AB 410: Vehicles: motor vehicle sideshows.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-22
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. (Ayes 13. Noes 1.) (April 8). Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on TRANS. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on TRANS. and PUB. S. |
| Feb 8, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 8, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Public Safety] | Assembly Standing Committee on Transportation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 410
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
SUMMARY:
Creates the crime of participating in a “motor vehicle sideshow,” defined as an event in which two or more persons block or impede traffic on a highway for the purpose of performing motor vehicle stunts, motor vehicle speed contests, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed, or reckless driving, for spectators. Specifically, this bill:
- States that a person who actively participates in, or aids and abets, a motor vehicle sideshow, as defined, is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period not to exceed 90 days, by a fine not less than $355 nor more than $1000, or by both that imprisonment and fine.
- Specifies that a second or subsequent conviction of participating in a motor vehicle sideshow, within a five-year period, is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period not to exceed six months, by a fine of not less than $500 nor more than $1000, or by both imprisonment and fine.
- Provides that a person convicted of a violation of this participating in a motor vehicle sideshow that proximately causes bodily injury to a person other than the driver is guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in county jail not to exceed six months, by a fine of not less than $500 nor more than $1000, or by both imprisonment and fine.
- States that a second or subsequent conviction of participating in a motor vehicle sideshow causing bodily injury to another person, within a five-year period, is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period not to exceed one year, by a fine not to exceed $1000, or by both imprisonment and fine, or a felony, punishably by imprisonment up to three years in the county jail, by a fine not less than $500 nor more than $1000, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
- Defines “Motor vehicle sideshow” as “an event in which two or more persons block or impede traffic on a highway or other public place open to vehicle traffic, or access private property without the consent of the owner, operator, or agent thereof, for the purpose of performing motor vehicle stunts, motor vehicle speed contests, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed, or reckless driving, for spectators.”
- States that participants in a motor vehicle sideshow include drivers or passengers of the involved motor vehicles, and any pedestrians, drivers, or passengers who barricade or prevent access to a highway or other property where the motor vehicle sideshow is being performed. An aider or abettor to a motor vehicle sideshow includes any person who organizes, facilitates, encourages, or promotes a motor vehicle sideshow.
- Specifies that liability for a violation of participating in a motor vehicle sideshow shall not be imposed upon a person who is merely present as a spectator at a place where a violation is occurring.
- States that a magistrate presented with the affidavit of a peace officer establishing reasonable cause to believe that a vehicle, described by vehicle type and license number, was an instrumentality used in the peace officer’s presence in violation of this section, shall issue a warrant or order authorizing any peace officer to immediately seize and cause the removal of the vehicle. The warrant or court order may be entered into a computerized database. A vehicle so impounded may be impounded for a period not to exceed 30 days.
- Provides that the impounding agency, within two working days of impoundment, shall send a notice by certified mail, return receipt requested, to the legal owner of the vehicle, at the address obtained from the department, informing the owner that the vehicle has been impounded.
- States that failure to notify the legal owner within two working days shall prohibit the impounding agency from charging for more than 15 days’ impoundment when the legal owner redeems the impounded vehicle. The impounding agency shall maintain a published telephone number that provides information 24 hours a day regarding the impoundment of vehicles and the rights of a registered owner to request a hearing. The law enforcement agency shall be open to issue a release to the registered owner or legal owner, or the agent of either, whenever the agency is open to serve the public for nonemergency business.
- Requires an impounding agency to release a vehicle to the registered owner or the registered owner’s agent prior to the end of the impoundment period, without the need to obtain authorization from the magistrate authorizing the vehicle’s seizure, under any of the following circumstances:
- If the vehicle is stolen;
- If the vehicle is subject to bailment and the violation of this section was committed by an employee of a business establishment, including a parking service or repair garage; or
- If the registered owner of the vehicle causes a peace officer to reasonably believe, based on the totality of the circumstances, that the registered owner was not the person who violated this section, the agency shall immediately release the vehicle to the registered owner or the registered owner’s agent.
- If the vehicle is stolen;
- States that a vehicle shall not be released pursuant to this subdivision, except upon presentation of the registered owner’s or agent’s currently valid driver’s license to operate the vehicle and proof of current vehicle registration, or upon order of the court.
