AB 729: Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-09
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 9, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 680, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 9, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 52. Noes 23.). |
| Sep 5, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 7 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (July 3). |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and JUD. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 16, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 15, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (May 15). |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2019 | AB 729 Chu Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 4, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB729 Chu By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 729 Chu Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 729
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:July 5, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Revises the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program to, among other things, require the stewardship plan include a funding mechanism with differential assessments, require a "contingency plan" in the absence of an approved plan by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle), and increase the administrative penalties from $1,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
The Senate Amendments:
- Specify that a contingency plan should the carpet stewardship plan expire without approval of a new plan or if the plan is revoked be carried out by the department or another entity, as specified.
- Require that the funding mechanism be composted of a system of differential assessments that take into account the financial burden that a particular carpet material has on the stewardship program and the amount of postconsumer recycled content contained in a particular carpet.
- Declare the intent of the Legislature that the amount of the assessment be reduced as the program is implemented and becomes more efficient.
- Specify that if the amount of the assessment is insufficient to fund the program, the stewardship organization shall submit a plan update to increase the assessment to CalRecycle for approval, conditional approval, or disapproval.
- If the assessment generates a fund balance at the end of a program year that is greater than one year’s operating expenses, requires the organization to submit a plan to decrease the assessment.
- Remove the 5% cap on CalRecycle’s administrative costs.
- Repeal the existing carpet assessment provisions.
- Increase the penalty from $1,000 to $5,000 per day for specified violations.
- Make technical and clarifying changes.
COMMENTS:
California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Perez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
The stewardship plan is a critical part of the program; it defines a compliant program and communicates a course of action to stakeholders and the public. Stewardship organizations (or individual manufacturers that are not represented by a stewardship organization) are responsible for submitting the plans to CalRecycle for approval. Approved plans are posted on CalRecycle's website.
Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE), based in Georgia, is the carpet industry's stewardship organization. CARE has struggled with enforcement and compliance issues throughout its existence.
On September 24, 2018, CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle for approval. This plan was conditionally approved, with a requirement for CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted an addendum to the plan to address CalRecycle's recommendations. This plan was approved on February 19, 2019.
This bill provides a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE in order to preserve California's carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
According to the Author:
California has led the way with its flagship carpet recycling program. My bill from 2017, AB 1158, outlined specific targets and gave the State the authority to set future targets for carpet recycling. However, the State needs additional tools to provide a backstop in the case a plan is inadequate to meet set recycling goals. Currently, there is no mechanism to continue the program if a stewardship plan submitted by manufacturers is disapproved, AB 729 will allow for a "bridge" plan to avoid disruptions in our carpet recycling infrastructure and protect consumer fees if a plan is disapproved or revoked.
Arguments in Support:
According to the National Stewardship Action Council, "the purpose of AB 729 is very simple yet important - to ensure California feepayer money is transferred back and used to support California's carpet recycling infrastructure if the existing stewardship organization for some reason can no longer run the program."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the California Chamber of Commerce, "adding costs to carpet increases the cost of housing, and even small amounts have a detrimental effect. An excellent study recently published by NAHB (January 2019) demonstrated that a $1000 increase in the cost of the median priced home in California prices out 9787 households. That is, a $1000 increase effectively prevents 9787 households from being able to buy a home in California. While in the throws [sic] of an unprecedented housing crisis, California does not need to pass legislation that increases the cost of housing."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CalRecycle estimates approximately $120,000 annually from the Carpet Stewardship Account for an additional Environmental Scientist at CalRecycle to implement this bill. Additionally, unknown potential cost pressures, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, if CalRecycle takes over administration of the program. To the extent that differential assessments raise the assessment on carpet purchased by the state, unknown potential cost increases.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 7-2-2
YES: Friedman, Chau, Cristina Garcia, Limón, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Mark Stone
NO: Mathis, Melendez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, Eggman
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-4-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough, Eduardo Garcia
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-17-5
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Flora, Eduardo Garcia, Ramos
SENATE FLOOR: 27-11-2
YES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta, Hueso
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. / (916) 319-2092 FN: 0001831
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 729 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 729
Amended: 7/5/19 in Senate
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 7/3/19
AYES: Allen, Dahle, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-17, 5/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship
SOURCE: National Stewardship Action Council
DIGEST:
This bill revises the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program to, among other things, require the stewardship plan include a funding mechanism with differential assessments, require a “contingency plan” in the absence of an approved plan by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle), and increase the administrative penalties from $1,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
Existing law, the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program:
- Requires manufacturers of carpets sold in this state, individually or through a carpet stewardship organization, to submit a carpet stewardship plan to CalRecycle that includes specified elements relating to the recycling of postconsumer carpet (Public Resources Code (PRC) §42972).
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan and that is remitted to the organization to carry out the plan (PRC §42972(a)(7)).
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan and that is remitted to the organization to carry out the plan (PRC §42972(a)(7)).
- Requires CalRecycle, within 60 days after receiving a plan, to review and determine whether the plan complies with the law's requirements and notify the submitter of its decision. Specifies that any plan not approved by March 31, 2012, is out of compliance until determined to be complete by CalRecycle (PRC §§42973).
- Requires the stewardship organization to annually demonstrate that it has achieved continuous meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion and other specified goals to be in compliance (PRC §42975).
- Provides for the imposition of administrative civil penalties for a violation of the program (PRC §42978).
- Declares a state goal to reach a carpet recycling rate of 24% by January 1, 2020, and requires CalRecycle to establish a minimum carpet recycling rate by January 1, 2023 (PRC §42972.2).
- Requires the organization to pay CalRecycle a quarterly administrative fee, set by CalRecycle at an amount that is adequate to cover the costs of administering and enforcing the Act. Limits the amount of administrative fees paid for a calendar year to 5% of the aggregate assessments collected for the preceding calendar year (PRC §42977).
This bill:
- Requires a carpet stewardship organization to be a 501(c)(3) organization.
- Requires the funding mechanism to be composed of a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden that a particular carpet material has on the stewardship program and the amount of postconsumer recycled content contained in a particular carpet. If a certain carpet material requires a higher subsidy to incentivize use in the market place, based on market history and modeling, requires that material to have a proportionally higher assessment.
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that the amount of the assessment be reduced by the organization as the program is implemented over time and becomes more efficient.
- Requires the organization to update the plan to either increase or decrease the assessment as appropriate and to submit the updated plan to CalRecycle.
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that the amount of the assessment be reduced by the organization as the program is implemented over time and becomes more efficient.
- Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a “contingency plan” that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle through an independent entity. If a new plan has not been approved within one year, authorizes CalRecycle to make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan.
- Requires, upon the approval of a successor organization, the trustee or escrow agent to transfer funds to the new organization.
- Removes the 5% of the aggregate assessments cap on administrative fees paid to CalRecycle.
- Increases the penalty amounts for the program from $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day.
Background
- California’s carpet recycling program. California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Perez, Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010). As an EPR program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program, and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress, and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
AB 2398 established Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE), a third-party nonprofit carpet stewardship organization based in Georgia, as the sole carpet stewardship organization until April 1, 2015, and after that date, permits an organization to submit a stewardship plan to CalRecycle for approval. Currently, CARE is the only carpet stewardship organization in California.
- Enforcement actions against CARE. On March 10, 2017, CalRecycle began an enforcement proceeding against CARE for failing to achieve “continuous and meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion of postconsumer carpet subject to its stewardship plan and in meeting the other goals included in the organization’s plan.” In spite of the significant amount of money collected by CARE from California consumers, CalRecycle found that CARE did not meet these requirements in 2013, 2014, or 2015. After each finding, CalRecycle provided CARE with recommendations on adjustments to the plan that would result in meaningful improvement; however, CARE has not, yet, officially incorporated CalRecycle's suggestions in any subsequent plans, although they are looking into the possibility of implementing a system for differential assessments (see below). CalRecycle sought a total of $3.285 million in penalties: $182,500 for 2013; $1.46 million for 2014; and, $1.64 million for 2015.
Following a hearing on September 26, 2017, the Office of Administrative Hearings issued a proposed decision on February 13, 2018, that concluded that there is cause to impose a civil penalty against CARE but reduced the total penalties to $1,003,750. It is noted that the Court also concluded that a civil penalty in the amount of $1,500/day is more appropriate to serve as a deterrent effect going forward for the 2015 reporting period. CalRecycle had until May 23, 2018, to accept, reject, or modify the decision. On April 26, 2018, CalRecyle accepted the proposed decision, with modifications which included reducing the penalty amount to be consistent with penalties specified in statute.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has led the way with its flagship carpet recycling program. My bill from 2017, AB 1158, outlined specific targets and gave the State the authority to set future targets for carpet recycling. However, the State needs additional tools to provide a backstop in the case a plan is inadequate to meet set recycling goals. Currently, there is no mechanism to continue the program if a stewardship plan submitted by manufacturers is disapproved, AB 729 will allow for a “bridge” plan to avoid disruptions in our carpet recycling infrastructure and protect consumer fees if a plan is disapproved or revoked.”
