AB 648: Wellness programs.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-01-23
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 23, 2020 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jan 28, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 12. Noes 5.) (January 23). |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 3). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. (Ayes 10. Noes 3.) (March 26). |
| Mar 13, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 11, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and L. & E. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 27, 2020 | AB 648 Nazarian Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Labor and Employment] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
(Without Reference to File)
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 648
Author:(Nazarian)
As Amended Ver:January 23, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes the Wellness Program Protection Act, and imposes various requirements related to wellness programs on health care services plans (health plans)/insurers/employers, including prohibitions to retaliate against an enrollee/insured/member/employee if the health plan/insurer/employer's action is in response to an individual's election not to participate in a wellness program; and, to share any personal information or data collected through a wellness program.
Major Provisions
Excludes any wellness program for licensed health care professionals administered or operated by a professional association or its affiliates or subsidiaries or the personal information or data collected by a professional association or its affiliates or subsidiaries in relation to, or in support of, the administration or operation of a wellness program for licensed health care professionals. Defines wellness program as a health plan/insurer/employer program aimed at promoting health-related behaviors and disease prevention, but also excludes care coordination by or between health care providers in the practice of medicine.
COMMENTS:
Wellness programs. According to the United States Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, implementing and expanding employer wellness programs may offer the opportunity to not only improve the health of Americans, but also help control health care spending. The Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) creates new incentives and builds on existing wellness program policies to promote employer wellness programs and encourage opportunities to support healthier workplaces.
According to a 2015 Health Affairs article, federal policy makers have long seen both the promise and perils of employer wellness incentives. When Congress prohibited group health plans from discriminating based on health factors under federal privacy law, it created an exception for programs of health promotion and disease prevention. When regulators (the federal Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and Treasury) promulgated a final rule implementing this provision, they imposed a limit on wellness incentives tied to health factors of 20% of the total cost of coverage, a level thought to avoid "rewards or penalties so large as to deny coverage or create too heavy a penalty" on individuals not meeting the requisite standards. The ACA offered support for the development and expansion of health incentives in a variety of ways, including to lift the ceiling on health-contingent wellness incentives to 30% (close to $1,800 annually for an average employee-only plan) and to invite regulators to increase the ceiling to 50%, if appropriate.
According to an article from Case Western Reserve University (Case article), "The Dubious Empirical and Legal Foundations of Workplace Wellness Programs," wellness programs come in two forms. First, participatory wellness programs offer employees a financial incentive based only on their participation and employees might receive a reward, for instance, if they fill out a health assessment or attend a smoking-cessation class. The reward can take a variety of forms, such as a premium discount or rebate. Alternatively, employees might be penalized for failing to participate. Health-contingent wellness programs require employees to achieve health related targets in order to receive the financial incentive. Employees might, for example, have to visit the gym a certain number of times each month or keep their blood pressure under control. On their face, participatory wellness programs treat all employees alike. Health-contingent programs, however, discriminate among employees based on factors related to their health, and creates a potential conflict with laws that aim to prevent employers from discriminating against their sickest employees in the provision of health insurance.
Additionally, according to the Case article noted above, most of the numerous studies on the efficacy of employer-based wellness programs suffer from serious methodological shortcomings and some are promotional materials pulled together at the wellness industry's behest. However, the Case study notes that good studies do exist and, when considered together, they paint a reasonably consistent picture of wellness programs' performances, or lack thereof. According to the Case study, wellness programs aimed at improving employee lifestyles yield little, if any, savings. Programs that focus on managing employees' chronic diseases, however, hold substantially more promise.
According to the Author:
Wellness programs are promoted as a way to support healthy behaviors and improve health outcomes for participants. However, many come with unspoken tradeoffs as they require participants to give up their personal data, including sensitive personal health information, in exchange for unsupported promises of wellness. For many enrollees, the type of surveillance that comes with a wellness program may seem like more than they signed up for. This bill will protect wellness program participants' privacy by establishing clear requirements around fair collection and use of data; prohibit discrimination related to wellness programs; and, require transparency for candidates to make informed decisions when participating in wellness programs. As the popularity of health-related technology and programs increases, so does sensitivity to privacy concerns. According to the author, it is absolutely necessary to create standards for wellness programs to ensure consumer protections.
