AB 846: Public employment: public officers or employees declared by law to be peace officers.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 322, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 30, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 14, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Action rescinded whereby the bill was re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 27, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 27, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 30. Noes 0. Page 4354.). |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 20). |
| Aug 13, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 1, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 31). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 24, 2020 | From inactive file. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Jackson. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 9). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 28, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 8). |
| May 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 23). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 23. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | AB 846 BURKE Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB846 Burke et al. By Bradford | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 13, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 31, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 28, 2019 | AB 846 Burke Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 846
Author:(Burke and Irwin)
As Amended Ver:June 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires that evaluations of peace officers include an evaluation of bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation; also requires every department or agency that employs peace officers to review their job descriptions and deemphasize the paramilitary aspects of employment and place more emphasis on community interaction and collaborative problem solving.
The Senate Amendments
Delete the assembly version of this bill and instead:
- Require that prospective officers' evaluations for mental fitness include bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation.
- Require, by January 1, 2022, for POST to study, review, and update regulations and screening materials to identify explicit and implicit bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation related to emotional and mental condition evaluations.
- Require that local law enforcement agencies shall review their job descriptions used to recruit and hire peace officers and shall make changes that emphasize community-based policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving, and de-emphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job.
- Specify that the recruitment provisions change is not intended to alter the required duties of any peace officer.
- Provide that the Legislature finds and declares that changes to these job descriptions are necessary to allow peace officers to feel like the public can trust law enforcement and to implement problem-solving policing and intelligence-led policing strategies in contrast with reactive policing strategies.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
The goal of this bill is to screen for both implicit and explicit biases during the hiring process, and focus on more community-oriented practices in law enforcement by reassessing job descriptions and recruitment practices. This can foster a more communal and less militaristic and aggressive approach to policing.
AB 846 will require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training to study and update regulations and screening materials to identify explicit and implicit bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation related to emotional and mental condition evaluations of peace officers. Additionally, the minimum standards for each peace officer will be amended in order to require that each individual must be free from explicit and implicit bias when evaluating their mental condition through their training and examination.
Implicit bias among law enforcement is especially dangerous because of the positions of power they hold. We already recognize the disparities in stop, search and arrest rates across demographic groups. The latest murders of black men by white police officers across our nation are being amplified as needed calls for reform. It is therefore critical that we require screening of bias during the hiring process and recognize how to take steps to counteract their influence. We must make sure that officers are trained and acting on facts, not biases.
This language will also require a review of the job descriptions used in the recruitment and hiring of law enforcement officers and require changes that de-emphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job in order to place more emphasis on community interaction and collaborative problem solving. The objective is to move away from militaristic focused job descriptions in an effort to attract a wider range of applicants and promote a greater focus on community involvement.
Recruitment can improve if the description of these jobs are re-imagined. We have seen a demand for systemic change within law enforcement and part of that task includes changing the culture, which can begin with the way we recruit, evaluate, and re-frame positions for potential applicants. There needs to be better trust and coordination between the police and the communities they are hired to protect and serve. Our justice system is based around the idea of fairness and impartiality. Working to bring in a wider applicant pool for law enforcement positions while simultaneously screening for biases will help reform the system as it currently exists and move us in the direction of equity.
Argument in Support:
According to the California Public Defenders Association: "While current law requires law enforcement officers in the state of California to meet current standards, including an evaluation for physical, emotional and mental fitness, AB 846 would require that evaluation to also include factors relating to explicit and implicit bias. Additionally, AB 846 would require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training ["POST"] to study, review and update regulations and screening materials related to explicit and implicit bias. This is an urgently needed bill, which will save the lives of many people of California that have interactions with law enforcement officers.
"The recent news coverage of bias-related incidents by law enforcement officers in California shows how critical a need there is for law enforcement officers to be screened and trained on implicit and explicit bias. Just yesterday, KRON4.com reported that the mayor of San Jose was calling for the firing of four San Jose police officers accused of making racist comments on Facebook in what he called "an online ring of hate." In a welcome surprise, San Jose Police Association President Paul Kelly condemned the officers, saying, "There is no place in our police department or our union for racists or bigots, or for those that enable them by not speaking up when they see those types of behaviors."
Argument in Opposition:
According to the California Police Chiefs Association: "The current manual utilized by POST was published in 2014 and revised in 2017, 2018, and most recently in January of 2019. Countless individuals, including numerous doctors, psychologists, professionals, and law enforcement experts worked with POST to conduct meta-analysis of research and validate the guidelines with empirical evidence. AB 846 contemplates recreating the painstaking work that has been already complete. Given POST's expanding role, it is improvident to create this new task.
"The limitations AB 846 sets on recruitment are also costly and concerning. This measure would require every law enforcement agency to "review the job description that is used in the recruitment and hiring" of peace officers and make changes that "emphasize community-based policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving, while de-emphasizing the paramilitary aspects of the job." This section raises numerous questions concerning what is being asked of agencies. What is included in "paramilitary aspect of the job" and what would constitute sufficient de-emphasis of those duties? Should a recruitment video that shows SWAT teams and helicopters be removed or edited?
"Recruiting qualified peace officer candidates has become increasingly difficult in the last decade. Most agencies find themselves short-staffed, even when reduced budgets have allowed for additional officers. As such, municipal police agencies have expanded outreach and created incentive packages to entice qualified candidates. Many of these very qualified candidates also come from our armed forces, and it remains unclear how this bill would impact outreach to those individuals.
"Finally, AB 846 finds and declares that the changes to these job descriptions are meant to facilitate the implementations of "problem-solving policing and intelligence-led policing in contrast with reactive policing strategies." These terms are also somewhat confusing in their intent as intelligence-led policing has been criticized by social justice organizations for disproportionately impacting minority communities."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- POST: One-time costs of approximately $100,000 for subject-matter experts to create a section in the Psychological Screening Manual on implicit and explicit bias. (General Fund)
- Bias Evaluation: Minor to no costs to law enforcement agencies, as many indicate that the mental condition evaluation they use currently screens for bias against the characteristics listed in the bill.
- Job Description: Minor to no costs to peace officer employers to review, and make changes if necessary to, their job description that is used in recruitment and hiring. Most peace officer employers have relayed to the Committee that their job descriptions currently are aligned with this measure.
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Chau, Kiley, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-4-7
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO: Gallagher, Kamlager-Dove, Mark Stone, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gray, Kalra, Limón, Ting
SENATE FLOOR: 30-0-10
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Melendez, Moorlach, Morrell, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0003559
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 846 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 846
Author: Burke (D) and Irwin (D)
Amended: 6/25/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/31/20 (Pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10)
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Public employment: public officers or employees declared by law to be peace officers
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill (1) requires that evaluations of peace officers include an evaluation of bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation; and (2) requires every department or agency that employs peace officers to review their job descriptions and deemphasize the paramilitary aspects of employment and place more emphasis on community interaction and collaborative problem solving.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires that each class of peace officers must meet the following minimum standards: (Gov. Code § 1031.)
- A citizen or permanent resident who is eligible and has applied for citizenship.
- At least 18-years of age.
- Of good moral character, as determined through a background investigation.
- A high-school graduate, or a specified equivalent.
- Free from any physical, emotional, or mental condition that might adversely affect the exercise of the powers of a peace officer.
- Specifies that emotional and mental condition of peace officer candidates shall be evaluated by either of the following: (Gov. Code § 1031; subd. (f)(1)&(2).)
- A physician who holds a valid license and has successfully completed a postgraduate residency education program in accredited psychology with at least the equivalent of five full-time years of experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders.
- A licensed psychologist who has at least the equivalent of five full-time years of experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders, including the equivalent of three full-time years accrued post-doctorate.
- Requires the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) to develop and disseminate guidelines and training for all peace officers in California on the racial and cultural differences. The course or courses of instruction and the guidelines shall stress understanding and respect for racial, identity, and cultural differences, and development of effective, noncombative methods of carrying out law enforcement duties in a diverse racial, identity, and cultural environment. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (a).)
- Establishes the course of basic training for peace officers shall include adequate instruction on racial, identity, and cultural diversity in order to foster mutual respect and cooperation between law enforcement and members of all racial, identity, and cultural groups. In developing the training, the commission shall consult with appropriate groups and individuals having an interest and expertise in the field of racial, identity, and cultural awareness and diversity. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (b).)
- States that every peace officer in this state shall participate in expanded training as prescribed and certified by the POST. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (g).)
- Establishes that the curriculum shall be evidence-based and shall include and examine evidence-based patterns, practices, and protocols that make up racial or identity profiling, including implicit bias. This training shall prescribe evidence-based patterns, practices, and protocols that prevent racial or identity profiling. In developing the training, the commission shall consult with the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board. The course of instruction shall include, but not be limited to, significant consideration of each of the following subjects:
- Identification of key indices and perspectives that make up racial, identity, and cultural differences among residents in a local community.
- Negative impact of intentional and implicit biases, prejudices, and stereotyping on effective law enforcement, including examination of how historical perceptions of discriminatory enforcement practices have harmed police-community relations and contributed to injury, death, disparities in arrest detention and incarceration rights, and wrongful convictions.
- The history and role of the civil and human rights movement and struggles and their impact on law enforcement.
- Specific obligations of peace officers in preventing, reporting, and responding to discriminatory or biased practices by fellow peace officers.
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, and cultural and police-community relations issues in a local area.
- The prohibition against racial or identity profiling. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (h)(1)-(6).)
- Provides that once the initial basic peace officer training is completed, specified peace officers who adhere to the standards approved by the POST shall be required to complete a refresher course on racial and identity profiling, including implicit bias, every five years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (i).)
- Establishes the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) for the purposes of eliminating racial and identity profiling, and improving diversity and racial and identity sensitivity in law enforcement. Every year RIPA shall analyze law enforcement training and issue a report that provides RIPA’s analysis. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (j)(3)(B)(E).)
This bill:
- Requires that prospective officers’ evaluations for mental fitness include bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation.
- Requires, by January 1, 2022, for POST to study, review, and update regulations and screening materials to identify explicit and implicit bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation related to emotional and mental condition evaluations.
- Requires that local law enforcement agencies shall review their job descriptions used to recruit and hire peace officers and shall make changes that emphasize community-based policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving, and de-emphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job.
- Specifies that the recruitment provisions change is not intended to alter the required duties of any peace officer.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that changes to these job descriptions are necessary to allow peace officers to feel like the public can trust law enforcement and to implement problem-solving policing and intelligence-led policing strategies in contrast with reactive policing strategies.
Background
According to Section 13519.4 (f) of the California Penal Code, “A peace officer shall not engage in racial or identity profiling.” Peace officers are encouraged to not engage in racial or identity profiling through various POST courses but this has not resulted in less racial profiling. The LA Times reported, “California's attorney general says 157 people died during encounters with police in the state last year [2016]…Forty-two percent of the civilians involved were Latino. Although black people make up just 6% of the state's population, according to the most recent Census data, they represented nearly 20% of the use-of-force and shooting cases last year. More than half of the officers involved were white.” In the 2019 Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) report, in 2017 there were 741 civilians involved in use of force incidents with Latino civilians comprising of 43.9% and Black civilians comprising of 19.3%.
The 2019 RIPA report had also found that in 2018 several of the trainings did not meet all of the curriculum requirements. The Board is currently working with POST to recreate this training to better meet the requirements. RIPA’s recommendations strongly emulate AB 243. For example, RIPA also recommends more frequent trainings and inclusion of implicit bias training.
This bill takes a slightly different tact from previous legislation that focused on training of officers, and setting policy for local law enforcement agencies. The legislation herein approaches the issue by requiring that all local law enforcement agencies shift the advertisement and recruiting of officers away from the more militaristic aspects of the job and towards community interaction and problem solving. In addition, as a part of the screening process, this bill would require officers undergo an evaluation to determine whether they hold biases that could impact their ability to effectively and neutrally act in the role of a peace officer, and to handle the extraordinary responsibility that goes along with that highly-trusted role.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- POST: One-time costs of approximately $100,000 for subject-matter experts to create a section in the Psychological Screening Manual on implicit and explicit bias. (General Fund)
- Bias Evaluation: Minor to no costs to law enforcement agencies, as many indicate that the mental condition evaluation they use currently screens for bias against the characteristics listed in this bill.
