AB 508: Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-27
(1)Existing law, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, provides for the operation of public water systems and imposes on the State Water Resources Control Board various responsibilities and duties. The act authorizes the state board to order consolidation with, or extension of service from, a receiving water system, as defined, if a public water system or state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water or if a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water. The act requires the state board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to, among other things, obtain written consent from any domestic well owner for consolidation or extension of service. The act makes any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area that does not provide written consent ineligible, until consent is provided, for water-related grant funding, as specified. The act also requires the state board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make a finding that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service to the subsumed water system is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. The act defines subsumed water system for these purposes as the public water system, state small water system, or affected residences consolidated into or receiving service from the receiving water system.
This bill would modify the provision that authorizes consolidation or extension of service if a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well described above to instead authorize consolidation or extension of service if a disadvantaged community, in whole or in part, is substantially reliant on domestic wells that consistently fail to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water. The bill would impose the additional requirement that the state board consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided or are likely to provide written consent to extension of service and would specify that the state board need not find that any specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area are likely to consent to the consolidation or extension of service to serve their dwelling units. The bill would revise the requirement for written consent from a domestic well owner to instead prohibit an order from requiring the consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well until an owner of the affected residence provides written consent to the consolidation or extension of service. The bill would revise the definition of a subsumed water system to apply to affected residences served by domestic wells.
(2)The act also requires the state board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to, among other things, hold at least one public meeting at the initiation of this process in a place as close as feasible to the affected areas. The act requires the state board to make reasonable efforts to provide a 30-day notice of the meeting, as specified.
This bill would require the state board to include prescribed information in the 30-day notice.
(3)Upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, the act requires the board, among other things, to compensate the receiving water system for any capacity lost as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, as necessary and appropriate, either by paying a capacity connection fee or providing additional capacity needed as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, and by paying legal fees.
This bill would rename a capacity connection fee a capacity charge and would require a capacity charge to be paid only to the extent that it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service.
The following definitions shall apply to this section and Sections 116682, 116684, and 116686:
(a)Adequate supply means sufficient water to meet residents health and safety needs at all times.
(b)Affected residence means a residence within a disadvantaged community that is reliant on a water supply that is either inadequate or unsafe and that is not served by a public water system or state small water system.
(c)Consistently fails means a failure to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(d)Consolidated water system means the public water system resulting from the consolidation of a public water system with another public water system, state small water system, or affected residences.
(e)Consolidation means joining two or more public water systems, state small water systems, or affected residences into a single public water system.
(f)Disadvantaged community means a disadvantaged community, as defined in Section 79505.5 of the Water Code.
(g)Domestic well means a groundwater well used to supply water for the domestic needs of an individual residence or a water system that is not a public water system and that has no more than four service connections.
(h)Extension of service means the provision of service through any physical or operational infrastructure arrangement other than consolidation.
(i)Infill site means a site within the area served by a subsumed water system that, as of the date of consolidation, is adjacent to a parcel that is developed for qualified urban uses.
(j)Qualified urban use means any residential, commercial, public institutional, industrial, transit or transportation facility, or retail use, or any combination of those uses.
(k)Receiving water system means the public water system that provides service to a subsumed water system through consolidation or extension of service.
(l)Safe drinking water means water that meets all primary and secondary drinking water standards.
(m)State small water system has the same meaning as provided in Section 116275.
(n)Subsumed water system means the public water system, state small water system, or affected residences served by domestic wells consolidated into or receiving service from the receiving water system.
SEC. 2.Section 116682 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:116682.(a)(1)The state board, in circumstances described in subparagraph (A) or (B), may order consolidation with a receiving water system as provided in this section and Section 116684. The consolidation may be physical or operational. The state board may also order the extension of service to an area within a disadvantaged community that does not have access to an adequate supply of safe drinking water so long as the extension of service is an interim extension of service in preparation for consolidation. The consolidation shall occur within six months of the initiation of the extension of service. The state board may set timelines and performance measures to facilitate completion of consolidation.
(A)A public water system or a state small water system, serving a disadvantaged community, consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(B)A disadvantaged community, in whole or in part, is substantially reliant on domestic wells that consistently fail to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(2)No later than July 1, 2020, the state board shall develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the state board to consider ordering consolidation. The state board shall adopt the policy in a policy handbook consistent with the process provided for in subdivision (a) of Section 116760.43.
(b)Before ordering consolidation or extension of service as provided in this section, the state board shall do all of the following:
(1)Encourage voluntary consolidation or extension of service.
(2)Consider other enforcement remedies specified in this article.
(3)Consult with, and fully consider input from, the relevant local agency formation commission regarding the provision of water service in the affected area, the recommendations for improving service in a municipal service review, whether the consolidation or extension of service is cost effective, and any other relevant information.
(4)Consult with, and fully consider input from, the Public Utilities Commission when the consolidation would involve a water corporation subject to the commissions jurisdiction. If a receiving water system is regulated by the Public Utilities Commission, the state board shall inform the commission at least 60 days before the consolidation order, and upon issuance of the order the commission shall open a proceeding to determine cost allocation, ratemaking, and commission public participation requirements for the consolidation process.
(5)Consult with, and fully consider input from, the local government with land use planning authority over the affected area, particularly regarding any information in the general plan required by Section 65302.10 of the Government Code.
(6)Consult with, and fully consider input from, all public water systems in the chain of distribution of the potentially receiving water systems.
(7)(A)Notify the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water system, if any, and establish a reasonable deadline of no less than six months, unless a shorter period is justified, for the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water system, if any, to negotiate consolidation or another means of providing an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(B)During this period, the state board shall provide technical assistance and work with the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water system to develop a financing package that benefits both the receiving water system and the subsumed water system.
(C)Upon a showing of good cause, the deadline may be extended by the state board at the request of the potentially receiving water system, potentially subsumed water system, the local agency formation commission with jurisdiction over the potentially subsumed water system, or the Public Utilities Commission.
(8)Consider the affordability of the anticipated monthly rates for drinking water service to residential customers of the potentially subsumed water system.
(9)(A)Hold at least one public meeting at the initiation of this process in a place as close as feasible to the affected areas. The state board shall make reasonable efforts to provide a 30-day notice of the meeting to the ratepayers, renters, and property owners to receive water service through service extension or in the area of the subsumed water system and all affected local government agencies and drinking water service providers. The 30-day notice shall include information about water quality concerns in the area, relevant information about health effects of water contaminants, and information about opportunities for consolidation or extension of service to address water quality issues. The meeting shall provide representatives of the potentially subsumed water system, affected ratepayers, renters, property owners, the potentially receiving water system, and the public an opportunity to present oral and written comments.
(B)The state board shall provide an opportunity to submit comments by mail or electronically during the notice period and for at least one week after the meeting.
(C)The state board shall review comments received during the meeting and received by mail and electronically during the notice period and for one week after the public meeting.
(c)If a consolidation or other means of providing an adequate supply of safe drinking water has not been negotiated by the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water system before the expiration of the deadline set by the state board pursuant to paragraph (7) of subdivision (b), the state board shall do the following:
(1)Consult with the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water system, if any.
(2)(A)If the consolidation has not concluded within six months following the first public meeting held pursuant to paragraph (9) of subdivision (b), conduct a public meeting in a location as close as feasible to the affected communities. The meeting shall be held after the state board has made the findings described in subdivision (d).
(B)The state board shall make reasonable efforts to provide a 30-day notice of the meeting to the ratepayers, renters, property owners to receive water service through service extension or in the area of the subsumed water system, and the public, and to all affected local government agencies and drinking water service providers.
(C)The meeting shall provide representatives of the potentially subsumed water system, affected ratepayers, renters, property owners, and the potentially receiving water system an opportunity to present oral and written comments.
(D)The meeting shall provide an opportunity for public comment.
(3)The state board shall make reasonable efforts to ensure that a receiving water system and a subsumed water system are informed on a regular basis of progress regarding actions taken pursuant to this section.
(d)Before ordering consolidation or extension of service, the state board shall find all of the following:
(1)The potentially subsumed water system has consistently failed to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(2)Reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made.
(3)Consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. In making this finding, the state board shall consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service. The state board need not find that any specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area are likely to consent to the consolidation or extension of service to serve their dwelling unit.
(4)There is no pending local agency formation commission process that is likely to resolve the problem in a reasonable amount of time.
(5)Concerns regarding water rights and water contracts of the subsumed and receiving water systems have been adequately addressed.
(6)Consolidation or extension of service is an effective and cost-effective means to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
(7)The capacity of the proposed interconnection needed to accomplish the consolidation is limited to serving the current customers of the subsumed water system, infill sites within the community served by the subsumed water system, residents of disadvantaged communities in existence as of the date of consolidation and that are located along the service line connecting the subsumed water system and the receiving water system, and vacant lots within the community served by the subsumed water system that are zoned to allow residential use and have no more than one other vacant lot between that parcel and an infill parcel, including capacity needed for services such as firefighting.
(e)Upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, the state board shall do all of the following:
(1)As necessary and appropriate, as determined by the state board, compensate the receiving water system for any capacity lost as a result of the consolidation or extension of service either by paying the water systems capacity charge set out in the water systems adopted rate structure or by providing additional capacity needed as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, and by paying legal fees. When the receiving water system is compensated for capacity lost by payment of a capacity charge, the capacity charge shall be paid only to the extent that it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service in accordance with Section 66013 of the Government Code. If capacity beyond what is needed for consolidation is provided by a project funded through the state board, the state board shall retain an option to use that capacity for future consolidations, without paying additional capacity charges, for five years, unless it releases that option in writing. Funding pursuant to this paragraph is available for the general purpose of providing financial assistance for the infrastructure needed for the consolidation or extension of service and does not need to be specific to each individual consolidation project. The state board shall provide appropriate financial assistance for the water infrastructure needed for the consolidation or extension of service. The state boards existing financial assistance guidelines and policies shall be the basis for the financial assistance.
(2)Ensure payment of standard local agency formation commission fees caused by state board-ordered consolidation or extension of service.
(3)Adequately compensate the owners of a privately owned subsumed water system for the fair market value of the system, as determined by the Public Utilities Commission or the state board.
(4)Coordinate with the appropriate local agency formation commission and other relevant local agencies to facilitate the change of organization or reorganization.
(5)If ordering consolidation or extension of service between two water systems, consider any existing domestic wells within the service area that could also be subject to consolidation or extension of service pursuant to this section.
(6)If ordering consolidation or extension of service to a community containing residences served by domestic wells, promptly take all reasonable steps to obtain written consent to the consolidation or extension of service from an owner of each residence served by a domestic well.
(f)If funds are appropriated for this purpose, the state board may make funds available for the purposes of subdivision (e), as necessary and appropriate, to the receiving water system, the subsumed water system, or an administrator providing full oversight of construction or development projects related to a consolidation or extension of service.
(g)(1)For purposes of this section, fees, charges, and terms and conditions that may be imposed on new and existing customers of a receiving water system shall be subject to the following limitations:
(A)The consolidated water system shall not increase charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit.
(B)Except as provided in paragraph (2), fees or charges imposed on a customer of a subsumed water system shall not exceed the costs of the service.
(C)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the receiving water system shall not charge any fees to, or place conditions on, customers of the subsumed water system that it does not charge to, or impose on, new customers that are not subject to the consolidation with the receiving water system.
