AB 686: Indian children.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 434, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 19, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 11 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | From Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 14, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 10). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HUMAN S. and JUD. |
| May 2, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (March 26). |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HUM. S. and JUD. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 10, 2019 | AB 686 Waldron Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB686 Waldron et al. By Rubio | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2019 | AB 686 Waldron Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 686
Author:(Waldron and Ramos)
As Amended Ver:September 4, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Clarifies requirements pertaining to the out-of-home placement of Indian children, and requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court allowing for an Indian child's tribe to participate remotely in proceedings.
Major Provisions:
Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for fee-free telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child's tribe in proceedings where the federal Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978, as specified, may apply.
Requires, in the case of an Indian child for whom the child's tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, the county or the foster family agency (FFA) to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to resource family approval for that child, as specified.
Stipulates that tribal home approvals, as specified, are not subject to resource family approval requirements.
The Senate Amendments:
- Adopt requirements for FFA placements related to the application of the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to resource family approval for an Indian child, and require the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to engage in the tribal consultation process and develop regulations to implement requirements related to county and FFA application of prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community.
- Add provisions from AB 819 (Stone) and AB 865 (Reyes) of the current legislative session to avoid chaptering out conflicts.
COMMENTS:
Resource Family Approval: Per statute, CDSS is required to implement the resource family approval process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. Initially implemented in select counties, resource family approval was adopted on a statewide basis through continuum of care reform (CCR) legislation. Because it includes elements of adoption and guardianship processes, the resource family process can create opportunities for more direct routes to permanency for foster youth. The resource family approval process includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to better meet the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
Tribally approved homes: Pursuant to the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA), a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child (although it is not required to do so). These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. A forthcoming all-county letter from CDSS, currently in draft form, states that tribally approved homes are not subject to California's resource family approval requirements.
According to the Author:
"The Indian Child Welfare Act provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted. In 2015, the California ICWA Compliance Task Force was formed to examine compliance issues and provide recommendations to improve understanding of and compliance with ICWA. The Task Force report identified ongoing concerns regarding the placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case. This bill would increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child's tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings."
Arguments in Support:
Writing in support, the Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria state that, "This bill seeks to remedy…important issues to ensure that Indian children are afforded the rights and protections they are promised by federal law." The Judicial Council of California also supports the bill, stating that "the availability of remote access for tribes in ICWA cases is a proven and federally encouraged mechanism for expanding tribal participation in courts where the lives and family relationships of tribal children are at stake."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, this bill has negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 8-0-0
YES: Reyes, Mathis, Luz Rivas, Choi, Friedman, Gipson, Maienschein, Mark Stone
ASM JUDICIARY: 12-0-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0-4
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Grayson, Mullin, Quirk
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 4, 2019
CONSULTANT: Daphne Hunt & Gail Gronert / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0002220
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 686 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 686
Author: Waldron (R) and Ramos (D), et al.
Amended: 9/4/19 in Senate
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/10/19
AYES: Hurtado, Beall, Jackson, Pan, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stone
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/25/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/2/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies existing law regarding resource family approval (RFA) and the placement of Indian children under the provisions of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). Specifically, this bill provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA are not subject to RFA requirements; requires the county and foster family agency, when placing an Indian child, to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for that child; and, requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to issue guidance to counties and foster family agencies on how to consistently implement the application of prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community. Additionally, this bill requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court related to telephone or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe, as provided.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/4/19 avoid chaptering issues in the event this bill and AB 819, this bill and AB 865, or all three bills are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law:
- Establishes a system of juvenile dependency for children for specified reasons, including but not limited to children who are, or are at risk of, being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected or being exploited, to ensure their safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being, as specified. (WIC 300 et seq.)
- States that the purpose of foster care law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. (WIC 300.2)
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to, whenever possible, preserve and strengthen a child’s family ties and, when a child must be removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, to give preferential consideration to placement with relatives. (WIC 16000)
- Establishes ICWA, which provides guidance to states regarding jurisdictional requirements, proceedings of tribal courts, and custody proceedings involving the removal of Indian children from the custody of their parents. (25 USC 1901 et seq.)
- Declares California’s commitment to protecting the essential tribal relations and best interest of Indian children by promoting child welfare practices in accordance with federal law, as provided. (WIC 224(a))
- Requires the dependency court, in all Indian child custody proceedings as defined by ICWA, to strive to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families, comply with ICWA, and seek to protect the best interest of the child. Further requires, whenever an Indian child is removed from a foster care home or institution, guardianship, or adoptive placement for the purpose of further foster care, guardianship, or adoptive placement, that the placement of the child be in accordance with ICWA. (WIC 244(b))
- Requires ICWA to apply to any proceedings regarding an unmarried minor who is either the member of an Indian tribe or who is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and a biological child of a member or citizen of an Indian tribe, as specified. (WIC 244(c))
- Defines a number of terms related to Indian child welfare and delineates processes for designating an Indian child’s tribe for purposes of an Indian child custody proceeding, as specified. (WIC 224.1)
- Stipulates processes and requirements regarding the determination of a child’s status as an Indian child, as specified. (WIC 224.2)
- Establishes requirements and processes related to the placement of an Indian child who has been removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, including establishing priorities for placement preferences, as specified. (WIC 361.31)
- Establishes in state law the authority for a federally recognized tribe to approve a home for the purposes of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child per ICWA and provides for processes related to this approval. (WIC 10553.12)
- Defines “resource family approval” to mean that the applicant or resource family successfully meets the home environment assessment and permanency assessment standards, as specified. (HSC 1517)
- Defines a “resource family” to mean an individual or family that has successfully met both the home environment assessment and the permanency assessment criteria, as specified, necessary for providing care for a child placed by a public or private child placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (HSC 1517; WIC 16519.5(c)(1))
- Requires CDSS to implement the RFA process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members (NREFMs) as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. (WIC 16519.5(a))
- Stipulates that a resource family shall be considered eligible to provide foster care for children in out-of-home placement and shall be considered approved for adoption and guardianship, and authorizes a county to approve a resource family to care for a specific child, as specified. (WIC 16519.5(c)(4))
This bill:
- Provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, for Indian children, as defined, are not subject to RFA requirements.
- Provides that for an Indian child for whom the child’s Tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, the foster family agency shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to RFA for that child, as required by ICWA.
- Requires CDSS to engage in the tribal consultation process and develop regulations to implement provisions of this bill and permits CDSS to provide guidance to counties and foster family agencies regarding consistent implementation of provisions of this bill through the issuance of written directives that shall have the same force and effect as regulations, until regulations are adopted.
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe in proceedings where ICWA applies.
- Makes technical changes.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “ICWA provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted.” Additionally, there have been “documented barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court house,” per the author. Thus, the author states AB 686 will “increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.”
Child welfare system (CWS). California’s CWS is charged with protecting children from abuse and neglect and providing for their health, safety, and overall well-being. When warranted, abused and neglected children may be removed from their homes and placed into foster care. In 2018, the state’s child welfare agencies received 485,651 reports of abuse or neglect. Of those reports, 66,584 contained allegations that were substantiated and 27,110 of the substantiated reports resulted in children being removed from their homes and placed into foster care.
Abused and neglected children who have been removed from their homes fall under the jurisdiction of the county’s juvenile dependency court, while the children are served by the county child welfare social worker. This system seeks to ensure the safety and protection of these children, and where possible, preserve and strengthen families through visitation and family reunification. It is the state’s goal to reunify a foster child or youth with their biological family whenever possible. In instances where reunification is not possible, it is the state’s goal to provide a permanent placement alternative, such as adoption or guardianship, with placement priority given to placing children with other relatives or NREFMs. As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children in California’s CWS system.
Continuum of Care Reform (CCR). The CCR is a system-wide effort to institute a series of reforms to California’s CWS program. It is designed out of an understanding that children who must live apart from their biological parents do best when they are cared for in committed nurturing family homes. For more than a decade, researchers have documented poor outcomes for foster children. These poor outcomes have been especially pronounced for those placed in a group or congregate care settings. CCR intends to reduce the number of foster children placed in congregate care settings by improving the assessments of children and families and establishing a child and family team for each child in foster care. AB 403 (Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015) was the first of five CDSS-sponsored CCR bills and it provides the statutory and policy framework to ensure services and supports provided to the child or youth and their family are tailored toward the ultimate goal of maintaining a stable permanent family.
Resource Family Approval program. Concurrent with the implementation of CCR, the state replaced the existing process for licensing foster family homes, approving relatives and non-relative extended family members, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, and approving legal guardians and adoptive families. It combines elements of each of these prior processes into a single approval standard, regardless of the child’s case plan. The RFA program includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to address the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
The goal of the RFA program is to eliminate the duplication of processes and streamline placement of children in a way that is unified, family friendly, and child-centered. Because it includes elements of adoption and guardianship processes, the RFA program can create opportunities for more direct routes to permanency for foster youth. Initially implemented in select counties through legislation sponsored by the County Welfare Directors Association in 2007, RFA was then expanded through SB 1013 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 35, Statutes of 2012) and adopted on a statewide basis through AB 403 (Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015).
Indian Child Welfare Act. In the 1970s, a multiyear Congressional investigation found that Indian children were being removing from their homes at significantly high rates, and that such removal was often unwarranted. Indian children were being removed at rates as high as 25 to 35 percent and these children were then often placed in non-Indian foster homes.
In response to this investigation, ICWA was enacted by Congress in 1978 to address states “often fail[ing] to recognize the essential tribal relations of Indian people and the cultural and social standards prevailing in Indian communities and families,” and the resulting unwarranted removal of Indian children. Congress’s goal through the enactment of ICWA was to “protect the best interests of Indian children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families.”[1] In an effort to meet this goal, ICWA established minimum federal standards for state courts to meet any time an Indian child is removed from their family or custodial home and placed in foster care or adoptive homes. This results in a presumption that it is in the best interest of the Indian child to retain tribal ties.