- The show must go on. This bill is intended to address a shortcoming that has been identified in the state’s product stewardship programs – what happens to the fee money collected from consumers if the organization is unable to continue program operations, either through an enforcement action by CalRecycle or if the organization is dissolved or unwilling to continue operations. Particularly, given the complex enforcement history in this program, it is important that the state has a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE after the current September 1st deadline to preserve California’s carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
Under AB 729, if a plan is terminated or revoked and CalRecycle does not approve a new carpet stewardship plan within one year, CalRecycle would be authorized to modify the previously approved plan and take over the program. Opponents of this bill have expressed concern of allowing CalRecycle to take over the program, without any parameters, and instead think it would be more appropriate for CARE to continue to implement the plan until a new organization is designated. However, given the complicated past between CalRecycle and CARE and the program history, this may not be an ideal solution either.
- CalRecycle’s administrative costs. Under the Act, CARE is required to pay CalRecycle a quarterly administrative fee to cover the department’s costs in administering and enforcing the chapter, but that fee is limited, on an annual basis, to 5% of the amount of assessments collected in the prior year.
According to the author, CalRecycle’s costs have exceeded the 5% cap for the last three out of seven years, with costs of implementation highest in 2015 and 2016. It is noted that this is when CARE was found to not be improving carpet recycling and not making progress towards the statutory recycling goals. During this time, according to the author, significant CalRecycle staff time was allocated to work with CARE to improve its program and bring CARE into compliance. Recent adjustments to the assessment by CARE have resulted in the administrative fees falling below the 5% limitation, but history supports, or at least the consideration of, this 5% cap being removed.
Even with the removal of the 5% cap, the administrative fee will still be limited to CalRecycle’s costs of enforcing and implementing the Act. It is also recognized, however, the amount of assessments collected is dependent on the amount of new carpet sold, which has been decreasing in recent years. What happens if assessments collected (revenue) is low due to declining carpet sales but enforcement/administrative fees are high? How does CARE make up this difference? Through cutting program funding or an increased consumer assessment? Would an increased assessment on carpet cause consumers to want to look into alternative flooring options other than carpet? But if CalRecycle is not fully reimbursed by CARE for its enforcement costs, where does that money come from?
- Differential Assessments. In February 2018, in response to CARE’s draft 2018-2022 Plan, the advisory committee recommended that CARE implement a system of differential assessments based on face fiber type that correlates to the subsidy required to have it be economically recycled, with adequate time for implementation within 12 months of the approved plan.
AB 729 changes the differential assessment recommendation into a mandate, and instead require the plan to establish a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden a particular carpet material has on the program, and the amount of postconsumer recycled content contained in a particular carpet. AB 729 does not impose a timeframe by which CARE would be required to develop and implement the differential assessments.
According to the 2018-2022 Plan approved in February 2019, CARE has been engaged in internal discussions to consider the potential adoption of differential assessments and may amend the program to apply differential assessments such as for different fiber types, market segments, or price if CARE determines it is in the best interest of achieving the goals of the Act. CARE will consult both the advisory committee and CalRecycle to provide input on the approach if CARE decides to move forward with development of a differential assessment. CARE may also consider hosting a public stakeholder workshop and/or a targeted mill/retailer participant workshop to solicit broader input on the potential implications, benefits, and challenges with adopting differential assessments.
It seems AB 729’s differential assessments mandate is a direct response to CARE’s open-ended approach, instead specifying that the differential assessments take into account the financial burden and recyclability of a particular carpet material type, and the amount of postconsumer recycled content. Additionally, a lower assessment for carpet that costs less to recycle and a higher assessment for carpet that is harder to recycle; the intent to incentivize the purchase of easier to recycle carpet in the marketplace.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2097 (Acosta, Chapter 340, Statutes of 2018) extended the date by which carpet manufacturers are required to submit their annual report to CalRecycle from July 1 to September 1 of each year.
AB 1158 (Chu, Chapter 794, Statutes 2017), among other things, required a carpet stewardship plan to achieve a 24% recycling rate for postconsumer carpet by January 1, 2020, revised the criteria a carpet stewardship organization is required to meet to achieve compliance with carpet stewardship laws, and created an advisory committee to provide comments and recommendations on carpet stewardship plans, amendments to plans, and annual reports.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CalRecycle estimates approximately $120,000 annually from the Carpet Stewardship Account for an additional Environmental Scientist at CalRecycle to implement this bill. Additionally, unknown potential cost pressures, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, if CalRecycle takes over administration of the program. To the extent that differential assessments raise the assessment on carpet purchased by the state, unknown potential cost increases.
National Stewardship Action Council (source)
ACR Solar
Aquafil USA, Inc.
California Product Stewardship Council
California Refuse Recycling Council, Northern District
California Resource Recovery Association
Castro Valley Sanitary District
Changing Markets Foundation
City of Fremont
City of Sunnyvale
City of Torrance
Clean Water Action/Clean Water Fund
Ecology Center
Interface, Inc.
Los Angeles County Solid Waste Management Committee
Nate Miley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors
Northern California Recycling Association
Planet Recycling, Inc.
Plastic Pollution Coalition
RethinkWaste
Sea Hugger
Seventh Generation Advisors
StopWaste
SWANA California Chapter’s Task Force
Tehama County Solid Waste Management Agency
Textile Exchange
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Center for Oceanic Awareness, Research, and Education
UPSTREAM
Western Placer Waste Management
Zanker Recycling
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
A&S Floor Covering, Inc.
Beau Monde Fine Floors, Inc.
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Retailers Association
Camino Carpets
Carpet & Rug Institute
Carpet House
Carpetcraft Inc.
Creative Floor Design, Inc.
D.A. Roberts Enterprises, Inc.
Mohawk Industries
Stan Bilchik Carpet Co.
The Floor Store
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-17, 5/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Flora, Eduardo Garcia, Ramos
Prepared by: Genevieve M. Wong / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
9/1/19 10:14:11
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 729 (Chu) - Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship
Version: July 5, 2019 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 6 - 1, JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would revise the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program to require the stewardship plan include a funding mechanism with differential assessments, require a “contingency plan” in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle, and increase the administrative penalties from $1,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
Fiscal Impact:
- CalRecycle estimates approximately $120,000 annually (Carpet Stewardship Account) for an additional Environmental Scientist at CalRecycle to implement this bill.
- Unknown potential cost pressures, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, if CalRecycle takes over administration of the program.
- To the extent that differential assessments raise the assessment on carpet purchased by the state, unknown potential cost increases.
Background:
Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) Programs. According to CalRecycle, EPR is a strategy that places shared responsibility for end-of-life product management on the producers, and all entities involved in the product chain, instead of on the general public and local governments, with oversight and enforcement provided by a governmental agency. This approach provides flexibility for manufacturers, based on their expertise in designing products and the systems that bring these products to market, to design systems to capture those products at the end-of-life to meet statutory goals. Currently there are 4 statewide EPR programs: paint, carpet, mattresses, and pharmaceutical and sharps waste.
California’s carpet recycling program. California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Perez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an EPR program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program, and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress, and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE). CARE is a third-party nonprofit carpet stewardship organization based in Georgia. AB 2398 established CARE as the sole carpet stewardship organization until April 1, 2015, and after that date, permits an organization to submit a stewardship plan to CalRecycle for approval. Currently, CARE is the only carpet stewardship organization in California. Unfortunately, CARE has repeatedly been noncompliant with its duties under the program.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require a carpet stewardship organization to be a 501(c)(3) organization.
- Require the funding mechanism to be composed of a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden that a particular carpet material has on the stewardship program. If a certain carpet material requires a higher subsidy to incentivize use in the marketplace, based on market history and modeling, requires that material to have a proportionally higher assessment.
- Require a carpet stewardship plan to include a contingency plan that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
- Require the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit unexpended funds and ongoing consumer assessments if the plan is terminated or revoked, as provided.
- Require the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit unexpended funds and ongoing consumer assessments if the plan is terminated or revoked, and requires the trustee or escrow agent to take certain actions if the plan is terminated or revoked.
