AB 995: Hazardous waste.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-04
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 29, 2020 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 14, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 28. Noes 9.). |
| Aug 30, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Aug 29, 2020 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on EQ. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(b). (Ayes 3. Noes 0.) Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Aug 27, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(b). |
| Aug 26, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (August 20). |
| Aug 17, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 11, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 0.) (August 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on EQ. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| May 30, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| Apr 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | AB 995 GARCIA, C. Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB995 Cristina Garcia et a By Leyva | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 17, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2019 | AB 995 Ting Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 995
Author:(Cristina Garcia, et al.)
As Enrolled Ver:September 4, 2020
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (Cal/EPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). Raises and recasts existing fees within the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) to fill a projected deficit of approximately eighteen million dollars.
Major Provisions:
1) Creates the Board within Cal/EPA to oversee and provide transparency to DTSC and would consist of five members, all of whom shall represent the general public interest.
2) Re-establishes the Fee Task Force (originally established pursuant to SB 1222 (Calderon), Chapter 638, Statutes of 1995), to be convened by the Secretary of Cal/EPA, to review the existing charges supporting the HWCA and the Toxics Substances Control Account (TSCA). Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 2022 as part of the Governor's proposed budget.
3) Repeals outdated statute regarding a statewide hazardous waste management plan (Plan, enacted in the 1980's) and update the statutory requirements for the state to develop a Plan to include an identification of areas of the state that are disproportionately impacted by hazardous waste treatment and disposal activities. Requires the Plan to contain a description of steps to reduce the generation of hazardous wastes. Requires this Plan to involve a public process with meetings throughout the state and require the Plan to be completed by January 1, 2024 and updated every three years thereafter.
4) Requires that the owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility submit to DTSC a written cost estimate associated with necessary corrective actions after DTSC has identified a release of hazardous waste; applying this same process for responsible parties for cleanup sites.
5) Eliminates the Manifest Fee, Disposal Fee, and Environmental Protection Agency Identification Fee and revises, recasts, and raises the Facility Fee and Generation and Handling Fee to raise approximately $20 million annually for regulated activities under the HWCA. Eliminates current exemptions to the Facility Fee and Generation and Handling Fee to be compliant with the Supermajority Vote to Pass New Taxes and Fees Act, enacted by voters in 2010, known as Proposition 26.
6) Phases in a requirement that all permit renewal applications must be submitted at least two years before expiration. Deems the permit extended until DTSC takes final action on the application, if the renewal application is submitted in time. Establishes a process by which the Board may review any final permit decision that DTSC has not made by these deadlines.
7) Authorizes a one-time surcharge to the Generation and Handling Fee and Facility Fee only for calendar year 2021 to cover the costs associated with the development of the Plan.
Governor's Veto Message:
This bill would create the Board of Environmental Safety within CalEPA to provide policy direction to and oversight of DTSC.
I applaud the author's diligence in seeking to increase transparency and accountability in DTSC. However, the bill as written falls short of the goals we have previously set for needed changes to better protect public health and safety. Without necessary funding, DTSC will be unable to deliver on the promise of this legislation - cleaning up too many abandoned sites adversely impacting the health of low-income communities across our state and better protecting Californians from dangerous chemicals going forward.
Understanding that governance and fiscal changes are both necessary and inextricably tied to achieving the mandates DTSC is currently responsible for, my 2020 Budget proposed a comprehensive approach to achieve a more transparent decision-making process through the creation of a board and restructured fees to adequately fund this Department.
AB 995 seeks to impose changes to governance but lacks necessary fiscal reform.
To accomplish comprehensive change and make progress on the more than 150,000 brownfield sites where no responsible party exists, we will need comprehensive fiscal reform to support adequate revenues. Over the last year, we were able to reach agreement with the Legislature on many of the key elements of DTSC reform. I am confident that in the upcoming legislative session we will achieve the much needed fiscal and governance reforms to better protect communities across our state.
COMMENTS:
California Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL): The HWCL is the state's program that implements and enforces federal hazardous waste law in California and directs DTSC to oversee and implement the state's HWCL. Any person who stores, treats, or disposes of hazardous waste must obtain a permit from DTSC. The HWCL covers the entire management of hazardous waste, from the point the hazardous waste is generated, to management, transportation, and ultimately disposal into a state or federal authorized facility.
Recent criticism of DTSC: Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
Legislative Oversight: Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: 1) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; 2) auditing cost recovery at the department; 3) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, 4) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain, in addition a fiscal deficit persists.
DTSC Independent Review Panel (IRP): In 2015, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed SB 83 (Budget Committee), Chapter 24, Statutes of 2015, which established within DTSC a three-member IRP to review and make recommendations regarding improvements to DTSC's permitting, enforcement, public outreach, and fiscal management. Pursuant to SB 83, the IRP was authorized until January 1, 2018. Over the course of its term, the IRP conducted 24 public meetings and released 11 progress and annual reports. On January 8, 2018 the IRP released its final report and recommendations concluding: "The Department has implemented, or is working on, most of the IRP's recommendations and has achieved, or partially achieved, many of the IRP's suggested performance metrics. However, there is more work to be done. In the absence of the IRP, the Governor and the Legislature should consider a DTSC governing board or other structural change to enhance transparency and accountability and regularly monitor the status of the IRP-suggested recommendations and performance metrics, as well as DTSC's ongoing initiatives and decision-making."