ICWA authorized states to establish higher standards that go above the federal baseline. In 2006, California adopted a state-level implementation of ICWA through the passage of SB 678 (Ducheny, Chapter 838, Statutes of 2006). SB 678 established Cal-ICWA, revising and recasting portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings and codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for state courts, and state Rules of Court. As a result, in any child custody proceeding in which the court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is involved, the child’s tribe must be notified of the proceeding and of their right to intervene in the proceeding.
Of the 59,487 children and youth in the state’s CWS system as of October 1, 2018, 1,216 were ICWA-eligible. Of those, 466 were placed with relatives.
Tribally approved homes. Under ICWA, a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. However, tribes and tribal agencies are not required to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. If Tribe or tribal agency chooses to not be responsible for the Indian child’s placement, the county would be required to place the Indian child, subject to the requirements of ICWA, as provided.
This bill clarifies that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, are not subject to RFA requirements. When the child’s Tribe is not exercising their right to approve the home, it requires the county child welfare agency placing the Indian child to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for the Indian child’s placement. Additionally, this bill requires CDSS to engage in the tribal consultation process and develop regulations to implement provisions of this bill and permits CDSS to provide guidance to counties and foster family agencies regarding consistent implementation of provisions of this bill through the issuance of written directives that shall have the same force and effect as regulations, until regulations are adopted.
According to CDSS, an all-county letter states tribally approved homes are not subject to California’s RFA requirements is forthcoming.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 685 (Reyes, 2019) requires the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters, requires topics of ICWA and cultural competency related to Indian children in out-of-home care be included in certain training for legal counsel, and requires the court of appeal to appoint counsel for a child’s Indian tribe. AB 685 is waiting to be heard by the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 3047 (Daly, Chapter 399, Statutes of 2018) provided a fee waiver for out-of-state attorneys appearing pro hac vice in specified ICWA matters.
AB 3076 (Reyes, 2018) would have required the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers in order to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters and would have required the grants to be provided only to qualified legal services projects and support centers that have experience handling child welfare matters under the federal ICWA or providing legal services to Indian tribes. AB 3076 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
Alliance for Children's Rights
Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria
Fernandeno Tataviam Mission Band of Indians
Judicial Council of California
Juvenile Court Judges of California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Center for Youth Law
Tule River Tribal Council
Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/2/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Grayson, Mullin, Quirk
Prepared by: Taryn Smith / HUMAN S. /
9/5/19 15:39:43
**** END ****
See 25 U.S.C. 1902 ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 686 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 686
Author: Waldron (R) and Ramos (D), et al.
Amended: 7/9/19 in Senate
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/10/19
AYES: Hurtado, Beall, Jackson, Pan, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stone
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/25/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/2/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Tribal Families Coalition
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies existing law regarding resource family approval (RFA) and the placement of Indian children under the provisions of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). Specifically, this bill provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA are not subject to RFA requirements; requires the county and foster family agency, when placing an Indian child, to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for that child; and, requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to issue guidance to counties and foster family agencies on how to consistently implement the application of prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community. Additionally, this bill requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court related to telephone or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe, as provided.
Existing law:
- Establishes a system of juvenile dependency for children for specified reasons, including but not limited to children who are, or are at risk of, being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected or being exploited, to ensure their safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being, as specified. (WIC 300 et seq.)
- States that the purpose of foster care law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. (WIC 300.2)
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to, whenever possible, preserve and strengthen a child’s family ties and, when a child must be removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, to give preferential consideration to placement with relatives. (WIC 16000)
- Establishes ICWA, which provides guidance to states regarding jurisdictional requirements, proceedings of tribal courts, and custody proceedings involving the removal of Indian children from the custody of their parents. (25 USC 1901 et seq.)
- Declares California’s commitment to protecting the essential tribal relations and best interest of Indian children by promoting child welfare practices in accordance with federal law, as provided. (WIC 224(a))
- Requires the dependency court, in all Indian child custody proceedings as defined by ICWA, to strive to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families, comply with ICWA, and seek to protect the best interest of the child. Further requires, whenever an Indian child is removed from a foster care home or institution, guardianship, or adoptive placement for the purpose of further foster care, guardianship, or adoptive placement, that the placement of the child be in accordance with ICWA. (WIC 244(b))
- Requires ICWA to apply to any proceedings regarding an unmarried minor who is either the member of an Indian tribe or who is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and a biological child of a member or citizen of an Indian tribe, as specified. (WIC 244(c))
- Defines a number of terms related to Indian child welfare and delineates processes for designating an Indian child’s tribe for purposes of an Indian child custody proceeding, as specified. (WIC 224.1)
- Stipulates processes and requirements regarding the determination of a child’s status as an Indian child, as specified. (WIC 224.2)
- Establishes requirements and processes related to the placement of an Indian child who has been removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, including establishing priorities for placement preferences, as specified. (WIC 361.31)
- Establishes in state law the authority for a federally recognized tribe to approve a home for the purposes of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child per ICWA and provides for processes related to this approval. (WIC 10553.12)
- Defines “resource family approval” to mean that the applicant or resource family successfully meets the home environment assessment and permanency assessment standards, as specified. (HSC 1517)
- Defines a “resource family” to mean an individual or family that has successfully met both the home environment assessment and the permanency assessment criteria, as specified, necessary for providing care for a child placed by a public or private child placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (HSC 1517; WIC 16519.5(c)(1))
- Requires CDSS to implement the RFA process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members (NREFMs) as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. (WIC 16519.5(a))
- Stipulates that a resource family shall be considered eligible to provide foster care for children in out-of-home placement and shall be considered approved for adoption and guardianship, and authorizes a county to approve a resource family to care for a specific child, as specified. (WIC 16519.5(c)(4))
This bill:
- Provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, for Indian children, as defined, are not subject to RFA requirements.
- Provides that for an Indian child for whom the child’s Tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, the foster family agency shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to RFA for that child, as required by ICWA.
- Requires CDSS to engage in the tribal consultation process and develop regulations to implement provisions of this bill and permits CDSS to provide guidance to counties and foster family agencies regarding consistent implementation of provisions of this bill through the issuance of written directives that shall have the same force and effect as regulations, until regulations are adopted.
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe in proceedings where ICWA applies.
- Makes technical changes.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “ICWA provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted.” Additionally, there have been “documented barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court house,” per the author. Thus, the author states AB 686 will “increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.”
Child welfare system (CWS). California’s CWS is charged with protecting children from abuse and neglect and providing for their health, safety, and overall well-being. When warranted, abused and neglected children may be removed from their homes and placed into foster care. In 2018, the state’s child welfare agencies received 485,651 reports of abuse or neglect. Of those reports, 66,584 contained allegations that were substantiated and 27,110 of the substantiated reports resulted in children being removed from their homes and placed into foster care.
Abused and neglected children who have been removed from their homes fall under the jurisdiction of the county’s juvenile dependency court, while the children are served by the county child welfare social worker. This system seeks to ensure the safety and protection of these children, and where possible, preserve and strengthen families through visitation and family reunification. It is the state’s goal to reunify a foster child or youth with their biological family whenever possible. In instances where reunification is not possible, it is the state’s goal to provide a permanent placement alternative, such as adoption or guardianship, with placement priority given to placing children with other relatives or NREFMs. As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children in California’s CWS system.
Continuum of Care Reform (CCR). The CCR is a system-wide effort to institute a series of reforms to California’s CWS program. It is designed out of an understanding that children who must live apart from their biological parents do best when they are cared for in committed nurturing family homes. For more than a decade, researchers have documented poor outcomes for foster children. These poor outcomes have been especially pronounced for those placed in a group or congregate care settings. CCR intends to reduce the number of foster children placed in congregate care settings by improving the assessments of children and families and establishing a child and family team for each child in foster care. AB 403 (Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015) was the first of five CDSS-sponsored CCR bills and it provides the statutory and policy framework to ensure services and supports provided to the child or youth and their family are tailored toward the ultimate goal of maintaining a stable permanent family.
Resource Family Approval program. Concurrent with the implementation of CCR, the state replaced the existing process for licensing foster family homes, approving relatives and non-relative extended family members, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, and approving legal guardians and adoptive families. It combines elements of each of these prior processes into a single approval standard, regardless of the child’s case plan. The RFA program includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to address the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
The goal of the RFA program is to eliminate the duplication of processes and streamline placement of children in a way that is unified, family friendly, and child-centered. Because it includes elements of adoption and guardianship processes, the RFA program can create opportunities for more direct routes to permanency for foster youth. Initially implemented in select counties through legislation sponsored by the County Welfare Directors Association in 2007, RFA was then expanded through SB 1013 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 35, Statutes of 2012) and adopted on a statewide basis through AB 403 (Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015).
Indian Child Welfare Act. In the 1970s, a multiyear Congressional investigation found that Indian children were being removing from their homes at significantly high rates, and that such removal was often unwarranted. Indian children were being removed at rates as high as 25 to 35 percent and these children were then often placed in non-Indian foster homes.
In response to this investigation, ICWA was enacted by Congress in 1978 to address states “often fail[ing] to recognize the essential tribal relations of Indian people and the cultural and social standards prevailing in Indian communities and families,” and the resulting unwarranted removal of Indian children. Congress’s goal through the enactment of ICWA was to “protect the best interests of Indian children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families.”[1] In an effort to meet this goal, ICWA established minimum federal standards for state courts to meet any time an Indian child is removed from their family or custodial home and placed in foster care or adoptive homes. This results in a presumption that it is in the best interest of the Indian child to retain tribal ties.
