AB 749: Settlement agreements: restraints in trade.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-12
Existing law provides that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is void to the extent that the contract restrains that person.
This bill would prohibit an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing a provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts a settling party that is an aggrieved person, as defined, from working for the employer against which the aggrieved person has filed a claim or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, or contractor of the employer.
The bill would also clarify that an employer and an aggrieved person are free to agree to end a current employment relationship, or to prohibit or otherwise restrict the aggrieved person from obtaining future employment with the employer, if the employer has made a good faith determination that the person engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault, as defined. The bill would further clarify that an employer is not required to continue to employ or rehire a person if there is a legitimate nondiscriminatory or nonretaliatory reason for terminating or refusing to rehire the person.
The bill would provide that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this prohibition is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(a)An agreement to settle an employment dispute shall not contain a provision prohibiting, preventing, or otherwise restricting a settling party that is an aggrieved person from obtaining future employment with the employer against which the aggrieved person has filed a claim, or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, or contractor of the employer. A provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(b)Nothing in subdivision (a) does any of the following:
(1)Preclude the employer and aggrieved person from making an agreement to do either of the following:
(A)End a current employment relationship.
(B)Prohibit or otherwise restrict the settling aggrieved person from obtaining future employment with the settling employer, if the employer has made a good faith determination that the person engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault.
(2)Require an employer to continue to employ or rehire a person if there is a legitimate non-discriminatory or non-retaliatory reason for terminating the employment relationship or refusing to rehire the person.
(c)For purposes of this section:
(1)Aggrieved person means a person who has filed a claim against the persons employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employers internal complaint process.
(2)Sexual assault means conduct that would constitute a crime under Section 243.3, 261, 262, 264.1, 286, 287, or 289 of the Penal Code, assault with the intent to commit any of those crimes, or an attempt to commit any of those crimes.
(3)Sexual harassment has the same meaning as in subdivision (j) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 12, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 808, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 5 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (June 25). |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 2, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (April 9). |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 5, 2019 | AB 749 Mark Stone Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB749 Mark Stone et al. By Durazo | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2019 | AB 749 Mark Stone Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 749
Author:(Mark Stone, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 15, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits settlement agreements that contain a provision that restricts an employee from working for the employer against which the employee has filed a claim, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits, and makes void, an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an "aggrieved person," as defined, from obtaining future employment with the employer against which a claim or action has been filed.
- Defines "aggrieved person" for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person's employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer's internal complaint process.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill would prohibit an employer and aggrieved employee from entering an agreement to end a current employment relationship.
- Permits no rehire agreements between employer and an aggrieved employee if the employer has made good faith determination that the aggrieved employee engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault, as defined.
- Clarifies that nothing in the bill requires an employer to continue to employ or rehire an employee if there is a legitimate reason for terminating the employment relationship or refusing to rehire the employee.
The Senate Amendments:
- Clarify that this bill only applies to agreements that restrict future employment and that nothing in the bill requires an employer to continue to employ or rehire an employee if there is a legitimate reason for terminating the relationship or refusing to rehire the employee.
- Permit settlement provisions that prohibit the employee from obtaining future employment if the employer has made a good faith determination that the aggrieved employee engaging in sexual harassment or sexual assault, as defined.
COMMENTS:
When employees settle claims against their employers, it is increasingly common for a settlement agreement to contain a "no rehire" provision. Sometimes these provisions prohibit an employee from working at any workplace owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the employer. Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. For example, in a much-publicized case involving allegations of sexual harassment at the California Department of Justice (DOJ), a woman accused a supervisor of sexual harassment and sued DOJ for tolerating a hostile work environment. The victim settled her dispute on the condition that she give up her job and never seek re-employment with the DOJ. The harasser remained on the job. In another example, a woman accused her male supervisor at the California Highway Patrol (CHP) of sexual harassment. Even though the harasser reportedly did not deny the conduct, CHP conditioned the settlement agreement on never seeking employment with CHP again, while the harassing supervisor continued his employment. (Sacramento Bee November 19, 2017, April 22, 2018.)
This bill would prohibit and make unenforceable a provision in a settlement agreement that prohibits an employee from obtaining future employment with the employer if the aggrieved employee, as defined, has filed a claim or civil action against the employer. As amended in the Senate, this bill clarifies that the bill does not prevent an employer and employee from mutually agreeing to terminate a current employment relationship. Recent amendments clarify that nothing in this bill requires an employer to continue an employment relationship or refuse to rehire an employee who has settled a dispute if there is a legitimate, nondiscriminatory and nonretaliatory reason for doing so. Finally, in response to claims that employers could expose themselves to liability if refused to rehire a perpetrator of sexual harassment, the bill now specifically authorizes no rehire agreements where the employer has made a good faith determination that the person engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault. In short, contrary to the claims of the opposition, nothing in this bill will prevent an employer from terminating an employee who engaged in wrongful conduct, and nothing in this bill would require an employer to rehire an employee "that the employer has already determined was unsuitable for the job." This bill merely follows the logic of a rule established by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) that prohibits no rehire agreements in claims settled by the EEOC, on the grounds that no rehire agreements are inherently retaliatory, because they punish employees for exercising their right to filing a claim against an employer.
According to the Author:
According to the author, recent coverage of sexual harassment in the workplace brings increased attention to so-called "no rehire" provisions in settlement agreements. "These provisions require employees who have the courage to give up their jobs and never to seek re-employment as a condition of settlement, even though they have done nothing wrong."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters state that this bill "would bring greater fairness to the settlement process by prohibiting any provision that restricts the ability of an 'aggrieved' employee to work for the employer. The bill will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor or employment law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute."
Arguments in Opposition:
Opponents state that this bill "would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer." The Chamber objects first to the broad definition of an "aggrieved" person as anyone who has "filed a claim against the employer in court, before an administrative agency, an alternative dispute forum, or an employer's internal complaint process." The Chamber also argues that this bill is unnecessary because the courts have already determined that excessively broad no-rehire provisions violate Business and Professions Code Section 16600.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 41-19-20
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Cervantes, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Maienschein, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Smith
SENATE FLOOR: 21-13-6
YES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Galgiani, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta, Dodd, Glazer, Hueso, Hurtado, Roth
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 15, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001486
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 749 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 749
Author: Mark Stone (D), Gonzalez (D) and Reyes (D), et al.
Amended: 8/15/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 6/25/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 41-19, 5/2/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Settlement agreements: restraints in trade
SOURCE: California Employment Lawyers Association
Equal Rights Advocates
DIGEST:
This bill voids no-rehire provisions in settlement agreements resolving employment disputes in which the worker filed an official complaint. This bill applies prospectively to any settlement agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/15/19 authorize the use of no-rehire provisions where the employer has made a good faith determination that the “aggrieved” worker engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault. The amendments also provide a definition for sexual harassment and sexual assault.
Existing law:
- Identifies certain types of contracts as unlawful or contrary to public policy and therefore void and unenforceable. (Civ. Code §§. 1667-1670.10.)
- Provides that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void, except as provided by statute. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.)
This bill:
- Prohibits an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an “aggrieved person,” as defined, from obtaining future employment with the employer against which a claim or action has been filed; and provides that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is against public policy and void as a matter of law.
