AB 767: Victim compensation: use of excessive force by a peace officer.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-03
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 17, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 8, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (August 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 3, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 14, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 2, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 30, 2020 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 28, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| May 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 2.) (April 23). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 17, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 7, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2019 | AB 767 Wicks Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 767 (Grayson) - Victim compensation: use of excessive force by a peace officer
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 767, an urgency measure, would expand eligibility for compensation under the Victims Compensation Program (VCP) for injuries or death caused by use of force by a police officer. It also would make other reforms to VCP.
Fiscal Impact:
The Victim Compensation Board (VCB) report annual costs of approximately $200 million (including payments and administrative costs) associated with this measure. Additionally, the board estimates increased payments of about $714 million for, and administrative costs of $10.5 million to process, claims filed for incidents that took place within the past seven years. (Special fund*/General Fund, federal funds)
*Restitution Fund—structurally imbalanced
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Public Safety:
The victim compensation program was created in 1965, the first such program in the country. The board provides compensation for victims of violent crime. It reimburses eligible victims for many crime-related expenses, such as counseling and medical fees. Funding for the board comes from restitution fines and penalty assessments paid by criminal offenders, as well as federal matching funds.
The CalVCB is considered the payer of last resort and can only pay treatment expenses after other available sources of payment have been applied to a bill. Those sources include, but are not limited to, health insurance, workers compensation insurance, automobile insurance, Medi-cal, and Medicare.
…
The CalVCP reimburses eligible victims for specified expenses such as counseling and medical fees. Eligible persons are victims and derivative victims and the crime either occurred in California or the victim is a resident of California or a member or a family member living with a member of the military stationed in California. The victim or derivative victim must have sustained either physical injury or emotional injury for specified crimes.
Once an application is filed, the board is required to verify with hospitals, physicians, law enforcement officials, or other interested parties involved, the treatment of the victim or derivative victim, circumstances of the crime, amounts paid or received by or for the victim or derivative victim, and any other pertinent information deemed necessary by the board. Any verification information requested by the board must be returned within 10 days of the request. The applicant is also required to cooperate with the staff of the board or the victim center in the verification of the information contained in the application. Failure to cooperate may constitute grounds to reject the application. The board is required to approve or deny applications within an average of 90 days and no later than 180 calendar days of acceptance by the board or victim center.
Under existing law, the board may deny an application based on a finding that the victim was involved in the events leading to the crime or the victim’s failure to reasonably cooperate with law enforcement. [Citations omitted.]
A victim may receive a total maximum payment of $70,000 from VCB. Payments are paid from a combination of state funds and federal matching funds. Specifically, claims are paid from the Restitution Fund, which is a continuously-appropriated fund, and a 60-percent match (of state funds spent) from the federal Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) grant.
Existing law requires a victim or directive victim to file a claim for compensation within seven years of the date of the crime, seven years after the victim attains age 21, or seven years from the discovery that an injury or death had been sustained as a direct result of the crime, whichever is later.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Include in the definition of “crime,” for purposes of VCP, the use of force by a peace officer that is beyond what is reasonable under the totality of the circumstances, and that causes the victim injury or death, regardless of whether the peace officer is arrested for or charged with the commission of a crime or a public offense.
- Redefine “crime,” for purposes of VCP, to include any public offense, as specified, regardless of whether any suspect is arrested for or charged with the commission of the crime.
- Recast the factors that may be considered in determining whether the victim was involved in the events leading to the qualifying crime.
- Prohibit VCB, notwithstanding the prohibition to compensation due to a victim’s involvement in the events leading to a qualified crime, from denying an application based upon the victim’s involvement in the crime if the claim is for injury or death that happened as a result of the use of excessive force by a peace officer.
- Prohibit VCB from determining that a victim failed to cooperate with law enforcement based upon their conduct with law enforcement at the scene of the crime or in a hospital following the crime.
- Prohibit a determination that there was lack of cooperation by the victim solely because a victim delayed in reporting the qualifying crime.
- Prohibit VCB from denying an application based solely upon the victim’s failure to cooperate if the claim is for injury or death that happened as a result of the use of excessive force by a peace officer.
- Prohibit VCB from denying an application for a claim based on injuries or death as a result of the use of excessive force by a peace officer based solely on a police report, or the lack thereof, or based upon whether the peace officer was arrested or charged with a crime. Absent a police report, these claims would be allowed to be supported by other evidence.
- Prohibit VCB from denying an application, in whole or in part, based solely upon the contents of a police report, or because a police report was not made by the victim, or based upon whether any suspect was arrested or charged with the qualifying crime. It would require VCB to consider other evidence to establish that a qualifying crime occurred.
- Take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Staff Comments:
According to the 2019 Crime in California report by the Department of Justice, there were 15,890 civilian complaints against peace officers, including 865 criminal complaints. The expansion to the definition of a crime involving use of force “that is beyond what is reasonable under the totality of the circumstances” in proposed Government Code section 13951, subdivision (b)(3) could be interpreted and applied in a variety of ways and, consequently, could lead to a larger number of compensation claims submitted that may not meet the general understanding of “excessive force” incidents. Moreover, VCB also may have difficulty in navigating the expanded definition in making eligibility determinations. Additionally, by including all peace officers as defined in Penal Code section 830, this measure would allow claims related to the injury or death of a victim when the incident involves a whole host of officers, including, but not limited to, correctional/custodial officers, California Highway Patrol officers, park officers, state hospital police officers, and Franchise Tax Board investigative specialists, thereby leading to a further increase in the number of claims that would be eligible for compensation through VCP. Using these factors as a guide of how many claims potentially could be submitted under this measure, if 1,000 individuals applied annually and received the maximum compensation amount of $70,000, it would lead to $70 million in compensation payouts to direct victims alone. This would be exclusive of compensation payments to derivative victims and costs for workload that would be necessary to handle the higher volume of claims. Additionally, as existing law provides victims seven years within which to submit a compensation claim, VCB likely would have to process, decide, and payout claims for incidents going as far back as 2013.
The Restitution Fund has been operating under a structural deficient for a number of years. In the Budget Act of 2020, the Legislature appropriated $23.5 million from the General Fund to the Restitution Fund to address the imbalance and keep the fund solvent through the 2020-2021 fiscal year. Given the operational deficit of the Restitution Fund, added expenses (such as those associated with AB 767) would create greater cost pressure on the General Fund to backfill a larger shortage.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 767 Hearing Date: August 7, 2020
Author: | Grayson | ||
Version: | August 3, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Victim Compensation: Use of Excessive Force by a Peace Officer
HISTORY
Source: Betty T. Yee, California State Controller
Californians for Safety and Justice
Prior Legislation: AB 375 (Durazo), Ch. 592, 2019
SB 1232 (Bradford), Ch. 983, Stats. 2018
SB 381 (de León), 2017, held in Assembly Appropriations Comm.
AB 1061 (Gloria), 2017, held in Assembly Appropriations Comm.
SB 556 (Grayson), 2016, held in Assembly Appropriations Comm.
AB 2160 (Bonta), 2016, held in Assembly Appropriations Comm.
SB 1324 (Hancock), Ch. 730, Stats. 2016
AB 1563 (Rodriguez), Ch. 121, Stats. 2016
AB 1140 (Bonta), Ch. 569, Stats. 2015
AB 2685 (Cooley), Ch. 508, Stats. 2014
SB 1299 (Wright), Ch. 870, Stats. 2012
Support: San Francisco District Attorney’s Office; Underground GRIT; Youth Alive!
Opposition: None known
Assembly Floor Vote: Not Relevant
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to expand eligibility for compensation under the Victims Compensation Program for injuries or death caused by use of force by a police officer.
Existing law states that the Legislature finds and declares that it is in the public interest to assist residents of the State of California in obtaining compensation for the pecuniary losses they suffer as a direct result of criminal acts. (Gov. Code, § 13950, subd. (a).)
Existing law establishes the California Victims Compensation Claims Board (board) to operate the California Victim Compensation Program (CalVCP). (Gov. Code, §§ 13950 et. seq.)
Existing law authorizes the board to reimburse for pecuniary loss for the following types of losses:
- Medical or medical-related expenses incurred by the victim for services provided by a licensed medical provider;
- Out-patient psychiatric, psychological or other mental health counseling-related expenses incurred by the victim or derivative victim, including peer counseling services provided by a rape crisis center;
- Compensation equal to the loss of income or loss of support, or both, that a victim or derivative victim incurs as a direct result of the victim’s injury or the victim’s death;
- Cash payment to, or on behalf of, the victim for job retraining or similar employment-oriented services;
- The expense of installing or increasing residential security, not to exceed $1,000;
- The expense of renovating or retrofitting a victim’s residence or a vehicle to make them accessible or operational, if it is medically necessary;
- Relocation expenses up to $2,000 if the expenses are determined by law enforcement to be necessary for the victim's personal safety, or by a mental health treatment provider to be necessary for the emotional well-being of the victim; and,
- Funeral or burial expenses. (Gov. Code, § 13957, subd. (a).)
Existing law limits the total award to or on behalf of each victim to $35,000, except that this amount may be increased up to $70,000 if federal funds for that increase are available. (Gov. Code, § 13957, subd. (b).)