ICWA authorized states to establish higher standards that go above the federal baseline. In 2006, California adopted a state-level implementation of ICWA through the passage of SB 678 (Ducheny, Chapter 838, Statutes of 2006). SB 687 established Cal-ICWA, revising and recasting portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings and codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for state courts, and state Rules of Court. As a result, in any child custody proceeding in which the court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is involved, the child’s tribe must be notified of the proceeding and of their right to intervene in the proceeding.
Of the 59,487 children and youth in the state’s CWS system as of October 1, 2018, 1,216 were ICWA-eligible. Of those, 466 were placed with relatives.
Tribally approved homes. Under ICWA, a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. However, tribes and tribal agencies are not required to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. If Tribe or tribal agency chooses to not be responsible for the Indian child’s placement, the county would be required to place the Indian child, subject to the requirements of ICWA, as provided.
This bill clarifies that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, are not subject to RFA requirements. When the child’s Tribe is not exercising their right to approve the home, it requires the county child welfare agency placing the Indian child to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for the Indian child’s placement. Additionally, this bill requires CDSS to engage in the tribal consultation process and develop regulations to implement provisions of this bill and permits CDSS to provide guidance to counties and foster family agencies regarding consistent implementation of provisions of this bill through the issuance of written directives that shall have the same force and effect as regulations, until regulations are adopted.
According to CDSS, an all-county letter states tribally approved homes are not subject to California’s RFA requirements is forthcoming.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 685 (Reyes, 2019) requires the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters, requires topics of ICWA and cultural competency related to Indian children in out-of-home care be included in certain training for legal counsel, and requires the court of appeal to appoint counsel for a child’s Indian tribe. AB 685 is waiting to be heard by the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 3047 (Daly, Chapter 399, Statutes of 2018) provided a fee waiver for out-of-state attorneys appearing pro hac vice in specified ICWA matters.
AB 3076 (Reyes, 2018) would have required the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers in order to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters and would have required the grants to be provided only to qualified legal services projects and support centers that have experience handling child welfare matters under the federal ICWA or providing legal services to Indian tribes. AB 3076 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
California Tribal Families Coalition (source)
Alliance for Children's Rights
Federated Indians of Graton Rancheria
Judicial Council of California
Juvenile Court Judges of California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Center for Youth Law
Yocha Dehe Wintun Nation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/19)
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/2/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Grayson, Mullin, Quirk
Prepared by: Marisa Shea / HUMAN S. /
8/15/19 11:54:55
**** END ****
See 25 U.S.C. 1902 ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 686 (Author:Waldron)
Version: June 14, 2019
Hearing Date: June 25, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Indian children
DIGEST
This bill (1) requires the Judicial Council of California to adopt a rule of court to allow for remote appearance by an Indian child’s tribe in the child’s dependency court proceedings and (2) clarifies certain requirements relating to the out-of-home placement of such children.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
“The Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (ICWA), which establishes federal standards for state-court child custody proceedings involving Indian children, was enacted to address ‘the consequences . . . of abusive child welfare practices that [separated] Indian children from their families and tribes through adoption or foster care placement, usually in non-Indian homes,’ [citation].” (Adoptive Couple v. Baby Girl (2013) 570 U.S. 637, 637.) Among other things, ICWA sets forth minimum federal standards by: (1) establishing jurisdictional requirements; (2) allowing for notice of and intervention in Indian child custody proceedings by a tribe; and (3) providing that the acts, records, and judicial proceedings of tribal courts are entitled to full faith and credit to the same extent that the acts, records, or judicial proceedings of another state would be.
This bill, which is co-sponsored by the California Tribal Families Coalition, California Indian Legal Services, Alliance for Children’s Rights, and National Center for Youth Law, seeks to increase compliance with ICWA by (1) requiring the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where ICWA may apply and (2) making other clarifications regarding placement of Indian children. The bill’s supporters include numerous tribes, the Judicial Council, and Juvenile Court Judges of California. The bill has no known opposition. The bill passed the Senate Human Services Committee by a vote of 5-0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Establishes ICWA (25 U.S.C. § 1901) to protect the best interest of Indian children by promoting the stability and security of Indian tribes and families by establishing minimum standards for:
- removal of Indian children from their families;
- placement of such children in foster or adoptive homes that reflect the unique values of Indian culture; and
- assistance to Indian tribes in the operation of child and family service programs. (Id. at § 1902.)
- Mandates placement preferences in foster care, preadoptive, and adoptive proceedings involving Indian children. (Id. at § 1915) In the absence of good cause, such children must be placed with:
- a member of the child’s extended family;
- other members of the Indian child’s tribe; or
- other Indian families.
- Absent good cause, requires state courts to transfer proceedings concerning an Indian child to the Indian child’s tribal court. (Id. at § 1911(b).) In state court proceedings for foster care placement of, or termination of parental rights to, an Indian child, provides a right of intervention to the Indian custodian of the child and the Indian child’s tribe. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides that an indigent Indian parent or custodian has the right to court-appointed counsel. (Id. at § 1912(b).) Prohibits placement in foster care unless clear and convincing evidence shows that continued custody of the child by the parent or custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child. (Id. at (e).) Prohibits termination of parental rights for an Indian child absent evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that continued custody of the child by the parent or Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child. (Id. at (f).)
Existing state law:
- Finds and declares that there is no resource more vital to the continued existence and integrity of Indian tribes than their children; that California has an interest in protecting Indian children; and that California is committed to protecting the essential tribal relations and the best interest of Indian children by promoting practices in accordance with ICWA and other applicable laws designed to prevent involuntary out-of-home placements. Finds and declares that if placement is necessary, California is also committed to ensuring that the placement reflects the unique values of the child’s tribal culture and is best able to assist the child in establishing, developing, and maintaining a political, cultural, and social relationship with the child’s tribe and tribal community. (Welf. & Inst. Code § 224.)[1]
- Imposes on courts, county welfare departments, and probation departments an affirmative, continuing duty to inquire whether a child for whom placement is sought may be an Indian child. (§ 224.2(a)-(c).) Describes conditions in which there is reason to know the child may be an Indian child. (Id. at (d).) Imposes duties of further inquiry on the court, social worker, or probation officer, upon learning a child may be an Indian child. (Id. at (e).) Establishes additional processes for determining whether the child is an Indian child for whom ICWA applies. (Id. at (f)-(j).)
- Imposes requirements for the placement of an Indian child who is removed from the physical custody of their parents or custodian. (§ 361.31(a).) Requires that in any foster care or guardianship placement of an Indian child, or any emergency removal of an Indian child, the child be placed in the least restrictive setting that most approximates a family situation and in which the child’s special needs may be met. (Id. at (b).) Additionally requires that the placement be within reasonable proximity to the child’s home, taking into account any special needs. Establishes the following order of priority:
- a member of the child’s family, as specified;
- a foster home licensed, approved, or specified by the child’s tribe;
- an Indian foster home licensed or approved by an authorized non-Indian licensing authority; and
- an institution for children approved by an Indian tribe or operated by an Indian organization that has a program suitable to meet the Indian child’s needs. (Id. at (c).)
- Requires that the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community in which the parent or extended family members of an Indian child reside, or with which the parent or extended family members maintain social and cultural ties, or the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian child’s tribe, be applied in meeting the placement preferences described above. (Id. at (f).)
- Permits a tribe to approve a home for purposes of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child and permits an Indian child that has been remove from the child’s parents in a dependency court proceeding to be placed in a tribally-approved home. (§ 10553.12.)
- Requires the State Department of Social Services (DSS), in consultation with county child welfare agencies, foster parent associations, and other interested community parties, to implement a unified, family friendly, and child-centered resource family approval process to replace existing processes to identify suitable homes and caretakers for children. (§ 16519.5(a).) Defines a “resource family” as an individual or family that meets specified home assessment standards and permanency assessment criteria for providing care for a child placed by a placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (Id. at (c).)
- Permits a party to appear by telephone in all “general civil cases,” as defined and provided. Requires the Judicial Council to establish statewide, uniform fees for parties appearing by telephone, but if a party is appearing by fee waiver, prevents the court and the vendor from charging the party a fee, as provided. Among other cases, excludes juvenile cases from general civil cases. (Code Civ. Proc. §§ 367.5-367.6; Cal. Rules Court § 1.6 (4).) Requires Judicial Council to adopt rules to allow for telephonic appearances by nonminor dependents or nonminor delinquents in specified proceedings. (§ 388; Cal. Rules Court § 5.530.) Provides standards for appearance in Juvenile Court by telephone, videoconference, or other authorized digital or electronic means, but does not independently confer a right to appear by telephone, videoconference, or other electronic means. (Cal. Rules Court § 5.531.)
This bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearances by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings in which ICWA may apply. Exempts such appearances from applicable fees.
- Provides that tribal home approvals are not subject to resource family approval requirements.
- Provides that in the case of an Indian child for whom the child’s tribe has not exercised its right to approve a home, the county must apply prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to resource family approval for that child, as specified. Requires the DSS to issue all-county letters or other similar instruction to provide guidance to counties for consistent implementation of this provision.
COMMENTS
- Background
Congress enacted ICWA in 1978. In enacting ICWA, Congress explained that states “often failed to recognize the essential tribal relations of Indian people and the cultural and social standards prevailing in Indian communities and families,” and that the removal of Indian children was “often unwarranted.” (25 U.S.C. § 1901.) The goal of ICWA is thus to “protect the best interests of Indian children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families.” (25 U.S.C § 1902.) ICWA establishes minimum federal standards, both procedural and substantive, that govern the removal of Indian children from their families and subsequent placement in foster or adoptive homes. (Fresno County Dep’t of Children & Family Services v. Superior Court (2004) 122 Cal.4th 626.) Under ICWA, there is a presumption that it is in the best interest of an Indian child to retain tribal ties and cultural heritage, and that this serves the interest of the tribe in preserving future generations.