DTSC's fiscal situation: DTSC's funding comes primarily from the HWCA and TSCA. The HWCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery activities and fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. The HWCA funds DTSC's regulatory work overseeing hazardous waste management activities in the state. The TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee (which was established as a 2/3 vote tax). TSCA funds DTSC's work dealing with cleaning up contaminated properties, including federal Superfund sites and state orphan sites, as well as funding the Safer Consumer Products Program (also known as the Green Chemistry Program).
Both HWCA and TSCA have been operating with a structural deficit. Expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. The Budget Act of 2019-2020 provided the HWCA with $27.5 million from the General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. The Governor's proposed budget for 2020-2021 provides a $12 million backfill from special funds for the TSCA and a backfill of approximately $19 million for the HWCA (also from special funds) as those accounts were projected to be insolvent in the budget year.
Governor Newsom's response to DTSC's fiscal situation: As part of the 2020-2021 budget the Newsom Administration proposed a reform package intended to resolve DTSC's governance and fiscal problems. The Administration proposed to remedy DTSC's fiscal instability by providing DTSC the ongoing authority to set and revise fees. The Administration included trailer bill language with its proposal to raise fees in the HWCA and TSCA; this language was proposed as a 2/3 vote measure. To address transparency and governance issues, the Administration proposed, also with trailer bill language, to create the Board of Environmental Safety. This bill similarly enacts the Board as well as raises the HWCA fees, nearly identical to the Administration HWCA proposal, except it leaves out the 2/3 vote increase for TSCA.
Over the past few years many legislative efforts to improve DTSC's function were vetoed by the Brown Administration, citing fiscal issues with DTSC. While Governor Brown recognized the need for improved programmatic performance by DTSC, he vetoed multiple efforts citing that none of those statutory changes should be done without also addressing the budget issues with DTSC. Therefore, DTSC's fiscal issues and structural issues are linked.
This bill builds upon the oversight work done by the Legislature by bringing some transparency to DTSC's decision-making process. Holding public meetings to discuss regulatory work, the status of cleanup sites, or why a permit decision has been delayed for a decade or longer will at least provide stakeholders with access to information they otherwise would not have.
Managing hazardous waste is a complex and potentially dangerous task; incorrect handling of certain hazardous wastes could pose significant threats to human health and safety and the environment. Ensuring compliance with state and federal hazardous waste laws is one DTSC's core regulatory functions. The Legislature has seen many bills over the last several years that deal with changes or reforms to DTSC; while the Governor and the Director of DTSC change, the problems seem to continue. While there has been some progress by DTSC in some areas, is it time for a bigger change? This bill seeks to answer this question by adding a policy setting and oversight Board over DTSC. The Board envisioned within AB 995 would provide the public with transparency to DTSC's major permitting and cleanup decisions to address the perceived lack of transparency, which is a major concern cited by virtually all stakeholders of DTSC. Additionally, this bill gives the Board some early direction to help focus DTSC's efforts on improving its permitting of hazardous waste facilities as well as improving its ability to safely and efficiently oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites. AB 995 also stabilizes the funding for DTSC's hazardous waste regulatory work while setting up a stakeholder process to address DTSC's long-term fiscal situation.
According to the Author:
"For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.
We strongly share the Administration's belief that programmatic improvements to DTSC will not be achieved unless and until DTSC has sufficient fiscal resources to achieve its statutory mandates. But at the same time the legislature must be able to anticipate improved performance by the department with sufficient funding.
The current poor condition of DTSC will continue to put disadvantaged communities in danger. Many of these communities are similar to those that lack safe and affordable drinking water, which is why we believe we share a common goal of protecting these communities for this generation and the next. DTSC must be reformed if we want to properly care for our most vulnerable populations that have been exposed to toxics from decades. If we are going to truly start to address the systemic racism in our systems, we need to take action now to fix a department that's in charge of protecting the public's health, especially those in low income communities of color where we are most likely to be over burdened with these toxics. DTSC's inefficiencies and the inability to address this is cutting black and brown and poor people's life's short in addition to making us live with chronic diseases. We optimistically hope that the Administration will look to AB 995 as we continue to negotiate and will work together along with stakeholders to fully reshape this entity into one that can oversee the management of hazardous waste in the state in a transparent manner that is fully protective of communities and public health."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance (CCEEB), "Based on the latest amendments, CCEEB is supportive of AB 995 as the first step to meaningfully address issues raised by CCEEB and other stakeholders. While CCEEB supports AB 995 as amended, we would note that additional work remains ahead of us to ensure the provisions of AB 995, and more, address the fundamental operational, regulatory and fiscal concerns with the Department."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown. Recent amendments to this bill have not be heard before a fiscal committee as of the writing of this analysis.
VOTES:
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 8-0-0
YES: Reyes, Mathis, Berman, Choi, Friedman, Gipson, Maienschein, Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0-3
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia
SENATE FLOOR: 28-9-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Melendez, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dahle, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-9-9
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Obernolte, Patterson, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Choi, Megan Dahle, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Gallagher, Mayes, Voepel
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 4, 2020
CONSULTANT: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003723
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 995 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 995
Author: Cristina Garcia (D), Bloom (D), Carrillo (D), Kalra (D), Reyes (D) and Santiago (D), et al.