- Defines “aggrieved person” for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person’s employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer’s internal complaint process.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill requires an employer to employ or rehire anyone where there is a legitimate, non-discriminatory and non-retaliatory reason for terminating the employment relationship or refusing to hire the person.
- Authorizes the use of a no-rehire provision where the employer has made a good faith determination that the “aggrieved” worker engaged in sexual harassment or sexual assault.
Comments
- No-rehire provisions. When there is a dispute between an employee and an employer, the employer will often demand, as a condition of settling the matter, that the employee agree not to seek work with the employer ever again. The employer’s motivation for demanding such a clause may be that the employer views the employee as problematic, but after all, the employer could also simply decline to rehire the employee. More often, the employer’s chief concern is that, if the employee applies for another position with the employer, and is denied, the employee will allege that this constitutes unlawful retaliation against the employee.
Yet a no-rehire clause can be seen as a form of retaliation, too, albeit one that the employee ostensibly accepts voluntarily in exchange for the settlement payment. Especially when the employer is a major player in the local economy, or the dominant company in the employee’s area of specialty, a no-rehire clause can have devastating professional and financial consequences for the employee. Not only does this hurt the individual employee who enters into the settlement; it also sends a message to co-workers about the professional consequences of speaking up about workplace abuses.
- Existing limitations on no-rehire clauses under California law. Existing California law does not ban no-rehire clauses altogether, as this bill will, but it does place certain limitations on their scope. California Business and Professions Code Section 16600 states that: “every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.”
In Golden v. Cal. Emergency Physicians Med. Group (Ninth Cir. 2015) 782 F.3d 1083, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to no-rehire provisions. In that case, a physician tried to back out of a settlement agreement with his former medical group when he considered the impact of a provision in the settlement that both barred him from continuing to work for the medical group and specified that he could be immediately fired from any other medical facility if his former medical group took over management of the facility.
In evaluating whether the physician should be bound by the settlement, the Golden court interpreted Business and Professions Code Section 16600 broadly to encompass not just agreements not to compete, but also terms like those in the settlement. In effect, the court held that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to “no-rehire” agreements that overly restrict a party’s ability to engage in their profession, trade, or business.
In prior cases, however, other courts have read the application of Business and Professions Code Section 16600 more narrowly. In the 2012 case Brown v. State Personnel Board (Jan. 27, 2012, No. F059897) 2012 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 676,[1] a California State University (CSU) police officer sued the school for sexual harassment by her supervisor. The matter settled on terms that required a significant payment to the officer, but also her eventual resignation and her agreement not to seek rehire within the CSU system thereafter. Later, the police officer sought to revoke her resignation and the question arose whether the no-rehire clause was legal under California law. California’s Court of Appeal for the Fifth District determined that it was, reasoning that the clause allowed the police officer to continue in her trade, albeit not with this particular employer. It should be noted that though the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court cases.
This bill forgoes drawing distinctions between no-rehire clauses that overly constrain workers and those that do not. Instead, this bill bans the use of no-rehire clauses altogether.
- Employers would retain the right to terminate or refuse to rehire for valid reasons; workers would retain the right to quit. The purpose behind this bill is to prevent settlement agreements from being used in a retaliatory fashion. It is not intended to prevent, and should not in practice prevent, employers from refusing to hire former employees for any valid, non-retaliatory reason.
Thus, even in the absence of a no-rehire clause, an employer would be under no obligation to reemploy someone it sincerely believes to be unfit for the job. The opposition’s statement that this bill “would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer,” while technically accurate, omits a critical detail: just because the former employee seeks future employment does not mean that the former employer has to rehire, or even interview the former employee, for the job.
Workers under this bill, for their part, would retain the right to quit their jobs at any point before or after settlement of the case. The only difference is that, under this bill, once a worker filed an official complaint regarding a workplace violation, the worker could still demand money to settle the claim, but would no longer be able to ask to get paid for agreeing never to try to come back.
In essence, then, all this bill does is take discussion about the possibility of future hiring off the table in settlement negotiations.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Employment Lawyers Association (co-source)
Equal Rights Advocates (co-source)
American Association of University Women – San Jose
American Association of University Women of California
American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California
California Women’s Law Center
California Work & Family Coalition
Child Care Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
Legal Aid at Work
National Council of Jewish Women, California
Voices for Progress
Women’s Foundation of California
YWCA San Francisco & Marin
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/19)
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California New Car Dealers Association
California Restaurant Association
California State Association of Counties - Excess Insurance Authority
Civil Justice Association of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
[…] AB 749 will bring greater fairness and clarity to existing law by voiding any settlement provision arising from an employment dispute if the provision restricts the ability of an “aggrieved” employee to work for the employer. The bill defines an “aggrieved” employee as one who has filed a claim against the employer, whether the employee filed the claim in court, with an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through an internal grievance procedure. In short, it will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute. An employer always retains the right to discharge an employee or refuse to re-hire an employee if there are valid grounds for doing so.
As sponsors of this bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association and Equal Rights Advocates write:
A troubling trend that our attorneys have witnessed in these negotiations, particularly in the wake of the #MeToo movement, is the increasingly common use of “no-rehire” provisions that employers impose as a condition of settling a dispute. Often, this bars workers from not only returning to their same employer, but from working at any workplace that is owned, operated, affiliated, or that contracts with the employer. […]
Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. Such clauses can therefore also dissuade employees from reporting workplace misconduct in the first place for fear of lasting repercussions on their careers.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 21 co-signatory business and trade associations write:
[AB 749’s] language fails to consider […] that many employees who have engaged in unlawful or egregious behavior often file complaints against their employers.
For example, in sexual harassment cases, it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation. […] [B]y simply filing a complaint of defamation through the employer’s internal complaint process, the alleged harasser would be protected under AB 749 and have the right to seek re-employment at the same workplace, with the same employee whom the individual harassed. […]
[E]xisting law already provides a limitation on the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements to the extent they impose a “restraint of a substantial character.” Completely banning the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements for any “aggrieved employee,” no matter how narrowly tailored, as proposed by AB 749, imposes unnecessary administrative burdens on an employer as well as potential litigation.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 41-19, 5/2/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Cervantes, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Maienschein, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Smith
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/21/19 10:08:10
It should be noted that the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 749 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 749
Author: Mark Stone (D), Gonzalez (D) and Reyes (D)
Amended: 6/27/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 6/25/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 41-19, 5/2/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Settlement agreements: restraints in trade
SOURCE: California Employment Lawyers Association
Equal Rights Advocates
DIGEST:
This bill voids no-rehire provisions in settlement agreements resolving employment disputes in which the worker filed an official complaint. This bill applies prospectively to any settlement agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020.
Existing law:
- Identifies certain types of contracts as unlawful or contrary to public policy and therefore void and unenforceable. (Civ. Code §§. 1667-1670.10.)
- Provides that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void, except as provided by statute. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.)
This bill:
- Prohibits an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an “aggrieved person,” as defined, from obtaining future employment with the employer against which a claim or action has been filed; and provides that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is against public policy and void as a matter of law.
- Defines “aggrieved person” for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person’s employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer’s internal complaint process.
- Clarifies that nothing in this bill requires an employer to employ or rehire anyone where there is a legitimate, non-discriminatory and non-retaliatory reason for terminating the employment relationship or refusing to hire the person.