Among other things, ICWA sets forth minimum federal standards by: (1) establishing jurisdictional requirements; (2) allowing for notice of and intervention in Indian child custody proceedings by a tribe; and (3) providing that the acts, records, and judicial proceedings of tribal courts are entitled to full faith and credit to the same extent that the acts, records, or judicial proceedings of another state would be. ICWA provides that an indigent Indian parent or custodian has the right to court-appointed counsel. (Id. at § 1912(b).) ICWA also prohibits placement in foster care unless clear and convincing evidence shows that continued custody of the child by the parent or custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child. (Id. at (e).) Finally, ICWA prohibits termination of parental rights for an Indian child absent evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that continued custody of the child by the parent or Indian custodian is likely to result in serious emotional or physical damage to the child. (Id. at (f).)
In 2007, SB 678 (Ducheny, Ch. 838, Stats. 2006) codified many of the ICWA requirements into California law. As a result, the court in a child welfare proceeding involving an Indian child must not only consider the child’s interests, but also the interests of the child’s tribe. In any child custody proceeding in which the court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is involved, the child’s tribe must be notified of the proceeding and of their right to intervene in the proceeding. (25 U.S.C. § 1912(a); Welf. & Inst. Code § 224.2(a).) Over the years, additional changes have made been to California’s statutes to better implement ICWA. Last session, AB 3176 (Waldron, Ch. 833, Stats. 2018) made several changes to state law regarding the removal of Indian children from their families and their out-of-home placement in order to conform to changes to federal regulations governing ICWA.
As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children and youth in the state’s child welfare services system; 1,216 were ICWA-eligible. Of those 1,216 children and youth, 466 were placed with relatives.
2. Enables tribes to make telephonic appearances in dependency proceedings
Under federal and state law, a tribe has standing to intervene in dependency proceedings. (25 U.S.C. § 1911(c); Welf. & Inst. Code, § 224.4; Cal. Rule Court § 5.482(e).) On occasion, a tribe may instead choose to monitor or participate in the proceeding as a nonparty. In this capacity, the representative of the tribe may attend hearings, address the court, examine documents, submit reports and recommendations, and perform other activities requested or approved by the court.
In 2015, the California Attorney General’s Bureau of Children’s Justice helped create the California ICWA Compliance Task Force, an independent, tribal-led entity, to help increase compliance with ICWA in the dependency system. Among other concerns, the Task Force documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case. The Task Force noted as follows:
Whether due to ignorance or indifference or both, this right to participate as a non-participating party is not being recognized by many courts. The denial of this right especially negatively impacts lower-income tribes, as they often do not have resources to retain legal counsel, travel and be present at all hearings or even pay fees associated with telephonic appearances and therefore feel compelled to engage as a non-participating party.[2]
To ensure the ability of tribes to remotely monitor or participate in such proceedings, this bill would require the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearances by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings in which ICWA may apply. The bill would exempt such appearances from applicable fees.
According to Juvenile Court Judges of California:
One of the significant deficiencies in these legal proceedings has been the failure of the tribes to be present at juvenile court proceedings. The voice of the tribe is not often heard in these proceedings. The reason is that many of the tribes are located hundreds (or thousands) of miles from the juvenile court where the case is being heard. The result is that the interests of the tribe are not presented or argued forcefully, and the judge is denied information that might make their decision more accurate and compliant with the ICWA.
3. Clarifies requirements for placements in tribal homes or resource families
Existing law requires the DSS, in consultation with county child welfare agencies, foster parent associations, and other interested community parties, to implement a unified, family-friendly, and child-centered resource family approval process to replace existing processes to identify suitable homes and caretakers for children. (§ 16519.5(a).) A “resource family” is defined as an individual or family that meets specified home assessment standards and permanency assessment criteria for providing care for a child placed by a placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (Id. at (c).) The resource family approval process includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to better meet the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
Pursuant to ICWA, a federally-recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. These tribally-approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. (See 25 U.S.C. 1915(b)(ii).) A forthcoming all-county letter from DSS states that tribally-approved homes are not subject to California’s resource family approval requirements. This bill clarifies in statute that tribally-approved homes are exempt from resource family standards.
Finally, the bill provides that in the case of an Indian child for whom the child’s tribe has not exercised its right to approve a home, the county must apply prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to resource family approval for that child, as specified. This reflects the ICWA requirement that the standards to be applied in determining the placement of the child “be the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community in which the parent or extended family resides or with which the parent or extended family members maintain social and cultural ties.” (25 U.S.C. 1915(d).) The bill also requires the DSS to issue all-county letters or other similar instruction to provide guidance to counties for consistent implementation of this provision.
4. Arguments in support
According to the author:
The Indian Child Welfare Act provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted. In 2015, the California ICWA Compliance Task Force was formed to examine compliance issues and provide recommendations to improve understanding of and compliance with ICWA. The Task Force report identified ongoing concerns regarding the placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case.
This bill would increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.
The California Tribal Families Coalition, a co-sponsor that is comprised of 33 member tribes and the three California Tribal Chairman’s Associations, writes:
Since its passage, ICWA has provided important rights and protections to Indian families. While progress has been made, major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted. In 2015, the California ICWA Compliance Task Force was formed to examine compliance issues and provide recommendations to strengthen understanding and compliance of the ICWA. The Task Force report documented ongoing compliance concerns regarding placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to participation tribes experience in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case.
SUPPORT
California Tribal Families Coalition (co-sponsor)
California Indian Legal Services (co-sponsor)
Alliance for Children’s Rights (co-sponsor)
National Center for Youth Law (co-sponsor)
Barona Band of Mission Indians
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
California Tribal Business Alliance
Chicken Ranch Rancheria of Me-Wuk Indians of California
Fernandeño Tataviam Band of Mission Indians
Habematolel Pomo of Upper Lake
Jamul Indian Village of California
Judicial Council of California
Juvenile Court Judges of California
Morongo Band of Mission Indians
National Association of Social Workers
Paskenta Band of Nomiaki Indians
Picayune Rancheria of the Chukchansi Indians
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Soboba Band of Luiseño Indians
Table Mountain Rancheria of Fresno County
Tule River Tribal Council
Wilton Rancheria
Yoka Dehe Wintun Nation
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 685 (Reyes & Ramos, 2019) would require the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters. That bill would also require that topics of the ICWA and cultural competency related to Indian children in out-of-home care be included in certain training for legal counsel. The bill also requires the court of appeal to appoint counsel for a child’s Indian tribe, as specified. The bill is pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation: See Comment 1.
AB 3047 (Ch. 399, Stats. 2018) provided a fee waiver for out-of-state tribal attorneys appearing pro hac vice in specified ICWA matters.
AB 3076 (Reyes, 2018) would have required the State Bar to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and qualified support centers for the purpose of providing legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters under ICWA (if more than $1 million was included in the Budget Act). The bill would have required the State Bar to provide grants only to qualified legal service projects and qualified support centers that have experience handling child welfare matters under ICWA or that have experience providing legal services to Indian tribes. The bill was held on suspense in Senate Appropriations Committee.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Human Services Committee (Ayes 5, Notes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 18, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
Assembly Human Services Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Hurtado, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 686 | ||
Author: | Waldron | ||
Version: | March 28, 2019 | Hearing Date: | June 10, 2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Marisa Shea | ||
Subject: Indian children
SUMMARY
This bill clarifies existing law regarding resource family approval (RFA) and the placement of Indian children under the provisions of the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA). Specifically, this bill: provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA are not subject to RFA requirements; requires the county, when placing an Indian child, to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for that child; and, requires CDSS to issue guidance to counties on how to consistently implement the application of prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community. Additionally, this bill requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court related to telephone or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe, as provided.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Establishes a system of juvenile dependency for children for specified reasons, including but not limited to children who are, or are at risk of, being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, being neglected or being exploited, to ensure their safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being, as specified. (WIC 300 et seq.)
- States that the purpose of foster care law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. (WIC 300.2)
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to, whenever possible, preserve and strengthen a child’s family ties and, when a child must be removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, to give preferential consideration to placement with relatives. States the intent of the Legislature to reaffirm its commitment to children who are in out-of-home placement to live in the least restrictive family setting and as close to the child’s family as possible, as specified. Further states the intent of the Legislature that all children live with a committed, permanent, nurturing family and states that services and supports should be tailored to meet the specific needs of the individual child and family being served, as specified. (WIC 16000)
- Establishes ICWA, which provides guidance to states regarding jurisdictional requirements, proceedings of tribal courts, and custody proceedings involving the removal of Indian children from the custody of their parents. (25 USC 1901 et seq.)
- Declares California’s commitment to protecting the essential tribal relations and best interest of Indian children by promoting child welfare practices in accordance with federal law, as provided. (WIC 224(a))
- Requires the dependency court, in all Indian child custody proceedings as defined by ICWA, to strive to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families, comply with ICWA, and seek to protect the best interest of the child. Further requires, whenever an Indian child is removed from a foster care home or institution, guardianship, or adoptive placement for the purpose of further foster care, guardianship, or adoptive placement, that the placement of the child be in accordance with ICWA. (WIC 244(b))
- Requires ICWA to apply to any proceedings regarding an unmarried minor who is either the member of an Indian tribe or who is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and a biological child of a member or citizen of an Indian tribe, as specified. (WIC 244(c))
- Defines a number of terms related to Indian child welfare and delineates processes for designating an Indian child’s tribe for purposes of an Indian child custody proceeding, as specified. (WIC 224.1)
- Stipulates processes and requirements regarding the determination of a child’s status as an Indian child, as specified. (WIC 224.2)
- Establishes requirements and processes related to the placement of an Indian child who has been removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, including establishing priorities for placement preferences, as specified. (WIC 361.31)
- Establishes in state law the authority for a federally recognized tribe to approve a home for the purposes of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child per ICWA and provides for processes related to this approval. (WIC 10553.12)
- Defines “resource family approval” (RFA) to mean that the applicant or resource family successfully meets the home environment assessment and permanency assessment standards, as specified. (HSC 1517)
- Defines a “resource family” to mean an individual or family that has successfully met both the home environment assessment and the permanency assessment criteria, as specified, necessary for providing care for a child placed by a public or private child placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (HSC 1517; WIC 16519.5(c)(1))
- Requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to implement the RFA process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. (WIC 16519.5(a))
- Stipulates that a resource family shall be considered eligible to provide foster care for children in out-of-home placement and shall be considered approved for adoption and guardianship, and authorizes a county to approve a resource family to care for a specific child, as specified. (WIC 16519.5(c)(4))
This Bill:
- Provides that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, for Indian children, as defined, are not subject to RFA requirements.