Arguments in Support:
Consumer Reports (CR), a sponsor of this bill, writes that this bill will ensure that privacy protections exist and are sufficient to protect all enrollees of wellness programs. CR also states that this bill will also protect program enrollees against misuse and sharing of their personal data and will curb the reach of employer and insurer control over employees' and enrollees' data. CR contends that this bill will empower individuals to make more informed decisions to join or not to join a wellness program, and ensure that those who do participate can do so without giving up their right to privacy and without suffering discrimination or penalty based on participation.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Chamber of Commerce (CCC) and other organizations, in a previous version of this bill, contend that this bill creates significant liability for employers and imposes requirements which would likely end voluntary workplace Wellness Programs that benefit employees and contribute to a healthy workforce. The CCC states that employee wellness programs are generally provided as an additional voluntary benefit or perk for working for the employer and their goal is to encourage healthy lifestyles.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs to the Department of Managed Health Care of $60,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $140,000 in 2020-21 and around $16,000 in 2021-22 and ongoing. Costs to the Department of Industrial Relations in the range of $100,000 to $450,000 annually in the Department of Labor Standards Enforcement Retaliation Claims Investigation unit.
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 10-3-2
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Bonta, Carrillo, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago
NO: Bigelow, Flora, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mayes, Burke
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-5-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Megan Dahle, Diep, Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Maienschein
UPDATED:
VERSION: January 23, 2020
CONSULTANT: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0002672
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 648
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 28, 2019
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 10 - 3 |
Labor and Employment | 6 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes rules that govern wellness programs instituted by health plans, insurers and employers. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee to participate in a wellness program as a condition of employment.
- Prohibits a health plan/insurer/employer from retaliating or taking any adverse action against an enrollee/insured/member/employee if the health plans/insurer’s/employer’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program.
- Requires a health plan/insurer/employer to comply with data privacy protections, limit sharing of data and destroy data upon conclusion of the program, and provide clear written explanations about program parameters, data collection and enrollee rights. Establishes enrollee/insured/member/employee rights to view and challenge the accuracy of their personal records.
- Allows the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) Director or State Insurance Commissioner to adopt regulations to conform to federal law if this bill conflicts with federal law.
- Subjects a person who willfully violates this bill’s provisions to existing enforcement procedures and any other sanctions and penalties permitted by existing law.
- Specifies that any person who violates the employment provisions of this bill is guilty of a misdemeanor.
- Allows any person who believes they have been discharged or otherwise discriminated against by an employer in violation of the employment provisions of this bill to file a complaint with Department of Industrial Relations (DIR).
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Costs to the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) of $60,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $140,000 in 2020-21 and around $16,000 in 2021-22 and ongoing. Costs will be incurred to review health plan documents for compliance, draft legal opinion memoranda to clarify various aspects of the law, enforce the requirements and respond to consumer complaints through the consumer Help Line.
- Costs to DIR in the range of $100,000 to $450,000 annually in the Department of Labor Standards Enforcement Retaliation Claims Investigation unit, based on assumptions of an additional 25 to 100 new claims a year for investigation (Labor Enforcement & Compliance Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, it is necessary to create consumer protection standards by establishing clear requirements around fair collection and use of data, prohibiting discrimination and enhancing transparency to allow employees to make informed decisions when participating in these programs.
- Background. Wellness programs offer financial incentives, penalties or both for either health-related behaviors (such as participation in a smoking cessation program) or achieving a biometric target (such as control of one’s blood pressure). These programs can be run by insurers or employers to encourage healthier enrollees and reduce costs and burden associated with chronic conditions. The federal Affordable Care Act established standards for wellness programs, including limiting financial incentives under health-contingent wellness programs to no more than 30% of the total health plan premium.
Researchers and health advocates have expressed concerns that incentives and penalties associated with wellness programs can be applied in unfair or discriminatory ways. For instance, Health Access California (HAC) writes in support of this bill that most wellness program studies that found benefits from wellness incentives did not control for selection bias and those who took advantage of wellness incentives were more likely to be healthy and affluent than those who did not. Additionally, HAC notes that wellness incentives are problematic for those with disabilities, many of those who live in low-income areas where outside exercise may be unsafe, and those who are less affluent and thus less able to take advantage of sports or other exercise-related activities.