Existing law provides than an application for compensation shall be filed with the board in the manner determined by the board. (Gov. Code, § 13952, subd. (a).)
Existing law authorizes the board to require submission of additional information supporting the application that is reasonably necessary to verify the application and determine eligibility for compensation. (Gov. Code, § 13952, subd. (c)(1).)
Existing law requires the board to verify with hospitals, physicians, law enforcement officials, or other interested parties involved, the treatment of the victim or derivative victim, circumstances of the crime, amounts paid or received by or for the victim or derivative victim, and any other pertinent information deemed necessary by the board. (Gov. Code, § 13954, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires an application to be filed in accordance with the following timelines:
- Within seven years of the date of the crime;
- Seven years after the victim attains 21 years of age; or,
- Seven years of the time the victim or derivative victim knew or in the exercise of ordinary diligence could have discovered than an injury or death had been sustained as a direct result of crime, whichever is later. (Gov. Code, § 13953, subd. (a).)
Existing law defines “victim” to mean an individual who sustains injury or death as a direct result of a crime as specified. (Gov. Code, 13951, subd. (e).)
Existing law defines “derivative victim” to mean an individual who sustains pecuniary loss as a result of injury or death to a victim. (Gov. Code, 13951, subd. (e).)
Existing law defines “crime” for purposes of victim compensation to mean “a crime or public offense, wherever it may take place, that would constitute a misdemeanor or a felony if the crime had been committed in California by a competent adult. (Gov. Code, § 13951, subd. (b)(1).)
This bill amends the definition of “crime” to specify that a suspect need not be arrested or charged for the commission of the crime.
This bill additionally defines “crime” to include the use of force by a peace officer that is beyond what is reasonable under the totality of circumstances and causes injury or death to the victim, regardless of whether the peace officer is arrested for, charged with, or convicted of committing a crime or public offense.
This bill provides that “peace officer” has the same meaning as in Section 830 of the Penal Code.
This bill defines “victim services provider” to mean an individual, whether paid or serving as a volunteer, who provides services to victims under the auspices or supervision of either an agency or organization that has a documented record of providing services to victims, or a law enforcement or prosecution agency.
Existing law provides that a person shall not be eligible for compensation under the following conditions:
- If the board finds that denial is appropriate because of the nature of the victim’s or other applicant’s involvement in the events leading to the crime, or the involvement of the person whose injury or death gives rise to the application. Factors that may be considered when making this determination include, but are not limited to:
- The victim or derivative victim initiated the qualifying crime, or provoked or aggravated the suspect into initiating the qualifying crime;
- The qualifying crime was a reasonably foreseeable consequence of the conduct of the victim or derivative victim;
- The victim or derivative victim was committing a crime that could be charged as a felony and reasonably lead to them being victimized, unless the injury or death occurred as a direct result of specified crimes including rape, domestic violence, or statutory rape where the minor is under 16 and the perpetrator is over 20.
- If the board finds that the victim or, if compensation is sought by, or on behalf of, a derivative victim, either the victim or derivative victim failed to cooperate reasonably with a law enforcement agency in the apprehension and conviction of a criminal committing the crime. In determining whether cooperation has been reasonable, the board shall consider:
- The victim’s or derivative victim’s age, physical condition, and psychological state, cultural or linguistic barriers, any compelling health and safety concerns, including but not limited to, a reasonable fear of retaliation or harm that would jeopardize the well-being of the victim or victim’s family or the derivative victim or derivative victim’s family, and giving due consideration to the degree of cooperation of which the victim or derivative victim is capable in light of the presence of any of these factors.
- A victim of domestic violence shall not be determined to have failed to cooperate based on their conduct with law enforcement at the scene of the crime.
- Lack of cooperation shall not be found solely because a victim of sexual assault, domestic violence, or human trafficking delayed reporting the qualifying crime. (Gov. Code, § 13956, subds. (a) & (b).)
Existing law states that if the victim is determined to have been involved in the events leading to the qualifying crime, factors that may be considered to mitigate or overcome involvement include, but are not limited to:
- The victim’s injuries were significantly more serious than reasonably could have been expected based on the victim’s level of involvement;
- A third party interfered in a manner not foreseeable by the victim or derivative victim; and,
- The board shall consider the victim’s age, physical condition, and psychological state, as well as any compelling health and safety concerns, in determining whether the application should be denied for this reason. (Gov. Code, § 13956, subd. (a)(2).)
This bill states that victim or derivative victim’s involvement in the events leading to the crime requires that they initiated the qualifying crime, or directly provoked or aggravated the suspect into committing the qualifying crime.
This bill further provides for involvement in the events leading to the crime, the victim or derivative victim must have knowingly and willingly committed a crime that could be charged as a felony, absent consideration of any enhancement or prior conviction which reasonably lead to them being victimized.
This bill states that an application for compensation based on peace officer use of force shall not be denied based upon the victim’s involvement in the crime or the victim’s failure to cooperate.
Existing law states that a victim of domestic violence shall not be determined to have failed to cooperate based on his or her conduct with law enforcement at the scene of the crime. Lack of cooperation shall also not be found solely because a victim of sexual assault, domestic violence, or human trafficking delayed reporting the qualifying crime. (Gov. Code, § 13956, subd. (b)(1).)
This bill applies the above provision to all victims applying for compensation and also states that a victim shall not be determined to have failed to cooperate based on their conduct with law enforcement in a hospital following the crime.
Existing law provides that an application for a claim based on domestic violence, human trafficking, or sexual assault shall not be denied solely because a police report was not made by the victim and requires the board to adopt guidelines that allow it to consider and approve applications for assistance other than a police report to establish that a sexual assault crime has occurred. (Gov. Code, § 13956, subd. (b)(2)-(4).
This bill provides that if an application for a claim based on injury or death that happened as a result of police use of force, the board shall not deny the application based solely on a police report, or the lack thereof, or based upon whether the law enforcement officer was arrested or charged with a crime. If there is no police report, the application may be supported by other evidence to establish that a crime occurred.
Existing law provides factors for the board to consider outside of a police report for applications for claims based on sexual assault, human trafficking or domestic violence to determine that a crime has occurred including, but not limited to medical records or mental health records. (Gov. Code, § 13956, subd. (b)(2)-(5).)
This bill states that notwithstanding other provisions, the board shall not deny an application, in whole or in part, based solely on the contents of the police report, or because a police report was not made by the victim, or based upon whether any suspect was arrested or charged with the qualifying crime. The board shall consider other evidence to establish that a qualifying crime occurred. The additional factors evidencing that a qualifying crime has occurred may include, but are not limited to, the following:
- A written statement provided by a victim services provider who has provided services to the victim or derivative victim in response to the impact of the qualifying crime;
- A statement provided by a credible witness to the qualifying crime;
- A permanent restraining order or protective order issued by a court to protect or separate the victim or derivative victim from the person responsible for the qualifying crime;
- A statement from a licensed medical provider, physician’s assistant, nurse practitioner, or other person licensed to provide medical or mental healthcare documenting that the victim experienced physical, mental, or emotional injury as a result of the qualifying crime;
- Video, audio, or photographic recordings of the commission of the qualifying crime; or,
- Any other reliable corroborating evidence that the board finds sufficient to reasonably establish that a qualifying crime occurred.
This bill contains an urgency clause.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
Current eligibility restrictions can lock survivors out of compensation, and victims of police violence and their families typically cannot access compensation.
CalVCB has discretion to deny applications if it determines the victim’s involvement in the events gives rise to the application. In cases of police violence, a police report documenting the victimization is often elusive. And, CalVCB must rely on a police report when assessing the victim’s role. They are not given the same flexibility, as given to victims of other crimes, to use forms of documentation other than a police report.
Many crime survivors are denied access to needed resources because they have failed to report to law enforcement. Yet data collected by the Bureau of Justice Statistics found that only 45% of violent victimizations are ever reported to police. People do not report crimes to law enforcement for various reasons, including fear of reprisal or negative past interactions with police.
- Purpose and History of CalVCP
The victim compensation program was created in 1965, the first such program in the country. The board provides compensation for victims of violent crime. It reimburses eligible victims for many crime-related expenses, such as counseling and medical fees. Funding for the board comes from restitution fines and penalty assessments paid by criminal offenders, as well as federal matching funds. (See the California Victim Compensation Board’s (CalVCB) website <http://www.vcgcb.ca.gov/board/> [as of July 16, 2020].)
The CalVCB is considered the payer of last resort and can only pay treatment expenses after other available sources of payment have been applied to a bill. Those sources include, but are not limited to, health insurance, workers compensation insurance, automobile insurance, Medi-cal, and Medicare. (CalVCB’s website, Billing and Payments page <https://victims.ca.gov/providers/billing.aspx#:~:text=The%20Victim%20Compensation%20Board%20is,been%20applied%20to%20a%20bill> [as of July 16, 2020].)
- Eligibility Requirements for Compensation
The CalVCP reimburses eligible victims for specified expenses such as counseling and medical fees. Eligible persons are victims and derivative victims and the crime either occurred in California or the victim is a resident of California or a member or a family member living with a member of the military stationed in California. The victim or derivative victim must have sustained either physical injury or emotional injury for specified crimes.
