AB 394: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route projects: fire safety.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-16
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 12 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 26, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 9). |
| Jun 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on N.R. & W. (Ayes 4. Noes 0.) (June 5). |
| May 1, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and N.R. & W. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 2, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 1.) (March 25). |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | AB 394 Obernolte Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB394 Obernolte et al. By Portantino | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Jun 5, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Natural Resources and Water] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | AB 394 Obernolte Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 25, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Obernolte)
As Enrolled Ver:September 16, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) an egress route project specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) that improves fire safety of an existing residential subdivision if specified conditions are met. Specifically, this bill:
- Exempts from CEQA an egress route project specifically recommended by the Board that improves fire safety of an existing subdivision, if all of the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either a state responsible area (SRA) classified as high or very high fire hazard severity zone or locally-designated very high fire hazard severity zone (VHFHSZ).
- The location of the project does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project does not harm or take any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, the CEQA Guidelines, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The project does not affect known archaeological, historical, or other cultural resources.
- The project is carried out by a public agency.
- The lead agency determines that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any commercial timber harvest is incidental to the project's primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act.
- The lead agency determines that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of the filing of the notice of exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project is exempt, to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
- Sunsets January 1, 2025.
The Senate Amendments:
- Require that the project does not affect known archaeological, historical, or other cultural resources.
- Require the entity carrying out the project, if the project involves substantial tree removal, to have a registered professional forester or the forester's designee onsite on days during which trees are removed to assist with resource identification and protection.
- Require the entity carrying out the project to employ the best management practices set forth in the California Forest Practice Rules to ensure resource protection.
- Provide that the application and implementation of the bill is limited to the purposes of CEQA.
Governor's Veto Message:
This bill exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), until January 1, 2025, egress route projects or activities undertaken by a public agency. The affected projects include those that are specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection to improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision when certain conditions are met.
California's devastating wildfires of 2017 and 2018 amplified the urgent imperative to mitigate risk and build robust community emergency plans, especially for our most vulnerable in the Wildland-Urban Interface (WUI). However, the CEQA exemption provided in this bill is premature and may result in unintended consequences. Without better information on the number, location and potential impacts of future fire safety road construction projects, it is not clear whether statutory changes are needed. Furthermore, it is important that we build solutions around the unique and targeted needs of each community.
COMMENTS:
It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance. First, the CEQA Guidelines provide a categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)). Second, if the project is not exempt from CEQA, but the initial study shows that it would not result in a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration, and no EIR is required. In addition, a road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project's potential to have a significant effect on the environment.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. CAL FIRE acknowledges the importance of planning and its importance to wildland fire safety and risk mitigation. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHSZ; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHSZ; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR's "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
Local jurisdictions with land in the SRA and VHFHSZ must revise their general plan safety elements to include information relating to the protection of the planning area from wildfire, and update that information whenever the housing element is amended. New requirements for wildfire planning in the safety element have increased wildfire planning efforts. Since April 2013, the Board has reviewed 45 safety elements, and has received letters back from jurisdictions explaining which recommendations they did or did not incorporate from 11 of them. Last year, AB 2911 (Friedman) provided more tools for the Board to collaborate with local governments and enhanced its ability to recommend changes based on best practices.
Many developments in the SRA and VHFHSZ were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and they do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
According to the Author:
Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. AB 394 addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that creating, improving, and maintaining egress routes is critical for public safety as illustrated by recent major wildfires in the state. The California Chamber of Commerce notes, "AB 394 is a narrowly tailored CEQA exemption that only applies to a limited set of projects carried out by public agencies, with the primary purpose of conducting fire safety egress projects, with a reasonable sunset period of 2025."
Arguments in Opposition:
None received
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CAL FIRE estimates one-time costs of $756,000 in fiscal year 2019-20 and ongoing costs of about $700,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) to facilitate an expedited review of these critical projects, to conduct hearings as a lead agency, and to process all applicable permits and notices required. Staff notes that some of CAL FIRE's costs would likely be recoverable as part of the overall local project costs. Additionally, the Department of Fish and Wildlife estimates costs of $709,000 for fiscal year 2019-20 and $1,239,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) for increased workload on permits that would have otherwise tiered off of a CEQA document, to monitor local newspapers for notices and review and attend public hearings to provide comments to the lead agency. Staff notes that costs related to other permits would be offset by fee revenue.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 10-1-0
YES: Friedman, Flora, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, Mathis, McCarty, Melendez, Muratsuchi
NO: Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, McCarty, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bloom
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1-6
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager- Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie- Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Mark Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kalra, Reyes, Ting
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-1-2
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Mark Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cristina Garcia, Ting
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0002491
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Obernolte)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) an egress route project specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) that improves fire safety of an existing residential subdivision if specified conditions are met. Specifically, this bill:
- Exempts from CEQA an egress route project specifically recommended by the Board that improves fire safety of an existing subdivision, if all of the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either a state responsible area (SRA) classified as high or very high fire hazard severity zone or locally-designated very high fire hazard severity zone (VHFHSZ).
- The location of the project does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project does not harm or take any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, the CEQA Guidelines, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The project does not affect known archaeological, historical, or other cultural resources.
- The project is carried out by a public agency.
- The lead agency determines that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any commercial timber harvest is incidental to the project's primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act.
- The lead agency determines that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of the filing of the notice of exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project is exempt, to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
- Sunsets January 1, 2025.
The Senate Amendments:
- Require that the project does not affect known archaeological, historical, or other cultural resources.
- Require the entity carrying out the project, if the project involves substantial tree removal, to have a registered professional forester or the forester's designee onsite on days during which trees are removed to assist with resource identification and protection.
- Require the entity carrying out the project to employ the best management practices set forth in the California Forest Practice Rules to ensure resource protection.
- Provide that the application and implementation of the bill is limited to the purposes of CEQA.
COMMENTS:
It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance. First, the CEQA Guidelines provide a categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)). Second, if the project is not exempt from CEQA, but the initial study shows that it would not result in a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration, and no environmental impact report (EIR) is required. In addition, a road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project's potential to have a significant effect on the environment.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. CAL FIRE acknowledges the importance of planning and its importance to wildland fire safety and risk mitigation. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHSZ; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHSZ; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR's "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
Local jurisdictions with land in the SRA and VHFHSZ must revise their general plan safety elements to include information relating to the protection of the planning area from wildfire, and update that information whenever the housing element is amended. New requirements for wildfire planning in the safety element have increased wildfire planning efforts. Since April 2013, the Board has reviewed 45 safety elements, and has received letters back from jurisdictions explaining which recommendations they did or did not incorporate from 11 of them. Last year, AB 2911 (Friedman) provided more tools for the Board to collaborate with local governments and enhanced its ability to recommend changes based on best practices.