- Support. This bill is sponsored by Consumer Reports (CR), who contends this bill will empower individuals to make more informed decisions to join or not to join a wellness program and ensure that those who do participate can do so without giving up their right to privacy and without suffering discrimination or penalty based on participation. American Federation of State, County And Municipal Employees and health advocates support this bill.
- Opposition. Health plans and insurers as well as the California Chamber of Commerce oppose this bill. CalChamber contends this bill exposes employers to criminal and civil liability, which will disincentive their use of wellness programs. The Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies (ACLHIC) states this bill would prevent plans and insurers from working collaboratively with employer groups to come up with innovative ways to improve their employees’ quality of life and overall health status while in turn reducing their healthcare costs.
- Staff Comment. According to the California Department of Public Health’s 2013 report, “The Burden of Chronic Disease and Injury,” chronic conditions account for 80% of health care expenditures and 80% of hospital admissions. Many chronic diseases and conditions have common, preventable risk behaviors including poor diet, tobacco use and lack of physical activity. Furthermore, the California Wellness Plan of 2014 recognizes work sites as critical partners in the effort to promote a healthier California. A Kaiser Family Foundation issue brief published in 2017 titled “Changing Rules for Workplace Wellness Programs: Implications for Sensitive Health Conditions” notes the potential for workplace wellness programs to improve health and save costs continues to hold great appeal for employers and policymakers alike. The report notes the challenge is to balance this potential with protections to ensure programs do not discriminate against people with health problems or compel disclosure of health information people want to keep private.
Given the high cost and risk chronic conditions linked to unhealthy behaviors pose to the overall financial sustainability of our health care system across sectors and the relatively miniscule funding and effort for health promotion activities statewide, the author may wish to ensure efforts to protect enrollees from abuse do not render unworkable bonafide programs that can promote healthy behaviors through a workplace setting, imperfect as they may be. In particular, it would be unfortunate if restrictions that sound reasonable in fact create significant legal liability that discourages participation in efforts to promote health and reduce the immense burden of chronic conditions. A balanced approach would appear to best serve the public interest.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 648 (
Author:Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 28, 2019
SUBJECT: Wellness programs
SUMMARY: Prohibits health care plans, insurers, and employers from discriminating against persons who decline to participate in a wellness program and ensures that only essential health information is collected.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits health care service plans or insurers from taking any adverse action, as defined, if the action of the health care service plans or insurers is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, such as an individual’s election to not participate in a wellness program.
- Requires that health care service plans or insurers provide written information about the wellness program, the scope of data collection, and the enrollee or insured’s rights regarding the program under both state and federal law.
- Requires a health care service plan, insurer, or entity it contracts with, for purposes of administering and operating a wellness program, to limit its collection, dissemination, retention, and use of any personal information of an individual to only information that is reasonably necessary to operate a wellness program.
- Authorizes the Insurance Commissioner (IC) to assess penalties on an insurer for any violation of these provisions, as specified.
- Authorizes the director of the Department of Insurance and the IC to adopt regulations to conform to federal law in the event that the provisions conflict with federal law.
Employment-Related Provisions:
- Defines employer as either of the following:
- Any person who directly employs 50 or more persons to perform services for a wage or salary.
- The state and any political or civil subdivision of the state, a county, or a city.
- Defines “retaliatory” or “adverse action” as including an adverse employment action taken by an employer against an employee, including termination, fine, or suspension, if an employer’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, such as an employee’s election to not participate in a wellness program or the data collected through the wellness program about an employee.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee to participate in a wellness program as a condition of employment or retaliating against an employee who declines to participate in a wellness program.
- Requires an employer to provide written information about the wellness program, the scope of data collection, and the employee’s rights regarding the program under both state and federal law.
- Requires an employer or entity it contracts with, for purposes of administering and operating a wellness program, to limit its collection, dissemination, retention, and use of any personal information of an individual to only information that is reasonably necessary to operate a wellness program.