- Specifies that if a vehicle is impounded pursuant to this section, the magistrate ordering the storage shall provide the vehicle’s registered and legal owners of record, or their agents, with the opportunity for a poststorage hearing to determine the validity of the storage.
- Provides that a notice of the storage shall be mailed or personally delivered to the registered and legal owners within 48 hours after issuance of the warrant or court order, excluding weekends and holidays, by the person or agency executing the warrant or court order, and shall include all of the following information:
- The name, address, and telephone number of the agency providing the notice;
- The location of the place of storage and a description of the vehicle, which shall include, if available, the name or make, the manufacturer, the license plate number, and the mileage of the vehicle;
- A copy of the warrant or court order and the peace officer’s affidavit, as described; and
- A statement that, in order to receive their poststorage hearing, the owners, or their agents, are required to request the hearing from the magistrate issuing the warrant or court order in person, in writing, or by telephone, within 10 days of the date of the notice.
- The name, address, and telephone number of the agency providing the notice;
- Requires the poststorage hearing to be conducted within two court days after receipt of the request for the hearing.
- States that at the hearing, the magistrate may order the vehicle released if the magistrate finds that any of the circumstances described that allow release of a vehicle by the impounding agency apply.
- States that the magistrate may also consider releasing the vehicle when the magistrate finds that the continued impoundment will cause undue hardship to persons dependent upon the vehicle for employment or to a person with a community property interest in the vehicle or if the public safety considerations for continued impoundment do not outweigh the possessory interest in the vehicle.
- Specifies that failure of either the registered or legal owner, or the registered or legal owner’s agent, to request, or to attend, a scheduled hearing satisfies the poststorage hearing requirement.
- States that the agency employing the peace officer who caused the magistrate to issue the warrant or court order shall be responsible for the costs incurred for towing and storage if it is determined in the poststorage hearing that reasonable grounds for the storage are not established.
- Provides that the registered owner or the registered owner’s agent is responsible for all towing and storage charges related to the impoundment, and any administrative charges, as specified.
- Requires a vehicle removed and seized, as specified to be released to the legal owner of the vehicle or the legal owner’s agent prior to the end of the impoundment period without the need to obtain authorization from the magistrate authorizing the seizure of the vehicle if all of the following conditions are met:
- The legal owner is a motor vehicle dealer, bank, credit union, acceptance corporation, or other licensed financial institution legally operating in this state or is another person, not the registered owner, holding a financial interest in the vehicle;
- The legal owner or the legal owner’s agent pays all towing and storage fees related to the seizure of the vehicle;
- The legal owner or the legal owner’s agent presents to the impounding agency a specified documents; and
- A failure by a storage facility to comply with any applicable conditions set forth in this subdivision shall not affect the right of the legal owner or the legal owner’s agent to retrieve the vehicle, provided all conditions are satisfied.
- The legal owner is a motor vehicle dealer, bank, credit union, acceptance corporation, or other licensed financial institution legally operating in this state or is another person, not the registered owner, holding a financial interest in the vehicle;
- Specifies that a legal owner who obtains release of the vehicle shall not release the vehicle to the registered owner or the person who was listed as the registered owner when the vehicle was impounded, unless a registered owner is a rental car agency, until the expiration of the impoundment period or until the termination of the impoundment period by court order.
- States that the legal owner shall not relinquish the vehicle to the registered owner or the person who was listed as the registered owner when the vehicle was impounded until the registered owner presents their valid driver’s license.
- States that prior to relinquishing the vehicle, the legal owner may require the registered owner to pay all towing and storage charges related to the impoundment and the administrative charges, as specified, that were incurred by the legal owner in connection with obtaining the custody of the vehicle.
- Provides that any legal owner who knowingly releases a vehicle to a registered owner or the person in possession of the vehicle at the time of the impoundment or any agent of the registered owner in violation of the provisions of this bill is guilty of a misdemeanor and subject to a fine in the amount $2,000 in addition to any other penalties established by law.
- States that the legal owner, registered owner, or person in possession of the vehicle shall not change or attempt to change the name of the legal owner or the registered owner on the records of the department until the vehicle is released from the impoundment.