(2)(A)Notwithstanding subparagraph (B) or (C) of paragraph (1), if costs incurred by the receiving water system in completing the consolidation or extension of service are not otherwise recoverable as provided in subparagraph (B) of this paragraph, the receiving water system may charge fees to customers of the subsumed water system to recover those costs.
(B)A receiving water system shall not charge a fee pursuant to subparagraph (A) for costs that are otherwise recoverable from the state, the federal government, programs administered by local agencies, parties responsible for causing contamination that the consolidation or extension of service is designed to address, or other sources, as determined by the state board.
(h)The state board shall not, pursuant to this section, fund public works or upgrades unrelated to the delivery of an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water, including, but not limited to, the installation of streetlights, sidewalks, curbs, and gutters. A local agencys decision whether to provide these public works or upgrades shall not delay the consolidation or extension of service.
(i)When a public water system is operated by a local educational agency, the state board may order a receiving water system to consolidate or extend service to a public water system operated by a local educational agency pursuant to this section if both the following additional conditions are met:
(1)The local educational agency serves students from one or more census blocks that are disadvantaged communities.
(2)The state board obtains a written determination from the local educational agency that the state boards analysis in the financing package, developed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (7) of subdivision (b), indicates that consolidating or extending service would not result in additional unacceptable costs to the local educational agency and would result in safe drinking water being available to the local educational agency.
(j)An order pursuant to this section shall not require consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well until an owner of the affected residence provides written consent to the consolidation or extension of service. Any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area that does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency.
(k)Division 3 (commencing with Section 56000) of Title 5 of the Government Code does not apply to an action taken by the state board pursuant to this section.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 27, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 352, Statutes of 2019. |
| Sep 27, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 5 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 31, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (July 3). |
| Jun 12, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and GOV. & F. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| May 7, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 6, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on L. GOV. (Ayes 6. Noes 3.) (April 9). |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and L. GOV. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 5, 2019 | AB 508 Chu Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB508 Chu By Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 508 Chu Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Local Government] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 508
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:August 12, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes changes to statute related to the State Water Resources Control Board's (State Water Board's) authority to order the consolidation of drinking water systems, including setting a deadline of July 1, 2020, as the date by which the State Water Board must develop a policy that provides a process for members of a disadvantaged community to petition for consolidation; deleting statute that requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to obtain written consent to the project from a domestic well owner; providing that when the receiving water system is compensated for capacity lost by payment of a capacity charge, the capacity charge shall be paid only to the extent that it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service; and, makes other technical and conforming changes.
The Senate Amendments:
- Delete provisions that would have required the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and occupants of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit's drinking water.
- Delete provisions that would have required the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to provide written notice to the potentially receiving water system of a request to obtain consent of well and dwelling unit owners for consolidation or extension of service.
- Delete provisions that would have declared that the domestic well shall be ineligible for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency until the owner provides written consent for consolidation or extension of service.
- Add information that must be included in the 30-day notice for the public meeting that the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, must conduct.
- Prohibit an order for consolidation or extension of service from requiring consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well.
- Make other technical and conforming changes.
COMMENTS:
Drinking water contamination in disadvantaged communities: According to a 2018 University of California at Davis report, "In low-income communities located outside city boundaries (known as disadvantaged unincorporated communities or DUCs), drinking water is often unsafe to drink. In many such localities, drinking water is contaminated by industrial by-products (usually associated with agriculture, oil and gas production, transportation, and manufacturing) and compromised by inadequate wastewater treatment and disposal systems, as well as naturally occurring toxic substances like arsenic and uranium." The report found that a significant number of DUC residents live close to an existing, and water-quality-compliant, community water system that could provide them with clean drinking water.
Providing safe, affordable drinking water to disadvantaged communities: For common sources of drinking water contamination, such as arsenic and nitrates, expensive systems must be installed and operated to treat the water to meet drinking water standards. In many cases, technological advances have not yet been sufficient to make such treatment systems affordable, especially to small, disadvantaged communities. In addition, many small, disadvantaged communities do not have the technical, managerial, or financial capability to maintain and operate what are sometimes complex drinking water systems.
Consolidation of water systems: Restructuring can be an effective means to help small water systems achieve and maintain technical, managerial, and financial capacity, and to reduce the oversight and resources that the state needs to devote to these systems. Consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities that rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, or on private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidation does this by extending costs to a larger pool of ratepayers.
California has recognized the benefits of consolidation for decades, through legislation and regulation. This bill builds upon the authority vested in the State Water Board to order the consolidation of dwellings that are reliant on domestic wells with inadequate supplies of safe water in disadvantaged communities with water systems that can provide safe, affordable drinking water. Its intent is to remove barriers to, and to encourage, consolidation efforts.
According to the Author:
"Last year, the State made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501 [(Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018]. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on our progress by improving transparency and efficiency in the ordered consolidation or extension of service process. This bill will give all community members the information they need to be engaged in efforts to improve water quality in their neighborhood."
Arguments in Support:
A coalition of supporters argues, "Upwards of one million Californians lack safe drinking water. Water that runs from the taps in their homes and in their schools is tainted with arsenic, nitrate, uranium, 1,2,3 TCP, E. coli, and other contaminants and pathogens. For many families, domestic wells have run dry and no water runs into their homes. AB 508 would build on SB 88 (2015) and AB 2501 (2018) to strengthen important tools for addressing this drinking water crisis."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 6-3-0
YES: Quirk, Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Melendez, Dahle, Mathis
ASM LOCAL GOVERNMENT: 7-0-1
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Lackey
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-18-4
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Mayes
SENATE FLOOR: 27-9-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Chang, Hurtado, Moorlach
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 12, 2019
CONSULTANT: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0001814
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 508 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 508
Amended: 8/12/19 in Senate
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 7/3/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Dahle
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 7/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach, Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-18, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells
SOURCE: Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
DIGEST: This bill makes changes to statute related to the State Water Resources Control Board’s (SWRCB’s) authority to order the consolidation of drinking water systems, including setting a deadline of July 1, 2020, as the date by which the SWRCB must develop a policy that provides a process for members of a disadvantaged community to petition for consolidation; and requiring the SWRCB, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and occupants of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit’s drinking water.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards. (42 United States Code § 300(f) et seq.)
- Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code § 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the California SDWA, the SWRCB to regulate drinking water and to enforce the federal SDWA and other regulations. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 116275 et seq.)
- Authorizes the SWRCB, where a public water system or a state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water or where a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, to order consolidation, either physical or operational, with a receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (a)(1))
- Requires the SWRCB to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the SWRCB to consider ordering consolidation. (HSC § 116682 (a)(2))
- Provides that any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area who does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency. (HSC § 116682 (b)(9))
- Requires the SWRCB, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make seven findings, including that the potentially subsumed water system has consistently failed to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; that all reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made; and, that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. (HSC §116682 (d))
- Prohibits, in the case of an ordered consolidation, the consolidated water system from increasing charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit. Provides that, in the case of an ordered consolidation, fees or charges imposed on a customer of a subsumed water system shall not exceed the cost of the service. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(A) - (B))
- Prohibits the receiving water system from charging any fees to, or place conditions on, customers of the subsumed water system that it does not charge to, or impose on, new customers that are not subject to the consolidation with the receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(C))
This bill:
- Establishes a deadline of July 1, 2020, for the existing requirement that the SWRCB develop and adopt a policy for members of a disadvantaged community to petition the SWRCB to consider ordering a consolidation.
- Makes other changes to the provisions of law that allow consolidation or extension of service to a community served by a failing domestic well. Specifically, clarifies that the SWRCB may order a consolidation with a receiving water system or extension of service in a disadvantaged unincorporated community that is, in whole or in part, substantially reliant on domestic wells that consistently fail to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Requires the 30-day notice prior to initiating consolidation to include information about water quality concerns in the area, relevant information about health effects of water contaminants, and information about opportunities for consolidation or extension of service to address water quality issues.
- Elaborates on the findings that the SWRCB must make prior to ordering a consolidation or extension of service. Specifically, when making a finding that consolidation or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible, requires the SWRCB to consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service. If the SWRCB orders a consolidation or extension of service to a community containing residences served by domestic wells, it must promptly take all reasonable steps to obtain written consent to the consolidation or extension of service from an owner of each residence served by a domestic well.
- Makes other clarifying and technical changes to the provisions that govern the imposition and payment of fees and charges by residents of a consolidated system, including renaming a “capacity connection fee” as a “capacity charge,” in accordance with current law; and requiring a capacity charge to be paid only to the extent it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service, in conformity with existing law.
- Specifies that an order pursuant to these provisions shall not require consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well until an owner or the affected residence provides written consent to the extension of service.
- Specifies that any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area that does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency.
Background
- The Legislative Analyst’s Office provides a succinct background on the general topic of Safe and Affordable Drinking Water in their Analysis of the 2018-19 Governor’s Budget, as follows:
“Federal, State, and Local Entities Regulate Drinking Water. The federal Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Act (SDWA) was enacted in 1974 to protect public health by regulating drinking water. California has enacted its own safe drinking water act to implement the federal law and establish state standards. The U.S. EPA enforces the federal SDWA at the national level. However, most states, including California, have been granted “primacy” by the U.S. EPA, giving them authority to implement and enforce the federal SDWA at the state level.
“Maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) are health-based drinking water standards that public water systems are required to meet. MCLs take into account the health risk, detectability, treatability, and costs of treatment associated with a pollutant. Agencies responsible for regulating water quality enforce these standards.
“The California State Water Resources Control Board’s (SWRCB) Division of Drinking Water (DDW) regulates public water systems that provide water for human consumption and have 15 or more service connections, or regularly serve at least 25 individuals daily at least 60 days out of the year. (A ‘service connection’ is usually the point of access between a water system’s service pipe and a user’s piping.) The state does not regulate water systems with less than 15 connections; county health officers oversee them. At the local level, 30 of the 58 county environmental health departments in California have been delegated primacy—known as Local Primacy Agencies (LPAs)—by the SWRCB to regulate systems with between 15 and 200 connections within their jurisdiction. For investor-owned water utilities under the jurisdiction of California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), the DDW or LPAs share water quality regulatory authority with CPUC.
“The DDW regulates approximately 7,500 water systems. About one-third of these systems have between 15 and 200 service connections. The number of smaller systems—specifically, those with 14 or fewer connections— is unknown but estimated to be in the thousands.
“Multiple Causes of Unsafe Drinking Water. The causes of unsafe drinking water can generally be separated into two categories (1) contamination caused by human action and (2) naturally occurring contaminants. In some areas, there are both human caused and natural contaminants in the drinking water.
“Three of the most commonly detected pollutants in contaminated water are arsenic, perchlorate, and nitrates. While arsenic is naturally occurring, perchlorate contamination is generally a result of military and industrial uses. High concentrations of nitrate in groundwater are primarily caused by human activities, including fertilizer application (synthetic and manure), animal operations, industrial sources (wastewater treatment and food processing facilities), and septic systems. Agricultural fertilizers and animal wastes applied to cropland are by far the largest regional sources of nitrate in groundwater, although other sources can be important in certain areas.