- Increase the existing administrative penalty from up to $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day.
This bill is intended to address a shortcoming that has been identified in the state’s product stewardship programs – what happens to the fee money collected from consumers if the organization is unable to continue program operations, either through an enforcement action by CalRecycle or if the organization is dissolved or unwilling to continue operations. Particularly, given the complex enforcement history in this program, it is important that the state has a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE after the current September 1st deadline to preserve California’s carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
Under AB 729, if a plan is terminated or revoked and CalRecycle does not approve a new carpet stewardship plan within one year, CalRecycle would be authorized to modify the previously approved plan and take over the program.
Related Legislation:
AB 2097 (Acosta, Chapter 340, Statutes of 2018) extended the date by which carpet manufacturers are required to submit their annual report to CalRecycle from July 1 to September 1 of each year.
AB 1158 (Chu, Chapter 794, Statutes 2017), among other things, requires a carpet stewardship plan to achieve a 24% recycling rate for postconsumer carpet by January 1, 2020, revises the criteria a carpet stewardship organization is required to meet to achieve compliance with carpet stewardship laws, and creates an advisory committee to provide comments and recommendations on carpet stewardship plans, amendments to plans, and annual reports.
Staff Comments:
CARE’s 2017-2021 plan submitted to CalRecycle identifies $764,142 for CARE salaries and staffing. Should CalRecycle take over administration of the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program, staff assumes the department’s administrative costs would be similar.
Data from the State Contracting and Procurement Registration System indicate that the state spends about $1.5 million annually on carpeting. This data does not include carpet purchased as part of new construction or tenant improvements in space leased by the state, so the actual expenditures are likely much higher. The state also provides matching funds for some school facility purchases, which could include carpeting. To the extent that the differential assessments included in this bill raise the assessment on carpet purchased by the state, this bill would result in potential cost increases.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 729 (Author:Chu)
Version: July 5, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship
DIGEST
This bill the revises existing provisions of law under the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program to, among other things, require the stewardship plan to include a funding mechanism with differential assessments and to require a contingency plan in the absence of an approved plan by the California Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle), as provided. The bill increases existing administrative penalties for a violation of the stewardship program from up to $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
California was the first state in the nation to require a statewide carpet recycling program designed and implemented by the manufacturers with oversight by the CalRecycle. The goal of the program is to increase the recycling rate of carpets in order to increase landfill diversion and post-consumer recycling. A main component of the stewardship plan is an assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state that is used to support and encourage more recycling. The Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE) was statutorily designated as the stewardship organization to carry out the responsibilities of the stewardship program. Unfortunately, CARE has repeatedly failed to meet its requirements under the stewardship program. The author has brought this bill in response to these repeatedly failures in order to ensure the goals of the stewardship program can continue to be met.
The bill is sponsored by the National Stewardship Action Council. The bill is supported by various environmental organizations and local governments. The bill is opposed by various associations representing business interests and the carpet manufacturing industry. The bill passed the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on a vote of 6-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires manufacturers of carpets sold in this state, individually or through a carpet stewardship organization, to submit a carpet stewardship plan to CalRecycle that includes specified elements relating to the recycling of postconsumer carpet. (Pub. Res. Code § 42972.)
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan, and that is remitted to the organization to carry out the plan. (Pub. Res. Code § 42972(a)(7)).
- Specifies that CARE, a third-party nonprofit carpet stewardship organization incorporated as a nonprofit corporation pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of Title 26 of the United States Code in 2002 and established to increase the reclamation and stewardship of postconsumer carpet, is the sole carpet stewardship program. (Pub. Res. Code § 42971(e)(2)).
- Authorizes a carpet manufacturer to comply with the stewardship program as an individual manufacturer. (Pub. Res. Code § 42971(e)(1)(B)).
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan, as provided. (Pub. Res. Code § 42972(a)(7)).
- Requires CalRecycle, within 60 days after receiving a plan, to review and determine whether the plan complies with the law's requirements and notify the submitter of its decision. Specifies that any plan not approved by March 31, 2012, is out of compliance until determined to be complete by CalRecycle. (Pub. Res. Code §§ 42973.)
- Declares a state goal to reach a carpet recycling rate of 24 percent by January 1, 2020. (Pub. Res. Code § 42972.2.)
- Requires the carpet stewardship organization to annually demonstrate to CalRecycle that it has achieved continuous meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion and other specified goals in order to be in compliance. (Pub. Res. Code § 42975.)
- Authorizes CalRecycle to administratively impose a civil penalty on any person who violates the provisions of the stewardship program in an amount up to $1,000 per day or $10,000 per day if the violation is intentional, knowing, or negligent. (Pub. Res. Code § 42978.)
- In assessing or reviewing the amount of a civil penalty imposed, CalRecycle is required to consider all of the following factors;
- the nature and extent of the violation;
- the number and severity of the violation or violations;
- the economic effect of the penalty on the violator;
- whether the violator took good faith measures to comply and the period of time over which these measures were taken;
- the willfulness of the violator’s misconduct;
- the deterrent effect that the imposition of the penalty would have on both the violator and the regulated community; and
- any other factor that justice may require. (Pub. Res. Code § 42978(b)-(7).)
- In assessing or reviewing the amount of a civil penalty imposed, CalRecycle is required to consider all of the following factors;
This bill:
- Requires a carpet stewardship organization to be a 501(c)(3) organization.
- Requires the funding mechanism to be composed of a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden that a particular carpet material has on the stewardship program. If a certain carpet material requires a higher subsidy to incentivize use in the marketplace, based on market history and modeling, requires that material to have a proportionally higher assessment.
- Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a contingency plan that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
- Requires the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit unexpended funds and ongoing consumer assessments if the plan is terminated or revoked, as provided.
- Requires the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit unexpended funds and ongoing consumer assessments if the plan is terminated or revoked, and requires the trustee or escrow agent to take certain actions if the plan is terminated or revoked.
- Increases the existing administrative penalty from up to $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
My bill from 2017, AB 1158, outlined specific targets and gave the State the authority to set future targets for carpet recycling. However, the State needs additional tools to provide a backstop in the case a plan is inadequate to meet set recycling goals. Currently, there is no mechanism to continue the program if a stewardship plan submitted by manufacturers is disapproved. AB 729 will allow for a “bridge” plan to avoid disruptions in our carpet recycling infrastructure and protect consumer fees if a plan is disapproved or revoked.”
2. Carpet Stewardship Program and enforcement
a. Failure of CARE to meet requirements of the stewardship program
California was the first state in the nation to require a statewide carpet recycling program designed and implemented by the manufacturers with oversight by CalRecycle. The goal of the program is to increase the recycling rate of carpets in order to increase landfill diversion and post-consumer recycling. CARE is statutorily designated at the sole carpet stewardship organization under the stewardship program. Unfortunately, CARE has repeatedly been noncompliant with its duties under the program.
In light of the inability of CARE to meet their requirements under the program, this bill seeks to revise the program. Specifically, it addresses the issue of what would happen to the assessment collected if CARE is unable to continue program operations. The bill requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a contingency plan that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company or trustee. If a new carpet stewardship plan has not been approved within one year after termination or revocation of the existing plan, CalRecycle may make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan.
b. Inadequacy of current civil penalty
From 2013-2016, CARE failed to meet the requirement of continuous and meaningful improvement of diverting carpet from landfills as required under the stewardship program. An enforcement action was instituted by CalRecycle and, following a hearing on September 26, 2017, an Administrative Law Judge (ALJ) issued a proposed decision concluding that CARE should pay an increasing fine for each year it failed to meet its meaningful improvement requirement, beginning with a penalty $500 per day for 2013 and a civil penalty of $1500 per day for failing to demonstrate meaningful improvement during the 2015 reporting period. The ALJ stated that the $1,500 per day penalty was “more appropriate to serve as a deterrent effect going forward.”[1] The Director of CalRecycle; however, had to reduce the $1,500 a day penalty when adopting the decision because under subdivision (a) of Section 42978 of the Public Resources Code, a person can only be fined above $1,000 per violation if the violation is intentional, knowing, or negligent. The ALJ expressly found that there was no evidence of negligence, even though the ALJ imposed a $1,500 civil penalty.[2]
In light of this, the bill seeks to increases the existing fine of up to $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day in order to better deter violations of the stewardship program. The requirement that CalRecycle take into consideration various factors, such as the nature and extent of the violation and whether the violator took good faith measures, would still apply to the increased penalty amount but will give CalRecycle more flexibility to enforce the stewardship program’s provisions. (Pub. Res. Code § 42978(b)-(7).) This will help ensure that the goal of reaching a carpet recycling rate of 24 percent by January 1, 2020 is able to be attained. (Pub. Res. Code § 42972.2.)