- Provides that for an Indian child for whom the child’s Tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, the county shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to RFA for that child, as required by ICWA.
- Requires CDSS to issue guidance, through all-county letters or other similar instruction, to counties regarding the consistent implementation of applying the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to RFA for an Indian child that the counties are responsible for placing.
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s Tribe in proceedings where ICWA applies.
- Makes technical changes.
FISCAL IMPACT
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee this bill presents the following fiscal impact:
- Minor costs to the Judicial Council.
- Negligible costs to CDSS.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “ICWA provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted.” Additionally, there have been “documented barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court house,” per the author. Thus, the author states AB 686 will “increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.”
Child Welfare Services
California’s child welfare services (CWS) system is an essential component of the state’s safety net. Social workers in each county who receive reports of abuse or neglect, investigate and resolve those reports. When a case is substantiated, a family is either provided with services to ensure a child’s well-being and avoid court involvement, or a child is removed and placed into foster care. In 2018, the state’s child welfare agencies received 485,651 reports of abuse or neglect. Of these 485,651, 66,584 reports contained allegations that were substantiated and 27,110 of the substantiated reports resulted in children being removed from their homes and placed into foster care via the CWS system.
Abused and neglected children who have been removed from their homes fall under the jurisdiction of the County’s juvenile dependency court. The dependency court holds legal jurisdiction over the child, while the child is served by the CWS system social worker. This system seeks to ensure the safety and protection of these children, and where possible, preserve and strengthen families through visitation and family reunification. The CWS system provides multiple opportunities for the custody of the child, or the child’s placement outside of the home, to be evaluated, reviewed and determined by the judicial system in consultation with the child’s social worker to help provide the best possible services to the child. It is the state’s goal to reunify a foster child or youth with their biological family whenever possible. In instances where reunification is not possible, it is the state’s goal to provide a permanent placement alternative, such as adoption or guardianship, with the second highest placement priority of the CWS system being to unite children with other relatives or nonrelative extended family members.
As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children in California’s CWS system.
Continuum of Care Reform (CCR) Effort
For more than a decade, researchers have documented poor outcomes for foster children, especially for those who are placed in group care. CCR intends to reduce the numbers of foster children placed in congregate settings by improving assessments of children and families, emphasizing home-based family placements of foster children, and changing the goals of congregate care placements.
“Children should live in their communities in home-based family care settings,” according to a 2015 report by CDSS entitled “California’s Child Welfare Continuum of Care Reform,” which forms the basis of the CCR. This report contained a number of recommendations aimed at reforming the foster care system and reducing California’s reliance on group home settings as acceptable foster care placements. In 2015, the Legislature passed the first of four CDSS-sponsored bills enacting CCR, AB 403 (Mark Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015). Among the essential components of CCR is the establishment of a child and family team for each child in care, the expansion of the RFA process, the elimination of the group home category, and the creation of short term residential therapeutic programs.
A key element of CCR was creation of the RFA process, which replaces former processes for licensing foster family homes, approving relatives and non-relative extended family members (NREFMs) as caregivers, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, and approving legal guardians and adoptive families. It combines elements of each of these prior processes into a single approval standard, regardless of the child’s case plan. The goal of the RFA process is to eliminate the duplication of existing processes and streamline the placement process of children in a way that is unified, family friendly, and child-centered.
Initially implemented in select counties through legislation sponsored by the County Welfare Directors Association in 2007, RFA was expanded through SB 1013 (Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 35, Statutes 2012), and adopted on a statewide basis through CCR legislation (AB 403, Stone, Chapter 773, Statutes 2015). Counties began implementing the new RFA process on January 1, 2017. Backlog caused by the enactment of the RFA process has been reported in some counties during the implementation of CCR. Because it includes elements of adoption and guardianship processes, the RFA process can create opportunities for more direct routes to permanency for foster youth. The RFA process includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to better meet the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA)
In the 1970s, a multiyear Congressional investigation found that Indian children were being removing from their homes at significantly high rates, and that such removal was often unwarranted. Indian children were being removed at rates as high as 25 to 35 percent and these children were then often placed in non-Indian foster homes. This investigation found that four main factors were contributing to this high rate of removal and unnecessary termination of parental rights:
- State child welfare standards for assessing Indian families lacked cultural competence;
- Due-process violations against Indian children and their parents that existed on a system-wide basis;
- Economic incentives that favored the removal of Indian children from their families and communities; and,
- Social conditions existing in Indian country.
In response to this investigation, ICWA was enacted by Congress in 1978 to address states “often fail[ing] to recognize the essential tribal relations of Indian people and the cultural and social standards prevailing in Indian communities and families,” and the resulting unwarranted removal of Indian children. Congress’s goal through the enactment of ICWA was to “protect the best interests of Indian children and to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families.”[1] In an effort to meet this goal, ICWA established minimum federal standards for state courts to meet any time an Indian child is removed from their family or custodial home and placed in foster care or adoptive homes. This results in a presumption that it is in the best interest of the Indian child to retain tribal ties.
ICWA authorized states to establish higher standards that go above the federal baseline. In 2006, California adopted a state-level implementation of ICWA through the passage of SB 678 (Ducheny, Chapter 838, Statutes 2006). SB 687 established Cal-ICWA, revising and recasting portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings and codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for State courts, and state Rules of Court. As a result, in any child custody proceeding in which the court knows or has reason to know that an Indian child is involved, the child’s tribe must be notified of the proceeding and of their right to intervene in the proceeding.
Of the 59,487 children and youth in the state’s CWS system as of October 1, 2018, 1,216 were ICWA-eligible. Of those, 466 were placed with relatives.
Tribally Approved Homes
Under ICWA, a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. Tribes and tribal agencies are however not required to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. If Tribe or tribal agency chooses to not be responsible for the Indian child’s placement, the county would be required to place the Indian child, subject to the requirements of ICWA, as provided.
This bill clarifies that tribal home approvals, conducted in compliance with ICWA, are not subject to RFA requirements. When the child’s Tribe is not exercising their right to approve the home, it requires the county child welfare agency placing the Indian child to apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to the RFA process for the Indian child’s placement. Additionally, this bill requires CDSS to issue guidance, through an all-county letter or similar instruction, to counties regarding the consistent implementation of applying the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community to RFA for Indian child placements.
According to CDSS, an all-county letter states tribally approved homes are not subject to California’s resource family approval requirements is forthcoming.
Related/Prior Legislation:
AB 685 (Reyes, 2019) requires the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters, requires topics of ICWA and cultural competency related to Indian children in out-of-home care be included in certain training for legal counsel, and requires the court of appeal to appoint counsel for a child’s Indian tribe. AB 685 is waiting to be heard by the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 3047 (Daly, Chapter 399, Statutes 2018) provided a fee waiver for out-of-state attorneys appearing pro hac vice in specified ICWA matters.
AB 3076 (Reyes, 2018) would have required the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers in order to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters and would have required the grants to be provided only to qualified legal services projects and support centers that have experience handling child welfare matters under the federal ICWA or providing legal services to Indian tribes. AB 3076 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 3176 (Waldron, Chapter 833, Statutes 2018) made a number of changes to state law regarding the removal of Indian children from their families and their out-of-home placement in order to conform to changes to federal regulations governing ICWA.
SB 678 (Ducheny, Chapter 838, Statutes 2006) revised and recast the portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings by codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for State Courts, and state Rules of Court.
COMMENTS
This bill is double referred, should it pass out of this Committee it will be heard by the Senate Judiciary Committee. Rules of court is within the jurisdiction of that Committee and as such the portion of this bill dealing with the creation of new rules of court was not considered by this Committee.
PRIOR VOTES
Assembly Floor: | 76 - 0 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 18 - 0 |
Assembly Human Services Committee: | 8 - 0 |
POSITIONS
Support:
Alliance for Children's Rights
Judicial Council of California
Juvenile Court Judges of California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Center for Youth Law
Oppose:
None received
-- END --
See 25 U.S.C. 1902 ↑
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 686
Author:(Waldron) – As Amended Ver:March 28, 2019
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Judiciary | 12 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill clarifies foster and adoptive placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals and requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to allow an Indian child’s tribe to appear remotely in dependency proceedings involving the child. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) may apply. Prohibits the charging of fees for remote access for these court appearances.
- Authorizes an Indian child’s tribe or tribal organization as eligible for adoption assistance funds under the Private Adoption Assistance Reimbursement Program (PAARP) as compensation for costs related to placement of Indian children where ICWA applies to their juvenile dependency case.
- Clarifies that tribal home approvals, as provided, are not subject to resource family approval requirements.
- Clarifies that in the case of an Indian child where the tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, resource family approval shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community, as required, and requires the Department of Social Services (DSS) to provide guidance to counties regarding consistent implementation of this requirement through all-county letters or other similar instruction.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor costs to the Judicial Council.
