AB 407: Fluoroscopy and radiography permit or certification and continuing education: exceptions.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-01
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (June 24). |
| Jun 17, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 20, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 8). |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. (Ayes 14. Noes 1.) (April 9). |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and B. & P. |
| Feb 8, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 20, 2019 | AB 407 Santiago Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Business and Professions] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 407 (Santiago) - Fluoroscopy and radiography permit or certification and continuing education: exceptions
Version: July 1, 2019 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 8 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
Assembly Bill 407 would authorize a physician and surgeon, or podiatrist, who complies with specified radiation training, to provide fluoroscopy and radiography services, and may supervise radiologic technologies prior to receiving a supervisor and operator’s permit or certification.
Fiscal Impact:
According to the Department of Public Health (CDPH), there are about 175,635 licensed physicians, surgeons, and podiatrists. Approximately 11 percent (or, 20,000) of these licensees currently hold a CDPH-issued authorization. The remaining 155,635 could apply for new permit. Staff notes:
- $400,000 General Fund in FY 2019-20 and FY 2020-21, for staff to develop regulations, prepare required rulemaking documentation, issue public notices, and conduct public hearings. Limited-term workload for regulation promulgation and development.
- Unknown, potentially ongoing, mid-tens of thousands, General Fund for increased workload commensurate with a possible increase in applicants. However, it is unknown the number of licensees who will apply for a new permit, or the rate at which applicants submit specified information to CDPH for the increased workload. Additional personnel may be needed on an ongoing basis.
No anticipated costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA).
Background:
- The CDPH Radiologic Health Branch certifies radiological technologists, physicians, and surgeons, to use certain radiologic technology (HSC §114870). Currently law authorizes only a licensed physician and surgeon, podiatrist, chiropractor, or any person practicing a licensed healing art, or any technician working under the direct and immediate supervision of those persons, to operate or maintain any X-ray fluoroscope, or other equipment or apparatus employing roentgen rays, in the fitting of shoes or other footwear or in the viewing of bones in the feet; and prohibits any healing arts licensee from administering or using diagnostic, mammographic, or therapeutic X-rays on human beings unless that person is certified and acting within the scope of that certification. (HSC § 107110).
According to the Food and Drug Administration, fluoroscopy is a type of medical imaging, where movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (“X-ray dye”) through the body can be seen in detail.
In California, a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit is required to operate fluoroscopy equipment. To obtain such a permit, an applicant must currently pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists.
According to the CDPH, close to 8,800 physicians and podiatrists currently hold valid fluoroscopy permits.
Proposed Law:
AB 407 would authorize a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who complies with specified radiation safety training, may provide fluoroscopy and radiography services and may supervise radiologic technologists prior to receiving a Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permit or certification.
The bill would require a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who has completed the radiation safety training provided by a facility accredited by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Conditions for Coverage (CfC) relating to radiation safety, to submit evidence that they have completed the facility’s radiation safety training to CDPH within 60 days of completing the training.
The bill would require the CMS CfC training to serve in lieu of passing the Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permitting or certification test require by CDPH.
The bill would require CDPH, after receiving evidence that the radiation safety training is complete, along with a copy of their valid license and any required and reasonable permit or certification fee, to issue the physician and surgeon or the doctor of podiatric medicine a Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permit or certification without requiring a permitting or certification examination.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 407 Hearing Date: June 24, 2019
Author: | Santiago | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: Fluoroscopy and radiography permit or certification and continuing education: exceptions
SUMMARY:
Authorizes a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who works in a setting that is in compliance with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' (CMS) Conditions for Coverage (CfC) relating to radiation safety, to provide fluoroscopy services without a fluoroscopy permit or certification. States that a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who works in a setting that is in compliance with the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety satisfies the requirement for fluoroscopy continuing education.
Existing law:
- Provides the Radiologic Health Branch (RHB) within the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) with responsibility for administering and enforcing the Radiologic Technology Act. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §§ 106955 et seq.)
- Requires the RHB to provide for the certification of radiologic technologists, as well as physicians and surgeons, to use certain radiologic technology. (HSC § 114870)
- Requires the RHB to issue a fluoroscopy permit to a qualified licensee of the healing arts. (HSC § 114872)
- Authorizes only a licensed physician and surgeon, podiatrist, chiropractor, or any person practicing a licensed healing art, or any technician working under the direct and immediate supervision of those persons, to operate or maintain any X-ray fluoroscope, or other equipment or apparatus employing roentgen rays, in the fitting of shoes or other footwear or in the viewing of bones in the feet. (HSC § 106955)
- Prohibits any healing arts licensee from administering or using diagnostic, mammographic, or therapeutic X-rays on human beings unless that person is certified and acting within the scope of that certification. (HSC § 107110)
- Allows the RHB to grant limited-term special permits to persons exempting them from certification requirements if there is substantial evidence that the people in the locality in which the exemption is sought would be denied adequate medical care because of unavailability of certified radiologic technologists. (HSC § 114885)
- Requires those holding a fluoroscopy permit, in the two years immediately preceding the expiration date of that permit, to earn approved continuing education (CE) credits, including credits in radiation safety for the clinical uses of fluoroscopy. (Title 17, CCR § 30403 (b))
This bill:
- Authorizes a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine to provide fluoroscopy and radiography services and supervise radiologic technologists without a fluoroscopy permit if they have completed the radiation safety training provided by a facility accredited by the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety.
