AB 705: Mobilehome parks: change of use.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-19
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 705 (
Author:Mark Stone) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
SUBJECT: Mobilehome parks: change of use
SUMMARY: Mandates relocation and specifies requirements for residents of mobilehome or floating home parks proposing to close. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes requirements that must be fulfilled prior to closure, cessation of land use, or filing of a tentative or parcel map for a subdivision to be created from the conversion of a mobilehome park to another use, as follows:
- The person or entity proposing the change must file a report on the social and economic impact of the change. This report must include a replacement and relocation plan that includes a binding commitment to provide adequate replacement housing in mobilehome parks, and the costs of doing so; and,
- Requires the person proposing the change to provide a copy of the report to each resident of the mobilehome at least 60 days before the hearing, if any, on the impact report by the advisory agency or legislative body.
- Requires that the legislative body, or its delegated advisory agency, must undertake the following with regards to this report:
- Review the report;
- Not disapprove or conditionally approve the report unless its replacement and relocation plan demonstrates that, with the mitigation assistance that it provides or that can be imposed as conditions of approval, it will enable each displaced resident to obtain and relocate into adequate housing in a mobilehome park; and,
- Not disapprove the report if the application for the proposed change is not accompanied concurrently by an application for a new use of the park, unless the applicant demonstrates with evidence that the mobilehome park cannot continue to be operated as its current use, while earning a reasonable return on their investment, until the applicant is able to determine a new use and apply for its necessary local permits.
- Defines “adequate housing” to mean an available mobilehome, or an available space in a mobilehome park, if it is determined that the displaced resident’s current mobilehome can be moved into it, that meets all of the following criteria:
- The mobilehome is decent, safe, and sanitary and located in a mobilehome park that is decent, safe, and sanitary;
- The mobilehome is adequate in size to accommodate the occupant;
- The mobilehome is located in a mobilehome park in which the displaced resident has the financial ability to pay the rents and charges of the park, in that their monthly housing costs do not exceed 33% of the displaced resident’s average monthly income;
- The mobilehome is comparable to the displaced resident’s current or prior mobilehome with respect to the number of rooms, habitable space, and type and quality of construction, in that the principal features of the prior or current mobilehome or floating home are present, but not there is strict adherence to a detailed, feature-by-feature comparison, and the mobilehome is not required to possess every feature of the displaced mobilehome;
- The mobilehome is located in an area not subject to unreasonable adverse environmental conditions; and,
- The mobilehome is in a location generally not less desirable than the location of the displaced mobilehome park resident’s current mobilehome with respect to public utilities, facilities, services, and the displaced resident’s place of employment.
- Requires the amount of relocation assistance to obtain adequate housing in a mobilehome park as follows:
- If compliance requires a comparable mobilehome to the current one, the amount of that assistance must be equal to the value of the current mobilehome; and,
- If compliance requires a more valuable mobilehome than the current one, the amount of that assistance must be equal to the actual reasonable costs of obtaining that mobilehome.
- Applies, in the instance of filing of a tentative or parcel map subdivision related to the conversion of a floating home marina, the requirements above apply to floating homes and floating marinas.
- Establishes that a mobilehome tenancy may be terminated by the management for a change of use of the mobilehome park if the following occur:
- The management gives the homeowners at least 60 days written notice that the management will be appearing before a local governmental board, commission, or body to request permits for a change of use of the mobilehome park;
- The management has given the homeowners six months or more written notice of termination of tenancy after all permits that are required for the intended new use of the park have been approved by the local governmental board, commission, or body;
- The applicant has complied with all other applicable state laws, including the binding relocation plan discussed above; and,
- A finding has been made by the local government that the approval of the closure of the park and of its conversion into its intended new use will not result in or materially contribute to a shortage of housing opportunities and choices within the local jurisdiction for low- and moderate-income households.
- Establishes that, for conversions, closures, and cessations of mobilehome parks, that the above are the minimum standards for local regulation, and that local agency may enact more stringent measures.
- Provides that no reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIII B of the California Constitution.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates, pursuant to the MRL, the rights, responsibilities, obligations, and relationships between mobilehome park management and park residents. (Civil Code Section 798, et seq.) (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 798) of Title 2 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Civil Code)
- Establishes that a change of use of a mobilehome park may result in the termination of the tenancy for mobilehome owners only if:
- The management gives the homeowners at least 15 days’ written notice that the management will be appearing before a local governmental board, commission, or body to request permits for a change of use of the mobilehome park; and,
- After all required permits requesting a change of use have been approved by the local governmental board, commission, or body, the management has given the homeowners six months’ or more written notice of termination of tenancy. If the change of use requires no local governmental permits, then notice must be given 12 months or more prior to the management’s determination that a change of use will occur. The management in the notice must disclose and describe in detail the nature of the change of use.