- Job Description: Minor to no costs to peace officer employers to review, and make changes if necessary to, their job description that is used in recruitment and hiring. Most peace officer employers have relayed to the Committee that their job descriptions currently are aligned with this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Attorney for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
California State Sheriffs’ Association
City of Thousand Oaks
Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Police Chiefs Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the California Public Defenders Association:
While current law requires law enforcement officers in the state of California to meet current standards, including an evaluation for physical, emotional and mental fitness, AB 846 would require that evaluation to also include factors relating to explicit and implicit bias. Additionally, AB 846 would require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training [“POST”] to study, review and update regulations and screening materials related to explicit and implicit bias. This is an urgently needed bill, which will save the lives of many people of California that have interactions with law enforcement officers.
The recent news coverage of bias-related incidents by law enforcement officers in California shows how critical a need there is for law enforcement officers to be screened and trained on implicit and explicit bias. Just yesterday, KRON4.com reported that the mayor of San Jose was calling for the firing of four San Jose police officers accused of making racist comments on Facebook in what he called “an online ring of hate.” In a welcome surprise, San Jose Police Association President Paul Kelly condemned the officers, saying, ‘There is no place in our police department or our union for racists or bigots, or for those that enable them by not speaking up when they see those types of behaviors.’
The passage of AB 846 would be a significant step towards protecting the people of California from biased law enforcement officers who have no place in our law enforcement agencies.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Police Chiefs Association:
AB 846 requires POST to “study, review, and update their regulations and associated screening material related to the emotional and mental condition evaluation” of peace officer candidates to include the identification of explicit and implicit bias. POST already includes these factors in their mental health evaluations, making this new mandate a costly duplicative mandate. For example, in the POST Psychological Screening Manual, screening psychologists interviewing peace officer candidates are already required to discuss topics of bias specifically on gender, racial, disability, nationality, religion, sexual orientation, and more. Polygraphs are also utilized in the background process to identify tolerance-related issues, acts of physical/domestic violence, or the use of racial or ethnic slurs directed at others, among other potentially disqualifying acts.
The current manual utilized by POST was published in 2014 and revised in 2017, 2018, and most recently in January of 2019. Countless individuals, including numerous doctors, psychologists, professionals, and law enforcement experts worked with POST to conduct meta-analysis of research and validate the guidelines with empirical evidence. AB 846 contemplates recreating the painstaking work that has been already complete. Given POST’s expanding role, it is improvident to create this new task.
The limitations AB 846 sets on recruitment are also costly and concerning. This measure would require every law enforcement agency to “review the job description that is used in the recruitment and hiring” of peace officers and make changes that “emphasize community-based policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving, while de-emphasizing the paramilitary aspects of the job.” This section raises numerous questions concerning what is being asked of agencies. What is included in “paramilitary aspect of the job” and what would constitute sufficient de-emphasis of those duties? Should a recruitment video that shows SWAT teams and helicopters be removed or edited?
Recruiting qualified peace officer candidates has become increasingly difficult in the last decade. Most agencies find themselves short-staffed, even when reduced budgets have allowed for additional officers. As such, municipal police agencies have expanded outreach and created incentive packages to entice qualified candidates. Many of these very qualified candidates also come from our armed forces, and it remains unclear how this bill would impact outreach to those individuals.
Finally, AB 846 finds and declares that the changes to these job descriptions are meant to facilitate the implementations of “problem-solving policing and intelligence-led policing in contrast with reactive policing strategies.” These terms are also somewhat confusing in their intent as intelligence-led policing has been criticized by social justice organizations for disproportionately impacting minority communities.
Overall, this bill would duplicate work already complete, unnecessarily increase costs to local agencies already facing budget cuts due to the current pandemic,
and hampers law enforcement agencies’ abilities to recruit qualified candidates. For these reasons, CPCA must oppose AB 846.
Prepared by: Gabe Caswell / PUB. S. /
8/21/20 17:52:48
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 846 (Burke) - Public employment: public officers or employees declared by law to be peace officers
Version: June 25, 2020 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 13, 2020 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 846 would require evaluations of peace officers to include an evaluation of bias against specified protected characteristics and require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) to review and update their materials according. It also would require every department or agency that employs peace officers to review their job descriptions and emphasize community-based policing and collaborative problem solving and deemphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job.
Fiscal Impact:
- POST: One-time costs of approximately $100,000 for subject-matter experts to create a section in the Psychological Screening Manual on implicit and explicit bias. (General Fund)
- Bias Evaluation: Minor to no costs to law enforcement agencies, as many indicate that the mental condition evaluation they use currently screens for bias against the characteristics listed in the bill.
- Job Description: Minor to no costs to peace officer employers to review, and make changes if necessary to, their job description that is used in recruitment and hiring. Most peace officer employers have relayed to the Committee that their job descriptions currently are aligned with this measure.
Background:
Existing law requires that each peace officer class to meet certain minimum standards, including each person being a citizen or permanent resident who is eligible and has applied for citizenship, at least age 18, of good moral character, and a high school graduate or a specified equivalent. Peace officers also must be free from any physical, emotional, or mental condition that might adversely affect the exercise of the powers of a peace officer, as determined by an evaluation by a licensed professional.
Additionally, POST is required to develop and disseminate guidelines and training for all peace officers on the racial and cultural differences of California residents. The course or courses of instruction and the guidelines must stress understanding and respect for racial, identity, and cultural differences and development of effective, noncombative methods of carrying out law enforcement duties in a diverse racial, identity, and cultural environment. Moreover, existing law mandates that basic training courses for peace officers include adequate instruction on racial, identity, and cultural diversity in order to foster mutual respect and cooperation between law enforcement and members of all racial, identity, and cultural groups. In developing the training, POST is required to consult with appropriate groups and individuals having an interest and expertise in the field of racial, identity, and cultural awareness and diversity. Once the initial basic peace officer training is completed, specified peace officers must complete a refresher course on racial and identity profiling, including implicit bias, every five years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require evaluations of peace officers include a finding that they are free from bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation and require POST to study, review, and update their regulations and associated screening materials related to the emotional and mental condition evaluation of implicit and explicit bias against these characteristics. It also would require every department or agency that employs peace officers to review the job descriptions used in the recruitment and hiring of officers and to make changes that emphasize community policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving whiling deemphasizing the paramilitary aspects of the job.
Related Legislation:
AB 1022 (Holden, 2019-2022 Reg. Sess.) would, among other things, revise policies related to law enforcement officers’ duty to intervene when force is used. AB 1022 is pending in this Committee.
SB 230 (Caballero, Ch. 285, Stats. 2019) required law enforcement agencies, by January 1, 2021, to maintain a policy that provides guidelines on the use of force, the use of de-escalation techniques and other alternatives to use of force. It required specific guidelines for the application of deadly force and factors for evaluating and reviewing all use of force incidents.
Staff Comments:
Proposed Government Code section 1031.1, subdivision (b) references Penal Code section 422.55 for the meaning of certain words in AB 846. The author may wish to consider a reference to Penal Code section 422.56 instead, as it is this latter section that actually defines the relevant terms.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 846 Hearing Date: July 31, 2020
Author: | Burke | ||
Version: | June 25, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | GC | ||
Subject: Public Employment: Public Officers or Employees Declared by Law to be Peace Officers
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: SB 230 (Caballero) Chapter 285, Stats. 2019
Support: California Attorney for Criminal Justice; California Public Defenders Association; California State Sheriffs’ Association; City of Thousand Oaks; Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department; Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Opposition: California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Assembly Floor Vote: Not relevant
PURPOSE
The purpose of this legislation is to (1) require that evaluations of peace officers include an evaluation of bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation; and (2) require every department or agency that employs peace officers to review their job descriptions and deemphasize the paramilitary aspects of employment and place more emphasis on community interaction and collaborative problem solving.
Existing law requires that each class of peace officers must meet the following minimum standards: (Gov. Code § 1031.)
- A citizen or permanent resident who is eligible and has applied for citizenship.
- At least 18-years of age.
- Of good moral character, as determined through a background investigation.
- A high-school graduate, or a specified equivalent.
- Free from any physical, emotional, or mental condition that might adversely affect the exercise of the powers of a peace officer.
Existing law specifies that emotional and mental condition of peace officer candidates shall be evaluated by either of the following: (Gov. Code § 1031; subd. (f)(1)&(2).)
- A physician who holds a valid license and has successfully completed a postgraduate residency education program in accredited psychology with at least the equivalent of five full-time years of experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders.
- A licensed psychologist who has at least the equivalent of five full-time years of experience in the diagnosis and treatment of emotional and mental disorders, including the equivalent of three full-time years accrued post-doctorate.
Existing law requires the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) to develop and disseminate guidelines and training for all peace officers in California on the racial and cultural differences. The course or courses of instruction and the guidelines shall stress understanding and respect for racial, identity, and cultural differences, and development of effective, noncombative methods of carrying out law enforcement duties in a diverse racial, identity, and cultural environment. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (a).)
Existing law establishes the course of basic training for peace officers shall include adequate instruction on racial, identity, and cultural diversity in order to foster mutual respect and cooperation between law enforcement and members of all racial, identity, and cultural groups. In developing the training, the commission shall consult with appropriate groups and individuals having an interest and expertise in the field of racial, identity, and cultural awareness and diversity. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (b).)
Existing law states that every peace officer in this state shall participate in expanded training as prescribed and certified by the POST. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (g).)
Existing law establishes that the curriculum shall be evidence-based and shall include and examine evidence-based patterns, practices, and protocols that make up racial or identity profiling, including implicit bias. This training shall prescribe evidence-based patterns, practices, and protocols that prevent racial or identity profiling. In developing the training, the commission shall consult with the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board. The course of instruction shall include, but not be limited to, significant consideration of each of the following subjects:
- Identification of key indices and perspectives that make up racial, identity, and cultural differences among residents in a local community.
- Negative impact of intentional and implicit biases, prejudices, and stereotyping on effective law enforcement, including examination of how historical perceptions of discriminatory enforcement practices have harmed police-community relations and contributed to injury, death, disparities in arrest detention and incarceration rights, and wrongful convictions.
- The history and role of the civil and human rights movement and struggles and their impact on law enforcement.
- Specific obligations of peace officers in preventing, reporting, and responding to discriminatory or biased practices by fellow peace officers.
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, and cultural and police-community relations issues in a local area.
- The prohibition against racial or identity profiling. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (h)(1)-(6).)
Existing law provides that once the initial basic peace officer training is completed, specified peace officers who adhere to the standards approved by the POST shall be required to complete a refresher course on racial and identity profiling, including implicit bias, every five years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (i).)
Existing law establishes the Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) for the purposes of eliminating racial and identity profiling, and improving diversity and racial and identity sensitivity in law enforcement. Every year RIPA shall analyze law enforcement training and issue a report that provides RIPA’s analysis. (Pen. Code, § 13519.4 (j)(3)(B)(E).)
This bill requires that prospective officers’ evaluations for mental fitness include bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation.
This bill would require, by January 1, 2022, for POST to study, review, and update regulations and screening materials to identify explicit and implicit bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation related to emotional and mental condition evaluations.
This bill requires that local law enforcement agencies shall review their job descriptions used to recruit and hire peace officers and shall make changes that emphasize community-based policing, familiarization between law enforcement and community residents, and collaborative problem solving, and de-emphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job.
This bill specifies that the recruitment provisions change is not intended to alter the required duties of any peace officer.
This bill provides that the Legislature finds and declares that changes to these job descriptions are necessary to allow peace officers to feel like the public can trust law enforcement and to implement problem-solving policing and intelligence-led policing strategies in contrast with reactive policing strategies.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
The goal of this bill is to screen for both implicit and explicit biases during the hiring process, and focus on more community-oriented practices in law enforcement by reassessing job descriptions and recruitment practices. This can foster a more communal and less militaristic and aggressive approach to policing.