Amended: 8/25/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 8/11/20
AYES: Allen, Hill, Stern, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dahle, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SUBJECT: Hazardous waste
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST: This bill creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), restructures the Hazardous Waste Management Account (HWCA), and makes various other changes to the hazardous waste control laws.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/25/20 make various changes to the bill, most notably they incorporate portions of the Governor’s budget trailer legislation that make changes to the fees that generate revenue for the HWCA.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires DTSC to enforce the standards within the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL) and the regulations adopted by DTSC pursuant to the HWCL. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) § 25180)
- Authorizes DTSC to deny, suspend, or revoke any permit, registration, or certificate applied for, or issued pursuant to the HWCL. (HSC § 25186)
- Imposes various fees, including a disposal fee, generator fee, and facility fee, that are deposited in the HWCA and that, upon appropriation by the Legislature to DTSC, are authorized to be expended for, among other things, the administration and implementation of the HWCLs. (HSC § 25174)
This bill:
- Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within CalEPA consisting of five members with three members appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the Senate, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Requires the Board, using a public process, to do all of the following: review the Department’s duties and responsibilities in law, the current status of hazardous waste facility permits, the site mitigation program and remediation activities, and enforcement decisions for hazardous waste facilities and propose statutory, regulatory, and policy changes; hear and decide appeals of hazardous waste facility permit decisions and certain financial assurances decisions; provide opportunities for public hearings on individual permitted or remediation sites; and set priorities for each program at a public hearing, which the director shall carry out; and
- Authorizes the Board to meet in Executive Session for any purpose authorized pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and requires the Board to adopt rules for conduct of its affairs in conformity with existing law.
- Requires the Board to conduct at least six public hearings per year, with three of those hearings being held in locations outside the County of Sacramento.
- Establishes an office of ombudsperson in the Board to receive complaints and suggestions from the public, to evaluate complaints received, to report findings and make recommendations to DTSC and the Board, and to render assistance to the public.
- Requires the Secretary of CalEPA (Secretary) to convene a Fee Task Force by March 2, 2021 to review the existing fee structure supporting the HWCA and the funding structure supporting the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 10, 2022, as part of the Governor’s Budget, on a fee system for the HWCA and a funding structure for the TSCA, as specified.
- Requires the Board to annually submit to the Secretary and the Legislature a review of the Department’s performance measured against the Board’s objectives.
- Updates the statutory requirements for the state to develop a Hazardous Waste Management Plan to include an identification of areas of the state that are disproportionately impacted by hazardous waste treatment and disposal activities.
- Adds a one-time funding increase, for the 2021 reporting period only, (an additional $1,500 to the Facility Fee base rate and $0.75 to the Generation and Handling Fee for wastes generated in 2021) for DTSC to complete the work necessary to develop the Hazardous Waste Management Plan.
- Requires that the owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility submit to DTSC a written cost estimate associated with necessary corrective actions after DTSC has identified a release of hazardous waste. Requires the Board to review all financial assurances at least every five years.
- Phases in a requirement that all permit renewal applications must be submitted at least two years before expiration. If the renewal application is submitted in time, the permit is deemed extended until the Board takes final action on the application.
- Modifies the HWCA by: removing references to the fees that are being repealed (Disposal Fee, Manifest Fee and EPA ID Verification Fee) from the list of fees and revenues deposited into HWCA and adding a new Generation and Handling Fee, which would be based on a price-per-ton model and effective in January 1, 2021; adding Board activities to the list of activities to be funded by HWCA; eliminating numerous fee exemptions, including the used oil exemption, to ensure Proposition 26 compliance; and eliminating tiers and establishing a new per ton of hazardous waste generated rate ($35.50), which represents an increase of approximately 40 percent over the current effective base rate.
- Establishes the Hazardous Waste Facilities Account (HWFA) on January 1, 2021, to be administered by the Director of DTSC. Includes Board activities as activities to be funded by HWFA. Authorizes expenditures from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature and resets the base facility fee to $71,250, which is approximately double the current Facility Fee rate.
- Makes findings that it is the intent of the Legislature that the fee structure and amounts in this bill will be amended in the future based on the Secretary’s recommendations based on the work of the Fee Task Force.
Background
- Recent criticism of DTSC. Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
- Legislative Oversight. Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: (a) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; (b) auditing cost recovery at the department; (c) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, (d) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain.
- Funding sources for DTSC. DTSC's funding comes primarily from the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee. HWCA revenues are derived from fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. They were last amended in statute in 1998 or earlier.
Both HWCA and TSCA have been operating with a structural deficit five out of the last six years. The Budget Act of 2020 included $28.2 million in loans to cover the shortfall in both HWCA and TSCA. A number of factors contribute to the operating structural deficit in both accounts. They include increasing legislative mandates, an outdated fee structure that no longer corresponds to the proportion of waste generated or disposed, increasing costs relating to the state obligated cost share for National Priority List sites, and a backlog of unresolved response costs worth approximately $194 million at over 1,600 cleanup sites over a 25-year period.
- Existing vs Revised Fees. The current tiered-rate Generator Fee exempts generators of less than five tons of hazardous waste. For those hazardous waste generators that pay the fee, the amount of the fee can be anywhere from $10 per ton all the way up to $100 per ton, depending on the number of tons they generate and where in the current fee tier their amount of waste falls. The new Generator and Handling Fee proposed in AB 995 eliminates the exemptions, so all generators of any amount of hazardous waste will pay the same amount per ton ($35.50). This is more than what those exempted generators currently pay, and is nearly four times the amount those paying the lowest amount currently pay, but only 1/3 what those paying the highest amount currently pay.