Once an application is filed, the board is required to verify with hospitals, physicians, law enforcement officials, or other interested parties involved, the treatment of the victim or derivative victim, circumstances of the crime, amounts paid or received by or for the victim or derivative victim, and any other pertinent information deemed necessary by the board. Any verification information requested by the board must be returned within 10 days of the request. The applicant is also required to cooperate with the staff of the board or the victim center in the verification of the information contained in the application. Failure to cooperate may constitute grounds to reject the application. The board is required to approve or deny applications within an average of 90 days and no later than 180 calendar days of acceptance by the board or victim center.
Under existing law, the board may deny an application based on a finding that the victim was involved in the events leading to the crime or the victim’s failure to reasonably cooperate with law enforcement. The proponents of this bill state that these disqualifying factors unjustly exclude victims of excessive police force from compensation. Specifically, the board may find that the victim was involved in the events leading up to their own injury or death because of an infraction or some other minor act that caused the police to initiate contact or because the victim resisted the officer’s orders during the encounter. The board may also find that the victim failed to reasonably cooperate with law enforcement by not filing a police report regarding the use of force or not answering officers’ questions when arrested or detained.
This bill provides statutory authority for victims of police use of force to apply for victim compensation. This bill accomplishes this by expanding the definition of a qualifying crime to include “the use of force by a peace officer that is beyond what is reasonable under the totality of circumstances, and causes the victim injury or death. . . .” Because this is a new standard for a qualifying crime, it is unclear what evidence may be needed to help the board make this highly factual finding. This bill further provides that the board shall not deny the application based solely on a police report, or the lack thereof, or based upon whether the law enforcement officer was arrested or charged with a crime. If there is no police report, the application may be supported by other evidence to establish that a crime occurred.
This bill also makes changes to existing laws that that impact victims in general, not just those who are injured or killed by police use of force. Specifically, the bill makes changes to the provisions describing victim involvement in events leading to the crime by requiring that the victim or derivative victim directly provoked or aggravated the suspect into committing the crime. Also, if involvement means the victim or derivative victim was committing a felony, the victim or must have knowingly and willingly committed the offense and the offense must be one that can be charged as a felony absent consideration of any enhancement or prior conviction. This bill also provides that a victim shall not have failed to cooperated based on their conduct with law enforcement in a hospital following the crime.
- Fund Condition of CalVCP
The CalVCB Restitution Fund has been operating under a structural deficient for a number of years. In 2015, the Legislative Analyst’s Office reported the CalVCB Restitution Fund was depleting and would eventually face insolvency. Although revenue has remained consistent, expenditures have outpaced revenues since FY 2015-16. The Governor’s 2020-21 revised budget allocated $23.5 million dollars in one-time General Fund monies to backfill declining fine and fee revenues in the Restitution Fund. This amount will allow the CalVCB to continue operating at its current resource level. Expanding compensation eligibility to victims currently not eligible will put cost pressures on an already deficient fund. Additionally, whether the bill applies retroactively (currently VCP has a statute of limitations of 7 years) or prospectively can greatly impact costs as well.
- San Francisco District Attorney’s Office Victim Compensation for Police Violence
In June of this year, San Francisco District Attorney Chesa Boudin announced a new policy to provide compensation for victims of police violence that occurred in San Francisco or to a San Francisco resident. The new program will make victims and their families eligible for up to $7,500 in funeral costs, $5,000 for medical bills, $2,500 for relocation costs, $1,000 for mental health treatment and $1,000 for crime scene cleanup if property is damaged during an incident. The district attorney’s office will determine eligibility and may require documentation of harm such as medical bills. The program will not apply retroactively. (Iovino, San Francisco DA Makes Victims of Police Violence Eligible for Compensation, Courthouse News Service (June 9, 2020) < https://www.courthousenews.com/san-francisco-da-makes-victims-of-police-violence-eligible-for-compensation/> [as of July 30, 2020].)
- Argument in Support
According to Californians for Safety and Justice, a cosponsor of this bill:
Current eligibility restrictions can lock survivors out of compensation, and victims of police violence and their families typically cannot access compensation. The California Victim Compensation Board (CalVCB) has discretion to deny applications if it determines the victim’s involvement in the events leading to the crime... gives rise to the application, or if it finds the survivor “failed to cooperate reasonably” with law enforcement. These restrictions apply even to homicide victims, compounding trauma for family members who are left without needed support for funeral expenses and other critical supports. These determinations also leave room for implicit bias to enter the process, and open survivors up to judgment based on their past interactions with law enforcement and perceptions of criminality.
In cases of police brutality, a police report documenting the victimization is often elusive. Survivors and witnesses may also not want to speak with officers, resulting in exclusion from compensation for noncooperation. And, CalVCB must rely on a police report when assessing the victim’s role, which can be biased in cases where the very people responsible for the injury or death are those tasked with documenting it and assigning blame.
AB 767 takes a comprehensive approach to tackling these issues and is driven by the calls from survivors to remove unjust barriers to compensation. Overall, this bill will further improve survivor experiences with the compensation program as a payer of last resort.
-- END –
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
BILL NO: AB 767
AUTHOR: | Wicks | ||
VERSION: | June 6, 2019 | ||
HEARING DATE: | July 10, 2019 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Teri Boughton | ||
SUBJECT: Health care coverage: in vitro fertilization
SUMMARY:
Requires Covered California, in consultation with stakeholders, to develop options for the inclusion of in vitro fertilization coverage as part of, or as supplementary to, coverage currently offered through Covered California, and report the options to the Legislature on or before July 1, 2020.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Services Plan Act of 1975; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health and other insurers; Covered California as California’s health benefit exchange for individual and small business purchasers as authorized under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA); and, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to administer the Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1340, et seq., INS §106, et seq., GOV §100500 -100522, and WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Establishes as California's essential health benefits (EHBs) benchmark the Kaiser Small Group Health Maintenance Organization, existing California mandates (including medically necessary basic health care services), and ten ACA mandated benefits. Requires non-grandfathered individual and small group plan contracts and insurance policies to cover these EHBs. [HSC §1367.005 and INS §10112.27]
- Requires most health plan contracts and health insurance policies to offer group coverage for the treatment of infertility, except in vitro fertilization (IVF), as defined. This does not apply to health maintenance organizations with group contract holders with less than 20 employees to whom the plan is offered. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
- Defines “infertility” as either the presence of a demonstrated condition recognized by a licensed physician and surgeon as a cause of infertility, or, the inability to conceive a pregnancy or to carry a pregnancy to live birth after a year or more of regular sexual relations without contraception. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
- Defines “treatment for infertility” as procedures consistent with established medical practices in the treatment of infertility by licensed physicians and surgeons including, but not limited to, diagnosis, diagnostic tests, medication, surgery, and gamete intrafallopian transfer. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
- Defines “IVF” as the laboratory medical procedures involving the actual IVF process. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
- Prohibits 3) above from being construed to require any employer or other specified organizations that are religious organizations to offer coverage for forms of treatment of infertility in a manner inconsistent with the religious organization’s religious and ethical principles. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
- Requires coverage for infertility treatment to be offered and, if purchased, provided without discrimination on the basis of age, ancestry, color, disability, domestic partner status, gender, gender expression, gender identity, genetic information, marital status, national origin, race religion, sex, or sexual orientation. [HSC §1374.55 and INS §10119.6]
This bill:
- Requires Covered California, in consultation with stakeholders, to develop options for the inclusion of IVF coverage as part of, or as supplementary to, coverage currently offered through Covered California. Requires Covered California to consider options that minimize impact on premiums, and state fiscal impact.
- Requires, on or before July 1, 2020, Covered California to report to the Legislature on these options, and make the report publicly available on its internet website.
- Sunsets this bill on January 1, 2022.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 59 - 10 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 14 - 0 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 11 - 2 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, infertility is a disease that affects millions of women of child bearing age in this country. While IVF is one of many effective treatments for infertility, it is explicitly excluded from being offered by health plans in California. This treatment option is unattainable for many couples who cannot afford it. Reproductive freedom should not be limited to those who can afford it. This bill will help remove the cost barrier to IVF treatment by requiring Covered California to develop options for the inclusion of the treatment as part of, or as supplementary to, coverage currently offered through Covered California. This change will provide access to IVF for those who cannot afford to pay for this medical treatment out of pocket.
- California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP) analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson, Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002) requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996, and reviewed an earlier version of this bill which would have required most group health plans and policies, excluding the individual market and Medi-Cal, to provide coverage for infertility treatments, including IVF, and mature oocyte cryopreservation. Key findings that remain relevant include:
- Background on infertility. Infertility is the inability to have a child and is a complex condition that can take many forms. There are numerous medical causes of infertility, and an individual can have more than one cause of infertility. Within a couple, one or both partners can have a cause of infertility. In the United States, results from a prospective cohort study of almost 400 women presenting at eight infertility practices showed that 58% of infertility cases were attributable to female factors, 7% were attributable to male factors, 31% were attributable to both male and female factors, and 4% were not directly attributable to either partner. National datasets of IVF use show that less than 1% of women initiating IVF at age 44 or older will have a live birth; however, women up to the age of menopause, average age 51 in the US, may experience fertility treatment success using donor materials. In contrast, males become able to produce sperm during puberty (median age 12 years) and, according to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), retain optimal reproductive capabilities until 60 years of age.
