AB 751: Pupil assessments: Pathways to College Act.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-18
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 25, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 28, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (March 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB751 O'Donnell et al. By Wiener | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2019 | AB 751 O'Donnell Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 751
Author:(O'Donnell)
As Enrolled Ver:September 18, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes the Pathways to College Act, which requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local educational agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC).
Major Provisions
Requires the SPI to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may administer in lieu of the SBAC in grade 11, commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
- Authorizes an LEA to administer an alternative assessment instead of the SBAC only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA’s governing board or body at a public meeting. Includes additional requirements of an LEA that administers an alternative assessment.
Governor's Veto Message:
This bill would establish the Pathways to College Act and require the Superintendent of Public Instruction to approve nationally recognized high school assessments that a local education agency may administer in place of the state-sponsored high school summative assessment, Smarter Balanced, beginning with the 2020-21 school year.
Encouraging student access to college and reducing the student testing burden in high school are laudable goals. However, I am concerned that replacing the state's high school assessment with the Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) or American College Test (ACT) will have the opposite effect. Specifically, their use exacerbates the inequities for underrepresented students, given that performance on these tests is highly correlated with race and parental income, and is not the best predictor for college success.
It is important to remember that over the last several years California has made great strides towards establishing a coherent accountability system. Measuring how students throughout the state perform on our state's assessments, including the grade 11 assessment, provides critical information to students, families, educators, and our state
Finally, our K-12 system and public universities continue to discuss the potential for using of California's grade 11 state assessment for college admissions or eligibility purposes in the future. This would be a better approach to improving access to college for underrepresented students and reducing 'testing fatigue.'
COMMENTS:
The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3, inclusive, and grade 11. SBAC scores are used as part of the state's accountability system, which uses SBAC scores along with other state and local performance measures to evaluate school and district performance. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment.
There are 45 school districts in California that have been administering either the American College Test (ACT) or Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) during the regular school day in addition to the SBAC in 11th grade. The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), authorizes states to approve a nationally recognized high school assessment that LEAs may administer in lieu of the existing statewide assessment (which is the SBAC for California), provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Consistent with federal and state law, this bill requires the alternative assessment to provide appropriate accommodations for English learners (EL) and special education students, including students eligible under both the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Special education students would be allowed to take the California Alternative Assessment if their individualized education plan (IEP) provides for it.
According to the Author:
"In an effort to increase college-attendance rates, approximately 45 school districts, including Long Beach Unified School District (USD), Fresno USD, Oakland USD, Paramount USD, San Jose USD, and Sacramento City USD administer college entrance exams to 11th grade pupils free of charge during the school day. This bill will enable the state to take advantage of a federal option to meet accountability requirements using an alternative assessment while removing a barrier to college attendance for students who may not otherwise have access to the exam or take it on their own. This bill is about equity and opportunity."
Arguments in Support:
The Association of California School Administrators states, "If more students are able to take a college admissions test during the school day, more underrepresented students can be connected directly to scholarships and college application fee waivers—removing their historic barriers to higher education. This bill results in leveling the playing field because the SAT and ACT offer free, personalized test practice and other resources to students of all means, no matter where they’re from or how much their parents make. AB 751 also ensures that students with exceptional needs are appropriately accommodated and requires English learners to be provided appropriate accommodations, including access to testing instructions in their primary language, bilingual glossaries and extended testing time."
Arguments in Opposition:
The Education Trust-West states, "If enacted, this bill would pave the way for districts to replace the 11th grade CAASPP assessment with either the SAT or the ACT. Doing so would undermine fairness in our high schools in three ways: 1) it would weaken our K-12 accountability system—which is built upon an assumption that all schools and districts are measured against the same standards; 2) it would limit accessibility for English learners and students with disabilities and hinder their ability to fully demonstrate their knowledge and skills; and 3) it would reinforce and expand the use of the SAT and ACT at a time when we should be reassessing these tools for bias and fraud."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee,
- Potential one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of about $1.5 million for California Department of Education (CDE) to contract for validation of the assessments to ensure they meet certain federal requirements. This cost assumes CDE must go through a process to validate the alternative assessments for federal accountability purposes; however, it is unclear whether this process is necessary because the assessments have already been approved by the federal government for use by other states.
- If the assessments meet federal requirements, as outlined in 1), one-time General Fund (GF) costs of about $400,000 for the CDE to amend the state plan required by federal law to include information about the assessments, hire staff to produce technical guides, add the new assessment to the state’s accountability system, communicate with LEAs on the alternative assessment options and respond to LEA questions.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 GF or GF costs of costs of about $600,000 for various activities related to the alternative assessments, such as hiring staff to review and monitor LEAs’ use of the assessments, provide guidance to LEAs and monitor the assessment’s inclusion in the state’s accountability system. To the extent activities are performed by CDE staff, they would be supported using GF. If the CDE were to contract out activities, they likely would be supported using Proposition 98 GF. (CDE generally does not receive Proposition 98 GF for its state operations, but typically uses Proposition 98 GF to contract out activities.)
- Cost pressures to LEAs that elect to administer the alternative assessment in lieu of the SBAC assessment. The cost to a school district to administer an alternative assessment is about $45 per student, significantly more than the $4 per student they now receive to administer the SBAC assessment.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 6-0-0
YES: O'Donnell, Kiley, Kalra, McCarty, Smith, Weber
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0-5
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk‑Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kamlager-Dove, Ting
SENATE FLOOR: 38-2-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Glazer, Wieckowski
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 18, 2019
CONSULTANT: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0002560
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 751 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 751
Introduced: 2/19/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 6-1, 6/19/19
AYES: Leyva, Wilk, Chang, Durazo, McGuire, Pan
NOES: Glazer
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/28/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Pupil assessments: Pathways to College Act
SOURCE: Association of California School Administrators
California School Boards Association
DIGEST:
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local education agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC), commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress, which consists of, among other exams, the SBAC, which assesses English language arts and mathematics, and requires the SBAC to be administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11. (Education Code § 60640)
This bill requires the SPI to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC, commencing with the 2021-22 school year. Specifically, this bill:
1) Requires the SPI, pursuant to authority granted to the state pursuant to the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act, to approve, within 30 days after the SPI determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment satisfies specified requirements, one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a LEA may administer at its own discretion, commencing with the 2020–21 school year, in lieu of the SBAC.
2) Requires a nationally recognized high school assessment approved by the SPI to meet all of the following requirements:
a) Align with the academic content standards adopted by the State Board of Education (SBE) and address the depth and breadth of those standards.
b) Be at least as rigorous as the consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics for grade 11 that measures content standards adopted by the SBE, as required by the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress.
c) Satisfy federal regulations to ensure appropriate accommodations for English learners and pupils with disabilities, including pupils identified pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
d) Produce valid and reliable data on pupil academic achievement with respect to all high school pupils and each subgroup of high school pupils in the LEA.
e) Produce disaggregated scores based on English proficiency status, gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic disadvantage, foster care status, and special education designation.
f) Produce individual pupil scores that can be linked to scores from the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress assessments.
g) Ensure that the use of appropriate accommodations by a pupil with disabilities or an English learner does not deny the opportunity of any pupil to participate in the assessment or deny any pupil of any benefit from participating in the assessment that is afforded to pupils without disabilities or pupils who are not English learners.
h) Satisfy the peer review requirements specified by federal law.
3) Authorizes the SPI to require a publisher of a nationally recognized high school assessment that is being considered for approval to provide documentation that the assessment meets or exceeds the requirements of 2) above.
4) Requires the SPI, if he or she determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment being considered for approval does not meet the requirements of 2) above, to inform the publisher of the assessment in writing of the specific deficiencies and changes needed to meet those requirements.
5) Requires the SPI, to the extent permitted by the U.S. Department of Education, to approve any nationally recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by any state that has adopted the Common Core State Standards and that meets applicable federal requirements under the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act.
6) Authorizes an LEA to administer an approved assessment instead of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment, only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA’s governing board or body at a public meeting.
7) Requires the state board of education, before a LEA may administer the assessment, to amend the state plan required pursuant to federal law to account for the authorization, if required by federal law.
8) Requires an LEA that administers a nationally recognized high school assessment to do all of the following:
a) Notify the SPI, and the parents and legal guardians of its pupils entering grade 11, at the beginning of each school year during which the assessment will be administered to those pupils, that it will be administering an assessment that is different from 11th grade SBAC.
b) Administer the assessment free of charge to all pupils in grade 11, except for those pupils who opt out, as authorized by law.
c) Administer the assessment to individuals with exceptional needs with appropriate accommodations, where necessary, and provide an alternate assessment to individuals with exceptional needs who are unable to participate in testing, even with accommodations.
d) Administer the assessment to English learner pupils with appropriate accommodations, where necessary. To the extent permissible under federal law, recently arrived English learner pupils shall be exempt from taking the alternative assessment in English language arts.
e) Report scores and pupil participation data to the California Department of Education (CDE) in a manner prescribed by the SPI.
9) Requires the SPI to apportion to an LEA that administers an approved nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the 11th grade SBAC, the lesser of the following:
a) The actual cost of administering the nationally recognized high school assessment, including, but not necessarily limited to, administering and scoring the assessment and reporting results of the assessment to the SPI.
b) The amount that would have been apportioned to the LEA if it had administered 11th grade SBAC.
10) Authorizes an LEA to administer only one nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC, but does not prohibit an LEA that does not administer such an assessment from administering one or more assessments in addition to the grade 11 SBAC.