(Civil Code Section 798.56 of the Civil Code)
- Establishes requirements for approval of the closure of a mobilehome park (except pursuant to the Subdivision Map Act) by a local agency, including that:
- Prior to the closure, the person or entity proposing the change in use must file a report on the impact of the conversion, closure, or cessation of use upon the displaced residents of the mobilehome park to be converted or closed. In determining the impact of the conversion, closure, or cessation of use on displaced mobilehome park residents, the report shall address the availability of adequate replacement housing in mobilehome parks and relocation costs;
- The person proposing the change in use shall provide a copy of the report to a resident of each mobilehome in the mobilehome park at least 15 days prior to the hearing, if any, on the impact report by the advisory agency, or if there is no advisory agency, by the legislative body.
- When the impact report is filed prior to the closure or cessation of use, the person or entity filing the report or park resident may request, and must have a right to, a hearing before the legislative body on the sufficiency of the report.
- The legislative body, or its delegated advisory agency, must review the report, prior to any change of use, and may require, as a condition of the change, the person or entity to take steps to mitigate any adverse impact of the conversion, closure, or cessation of use on the ability of displaced mobilehome park residents to find adequate housing in a mobilehome park. The steps required to be taken to mitigate must not exceed the reasonable costs of relocation.
(Government Code Section 65863.7)
- Establishes the same requirements for approval of the closure of a mobilehome park by a local agency as specified above, but for mobilehome closures pursuant to the Subdivision Map Act. These rules also apply to closure of floating home marinas. Additionally, establishes that this section establishes a minimum standard for local regulation of conversions of mobilehome parks and floating home marinas into other uses, and does not prevent a local agency from enacting more stringent measures (Government Code Section 66427.4).
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Purpose of the Bill: According to the author, “California is currently experience a housing crisis, particularly felt in its lack of low-income homeownership opportunities. As the Legislature encourages local jurisdictions to preserve and create affordable housing, locals often rely on mobilehome parks to provide a substantial amount of this housing. However, as housing prices increase, mobilehome parks are being converted to high-end developments at an alarming rate. AB 705 expands protections for homeowners at risk for park closure or conversion by extending notice timelines and specifies detailed mitigation assistance.”
Background: Mobilehomes are not truly mobile, in that it is often cost prohibitive (up to $20,000) to relocate them. A mobilehome owner whose home is located in a mobilehome park does not own the land the unit sits on, and he or she must pay rent and fees for the land and any community spaces. As such, mobilehomes are considered chattel property and not real property. Purchasing a mobilehomes is often much less expensive than other forms of housing. As such, mobilehomes are an important source of housing statewide – particularly, affordable homeownership housing. However, like other forms of chattel property (like cars), they generally decrease in value over time.
There are approximately 700,000 Californians living in about 400,000 mobilehomes dispersed over 4,100 mobilehome parks. Information collected by the California Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) shows that at least 565 mobile home and recreational vehicle parks had been converted to another use or closed in California between 3/22/1998 and 3/22/2019, causing the loss of at least approximately 17,000 spaces and the homes that were on them. There are also nearly 400 parks whose permits have expired. Assuming some of them are closed, the actual number of lost spaces will be somewhat greater. In terms of adding spaces, while some parks have expanded and/or reconfigured the number of units, there have been no new mobilehome parks created in the past 20 years.
The Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL) extensively regulates the relationship between landlords and homeowners who occupy a mobilehome park. A limited number of provisions also apply to residents who rent, as opposed to own, their mobilehome. Provisions within the MRL cover many issues including but not limited to the following: 1) the rental and lease contract terms and specific conditions of receipt and delivery of written leases, park rules and regulations, and other mandatory notices; 2) mandatory notice and amendment procedures for mobilehome park rules and regulations; 3) mandatory notice of fees and charges, and increases or changes in them; and 4) specified conditions governing mobilehome park evictions.
Procedure for Closure of Mobilehome Parks: Prior to the closure of a mobilehome park, the park owner must file a closure impact report (CIR) to the local jurisdiction on the impact of the closure upon the displaced residents, including the availability of adequate replacement housing in mobilehome parks and relocation costs. The local jurisdiction may require, as a condition of the park closure, the park owner to take steps to mitigate any adverse impact of the conversion, closure, or cessation of use on the ability of displaced mobilehome park residents to find adequate housing in a mobilehome park. The steps required to be taken to mitigate the displacement must not exceed the reasonable costs of relocation. The park owner is required to give 15 days written notice to homeowners that a hearing regarding a park closure is occurring, along with a copy of the CIR. After a local jurisdiction approves the closure of the park, the park owner can give residents a notice of termination of tenancy, which must be no less than six months. If no permits are required, then the notice of termination of tenancy must be no less than 12 months before closure.