- Provides that if an employee terminates their participation in a wellness program, the employer shall destroy all related personal information collected, and the employee shall be permitted to do the following:
- Obtain a copy of the employee’s records, including personal information collected in connection with the wellness program.
- Challenge the completeness and accuracy of any records, including personal information collected as part of the wellness program.
- File a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within six months of the occurrence of the violation.
- Provides that a violation of these provisions shall constitute a misdemeanor.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Establishes the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA) that enacted various health care coverage market reforms and sets forth requirements related to wellness programs.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Establishes the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975 that provides for the licensure and regulation of health care service plans by the Department of Managed Health Care.
- Provides for the regulation of various insurers by the Department of Insurance and authorizes the department director and the Insurance Commissioner to adopt regulations for purposes of implementing specified provisions of law.
- Establishes the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement within the Department of Industrial Relations, for the purpose of enforcing labor laws, including those relating to employer retaliation.
- Provides that discriminating, retaliating against, or discharging an employee for exercising certain rights under the labor code is a misdemeanor.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: As this bill was also referred to the Assembly Health Committee, committee comments will focus on the employment provisions of this bill.
According to the author, “Wellness programs are promoted as a way to support healthy behaviors and improve health outcomes for participants. However, many come with unspoken tradeoffs: they require participants to give up their personal data, including sensitive personal health information, in exchange for unsupported promises of wellness and, in some cases, to win rewards.”
The author further states that employer-sponsored wellness programs can raise significant employee privacy concerns. Wellness programs may “directly violat[e] employees’ privacy by creating a channel for employers to ask questions they otherwise would never ask, such as an employees’ pregnancy status or intent to become pregnant, [and] the personal health data that is collected can be misused. For example, health data on enrollees can be compiled from multiple data sources and then sold, or ‘shared,’ for profit.”
According to a 2014 report by Bloomberg, employer collection of employee health information and personal data warrants privacy concerns. The report points out that “the recent hack of Sony Corp—in which health information on more than three dozen employees was stolen from the company’s servers—is highlighting the amount of medical data proliferating outside of doctor’s offices in electronic form, and how vulnerable the records are to theft. Corporate wellness programs have become one of the biggest areas where health data is being collected, with hundreds of vendors amassing millions of pieces of intimate and potentially embarrassing health information on American workers.”[1]
Furthermore, the scholarship suggests that employee wellness programs may act to discriminate against employees with disabilities and, if mandatory, could be violative of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act. According to a 2016 literature review in the American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, wellness programs can create health inequity for disabled employees and reinforce negative bias towards hiring them.”[2]
Arguments in Support
Consumer Reports, sponsor to the bill, states that “by ensuring that no Californian can be compelled to participate in a wellness program, setting high transparency standards, and limiting data collection and use, AB 648 will grant Californians the freedom to either participate in wellness programs without unintentionally or involuntarily entering into unfair
deals, or to decline to participate without repercussion.”
Arguments in Opposition
The California Chamber of Commerce, in opposition to the bill, points out that a number of federal laws protect employee health information. The Chamber states, “Both the American with Disabilities Act (ADA) and the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act (GINA) impose limits on wellness programs. HIPAA and the Affordable Care Act (ACA) also contain rules regarding wellness programs. The ADA prohibits employers from obtaining medical information from applicants and employees unless they want to volunteer that information if they choose to participate in a wellness program. The GINA prohibits the use of genetic information, which includes an employee’s family medical history, in making employment decisions and limits an employer’s ability to unilaterally request, acquire or disclose genetic information.”
Prior Legislation
AB 2688 (Gordon) of 2016 would have required an employer that receives health monitoring information from a commercial health monitoring program to establish procedures to preserve the confidentiality and security of that information. The bill also would have prohibited an employer from discriminating against an employee based on an employee’s health monitoring information or if that employee does not authorize consent to the use of their health monitoring information. The measure died on the Senate floor.
SB 189 (Monning) of 2013 would have prohibited a health plan or health insurer from offering a wellness plan unless certain requirements were met. The bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees, Afl-Cio
California Nurses Association
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
Consumer Reports
Health Access California
Western Center On Law & Poverty, Inc.