3. Statements in support
The National Stewardship Action Council, the sponsor of the bill, and the California Product Stewardship Council write:
CalRecycle is the oversight agency for the carpet stewardship program and they simply do not have enough tools to ensure this program works properly. It is working well enough that California has the highest recycling rate in the country as the national average is 3% recycled and California is now at 15% but that is very low considering the original legislation was passed in 2010 with a recycling baseline rate of 8%.
CalRecycle is expected to know by September 1, 2019 if the Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE) will have met their programmatic requirements and will be making a very important decision to either approve the program or determine CARE has not lived up to its commitment and enforce against CARE or disallow them from running the program. If that happens, it is critical for California’s businesses that we have a way to get the $15.5 million in California fee money back from CARE to allow another stewardship organization to take over and continue to support carpet recycling infrastructure.
The purpose of AB 729 is very simple yet important - to ensure California feepayer money is transferred back and used to support California’s carpet recycling infrastructure if the existing stewardship organization for some reason can no longer run the program.
4. Statements in opposition
In opposition of the bill, the Carpet and Rug Institute, writes:
For decades, a significant amount of carpet has been manufactured in the state of California and we are concerned that legislation like AB 729 will dissuade additional manufacturing investment in California and further accelerate the decline in carpet sales in the state. This legislation has the potential to also discourage further investment in carpet recycling infrastructure due to added uncertainty in the marketplace.
Over the past several years, CRI has worked with the Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE) and CalRecycle to establish the first carpet recycling stewardship plan in the country. Through the hard work of CARE, carpet recycling rates are continuing to increase, and as an industry, we continue to strive to identify new technologies to ensure that California carpet gets recycled.
Currently, the CARE Program is funded through a 35-cent assessment on each square yard of carpet sold in California (the assessment started at 5 cents per square yard in 2011 and has increased 7-fold since then). The June 20th amendment now requires the funding mechanism to be composed of a system of differential assessments, which could be difficult to administer and possibly have no impact on the recycling rate of carpet in California.
SUPPORT
National Stewardship Action Council (sponsor)
ACR Solar
Aquafil
California Product Stewardship Council
California Refuse Recycling Council, Northern District
California Resource Recovery Association
City of Torrance
Los Angeles County Solid Waste Management Committee
Nate Miley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors
Sea Hugger
Seventh Generation Advisors
Zero Waste Company
OPPOSITION
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
Carpet & Rug Institute
Mohawk Industries
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
AB 2097 (Acosta, Ch. 340, Stats. 2018) extended the date by which carpet manufacturers are required to submit their annual report to CalRecycle from July 1 to September 1 of each year.
AB 1158 (Chu, Ch. 794, Stats. 2017), among other things, required a carpet stewardship plan to achieve a 24 percent recycling rate for postconsumer carpet by January 1, 2020, revised the criteria a carpet stewardship organization is required to meet to achieve compliance with carpet stewardship laws, and created an advisory committee to provide comments and recommendations on carpet stewardship plans, amendments to plans, and annual reports.
AB 2398 (Pérez, Ch. 681, Stats. 2010) established the stewardship program, as provided.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 6, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 58, Noes 17)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 4)
Assembly Natural Resources Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
**************
Proposed Decision In the Matter of the Accusation Against: Carpet America Recovery Effort, OAH No. 2017040578 (Feb. 13, 2018), p. 11, available at https://www.calrecycle.ca.gov/docs/cr/carpet/propdecision.pdf (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
In the Matter of: Carpet Recovery Effort, Dept. of Resources Recycling and Recovery, Agency No: 2017-001-CARPET (OAH No. 2017040578), pp. 1-2, available at https://www2.calrecycle.ca.gov/Docs/EnforcementOrder/107444 (as of Jun. 30, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 729
Author: | Chu | ||
Version: | 6/20/2019 | Hearing Date: | 7/3/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Genevieve M. Wong | ||
SUBJECT: Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship
DIGEST: Revises the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program to, among other things, require the stewardship plan include a funding mechanism with differential assessments, require a “contingency plan” in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle, and increase the administrative penalties from $1,000 per day to $5,000 per day.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law, the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program:
- Requires manufacturers of carpets sold in this state, individually or through a carpet stewardship organization, to submit a carpet stewardship plan to CalRecycle that includes specified elements relating to the recycling of postconsumer carpet (Public Resources Code (PRC) §42972).
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan and that is remitted to the organization to carry out the plan (PRC §42972(a)(7)).
- Requires the plan to establish and provide for a carpet stewardship assessment per unit of carpet sold in the state to fund the plan and that is remitted to the organization to carry out the plan (PRC §42972(a)(7)).
- Requires CalRecycle, within 60 days after receiving a plan, to review and determine whether the plan complies with the law's requirements and notify the submitter of its decision. Specifies that any plan not approved by March 31, 2012, is out of compliance until determined to be complete by CalRecycle (PRC §§42973).
- Requires CalRecycle to post a notice on its website listing manufacturers that are in compliance with the bill’s requirements. Requires a wholesaler or retailer that distributes or sells carpets to monitor the website to determine if the sale of a manufacturer’s carpet is in compliance (PRC §42978).
- Requires the carpet stewardship organization to annually demonstrate to CalRecycle that it has achieved continuous meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion and other specified goals in order to be in compliance (PRC §42975).
- Provides for the imposition of administrative civil penalties upon a person who violates the bill and would provide that the manufacturer or organization whose plan is not approved by CalRecycle by March 31, 2012, is subject to those penalties until the plan is approved (PRC §42978, 42973(b)).
- Declares a state goal to reach a carpet recycling rate of 24% by January 1, 2020 (PRC §42972.2).
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2023, CalRecycle to establish the minimum carpet recycling rate (PRC §42972.2(b)).
- Prohibits an organization from expending funds from an assessment for any of the following purposes (PRC §42972):
- Penalties imposed by CalRecycle;
- Costs associated with litigation against the state; or,
- Engineered municipal solid waste conversion, use in cement kilns, and transformation, as defined.
- Requires the organization to pay CalRecycle a quarterly administrative fee, set by CalRecycle at an amount that is adequate to cover the costs of administering and enforcing the Act. Limits the amount of administrative fees paid for a calendar year to 5% of the aggregate assessments collected for the preceding calendar year (PRC §42977).
- Establishes an advisory committee to make recommendations on carpet stewardship plans (PRC §42972.1).
This bill:
- Requires a carpet stewardship organization to be a 501(c)(3) organization.
- Requires the funding mechanism to be composed of a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden that a particular carpet material has on the stewardship program. If a certain carpet material requires a higher subsidy to incentivize use in the market place, based on market history and modeling, requires that material to have a proportionally higher assessment.
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that the amount of the assessment be reduced by the organization as the program is implemented over time and becomes more efficient.
- Requires the organization to update the plan to either increase or decrease the assessment as appropriate and to submit the updated plan to CalRecycle.
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that the amount of the assessment be reduced by the organization as the program is implemented over time and becomes more efficient.
- Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a “contingency plan” that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
- Requires the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit unexpended funds and ongoing consumer assessments if the plan is terminated or revoked.
- If the plan is terminated or revoked, requires that the trustee or escrow agent:
- Accept carpet stewardship assessment payments directly from manufacturers into the trust fund or escrow account; and,
- Make payments from the trust fund or escrow account, at the direction of CalRecycle, to implement the most recently approved plan.
- If a new plan has not been approved within one year, authorizes CalRecycle to make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan.
- Upon the approval of a successor organization, requires the trustee or escrow agent to transfer funds to the new organization.
- Removes the 5% of the aggregate assessments cap on administrative fees paid to CalRecycle.
- Increases the penalty amounts for the program from $1,000 per day to up to $5,000 per day.
Background
- Extended Producer Responsibility (EPR) Programs. According to CalRecycle, EPR is a strategy that places shared responsibility for end-of-life product management on the producers, and all entities involved in the product chain, instead of on the general public and local governments, with oversight and enforcement provided by a governmental agency. This approach provides flexibility for manufacturers, based on their expertise in designing products and the systems that bring these products to market, to design systems to capture those products at the end-of-life to meet statutory goals. Currently there are 4 statewide EPR programs: paint, carpet, mattresses, and pharmaceutical and sharps waste.