AB 846 will require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training to study and update regulations and screening materials to identify explicit and implicit bias against race or ethnicity, gender, nationality, religion, disability, or sexual orientation related to emotional and mental condition evaluations of peace officers. Additionally, the minimum standards for each peace officer will be amended in order to require that each individual must be free from explicit and implicit bias when evaluating their mental condition through their training and examination.
Implicit bias among law enforcement is especially dangerous because of the positions of power they hold. We already recognize the disparities in stop, search and arrest rates across demographic groups. The latest murders of black men by white police officers across our nation are being amplified as needed calls for reform. It is therefore critical that we require screening of bias during the hiring process and recognize how to take steps to counteract their influence. We must make sure that officers are trained and acting on facts, not biases.
This language will also require a review of the job descriptions used in the recruitment and hiring of law enforcement officers and require changes that de-emphasize the paramilitary aspects of the job in order to place more emphasis on community interaction and collaborative problem solving. The objective is to move away from militaristic focused job descriptions in an effort to attract a wider range of applicants and promote a greater focus on community involvement.
Recruitment can improve if the description of these jobs are re-imagined. We have seen a demand for systemic change within law enforcement and part of that task includes changing the culture, which can begin with the way we recruit, evaluate, and re-frame positions for potential applicants. There needs to be better trust and coordination between the police and the communities they are hired to protect and serve. Our justice system is based around the idea of fairness and impartiality. Working to bring in a wider applicant pool for law enforcement positions while simultaneously screening for biases will help reform the system as it currently exists and move us in the direction of equity.
2. Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST)
The Commission on Peace Officers Standards and Training (POST) was established by the Legislature in 1959 to set minimum selection and training standards for California law enforcement. POST develops and implements various courses to train peace officers, including both basic and continuing professional training. Peace officer basic training includes a minimum of 664 hours of POST-developed training and testing in 42 separate areas of instruction. According to POST’s website, most POST-certified basic training academies exceed the 664 minimum hours by 200 or more hours.
3. Racial Profiling and Bias Training by POST
According to Section 13519.4 (f) of the California Penal Code, “A peace officer shall not engage in racial or identity profiling.” Peace officers are encouraged to not engage in racial or identity profiling through various POST courses but this has not resulted in less racial profiling. The LA Times reported, “California's attorney general says 157 people died during encounters with police in the state last year [2016]…Forty-two percent of the civilians involved were Latino. Although black people make up just 6% of the state's population, according to the most recent Census data, they represented nearly 20% of the use-of-force and shooting cases last year. More than half of the officers involved were white.” In the 2019 Racial and Identity Profiling Advisory Board (RIPA) report, in 2017 there were 741 civilians involved in use of force incidents with Latino civilians comprising of 43.9% and Black civilians comprising of 19.3%.
The 2019 RIPA report had also found that in 2018 several of the trainings did not meet all of the curriculum requirements. The Board is currently working with POST to recreate this training to better meet the requirements. RIPA’s recommendations strongly emulate AB 243. For example, RIPA also recommends more frequent trainings and inclusion of implicit bias training.
4. Recruitment and Evaluation of Officers
This bill takes a slightly different tact from previous legislation that focused on training of officers, and setting policy for local law enforcement agencies. The legislation herein approaches the issue by requiring that all local law enforcement agencies shift the advertisement and recruiting of officers away from the more militaristic aspects of the job and towards community interaction and problem solving. In addition, as a part of the screening process, this bill would require officers undergo an evaluation to determine whether they hold biases that could impact their ability to effectively and neutrally act in the role of a peace officer, and to handle the extraordinary responsibility that goes along with that highly-trusted role.
5. Argument in Support
According to the California Public Defenders Association:
While current law requires law enforcement officers in the state of California to meet current standards, including an evaluation for physical, emotional and mental fitness, AB 846 would require that evaluation to also include factors relating to explicit and implicit bias. Additionally, AB 846 would require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training [“POST”] to study, review and update regulations and screening materials related to explicit and implicit bias. This is an urgently needed bill, which will save the lives of many people of California that have interactions with law enforcement officers.
The recent news coverage of bias-related incidents by law enforcement officers in California shows how critical a need there is for law enforcement officers to be screened and trained on implicit and explicit bias. Just yesterday, KRON4.com reported that the mayor of San Jose was calling for the firing of four San Jose police officers accused of making racist comments on Facebook in what he called “an online ring of hate.” In a welcome surprise, San Jose Police Association President Paul Kelly condemned the officers, saying, “There is no place in our police department or our union for racists or bigots, or for those that enable them by not speaking up when they see those types of behaviors.”
The passage of AB 846 would be a significant step towards protecting the people of California from biased law enforcement officers who have no place in our law enforcement agencies.
6. Argument in Opposition
According to California Statewide Law Enforcement Association:
While we certainly understand the author’s position to require the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) to review and update regulations regarding explicit and implicit biases, necessary funding should be provided to POST to meet these new requirements. However, AB 846 also requires departments and agencies that employ peace officers to change the job descriptions used in hiring those officers, which could have significant impacts to our job classifications, pay and benefits. Further, AB 846 implies peace officers do not have relationships within their communities and that officers do not implement problem-solving and intelligence-led policing. Peace officers are already highly trained in problem-solving and critical thinking, often having to make split second decisions to protect and serve the public, and risking their lives to ensure the safety of communities in California. Lastly, departments and agencies take particular care to ensure officers are communicating and building relationships within the communities they serve; AB 846 will do nothing to enhance community and police relations.
-- END –
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 846 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 846
Author: Burke (D), Low (D) and Mullin (D), et al.
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-4, 5/28/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Customer loyalty programs
SOURCE: California Retailers Association
DIGEST:
This bill provides that the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) does not prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering them for no fee, if the offering is in connection with a loyalty or rewards program.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 provide an exception to the prohibition on selling personal information collected in connection with loyalty programs.
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. This right may be referred to as the right to opt out. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Requires a business that sells consumers’ personal information to third parties to provide notice to consumers, as specified, that this information may be sold and that consumers have the “right to opt-out” of the sale of their personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of the consumer’s rights under the CCPA, including, but not limited to, by:
- Denying goods or services to the consumer;
- Charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
- Providing a different level or quality of goods or services to a consumer; or
- Suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(1).)
- Provides the above provision does not prohibit charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(2).)
- Authorizes a business to offer financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection of personal information, the sale of personal information, or the deletion of personal information. A business may also offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(1).)
- Authorizes a business to enter a consumer into a financial incentive program only if the consumer gives the business prior opt-in consent which clearly describes the material terms of the financial incentive program, and which may be revoked by the consumer at any time. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(3).)
- Prohibits a business from using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(4).)
- Defines “sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” to mean selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(t)(1).)
This bill:
- Defines “loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program” to include an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
- Provides that the CCPA shall not be construed to prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if the offering is in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.
- Prohibits a business from offering loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card programs that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.
- Provides that nothing therein shall be construed to deny a consumer’s rights pursuant to Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code.
- Prohibits a business from selling the personal information of consumers collected as part of a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program except where the business sells the personal information to a third party in order for the third party to provide the consumer with a financial incentive, sale, or other discount and both of the following conditions are met:
- The business obtains the express consent of the consumer to sell the information to the specific third party after the business discloses the terms of the sale. A consumer shall be given the option to participate in the program, on equal terms with other participants, without consenting to the sale of the consumer’s personal information to any third parties.
- The third party uses the information only for the purposes of identifying the consumer as an eligible member of the business' loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program. The third party may not retain or otherwise use or disclose the personal information.
- Makes a series of findings and declarations.
Background
The CCPA prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer based on the consumer’s exercise of their CCPA rights. The provision includes a non-exclusive list of conduct amounting to discrimination, including charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; or providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer. However, it also states that it does not prohibit a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.
Concerns have been raised that these non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA could be interpreted to interfere with various customer loyalty and rewards programs. This bill explicitly provides that the CCPA does not prohibit a business from offering a different price or quality of goods or services in connection with a consumer’s participation in loyalty programs. To ensure consumers’ personal information is protected as part of these programs, this bill provides that businesses cannot sell personal information collected in conjunction with the programs with one narrow exception. It is sponsored by the California Retailers Association.
Comments
Ensuring the Legal Survival of Loyalty Programs
The author lays out the intent and need for this bill:
AB 846 will ensure that customer loyalty programs can continue to operate under the CCPA. Loyalty rewards programs are designed by businesses to encourage consumers to continue to shop at or use the services of businesses associated with each program. Through their participation, consumers are rewarded by businesses with built in incentives. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small. The CCPA was not intended to interfere with loyalty programs. However, the nondiscrimination section in the Act is unclear on this issue and businesses are concerned that as drafted, the CCPA could lead to the end of these programs as well as unnecessary litigation. AB 846 will provide more certainty for consumers and businesses by explicitly allowing loyalty programs to continue, while not weakening or diluting the nondiscrimination provision within the CCPA.
This bill provides that the CCPA does not prohibit “a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee” if such an offering is “in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.” Such programs are defined to include:
an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
This language allows businesses to offer special perks to members of their frequent flyer program or discounts to their grocery store rewards program. To ensure that such programs do not exacerbate a “pay-for-privacy” dynamic in which only those that can afford to forego the discounts or to pay for upgrades are able to protect their privacy, this bill makes clear that it shall not be construed to deny certain consumer rights under the CCPA and explicitly prohibits the sale of personal information collected as part of these loyalty programs with one narrow exception.
A business is permitted to sell a consumer’s personal information to a third party in order for the third party to provide a financial incentive, sale, or other discount directly to the consumer under certain strict conditions. The business must clearly disclose the terms of the sale to the consumer and thereafter obtain the consumer’s express authorization for the sale to each specific third party before so selling the information. One required term is that a consumer must be able to participate in the loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program on equal terms with other participants without providing such authorization or consent. Furthermore, the bill strictly limits what the third party can do with the personal information. It can only use this information for the purpose of identifying the consumer as an eligible member of the business’ loyalty program. The purpose is to facilitate certain loyalty program features where a third party business provides a discount, such as discounted gasoline, for eligible members of a specific loyalty program, such as a grocery store’s.
This bill makes clear that this eligibility determination is the only permissible use of the personal information. The third party cannot otherwise use the personal information and is barred from retaining it. In addition, not only is the third party prohibited from further using or selling the information, but the third party is prohibited from allowing any disclosure of the information. The purpose is to allow for specific loyalty program benefits, such as the example above, without allowing the personal information to enter a wider data-sharing ecosystem. Even for the third party, the information can only be used for eligibility determination.
Support and opposition. The list of organizations in support and in opposition is largely based on a previous version of this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Retailers Association (source)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
Association of National Advertisers
Azusa Chamber of Commerce
Biulding Owners and Managers Association of California
Brawley Chamber of Commerce
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Carlitos Way Fresh Mexican Market
Carnicería Mi Mercadito, LLC
Chamber of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
Common Sense Media
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Action
Consumer Data Industry Association
Consumer Reports
Consumer Technology Association
Cost Plus World Market
CTIA
El Dorado County Joint Chambers Commission
El Rancho Mexican Restaurant
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Email Sender and Provider Coalition
Encino Chamber of Commerce
Feld Entertainment
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Insights Association
Interactive Advertising Bureau
International Council of Shopping Centers
JCPenney
La Rosa Meat Market
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Lowe’s
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Association of Theatre Owners of CA/NV
National Federation of Independent Business
NetChoice
North Orange County Chamber
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Panadería Los Arcos
PetSmart
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Ralphs/Food 4 Less
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber
Simi Valley Chamber
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Privacy and Security Coalition
Tacos La Tortillería – El Amigazo Western Wear
The Silicon Valley Organization
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Walgreens
Westside Council of Chambers of Commerce
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/20)
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-4, 5/28/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Gallagher, Kamlager-Dove, Mark Stone, Wicks
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gray, Kalra, Limón, Ting
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
6/25/20 13:11:22
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 846 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 846
Author: Burke (D), Low (D) and Mullin (D), et al.
