AB 432: Released waste: certification of local officers.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-07
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (March 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Feb 8, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 12, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 20, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 432
Author:(Quirk) – As Introduced Ver:February 7, 2019
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 5-1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), in cooperation with the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC), to develop and implement a program to certify local officers to enter into remedial action agreements for the oversight and abatement of hazardous wastes.
Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes specified criteria the State Water Board shall consider to determine if the local officer is qualified.
- Requires the State Water Board to adopt procedures for certifying and revoking certification from local officers and exempts the adoptions of the procedures from the Administrative Procedures Act (APA).
- Provides only a local officer certified by the State Water Board or DTSC may enter into a remedial action agreement after July 1, 2020. This does not prohibit the State Water Board, DTSC or the regional water quality control boards from assuming jurisdiction or taking enforcement over a hazardous release per existing law.
- Requires the State Water Board to review the qualifications of a certified local officer every three years and allows the board to revoke the certification and assume responsibilities or transfer them to DTSC or the regional water quality boards, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time increased State Water Board costs of $175,000 (1 PY) to develop and adopt the certification process and consult with DTSC, regional water quality boards and counties (Site Cleanup Subaccount).
- Ongoing increased annual State Water Board costs of $350,000 (2 PY) to oversee and administer the program (Site Cleanup Subaccount).
- One-time costs of $450,000 over three years for DTSC to assist the State Water Board in developing the certification process and issue initial certifications (special fund).
- Ongoing annual costs of $300,000 for DTSC to oversee compliance and re-certify local agencies (special fund).
DTSC is concerned this bill may result in fewer local agencies overseeing cleanup because some local agencies might not want to seek certification might not qualify, resulting in significant state costs for cleanup.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 432 will establish a state certification program for local health officers who oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites in order to ensure that all hazardous waste cleanup, whether done by the state, a local health agency, or a responsible party, is completed using uniform standards and procedures to ensure maximum protection of public health and the environment. AB 432 will empower local health officers with the knowledge and state assistance to tackle complex hazardous cleanup efforts.
- Background. There are currently thousands of hazardous waste contaminated sites throughout the state where recent or historical releases of pollutants have occurred. State law provides various state and local authorities to address this contamination.
Regional water quality control boards and DTSC the responsibility for identifying responsible parties, setting cleanup standards and ensuring the sites are properly remediated.
Certified Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs) carry out programs on behalf of the state including the regulation of hazardous waste generators and onsite hazardous waste treatment and the regulation of petroleum underground storage tanks.
The State Water Board certifies local agencies as qualified to cleanup or oversee the cleanup by a responsible party of soil and groundwater contamination from leaking underground storage tanks. Local agencies also oversee voluntary cleanup programs performed by responsible parties, which does not require any state certification or oversite.
The author intends this bill to be similar to the State Water Board’s existing certification of local agencies.
- Work-In-Progress. According to the author, the intent of this bill is to provide sufficient resources and technical expertise to local health agencies through a certification process similar to other state certification programs. The author is continuing to work with local health officers, the State Water Board, DTSC and other stakeholders to determine the appropriate scope of the licensing program and address any potential overlap.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 12, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 432 (
Author:Quirk) – As Introduced Ver:February 7, 2019
SUBJECT: Released waste: certification of local officers
SUMMARY: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), in cooperation with the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), to develop and implement a certification program for local health officers who enter into remedial action agreements. Specifically, this bill:
- Amends the definition of "local officer" to mean a county health officer, city health officer, or county director of environmental health that has been certified by DTSC or by the State Water Board to enter remedial action agreements and supervise remedial action sites with released hazardous waste.
- Requires a voluntary remedial action agreement between a responsible party and a local health officer to additionally include required reporting requirements, public notification requirements, the enforcement actions that may occur in the event of noncompliance with directives, and the cleanup goals that the local officer determines are necessary to comply with applicable requirements of state law to protect human health or safety or the environment, and that, if met, constitute a permanent remedy to the release of the waste.