11) Defines an “LEA” to mean a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
12) Requires the CDE to ensure that LEAs comply with each of the following requirements if they administer nationally recognized high school assessment, which are also applicable to the 11th grade SBAC:
a) That the test be administered to all pupils.
b) That the individual results of each student be reported, in writing, to the parent or guardian of the pupil. The report is required to include a clear explanation of the purpose of the test, the score of the student, and the intended use by the LEA of the test score.
c) That state agencies and LEAs do not use a comparison resulting from the scores and results of the test and the assessment scores and results from assessments that measured previously adopted content standards (STAR Testing).
d) That valid individual student results also be reported to the school and teachers of a student, and that LEA include the test results of a pupil in his or her student records.
e) That the districtwide and school-level results of the test, but not the score or relative position of any individually ascertainable student, be reported to the governing board of the school district at a regularly scheduled meeting, and the countywide, school-level, and grade-level results for classes and programs under the jurisdiction of the county office of education shall be similarly reported to the county board of education at a regularly scheduled meeting.
f) That the aggregated, disaggregated, or group scores or reports not be publicly reported to any party other than the school or LEA where the students were tested, if the aggregated, disaggregated, or group scores or reports are comprised of 10 or fewer individual student assessment results.
g) That students in grade 11, or parents or legal guardians of those students, may request results from the test for the purpose of determining credit, placement, or readiness for college-level coursework be released to a postsecondary educational institution.
13) Authorizes the governing board of an LEA that is part of a consortium of LEAs to enter into a cooperative contract with a publisher for the purposes of providing a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC.
14) Authorizes an LEA to choose to administer a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC to utilize the terms of a contract with a publisher that has been entered into with another district for purposes of providing the assessment.
15) Requires the SPI to prepare and submit, and subsequently post on the Internet Web site of the department, an annual report to the state board containing an analysis of the results and test scores of the test.
16) Makes its provisions inoperative five years after the first school year in which a LEA is able to exercise the authority granted to it by the SPI, and requires the SPI to inform the Legislative Counsel within 30 days of when those conditions have been satisfied, and to post that determination on the department’s Internet Web site.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “In an effort to increase college-attendance rates, over 45 school districts, including Long Beach Unified School District (LBUSD), Fresno USD, Oakland USD, Sacramento City USD, and San Jose USD are administering an alternative assessment, such as the SAT or ACT, during the school day for free to 11th grade students, in addition to administering the Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBAC). This bill allows, for five years, local educational agencies (LEAs) to administer the SAT or ACT in lieu of the SBAC. The bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessment that meets specified criteria, including that the assessment is consistent with our state standards, is a statistically reliable and a valid norm-referenced or criterion-referenced test, and will produce valid and reliable data on pupil academic achievement. LEAs that choose to administer an alternative assessment must first receive approval at a local governing board meeting, administer the assessment to all 11th grade students, offer the assessment for free, and ensure that students with disabilities and English learners have accommodations.”
2) Grade 11 SBAC. According to The Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium, the SBAC “is a valid, fair, and reliable approach to student assessment that provides educators, students and parents meaningful results with actionable data to help students succeed.” Its assessment system is aligned to the Common Core State Standards, which serve as the basis for California’s academic content standards. The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English and language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11, and is untimed, with an average of 7.5 hours to complete the exam. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment.
The SBAC’s summative assessments “determine students’ progress toward college and career readiness in English language arts/literacy and math. These are given at the end of the school year and consist of two parts: a computer adaptive test and a performance task. The summative assessments:
a) Accurately describe both student achievement (how much students know at the end of the year) and student growth (how much students have improved since the previous year) to inform program evaluation and school, district, and state accountability systems.
b) Include writing at every grade and ask students to solve multi-step, real-world problems in mathematics.
c) Capitalize on the strengths of computer adaptive testing: efficient and precise measurement with a quick turnaround of results.
3) The Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT). The SAT is a commonly administered college admissions exams.
The SAT includes a Reading Test, Writing and Language Test, and a Math Test. There is also an option SAT Essay. According to the College Board, “In the Reading Test, students will encounter questions like those asked in a lively, thoughtful, evidence-based discussion.” The Reading Test measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. The Writing and Language Test asks students “to be an editor and improve passages that were written especially for the test—and that include deliberate errors.” The Writing and Language Test also measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. Finally, the Math Test “covers a range of math practices, with an emphasis on problem solving, modeling, using tools strategically, and using algebraic structure.” The Math Test measures fluency, conceptual understanding, and applications. The redesigned SAT Essay “asks you to use your reading, analysis, and writing skills.” The SAT is a timed, paper exam.
4) The American College Test (ACT). According to the ACT, The ACT Exam “test scores reflect what students have learned throughout high school and provide colleges and universities with excellent information for recruiting, advising, placement, and retention.” The ACT contains four multiple-choice tests—English, mathematics, reading, and science—and an optional writing test. According to ACT, “these tests are designed to measure skills that are most important for success in postsecondary education and that are acquired in secondary education. The ACT English test measures understanding of the conventions of standard English, production of writing, and knowledge of language. The ACT mathematics test assesses the skills students typically acquire in courses taken through grade 11.
“The ACT reading test measures reading comprehension. The ACT science test measures the interpretation, analysis, evaluation, reasoning, and problem-solving skills required in the natural sciences. The optional ACT writing test is an essay test that measures writing skills taught in high school English classes and entry level college composition courses.” The ACT is a timed, paper exam.
5) Long Beach Unified School District’s (LBUSD) waiver request. LBUSD submitted a letter to the president of the SBE on January 17, 2017, requesting a waiver to permit the district to administer the SAT instead of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment for the 2016-17 school year. The district received a reply jointly signed by the SPI and the SBE president stating that the statutory provisions requiring the administration of all CAASPP assessments are not waivable. LBUSD submitted another waiver request for the 2017-18 school year and was again denied.
6) Federal authorization for alternate assessment. Federal law, the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), authorizes states to approve a nationally recognized high school assessment that LEAs may administer in lieu of the existing state-wide assessment (which is the Smarter Balanced Assessment for California), provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Federal regulations define "nationally recognized high school assessment" to mean "an assessment of high school students' knowledge and skills that is administered in multiple States and is recognized by institutions of higher education in those or other States for the purposes of entrance or placement into courses in postsecondary education or training programs." ESSA gives states discretion in offering this flexibility, but requires states to first establish that the approved alternative assessment meets certain requirements, all of which are incorporated into this bill by reference and, in some cases, explicitly.
7) SBAC and Accountability. SBAC scores are used as part of the state's accountability system, in particular the school dashboard, which uses SBAC scores along with other state and local performance measures to evaluate school and district performance. According to the California Department of Education, the Academic Indicator “is based on performance on the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments for English Language Arts/Literacy (ELA) and mathematics—which is administered to students in grades three through eight and grade eleven—and how far the average student is from meeting the grade-level standard, or the ‘Distance from Standard’ (DFS). To calculate the DFS, each student's score is first compared to the “Standard Met” threshold for that grade level on the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments. Then, all distance results are averaged to produce a school- and student-group-level average scale score (the DFS). The results will show the needed improvement to bring the average student score to “Standard Met” or the extent to which the average student score meets or exceeds ‘Standard Met’. Using scale scores, rather than reporting on the percent of students who performed at or above the “Standard Met”, provides a more comprehensive picture of how all students at the school are performing on the Smarter Balanced assessments.
It should be noted that the SPI and the President of the State Board of Education, in their October 31, 2017 letter to LBUSD denying its waiver request for the 2016-17 school year, they stated that federal law “mandates that the Stated Educational Agency State Plan require all local educational agencies (LEAs) to administer the same academic assessment to measure student achievement for the purpose of accountability. Each LEA must assure that it will comply with the State Plan irrespective of Title I participation. LBUSD’s intent to offer a different assessment, in lieu of the state’s designated assessment, will put it out of compliance with federal law as it pertains to assessment and accountability. In addition, if an LEA does not give the grade eleven Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC), it will negatively impact its College/Career Indicator in the California School Dashboard.” However, this bill requires the State Board of Education to amend the state plan to account for the authorization for local educational agencies to use an alternate assessment pursuant to this section, if required by federal law, before a local educational agency may administer an assessment in lieu of the SBAC.
8) Peer Review. As noted above, one of the requirements to use an alternate assessment is that the assessment must go through a federally mandated peer review process to ensure that it satisfies all of the federal requirements identified above. As stated in a U.S. Department of Education (USDOE) letter to State Assessment Directors, dated May 15, 2017, “the state must establish the criteria and undertake its review of the nationally recognized high school assessment before it may offer the opportunity for an LEA to select that assessment… Prior to any LEA use of nationally recognized assessment in lieu of Statewide assessments, States must submit evidence to the Department demonstrating that any such assessment meets the peer review requirements under section 1111(a)(4) of the ESEA and receive feedback that the nationally recognize assessment meets or substantially meets the requirements in the state and regulations.”
This bill explicitly requires the state to undertake the peer review process before the Superintendent approves one or more nationally recognized high school assessments.
However, this bill does contain a provision that requires the state to substitute another state’s peer review process for its own if the other state has approved a nationally recognized high school assessment, that the state has adopted the common core state standards, and it meets the federal requirements identified above, if the U.S. Department of Education allows the state to do so. However, as noted in a letter to State Assessment Directors from the USDOE dated May 15, 2017, the U.S. Department of Education stated that the “Department recognizes that it may have conducted a peer review of a nationally recognized high school test prior to a State selecting that test for this flexibility. In such a case, the State may be able to leverage the prior peer review for submission of the nationally recognized high school test. However, a prior peer review of a particular nationally recognized national assessment that resulted in a determination that such assessment met or substantially met peer review requirements relative to a State’s challenging academic standards may not mean that assessment would meet the requirements for another state. For example, if two states have different challenging academic standards, a single assessment may not adequately address both sets of standards.”
According to the author, “other states, including Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Michigan, and Wisconsin have received approval from the U.S. Department of Education to administer the SAT or ACT for federal accountability purposes, in place of a state adopted assessment program. North Dakota received permission to give districts choice to administer the ACT.” Of the states identified by the author, only North Dakota has not adopted common core. According to a survey conducted by EdWeek, 24 states, plus the District of Colombia, require students to take either the SAT or the ACT. It appears that approximately 17 of those states use only the SAT or the ACT.