AB 995 also proposes a new base rate for the Facility Fee for fully permitted facilities, which is approximately double the current base rate. The amount paid by individual facilities is a function of the base rate (from ¼ the base rate for mini storage facilities, up to 10 times the base rate for disposal facilities).
- Governor proposal. In January, the Governor proposed, as part of his 2020-21 Budget, trailer bill language that would create a Board of Environmental Safety, generally similar to AB 995, increase fees to support current hazardous waste and cleanup activities, and provide authority to the Board to raise these fees. While Budget actions were taken in June to provide bridge funding to the Department for a year, efforts to move structural and fiscal reform through the Budget this year have ended.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
“AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.”
- Governance and Policy Reform at DTSC. Effective regulation of hazardous waste is essential for the protection of public health and the environment. Over the last several years, there has been a number of internal and external efforts to improve DTSC’s ability to adequately meet its core mission and statutory mandates. Despite these efforts, the Department continues not to meet public expectations, especially in regards to clean-up and permitting activities.
The establishment of a Board could provide strategic guidance and bring some transparency to DTSC's decision-making process. Holding public meetings to discuss regulatory work, the status of cleanup sites, or why a permit decision has been delayed for a decade or longer will at least provide stakeholders with access to information they otherwise would not have.
AB 995 proposes several additional worthy elements: it creates a fee taskforce in order to evaluate the appropriate fee structure at DTSC; funds the development of a statewide hazardous waste management plan, proposes statutory changes to improve and speed up the permitting process; and ensures the proper financial assurances are in place.
- Fiscal Reform of HWCA. DTSC’s difficulties are a result of multiple factors, though undoubtedly a major factor is the shortage of funding in both HWCA and TSCA. The fees that feed into these funds have not been adjusted for over 20 years and do not reflect significant program expansions and new mandates. Both HWCA and TSCA are in need of funding from the General Fund in order to backfill the deficit. Absent any changes, both accounts will continue to need funding from the General Fund to stay balanced. However, by doing so, the state would continue to subsidize fee payers with taxpayer dollars.
As mentioned previously, efforts to move structural and fiscal reform through the Budget this year were unsuccessful. However, recent amendments to AB 995 incorporate portions of the Governor’s budget trailer legislation that make changes to the fees that generate revenue for HWCA. The amendments reset the base Facility Fee and replace the existing Generator, EPA Identification Verification, Manifest, and Disposal Fees with a new Generation and Handling Fee, which would be based on a price-per-ton model. These changes, in combination with the proposed elimination of some fee exemptions, are projected to increase revenues into HWCA at a level that will close the structural imbalance in the HWCA, cover the costs imposed by this bill for the new Board, the development of the Hazardous Waste Management Plan, and provide additional revenues to build a prudent reserve.
It is important to note that the amendments do not address the current deficit within TSCA. Without addressing the shortfalls in both HWCA and TSCA, DTSC will continue to lack the resources it needs to carry out its mission and will continue to need funding from the General Fund to stay balanced. The Administration has maintained that any governance reform of DTSC must go hand-in-hand with fiscal reform of both HWCA and TSCA, arguing that only such a comprehensive reform will position the department for success.
While the establishment of the new Board and a number of the other policy changes proposed in AB 995 have considerable merit, a question remains as to whether or not it makes sense to establish governance and other reforms at the Department with only a partial fix to the Department’s funding shortfall.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, DTSC estimates ongoing costs of about $18 million annually (special fund) to implement this bill. The DOJ estimates ongoing cost pressure of $1.4 million annually (special fund) due to increased workload for its Environment Section and Natural Resources Law Section within DOJ’s Public Rights Division from representing the Board of Environmental Safety.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/28/20)
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California for A Healthy & Green Economy
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians Against Waste
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Clean Harbors Environmental Services, INC.
Clean Water Action
Environmental Working Group
Military Services in California
Natural Resources Defense Council
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Republic Services INC.
Safety-Kleen
Sierra Club California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/28/20)
Prepared by: Gabrielle Meindl / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/31/20 0:29:05
**** END ****
(Without Reference to File)
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 995
Author:(Cristina Garcia, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (Cal/EPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC). Raises and recasts existing fees within the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) to fill a projected deficit of approximately eighteen million dollars.
The Senate Amendments:
Delete the contents of the bill as it left the Assembly and replace with the following:
1) Create the Board within Cal/EPA to oversee and provide transparency to DTSC and would consist of five members, all of whom shall represent the general public interest.
2) Re-establish the Fee Task Force (originally established pursuant to SB 1222 (Calderon), Chapter 638, Statutes of 1995), to be convened by the Secretary of Cal/EPA, to review the existing charges supporting the HWCA and the Toxics Substances Control Account (TSCA). Require the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 2022 as part of the Governor's proposed budget.
3) Repeal outdated statute regarding a statewide hazardous waste management plan (Plan, enacted in the 1980's) and update the statutory requirements for the state to develop a Plan to include an identification of areas of the state that are disproportionately impacted by hazardous waste treatment and disposal activities. Require the Plan to contain a description of steps to reduce the generation of hazardous wastes. Require this Plan to involve a public process with meetings throughout the state and require the Plan to be completed by January 1, 2024 and updated every three years thereafter.