- Requires a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine who has completed the radiation safety training provided by a facility accredited by the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety to submit evidence that they have completed the facility’s radiation safety training to the CDPH within 60 days of completing the training. States that the training shall serve in lieu of passing the test required by the CDPH for fluoroscopy permit and requires CDPH, after receiving evidence that the training is complete, to issue the permit.
- Specifies that a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine who works in a setting that is in compliance with the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety satisfies the requirement for fluoroscopy and radiography continuing education.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations analysis dated May 8, 2019, this bill will result in minor and absorbable costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the California Podiatric Medical Association and California Orthopaedic Association. According to the Author, “fluoroscopy is an important diagnostic tool for surgeons to ensure that when a surgeon is setting a bone (fracture), the bone is positioned correctly before closing the incision. If the bone is not set correctly, the patient may have to go back into surgery and have the bone rebroken to have the bone aligned correctly.”
The Author states that “With the exception of radiologists, all physicians, osteopaths, and podiatrists must pass a fluoroscopy certification exam to be able to utilize and operate fluoroscopy equipment in a surgical procedure. California is one of, if not the only, state that requires a separate fluoroscopy certificate.” The Author contends that “to obtain a fluoroscopy and radiography permit under current California law, physicians and surgeons, and doctors of podiatric medicine, are required to undergo a laborious and lengthy examination process that can sometimes take months to complete, start to finish. This examination only exists in California and goes well beyond what is necessary to ensure radiation safety. California’s requirements are extremely cumbersome, requiring letters by mail, and a 45 day wait time to take a test and receive results. This is the most onerous in the nation and results in patients not having the benefit in surgery or requiring more doctors to join the surgery which adds to delays and costs in surgeries. We need to be streamlining and making more cost-efficient the best delivery of care for Californians which this bill will help do while still ensuring surgeons are trained.”
- Background.
Fluoroscopy. According to the Food and Drug Administration, fluoroscopy is a type of medical imaging that shows a continuous X-ray image on a monitor, much like an X-ray movie. During a fluoroscopy procedure, an X-ray beam is passed through the body. The image is transmitted to a monitor so that the movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (“X-ray dye”) through the body can be seen in detail. Fluoroscopy is used in a wide variety of examinations and procedures to diagnose or treat patients. Some examples are: barium X-rays and enemas (to view the gastrointestinal tract); catheter insertion and manipulation (to direct the movement of a catheter through blood vessels, bile ducts or the urinary system); placement of devices within the body, such as stents (to open narrowed or blocked blood vessels); angiograms (to visualize blood vessels and organs); and, orthopedic surgery (to guide joint replacements and treatment of fractures). Like most other forms of radiologic procedures, use of this technology is regulated through the CDPH, and healing arts licensees must meet certain training and certification requirements to perform fluoroscopy services.
In California, a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit is required to operate fluoroscopy equipment. To obtain such a permit, an applicant must currently pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists. According to the CDPH, close to 8,800 physicians and podiatrists currently hold valid fluoroscopy permits.
In order to participate in and receive federal payments from Medicare or Medicaid programs, a health care organization must meet the government requirements for program participation, including a certification of compliance with the health and safety requirements. The CfC certification is achieved based on either a survey conducted by a state agency on behalf of the federal government, such as the CMS, or by a national accrediting organization, such as The Joint Commission, that has been recognized by the CMS as having standards and a survey process that meet or exceed Medicare’s requirements.
The CfC now requires that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers must maintain, or have available, radiologic services according to the needs of the patients. These new standards specifically require that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers must verify and document that individuals who use fluoroscopic equipment participate in ongoing education that includes annual training on radiation dose optimization techniques, and safe procedures for operation of the equipment. Because the supporters of this bill believe that these requirements under the CfC are effectively duplicative with the requirements for a fluoroscopy permit from the RHB, obtaining eligibility to perform fluoroscopy services in a compliant setting should sufficiently take the place of the permit examination.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters note that “While other states requiring training, nothing amounts to the burden in California. The test is overseen by the Radiologic Health Branch of the California Department of Public Health. The process to take and pass the test is cumbersome, requiring letters by mail, and a 45 day wait time after taking the test to receive results. That means that doctors who move to California and want to start their practice, may have a delay of up to six months before they are able to use fluoroscopy in surgery. For patients, that is bad–either the patient cannot have the benefit of fluoroscopy or radiography in surgery, which is less than ideal patient care, or a second doctor must join the surgeon in the operating rate, to push a button to activate the equipment, which leads to additional cost and potential delays in surgery.”