Comments
- No-rehire provisions. When there is a dispute between an employee and an employer, the employer will often demand, as a condition of settling the matter, that the employee agree not to seek work with the employer ever again. The employer’s motivation for demanding such a clause may be that the employer views the employee as problematic, but after all, the employer could also simply decline to rehire the employee. More often, the employer’s chief concern is that, if the employee applies for another position with the employer, and is denied, the employee will allege that this constitutes unlawful retaliation against the employee.
Yet a no-rehire clause can be seen as a form of retaliation, too, albeit one that the employee ostensibly accepts voluntarily in exchange for the settlement payment. Especially when the employer is a major player in the local economy, or the dominant company in the employee’s area of specialty, a no-rehire clause can have devastating professional and financial consequences for the employee. Not only does this hurt the individual employee who enters into the settlement; it also sends a message to co-workers about the professional consequences of speaking up about workplace abuses.
- Examples of the problem this bill is intended to address. As evidence of the need for this bill, the author points to the following incidents:
- An employee at the California Department of Justice (DOJ), filed state and federal civil rights complaints alleging that her supervisor harassed her on the basis of her gender. Among other things, she alleged that the supervisor forced her to crawl under his desk to add paper to a printer the supervisor kept there, while he and others watched. According to media reports, the DOJ ultimately settled the case with the employee. She received $400,000 but had to agree, as part of the deal, to leave her job and never seek employment with the DOJ again.[1]
- An employee at the California Highway Patrol (CHP) filed civil rights claims after enduring sexual harassment at the hands of one of her supervisors. Among other things, the supervisor fondled her hair, sat in her lap, and may have tried to kiss her. Eventually, CHP settled the case with the employee for $600,000, but despite her desire to remain in her post, CHP insisted that she retire and agree not to seek reemployment as part of the settlement. The alleged perpetrator, meanwhile, continued to work for the state.[2]
- Existing limitations on no-rehire clauses under California law. Existing California law does not ban no-rehire clauses altogether, as this bill would, but it does place certain limitations on their scope. California Business and Professions Code Section 16600 states that: “every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.”
In Golden v. Cal. Emergency Physicians Med. Group (Ninth Cir. 2015) 782 F.3d 1083, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to no-rehire provisions. In that case, a physician tried to back out of a settlement agreement with his former medical group when he considered the impact of a provision in the settlement that both barred him from continuing to work for the medical group and specified that he could be immediately fired from any other medical facility if his former medical group took over management of the facility.
In evaluating whether the physician should be bound by the settlement, the Golden court interpreted Business and Professions Code Section 16600 broadly to encompass not just agreements not to compete, but also terms like those in the settlement. In effect, the court held that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to “no-rehire” agreements that overly restrict a party’s ability to engage in their profession, trade, or business.
In prior cases, however, other courts have read the application of Business and Professions Code Section 16600 more narrowly. In the 2012 case Brown v. State Personnel Board (Jan. 27, 2012, No. F059897) 2012 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 676,[3] a California State University (CSU) police officer sued the school for sexual harassment by her supervisor. The matter settled on terms that required a significant payment to the officer, but also her eventual resignation and her agreement not to seek rehire within the CSU system thereafter. Later, the police officer sought to revoke her resignation and the question arose whether the no-rehire clause was legal under California law. California’s Court of Appeal for the Fifth District determined that it was, reasoning that the clause allowed the police officer to continue in her trade, albeit not with this particular employer. It should be noted that though the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court cases.
This bill would forgo drawing distinctions between no-rehire clauses that overly constrain workers and those that do not. Instead, this bill bans the use of no-rehire clauses altogether.
- Federal regulatory guidance regarding no-rehire provisions. The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is charged with investigating complaints and enforcing federal law that prohibits workplace discrimination. Under certain circumstances, the EEOC will represent aggrieved parties or engage in mediation. In either capacity, the EEOC sometimes engages in trying to reach settlement agreements between the workers alleging discrimination and employers accused of allowing it. To guide its staff on what sort of settlement terms the EEOC believes are appropriate and which are not, the EEOC has issued a set of settlement standards. Under those standards, the EEOC refuses to permit the inclusion of no-rehire agreements in settlements. Specifically, the EEOC instructs its staff: “no individual can be required as a condition of obtaining relief on a Commission claim to agree to refrain from seeking future employment with the defendant.”[4] This policy presumably reflects the EEOC’s belief that, even though some federal courts might uphold them (see, e.g., Jencks v. Modern Woodmen of America (10th Cir. 2007) 479 F.3d 1261, 1265‐66 (affirming a lower court ruling that enforcement of an existing no-rehire clause was a legitimate, non-retaliatory basis for declining a former employee’s application)), at least as a matter of best practice, no-rehire provisions should not be included in settlement agreements.
- Employers would retain the right to terminate or refuse to rehire for valid reasons; workers would retain the right to quit. The purpose behind this bill is to prevent settlement agreements from being used in a retaliatory fashion. It is not intended to prevent, and should not in practice prevent, employers from refusing to hire former employees for any valid, non-retaliatory reason.
Thus, even in the absence of a no-rehire clause, an employer would be under no obligation to reemploy someone it sincerely believes to be unfit for the job. The opposition’s statement that the bill “would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer,” while technically accurate, omits a critical detail: just because the former employee seeks future employment does not mean that the former employer has to rehire, or even interview the former employee, for the job.
Workers under this bill, for their part, would retain the right to quit their jobs at any point before or after settlement of the case. The only difference is that, under this bill, once a worker filed an official complaint regarding a workplace violation, the worker could still demand money to settle the claim, but would no longer be able to ask to get paid for agreeing never to try to come back.
In essence, then, all the bill does is take discussion about the possibility of future hiring off the table in settlement negotiations.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Employment Lawyers Association (co-source)
Equal Rights Advocates (co-source)
American Association of University Women – San Jose
American Association of University Women of California
American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California
California Women’s Law Center
California Work & Family Coalition
Child Care Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
Legal Aid at Work
National Council of Jewish Women, California
Voices for Progress
Women’s Foundation of California
YWCA San Francisco & Marin
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/26/19)
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California New Car Dealers Association
California Restaurant Association
California State Association of Counties - Excess Insurance Authority
Civil Justice Association of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
[…] AB 749 will bring greater fairness and clarity to existing law by voiding any settlement provision arising from an employment dispute if the provision restricts the ability of an “aggrieved” employee to work for the employer. The bill defines an “aggrieved” employee as one who has filed a claim against the employer, whether the employee filed the claim in court, with an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through an internal grievance procedure. In short, it will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute. An employer always retains the right to discharge an employee or refuse to re-hire an employee if there are valid grounds for doing so.
As sponsors of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association and Equal Rights Advocates write:
A troubling trend that our attorneys have witnessed in these negotiations, particularly in the wake of the #MeToo movement, is the increasingly common use of “no-rehire” provisions that employers impose as a condition of settling a dispute. Often, this bars workers from not only returning to their same employer, but from working at any workplace that is owned, operated, affiliated, or that contracts with the employer. […]
Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. Such clauses can therefore also dissuade employees from reporting workplace misconduct in the first place for fear of lasting repercussions on their careers.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 21 co-signatory business and trade associations write:
[AB 749’s] language fails to consider […] that many employees who have engaged in unlawful or egregious behavior often file complaints against their employers.