Many developments in the SRA and VHFHSZ were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and they do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
According to the Author:
Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. AB 394 addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that creating, improving, and maintaining egress routes is critical for public safety as illustrated by recent major wildfires in the state. The California Chamber of Commerce notes, "AB 394 is a narrowly tailored CEQA exemption that only applies to a limited set of projects carried out by public agencies, with the primary purpose of conducting fire safety egress projects, with a reasonable sunset period of 2025."
Arguments in Opposition:
None received
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CAL FIRE estimates one-time costs of $756,000 in fiscal year 2019-20 and ongoing costs of about $700,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) to facilitate an expedited review of these critical projects, to conduct hearings as a lead agency, and to process all applicable permits and notices required. Staff notes that some of CAL FIRE's costs would likely be recoverable as part of the overall local project costs. Additionally, the Department of Fish and Wildlife estimates costs of $709,000 for fiscal year 2019-20 and $1,239,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) for increased workload on permits that would have otherwise tiered off of a CEQA document, to monitor local newspapers for notices and review and attend public hearings to provide comments to the lead agency. Staff notes that costs related to other permits would be offset by fee revenue.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 10-1-0
YES: Friedman, Flora, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, Mathis, McCarty, Melendez, Muratsuchi
NO: Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, McCarty, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bloom
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1-6
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager‑Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Mark Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kalra, Reyes, Ting
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Wieckowski
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0002212
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 394 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 394
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 6/5/19
AYES: Allen, Bates, Hill, Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/9/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1, 4/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route projects: fire safety
DIGEST:
This bill exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), until January 1, 2025, egress route projects or activities undertaken by a public agency that are specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection that improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 make a technical clarification that a project eligible for the CEQA exemption provided for under this bill does not take any species that are protected by specified state and federal environmental laws.
Existing law:
- Enacts CEQA, which requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Requires, pursuant to the Planning and Zoning Law, cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires. The safety element is required to address evacuation routes, military installations, peakload water supply requirements, and minimum road widths and clearances around structures as they relate to fire hazards (Government Code §65583).
- Requires the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board), in consultation with the State Fire Marshal, to survey local governments to identify existing subdivisions located in a state responsibility area (SRA, defined as areas of the state where the financial responsibility of preventing or suppressing fires has been determined by the Board to be the responsibility of the state) or a very high fire hazard severity (VHFHS) zone without a secondary egress route that are at significant risk and to develop recommendations to improve the subdivision’s fire safety (PRC §4290.5). Authorizes the recommendations to include, but not be limited to, the following:
- Creating secondary access to the subdivision.
- Improvements to the existing access road.
- Other additional fire safety measures.
This bill:
- Exempts from CEQA, until January 1, 2025, an egress route project specifically recommended by the Board that improves the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project is not subject to CEQA pursuant to this bill, to hold a noticed public meeting on the project or activity to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with OPR and the county clerk in the county in which the project is located.
Background
- CEQA
- Overview of CEQA Process. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a ND. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings.
- What is analyzed in an environmental review? An environmental review analyzes the significant direct and indirect environmental impacts of a proposed project and may include water quality, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, transportation and circulation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources. The analysis must also evaluate the cumulative impacts of any past, present, and reasonably foreseeable projects/activities within study areas that are applicable to the resources being evaluated. A study area for a proposed project must not be limited to the footprint of the project because many environmental impacts of a development extend beyond the identified project boundary.
- CEQA provides a hub for multi-disciplinary regulatory process. An environmental review provides a forum for all the described issue areas to be considered together rather than siloed from one another. It provides a comprehensive review of the project, considering all applicable environmental laws and how those laws interact with one another. For example, it would be prudent for a lead agency to know that a proposal to mitigate a significant impact (i.e. alleviate temporary traffic congestion, due to construction of a development project, by detouring traffic to an alternative route) may trigger a new significant impact (i.e. the detour may redirect the impact onto a sensitive resource, such as a habitat of an endangered species). The environmental impact caused by the proposed mitigation measure should be evaluated as well. CEQA provides the opportunity to analyze a broad spectrum of a project’s potential environmental impacts and how each impact may intertwine with one another.
- Local planning. New houses are being built fastest in the places where they are most likely to burn: the wild fringe of urban areas, where neighborhoods are surrounded by canyons, hills or other open land covered in flammable vegetation. This is especially true in Southern California. Between 1990 and 2010, new houses went up twice as fast on the edge of developed lands than in the region as a whole. Riverside County leads the area with over 190,000 more houses built in high-risk areas during that time period, an increase of about 75%. The planning of communities in a way that reduces fire risk can be achieved through ensuring evacuation routes exist, identifying locations where fire breaks can be put in, and ensuring an adequate water supply exists are important steps to protecting communities from fire risks. The fire hardening of homes with the latest fire resistant material can also mitigate the risk of development in the SRA and VHFHS zones.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHS zones; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHS zones; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR’s "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
- Existing development. Many developments in the SRA and VHFHS zones were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has seen record numbers of wildfires in the past few years, which have caused mass amounts of devastation to the residents of this state. In 2017 and 2018 alone, there were over 13,000 wildfires which burned almost 1.4 million acres of the State. Additionally, according to census data, California leads the nation by large numbers when it comes to residents who are wildfire prone with 2,044,800 households at high or extreme risk from wildfires. Texas is a distant second with 715, 300 households.
“The Board of Forestry has been tasked with identifying those communities at high risk of experiencing a wildfire who also lack sufficient egress (exit) routes from their communities, and then making recommendations for how to improve egress in these communities. Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. This bill addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent very narrow set of projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in these fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.”
- Projects eligible for AB 394 exemption. This bill aims to fast track certain projects that would improve a community’s fire safety that are specifically recommended by the Board for that particular community. These expedited projects may include creating secondary access to the community, improvements to the existing access road, or additional fire safety measures.
- What Is Lost With An Exemption From CEQA? It is not unusual for some interests to assert that a particular exemption will expedite construction of a particular type of project and reduce costs. This, however, frequently overlooks the benefits of adequate environmental review where lead and responsible agencies are legally accountable for their actions: to inform decisionmakers and the public about project impacts, identify ways to avoid or significantly reduce environmental damage, prevent environmental damage by requiring feasible alternatives or mitigation measures, disclose to the public reasons why an agency approved a project if significant environmental effects are involved, involve public agencies in the process, and increase public participation in the environmental review and the planning processes.
Because adverse project impacts do not disappear when they are not identified and mitigated, does an exemption result in a direct transfer of responsibility for mitigating impacts from the applicant to the public (i.e., taxpayers) if impacts are ultimately addressed after completion of the project?
A lot of changes can happen in a community and environment over time. The short-term, long-term, and/or permanent consequences of a project should be known by the decisionmakers, the project proponent, and the public before a project is approved, and mitigated or avoided if possible before it is too late – CEQA specifically provides for that informed and responsible decisionmaking. Does the short-term benefit of expediency justify potentially long-term, permanent consequences/damages to the community?