- Requires the local officer to conduct a public notification process, prescribed by DTSC or by the State Water Board, whichever entity certified the local officer, prior to issuing a letter to the responsible party certifying that the remedial action has been completed. Requires the local officer to then send the letter or document to DTSC, or the appropriate regional water quality control board (regional water board) within whose jurisdiction the waste release occurred, at least 30 days prior to certifying that the cleanup goals embodied in the remedial action agreement were accomplished.
- Requires the State Water Board, in cooperation with DTSC and the regional water boards, to develop and implement a local health officer certification program.
- Provides that the authority granted to the State Water Board and DTSC is in addition to the authority already statutorily granted to those entities.
- Authorizes the State Water Board to certify a local officer pursuant to this section if the State Water Board determines that the local officer is qualified to oversee or perform the abatement of unauthorized releases of waste. Requires the State Water Board to consider, as criteria for determining whether a local officer is qualified, at a minimum, all of the following factors:
- Adequacy of the technical expertise possessed by the local officer and his or her staff resources;
- Adequacy of staff resources;
- Knowledge of the Health and Safety Code, Water Code, and regulations or policies enacted by DTSC, the State Water Board, or a regional water board regarding the requirements for remediation of released waste;
- Adequacy of budget resources and funding mechanisms;
- Training requirements;
- Past performance in implementing and enforcing remedial action agreements;
- Recordkeeping and accounting systems and practices, including the use of the State Water Board’s environmental data management system for case management; and,
- Public notification practices and the provision of due process.
- Requires the State Water Board to adopt procedures and criteria for certifying and revoking certification of local officers. Exempts the adoption of these procedures and criteria from the Administrative Procedures Act.
- Authorizes, on and after July 1, 2020, only a certified local officer, or DTSC pursuant to its existing authorities, to enter into a remedial action agreement.
- Requires the State Water Board, if it does not, by July 1, 2021, certify a local officer who has been implementing remedial action agreements entered into before July 1, 2021, to transfer the cases for which certification of the officer is required from that local officer to DTSC, the appropriate regional water board, or a local officer who is certified by the State Water Board.
- Provides that an order or directive issued by an uncertified local officer before July 1, 2020, shall remain in effect and may be enforced by DTSC, the appropriate regional water board, or the local officer who receives the case.
- Requires the State Water Board to review, at least once every three years, the qualifications of a certified local officer to oversee or perform the abatement of unauthorized releases of waste. Requires the State Water Board, when conducting this review, to consider the certification criteria and the criteria adopted.
- Authorizes the State Water Board, after conducting the review, to revoke the certification of the local officer. Provides that, upon certification revocation, the oversight of or performance of the abatement that was handled by the formerly certified local officer may be transferred from the local officer to DTSC, the appropriate regional water board, or a local officer who is certified by the State Water Board. Requires the orders and directives issued by the formerly certified local officer to remain in effect and be enforceable.
- Requires the State Water Board to not make the date for the revocation of a certification effective prior to the termination date of the remedial action agreement entered into between the State Water Board and the local officer, unless the certified local officer fails to comply with the terms of the agreement.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a responsible party, whenever a release of waste occurs and remedial action is required, to request the local health officer to supervise the remedial action. Authorizes the local health officer to supervise the remedial action if she or he determines that adequate staff resources and the requisite technical expertise and capabilities are available to supervise the remedial action. (Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 101480 (b))
- Prohibits a local health officer from overseeing remedial action at specified sites determined by DTSC. (HSC § 101483)
- Requires a local health officer to provide written notice with specified information to DTSC and the appropriate regional water quality control board at least 10 working days prior to entering into an agreement with a responsible party. (HSC § 101487)
- Authorizes the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to certify Unified Program Agencies (CUPAs) to carry out environmental programs on behalf of the state, including programs related to the regulation of hazardous waste generators and onsite hazardous waste treatment, and the regulation of petroleum underground storage tanks. (HSC § 25404 - 25404.9)
- Authorizes the State Water Board to certify local agencies as qualified to clean up or oversee a responsible party to clean up soil and groundwater contamination from leaking underground storage tanks. Prohibits local agencies from overseeing the cleanup of leaking underground storage tank sites unless they have been certified by the State Water Board. (HSC § 25297.01)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "AB 432 will establish a state certification program for local health officers who oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites in order to ensure that all hazardous waste cleanup, whether done by the state, a local health agency, or a responsible party, is completed using uniform standards and procedures to ensure maximum protection of public health and the environment. AB 432 will empower local health officers with the knowledge and state assistance to tackle complex hazardous cleanup efforts."