For example, in sexual harassment cases, it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation. […] [B]y simply filing a complaint of defamation through the employer’s internal complaint process, the alleged harasser would be protected under AB 749 and have the right to seek re-employment at the same workplace, with the same employee whom the individual harassed. […]
[E]xisting law already provides a limitation on the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements to the extent they impose a “restraint of a substantial character.” Completely banning the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements for any “aggrieved employee,” no matter how narrowly tailored, as proposed by AB 749, imposes unnecessary administrative burdens on an employer as well as potential litigation.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 41-19, 5/2/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Cervantes, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Cristina Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Maienschein, Mullin, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Smith
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/28/19 12:04:44
Koseff, Kamala Harris Aide Resigns After Harassment, Retaliation Settlement Surfaces (Dec. 5, 2018) Sacramento Bee https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article222688740.html (as of Jun. 16, 2019). ↑
Lundstrom and Koseff, They Reported Sex Harassment in State Jobs and Found ‘Retaliation is Alive and Well’ (Nov. 20, 2017) Sacramento Bee https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article185439048.html (as of Jun. 16, 2019). ↑
It should be noted that the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court. ↑
Regional Attorneys’ Manual: Settlement Standards and Procedures (Apr. 2005) U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/litigation/manual/3-4-a_settlement_standards.cfm#section2d (as of Jun. 16, 2019) at Part 3(IV)(A)(2)(d). ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 749 (Author:Mark Stone)
Version: February 19, 2019
Hearing Date: June 25, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Settlement agreements: restraints in trade
DIGEST
This bill voids termination and no-rehire provisions in settlement agreements that resolve employment disputes in which the worker filed an official complaint. The bill would apply prospectively to any settlement agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In order to ensure that California employees feel safe coming forward to report legal violations in the workplace, state law strongly prohibits employers from retaliating against them. Among other things, an employer cannot fire an employee for filing a complaint about workplace violations and the employer cannot threaten that the employee will never work for the company again. However, if the employer achieves those same ends by including a termination provision and a no-rehire clause in a settlement agreement, it is generally permissible. In other words, through the terms of a settlement agreement, an employer can retaliate against an employee in ways that the law otherwise prohibits. This dynamic has a chilling effect on workers. The fact that it comes in the form of a settlement agreement makes little difference. What other workers observe is a pattern in which whoever steps forward to file a complaint leaves and can never come back. To address this problem, the current form of this bill effectively bans employers from settling an employment dispute on the condition that the worker leave and never come back, if the dispute involves an official complaint from the worker of workplace violations.
The bill is co-sponsored by the California Employment Lawyers Association and Equal Rights Advocates. Support is from worker and women’s rights advocates. Opposition comes from employer and business associations, who contend that termination and no-rehire clauses can be motivated by valid, non-retaliatory purposes and that existing law sufficiently limits no-rehire clauses so that workers who sign them are not kept out of their chosen business, trade, or profession.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Identifies certain types of contracts as unlawful or contrary to public policy and therefore void and unenforceable. (Civ. Code §§. 1667-1670.10.)
- Provides that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void, except as provided by statute. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 16600.)
This bill:
- Prohibits an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an “aggrieved person,” as defined, from working for the employer against which a claim or action has been filed; and provides that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is against public policy and void as a matter of law.
- Defines “aggrieved person” for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person’s employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer’s internal complaint process.
COMMENTS
- Background on no-rehire provisions
When there is a dispute between an employee and an employer, the employer will often demand, as a condition of settling the matter, that the employee agree not to seek work with the employer ever again. The employer’s motivation for demanding such a clause may be that the employer views the employee as problematic, but after all, the employer could also simply decline to rehire the employee. More often, the employer’s chief concern is that, if the employee applies for another position with the employer, and is denied, the employee will allege that this constitutes unlawful retaliation against the employee.
Yet a no-rehire clause can be seen as a form of retaliation, too, albeit one that the employee ostensibly accepts voluntarily in exchange for the settlement payment. Especially when the employer is a major player in the local economy, or the dominant company in the employee’s area of specialty, a no-rehire clause can have devastating professional and financial consequences for the employee. Not only does this hurt the individual employee who enters into the settlement; it also sends a message to co-workers about the professional consequences of speaking up about workplace abuses.
- The bill also bans conditioning a settlement on termination or resignation
Although much of the discussion around the bill has characterized it as a ban on no-rehire clauses, it is important to note that the bill in print does more than just prohibit settlement terms that bar former employees from applying for work in the future. Because the bill broadly prohibits settlement terms that prevent an aggrieved party from working for the employer against whom the claim was filed, it also bans settlement agreements conditioned on a current employee agreeing to resign or to be fired.
- Examples of the problem the bill is intended to address
As evidence of the need for this bill, the author points to the following incidents:
- An employee at the California Department of Justice (DOJ), filed state and federal civil rights complaints alleging that her supervisor harassed her on the basis of her gender. Among other things, she alleged that the supervisor forced her to crawl under his desk to add paper to a printer the supervisor kept there, while he and others watched. According to media reports, the DOJ ultimately settled the case with the employee. She received $400,000 but had to agree, as part of the deal, to leave her job and never seek employment with the DOJ again.[1]
- An employee at the California Highway Patrol (CHP) filed civil rights claims after enduring sexual harassment at the hands of one of her supervisors. Among other things, the supervisor fondled her hair, sat in her lap, and may have tried to kiss her. Eventually, CHP settled the case with the employee for $600,000, but despite her desire to remain in her post, CHP insisted that she retire and agree not to seek reemployment as part of the settlement. The alleged perpetrator, meanwhile, continued to work for the state.[2]
4. Existing limitations on no-rehire clauses under California law
Existing California law does not ban no-rehire clauses altogether, as this bill would, but it does place certain limitations on their scope. California Business and Professions Code Section 16600 states that: “every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void.”
In Golden v. Cal. Emergency Physicians Med. Group (Ninth Cir. 2015) 782 F.3d 1083, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit ruled that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to no-rehire provisions. In that case, a physician tried to back out of a settlement agreement with his former medical group when he considered the impact of a provision in the settlement that both barred him from continuing to work for the medical group and specified that he could be immediately fired from any other medical facility if his former medical group took over management of the facility.
In evaluating whether the physician should be bound by the settlement, the Golden court interpreted Business and Professions Code Section 16600 broadly to encompass not just agreements not to compete, but also terms like those in the settlement. In effect, the court held that Business and Professions Code Section 16600 applies to “no-rehire” agreements that overly restrict a party’s ability to engage in their profession, trade, or business.
In prior cases, however, other courts have read the application of Business and Professions Code Section 16600 more narrowly. In the 2012 case Brown v. State Personnel Board (Jan. 27, 2012, No. F059897) 2012 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 676,[3] a California State University (CSU) police officer sued the school for sexual harassment by her supervisor. The matter settled on terms that required a significant payment to the officer, but also her eventual resignation and her agreement not to seek rehire within the CSU system thereafter. Later, the police officer sought to revoke her resignation and the question arose whether the no-rehire clause was legal under California law. California’s Court of Appeal for the Fifth District determined that it was, reasoning that the clause allowed the police officer to continue in her trade, albeit not with this particular employer. It should be noted that though the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court cases.
This bill would forgo drawing distinctions between no-rehire clauses that overly constrain workers and those that do not. Instead, the bill would ban the use of no-rehire clauses altogether.