“Unsafe Drinking Water a Statewide Problem. The SWRCB has identified a total of 331 water systems that it or LPAs regulate that are in violation of water quality standards. These water systems serve an estimated 500,000 people throughout the state. The number of water systems with 14 or fewer connections that are currently in violation of water quality standards is unknown, but estimated to be in the thousands by the SWRCB. Of the 331 systems identified by the SWRCB, 68 have violations associated with nitrates (and in some cases, additional contaminants). In some of these water systems, unsafe contamination levels persist over time because the local agency cannot generate sufficient revenue from its customer base to implement, operate, or maintain the improvements necessary to address the problem. The challenge in these systems is often a product of a combination of factors, including the high costs of the investments required, low income of the customers, and the small number of customers across whom the costs would need to be spread.” - Consolidation of Public Water Systems. SB 88 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, Chapter 27, Statutes of 2015) authorized SWRCB to require water systems that are serving disadvantaged communities with unreliable and unsafe drinking water to consolidate with or receive service from public water systems with safe, reliable, and adequate drinking water. SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016) authorized the SWRCB to identify public water systems that are consistently unable to provide an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water and, once funding is available, to then contract with a competent administrator to provide managerial and technical expertise to that system.
Consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities and areas, which currently rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, as well as private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidating or extending service from a public water system to a community otherwise served by unreliable systems or unregulated private wells advances the goal of a reliable, accessible supply of safe drinking water for all California residents.
The SWRCB currently posts information on its website about ordered consolidations. It also tracks and has information on voluntary consolidations. Currently, 60 consolidations are being funded by SWRCB. Fifteen mandatory consolidations are currently proceeding, although 5 of those have decided to pursue voluntary consolidation. Only one mandatory consolidation has been completed so far. In 2017-18, there were 90 voluntary physical consolidations and six voluntary managerial consolidations. Physical consolidations are for systems that are close enough to be connected by new pipelines. In managerial or operational consolidation, the systems remain physically separate, but are managed by the same entity.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Last year, the state made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501 [(Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018]. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on progress made by AB 2501 by reducing existing barriers between these communities and safe drinking water.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2501 (Chu, Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018) authorized the SWRCB to order consolidation with a receiving water system when a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; prohibited, for an ordered consolidation, the receiving water system from charging specified fees or imposing specified conditions on customers of the subsumed water system that it would not otherwise charge or impose; and, made other changes to ordered consolidation law.
SB 623 (Monning, 2017) would have created the Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund, administered by the SWRCB, to assist communities and individual domestic well users to address contaminants in drinking water that exceed safe drinking water standards. The bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 778 (Hertzberg, 2017) would have required the SWRCB to report on public water system consolidations to date, and their success or failure. The bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016) authorized the SWRCB to contract with an administrator to provide administrative and managerial services to a designated public water system to assist with the provision of an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water.
SB 1263 (Wieckowski, Chapter 843, Statutes of 2016) authorized the SWRCB to deny a permit for a new public water system if it determines that it is reasonably foreseeable that the proposed new public water system will be unable to provide affordable, safe drinking water.
SB 88 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, Chapter 27, Statutes of 2015) authorized the SWRCB to require water systems that are serving disadvantaged communities with unreliable and unsafe drinking water to consolidate with, or receive service from, public water systems with safe, reliable, and adequate drinking water.
AB 685 (Eng, Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012) declared that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes and that relevant state agencies, including the Department of Water Resources, the SWRCB, and the State Department of Public Health shall consider this state policy when revising, adopting, or establishing policies, regulations, and grant criteria pertinent to the human uses of water.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability (source)
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment Action
Aoki Water Justice Clinic, University of California, Davis, School of Law
Association of California Water Agencies
Audubon California
California Apartment Association
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Institute for Rural Studies
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice
Center for Sustainable Neighborhoods
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Clean Water Action
Community Water Center
Courage Campaign
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Lutheran Office of Public Policy- California
Planning and Conservation League
Policy Link
Pueblo Unido CDC
Sierra Club California
Social Justice Ministry, Diocese of Fresno
The Trust for Public Land
Western Center on Law & Poverty
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-18, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O’Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Mayes
Prepared by: Gabrielle Meindl / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/21/19 16:16:39
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 508 | Hearing Date: | 7/10/19 |
Author: | Chu | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 7/5/19 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells
Establishes a deadline of July 1, 2020, for the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to adopt a policy for members of a disadvantaged community to petition the SWRCB to consider ordering a consolidation, and updates the law allowing extension of service to a community with a failing domestic well.
Background
Local government boundaries. The Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Act creates a local agency formation commission (LAFCO) in each county to control the boundaries of cities, county service areas, and most special districts. The courts often refer to LAFCOs as the Legislature’s watchdog over boundary changes. To plan for the future boundaries and service areas of the cities and special districts, a LAFCO must adopt a policy document for each city and district called a sphere of influence. The LAFCO’s boundary decisions must be consistent with the spheres of influence of the affected cities or districts. LAFCOs must update spheres at least every five years.
Local governments can only exercise their powers and provide services where LAFCO allows them to: within their boundaries (which LAFCO sets), within their spheres of influence but outside their boundaries (with authorization by LAFCO), and outside their spheres to address a major threat to public health if the extension is consistent with LAFCO’s policies. In 2015, the Legislature approved AB 402 (Dodd), which established a pilot program in Napa County and San Bernardino County that allowed the extension of services outside a local agency’s sphere of influence to support existing or planned uses under specified conditions. A local government that wants to expand its territory must ask LAFCO to annex new territory into the local government’s boundaries.
To determine spheres of influence, LAFCOs must periodically conduct a “municipal service review” (MSR) to inform their decisions. Among other topics, MSRs must analyze and make determinations about whether adequate public services are available to current and future residents in the county, and whether services could be improved by governmental reorganizations.
Drinking water challenges. In 2013, SWRCB released a report, Communities that Rely on Contaminated Groundwater. The report identified 682 water systems in California, serving nearly 21 million people, that rely on contaminated groundwater as a primary source of drinking water. While many of those systems successfully treat their water to all required standards, the report also found that 265 water systems, serving a little more than two million people, had received at least one drinking water quality violation within the last compliance cycle. The report also noted that an additional two million Californians rely on groundwater from a private domestic well or a smaller groundwater-reliant system that is not regulated by the state, of which the water quality is uncertain. The findings from SWRCB report, as well as a January 2012, University of California at Davis study on nitrate contamination in California’s groundwater, indicate that drinking water contamination in California disproportionally affects small, rural, and low-income communities that depend mostly on groundwater as their drinking water source.
SB 244 (Wolk, 2011). In recent years, the Legislature has taken several steps to try to address some of the service problems experienced by disadvantaged unincorporated communities (DUCs). SB 244 (Wolk, 2011) aimed to prevent cities from carving out DUCs by prohibiting annexations to a city of territory greater than 10 acres if a DUC is contiguous with the territory proposed for annexation, unless there is an application with the commission to annex the unincorporated area or if the residents of the affected territory oppose annexation. SB 244 also required LAFCOs to include in the MSR a description of the location and characteristics of any DUCs within or contiguous to the sphere of influence and to consider the water, sewer, or fire protection needs of DUCs within the sphere when considering updates. When conducting an MSR, LAFCOs can also assess options for governmental reorganizations or consolidations that improve the efficiency and affordability of service delivery and can review whether water systems in the area are in compliance with the Safe Drinking Water Act. Finally, SB 244 required cities and counties to review the water and fire service needs of DUCs in their general plans.
SB 88 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2015). Subsequently, the Legislature took this effort a step further. SB 88 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2015) granted SWRCB the authority to order the consolidation of neighboring drinking water systems where it is economically feasible to address public health threats (SB 88, Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2015). SB 88 established an elaborate process for consolidating water systems that requires multiple public hearings, as well as consultations with affected entities (such as the water system being subsumed, the receiving water system, domestic well owners, and the local government with land use authority over the area) and LAFCO. Among other requirements, SWRCB must hold at least one public meeting at the initiation of a consolidation or extension of service in a place as close as feasible to the affected areas and must make reasonable efforts to provide a 30-day notice of the meeting to affected ratepayers, renters, and property owners.
Before ordering consolidation or extension of service, SWRCB must also encourage voluntary consolidations or extension of service, consider other enforcement remedies, obtain written consent from any domestic well owner, and provide technical assistance to both systems. The SWRCB must also make a series of findings, including that:
- Consolidation or extension of service is the most effective and cost-effective means to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; and
- The capacity of the proposed interconnection needed to accomplish the consolidation is limited to serving the current customers of the subsumed water system.
Under SB 88, SWRCB must pay the full cost of the new capacity, including replacing any capacity lost as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, providing additional capacity needed as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, and legal fees. The SWRCB must also pay LAFCO’s costs and fees, adequately compensate the owners of any privately owned subsumed water system, and coordinate with the appropriate local agency formation commission and other relevant local agencies to facilitate the change of organization or reorganization.
The following year, SB 552 (Wolk, 2016) gave SWRCB another tool to address the systemic issues affecting public water systems serving small, disadvantaged communities. SB 552 authorizes SWRCB to identify public water systems that are consistently unable to provide an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water and, once funding is available, to then contract with a competent administrator to provide managerial and technical expertise to that system.
To date, SWRCB has completed one mandatory consolidation and initiated an additional 15 mandatory consolidations, five of which are now pursuing consolidations voluntarily. SWRCB has also issued numerous informal consolidation letters indicating SWRCB’s intent to initiate consolidation, which have led to over 90 voluntary consolidations from 2017 to 2018. In addition, SWRCB now tracks non-compliant water systems and makes that information publicly available on its website.
Despite the recent legislation and state action, as of February 2019, SWRCB had identified 330 systems statewide that chronically serve contaminated drinking water or cannot provide reliable water service due to either unsound infrastructure or lack of local financial, managerial, and technical resources. As noted in a February 2018, University of California (UC) Davis report, The Struggle for Water Justice in California’s San Joaquin Valley: A Focus on Disadvantaged Unincorporated Communities, “in California, lack of access to clean, safe, and affordable water is a threat to public health and well-being, and violates the state’s newly codified Human Right to Water. In low-income communities located outside city boundaries (known as disadvantaged unincorporated communities or DUCs), drinking water is often unsafe to drink. In many such localities, drinking water is contaminated by industrial by-products (usually associated with agriculture, oil and gas production, transportation, and manufacturing) and compromised by inadequate wastewater treatment and disposal systems, as well as naturally occurring toxic substances like arsenic and uranium.”
The 2018 UC Davis report included policy recommendations to better enable DUCs to secure access to safe and affordable drinking water. These recommendations included that
“state law should clarify that the [SWRCB] may use its authority to extend services to DUC residents who receive residential water from [state small water systems] and private wells. Another potential mechanism for expanding the reach and effectiveness of the law would be to allow communities without safe drinking water to petition the state to consider ordering consolidations.”
Last year, the Legislature implemented these recommendations in AB 2501 (Chu, 2018). AB 2501 required SWRCB to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the state board to consider ordering consolidation and authorized SWRCB to use its SB 88 authority to consolidate a disadvantaged community that is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water. AB 2501 also revised various provisions established by SB 88 and SB 552, including provisions that require SWRCB to pay for infrastructure needed and capacity lost as part of a consolidation.
The Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability wants the Legislature to clean up and enhance some provisions of AB 2501.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 508 establishes a deadline of July 1, 2020, for the existing requirement that the SWRCB develop and adopt a policy for members of a disadvantaged community to petition the SWRCB to consider ordering a consolidation. It also makes other changes to the provisions of law that allow consolidation or extension of service to a community served by a failing domestic well. Specifically, AB 508 clarifies that the SWRCB may order a consolidation with a receiving water system or extension of service in a DUC that is, in whole or in part, substantially reliant on domestic wells that consistently fail to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
AB 508 requires the 30-day notice prior to initiating consolidation to include information about water quality concerns in the area, relevant information about health effects of water contaminants, and information about opportunities for consolidation or extension of service to address water quality issues.