- Requires a vehicle impounded and seized, as specified, to be released to a rental car agency prior to the end of the impoundment period if the agency is either the legal owner or registered owner of the vehicle and the agency pays all towing and storage fees related to the seizure of the vehicle.
- Allows the owner of a rental vehicle that was seized to continue to rent the vehicle upon recovery of the vehicle. However, the rental car agency shall not rent another vehicle to the driver who used the vehicle that was seized until 30 days after the date that the vehicle was seized.
- Specifies that the rental car agency may require the person to whom the vehicle was rented and who committed the violation of this section to pay all towing and storage charges related to the impoundment and any administrative charges that were incurred by the rental car agency in connection with obtaining custody of the vehicle.
- States that notwithstanding any other provision of this section, the registered owner and not the legal owner shall remain responsible for any towing and storage charges related to the impoundment and the administrative charges and any parking fines, penalties, and administrative fees incurred by the registered owner.
- Provides that the impounding agency, including any storage facility acting on behalf of the impounding agency, shall comply with this section and shall not be liable to the registered owner for the improper release of the vehicle to the legal owner or the legal owner’s agent, provided the release complies with the provisions of this section.
- Specifies that the legal owner shall indemnify and hold harmless a storage facility from any claims arising out of the release of the vehicle to the legal owner or the legal owner’s agent and from any damage to the vehicle after its release, including the reasonable costs associated with defending those claims.
- States that an impounding agency shall not refuse to issue a release to a legal owner or the agent of a legal owner on the grounds that it previously issued a release.
EXISTING LAW:
- Specifies that it is a crime for a person to engage in a motor vehicle speed contest on a highway (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (a).)
- States that a person shall not aid or abet in any motor vehicle speed contest. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that it is a crime to engage in a motor vehicle exhibition of speed on a highway, and a person shall not aid or abet in a motor vehicle exhibition of speed on any highway. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (c).)
- Specifies that it is a crime for the purpose of facilitating or aiding or as an incident to any motor vehicle speed contest or exhibition upon a highway, in any manner obstruct or place a barricade or obstruction or assist or participate in placing a barricade or obstruction upon any highway. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (d).)
- Provides that a person convicted of a motor vehicle speed contest shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not less than 24 hours nor more than 90 days or by a fine of not less than $355 nor more than $1,000, or by both that fine and imprisonment. That person shall also be required to perform 40 hours of community service. The court may order the privilege to operate a motor vehicle suspended for 90 days to six months. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (e)(1).)
- Provides that if a person is convicted of a motor vehicle speed contest and that violation proximately causes bodily injury to a person other than the driver, the person convicted shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than six months or by a fine of not less than $500 nor more $1,000, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Veh. Code,§ 23109, subd. (e)(2).)
- States that if a person is convicted of a motor vehicle speed contest for an offense that occurred within five years of the date of a prior offense that resulted in a conviction of a violation of motor vehicle speed contest, that person shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not less than four days nor more than six months, and by a fine of not less than $500 nor more than one thousand dollars $1,000. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (f)(1).)
- Provides that if the most recent offense within the five-year period causes bodily injury to a person other than the driver, a person convicted of that second violation shall be imprisoned in a county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than six months and by a fine of not less than five hundred dollars $500 nor more than $1,000. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (f)(2).)
- States that if the most recent offense within the five-year period proximately causes serious bodily injury, as specified, to a person other than the driver, a person convicted of that second violation shall be imprisoned in the state prison, or in a county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than one year, and by a fine of not less than $500 nor more than $1,000. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (f)(3).)
- Specifies that if a person is convicted of a second offense within five years, the court shall order the privilege to operate a motor vehicle of the person suspended for a period of six months, as specified. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (f)(4).)
- States that if a person is convicted of motor vehicle speed contest and the vehicle used in the violation is registered to that person, the vehicle may be impounded at the registered owner’s expense for not less than one day nor more than 30 days. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (h).)
- Provides that a person who aids and abets a motor vehicle speed contest, engages in, or aides and abets, a motor vehicle speed exhibition, or for the purpose of facilitating or aiding or as an incident to any motor vehicle speed contest or exhibition upon a highway, in any manner obstruct or place a barricade or obstruction upon any highway, shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail for not more than 90 days, by a fine of not more than five hundred dollars $500, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (i).)