Amended: 7/11/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-4, 5/28/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Customer loyalty programs
SOURCE: California Retailers Association
DIGEST:
This bill provides that the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) does not prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering them for no fee, if the offering is in connection with a loyalty or rewards program.
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. This right may be referred to as the right to opt out. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Requires a business that sells consumers’ personal information to third parties to provide notice to consumers, as specified, that this information may be sold and that consumers have the “right to opt-out” of the sale of their personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of the consumer’s rights under the CCPA, including, but not limited to, by:
- Denying goods or services to the consumer;
- Charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
- Providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or
- Suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(1).)
- Provides that the above provision does not prohibit a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(2).)
- Authorizes a business to offer financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection of personal information, the sale of personal information, or the deletion of personal information. A business may also offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(1).)
- Authorizes a business to enter a consumer into a financial incentive program only if the consumer gives the business prior opt-in consent which clearly describes the material terms of the financial incentive program, and which may be revoked by the consumer at any time. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(3).)
- Prohibits a business from using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(4).)
- Defines “sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” to mean selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(t)(1).)
This bill:
- Defines “loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program” to include an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
- Provides that the CCPA shall not be construed to prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if the offering is in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.
- Prohibits a business from offering loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card programs that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.
- Provides that nothing therein shall be construed to deny a consumer’s rights pursuant to Section 1798.120 of the Civil Code.
- Prohibits a business from selling the personal information of consumers collected as part of a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.
- Makes a series of findings and declarations.
Background
The CCPA prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer based on the consumer’s exercise of their CCPA rights. The provision includes a non-exclusive list of conduct amounting to discrimination, including charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; or providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer. However, it also states that it does not prohibit a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.
Concerns have been raised that these non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA could be interpreted to undermine various customer loyalty and rewards programs. This bill explicitly provides that the CCPA does not prohibit a business from offering a different price or quality of goods or services in connection with a consumer’s participation in loyalty programs. To ensure consumers’ personal information is protected as part of these programs, the bill provides that businesses cannot sell personal information collected in conjunction with the programs. This bill is sponsored by the California Retailers Association.
Comments
Non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA
The CCPA prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer based on the consumer’s exercise of the rights afforded in the CCPA. The provision includes a non-exclusive list of conduct amounting to discrimination:
- Denying goods or services;
- Charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
- Providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or
- Suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services.
However, within that same subdivision, the statute reads: “Nothing in this subdivision prohibits a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.”
The following subdivision authorizes businesses to provide “financial incentives” for the collection and sale of personal information. It authorizes a business to offer “a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.” However, such practices require certain disclosures and consent and must not be “unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.”
The language used in this section is arguably unclear as to what exactly it allows and prohibits. It should be noted that the CCPA authorizes the Attorney General to establish rules and guidelines regarding these “financial incentive offerings” and these regulations will work towards alleviating this confusion and avoiding conflicting interpretations.
Ensuring the Legal Survival of Loyalty Programs
The author lays out the intent and need for the bill:
AB 846 will ensure that customer loyalty programs can continue to operate under the CCPA. Loyalty rewards programs are designed by businesses to encourage consumers to continue to shop at or use the services of businesses associated with each program. Through their participation, consumers are rewarded by businesses with built in incentives. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small. The CCPA was not intended to interfere with loyalty programs. However, the nondiscrimination section in the Act is unclear on this issue and businesses are concerned that as drafted, the CCPA could lead to the end of these programs as well as unnecessary litigation. AB 846 will provide more certainty for consumers and businesses by explicitly allowing loyalty programs to continue, while not weakening or diluting the nondiscrimination provision within the CCPA.
This bill provides that the CCPA does not prohibit “a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee” if such an offering is “in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.” Such programs are defined to include:
an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
This language makes clear that businesses can offer special perks to members of their frequent flyer program or discounts to their grocery store rewards program. To ensure that such programs do not exacerbate a “pay-for-privacy” dynamic in which only those that can afford to forego the discounts or to pay for upgrades are able to protect their privacy, this bill prohibits the sale of personal information collected as part of these loyalty programs. This bill also makes clear that it shall not be construed to deny certain consumer rights under the CCPA.
Support and opposition. The list of organization in support and in opposition is largely based on a previous version of this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Retailers Association (source)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
Association of National Advertisers
Azusa Chamber of Commerce
Biulding Owners and Managers Association of California
Brawley Chamber of Commerce
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Carlitos Way Fresh Mexican Market
Carnicería Mi Mercadito, LLC
Chamber of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Civil Justice Association of California
Common Sense Media
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Action
Consumer Data Industry Association
Consumer Federation of America
Consumer Reports
Consumer Technology Association
Cost Plus World Market
CTIA
El Dorado County Joint Chambers Commission
El Rancho Mexican Restaurant
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Email Sender and Provider Coalition
Encino Chamber of Commerce
Feld Entertainment
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Insights Association
Interactive Advertising Bureau
International Council of Shopping Centers
JCPenney
La Rosa Meat Market
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Lowe’s
Media Alliance
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Association of Theatre Owners of CA/NV
National Federation of Independent Business
NetChoice
North Orange County Chamber
Oakland Privacy
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Panadería Los Arcos
PetSmart
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
Ralphs/Food 4 Less
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber
Simi Valley Chamber
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Privacy and Security Coalition
Tacos La Tortillería – El Amigazo Western Wear
The Silicon Valley Organization
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Walgreens
Westside Council of Chambers of Commerce
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/14/19)
Access Humboldt
Californians for Consumer Privacy
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 69-4, 5/28/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Gallagher, Kamlager-Dove, Mark Stone, Wicks
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gray, Kalra, Limón, Ting
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/14/19 15:20:12
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 846 (Author:Burke)
Version: May 20, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Customer loyalty programs
DIGEST
This bill provides that the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) does not prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering them for no fee, if either the offering is in connection with a loyalty or rewards program, or the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The CCPA prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer based on the consumer’s exercise of the rights afforded in the CCPA. The provision includes a non-exclusive list of conduct amounting to discrimination, including charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; or providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer. However, it also states that it does not prohibit a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.
Concerns have been raised that these non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA could be interpreted to undermine various customer loyalty and rewards programs that are popular with many consumers. This bill explicitly provides that the CCPA does not prohibit a business from offering a different price or quality of goods or services in connection with a consumer’s participation in loyalty programs. Various industry groups support the bill. However, the bill also provides another basis for disparate offerings to consumers that is vague and much broader than in the loyalty program context, drawing opposition from consumer and privacy groups. It is also unclear whether consumers can opt out of the sale of the information collected as part of these programs, and if so, whether they can be discriminated against for doing so. This bill is sponsored by the California Retailers Association.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that sells the consumer’s personal information, or that discloses it for a business purpose, disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information that the business collected about the consumer;
- the categories of personal information that the business sold about the consumer and the categories of third parties to whom the personal information was sold, by category or categories of personal information for each third party to whom the personal information was sold; and
- the categories of personal information that the business disclosed about the consumer for a business purpose. (Civ. Code § 1798.115.)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. This right may be referred to as the right to opt out. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Requires a business that sells consumers’ personal information to third parties to provide notice to consumers, as specified, that this information may be sold and that consumers have the “right to opt-out” of the sale of their personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of the consumer’s rights under the CCPA, including, but not limited to, by:
- denying goods or services to the consumer;
- charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
- providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or
- suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(1).)
- Provides that the above provision does not prohibit a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(a)(2).)
- Authorizes a business to offer financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection of personal information, the sale of personal information, or the deletion of personal information. A business may also offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(1).)
- Authorizes a business to enter a consumer into a financial incentive program only if the consumer gives the business prior opt-in consent which clearly describes the material terms of the financial incentive program, and which may be revoked by the consumer at any time. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(3).)
- Prohibits a business from using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature. (Civ. Code § 1798.125(b)(4).)
- Defines “sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” to mean selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(t)(1).)
- Provides that a business does not sell personal information when:
- A consumer uses or directs the business to intentionally disclose personal information or uses the business to intentionally interact with a third party, provided the third party does not also sell the personal information, unless that disclosure would be consistent with the provisions of this title. An intentional interaction occurs when the consumer intends to interact with the third party, via one or more deliberate interactions. Hovering over, muting, pausing, or closing a given piece of content does not constitute a consumer’s intent to interact with a third party;
- The business uses or shares an identifier for a consumer who has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information for the purposes of alerting third parties that the consumer has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information;
- The business uses or shares with a service provider personal information of a consumer that is necessary to perform a business purpose if both of the following conditions are met:
- The business has provided notice that information being used or shared in its terms and conditions consistent with Section 1798.135 of the Civil Code.
- The service provider does not further collect, sell, or use the personal information of the consumer except as necessary to perform the business purpose; or
- The business transfers to a third party the personal information of a consumer as an asset that is part of a merger, acquisition, bankruptcy, or other transaction in which the third party assumes control of all or part of the business, provided that information is used or shared consistently with Sections 1798.110 and 1798.115 of the Civil Code. If a third party materially alters how it uses or shares the personal information of a consumer in a manner that is materially inconsistent with the promises made at the time of collection, it shall provide prior notice of the new or changed practice to the consumer. The notice shall be sufficiently prominent and robust to ensure that existing consumers can easily exercise their choices consistently with Section 1798.120. This subparagraph does not authorize a business to make material, retroactive privacy policy changes or make other changes in their privacy policy in a manner that would violate the Unfair and Deceptive Practices Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code). (Civ. Code § 1798.140(t)(2).)
- Defines “business purpose” to mean the use of personal information for the business’s or a service provider’s operational purposes, or other notified purposes, provided that the use of personal information shall be reasonably necessary and proportionate to achieve the operational purpose for which the personal information was collected or processed or for another operational purpose that is compatible with the context in which the personal information was collected. It provides a list of business purposes, including performing services on behalf of the business or service provider of which providing advertising or marketing services is specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(d).)
This bill:
- Defines “loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program” to include an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
- Provides that the CCPA shall not be construed to prohibit a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if either of the following is true:
- the offering is in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program; or
- the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.
- Prohibits a business from offering loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card programs that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.
- Makes a series of findings and declarations.
COMMENTS
- Protecting the fundamental right to privacy
Article I, Section 1 of the California Constitution provides: “All people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy.” Privacy is therefore not just a policy goal; it is a constitutional right of every Californian. However, it has been under increasing assault.
The phrase “and privacy” was added to the California Constitution as a result of Proposition 11 in 1972; it was known as the “Privacy Initiative.” The arguments in favor of the amendment were written by Assemblymember Kenneth Cory and Senator George Moscone. The ballot pamphlet stated, in relevant part:
At present there are no effective restraints on the information activities of government and business. This amendment creates a legal and enforceable right of privacy for every Californian. The right of privacy . . . prevents government and business interests from collecting and stockpiling unnecessary information about us and from misusing information gathered for one purpose in order to serve other purposes or to embarrass us. . . . The proliferation of government and business records over which we have no control limits our ability to control our personal lives. . . . Even more dangerous is the loss of control over the accuracy of government and business records on individuals. . . . Even if the existence of this information is known, few government agencies or private businesses permit individuals to review their files and correct errors. . . . Each time we apply for a credit card or a life insurance policy, file a tax return, interview for a job[,] or get a drivers' license, a dossier is opened and an informational profile is sketched.[1]
In 1977, the Legislature reaffirmed that the right of privacy is a “personal and fundamental right” and that “all individuals have a right of privacy in information pertaining to them.”[2] The Legislature further stated the following findings:
- “The right to privacy is being threatened by the indiscriminate collection, maintenance, and dissemination of personal information and the lack of effective laws and legal remedies.”
- “The increasing use of computers and other sophisticated information technology has greatly magnified the potential risk to individual privacy that can occur from the maintenance of personal information.”
- “In order to protect the privacy of individuals, it is necessary that the maintenance and dissemination of personal information be subject to strict limits.”