4) Require that the owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility submit to DTSC a written cost estimate associated with necessary corrective actions after DTSC has identified a release of hazardous waste; applying this same process for responsible parties for cleanup sites.
5) Eliminate the Manifest Fee, Disposal Fee, and Environmental Protection Agency Identification Fee and revises, recasts, and raises the Facility Fee and Generation and Handling Fee to raise approximately $20 million annually for regulated activities under the HWCA. Eliminates current exemptions to the Facility Fee and Generation and Handling Fee to be compliant with the Supermajority Vote to Pass New Taxes and Fees Act, enacted by voters in 2010, known as Proposition 26.
6) Phase in a requirement that all permit renewal applications must be submitted at least two years before expiration. Deem the permit extended until DTSC takes final action on the application, if the renewal application is submitted in time. Establish a process by which the Board may review any final permit decision that DTSC has not made by these deadlines.
7) Authorize a one-time surcharge to the Generation and Handling Fee and Facility Fee only for calendar year 2021 to cover the costs associated with the development of the Plan.
COMMENTS:
California Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL): The HWCL is the state's program that implements and enforces federal hazardous waste law in California and directs DTSC to oversee and implement the state's HWCL. Any person who stores, treats, or disposes of hazardous waste must obtain a permit from DTSC. The HWCL covers the entire management of hazardous waste, from the point the hazardous waste is generated, to management, transportation, and ultimately disposal into a state or federal authorized facility.
Recent criticism of DTSC: Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
Legislative Oversight: Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: 1) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; 2) auditing cost recovery at the department; 3) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, 4) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain, in addition a fiscal deficit persists.
DTSC Independent Review Panel (IRP): In 2015, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed SB 83 (Budget Committee), Chapter 24, Statutes of 2015, which established within DTSC a three-member IRP to review and make recommendations regarding improvements to DTSC's permitting, enforcement, public outreach, and fiscal management. Pursuant to SB 83, the IRP was authorized until January 1, 2018. Over the course of its term, the IRP conducted 24 public meetings and released 11 progress and annual reports. On January 8, 2018 the IRP released its final report and recommendations concluding: "The Department has implemented, or is working on, most of the IRP's recommendations and has achieved, or partially achieved, many of the IRP's suggested performance metrics. However, there is more work to be done. In the absence of the IRP, the Governor and the Legislature should consider a DTSC governing board or other structural change to enhance transparency and accountability and regularly monitor the status of the IRP-suggested recommendations and performance metrics, as well as DTSC's ongoing initiatives and decision-making."
DTSC's fiscal situation: DTSC's funding comes primarily from the HWCA and TSCA. The HWCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery activities and fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. The HWCA funds DTSC's regulatory work overseeing hazardous waste management activities in the state. The TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee (which was established as a 2/3 vote tax). TSCA funds DTSC's work dealing with cleaning up contaminated properties, including federal Superfund sites and state orphan sites, as well as funding the Safer Consumer Products Program (also known as the Green Chemistry Program).
Both HWCA and TSCA have been operating with a structural deficit. Expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. The Budget Act of 2019-2020 provided the HWCA with $27.5 million from the General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. The Governor's proposed budget for 2020-2021 provides a $12 million backfill from special funds for the TSCA and a backfill of approximately $19 million for the HWCA (also from special funds) as those accounts were projected to be insolvent in the budget year.
Governor Newsom's response to DTSC's fiscal situation: As part of the 2020-2021 budget the Newsom Administration proposed a reform package intended to resolve DTSC's governance and fiscal problems. The Administration proposed to remedy DTSC's fiscal instability by providing DTSC the ongoing authority to set and revise fees. The Administration included trailer bill language with its proposal to raise fees in the HWCA and TSCA; this language was proposed as a 2/3 vote measure. To address transparency and governance issues, the Administration proposed, also with trailer bill language, to create the Board of Environmental Safety. This bill similarly enacts the Board as well as raises the HWCA fees, nearly identical to the Administration HWCA proposal, except it leaves out the 2/3 vote increase for TSCA.
Over the past few years many legislative efforts to improve DTSC's function were vetoed by the Brown Administration, citing fiscal issues with DTSC. While Governor Brown recognized the need for improved programmatic performance by DTSC, he vetoed multiple efforts citing that none of those statutory changes should be done without also addressing the budget issues with DTSC. Therefore, DTSC's fiscal issues and structural issues are linked.
This bill builds upon the oversight work done by the Legislature by bringing some transparency to DTSC's decision-making process. Holding public meetings to discuss regulatory work, the status of cleanup sites, or why a permit decision has been delayed for a decade or longer will at least provide stakeholders with access to information they otherwise would not have.
Managing hazardous waste is a complex and potentially dangerous task; incorrect handling of certain hazardous wastes could pose significant threats to human health and safety and the environment. Ensuring compliance with state and federal hazardous waste laws is one DTSC's core regulatory functions. The Legislature has seen many bills over the last several years that deal with changes or reforms to DTSC; while the Governor and the Director of DTSC change, the problems seem to continue. While there has been some progress by DTSC in some areas, is it time for a bigger change? This bill seeks to answer this question by adding a policy setting and oversight Board over DTSC. The Board envisioned within AB 995 would provide the public with transparency to DTSC's major permitting and cleanup decisions to address the perceived lack of transparency, which is a major concern cited by virtually all stakeholders of DTSC. Additionally, this bill gives the Board some early direction to help focus DTSC's efforts on improving its permitting of hazardous waste facilities as well as improving its ability to safely and efficiently oversee the cleanup of contaminated sites. AB 995 also stabilizes the funding for DTSC's hazardous waste regulatory work while setting up a stakeholder process to address DTSC's long-term fiscal situation.