Oppose
Association Of California Life & Health Insurance Companies
California Association Of Health Plans
California Chamber Of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
“Wellness Programs at Work May Not Be as Private as You Think,” Bloomberg, December 16, 2014. ↑
American Medical Association Journal of Ethics, April 2016, vol. 18, no. 4, review of Griffin Basas, C., “What is bad about wellness? What the disability rights perspective offers about the limitations of wellness,” Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law, 2014, pages 1035-1066. ↑
Date of Hearing: March 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 648
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2019
SUBJECT: Wellness programs.
SUMMARY: Establishes the Making Wellness Programs Healthy for Consumers Act of 2019, and imposes various requirements related to wellness programs on health care services plans (health plans)/insurers/employers, including a prohibition from offering an incentive or reward to an enrollee/insured/member/employee, based on adherence to a wellness program; retaliating against an enrollee/insured/member/employee if the health plan/insurer/employer’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program; and, sharing any personal information or data collected through a wellness program. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee to participate in a wellness program as a condition of employment.
- Prohibits a health plan/insurer/employer from doing any of the following:
- Offering an incentive or reward to an enrollee/insured/member/employee based on adherence to a wellness program;
- Retaliating or taking any adverse action against an enrollee/insured/member/employee if the health plan/insurer/employer’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, such as an individual’s election to not participate in a wellness program or the data collected through the wellness program about the enrollee/insured/member/ employee; and,
- Sharing any personal information or data collected through a wellness program.
- Requires a health plan/insurer/employer that collects personal information of an enrollee/insured/member/employee as part of its administration and operation of a wellness program, to ensure compliance with state and federal privacy laws, as specified.
- Requires a health plan/insurer/employer to provide an enrollee/insured/member/employee a written explanation, in clear and easily understandable language, about the basis of the wellness program, a description about the data collection process and which data will be collected through the wellness program, policies and practices pertaining to the wellness program, and the rights of the enrollee/insured/member/employee concerning the wellness program under federal and state laws and regulations.
- Requires a health plan/insurer/employer, for purposes of administering and operating a wellness program, to limit its collection, dissemination, retention, and use of any personal information of an enrollee/insured/member/employee to only information that is reasonably necessary to operate the wellness program.
- Requires a health plan/insurer/employer to destroy any personal information received or collected through the wellness program, and to order the destruction of this material, if an enrollee/insured/member/employee terminates their participation in a wellness program, or upon the conclusion of a wellness program.
- Gives an enrollee/insured/member/employee the right to do both of the following:
- Obtain a copy of their records, including personal information collected by the health plan/insurer/employer pertaining to the wellness program, in a format accessible to the individual; and,
- Challenge the completeness and accuracy of any records, including personal information or data, related to the enrollee/insured/member/employee collected by a health plan/ insurer/employer.
- Requires the provisions of this bill to apply, to the extent that they are applicable, to any entity that the health plan/insurer/employer contracts with for purposes of administering or operating a wellness program on the health plan or insured’s behalf.
- Prohibits a health plan or insurer or entity in 8) above from sharing any personal information about the enrollee/insured/member/employee with the employer, as specified.
- Defines the following:
- Administration and operation of a wellness program as, but is not limited to, the use of personal information when reasonably necessary and proportionate to achieve one of the following purposes:
- Detecting and responding to security incidents arising from a wellness program and protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity related to a wellness program;
- Executing functions of a wellness program for the benefit of the enrollee or insured or member;
- Undertaking internal research for technological development and demonstration related to a wellness program; or,
- Undertaking activities to verify or maintain the quality or safety of a service or device that is owned by, manufactured by, manufactured for, or controlled by the health plan or insurer, or to improve, upgrade, or enhance the service or device that is owned by, manufactured by, manufactured for, or controlled by the health plan/ insurer/employer related to a wellness program.
- Collects, collected, or collection as buying, renting, gathering, obtaining, receiving, or accessing, by any means, any personal information pertaining to an enrollee/insured/ member/employee. Includes information that the health plan/insurer/employer receives from an enrollee/insured/member/employee either directly or indirectly, such as through observation of the enrollee/insured/member/employee.
