AB 576: State Board of Equalization: transfer of duties.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-03-21
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 576
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill transfers the remaining powers, duties, and responsibilities of the State Board of Equalization (BOE) to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). This bill’s provisions become operative only when Assembly Constitutional Amendment (ACA) 2, of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, is approved by the voters.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill’s costs to the state will come from the transition of BOE and its remaining duties and budget to CDTFA and OTA. Both CDTFA and OTA could incur significant one-time administrative costs related to taxpayer outreach, facility management and lease obligations and other administrative workload related to the transition.
Ongoing savings from combining BOE with CDTFA and OTA would offset these one-time administrative costs. In addition to the administrative efficiencies that come with consolidating government functions, there will be significant personnel savings from reduced spending on BOE members and some of their staff. Current law allows each board member to have two civil service-exempt employees, and this bill eliminates that authorization, while ACA 2 eliminates BOE members’ formal roles. Eliminating BOE members’ positions and their civil service exempt staff positions would generate ongoing savings of approximately $1.7 million.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. AB 102 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 16, Statutes of 2017, transferred much of BOE’s administrative authority and assorted powers and duties to CDTFA and OTA. However, BOE retains its original constitutional duties, which include the review, equalization or adjustment of property tax assessments, as well as the assessment of the insurance tax and alcoholic beverage taxes. While BOE – in terms of its employees and its budget – is just a fraction of what it was, it still performs important tax administration functions.
According to the author, AB 576 will eliminate redundancies in California’s tax administration by assigning the last of BOE’s operations to the relevant state agencies.
- What will happen to staff? Opponents state that this bill will result in the loss of staff with significant expertise. However, AB 576 explicitly states that BOE’s remaining civil service will be transferred to CDTFA. As noted above, the only staff not provided this guarantee are those positions exempt from civil service. Those positions include the BOE Executive Director and certain positions who work directly for a BOE member.
- Related legislation. ACA 2 (Nazarian), of the current Legislative Session, abolishes the BOE and requires the Legislature to create a state tax agency by statute for purposes of carrying out those powers, duties and responsibilities previously vested in the BOE by the California Constitution and by statute. ACA 2 is pending referral in the Committee on Rules.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 576 (
Author:Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2019
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: State Board of Equalization: transfer of duties
SUMMARY: Implements ACA 2 (Nazarian), pending rereferral by the Assembly Rules Committee, by transferring the remaining powers, duties, and responsibilities of the State Board of Equalization (BOE) to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA), as provided. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that on and after the operative date of this bill, except as provided, CDTFA is the successor to all of the duties, powers, and responsibilities of the BOE.
- Provides that any permit, registration, or other authorization issued by the BOE and in effect on the day before this bill's operative date shall be deemed on and after this bill's operative date to be a permit, registration, or other authorization of CDTFA.
- Provides that all employees serving in state civil service, including temporary employees, who are engaged in the performance of functions transferred to CDTFA are transferred to the CDTFA. The status, positions, and rights of those persons shall not be affected by their transfer and shall continue to be retained by them pursuant to the State Civil Service Act, except as to positions the duties of which are vested in a position exempt from civil service.
- Provides that the personnel records of all transferred employees shall be transferred to CDTFA.
- Provides that CDTFA shall succeed to all of the rights and property of the BOE. The property of any office, agency, or other entity of state government related to functions transferred to CDTFA is transferred to CDTFA. If any doubt arises as to where that property is transferred, the Department of General Services shall determine where the property is transferred.
- Provides that all unexpended balances of appropriations and other funds available for use in connection with any function or the administration of any law transferred to CDTFA shall be transferred to CDTFA for the use and for the purpose for which the appropriation was originally made or the funds were originally available. If there is any doubt as to where those balances and funds are transferred, the Department of Finance shall determine where the balances and funds are transferred.
- Provides that CDTFA is subject to all the debts and liabilities of the BOE as if CDTFA had incurred them.
- Deletes Government Code Section 15600, which specifies the BOE's remaining duties under current law.
- Provides that on and after this bill's operative date, OTA shall be vested with all of the duties, powers, and responsibilities of the BOE necessary or appropriate to conduct appeals hearings.
- Provides that on or after this bill's operative date, OTA tax appeals panels shall conduct all appeals hearings for those duties, powers, and responsibilities transferred to the OTA.
- Provides that all employees serving in state civil service, including temporary employees, who are engaged in the performance of functions transferred to OTA are transferred to OTA. The status, positions, and rights of those persons shall not be affected by their transfer and shall continue to be retained by them pursuant to the State Civil Service Act, except as to positions the duties of which are vested in a position exempt from civil service.
- Provides that the personnel records of all transferred employees shall be transferred to OTA.
- Provides that OTA shall succeed to all of the rights and property of the BOE. The property of any office, agency, or other entity of state government related to functions transferred to OTA is transferred to OTA. If any doubt arises as to where that property is transferred, the Department of General Services shall determine where the property is transferred.