According to the Author:
"For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.
We strongly share the Administration's belief that programmatic improvements to DTSC will not be achieved unless and until DTSC has sufficient fiscal resources to achieve its statutory mandates. But at the same time the legislature must be able to anticipate improved performance by the department with sufficient funding.
The current poor condition of DTSC will continue to put disadvantaged communities in danger. Many of these communities are similar to those that lack safe and affordable drinking water, which is why we believe we share a common goal of protecting these communities for this generation and the next. DTSC must be reformed if we want to properly care for our most vulnerable populations that have been exposed to toxics from decades. If we are going to truly start to address the systemic racism in our systems, we need to take action now to fix a department that's in charge of protecting the public's health, especially those in low income communities of color where we are most likely to be over burdened with these toxics. DTSC's inefficiencies and the inability to address this is cutting black and brown and poor people's life's short in addition to making us live with chronic diseases. We optimistically hope that the Administration will look to AB 995 as we continue to negotiate and will work together along with stakeholders to fully reshape this entity into one that can oversee the management of hazardous waste in the state in a transparent manner that is fully protective of communities and public health."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance (CCEEB), "Based on the latest amendments, CCEEB is supportive of AB 995 as the first step to meaningfully address issues raised by CCEEB and other stakeholders. While CCEEB supports AB 995 as amended, we would note that additional work remains ahead of us to ensure the provisions of AB 995, and more, address the fundamental operational, regulatory and fiscal concerns with the Department."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Not applicable; recent amendments to the bill have not be heard before a fiscal committee as of the writing of this analysis.
VOTES:
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 8-0-0
YES: Reyes, Mathis, Berman, Choi, Friedman, Gipson, Maienschein, Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0-3
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003677
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 995
Author: | Cristina Garcia, et al. | ||
Version: | 8/25/2020 | Hearing Date: | 8/30/2020 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Hazardous waste
DIGEST: Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), restructures the Hazardous Waste Management Account (HWCA), and makes various other changes to the hazardous waste control laws.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires DTSC to enforce the standards within the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL) and the regulations adopted by DTSC pursuant to the HWCL. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) § 25180)
2) Authorizes DTSC to deny, suspend, or revoke any permit, registration, or certificate applied for, or issued pursuant to the HWCL. (HSC § 25186)
3) Authorizes DTSC to issue permits for the use and operation of one or more hazardous waste management units at a facility that meets the standards adopted pursuant to the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL). (HSC § 25200 (a))
4) Requires DTSC to impose conditions on each permit specifying the types of hazardous wastes that may be accepted for transfer, storage, treatment, or disposal. (HSC § 25200 (a))
5) Imposes various fees, including a disposal fee, generator fee, and facility fee, that are deposited in the HWCA and that, upon appropriation by the Legislature to DTSC, are authorized to be expended for, among other things, the administration and implementation of the HWCLs. (HSC § 25174)
This bill:
- Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within CalEPA consisting of five members with three members appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the Senate, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Requires the Board, using a public process, to do all of the following:
- Review the Department’s duties and responsibilities in law, the current status of hazardous waste facility permits, the site mitigation program and remediation activities, and enforcement decisions for hazardous waste facilities and propose statutory, regulatory, and policy changes;
- Hear and decide appeals of hazardous waste facility permit decisions and certain financial assurances decisions;
- Provide opportunities for public hearings on individual permitted or remediation sites, and, if necessary, direct the department to respond to or address public concerns and questions;
- Set priorities for each program for each year at a public hearing, which the director shall carry out; and
- Review how the Department is coordinating with other regulatory agencies, including the State Water Board and CalRecycle.
- Requires the Board, by January 1, 2022 to establish guidelines for site prioritization under the site mitigation program, including orphan sites.
- Authorizes the Board to meet in Executive Session for any purpose authorized pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and requires the Board to adopt rules for conduct of its affairs in conformity with existing law.
- Provides that the Chairperson of the Board is appointed by the Governor and shall be full-time and the remaining members of the Board shall be half-time.
- Requires the Board to conduct at least six public hearings per year, with three of those hearings being held in locations outside the county of Sacramento.
- States Legislative intent that the Board improve the function, accountability, transparency, and responsiveness of DTSC and that the Board’s role and responsibilities may evolve over time.
- Establishes an office of ombudsperson in the Board to receive complaints and suggestions from the public, to evaluate complaints received, to report findings and make recommendations to DTSC and the Board, and to render assistance to the public.
- Requires the Secretary of CalEPA (Secretary) to convene a Fee Task Force by March 2, 2021 to review the existing fee structure supporting the HWCA and the funding structure supporting the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 10, 2022, as part of the Governor’s Budget, on a fee system for the HWCA and a funding structure for the TSCA, as specified.