9) Alignment between SAT/ACT and state standards. This bill requires that the nationally recognized high school assessment approved by the Superintendent to be aligned with the academic content standards adopted by the State Board of Education and to address the depth and breadth of those standards. As previously noted, California’s English language arts and mathematics academic content standards are based on the Common Core State Standards (CCSS). As noted in the Assembly Education Committee’s analysis, California is one of 15 states that administer the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments (SBAC), although according to Education Week, only eight states administer the SBAC in grade 11. All of these states have adopted the CCSS, but all of these states have also modified those standards to meet local needs and priorities. However, the SBAC does not differ from state to state. This means there will always be some amount of "misalignment" between the SBAC and each state's content standards, and the areas of misalignment will vary from state to state. The same will hold true for an alternative test, which federal law requires to be a test that is offered in multiple states. However, the College Board, which publishes the SAT, indicates that studies have shown that the alignment between the SAT and the CCSS is comparable to the alignment between the SBAC and the CCSS.
Conversely, a March 2018 brief from Achieve states: “In 2017, Achieve conducted an independent alignment study of the ACT with the Common Core State Standards. Achieve used an evaluation approach adapted from a methodology based on the Council of Chief State School Officers’ (CCSSO) Criteria for Procuring and Evaluating Large Scale Assessments. Overall, Achieve’s review of the ACT found significant weaknesses across both English language arts (comprising the Reading, Writing, and Essay tests) and mathematics for both content and depth. In ELA, fewer than 50 percent of items reviewed were judged to be aligned to the claimed Common Core State Standards. For example, many items that claimed to measure writing standards did not ask students to produce writing, as indicated in the state’s content standards. The ACT emphasized some aspects of reading text critically and language skills as well as real-world activities, but did not require students to demonstrate their abilities to write in different modes (argumentative, expository/nonfiction, and narrative), use text-based evidence in support of their writing, or focus on the vocabulary words most appropriate to high school. In mathematics, fewer than half of items on the assessment were judged to be aligned to the claimed Common Core mathematical content standards for high school. This finding, while low, may be less surprising given that ACT, in its technical documentation, indicates that 40-43 percent of mathematics items are designed to measure pre-8th grade mathematics content.”
However, the LBUSD has been administering the SAT and the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments (SBAC) to 11th graders for several years. According to information provided by the author's office, "The LBUSD found that pupil performance on the SAT correlates almost identically with the performance on the CAASPP assessment." Specifically, the same percentage (49 percent) of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on both English language arts tests, while 28 percent of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on the SBAC math, compared with 29 percent on the SAT math test. Additionally, A study by Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE) found that the SAT and SBAC are equally predictive of first- and second-year college grade point averages. This study compared the effectiveness of three assessments—high school grade point average (HSGPA), the SAT, and the SBAC—in predicting how well California State University students do in their first and second years of college. HSGPA is a better predictor than either the SAT or the SBAC in predicting first- and second-year college GPAs, and the SAT and SBAC are similar, "if not identical," predictors. This is an indication that the SAT and SBAC measure very similar academic achievement levels and abilities.
10) Shifting attitudes toward college admissions tests. The University of California (UC) has formed the Standardized Testing Task Force to evaluate “whether the University and its students are best served by our current testing practices, a modification of our current practices, another testing approach altogether, or perhaps even no testing at all. The goal of the Task Force is to develop recommendations for implementation in UC undergraduate admissions…”
Related/Prior Legislation
ACR 64 (McCarty, 2019) resolves that the Trustees of the California State University and the Regents of the UC are requested to conduct a study on the usefulness, effectiveness, and need for the SAT and ACT to determine student admissions, and that the study should include recommendations and, if determined necessary, a plan for phasing out the use of the SAT and ACT as a basis for admission. ACR 64 is pending on the Senate Floor.
AB 1951 (O’Donnell, 2018) was identical to this bill and was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated:
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local school may administer in lieu of the state-administered high school summative assessment, commencing with the 2019-20 school year.
Since 2010, California has eliminated standardized testing in grades 9 and 10 and the high school exit exam. While I applaud the author's efforts to improve student access to college and reduce ‘testing fatigue’ in grade 11, I am not convinced that replacing the state's high school assessment with the Scholastic Aptitude Test or American College Test achieves that goal.
Our K-12 system and our public universities are now discussing the possible future use of California's grade 11 state assessment for college admission purposes. This is a better approach to improving access to college for under-represented students and reducing ‘testing fatigue’.
AB 1602 (O’Donnell, 2017) would have established the Alternative Grade 11 Assessment Pilot Program to allow participating districts to administer an assessment other than the grade 11 SBAC. AB 1602 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- CDE estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $543,000 beginning in the 2019-20 fiscal year, $893,000 in 2020-21, and up to $1.3 million in 2021-22 to comply with this bill. These costs assume various activities necessary to conduct a peer review process that is required by federal law. These costs also assume workload to redesign and analyze the state’s existing accountability system to integrate the new assessments.
- By requiring LEAs to accept the lesser of the cost of administering the SAT or ACT or the amount that would have been apportioned to the LEA had it administered the SBAC, this bill essentially allows LEAs to continue to receive the current apportionment amount of $4 per student. The cost to administer the SAT or ACT is significantly more than this amount ($45 per student) so LEAs would need to absorb the additional costs within existing resources if they elect to administer these assessments. According to CDE, currently there are LEAs representing about 20 percent of 11th grade enrollment that administer the SAT or ACT to all students in 11th grade or support using the test as an alternative to the SBAC.
- The CDE does not believe there will be any contract savings to the state even if all 11th graders took the SAT or ACT in lieu of the SBAC since the state’s existing contract with the test vendor is capped at one million students. CDE indicates that last year more than 3.3 million students were tested, and the vendor would still have to administer, score, analyze and report the assessments for students in grades three through eight even if this measure were to pass. The state’s current annual contract amount with the vendor is $9.55 million.
Association of California School Administrators (co-source)
California School Boards Association (co-source)
AVID Center
California Association of Latino Superintendents and Administrators
California Association of Student Councils
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California Federation of Teachers
Central Valley Education Coalition
Corona Norco Unified School District
Long Beach Unified School District
Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District
Oakland Unified School District
Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Sacramento City Unified School District
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools
San Diego Unified School District
San Francisco Unified School District
San Jose Unified School District
Small School Districts Association
Torrance Unified School District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Alliance for a Better Community
California Association for Bilingual Education
California Community Colleges Chancellor's Office
California Latino School Board Association
Californians for Justice
Californians Together
Campaign for College Opportunity
Canal Alliance
Career Ladders Project
City of Oakland
Community Coalition
Equal Justice Society
Faith in The Valley
Go Public Schools
Just Equations
Kid City Hope Place
Latino and Latina Roundtable of the San Gabriel and Pomona Valley
Los Angeles United Methodist Urban Foundation
Miller Advocacy Group
National Center for Fair & Open Testing
Parent Organizing Network
Parent Revolution
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Southern California College Access Network
Stockton Schools Initiative
Student Senate for California Community Colleges
The Desertsong Group
The Education Trust - West
The Opportunity Institute
The Village Method
University of California Student Association
Youth Policy Institute
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 75-0, 5/28/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Kamlager-Dove, Ting
Prepared by: Brandon Darnell / ED. /
9/1/19 10:04:01
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 751 (O'Donnell) - Pupil assessments: Pathways to College Act
Version: February 19, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 6 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local education agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment, commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Department of Education (CDE) estimates ongoing General Fund costs of $543,000 beginning in the 2019-20 fiscal year, $893,000 in 2020-21, and up to $1.3 million in 2021-22 to comply with this measure. These costs assume various activities necessary to conduct a peer review process that is required by federal law. These costs also assume workload to redesign and analyze the state’s existing accountability system to integrate the new assessments.
- By requiring LEAs to accept the lesser of the cost of administering the SAT or ACT or the amount that would have been apportioned to the LEA had it administered the SBAC, this bill would essentially allow LEAs to continue to receive the current apportionment amount of $4 per student. The cost to administer the SAT or ACT is significantly more than this amount ($45 per student) so LEAs would need to absorb the additional costs within existing resources if they elect to administer these assessments. According to CDE, currently there are LEAs representing about 20 percent of 11th grade enrollment that administer the SAT or ACT to all students in 11th grade or support using the test as an alternative to the SBAC.
- The CDE does not believe there will be any contract savings to the state even if all 11th graders took the SAT or ACT in lieu of the SBAC since the state’s existing contract with the test vendor is capped at 1 million students. CDE indicates that last year more than 3.3 million students were tested, and the vendor would still have to administer, score, analyze and report the assessments for students in grades three through eight even if this measure were to pass. The state’s current annual contract amount with the vendor is $9.55 million.
Background:
Existing law establishes the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP), which consists of the following assessments:
- The Smarter Balanced Assessments Consortium (SBAC), which assesses English language arts and mathematics.
- The California Alternative Assessment, which may be administered only to special education students as required by their Individualized Education Program.
- The California Science Tests, which will be field tested in the spring on 2018.
Existing law requires the SBAC to be administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11. Its assessment system is aligned to the Common Core State Standards, which serve as the basis for California’s academic content standards. The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English and language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11, and is untimed, with an average of 7.5 hours to complete the exam. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment.
The SBAC’s summative assessments “determine students’ progress toward college and career readiness in English language arts/literacy and math. These are given at the end of the school year and consist of two parts: a computer adaptive test and a performance task.
The SAT and ACT are commonly administered college admissions exams. The SAT includes a Reading Test, Writing and Language Test, and a Math Test. There is also an option SAT Essay. According to the College Board, “In the Reading Test, students will encounter questions like those asked in a lively, thoughtful, evidence-based discussion.” The Reading Test measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. The Writing and Language Test asks students “to be an editor and improve passages that were written especially for the test—and that include deliberate errors.” The Writing and Language Test also measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. Finally, the Math Test “covers a range of math practices, with an emphasis on problem solving, modeling, using tools strategically, and using algebraic structure.” The Math Test measures fluency, conceptual understanding, and applications. The redesigned SAT Essay “asks you to use your reading, analysis, and writing skills.” The SAT is a timed, paper exam.