- Coverage impacts and enrollees covered. Currently, 4.3% of enrollees with health insurance in DMHC-regulated group plans or CDI-regulated group policies have coverage for infertility treatments, including IVF. Plans vary with regards to how infertility services are covered, such as imposing cost-sharing, age restrictions, restrictions on number of treatment cycles, or a cap on the dollar amount covered for services. Based on responses to the carrier survey, a portion of enrollees who currently have coverage for infertility services have cost sharing for infertility services that is the same as major medical services. For enrollees who have infertility coverage but do not have the same cost share as major medical services, CHBRP found in its carrier survey that coverage includes a 50% co-insurance for these services, including IVF, without an out of pocket maximum.
- Medical effectiveness. CHBRP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF is an effective treatment for infertility, resulting in increased pregnancy rates and live birth rates. There is also a preponderance of evidence that planned mature oocyte cryopreservation (OC) is an effective treatment for infertility, resulting in pregnancies and live births. CHBRP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF is associated with certain maternal harms, including ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and thromboembolism. There is also clear and convincing evidence that IVF can lead to multiple gestation and preterm delivery. However, it is important to note that multiple gestation is associated with higher numbers of embryos transferred per cycle, and that preterm delivery is associated with multiple gestation — these outcomes can be mitigated by single embryo transfers. CHRBP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF mandates are associated with lower numbers of embryos transferred per cycle. There is also a preponderance of evidence that IVF mandates lead to fewer births per cycle (due to the decreased number of embryos transferred per cycle), and a reduction in overall harms of IVF (i.e., lower rates of multiple gestation, preterm deliveries, and low birthweight births).
- Utilization. Data from a cohort of couples recruited from eight community and academic endocrinology clinics in California indicates that out-of-pocket costs are significant and may impact overall utilization of infertility treatments. The median out-of-pocket cost of infertility treatments is estimated to range from $912 for medications alone, up to $19,234 for one cycle of IVF, with each additional cycle of IVF costing $6,995. Further analysis found that, on average, couples undergo 3.7 cycles of IVF, which means that an average couple utilizing IVF might accrue up to $40,219 in out-of-pocket treatment costs for infertility treatment. Costs were even higher for couples utilizing donor eggs. In addition to oocyte retrieval and IVF, persons undergoing planned OC generally also need to pay out of pocket for frozen storage costs, which range from $100 to $1,500 per year (average $300/year). Treatments for infertility are also complex and time-consuming, with one study estimating that a single cycle of IVF could account for 15.6 work-day equivalents, mostly in administrative time.
- Background on infertility. Infertility is the inability to have a child and is a complex condition that can take many forms. There are numerous medical causes of infertility, and an individual can have more than one cause of infertility. Within a couple, one or both partners can have a cause of infertility. In the United States, results from a prospective cohort study of almost 400 women presenting at eight infertility practices showed that 58% of infertility cases were attributable to female factors, 7% were attributable to male factors, 31% were attributable to both male and female factors, and 4% were not directly attributable to either partner. National datasets of IVF use show that less than 1% of women initiating IVF at age 44 or older will have a live birth; however, women up to the age of menopause, average age 51 in the US, may experience fertility treatment success using donor materials. In contrast, males become able to produce sperm during puberty (median age 12 years) and, according to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), retain optimal reproductive capabilities until 60 years of age.
CHBRP examined claims data for estimates of utilization of infertility services among enrollees in California. There are approximately 53,000 users of female diagnostic tests and 14,000 users of medications for infertility (i.e., only medications and no other service). Intrauterine insemination (IUI) utilization is about 9,000 users annually. IVF services alone (i.e. without Intracytoplasmic sperm injection [ICSI]) is estimated to have about 2,000 users and ICSI, which is done with IVF, is about 2,000 users annually. For males, there are 25,000 users of diagnostic tests and 11,000 users of any male treatment. There are an estimated 7,000 pregnancies due to the use of infertility services and 6,000 live births from these pregnancies. In California, 41.2% of all IVF procedures result in pregnancy, 67.5% of which result in live birth, 12.4% are twin live birth, and 1.6% are multiple births.
- Public health. Although CHBRP found evidence that engaging in infertility treatments may result in short-term psychosocial harms, evidence-based literature also indicates that the inability to have wanted children is itself associated with stress, anxiety, depression, and quality of life deficits that are likely to decrease upon the achievement of a successful pregnancy through treatment. Therefore, it stands to reason that mental health and quality of life would improve for the additional persons and couples who would have a live birth resulting from infertility treatments.
- Public health. Although CHBRP found evidence that engaging in infertility treatments may result in short-term psychosocial harms, evidence-based literature also indicates that the inability to have wanted children is itself associated with stress, anxiety, depression, and quality of life deficits that are likely to decrease upon the achievement of a successful pregnancy through treatment. Therefore, it stands to reason that mental health and quality of life would improve for the additional persons and couples who would have a live birth resulting from infertility treatments.
- Other states. Currently, 14 states have laws that require insurance companies to cover infertility treatment and two states (California and Texas) have laws that require insurance companies to offer coverage for infertility treatment. States that require coverage of infertility treatment are: Arkansas, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Rhode Island, and West Virginia, and most recently Delaware, which passed legislation in 2018. In 2019, New York amended its existing mandate through a measure in the 2020 state budget that mandates certain large-group insurance plans cover IVF, and requires all private insurance companies to cover medically necessary egg freezing. While most states with laws requiring insurance companies to offer or provide coverage for infertility treatment include coverage for IVF, California and Louisiana have laws that specifically exclude coverage for the procedure. Other examples of unique state laws are Louisiana and New York’s previous law, which prohibit the exclusion of coverage for a medical condition otherwise covered solely because the condition results in infertility; Minnesota, which specifies that medical assistance will not provide coverage for fertility drugs when specifically used to enhance fertility; and Utah, which requires insurers providing coverage for maternity benefits to also provide an indemnity benefit for adoption or infertility treatments. Limits on infertility coverage in other states that mandate coverage include applying dollar lifetime caps, and limiting the number of treatment cycles covered.
- EHB plan selection. Under the ACA, qualified health plans (QHPs) are sold through Covered California and also provide coverage to individuals and small employers not through Covered California. QHPs are required to ensure coverage of EHBs, as defined by the federal Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS). EHBs must include coverage of services and items in all ten statutory categories required in the ACA. In addition, states are permitted to choose a benchmark plan as the basis for a state’s EHBs. California has reviewed its EHB options twice. Once in 2012 and again in 2015. On both occasions, the consulting firm, Milliman, analyzed and compared the health services covered by the ten EHB California benchmark plan options. Both times the plans compared were comprehensive with small cost differences between them. The Legislature, with stakeholder input, chose the Kaiser Small Group HMO, which was also the default plan had California not made an affirmative choice. However, Milliman found differing coverage among the plan options for acupuncture, infertility treatment, chiropractic care, and hearing aids. In 2015, the three California small group plans were essentially the same average cost as the California EHB plan; and, the California large group and CalPERS plans were approximately 0.2-1% higher. The estimated average costs for the three federal plan options were approximately 0.8-1.2% higher than the California EHB benchmark plan. With this information, the Legislature passed SB 43 (Hernandez, Chapter 648, Statutes of 2015) which adopted the federal definition of habilitative services and maintained the Kaiser Small Group HMO Plan as California’s EHB benchmark. The Kaiser Small Group HMO Plan does not cover infertility treatment.
- Benchmark plan. Under a new regulation issued in 2018, a state may change its EHB-benchmark plan for plan years on or after January 1, 2020 by: a) selecting the EHB-benchmark plan that another state used for the 2017 plan year; b) replacing one or more categories of EHBs in the state’s benchmark plan used for the 2017 plan year with the same category or categories of EHBs from the EHB-benchmark plan that another state used for the 2017 plan year; c) or, otherwise selecting a set of benefits that would become the state’s EHB benchmark plan. The regulation requires the scope of benefits to be equal to, or greater than, the scope of benefits of a typical employer plan, to the extent any supplementation is required to provide coverage within each EHB category. The scope of benefits cannot exceed the generosity of the most generous among a set of comparison plans, including the state’s EHB benchmark plan used for the 2017 plan year, and any of the state’s base-benchmark plan options for the 2017 plan year. According to Covered California, the proposed federal deadline to select a new EHB benchmark plan for the 2022 plan year is May 8, 2020. The regulation also requires the state to provide reasonable public notice and an opportunity for public comment on the state’s selection of an EHB-benchmark plan.
- Related legislation. SB 600 (Portantino) requires a health plan contract or health insurance policy that covers hospital, medical, or surgical expenses, and Medi-Cal, to include coverage for medically necessary expenses for standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may directly or indirectly cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. SB 600 is scheduled to be heard in the Assembly Health Committee on June 9, 2019.
AB 888 (Low) among other provisions, finds and declares nonpharmacological treatments for pain are vitally important to the state’s efforts to combat the opioid crisis, and that coverage of these treatments should be considered during the next update to the state’s EHB benchmark plan, as specified. AB 888 is pending in the Senate Committee on Business Professions and Economic Development.
