AB 777: Property tax postponement.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-24
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 22). |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. Re-referred. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (March 25). Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Mar 25, 2019 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 777
Author:(Patterson) – As Amended Ver:April 24, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
| |||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill modifies the existing $35,500 income eligibility threshold for the Property Tax Postponement (PTP) Program by making it the greater of either $35,000 or the definition of “very low income,” as adjusted by household size, as defined by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). This bill also reduces the interest rate charged on postponed property taxes from, 7% to 5%.
FISCAL EFFECT:
The PTP Program is designed to be self-funding. Revenues from repayments and interest go into the PTP Fund, which supports new PTP tax payments to county agencies. The PTP Fund balance cannot exceed $15 million, and amounts above that cap are transferred to the General Fund (GF). The current PTP Fund balance is $12.9 million.
While the PTP Fund is self-funding and can even generate GF revenue, AB 777 is likely to lead to significant new costs. Those costs include:
- Significant administrative costs for the state controller’s office (SCO). It is unknown just how many more applications there will be as a result of AB 777, but even a modest increase would be costly. For example, if applications increase just 30%, ongoing administrative costs would be $350,000 in 2021-21, $440,000 in 2021-22 and $554,000 in 2022-23. If the increase in applications is larger, then costs would be higher and the SCO would have to address other complications, such as maintaining a waitlist if applications exceed what can be supported with available resources.
- Possible significant GF cost pressures, possibly in the millions of dollars, as a result of inadequate moneys in the PTP Fund. A large influx of applications from AB 777 could deplete the PTP Fund, which would increase pressure for a GF transfer. This pressure is more likely during an economic downturn, when demand for the program is high but the $15 million cap on the PTP Fund restricts access. This situation would be similar to what inspired AB 1952 (Gordon), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session: AB 1952 would have authorized the Department of Finance to use GF dollars to cover the costs of accepting new PTP participants if there weren’t adequate funds available. AB 1952 was vetoed by the governor.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. The PTP Program aims to help low-income seniors remain in their homes by paying their current-year property taxes. A homeowner is eligible if the homeowner is are over 62 years old, disabled or blind; has a household income less than $35,500; and owns at least 40% equity in their home. Another requirement of the PTP Program is that the homeowner (or their heir) repays the state the property taxes that were paid on their behalf, with interest.
According to the author, AB 777 will make the PTP Program more equitable and more sustainable. This bill is in response to a 2018 Legislative Analyst’s Office evaluation of the program that suggested a number of reforms to increase utilization, fairness and sustainability of the program.
- Related legislation. AB 133 (Patterson), of the 2018-19 Legislative Session, similarly expands the PTP Program. AB 133 modifies the income limit to the greater of $35,500 or the “low income” limits for a two-person household published by HCD. AB 133 is currently pending on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 777 (
Author:Patterson) – As Introduced Ver:February 19, 2019
2/3 vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Property tax postponement
SUMMARY: Revises the income eligibility threshold for a homeowner to qualify for the Property Tax Postponement (PTP) Program from $35,500 statewide to a variable county-specific "very low income" threshold adjusted for household size. Specifically, this bill:
- Modifies the statewide $35,500 household income threshold to participate in the PTP Program to the greater of $35,500[1] or the "very low income" threshold amount, adjusted for household size, in the county as annually published by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD). This, in turn:
- Varies income eligibility by county;
- Varies income eligibility within each county by household size; and,
- Adjusts the income threshold automatically each year.
- Modifies the interest rate charged on postponed property taxes from 7% to the rate of interest earned by the Pooled Money Investment Account (PMIA).
- Eliminates the annual sweep of money in the PTP Fund in excess of $15 million to the General Fund.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Legislature to provide a program where a person of low or moderate income who is 62 or older or disabled may postpone payment of ad valorem property taxes on a dwelling that is their principal place of residence.[2]
- Provides the Senior Citizens and Disabled Citizens Property Tax Postponement Law, which allows the State Controller's Office (SCO) to pay property taxes to county tax collectors on behalf of eligible homeowners.
- Establishes the Senior Citizens and Disabled Citizens Property Tax Postponement Fund (PTP Fund) which is continuously appropriated to the SCO to i) make disbursements to the county tax collector for approved Program loans and ii) pay Program administrative costs. Also requires the SCO to deposit any loan repayments from the Program into the fund.[3]
- Requires a homeowner to file an application to participate in the PTP Program and to meet all of the following criteria:
- Be at least 62 years of age, or blind, or disabled;
- Have a total household income of $35,500 or less;
- Own and occupy the real property as his or her principal place of residence (floating homes and house boats are ineligible);
- Have at least 40% equity in the property; and,
- Not have a reverse mortgage on the property.
- Sets the interest rate charged on postponed taxes at 7%.[4]
- Allows homeowners to repay all, or part, of the outstanding balance to the SCO at any time.