AB 394 does not exempt a specific, identified project, instead exempting any project that is recommended by the Board. Without knowing the specific project, it is difficult to evaluate the potential environmental impacts that will be unmitigated as a result of the exemption. For example, without an environmental review, how do the local governments know things such as congestion, tribal cultural resources, landslides, soil erosion, water-quality impacts from run-off, etc., have been adequately addressed?
- Applicable alternatives. It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance, which could be applicable to AB 394 projects.
- Statutory exemption for work to repair, maintain, or make minor alterations to existing roadways if certain conditions are met (PRC §21080.37).
- Categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)).
- Negative Declaration or Mitigated Negative Declaration May Apply…
If an exemption does not apply, then it should be noted that not all projects subject to CEQA are required to do an EIR. In fact, based on the number of documents submitted to the State Clearinghouse, data shows that most projects do not trigger an EIR.
A lead agency could prepare an ND if the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows potentially significant impacts but the applicant revises the project plan, which would avoid or mitigate those impacts, the lead agency could prepare a MND. These types of environmental reviews tend to be less expensive and time-consuming than an EIR.
- Development projects consistent with a general plan. A road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment (PRC §21083.3).
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 632 (Galgiani, 2019) requires the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection to complete the CEQA review of, and certify, a specified program environmental impact report for a vegetation treatment program by June 30, 2020. SB 632 is being enrolled.
AB 2911 (Friedman, Chapter 641, Statutes of 2018) made various changes to fire safety planning efforts, defensible space requirements, and electrical transmission or distribution lines’ vegetation clearance requirements with the intent to improve the fire safety of California communities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CAL FIRE estimates one-time costs of $756,000 in fiscal year 2019-20 and ongoing costs of about $700,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) to facilitate an expedited review of these critical projects, to conduct hearings as a lead agency, and to process all applicable permits and notices required. Staff notes that some of CAL FIRE’s costs would likely be recoverable as part of the overall local project costs. Additionally, the Department of Fish and Wildlife estimates costs of $709,000 for fiscal year 2019-20 and $1,239,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) for increased workload on permits that would have otherwise tiered off of a CEQA document, to monitor local newspapers for notices and review and attend public hearings to provide comments to the lead agency. Staff notes that costs related to other permits would be offset by fee revenue.
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Forestry Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
County of San Bernardino
Fire Districts Association of California
Rural County Representatives of California
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
South Bay Association Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1, 4/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Mark Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kalra, Reyes, Ting
Prepared by: Genevieve M. Wong / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
9/9/19 18:22:04
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 394 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 394
Amended: 8/13/19 in Senate
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 6/5/19
AYES: Allen, Bates, Hill, Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/9/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1, 4/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route projects: fire safety
DIGEST:
This bill exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), until January 1, 2025, egress route projects or activities undertaken by a public agency that are specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection that improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
Existing law:
- Enacts CEQA, which requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Requires, pursuant to the Planning and Zoning Law, cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires. The safety element is required to address evacuation routes, military installations, peakload water supply requirements, and minimum road widths and clearances around structures as they relate to fire hazards (Government Code §65583).
- Requires the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board), in consultation with the State Fire Marshal, to survey local governments to identify existing subdivisions located in a state responsibility area (SRA, defined as areas of the state where the financial responsibility of preventing or suppressing fires has been determined by the Board to be the responsibility of the state) or a very high fire hazard severity (VHFHS) zone without a secondary egress route that are at significant risk and to develop recommendations to improve the subdivision’s fire safety (PRC §4290.5). Authorizes the recommendations to include, but not be limited to, the following:
- Creating secondary access to the subdivision.
- Improvements to the existing access road.
- Other additional fire safety measures.
This bill:
- Exempts from CEQA, until January 1, 2025, an egress route project specifically recommended by the Board that improves the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project is not subject to CEQA pursuant to this bill, to hold a noticed public meeting on the project or activity to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with OPR and the county clerk in the county in which the project is located.
Background
- CEQA
- Overview of CEQA Process. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a ND. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings.
- What is analyzed in an environmental review? An environmental review analyzes the significant direct and indirect environmental impacts of a proposed project and may include water quality, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, transportation and circulation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources. The analysis must also evaluate the cumulative impacts of any past, present, and reasonably foreseeable projects/activities within study areas that are applicable to the resources being evaluated. A study area for a proposed project must not be limited to the footprint of the project because many environmental impacts of a development extend beyond the identified project boundary.
- CEQA provides a hub for multi-disciplinary regulatory process. An environmental review provides a forum for all the described issue areas to be considered together rather than siloed from one another. It provides a comprehensive review of the project, considering all applicable environmental laws and how those laws interact with one another. For example, it would be prudent for a lead agency to know that a proposal to mitigate a significant impact (i.e. alleviate temporary traffic congestion, due to construction of a development project, by detouring traffic to an alternative route) may trigger a new significant impact (i.e. the detour may redirect the impact onto a sensitive resource, such as a habitat of an endangered species). The environmental impact caused by the proposed mitigation measure should be evaluated as well. CEQA provides the opportunity to analyze a broad spectrum of a project’s potential environmental impacts and how each impact may intertwine with one another.
- Local planning. New houses are being built fastest in the places where they are most likely to burn: the wild fringe of urban areas, where neighborhoods are surrounded by canyons, hills or other open land covered in flammable vegetation. This is especially true in Southern California. Between 1990 and 2010, new houses went up twice as fast on the edge of developed lands than in the region as a whole. Riverside County leads the area with over 190,000 more houses built in high-risk areas during that time period, an increase of about 75%. The planning of communities in a way that reduces fire risk can be achieved through ensuring evacuation routes exist, identifying locations where fire breaks can be put in, and ensuring an adequate water supply exists are important steps to protecting communities from fire risks. The fire hardening of homes with the latest fire resistant material can also mitigate the risk of development in the SRA and VHFHS zones.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHS zones; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHS zones; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR’s "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
- Existing development. Many developments in the SRA and VHFHS zones were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has seen record numbers of wildfires in the past few years, which have caused mass amounts of devastation to the residents of this state. In 2017 and 2018 alone, there were over 13,000 wildfires which burned almost 1.4 million acres of the State. Additionally, according to census data, California leads the nation by large numbers when it comes to residents who are wildfire prone with 2,044,800 households at high or extreme risk from wildfires. Texas is a distant second with 715, 300 households.
“The Board of Forestry has been tasked with identifying those communities at high risk of experiencing a wildfire who also lack sufficient egress (exit) routes from their communities, and then making recommendations for how to improve egress in these communities. Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. This bill addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent very narrow set of projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in these fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.”
- Projects eligible for AB 394 exemption. This bill aims to fast track certain projects that would improve a community’s fire safety that are specifically recommended by the Board for that particular community. These expedited projects may include creating secondary access to the community, improvements to the existing access road, or additional fire safety measures.