AB 508 elaborates on the findings that the SWRCB must make prior to ordering a consolidation or extension of service. Specifically, when making a finding that consolidation or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible, AB 508 requires the SWRCB to consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service. If the SWRCB orders a consolidation or extension of service to a community containing residences served by domestic wells, it must promptly take all reasonable steps to obtain written consent to the consolidation or extension of service from an owner of each residence served by a domestic well.
AB 508 makes other clarifying and technical changes to the provisions of SB 88 that govern the imposition and payment of fees and charges by residents of a consolidated system, including to:
- Rename a “capacity connection fee” as a “capacity charge,” in accordance with current law; and
- Require a capacity charge to be paid only to the extent it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service, in conformity with existing law.
AB 508 specifies that an order pursuant to these provisions shall not require consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well until an owner or the affected residence provides written consent to the extension of service.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Last year, the State made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on our progress by improving transparency and efficiency in the ordered consolidation or extension of service process. This bill will give all community members the information they need to be engaged in efforts to improve water quality in their neighborhood.”
2. Whose responsibility? The Legislature delegated responsibility for ensuring adequate service delivery to LAFCOs. To make sure that DUCs weren’t getting left behind, in 2011 the Legislature mandated that LAFCOs to identify service deficiencies for those communities. The Legislature also told cities and counties that where there are nearby DUCs, their general plans must identify service deficiencies and evaluate means to extend services to those communities. Eight years after SB 244 was signed, the state continues to have many communities that don’t have adequate services, including water. Noting the lack of progress, the Legislature since granted a separate entity, the SWRCB, the ability to consolidate failing water systems—a power historically given only to LAFCOs. AB 508 establishes a date certain by which SWRCB must develop a petition process for initiating consolidations, but the bill raises the question of why such a petition process is needed in the first place. Are LAFCOs and cities and counties fulfilling their responsibilities adequately under SB 244, and if not, should more substantial measures be taken to ensure that they do?
3. Incoming! The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double-referral of AB 508: first to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, which approved AB 508 at its July 3rd meeting on a vote of 5-1, and then to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee. The Committee is hearing the bill as the committee of second reference.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee: 6-3
Assembly Local Government Committee: 7-0
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 13-4
Assembly Floor: 58-18
Support and Opposition
(7/5/19)
Support: Leadership Counsel For Justice And Accountability (Sponsor); Alliance Of Californians For Community Empowerment (Acce) Action; Audubon California; California Apartment Association; California Coastkeeper Alliance; California Environmental Justice Alliance; California Institute For Rural Studies; California League Of Conservation Voters; Center For Community Action And Environmental Justice; Center For Sustainable Neighborhoods; Central California Environmental Justice Network; Clean Water Action; Community Water Center; Courage Campaign; Ella Baker Center For Human Rights; Lutheran Office Of Public Policy - California; Planning And Conservation League; Policylink; Pueblo Unido Cdc; Social Justice Ministry, Diocese Of Fresno; The Trust For Public Land; Western Center On Law And Poverty
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 508
Author: | Chu | ||
Version: | 6/6/2019 | Hearing Date: | 7/3/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells
DIGEST: This bill makes changes to statute related to the State Water Resources Control Board's (SWRCB's) authority to order the consolidation of drinking water systems, including setting a deadline of July 1, 2020 as the date by which the SWRCB must develop a policy that provides a process for members of a disadvantaged community to petition for consolidation; and requiring the SWRCB, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and occupants of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit's drinking water.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards. (42 United States Code § 300(f) et seq.)
- Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code § 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the California SDWA, the SWRCB to regulate drinking water and to enforce the federal SDWA and other regulations. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 116275 et seq.)
- Requires the SWRCB, in administering SDWA programs to fund improvements and expansions of small community water systems, to encourage the consolidation of small community water systems that serve disadvantaged communities; and, to prioritize funding for construction projects that involve the physical restructuring of two or more community water systems, at least one of which is a small community water system that serves a disadvantaged community, into a single, consolidated system. (HSC § 116326)
- Authorizes the SWRCB, where a public water system or a state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water or where a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, to order consolidation, either physical or operational, with a receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (a)(1))
- Requires the SWRCB to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the SWRCB to consider ordering consolidation. (HSC § 116682 (a)(2))
- Requires the SWRCB, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to perform a series of activities, including, encouraging voluntary consolidation or extension of service; considering other enforcement remedies; consulting with the relevant local agency formation commission; and, notifying the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water systems. (HSC § 116682 (b))
- Provides that any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area who does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency. (HSC § 116682 (b)(9))
- Requires the SWRCB, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make seven findings, including that the potentially subsumed water system has consistently failed to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; that all reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made; and, that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. (HSC §116682 (d))
- Prohibits, in the case of an ordered consolidation, the consolidated water system from increasing charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit. Provides that, in the case of an ordered consolidation, fees or charges imposed on a customer of a subsumed water system shall not exceed the cost of the service. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(A) - (B))
- Prohibits the receiving water system from charging any fees to, or place conditions on, customers of the subsumed water system that it does not charge to, or impose on, new customers that are not subject to the consolidation with the receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(C))
- Authorizes the SWRCB, in order to provide an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water to disadvantaged communities and to prevent fraud, waste, and abuse, to, if sufficient funding is available, contract with, or provide a grant to, an administrator to provide administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services, or any combination of those services, to a designated water system to assist the designated water system with the provision of an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water. (HSC § 116686 (a)(1)(A)(i))
- Authorizes the SWRCB to order the designated water system to accept administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services from an administrator appointed by the SWRCB for full oversight of construction or development projects related to a consolidation or extension of service, including, but not limited to, accepting loans and grants and entering into contracts on behalf of the designated water system. (HSC § 116686 (a)(1)(C))
- Makes legislative findings that regional solutions to water contamination problems are often more effective, efficient, and economical than solutions designed to address solely the problems of a single small public water system, and that it is in the interest of the people of the State of California to encourage the consolidation of the management and the facilities of small water systems to enable those systems to better address their water contamination problems. (HSC § 116760.10 (h))
This bill:
- Clarifies that the SWRCB may order a consolidation with a receiving water system or extension of service in a disadvantaged community that is, in whole or in part, substantially reliant on domestic wells that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Establishes the deadline of July 1, 2020, for the existing law provision that requires the SWRCB to develop and adopt a policy for members of a disadvantaged community to petition the Water Board to consider ordering a consolidation.
- Requires the SWRCB to inform the owner of a dwelling unit and, if different, the owner of a domestic well, if the dwelling unit is reliant on a domestic well within a service area that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Deletes the requirement that the Water Board obtain a domestic well owner’s consent prior to ordering a consolidation or extension of service.
- Requires, if the owner of the dwelling unit or, if applicable, the domestic well does not provide written consent for consolidation or extension of service to serve the dwelling unit, both of the following to occur:
- The owner of the dwelling unit or domestic well shall be ineligible, until the owner provides written consent, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster or other emergency; and
- The SWRCB shall promptly take all reasonable steps to provide the occupants of the dwelling unit a written statement regarding their drinking water, as follows:
- That the domestic well does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- All likely health risks associated with all of the dwelling unit’s specific known and likely water supply and water quality issues.
- That the owner of the dwelling unit has been informed that the domestic well does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water and, despite being informed, has refused to consent to the construction of a lateral.
- That the dwelling owner’s failure to consent to construction of a lateral or provide an alternate adequate supply of safe drinking water evidences a failure to provide the bare living requirements necessary for a habitable dwelling.
- That the dwelling unit is untenantable because the dwelling unit substantially lacks an approved water supply.
- Requires the SWRCB to consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service when determining if a consolidation is feasible, as specified.
- Renames a capacity connection fee a capacity charge and would require a capacity charge to be paid only to the extent it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service.
- Requires the SWRCB, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service to a community containing residences served by domestic wells to promptly take all reasonable steps to obtain written consent to the consolidation or extension of service from an owner of each residence served by a domestic well.
- Specifies that an order pursuant to these provisions shall not require consolidation or extension of service to a residence served solely by a domestic well until an owner or the affected residence provides written consent to the extension of service.
Background
- The Legislative Analyst’s Office provides a succinct background on the general topic of Safe and Affordable Drinking Water in their Analysis of the 2018-19 Governor’s Budget, as follows:
“Federal, State, and Local Entities Regulate Drinking Water. The federal Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Act (SDWA) was enacted in 1974 to protect public health by regulating drinking water. California has enacted its own safe drinking water act to implement the federal law and establish state standards. The U.S. EPA enforces the federal SDWA at the national level. However, most states, including California, have been granted “primacy” by the U.S. EPA, giving them authority to implement and enforce the federal SDWA at the state level.
“Maximum contaminant levels (MCLs) are health-based drinking water standards that public water systems are required to meet. MCLs take into account the health risk, detectability, treatability, and costs of treatment associated with a pollutant. Agencies responsible for regulating water quality enforce these standards.
“The California State Water Resources Control Board’s (SWRCB) Division of Drinking Water (DDW) regulates public water systems that provide water for human consumption and have 15 or more service connections, or regularly serve at least 25 individuals daily at least 60 days out of the year. (A “service connection” is usually the point of access between a water system’s service pipe and a user’s piping.) The state does not regulate water systems with less than 15 connections; county health officers oversee them. At the local level, 30 of the 58 county environmental health departments in California have been delegated primacy—known as Local Primacy Agencies (LPAs)—by the SWRCB to regulate systems with between 15 and 200 connections within their jurisdiction. For investor-owned water utilities under the jurisdiction of California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), the DDW or LPAs share water quality regulatory authority with CPUC.
“The DDW regulates approximately 7,500 water systems. About one-third of these systems have between 15 and 200 service connections. The number of smaller systems—specifically, those with 14 or fewer connections— is unknown but estimated to be in the thousands.
“Multiple Causes of Unsafe Drinking Water. The causes of unsafe drinking water can generally be separated into two categories (1) contamination caused by human action and (2) naturally occurring contaminants. In some areas, there are both human caused and natural contaminants in the drinking water.
“Three of the most commonly detected pollutants in contaminated water are arsenic, perchlorate, and nitrates. While arsenic is naturally occurring, perchlorate contamination is generally a result of military and industrial uses. High concentrations of nitrate in groundwater are primarily caused by human activities, including fertilizer application (synthetic and manure), animal operations, industrial sources (wastewater treatment and food processing facilities), and septic systems. Agricultural fertilizers and animal wastes applied to cropland are by far the largest regional sources of nitrate in groundwater, although other sources can be important in certain areas.
“Unsafe Drinking Water a Statewide Problem. The SWRCB has identified a total of 331 water systems that it or LPAs regulate that are in violation of water quality standards. These water systems serve an estimated 500,000 people throughout the state. The number of water systems with 14 or fewer connections that are currently in violation of water quality standards is unknown, but estimated to be in the thousands by the SWRCB. Of the 331 systems identified by the SWRCB, 68 have violations associated with nitrates (and in some cases, additional contaminants). In some of these water systems, unsafe contamination levels persist over time because the local agency cannot generate sufficient revenue from its customer base to implement, operate, or maintain the improvements necessary to address the problem. The challenge in these systems is often a product of a combination of factors, including the high costs of the investments required, low income of the customers, and the small number of customers across whom the costs would need to be spread.” - Consolidation of Public Water Systems. SB 88 (Budget Committee, Chapter 27 Statutes of 2015) authorizes SWRCB to require water systems that are serving disadvantaged communities with unreliable and unsafe drinking water to consolidate with or receive service from public water systems with safe, reliable, and adequate drinking water. SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016) authorizes the SWRCB to identify public water systems that are consistently unable to provide an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water and, once funding is available, to then contract with a competent administrator to provide managerial and technical expertise to that system.
Consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities and areas, which currently rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, as well as private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidating or extending service from a public water system to a community otherwise served by unreliable systems or unregulated private wells advances the goal of a reliable, accessible supply of safe drinking water for all California residents.
The SWRCB currently posts information on its website about ordered consolidations. It also tracks and has information on voluntary consolidations. Currently, 60 consolidations are being funded by SWRCB. Fifteen mandatory consolidations are currently proceeding, although 5 of those have decided to pursue voluntary consolidation. Only one mandatory consolidation has been completed so far. In 2017-18, there were 90 voluntary physical consolidations and 6 voluntary managerial consolidations. Physical consolidations are for systems that are close enough to be connected by new pipelines. In managerial or operational consolidation, the systems remain physically separate, but are managed by the same entity.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "Last year, the state made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501 [(Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018]. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on progress made by AB 2501 by reducing existing barriers between these communities and safe drinking water."
- Problematic domestic well notification requirements. This bill builds upon the authority vested to the SWRCB to order the consolidation of domestic wells with inadequate supplies of safe water in disadvantaged communities. Its intent is to remove barriers to, and to encourage, consolidation efforts. However, the bill’s provisions relating to domestic well notifications are problematic.
SWRCB does not have statutory authority to regulate domestic wells. This means that SWRCB does not have information about specific domestic wells, nor is it able to require testing for domestic well owners or able to access private property in order to conduct testing itself. Further, the SWRCB lacks infrastructure at present to manage data collected from domestic wells even if it were to be granted that authority.
AB 508 would impose substantial new notification requirements on the SWRCB that assume it possesses information on the locations of domestic wells, who they serve, what contaminants may be present in them, and what the health effects of those contaminants may be.
Thus, the SWRCB does not have the authority to obtain the necessary information to implement these provisions of the bill; extending its authority to regulate private wells would be a major policy initiative well beyond the scope of this legislation.
The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to:
- Remove the domestic well notifications provisions;
- Require the SWRCB, when ordering a consolidation or extension of service to a disadvantaged community with inadequate safe drinking water, to include in its public meeting notice to ratepayers, renters, and property owners, information about water quality concerns in the area, relevant information about health effects of water contaminants, and information about opportunities for consolidation or extension of service to address water quality issues.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2501 (Chu, Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018). Authorizes the SWRCB to order consolidation with a receiving water system when a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; prohibits, for an ordered consolidation, the receiving water system from charging specified fees or imposing specified conditions on customers of the subsumed water system that it would not otherwise charge or impose; and, makes other changes to ordered consolidation law.
SB 623 (Monning, 2017). Would have created the Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund, administered by the SWRCB, to assist communities and individual domestic well users to address contaminants in drinking water that exceed safe drinking water standards. This bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 778 (Hertzberg, 2017). Would have required the SWRCB to report on public water system consolidations to date, and their success or failure. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016). Authorizes the SWRCB to contract with an administrator to provide administrative and managerial services to a designated public water system to assist with the provision of an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water.
SB 1263 (Wieckowski, Chapter 843, Statutes of 2016). Authorizes the SWRCB to deny a permit for a new public water system if it determines that it is reasonably foreseeable that the proposed new public water system will be unable to provide affordable, safe drinking water.
SB 88 (Budget Committee, Chapter 27 Statutes of 2015). Authorizes the SWRCB to require water systems that are serving disadvantaged communities with unreliable and unsafe drinking water to consolidate with, or receive service from, public water systems with safe, reliable, and adequate drinking water.
AB 685 (Eng, Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012). Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes and that relevant state agencies, including the Department of Water Resources, the SWRCB, and the State Department of Public Health shall consider this state policy when revising, adopting, or establishing policies, regulations, and grant criteria pertinent to the human uses of water.
Double Referral:
If this measures is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
SOURCE:
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability
SUPPORT:
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) Action
Aoki Water Justice Clinic, UC Davis School of Law
Audubon California
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Institute for Rural Studies
California League of Conservation Voters
Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice (CCAEJ)
Center for Sustainable Neighborhoods
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Clean Water Action
Community Water Center
Courage Campaign
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability
Lutheran Office of Public Policy- California
Planning and Conservation League
Policy Link
Pueblo Unido CDC
Sierra Club California
Social Justice Ministry, Diocese of Fresno
The Trust for Public Land
Western Center on Law & Poverty
OPPOSITION:
None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 508
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:May 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes changes to statute related to the State Water Resources Control Board's (State Water Board's) authority to order the consolidation of drinking water systems, including setting a deadline of July 1, 2020 as the date by which the State Water Board must develop a policy that provides a process for members of a disadvantaged community to petition for consolidation; requiring the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and occupants of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit's drinking water; deleting statute that requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to obtain written consent to the project from a domestic well owner; requiring the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to provide written notice to the potentially receiving water system of a request to obtain consent of well and dwelling unit owners for consolidation or extension of service; and, makes other technical and conforming changes.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
Drinking water contamination in disadvantaged communities: According to a 2018 University of California at Davis report, "In low-income communities located outside city boundaries (known as disadvantaged unincorporated communities or DUCs), drinking water is often unsafe to drink. In many such localities, drinking water is contaminated by industrial by-products (usually associated with agriculture, oil and gas production, transportation, and manufacturing) and compromised by inadequate wastewater treatment and disposal systems, as well as naturally occurring toxic substances like arsenic and uranium." The report found that a significant number of DUC residents live close to an existing, and water-quality-compliant, community water system that could provide them with clean drinking water.
Providing safe, affordable drinking water to disadvantaged communities: For common sources of drinking water contamination, such as arsenic and nitrates, expensive systems must be installed and operated to treat the water to meet drinking water standards. In many cases, technological advances have not yet been sufficient to make such treatment systems affordable, especially to small, disadvantaged communities. In addition, many small, disadvantaged communities do not have the technical, managerial, or financial capability to maintain and operate what are sometimes complex drinking water systems.
Consolidation of water systems: Restructuring can be an effective means to help small water systems achieve and maintain technical, managerial, and financial capacity, and to reduce the oversight and resources that the state needs to devote to these systems. Consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities that rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, or on private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidation does this by extending costs to a larger pool of ratepayers.
California has recognized the benefits of consolidation for decades, through legislation and regulation. This bill builds upon the authority vested in the State Water Board to order the consolidation of dwellings that are reliant on domestic wells with inadequate supplies of safe water in disadvantaged communities with water systems that can provide safe, affordable drinking water. Its intent is to remove barriers to, and to encourage, consolidation efforts.
According to the Author:
"Last year, the state made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501 [(Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on progress made by AB 2501 by reducing existing barriers between these communities and safe drinking water."
Arguments in Support:
A coalition of supporters argues, "Upwards of one million Californians lack safe drinking water. Water that runs from the taps in their homes and in their schools is tainted with arsenic, nitrate, uranium, 1,2,3 TCP, E. coli, and other contaminants and pathogens. For many families, domestic wells have run dry and no water runs into their homes. AB 508 would build on SB 88 [(Committee on Budget), Chapter 27, Statutes of 2015] and AB 2501 (2018) to strengthen important tools for addressing this drinking water crisis. These provisions will make the process for ordering mandatory consolidation and extension of drinking water service more efficient and transparent while ensuring that residents are informed about relevant health risks associated with the drinking water problems and available solutions."
Arguments in Opposition:
None received.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, enactment of this bill could result in annual ongoing costs of $350,000 (Safe Drinking Water Fund) to the State Water Board for two staff to implement the provisions of the bill. There is a lack of information regarding domestic wells, but certain regions are more likely to contain a higher concentration of well users. If consolidations in any given year happen to focus in such an area, more staff and funding may be necessary.
VOTES:
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 6-3-0
YES: Quirk, Kalra, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Melendez, Dahle, Mathis
ASM LOCAL GOVERNMENT: 7-0-1
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Lackey
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0000529
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 508
Author:(Chu) – As Amended Ver:May 6, 2019
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 6 - 3 |
Local Government | 7 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill makes a variety of changes to the State Water Resources Control Board’s (State Water Board) authority to order the consolidation of certain public water systems. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the deadline of July 1, 2020, for the existing law provision that requires the State Water Board to develop and adopt a policy for members of a disadvantaged community to petition the Water Board to consider ordering a consolidation.
- Requires the State Water Board to inform the owner of a dwelling unit and, if different, the owner of a domestic well, if the dwelling unit is reliant on a domestic well within a service area that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Deletes the requirement that the Water Board obtain a domestic well owner’s consent prior to ordering a consolidation or extension of service.
- Requires, if the owner of the dwelling unit or, if applicable, the domestic well does not provide written consent for consolidation or extension of service to serve the dwelling unit, both of the following to occur:
- The owner of the dwelling unit or domestic well shall be ineligible, until the owner provides written consent, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster or other emergency:
- The State Water Board shall promptly take all reasonable steps to provide the occupants of the dwelling unit a written statement regarding their drinking water, as specified.
- Requires the State Water Board to consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service when determining if a consolidation is feasible, as specified.
- Requires the State Water Board to pay a capacity connection fee to the receiving water system only to the extent it does not exceed the reasonable cost of providing the service.
FISCAL EFFECT:
State Water Board annual ongoing costs of $350,000 (Safe Drinking Water Fund) for two staff to implement the provisions of the bill. There is a lack of information regarding domestic wells, but certain regions are more likely to contain a higher concentration of well users. If consolidations in any given year happen to focus in such an area, more staff and funding may be necessary.
COMMENTS:
- Background and Purpose. It is the policy of the state to encourage the consolidation of small water systems. In 2015, the State Water Board was given the authority to order consolidation of a public water system within a disadvantaged community under specified conditions. In 2016, the State Water Board was given the authority to evaluate the ability of a proposed new public water system to meet drinking water standards for the foreseeable future and to deny a permit if the board determined the new public water system will not be sustainable into the future. In 1997, the CPUC was required to use fair market value when setting rates, creating a greater incentive for CPUC-regulated water providers to consolidate.
The report found drinking water contamination in California disproportionally affects small, rural and low-income communities that depend mostly on groundwater. Similarly, a 2013 State Water Board report found 682 community public water systems in California, which serve nearly 21 million people, rely on contaminated groundwater as a primary source of drinking water. It also found that 265 community public water systems, which serve a little more than two million people, had received at least one drinking water quality violation within the last compliance cycle. The State Water Board’s report points out that an additional two million Californians rely on groundwater from private domestic wells or smaller groundwater-reliant systems that are not regulated by the state. While these statistics may have changed over the past several years, the State Water Board notes approximately 282 drinking water systems are currently not in compliance with drinking water standards.
The 2018 UC Davis report also found a significant number of residents live close to an existing and water-quality compliant community water system that could provide clean drinking water.
The 2018 UC Davis report included policy recommendations to better enable communities to secure access to safe and affordable drinking water. These recommendations included: (a) clarifying state law to allow the State Water Board to use its authority to extend services to residents who receive water from [state small water systems] and private wells, and (b) allowing communities without safe drinking water to petition the state to consider ordering consolidations.
AB 2501 (Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018, provided additional authority to the State Water Board to order consolidations. According to the author:
Last year, the State made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing AB 2501. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on progress made by AB 2501 by reducing existing barriers between these communities and safe drinking water.