- Provides that all unexpended balances of appropriations and other funds available for use in connection with any function or the administration of any law transferred to OTA shall be transferred to OTA for the use and for the purpose for which the appropriation was originally made or the funds were originally available. If there is any doubt as to where those balances and funds are transferred, the Department of Finance shall determine where the balances and funds are transferred.
- Specifies that this bill shall become operative only if ACA 2 (Nazarian) is approved by the voters.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the BOE, which consists of the State Controller and 4 other members elected from districts.
- Vests the BOE with various powers, duties, and responsibilities related to the administration of taxes imposed on property, insurance, and alcoholic beverages.
- Establishes, within the Government Operations Agency, the CDTFA.
- Vests the CDTFA with the administration of various statutory taxes and fees that had previously been administered by the BOE.
- Specifies that all laws prescribing the duties, powers, and responsibilities of the BOE to which the CDTFA has succeeded, together with all lawful rules and regulations established under those laws, are expressly continued in force, including existing processes and remedies available to a taxpayer or feepayer, such as settlement options and appeals processes.
- Establishes the OTA, which is now vested with responsibility for conducting appeals hearings for the various taxes and fees administered by the CDTFA and for the administrative appeals of state personal income taxes and corporation franchise and income taxes, which are administered by the Franchise Tax Board.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
The Board of Equalization (BOE) is a redundant, scandal-plagued office that can be eliminated to save [taxpayer] money and re-direct resources to strengthen the middle class.
Following an investigation by the Department of Justice, the California Legislature passed and Governor Brown signed AB 102 in June 2017. AB 102 stripped the BOE of nearly all tax administration and appeal functions, and gave the responsibilities to two new tax departments: the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA).
The BOE now only handles assessing and allocating the property values of railroads and specified utilities and businesses; adjudicating property tax appeals of taxable government-owned property; overseeing the property tax assessment practices of the 58 county assessors; and adopting rules to clarify property tax laws. The BOE contracts with the CDTFA to administer the alcoholic beverage excise tax and the insurance tax, including appeals.
In 2017 the BOE retained 400 employees, with the rest of its 4,800 workers shifted to the new departments. Their budget went from $550,000,000 in the 2016-2017 fiscal year to $30,000,000 in 2017-2018 and down to $29,000,000 in 2018-2019. According to the budget, the current number of positions in the BOE is 195. By eliminating the BOE, millions of dollars could be re-invested in programs that strengthen the middle class.
AB 576 in conjunction with ACA 2 will eliminate the final redundancies of having three separate tax entities and assign the last of the BOE's operations to the relevant existing state agencies. In addition the staff, property, assets and debts of the [BOE] will be moved and reassigned to the CDTFA and OTA, respectively.
- This bill is supported by California State Controller Betty T. Yee, who notes:
I believe that in the interest of fair and expert tax administration for all California taxpayers, it is time for BOE to be abolished. I was a strong proponent of Assembly Bill 102 (Chapter 16, Statutes of 2017), which transferred all non-constitutionally required BOE functions to the California Department of Tax & Fee Administration (CDTFA) and the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). Now that the vast majority of BOE workload has been transferred to CDTFA and OTA, it is time to eliminate the nation's only elected tax commission.
It is critical to retain BOE's staff expertise in the property tax and other arenas. These functions, and the accompanying seasoned personnel, can be easily housed as a separate division in an existing state tax agency, which AB 576 attempts to accomplish.
- This bill is opposed by four of the five BOE members, who note:
On July 1, 2017, Assembly Bill 102 (Stats. 2017, ch. 16) separated the BOE into three agencies: the BOE, the CDTFA, and the OTA, and almost two years later the challenges still exist.
First, the impact on BOE employees, who are the state's subject matter experts on property tax programs, is costly in terms of staff morale, retention and hiring of new employees. The property tax programs nor its professional staff were the source of the problems that resulted in the restructuring of BOE. Yet, as the remaining BOE state resources with specific and unique property tax expertise, the retention of these employee[s] would be at risk with the passage of AB 576. The breadth and depth of expertise has been developed from decades as practitioners in the county-assessed and state-assessed tax sectors. Losing this treasure of statewide knowledge is not easily or quickly replaceable and would leave a significant gap in the state's ability to administer property tax programs.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- The long road to reform: In November 2015, State Controller Yee released a detailed report on the BOE's accounting and administrative controls. Among other things, this report found that the BOE lacked adequate controls over the retail sales tax fund, rendering it unable to detect errors in a timely manner. In one case, the state General Fund received $47.8 million too much, while other funds were shortchanged by that amount. The report also found that, in quarterly reconciliations of tax revenue allocations, the BOE improperly counted items that should have been left out and made incorrect adjustments, leading to misallocation of funds. Finally, the report identified weaknesses in the BOE's oversight of its internal revolving fund used for salaries, travel, and vendor payments.