Although written almost 50 years ago, these concerns seem strikingly prescient. Today, the world’s most valuable resource is no longer oil, but data. Companies regularly and systematically collect, analyze, share, and sell the personal information of consumers. While this data collection provides consumers various benefits, public fears about the widespread, unregulated amassing of personal information have only grown since privacy was made a part of California’s Constitution.
In response to growing concerns about the privacy and safety of consumers’ data, proponents of the CCPA, a statewide ballot initiative, began collecting signatures in order to qualify it for the November 2018 election. The goal was to empower consumers to find out what information businesses were collecting on them and give them the choice to tell businesses to stop selling their personal information. In response to the pending initiative, which was subsequently withdrawn, AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) was introduced, quickly shepherded through the legislative process, and signed into law. The outcome was the CCPA, Civil Code Section 1798.100 et seq.
The CCPA grants a set of rights to consumers with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice and disclosure rights regarding information collection and use practices, access to the information collected, the right to delete certain information, the right to restrict the sale of information, and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights.
This bill seeks to add a section to the CCPA explicitly providing for loyalty programs.
- Non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA
The CCPA prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer based on the consumer’s exercise of the rights afforded in the CCPA. The provision includes a non-exclusive list of conduct amounting to discrimination:
- denying goods or services;
- charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties;
- providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or
- suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services.
This language essentially protects consumers from retaliation for exercising their rights under the CCPA. This provision is fundamental to ensuring the remaining rights provided for by the statute are meaningful for consumers.
However, within that same subdivision, the statute reads: “Nothing in this subdivision prohibits a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.” In the following subdivision, the CCPA authorizes businesses to provide “financial incentives” for the collection and sale of personal information. It also authorizes a business to offer “a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.” However, such practices require certain disclosures and consumer consent and must not be “unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.”
The language used in this section is arguably unclear as to what exactly it allows and prohibits. It should be noted that the CCPA authorizes the Attorney General to establish rules and guidelines regarding these “financial incentive offerings” and these regulations will work towards alleviating this confusion and avoiding conflicting interpretations.
However, businesses have expressed concerns that, as is, the non-discrimination provisions may prohibit a variety of loyalty and rewards programs that are currently in existence.
- Ensuring the legal survival of loyalty programs
The author lays out the intent and need for the bill:
AB 846 will ensure that customer loyalty programs can continue to operate under the CCPA. Loyalty rewards programs are designed by businesses to encourage consumers to continue to shop at or use the services of businesses associated with each program. Through their participation, consumers are rewarded by businesses with built in incentives. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small. The CCPA was not intended to interfere with loyalty programs. However, the nondiscrimination section in the Act is unclear on this issue and businesses are concerned that as drafted, the CCPA could lead to the end of these programs as well as unnecessary litigation. AB 846 will provide more certainty for consumers and businesses by explicitly allowing loyalty programs to continue, while not weakening or diluting the nondiscrimination provision within the CCPA.
The bill accomplishes its ostensible goal by providing that nothing in the CCPA prohibits “a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee” if such an offering is “in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program.” Such programs are defined to include:
an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
This language makes clear that businesses can offer special perks to members of their frequent flyer program or discounts to their grocery store rewards program. However, the bill does not constrain what the business can do with personal information collected as part of such programs. Therefore, it leaves open the possibility that businesses could systematically offer discounts and rewards as part of these programs and, in exchange, collect and sell such information across the internet without clear guidelines on what rights consumers have to restrict such sales.
Such a situation exacerbates a “pay-for-privacy” dynamic in which only those that can afford to forego the discounts or to pay for upgrades are able to protect their privacy. The language of the bill therefore could be interpreted to disproportionately disadvantage the fundamental privacy rights of lower-income consumers. The non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA were intended to avoid just such a situation.
Therefore, in order to avoid such an outcome, the Committee may wish to consider whether the following provisions should be included in the bill.
Amendment
In Section 2 of the bill, add the following provisions:
(d) A business that offers a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer who exercises any of the consumer’s rights under this title shall comply with subdivision (b) of Section 1798.125.
(e) Nothing in this section shall be construed to deny a consumer’s rights pursuant to Section 1798.120.
(f) A business shall not offer a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program without expressly and conspicuously providing the consumer with the option to participate in the program, on equal terms with other participants, without consenting to the sharing or sale of the consumer’s personal information with third parties.
These provisions ensure that consumers maintain their ability to exercise some control over the information that is collected as part of these programs and are not discriminated against for so exercising their rights. One example that has been raised is a grocery store program that allows a consumer to use their points for discounts on gas at certain gas stations. This language explicitly allows the store to share that information with the gas station.
The bill as so amended achieves the following:
- ensures that “customer loyalty programs can continue to operate under the CCPA,” the stated goal of the author and sponsor;
- allows businesses that operate such programs to collect and sell the personal information of consumers participating in the programs; but also
- provides consumers the clear ability to opt out of the sale of their personal information and to be protected from discrimination and retaliation within the program as a result of exercising that right.
- Additional language eroding the non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA
Beyond allowing for customer loyalty programs, the bill also provides that nothing in the CCPA prohibits “a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee” if such an offering is “for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.” It is unclear exactly what is intended to be authorized by this language and no explanation has been provided by the author or sponsor. The provision operates completely independently from the paragraph authorizing “loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card programs,” the stated goal of the bill.
If this language is interpreted broadly, it could fundamentally undermine the non-discrimination provisions of the CCPA and prevent many consumers from meaningfully exercising their rights under the CCPA. The issues identified above regarding the creation of a pay-for-privacy framework are heightened by this vague language authorizing disparate treatment of consumers with respect to an unknown universe of offerings.
Writing in an oppose-unless-amended position, Consumer Reports addresses this provision of the bill: “This language is vague and could allow companies to penalize consumers for opting out of targeted advertising. In addition, the bill could prevent the Attorney General from setting guidelines regarding the CCPA’s notice requirements, so consumers may not even be able to make an informed choice about these programs.”
The Committee may wish to consider an amendment removing this provision of the bill to avoid turning privacy into a luxury commodity.
Amendment
Remove the following paragraph: “(2) The offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.”
In addition, the bill includes certain findings and declarations that are based on a sponsored study of loyalty programs. Without access to the methodologies of such research, the Committee may wish to remove the quantitative findings from the bill.
SUPPORT
California Retailers Association (sponsor)
Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers
Association of National Advertisers
Azusa Chamber of Commerce
Brawley Chamber of Commerce
Biulding Owners and Managers Association of California
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Grocers Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Restaurant Association
California Travel Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Carlitos Way Fresh Mexican Market
Carnicería Mi Mercadito, LLC
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Data Industry Association
Consumer Technology Association
Cost Plus World Market
CTIA
Chamber of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
El Dorado County Joint Chambers Commission
El Rancho Mexican Restaurant
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Email Sender and Provider Coalition
Encino Chamber of Commerce
Feld Entertainment
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Insights Association
Interactive Advertising Bureau
International Council of Shopping Centers
JCPenney
La Rosa Meat Market
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Lowe’s
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Association of Theatre Owners of CA/NV
National Federation of Independent Business
NetChoice
North Orange County Chamber
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Panadería Los ArcosPleasanton Chamber of Commerce
PetSmart
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Ralphs/Food 4 Less
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber
Simi Valley Chamber
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Privacy and Security Coalition
The Silicon Valley Organization
Tacos La Tortillería – El Amigazo Western Wear
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Walgreens
Westside Council of Chambers of Commerce
Wine Institute
OPPOSITION
Access Humboldt
ACLU of California
Californians for Consumer Privacy
Center for Digital Democracy
Common Sense Kids Action
Consumer Federation of America
Consumer Reports
Digital Privacy Alliance
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Media Alliance
Oakland Privacy
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 561 (Jackson, 2019) amends the private and consumer enforcement mechanisms in the CCPA. The bill also authorizes the Attorney General to provide general guidance on compliance with the CCPA. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 753 (Stern, 2019) provides that a business does not sell personal information if the business, pursuant to a written contract, shares, discloses, or otherwise communicates to another business or third party a unique identifier only to the extent necessary to serve or audit a specific advertisement to the consumer. The bill requires the contract to prohibit the other business or third party from sharing, selling, or otherwise communicating the information except as necessary to serve or audit advertisement from the business. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 25 (Chau, 2019) excludes from the definition of “consumer” in the CCPA a natural person whose personal information has been collected by a business in the course of a person acting as a job applicant or as an employee, contractor, or agent, on behalf of the business, to the extent their personal information is used for purposes compatible with the context of the person’s activities for the business as a job applicant, employee, contractor, or agent of the business. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 288 (Cunningham, 2019) provides that when a user of a social networking service deactivates or deletes the user’s account, the service shall provide the user the option of having the user’s personally identifiable information permanently removed from any database controlled by the service, from the service’s records, and to prohibit the service from selling that information to, or exchanging that information with, a third party in the future. Consumers are authorized to bring civil actions for damages that occur as a result of violations of the bill, including attorney’s fees, pain and suffering, and punitive damages, as specified. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 873 (Irwin, 2019) loosens the definition of “deidentified” and narrows the definition of “personal information” in the CCPA. The bill thereby limits the personal information subject to the protections of the CCPA. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 874 (Irwin, 2019) amends the definitions of “personal information” and “publicly available” in the CCPA. It removes the application of the CCPA to publicly available information that is used for a purpose that is not compatible with the purpose for which the data is maintained and made available in government records or for which it is publicly maintained. This bill is currently in pending consideration the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 981 (Daly, 2019) eliminates a consumer’s right to request a business delete or not sell the consumer’s personal information under the CCPA if it is necessary to retain or share the consumer’s personal information to complete an insurance transaction requested by the consumer. It also strengthens privacy protections for the information of insureds. This bill is currently in pending consideration the Senate Insurance Committee.
AB 1146 (Berman, 2019) exempts from the opt-out and deletion protections and provisions of the CCPA vehicle information, including ownership information, shared between a new motor vehicle dealer and the vehicle’s manufacturer, if the vehicle information is shared for the purpose of effectuating, or in anticipation of effectuating, a vehicle repair covered by a vehicle warranty or a recall and is not sold, shared, or used for any other purpose. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1355 (Chau, 2019) makes a series of technical changes to the CCPA and amends the definitions of “publicly available” and “personal information.” This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1416 (Cooley, 2019) establishes exceptions to the CCPA for a business that provides a consumer’s personal information to a government agency solely for the purposes of carrying out a government program or sells the personal information of a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information to another person for the sole purpose of detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity. This bill is currently in pending consideration the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1564 (Berman, 2019) reduces the methods a business must make available to consumers for submitting requests for information required to be disclosed pursuant to the CCPA. It removes the requirement that a business provide a toll-free telephone number for such purposes. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1760 (Wicks, 2019) strengthens various protections for consumers, including a change from opt-out consent for the sale of information to opt-in consent for the sharing of information. The bill also includes data minimization requirements and modifies various definitions. It also explicitly allows district attorneys, city attorneys, and county counsel to bring actions on behalf of the people for violations of the CCPA in addition to the Attorney General. It also removes the provision regarding the legal opinions of the Attorney General. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
Prior Legislation: AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) See Comment 2.
SB 1121 (Dodd, Ch. 735, Stats. 2018) amended the CCPA to make technical fixes and to address various stakeholder concerns.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 69, Noes 4)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 18, Noes 0)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 846
Author:(Burke, et al.)
As Amended Ver:May 20, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill adds separate authorization for certain "offerings" to the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), as specified.
Major Provisions
- Specifies that nothing in the CCPA prohibits a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if either of the following are true: a) the offering is in connection with a consumer's voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program, as defined; or b) the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer's data.
- Prohibits a business from offering loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card programs that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.
COMMENTS:
>
According to the Author:
"AB 846 will clarify that the nondiscrimination section of the CCPA does not result in the elimination of customer loyalty programs. It still maintains the intent of the law that allows consumers to exercise their right under the CCPA, and does not weaken or dilute the nondiscrimination provision in any way. Privacy advocates and some consumer groups have voiced that they believe these loyalty programs can continue. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small."