The group notes that “Assembly Bill 407 will solve this problem by allowing an additional way for surgeons to have permission to use fluoroscopy and radiography in surgery. This year, the Joint Commission who accredits over 21,000 facilities nationwide, has imposed additional requirements on facilities which require them to annually train physicians using fluoroscopy in fluoroscopy radiation safety in order for the hospital and surgery center to meet the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) radiation safety accreditation standards. Additionally, the annual training will count for four of the ten hours for continuing medical education regarding radiation safety required by the Radiologic Health Branch. Assembly Bill 407 will streamline a process and allow surgeons to get into practice in California more quickly and to use this important technology in hospital and outpatient surgery settings”
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Radiological Society (CRS) states that the existing permit process that requires the physician to demonstrate sufficient knowledge of radiation safety exists to protect the patient and the physician from unnecessary radiation exposure. CRS also opposes substituting the CMS CfC because the existing test for fluoroscopy permit is subject to review and is updated every five years. The examination covers radiation safety related to fluoroscopy equipment operation as opposed to clinical procedures. For the years 2016-2018 passage rate for physicians were 83%, thus the test is not an impediment to physician compliance.
The California Society of Radiologic Technologists opposes removing DPH's oversight of these practitioners because of safety concerns.
- Drafting Issues and Suggested Amendments.
Clarification. This bill proposes to waive the examination requirement currently necessary to obtain a fluoroscopy permit if the provider completes radiation safety training provided by an accredited facility so that the practitioner is able to provide fluoroscopy and radiography services to patients once that training is completed, and while they wait for the DPH to process their paperwork and issue the fluoroscopy permit. If the intent is for a trained practitioner who has completed the appropriate training but is delayed from providing fluoroscopy and radiography services due to a DPH wait time to receive the actual permit, the bill should be clarified and amended according to the following:
On page 3, in line 6, strike “without” and replace with “prior to receiving”
On page 3, in line 17, after “Health.”, insert (d)
(b) Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who complies with subdivision (c), may provide fluoroscopy and radiography services and may supervise radiologic technologists without prior to receiving a Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permit or certification.
(c) A physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who has completed the radiation safety training provided by a facility accredited by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Conditions for Coverage relating to radiation safety, shall submit evidence that they have completed the facility’s radiation safety training to the State Department of Public Health within 60 days of completing the training. That training shall serve in lieu of passing the Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permitting or certification test required by the State Department of Public Health.
(d) After receiving evidence that the radiation safety training is complete, along with a copy of their valid license and any required and reasonable permit or certification fee, the State Department of Public Health shall issue the physician and surgeon or the doctor of podiatric medicine a Fluoroscopy X-ray Supervisor and Operator’s permit or certification without requiring a permitting or certification examination.
What about residents and physicians and surgeons practicing with a postgraduate training license? SB 798 (Hill, Chapter 775, Statutes of 2017) updated postgraduate training requirements for licensure as a physician and surgeon from one or two years of postgraduate training to three years of postgraduate training, beginning in 2020, to ensure that licensed physicians have the training necessary to carry out their responsibilities. Practitioners undergoing postgraduate training (like a residency program) will obtain a postgraduate training license to ensure that they are able to practice according to the standards of their program and the abilities provided pursuant to their particular training. There will likely be individuals holding a postgraduate training license who may also be deserving of the efficiency and streamlined process for obtaining a fluoroscopy permit that this bill provides. The Author may wish to clarify that these individuals are eligible to provide fluoroscopy services in the same manner as other physician and surgeon licensees.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
California Chapter, American College of Cardiology
California Orthopaedic Association
California Podiatric Medical Association
Opposition:
California Radiological Society
California Society of Radiologic Technologists
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 407
Author:(Santiago)
As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Permits a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who works in a setting that is in compliance with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services' (CMS) Conditions for Coverage (CfC) relating to radiation safety, to provide fluoroscopy services without a fluoroscopy permit or certification. States that a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine, who works in a setting that is in compliance with the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety satisfies the requirement for fluoroscopy continuing education, as specified.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
California requirements. In California, the Radiology Technology Act defines a fluoroscopy as a technique for obtaining, continuously or periodically, a sequence of X-ray patterns and presenting them directly, or through a transfer and optional processing, simultaneously and continuously as visible images. To use fluoroscopy equipment, one must obtain either a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit. One of the requirements to obtain a permit is to pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists (AART). A fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit is also issued to a licentiate of the healing arts defined as a licensed physician and surgeon, licensed podiatrist, or licensed chiropractor. To supervise a radiologic technologist in the operation of fluoroscopy equipment or to operate fluoroscopy equipment, a physician, podiatrist or chiropractor must pass the examination administered by AART. According to DPH, as of June 1, 2018, there are 8,771 physicians and podiatrists with current/valid fluoroscopy permits.