The ACT Exam test scores reflect what students have learned throughout high school and provide colleges and universities with excellent information for recruiting, advising, placement, and retention.” The ACT contains four multiple-choice tests—English, mathematics, reading, and science—and an optional writing test. According to ACT, “these tests are designed to measure skills that are most important for success in postsecondary education and that are acquired in secondary education. The ACT English test measures understanding of the conventions of standard English, production of writing, and knowledge of language. The ACT mathematics test assesses the skills students typically acquire in courses taken through grade 11.
The ACT reading test measures reading comprehension. The ACT science test measures the interpretation, analysis, evaluation, reasoning, and problem-solving skills required in the natural sciences. The optional ACT writing test is an essay test that measures writing skills taught in high school English classes and entry level college composition courses.” The ACT is a timed, paper exam.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires the SPI, pursuant to authority granted to the state pursuant to the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act, to approve, no later than 30 days after determining a nationally recognized high school assessment satisfies specified requirements, one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may administer at its own discretion, commencing with the 2021–22 school year, in lieu of the consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics for grade 11 that measures content standards adopted by the State Board of Education (SBE), as required by the CAASPP.
This bill requires a nationally recognized high school assessment approved by the SPI to meet specified requirements, including that the assessment align with the academic content standards adopted by the SBE and address the depth and breadth of those standards and be at least as rigorous as the consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics for grade 11 that measures content standards adopted by the SBE, as required by the CAASPP. It shall also satisfy federal regulations to ensure appropriate accommodations for English learners and pupils with disabilities, including pupils identified pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, and satisfy the peer review requirements pursuant to federal law, as specified.
Other provisions of the bill would:
- Authorize the SPI to require a publisher of a nationally recognized high school assessment that is being considered for approval to provide documentation that the assessment meets or exceeds these requirements.
- Require the SPI, if he or she determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment being considered approval does not meet the requirements, to inform the publisher of the assessment in writing of the specific deficiencies and changes needed to meet those requirements.
- Require the SPI to approve any nationally recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by any state that has adopted the Common Core State Standards and that meets applicable federal requirements under the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act only to the extent permitted by the United States Department of Education.
- Authorize an LEA to administer an approved assessment instead of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment, only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA’s governing board or body at a public meeting. Before an LEA may administer this assessment, the State Board of Education shall amend the state plan to account for this authorization, as specified.
- Specify requirements for an LEA that administers a nationally recognized high school assessment, including notifying the SPI and the parents and legal guardians of its pupils entering grade 11, at the beginning of each school year during which the assessment will be administered to those pupils, that it will be administering an assessment that is different from 11th grade Smarter Balanced Assessment and administering the assessment free of charge to all pupils in grade 11, except for those pupils who opt out, as authorized by law.
- Require the SPI to apportion to an LEA that administers an approved nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the 11th grade Smarter Balanced Assessment, the lesser of the actual cost of administering the nationally recognized high school assessment, including, but not necessarily limited to, administering and scoring the assessment and reporting results of the assessment to the SPI and the amount that would have been apportioned to the local education agency if it had administered 11th grade Smarter Balanced Assessment.
- Authorize an LEA to administer only one nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment, but not prohibit an LEA that does not administer such an assessment from administering one or more assessments in addition to the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment.
- Require the CDE to ensure that LEAs comply with specified requirements if they administer nationally recognized high school assessment, which are also applicable to the 11th grade Smarter Balanced Assessment.
- Authorizes an LEA to chooses to administer a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC to utilize the terms of a contract with a publisher that has been entered into with another district for purposes of providing the assessment.
- Require the SPI to prepare and submit, and subsequently post on the Internet Web site of the department, an annual report to the state board containing an analysis of the results and test scores of the test.
- Makes its provisions inoperative five years after the first school year in which a LEA is able to exercise the authority granted to it by the SPI, and requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to inform the Legislative Counsel within 30 days of when those conditions have been satisfied, and to post that determination on the department’s Internet Web site.
Related Legislation:
ACR 64 (McCarty) resolves that the Trustees of the California State University and the Regents of the UC are requested to conduct a study on the usefulness, effectiveness, and need for the SAT and ACT to determine student admissions, and that the study should include recommendations and, if determined necessary, a plan for phasing out the use of the SAT and ACT as a basis for admission. ACR is scheduled to be heard by this Committee on August 12, 2019.
AB 1951 (O’Donnell, 2018) was nearly identical to this bill and vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated:
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local school may administer in lieu of the state-administered high school summative assessment, commencing with the 2019-20 school year.
Since 2010, California has eliminated standardized testing in grades 9 and 10 and the high school exit exam. While I applaud the author's efforts to improve student access to college and reduce ‘testing fatigue’ in grade 11, I am not convinced that replacing the state's high school assessment with the Scholastic Aptitude Test or American College Test achieves that goal.
Our K-12 system and our public universities are now discussing the possible future use of California's grade 11 state assessment for college admission purposes. This is a better approach to improving access to college for under-represented students and reducing ‘testing fatigue’.
Staff Comments:
While this bill requires the SPI to approve any nationally recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by any state that has adopted the Common Core State Standards and meets applicable federal requirements, the CDE does not believe it is authorized to approve an assessment for use in California based on another state’s approval. One of the requirements to use an alternate assessment is that the assessment must go through a federally mandated peer review process to ensure that it satisfies all of the federal requirements identified above. As stated in a U.S. Department of Education letter to State Assessment Directors, dated May 15, 2017, “the state must establish the criteria and undertake its review of the nationally recognized high school assessment before it may offer the opportunity for an LEA to select that assessment… Prior to any LEA use of nationally recognized assessment in lieu of Statewide assessments, States must submit evidence to the Department demonstrating that any such assessment meets the peer review requirements under section 1111(a)(4) of the ESEA and receive feedback that the nationally recognize assessment meets or substantially meets the requirements in the state and regulations.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 19, 2019
Author: | O'Donnell | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: .
SUMMARY
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local education agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC), commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
BACKGROUND
Existing law establishes the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress, which consists of, among other exams, the SBAC, which assesses English language arts and mathematics, and requires the SBAC to be administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11. (Education Code § 60640)
ANALYSIS
This bill requires the SPI to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC, commencing with the 2021-22 school year. Specifically, this bill:
1) Requires the SPI, pursuant to authority granted to the state pursuant to the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act, to approve, within 30 days after the SPI determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment satisfies specified requirements, one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a LEA may administer at its own discretion, commencing with the 2020–21 school year, in lieu of the SBAC.
2) Requires a nationally recognized high school assessment approved by the SPI to meet all of the following requirements:
a) Align with the academic content standards adopted by the State Board of Education (SBE) and address the depth and breadth of those standards.
b) Be at least as rigorous as the consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics for grade 11 that measures content standards adopted by the SBE, as required by the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress.
c) Satisfy federal regulations to ensure appropriate accommodations for English learners and pupils with disabilities, including pupils identified pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act, the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990.
d) Produce valid and reliable data on pupil academic achievement with respect to all high school pupils and each subgroup of high school pupils in the local educational agency (LEA).
e) Produce disaggregated scores based on English proficiency status, gender, ethnicity, socioeconomic disadvantage, foster care status, and special education designation.
f) Produce individual pupil scores that can be linked to scores from the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress assessments.
g) Ensure that the use of appropriate accommodations by a pupil with disabilities or an English learner does not deny the opportunity of any pupil to participate in the assessment or deny any pupil of any benefit from participating in the assessment that is afforded to pupils without disabilities or pupils who are not English learners.
h) Satisfy the peer review requirements specified by federal law.
3) Authorizes the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to require a publisher of a nationally recognized high school assessment that is being considered for approval to provide documentation that the assessment meets or exceeds the requirements of (2) above.
4) Requires the SPI, if he or she determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment being considered for approval does not meet the requirements of (2) above, to inform the publisher of the assessment in writing of the specific deficiencies and changes needed to meet those requirements.
5) Requires the SPI, to the extent permitted by the U.S. Department of Education, to approve any nationally recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by any state that has adopted the Common Core State Standards and that meets applicable federal requirements under the federal Elementary and Secondary Education Act.
6) Authorizes a LEA to administer an approved assessment instead of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment, only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA’s governing board or body at a public meeting.
7) Requires the state board of education, before a LEA may administer the assessment, to amend the state plan required pursuant to federal law to account for the authorization, if required by federal law.
8) Requires a local education agency (LEA) that administers a nationally recognized high school assessment to do all of the following:
a) Notify the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), and the parents and legal guardians of its pupils entering grade 11, at the beginning of each school year during which the assessment will be administered to those pupils, that it will be administering an assessment that is different from 11th grade Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC).
b) Administer the assessment free of charge to all pupils in grade 11, except for those pupils who opt out, as authorized by law.
c) Administer the assessment to individuals with exceptional needs with appropriate accommodations, where necessary, and provide an alternate assessment to individuals with exceptional needs who are unable to participate in testing, even with accommodations.
d) Administer the assessment to English learner pupils with appropriate accommodations, where necessary. To the extent permissible under federal law, recently arrived English learner pupils shall be exempt from taking the alternative assessment in English language arts.
e) Report scores and pupil participation data to the California Department of Education (CDE) in a manner prescribed by the SPI.
9) Requires the SPI to apportion to a LEA that administers an approved nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the 11th grade SBAC, the lesser of the following:
a) The actual cost of administering the nationally recognized high school assessment, including, but not necessarily limited to, administering and scoring the assessment and reporting results of the assessment to the SPI.
b) The amount that would have been apportioned to the LEA if it had administered 11th grade SBAC.
10) Authorizes a LEA to administer only one nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC, but does not prohibit a LEA that does not administer such an assessment from administering one or more assessments in addition to the grade 11 SBAC.