- Progress on Providing Safe Drinking Water. The State Water Board currently posts information on its website about ordered consolidations. It also tracks and has information on voluntary consolidations. Under the State Water Board's authority, three mandatory consolidations have been ordered, and there have been more than 100 voluntary consolidations. Among those consolidations, the State Water Board has had varying levels of participation. Some were consolidations the board helped fund, some for which the Water board provided guidance, and others for which the board only issued a permit.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 508 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
SUBJECT: Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells.
SUMMARY: Makes a number of changes to the State Water Resources Control Board’s (Water Board) authority to order the consolidation of certain drinking water systems. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes a deadline of no later than July 1, 2020, for the Water Board to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the Water Board to consider ordering a consolidation.
- Specifies that if a dwelling unit is reliant on a domestic well within the service area that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, the Water Board shall inform the owner of the dwelling unit and, if different, the owner of the domestic well, that the dwelling unit is supplied water by a domestic well that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Deletes the requirement that the Water Board obtain a domestic well owner’s consent prior to ordering a consolidation or extension of service.
- Requires, that if the owner of the dwelling unit or, if applicable, the domestic well does not provide written consent, upon request, for consolidation or extension of service to serve the dwelling unit, both of the following to occur:
- The owner of the dwelling unit shall be ineligible, until the owner provides written consent, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency; and,
- The Water Board shall promptly take all reasonable steps to provide the occupants of the dwelling unit a written statement, including the following information:
- That the domestic well supplying water to the dwelling unit does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water;
- All likely health risks associated with all of the dwelling unit’s specific known and likely water supply and water quality issues;
- That the owner of the dwelling unit has been informed that the domestic well does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water and, despite being informed, has refused to consent to the consolidation or extension of service; and,
- That the dwelling unit owner’s failure to consent to consolidation or extension of service or to provide an alternate adequate supply of safe drinking water evidences a failure to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water to the dwelling unit.
- Specifies that in making the finding that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible, the Water Board shall consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service.
- Provides that the Water Board need not find that any specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area are likely to consent to the consolidation or extension of service to serve their dwelling unit.
- Specifies that the receiving water system shall not charge any fees to mitigate or compensate for increased ground water use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service.
EXISTING LAW:
- Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes.
- Requires, pursuant to the California Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the Water Board to regulate drinking water and to enforce the federal SDWA and other regulations.
- Requires the Water Board, in administering SDWA programs to fund improvements and expansions of small community water systems, to encourage the consolidation of small community water systems that serve disadvantaged communities; and, to prioritize funding for construction projects that involve the physical restructuring of two or more community water systems, at least one of which is a small community water system that serves a disadvantaged community, into a single, consolidated system.
- Authorizes the Water Board, where a public water system or a state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water or where a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, to order consolidation, either physical or operational, with a receiving water system.
- Requires the Water Board to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the Water Board to consider ordering consolidation.
- Requires the Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to perform a series of activities, including, encouraging voluntary consolidation or extension of service; considering other enforcement remedies; consulting with the relevant local agency formation commission (LAFCO); and, notifying the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water systems.
- Provides that any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area who does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency.
- Requires the Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make seven findings, including that the potentially subsumed water system has consistently failed to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; that all reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made; and, that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible.
- Prohibits, in the case of an ordered consolidation, the consolidated water system from increasing charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service, unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit. Provides that, in the case of an ordered consolidation, fees or charges imposed on a customer of a subsumed water system shall not exceed the cost of the service.
- Prohibits the receiving water system from charging any fees to, or place conditions on, customers of the subsumed water system that it does not charge to, or impose on, new customers that are not subject to the consolidation with the receiving water system.
- Authorizes the Water Board, in order to provide an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water to disadvantaged communities and to prevent fraud, waste, and abuse, to,
if sufficient funding is available, contract with, or provide a grant to, an administrator to provide administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services, or any combination
of those services, to a designated water system to assist the designated water system with the provision of an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water. - Authorizes the Water Board to order the designated water system to accept administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services from an administrator appointed by the Water Board for full oversight of construction or development projects related to a consolidation or extension of service, including, but not limited to, accepting loans and grants and entering into contracts on behalf of the designated water system.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
- California’s Drinking Water Program. SB 861 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 35, Statutes of 2014, transferred the Drinking Water Program from the Department of Public Health (DPH) to the Water Board effective July 1, 2014, creating the new Division of Drinking Water within the Water Board, and made other statutory changes to create efficiencies and adoption and administration of the Drinking Water Program.
The Water Board directly enforces the SDWA for all large water systems (those with 200 or more service connections). For small water systems (those with less than 200 connections), local health departments can be delegated to have regulatory authority as the local primacy agency.
- Human Right to Water. In 2012, California became the first state to enact a Human Right to Water law [AB 685 (Eng), Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012]. Public policy continues to be focused on the right of every human being to have safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitation. Water supply, contaminants, costs of treatment and distribution systems, the number and nature of small public water systems, especially in disadvantaged communities, and many other factors will continue to challenge progress in addressing the Human Right to Water.
- Addressing Service Deficiencies. LAFCOs, along with the planning agencies of cities and counties, are tasked with ensuring that services are effectively and efficiently delivered to all communities throughout the state. Nevertheless, some communities continue to lack adequate public services, including safe drinking water and functioning wastewater systems, often due to their low income status. In some cases, these disadvantaged communities are contained within a city but lack adequate water and wastewater services. In other cases, these communities are located in unincorporated areas. These DUCs can be remote and far from other communities with better public services, but at other times they are adjacent to a city, special district, or county service area that provides water or wastewater services.
In recent years, the Legislature has taken several steps to try to address some of the service problems experienced by disadvantaged unincorporated communities. SB 244 (Wolk), Chapter 513, Statutes of 2011, aimed to prevent cities from carving out disadvantaged unincorporated communities by generally prohibiting annexations of small areas to a city if a disadvantaged unincorporated community is contiguous with that area. SB 244 also required LAFCOs to include in the MSR a description of the location and characteristics of any disadvantaged unincorporated communities within or contiguous to the sphere of influence and to consider the water, sewer, or fire protection needs of disadvantaged unincorporated communities within the sphere when considering updates. Finally, SB 244 required cities and counties to review the water and fire service needs of disadvantaged unincorporated communities in their general plans. SB 244 made it easier for LAFCOs to identify boundary changes and governmental reorganizations necessary to fix water and sewer service problems faced by disadvantaged communities.
- Consolidations. Subsequent legislation, SB 88 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 27, Statutes of 2015, took this effort a step further by authorizing the Water Board to order a consolidation of neighboring drinking water systems where it is economically feasible in order to address public health threats. SB 88 established an elaborate process for consolidating water systems that requires multiple public hearings, as well as consultations with affected entities, such as the water system being subsumed, the receiving water system, domestic well owners, and the local government with land use authority over the area, and the LAFCO.
Before ordering consolidation or extension of service, the Water Board must also encourage voluntary consolidations or extension of service, consider other enforcement remedies, obtain written consent from any domestic well owner, and provide technical assistance to both systems. The Water Board must also make a series of findings, including that:
- Consolidation or extension of service is the most effective and cost-effective means to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; and,
- The capacity of the proposed interconnection needed to accomplish the consolidation is limited to serving the current customers of the subsumed water system.
- Consolidation or extension of service is the most effective and cost-effective means to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; and,
Under SB 88, the Water Board must pay the full cost of the new capacity, including replacing any capacity lost as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, providing additional capacity needed as a result of the consolidation or extension of service, and legal fees. The Water Board must also pay the LAFCO’s costs and fees, adequately compensate the owners
of any privately owned subsumed water system, and coordinate with the appropriate LAFCO and other relevant local agencies to facilitate the change of organization or reorganization. SB 88 also prohibited the consolidated water system from increasing charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service, unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit. Cleanup legislation the following year added a few additional requirements to the SB 88 process, including prohibiting fees or charges on a customer of a subsumed water system from exceeding the cost of consolidating the water system with a receiving system or the extension of service to the area [SB 552 (Wolk), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016].
- How Does Consolidation of a Public Water System Work? Consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities and areas, which currently rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, as well as private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidating or extending service from a public water system to a community otherwise served by unreliable systems or unregulated private wells advances the goal of a reliable, accessible supply of safe drinking water for all California residents.
Public water systems experiencing chronic water quality failures or unreliable supplies are first provided technical assistance to analyze the problem and recommend a course of action. Enforcement may also be necessary to achieve compliance with SDWA requirements. Lacking progress, the Water Board may initiate discussions with the system and neighboring/adjacent public water systems regarding consolidation. Consolidation may involve the actual physical consolidation of the participating water systems (physical consolidation), just the management of the participating water system (managerial consolidation), or both. If voluntary consolidation cannot be negotiated in a reasonable time period, the Water Board may commence proceedings for direct mandatory consolidation or a mandatory extension of service. In this case, consolidation letters will be sent to the consistently failing water system (subsumed system) and to the receiving system notifying them that they have six months to develop a plan for voluntarily consolidation. If the two systems have not developed a plan for consolidation within six months of the letters being issued, the Water Board may then order the two systems to consolidate.
The Water Board will provide funding as necessary and appropriate from the Water Quality, Supply, and Infrastructure Improvement Act of 2014 (Proposition 1, 2014), the Drinking Water State Revolving Fund (DWSRF), and monies made available from the emergency drought relief package, for consolidation or extension of service, including infrastructure improvements. SB 88 added a provision to the law limiting the liability of water systems, wholesalers, or any other agencies that deliver water to consolidated water systems. This liability relief is available regardless of whether the consolidation occurs through the mandatory consolidation process or through a voluntary act. These new liability relief
provisions will protect water systems involved in consolidations and remove a barrier that previously limited voluntary consolidations.
- Progress on Providing Clean Drinking Water. The Water Board currently posts information on its website about ordered consolidations. It also tracks and has information on voluntary consolidations. Under the Water Board's authority, three mandatory consolidations have been ordered, and there have been more than 100 voluntary consolidations in that time period. Within those, the Water Board has had varying levels of participation. Some were consolidations the Water Board helped to fund, some to which the Water Board provided guidance, and others for which the Water Board just issued a permit.
- Other Related and Prior Legislation. SB 778 (Hertzberg) from 2017 would have required the Water Board to report on public water system consolidations to date, and their success or failure. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 1215 (Hertzberg) Chapter 982, Statutes of 2018, authorizes the Water Board to order the provision of sewer service by a special district, city, or county to a disadvantaged community, as defined, under specified circumstances, and requires the Water Board to take certain actions before ordering the provision of sewer service that are similar to those required for the consolidation or extension of water systems.
AB 2501 (Chu), Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018, authorizes the Water Board to order consolidation with a receiving water system when a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; prohibits, for an ordered consolidation, the receiving water system from charging specified fees or imposing specified conditions on customers of the subsumed water system that it would not otherwise charge or impose; and, makes other changes to ordered consolidation law.
- Bill Summary. This bill requires the Water Board to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process in which residents of a disadvantaged community can petition the Water Board to consider ordering consolidation by July 1, 2020. This bill removes the requirement that the Water Board obtain written consent from a well owner before a consolidation or extension of service to an area is approved. Consent is still required from an owner of a well or dwelling unit to participate in the consolidation or extension of service. This bill specifies that, if a dwelling unit does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, the Water Board shall notify the owner of the well and the owner of the dwelling unit. This bill provides that if the owner of the dwelling unit and, if different, the owner of the well does not give written consent for consolidation or extension of service, the Water Board shall promptly notify the occupants of the dwelling unit that the unit is not provided an adequate supply of water. This bill specifies that a receiving water system shall not charge any fees to mitigate increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service. The Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability is the sponsor of this bill.