- Employer as either of the following:
- Any person who directly employs 50 or more persons to perform services for a wage or salary; or,
- The state and any political or civil subdivision of the state, county, or city.
- Incentive as, but is not limited to, a discounted premium, cash reward, or other tangible item.
- Personal information as information that identifies or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with either an enrollee/insured/member/employee or their household.
- Personal information includes, but is not limited to, an enrollee/insured/member/ employee’s past, present, or future physical or mental health condition, common identifiers, including a name, address, birth date, social security number, or any other identification number, and protected health information.
- Personal information excludes any publicly available information, and excludes any deidentified or aggregate information about an enrollee/insured/member/employee.
- Specifies that, for purposes of this bill, the deidentification of personal information to meet the requirements set forth in existing federal law.
- Publicly available information as information that is lawfully made available pursuant to federal and state law.
- Protected health information as defined in existing federal law.
- Retaliatory or adverse action as, but is not limited to, an adverse action taken by a health plan or insurer against an enrollee/insured/member, including increasing a premium, if the health plan or insured’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, such as an enrollee/insured/member’s election to not participate in a wellness program or the data collected, as specified. States that retaliatory or adverse action is, but is not limited to, an adverse employment action taken by an employer against an employee, including termination, fine, or suspension, if an employer’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, as specified.
- Administration and operation of a wellness program as, but is not limited to, the use of personal information when reasonably necessary and proportionate to achieve one of the following purposes:
- Subjects a person who willfully violates this bill to be subject to the enforcement procedures, and any other sanctions and penalties, permitted by existing law.
- Allows the Insurance Commissioner to assess administrative penalties, as specified, against an insurer.
- Allows any person who believes that they have been discharged or otherwise discriminated against by an employer in violation of the employment provisions of this bill to file a complaint, as specified. Specifies that any person who violates the employment provisions of this bill is guilty of a misdemeanor, as specified.
- Allows the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) Director or Insurance Commissioner to adopt regulations to conform to federal law if this bill conflicts with federal law.
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Establishes, the Patient Protection Affordability Care Act (ACA), which enacts various health coverage market reforms.
- Permits, under the ACA, a program offered by an employer designed to promote health or prevent disease that meets specified requirements.
- Establishes under the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act of 1996 (HIPAA), standards for privacy of individually identifiable health information and security standards for the protection of electronic protected health information, including, through regulations, that a HIPAA covered entity may not condition the provision to an individual of treatment, payment, enrollment in the health plan, or eligibility for benefits on the provision of an authorization, except under specified circumstances, including an exception for programs of health promotion and disease prevention. Provides that if HIPAA provisions conflict with a state law, the provision that is most protective of patient privacy prevails.
- Defines protected health information as individually identifiable health information.
- Specifies that health information that does not identify an individual and with respect to which there is no reasonable basis to believe that the information can be used to identify an individual is not individually identifiable health information.
- Prohibits, under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act, discrimination by group health plans based on an individual’s health status, and makes exceptions for wellness programs to offer premium or cost sharing discounts based on an individual’s health status in certain circumstances.
- Establishes the Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act of 2008 (GINA), to protect individuals from discrimination based on genetic information.
- Establishes the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), among various provisions, that prohibits discrimination and guarantees that people with disabilities have the same opportunities as everyone else.
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Establishes, GINA in California, and includes genetic information in the list of protected classes under various public accommodations statutes established under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act, and the Health and Safety Code.
- Establishes the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA), and prohibits a health care provider, health plan, or contractor from disclosing medical information regarding a patient, enrollee, or subscriber without first obtaining an authorization, except as specified. States a violation of the provisions of CMIA that results in economic loss or personal injury to a patient is a crime.
- Defines medical information to mean any individually identifiable information, in electronic or physical form, in possession of or derived from a provider of health care, health care service plan, pharmaceutical company, or contractor regarding a patient’s medical history, mental or physical condition, or treatment. Defines individually identifiable to mean that the medical information includes or contains any element of personal identifying information sufficient to allow identification of the individual, such as the patient’s name, address, electronic mail address, telephone number, social security number, or other information that, alone or in combination with other publicly available information, reveals the individual’s identity.