- Makes postponed property taxes and interest immediately due and payable when the homeowner does any of the following:
- Moves from the property;
- Sells or conveys title to the property;
- Dies and does not have a spouse, registered domestic partner, or other qualified individual who continues to reside in the property;
- Allows future property taxes or other senior liens to become delinquent; or,
- Refinances or obtains a reverse mortgage for the property.
- Requires the SCO to transfer to the General Fund any money in the PTP Fund on June 30 of each year that is in excess of $15 million.
- Makes a continuous appropriation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. PTP is self-funding with payoffs from prior loans (principal and interest) funding new loans and administrative costs. This bill reduces the interest rate from a fixed 7% to the interest earned by the PMIA, which is variable. In the 2017-18 Fiscal Year (FY), PIMA's average annual yield was 1.376%.
Historically, PTP has generated General Fund money. This bill would eliminate the transfer of PTP Fund money in excess of $15 million to the General Fund. Currently, the PTP Fund balance is $12.9 million, thus it is possible that no fund sweep will occur on June 30, 2019.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
The Property Tax Postponement program provides much-needed financial relief to seniors and disabled Californians. The program allows thousands of residents to live in the comfort of their own homes without having to choose between paying their property tax bill or buying food and medicine. However, more can be done to lessen the burden on these individuals, including lowering the interest rate and expanding it in a sensible and equitable manner to more residents across the state.
AB 777 will implement recent recommendations by the Legislative Analyst's Office to make the Property Tax Postponement program more affordable and equitable while also limiting the state's risk and ensuring the program's long-term sustainability.
- This bill is supported by the Senior Legislature which notes:
On October 8, 2018, the Legislative Analyst's Office provided a variety of options to improve the PTP in its report, "Evaluation of the Property Tax Postponement Program." The report highlighted a variety of limitations to how the PTP determined eligibility; namely, the income threshold used by the PTP (individuals with incomes less than $35,500) doesn't vary by household size, geography, or with inflation.
Additionally, the LAO identified two areas where affordability could be addressed: 1) The PTP interest rate of 7% is "too high" when a much lower interest rate could still keep the program cost-neutral, and 2) the low-income participants in the program are "effectively subsidizing the state's General Fund" since any PTP balance above $15 million is swept to the General Fund.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- PTP History: In 1977, a constitutional amendment was approved to allow the Legislature to provide for property tax postponement for low- and moderate-income persons 62 or older (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 8.5). This pre-Proposition 13 constitutional amendment was in response to concerns that senior homeowners on fixed incomes might default on their property taxes and lose their homes if unable to pay rising property tax bills. At that time, property tax assessments were based on current market values. Today, property tax assessments are linked to a home's market value on the date it was purchased or the home's market value in 1975 if continuously owned by the same homeowner. In 1984, another constitutional amendment expanded PTP eligibility to blind or disabled persons regardless of age. Under PTP, it is possible to postpone taxes until after a homeowner's death with the heirs subsequently repaying the loan.
- PTP Program Halted: In 2009, PTP was indefinitely suspended as part of the budget reductions to the state's General Fund programs.[5] Program funding was eliminated and the SCO was prohibited from accepting any new applications.
- PTP Program Revived: In 2014, PTP was revived with a delayed restart applicable to property taxes for the 2016-17 FY. Unlike the prior Program, eligible participants must reapply each year. Additionally, the revised Program tightened eligibility criteria and the funding was no longer General Fund based.[6]
- What does this bill do? In October 2018, the LAO issued a comprehensive report, "Evaluation of the Property Tax Postponement Program." Noting the low participation rate since the Program's restart, the LAO recommended that the Legislature either eliminate or improve the Program. This bill reflects three recommendations in the Report to improve the Program related to: (i) income eligibility thresholds, (ii) the interest rate on loans, and (iii) the General Fund Sweep. The table below indicates the number of loans granted at various points in time.
- PTP History: In 1977, a constitutional amendment was approved to allow the Legislature to provide for property tax postponement for low- and moderate-income persons 62 or older (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 8.5). This pre-Proposition 13 constitutional amendment was in response to concerns that senior homeowners on fixed incomes might default on their property taxes and lose their homes if unable to pay rising property tax bills. At that time, property tax assessments were based on current market values. Today, property tax assessments are linked to a home's market value on the date it was purchased or the home's market value in 1975 if continuously owned by the same homeowner. In 1984, another constitutional amendment expanded PTP eligibility to blind or disabled persons regardless of age. Under PTP, it is possible to postpone taxes until after a homeowner's death with the heirs subsequently repaying the loan.