CMS CfC. This bill provides that if a setting complies with the CfC described above, a physician or doctor of podiatric medicine can provide fluoroscopy services without obtaining a permit or certificate from DPH.
In order to participate in and receive federal payments from Medicare or Medicaid programs, a health care organization must meet the government requirements for program participation, including a certification of compliance with the health and safety requirements called CfC or Conditions of Participation, which are set forth in federal regulations. The certification is achieved based on either a survey conducted by a state agency on behalf of the federal government, such as CMS, or by a national accrediting organization, such as The Joint Commission, that has been recognized by CMS (through a process called "deeming") as having standards and a survey process that meet or exceed Medicare's requirements.
The CfC specified in this bill are codified in Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations Section 482.26. The regulations state that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs) must maintain, or have available, radiologic services according to the needs of the patients. The standard for the safety of patients and personnel is as follows:
- Proper safety precautions must be maintained against radiation hazards. This includes adequate shielding for patients, personnel, and facilities, as well as appropriate storage, use, and disposal of radioactive materials;
- Periodic inspection of equipment must be made and hazards identified must be promptly corrected;
- Radiation workers must be checked periodically, by the use of exposure meters or badge tests, for amount of radiation exposure; and,
- Radiologic services must be provided only on the order of practitioners with clinical privileges or, consistent with State law, of other practitioners authorized by the medical staff and the governing body to order the services;
The sponsors point out that beginning January 1, 2019, the Joint Commission which accredits 21,000 facilities nationwide has imposed additional requirements on facilities for providing fluoroscopy services. The new standards state that for hospitals and ASC's, they must verify and document that individuals who use fluoroscopic equipment participate in ongoing education that includes annual training on radiation dose optimization techniques, and safe procedures for operation of the equipment. The sponsors indicate that compliance with these new standards should be a sufficient substitute for the existing fluoroscopy permit or certificate requirements.
According to the Author:
According to the author, this bill is essential to improve access to important fluoroscopy procedures. Today, to obtain a fluoroscopy permit, physicians and surgeons, and doctors of podiatric medicine, are required to undergo a laborious and lengthy examination process that can sometimes take months to complete, start to finish. This examination only exists in California and goes well beyond what is necessary to ensure radiation safety.
Arguments in Support:
The California Orthopaedic Association and the California Podiatric Medical Association, the cosponsors of this bill, state that this bill will streamline the process and allow physicians to enter into practice more quickly.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Radiological Society (CRS) states that the existing permit process that requires the physician to demonstrate sufficient knowledge of radiation safety exists to protect the patient and the physician from unnecessary radiation exposure. CRS also opposes substituting the CMS CfC because the existing test for fluoroscopy permit is subject to review and is updated every five years. The examination covers radiation safety related to fluoroscopy equipment operation as opposed to clinical procedures. For the years 2016-2018 passage rate for physicians were 83%, thus the test is not an impediment to physician compliance. The California Society of Radiologic Technologists opposes removing DPH's oversight of these practitioners because of safety concerns.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) are expected to be minor and absorbable
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 14-1-0
YES: Wood, Mayes, Aguiar-Curry, Bigelow, Bonta, Burke, Wicks, Flora, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago
NO: Waldron
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 20-0-0
YES: Low, Brough, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Dahle, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Rosielyn Pulmano / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000410
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 407
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 14 - 1 |
Business and Professions | Vote: | 20 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows for a physician or a doctor of podiatric medicine to provide fluoroscopy services without a fluoroscopy permit or certification if they are providing those services in a setting that is compliant with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Conditions for Coverage relating to radiation safety.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) are expected to be minor and absorbable.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is intended to allow medical professionals to use fluoroscopy without what supporters describe as a duplicative and unnecessary level of oversight in settings that are already compliant with federal law.
- Background. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration describes fluoroscopy as
“a type of medical imaging that shows a continuous X-ray image on a monitor, much like an X-ray movie. During a fluoroscopy procedure, an X-ray beam is passed through the body. The image is transmitted to a monitor so the movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (‘X-ray dye’) through the body can be seen in detail.”
In California, a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit is required to operate fluoroscopy equipment. To obtain such a permit, an applicant must currently pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists. According to the CDPH, approximately 8,800 physicians and podiatrists currently hold valid fluoroscopy permits.
The supporters of this bill point out that the current timeline for an applicant to sign up for, take and pass the permit examination is relatively protracted, taking up to six months for an applicant to ultimately receive their results. Supporters of this bill believe federal requirements are effectively duplicative with the requirements for a fluoroscopy permit from the Radiological Health Branch at CDPH; thus, obtaining eligibility to perform fluoroscopy services in a compliant setting should take the place of the permit examination.