Often local governments will have a mobilehome park conversion ordinance which parallels the requirements of state law and fills in the details of the relocation assistance that may be required by the city, whether it is actual relocation of the mobilehome or a buy-out of the home, and how the mobilehome is to be valued for these purposes. If the park is to be subdivided into individual parcels (where a conventional subdivision will replace the park) and where a tentative or final map is required, the city may impose even more stringent relocation requirements. Local officials are the final arbiters of any relocation assistance to which displaced mobilehome owners may be entitled.
This bill would make myriad changes to the requirements regarding closure of mobilehome parks. According to the author, these changes are intended to generally accomplish three things: 1) ensure that the closure of a mobilehome park does not reduce housing opportunity for lower income residents in the local jurisdiction, 2) ensure, in the case of park closure, proper relocation of the homeowners, and 3) eliminate “sham” closures where the park owner closes the park without simultaneously filing an application for a replacement use, thereby enabling them to avoid providing relocation assistance to existing mobilehome owners.
Regarding the housing opportunities for lower income households in a local jurisdiction, the bill
requires, before termination of tenancy for mobilehome owners, that a local jurisdiction must make a finding that the approval of the closure of the park and of its conversion into its intended new use “will not result in or materially contribute to a shortage of housing opportunities and choices within the local jurisdiction for low- and moderate-income households.” According to the bill’s sponsor, the Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League (GSMOL), “current law (California’s Housing Elements Law and related statutes) already require local governments to enact and enforce policies to preserve the low-income affordable housing stock contained in manufactured home parks and to reject any proposed manufactured home park conversion which would be inconsistent with those policies. However those laws are confusing and often not enforced. For example in a CRLA Foundation study, which examined the specifics of 12 MHP conversion, 11 of them did not perform that required evaluation.”
Regarding relocation of displaced mobilehome homeowners, the bill makes a series of changes, as outlined below. According to GSMOL, the bill does this by including “the clearer requirement of what constitutes adequate replacement housing under California’s Uniform Relocation Act, modified slightly to fit the unique circumstances of manufactured home park conversion.” In doing so, “AB 705 clarifies that in order to meet Government Code Sections 65863.7’s and 66127.4’s current requirement, that the benefits must enable the displaced homeowners to obtain adequate housing in other manufactured home parks that, when both spaces to receive those homes are not available and their in-place values are insufficient, then the displaced homeowners must be provided with the actual cost of purchasing the actually available manufactured homes in the other parks. Several local MHP conversion ordinances, in areas with high-priced housing markets, as well as the California Uniform Relocation Act, already recognize this circumstance and require these benefits when it is found to exist. However, many conversions have not been required to meet this standard because of the confusion in section 65863.7(e) that, although it mandates that the benefits must enable homeowners to obtain adequate housing in other mobile home parks, it then states that the benefit payment shall not exceed the cost of relocation. Based on that limitation, in 10 out of the 11 conversions reviewed in a CRLA Foundation study of MHP park, did not provide for this benefit, even though their CIRs concluded that spaces were not available for the displaced manufactured homes.” To meet the intended goal of clarifying that URL applies to mobilehome parks, the bill:
- Expands the CIR to include a social and economic impact of the closure;
- Requires the CIR to include a “replacement and relocation plan.” This plan would need to adequately mitigate the impact upon the displaced residents, including a binding commitment to provide “adequate replacement housing,” and the cost of doing so;
- Defines “adequate replacement housing” as a mobilehome, or space if the displaced mobilehome is truly mobile, that is:
- Decent, safe, and sanitary and located in a mobilehome park that is decent, safe, and sanitary:
- Adequate in size to accommodate the occupants;
- Located in a mobilehome park in which the displaced resident has the financial ability to pay the rents and charges of the park, in that housing doesn’t exceed 33 percent of their income;
- Comparable to the displaced resident’s current or prior mobilehome with respect to the number of rooms, habitable space, and type and quality of construction;
- Located in an area not subject to unreasonable adverse environmental conditions; and,
- In a location generally not less desirable than the location of the displaced mobilehome park resident’s current mobilehome with respect to public utilities, facilities, services, and the displaced resident’s place of employment; and,
- Allows local jurisdictions to have stricter requirements than these.