5. Federal regulatory guidance regarding no-rehire provisions
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) is charged with investigating complaints and enforcing federal law that prohibits workplace discrimination. Under certain circumstances, the EEOC will represent aggrieved parties or engage in mediation. In either capacity, the EEOC sometimes engages in trying to reach settlement agreements between the workers alleging discrimination and employers accused of allowing it. To guide its staff on what sort of settlement terms the EEOC believes are appropriate and which are not, the EEOC has issued a set of settlement standards. Under those standards, the EEOC refuses to permit the inclusion of no-rehire agreements in settlements. Specifically, the EEOC instructs its staff: “no individual can be required as a condition of obtaining relief on a Commission claim to agree to refrain from seeking future employment with the defendant.”[4] This policy presumably reflects the EEOC’s belief that, even though some federal courts might uphold them (see, e.g., Jencks v. Modern Woodmen of America (10th Cir. 2007) 479 F.3d 1261, 1265‐66 (affirming a lower court ruling that enforcement of an existing no-rehire clause was a legitimate, non-retaliatory basis for declining a former employee’s application)), at least as a matter of best practice, no-rehire provisions should not be included in settlement agreements.
6. Employers would retain the right to terminate or refuse to rehire for valid reasons; workers would retain the right to quit
The purpose behind this bill is to prevent settlement agreements from being used in a retaliatory fashion. It is not intended to prevent, and should not in practice prevent, employers from terminating current employees or refusing to hire former employees for any valid, non-retaliatory reason.
Thus, if an employer has legitimate reasons to be dissatisfied with a worker’s performance, even though that worker filed an allegation regarding workplace violations, the employer would still be able to fire that person at any point, either before or after settling the alleged violation. Of course, the employee might challenge whether the employer’s motivations were sincere, but so long as the employer did indeed have valid, non-retaliatory grounds for the termination, the employer should prevail against such a challenge. Similarly, even in the absence of a no-rehire clause, an employer would be under no obligation to reemploy someone it sincerely believes to be unfit for the job. Thus, the opposition’s statement that the bill “would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer,” while technically accurate, omits a critical detail: just because the former employee seeks future employment does not mean that the former employer has to rehire, or even interview the former employee, for the job.
Workers under this bill, for their part, would retain the right to quit their jobs at any point before or after settlement of the case. The only difference is that, under this bill, once a worker filed an official complaint regarding a workplace violation, the worker could still demand money to settle the claim, but would no longer be able to ask to get paid for leaving the job or agreeing never to try to come back.
In essence, then, all the bill would do is take discussion about termination, resignation, and the possibility of future hiring off the table in settlement negotiations. Employers would not be able to use settlement to get rid of employees that have come forward with allegations of workplace wrongdoing, and employees would not be able to try to get paid just to go away.
For this reason, the opponents of the bill may mischaracterize its potential impact when they assert that it could protect perpetrators of sexual harassment from getting fired. It is true that a particularly devious and/or legally savvy perpetrator could file a claim regarding a workplace violation and would then be protected against being fired as part of a settlement agreement, but nothing would stop the employer from firing the perpetrator outside of a settlement agreement. In other words, under the bill, the employer could still make the perpetrator go away, but the employer could no longer pay the perpetrator to go away.
7. Possible policy tradeoff in the bill in print
Conditioning settlement of an employment dispute in which the worker has alleged workplace violations on the worker’s agreement to leave and never come back can be used in a retaliatory fashion. This bill would have the salutary effect of preventing settlements from being used nefariously in that way. In achieving that positive outcome, however, the bill would also foreclose the use of settlement agreements as pathway out of thorny employment situations; a pathway that is often advantageous for employers but that can even be convenient for workers sometimes as well.
Consider the following scenario, variations on which sometimes crop up in workplaces. An employee is performing poorly or behaves in ways that irritate customers or co-workers. The supervisor is overly lenient, conflict-averse, or just sloppy about documenting these concerns, so there is not much of a record to reflect them. At some point, the employee files a claim alleging that a co-worker is harassing the employee. Tensions flare around the workplace as a result. The employer investigates the allegation. The evidence is inconclusive or maybe it even suggest that the employee’s claim is without merit. The employer knows that if it fires the employee in that moment, that termination will look retaliatory, even though many of the concerns pre-date the employee’s complaint. If the employee sued for retaliation, the employer might ultimately prevail, but there is no guarantee of that and there would be considerable legal costs and workplace disruption from the lawsuit regardless. The employer also knows that if it does not respond to the complaint of harassment by disciplining the alleged perpetrator, the employee alleging the harassment is likely to pursue the claim of harassment further. Here again, the employer might ultimately prevail against such a claim, but there will be legal costs to the defense, it will divert time away from the employer’s business, and, in the meantime, the inter-personal dynamics around the workplace may remain toxic.
As the law stands today, an employer faced with this dilemma could offer to reach a deal with the employee who made the complaint: we will pay you something that helps you to get by while you seek other work or engage in other pursuits; we may even give you a neutral reference you can present to prospective employers. You agree to drop your claim; to resign; and not to seek further employment with us. The employee might feel this offer was retaliatory, in which case the employee could reject it and take a righteous stand. On the other hand, such an agreement might have advantages for the employee. Of course the employee never wanted to be harassed in the first place and is entitled to work in a harassment-free environment. At the same time, the employee may always have wanted to get away from that workplace anyhow, but could never afford to do so financially. Now, with the proceeds from the settlement payment, the employee is finally free to move on.
This bill would foreclose such a pathway to resolving thorny employment disputes, at least in the case of disputes in which the employee has filed an official complaint at some level. The employer could still pay a current employee to settle a claim about a workplace violation, but would not have any assurance that doing so would address tensions in the workplace or shed them of an employee that perhaps they should have let go earlier. Employees could still demand payment of damages for what they believe they wrongfully endured and then quit upon receiving the money, but such an outcome would probably be less likely to occur because the employer could no longer obtain assurance that the employee would leave as part of the bargain.
One of the key policy questions presented by the bill in print is whether the virtues of preventing settlement agreements from being used in a retaliatory fashion outweigh the loss of what can also sometimes be a useful tool for resolving difficult workplace disputes.
The author and sponsors indicate that the intention behind the bill is not to foreclose the possibility of settlement agreements that enable truly willing parties to go their separate ways when that is beneficial to all involved. Their primary aim is to eliminate the punitive, retaliatory use of settlement agreements, and, in particular, the inclusion of no-rehire provisions. Accordingly, the author proposes to offer amendments in Committee that would maintain the prohibition on no-rehire agreements while giving employers and employees flexibility to reach settlement agreements that include an end to the employment relationship when that outcome is appropriate.
8. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill that would:
- allow settlement agreements that result in the end of the aggrieved party’s employment relationship with the employer while maintaining the ban on provisions that prohibit aggrieved parties from ever applying to work for their former employer again; and
- clarify that the absence of a no-rehire provision in a settlement does not require an employer to rehire an aggrieved employee if the employer has legitimate, non-retaliatory and non-discriminatory reasons not to do so.
A mock-up of the amendments in context is attached to this analysis.
9. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
[…] AB 749 will bring greater fairness and clarity to existing law by voiding any settlement provision arising from an employment dispute if the provision restricts the ability of an “aggrieved” employee to work for the employer. The bill defines an “aggrieved” employee as one who has filed a claim against the employer, whether the employee filed the claim in court, with an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through an internal grievance procedure. In short, it will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute. An employer always retains the right to discharge an employee or refuse to re-hire an employee if there are valid grounds for doing so.