11) Defines a “LEA” to mean a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
12) Requires the CDE to ensure that LEAs comply with each of the following requirements if they administer nationally recognized high school assessment, which are also applicable to the 11th grade SBAC:
a) That the test be administered to all pupils.
b) That the individual results of each student be reported, in writing, to the parent or guardian of the pupil. The report is required to include a clear explanation of the purpose of the test, the score of the student, and the intended use by the local educational agency (LEA) of the test score.
c) That state agencies and LEAs do not use a comparison resulting from the scores and results of the test and the assessment scores and results from assessments that measured previously adopted content standards (STAR Testing).
d) That valid individual student results also be reported to the school and teachers of a student, and that LEA include the test results of a pupil in his or her student records.
e) That the districtwide and school-level results of the test, but not the score or relative position of any individually ascertainable student, be reported to the governing board of the school district at a regularly scheduled meeting, and the countywide, school-level, and grade-level results for classes and programs under the jurisdiction of the county office of education shall be similarly reported to the county board of education at a regularly scheduled meeting.
f) That the aggregated, disaggregated, or group scores or reports not be publicly reported to any party other than the school or LEA where the students were tested, if the aggregated, disaggregated, or group scores or reports are comprised of 10 or fewer individual student assessment results.
g) That students in grade 11, or parents or legal guardians of those students, may request results from the test for the purpose of determining credit, placement, or readiness for college-level coursework be released to a postsecondary educational institution.
13) Authorizes the governing board of an LEA that is part of a consortium of LEAs to enter into a cooperative contract with a publisher for the purposes of providing a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC).
14) Authorizes an LEA to chooses to administer a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the grade 11 SBAC to utilize the terms of a contract with a publisher that has been entered into with another district for purposes of providing the assessment.
15) Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to prepare and submit, and subsequently post on the Internet Web site of the department, an annual report to the state board containing an analysis of the results and test scores of the test.
16) Makes its provisions inoperative five years after the first school year in which a LEA is able to exercise the authority granted to it by the SPI, and requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to inform the Legislative Counsel within 30 days of when those conditions have been satisfied, and to post that determination on the department’s Internet Web site.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “In an effort to increase college-attendance rates, over 45 school districts, including Long Beach Unified School District (LBUSD), Fresno USD, Oakland USD, Sacramento City USD, and San Jose USD are administering an alternative assessment, such as the SAT or ACT, during the school day for free to 11th grade students, in addition to administering the Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBAC). This bill allows, for five years, local educational agencies (LEAs) to administer the SAT or ACT in lieu of the SBAC. The bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessment that meets specified criteria, including that the assessment is consistent with our state standards, is a statistically reliable and a valid norm-referenced or criterion-referenced test, and will produce valid and reliable data on pupil academic achievement. LEAs that choose to administer an alternative assessment must first receive approval at a local governing board meeting, administer the assessment to all 11th grade students, offer the assessment for free, and ensure that students with disabilities and English learners have accommodations.”
2) Grade 11 Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBAC). According to The Smarter Balanced Assessment Consortium, the SBAC “is a valid, fair, and reliable approach to student assessment that provides educators, students and parents meaningful results with actionable data to help students succeed.” Its assessment system is aligned to the Common Core State Standards, which serve as the basis for California’s academic content standards. The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English and language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11, and is untimed, with an average of 7.5 hours to complete the exam. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment.
The SBAC’s summative assessments “determine students’ progress toward college and career readiness in English language arts/literacy and math. These are given at the end of the school year and consist of two parts: a computer adaptive test and a performance task. The summative assessments:
a) Accurately describe both student achievement (how much students know at the end of the year) and student growth (how much students have improved since the previous year) to inform program evaluation and school, district, and state accountability systems.
b) Include writing at every grade and ask students to solve multi-step, real-world problems in mathematics.
c) Capitalize on the strengths of computer adaptive testing: efficient and precise measurement with a quick turnaround of results.
3) The Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT). The SAT is a commonly administered college admissions exams.
The SAT includes a Reading Test, Writing and Language Test, and a Math Test. There is also an option SAT Essay. According to the College Board, “In the Reading Test, students will encounter questions like those asked in a lively, thoughtful, evidence-based discussion.” The Reading Test measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. The Writing and Language Test asks students “to be an editor and improve passages that were written especially for the test—and that include deliberate errors.” The Writing and Language Test also measures command of evidence, words in context, and analysis in History/Social Studies and in Science. Finally, the Math Test “covers a range of math practices, with an emphasis on problem solving, modeling, using tools strategically, and using algebraic structure.” The Math Test measures fluency, conceptual understanding, and applications. The redesigned SAT Essay “asks you to use your reading, analysis, and writing skills.” The SAT is a timed, paper exam.
4) The American College Test (ACT). According to the ACT, The ACT Exam “test scores reflect what students have learned throughout high school and provide colleges and universities with excellent information for recruiting, advising, placement, and retention.” The ACT contains four multiple-choice tests—English, mathematics, reading, and science—and an optional writing test. According to ACT, “these tests are designed to measure skills that are most important for success in postsecondary education and that are acquired in secondary education. The ACT English test measures understanding of the conventions of standard English, production of writing, and knowledge of language. The ACT mathematics test assesses the skills students typically acquire in courses taken through grade 11.
The ACT reading test measures reading comprehension. The ACT science test measures the interpretation, analysis, evaluation, reasoning, and problem-solving skills required in the natural sciences. The optional ACT writing test is an essay test that measures writing skills taught in high school English classes and entry level college composition courses.” The ACT is a timed, paper exam.
5) Long Beach Unified School District’s (LBUSD) waiver request. LBUSD submitted a letter to the president of the State Board of Education (SBE) on January 17, 2017, requesting a waiver to permit the district to administer the SAT instead of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment for the 2016-17 school year. The district received a reply jointly signed by the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the State Board of Education (SBE) president stating that the statutory provisions requiring the administration of all (California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress) CAASPP assessments are not waivable. In their letter to Long Beach Unified School District (LBUSD), the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) and SBE president identified the following concerns with the district's request:
a) The SAT may not be aligned to the common core state standards.
b) The SAT does not provide a reliable and valid measurement across the entire spectrum of pupil performance (for example it is not designed to measure performance at the low end of the spectrum well), which could leave the district open to lawsuits based on discrimination.
c) The SAT does not offer disabled students the same set of supports and accommodations as the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) assessments.
d) The SAT does not report results on the same scale as the CAASPP assessments.
e) Not administering the CAASPP assessment could result in the loss of federal funds.
f) The College Board, which publishes the SAT, has different requirements regarding data ownership and pupil privacy.
Long Beach Unified School District submitted another waiver request for the 2017-18 school year and was again denied.
6) Federal authorization for alternate assessment. Federal law, the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), authorizes states to approve a nationally recognized high school assessment that local education agencies (LEAs) may administer in lieu of the existing state-wide assessment (which is the Smarter Balanced Assessment for California), provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Federal regulations define "nationally recognized high school assessment" to mean "an assessment of high school students' knowledge and skills that is administered in multiple States and is recognized by institutions of higher education in those or other States for the purposes of entrance or placement into courses in postsecondary education or training programs." ESSA gives states discretion in offering this flexibility, but requires states to first establish that the approved alternative assessment meets certain requirements, all of which are incorporated into this bill by reference and, in some cases, explicitly.
6) Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments (SBAC) and Accountability. SBAC scores are used as part of the state's accountability system, in particular the school dashboard, which uses SBAC scores along with other state and local performance measures to evaluate school and district performance. According to the California Department of Education, the Academic Indicator “is based on performance on the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments for English Language Arts/Literacy (ELA) and mathematics—which is administered to students in grades three through eight and grade eleven—and how far the average student is from meeting the grade-level standard, or the ‘Distance from Standard’ (DFS). To calculate the DFS, each student's score is first compared to the “Standard Met” threshold for that grade level on the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments. Then, all distance results are averaged to produce a school- and student-group-level average scale score (the DFS). The results will show the needed improvement to bring the average student score to “Standard Met” or the extent to which the average student score meets or exceeds ‘Standard Met’. Using scale scores, rather than reporting on the percent of students who performed at or above the “Standard Met”, provides a more comprehensive picture of how all students at the school are performing on the Smarter Balanced assessments.
It should be noted that the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the President of the State Board of Education, in their October 31, 2017 letter to Long Beach Unified School District (LBUSD) denying its waiver request for the 2016-17 school year, they stated that federal law “mandates that the Stated Educational Agency State Plan require all local educational agencies (LEAs) to administer the same academic assessment to measure student achievement for the purpose of accountability. Each LEA must assure that it will comply with the State Plan irrespective of Title I participation. LBUSD’s intent to offer a different assessment, in lieu of the state’s designated assessment, will put it out of compliance with federal law as it pertains to assessment and accountability. In addition, if an LEA does not give the grade eleven Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC), it will negatively impact its College/Career Indicator in the California School Dashboard.” However, this bill requires the State Board of Education to amend the state plan to account for the authorization for local educational agencies to use an alternate assessment pursuant to this section, if required by federal law, before a local educational agency may administer an assessment in lieu of the SBAC.
7) Peer Review. As noted above, one of the requirements to use an alternate assessment is that the assessment must go through a federally mandated peer review process to ensure that it satisfies all of the federal requirements identified above. As stated in a U.S. Department of Education (USDOE) letter to State Assessment Directors, dated May 15, 2017, “the state must establish the criteria and undertake its review of the nationally recognized high school assessment before it may offer the opportunity for an LEA to select that assessment… Prior to any LEA use of nationally recognized assessment in lieu of Statewide assessments, States must submit evidence to the Department demonstrating that any such assessment meets the peer review requirements under section 1111(a)(4) of the ESEA and receive feedback that the nationally recognize assessment meets or substantially meets the requirements in the state and regulations.”
This bill explicitly requires the state to undertake the peer review process before the Superintendent approves one or more nationally recognized high school assessments
However, the bill does contain a provision that requires the state to substitute another state’s peer review process for its own if the other state has approved a nationally recognized high school assessment, that the state has adopted the common core state standards, and it meets the federal requirements identified above, if the U.S. Department of Education allows the state to do so. However, as noted in a letter to State Assessment Directors from the USDOE dated May 15, 2017, the U.S. Department of Education stated that the “Department recognizes that it may have conducted a peer review of a nationally recognized high school test prior to a State selecting that test for this flexibility. In such a case, State may be able to leverage the prior peer review for submission of the nationally recognized high school test. However, a prior peer review of a particular nationally recognized national assessment that resulted in a determination that such assessment met or substantially met peer review requirements relative to a State’s challenging academic standards may not mean that assessment would meet the requirements for another state. For example, if two states have different challenging academic standards, a single assessment may not adequately address both sets of standards.”