To eliminate “sham” closures where the park owner closes the park without filing an application simultaneously for a replacement use, the bill would:
- Add requirements for proof of lack of financial feasibility for property owners seeking to close the park without proposing an intended use;
- Align the requirements for closures that occur through cessation of use, conversion to other uses that do not require subdivision of the land, and conversions to other uses that do require subdivisions of the land;
- Amend the termination requirement so that the six month notice of termination occurs after permits are issued for the intended new use of the park, instead of its closure; and,
- Extend the required notice of an upcoming hearing regarding of a park change of use, along with a copy of the CIR, from 15 days to 60 days.
Arguments in Support: According to GSMOL, “Current state law was intended to protect affordable housing and to ensure that park owners provide homeowners sufficient financial assistance to obtain a manufactured home in another park if the park closed or was converted. However, the enforcement mechanisms are too ambiguous and have not worked. AB 705 clarifies and strengthens existing law related to when parks containing low- and moderate-income affordable housing are converted to a different use and if that new use causes the unmitigated loss of that housing. If a park is closed, AB 705 ensures homeowners will receive adequate compensation to enable homeowners to relocate into another manufactured home park in the area, which will be affordable to homeowners. AB 705 also clarifies that local governments have the power to reject any conversion to a new use that will result in the unmitigated loss of low- and moderate-income affordable housing.”
Arguments in opposition: According to the Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association (WMA), “AB 705’s proposed changes hurt stakeholders and prevent future closures. AB 705 prevents park closures by requiring simultaneous relocation to area mobilehome parks, ignoring the will of residents and the rights of owners. AB 705 usurps local governments’ consideration of adequate relocation assistance packages to park residents by requiring tandem approval of park closures and future development. AB 705 unconstitutionally forces park owners to remain in business even when they are operating at a loss or are bankrupt. In practice, local governments always require generous mitigation assistance to be provided to mobilehome park households prior to approval of a park closure. Through the help of a relocation specialist, residents can always be successfully relocated.”
Staff Comments: The bill is intended to help preserve the stock of affordable housing found in mobilehome parks, and ensure that if parks close, displaced residents are relocated to adequate housing. Individually, most of the proposed changes would help achieve these intentions. However, cumulatively these changes would make closing parks via the permitting process quite challenging. The unintended consequence of this strategy is that park owners seeking to close their business would therefore be incentivized to undertake strategies that would result in outcomes counter to the intent of this bill, such as substantially increasing rents, or alternatively, abandoning the park.
One particular challenge is that both existing and proposed law require the replacement housing be in another mobilehome park. The rationale behind this requirement is to ensure that mobilehome owners have like housing, in terms of type as well as ownership. However, mobilehomes represent less than three percent of the housing stock in California, and they are unevenly dispersed throughout the state. Requiring replacement housing to be in a mobilehome park and that it meet the bill’s criteria, such that it is not in a less desirable location relative to the homeowner’s place of employment, could be virtually impossible in areas with limited mobilehome parks and/or vacancies at the park. As such, the City may wish to consider creating other mechanisms to meet these replacement requirements. One mechanism would that, if the park owner demonstrates that they are unable to comply with the requirement to find replacement housing in a mobilehome park without eliminating all reasonable economic use of the property then relocation to other kinds of housing may be allowed. The other would be specifying that the provision of state law do not prohibit a park owner and a displaced mobile home owner from agreeing on other alternate, mutually satisfactory, relocation assistance.
Finally, under the MRL, there is a 90-day noticing requirement for increases in rent. Noticing of a proposed park closure seems like an equivalently or more important notice for mobilehome owners to receive. As such, the Committee may wish to consider extending the required notice of an upcoming hearing regarding a park closure, along with providing a copy of the CIR, to 90 days.
Committee Amendments: To address the issues raised above, the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Creating a mechanisms by which, if the park owner demonstrates that they are unable to comply with the requirement to find replacement housing in a mobilehome park without eliminating all reasonable economic use of the property then relocation to other kinds of housing may be allowed;
- Specifying that the provision of state law do not prohibit a park owner and a displaced mobilehome owner from agreeing on other alternate, mutually satisfactory, relocation assistance; and,
- Extending the required notice of a upcoming hearing regarding a park closure, along with providing a copy of the CIR, to 90 days.
Related Legislation:
AB 3066 (Mark Stone), Chapter 774, Statutes of 2018: Established the Mobilehome Residency Law Protection Program, beginning July 1, 2020, within the Department of Housing and Community Development to help coordinate the resolution of complaints from homeowners relating to the Mobilehome Residency Law.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Golden State Manufactured-home Owners League (co-sponsor)
Center for Rural Legal Assistance (co-sponsor)
California Rural Assistance Foundation (co-sponsor)
California Alliance for Retired Americans
Ventura County Board of Supervisors
Individuals - 7
Opposition
California Association of Realtors
California Mobilehomes Parkowners Alliance
Cozen O’Connor
Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association
Analysis Prepared by: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):