- Negligible costs to DSS.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to increase ICWA compliance by clarifying foster and adoptive placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals. It also seeks to increase the likelihood of participation by Indian tribes in ICWA court proceedings by authorizing the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe.
- Background. The federal Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) establishes minimum standards that state courts must follow before removing Native American children from their homes and placing them in foster care or adoptive homes. ICWA resulted from congressional hearings held in the mid-1970s, which found that Native American children were six to seven times as likely as non-native children to be placed in foster care or adoptive homes, and approximately 25-35% of all Native American children were removed from their homes and placed in foster care, adoptive homes or boarding schools. In California, Native American children were more than eight times as likely as non-native children to be placed in adoptive homes, over 90% of California Native American children subject to adoption were placed in non-native homes. One in every 124 Native American children in California was in a foster home, compared to a rate of one in 367 for non-native children. ICWA was enacted to reduce the number of Native American children removed from their parents and their tribes through the child welfare system.
California codified many of the provisions of ICWA in SB 678 (Ducheny), Chapter 838, Statutes of 2006. In June, 2016, the Bureau of Indian Affairs promulgated new regulations, effective December 12, 2016, updating requirements that courts and child welfare agencies must meet to comply with ICWA. Last year’s AB 3176 (Waldron), Chapter 833, Statutes of 2018, brought California into compliance with the newest federal regulations.
According to DSS, 364 of the nearly 30,000 children who entered the child welfare system in 2016 were Native American, roughly 12 in every 1,000 children. As of October 1, 2017, only 36% of Native American children in the child welfare system were placed with relatives, while 43% were placed with non-relatives who were not Native American.
- California ICWA Compliance Task Force. In 2015, The California Attorney General’s Bureau of Children’s Justice helped create the California ICWA Compliance Task Force (Task Force), an independent, tribal-led entity, to help increase compliance with ICWA in the dependency system. The Task Force identified ongoing concerns regarding the placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case. This bill responds to those concerns.
- Tribally approved homes. Pursuant to ICWA, a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child. These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. A forthcoming all-county letter from DSS states that tribally approved homes are not subject to California’s resource family approval requirements. This bill clarifies in statute that tribally approved homes are exempt from resource family standards.
- Related Legislation. AB 685 (Reyes), of this legislative session, requires the State Bar, subject to funding in the state budget, to administer grants to qualified nonprofit legal services organizations in order to provide Indian tribes with legal services related to ICWA and requires the court of appeals to appoint counsel for the child’s tribe in ICWA case. AB 685 is also before this committee today.
- Prior Legislation: AB 3076 (Reyes), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have created a program to support qualified legal services projects providing legal services to Indian tribes on child welfare matters under the ICWA. It was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 686
Author:(Waldron) – As Amended Ver:March 28, 2019
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Indian child WELFARE ACT
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO INCREASE COMPLIANCE WITH THE INDIAN CHILD WELFARE ACT AND INCREASE THE LIKELIHOOD THAT A CHILD’S TRIBE WILL BE ABLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE CHILD’S DEPENDENCY COURT PROCEEDINGS, SHOULD THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL BE REQUIRED TO DEVELOP A RULE OF COURT TO ALLOW THE TRIBE TO APPEAR IN THE PROCEEDING BY TELEPHONE OR OTHER REMOTE APPEARANCE METHOD?
SYNOPSIS
After a long and troubling history of separation of Native American children from their families and their tribes, Congress established the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) in 1978, which established minimum standards that state courts must follow before removing these children from their families and placing them in foster care or adoptive homes. Compliance with ICWA in child welfare proceedings in California remains uneven, creating increased costs, time-consuming appeals, and unnecessary placement delays or changes, all of which hurt children, families, tribes, and the child welfare system overall. This bill, sponsored by California Tribal Families Coalition, seeks to increase compliance with ICWA generally and, of relevance to this Committee, assist children and tribes in particular cases by requiring the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where ICWA may apply. The bill makes other clarifications regarding placement of Native American children, but the remote appearance provision is the relevant change for this Committee.
The author states that this bill will help “to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.” This bill is supported by tribes, the juvenile court judges, and children's organizations. It passed the Assembly Human Services Committee last week on a vote of 8-0. There is no opposition to this bill.
SUMMARY: Requires Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to allow an Indian child’s tribe to appear remotely in dependency proceedings involving the child. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) may apply. Prohibits the charging of fees for telephonic or other computerized remote access for these court appearances.
- Clarifies that tribal home approvals, as provided, are not subject to resource family approval requirements.
- Clarifies that in the case of an Indian child where the tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, resource family approval shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian community, as required, and requires the Department of Social Services (DSS), notwithstanding the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act, to provide guidance to counties regarding consistent implementation of this requirement through all-county letters or other similar instruction.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes ICWA, which provides guidance to states regarding the jurisdictional requirements, proceedings of tribal courts, and custody proceedings involving the removal of Indian children from the custody of their parents. (25 U.S.C. 1901 et seq.; 25 C.F.R. Part 23.)
- Governs, through ICWA, specified custody proceedings involving Indian children, including:
- Establishing jurisdictional requirements, and allowing for notice of and intervention in Indian child custody proceedings by a tribe. (25 U.S.C. Sections 1911, 1912, 1918, 1920.)
- Providing that an indigent parent or Indian custodian has the right to court-appointed counsel. (25 U.S.C. Section 1912.)
- Requiring states to keep records of Indian child placements and providing them to the Secretary of the Interior and the child's tribe. (25 U.S.C. Sections 1915 and 1951.)
- Declares the commitment of California to protecting the essential tribal relations and best interest of an Indian child by promoting practices in accordance with federal law, as specified. Requires the court, in all Indian child custody proceedings as defined by ICWA, to strive to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families, comply with ICWA, and seek to protect the best interest of the child. Requires, whenever an Indian child is removed from a foster care home or institution, guardianship, or adoptive placement for purposes of foster care, guardianship, or adoptive placement, the placement of the child to be in accordance with ICWA. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 224.)
- Permits a party to appear by telephone in all “general civil cases,” as defined and as provided. Requires Judicial Council to establish statewide, uniform fees for parties appearing by telephone, but if a party is appearing by fee waiver, prevents the court and the vendor from charging the party a fee, as provided. Among other cases, excludes juvenile cases from “general civil cases.” (Code of Civil Procedure Sections 367.5-367.6; California Rules of Court, Rule 1.6 (4).)
- Requires Judicial Council to adopt rules to allow for telephonic appearances by nonminor dependents or nonminor delinquents in specified proceedings. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 388; California Rules of Court, Rule. 5.530.)
- Provides standards for appearance in Juvenile Court by telephone, videoconference, or other authorized digital or electronic means, but does not independently confer a right to appear by telephone, videoconference, or other electronic means. (California Rules of Court, Rule 5.531.)
- Establishes requirements and processes related to the placement of an Indian child who has been removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, including establishing priorities for placement preference, as specified. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 361.31.)
- Permits a tribe to approve a home for purposes of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child and permits an Indian child that had been remove from the child’s parents in a dependency court proceeding to be placed in a tribally approved home. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 10553.12.)
- Provides that licensing rules do not apply to any facility in which only Indian children who are eligible under ICWA are placed and that is either an extended family member of the Indian child, as defined, or a foster home that is licensed, approved, or specified by the Indian child’s tribe, as provided. (Welfare and Institutions Code Section 1505 (o).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: After a long and troubling history of separation of Native American children from their families and their tribes, Congress established ICWA in 1978, which established minimum standards that state courts must follow before removing these children from their families and placing them in foster care or adoptive homes. Compliance with ICWA in child welfare proceedings in California remains uneven, creating increased costs, time-consuming appeals, and unnecessary placement delays or changes, all of which hurt children, families, tribes, and the child welfare system. This bill seeks to increase compliance with ICWA generally and, of relevance to this Committee, assist children and tribes in particular cases by requiring the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearances by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where ICWA may apply. The bill makes other clarifications regarding placement of Native American children, but the remote appearance provision is the relevant change for this Committee.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
The Indian Child Welfare Act provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted. In 2015, the California ICWA Compliance Task Force was formed to examine compliance issues and provide recommendations to improve understanding of and compliance with ICWA. The Task Force report identified ongoing concerns regarding the placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case.
This bill would increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.
Basics on the Indian Child Welfare Act. Signed into law on November 8, 1978, ICWA (25 U.S.C. 1901 et seq.) was enacted as a result of congressional hearings held in the mid-1970s, which found that Native American children were removed from their homes in large numbers. At the time, studies showed that Native American children were six to seven times as likely as non-native children to be placed in foster care or adoptive homes, and approximately 25-35 percent of all Native American children were removed from their homes and placed in foster care, adoptive homes, or boarding schools. In California, Native American children were more than eight times as likely as non-native children to be placed in adoptive homes, over 90 percent of California Native American children subject to adoption were placed in non-native homes. One in every 124 Indian children in California was in a foster home, compared to a rate of one in 367 for non-native children. In order to ensure the preservation of Native American families, tribes, and tribal cultures, Congress passed ICWA as civil rights legislation to protect the interests of Native American children and families involved with the child welfare system. In June, 2016, the Bureau of Indian Affairs promulgated new regulations, effective December 12, 2016, updating requirements that courts and child welfare agencies must meet to comply with ICWA.
California codified many of the provisions of ICWA with the passage of SB 678 (Ducheny), Chap. 838, Stats. 2006, and declared that Native American children’s best interests are served by protecting and encouraging connection to their tribal community. That legislation built upon ICWA’s foundation and included additional protections. Last year, the Legislature passed AB 3176 (Waldron), Chap. 833, Stats. 2018, to bring California into compliance with the newest federal regulations.