- States that a person convicted of reckless driving that proximately causes one or more serious injuries, as specified, to a person other than the driver, shall be guilty of a felony, punishable by imprisonment in the county jail, or guilty of a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than six months, or by a fine of not less than $220 nor more than one thousand dollars $1,000, or by both that fine and imprisonment. (Veh. Code, § 23105, subd. (a).)
- Provides that whenever reckless driving of a vehicle proximately causes bodily injury to a person other than the driver, the person driving the vehicle shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and punished by imprisonment in the county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than six months or by a fine of not less than $220 nor more than $1,000, or by both the fine and imprisonment. (Veh. Code, §, 23104, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that person convicted of reckless driving that proximately causes great bodily injury, as defined, to a person other than the driver, who previously has been convicted of a specified violation of reckless driving or driving under the influence, shall be guilty of a felony punished by imprisonment county jail up to three years, or guilty of a misdemeanor and punished by imprisonment in the county jail for not less than 30 days nor more than six months or by a fine of not less than two $220 nor more than $1,000 or by both the fine and imprisonment. (Veh. Code, §, 23104, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that whenever a peace officer determines that a person was engaged in a motor vehicle speed contest, reckless driving, or exhibition of speed, the peace officer may immediately arrest and take into custody that person and may impound the vehicle. A motor vehicle so seized may be impounded for up to 30 days. (Veh. Code, §23109.2.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "Clearly defining a motor vehicle sideshow will deter participation and keep our roads safer. As social media evolves and creates new avenues for event organizers, law enforcement should be given clear direction on how to combat the proliferation of motor vehicle sideshows. AB 410 is a simple and necessary step to protect public safety. Through clear definitions and penalties, this policy will reaffirm California’s commitment to stop reckless behavior.”
- Current Law Already Criminalizes the Behavior Described by This Bill: This bill would define “Motor vehicle sideshow” as an event in which two or more persons block or impede traffic on a highway or other public place open to vehicle traffic, or access private property without the consent of the owner, operator, or agent thereof, for the purpose of performing motor vehicle stunts, motor vehicle speed contests, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed, or reckless driving, for spectators.
The conduct described in the definition of “motor vehicle sideshow” is covered by existing law. Current law already makes it a crime to engage in motor vehicle speed contests, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed, or reckless driving. (Veh. Code, § 23109, 23103.) In addition, current law specifies that it is a crime to obstruct or place a barricade or obstruction or assist or participate in placing a barricade or obstruction upon any highway, facilitating or aiding or as an incident to any motor vehicle speed contest or exhibition of speed. (Veh. Code, § 23109, subd. (d).) An exhibition of speed includes any conduct where the person accelerates or drives at a rate of speed that is dangerous and unsafe in order to show off or make an impression on someone else. (CalCrim 2202.) An individual who commits any of those crimes and cause bodily injury, is subject to elevated punishment. Any person that aides or abets one of those crimes, is criminally liable to the same extent at the driver of the car. A person aids and abets when they know of the perpetrator’s unlawful purpose and he or she intends to, and does in fact, aid, facility, or encourage the perpetrator’s commission of that crime.
Violations based exhibition of speed, speed contests, and reckless driving are generally punishable as misdemeanors. However, current law provides elevated penalties if those crimes result in bodily injury. A person can be charged and convicted for a felony under specified circumstances involving great bodily injury. Current law specifies circumstances under which vehicles involved in such crimes can be impounded. - Danger that This Bill Could Criminalize Behavior That Does Not Involve Any Criminal Intent: This bill would potentially create criminal liability for individuals who are present at a sideshow, but have no intent to encourage or facilitate any criminal action.
The bill states that “participants in a motor vehicle sideshow include drivers or passengers of the involved motor vehicles, and any pedestrians, drivers, or passengers who barricade or prevent access to a highway or other property where the motor vehicle sideshow is being performed.”