As sponsors of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association and Equal Rights Advocates write:
Our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and other forms of discrimination and workplace abuse in settlement negotiations. A troubling trend that our attorneys have witnessed in these negotiations, particularly in the wake of the #MeToo movement, is the increasingly common use of “no-rehire” provisions that employers impose as a condition of settling a dispute. Often, this bars workers from not only returning to their same employer, but from working at any workplace that is owned, operated, affiliated, or that contracts with the employer. […]
Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. Such clauses can therefore also dissuade employees from reporting workplace misconduct in the first place for fear of lasting repercussions on their careers.
In support, the California Women’s Law Center writes:
“No-rehire” clauses punish victims by barring them from returning to their employer as well as from working anywhere owned, operated or affiliated with that employer. In many cases, such provisions impose a substantial burden on an employee’s ability to practice a chosen occupation or career. These retaliatory provisions dissuade employees from reporting workplace misconduct out of fear of being penalized for doing so. AB 749 would bring greater fairness to the settlement process by prohibiting any provision that restricts the ability of an employee who is a victim of alleged discrimination, harassment or other labor employment law violation, to continue to work for that employer.
10. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 21 co-signatory business and trade associations write:
[AB 749’s] language fails to consider […] that many employees who have engaged in unlawful or egregious behavior often file complaints against their employers.
For example, in sexual harassment cases, it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation. […] [B]y simply filing a complaint of defamation through the employer’s internal complaint process, the alleged harasser would be protected under AB 749 and have the right to seek re-employment at the same workplace, with the same employee whom the individual harassed. […]
[E]xisting law already provides a limitation on the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements to the extent they impose a “restraint of a substantial character.” Completely banning the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements for any “aggrieved employee,” no matter how narrowly tailored, as proposed by AB 749, imposes unnecessary administrative burdens on an employer as well as potential litigation.
SUPPORT
California Employment Lawyers Association (sponsor)
Equal Rights Advocates (sponsor)
American Association of University Women of California
American Association of University Women – San Jose
American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California
California Women’s Law Center
California Work & Family Coalition
Child Care Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
Legal Aid at Work
National Council of Jewish Women, California
Voices for Progress
YWCA San Francisco & Marin
OPPOSITION
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Apartment Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California New Car Dealers Association
California Restaurant Association
California State Association of Counties - Excess Insurance Authority
Civil Justice Association of California
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending: None known
Prior: AB 3109 (Mark Stone, Ch. 949, Stats. 2018) ultimately prohibited settlements from including terms preventing the parties from testifying about the settled dispute in administrative, legislative, or judicial proceedings. An earlier version of AB 3109 would also have restricted the circumstances in which no-rehire clauses could be included in a settlement agreement.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 41, Noes 19)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
**************
Amended Mock-up for 2019-2020 AB-749 (Mark Stone (A) , Gonzalez (A) , Reyes (A))
Mock-up based on Version Number 99 - Introduced 2/19/19
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Chapter 3.6 (commencing with Section 1002.5) is added to Title 14 of Part 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:
CHAPTER 3.6. Agreements Settling Employment Disputes
1002.5. (a) An agreement to settle an employment dispute shall not contain a provision prohibiting, preventing, or otherwise restricting a settling party that is an aggrieved person from working for the obtaining future employment with the defendant employer against which the aggrieved person has filed a claim, or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, or contractor of the employer. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude the employer and aggrieved person from making an agreement to end a current employment relationship. A provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is void as a matter of law and public policy.
(b) Nothing in subdivision (a) shall require an employer to continue to employ or rehire a person where there is a legitimate non-discriminatory or non-retaliatory reason for terminating the employment relationship or refusing to rehire the person.
(bc) For purposes of this section, “aggrieved person” means a person who has filed a claim against the person’s employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer’s internal complaint process.
Koseff, Kamala Harris Aide Resigns After Harassment, Retaliation Settlement Surfaces (Dec. 5, 2018) Sacramento Bee https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article222688740.html (as of Jun. 16, 2019). ↑
Lundstrom and Koseff, They Reported Sex Harassment in State Jobs and Found ‘Retaliation is Alive and Well’ (Nov. 20, 2017) Sacramento Bee https://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/capitol-alert/article185439048.html (as of Jun. 16, 2019). ↑
It should be noted that the court’s ruling in Brown is unpublished and could not be cited as precedent in court. ↑
Regional Attorneys’ Manual: Settlement Standards and Procedures (Apr. 2005) U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/litigation/manual/3-4-a_settlement_standards.cfm#section2d (as of Jun. 16, 2019) at Part 3(IV)(A)(2)(d). ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 749
Author:(Mark Stone, et al.)
As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits settlement agreements that contain a provision that restricts an employee from working for the employer against which the employee has filed a claim, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an "aggrieved person," as defined, from working for the employer against which a claim or action has been filed; and provides that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Defines "aggrieved person" for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person's employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer's internal complaint process.
COMMENTS:
When employees settle claims against their employers, it is increasingly common for a settlement agreement to contain a "no rehire" provision. Sometimes these provisions bar workers from not only returning to their same employer, but also from working at any workplace owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the employer. Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. For example, in a much-publicized case involving allegations of sexual harassment at the California Department of Justice (DOJ), a woman accused a supervisor of sexual harassment and sued the DOJ for tolerating a hostile work environment. The victim settled her dispute with DOJ on the condition that she give up her job and never seek re-employment with the DOJ. The harasser remained on the job. In another example, a woman accused her male supervisor at the California Highway Patrol (CHP) of sexual harassment. Even though the harasser reportedly did not deny the conduct, CHP conditioned the settlement agreement on the victim giving up her job, while the harassing supervisor continued his employment. (Sacramento Bee November 19, 2017, April 22, 2018.)
This bill would prohibit no-rehire provisions in an agreement to settle an employment dispute where an aggrieved employee, as defined, has made a complaint, filed a claim, or initiated a civil action against the employer.
Contrary to the claims of opponents, this bill would not prohibit an employer from getting rid of employees who engage in unlawful or egregious conduct, including sexual harassment. They claim, for example, "that it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation," or for an employee who is fired for stealing from an employer to allege wrongful termination. Even if we assume that such suits are "common," an employer can lawfully fire or refuse to rehire that employee, with or without a no-rehire provision. Indeed, the opposition's own words make the point. As the California Chamber of Commerce argues, "to the extent that the employer has valid evidence that supports the lawful basis for the termination, the employer should be able to prevent the re-hire of the same employee that the employer already determined was unsuitable for the job." The author and co-sponsors agree. Employers unquestionably have the right to terminate an employee if there is "valid evidence that supports the lawful basis for the termination."
Moreover, with or without a no-rehire agreement, an employer has no duty to rehire an employee "that the employer has already determined was unsuitable for the job." If the disgruntled bad-actor employee sues the employer for wrongful termination, and the employer has evidence to support that prior termination, there is certainly no reason that the employer must rehire that employee. In short, nothing in this bill will prevent an employer from terminating an employee who engaged in wrongful conduct, and nothing in this bill would require an employer to rehire an employee "that the employer has already determined was unsuitable for the job."