- Support. California Podiatric Medical Association (CPMA) is co-sponsoring this bill. The CPMA explains all physicians (with exception of radiologists), osteopaths and podiatrists must pass a fluoroscopy certification test to utilize and operate fluoroscopy equipment in a surgical procedure, and that California is one of, if not the only, state that requires a separate fluoroscopy certification. California Orthopaedic Association (COA) is also a co-sponsor of this bill.
- Opposition. The California Radiological Society (CRS) opposes the bill. CRS states the existing test for a fluoroscopy permit ensures, safety is subject to review and is updated approximately every five years. The California Society of Radiologic Technologists (CSRT), representing over 12,000 Radiologic Technologists in California, also opposes the bill for similar reasons, contenting because of existing standards for fluoroscopy services, there has been no public safety alarm for unsafe practice due to over exposure from medical radiation of fluoroscopy.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 407
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
SUBJECT: Fluoroscopy permit or certification and continuing education: exceptions.
SUMMARY: Allows for a physician and surgeon or a doctor of podiatric medicine to provide fluoroscopy services without a fluoroscopy permit or certification if they are providing those services a setting that is compliant with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Conditions for Coverage (CfC) relating to radiation safety.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides the Radiologic Health Branch (RHB) within the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) with responsibility for administering and enforcing the Radiologic Technology Act. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §§ 106955 et seq.)
- Requires the RHB within the CDPH to provide for the certification of radiologic technologists, as well as physicians and surgeons, to use certain radiologic technology. (HSC § 114870)
- Requires the RHB within the CDPH to issue a fluoroscopy permit to a qualified licensee of the healing arts. (HSC § 114872)
- Authorizes only a licensed physician and surgeon, podiatrist, chiropractor, or any person practicing a licensed healing art, or any technician working under the direct and immediate supervision of those persons, to operate or maintain any X-ray fluoroscope, or other equipment or apparatus employing roentgen rays, in the fitting of shoes or other footwear or in the viewing of bones in the feet. (HSC § 106955)
- Prohibits any healing arts licensee from administering or using diagnostic, mammographic, or therapeutic X-rays on human beings unless that person is certified and acting within the scope of that certification. (HSC § 107110)
- Allows the RHB within the CDPH to grant limited-term special permits to persons exempting them from certification requirements if there is substantial evidence that the people in the locality in which the exemption is sought would be denied adequate medical care because of unavailability of certified radiologic technologists. (HSC § 114885)
THIS BILL:
- Allows a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine, to provide fluoroscopy services without a permit or certification from the RHB if they work in a setting that is compliant with the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety.
- Exempts a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine from fluoroscopy continuing education requirements prescribed by regulations if they work in a setting that is in compliance with the CMS CfC.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the California Podiatric Medical Association and the California Orthopaedic Association. According to the author:
AB 407 is essential to improve access to important fluoroscopy procedures. Today, to obtain a fluoroscopy permit, physicians and surgeons, and doctors of podiatric medicine, are required to undergo a laborious and lengthy examination process that can sometimes take months to complete, start to finish. This examination only exists in California and goes well beyond what is necessary to ensure radiation safety.
As of January 1, 2019, all fluoroscopy operators working in facilities accredited by the Joint Commission are now required to undergo radiation safety training to maintain their privileges. This on-site training, more specific to their clinical practice, will be provided on an annual basis and surveyed by the accrediting agency, and, unless the law is changed, this will be in addition to the exam. With this new radiation safety requirement in place, it just makes sense that anyone undergoing such training and deemed competent in radiation safety should not be withheld a fluoroscopy certification simply because they need to pass an additional test. These surgeons should be able to perform fluoroscopy in any CMS accredited facility following their radiation safety guidelines. It is time we update this archaic system, embrace this new training, and deploy more providers who can safely perform this procedure and treat patients.
Background.
The U.S. Food and Drug Administration describes fluoroscopy as “a type of medical imaging that shows a continuous X-ray image on a monitor, much like an X-ray movie. During a fluoroscopy procedure, an X-ray beam is passed through the body. The image is transmitted to a monitor so the movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (‘X-ray dye’) through the body can be seen in detail.” Like most other forms of radiologic procedures, use of this technology is regulated through the CDPH, and healing arts licensees must meet certain training and certification requirements to perform fluoroscopy services.
In California, a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit is required to operate fluoroscopy equipment. To obtain such a permit, an applicant must currently pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists. According to the CDPH, approximately 8,771 physicians and podiatrists currently hold valid fluoroscopy permits.
The supporters of this bill point out that the current timeline for an applicant to sign up for, take, and pass the permit examination is relatively protracted, taking up to six months for an applicant to ultimately receive their results. Because the examination must only be taken and passed once, most practitioners whose initial licensure takes place within California will sit for the permit exam immediately upon eligibility, and there is no significant interruption in their subsequent ability to perform those services if relevant to their practice. However, because California is unique in requiring this examination to perform fluoroscopy services, practitioners coming to California from other states can potentially see their ability to perform services interrupted as they must wait until they are able to take and pass the permit exam.