According to the author, “other states, including Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Michigan, and Wisconsin have received approval from the U.S. Department of Education to administer the SAT or ACT for federal accountability purposes, in place of a state adopted assessment program. North Dakota received permission to give districts choice to administer the ACT.” Of the states identified by the author, only North Dakota has not adopted common core. According to a survey conducted by EdWeek, 24 states, plus the District of Colombia, require students to take either the SAT or the ACT. It appears that approximately 17 of those states use only the SAT or the ACT.
The committee may wish to consider whether it would be appropriate, in light of California’s unique characteristics, and more consistent with the intent of the flexibility afforded by federal law, to delete subdivision (e) of Section 60640.5 to ensure that the only circumstance in which a California local educational agency would be afforded the flexibility to administer a nationally recognized high school assessment instead of the statewide assessment is if that assessment has undergone a peer review assessment specific to California, despite the cost saving that this provision would afford the state.
8) Alignment between SAT/ACT and state standards. This bill requires that the nationally recognized high school assessment approved by the Superintendent to be aligned with the academic content standards adopted by the State Board of Education and to address the depth and breadth of those standards. As previously noted, California’s English language arts and mathematics academic content standards are based on the Common Core State Standards (CCSS). As noted in the Assembly Education Committee’s analysis, California is one of 15 states that administer the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments (SBAC), although according to Education Week, only eight states administer the SBAC in grade 11. All of these states have adopted the CCSS, but all of these states have also modified those standards to meet local needs and priorities. However, the SBAC does not differ from state to state. This means there will always be some amount of "misalignment" between the SBAC and each state's content standards, and the areas of misalignment will vary from state to state. The same will hold true for an alternative test, which federal law requires to be a test that is offered in multiple states. However, the College Board, which publishes the SAT, indicates that studies have shown that the alignment between the SAT and the CCSS is comparable to the alignment between the SBAC and the CCSS.
Conversely, a March 2018 brief from Achieve states: “In 2017, Achieve conducted an independent alignment study of the ACT with the Common Core State Standards. Achieve used an evaluation approach adapted from a methodology based on the Council of Chief State School Officers’ (CCSSO) Criteria for Procuring and Evaluating Large Scale Assessments. Overall, Achieve’s review of the ACT found significant weaknesses across both English language arts (comprising the Reading, Writing, and Essay tests) and mathematics for both content and depth. In ELA, fewer than 50 percent of items reviewed were judged to be aligned to the claimed Common Core State Standards. For example, many items that claimed to measure writing standards did not ask students to produce writing, as indicated in the state’s content standards. The ACT emphasized some aspects of reading text critically and language skills as well as real-world activities, but did not require students to demonstrate their abilities to write in different modes (argumentative, expository/nonfiction, and narrative), use text-based evidence in support of their writing, or focus on the vocabulary words most appropriate to high school. In mathematics, fewer than half of items on the assessment were judged to be aligned to the claimed Common Core mathematical content standards for high school. This finding, while low, may be less surprising given that ACT, in its technical documentation, indicates that 40-43 percent of mathematics items are designed to measure pre-8th grade mathematics content.”
However, The Long Beach Unified School Districts (LBUSD) has been administering the SAT and the Smarter Balanced Summative Assessments (SBAC) to 11th graders for several years. According to information provided by the author's office, "The LBUSD found that pupil performance on the SAT correlates almost identically with the performance on the CAASPP assessment." Specifically, the same percentage (49 percent) of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on both English language arts tests, while 28 percent of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on the SBAC math, compared with 29 percent on the SAT math test. Additionally, A study by Policy Analysis for California Education (PACE) found that the SAT and SBAC are equally predictive of first- and second-year college grade point averages. This study compared the effectiveness of three assessments—high school grade point average (HSGPA), the SAT, and the SBAC—in predicting how well California State University students do in their first and second years of college. HSGPA is a better predictor than either the SAT or the SBAC in predicting first- and second-year college GPAs, and the SAT and SBAC are similar, "if not identical," predictors. This is an indication that the SAT and SBAC measure very similar academic achievement levels and abilities.
9) Shifting attitudes toward college admissions tests. The University of California (UC) has formed the Standardized Testing Task Force to evaluate “whether the University and its students are best served by our current testing practices, a modification of our current practices, another testing approach altogether, or perhaps even no testing at all. The goal of the Task Force is to develop recommendations for implementation in UC undergraduate admissions…” The Task Force has been asked to focus on the following questions:
a) How well do the University of California (UC) current standardized testing practices assess entering high school students for UC readiness?
b) How well do the UC current standardized practices predict student success in the context of our holistic, comprehensive review process?
c) Should UC testing practices be improved, changed or eliminated?
d) Do standardized testing assessments fairly promote diversity and opportunity for students applying to UC?
e) Does UC’s use of standardized tests enhance or detract from UC academic eligibility for high school students?
The scope of the Task Force is the full range of standardized tests used by UC for undergraduate admissions, but focus will likely be directed to SAT and ACT tests.
The committee may wish to consider the value of allowing local educational agencies to substitute the SAT or the ACT for the SBAC in the context of this evolving landscape. However, it should be noted that the bill includes 5-year sunset provision.
10) Related and previous legislation. ACR 64 (McCarty, 2019) resolves that the Trustees of the California State University and the Regents of the UC are requested to conduct a study on the usefulness, effectiveness, and need for the SAT and ACT to determine student admissions, and that the study should include recommendations and, if determined necessary, a plan for phasing out the use of the SAT and ACT as a basis for admission. ACR is pending referral in the Senate.
AB 1951 (O’Donnell, 2018) was identical to this bill and was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated:
“This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local school may administer in lieu of the state-administered high school summative assessment, commencing with the 2019-20 school year.
Since 2010, California has eliminated standardized testing in grades 9 and 10 and the high school exit exam. While I applaud the author's efforts to improve student access to college and reduce ‘testing fatigue’ in grade 11, I am not convinced that replacing the state's high school assessment with the Scholastic Aptitude Test or American College Test achieves that goal.
Our K-12 system and our public universities are now discussing the possible future use of California's grade 11 state assessment for college admission purposes. This is a better approach to improving access to college for under-represented students and reducing ‘testing fatigue’.”
AB 3233 (Kiley, 2018) would have authorized a local education agency (LEA) that administers a nationally recognized high school assessment that meets specified federal requirements to all students in grade 11 to report those assessments on the California School Dashboard as a local academic indicator. AB 3233 died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1602 (O’Donnell, 2017) would have established the Alternative Grade 11 Assessment Pilot Program to allow participating districts to administer an assessment other than the grade 11 SBAC. AB 1602 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SUPPORT
Association of California School Administrators (Co-Sponsor)
California School Boards Association (Co-Sponsor)
AVID Center
California Association of Latino Superintendents and Administrators
California Association of Student Councils
Central Valley Education Coalition
Corona Norco Unified School District
Long Beach Unified School District
Oakland Unified School District
Norwalk-La Mirada Unified School District
Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
Sacramento City Unified School District
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools
San Diego Unified School District
San Francisco Unified School District
San Jose Unified School District
Small School Districts Association
Torrance Unified School District
OPPOSITION
Alliance for a Better Community
California Association for Bilingual Education
California for Justice
Californians Together
Public Advocates
Student Senate for California Community Colleges
The Education Trust – West
The Opportunity Institute
An individual
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 751
Author:(O'Donnell)
As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes the Pathways to College Act, which requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local educational agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC).
Major Provisions
- Requires the SPI to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may administer in lieu of the SBAC in grade 11, commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
- Authorizes an LEA to administer an alternative assessment instead of the SBAC only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA's governing board or body at a public meeting. Includes additional requirements of an LEA that administers an alternative assessment.
COMMENTS:
The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3, inclusive, and grade 11. SBAC scores are used as part of the state's accountability system, which uses SBAC scores along with other state and local performance measures to evaluate school and district performance. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment.
There are 45 school districts in California that have been administering either the American College Test (ACT) or Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) during the regular school day in addition to the SBAC in 11th grade. The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), authorizes states to approve a nationally recognized high school assessment that LEAs may administer in lieu of the existing statewide assessment (which is the SBAC for California), provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Consistent with federal and state law, this bill requires the alternative assessment to provide appropriate accommodations for English learners (EL) and special education students, including students eligible under both the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Special education students would be allowed to take the California Alternative Assessment if their individualized education plan (IEP) provides for it.
According to the Author:
"In an effort to increase college-attendance rates, approximately 45 school districts, including Long Beach Unified School District (USD), Fresno USD, Oakland USD, Paramount USD, San Jose USD, and Sacramento City USD administer college entrance exams to 11th grade pupils free of charge during the school day. This bill will enable the state to take advantage of a federal option to meet accountability requirements using an alternative assessment while removing a barrier to college attendance for students who may not otherwise have access to the exam or take it on their own. This bill is about equity and opportunity."
Arguments in Support:
The Association of California School Administrators states, "If more students are able to take a college admissions test during the school day, more underrepresented students can be connected directly to scholarships and college application fee waivers—removing their historic barriers to higher education. This bill results in leveling the playing field because the SAT and ACT offer free, personalized test practice and other resources to students of all means, no matter where they're from or how much their parents make. AB 751 also ensures that students with exceptional needs are appropriately accommodated and requires English learners to be provided appropriate accommodations, including access to testing instructions in their primary language, bilingual glossaries and extended testing time."