According to the Author:
According to the author, recent coverage of sexual harassment in the workplace brings increased attention to so-called "no rehire" provisions in settlement agreements. These provisions require employees to give up their jobs and never to seek re-employment as a condition of settlement, even though they have done nothing wrong. Making matters worse, the employee who has been a victim of discrimination or sexual harassment is too often the one who must leave, while the perpetrator stays on the job. The analysis describes, for example, the California State University (CSU), Fresno police officer who was sexually harassed by her supervisor. She not only gave up her job at Fresno; the settlement prevented her from applying at any CSU campus. Of course, the harassing supervisor continued his employment. This bill will prohibit no-rehire provisions in agreements to settle employment disputes where the employee has filed a complaint or initiated a civil action against the employer.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters state that this bill "would bring greater fairness to the settlement process by prohibiting any provision that restricts the ability of an 'aggrieved' employee to work for the employer. The bill defines an 'aggrieved' employee as one who has filed a claim against the employer. Therefore, it will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor or employment law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute."
Arguments in Opposition:
Opponents state that this bill "would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer." The Chamber objects first to the broad definition of an "aggrieved" person as anyone who has "filed a claim against the employer in court, before an administrative agency, an alternative dispute forum, or an employer's internal complaint process." The Chamber believes that this language "fails to consider, however, that many employees who have engaged in unlawful or egregious behavior often file complaints against their employers." The Chamber also argues that this bill is unnecessary because the courts have already determined that excessively broad no-rehire provisions violate Business and Professions Code Section 16600.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 19, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000177
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 749
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
SUBJECT: Settlement agreements: restraints in trade
KEY ISSUE: Should a settlement agreement that imposes a “No-hire” provision on an aggrieved employee, as defined, be prohibited and unenforceable as against public policy?
SYNOPSIS
Recent coverage of sexual harassment in the workplace has brought increased attention to so-called “no rehire” provisions in settlement agreements. These provisions often require victimized employees to give up their jobs and never re-apply for employment with the employer. In too many cases, a victim of harassment, for example, can no longer work at the place where the harassment occurred, while the harasser continues to work there. Making matters worse, when the employer dominates a particular type of employment in a particular area – such as the state government or the state university system – no-rehire provisions sometimes place a substantial restraint upon a victim's ability to continue a chosen occupation or profession. For example, after a CSU Fresno police officer brought an action alleging sexual harassment by her supervisor, a no-rehire provision in a settlement agreement prevented her from seeking employment as a police officer anywhere in the CSU system, not just at CSU Fresno. The harassing supervisor continued working at the CSU system. The victimized officer accepted the arrangement because she felt she had no choice.
This bill would prohibit a no-rehire provision in an agreement to settle an employment dispute where an aggrieved employee, as defined, has made a complaint, filed a claim, or initiated a civil action against the employer. While some argue that such provisions are fair because the employee “agrees” to the provision as part of the settlement, there are too many instances where victims of harassment or discrimination would prefer to keep their jobs, but feel they must accept the no-rehire provision or forgo any settlement. If no-rehire provisions were “off the table” when negotiating a settlement, an employee could not be forced to accept such a provision as a condition of settlement. If the employee no longer wished to continue working at the place where the harassment occurred, the employee could simply choose to quit after obtaining the settlement.
Co-sponsored by the California Employment Lawyers Association and Equal Rights Advocates, AB 749 has the support of many labor, consumer, and women’s groups. The California Chamber of Commerce, writing on behalf of several business and employer associations, opposes this measure.
SUMMARY: Prohibits settlement agreements that contain a provision that restricts an employee from working for the employer against which the employee has filed a claim, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing any provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts an “aggrieved person,” as defined, from working for the employer against which a claim or action has been filed; and provides that a provision in an agreement entered into on or after January 1, 2020, that violates this section is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Defines “aggrieved person” for purposes of the above to mean a person who has filed a claim against the person’s employer in court, before an administrative agency, in an alternative dispute resolution forum, or through the employer’s internal complaint process.
EXISTING LAW:
- Identifies certain types of contracts as unlawful or contrary to public policy and therefore void and enforceable. (Civil Code Sections 1667 to 1670.10.)
- Provides that every contract by which anyone is restrained from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business of any kind is to that extent void, except as provided by statute. (Business & Professions Code Section 16600.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: When employees settle employment claims against their employers, it is increasingly common for a settlement agreement to contain a “no rehire” provision. Indeed, according to the sponsors of this bill, such agreements are becoming more common (and nearly automatic) in settlement agreements between employers and employees. Sometimes these provisions bar workers from not only returning to their same employer, but also from working at any workplace owned by, operated by, or affiliated with the employer. In many cases, especially with a large employer, such provisions impose a very substantial burden on the employee’s ability to practice a chosen occupation or career. For example, the settlement of a claim by a campus police officer who alleged sexual harassment by her supervisor at CSU Fresno required her to agree never to seek employment at any CSU campus. Likewise, a hospital’s settlement agreement with an emergency room doctor who filed a racial discrimination claim prevented him from seeking employment in any emergency room that the employer owned or contracted with, including any that it might own or contract with in the future. Such provisions are especially egregious when – as discussed below – they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job.
This bill would prohibit a no-rehire provisions in an agreement to settle an employment dispute where an aggrieved employee, as defined, has made a complaint, filed a claim, or initiated a civil action against the employer. While some argue that such provisions are fair because the employee “agrees” to the provision as part of the settlement, there are too many instances where victims of harassment or discrimination would prefer to keep their jobs, but feel they must accept the provision or forgo any settlement. If no-rehire provisions were “off the table” when negotiating a settlement, an employee could not be forced to accept such a provision as a condition of settlement. If the employee no longer wished to continue working at the place where the harassment occurred, the employee could simply choose to quit after obtaining the settlement.
Existing Restrictions on No-Rehire Provisions: Business & Professions Code Section 16600 voids any contract that prohibits a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business. The California Supreme Court finds that this statute “evinces settled legislative policy in favor of open competition and employee mobility.” (Edwards v. Arthur Anderson LLP (2008) 44 Cal. 4th 937.) In Golden v. CEP Medical Group (2018) 896 F.3d 1018, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeal held that Section 16600 prohibits enforcement of any settlement agreement that imposes a “substantial restriction” on a person’s ability to practice a lawful occupation. Prior to Golden, some courts held that Section 16600 only applied to “no compete” clauses that employees sometimes sign when leaving employment. The Golden decision made it clear that Section 16600 also limits no-rehire provisions in settlement agreements. Opponents of this bill claim that Section 16600, as interpreted in Golden, already provides sufficient protection for workers by voiding any provision that creates a “substantial restriction.” Unfortunately, the appellate courts do not always agree on what constitutes a “substantial” restriction on a person’s right to pursue a lawful calling. For example, the appellate court in Golden struck down a truly sweeping no-rehire provision that prevented an emergency room physician (who had filed a discrimination claim against his medical group) from working in any hospital owned by the medical group, or even with a hospital that it might own or contract with in the future. Unfortunately, in Brown v. State Personnel Board (2012), a California appellate court upheld a no-rehire provision that prevented a CSU Fresno police officer who had filed a sexual harassment claim from working at any of the twenty-three CSU campuses. According to the author, this bill will remove this ambiguity by eliminating no-rehire clauses whenever they prevent an employee from working for an employer merely because the employee brought a claim against the employer.