Pedestrians who are present at a sideshow might “prevent access to a highway” by virtue of being at the location where a sideshow is taking place, but not have any intent to prevent access or otherwise facilitate a sideshow. The same is true or drivers and passengers that get stuck in or near a sideshow. This bill contains language which seeks to limit liability for some that is merely present as a spectator. The bill states that, “Liability for a violation of this section shall not be imposed upon a person who is merely present as a spectator at a place where a violation is occurring.” However, it is not clear how such language interacts with the other provisions of this bill. - Vehicle Impoundment: This bill would provide for a vehicle impound procedure based on a declaration submitted by a police officer that a vehicle was involved in a motor vehicle sideshow. There is the opportunity for a registered owner to have a post impoundment hearing. The impound procedures for this bill have been adopted from an existing statute from the vehicle code involving impoundment in cases involving reckless driving or evading an officer. Existing law also provides impound procedures for vehicles involved in exhibitions of speed and motor vehicle speed contests. Recognizing that the impound language of this bill is consistent with impound procedures found in current law, the impound procedures of this bill raise due process concerns. The impound procedure does not require any showing that the registered owner was the person driving the car at the time of the conduct in question. This bill would only require a “reasonable belief” that the vehicle had been involved in a motor vehicle sideshow. The impound procedure in this bill does not provide for a hearing regarding impound prior to the time the vehicle is impounded. This bill would allow impoundment without any requirement for a criminal charge to be filed against the registered owner, or criminal conviction obtained against the registered owner. Without such requirements, there is concern that registered owners that did not engage in criminal behavior will be punished by the loss of their vehicle.
- Argument in Support: According to the Los Angeles Police Protective League, “According to the Los Angeles Times, 179 people have died in Los Angeles County between 2000 and 2017 in incidents where street racing was suspected. The Times notes that from July 2016 to July 2017, the California Highway Patrol recorded nearly 700 racing incidents in Los Angeles County. Those races involved roughly 17,000 vehicles and 22,000 people. Popular culture and social media have exacerbated the rise in street racing and other illegal activities on our roads and highways, including sideshows.
“While many reckless driving activities are illegal, organizing a sideshow is not considered a crime. Additionally, law enforcement agencies can wind up paying for impound fees on cars taken during sideshows when there is no clear conviction. Law enforcement agencies can be responsible for towing and storage costs incurred as a result of vehicle impoundment if criminal charges are not filed by the district attorney because of a lack of evidence, or if the charges are otherwise dismissed by the court. Current law also affords the owner of the vehicle the ability to retrieve it within days of impoundment.
“AB 410 would define a sideshow as a demonstration of automotive stunts organized by two or more people often occurring on a public street, highway, or private property open to the general public to block or impede traffic. It would specify that common activities at sideshows include motor vehicle stunting, motor vehicle speed contests, reckless driving, and speed chases. Clearly defining a motor vehicle sideshow will deter participation, support law enforcement, and keep our roads safer. As social media evolves and creates new avenues for event organizers, law enforcement should be given clear direction on how to combat the proliferation of motor vehicle sideshows.” - Argument in Opposition: According to the American Civil Liberties Union of California, “The behavior addressed under AB 410 is already subject to criminal penalties under existing law, Vehicle Code Section 2310 imposes criminal penalties for reckless driving. Under section 23104 those penalties are increased if the act results in bodily injury, and felony penalties are available for a second or subsequent conviction if the act results in great bodily injury. Section 23109 makes it a crime to engage in a motor vehicle speed contest; again the penalties are increased if great bodily injury results. Under Penal code section 31, person who aid or abet the commission of these crimes can also be held criminally liable. The vehicles used in commission of these offenses can be seized and impounded for up to thirty days. (Vehicle Code section 23109.2.)
“AB 410 would greatly increase these penalties. Under AB 410, a first conviction of participating in a sideshow could result in imprisonment for up to a year and a fine of up to $10,000; a second conviction would be a wobbler. Participation in a sideshow when it causes bodily injury would be a felony. Moreover, these heightened penalties could be applied to person who only involvement was to promote the sideshow – perhaps someone who shared a post about it on Facebook – or even to a pedestrian who stood in the street, thereby helping to prevent access to a street or other property.