- What Is Lost With An Exemption From CEQA? It is not unusual for some interests to assert that a particular exemption will expedite construction of a particular type of project and reduce costs. This, however, frequently overlooks the benefits of adequate environmental review where lead and responsible agencies are legally accountable for their actions: to inform decisionmakers and the public about project impacts, identify ways to avoid or significantly reduce environmental damage, prevent environmental damage by requiring feasible alternatives or mitigation measures, disclose to the public reasons why an agency approved a project if significant environmental effects are involved, involve public agencies in the process, and increase public participation in the environmental review and the planning processes.
Because adverse project impacts do not disappear when they are not identified and mitigated, does an exemption result in a direct transfer of responsibility for mitigating impacts from the applicant to the public (i.e., taxpayers) if impacts are ultimately addressed after completion of the project?
A lot of changes can happen in a community and environment over time. The short-term, long-term, and/or permanent consequences of a project should be known by the decisionmakers, the project proponent, and the public before a project is approved, and mitigated or avoided if possible before it is too late – CEQA specifically provides for that informed and responsible decisionmaking. Does the short-term benefit of expediency justify potentially long-term, permanent consequences/damages to the community?
AB 394 does not exempt a specific, identified project, instead exempting any project that is recommended by the Board. Without knowing the specific project, it is difficult to evaluate the potential environmental impacts that will be unmitigated as a result of the exemption. For example, without an environmental review, how do the local governments know things such as congestion, tribal cultural resources, landslides, soil erosion, water-quality impacts from run-off, etc., have been adequately addressed?
- Applicable alternatives. It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance, which could be applicable to AB 394 projects.
- Statutory exemption for work to repair, maintain, or make minor alterations to existing roadways if certain conditions are met (PRC §21080.37).
- Categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)).
- Negative Declaration or Mitigated Negative Declaration May Apply..
If an exemption does not apply, then it should be noted that not all projects subject to CEQA are required to do an EIR. In fact, based on the number of documents submitted to the State Clearinghouse, data shows that most projects do not trigger an EIR.
A lead agency could prepare an ND if the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows potentially significant impacts but the applicant revises the project plan, which would avoid or mitigate those impacts, the lead agency could prepare a MND. These types of environmental reviews tend to be less expensive and time-consuming than an EIR. - Development projects consistent with a general plan. A road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment (PRC §21083.3).
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 632 (Galgiani, 2019) requires the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection to complete the CEQA review of, and certify, a specified program environmental impact report for a vegetation treatment program by June 30, 2020. SB 632 is pending action in the Assembly.
AB 2911 (Friedman, Chapter 641, Statutes of 2018) made various changes to fire safety planning efforts, defensible space requirements, and electrical transmission or distribution lines’ vegetation clearance requirements with the intent to improve the fire safety of California communities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CAL FIRE estimates one-time costs of $756,000 in fiscal year 2019-20 and ongoing costs of about $700,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) to facilitate an expedited review of these critical projects, to conduct hearings as a lead agency, and to process all applicable permits and notices required. Staff notes that some of CAL FIRE’s costs would likely be recoverable as part of the overall local project costs. Additionally, the Department of Fish and Wildlife estimates costs of $709,000 for fiscal year 2019-20 and $1,239,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) for increased workload on permits that would have otherwise tired off of a CEQA document, to monitor local newspapers for notices and review and attend public hearings to provide comments to the lead agency. Staff notes that costs related to other permits would be offset by fee revenue.
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fire Chiefs Association
California Forestry Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
County of San Bernardino
Fire Districts Association of California
Rural County Representatives of California
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
South Bay Association Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-1, 4/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Mark Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kalra, Reyes, Ting
Prepared by: Genevieve M. Wong / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
9/1/19 10:14:02
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 394 (Obernolte) - California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route projects: fire safety
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would exempt from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), until January 1, 2025, egress route projects undertaken by a public agency that are specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (BOF) that improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFire) estimates one-time costs of $756,000 in fiscal year 2019-20 and ongoing costs of about $700,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) to facilitate an expedited review of these critical projects, to conduct hearings as a lead agency, and to process all applicable permits and notices required. Staff notes that some of CalFire’s costs would likely be recoverable as part of the overall local project costs.
- The Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) estimates costs of $709,000 for fiscal year 2019-20 and $1,239,000 annually thereafter (General Fund) for increased workload on permits that would have otherwise tired off of a CEQA document, to monitor local newspapers for notices and review and attend public hearings to provide comments to the lead agency. Staff notes that costs related to other permits would be offset by fee revenue.
Background:
CEQA. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a ND. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Existing development and egress routes. Many developments in high fire hazard zones were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, until January 1, 2025, exempt from CEQA egress route projects undertaken by a public agency that are specifically recommended by BOF that improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met. The bill would require the lead agency to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments before determining that a project is exempt. The bill would require the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research and with the clerk of the county in which the project will be located.
Related Legislation:
SB 632 (Galgiani) requires BOF to complete the CEQA review of, and certify, a specified program environmental impact report for a vegetation treatment program by June 30, 2020. SB 632 is in the Assembly pending referral.
AB 2911 (Friedman, Chapter 641, Statutes of 2018) made various changes to fire safety planning efforts, defensible space requirements, and electrical transmission or distribution lines’ vegetation clearance requirements with the intent to improve the fire safety of California communities.
Staff Comments:
Staff notes that while state departments may incur some costs for additional workload associated with permitting in the absence of a CEQA process or for acting as a lead agency, most of these costs would be offset by permit fee revenue or otherwise recoverable.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Author: | Obernolte | ||
Version: | June 13, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | William Craven | ||
Subject: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route project or activity: fire safety
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Existing law:
- The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA),
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Existing law, the Planning and Zoning Law,
- Requires cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires (Government Code (Gov. C.) §65583).
- Requires the safety element to address evacuation routes, military installations, peakload water supply requirements, and minimum road widths and clearances around structures as they relate to fire hazards.
- Requires cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires (Government Code (Gov. C.) §65583).
- Requires the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board), in consultation with the State Fire Marshall, to survey local governments to identify existing subdivisions located in a state responsibility area (SRA, defined as areas of the state where the financial responsibility of preventing or suppressing fires has been determined by the Board to be the responsibility of the state) or a very high fire hazard severity zone (VHFHSZ) without a secondary egress route that are at significant risk and to develop recommendations to improve the subdivision’s fire safety (PRC §4290.5). Authorizes the recommendations to include, but not be limited to, the following:
- Creating secondary access to the subdivision.
- Improvements to the existing access road.
- Other additional fire safety measures.