Arguments in Support:
California Retailers Association writes that while the CCPA "never intended to interfere with loyalty programs," the nondiscrimination statute "is confusing and could lead to unnecessary litigation […]." CRA writes that such programs help retailers of all sizes develop lasting relationships with their customers and "provide a myriad of benefits for customers who choose to participate. These customers frequently enjoy discounts as well unique services and rewards from the business offering the program. In addition […] some of the most popular rewards programs give customer reciprocal benefits with other merchants. For example, some supermarket rewards members earn discounts on gasoline. Similarly, hotels and airlines often allow customers to use their frequent flyer miles or points with other travel-related partners. These well-liked affiliations are integral to many programs and should not be jeopardized […]."
Arguments in Opposition:
Californians for Consumer Privacy writes that this bill would "create an unfortunate choice for consumers: participate in loyalty programs that, in many cases, are almost mandatory from a financial savings perspective, and allow data about your most intimate and personal purchases to be sold; or don't participate in the program, and pay much more for your food or medicine. […] Data collected pursuant to a loyalty program […] can be used to create profiles that can be used for targeting or discrimination. Moreover, increasingly there are concerns that data about, say, your food choices, will end up in the hands of health or life insurance companies and be used to make decisions about how much you are charged for health and life insurance. [… Also, it] is important to remember that deidentified and aggregate data are not defined as [PI] under CCPA. So, a loyalty program would be able to sell information such as how many male customers buy Pop-Tarts in a given store, and the retailer would be able to send coupons to those customers, all within the legal bounds of CCPA."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, possible minor costs (Consumer Privacy Fund/General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ) to revise proposed regulations pertaining to enforcement and prosecution of the CCPA. The CCPA requires DOJ to prosecute businesses that engage in discriminatory practices against consumers that request to access and retrieve their PI. DOJ regulations are expected in fall of 2019. DOJ has already accepted public comment on proposed regulations. Costs will be higher if DOJ is required to accept additional public comment on revised regulations.
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Chau, Kiley, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 20, 2019
CONSULTANT: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000839
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 846
Author:(Burke, et al.)
As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill replaces the "financial incentive programs" provisions of the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), with authorization for certain "offerings," as specified.
Major Provisions
- Specifies, except as provided below, that nothing in the CCPA's non-discrimination statute prohibits a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if either of the following are true: a) the offering is in connection with a consumer's voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discounts, or club card program, as defined; or b) the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer's data.
- Prohibits a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services that is unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.
COMMENTS:
Last year, the Legislature enacted the CCPA (AB 375 (Chau), Chapter 55, Statutes of 2018), to grant consumers certain rights regarding their personal information (PI), such as the right to opt-out of the sale of their PI. The CCPA was the byproduct of compromises made between business and consumer/privacy interests. This compromise is perhaps most visible in the CCPA's non-discrimination statute. First, it seeks to guarantee consumers the right to equal service and price even if they exercise their CCPA rights (i.e., by and large, a business cannot suddenly charge a consumer more, refuse or reduce their services because the consumer exercised their rights). This ensures that consumers are not forced to "pay for privacy," where only some can afford to do so. At the same time, it seeks to permit certain financial incentive practices that meet specified standards (e.g. not be unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious).
This bill seeks to revise that statute, largely to provide express authorization for loyalty and rewards programs. As noted in the policy committee analysis, nothing in the CCPA prevents an entity from providing such programs, if they operate in accordance with the CCPA. Accordingly, under the CCPA (and, arguably, in contrast to this bill) a consumer would retain the right to participate in a program even if they opted-out of their PI being sold.
According to the Author:
"AB 846 will clarify that the nondiscrimination section of the CCPA does not result in the elimination of customer loyalty programs. It still maintains the intent of the law that allows consumers to exercise their right under the CCPA, and does not weaken or dilute the nondiscrimination provision in any way. Privacy advocates and some consumer groups have voiced that they believe these loyalty programs can continue. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small."
Arguments in Support:
California Retailers Association (CRA) writes that while the CCPA "never intended to interfere with loyalty programs," the nondiscrimination statute "is confusing and could lead to unnecessary litigation […]." CRA writes that such programs help retailers of all sizes develop lasting relationships with their customers and "provide a myriad of benefits for customers who choose to participate. These customers frequently enjoy discounts as well unique services and rewards from the business offering the program. In addition […] some of the most popular rewards programs give customer reciprocal benefits with other merchants. For example, some supermarket rewards members earn discounts on gasoline. Similarly, hotels and airlines often allow customers to use their frequent flyer miles or points with other travel-related partners. These well-liked affiliations are integral to many programs and should not be jeopardized […]."
Arguments in Opposition:
Californians for Consumer Privacy writes that this bill would "create an unfortunate choice for consumers: participate in loyalty programs that, in many cases, are almost mandatory from a financial savings perspective, and allow data about your most intimate and personal purchases to be sold; or don't participate in the program, and pay much more for your food or medicine. […] Data collected pursuant to a loyalty program […] can be used to create profiles that can be used for targeting or discrimination. Moreover, increasingly there are concerns that data about, say, your food choices, will end up in the hands of health or life insurance companies and be used to make decisions about how much you are charged for health and life insurance. [… Also, it] is important to remember that deidentified and aggregate data are not defined as [PI] under CCPA. So, a loyalty program would be able to sell information such as how many male customers buy Pop-Tarts in a given store, and the retailer would be able to send coupons to those customers, all within the legal bounds of CCPA."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, possible minor costs (Consumer Privacy Fund/General Fund) to the Department of Justice (DOJ) to revise proposed regulations pertaining to enforcement and prosecution of the CCPA. The CCPA requires DOJ to prosecute businesses that engage in discriminatory practices against consumers that request to access and retrieve their PI. DOJ regulations are expected in fall of 2019. DOJ has already accepted public comment on proposed regulations. Costs will be higher if DOJ is required to accept additional public comment on revised regulations.
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Chau, Kiley, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 30, 2019
CONSULTANT: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000426
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 846
Author:(Burke) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
Policy Committee: | Privacy and Consumer Protection | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill amends the prohibition against consumer discrimination in the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA) to allow for differential treatment of consumers based on voluntary participation in financial incentive programs, including gift cards or certificates, discounts, payments to consumers or other benefits associated with a loyalty or rewards program, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Possible minor costs (Consumer Privacy Fund/GF) to the Department of Justice (DOJ) to revise proposed regulations pertaining to enforcement and prosecution of the CCPA. The CCPA requires DOJ to prosecute businesses that engage in discriminatory practices against consumers that request to access and retrieve their PI. DOJ regulations are expected in fall of 2019. DOJ has already accepted public comment on proposed regulations. Costs will be higher if DOJ is required to accept additional public comment on revised regulations.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 846 will clarify that the nondiscrimination section of the CCPA does not result in the elimination of customer loyalty programs….These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small.
- Background. The CCPA prohibits businesses from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised their right to access and retrieve their personal information (PI). The CCPA authorizes DOJ to prosecute businesses that deny goods or services, charge different prices or provide different levels of service to a consumer based on whether the consumers asked for their PI. This bill amends the CCPA to clarify businesses, like grocery stores, may offer customer loyalties programs for the benefit of consumer participants without violating the CCPA’s non-discrimination provisions.
- Support. According to the California Retailers Association:
While the sponsors of CCPA never intended to interfere with loyalty programs, the current language in the [CCPA] is confusing and could lead to unnecessary litigation against retailers who offer these popular programs.
- Opposition. According to Californians for Consumer Privacy:
AB 846 is aimed at allowing loyalty programs to sell personal information, which we think is a bad outcome for consumers, given that in many cases loyalty programs are almost financially mandatory for any rational consumer.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 846 (
Author:Burke) – As Amended Ver:April 12, 2019
SUBJECT: Customer loyalty programs
SUMMARY: This bill would replace the “financial incentive programs” provisions in the non-discrimination statute of the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA) with an authorization for offerings that include, among other things, gift cards or certificates, discounts, payments to consumers, or other benefits associated with a loyalty or rewards program, as specified. Specifically, this bill would:
- Repeal provisions authorizing certain financial incentive programs (including an offer by a business of different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if the price or difference is related to the value provided by the consumer’s data, as specified) within the CCPA’s non-discrimination statute ensuring a consumer’s right to equal service and price. In doing so, this bill would also repeal the CCPA’s prohibition against using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.
- Revise the non-discrimination statute to, instead, provide that nothing in the statute prohibits a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering goods or services for no fee, if any of the following are true:
- The offering is in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discount, or club card program.
- That difference is reasonably related to the value provided by the consumer’s data.
- The offering is related to a specific good or service whose functionality is reasonably related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.
- Revise the CCPA’s prohibition on discrimination against a consumer for exercising any of the consumer’s rights to, instead, specify that a business shall not engage in such discrimination by, among other things: (a) charging higher (as opposed to “different”) prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; or, (b) providing a lower (as opposed to “different”) level or quality of goods or services to the consumer.
- Define “loyalty, rewards, premium features, discount, or club card program” to include an offering to one or more consumers of lower prices or rates for goods or services or a higher level or quality of goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits, or a program through which consumers earn points, rewards, credits, incentives, gift cards, or certificates, coupons, or access to sales or discounts on a priority or exclusive basis.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the CCPA and provides various rights to consumers pursuant to the act. Subject to various general exemptions, a consumer has, among other things:
- the right to know what PI a business collects about consumers, as specified, including the categories of third parties with whom the business shares PI, and the specific pieces of information collected about the consumer;
- the right to know what PI a business sells about consumers, as specified, including the categories of PI that the business sold about the consumer and the categories of third parties to whom the PI was sold, by category or categories of PI for each third party to whom the PI was sold;
- the right to access the specific pieces of information a business has collected about the consumer;
- the right to delete information that a business has collected from the consumer; and
- the right to opt-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI if over 16 years of age, and the right to opt-in, as specified, if the consumer is a minor; and,
- the right to equal service and price, despite exercising any of these rights. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.100 et seq.)
- Generally requires under the CCPA that a business subject to the CCPA do all of the following, among other things: comply with the above requirements, provide various notices to those ends, and execute various requests upon receipt of a verifiable consumer request, as specified; and provide certain mechanisms for consumers to make their lawful requests, including a clear and conspicuous link titled “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” on the business’s internet homepage to enable consumers, or a person authorized by the consumer, to opt-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.100 et seq.)
- Prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of the consumer’s rights under the CCPA, including, but not limited to, by:
- Denying goods or services to the consumer.
- Charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties.
- Providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer.
- Suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.125(a)(1).)
- Specifies that nothing in the CCPA’s anti-discrimination statute prohibits a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.125(a)(2).)
- Expressly authorizes a business to offer financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection of PI, the sale of PI, or the deletion of PI. Further authorizes a business to offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.125(b)(1).)
- Specifies that a business that offers any such financial incentives shall notify consumers of the financial incentive, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.125(b)(2).)
- Provides that a business may enter a consumer into a financial incentive program only if the consumer gives the business prior opt-in consent, as specified, which clearly describes the material terms of the financial incentive program, and which may be revoked by the consumer at any time. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.125(b)(3).)
- Prohibits a business from using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature.
- Provides that, in order to comply with the various consumer rights provisions under the CCPA, a business subject to the CCPA must, in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers, do the following, among other things:
- Disclose certain information in its online privacy policy or policies if the business has an online privacy policy or policies and in any California-specific description of consumers’ privacy rights, or if the business does not maintain those policies, on its internet website, and update that information at least once every 12 months. This includes a description of a consumer’s rights pursuant to the non-discrimination provisions, above, and one or more designated methods for submitting requests.
- Ensure that all individuals responsible for handling consumer inquiries about the business’s privacy practices or the business’s compliance with the CCPA are informed of all requirements in various provisions of the CCPA enumerating consumer rights, as well as the provision prohibiting discrimination against consumers exercising those rights, and how to direct consumers to exercise their rights under those provisions. (Civ. Code Sec. 1978.130.)