AB 598 (Bloom) requires a health plan contract or health insurance policy issued, amended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, to include coverage for hearing aids up to the maximum covered amount of $3,000 per individual hearing aid, for all enrollees under 18 years of age when medically necessary. AB 598 passed the Senate Health Committee by an 8-0 vote on on June 26, 2019.
- Prior legislation. SB 172 (Portantino of 2017) would have required health plan contracts and health insurance policies to provide coverage for medically necessary expenses for standard fertility preservation services when medical treatment may directly or indirectly cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. SB 172 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 912 (Quirk-Silva of 2013) would have mandated that every large group health plan contract and health insurance policy to provide coverage for medically necessary expenses for standard fertility preservation services when a necessary medical treatment may directly or indirectly cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. AB 912 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated in part:
Large group employers already have the ability to negotiate richer benefit packages that meet the needs of their employees. While I understand the desire to preserve fertility where possible, such coverage was not included in the essential health benefits that the Legislature passed just last year for individual and small group coverage. Coverage that goes beyond the essential health benefits is no doubt useful and desirable for many, but we should not consider mandating additional benefits until we implement the comprehensive package of reforms that are required by the [ACA].
AB 428 (Portantino of 2011) was substantially similar to SB 172. AB 428 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
AB 1826 (Migden of 2002) would have required health plans and disability insurers provide, instead of just offer, coverage for the treatment of infertility. Expands the coverage for the treatment of infertility by including IVF. AB 1826 was never voted on in the Assembly Health Committee.
- Support. Proponents write that due to the lack of coverage for comprehensive infertility treatment options, the majority of patients that are able to access care are people of means that can come up with the out-of-pocket costs related to treatment. This disproportionately affects low-income individuals and partners that wish to start a family. The costs associated with infertility treatment should not bar persons from parenthood merely because they cannot afford medical treatment. It is time that California follows the lead of states such as New York by extending coverage to those who are diagnosed with infertility and provide them with options to treat their condition. The California Pan Ethnic health Network writes that infertility is a serious and chronic health condition, with health, social, and economic impacts. Rates of infertility differ by race, with black women experiencing it at nearly twice the rate of white women. Despite this, only 8% of black women have sought fertility services, compared to 15% of white women. An even lower percentage of Latinas (7.6%) have sought services. The disparity in seeking treatment has been found to be related largely to the cost of services, and puts treatment out of reach for many women.
- Opposition. According to the California Chamber of Commerce, the addition of IVF coverage would exceed the EHBs, requiring the state to defray the costs of state mandated benefits. When health care issuers are required to cover new services such as infertility treatment, premiums for all enrollees and purchasers go up. This is true even though only some enrollees will utilize the mandated product or service. This bill previously mandated that all health care issuers cover infertility treatment, forcing all enrollees and purchasers to pay more in premiums whether or not they will ever use these services or find this added coverage to be a good value. The California Association of Health Plans, the Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies, and America’s Health Insurance Plans oppose mandate bills that lead to higher premiums, harming affordability and access for small businesses and individual market consumers. Over the past several years, employers have been losing more and more flexibility to set their own benefit designs due to costly state and federal regulations. These mandates will add to those higher health care costs.
- Oppose unless amended. The California Catholic Conference asks that this bill be amended to include research of the health risks to women and overall statistics regarding IVF within California and nationwide, and hopes that the report can be clear and transparent of the IVF process in order for the legislature and all Californians to be well-informed.
- Policy comments.
- Covered California. If the author’s intent is to ensure coverage in the large group market for IVF treatment for infertility, it is not clear why Covered California is being tasked with the responsibility to conduct this study. It may be appropriate for Covered California to conduct this study if it is the author’s intent to impact EHBs which would apply to individual and small group plans only.
- EHB and Mandates. California’s existing coverage mandates, including EHB, provide comprehensive benefit coverage. While many policy arguments can be made to advance additional mandated benefits, Committee members may also wish to consider the cumulative effect of these bills and the tradeoffs associated with increasing health insurance premiums in the context of the already high cost of health insurance, another potential restructuring of health insurance markets nationally and in California because of actions taking place at the federal level to repeal the ACA, and in consideration of the budget action to fund state financial assistance to help Californians afford their health insurance, and a requirement that Californians have health insurance.
- EHB Benchmark Review. The Legislature has reviewed California’s benchmark plan twice before. Additionally, the process required under federal ACA requirements has changed from previous requirements. Since multiple bills have been introduced aimed at expanding benefits beyond California’s current EHBs, it may be time for California to review its benchmark plan options again.
- Covered California. If the author’s intent is to ensure coverage in the large group market for IVF treatment for infertility, it is not clear why Covered California is being tasked with the responsibility to conduct this study. It may be appropriate for Covered California to conduct this study if it is the author’s intent to impact EHBs which would apply to individual and small group plans only.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Black Health Network
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
National Association of Social Workers, CA Chapter
Oppose: America’s Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
California Association of Health Plans
California Catholic Conference (unless amended)
California Chamber of Commerce
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 767
Author:(Wicks)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
States the intent of the Legislature to consider the inclusion of infertility treatment in the definition of essential health benefits (EHBs).
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP) analysis. It should be noted this bill was substantially amended in the Assembly Appropriations Committee. CHBRP states in its analysis of a previous version of this bill requiring infertility coverage for in vitro fertilization (IVF), and mature oocyte cryopreservation (OC), on a group basis, the following:
- Enrollees covered. According to CHBRP, benefit coverage for infertility treatments, including IVF, would increase from 4.3% premandate to 100% postmandate. Benefit coverage of planned OC would increase from 0% premandate to 100% postmandate. This bill would likely exceed EHBs.
- Impact on expenditures. According to CHBRP, this bill would increase total net annual expenditures by $850.5 million or 0.49% for enrollees with Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC)-regulated group plans and California Department of Insurance (CDI)-regulated group policies. Per member per month (PMPM) premiums would increase between $2.76 among CalPERS HMOs (an increase of 0.47%) and $3.72 in the DMHC-regulated small-group market (an increase of 0.68%). CHBRP estimates that if 2% of women aged 25-37 years used planned OC services, the total expenditures would increase by $319.7 million. If a higher share of women aged 25-37 used planned OC (5%), total expenditures would increase by $799.2 million. This assumes the average cost for OC is $10,078.
- EHBs. State health insurance marketplaces, such as Covered California, are responsible for certifying and selling qualified health plans (QHPs) in the small-group and individual markets. QHPs are required to meet a minimum standard of benefits as defined by the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act as EHBs. In California, EHBs are related to the benefit coverage available in the Kaiser Foundation Health Plan Small Group Health Maintenance Organization 30 plan, the state’s benchmark plan for federal EHBs. States may require QHPs to offer benefits that exceed EHBs. However, a state that chooses to do so must make payments to defray the cost of those additionally mandated benefits, either by paying the purchaser directly or by paying the QHP. State rules related to provider types, cost-sharing, or reimbursement methods would not meet the definition of state benefit mandates that could exceed EHBs. This bill would require coverage for a new state benefit mandate that appears to exceed the definition of EHBs in California. CHBRP estimates that the state would potentially be required to defray the following amounts due to this bill: a) $6.52 PMPM for each QHP enrollee in a small-group DMHC-regulated plans; and, b) $7.14 PMPM for each QHP enrollee in a small-group CDI-regulated policy. CHBRP estimates that this translates to a state-responsibility of $52.5 million total, which includes: a) $51.5 million in payments to DMHC-regulated small group plans; and, b) $1 million in payments to CDI-regulated small group policies.
- Medical effectiveness. CHBRP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF is an effective treatment for infertility, resulting in increased pregnancy rates and live birth rates.
- Long-term impacts. In the short-term, the aggregate pregnancy and birth rate is expected to increase postmandate due to increased utilization of infertility services. In the longer term, it is possible that the coverage of infertility services results in encouraging couples to undergo infertility treatment earlier than they would normally and where pregnancy might be achieved naturally.
Other states. According to CHBRP, currently, 14 states have laws that require insurance companies to cover infertility treatment and two states, California and Texas, have laws that require insurance companies to offer coverage for infertility treatment. In 2019, New York amended its existing mandate through a budget measure in the 2020 state budget that mandates certain large-group insurance plans cover IVF, and requires all private insurance companies to cover medically necessary egg freezing. While most states with laws requiring insurance companies to offer or provide coverage for infertility treatment include coverage for IVF, California and Louisiana have laws that specifically exclude coverage for the procedure.
According to the Author:
According to the author, in a previous version of this bill, infertility is a disease that affects millions of women of child bearing age in this country. While IVF is one of many effective treatments for infertility, it is explicitly excluded from being offered by health plans in California. This prohibition of IVF health coverage in our state makes this treatment option unattainable for many couples who cannot afford it. Reproductive freedom should not be limited to those who can afford it. This bill would address this inequity in health coverage by requiring health plans and policies to provide IVF coverage so that women who seek infertility treatment can obtain IVF when needed.