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “Last year, the State made great progress in ensuring access to clean drinking water for small disadvantaged communities by passing
AB 2501. However, our state still has a long way to go, with over 1 million Californians still without this basic right. AB 508 builds on progress made by AB 2501 by reducing existing barriers between these communities and safe drinking water.” - Policy Consideration. Local agencies must comply with Proposition 218's (1996) restrictions on the use of property-related fees and charges, including the measure's calculation requirements. Specifically, local governments must make sure that no property owner's fee is greater than the proportionate cost to provide the property-related service to a parcel. Essentially, this means a local agency cannot subsidize the fees of one ratepayer with the fees of another.
This bill specifies that a receiving water system shall not charge any fees to mitigate increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service. The meaning of this provision is unclear as existing law already says fees or charges imposed on a customer shall not exceed the cost of the service. There is extensive case law on the establishment of fees and charges. While there are likely incidents where water providers charge more than they should, these cases are certainly challengeable in court. The Committee may wish to consider if this provision adds confusion to how charges and fees are calculated when water providers are ordered to consolidate or extend services by the Water Board.
- Committee Amendment. In response to the policy consideration above, the Committee may wish to remove the following provision:
Health and Safety Code Section 116682 (g)(1)(D):
(D) The receiving water system shall not charge any fees to mitigate or compensate for increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service.
- Arguments in Support. The sponsor argues that the provisions in this bill “will remove existing barriers to mandatory consolidation and extension of drinking water service, while ensuring that residents are informed about relevant health risks associated with the drinking water problems and available solutions.”
- Arguments in Opposition. None on file.
- Double-Referral. This bill was heard in the Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee on April 9, 2019, and passed with a 6-3 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability [SPONSOR]
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment
Audubon California
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Institute for Rural Studies
California League of Conservation Voters
Support (continued)
Center for Community Action and Environmental Justice
Center for Sustainable Neighborhoods
Central California Environmental Justice Network
Clean Water Action
Community Water Center
Courage Campaign
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Lutheran Office of Public Policy
Planning and Conservation League
Policy Link
Pueblo Unido CDC
Social Justice Ministry, Diocese of Fresno
Trust for Public Land
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Jimmy MacDonald / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 508 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
SUBJECT: Drinking water: consolidation and extension of service: domestic wells
SUMMARY: Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and renters of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit’s drinking water; deletes statute that requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to obtain written consent to the project from a domestic well owner; prohibits the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, from using a specific percentage of well owners that are likely to provide consent to the project as a metric of feasibility; prohibits a receiving water system from charging any fees to compensate for increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater before the consolidation or extension of service; and, makes other changes to ordered consolidation law. Specifically, this bill:
- Clarifies that the State Water Board may order a consolidation or extension of service in a disadvantaged community that has one or more residences that are reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Establishes a deadline of no later than July 1, 2020, as the date by which the State Water Board is required to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the State Water Board to consider ordering a consolidation.
- Deletes statute that requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to obtain written consent from any domestic well owner for consolidation or extension of service.
- Provides that the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, need not find, and shall not require, that any specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area are likely to consent to the construction of a lateral to serve their dwelling unit.
- Requires the State Water Board, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, to inform the owner of the dwelling unit and, if different, the owner of the domestic well, if a dwelling unit is reliant on a domestic well within the service area that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
- Requires, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, the State Water Board, if the owner of the dwelling unit or, if applicable, the domestic well, does not provide written consent for construction of a lateral to serve the dwelling unit, to promptly take all reasonable steps to provide to the tenants a written statement that includes the following information:
- That the domestic well does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water;
- All likely health risks associated with all of the dwelling unit’s specific known and likely water supply and water quality issues;
- That the owner of the dwelling unit has been informed that the domestic well does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water and, despite being informed, has refused to consent to the construction of a lateral;
- That the dwelling owner’s failure to consent to construction of a lateral or provide an alternate adequate supply of safe drinking water evidences a failure to provide the bare living requirements necessary for a habitable dwelling; and,
- That the dwelling unit is untenantable because the dwelling unit substantially lacks an approved water supply.
- Prohibits a receiving water system from charging any fees to mitigate or compensate for increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service.
- Makes other clarifying and conforming changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards. (42 United States Code § 300(f ) et seq.)
- Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes. (Water Code § 106.3)
- Requires, pursuant to the California SDWA, the State Water Board to regulate drinking water and to enforce the federal SDWA and other regulations. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) § 116275 et seq.)
- Requires the State Water Board, in administering SDWA programs to fund improvements and expansions of small community water systems, to encourage the consolidation of small community water systems that serve disadvantaged communities; and, to prioritize funding for construction projects that involve the physical restructuring of two or more community water systems, at least one of which is a small community water system that serves a disadvantaged community, into a single, consolidated system. (HSC § 116326)
- Authorizes the State Water Board, where a public water system or a state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water or where a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, to order consolidation, either physical or operational, with a receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (a)(1))
- Requires the State Water Board to develop and adopt a policy that provides a process by which members of a disadvantaged community may petition the State Water Board to consider ordering consolidation. (HSC § 116682 (a)(2))
- Requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to perform a series of activities, including, encouraging voluntary consolidation or extension of service; considering other enforcement remedies; consulting with the relevant local agency formation commission; and, notifying the potentially receiving water system and the potentially subsumed water systems. (HSC § 116682 (b))
- Provides that any domestic well owner within the consolidation or extended service area who does not provide written consent shall be ineligible, until the consent is provided, for any future water-related grant funding from the state other than funding to mitigate a well failure, disaster, or other emergency. (HSC § 116682 (b)(9))
- Requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make seven findings, including that the potentially subsumed water system has consistently failed to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; that all reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made; and, that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. (HSC §116682 (d))
- Prohibits, in the case of an ordered consolidation, the consolidated water system from increasing charges on existing customers of the receiving water system solely as a consequence of the consolidation or extension of service unless the customers receive a corresponding benefit. Provides that, in the case of an ordered consolidation, fees or charges imposed on a customer of a subsumed water system shall not exceed the cost of the service. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(A) – (B))
- Prohibits the receiving water system from charging any fees to, or place conditions on, customers of the subsumed water system that it does not charge to, or impose on, new customers that are not subject to the consolidation with the receiving water system. (HSC § 116682 (g)(1)(C))
- Authorizes the State Water Board, in order to provide an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water to disadvantaged communities and to prevent fraud, waste, and abuse, to, if sufficient funding is available, contract with, or provide a grant to, an administrator to provide administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services, or any combination of those services, to a designated water system to assist the designated water system with the provision of an adequate supply of affordable, safe drinking water. (HSC § 116686 (a)(1)(A)(i))
- Authorizes the State Water Board to order the designated water system to accept administrative, technical, operational, or managerial services from an administrator appointed by the State Water Board for full oversight of construction or development projects related to a consolidation or extension of service, including, but not limited to, accepting loans and grants and entering into contracts on behalf of the designated water system. (HSC § 116686 (a)(1)(C))
- Makes legislative findings that regional solutions to water contamination problems are often more effective, efficient, and economical than solutions designed to address solely the problems of a single small public water system, and that it is in the interest of the people of the State of California to encourage the consolidation of the management and the facilities of small water systems to enable those systems to better address their water contamination problems. (HSC § 116760.10 (h))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Need for the bill: According to the author,
"AB 508 improves the State Water Board’s process for expanding access to safe drinking water for disadvantaged communities across the state. Additionally, the bill prevents receiving water systems from charging specific mitigation or 'capacity' fees to homes already reliant on groundwater.
…Under the law, the [State Water] Board must obtain written consent from domestic well owners before ordering extension of services for the remainder of the community. In some communities, domestic well owners have withheld their consent, thus withholding the opportunity for other community members to access safe drinking water.
Additionally, some public water systems charge mitigation fees for connections that are intended to ensure that population growth pays for water supply improvements to serve the new development… However, in the case of consolidation or extension of service to existing groundwater users, as is addressed in AB 508, capacity fees are often charged both to existing households and new developments – thus treating existing households reliant on groundwater by way of domestic well the same as new development. Charging these fees is inappropriate for existing communities that are already reliant on groundwater and is diverting critical State funds from further efforts to building groundwater capacity and access to safe drinking water."
Human right to water: In 2012, by enacting Assembly Bill (AB) 685 (Eng, Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012), California became the first state with a Human Right to Water law. AB 685 established state policy that every human being has the right to safe, clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitation. Water supply issues, contaminants, costs of treatment and distribution systems, climate change, the number and nature of small public water systems, especially in disadvantaged communities, and many other factors continue to challenge progress in implementing the Human Right to Water.
Drinking water contamination in disadvantaged communities: The February 2018, University of California (UC) Davis report, "The Struggle for Water Justice in California’s San Joaquin Valley: A Focus on Disadvantaged Unincorporated Communities," summarizes drinking water issues facing disadvantaged communities in California as follows.
"In California, lack of access to clean, safe, and affordable water is a threat to public health and well-being, and violates the state’s newly codified Human Right to Water. In low-income communities located outside city boundaries (known as disadvantaged unincorporated communities or DUCs), drinking water is often unsafe to drink. In many such localities, drinking water is contaminated by industrial by-products (usually associated with agriculture, oil and gas production, transportation, and manufacturing) and compromised by inadequate wastewater treatment and disposal systems, as well as naturally occurring toxic substances like arsenic and uranium. Many DUC residents in the San Joaquin Valley pay a triple penalty to obtain safe water: they bear the health costs of unsafe drinking water; they purchase that unsafe water at high costs; and they must also purchase 'substitute' water—typically expensive bottled water—for drinking and cooking.
Lack of access to clean, safe and affordable drinking water has a racial and ethnic component: the vast majority of DUC residents are people of color who also face cumulative impacts from environmental contamination brought on by proximity to air pollution, pesticides, toxic facilities and waste disposal. Without city governments to directly represent their interests and provide essential services, residents of DUCs have been systematically deprived of access to important means of democratic governance."
While the 2018 UC Davis report focuses on DUCs in the San Joaquin Valley, the findings are consistent with a more expansive 2013 State Water Board report and 2012 UC Davis report that found that drinking water contamination in California disproportionally affects small, rural, and low-income communities that depend mostly on groundwater as their drinking water source. The 2013 State Water Board report found that 682 community public water systems in California, which serve nearly 21 million people, rely on contaminated groundwater as a primary source of drinking water. It also found that 265 community public water systems, which serve a little more than two million people, had received at least one drinking water quality violation within the last compliance cycle. The report points out that an additional two million Californians rely on groundwater from a private domestic well or a smaller groundwater-reliant system that is not regulated by the state. The State Water Board reports that currently approximately 330 drinking water systems are not in compliance with drinking water standards.
The 2018 UC Davis report also found that a significant number of DUC residents live close to an existing, and water quality compliant, community water system that could provide them with clean drinking water.
Providing safe, affordable drinking water to disadvantaged communities: According to the State Water Board, for common sources of drinking water contamination, such as arsenic and nitrates, expensive systems must be installed and operated to treat the water to meet drinking water standards. In many cases, technological advances have not yet been sufficient to make such treatment systems affordable, especially to small, disadvantaged communities. In addition, many small disadvantaged communities do not have the technical, managerial, or financial capability to maintain and operate what are sometimes complex drinking water systems.