“Increasing the sentences for those who participate in sideshows will do nothing to stop these events from happening. Research has shown that the severity of punishment does not generally have an increased effect on deterrence. Rather, studies have concluded that the certainty of punishment – that someone will be punished for a particular crime – has a greater deterrent effect than the severity of the punishment itself. An increased sentence will only unnecessarily send people to prison or jail for longer periods of time, requiring increased state spending with no benefit to public safety.” - Related Legislation: AB 1407 (Friedman), would require that a vehicle be impounded for 30 days if the vehicle's registered owner is convicted of second or subsequent offense for reckless driving or engaging in a speed contest while operating the vehicle. AB 1407 is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1393 (Friedman), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required that a vehicle be impounded for 30 days if the vehicle's registered owner is convicted of second or subsequent offense for reckless driving or engaging in a speed contest while operating the vehicle. AB 1393 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
- AB 2876 (Jones-Sawyer), Chapter 592, Statutes of 2018, clarifies that the protections against unreasonable seizures provided by the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution apply even when a vehicle is removed pursuant to an authorizing statute.
- AB 1206 (Bocanegra), Chapter 531, Statutes of 2017, authorized a two-year pilot program in the Cities of Los Angeles, Oakland, and Sacramento to permit law enforcement officers to tow vehicles used in the commission, or attempted commission of specified offenses related to prostitution.
- AB 1393 (Friedman), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required that a vehicle be impounded for 30 days if the vehicle's registered owner is convicted of second or subsequent offense for reckless driving or engaging in a speed contest while operating the vehicle. AB 1393 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association
California Police Chiefs Association
Los Angeles County Sheriff Department
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Oppose
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Public Defenders Association
Analysis Prepared by:
David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Date of Hearing: April 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON TRANSPORTATION
Jim Frazier, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 410 (
Author:Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2019
SUBJECT: Vehicles: motor vehicle sideshows
SUMMARY: Makes it a misdemeanor or a felony to participate in, or aid and abet, a motor vehicle sideshow, as defined. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that any person who actively participates in, or aids and abets, a motor vehicle sideshow is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period not to exceed one year, by a fine not to exceed $10,000, or by both imprisonment and fine.
- Provides that a second violation of this provision is a misdemeanor or a felony and a fine not to exceed $25,000.
- Provides that any violation of this provision that proximately causes bodily injury to a person other than the driver is guilty of a felony.
- Defines a “motor vehicle sideshow” to mean an event in which two or more persons block or impede traffic on a highway or other public place open to vehicle traffic, or access private property without the consent of the owner, operator, or agent thereof, for the purpose of performing motor vehicle stunts, motor vehicle speed contents, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed or reckless driving, for spectators.
- Specifies that participants in a motor vehicle sideshow include drivers or passengers of the involved motor vehicles, and any pedestrians, drivers, or passengers who barricade or prevent access to a highway or other property where the motor vehicle sideshow is being performed.
- Specifies that an aider or abettor to a motor vehicle sideshow is any person who organizes, facilitates, encourages, or promotes a motor vehicle sideshow.
- Specifies that liability for a violation of this section shall not be imposed upon a person who is merely present as a spectator at a place where a violation is occurring.
- Allows for a vehicle involved in a motor vehicle sideshow to be impounded for a period up to 30 days, as specified.
- Allows for an impounded vehicle to be released prior to the impoundment period to the registered owner or the registered owner’s agent under the following circumstances:
- The vehicle is stolen.
- The vehicle is subject to bailment and the violation of this section was committed by an employee of a business establishment, including a parking service or repair garage.
- The registered owner of the vehicle was not the person who violated this section.
- Establishes a notice requirement to be mailed to the legal owner if the vehicle is impounded.
- Imposes the cost of towing and storing the vehicle on the owner unless it is determined at a post-storage hearing that reasonable grounds for the storage were not established.
- Allows a rental car agency to recover the costs of the towing and storage charges from the person to whom the vehicle was rented.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that any person who drives a vehicle upon a highway in willful or wanton disregard for the safety of persons or property is guilty of reckless driving.
- Prohibits a person from engaging in any motor vehicle speed contest which includes a motor vehicle race against another vehicle, a clock, or other timing device.