Recent Examples of Punitive and Arguably Retaliatory No-Rehire Provisions. While the no-rehire provisions in the Golden and Brown decisions were breathtaking in scope, even no rehire provisions that only restrict an aggrieved employee from working for a single employer at a single location can unfairly punish the victim of harassment, discrimination, or some other wrongdoing, especially in a case where the victim wants to continue working. For example, in a much-publicized case involving allegations of sexual harassment at the California Department of Justice (DOJ), a woman accused a supervisor of sexual harassment and sued the DOJ for tolerating a hostile work environment. According to reports in the Sacramento Bee, the victim settled her dispute with DOJ, but only on the condition that she give up her job and never seek re-employment with the DOJ. In another example, Carmyn Fields accused her male supervisor at the California Highway Patrol (CHP) of sexual harassment. Even though the harasser reportedly did not deny the conduct, CHP conditioned the settlement agreement on Field’s agreement to give up her job and not seek reemployment. While opponents of this bill contend that employees freely agree to no-rehire provisions and even use them to negotiate higher settlements, this was certainly not the experience of Ms. Fields, who told the Sacramento Bee, “I didn’t feel I had a choice in the matter . . . I was done, I was beat up.” (Sacramento Bee November 19, 2017, April 22, 2018.)
Although there is no federal legislation directly addressing this subject, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has developed guidelines that recommend the approach taken by this bill. That is, EEOC guidelines prohibit the use of no-rehire provisions in settlement agreements in any actions seeking relief from the EEOC. The EEOC’s reasoning for this position is that no-rehire provisions are essentially retaliatory, because they deny continued employment to any employee who had the temerity to file a complaint against the employer. (For EEOC guideline and a summary of its policy, see https://www.eeoc.gov/eeoc/litigation/manual/3-4-a_settlement_standards.cfm#section2d.)
Will AB 749 prevent an employer from terminating an employee who engaged in wrongful conduct? Opponents of AB 749 contend that this bill would prohibit an employer from ridding itself of employees who engage in unlawful or egregious conduct, including sexual harassment. Opponents claim, for example, “that it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation,” or for an employee who is fired for stealing from an employer to allege wrongful termination. Even if we assume that such suits are as “common” as the opposition claims, an employer can lawfully fire or refuse to rehire that employee, with or without a no-rehire provision. Indeed, the opposition’s own words make the point. As the Chamber reasonably argues in its letter of opposition, “to the extent that the employer has valid evidence that supports the lawful basis for the termination, the employer should be able to prevent the re-hire of the same employee that the employer already determined was unsuitable for the job.” The author and co-sponsors would likely agree. Employers unquestionably have the right to terminate an employee if there is “valid evidence that supports the lawful basis for the termination.”
Moreover, with or without a no-rehire agreement, an employer has no duty to rehire an employee “that the employer has already determined was unsuitable for the job.” If the disgruntled bad-actor employee sues the employer for wrongful termination, and the employer has evidence to support that prior termination, there is certainly no reason that the employer must rehire that employee. In short, nothing in this bill will prevent an employer from terminating an employee who engaged in wrongful conduct, and nothing in this bill would require an employer to rehire an employee “that the employer has already determined was unsuitable for the job.” If the opponents assume that this bill will encourage a bad-actor employee who has suffered some adverse action to file a claim, their own letter of opposition suggests that bad-actor employees do not need any encouragement, as the letter claims that they already commonly do this without this bill. What this bill will do, however, is ensure that employees who have been the victims of someone else’s wrongdoing will be allowed to continue their employment if they so choose.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Employment Lawyers Association (CELA) and Equal Rights Advocates (ERA), the co-sponsors of AB 749, write that their attorneys “often represent victims of sexual harassment and other forms of discrimination and workplace abuse in settlement negotiations. A troubling trend that our attorneys have witnessed in these negotiations, particularly in the wake of the #MeToo movement, is the increasingly common use of ‘no rehire’ provisions that employers impose as a condition of settling a dispute.” CELA and ERA contend that in many cases, “especially with a large employer, such provisions impose a very substantial burden on the employee’s ability to practice a chosen occupation or career . . . Such provisions are especially egregious when they require the victim of discrimination or sexual harassment to forgo continuing employment, while the offender remains in the job. Such clauses can therefore also dissuade employees from reporting workplace misconduct in the first place for fear of lasting repercussions on their careers.”
CELA and ERA add, the “only law that currently addresses restrictions on future employment is Business & Professions Code Section 16600, which voids any contract that prohibits a person from engaging in a lawful profession, trade, or business. The California Supreme Court has found that this statute ‘evinces settled legislative policy in favor of open competition and employee mobility.’ (Edwards v. Arthur Anderson LLP (2008).” However, CELA and ERA point out that “this pro-competition law is not specific to no rehire clauses in settlement agreements and the appellate courts have been inconsistent in determining what constitutes a ‘substantial’ restriction on a person’s right to pursue a lawful calling.”
CELA and ERA conclude, “AB 749 would bring greater fairness to the settlement process by prohibiting any provision that restricts the ability of an ‘aggrieved’ employee to work for the employer. The bill defines an ‘aggrieved’ employee as one who has filed a claim against the employer. Therefore, it will only protect employees who are victims of alleged discrimination, harassment, or other labor or employment law violations. It will not protect the perpetrators of wrongful acts that give rise to an employment dispute.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Chamber of Commerce, writing on behalf of itself and several other business and employer organizations, opposes AB 749 primarily because they believe “it would preclude an employer from prohibiting an employee that has engaged in unlawful or egregious conduct, from seeking future employment with the same employer.” The Chamber objects first to the broad definition of an “aggrieved” person as anyone who has “filed a claim against the employer in court, before an administrative agency, an alternative dispute forum, or an employer’s internal complaint process.” The Chamber believes that this language “fails to consider, however, that many employees who have engaged in unlawful or egregious behavior often file complaints against their employers.” For example, the Chamber claims, “in sexual harassment cases, it is not uncommon for the alleged harasser to file a complaint against an employer for defamation. . . [Therefore by] simply filing a complaint of defamation through the employer’s internal complaint process, the alleged harasser would be protected under AB 749 and have the right to seek re-employment at the same workplace, with the same employee whom the individual harassed.” The Chamber claims that it is also “common” for employees charged with other forms of wrongful conduct (e.g. theft) to claim “defamation or wrongful termination.” The Chamber believes that employers would not be likely to settle with such employees if they could not impose a no-rehire provision.
The Chamber also argues that this bill is unnecessary because the courts have already determined that a no-rehire provision must be narrowly tailored to avoid violating Business and Professions Code Section 16600, citing Golden v. California Emergency Physicians Medical Group, 896 F.3d 1018 (9th Cir. 2018). “Accordingly,” the Chamber concludes, “existing law already provides a limitation on the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements to the extent they impose a ‘restraint of a substantial character. Completely banning the use of no re-hire provisions in settlement agreements for any ‘aggrieved employee, no matter how narrowly tailored, as proposed by AB 749, imposes unnecessary administrative burdens on an employer as well as potential litigation.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Employment Lawyers Association (co-sponsor)
Equal Rights Advocates (co-sponsor)
ACLU of Northern California
California Women’s Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
National Council of Jewish Women, California
Opposition
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California League of Food Producers
California New Car Dealers Association
California Restaurant Association
Civil Justice Association of California
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):