- Recycling Carpet. Discarded carpet is one of the 10 most prevalent waste materials in California landfills, comprising about 3.2% of waste by volume disposed of in California in 2008. Most carpet is made from nylon and other polymers derived from virgin fossil fuel. Carpet is difficult to recover plastics from due to the multiple materials bound together and is designed for durability and longevity. Numerous products can be manufactured from recycled carpet, including carpet backing and backing components, carpet fiber, carpet underlayment, plastics and engineered materials, and erosion control products.
- California’s carpet recycling program. California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Perez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an EPR program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program, and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress, and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
- Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE). CARE is a third-party nonprofit carpet stewardship organization based in Georgia. AB 2398 established CARE as the sole carpet stewardship organization until April 1, 2015, and after that date, permits an organization to submit a stewardship plan to CalRecycle for approval. Currently, CARE is the only carpet stewardship organization in California.
- Carpet stewardship plans.
- California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2011-2016. Consistent with AB 2398, CARE is directed to collect an assessment that is sufficient to meet, but not exceed, the anticipated cost of implementing the stewardship plan. In the approved California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2011-2016 (2011-2016 Plan), the initial ($0.05) per square yard assessment was approved through 2016. In 2015 and 2016, the 2011-2016 Plan was revised through three separate addenda in order to support continuous meaningful progress in line with the goals of AB 2398 and in response to market conditions. The first addenda provided justification for additional program incentives and enhancements to help CARE achieve compliance and increased the assessment from $0.05/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.10/square yard effective April 1, 2015. The second addenda authorized a one-year grant and loan pilot program. The third addenda, approved in 2016, increased the assessment from $0.10/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.20/square yard effective April 1, 2016. The 2011-2016 Plan was set to expire December 1, 2016.
- California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2017-2021. In October 2016, CARE submitted a new California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2017-2021 (2017- 2021 Plan), which included an increase of the assessment to $0.25/square yard. CalRecycle disapproved the plan on December 20, 2016, and gave CARE 60 days to resubmit a revised 2017-2021 Plan for consideration. The disapproval required CARE to continue operating under the 2011-2016 Plan until a new plan was approved by CalRecycle, but for no more than 120 days.
- California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2011-2016. Consistent with AB 2398, CARE is directed to collect an assessment that is sufficient to meet, but not exceed, the anticipated cost of implementing the stewardship plan. In the approved California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2011-2016 (2011-2016 Plan), the initial ($0.05) per square yard assessment was approved through 2016. In 2015 and 2016, the 2011-2016 Plan was revised through three separate addenda in order to support continuous meaningful progress in line with the goals of AB 2398 and in response to market conditions. The first addenda provided justification for additional program incentives and enhancements to help CARE achieve compliance and increased the assessment from $0.05/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.10/square yard effective April 1, 2015. The second addenda authorized a one-year grant and loan pilot program. The third addenda, approved in 2016, increased the assessment from $0.10/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.20/square yard effective April 1, 2016. The 2011-2016 Plan was set to expire December 1, 2016.
CalRecycle found that the new proposed plan, "taken as a whole, does not ensure continuous meaningful improvement in carpet recycling and diversion in 2017 and beyond." According to CalRecycle, the plan focuses on existing subsidies that have not demonstrated increased recycling rates; moreover, CARE intends to "scale back" subsidy guarantees going forward. The plan does not address the possibility of providing subsidies to points in the supply chain that may result in significant increases in recycling, such as installer subsidies to increase diversion and recycling, funding for discounted drop-off fees, or subsidies for secondary manufacturers to use post-consumer nylon. Most of the activities described in the 2017-2021 Plan, according to CalRecycle, continue existing initiatives at much the same level as the 2011-2016 Plan that expired in 2016, at a time when CalRecycle already found that the Program lacked continuous meaningful improvement three years in a row.
AB 2398 established administrative civil penalties of $1,000 per day ($10,000 for intentional, knowing, or negligent violations). In its disapproval of CARE's 2017-2021 plan, the director directed staff to delay enforcement action against carpet manufacturers, wholesalers, and retailers for 120 days, “provided the regulatory entity is participating in good faith in continuing to carry out the requirements of the law and CARE's existing plan.”
On February 20, 2017, CARE submitted a revised 2017-2021 Plan, which specified that with the $0.25/square yard assessment, it expects to collect $23.7 million in 2017. The plan identifies $1.7 million in reuse subsidy payments; $7.1 million in recycling processor payments; $11.1 million in manufacturer payments; just under $1 million in specified grants; and, $6.2 million in “program expenses,” which includes $764,142 for CARE salaries and staffing. On April 21, 2017, CalRecycle disapproved the revised 2017- 2021 Plan based upon a finding that the plan did not comply with statutory requirements. In its disapproval, CalRecycle noted that without an approved plan in place, all manufacturers that sell carpet in California are subject to penalties until they are covered by an approved plan. Additionally, wholesalers and retailers would be subject to penalties for selling carpet from non-compliant manufacturers. In order to preserve the recycling infrastructure and avoid market disruptions, CalRecycle authorized manufacturers, wholesalers, and retailers to continue to operate without penalties for 60 days.
The Director of CalRecycle directed staff to develop a draft plan to help CARE comply with state requirements. At the June 2017 public meeting, CalRecycle presented its Final Carpet Stewardship Program Enforcement Plan, which was later updated and presented at the October 2017 public meeting. Because the 2011-2016 Plan had ended on December 31, 2016, the Director allowed CARE to continue to operate under the 2011-2016 Plan under conditions specified in the updated enforcement plan, including a requirement that CARE submit a carpet stewardship plan to CalRecycle by March 16, 2018, that would incorporate the provisions of AB 1158.
- California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2018-2022. On March 16, 2018, CARE submitted a new Carpet Stewardship Plan 2018-2022 (2018-2022 Plan). The plan was disapproved on May 15, 2018, after reviewing staff found that the plan did not meet statutory requirements. On June 12, 2018, CalRecycle agreed to delay implementation of its Enforcement Plan (see below) for an additional 33 days, to allow public consideration of CARE’s revised plan at CalRecycle’s October 2018 Monthly Meeting. On August 17, 2018, CARE submitted its revised 2018-2022 Plan, and another revision on September 24, 2018. This plan was conditionally approved by the director at CalRecycle’s October 2018 public meeting, which required CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development, and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted a new “Chapter 0” as an addendum to the plan to address the recommendations of CalRecycle. This plan was approved by the director on February 19, 2019, with additional requirements that must be implemented by September 2, 2019.
- California Carpet Stewardship Plan 2018-2022. On March 16, 2018, CARE submitted a new Carpet Stewardship Plan 2018-2022 (2018-2022 Plan). The plan was disapproved on May 15, 2018, after reviewing staff found that the plan did not meet statutory requirements. On June 12, 2018, CalRecycle agreed to delay implementation of its Enforcement Plan (see below) for an additional 33 days, to allow public consideration of CARE’s revised plan at CalRecycle’s October 2018 Monthly Meeting. On August 17, 2018, CARE submitted its revised 2018-2022 Plan, and another revision on September 24, 2018. This plan was conditionally approved by the director at CalRecycle’s October 2018 public meeting, which required CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development, and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted a new “Chapter 0” as an addendum to the plan to address the recommendations of CalRecycle. This plan was approved by the director on February 19, 2019, with additional requirements that must be implemented by September 2, 2019.
- Enforcement actions against CARE. On March 10, 2017, separate from its consideration of the proposed 2017-2021 stewardship plan, CalRecycle began an enforcement proceeding against CARE for failing to meet the requirement that the carpet stewardship organization achieve “continuous and meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion of postconsumer carpet subject to its stewardship plan and in meeting the other goals included in the organization’s plan.” In spite of the significant amount of money collected by CARE from California consumers, CalRecycle found that CARE did not meet these requirements in 2013, 2014, or 2015. After each finding, CalRecycle provided CARE with recommendations on adjustments to the plan that would result in meaningful improvement; however, CARE has not, yet, officially incorporated CalRecycle's suggestions in any subsequent plans, although they are looking into the possibility of implementing a system for differential assessments (see below). CalRecycle sought a total of $3.285 million in penalties: $182,500 for 2013; $1.46 million for 2014; and, $1.64 million for 2015.
On June 20, 2017, CalRecycle considered and adopted the final Enforcement Plan which was later updated to extend the timeframe manufacturers may continue to avoid penalties until after August 17, 2018, when the resubmitted 2018-2022 Plan was due. At that time, according to the Enforcement Plan, if there is not an approved resubmitted plan, a noncompliance manufacturer without an approved plan may be subject to civil penalties.