- Contains the Forestry Practice Act, other forestry laws, the California Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act and several other laws designed to protect natural resources from various projects.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill:
- Exempts from CEQA, until January 1, 2025, an egress route project or activity specifically recommended by the Board that improves the fire safety of an existing subdivision if the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either (1) a SRA that is classified as high or very high fire hazard severity zone or (2) locally-designated VHFHSZ.
- The location of the project or activity does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project or activity does not harm any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project or activity does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The project or activity does not affect known archaeological, historical, or other cultural resources.
- The project is carried out by a public agency.
- The lead agency determines that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any commercial timber harvest is incidental to the project’s primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act and other specified conditions are met regarding when a registered professional forester must be on site and the project’s compliance with specific forestry regulations adopted by the Board of Forestry which may require consultation with other resource professionals.
- The lead agency determines that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of filing the notice of exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project or activity is not subject to CEQA pursuant to this bill, to hold a noticed public meeting on the project or activity to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with OPR and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
- According to the author, “California has seen record numbers of wildfires in the past few years, which have caused mass amounts of devastation to the residents of this state. In 2017 and 2018 alone, there were over 13,000 wildfires which burned almost 1.4 million acres of the State. Additionally, according to census data, California leads the nation by large numbers when it comes to residents who are wildfire prone with 2,044,800 households at high or extreme risk from wildfires. Texas is a distant second with 715,300 households.
The Board of Forestry has been tasked with identifying those communities at high risk of experiencing a wildfire who also lack sufficient egress (exit) routes from their communities, and then making recommendations for how to improve egress in these communities. Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. This bill addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent very narrow set of projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in these fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
None received
COMMENTS
- This committee’s jurisdiction does not include CEQA. The CEQA provisions of this bill were approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
- Thus, while some might ask this committee to create additional CEQA amendments that limit the size, width, or length of the egress roads in question, staff thinks those amendments are beyond the scope of this committee’s jurisdiction and that any CEQA amendments must be narrowly-targeted and by agreement with the author and the Senate Environmental Quality Committee. The following amendments meet those criteria.
- Staff is recommending the deletion of the word “activity” when used in conjunction with the term “egress route or activity” where it appears in the bill. (Amendment 1).
- Staff is recommending that on page 2, line 16 to add the term “community” so that the bill applies to smaller communities as well as to more traditional subdivisions. Staff notes that the definition of subdivision does not include an acreage limitation for the 30 dwelling threshold. (Amendment 2)
- Staff recommends that the provision on page 3, line 13, also include a cross reference to Sec. 15380 of the CEQA Guidelines which provides specific protections in additions to the referenced statutes. (Amendment 3)
- Staff recommends a general savings clause that clarifies that no other substantive provision of any applicable law is affected by the CEQA exemption in this bill assuming the bill advances beyond this Committee. (Amendment 4)
- Staff notes that the provision on page 3, line 8 which requires a determination by the lead agency that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress may be lost over time. These roads may likely be a magnet for future development with adverse consequences to egress during a wildfire event
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
Delete “activity” on page 2, line 22; page 3, line 7; page 3, line 5; page 3, line 6; page 3, line 28; page 3, line 32; page 3, line 36; page 3, line 40; page 4, line 14; page 4, line 20; page 4, line 21; and page 4, line 26.
AMENDMENT 2
Page 2, line 16, add “or community” after “development”
AMENDMENT 3
Page 3, line 13. Add cross reference to CEQA Guidelines Section 15380.
AMENDMENT 4
Add savings clause as developed by Legislative Counsel.
SUPPORT
California Civil Justice Association
Southwest California Legislative Council
San Bernadino County
San Diego County
California Business Properties Association
California Building Industry Association
California Association of Realtors
Rural County Representatives of California
California State Association of Counties
California Special Districts Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California Fire Chiefs Association
Fire District Association of California
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
OPPOSITION
None Received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 394
Author: | Obernolte | ||
Version: | 4/2/2019 | Hearing Date: | 6/5/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Genevieve M. Wong | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: egress route project or activity: fire safety
DIGEST: Exempts from CEQA, until January 1, 2025, egress route projects or activities undertaken by a public agency that are specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection that improve the fire safety of an existing subdivision if certain conditions are met.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA),
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration (ND), mitigated negative declaration (MND), or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Existing law, the Planning and Zoning Law,
- Requires cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires (Government Code (Gov. C.) §65583).
- Requires the safety element to address evacuation routes, military installations, peakload water supply requirements, and minimum road widths and clearances around structures as they relate to fire hazards.
- Requires cities and counties to prepare and adopt a general plan, including a safety element for the protection of the community from any unreasonable risks associated with, among other things, wildland and urban fires (Government Code (Gov. C.) §65583).
- Requires the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board), in consultation with the State Fire Marshall, to survey local governments to identify existing subdivisions located in a state responsibility area (SRA, defined as areas of the state where the financial responsibility of preventing or suppressing fires has been determined by the Board to be the responsibility of the state) or a very high fire hazard severity zone (VHFHSZ) without a secondary egress route that are at significant risk and to develop recommendations to improve the subdivision’s fire safety (PRC §4290.5). Authorizes the recommendations to include, but not be limited to, the following:
- Creating secondary access to the subdivision.
- Improvements to the existing access road.
- Other additional fire safety measures.
This bill:
- Exempts from CEQA, until January 1, 2025, an egress route project or activity specifically recommended by the Board that improves the fire safety of an existing subdivision if the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either (1) a SRA that is classified as high or very high fire hazard severity zone or (2) locally-designated VHFHSZ.
- The location of the project or activity does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project or activity does not harm any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project or activity does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The project is carried out by a public agency.
- The lead agency determines that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any commercial timber harvest is incidental to the project’s primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act.
- The lead agency determines that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of filing the notice of exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project or activity is not subject to CEQA pursuant to this bill, to hold a noticed public meeting on the project or activity to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with OPR and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
Background
- Background on CEQA.
- Overview of CEQA Process. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a ND. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
- Overview of CEQA Process. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a ND. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings.
- What is analyzed in an environmental review? An environmental review analyzes the significant direct and indirect environmental impacts of a proposed project and may include water quality, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, transportation and circulation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources. The analysis must also evaluate the cumulative impacts of any past, present, and reasonably foreseeable projects/activities within study areas that are applicable to the resources being evaluated. A study area for a proposed project must not be limited to the footprint of the project because many environmental impacts of a development extend beyond the identified project boundary.
- CEQA provides a hub for multi-disciplinary regulatory process. An environmental review provides a forum for all the described issue areas to be considered together rather than siloed from one another. It provides a comprehensive review of the project, considering all applicable environmental laws and how those laws interact with one another. For example, it would be prudent for a lead agency to know that a proposal to mitigate a significant impact (i.e. alleviate temporary traffic congestion, due to construction of a development project, by detouring traffic to an alternative route) may trigger a new significant impact (i.e. the detour may redirect the impact onto a sensitive resource, such as a habitat of an endangered species). The environmental impact caused by the proposed mitigation measure should be evaluated as well. CEQA provides the opportunity to analyze a broad spectrum of a project’s potential environmental impacts and how each impact may intertwine with one another.