As an alternative to the existing process, the author of this bill points to new requirements mandated by the CMS CfC. In order to participate in and receive federal payments from Medicare or Medicaid programs, a health care organization must meet the government requirements for program participation, including a certification of compliance with the health and safety requirements. The CfC certification is achieved based on either a survey conducted by a state agency on behalf of the federal government, such as the CMS, or by a national accrediting organization, such as The Joint Commission, that has been recognized by the CMS as having standards and a survey process that meet or exceed Medicare’s requirements.
The CfC now requires that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers must maintain, or have available, radiologic services according to the needs of the patients. These new standards specifically require that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers must verify and document that individuals who use fluoroscopic equipment participate in ongoing education that includes annual training on radiation dose optimization techniques, and safe procedures for operation of the equipment. Because the supporters of this bill believe that these requirements under the CfC are effectively duplicative with the requirements for a fluoroscopy permit from the RHB, obtaining eligibility to perform fluoroscopy services in a compliant setting should sufficiently take the place of the permit examination.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The California Podiatric Medical Association (CPMA) is co-sponsoring this bill. The CPMA explains that “with exception of radiologists, all physicians, osteopaths, and podiatrists must pass a fluoroscopy certification test to utilize and operate fluoroscopy equipment in a surgical procedure. California is one of, if not the only, state that requires a separate fluoroscopy certification.” The CPMA argues that the permit exam “is not specialty specific and can take several months for a surgeon to apply to take the state-mandated fluoroscopy certification test, be scheduled to take the test by the third-party testing facility and learn the results of the testing. This delays their ability to use this important diagnostic tool for the best patient care. If the surgeon is not certified to utilize fluoroscopy in their surgeries, patients will not have the benefit of this important diagnostic tool.”
The California Orthopaedic Association (COA) is co-sponsoring this bill. According to the COA, “California is the only state in the country that requires a test or certification for doctors to use fluoroscopy.” The COA believes that “the process to take and pass the test is cumbersome, requiring letters by mail, and a 45 day wait time after taking the test to receive results. That means that doctors who move to California and want to start their practice, may have a delay of up to six months before they are able to use fluoroscopy in surgery.” The COA argues that this “leads to additional cost and potential delays in surgery.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The California Radiological Society (CRS) opposes the bill. The CRS states that “The existing test for a fluoroscopy permit is subject to review and is updated approximately every 5 years. The exam covers radiation safety related to fluoroscopy equipment operation as opposed to specific clinical procedures. For the years 2016-2018 passage rate for physicians was 83%. Clearly the test is not an impediment to physician compliance.” The CRS states that while it has “heard complaints regarding the time delays in obtaining the permit” and “would welcome the opportunity to work with them and CDPH to make the completion process timelier,” they “do not support the bypass of the permit process.”
The California Society of Radiologic Technologists (CSRT), representing over 12,000 Radiologic Technologists in California, opposes the bill. The CSRT argues that because of existing standards for fluoroscopy services, “there has been no public safety alarm for unsafe practice due to over exposure from medical radiation of fluoroscopy.” The CSRT believes that “oversight should not be taken away from the branch that is designed to protect the public, radiation workers and the environment.” The CSRT finally asks, “why would members of our legislature seek to withdraw one of the elements that have proven to be effective in providing medical safety for Fluoroscopy?”
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Orthopaedic Association (Sponsor)
California Podiatric Medical Association (Sponsor)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
California Radiological Society
California Society of Radiologic Technologists
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 407
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:March 28, 2019
SUBJECT: Fluoroscopy permit or certification and continuing education: exceptions.
SUMMARY: Permits a physician and surgeon, or a doctor of podiatric medicine to provide fluoroscopy services in a setting that is in compliance with the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ (CMS) Conditions for Coverage (CfC) relating to radiation safety without a fluoroscopy permit or certification. States that working in a setting that is in compliance with the CMS CfC relating to radiation safety satisfies the requirement for fluoroscopy continuing education, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Radiologic Health Branch within the Department of Public Health (DPH) which provides for the licensing of radioactive materials, registration of X-ray-producing machines, certification of medical and industrial X-ray and radioactive material users, inspection of facilities using radiation, investigation of radiation incidents, and surveillance of radioactive contamination in the environment.
- Establishes the Radiology Technology Act (RTA) to protect the public and radiation workers from excessive or improper exposure to ionizing radiation.
- Makes it unlawful for any licentiate of the healing arts to administer or use diagnostic, mammographic, or therapeutic X-ray on human beings in this state after January 1, 1972, unless that person is certified, and is acting within the scope of that certification, as specified.
- Specifies continuing education requirements for those that use radiation equipment. Requires for those that hold a fluoroscopy supervisor or operator permit to fulfill four of the 10 continuing education credits in radiation safety for the clinical uses of fluoroscopy.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, this bill is essential to improve access to important fluoroscopy procedures. Today, to obtain a fluoroscopy permit, physicians and surgeons, and doctors of podiatric medicine, are required to undergo a laborious and lengthy examination process that can sometimes take months to complete, start to finish. This examination only exists in California and goes well beyond what is necessary to ensure radiation safety.