Fiscal Year | Key Event | Loans |
1977-78 | Program Starts | 13,000 |
1978-79 | Property Tax Reform (Prop 13) | 8,500 |
2008-09 | Last Year Before Program Suspension | 5,676 |
2016-17 | Program Restart | 812 |
2017-18 | 899 | |
2018-19 | 946[7] |
- Who uses the program? The LAO found that statewide, on average, approved applicants are 72 years old, have household incomes of about $20,000, and own 85% equity in their homes.
- Average loan amount: For the 2017-18 FY, the average postponement amount for approved applicants for that year was $3,200. However, as expected, the market value and postponement amount averages vary considerably for approved loans depending on the applicant's location as noted below for 2017-18 FY PTP applicants.
Area | Home Market Value | Loan Amount |
Northern | $208,805 | $1,834 |
Bay Area | $674,829 | $3,890 |
Motherlode | $298,315 | $2,486 |
Central | $203,587 | $1,620 |
Southern | $490,381 | $3,387 |
- One fixed income eligibility threshold: The LAO noted shortcomings with using one fixed household income threshold as follows: (i) it does not vary by household size, (ii) it is not indexed for inflation, and (iii) it does not vary geographically. To address these issues, the LAO recommends that PTP eligibility be based on the income limits published each year by HCD. These HCD income limits are based, in turn, on the federal Housing and Urban Development (HUD) regional income thresholds.
- Income categories: HCD publishes five income categories of county-level thresholds: (i) moderate income (120% of Area Median Income (AMI), (ii) median income, (iii) low income (80% of AMI), (iv) very low income (50% of AMI), and (v) extremely low income (60% of very low income). The income limits are based on a four-person household, and then that amount is adjusted for household size as follows:
1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
70% | 80% | 90% | Base | 108% | 116% | 124% | 132% |
- Uses the "very low income" threshold: This bill uses the very low-income, HCD-published amounts or $35,500, whichever is greater. The LAO states that selecting the "very low income" threshold keeps Program eligibility roughly similar, while selecting the "low income" threshold expands Program eligibility. Under this bill, the threshold for a one-person household will increase in eight counties: Orange County and seven Bay Area counties (Alameda, Contra Costa, Marin, San Francisco, San Mateo, Santa Clara, and Santa Cruz). In the three counties with the highest "very low" income threshold (Marin, San Francisco, and San Mateo), the income range would be $51,350 for a one-person household to $96,800 for an eight-person household. In 28 counties, $35,500 is greater than the four-person threshold, thus eligibility is generally unchanged in these counties.
- Sets the interest rate equal to the rate the state earns in the PMIA: The interest rate charged on PTP loans helps cover two costs that allow the Program to be self-funding: (i) the SCO's administration costs, and (ii) defaulted loan losses. The LAO recommended reducing the interest rate to an unspecified amount tied to PMIA because a historical analysis found that the state could afford to lower the interest rate and keep the Program self-funded. On March 6, 2019, in a presentation to a Senate Select Committee, the LAO specified the interest rate could be reduced to 4% or 5%. This bill specifies that the interest rate be set such that it equals the interest earned by PMIA. However, this bill lacks specificity, such as whether to use the average annual yield or average monthly yield. On a fiscal-year average annual yield basis, interest earned by PMIA has ranged from under 0.25% to over 12%. The State Treasurer's Office website posts the PMIA Average Annual Yields for Fiscal Years 1971-72 through 2017-18 as indicated below:
71/72 | 4.880 |
72/73 | 5.550 |
73/74 | 8.970 |
74/75 | 8.620 |
75/76 | 6.370 |
76/77 | 5.870 |
77/78 | 6.700 |
78/79 | 8.520 |
79/80 | 10.540 |
80/81 | 10.780 |
81/82 | 12.070 |
82/83 | 10.450 |
83/84 | 10.408 |
84/85 | 10.715 |
85/86 | 9.081 |
86/87 | 7.435 |
87/88 | 7.874 |
88/89 | 8.669 |
89/90 | 8.655 |
90/91 | 8.013 |
91/92 | 6.196 |
92/93 | 4.707 |
93/94 | 4.387 |
94/95 | 5.532 |
95/96 | 5.706 |
96/97 | 5.599 |
97/98 | 5.699 |
98/99 | 5.344 |
99/00 | 5.708 |
00/01 | 6.104 |
01/02 | 3.445 |
02/03 | 2.152 |
03/04 | 1.532 |
04/05 | 2.256 |
05/06 | 3.873 |
06/07 | 5.121 |
07/08 | 4.325 |
08/09 | 2.224 |
09/10 | 0.651 |
10/11 | 0.495 |
11/12 | 0.382 |
12/13 | 0.307 |
13/14 | 0.249 |
14/15 | 0.269 |
15/16 | 0.434 |
16/17 | 0.754 |
17/18 | 1.376 |
- Setting the interest rate equal to the PMIA risks Program self-funding: In recent years, interest rates have been historically low. Given that the interest charges fund the program and allow loans to other homeowners in need, Committee staff recommends that the interest rate be set at 5% consistent with the LAO's updated recommendation to the Legislature, which reduces the interest rate by 2%, from 7% to 5%. In the future, the Legislature could revisit this issue should interest rates change significantly.