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act, effective January 1, 2020, which provides consumers with the right to request the categories and specific pieces of information collected by a company, as specified.
- Establishes the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, led by the Labor Commissioner, within the Department of Industrial Relations, for the purpose of enforcing labor laws
- Establishes the DMHC to regulate health plans and the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health insurers.
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, which is administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), under which qualified low income individuals receive health care services.
- Authorizes Medi-Cal managed care (MCMC) plans to offer non-monetary incentives to promote good health practices.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, wellness programs are promoted as a way to support healthy behaviors and improve health outcomes for participants. However, many come with unspoken tradeoffs as they require participants to give up their personal data, including sensitive personal health information, in exchange for unsupported promises of wellness. For many enrollees, the type of surveillance that comes with a wellness program may seem like more than they signed up for. This bill will protect wellness program participants’ privacy by establishing clear requirements around fair collection and use of data; prohibit discrimination related to wellness programs; and, require transparency for candidates to make informed decisions when participating in wellness programs. As the popularity of health-related technology and programs increases, so does sensitivity to privacy concerns. According to the author, it is absolutely necessary to create standards for wellness programs to ensure consumer protections.
- BACKGROUND.
- Wellness programs. According to the U.S. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), implementing and expanding employer wellness programs may offer the opportunity to not only improve the health of Americans, but also help control health care spending. The ACA creates new incentives and builds on existing wellness program policies to promote employer wellness programs and encourage opportunities to support healthier workplaces.
According to a 2015 Health Affairs article, federal policy makers have long seen both the promise and perils of employer wellness incentives. When Congress prohibited group health plans from discriminating based on health factors under HIPAA, it created an exception for programs of health promotion and disease prevention. When regulators (the federal Departments of Health and Human Services, Labor, and Treasury) promulgated a final rule implementing this provision, they imposed a limit on wellness incentives tied to health factors of 20% of the total cost of coverage, a level thought to avoid "rewards or penalties so large as to deny coverage or create too heavy a penalty" on individuals not meeting the requisite standards. The ACA offered support for the development and expansion of health incentives in a variety of ways, including by lifting the ceiling on health-contingent wellness incentives to 30% (close to $1,800 annually for an average employee-only plan) and inviting regulators to increase the ceiling to 50% if appropriate. In a 2013 final rule, regulators preserved the 30% ceiling as a general matter but allowed it to rise to 50% for programs targeting tobacco use. Employers have structured wellness programs to comply with the HIPAA and ACA regulations, but have long been concerned about issues raised by other statutes, like the ADA and GINA. The ADA, for example, limits medical examinations and disability-related inquiries, but provides an exception for "voluntary medical examinations, including voluntary medical histories, which are part of an employee health program."
According to an article from Case Western Reserve University (Case article), “The Dubious Empirical and Legal Foundations of Workplace Wellness Programs”, wellness programs come in two forms. First, participatory wellness programs offer employees a financial incentive based only on their participation and employees might receive a reward, for instance, if they fill out a health assessment or attend a smoking-cessation class. The reward can take a variety of forms, such as a premium discount or rebate. Alternatively, employees might be penalized for failing to participate. Health-contingent wellness programs require employees to achieve health related targets in order to receive the financial incentive. Employees might, for example, have to visit the gym a certain number of times each month or keep their blood pressure under control. On their face, participatory wellness programs treat all employees alike. Health-contingent programs, however, discriminate among employees based on factors related to their health, and creates a potential conflict with laws that aim to prevent employers from discriminating against their sickest employees in the provision of health insurance.
- Workplace Wellness Studies. A 2016 Health Affairs article concluded that premium-based financial incentives did not promote workplace weight loss in a 2013 to 2015 study. Employers commonly use adjustments to health insurance premiums as incentives to encourage healthy behavior, but the effectiveness of those adjustments is controversial. The apparent failure of the incentives to promote weight loss suggests that employers that encourage weight reduction through workplace wellness programs should test alternatives to the conventional premium adjustment approach by using alternative incentive designs, larger incentives, or both.