- Provides various definitions under the CCPA. The CCPA, of particular relevance for this bill, defines the following terms:
- “Business” means a sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, corporation, association, or other legal entity that is organized or operated for the profit or financial benefit of its shareholders or other owners, that collects consumers’ PI, or on the behalf of which such information is collected and that alone, or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing of consumers’ PI, that does business in California, and that satisfies one or more of the following thresholds:
- Has annual gross revenues in excess of $25,000,000, as adjusted as specified.
- Alone or in combination, annually buys, receives for the business’s commercial purposes, sells, or shares for commercial purposes, alone or in combination, the PI of 50,000 or more consumers, households, or devices.
- Derives 50% or more of its annual revenues from selling consumers’ PI.
- “PI” means information that identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. PI includes certain specific types of information, if that information identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could be reasonably linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. These include, for example:
- Identifiers such as a real name, alias, postal address, unique personal identifier, online identifier, Internet Protocol address, email address, account name, social security number, driver’s license number, passport number, or other similar identifiers.
- Characteristics of protected classifications under California or federal law.
- Commercial information, including records of personal property, products or services purchased, obtained, or considered, or other purchasing or consuming histories or tendencies.
- Geolocation data.
- Inferences drawn from any of the information identified in the definition of PI to create a profile about a consumer reflecting the consumer’s preferences, characteristics, psychological trends, predispositions, behavior, attitudes, intelligence, abilities, and aptitudes.
PI does not include publicly available information, as specified. Among other things, specifies that for these purposes, “publicly available” means information that is lawfully made available from federal, state, or local government records, as specified. Information is not “publicly available” if that data is used for a purpose that is not compatible with the purpose for which the data is maintained and made available in the government records or for which it is publicly maintained.
- “Sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” means selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s PI by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. For purposes of the CCPA, a business does not “sell” PI when, among other things:
- A consumer uses or directs the business to intentionally disclose, as specified, PI or uses the business to intentionally interact with a third party, provided the third party does not also sell the PI, unless that disclosure would be consistent with this Act.
- The business uses or shares an identifier for a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI for the purposes of alerting third parties that the consumer has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI.
- The business uses or shares with a service provider PI of a consumer that is necessary to perform a business purpose if both of the following conditions are met: (i) the business has provided notice that information being used or shared in its terms and conditions, as otherwise specified under the bill; and (ii) the service provider does not further collect, sell, or use the PI of the consumer except as necessary to perform the business purpose. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.140.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to revise the CCPA to allow for business practices that involve the selling of consumers’ PI for the purpose of loyalty rewards programs. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s statement: According to the author:
The CCPA was passed last year with required clean-up legislation later in the session. There was a general understanding from last year that additional clean up measures would be needed to tighten the Act.
One of the unintended consequences of the CCPA was the potential elimination of customer loyalty programs. Current law states that a business cannot discriminate against a consumer for exercising their rights under the CCPA by denying goods or services, charging different prices or rates, or providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer.
AB 846 will clarify that the nondiscrimination section of the CCPA does not result in the elimination of customer loyalty programs. It still maintains the intent of the law that allows consumers to exercise their right under the CCPA, and does not weaken or dilute the nondiscrimination provision in any way. Privacy advocates and some consumer groups have voiced that they believe these loyalty programs can continue. These programs are offered by a wide breadth of businesses including grocery stores, hotels, drug stores, airlines, and a variety of other companies big and small.
- CCPA’s non-discrimination statute attempts to strike a balance between protecting consumers against retaliation for the exercise of their rights and certain financial incentive practices that potentially benefit all parties: Last year, the Legislature enacted the CCPA (AB 375, Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018), which gives consumers certain rights regarding their PI, including: (1) the right to know what PI that is collected and sold about them; (2) the right to request the categories and specific pieces of PI the business collects about them; and (3) the right to opt-out of the sale of their PI, or opt-in in the case of minors under 16 years of age. The CCPA was the byproduct of compromises made between business interests on the one side, and consumer and privacy interests on the other, to provide a legislative alternative to a ballot initiative on the same subject.
The compromise is evidenced by how the CCPA incorporates increased consumer rights (such as the right of deletion, right to specific pieces of information, and the separate treatment of minors’ data through an “opt-in” right) that would not have been in the underlying ballot initiative that served as the impetus and starting point for the final legislation. It is further evidenced by how, in turn, certain items were not included in (such as a whistleblower provision), limited by (such as the private right of action, and a single public enforcement entity as opposed to enforcement by all public prosecutors), or added to (such as the authorization for businesses to seek guidance from the Attorney General) the CCPA to alleviate certain concerns that businesses had with respect to the ballot initiative. This compromise is perhaps most visible in the CCPA’s non-discrimination statute.
Fundamentally, as currently drafted, the CCPA’s non-discrimination statute effectively prohibits retaliation (by way of denying goods or services, charging different prices or rates, as specified, or providing a different level or quality of goods or services, among other things) against consumers who exercise their data privacy rights under the CCPA. Ultimately, this particular statute aims to prevent “pay-for-privacy” pricing systems where only consumers who can afford to pay for their privacy rights receive the rights that have been afforded to all Californians under the California Constitution and the CCPA. Stated another way, in a pay-for-privacy framework, privacy becomes cast as a commodity for which companies can charge consumers money in exchange for protecting (or, rather, not monetizing) their privacy for the companies’ own profit. The concern with such schemes is that it only widens the gap between socioeconomic classes, where the “haves” can protect their PI from prying eyes and companies who wish to monetize data, and the “have nots” have no choice but to forfeit their privacy rights that should otherwise be ensured to them under the California Constitution and statutory law. Accordingly, the CCPA effectively seeks to guarantee consumers the right to equal service, regardless of whether or not they exercise their right to access their PI in the possession of a business, their right know what PI is collected or sold about them, the right to delete any PI they provide to a business, and/or their right to opt-out of the sale of their PI (or “opt-in,” in the case of minors under 16). As a practical matter, this means that a business cannot receive a deletion request, or right to know request, or right to opt-out request, and then turn around charge the consumer more for the same services, suddenly refuse services to them or reduce services to them simply because they opted-out and do not want their information to be shared with third parties, and so forth.
This same statute guaranteeing the consumer’s right to not be discriminated against and to receive equal service when exercising their rights, also permits certain financial incentive practices where the incentive offered is reasonably related to the value of the consumer’s data. To this end, however, the statute includes certain safeguards: the practice must not be unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious, and the business may only enroll a consumer who has provided prior opt-in consent pursuant to notice requirements that clearly describe the material terms of the program, and the consent may be revoked by the consumer at any time.
Since the passage of the CCPA, many stakeholders have indicated that they cannot reconcile the anti-discrimination provision of the statute (subdivision (a) of Section 1798.125) with the provisions allowing financial incentive programs (subdivision (a) of Section 1798.125). As this section was described in this Committee’s analysis of AB 375, at the time that bill was heard:
Similar to the initiative, AB 375 prohibits a business from discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of the consumer’s rights under the bill. Such discrimination may take the following forms, among other things: (1) denying goods or services to the consumer; (2) charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; (3) providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or (4) suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. Unlike the initiative however, the bill specifies that nothing in the above provisions prohibits a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data.
In addition, the bill provides that a business may offer consumers financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection, sale, or deletion of PI. A business may also offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. The business, however, is prohibited from using financial incentive practices that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious in nature. Additionally, the bill subjects businesses that offer financial incentives to consumers to various notice requirements, and specifies that a business may enter into a consumer into a financial incentive program only if the consumer provides prior opt-in consent which clearly describes the material terms of the program and which may be revoked by the consumer at any time.
Such provisions would authorize a business model by which consumers are allowed to elect to use free subscriptions in exchange for advertising or sign up for a paid subscription, such as with Spotify, for example. Ultimately, the bill anticipates that the AG will develop regulations by the time it becomes operative regarding financial incentive offerings which presumably will help reconcile these provisions to prevent discriminatory pay for privacy regimes.
This bill now seeks to amend that statute to repeal the provisions related to financial incentives, in favor of express authorization for loyalty or rewards programs. According to the California Retailers Association:
While the sponsors of CCPA never intended to interfere with loyalty programs, the current language in Section 1798.125 is confusing and could lead to unnecessary litigation against retailers who offer these popular programs. Such programs help retailers of all sizes – from local coffee shops to national companies – develop lasting relationships with their customers.
Club cards and other similar offerings provide a myriad of benefits for customers who choose to participate. These customers frequently enjoy discounts as well unique services and rewards from the business offering the program. In addition to those benefits, some of the most popular rewards programs give customer reciprocal benefits with other merchants. For example, some supermarket rewards members earn discounts on gasoline. Similarly, hotels and airlines often allow customers to use their frequent flyer miles or points with other travel-related partners. These well-liked affiliations are integral to many programs and should not be jeopardized by CCPA.
- Amending the non-discrimination statute to authorize certain “offerings” as opposed to “financial incentives”: As noted in Comment 3, above, the bill seeks to revise the non-discrimination statute to expressly authorize loyalty or rewards programs.
Notably, the bill largely does not alter the fundamental prohibition against discriminating against a consumer because the consumer exercised any of their rights under the CCPA, including, but not limited to, by: (1) denying goods or services to the consumer; (2) charging different prices or rates for goods or services, including through the use of discounts or other benefits or imposing penalties; (3) providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer; or, (4) suggesting that the consumer will receive a different price or rate for goods or services or a different level or quality of goods or services. It does, however, revise the law to state “higher prices or rates” and “lower level or quality” as opposed to “different prices or rates” and “different level or quality.” As a practical matter, it does not matter if a business were to: (a) charge a higher price or rate in retaliation against a consumer exercising their rights; (b) set a higher base price and revoke discounts previously provided to a consumer because the consumer exercised their CCPA rights; or, (c) restrict the availability of lower prices only to consumers who do not exercise their rights. In any of these situations, the business will arguably have violated this provision, even as amended by AB 846.
Of primary concern, is how this bill seeks to replace the non-discriminatory financial incentive practices permitted under the CCPA, with types of offerings that businesses may present to consumers without running afoul of the non-discrimination provisions.
Under the CCPA, existing law provides that nothing in the anti-discrimination language, above, prohibits a business from charging a consumer a different price or rate, or from providing a different level or quality of goods or services to the consumer, if that difference is reasonably related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. The CCPA then expressly provides, consistent with that recognition, that a business may offer: (1) financial incentives, including payments to consumers as compensation, for the collection of PI, the sale of PI, or the deletion of PI; and, (2) a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to the consumer if that price or difference is directly related to the value provided to the consumer by the consumer’s data. Ultimately, no financial incentive practice under the CCPA may be unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.
In contrast, this bill would, instead, provide that nothing in the anti-discrimination language above prevents a business from offering a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if any of the following are true:
- The offering is in connection with a consumer’s voluntary participation in a loyalty, rewards, premium features, discount, or club card program.
- That difference is reasonably related to the value provided by the consumer’s data.
- The offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is reasonably related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data.
Several concerns arise with respect to the types of offerings that are authorized under AB 846, in comparison to the CCPA. Those concerns relate to: (1) the ability of the business to offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services as long as the difference is reasonably related to the value provided by the consumer’s data; (2) the ability of a business to offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services if the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is reasonably related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data; and, (3) the removal of the CCPA provision which ensures against any unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious practices by businesses.
- The Committee should ensure, at minimum, that basic consumer protections are reinserted into the bill: Any difference in price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services should arguably be directly related to the value provided by the consumer’s data (consistent with the current CCPA), not “reasonably related.” Under the CCPA, while there is a provision providing recognition that different prices, rates, levels, or quality of goods can be provided where reasonably related to the consumer’s data in this non-discrimination statute, the very next provision of that statute expressly authorizes business to make offerings of a different price, rate, level or quality of goods or services when they are directly related to the value provided by the consumer’s data. Removing the second, qualifying statement, and now allowing for differences that are only “reasonably” related to the value provided by the consumer’s data potentially creates a significant loophole in the CCPA any time a consumer opts-out of the sale of their PI or deletes their PI.