Consolidation of water systems: According to the US EPA, restructuring can be an effective means to help small water systems achieve and maintain technical, managerial, and financial capacity, and to reduce the oversight and resources that states need to devote to these systems. The State Water Board maintains that consolidating public water systems and extending service from existing public water systems to communities and areas that currently rely on under-performing or failing small water systems, as well as private wells, reduces costs and improves reliability. Consolidation does this by extending costs to a larger pool of ratepayers.
Evolution of consolidation authority in California: California has recognized the benefits of consolidation for decades. SB 1307 (Costa and Thompson, Chapter 734, Statutes of 1997), instituted the state's Drinking Water State Revolving Fund (DWSRF), and declared that, "It is in the interest of the people of the State of California to encourage the consolidation of the management and the facilities of small water systems to enable those systems to better address their water contamination problems."
After the enactment of SB 1307, and in order to promote consolidation, the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), which managed that state's drinking water program at the time, established the Consolidation Incentive Program, which provided an incentive for larger, compliant water systems to consolidate with nearby noncompliant systems. Previously, CDPH only invited drinking water systems that were out of compliance with drinking water standards to submit applications for DWSRF funding. However, through this new program, compliant systems that agreed to consolidate with a neighboring noncompliant system became eligible for DWSRF funding.
AB 783 (Arambula, Chapter 614, Statutes of 2007) provided further support and direction for the state's consolidation efforts by directing CDPH to encourage; provide funds for and studies on; and, prioritize funding for projects that consolidate small public water systems in certain situations.
In 2014, SB 861 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 35, Statutes of 2014) transferred the Drinking Water Program from CDPH to the State Water Board effective July 1, 2014, creating the new Division of Drinking Water within the State Water Board. Since the transfer, the consolidation of failing drinking water systems in order to supply safe, affordable, and reliable drinking water has been a priority for the state.
Authority to require consolidation: Enacted June 24, 2015, SB 88 (Senate Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 27, Statutes of 2015) authorized the State Water Board, when a public water system or state small water system serving a disadvantaged community consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water, to order that system (referred to as a subsumed water system) to consolidate with, or receive an extension of service from, a compliant public water system (referred to as the receiving system).
SB 88 set up the existing structure for current ordered consolidation law. First, it requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to complete several tasks, such as notify the water systems, consult with various entities, provide technical expertise to both water systems, and obtain written consent from domestic well owners for consolidation or extension of service. Next, it requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to make certain findings, such as that all reasonable efforts to negotiate consolidation or extension of service were made and that consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. Finally, it requires the State Water Board, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, to complete certain tasks, such as making funds available to the receiving water system for the costs of completing the consolidation and compensating the owners of a privately owned subsumed water system for the fair market value of the system.
While for many years the state's drinking water program had encouraged voluntary consolidation of public water systems, SB 88 authorizes the state to mandate the consolidation of water systems, where appropriate.
Additional consolidation authority: SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016) expanded the State Water Board’s authority to order consolidation by enabling it to contract with a competent administrator to provide managerial and technical expertise for public water systems that are consistently unable to provide an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water. AB 2501 (Chu, Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018) authorized the State Water Board to also order consolidation or extension of service to a disadvantaged community that is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water.
Proposed changes to ordered consolidation laws: This bill builds upon the authority vested to the State Water Board to order the consolidation of domestic wells with inadequate supplies of safe water in disadvantaged communities. Its intent is to remove barriers to, and to encourage, consolidation efforts in several ways.
First, this bill deletes statute that requires the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, to obtain written consent from any domestic well owner. The bill also prohibits the State Water Board, before ordering consolidation or extension of service, from using, as a metric of feasibility of the project, a specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units (or well owners, if different) served by domestic wells in the service area that are likely to provide consent to the construction of a lateral to serve their dwellings units. Obtaining the consent of well owners prior to initiating a consolidation effort informs the State Water Board’s evaluation of the feasibility of the project and enables them to better prioritize resources toward potential ordered consolidation projects. The sponsors of the bill, the Leadership Counsel for Justice and Accountability, argue, however, that under current law and practice, a requirement for consent from well owners and then lack of consent could result in the early termination of a consolidation project, even when lack of written consent is due to either a desire for more information or failure of a landlord to respond. Sponsors argue that the provisions in the bill would alter the process so that a drinking water project is not thwarted by an artificial requirement that a certain percentage of a community consent to the project, regardless of whether the project is an economically feasible way to deliver safe drinking water to the community in need.
The Committee may wish to consider whether the State Water Board should retain some flexibility to use the possibility of consent to the consolidation project as a means to determine whether the project is feasible.
Second, the bill requires the State Water Board, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, to notify owners and renters of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit’s drinking water. According to the sponsors, these provisions are meant to provide those tenants with information about water quality inadequacies, as well as the fact that the landlord has not consented to a drinking water solution. Sponsors argue that this information will enable the tenant to take appropriate steps to address the problem, including switching to another drinking water source, use of appropriate filtration, relocation, or a request that the owner reconsider refusal of consent to extension of service. The sponsors assert that this written information, provided to tenants, should put pressure on landlords to consent to the extension of service.
In order to provide information about unsafe well water to tenants earlier, and in order to potentially encourage dwelling and well owners to consent to consolidation efforts, the Committee may wish to move the notification requirement provisions so that the notification occurs earlier in the consolidation process (before the consolidation efforts begin, not during the consolidation project).
Third, this bill makes other changes to ordered consolidation law, including prohibiting a receiving water system from charging any fees to mitigate or compensate for increased groundwater use if the subsumed water system was reliant on groundwater immediately before the consolidation or extension of service.
Proposed Committee amendments:
- Clarify that one well with unsafe water within a disadvantaged community would not necessarily trigger a consolidation effort by amending the bill to authorize the State Water Board to order consolidation or extension of service within a disadvantaged community, which is, in whole or in part, reliant on domestic wells that consistently fail to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water. (Page 4, line 1)
- Make the bill consistent with current statutory terms relating to consolidation and extension of service by replacing the phrases that include "lateral" throughout the bill with "consolidation or extension of service."
- Clarify that the State Water Board shall inform the owner of the dwelling, or well owner, if different, that the dwelling unit is supplied by a domestic well that does not provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water. (Page 8, line 25)
- Delete provisions requiring the State Water Board to determine whether a dwelling is rented to tenants and to provide a written statement to tenants about their drinking water, and instead require the State Water Board to provide a written statement, as specified in the bill, to the occupants of a dwelling supplied by a domestic well with unsafe water. (Page 8, line 35)
- Clarify that the dwelling owner’s failure to consent to an extension of service or to provide an alternate adequate supply of safe drinking water evidences a failure to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water to the dwelling, not failure to "provide bare living requirements necessary for a habitable dwelling." (Page 9, line 10)
- Delete the requirement that the written statement that must be sent to the occupants of a dwelling served by a well with unsafe water include the following information, "That the dwelling unit is untenantable because the dwelling unit substantially lacks an approved water supply." (Page 9, line 12)
- Reinsert an existing statutory requirement, which had been deleted in the bill, requiring the State Water Board to use well owner’s potential consent to the project as a means to determine if the project is feasible, by amending 116682 (d)(3) as follows: Before ordering consolidation or extension of service, the state board shall find… Consolidation of the receiving water system and subsumed water system or extension of service is appropriate and technically and economically feasible. In making this finding, the state board shall consider how many owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area have provided, or are likely to provide, written consent to extension of service. (Page 7, line 3)
- Delete, in order to provide the State Water Board with flexibility on how best to evaluate and prioritize consolidation projects, provisions that prohibit the State Water Board , in determining whether a consolidation project is feasible, from using a specific percentage of well owners that are likely to provide consent to the project as a metric of feasibility, by amending 116682 (d)(3) as follows: However, the state board need not find
, and shall not require,that any specific percentage of the owners of dwelling units served by domestic wells in the service area are likely to consent to theconstruction of a lateralconsolidation or extension of service to serve their dwelling unit. (Page 7, line 4) - Move the provisions in 116682 (e)(6), which require the State Water Board, to, upon ordering consolidation or extension of service, notify owners and renters of dwelling units that are reliant on a domestic well with unsafe drinking water about the adequacy and safety of the unit’s drinking water, to 116682 (b), which would require the State Water Board to take those actions before ordering consolidation or extension of service. (Page 8, line 22)
Related legislation:
- AB 2501 (Chu, Chapter 871, Statutes of 2018). Authorizes the State Water Board to order consolidation with a receiving water system when a disadvantaged community is reliant on a domestic well that consistently fails to provide an adequate supply of safe drinking water; prohibits, for an ordered consolidation, the receiving water system from charging specified fees or imposing specified conditions on customers of the subsumed water system that it would not otherwise charge or impose; and, makes other changes to ordered consolidation law.
- SB 623 (Monning, 2017). Would have created the Safe and Affordable Drinking Water Fund, administered by the State Water Board, to assist communities and individual domestic well users to address contaminants in drinking water that exceed safe drinking water standards. This bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
- SB 778 (Hertzberg, 2017). Would have required the State Water Board to report on public water system consolidations to date, and their success or failure. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 552 (Wolk, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2016). Authorizes the State Water Board to contract with an administrator to provide administrative and managerial services to a designated public water system to assist with the provision of an adequate and affordable supply of safe drinking water.
- SB 1263 (Wieckowski, Chapter 843, Statutes of 2016). Authorizes the State Water Board to deny a permit for a new public water system if it determines that it is reasonably foreseeable that the proposed new public water system will be unable to provide affordable, safe drinking water.
- SB 88 (Budget Committee, Chapter 27 Statutes of 2015). Authorizes the State Water Board to require water systems that are serving disadvantaged communities with unreliable and unsafe drinking water to consolidate with, or receive service from, public water systems with safe, reliable, and adequate drinking water.
- AB 685 (Eng, Chapter 524, Statutes of 2012). Declares that it is the established policy of the state that every human being has the right to clean, affordable, and accessible water adequate for human consumption, cooking, and sanitary purposes and that relevant state agencies, including the Department of Water Resources, the State Water Board, and the State Department of Public Health shall consider this state policy when revising, adopting, or establishing policies, regulations, and grant criteria pertinent to the human uses of water.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
LEADERSHIP COUNSEL FOR JUSTICE AND ACCOUNTABILITY (SPONSOR)
ALLIANCE OF CALIFORNIANS FOR COMMUNITY EMPOWERMENT (ACCE) ACTION
AUDUBON CALIFORNIA
CALIFORNIA COASTKEEPER ALLIANCE
CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE ALLIANCE
CALIFORNIA INSTITUTE FOR RURAL STUDIES
CENTER FOR SUSTAINABLE NEIGHBORHOODS
CENTRAL CALIFORNIA ENVIRONMENTAL JUSTICE NETWORK
CLEAN WATER ACTION
COMMUNITY WATER CENTER
COURAGE CAMPAIGN
DIOCESE OF FRESNO SOCIAL JUSTICE MINISTRY
ELLA BAKER CENTER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS
LUTHERAN OFFICE OF PUBLIC POLICY - CALIFORNIA
PLANNING AND CONSERVATION LEAGUE
POLICYLINK
PUEBLO UNIDO CDC
THE TRUST FOR PUBLIC LAND
Opposition
NONE ON FILE.
Analysis Prepared by: Shannon McKinney / E.S. & T.M. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):