Arguments in Opposition:
The Education Trust-West states, "If enacted, this bill would pave the way for districts to replace the 11th grade [California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress] CAASPP assessment with either the SAT or the ACT. Doing so would undermine fairness in our high schools in three ways: 1) it would weaken our K-12 accountability system—which is built upon an assumption that all schools and districts are measured against the same standards; 2) it would limit accessibility for English learners and students with disabilities and hinder their ability to fully demonstrate their knowledge and skills; and 3) it would reinforce and expand the use of the SAT and ACT at a time when we should be reassessing these tools for bias and fraud."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee,
- Potential one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of about $1.5 million for California Department of Education (CDE) to contract for validation of the assessments to ensure they meet certain federal requirements. This cost assumes CDE must go through a process to validate the alternative assessments for federal accountability purposes; however, it is unclear whether this process is necessary because the assessments have already been approved by the federal government for use by other states.
- If the assessments meet federal requirements, as outlined in 1), one-time General Fund (GF) costs of about $400,000 for the CDE to amend the state plan required by federal law to include information about the assessments, hire staff to produce technical guides, add the new assessment to the state's accountability system, communicate with LEAs on the alternative assessment options and respond to LEA questions.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 GF or GF costs of costs of about $600,000 for various activities related to the alternative assessments, such as hiring staff to review and monitor LEAs' use of the assessments, provide guidance to LEAs and monitor the assessment's inclusion in the state's accountability system. To the extent activities are performed by CDE staff, they would be supported using GF. If the CDE were to contract out activities, they likely would be supported using Proposition 98 GF. (CDE generally does not receive Proposition 98 GF for its state operations, but typically uses Proposition 98 GF to contract out activities.)
- Cost pressures to LEAs that elect to administer the alternative assessment in lieu of the SBAC assessment. The cost to a school district to administer an alternative assessment is about $45 per student, significantly more than the $4 per student they now receive to administer the SBAC assessment.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 6-0-0
YES: O'Donnell, Kiley, Kalra, McCarty, Smith, Weber
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 19, 2019
CONSULTANT: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0000673
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 751
Author:(O'Donnell) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
Policy Committee: | Education | Vote: | 6 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the State Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments a local education agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the 11th grade Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment Consortium (SBAC) assessment, commencing with the 2021-22 school year. The bill specifies the state plan required by federal law must be amended to include information about the assessments and student scores on these alternative assessments must be included as part of the state’s existing accountability system. It also requires CDE to provide funding to an LEA choosing to administer the alternative assessment that is the lesser of the costs of the SBAC or the alternative assessment. The bill includes a sunset date of five years after the first year in which a school is able to administer the assessment and require the SPI to notify Legislative Counsel of when that condition has been met.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Potential one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs of about $1.5 million for California Department of Education (CDE) to contract for validation of the assessments to ensure they meet certain federal requirements. This cost assumes CDE must go through a process to validate the alternative assessments for federal accountability purposes; however, it is unclear whether this process is necessary because the assessments have already been approved by the federal government for use by other states.
- If the assessments meet federal requirements, as outlined in 1), one-time General Fund (GF) costs of about $400,000 for the CDE to amend the state plan required by federal law to include information about the assessments, hire staff to produce technical guides, add the new assessment to the state’s accountability system, communicate with LEAs on the alternative assessment options and respond to LEA questions.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 GF or GF costs of costs of about $600,000 for various activities related to the alternative assessments, such as hiring staff to review and monitor LEAs’ use of the assessments, provide guidance to LEAs and monitor the assessment’s inclusion in the state’s accountability system. To the extent activities are performed by CDE staff, they would be supported using GF. If the CDE were to contract out activities, they likely would be supported using Proposition 98 GF. (CDE generally does not receive Proposition 98 GF for its state operations, but typically uses Proposition 98 GF to contract out activities.)
- Cost pressures to LEAs that elect to administer the alternative assessment in lieu of the SBAC assessment. The cost to a school district to administer an alternative assessment is about $45 per student, significantly more than the $4 per student they now receive to administer the SBAC assessment.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The ACT and SAT are nationally-normed assessments used for college admission purposes. Many school districts in California administer either the ACT or SAT in addition to the SBAC to students in 11th grade. Some districts indicate administering the ACT or SAT encourages their students to apply for college. The districts also report students find these assessment scores more meaningful than the SBAC scores. They also indicate giving the ACT or SAT and the SBAC is time consuming. LEAs representing about 20% of 11th grade enrollment administer the SAT or ACT to all students in 11th grade or support using the assessment as an alternative to the SBAC.
- SBAC Assessments. As a condition of receiving federal education funding, federal law requires states to assess students in English language arts and math in 3rd grade through 8th grade and at least once between 10th and 12th grade. To do this, California uses the SBAC, a computer-assisted assessment in English and language arts and mathematics administered in 3rd grade through 8th grade, and in 11th grade. In addition to meeting federal requirements, SBAC scores are part of the state's accountability system. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out and special education students who qualify for a different assessment.
- State Accountability. The state’s accountability system is known as the California School Dashboard. The dashboard provides information about student outcomes in various areas, including performance on assessments, graduation rates and the portion of students who are college and career ready. This bill would add ACT or SAT outcomes to the assessment performance indicators and to the college and career readiness indicator. (Because some LEAs would continue to use SBAC as their assessment, some LEAs indicators would consider SBAC while others would consider ACT or SAT.) Outcomes can be viewed by school district and school and separated by student subgroup.
- Approval for Federal Accountability Purposes. Federal law authorizes states to seek a waiver to allow LEAs to administer a nationally recognized high school assessment in lieu of the existing state-wide assessment, provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Currently, seven states use the SBAC and 25 use either the SAT or ACT in 11th grade as the statewide assessment for federal accountability purposes. Five states have received approval from the U. S. Department of Education to allow LEAs to administer the SAT in lieu of the statewide assessment.
- Related Legislation. AB 1951 (O’Donnell), of the 2017-18 legislative session, was very similar to this bill. The bill was vetoed by the governor, who indicated the state’s K-12 system and public universities were discussing the use of the 11th grade SBAC for college admission purposes.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 27, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 751 (
Author:O'Donnell) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
SUBJECT: Pupil assessments: Pathways to College Act
SUMMARY: Establishes the Pathways to College Act, which requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local education agency (LEA) may, at its own discretion, administer in lieu of the grade 11 Smarter Balanced Summative Assessment (SBAC), commencing with the 2021-22 school year. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the SPI to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that an LEA may administer in lieu of the SBAC in grade 11, commencing with the 2021-22 school year.
- Requires the nationally recognized alternative assessment to meet specified state and federal requirements:
- Be aligned with the academic content standards adopted by the State Board of education (SBE)
- Be at least as rigorous as the SBAC
- Meet federal requirements that currently apply to the SBAC, including:
- Be designed to be valid and reliable for use by the widest possible range of students, including students with disabilities and students with limited English proficiency
- Provide appropriate accommodations for English learners, in accordance with Sections 200.2(b), 200.5(a), and 200.6 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations, and students with special needs, including pupils identified pursuant to Section 602 of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401), Section 504 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794), and Title II of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12131 et seq.).
- Be valid and reliable for the purposes of the assessment
- Allow results to be disaggregated by major racial/ethnic groups, English proficiency status, migrant status, students with disabilities, and economically disadvantaged students
- Satisfy peer review requirements
- Allow for individual pupil scores that can be linked to scores from the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress (CAASPP) assessments
- Allow results to be disaggregated by foster care status, in addition to the groups required by federal law
- Ensure that the use of appropriate accommodations by a pupil with disabilities or an English learner does not deny the opportunity of any pupil to participate in the assessment or deny any pupil of any benefit from participating in the assessment that is afforded to pupils without disabilities or pupils who are not English learners.
- Authorizes the SPI to require a publisher of a nationally recognized high school assessment that is being considered for his or her approval as an alternative assessment to provide documentation that the assessment meets or exceeds the requirements for approval.
- Provides that, if the SPI determines that a nationally recognized high school assessment being considered for his or her approval does not meet the requirements for approval, then he or she shall inform the publisher of the assessment in writing of the specific deficiencies and changes needed to meet the requirements.
- Provides that a nationally recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by an state that has adopted the Common Core State Standards and that meets relevant federal requirements shall be deemed to have met the requirements for approval and shall be approved by the SPI as an alternative assessment.
- Authorizes an LEA to administer an alternative assessment instead of the SBAC only if the use of the alternative assessment has been approved by the LEA’s governing board or body at a public meeting.
- Requires that the State Board of Education first amend the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) State Plan to account for the authorization for LEAs to use an alternative assessment before an LEA may administer an approved alternative assessment.
- Requires an LEA that administers an alternative assessment to do all of the following:
- Notify the SPI, and the parents and legal guardians of its pupils entering grade 11, at the beginning of each school year during which the assessment will be administered to those pupils, that it will be administering an assessment that is different from the SBAC
- Administer the assessment free of charge to all pupils in grade 11, except for those pupils who exercise their existing right to opt out of the assessment
- Administer the assessment to individuals with exceptional needs with appropriate accommodations, where necessary, and provide an alternate assessment to individuals with exceptional needs who are unable to participate in testing, even with accommodations
- Administer the assessment to English learner pupils with appropriate accommodations, where necessary. To the extent permissible under federal law, exempts recently arrived English learner pupils from taking the alternative assessment in English language arts
- Report scores and pupil participation data to the CDE in a manner prescribed by the SPI.
- Requires the SPI to apportion to an LEA that administers an alternative assessment in lieu of the SBAC the lesser of the following:
- The actual cost of administering the alternative assessment, including, administering and scoring the assessment and reporting results of the assessment to the SPI; or
- The amount that would have been apportioned to the LEA if it had administered the SBAC.
- Provides that an LEA may administer only one alternative to the SBAC; however, this shall not be construed to prohibit an LEA that does not administer an alternative assessment in lieu of the SBAC from administering one or more assessments in addition to the SBAC.
- Defines "local education agency" to mean a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
- Adds a sunset date of five years after the first year in which an LEA is able to administer the alternative assessment and requires the SPI to notify Legislative Counsel of when the condition has been met.