Additionally, according to the Case article noted above, most of the numerous studies on the efficacy of employer-based wellness programs suffer from serious methodological shortcomings and some are promotional materials pulled together at the wellness industry’s behest. However, the Case study notes that good studies do exist and, when considered together, they paint a reasonably consistent picture of wellness programs’ performances, or lack thereof. According to the Case study, wellness programs aimed at improving employee lifestyles yield little, if any, savings. Programs that focus on managing employees’ chronic diseases, however, hold substantially more promise.
- SUPPORT. Consumer Reports (CR), a sponsor of this bill, writes that this bill will ensure that privacy protections exist and are sufficient to protect all enrollees of wellness programs. CR also states that this bill will also protect program enrollees against misuse and sharing of their personal data and will curb the reach of employer and insurer control over employees’ and enrollees’ data. CR contends that this bill will empower individuals to make more informed decisions to join or not to join a wellness program, and ensure that those who do participate can do so without giving up their right to privacy and without suffering discrimination or penalty based on participation. Health Access California (HAC) writes that most of the wellness program studies that found benefits from wellness incentives did not control for selection bias and those who took advantage of wellness incentives were more likely to be healthy (and affluent) than those who did not. Additionally, HAC notes that wellness incentives are problematic for those with disabilities, many of those who live in low-income areas where outside exercise may be unsafe, and those who are less affluent and thus less able to take advantage of sports or other exercise-related activities.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 384 (Chau) revises the CMIA, to expand the definition of medical information to include any individually identifiable information in electronic or physical form in possession of, or derived from, a digital health feedback system, as defined. AB 384 is pending in Assembly Health Committee.
- AB 990 (Gallagher) states the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation that would require MCMC plans, subject to federal approval, to offer financial incentives to enrollees for their improved wellness activities. AB 990 is pending in Assembly Rules Committee. As proposed to be amended, AB 990 requires a MCMC plan on or after January 1, 2021 to offer financial incentives to its existing enrollees for the purpose of promoting participation in preventative health or wellness activities.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 2935 (Chau) of 2018 would have prohibited an operator of a commercial health monitoring program (CHMP) from intentionally sharing, selling, or disclosing individually identifiable health monitoring information in its possession or derived from a CHMP without first obtaining the consumer’s consent. AB 2935 was never heard in Senate Judiciary Committee.
- AB 375 (Chau), Chapter 55, Statutes of 2018, enacts the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018, and grants a consumer a right to request a business to disclose the categories and specific pieces of personal information that it collects about the consumer, the categories of sources from which that information is collected, the business purposes for collecting or selling the information, and the categories of third parties with which the information is shared.
- SB 1121 (Dodd), Chapter 735, Statutes of 2018, modifies the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018, by requiring a business that collects personal information about a consumer to disclose the consumer’s right to delete personal information in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers, as specified.
- SB 189 (Monning) of 2013 would have prohibited a health plan or health insurer from offering a wellness plan unless certain requirements were met. SB 189 was held in Senate Appropriations.
- POLICY COMMENT. DHCS, in a 2016 All Plan Letter, updated its requirements for the use of non-monetary incentives by MCMC plans and provided a list of appropriate non-monetary incentives, including gift cards and products that promote or are associated with good health practices. According to DHCS, the use of incentives to motivate individuals to adopt healthy behaviors, such as quitting smoking, losing weight, receiving timely postpartum care, or accessing timely immunizations, could ultimately lead to improving health status, enhancing prevention and health outcomes, and reducing program costs. These types of incentives would be prohibited under this bill as it applies to all health plans, including MCMC plans. To ensure consistency in the marketplace and to allow for the continued availability of wellness programs to all enrollees, the Committee may wish to amend this bill as follows in the Health and Safety, Insurance, and Labor Code Sections:
1367.13. (a) A health care service plan shall not do any of the following:
(1) Offer an incentive or reward to an enrollee or member based on adherence to a wellness program.
(2) Retaliate or take any adverse action against an enrollee or member if the health care service plan’s action is in response to a matter related to a wellness program, such as an individual’s election to not participate in a wellness program or the data collected through the wellness program about the enrollee or member.
- DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill has been double-referred; upon passage of this Committee, it will be referred to the Assembly Labor and Employment Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Reports (sponsor)
American Federation of State, County And Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
Health Access California
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):