- Prohibits a person from aiding or abetting in a speed contest.
- Specifies the penalty for a speed contest or the exhibition of speed is a misdemeanor.
- Provides that when a person is arrested for street racing or a speed contest, an officer may impound the vehicle for not more than 30 days and that the registered and legal owner of the vehicle is required to be provided a hearing regarding the storage of the vehicle.
- Provides that when a person is convicted of a speed contest the court may impound the vehicle for not less than one day nor more than 30 days.
- Prohibits a person from bringing a vehicle to a complete stop upon a highway in a manner that impedes or blocks the normal and reasonable movement of traffic unless the stop is necessary for safe operation or in compliance with law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: In the 1980s in Oakland, California, a new tradition began to take hold in mall parking lots: sideshows. The original sideshows were just meant to show off cars, but they developed into larger events under Oakland’s unique hyphy culture in the 1990s. These events involve customized cars and hyphy music, an Oakland slang term meaning “hyperactive” that was coined by Rapper Keak da Sneak and popularized by E-40’s song, “Hyphy.”
According to an Interview by KQED with Sean Kennedy, a multimedia producer and local hip-hop historian in Oakland, sideshows began to change when guys with cheap cars started doing stunts to gain attention. These stunts include doing donuts (360 degree tire burnouts) and ghost riding the whip (exiting a moving vehicle and dancing beside and around it). Kennedy has noted that these sideshows have a nomadic, extra-legal element to them, as people often bring guns and sell drugs at the shows.
As sideshows grew in popularity and moved out of mall parking lots and onto streets, highways and bridges, the city of Oakland began to pass ordinances making even spectating at a sideshow a criminal offense. After the death of U’kendra K. Johnson, a 22-year old woman who was killed by a sideshow driver fleeing police in Oakland, the Legislature passed SB 1489 (Perata) Chapter 411, Statutes of 2002, also known as the U’kendra K. Johnson Memorial Act, which granted law enforcement the ability to impound a vehicle for reckless driving.
In recent years sideshows have gained popularity outside of Oakland. The Sacramento Bee reported in January of 2019 that sideshows have been occurring on the streets in North Sacramento County nearly every weekend. Some of the larger sideshows included one in November of 2017 on Highway 50 in Sacramento that involved 500 vehicles and 1,000 people participating in a sideshow that blocked all eastbound lanes of traffic for 15 minutes. The size of these events has made it difficult for law enforcement to effectively apprehend everyone involved.
This bill makes it unlawful for a person to participate in a motor vehicle sideshow. The bill defines a sideshow as an event with two or more persons that block or impede traffic on a highway or other public place open to vehicle traffic for the purpose of performing motor vehicle stunts, motor vehicle speed contests, motor vehicle exhibitions of speed, or reckless driving, for spectators.
While the bill provides that a person who is merely spectating is not criminally liable, a participant could be held liable if a law enforcement officer determines that the person was barricading or preventing access to a highway or other property. So in essence, anyone watching the sideshow that is not standing on a sidewalk could be criminally liable under this law.
Many of the acts that occur at sideshows are already illegal under California’s reckless driving laws, speed contest laws, or laws prohibiting the blocking of a highway. Many of the arrests that occur at these events also involve individuals fleeing a police officer in a vehicle, which is also against the law.
Nonetheless, the author contends that a specific crime for sideshows is necessary. According to the author, “Clearly defining a motor vehicle sideshow will deter participation and keep our roads safer. As social media evolves and creates new avenues for event organizers, law enforcement should be given clear direction on how to combat the proliferation of motor vehicle sideshows. AB 410 is a simple and necessary step to protect public safety. Through clear definitions and penalties, this policy will reaffirm California’s commitment to stop reckless behavior.”
This bill also grants the authority to law enforcement to tow someone’s vehicle that is involved in a sideshow as long as a magistrate judge was presented with an affidavit of a peace officer that established reasonable cause to believe that the vehicle was instrumentally used in the officer’s presence in violation of the provisions in this bill. The crimes of reckless driving, fleeing an officer in a vehicle and speed contests also allow law enforcement to tow and store a vehicle upon arrest.