- What is analyzed in an environmental review? An environmental review analyzes the significant direct and indirect environmental impacts of a proposed project and may include water quality, surface and subsurface hydrology, land use and agricultural resources, transportation and circulation, air quality and greenhouse gas emissions, terrestrial and aquatic biological resources, aesthetics, geology and soils, recreation, public services and utilities such as water supply and wastewater disposal, and cultural resources. The analysis must also evaluate the cumulative impacts of any past, present, and reasonably foreseeable projects/activities within study areas that are applicable to the resources being evaluated. A study area for a proposed project must not be limited to the footprint of the project because many environmental impacts of a development extend beyond the identified project boundary.
- Increasing Threat of Wildfires. Wildfires are a significant threat in California, particularly in recent years as the landscape responds to climate change and decades of fire suppression. Over 75 percent of forested areas and other woody
vegetation types are burning less frequently than historic averages, and fire sizes have increased significantly over the last 17 years. Drought conditions, low snow pack accumulation, and extreme temperature highs have also been prevalent in the last decade and are expected to worsen as climate change continues to alter landscapes and local climates.
These conditions have resulted in the largest, most destructive, and deadliest wildfires on record in California history, all occurring in 2018. Fifteen of the state's 20 largest wildfires have occurred since 2002. The 2018 Mendocino Complex, the state's largest wildfire, burned 1.5 times as many acres as the next largest fire. Fourteen of the state's 20 most destructive wildfires have occurred since 2003; the 2018 Camp Fire destroyed more than three times as many structures as the next most destructive fire. Ten of the state's 20 deadliest wildfires have occurred since 2003, and the 2018 Camp Fire resulted in more than twice as many deaths as the next deadliest fire.
Historically, California's wildfires were less severe, burning fewer acres and destroying fewer structures by factors of two and three, respectively, when compared with modern fire statistics. Additionally, fire seasons have been extending further into the winter months since 2000. The fire sieges in October and December of 2017 serve as prime examples of the expanding fire season. As environmental conditions become more conducive to larger and more severe wildfires, development in the wildland-urban interface (WUI) is also on the rise. A 2018 study indicates that the number of houses in the WUI increased nationwide by 41 percent between 1990 and 2010.
In response to these changing environmental conditions and the increased risk to California's citizens, former Governor Brown issued EO B-52-18, which mandates an increase in the pace and scale of fire fuel treatment programs to reduce wildfire risk. On March 22, 2019, Governor Newsom proclaimed a state of emergency throughout California ahead of the coming fire season. The Governor directed his administration to immediately expedite forest management projects to protect 200 of California’s most wildfire-vulnerable communities.
The emergency proclamation provides the Secretary of Natural Resources and the Secretary of CalEPA discretion to suspend state environmental permitting requirements on a case-by-case basis in order to allow projects to get underway immediately, including suspending requirements to prepare CEQA documents. For each project, CAL FIRE will follow Best Management Practices to avoid impacting any environmentally and culturally sensitive areas within these 35 project areas, including identifying and avoiding sensitive areas.
- Local planning. New houses are being built fastest in the places where they are most likely to burn: the wild fringe of urban areas, where neighborhoods are surrounded by canyons, hills or other open land covered in flammable vegetation. This is especially true in Southern California. Between 1990 and 2010, new houses went up twice as fast on the edge of developed lands than in the region as a whole. Riverside County leads the area with over 190,000 more houses built in high-risk areas during that time period, an increase of about 75%. The planning of communities in a way that reduces fire risk can be achieved through ensuring evacuation routes exist, identifying locations where fire breaks can be put in, and ensuring an adequate water supply exists are important steps to protecting communities from fire risks. The fire hardening of homes with the latest fire resistant material can also mitigate the risk of development in the SRA and VHFHS zones.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHS zones; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHS zones; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR’s "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
- Existing development. Many developments in the SRA and VHFHS zones were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has seen record numbers of wildfires in the past few years, which have caused mass amounts of devastation to the residents of this state. In 2017 and 2018 alone, there were over 13,000 wildfires which burned almost 1.4 million acres of the State. Additionally, according to census data, California leads the nation by large numbers when it comes to residents who are wildfire prone with 2,044,800 households at high or extreme risk from wildfires. Texas is a distant second with 715, 300 households.
The Board of Forestry has been tasked with identifying those communities at high risk of experiencing a wildfire who also lack sufficient egress (exit) routes from their communities, and then making recommendations for how to improve egress in these communities. Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. This bill addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent very narrow set of projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in these fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.”
- Projects eligible for AB 394 exemption. This bill would aim to fast track certain projects and activities that would improve a community’s fire safety that are specifically recommended by the Board for that particular community. These expedited projects and activities may include creating secondary access to the community, improvements to the existing access road, or additional fire safety measures.
- What Is Lost With An Exemption From CEQA?
It is not unusual for some interests to assert that a particular exemption will expedite construction of a particular type of project and reduce costs. This, however, frequently overlooks the benefits of adequate environmental review where lead and responsible agencies are legally accountable for their actions: to inform decisionmakers and the public about project impacts, identify ways to avoid or significantly reduce environmental damage, prevent environmental damage by requiring feasible alternatives or mitigation measures, disclose to the public reasons why an agency approved a project if significant environmental effects are involved, involve public agencies in the process, and increase public participation in the environmental review and the planning processes.
Because adverse project impacts do not disappear when they are not identified and mitigated, does an exemption result in a direct transfer of responsibility for mitigating impacts from the applicant to the public (i.e., taxpayers) if impacts are ultimately addressed after completion of the project?
Despite criticisms that CEQA often results in litigation, CEQA-related litigation is relatively rare. Those citing CEQA and CEQA litigation as a problem do not indicate the result of that litigation. Were significant impacts that were not evaluated in the initial document ultimately addressed? What would have been the result if those impacts had not been mitigated (e.g., flooding, exposure of people to hazards, inadequate public services, congestion).
A lot of changes can happen in a community and environment over time. The short-term, long-term, and/or permanent consequences of a project should be known by the decisionmakers, the project proponent, and the public before a project is approved, and mitigated or avoided if possible before it is too late – CEQA specifically provides for that informed and responsible decisionmaking. Does the short-term benefit of expediency justify potentially long-term, permanent consequences/damages to the community?
SB 394 does not exempt a specific, identified project, instead exempting any project that is recommended by the Board. Without knowing the specific project, it is difficult to evaluate the potential environmental impacts that will be unmitigated as a result of the exemption. For example, without an environmental review, how do the local governments know things such as congestion, tribal cultural resources, landslides, soil erosion, water-quality impacts from run-off, etc., have been adequately addressed?