Arguments in Support:
According to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, a sponsor of this bill, the right to procreate is a fundamental right, as recognized by Supreme Court case law. With that long recognized right in observance, it is crucial that California continues its leadership role in the country and take an affirmative act by protecting access to all reproductive health care services.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the California Chamber of Commerce, in a previous version, this bill would impose a new benefit mandate that exceeds EHBs established for individual and small group market plans and the state would be responsible for covering the cost to subsidize that benefit for individuals purchasing subsidized coverage through Covered California. The state has not enacted a benefit mandate that clearly exceeds EHB requirements. This mandate would set precedent and would result in ongoing annual costs to subsidize the provision of infertility treatment for individuals enrolled in health care coverage through Covered California.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 11-2-2
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Bonta, Burke, Carrillo, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago
NO: Bigelow, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mayes, Flora
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-4
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000940
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 767
Author:(Wicks) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 11 - 2 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires large-group health plans and insurers to cover treatment of infertility. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires coverage for a maximum of three cycles of in vitro fertilization and mature oocyte cryopreservation.
- Requires plans and insurers to limit the coverage required by paragraph (1) to a lifetime maximum benefit of $75,000 paid at contracted rates per enrollee.
- Defines “treatment of infertility” as procedures consistent with established medical practices in the treatment of infertility by a licensed physician and surgeon, including, but not limited to, diagnosis, diagnostic tests, medication, surgery, gamete intrafallopian transfer and in vitro fertilization (IVF).
- Exempts Medi-Cal managed care and individual and small-group markets from the coverage requirement.
- Eliminates a religious exemption that applies to the requirement to offer infertility coverage and does not allow a religious exemption to the requirement to cover infertility services.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- According to the California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP), this bill has no cost to Medi-Cal.
For CalPERS, CHBRP estimates costs of $14.5 million (GF/federal/special/local) with respect to infertility treatment.
- CHBRP reports the following private market costs with respect to infertility treatment:
- Increased employer-funded premium costs in the private insurance market of approximately $350 million.
- Increased premium expenditures by employees purchasing insurance of $31 million, and increased out of pocket expenses of $156 million, offset by a decrease in out-of-pocket expenses for non-covered benefits of $87 million.
- With respect to planned oocyte cryopreservation, CHBRP estimates if 2% of women aged 25–37 years used planned OC services, total expenditures would increase by $246 million (premiums for large-group insurance would increase by 0.67% and CalPERS HMO would increase by 0.80%). If 5% of women used the service, total expenditures would increase by $616 million (premium increases for large group insurance increase 1.08% and CalPERS HMO 1.29%). This assumes the average cost for OC is around $10,000.
- Minor and absorbable one-time costs to the California Department of Insurance (Insurance Fund) to verify compliance.
- Costs of about $140,000 in 2019-20, $300,000 in 201-21 and $200,000 ongoing to the Department of Managed Health Care (Managed Care Fund) to verify compliance.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, because treatment of infertility is not commonly covered by insurance, many individuals diagnosed with fertility problems are not able to access necessary treatment. The author believes reproductive freedom should not be limited to those who can afford it and that this bill creates equity by allowing individuals who cannot afford to pay out of pocket to access fertility treatments.
- Background. Currently, 14 states have laws that require insurance companies to cover infertility treatment and two states — California and Texas — have laws that require insurance companies to offer coverage for infertility treatment. There are a number of treatment options for women and men seeking medical help to achieve a pregnancy, including medical advice, medications, surgery, artificial insemination and assisted reproductive technology, which includes IVF and a related technology called intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI). ICSI is an IVF procedure wherein a single sperm is injected into a mature egg.
This bill also mandates coverage of “mature oocyte cryopreservation”– known in common parlance as egg freezing– a procedure in which viable, unfertilized eggs (oocytes) are frozen and preserved for future fertilization and implantation via IVF. This is generally performed when women are either undergoing medical treatment that may impair fertility (leading to what is called iatrogenic infertility) or when women choose to have their eggs frozen to increase the likelihood of having viable eggs in the event they experience difficulty conceiving when they are ready to become pregnant.
- CHBRP Analysis. The CHBRP analysis of this bill notes the following pertinent facts and projections:
- Fertility treatments are medically effective and are associated with some maternal harm. However, coverage of IVF treatments may reduce risks associated with transferring a higher number of embryos per cycle (transferring just a single embryo is safer, and more likely to occur when a coverage mandate is in place).
- Most of the increased utilization and cost is associated with significant increases in IVF treatment. Prior to the mandate, IVF services alone are estimated to have about 2,000 users and ICSI, which is done with IVF, has about 2,000 users annually. Post-mandate, CHBRP predicts an increase of roughly 4,000 IVF users and 5,000 IVF-ICSI users, as well as increases in other services, resulting in an additional 5,000 pregnancies and 4,000 babies.
- Recent amendments to impose a $75,000 lifetime limit on infertility treatment and a three-cycle limit on IVF cycles per enrollee did not materially change the cost estimate from the prior bill version, although these restrictions may limit the cost growth associated with this mandate in future years. The limit may also encourage enrollees and insureds to attempt less costly treatments, such as IUI, prior to seeking IVF.
- Related Legislation. SB 600 (Portantino) clarifies that an individual or group health plan contract or health insurance policy that covers hospital, medical or surgical expenses includes coverage for standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. SB 600 is currently pending in Senate Appropriations Committee.
- Prior Legislation. SB 172 (Portantino), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, expands the definition of basic health care services to include standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may directly or indirectly cause iatrogenic infertility. SB 172 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee. AB 912 (Quirk-Silva), of the 2013-14 Legislative Session, was similar to SB 600 (Portantino) and was vetoed by Governor Brown, who noted this coverage may be useful and desirable for many, but that the state should first implement the package of reforms required by the Affordable Care Act.
- Support. According to American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), a sponsor of this bill, the right to procreate is a fundamental right, as recognized by Supreme Court case law. ASRM states this bill will give hope to many Californians who suffer from infertility and cannot financially access treatment options.
- Opposition. Health plans and insurers and the California Chamber of Commerce oppose this bill, citing the high cost. Plans and insurers contend high-cost mandates will drive more employers away from fully insured products and towards self-insurance.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 767
Author:Wicks – As Amended Ver:April 9, 2019
SUBJECT: Health care coverage: infertility.
SUMMARY: Requires every health care service plan (health plan) contract or health insurance policy that is issued, amended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2020, to provide coverage for in vitro fertilization (IVF), as a treatment of infertility, and mature oocyte cryopreservation (OC). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires, on and after January 1, 2020, every health plan contract that is issued, amended, or renewed that covers hospital, medical, or surgical expenses on a group basis or every insurer issuing, renewing, or amending a policy of disability insurance that covers hospital, medical, or surgical expenses on a group basis, to provide coverage for the treatment of infertility, including IVF, and mature OC.
- Deletes the exemption for religiously affiliated employers, health plans, and health insurance policies, from the requirements relating to coverage for the treatment of infertility, thereby imposing these requirements on these employers, plans, and policies.
- Deletes the requirement that a health care service plan contract and health insurance policy provide infertility treatment under agreed upon terms that are communicated to all group contractholders and prospective group contractholders.
- Defines the following:
- “Infertility” as the presence of a demonstrated condition recognized by a licensed physician and surgeon as a cause of infertility;
- “IVF” as the laboratory medical procedures involving the IVF process;
- “Mature OC” as the procedures consistent with established medical practices, including laboratory medical procedures, involving ovulation induction, egg retrieval, and freezing of the egg; and,
- “Treatment of infertility” as procedures consistent with established medical practices in the treatment of infertility by a licensed physician and surgeon, including, but not limited to, diagnosis, diagnostic tests, medication, surgery, gamete intrafallopian transfer, and IVF.
- Makes other technical and conforming changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans and the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health insurers.
- Requires health plans and health insurers providing health coverage in the individual and small group markets to cover, at a minimum, essential health benefits (EHBs), including the ten EHB benefit categories in the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), and consistent with California’s EHB benchmark plan, the Kaiser Foundation Health Plan Small Group HMO 30 plan (Kaiser benchmark), as specified in state law.
- Establishes, in state government, California’s Health Benefit Exchange (Exchange), or Covered California, as an independent public entity not affiliated with an agency or department, and requires the Exchange to compare and make available through selective contracting, health insurance for individual and small business purchasers, as authorized under the ACA. Specifies the powers and duties of the board governing the Exchange, and requires the board to facilitate the purchase of qualified health plans (QHPs) through the Exchange by qualified individuals and small employers.
- Specifies the EHBs in the following 10 categories: ambulatory patient services; emergency services; hospitalization; maternity and newborn care; mental health and substance use disorder services, including behavioral health treatment; prescription drugs; rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices; laboratory services; preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management; and, pediatric services, including oral and vision care.
- Requires health plans to provide basic health care services, including: physician services; hospital inpatient and ambulatory care services; diagnostic laboratory and diagnostic and therapeutic radiologic services; home health services; preventive health services; emergency health care services; and, hospice care.
- Requires, on and after January 1, 1990, every health care service plan contract or insurance policy that is issued, amended, or renewed that covers hospital, medical, or surgical expenses on a group basis, where the plan is not a health maintenance organization as defined, to offer coverage for the treatment of infertility, except IVF, under those terms and conditions as may be agreed upon between the group subscriber and the plan. Requires every plan to communicate the availability of that coverage to all group contractholders and to all prospective group contractholders with whom they are negotiating.