As of January 1, 2019, all fluoroscopy operators working in facilities accredited by the Joint Commission are now required to undergo radiation safety training to maintain their privileges. This on-site training, more specific to their clinical practice, will be provided on an annual basis and surveyed by the accrediting agency, and, unless the law is changed, this will be in addition to the required examination. With this new radiation safety requirement in place, it just makes sense that anyone undergoing training and deemed competent in radiation safety should not be withheld a fluoroscopy certification simply because they need to pass an additional test. These physicians should be able to perform fluoroscopy in any CMS accredited facility following compliant with CMS’ radiation safety guidelines. It is time to update this archaic system, adopt new training requirements so that more providers are deployed to safely perform these procedures and treat patients. - BACKGROUND.
- Fluoroscopy. According to the Food and Drug Administration, fluoroscopy is a type of medical imaging that shows a continuous X-ray image on a monitor, much like an X-ray movie. During a fluoroscopy procedure, an X-ray beam is passed through the body. The image is transmitted to a monitor so that the movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (“X-ray dye”) through the body can be seen in detail. Fluoroscopy is used in a wide variety of examinations and procedures to diagnose or treat patients. Some examples are: barium X-rays and enemas (to view the gastrointestinal tract); catheter insertion and manipulation (to direct the movement of a catheter through blood vessels, bile ducts or the urinary system); placement of devices within the body, such as stents (to open narrowed or blocked blood vessels); angiograms (to visualize blood vessels and organs); and, orthopedic surgery (to guide joint replacements and treatment of fractures).
Fluoroscopy carries some risks, as do other X-ray procedures. The radiation dose that a patient receives varies depending on the individual procedure. Fluoroscopy can result in relatively high radiation doses, especially for complex interventional procedures (such as placing stents or other devices inside the body) which require fluoroscopy to be administered for a long period of time. Radiation-related risks associated with fluoroscopy include: radiation-induced injuries to the skin and underlying tissues (“burns”), which occur shortly after the exposure; and, radiation-induced cancers, which may occur sometime later in life.
The statistical probability that a person will experience these effects from a fluoroscopic procedure is very small. Therefore, if the procedure is medically needed, the radiation risks are outweighed by the benefit to the patient. In fact, the radiation risk is usually far less than other risks not associated with radiation, such as anesthesia or sedation, or risks from the treatment itself. To minimize the radiation risk, fluoroscopy should always be performed with the lowest acceptable exposure for the shortest time necessary. - California requirements. In California, the RTA defines a fluoroscopy as a technique for obtaining, continuously or periodically, a sequence of X-ray patterns and presenting them directly, or through a transfer and optional processing, simultaneously and continuously as visible images. To use fluoroscopy equipment, one must obtain either a radiologic technologist fluoroscopy permit, a fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit, or a Physician Assistants fluoroscopy permit. One of the requirements to obtain a permit is to pass an examination administered by the American Registry of Radiology Technologists (AART). A fluoroscopy supervisor and operator permit is also issued to a licentiate of the healing arts defined as a licensed physician and surgeon, licensed podiatrist, or licensed chiropractor. To supervise a radiologic technologist in the operation of fluoroscopy equipment or to operate fluoroscopy equipment, a physician, podiatrist or chiropractor must pass the examination administered by AART. According to DPH, as of June 1, 2018, there are 8,771 physicians and podiatrists with current/valid fluoroscopy permits.
According to the sponsors of this bill, the California Orthopaedic Association and the California Podiatric Medical Association, it can take several months for a physician to apply to take the fluoroscopy examination, be scheduled to take the test administered by AART and receive the results of the testing. They state that this process delays the ability of these practitioners to use this important diagnostic tool for the best patient care. Alternatively, the sponsors state that if a facility is in compliance with the CMS’ CfC relating to radiation safety then the physician or podiatrists does not need to take the examination to obtain a fluoroscopy permit or certification. - CMS CfC. This bill provides that if a setting complies with the CfC described above, a physician or doctor of podiatric medicine can provide fluoroscopy services without obtaining a permit or certificate from DPH.
In order to participate in and receive federal payments from Medicare or Medicaid programs, a health care organization must meet the government requirements for program participation, including a certification of compliance with the health and safety requirements called CfC or Conditions of Participation, which are set forth in federal regulations. The certification is achieved based on either a survey conducted by a state agency on behalf of the federal government, such as CMS, or by a national accrediting organization, such as The Joint Commission, that has been recognized by CMS (through a process called “deeming”) as having standards and a survey process that meet or exceed Medicare’s requirements.