- Applicable alternatives. It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance, which could be applicable to AB 394 projects.
- Statutory exemption for work to repair, maintain, or make minor alterations to existing roadways if certain conditions are met (PRC §21080.37).
- Categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)).
- Negative Declaration or Mitigated Negative Declaration May Apply..
If an exemption does not apply, then it should be noted that not all projects subject to CEQA are required to do an EIR. In fact, based on the number of documents submitted to the State Clearinghouse, data shows that most projects do not trigger an EIR.
A lead agency could prepare an ND if the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows potentially significant impacts but the applicant revises the project plan, which would avoid or mitigate those impacts, the lead agency could prepare a MND. These types of environmental reviews tend to be less expensive and time-consuming than an EIR. - Development projects consistent with a general plan. A road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment (PRC §21083.3).
- Statutory exemption for work to repair, maintain, or make minor alterations to existing roadways if certain conditions are met (PRC §21080.37).
- Identifying and avoiding sensitive areas. While implementing Governor Newsom’s order to expedite the specified forest management projects, CAL FIRE will take certain steps to identify and avoid sensitive natural and archaeological resources. Similar to AB 394, CAL FIRE will avoid disturbing, threatening, or damaging known sites of rare, threatened, or endangered plants or animals. However, CAL FIRE will also take the following additional environmentally protective steps:
- Avoid damaging known archaeological or historical sites based on information available from the Information Centers of the California Historical Resources Information System within the Department of Parks and Recreation. Cal FIRE will utilize this system during project scoping to evaluate the presence of cultural resources and ensure cultural resource protection by avoiding those sites. Where unmapped resources may be, trained field crews (including but not limited to Registered Professional Foresters) will be onsite to identify possible resource issues ahead of project work as it progresses.
- Have a registered Professional Forester or designee on site during project implementation to assist with resource identification and protection as the projects progress.
- Employ standard Forest Practice Rule best management practices for projects to ensure resource protection and require environmental resource professionals early in project design, including Registered Professional Foresters, environmental scientists, archeologists, hydrologists, soil scientists, fire scientists, and other experts in natural resource protection.
AB 394 would bypass the environmental review for egress route projects and activities, which could potentially cause permanent damage to natural and archaeological resources. Without environmental review, will the Board know of unique circumstances of the area and potential impacts on the environment? While the bill does provide for a noticed public meeting before making a determination that the project is exempt from CEQA, shouldn’t the project or activity, at the very least, be held to the same standards and procedures that CAL FIRE is currently employing for the implementation of Governor Newsom’s expedited forest management projects?
The committee may wish to amend the bill to require the projects and activities to be subject to the same environmental considerations given to the expedited forest management projects.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 632 (Galgiani) requires the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection to complete the CEQA review of, and certify, a specified program environmental impact report for a vegetation treatment program by June 30, 2020. SB 632 is in the Assembly pending referral.
AB 2911 (Friedman, Chapter 641, Statutes of 2018) made various changes to fire safety planning efforts, defensible space requirements, and electrical transmission or distribution lines’ vegetation clearance requirements with the intent to improve the fire safety of California communities.
DOUBLE REFERRAL
If this measure if approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fire Chiefs Association (CFCA)
Civil Justice Association of California
Fire Districts Association of California (FDAC)
County of San Bernardino
Rural County Representatives of California
Southwest California Legislative Council
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Obernolte)
As Amended Ver:April 2, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) an egress route project or activity specifically recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) that improves fire safety of an existing residential subdivision if specified conditions are met.
Major Provisions
- Exempts from CEQA an egress route project or activity specifically recommended by the Board that improves fire safety of an existing subdivision, if all of the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either a state responsible area (SRA) classified as high or very high fire hazard severity zone or locally-designated very high fire hazard severity zone (VHFHSZ).
- The location of the project or activity does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project or activity does not harm any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project or activity does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The project is carried out by a public agency.
- The lead agency determines that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any commercial timber harvest is incidental to the project’s primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act.
- The lead agency determines that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of the filing of the notice of exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project or activity is exempt, to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
- Sunsets January 1, 2025.
COMMENTS:
CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an environmental impact report (EIR).
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance. First, the CEQA Guidelines provide a categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)). Second, if the project is not exempt from CEQA, but the initial study shows that it would not result in a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration, and no EIR is required. In addition, a road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment.
Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. CAL FIRE acknowledges the importance of planning and its importance to wildland fire safety and risk mitigation. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHSZ; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHSZ; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR’s "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
Local jurisdictions with land in the SRA and VHFHSZ must revise their general plan safety elements to include information relating to the protection of the planning area from wildfire, and update that information whenever the housing element is amended. New requirements for wildfire planning in the safety element have increased wildfire planning efforts. Since April 2013, the Board has reviewed 45 safety elements, and has received letters back from jurisdictions explaining which recommendations they did or did not incorporate from 11 of them. Last year, AB 2911 (Friedman), Chapter 641, provided more tools for the Board to collaborate with local governments and enhanced its ability to recommend changes based on best practices.
Many developments in the SRA and VHFHSZ were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and they do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
According to the Author:
Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. AB 394 addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that creating, improving, and maintaining egress routes is critical for public safety as illustrated by recent major wildfires in the state. The California Chamber of Commerce notes, "AB 394 is a narrowly tailored CEQA exemption that only applies to a limited set of projects carried out by public agencies, with the primary purpose of conducting fire safety egress projects, with a reasonable sunset period of 2025
Arguments in Opposition:
None received
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, no additional state costs.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 10-1-0
YES: Friedman, Flora, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, Mathis, McCarty, Melendez, Muratsuchi
NO: Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, McCarty, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bloom
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 2, 2019
CONSULTANT: Patricia Pfautch / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0000228
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 394
Author:(Obernolte) – As Amended Ver:April 2, 2019
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 10 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: >
SUMMARY:
This bill provides an exemption from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for egress route (exit) projects or activities undertaken by a public agency specifically recommended by the Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) to improve the fire safety of existing subdivisions if all the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision, defined as a residential development of more than 30 dwelling units, has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in a state responsibility area classified as a high or very high fire hazard zone or is located in a very high fire hazard severity zone, as specified.
- The location of the project or activity does not contain wetlands or riparian areas, as defined.
- The project or activity does not harm any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project or activity does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- The lead agency determines the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Any timber harvest is incidental to the project’s primary purpose and complies with the Forest Practice Act.
- The lead agency determines the project proponent has obtained or will obtain all funding and any local, state and federal approvals within one year of filing the notice exemption.
- All roads that comprise the egress route are publicly accessible to vehicular traffic at all times.
Additionally, this bill:
- Requires the lead agency, before determining a project or activity is exempt, to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research (OPR) and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
- Sunsets January 1, 2025.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No additional state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. AB 394 addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.