- Requires that the results and test scores of the alternative assessment be included in the annual report provided by the SPI to the SBE containing an analysis of the results and test scores of the summative assessments administered under the CAASPP.
- Requires the CDE to ensure that LEAs comply with specified requirements concerning the alternative assessment that apply in connection with the summative assessments under the CAASPP, including that grade 11 pupils, or parents or legal guardians of those pupils, may request results from the alternative assessments.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the CAASPP, which consists of the following assessments:
- The SBAC, which assesses English language arts and mathematics
- The California Alternative Assessment, which may be administered only to special education students as required by their IEP
- The California Science Tests
- Requires the SBAC to be administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11.
- The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) permits LEAs to administer a locally-selected assessment in lieu of the State designed academic assessment if the LEA selects a nationally-recognized high school assessment that has been approved for use by the State. (ESSA Section 1111 (b)(1)(H))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Background. The SBAC is a computer-assisted assessment in English and language arts and mathematics that is administered in grades 3 through 8, inclusive, and grade 11. SBAC scores are used as part of the state's accountability system, in particular the California School Dashboard, which uses SBAC scores along with other state and local performance measures to evaluate school and district performance. All LEAs are required to administer the SBAC assessments to all students except those who opt out (as permitted by existing state law) and special education students who qualify for an alternative assessment. The SBAC is an untimed test, which means students can take as long as they need to complete it. The Smarter Balanced consortium estimates that it takes an 11th grader an average of 7.5 hours broken up over several days to complete the exam, although some may take longer. This is longer than a typical school day.
Need for the bill. The purpose of this bill is to allow LEAs to administer an alternative assessment to the SBAC, as permitted by federal law. There are 45 school districts in California have been administering either the American College Test (ACT) or Scholastic Aptitude Test (SAT) during the regular school day in addition to the SBAC in 11th grade, because they find they are more meaningful to students and encourage students to think about postsecondary education who otherwise may not have done so. The ACT and SAT are nationally-normed tests that are used for college admission purposes. Both are timed tests: the ACT takes 2 hours and 55 minutes, and the SAT takes 3 hours and 50 minutes. Districts that administer both tests also are seeking to reduce total test-taking time by having the option of offering an assessment in lieu of the SBAC.
According to the author’s office, “In an effort to increase college-attendance rates, approximately 45 school districts, including Long Beach Unified School District (USD), Fresno USD, Oakland USD, Paramount USD, San Jose USD, and Sacramento City USD administer college entrance exams to 11th grade pupils free of charge during the school day. This bill will enable the state to take advantage of a federal option to meet accountability requirements using an alternative assessment while removing a barrier to college attendance for students who may not otherwise have access to the exam or take it on their own. This bill is about equity and opportunity.”
Federal law. The Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA), authorizes states to approve a nationally recognized high school assessment that LEAs may administer in lieu of the existing statewide assessment (which is the SBAC for California), provided the alternative assessment meets or exceeds strict requirements. Federal regulations define "nationally recognized high school assessment" to mean "an assessment of high school students' knowledge and skills that is administered in multiple States and is recognized by institutions of higher education in those or other States for the purposes of entrance or placement into courses in postsecondary education or training programs." ESSA gives states discretion in offering this flexibility, but requires states to first establish that the approved alternative assessment:
- Is aligned with the state’s academic standards.
- Addresses the depth and breadth of those standards.
- Is equivalent to, or more rigorous than, the statewide assessment it is replacing in terms of the following:
- The coverage of academic content
- The difficulty of the assessment
- The overall quality of the assessment
- Other aspects of the assessment that the state may establish
- Meets all federal requirements that apply to the statewide assessment.
- Produces valid and reliable data on student academic achievement with respect to all high school students and each subgroup of high school students in the LEA that:
- Are comparable to achievement data produced by the statewide assessment (i.e., SBAC)
- Are expressed in terms consistent with the states academic achievement standards
- Provide unbiased, rational, and consistent differentiation among schools within the state for the purpose of the state accountability system
In addition, the state must also:
- Ensure that the use of appropriate accommodations by a student with disabilities or an English learner does not deny the opportunity of any student to participate in the assessment or deny any of the benefits from participation in the assessment that are afforded to students without disabilities or who are not English learners
- Submit evidence to the U. S. Department of Education that demonstrates that each alternative assessment meets the requirements of the federal peer review guidance
In addition to imposing requirements on state, federal law also requires LEAs that select to use the alternative assessment to:
- Notify all parents of high school students it serves:
- That the LEA intends to use an alternative assessment in place of the SBAC in grade 11
- How parents and, as appropriate, students may provide meaningful input regarding the LEAs request
- Of any effect of such a request on the LEA's instructional program
- Provide an opportunity for meaningful consultation with all public charter schools whose students would be included in such assessments.
All of these federal requirements are incorporated into this bill by reference and, in some cases, explicitly.
Accommodations for English learners and students with exceptional needs. Consistent with federal and state law, this bill requires the alternative assessment to provide appropriate accommodations for English learners and special education students, including students eligible under both the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973. Special education students would be allowed to take the California Alternative Assessment if their IEP provides for it. Federal regulations require accommodations to be appropriate, not identical to the accommodations provided for the SBAC. In fact, because the SBAC is a computer-assisted test and the SAT and ACT are paper and pencil tests, it is not possible to provide identical accommodations. For example, an accommodation provided via a drop-down menu of a computer-assisted test does not apply to a paper and pencil test. As with the SBAC, recently arrived English learners (within the last 12 months) are exempt from the test. However, by grade 11, the vast majority of English learners have been reclassified as English proficient and do not qualify for accommodations.
Alignment with California's content standards. Consistent with federal law, this bill requires the alternative assessment to be aligned with California's curriculum content standards, which are based on the Common Core State Standards (CCSS). However, alignment is never perfect, even for the SBAC. California is one of 11 states that administers the SBAC, although according to Education Week, only seven states administer the SBAC in grade 11. All of these states have adopted the CCSS, but all of these states have also modified those standards to meet local needs and priorities. However, the SBAC does not differ from state to state. This means there will always be some amount of "misalignment" between the SBAC and each state's content standards, and the areas of misalignment will vary from state to state.
The same will hold true for an alternative test, which federal law requires to be a test that is offered in multiple states. However, the College Board, which publishes the SAT, indicates that studies have shown that the alignment between the SAT and the CCSS is comparable to the alignment between the SBAC and the CCSS.
Compatibility with California's school accountability system. Consistent with federal law, this bill requires an alternative test to produce scores that are comparable to student academic achievement data for all high school students and each subgroup of high school students produced by the statewide assessment at each academic achievement level. In addition, this bill requires LEAs that use the alternative test in lieu of the SBAC to report scores to the CDE in a manner determined by the SPI. This is intended to ensure further that scores from an alternative test can be blended into the state accountability framework.
Other states. According to Education Week, seven states use the SBAC and 25 use either the SAT or ACT in grade 11 as the statewide assessment for federal accountability purposes. Five states—Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, and Michigan—have received approval from the U. S. Department of Education to allow LEAs to administer the SAT in lieu of the statewide test. This bill attempts to leverage the actions of other states by providing that, if an alternative test has been approved for use in another state that has also adopted the CCSS, then it shall be approved in California. Approval for use in another state is an indication that the assessment has met or exceeds the federal standards required by this bill.
Figure 1. States That Use Partnership for Assessment of Readiness for College and Careers (PARCC) or Smarter Balanced Tests.
Source: “What Tests Does Each State Require?” Education Week. Updated March 5, 2019.
- Fifteen states and the District of Columbia will administer PARCC or Smarter Balanced tests in the spring of 2019. That’s five fewer than in 2016 and 2017.
- Thirty-two states use tests they designed or bought.
- Three states give hybrid tests. Two mix their own questions with items from the PARCC/New Meridian item bank, and one adds its own questions onto the full Smarter Balanced test.
Figure 2. Which States Require Students to Take the SAT or ACT?
Twenty-five states require students to take the SAT or ACT, the same number as in 2016 and 2017. That number had been climbing steadily—from seven states a decade ago— as states looked for ways to encourage students to go to college.
Source: “What Tests Does Each State Require?” Education Week. Updated March 5, 2019.
How the SAT compares with the SBAC. The Long Beach Unified School Districts (LBUSD) has been administering the SAT and the SBAC to 11th graders for several years. According to information provided by the author's office, "The LBUSD found that pupil performance on the SAT correlates almost identically with the performance on the CAASPP assessment." Specifically, the same percentage (49%) of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on both English language arts tests, while 28% of 11th graders met or exceeded benchmarks on the SBAC math, compared with 29% on the SAT math test.
Prior legislation. AB 1951 (O’Donnell) of the 2017-18 Session included the same language as this bill. The implementation has been moved forward one year compared to the prior version. The proposal was vetoed by the Governor Brown with the following veto message:
This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to approve one or more nationally recognized high school assessments that a local school may administer in lieu of the state-administered high school summative assessment, commencing with the 2019-20 school year.
Since 2010, California has eliminated standardized testing in grades 9 and 10 and the high school exit exam. While I applaud the author's efforts to improve student access to college and reduce "testing fatigue" in grade 11, I am not convinced that replacing the state's high school assessment with the Scholastic Aptitude Test or American College Test achieves that goal.
Our K-12 system and our public universities are now discussing the possible future use of California's grade 11 state assessment for college admission purposes. This is a better approach to improving access to college for under-represented students and reducing "testing fatigue".
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alameda Unified School District
Association Of California School Administrators (Co-Sponsor)
Avid Center
California Association Of Latino Superintendents & Administrators
California Association Of Suburban School Districts
California School Boards Association (Co-Sponsor)
Central Valley Education Coalition
City Of Long Beach
Corona Norco Unified School District
Downey Unified School District
Jurupa Unified School District
Long Beach Unified School District
Murrieta Valley Unified School District
Napa Valley Unified School District
Sacramento City Unified School District
San Bernardino County District Advocates For Better Schools (Sandabs)
San Diego Unified School District
San Francisco Unified School District
San Jose Unified School District
Small School Districts Association
South Bay Union School District
Torrance Unified School District
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):