- Eliminates fund sweep: PTP is administered on a first-come, first-serve basis. The PTP Fund's current balance is $12.9 million. Repayments of prior loans replenish the fund. Since the loans have no due date, the loans are indefinite. Repayment requirements are event driven, such as after a participant's home is sold, refinanced, or the participant's death if no qualified person resides in the home. Current law requires any balances over $15 million to be swept to the General Fund. The LAO states no clear public policy reason exists for generating a General Fund benefit from the Program. The LAO notes that this is essentially a safety net program, and no other safety net program generates General Fund revenue. Thus, the LAO recommends discontinuing the sweep stating that:
General Fund Revenue Sweep Might Hamper Fund's Long‑Term Sustainability. Over the long term, without the General Fund sweep, the program is likely to have enough funds to pay disbursements using collections. (This has been true historically and new features of the program, like annual applications, limit the state's risk even further.) However, in some years, particularly in a recession, disbursements could exceed collections. In those years, the fund will need a reserve to cover these costs. The General Fund sweep limits the size of the program's reserve, potentially hampering its long‑term sustainability.
- Keeping it simple: Varying income limits by household size introduces complexity to PTP. Additionally, the administrative cost to SCO will increase to accommodate 58 different income levels in addition to varying household sizes. Informational materials developed for outreach purposes would become more complicated. The author may wish to amend this bill to instead select one household size at an appropriate level.
- County loans: During the State's PTP hiatus, counties were authorized to create their own county-run program. This bill does not change the income limit under the county deferred property tax program that a county may opt to create and administer. As such, any county program retains the $35,500 income limit. Committee staff is unaware of any county currently operating their own program. The County of Santa Cruz had instituted its own program but discontinued it when the State program became once again operational.
- Technical amendments: Committee staff recommends the following technical amendments:
- On page 4, in line 29, strike "($35,000)" and insert "($35,500)"; and,
- On page 4, in line 30, insert ", as adjusted for household size," after "limit".
- Related legislation:
- AB 133 (Quirk-Silva) increases the PTP income threshold to $45,000 or the "low income" limit for a two-person household in the county in which the household is located, whichever is greater. AB 133 is currently on the Assembly Appropriations' Committee Suspense File.
- SB 770 (Galgiani) reduces the home equity requirement for PTP eligibility from 40% to 20%. SB 770 will be heard in the Senate Governance and Finance Committee on April 24, 2019.
- Prior legislation:
- SB 1130 (Leyva), Chapter 896, Statutes of 2018, allows manufactured homeowners (MH) to participate in PTP by creating a separate MH Program and shifting money from the general PTP Fund to the MH Fund.
- AB 1952 (Gordon), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, would have allowed the Director of Finance to authorize expenditures to the SCO to fund approved PTP applications if the SCO determined the PTP Fund balance was insufficient. Governor Brown vetoed AB 1952 because the premise of reinstating PTP was that it be entirely self-financing.
- AB 2231 (Gordon), Chapter 703, Statutes of 2014, reauthorized PTP in a modified form but, among other things, reduced the income limit from $39,000 to $35,500. The new program delayed loans until those for the 2016-17 FY.
- SBx3 8 (Ducheny), Chapter 4, Statutes of 2009, Third Extraordinary Session, suspended immediately and indefinitely PTP.
- AB 2719 (Houston), Chapter 616, Statutes of 2006, increased the income limit over a period of years to $39,000 for the 2009 calendar year, and thereafter would have applied an inflation factor to increase the income limit annually.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Senior Legislature
Choice in Aging
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Multipurpose Senior Services Program Site Association
The Central Valley Long Term Support and Services Coalition
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
This bill's text requires correction from $35,000 to $35,500. ↑
Article XIII, Sec 8.5 of the California Constitution. (Adopted on June 8, 1976 by Proposition 13 (1976) via SCA 16, Stats. 1976, Res. Chapter 2.) Expanded to include disabled and blind persons. (Adopted on November 6, 1984 by Proposition 33 (1984) via ACA 66, Stats. 1984, Res. Chapter 65.) ↑
Government Code (GC) Section 16180. ↑
GC Section 16183. ↑
SBx3 8 (Ducheny), Chapter 4, Statutes of 2009-10 Third Extraordinary Session, added R&TC Section 20623 to prohibit the SCO from accepting applications on and after February 20, 2009. ↑
AB 2231 (Gordon), Chapter 703, Statutes of 2014, repealed R&TC Section 20623. ↑
To date, applications are still pending. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):