- Background. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects approved or undertaken by public agencies. For projects that are not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine if the projects may have a significant impact on the environment. If the initial study shows no significant impact, a negative declaration is issued. If the project may significantly impact the environment, a full Environmental Impact Report (EIR) must be prepared, including the identification of environmental impacts and required mitigation, compliance and reporting measures intended to reduce the environmental impacts to the extent feasible. CEQA also provides for public process and legal challenges.
CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA Guidelines.
CEQA provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance. CEQA Guidelines provide a categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "existing highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)).
Additionally, if a project is not exempt from CEQA, but the initial study shows it would not result in a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration and no EIR is required. In addition, a road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment.
This bill provides a limited CEQA exemption for egress route projects undertaken by a public agency and recommended by the Board to improve the safety of an existing subdivision located in areas known to be fire hazard zones.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 25, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 394 (
Author:Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 6, 2019
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act: exemption: fire safety
SUMMARY: Exempts from the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) a project or activity recommended by the State Board of Forestry and Fire Protection (Board) that improves fire safety of an existing residential subdivision if specified conditions are met.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated negative declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines).
- Exempts, until January 1, 2020, minor roadway repairs, maintenance and minor alterations meeting the following conditions:
- The project is carried out by a city or county with a population of less than 100,000 to improve public safety.
- The project does not cross a "waterway" (defined as a bay, estuary, lake, pond, river, slough, or a perennial, intermittent, or ephemeral stream, lake, or estuarine-marine shoreline).
- Excludes projects on state roadways; sites containing wetlands, riparian areas, and significant wildlife habitat value; and that harm any protected species, impact cultural resources, or affect scenic resources.
- Requires the lead agency to mitigate potential vehicular traffic and safety impacts, and bicycle and pedestrian safety impacts; hold a noticed public hearing on the project to hear and respond to public comments; and to file a notice of exemption with the Office of Planning and Research (OPR).
- Requires on or before July 1, 2021, and every five years thereafter, the Board, in consultation with the State Fire Marshall, to survey local governments to identify existing subdivisions (i.e., an existing residential development of more than 30 dwelling units) in the state responsible area (SRA) or locally-designated “very high fire hazard severity zones” (VHFHSZ) without a secondary egress route that are at significant fire risk, then develop recommendations to improve the subdivision's fire safety. Authorizes the recommendations to include, but not be limited to, the following:
- Creating secondary access to the subdivision;
- Improvement to existing access road; and,
- Other additional fire safety measures.
THIS BILL:
- Exempts from CEQA a project or activity, recommended by the Board pursuant to the provisions referenced above, that improves fire safety of an existing subdivision, if all of the following conditions are met:
- The subdivision has insufficient egress routes, as determined by the lead agency.
- The subdivision is located in either an SRA or VHFHSZ.
- The location of the project or activity does not contain wetlands or riparian areas.
- The project or activity does not harm any species protected by the federal Endangered Species Act, the Native Plant Protection Act, or the California Endangered Species Act.
- The project or activity does not cause the destruction or removal of any species protected by an applicable local ordinance.
- Requires the lead agency, before determining that a project or activity is exempt, to hold a noticed public meeting to hear and respond to public comments.
- Requires the lead agency to file a notice of exemption with OPR and the county clerk in the county in which the project or activity is located.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- CEQA review for roads. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of applicable projects undertaken or approved by public agencies. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
It should be noted that CEQA already provides alternatives to comprehensive environmental review for minor projects, including road maintenance. First, the CEQA Guidelines provide a categorical exemption for work on existing facilities where there is negligible expansion of an existing use, specifically including "(e)xisting highways and streets, sidewalks, gutters, bicycle and pedestrian trails, and similar facilities," (CEQA Guidelines, Section 15301(c)). Second, if the project is not exempt from CEQA, but the initial study shows that it would not result in a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration, and no EIR is required. In addition, a road project that has been considered in a local planning EIR would be subject to abbreviated review, or possibly exemption, depending on the project’s potential to have a significant effect on the environment.
- Local fire safety planning. Cities and counties are required to adopt a comprehensive general plan with various elements including a safety element for protection of the community from unreasonable risks associated with various hazards, including wildfires. CAL FIRE acknowledges the importance of planning and its importance to wildland fire safety and risk mitigation. Land use planning incorporates safety element requirements for state SRA and VHFHSZ; requires local general plan safety elements, upon the next revision of the housing element on or after January 1, 2014, to be reviewed and updated as necessary to address the risk of fire in the SRA and VHFHSZ; requires each safety element update to take into account the most recent version of OPR’s "Fire Hazard Planning" document; and requires OPR to include a reference to materials related to fire hazards or fire safety.
Local jurisdictions with land in the SRA and VHFHSZ must revise their general plan safety elements to include information relating to the protection of the planning area from wildfire, and update that information whenever the housing element is amended. New requirements for wildfire planning in the safety element have increased wildfire planning efforts. Since April 2013, the Board has reviewed 45 safety elements, and has received letters back from jurisdictions explaining which recommendations they did or did not incorporate from 11 of them. Last year, AB 2911 (Friedman) provided more tools for the Board to collaborate with local governments and enhanced its ability to recommend changes based on best practices.
Many developments in the SRA and VHFHSZ were constructed prior to building standards and the fire prevention regulations developed by the Board, including limits on dead end roads. These older nonconforming developments are not required to take proactive steps to reduce their fire risk, and could be in jeopardy because their homes are not fire resistant and they do not have secondary access roads. Lack of a secondary road is a serious problem that could leave people trapped and unable to escape a wildfire.
- Author’s statement:
Given the unpredictability of wildfires, these projects identified by the Board of Forestry are of the utmost importance and must be implemented as soon as possible to prevent more destruction and save lives. People living in these communities need protection now and deserve every effort from the state to expedite these vital projects. AB 394 addresses this problem by exempting from the burdensome CEQA process these urgent projects recommended by the Board of Forestry to improve fire safety in fire-prone subdivisions identified as lacking sufficient egress (exit) routes.
- Suggested amendments. The author and the committee may wish to consider adopting the following amendments:
- Limit eligibility for the exemption to specific egress route projects identified by the Board of Forestry.
- Limit to SRA lands classified as high or very high, as well as locally-designated VHFHSZs.
- Limit to projects undertaken by a public agency.
- Require the lead agency to determine that the primary purpose of the project is fire safety egress.
- Require any commercial timber harvest incidental to that purpose to comply with the Forest Practices Act.
- Require the lead agency to determine that the project has obtained, or is able to obtain, all necessary funding and any federal, state, and local approvals within one year of filing of the notice of exemption.
- Require all roads to be publicly accessible at all times.
- Sunset the exemption on January 1, 2025.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Forestry Association
California Special Districts Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Rural County Representatives of California
San Bernardino County
Southwest California Legislative Council
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Lawrence Lingbloom / NAT. RES. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):