Remedial actions: There are currently thousands of contaminated sites across the state where recent or historical unauthorized releases of pollutants to the environment have occurred. These sites are varied, but can include pesticide manufacturing facilities, rail yards, ports, dry cleaners and refineries where there have been releases of pollutants in to the soil, groundwater, surface water, and/or sediment. The types of pollutants encountered at these sites are plentiful and diverse and can include solvents, heavy metals, and petroleum.
The regional water boards and DTSC have the responsibility for identifying parties that are responsible for the contamination, setting cleanup standards and requirements, and overseeing the cleanup of the contaminated sites to ensure that they are properly remediated and do not continue to pose a threat to public health and the environment, or to contaminate groundwater. State law specifies requirements for cleaning up contaminated sites, and the regional water boards and DTSC have developed extensive policies and procedures for determining the extent and type of contamination, and processes and standards for the proper remediation of contaminated sites.
Legislative history on local oversight of hazardous waste cleanup: The California legislature has long been sensitive to the impacts that contaminated properties have on their local communities. It has also acknowledged that local agencies, when provided sufficient resources and information, can help the state address, through oversight or abatement efforts, the sites that require cleanup. This has resulted in a rich history of bestowing and revising local control over hazardous waste oversight and cleanup.
One of the earlier legislative initiatives related to local oversight of cleanup was the adoption of AB 3193 (Polanco, Chapter 1113, Statutes of 1990), known as the Polanco Redevelopment Act (HSC § 33459-33459.8). AB 3193 was enacted as part of the Community Redevelopment Act to assist redevelopment agencies in responding to brownfield properties in their redevelopment areas. Under the law, redevelopment agencies could take action to remediate releases of hazardous substances on a property that was part of a redevelopment project. The redevelopment agencies were granted a qualified immunity from liability under state or local law, provided that the cleanup was conducted in accordance with a remedial action plan approved by DTSC or a regional water board. (HSC § 33459.3)
In 1993, the Legislature created CUPAs through the enactment of SB 1082 (Calderon, Chapter 418, Statutes of 1993) to be regulated under the unified hazardous waste and hazardous materials management regulatory program (Unified Program) regulated by CalEPA. The Unified Program consolidates the administration, permit, inspection, and enforcement activities of six environmental and emergency management programs for hazardous waste management and cleanup at the local level. Under the Unified Program, CUPAs are certified to do corrective action on a limited number of tiered permitted hazardous waste facility sites. DTSC may certify CUPAs to oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites, if DTSC determines they are qualified to do so. These CUPAs may be certified by DTSC as approved for "Tier 1 cleanup oversight" for less complex sites or "Tier 2 cleanup oversight" for complex or high risk sites.
That same year, the legislature enacted AB 2061 (Umberg, Chapter 1184, Statutes of 1993) to establish the Site Designation Process to allow a responsible party to request CalEPA to designate a local agency to oversee the cleanup action.
In 1995, the Legislature enacted SB 1248 (O'Connell, Chapter 671, Statutes of 1995) authorizing a responsible party, whenever a release of waste occurs and remedial action is required, to request the local health officer to supervise the remedial action. The law authorizes the local health officer to supervise the remedial action if she/he determined that adequate staff resources and the requisite technical expertise and capabilities are available to supervise the remedial action. This program is commonly referred to as a "voluntary cleanup program." In this program, local health officers are required to enter into a remedial action agreement with the responsible party which specifies the testing, monitoring, and analysis that the responsible party will undertake to determine the extent and type of contamination at the site and the remedial actions that will be undertaken by the responsible party. (HSC § 101480)
In 2001, the California Land Environmental Restoration & Reuse Act (SB 32, Escutia, Chapter 764, Statutes of 2000), established a new hazardous materials investigation and cleanup program to be administered by local agencies with state oversight. Specifically, it authorized local agencies to enter into an agreement with DTSC or a regional water board for a property regarding DTSC’s or the regional water board’s activities to review documents, assure implementation, perform other related site investigation and remediation activities, and provide for cost reimbursement.