- Requires DTSC to submit a workload analysis to the Secretary prior to the formation of the Fee Task Force. Authorizes the Secretary to enter into an agreement with an outside entity to conduct the Fee Task Force. Directs the Fee Task Force to consider the funding needs to bring back the Pollution Prevention Program either in its entirety or in part.
- Requires the Board to annually submit to the Secretary and the Legislature a review of the Department’s performance measured against the Board’s objectives.
- Repeals outdated statute regarding a statewide hazardous waste management plan (enacted in the 1980's) and updates the statutory requirements for the state to develop a Hazardous Waste Management Plan to include an identification of areas of the state that are disproportionately impacted by hazardous waste treatment and disposal activities. Requires the plan to contain a description of steps to reduce the generation of hazardous wastes.
- Requires this statewide hazardous waste management plan to involve a public process and with meetings throughout the state and be completed by January 1, 2024 and updated every three years thereafter.
- Adds a one-time funding increase, for the 2021 reporting period only, (an additional $1,500 to the Facility Fee base rate and $0.75 to the Generation and Handling Fee for wastes generated in 2021) for DTSC to complete the work necessary to develop the Hazardous Waste Management Plan.
- Requires that the owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility submit to DTSC a written cost estimate associated with necessary corrective actions after DTSC has identified a release of hazardous waste. Establishes a process by which DTSC can seek changes to the estimate and requires the owner or operator to fund the estimate, via a financial assurance mechanism, within 90 days. Applies this same process for responsible parties for cleanup sites. Requires the Board to review all financial assurances at least every five years.
- Phases in a requirement that all permit renewal applications must be submitted at least two years before expiration. If the renewal application is submitted in time, the permit is deemed extended until the Board takes final action on the application. Also phases in a requirement that the Board issue a final permit decision within one year of the expiration of the permit. Applies these requirements to standardized permits also. Requires the Board to post on its internet website a timeline of the estimate dates of milestones in the application review process within 90 days of receiving a completed application. Establishes a process by which the Board may review any final permit decision that has not been made by the deadlines, requiring the department to issue a public report that includes the reasons why the final permit decision has been delayed along with a proposed schedule for issuing the final permit decision.
- Modifies the HWCA by:
- Removing references to the fees that are being repealed (Disposal Fee, Manifest Fee and EPA ID Verification Fee) from the list of fees and revenues deposited into HWCA and adding a new Generation and Handling Fee, which would be based on a price-per-ton model and effective in January 1, 2021.
- Limiting the fee revenues to be deposited into HWCA to only the Generation and Handling Fee.
- Limiting activities to be funded by HWCA to only those hazardous waste regulatory activities that are not associated with authorized facilities.
- Adds Board activities to the list of activities to be funded by HWCA.
- Eliminating numerous fee exemptions, including the used oil exemption, to ensure Proposition 26 compliance.
- Eliminating tiers and establishing a new per ton of hazardous waste generated rate ($35.50), which represents an increase of approximately 40 percent over the current effective base rate.
- Exempting hazardous wastes that are transferred only (manifested to a permitted facility, unloaded, then reloaded and re-manifested) to avoid double counting same waste.
- Eliminating generator refund provisions.
- Making numerous conforming changes to Revenue and Taxation Code.
- Establishes the Hazardous Waste Facilities Account (HWFA) on January 1, 2021 to be administered by the Director of DTSC. Fee revenues to be deposited into HWFA include Facility Fee and Permitting Fee for Service. Limits activities to be funded by HWFA to only those hazardous waste regulatory activities that are associated with authorized facilities. Includes Board activities as activities to be funded by HWFA. Authorizes expenditures from the fund, upon appropriation by the Legislature and resets the base facility fee to $71,250, which is approximately double the current Facility Fee rate.
- Makes findings that it is the intent of the Legislature that the fee structure and amounts in this bill will be amended in the future based on the Secretary’s recommendations based on the work of the Fee Task Force.
Background
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management permitting program. DTSC is responsible for administering the hazardous waste facility permitting program established under the HWCL and the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The core activities of the permitting program include: review of RCRA and non-RCRA hazardous waste permit applications to ensure safe design and operation; issuance and denial of operating permits; issuance of post-closure permits; approval and denial of permit modifications; issuance and denial of emergency permits; review and approval of closure plans; oversight of approved closure plans; and, providing public involvement on issues related to permitted facilities.
- Recent criticism of DTSC. Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
- Legislative Oversight. Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: (1) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; (2) auditing cost recovery at the department; (3) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, (4) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain.
- Funding sources for DTSC. DTSC's funding comes primarily from the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). The most recent Governor’s Budget shows a budget of over $350 million in the current year, with the largest expenditures from the TSCA ($124.6 million, which includes $68.3 million for the Exide Project), General Fund ($85 million), HWCA ($49.7 million), and federal funds ($35 million).
TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee. HWCA revenues are derived from fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. They were last amended in statute in 1998 or earlier. The fees include:- Generator (45 percent of total), Disposal (10 percent), and Facility fees (9 percent). The Generator, Disposal, and some Facility Fees are subject to an annual CPI and are collected by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
- EPA ID Verification (9 percent) and Manifest fees (4 percent): these fees are the same rate as when they were established, are not adjusted for inflation and are collected by DTSC.
HWCA also receives a small Transportable Treatment Unit fee (CPI adjusted) and the Permitting Fee-for-Service. HWCA receives revenue from cost recovery activities.