Following a hearing on September 26, 2017, the Office of Administrative Hearings issued a proposed decision on February 13, 2018, that concluded that there is cause to impose a civil penalty against CARE but reduced the total penalties to $1,003,750. It is noted that the Court also concluded that a civil penalty in the amount of $1,500/day is more appropriate to serve as a deterrent effect going forward for the 2015 reporting period. CalRecycle had until May 23, 2018 to accept, reject, or modify the decision. On April 26, 2018, CalRecyle accepted the proposed decision, with modifications which included reducing the penalty amount to be consistent with penalties specified in statute.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “California has led the way with its flagship carpet recycling program. My bill from 2017, AB 1158, outlined specific targets and gave the State the authority to set future targets for carpet recycling. However, the State needs additional tools to provide a backstop in the case a plan is inadequate to meet set recycling goals. Currently, there is no mechanism to continue the program if a stewardship plan submitted by manufacturers is disapproved, AB 729 will allow for a “bridge” plan to avoid disruptions in our carpet recycling infrastructure and protect consumer fees if a plan is disapproved or revoked.”
- The show must go on. This bill is intended to address a shortcoming that has been identified in the state’s product stewardship programs – what happens to the fee money collected from consumers if the organization is unable to continue program operations, either through an enforcement action by CalRecycle or if the organization is dissolved or unwilling to continue operations. Particularly, given the complex enforcement history in this program, it is important that the state has a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE after the current September 1st deadline to preserve California’s carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
Under AB 729, if a plan is terminated or revoked and CalRecycle does not approve a new carpet stewardship plan within one year, CalRecycle would be authorized to modify the previously approved plan and take over the program.
Opponents of the bill have expressed concern of allowing CalRecycle to take over the program, without any parameters, and instead think it would be more appropriate for CARE to continue to implement the plan until a new organization is designated. However, given the complicated past between CalRecycle and CARE and the program history, this may not be an ideal solution either.
As the state entity with the subject matter expertise when it comes to recycling and waste reduction, CalRecycle would be the most logical choice. The Legislature has entrusted CalRecycle with the fair regulation of its waste and recycling programs. If not CalRecycle, then who?
- CalRecycle’s administrative costs. Under the Act, CARE is required to pay CalRecycle a quarterly administrative fee to cover the department’s costs in administering and enforcing the chapter, but that fee is limited, on an annual basis, to 5% of the amount of assessments collected in the prior year.
According to the author, CalRecycle’s costs have exceeded the 5% cap for the last 3 out of 7 years, with costs of implementation highest in 2015 and 2016. It is noted that this is when CARE was found to not be improving carpet recycling and not making progress towards the statutory recycling goals. During this time, according to the author, significant CalRecycle staff time was allocated to work with CARE to improve its program and bring CARE into compliance. Recent adjustments to the assessment by CARE have resulted in the administrative fees falling below the 5% limitation, but history supports, or at least the consideration of, this 5% cap being removed.
Even with the removal of the 5% cap, the administrative fee will still be limited to CalRecycle’s costs of enforcing and implementing the Act. It is also recognized, however, the amount of assessments collected is dependent on the amount of new carpet sold, which has been decreasing in recent years. What happens if assessments collected (revenue) is low due to declining carpet sales but enforcement/administrative fees are high? How does CARE make up this difference? Through cutting program funding or an increased consumer assessment? Would an increased assessment on carpet cause consumers to want to look into alternative flooring options other than carpet? But if CalRecycle is not fully reimbursed by CARE for its enforcement costs, where does that money come from?
- Differential Assessments. In February 2018, in response to CARE’s draft 2018-2022 Plan, the advisory committee recommended that CARE implement a system of differential assessments based on face fiber type that correlates to the subsidy required to have it be economically recycled, with adequate time for implementation within 12 months of the approved plan.
AB 729 would change the differential assessment recommendation into a mandate, and instead require the plan to establish a system of differential assessments that takes into account the financial burden a particular carpet material has on the program, and require carpet materials that are associated with higher subsidies due to low level of recyclability to have a higher assessment. AB 729 does not impose a timeframe by which CARE would be required to develop and implement the differential assessments.
According to the 2018-2022 Plan approved in February 2019, CARE has been engaged in internal discussions to consider the potential adoption of differential assessments and may amend the program to apply differential assessments such as for different fiber types, market segments, or price if CARE determines it is in the best interest of achieving the goals of the Act. CARE will consult both the advisory committee and CalRecycle to provide input on the approach if CARE decides to move forward with development of a differential assessment. CARE may also consider hosting a public stakeholder workshop and/or a targeted mill/retailer participant workshop to solicit broader input on the potential implications, benefits, and challenges with adopting differential assessments.
It seems AB 729’s differential assessments mandate is a direct response to CARE’s open-ended approach, instead specifying that the differential assessments take into account the financial burden and recyclability of a particular carpet material type. A lower assessment for carpet that costs less to recycle and a higher assessment for carpet that is harder to recycle; the intent to incentivize the purchase of easier to recycle carpet in the marketplace.
CARE has expressed concern for unintended consequences with this approach such as putting PET carpet at a disadvantage, which, it is argued, could have effects on other legislative efforts surrounding the use of PET, and encouraging consumers to consider other flooring alternatives. Additionally, recycling markets fluctuate, causing the recyclability and demand for materials to fluctuate also.
Opposition also points out that existing grants and subsidies for recycling postconsumer carpet is already structured to incentivize the recycling of carpet materials that have the highest recyclability, and therefore to additionally assign that type of carpet with the lowest assessment rate would put other carpet manufacturers at an unfair disadvantage. They assert that the differential assessment would only benefit one carpet manufacturer that produces a certain type of carpet material, which makes up a very small portion the amount of carpet sold. To increase recycling rates, according to the opposition, the assessment should focus on a material that comprises a larger percentage of the program. The underlying logic is if the Legislature wants to increase recycling rates of already purchased carpet, the Legislature needs to encourage consumers to continue to buy carpet of similar material, even if harder to recycle, by having a lower assessment. If there is more demand for it, more will be recycled.
Although certain types of carpet may have been popular in the past or continue to be popular and therefore have a larger presence in the market, does that mean the Legislature should provide incentives and promote that particular type if it is hard to recycle when other more sustainable, easier to recycle carpet options are available? Does this reasoning promote an endless cycle of trying to process and find markets for unsustainable, harder to recycle carpet material? Although recyclability of a material depends on finding end-markets for those materials, does the Legislature want to encourage the use of hard to recycle materials for carpet because the state needs end markets for those materials? Or should the amount of recycled content in carpet play a roll in the differential assessment?
The committee may wish to amend the bill to also require the differential assessments to take into account the amount of postconsumer content contained in a particular face fiber type.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2097 (Acosta, Chapter 340, Statutes of 2018) extended the date by which carpet manufacturers are required to submit their annual report to CalRecycle from July 1 to September 1 of each year.
AB 1158 (Chu, Chapter 794, Statutes 2017), among other things, requires a carpet stewardship plan to achieve a 24% recycling rate for postconsumer carpet by January 1, 2020, revises the criteria a carpet stewardship organization is required to meet to achieve compliance with carpet stewardship laws, and creates an advisory committee to provide comments and recommendations on carpet stewardship plans, amendments to plans, and annual reports.
SOURCE:
National Stewardship Action Council
DOUBLE REFERRAL
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SUPPORT:
ACR Solar
Aquafil
California Product Stewardship Council
California Refuse Recycling Council, Northern District
California Resource Recovery Association
Castro Valley Sanitary District
Changing Markets
Changing Markets Foundation
Clean Water Action/Clean Water Fund
Ecology Center
Interface, Inc.
Los Angeles County Solid Waste Management Committee
Nate Miley, Alameda County Board of Supervisors
National Stewardship Action Council (sponsor)
Planet Recycling, Inc.
Plastic Pollution Coalition
RethinkWaste
Sea Hugger
Seventh Generation Advisors
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Center for Oceanic Awareness, Research, and Education (COARE)
UPSTREAM
OPPOSITION:
Beau Monde Fine Floors, Inc.
Carpet & Rug Institute
Carpet House
Creative Floor Design, Inc.
D.A. Roberts Enterprises, Inc.
Mohawk Industries
Stan Bilchik Carpet Co.
The Floor Store
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition letter, which included, among others, California Product Stewardship Council and National Stewardship Action Council, “CalRecycle is the oversight agency for the carpet stewardship program and they simply do not have enough tools to ensure this program works properly. It is working well enough that California has the highest recycling rate in the country as the national average is 3% recycled and California is now at 15% but that is very low considering the original legislation passed in 2010 with a recycling baseline rate of 8%.