- Fluoroscopy. According to the Food and Drug Administration, fluoroscopy is a type of medical imaging that shows a continuous X-ray image on a monitor, much like an X-ray movie. During a fluoroscopy procedure, an X-ray beam is passed through the body. The image is transmitted to a monitor so that the movement of a body part or of an instrument or contrast agent (“X-ray dye”) through the body can be seen in detail. Fluoroscopy is used in a wide variety of examinations and procedures to diagnose or treat patients. Some examples are: barium X-rays and enemas (to view the gastrointestinal tract); catheter insertion and manipulation (to direct the movement of a catheter through blood vessels, bile ducts or the urinary system); placement of devices within the body, such as stents (to open narrowed or blocked blood vessels); angiograms (to visualize blood vessels and organs); and, orthopedic surgery (to guide joint replacements and treatment of fractures).
The CfC specified in this bill are codified in Title 42 of the Code of Federal Regulations Section 482.26. The regulations state that hospitals and ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs) must maintain, or have available, radiologic services according to the needs of the patients. The standard for the safety of patients and personnel is as follows:
- Proper safety precautions must be maintained against radiation hazards. This includes adequate shielding for patients, personnel, and facilities, as well as appropriate storage, use, and disposal of radioactive materials;
- Periodic inspection of equipment must be made and hazards identified must be promptly corrected;
- Radiation workers must be checked periodically, by the use of exposure meters or badge tests, for amount of radiation exposure;
- Radiologic services must be provided only on the order of practitioners with clinical privileges or, consistent with State law, of other practitioners authorized by the medical staff and the governing body to order the services;
Additionally, the standard for personnel is as follows:
- A qualified full-time, part-time, or consulting radiologist must supervise the ionizing radiology services and must interpret only those radiologic tests that are determined by the medical staff to require a radiologist's specialized knowledge. For purposes of this section, a radiologist is a doctor of medicine or osteopathy who is qualified by education and experience in radiology; and,
- Only personnel designated as qualified by the medical staff may use the radiologic equipment and administer procedures.
The CfC also require records of radiologic services to be maintained and the radiologist or other practitioner who performs radiology services must sign the reports of interpretations. The hospitals and ASCs are also required to maintain copies of reports, printouts and films, scans, and other image records, as appropriate.
The sponsors point out that beginning January 1, 2019, the Joint Commission which accredits 21,000 facilities nationwide has imposed additional requirements on facilities for providing fluoroscopy services. The new standards state that for hospitals and ASC’s, they must verify and document that individuals who use fluoroscopic equipment participate in ongoing education that includes annual training on radiation dose optimization techniques, and safe procedures for operation of the equipment. The sponsors indicate that compliance with these new standards should be a sufficient substitute for the existing fluoroscopy permit or certificate requirements.
- SUPPORT. The California Orthopaedic Association and the California Podiatric Medical Association, the cosponsors of this bill, state that this bill will streamline the process and allow physicians to enter into practice more quickly.
- OPPOSITION. The California Radiological Society (CRS) states that the existing permit process that requires the physician to demonstrate sufficient knowledge of radiation safety exists to protect the patient and the physician from unnecessary radiation exposure. CRS also opposes substituting the CMS CfC because the existing test for fluoroscopy permit is subject to review and is updated every five years. The examination covers radiation safety related to fluoroscopy equipment operation as opposed to clinical procedures. For the years 2016-2018 passage rate for physicians were 83%, thus the test is not an impediment to physician compliance.
- POLICY CONCERNS.
- CfC. The CfC requirements are facility specific, and tied to the payment of services for a specific patient. However, the RTA requirements to obtain fluoroscopy permits are based on a physician’s or podiatrist’s competence. Moreover, under the CMS standards, inspections are facility-driven rather than based on the certificate/permit holder. Thus, is it appropriate to substitute the CfC with existing fluoroscopy requirements for physicians and podiatrists? Additionally, as the bill is written it is unclear if the exemption applies to all physicians and podiatrists or only those working in settings that comply with CMS’ CfC.
- Supervising radiologic technologist. The RTA also prohibits a radiologic technologist from using an x-ray equipment unless they are under the supervision of a certified supervisor and operator (physician/podiatrist). As written, this bill is unclear if physicians or podiatrists can continue to supervise a radiologic technologist if they are exempt from the permit or certificate requirements.
- CfC. The CfC requirements are facility specific, and tied to the payment of services for a specific patient. However, the RTA requirements to obtain fluoroscopy permits are based on a physician’s or podiatrist’s competence. Moreover, under the CMS standards, inspections are facility-driven rather than based on the certificate/permit holder. Thus, is it appropriate to substitute the CfC with existing fluoroscopy requirements for physicians and podiatrists? Additionally, as the bill is written it is unclear if the exemption applies to all physicians and podiatrists or only those working in settings that comply with CMS’ CfC.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Orthopaedic Association (cosponsor)
California Podiatric Medical Association (cosponsor)
Opposition
California Radiological Society
Analysis Prepared by: Rosielyn Pulmano / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):