing DWR to include incentives for undertaking such projects in the IRWM grant application process. Generally, IRWM grants are allocated as competitive grants to local agencies, and applicants must commit to funding a portion of the project’s cost (typically 50 percent) with local monies. We recommend that the Legislature require DWR to structure future IRWM grant programs such that regions that opt to undertake projects improving upper watershed health (1) are awarded additional points in the scoring of competitive grants applications and/or (2) face lower local cost‑share requirements (for example, 30 percent rather than 50 percent). These incentives would encourage IRWM regions to invest in projects that benefit their water supply and quality even if they are implemented upstream and outside of their region. These new grant conditions could be imposed for IRWM grants from future bonds. Moreover, the Legislature could direct DWR to apply prioritized application scoring for the roughly $200 million in IRWM funds remaining to be appropriated from Proposition 1 (the 2014 water bond). (Proposition 1 language prohibits changes to local match requirements.)
Prior and Related Legislation
AB 2480 (Bloom), Chapter 695, Statutes of 2016, defines source watersheds as “ integral components of California’s water infrastructure.”
SB 1672 (Costa), Chapter 767, Statutes of 2002, the Regional Water Management Planning Act, authorized a regional water management group to prepare and adopt a regional plan that addresses water supply, water quality, flood protection, or other similar issues.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Catherine Freeman / W., P., & W. / (916) 319-2096
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):