“CalRecycle is expected to know by September 1, 2019 if the Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE) will have met their programmatic requirements and will be making a very important decision to either approve the program or determine CARE has not lived up to its commitment and enforce against CARE or disallow them from running the program. If that happens, it is critical for California’s businesses that we have a way to get the $15.5 million in California fee money back from CARE to allow another stewardship organization to take over and continue to support carpet recycling infrastructure.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to Mohawk Industries,
“CARE and its members are working diligently to collect, process, and find end-markets for recycled carpet in order to meet the goals of AB 1158 which was signed by the Governor in 2017 and only implemented last year.
“AB 729 does not help with collection, processing, or end-markets for carpet and as noted above, only serves to distract from what is necessary to achieve the goals of this program. Rather than introducing more legislation to continue to change the rules, the proponents and CalRecycle need to allow CARE and its members to run the program according to existing law.”
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 729
Author:(Chu)
As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a "contingency plan" that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan, either by the organization or by the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
Major Provisions
- Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a "contingency plan" that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan, either by the organization or by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
- Requires the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit sufficient funds to implement the plan for one year in the event that the plan is terminated or revoked.
- If the plan is terminated or revoked, requires that the trustee or escrow agent:
- Accept carpet stewardship assessment payments directly from manufacturers into the trust fund or escrow account; and,
- Make payments from the trust fund or escrow account, at the direction of CalRecycle, to implement the most recently approved plan.
- If a new plan has not been approved within one year, CalRecycle may make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan. Upon the approval of a successor organization, requires the trustee or escrow agent to transfer funds to the new organization.
- Increases the penalty amounts for the program from $1,000 per day to up to $10,000 per day.
COMMENTS:
California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Perez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
The stewardship plan is a critical part of the program; it defines a compliant program and communicates a course of action to stakeholders and the public. Stewardship organizations (or individual manufacturers that are not represented by a stewardship organization) are responsible for submitting the plans to CalRecycle for approval. Approved plans are posted on CalRecycle's website.
Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE), based in Georgia, is the carpet industry's stewardship organization. CARE has struggled with enforcement and compliance issues throughout its existence.
On September 24, 2018, CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle for approval. This plan was conditionally approved, with a requirement for CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted an addendum to the plan to address CalRecycle's recommendations. This plan was approved on February 19, 2019, with additional requirements that must be implemented by September 2, 2019.
This bill provides a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE in order to preserve California's carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
According to the Author:
AB 1158 (Chu) Chapter 794, Statutes of 2017, improved and clarified [carpet] compliance standards, setting tangible goals for the stewardship program including a 24% recycling target by 2020 and giving CalRecycle authority to set targets thereafter. CARE plans must specifically outline how they plan to reach the targets for recycled targets, improve convenience for recycling and collection, incentivize markets, increase processor capacity, and increase recyclability of new carpet. Additionally, the bill protects consumer fees by limiting what the fee may be used for, including prohibiting use for fines to CARE for noncompliance, litigation against the State, and for activities related to incineration of carpet. The bill also formalizes an advisory committee and improves transparency.
Arguments in Support:
According to the National Stewardship Action Council, "the purpose of AB 729 is very simple yet important - to ensure California feepayer money is transferred back and used to support California's carpet recycling infrastructure if the existing stewardship organization for some reason can no longer run the program."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Carpet and Rug Institute, "AB 729 would require CARE to establish a trust or escrow fund with reserve funding for one year in the event the stewardship plan is terminated or revoked. Currently, the stewardship plan does not have the financial capability to fund such an account as it currently operates on a two-month reserve which is in compliance with CalRecycle's direction and consistent with the approved Plan."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee Negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 7-2-2
YES: Friedman, Chau, Cristina Garcia, Limón, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Mark Stone
NO: Mathis, Melendez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, Eggman
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-4-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough, Eduardo Garcia
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /(916)319-2092 FN: 0000459
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 729
Author:(Chu) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
Policy Committee: | Natural Resources | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a “contingency plan” that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan, either by the organization or by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
Specifically, this bill:
- Requires an organization, as part of its carpet stewardship plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit sufficient funds to implement a plan for one year in the event the plan is terminated or revoked.
- If a plan is terminated or revoked, requires the trustee or escrow agent to:
- Accept carpet stewardship assessment payments directly from manufacturers into the trust fund or escrow account.
- Make payments from the trust fund or escrow account, at the direction of CalRecycle, to implement the most recently approved plan.
- If a new plan has not been approved within one year, allows CalRecycle to make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan.
- Upon the approval of a successor organization, requires the trustee or escrow agent to transfer funds to the new organization.
- Increases the penalty amounts for the program, from $1,000 per day to up to $10,000 per day.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Negligible state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill addresses a shortcoming that has been identified in the state’s product stewardship programs – what happens to fee money collected from consumers if the organization is unable to continue program operations, either through an enforcement action by CalRecycle or if the organization is dissolved or unwilling to continue operations.
- Background. California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2396 (Perez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
The stewardship plan is a critical part of the program; it defines a compliant program and communicates a course of action to stakeholders and the public. Stewardship organizations (or individual manufacturers that are not represented by a stewardship organization) are responsible for submitting the plans to CalRecycle for approval. Approved plans are posted on CalRecycle's website.
Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE), based in Georgia, is the carpet industry's stewardship organization. CARE has struggled with enforcement and compliance issues throughout its existence.
On September 24, 2018, CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle for approval. This plan was conditionally approved, with a requirement for CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted an addendum to the plan to address CalRecycle’s recommendations. This plan was approved on February 19, 2019, with additional requirements that must be implemented by September 2, 2019.
This bill provides a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE in order to preserve California’s carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 729 (
Author:Chu) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
SUBJECT: Carpet recycling: carpet stewardship
SUMMARY: Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a “contingency plan” that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan, either by the organization or by the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
EXISTING LAW establishes the Product Stewardship for Carpets Program, which:
- Requires manufacturers of carpets sold in this state, individually or through a carpet stewardship organization, to submit a carpet stewardship plan to CalRecycle that includes specified elements.
- Requires CalRecycle, within 60 days after receiving a plan, to review and determine whether the plan complies with the law's requirements and notify the submitter of its decision. Specifies that any plan not approved by March 31, 2012, is out of compliance until determined to be complete by CalRecycle.
- Requires CalRecycle to post a notice on its website listing manufacturers that are in compliance with the bill’s requirements. Requires a wholesaler or retailer that distributes or sells carpets to monitor the website to determine if the sale of a manufacturer’s carpet is in compliance.
- Requires the carpet stewardship organization to demonstrate to CalRecycle that it has achieved continuous meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion and other specified goals in order to be in compliance.
- Provides for the imposition of administrative civil penalties upon a person who violates the bill and would provide that the manufacturer or organization whose plan is not approved by CalRecycle by March 31, 2012, is subject to those penalties until the plan is approved.
- Establishes a carpet recycling rate of 24% by January 1, 2020.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2023, CalRecycle to establish the minimum carpet recycling rate.
- Prohibits an organization from expending funds from an assessment for any of the following purposes:
- Penalties imposed by CalRecycle;
- Costs associated with litigation against the state; or,
- Engineered municipal solid waste conversion, use in cement kilns, and transformation, as defined.
- Penalties imposed by CalRecycle;
- Establishes an advisory committee to make recommendations on carpet stewardship plans.
THIS BILL:
- Requires a carpet stewardship plan to include a “contingency plan” that demonstrates how the activities in the plan will continue to be carried out in the absence of an approved plan, either by the organization or by CalRecycle through an independent entity, such as an escrow company.
- Requires the organization, as part of its plan, to set up a trust fund or escrow account into which it shall deposit sufficient funds to implement the plan for one year in the event that the plan is terminated or revoked.
- If the plan is terminated or revoked, requires that the trustee or escrow agent:
- Accept carpet stewardship assessment payments directly from manufacturers into the trust fund or escrow account; and,
- Make payments from the trust fund or escrow account, at the direction of CalRecycle, to implement the most recently approved plan.
- If a new plan has not been approved within one year, CalRecycle may make modifications to the previously approved plan and continue to direct payments from the trust fund or escrow account to implement the modified plan.
- Upon the approval of a successor organization, requires the trustee or escrow agent to transfer funds to the new organization.