The Legislature eventually dissolved local redevelopment agencies (AB 1X 26, Blumenfield, Chapter 5, Statutes of 2011), which resulted in problems regarding local access to brownfield remediation tools previously granted under Polanco Redevelopment Act authority. AB 1X 26 required successor agencies to expeditiously dispose of assets and properties of former redevelopment agencies. However, there was concern that many of those properties would either be difficult for successor agencies to sell or to maximize the value of in the sale due to the actual or perceived contamination of the site. Therefore, the Legislature subsequently enacted AB 440 (Gatto, Chapter 588, Statues of 2013) to grant cities, counties, and housing authorities the power to investigate and clean up releases or spills within the boundaries of the local agency. AB 440 also provides immunity from further liability to the local agency, any person who enters into an agreement with that local agency to develop the property, and any future property owners.
Lastly, under the State Water Board’s Local Oversight Program (LOP), the State Water Board may certify local agencies (regardless of whether they are local health agencies) as qualified to clean up or oversee a responsible party cleanup soil and groundwater contamination from leaking underground storage tanks (HSC § 25297.1). Local agencies are prohibited from overseeing the cleanup of leaking underground storage tank cleanup sites unless they have been certified by the State Water Board.
Status of the voluntary cleanup program established pursuant to SB 1248: The remediation sites a local health officer currently oversees pursuant to a voluntary agreement include any site where there is no current lead agency (i.e. DTSC or regional water board) providing oversight, and where the local health officer determines she/he has the appropriate level of expertise. These sites include redevelopment with various previous site uses, such as gas stations, dry cleaners, industrial sites; gun range contamination; large spills from truck accidents; spills from aboveground tanks; contaminated soils associated with disposal sites; and, spills from machinery or other equipment, including transformers.
The United States Environmental Protection Agency estimates that there are between 96,000 and 212,000 contaminated sites in California. DTSC has identified approximately 9,800 contaminated sites statewide. This current law authorizing local health officers to oversee site remediation helps to fill the gap where state agencies may not have the bandwidth to address in a timely manner.
Before a local health officer can enter into a voluntary cleanup agreement with a responsible party, she/he is required to provide written notification to DTSC and the appropriate regional water board(s) within ten days prior to entering into an agreement with a responsible party (HSC § 101487). This ensures the state is aware of the site remediation and who is conducting it.
Importantly, a local health officer must determine the applicability of his/her authority to enter into a voluntary agreement. There are many prohibitions — sites where local health officers are prohibited from using the voluntary cleanup agreement authority, including, but not limited to, any State Response, federal Superfund and backlog sites designated by DTSC; sites subject to a cleanup and abatement order for a violation of any waste discharge requirement into a water source; or, sites that are under Phase I Environmental Assessment (HSC § 101483). Therefore, the notification required to the state before entering into a voluntary agreement provides the opportunity for the state and the local health officer to determine the applicability of the local health officer’s authority to oversee the site remediation.
Additionally, current law allows the local health officer to make the judgement call as to whether she/he has the staff resources, technical expertise, and capabilities to oversee site remediation, and if not, she/he can refer the site to the state. Also, a local health officer can, and often does, refer local voluntary cases to DTSC or regional water board when the site became larger or more complex than first expected, or where the responsible party did not agree to conduct the additional work being requested in the agreement.
It is unknown how many remediation sites statewide have been overseen by local health officers, but the authority is widely, currently used.