According to data provided by the Department of Social Services last year, 364 of the nearly 30,000 children who entered the child welfare system in 2016 were Native American, roughly 12 in every 1,000 children. As of October 1, 2017, only 36 percent of Native American children in the child welfare system were placed with relatives, while 43 percent were placed with non-relatives who were not Native American.
California ICWA Compliance Task Force. In 2015, The California Attorney General’s newly created Bureau of Children’s Justice helped create the California ICWA Compliance Task Force (Task Force), to help increase compliance with ICWA in the dependency system. The Task Force is an independent, tribal-led entity. The Task Force, in its report to the Attorney General, noted key areas where California’s implementation of ICWA was significantly flawed, resulting in negative impacts on tribes and tribal families across the state: “[L]ack of funding which created an unfunded mandate of ICWA compliance for underresourced tribes, lack of pre-removal remedial services, lack of robust active reunification efforts, failure to complete diligent inquiry and notice, resistance to tribal court jurisdiction, barriers to tribal participation in court processes, lack of competency within court systems, and deviation from or violation of placement preferences.” (California ICWA Compliance Task Force, Report to the California Attorney General’s Bureau of Children’s Justice, p. iv (2017).)
Of particular relevance to this bill, the Task Force raised concern about a tribe’s access to their children’s dependency proceedings:
A separate but related issue is allowing tribal representatives to participate and appear telephonically. Not all dependency cases scheduled are resolved when calendared, and for tribes that are remote, out of state or have travel difficulties, the cost to participate in person is prohibitive—especially if a case is continued. CRC 3.670 implements CCP [Section] 367.5 and promotes remote access to courts in all civil cases, including dependency cases. The rule sets up a fee structure that is imposed, largely by a single contract provider, but does not make any special accommodations for tribes in ICWA cases. One recommendation for improving access to courts and participation in routine and uncontested hearings would be for the courts to specifically waive fees for tribal representatives in dependency/ICWA cases. This serves multiple purposes, including demonstrating active efforts by the agency, but also eliminating the disenfranchisement of remote and resource-poor tribes. Some counties have implemented this on a local basis, and a few tribal representatives noted such fee waivers as helpful to their participation in their comments to the Task Force. Improving remote, telephonic and/or Skype access would be a substantial step forward. (Id., at p. 44.)
To address this concern, the Task Force recommends that, among other things, courts should “waive fees for tribal representatives appearing remotely in ICWA/dependency cases to improve participation in routine and uncontested hearings.” (Id., at p. 45.)
This bill seeks to implement some recommendations of the California ICWA Compliance Task Force. To encourage and facilitate greater tribal participation in child welfare proceedings involving a tribe’s children, this bill requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where ICWA may apply. Most importantly, this bill prohibits charging fees for telephonic or other computerized remote access for these court appearances, similar to the treatment of parties with fee waivers (Code of Civil Procedure Section 367), thus making it more likely that tribes with few resources will be able to participate in these court proceedings. It is hoped that allowing tribes to participate remotely will encourage more tribes to participate in dependency hearings involving their children, which should improve ICWA compliance and the outcomes for children.
The Juvenile Court Judges of California best explain the need for this provision of the bill:
One of the significant deficiencies in these legal proceedings has been the failure of the tribes to be present at juvenile court proceedings. The voice of the tribe is not often heard in these proceedings. The reason is that many of the tribes are located hundreds (or thousands) of miles from the juvenile court where the case is being heard. The result is that the interests of the tribe are not presented or argued forcefully, and the judge is denied information that might make their decision more accurate and compliant with the ICWA. . . .
With additional input, the court will be able to make better decisions on behalf of the Indian child and family. . . .
Our juvenile court judges have not had the benefit of counsel speaking on behalf of the tribe. We believe we will be better judges when we can use technology to hear from the tribal representative.
Related Legislation: AB 685 (Reyes and Ramos) requires the State Bar, subject to funding in the State Budget, to administer grants to qualified nonprofit legal services organizations in order to provide Indian tribes with legal services related to ICWA and requires the court of appeals to appoint counsel for the child’s tribe in ICWA case. AB 685 is scheduled to be heard in this Committee on the same day as this bill.
Prior Legislation: AB 3076 (Reyes), 2018, would have created, if funded, a program to support qualified legal services projects providing legal services to Indian tribes on child welfare matters under the ICWA. AB 3076 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 3176 (Waldron), Chap. 833, Stats. 2018, updated California’s ICWA statutes with new regulations from the Bureau of Indian Affairs.
SB 678 (Ducheny), Chap. 838, Stats. 2006, revised portions of state codes that address Indian child custody proceedings by codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for State Courts, and California Rules of Court.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Tribal Families Coalition (sponsor)
Alliance for Children's Rights
Barona Band of Mission Indians
California Judges Association
California Tribal Business Alliance
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
National Center for Youth Law
Picayune Rancheria of the Chukchansi Indians
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Eloise Gómez Reyes, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 686 (
Author:Waldron) – As Introduced Ver:February 15, 2019
SUBJECT: Indian children
SUMMARY: Authorizes an Indian child’s tribe or tribal organization to be eligible for adoption assistance funds under the Private Adoption Assistance Reimbursement Program (PAARP) as compensation for costs related to the placement of Indian children where the Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA) applies, acknowledges authority of an Indian child’s tribe to conduct a child-specific placement approval for an Indian child and exempts the tribe from resource family standards, and requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules of court allowing for an Indian child’s tribe to participate remotely in proceedings. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Judicial Council, by July 1, 2021, to adopt rules of court to allow for fee-free telephonic or other remote appearance options by an Indian child’s tribe in proceedings where the federal Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 may apply.
- Prohibits provisions of current law governing the PAARP from being construed as preventing adoption assistance funds from being used to compensate an Indian child’s tribe or tribal organization for the placement of Indian children where ICWA applies to their juvenile dependency case.
- Prohibits an Indian tribe or tribal organization from being subject to state licensing requirements in order to be eligible for compensation under PAARP.
- States that, in provisions of current law pertaining to child-specific resource family approval, if the child is an Indian child, and the Indian child’s tribe so chooses, the tribe shall conduct the placement approval, as specified.
- Prohibits resource family standards from applying to an Indian child’s tribe in cases where the tribe conducts a child-specific approval for an Indian child.
- Requires, in instances where an Indian child’s tribe is not conducting a home evaluation for a child-specific approval for that child, the approval to be conducted for the specific Indian child and in accordance with specified provisions of state law pertaining to the placement of Indian children and with ICWA, applying the standards of the Indian community.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- States that the purpose of foster care law is to provide maximum safety and protection for children who are currently being physically, sexually, or emotionally abused, neglected, or exploited, and to ensure the safety, protection, and physical and emotional well-being of children who are at risk of harm. (Welfare and Institutions Code [WIC] Section 300.2)
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to, whenever possible, preserve and strengthen a child's family ties and, when a child must be removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, to give preferential consideration to placement with relatives. States the intent of the Legislature to reaffirm its commitment to children who are in out-of-home placement to live in the least restrictive family setting and as close to the child's family as possible, as specified. Further states the intent of the Legislature that all children live with a committed, permanent, nurturing family and states that services and supports should be tailored to meet the specific needs of the individual child and family being served, as specified. (WIC 16000)
- Establishes ICWA, which provides guidance to states regarding the jurisdictional requirements, proceedings of tribal courts, and the custody proceedings involving the removal of Indian children from the custody of their parents. (25 United States Code Section 1901 et seq.)
- Declares the commitment of California to protecting the essential tribal relations and best interest of an Indian child by promoting practices in accordance with federal law, as specified. (WIC 224(a))
- Requires the court, in all Indian child custody proceedings as defined by ICWA, to strive to promote the stability and security of Indian tribes and families, comply with ICWA, and seek to protect the best interest of the child and further, requires, whenever an Indian child is removed from a foster care home or institution, guardianship, or adoptive placement for purposes of foster care, guardianship, or adoptive placement, the placement of the child to be in accordance with ICWA. (WIC 224(b))
- Requires ICWA to apply to any proceedings regarding an unmarried minor who is either the member of an Indian tribe or who is eligible for membership in an Indian tribe and a biological child of a member or citizen of an Indian tribe, as specified. (WIC 224(c))
- Defines a number of terms related to Indian child welfare and delineates processes for designating an Indian child's tribe for purposes of an Indian child custody proceeding, as specified. (WIC 224.1)
- Stipulates processes and requirements regarding the determination of a child's status as an Indian child, as specified. (WIC 224.2)
- Establishes requirements and processes related to the placement of an Indian child who has been removed from the physical custody of his or her parents, including establishing priorities for placement preference, as specified. (WIC 361.31)
- Establishes in state law the authority for a federally recognized tribe to approve a home for the purpose of foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child per ICWA, and provides for processes related to this approval. (WIC 10553.12)
- Establishes the PAARP to provide compensation to licensed private adoption agencies for costs of placing for adoption children or nonminor dependents who are eligible for Adoption Assistance Program benefits, as specified. (WIC 16122)
- Defines a “resource family” to mean an individual or family that has successfully met both the home environment assessment and the permanency assessment criteria, as specified, necessary for providing care for a child placed by a public or private child placement agency by court order, or voluntarily placed by a parent or legal guardian. (Health and Safety Code [HSC] Section 1517, WIC 16519.5 (c)(1))
- Define “resource family approval” to mean that the applicant or resource family successfully meets the home environment assessment and permanency assessment standards, as specified. (HSC 1517)
- Requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to implement the resource family approval process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. (WIC 16519.5 (a))
- Stipulates that a resource family shall be considered eligible to provide foster care for children in out-of-home placement and shall be considered approved for adoption and guardianship, and authorizes a county to approve a resource family to care for a specific child, as specified. (WIC 16519.5 (c)(4))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Child Welfare Services: In California during calendar year 2017, almost 500,000 children had allegations of child abuse or neglect made regarding them. Of these children, approximately 71,000 (14%) had allegations that were substantiated, and 28,000 (40% of children with substantiations) were removed from their homes and entered foster care via the state’s Child Welfare Services (CWS) system. (However, children who have reports of abuse or neglect substantiated but are not removed from the home may also receive, along with their families, family maintenance services; these services may in some instances be ordered by the court and, in others, based upon a voluntary agreement with the parent where the courts is not involved. Family maintenance services typically involve a social worker working with a family in the home to prevent and remedy abuse and neglect, and can include a variety of services such as counseling, parent education, respite care, substance use disorder treatment, domestic violence intervention, and victim services.)