The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV), in conjunction with the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration commissioned a series of studies to evaluate the deterrence effect of impounding a vehicle. While a study on the general deterrence effect of the law “did not find compelling evidence of a general deterrent impact of vehicle impoundment and forfeiture on crashes for one of the main groups it targets,” another study on the specific deterrent effect found the law had a great impact on future traffic offenses.
The DMV report, An Evaluation of the Specific Deterrent Effect of Vehicle Impoundment on Suspended, Revoked and Unlicensed Driver’s in California (DeYoung, 1997), found that first time offenders who had their vehicles impounded for driving while unlicensed (DWU) or driving with a suspended license (DWS) saw a 23.8 percent drop in subsequent convictions for DWU or DWS. For repeat offenders, subsequent violations dropped 34.2 percent. Those drivers who had their vehicles impounded also saw an 18 percent drop in total traffic convictions, and a 22.3 percent drop in traffic violations for repeat offenders.
The cost to recover an impounded vehicle could be substantial. According to a 2019 report from Western Center and Law and Poverty entitled Towed into Debt: How Towing Practices in California Punish Poor People, the average towing fee in California is $189, the cost of storage averages $53 a day, and the average administrative fee is $153. If a judge were to elect to impound someone’s vehicle for 30 days, as is allowed in this bill, the towing and storage fee to recover the vehicle could be $1,929.
Nearly 50% of all vehicles in California are valued under $5,000. With a $1,925 towing and storage fee, many drivers will likely lose their car as a result of a tow authorized under this bill because the cost of recovering their vehicle will either by half or all of its total value. The number of vehicles impounded could be substantial, as The California Highway Patrol alone has issued a total of 5,675 citations for reckless driving and speed contests between 2014 and 2018.
Double Referral: This bill will be referred to the Assembly Public Safety Committee should it pass out of this committee. That analysis will likely cover the criminal sanctions in this bill and their effects.
Committee concerns: It is important to note that California law considers a motor vehicle any vehicle that is self -propelled. As a result, this bill may have implications beyond the author’s intent. For example, two 18 year-olds using a shared electric scooter and performing stunts or racing them could be found criminally liable if they or spectators were blocking a road as the stunts were being performed.
This bill also provides that anyone who encourages or promotes a motor vehicle sideshow could be criminally charged with a felony if someone is injured. This may include anyone who shares or “likes” a Facebook post about a sideshow.
In addition to jail time, this bill provides that someone who violates this law could face a fine of up to $10,000 for a first offense, and $25,000 for a second offense or $25,000 for the first offense if a violation of this section proximately causes bodily injury to a person other than a driver. These fines do not include the total costs of all fees and assessments.
As noted earlier, many of the behaviors this bill seeks to criminalize are already against the law. Existing law also carries significant fines. Reckless driving, in addition to criminal penalties, includes a total fine of $684, or $2,145 if an injury is caused. Speed contests, in addition to criminal penalties, includes a total fine of $485, or $3,150 if an injury is caused. Fleeing a peace officer in a vehicle, in addition to criminal penalties, includes fine costs of $2,145, or $20,575 if an injury is caused. Blocking traffic can result in $238 fine.
The Legislature should consider if the additional penalties this bill prescribes for this violation are necessary.
Related Legislation:
SB 67 (Perata) Chapter 727, Statutes of 2007 reenacted provisions that were allowed to sunset that provide for vehicle impoundments when a person is arrested for reckless driving, exhibition of speed, or a speed contest.
SB 1489 (Perata) Chapter 411, Statues of 2002 gave law enforcement the authority to seize and impound a vehicle for no more than 30 days when a person was arrested for reckless driving, exhibition of speed, or a speed contest. This bill sunsets on January 1, 2007.
AB 1407 (Friedman, 2019) Provides that a vehicle may be impounded for 30 days if the vehicle's registered owner is convicted of reckless driving or engaging in a speed contest while operating the vehicle, as specified. This bill is set to be heard in this committee.
SB 699 (Galgiani, 2017) would have made it a crime to engage in, or aid or abet, a speed contest or an exhibition of speed in a parking facility. That bill passed out of the Senate and was later amended into a different measure and died in Assembly Public Safety Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: David Sforza / TRANS. / (916) 319-2093
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):