Which brings us to AB 432: Under all of the aforementioned statutes providing local agencies with the authority to oversee hazardous waste cleanup, the local agencies are certified by the state to do so. The only exception is the authority provided to do the voluntary cleanup program under SB 1248, which did not require any state certification or oversight.
The voluntary cleanup program does not specify any standards or requirements to which the remediation overseen by the local health officer must be conducted. AB 432 intends to bring this statute into the fold of state oversight to ensure hazardous waste cleanup is implemented under the same stringent standards that DTSC and the regional water boards follow for cleanup under other programs.
As envisioned, the certification program established by AB 432 would be similar to the State Water Board’s existing program for certifying local agencies to oversee the cleanup of sites contaminated by leaking underground storage tanks (LOP), and which prohibits local agencies from overseeing the cleanup of such sites unless they have been certified by the State Water Board.
AB 432 would require the State Water Board, in cooperation with DTSC, to develop and administer a program for certifying and overseeing local health officers who enter into remedial action agreements. The bill specifies that the State Water Board, in determining whether a local health officer is qualified to oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites, must evaluate specific factors, including staff resources and expertise, past performance, and record keeping. It would also prohibit local health officers from entering into remedial action agreements unless they have been certified by the State Water Board or by DTSC to do so.
Notably, while the State Water Board and DTSC both have authority to do hazardous waste cleanup, they have different jurisdictions. The State Water Board oversees remediation where hazardous waste impacts surface or ground waters of the state, as well as underground storage tank contamination. DTSC oversees essentially all other hazardous waste release cleanup.
Local concerns: There is concern that this certification program could become too onerous, time-consuming, and costly for local health officers. If that is the case, local officers will likely be disinclined to apply for this authority due to limited local resources.
The intent of the current law is to authorize local oversight and enable more entities to oversee hazardous waste cleanup. Given the magnitude of cleanup sites around the state, the more local agencies equipped to oversee site remediation, the more sites will be cleaned up in a timely manner. If local health officers opt out of the certification program established by this bill, then there will be a greater burden on DTSC and the regional water boards to oversee more cleanup sites.
This committee held a joint legislative hearing in February of this year on DTSC’s budget and fiscal constraints. There is concern that DTSC may not have the bandwidth or financial capabilities to take on more site remediation should the local agencies decide not to pursue certification pursuant to this bill.
The author is working with the State Water Board and DTSC to identify the costs and time commitment to comply with the anticipated requirements of a new certification program, and ascertain whether any costs will be passed down to the local health officer.
Policy issues for further consideration: It is critical that any entity overseeing or conducting hazardous waste cleanup have sufficient resources and technical expertise to ensure that the cleanup is done to state standards to ensure protection of public health and the environment. The intent of AB 432 is to provide that support to local health agencies through a certification program similar to other state certification programs.
In order to do that in a comprehensive way, there are some policy issues, summarized below, that the author should continue working on with the local health officers, the State Water Board, and DTSC, and other stakeholders, including:
- There are currently 81 CUPAs and 62 local health officers. Given the array of local agencies with potentially overlapping hazardous waste cleanup authorities, and which may not be local health officers, the author may wish to consider whether this bill should solely apply to local health officers, or whether the law should be extended to any local agency that is qualified and certified by the state to provide remediation oversight.
- Current law authorizes local health officers to oversee site remediation. This bill provides certification for that oversight and would give those local health officers, upon certification, authority to conduct the abatement. The author may wish to consider the intended scope of the bill, which may be appropriate to consider within the context of discussion on whether this provision of law should apply to all local agencies who qualify and can be certified, or just local health officers.
- In HSC § 101480(e) of the bill, the language recognizes that a local health officer may be certified by either the State Water Board or DTSC, and HSC § 101481(b) only authorizes the State Water Board to certify a local health officer. The author may wish to consider clarifying that § 101480 is recognizing existing DTSC certification (under other programs for hazardous waste cleanup) and that the State Water Board certification pursuant to § 101481is only needed in the absence of DTSC certification.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None received.
Opposition
None received.
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):