The CWS system serves to protect children from abuse and neglect, and to provide for their health and safety. When a county juvenile court finds that a youth is subject to or at substantial risk of maltreatment warranting their removal from the home, the court holds legal jurisdiction over the youth. A youth is served by the CWS system through the appointment of a social worker, and many opportunities exist during which the custody of the youth, or their placement outside of the home, must be evaluated, reviewed and determined by the judicial system, in consultation with the youth's social worker, to help provide the best possible services to the youth. When a youth has been removed from the home, the goal of the CWS system is, often, to reunify them with their parents or guardians, whenever appropriate. When a youth’s reunification with their family is not appropriate, the second highest placement priority of the CWS system is to place youth with other relatives or nonrelative extended family members. Youth may also be placed in foster homes – referred to as “resource family” homes – overseen by either the county or a foster family agency. Specialized placement and service options also exist for youth with significant behavioral health and other needs; these placements and related services can include specially trained intensive services foster care resource families, and intensive, temporary placement in short-term residential therapeutic programs, which are replacing group homes under significant changes adopted in recent years per the state’s Continuum of Care Reform. As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children in California’s child welfare system.
Indian Child Welfare Act (ICWA): Historically, Indian children have been removed from their homes at significantly high rates, with as high as 25% to 35% of Indian children being taken from the custody of their families, often to be placed as foster youth in non-Indian homes. In the 1970s, a Congressional investigation lasting multiple years found that the four main factors that contributed to removal of children and unnecessary termination of parental rights were:
- State child welfare standards for assessing families that lack cultural competence;
- Due-process violations against Indian children and their parents that existed on a system-wide basis;
- Economic incentives that favored the removal of Indian children from their families and communities; and,
- Social conditions existing in Indian country.
Additionally, this Congressional investigation determined that states, when carrying out child custody proceedings, frequently neglected to recognize the tribal relations of Indian people and their cultural and social standards.
ICWA was adopted at the federal level to address a number of the issues related to the custody of Indian children and, ultimately, to ensure the preservation of Native American families, tribes, and tribal cultures. ICWA set minimum standards for state courts to meet any time an Indian child is removed from their family or custodial home and placed in foster care or adoptive homes. States were authorized to establish higher standard above the federal baseline. California’s state-level implementation of ICWA was adopted with the passage of SB 678 (Ducheny), Chapter 838, Statutes of 2006. SB 678 established Cal-ICWA, revising and recasting those portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings as it codified into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) Guidelines for State Courts, and state Rules of Court. As of October 1, 2018, there were 59,487 children and youth in the state’s child welfare services system; 1,216 were ICWA-eligible. Of those 1,216 children and youth, 466 were placed with relatives.
Continuum of Care Reform: SB 1013 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee), Chapter 35, Statutes of 2012, was legislation that realigned child welfare services to counties, adopted a number of changes and directed CDSS to convene a working group to examine the use of group homes in California. As a result of the work of that workgroup, CDSS submitted a report to the Legislature in January 2015 containing a number of recommendations aimed at reforming the foster care system and reducing California's reliance on group home settings as acceptable placements for foster youth. Initially dubbed "Congregate Care Reform," these efforts were later renamed "Continuum of Care Reform" (CCR) in recognition of the need to strengthen the state's entire system of home-based care and supports while decreasing reliance on group homes. AB 403 (Stone), Chapter 773, Statutes of 2015, and subsequent clean-up language, adopted many of the CCR report recommendations. These adopted recommendations included adopting a sunset for existing licensure, rate-setting, and other provisions for group homes and providing for a new licensure category of Short-Term Residential Therapeutic Programs (STRTPs) to offer temporary housing and intensive up-front services for youth prior to placing them with a family. They also included the creation of and reliance upon child and family teams to be involved in child-centered decision-making for each youth in the child welfare services system, and a child-centered approval process for all families seeking to care for a foster youth, regardless of whether or not the youth is related to the family, known as “resource family approval.”
Resource Family Approval: Per statute, CDSS is required to implement the resource family approval process as a unified, family friendly, and child-centered process to replace the existing multiple processes for licensing foster family homes, certifying foster homes by licensed foster family agencies, approving relatives and nonrelative extended family members as foster care providers, and approving guardians and adoptive families. Initially implemented in select counties, resource family approval was adopted on a statewide basis through CCR legislation. Because it includes elements of adoption and guardianship processes, the resource family process can create opportunities for more direct routes to permanency for foster youth. The resource family approval process includes a psychosocial assessment, home environment check, and training for all resource families, including relatives, in order to prepare families to better meet the needs of vulnerable children in the foster care system.
Tribally approved homes: Pursuant to ICWA, a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal agency is permitted to approve a home for the foster or adoptive placement of an Indian child (although it is not required to do so). These tribally approved homes are not subject to state licensing approval standards, with the exception of requirements related to criminal background checks. Tribes and tribal agencies have the independent authority to approve homes using their own socially and culturally appropriate standards. A forthcoming all-county letter from CDSS, currently in draft form, states that tribally approved homes are not subject to California’s resource family approval requirements.
Need for this bill: According to the author, “The Indian Child Welfare Act provides important rights and protections to Indian families. Progress has been made, but major concerns persist regarding ICWA compliance and how ICWA proceedings are conducted. In 2015, the California ICWA Compliance Task Force was formed to examine compliance issues and provide recommendations to improve understanding of and compliance with ICWA. The Task Force report identified ongoing concerns regarding the placement of Indian children, including an underutilization of Tribal Customary Adoption. It also documented the barriers to tribal participation in these cases due to geographic distance between the location of the tribe and the location of the state court case. This bill would increase ICWA compliance by clarifying placement approval standards for Indian children and funding for home approvals. It would also authorize the use of telephonic or other remote access by an Indian child’s tribe to ensure full participation by Indian tribes in ICWA proceedings.”
Staff comments and recommended amendments: This bill seeks to better support the tribal customary adoption process by enabling an Indian child’s tribe or tribal organization to be eligible for adoption assistance funds under PAARP as compensation for costs related to the placement of Indian children where ICWA applies. However, making tribes and tribal organizations eligible for assistance allocated for private adoption purposes is problematic. Instead, should this bill move forward, committee staff encourages the author to pursue legislative avenues that would enable tribes and tribal organizations to draw down federal funds to better support the tribal customary adoption process. Committee staff recommends the following amendment:
- Delete lines 28 through 40 on page 5, and lines 1 through 32 on page 6, of the bill.
Additionally, this bill seeks to prohibit resource family standards from applying to an Indian child’s tribe in cases where the tribe conducts a child-specific tribal home approval for an Indian child. Per the forthcoming all-county letter from CDSS, this is already current interpretation of law. In order to clarify this understanding in statute, committee staff recommends the following amendments:
- Delete lines 21 through 31 on page 9 of the bill.
- Add new subdivision (f) to Section 10553.12 of Welfare and Institutions Code:
(f) Pursuant to subdivision (o) of Section 1505 of Health and Safety Code, tribal home approvals conducted in compliance with this section shall not be subject to resource family approval requirements.
Lastly, in order to better realize this bill’s goal of ensuring, in instances where an Indian child’s placement involves resource family approval (versus placement in a tribally approved home), that prevailing social and cultural standards are heeded, committee staff recommends the following amendment:
- After line 20 on page 9 of the bill, insert the following:
(i) In the case of an Indian child where the Tribe is not exercising its right to approve a home, resource family approval shall apply the prevailing social and cultural standards of the Indian Community as required by Section 361.31(f) and the federal Indian Child Welfare Act of 1978 (25 U.S.C. Sec. 1901 et seq.). The department shall, through all-county letters or other similar instruction, provide guidance to counties regarding consistent implementation of this clause
Double referral: This bill will be referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee should it pass out of this committee.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 685 (Reyes) of 2019 requires the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters, requires topics of ICWA and cultural competency related to Indian children in out-of-home care be included in certain training for legal counsel, and requires the court of appeal to appoint counsel for a child’s Indian tribe. AB 685 is scheduled to be heard in the Assembly Human Services Committee on March 26, 2019.
AB 3047 (Daly), Chapter 399, Statutes of 2018, provided a fee waiver for out-of-state attorneys appearing pro hac vice in specified ICWA matters.
AB 3076 (Reyes) of 2018 would have required the State Bar of California, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to administer grants to qualified legal services projects and support centers in order to provide legal services to Indian tribes in child welfare matters and would have required the grants to be provided only to qualified legal services projects and support centers that have experience handling child welfare matters under the federal ICWA or providing legal services to Indian tribes. AB 3076 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 3176 (Waldron), Chapter 833, Statutes of 2018, made a number of changes to state law regarding the removal of Indian children from their families and their out-of-home placement in order to conform to changes to federal regulations governing ICWA.
SB 678 (Ducheny), Chapter 838, Statutes of 2006, revised and recast the portions of state code that address Indian child custody proceedings by codifying into state law various provisions of ICWA, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Guidelines for State Courts, and state Rules of Court.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alliance for Children’s Rights (Sponsor)
Juvenile Court Judges of California
California Nations Indian Gaming Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Daphne Hunt / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):