- Defines the following:
- “Infertility” as either: i) the presence of a demonstrated condition recognized by a licensed physician and surgeon as a cause of infertility; or, ii) the inability to conceive a pregnancy or to carry a pregnancy to a live birth after a year or more of regular sexual relations without contraception.
- “Treatment for infertility” as procedures consistent with established medical practices in the treatment of infertility by licensed physicians and surgeons including, but not limited to, diagnosis, diagnostic tests, medication, surgery, and gamete intrafallopian transfer.
- “IVF” as the laboratory medical procedures involving the actual IVF process.
- Requires, on and after January 1, 1990, every health plan that is a health maintenance organization, as defined, and that issues, renews, or amends a health care service plan contract that provides group coverage for hospital, medical, or surgical expenses to offer infertility treatment, according to the terms and conditions that may be agreed upon between the group subscriber and the plan to group contractholders with at least 20 employees to whom the plan is offered. Requires the plan to communicate the availability of the coverage to those group contractholders and prospective group contractholders with whom the plan is negotiating.
- Prohibits 4) to 7) above from being construed to deny or restrict in any way any existing right or benefit to coverage and treatment of infertility under an existing law, plan, or policy; to require any employer that is a religious organization to offer coverage for forms of treatment of infertility in a manner inconsistent with the religious organization’s religious and ethical principles; or, to require any plan, which is a subsidiary of an entity whose owner or corporate member is a religious organization, to offer coverage for treatment of infertility in a manner inconsistent with that religious organization’s religious and ethical principles.
- Requires coverage for the treatment of infertility to be offered and, if purchased, provided without discrimination on the basis of age, ancestry, color, disability, domestic partner status, gender, gender expression, gender identity, genetic information, marital status, national origin, race, religion, sex, or sexual orientation.
- Authorizes a religious employer to request a health plan contract or insurance policy without coverage for Federal Drug Administration-approved contraceptive methods that are contrary to the religious employer’s religious tenets, as specified.
- Defines religious employer as an entity for which each of the following is true:
- The inculcation of religious values is the purpose of the entity;
- The entity primarily employs persons who share the religious tenets of the entity;
- The entity serves primarily persons who share the religious tenets of the entity; and,
- The entity is a nonprofit organization as described in federal law.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, infertility is a disease that affects millions of women of child bearing age in this country. While IVF is one of many effective treatments for infertility, it is explicitly excluded from being offered by health plans in California. This prohibition of IVF health coverage in our state makes this treatment option unattainable for many couples who cannot afford it. Reproductive freedom should not be limited to those who can afford it. This bill would address this inequity in health coverage by requiring health plans and policies to provide IVF coverage so that women who seek infertility treatment can obtain IVF when needed.
- BACKGROUND. According to the California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP), infertility is the inability to have a child and is a complex condition that can take many forms. In order for a live baby to be born without medical intervention, several conditions must be met:
- An egg (oocyte) must be released from an ovary;
- Sperm must join with (fertilize) the egg;
- A fertilized egg must be able to move through the fallopian tube toward the uterus;
- The fertilized egg must attach (implant) to the lining of the uterus to begin pregnancy; and,
- The fertilized egg must develop to an embryo and then fetus in the uterus and be gestated (carried) until live birth occurs.
Infertility may result from a problem with any one of these steps, or a combination of several steps. Persons attempting to have a child may experience primary infertility (physical difficulties having a first child) or secondary infertility (having had at least one child, but experiencing difficulty having another), either of which may be related to the inability to become pregnant or successfully carry a pregnancy to term. There are important differences between male and female reproductive biology that impact infertility. Women are born with a finite number of eggs (oocytes) that mature with the onset of menarche (median age 12 years) and decrease in number and quality until the onset of menopause, beyond which women are not able to naturally bear children; this is generally referred to as the female reproductive range. National datasets of IVF use show that less than 1% of women initiating IVF at age 44 or older will have a live birth; however, women up to the age of menopause, average age 51 in the U.S., may experience fertility treatment success using donor materials. In contrast, males become able to produce sperm during puberty (median age 12 years) and, according to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), retain optimal reproductive capabilities until 60 years of age.
- CHBRP analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson), Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002, requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996. SB 125 (Hernandez), Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015, added an impact assessment on EHBs, and legislation that impacts health insurance benefit designs, cost sharing, premiums, and other health insurance topics. CHBRP states in its analysis of this bill the following:
- Enrollees covered. According to CHBRP, benefit coverage for infertility treatments, including IVF, would increase from 4.3% premandate to 100% postmandate. Benefit coverage of planned OC would increase from 0% premandate to 100% postmandate. This bill would likely exceed EHBs.
- Impact on expenditures. According to CHBRP, this bill would increase total net annual expenditures by $850.5 million or 0.49% for enrollees with DMHC-regulated group plans and CDI-regulated group policies. This is due to a $537.8 million increase in total health insurance premiums paid by employers and enrollees for newly covered benefits, adjusted by decrease in enrollee expenses for covered and/or noncovered benefits. CHBRP estimates that enrollees with uncovered expenses at baseline would receive on the whole a $133.9 million reduction in their out-of-pocket spending for covered and noncovered expenses associated with this bill’s coverage of infertility services. Per member per month (PMPM) premiums would increase between $2.76 among CalPERS HMOs (an increase of 0.47%) and $3.72 in the DMHC-regulated small-group market (an increase of 0.68%). Total expenditures would increase between 0.33% in the CDI-regulated large-group market and 0.64% in the DMHC-regulated small-group market. CHBRP did not find any source of data on baseline utilization for planned OC or likely changes postmandate. CHBRP estimates that if 2% of women aged 25-37 years used planned OC services, the total expenditures would increase by $319.7 million. If a higher share of women aged 25-37 used planned OC (5%), total expenditures would increase by $799.2 million. This assumes the average cost for OC is $10,078.
- Medi-Cal. This bill does not apply to Medi-Cal enrollees and therefore there is no measurable impact.
- The California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS). CalPERS employer expenditures are projected to increase by $14.5 million for coverage of infertility treatments. Total premiums would increase by $2.76 PMPM (0.47%) and total expenditures would increase by $3.38 PMPM (0.53%).
- Number of Uninsured in California. Since the change in average premiums does not exceed 1% for any market segment for coverage of infertility treatments, CHBRP expects no measurable change in the number of uninsured persons due to the enactment of this bill. However, should 5% of female enrollees aged 25–37 use mature OC services as a form of fertility preservation, premiums would increase by more than 1% for enrollees in group and CalPERS HMO plans (premium increases for private employers for group insurance increase 1.24% and CalPERS HMO 1.31%). It is unclear how the increase in premiums translates into uninsurance since not all of the increase is transferred to the enrollee.
- EHBs. This bill would require coverage for a new state benefit mandate that appears to exceed the definition of EHBs in California. A state that requires QHPs to offer benefits in excess of the EHBs must make payments to defray the cost of those additionally mandated benefits, either by paying the purchaser directly or by paying the QHP. CHBRP estimates that the state would potentially be required to defray the following amounts due to this bill: (1) $6.52 PMPM for each QHP enrollee in a small-group DMHC-regulated plans; and, (2) $7.14 PMPM for each QHP enrollee in a small-group CDI-regulated policy.
- CHBRP analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson), Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002, requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996. SB 125 (Hernandez), Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015, added an impact assessment on EHBs, and legislation that impacts health insurance benefit designs, cost sharing, premiums, and other health insurance topics. CHBRP states in its analysis of this bill the following:
CHBRP estimates that this translates to a state-responsibility of $52.5 million total, which includes: (1) $51.5 million in payments to DMCH-regulated small group plans; and, (b) $1 million in payments to CDI-regulated small group policies.
- Medical effectiveness. CHBRP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF is an effective treatment for infertility, resulting in increased pregnancy rates and live birth rates. There is also a preponderance of evidence that planned OC is an effective treatment for infertility, resulting in pregnancies and live births. CHBRP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF is associated with certain maternal harms, including ovarian hyperstimulation syndrome and thromboembolism. There is also clear and convincing evidence that IVF can lead to multiple gestation and preterm delivery. However, it is important to note that multiple gestation is associated with higher numbers of embryos transferred per cycle, and that preterm delivery is associated with multiple gestation, these outcomes can be mitigated by single embryo transfers. CHRBP found a preponderance of evidence that IVF mandates are associated with lower numbers of embryos transferred per cycle. There is also a preponderance of evidence that IVF mandates lead to fewer births per cycle (due to the decreased number of embryos transferred per cycle), and a reduction in overall harms of IVF (i.e., lower rates of multiple gestation, preterm deliveries, and low-birthweight births).
- Benefit coverage. According to CHBRP, currently, 4.3% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill in DMHC-regulated plans or CDI-regulated policies have coverage for infertility treatments, including in vitro fertilization. No enrollees currently have coverage for mature OC as defined by this bill. Benefit coverage for infertility treatments and planned OC would increase to 100% postmandate.