Furthermore, if a business’s goods or services truly rely on the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data and a consumer opts-out or deletes information in manner that would affect the functionality of that good or service, then presumably the business should be able to show a direct relationship between functionality and that data. A reasonable relationship undermines the claim of reliance. In both cases, the determinations of “reasonableness” would be largely dependent on the interpretation of the business, and it is foreseeable that a business could use that malleable standard to effectively gut the “equal services and price” guarantees of the non-discrimination statute. As such, the Committee may wish to ensure that both cases rely on a “direct” relationship.
Also as noted above, this bill reflects a concerning shift in public policy whereby this bill would repeal the CCPA’s prohibition against unjust, unreasonable, coercive, and usurious “financial incentive practices.” To that end, the Committee may wish to equally ensure that any “offerings” are never unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious. The implication, otherwise, is that where California law previously prohibited such unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious business practices in the form of financial incentives under the CCPA, California law could now be interpreted to allow them in the form of these specific offerings pursuant to AB 846. It is equally unclear why the programs cannot abide by a requirement that they be just, reasonable, non-coercive, and non-usurious. To that end, the Committee may wish to also consider reinstating this provision for any offerings made by businesses under this bill.
Echoing these concerns, Californians for Consumer Privacy writes in opposition to this bill that “[t]here is nothing in the [CCPA] that prevents an entity from providing a loyalty or reward program, if that program operates in accordance with the CCPA. In fact, the CCPA expressly authorizes a business to provide financial incentives for a consumer to share and authorize the sale of their data so long as those incentives are directly related to the value provided to the business by the consumer’s data. Moreover, the CCPA provides important protections that ensure that incentives offered cannot be unjust, unreasonable, coercive or usurious. It is clear that loyalty programs are permitted by the CCPA.”
If this Committee were to approve this bill, it may wish to amend the bill, at minimum to address these concerns by: (1) replacing references to “reasonably related” with “directly related; (2) prohibiting businesses from engaging in any offerings that are unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious:
Suggested amendment:
- On page 3, lines 33 and 36, replace references to “reasonably related” with “directly related”
- On page 3, line 6, strike “Nothing” and insert “Except as provided in paragraph (3), nothing” before “in this subdivision prohibits a business from”
On page 3, after line 37, insert “(3) A business shall not offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services that is unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.”
That being said, Committee staff notes that the current CCPA language regarding permissible financial offerings, in the construct of a non-discrimination statute, was heavily nuanced. As such, there remains a broader question as to whether, in attempting to expressly authorize activity that is arguably already allowed under the CCPA, the bill has now created a new structure that undermines the equal service and price guarantees of this section by forcing consumers to choose between participation in their loyalty and rewards programs and protecting their data. Under the CCPA, those loyalty programs could exist, but a consumer could arguably still participate in those programs even if they opted-out of their PI being sold. (See Comment 6, for more.)
- Other arguments in opposition: In its letter of opposition, Californians for Consumer Privacy (CCP) writes:
The amendments proposed to Civil Code Section 1798.125 would create an unfortunate choice for consumers: participate in loyalty programs that, in many cases, are almost mandatory from a financial savings perspective, and allow data about your most intimate and personal purchases to be sold; or don’t participate in the program, and pay much more for your food or medicine. CCP does not believe that personal information collected from consumers via their participation in a loyalty program should be treated differently than other personal information. Data collected pursuant to a loyalty program contains some of the most specific data about a consumer, i.e. where you travel, where you stay, and what you eat, among other items. This data can be used to create profiles that can be used for targeting or discrimination. Moreover, increasingly there are concerns that data about, say, your food choices, will end up in the hands of health or life insurance companies and be used to make decisions about how much you are charged for health and life insurance.
Please note that if loyalty programs offered consumers the right to participate in the loyalty program, and not have their personal information sold, then such loyalty program would be in compliance with CCPA. Also, it is important to remember that deidentified and aggregate data are not defined as personal information under CCPA. So, a loyalty program would be able to sell information such as how many male customers buy Pop-Tarts in a given store, and the retailer would be able to send coupons to those customers, all within the legal bounds of CCPA. Because of this wide latitude, it appears that AB 846 is aimed at allowing loyalty programs to sell personal information, which we think is a bad outcome for consumers, given that in many cases loyalty programs are almost financially mandatory for any rational consumer.
CCP also believes that concerns with respect to loyalty programs can and should be addressed in regulations promulgated by the Attorney General.
A coalition of consumer and privacy organizations, including Common Sense Kids Action, Electronic Frontier Foundation, and the American Civil Liberties Union among others, writes that it opposes the most recent version of this bill (though the subject of their letter reflects an “oppose unless amended” position) because “AB 846 would excessively allow businesses to force consumers to pay for their CCPA rights.” Specifically, they write:
The “loyalty club” exception contains virtually no limitations on when a business may charge a higher price or provide a lower quality because consumers exercise their privacy rights. Most importantly, this bill would allow a company to discriminate against a consumer, by charging a higher price, if the consumer opted-out of the sale of their personal information to another business.
The “reasonably related in value” exception is a continuation of a similar existing CCPA exception, which we hope will be removed by AB 1760. But AB 846 would make this exception worse, by eliminating the existing bar on pay-for-privacy rules that are “unjust, unreasonable, coercive, or usurious.”
The “reasonably related functionality” exception would seem to authorize sharing of personal information throughout the adtech ecology, on the supposed grounds that behavior-based advertising is functionally related to collection and use of consumer’s personal information. We oppose such dissemination of personal information.
As further argued by the coalition, there are different types of rewards programs:
- Repeat patronage loyalty clubs where the “loyalty clubs pay customers for their repeat patronage. They say to customers: ‘Every Nth purchase with us will be free.’ These can include punch cards at a coffee shop, and frequent flier accounts with airlines. These clubs generally do not involve the collection, use, or sale of personal information. So the CCPA does not affect them.
- Internal-use loyalty clubs are those clubs that “pay customers for their personal information, but keep that information inside the business. These internal-use clubs say to customers: ‘If you join our loyalty program, we will give you a discount, we will track your shopping with us, and we will use your behavior with us to send you targeted ads – but, we will not give data about your shopping with us to anyone else.’ While privacy advocates have concerns about such pay-for-privacy programs, these concerns are partly mitigated by the non-dissemination of the personal information. The CCPA does not apply to such internal-use loyalty clubs, because the CCPA generally does not limit a business’ collection and use of consumer personal information.
- External-transfer loyalty clubs are those clubs that “pay customers for their personal information, and disseminate that information outside the business. These external-transfer clubs say to customers: ‘If you join our loyalty program, we will give you a discount, we will track your shopping with us, we will use your behavior with us to send you targeted ads – and, we will transfer data about your shopping to other businesses.’ The CCPA applies to such clubs. A business cannot sell a consumer’s personal information if the consumer opts-out from such sale. If the consumer does opt-out, then the business can charge a higher price, but only up to the lost value of the consumer’s data.
- Related legislation: AB 25 (Chau) seeks to clarify the CCPA’s definition of consumer and how businesses may comply with a consumer’s request for specific pieces of information in a privacy protective manner under the CCPA. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 288 (Cunningham) seeks to establish laws governing “social media privacy” separate and apart from the CCPA’s existing requirements for such companies that meet the “business” definition thresholds identified in the CCPA. Specifically, the bill would require a social networking service, as defined, to provide users that close their accounts the option to have the user’s “personally identifiable information” permanently removed from the company’s database and records and to prohibit the service from selling that information to, or exchanging that information with, a third party in the future, subject to specified exceptions. The bill would require a social networking service to honor such a request within a commercially reasonable time. The bill would authorize consumers to bring private right of action for a violation of these provisions, as specified. This bill has been referred to this Committee.
AB 523 (Irwin) seeks to address the sale of geolocation information by certain businesses, separate and apart from the CCPA’s existing requirements and restrictions governing companies that meet the “business” definition thresholds identified in the CCPA and seek to sell their consumers’ PI (which the CCPA defines to include geolocation information). This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee.
AB 873 (Irwin) seeks to narrow the CCPA’s definitions of “PI” and “deidentified” and to revise the CCPA’s existing provision that prohibits the act from being construed to require a business to reidentify or otherwise link information that is not maintained in a manner that would be considered PI. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 874 (Irwin) seeks to broaden the definition of “publicly available” for purposes of the PI definition, which excludes “publicly available” information. The bill would also correct a drafting error in the definition of “PI” to clarify that PI does not include deidentified or aggregate consumer information. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 981 (Daly) would add numerous privacy protections to the Insurance Information and Privacy Protection Act (IIPPA), to reflect the CCPA. The bill would exempt entities subject to the IIPPA, as specified, from the CCPA, with the exception of the CCPA’s data breach section. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1035 (Mayes) seeks to require, under the Data Breach Notification Law, a person or business, as defined, that owns or licenses computerized data that includes PI to disclose any breach of the security of the system within 72 hours following discovery or notification of the breach, subject to the legitimate needs of law enforcement, as provided. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1138 (Gallagher) seeks to prohibit a person or business that conducts business in California, and that operates a social media website or application, from allowing a person under 16 years of age to create an account with the website or application unless the website or application obtains the consent of the person’s parent or guardian before creating the account. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1146 (Berman) seeks to expand the CCPA exemptions to expressly exclude from the CCPA vehicle information shared between a new motor vehicle dealer and the vehicle’s manufacturer, if the information is shared pursuant to, or in anticipation of, a vehicle repair relating to warranty work or a recall, as specified. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1355 (Chau) seeks to address a drafting error in the definition of PI to clarify that it does not include deidentified or aggregate consumer information. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1395 (Cunningham) seeks to prohibit a smart speaker device, as defined, or a specified manufacturer of that device, from saving or storing recordings of verbal commands or requests given to the device, or verbal conversations heard by the device, regardless of whether the device was triggered using a key term or phrase. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1416 (Cooley) seeks to expand the CCPA exemptions to specify that the act does not restrict a business’s ability comply with any rules or regulations. The bill would also expand the CCPA existing exemptions, which already include that the act does not restrict a business’s ability to exercise or defend legal claims, to instead specify that the act does not restrict a business’s ability to collect, use, retain, sell, authenticate, or disclose PI: (1) in order to exercise, defend, or protect against legal claims; (2) in order to protect against or prevent fraud or unauthorized transactions; (3) in order to protect against or prevent security incidents or other malicious, deceptive, or illegal activity; (4) in order to investigate, report, or prosecute those responsible for protecting against fraud, unauthorized transactions, and preventing security incidents or other specified activities; or, (5) for the purpose of assisting another person or government agency to conduct the aforementioned activities. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1564 (Berman) would revise a requirement in the CCPA for businesses to make available to consumers “two or more designated methods” for submitting requests for information to be disclosed pursuant to specified provisions of the CCPA, including, at a minimum, a toll free telephone number and, if the business maintains an internet website, a website address. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1760 (Wicks) would restate the CCPA rights using similar terminology, expand those existing CCPA rights to include new rights, and replace the “opt-out” rights of consumers 16 years and older with an “opt-in” right, among other things. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
- Prior legislation: AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) See Comment 3.
SB 1121 (Dodd, Ch. 735, Stats. 2018) See Comment 3. This bill ensured that a private right of action under the CCPA applies only to the CCPA’s data breach section on and not to any other section of the CCPA, as specified, corrected numerous drafting errors, made non-controversial clarifying amendments, and addressed several policy suggestions made by the AG in a preliminary clean-up bill to AB 375.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Association of National Advertisers
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
California Grocers Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Data Industry Association
Consumer Technology Association
CTIA-The Wireless Association
Insights Association
National Association of Theatre Owners of California/Nevada
National Federation of Independent Business – California
Netchoice
Ralphs Grocery Company
Telecommunications Industry Association
Wine Institute
Opposition
Access Humboldt (unless amended)
ACLU of California (unless amended)
Californians for Consumer Privacy
Center for Digital Democracy (unless amended)
Common Sense Kids Action (unless amended)
Consumer Federation of America (unless amended)
Consumer Reports
Digital Privacy Alliance (unless amended)
Electronic Frontier Foundation (unless amended)
Media Alliance (unless amended)
Oakland Privacy (unless amended)
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):