This report was followed by a Department of Finance evaluation issued in March 2017. Among other things, this evaluation included the following key findings:
- Certain BOE member practices intervened in administrative activities and created inconsistencies in operations; breakdowns in centralized processes; and, in certain instances, resulted in activities contrary to state law;
- The BOE had difficultly providing complete and accurate documentation in response to evaluation inquiries. Specific examples included the informal establishment of a call center, the creation of an unofficial office location, and the inconsistent use of community liaisons;
- Despite having dedicated staff and operating budgets of $1.5 million, some BOE members routinely supplemented their staff by redirecting revenue-generating staff to perform non-revenue-generating BOE member activities, including "outreach"; and,
- So-called outreach activities had a limited nexus with the BOE's core mission, and had increased in recent years.
On April 13, 2017, Governor Brown responded to these reports, and numerous related media stories, by sending a letter to all BOE members that asked the Department of Human Resources and the Department of Justice to coordinate investigations of BOE employee complaints. The letter also suspended the BOE's delegated authority for personnel, contracting, and technology. Finally, the letter convened legislative leaders to identify statutory changes to address the problems identified at BOE and to enact changes by June 2017.
- The Legislature takes action: The Governor's call to action culminated in the passage and enactment of AB 102 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 16, Statutes of 2017. Among other things, AB 102:
- Established, within the Government Operations Agency, the CDTFA and placed the newly-established department under the control of a director appointed by the Governor and subject to Senate confirmation;
- Transferred to CDTFA the various duties, powers, and responsibilities of the BOE related to the administration of various taxes and fees except for those duties imposed or conferred upon the BOE by the California Constitution, as specified;
- Provided for the transfer to the CDTFA of the BOE's employees serving in civil service, as specified;
- Required each member of the BOE elected by the voters of an equalization district to have only one office in Sacramento and one district office;
- Required BOE member procurements to be processed through the Department of General Services; and,
- Restricted ex parte communications in relation to a BOE adjudicatory proceeding.
- The Legislature takes action: The Governor's call to action culminated in the passage and enactment of AB 102 (Committee on Budget), Chapter 16, Statutes of 2017. Among other things, AB 102:
The above-described provisions were made operative on July 1, 2017. AB 102 also established in state government the OTA and placed the office under the control of a director appointed by the Governor and subject to Senate confirmation. To that end, AB 102 transferred to the OTA the various duties, powers, and responsibilities of the BOE necessary or appropriate to conduct appeals hearings, except for those duties imposed upon the BOE by the California Constitution.
- The BOE's remaining duties: The BOE's remaining duties, prescribed by the California Constitution, are codified in Government Code Section 15600. Those duties include:
- The review, equalization, or adjustment of a property tax assessment pursuant to Section 11 of Article XIII of the California Constitution;
- The assessment of pipelines, flumes, canals, ditches, and aqueducts lying within two or more counties and property owned or used by regulated railway, telegraph, or telephone companies, specified car companies, and companies transmitting or selling gas or electricity pursuant to Section 19 of Article XIII of the California Constitution, as well as the equalization of that assessment;
- The assessment of taxes on insurers pursuant to Section 28 of Article XIII of the California Constitution[1];
- The assessment and collection of excise taxes on the manufacture, importation, and sale of alcoholic beverages in this state pursuant to Section 22 of Article XX of the California Constitution[2];
- The administration of the welfare exemption provided by Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214 and the veterans' organization exemption provided by R&TC Section 215.1;
- The responsibility for receiving a change in ownership statement required to be filed due to a change in control or a change in ownership of a corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or other legal entity, as specified; and,
- The administration of the Tax-Rate Area System.
- ACA 2: ACA 2 (Nazarian), of the current Legislative Session, would abolish the BOE and instead require the Legislature to create a state tax agency by statute for purposes of carrying out those powers, duties, and responsibilities previously vested in the BOE by the California Constitution and by statute. ACA 2 has not been referred by the Committee on Rules and is not currently before this Committee. Instead, this bill simply puts in place a statutory framework for transferring the BOE's remaining duties to CDTFA and OTA, as applicable, should ACA 2 receive a 2/3rds vote from each house of the Legislature and be approved by the voters at a statewide election. Under this framework, CDTFA would be the successor agency to the BOE for all remaining tax administrative functions. Moreover, BOE's remaining appellate functions would be transferred to OTA.
- The BOE's remaining duties: The BOE's remaining duties, prescribed by the California Constitution, are codified in Government Code Section 15600. Those duties include:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State Controller Betty T. Yee
Opposition
California Alliance of Taxpayer Advocates
Ryan, LLC
State Board of Equalization Member Antonio Vazquez
State Board of Equalization Member Malia M. Cohen
State Board of Equalization Mike Schaefer
State Board of Equalization Member Ted Gaines
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):