- Utilization. In California, there are approximately 53,000 users of female diagnostic tests at baseline and about the same number of users of medications for infertility (i.e., only medications and no other service). Intrauterine insemination baseline utilization is about 9,000 users annually. IVF services alone (i.e., without intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI)) is estimated to have about 2,000 users and ICSI, which is done with IVF, is 2,000 users annually. For males, at baseline there are 25,000 users of diagnostic tests and 11,000 users of any male treatment. Pent-up demand is assumed to occur given the financial burden currently cited by couples hoping to use infertility services but are unable to because of cost barriers. It is assumed that utilization in the first and second year would be 10% greater. Pent-up demand for infertility services likely dissipates over time and utilization reaches a steady state after a few years postmandate.
- Public health. CHBRP estimates that the number of pregnancies resulting from infertility treatments in the first year postmandate will increase the number of pregnancies by 6,000 (from 7,000 to 13,000) and the number of live births by 5,000 (from 6,000 to 11,000).These estimates are supported by a preponderance of evidence that infertility treatments, including IVF, are medically effective and that health insurance benefit mandates are effective in increasing utilization of treatments for infertility, including IVF. Although CHBRP found evidence that engaging in infertility treatments may result in short-term psychosocial harms, evidence-based literature also indicates that the inability to have wanted children is itself associated with stress, anxiety, depression, and quality of life deficits that are likely to decrease upon the achievement of a successful pregnancy through treatment. Therefore, it stands to reason that mental health and quality of life would improve for the additional 5,000 persons and couples who would have a live birth resulting from infertility treatments postmandate. With respect to health disparities, CHBRP found that barriers in fertility treatment access related to sexual orientation are reduced with the change in language defining infertility to be more inclusive, however barriers remain as the bill does not cover donor materials (sperm or eggs) or gestational carriers (surrogates) that are required for same-sex couples. Cost-related barriers to infertility treatment would be significantly reduced for those covered by this bill, however cost sharing could still represent a significant cost barrier.
- Long-term impacts. In the short-term, the aggregate pregnancy and birth rate is expected to increase postmandate due to increased utilization of infertility services. In the longer term, it is possible that the coverage of infertility services results in encouraging couples to undergo infertility treatment earlier than they would normally and where pregnancy might be achieved naturally. For each cohort of females electing to undergo mature OC for the prevention of age-related infertility in a given year, CHBRP estimates the long-term marginal impact of this bill would yield about 685 more live births among these women over a 20-year period. Although this bill would decrease the financial burden of planned OC services in the short term, this bill would not cover future storage costs, which can range from range from $100 to $1,500 per year (average $300/year). These additional uncovered costs may have an impact on the demand for these services, but the magnitude of this effect is unknown.
- Other states. According to CHBRP, currently, 14 states have laws that require insurance companies to cover infertility treatment and two states, California and Texas, have laws that require insurance companies to offer coverage for infertility treatment. States that require coverage of infertility treatment include: Arkansas, Connecticut, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Montana, New Jersey, New York, Ohio, Rhode Island, and West Virginia, and most recently Delaware, which passed legislation in 2018. In 2019, New York amended its existing mandate through a budget measure in the 2020 state budget that mandates certain large-group insurance plans cover IVF, and requires all private insurance companies to cover medically necessary egg freezing. The Connecticut, New Jersey, and Rhode Island mandates are closest to this bill, with the exception of planned OC, which is not included those states’ mandates. While most states with laws requiring insurance companies to offer or provide coverage for infertility treatment include coverage for IVF, California and Louisiana have laws that specifically exclude coverage for the procedure.
Other examples of unique state laws are Louisiana and New York’s previous law, which prohibit the exclusion of coverage for a medical condition otherwise covered solely because the condition results in infertility; Minnesota, which specifies that medical assistance will not provide coverage for fertility drugs when specifically used to enhance fertility; and, Utah, which requires insurers providing coverage for maternity benefits to also provide an indemnity benefit for adoption or infertility treatments. Limits on infertility coverage in other states that mandate coverage include applying dollar lifetime caps, and limiting the number of treatment cycles covered. Connecticut allows four cycles of ovulation induction, a lifetime maximum coverage of three cycles of intrauterine insemination, and a lifetime maximum coverage of two cycles of IVF, Gamete intrafallopian transfer, zygote intrafallopian transfer or low tubal ovum transfer, with not more than two embryo implantations per cycle. Hawaii requires that only one cycle of IVF be covered. Illinois mandates that each patient is covered for up to four egg retrievals. However, if a live birth occurs, two additional egg retrievals will be covered, with a lifetime maximum of six retrievals covered. New York covers up to three IVF cycles. Rhode Island limits coverage to a lifetime cap of $100,000.
- SUPPORT. According to ASRM, a sponsor of this bill, the right to procreate is a fundamental right, as recognized by Supreme Court case law. With that long recognized right in observance, it is crucial that California continues its leadership role in the country and take an affirmative act by protecting access to all reproductive health care services. ASRM states that this bill will give hope to many Californians who suffer from infertility and cannot financially access treatment options.
- OPPOSITION. According to the California Chamber of Commerce, this bill would impose a new benefit mandate that exceeds EHBs established for individual and small group market plans and the state would be responsible for covering the cost to subsidize that benefit for individuals purchasing subsidized coverage through Covered California. The state has not enacted a benefit mandate that clearly exceeds EHB requirements. This mandate would set precedent and would result in ongoing annual costs to subsidize the provision of infertility treatment for individuals enrolled in health care coverage through Covered California.
The California Association of Health Plans (CAHP), the Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies (ACLHIC), and America’s Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) oppose state mandates as it would increase costs of coverage, especially for families who buy coverage without subsidies, small business owners who cannot or do not wish to self-insure, and California taxpayers who foot the bill for the state’s share of those mandates. According to CAHP, ACLHIC, and AHIP, with the elimination of the federal individual mandate, Covered California reported that new enrollment growth dropped by 24% and the average benchmark premium rose by 7.7% from 2018 to 2019. The repeal of the individual mandate has already caused increased premiums and coverage losses, and these mandates would further exacerbate the situation.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. SB 600 (Portantino) clarifies that an individual or group health plan contract or health insurance policy that covers hospital, medical, or surgical expenses includes coverage for standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. SB 600 is currently pending in Senate Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- SB 172 (Portantino) of 2017 expands the definition of basic health care services to include standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may directly or indirectly cause iatrogenic infertility. SB 172 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- SB 1053 (Mitchell), Chapter 576, Statutes of 2014, requires a health care service plan contract or health insurance policy issued, amended, or renewed on or after January 1, 2016, to provide coverage for women for all prescribed and FDA-approved female contraceptive drugs, devices, and products, as well as voluntary sterilization procedures, contraceptive education and counseling, and related follow-up services. Prohibits a nongrandfathered plan contract or health insurance policy from imposing any cost-sharing requirements or other restrictions or delays with respect to this coverage, as specified.
- AUTHOR’S AMENDMENTS. The author wishes to explicitly exclude the Medi-Cal program from the provisions of this bill.
- POLICY COMMENTS.
- Cost containment. As the CHBRP analysis points out, this bill would increase total net annual expenditures by $850,696,000 for enrollees with DMHC-regulated group plans and CDI-regulated group policies. To address concerns regarding the cost of the services described in this bill, the committee recommends the following amendments:
- Delete small group contracts from the provisions of this bill. As noted by CHBRP, Covered California is responsible for certifying and selling QHPs in the small-group and individual markets. QHPs are required to meet a minimum standard of benefits as defined by the ACA as EHBs. In California, EHBs are related to the benefit coverage carefully selected and made available in the Kaiser Foundation Health Plan Small Group HMO 30 plan, the state’s benchmark plan for federal EHBs. The benchmark plan did not include infertility coverage. While states may require QHPs to offer benefits that exceed EHBs, a state that chooses to do so must make payments to defray the cost of those additionally mandated benefits, either by paying the purchaser directly or by paying the QHP. CHBRP estimates that this translates to a state-responsibility of $51,823,000 total.
- To further limit the cost of these services similarly to those limitations placed by other states that mandate infertility coverage, such as applying dollar lifetime caps, or limiting the number of treatment cycles or type of treatment covered. The Committee recommends a $50,000 coverage limit for infertility treatment.
- Religious exemption. Existing law requires health plans or insurers of group contracts or policies to offer infertility coverage and exempts any employer that is a religious organization from offering coverage for forms of treatment of infertility, as specified. This bill deletes these exemptions and appears to require such religious organizations to cover infertility services, even if such services may be inconsistent with the religious organization’s religious and ethical principles. It is unclear as to whether this deletion is consistent with federal law, including the U.S. Constitution and federal rules.
- Cost containment. As the CHBRP analysis points out, this bill would increase total net annual expenditures by $850,696,000 for enrollees with DMHC-regulated group plans and CDI-regulated group policies. To address concerns regarding the cost of the services described in this bill, the committee recommends the following amendments:
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Society for Reproductive Medicine (sponsor)
American Association of University Women – California
American Society for Reproductive Medicine
California Black Health Network
California Chronic Care Coalition
California Pan - Ethnic Health Network
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, Inc.
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Opposition
America's Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life & Health Insurance Companies
California Association of Health Plans
California Catholic Conference
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Right to Life Committee, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):