- Increases the penalty amounts for the program from $1,000 per day to up to $10,000 per day.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
AB 1158 (Chu) Chapter 794, Statutes of 2017, improved and clarified [carpet] compliance standards, setting tangible goals for the stewardship program including a 24% recycling target by 2020 and giving CalRecycle authority to set targets thereafter. CARE plans must specifically outline how they plan to reach the targets for recycled targets, improve convenience for recycling and collection, incentivize markets, increase processor capacity, and increase recyclability of new carpet. Additionally, the bill protects consumer fees by limiting what the fee may be used for, including prohibiting use for fines to CARE for noncompliance, litigation against the State, and for activities related to incineration of carpet. The bill also formalizes an advisory committee and improves transparency.
[CalRecycle approved CARE’s most recent] plan under the condition CARE meet specified requirements by September 1, 2019. These include showing meaningful progress and a determination of sufficiency to meet the 24% target for recycled carpet. Among other conditions, if CARE fails to meet them, CalRecycle has stated they will not grant an extension to CARE. If this is the case, California’s carpet recycling program will cease, stopping funding to recyclers, missing opportunities for recycled materials – adding carpets to landfills, and leaving collected fees with CARE – without recourse for CalRecycle to continue the program and take possession of fees.
- Carpet stewardship. California's carpet stewardship program was created by AB 2398 (Pérez), Chapter 681, Statutes of 2010. As an extended producer responsibility (EPR) program, manufacturers (either individually or through their stewardship organization) are required to design and implement their own stewardship program. This means there is a stewardship organization that prepares and implements a plan to reach certain goals, finances and distributes funds to support the stewardship program, and reports to CalRecycle on their progress. CalRecycle's role in the carpet stewardship program is to review and approve plans, check progress, and support industry by providing oversight and enforcement to ensure a level playing field among carpet manufacturers. Other service providers participate in the management system as negotiated with the stewardship organization.
The stewardship plan is a critical part of the program; it defines a compliant program and communicates a course of action to stakeholders and the public. Stewardship organizations (or individual manufacturers that are not represented by a stewardship organization) are responsible for submitting the plans to CalRecycle for approval. Approved plans are posted on CalRecycle's website.
- CARE. The Carpet America Recovery Effort (CARE), based in Georgia, is the carpet industry's stewardship organization. In keeping with AB 2396, CARE is directed to collect an assessment that is sufficient to meet, but not exceed, the anticipated cost of implementing the stewardship plan. In the approved California Carpet Stewardship Plan, the initial ($0.05) per square yard assessment was approved to remain through 2016. On December 28, 2014, CARE submitted and CalRecycle approved an addendum to its approved plan. This addendum provided justification for additional program incentives and enhancements to help CARE achieve compliance. CARE also requested an increase in the assessment from $0.05/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.10/square yard effective April 1, 2015. On November 30, 2015, CARE submitted an additional addendum to increase the assessment from $0.10/square yard of carpet sold in California to $0.20/square yard effective April 1, 2016. In October 2016, CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle that included an increase in the assessment to $0.25/square yard. CalRecycle disapproved that plan on December 23, 2016. The disapproval states that CARE is to continue operating under the previous plan until a new plan is approved by CalRecycle. On January 16, 2017, CalRecycle conditionally approved Addendum #3 of the plan, with specified modifications. The conditional approval includes increasing the assessment to $0.25/square yard.
CalRecycle found that the plan, "taken as a whole, does not ensure continuous meaningful improvement in carpet recycling and diversion in 2017 and beyond." According to CalRecycle, the plan focuses on existing subsidies that have not demonstrated increased recycling rates; moreover, CARE intends to "scale back" subsidy guarantees going forward. The plan does not address the possibility of providing subsidies to points in the supply chain that may result in significant increases in recycling, such as installer subsidies to increase diversion and recycling, funding for discounted drop-off fees, or subsidies for secondary manufacturers to use post-consumer nylon.
AB 2396 established administrative civil penalties of $1,000 per day ($10,000 for intentional, knowing, or negligent violations). In its disapproval of CARE's October 2016 plan, the director directed staff to delay enforcement action against carpet manufacturers, wholesalers, and retailers for 120 days, "provided the regulatory entity is participating in good faith in continuing to carry out the requirements of the law and CARE's existing plan."
CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle on February 20th, which was considered at CalRecycle's public meeting on April 18th. The plan specifies that with the $0.25/square yard assessment, it expects to collect $23.7 million in 2017. The plan identifies $1.7 million in reuse subsidy payments; $7.1 million in recycling processor payments; $11.1 million in manufacturer payments; just under $1 million in specified grants; and, $6.2 million in "program expenses," which includes $764,142 for CARE salaries and staffing. On April 21st, CalRecycle disapproved CARE's plan based upon a finding that the plan does not comply with statutory requirements. Without an approved plan in place, all manufacturers that sell carpet in California are subject to penalties until they are covered by an approved plan. Additionally, wholesalers and retailers are subject to penalties for selling carpet from non-compliant manufacturers. In order to preserve the recycling infrastructure and avoid market disruptions, CalRecycle authorized manufacturers, wholesalers, and retailers to continue to operate without penalties for 60 days. The director of CalRecycle directed staff to develop a draft plan to help CARE comply with state requirements; the draft plan was discussed at CalRecycle's public meeting on May 16, 2017.
On March 10, 2017, CalRecycle began an enforcement proceeding against CARE for failing to meet the requirement that the carpet stewardship organization is required to achieve "continuous and meaningful improvement in the rates of recycling and diversion of postconsumer carpet subject to its stewardship plan and in meeting the other goals included in the organization's plan." In spite of the significant amount of money collected by CARE from California consumers, CalRecycle found that CARE did not meet these requirements in 2013, 2014, and 2015. After each finding, CalRecycle provided CARE with recommendations on adjustments to the plan that would result in meaningful improvement; however, CARE has not incorporated CalRecycle's suggestions in any subsequent plans. CalRecycle is seeking a total of $3.285 million in penalties: $182,500 for 2013; $1.46 million for 2014; and, $1.6425 million for 2015.
On June 20, 2017, CalRecycle considered and adopted the final Enforcement Plan. Manufacturers may choose to stay with CARE or choose to submit their own stewardship plan. By October 19, 2017, each carpet manufacturer, individually or through a stewardship organization, is required to submit a plan to CalRecycle in order to avoid penalties under the Enforcement Plan.
In response to the ongoing enforcement, AB 1158 established an initial recycling rate of 24% for carpet, and allows CalRecycle to establish the rate beginning in 2023. The bill also prohibits the organization from expending funds generated by the fee on consumers for penalties imposed by CalRecycle, costs associated with litigation against the state, and incineration of carpet. AB 1158 codified an advisory committee to make recommendations to the organization on carpet stewardship plans.
On September 24, 2018, CARE submitted a revised plan to CalRecycle for approval. This plan was conditionally approved by the director at CalRecycle’s October 2018 public meeting, which required CARE to submit an additional revised plan within 60 days to address a number of recommendations regarding economic analysis, consumer convenience, incentivizing market development, and source reduction. On December 14, 2018, CARE submitted a new “Chapter 0” as an addendum to the plan to address the recommendations of CalRecycle. This plan was approved by the director on February 19, 2019, with additional requirements that must be implemented by September 2, 2019.
- This bill. This bill is intended to address a shortcoming that has been identified in the state’s product stewardship programs – what happens to the fee money collected from consumers if the organization is unable to continue program operations, either through an enforcement action by CalRecycle or if the organization is dissolved or unwilling to continue operations. Particularly given the complex enforcement history in this program, it is important that the state has a mechanism to oversee funds if CalRecycle does not grant additional extensions to CARE after the current September 1st deadline to preserve California’s carpet recycling infrastructure and protect California consumers.
According to the CARE Sustainable Funding Oversight Committee, as of February, CARE had a fund balance of approximately $15.5 million, with a reserve of $4.5 million. The author may wish to continue working with CalRecycle, CARE, and other stakeholders to ensure that setting aside a full year’s worth of program expenses (approximately $20 million) is feasible without increasing the consumer assessment or impacting the effectiveness of the program.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
7th Generation Advisors
ACR Solar
Alameda County Supervisor, Nate Miley
California Product Stewardship Council
California Refuse Recycling Council-Northern District
California Resource Recovery Association
Changing Markets Foundation
Clean Water Action
GAIA
Interface Americas, Inc.
National Stewardship Action Council
Plastic Pollution Coalition
Rethink Waste
Sea Hugger
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Center for Oceanic Awareness
UPSTREAM
Zero Waste Company
Opposition
Carpet & Rug Institute
Mohawk Industries, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):