Both HWCA and TSCA have been operating with a structural deficit five out of the last six years. Expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. HWCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2018-19 with a $4.8 million shortfall and a projected -$24.8 million in 2019-20 absent remedial action. The Budget Act of 2019 provided HWCA with $27.5 million in General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. The Budget Act of 2020 included $28.2 million in loans to cover the shortfall in both HWCA and TSCA.
A number of factors contribute to the operating structural deficit in both accounts. They include increasing legislative mandates, an outdated fee structure that no longer corresponds to the proportion of waste generated or disposed, increasing costs relating to the state obligated cost share for National Priority List sites, and a backlog of unresolved response costs worth approximately $194 million at over 1,600 cleanup sites over a 25-year period.
- Existing vs Revised Fees. The current tiered-rate Generator Fee exempts generators of less than 5 tons of hazardous waste. For those hazardous waste generators that pay the fee, the amount of the fee can be anywhere from $10 per ton all the way up to $100 per ton, depending on the number of tons they generate and where in the current fee tier their amount of waste falls. The new Generator and Handling Fee proposed in AB 995 eliminates the exemptions, so all generators of any amount of hazardous waste will pay the same amount per ton ($35.50). This is more than what those exempted generators currently pay, and is nearly four times the amount those paying the lowest amount currently pay, but only 1/3 what those paying the highest amount currently pay.
AB 995 also proposes a new base rate for the Facility Fee for fully permitted facilities, which is approximately double the current base rate. The amount paid by individual facilities is a function of the base rate (from ¼ the base rate for mini storage facilities, up to 10 times the base rate for disposal facilities).
For post-closure and standardized permits, the bill changes the rates, which have not been adjusted for CPI since their establishment in 1998, to reflect the inflationary increases from that time forward, and then doubles the rate in the same way as the other facility rates. The result is rates effectively four times the rates currently paid by these facilities.
- Governor proposal. In January, the Governor proposed, as part of his 2020-21 Budget, trailer bill language that would create a Board of Environmental Safety, generally similar to AB 995, increase fees to support current hazardous waste and cleanup activities, and provide authority to the Board to raise these fees. While Budget actions were taken in June to provide bridge funding to the Department for a year, efforts to move structural and fiscal reform through the Budget this year have ended.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
“AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.”
- Fiscal Reform of HWCA. As mentioned above, efforts to move structural and fiscal reform through the Budget this year were unsuccessful. Recent amendments to AB 995 incorporate portions of the Governor’s budget trailer legislation that make changes to the fees that generate revenue for HWCA. The amendments reset the base Facility Fee and replace the existing Generator, EPA Identification Verification, Manifest, and Disposal Fees with a new Generation and Handling Fee, which would be based on a price-per-ton model. These changes, in combination with the proposed elimination of some fee exemptions, are projected to increase revenues into HWCA at a level that will close the structural imbalance in the HWCA, cover the costs imposed by this bill for the new Board, the development of the Hazardous Waste Management Plan, and provide additional revenues to build a prudent reserve.
It should be noted that the amendments do not address the current deficit within TSCA. Without addressing the shortfalls in both HWCA and TSCA, DTSC will continue to lack the resources it needs to carry out its mission and will continue to need funding from the General Fund to stay balanced. The Administration has maintained that any governance reform of DTSC must go hand-in-hand with fiscal reform of both HWCA and TSCA, arguing that only such a comprehensive reform will position the department for success.
Having supported the policy elements of the bill in the previous hearing, the essential question before the Committee, based on the recent amendments, is whether or not it makes sense to establish governance reform at the Department with only a partial fix to the Department’s funding shortfall.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2094 (Kalra, 2018). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2021, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities; hazardous waste generators; and, transporters. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2345 (Reyes, 2018). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have made statutory changes to improve the process for the permitting of hazardous waste facilities. This bill was later amended to require the California Energy Commission to require each large electrical corporation to establish a tariff or tariffs that provide for bill credits for electricity generated by eligible renewable generating facilities and exported to the electrical grid. This bill was held in Senate the Rules Committee.
AB 2606 (Fong, 2018). Would have required DTSC to process a hazardous waste facility renewal permit in an expedited manner if DTSC determines certain conditions apply. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 248 (Reyes, 2017). Would have made statutory changes to improve the permitting process for hazardous waste facilities. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1179 (Kalra, 2017). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2020, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities and for hazardous waste generators and transporters. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 774 (Leyva, 2017). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have created the California Toxic Substances Board within DTSC to provide oversight of California's hazardous waste management and the remediation of contaminated sites. This bill was later amended to require the California State University Trustees to oversee a competitive process to award funds to the Wildland and Wildland Urban Interface Wildfire Research Grant Program and appropriate $5 million from the General Fund to the Trustees in order to oversee the program. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 812 (De León, 2014). Would have modified the permitting process and public participation requirements for hazardous waste facilities. Would have established a Bureau of Internal Affairs to oversee DTSC and investigate departmental misconduct and a DTSC Citizen Oversight Committee to receive and review allegations of misconduct. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance (CCEEB)
California Environmental Justice Alliance (CEJA) Action
California Environmental Justice Alliance.
California for A Healthy & Green Economy
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians Against Waste
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Clean Harbors Environmental Services, INC. and Safety-Kleen
Clean Water Action
Environmental Working Group
Military Services in California
Natural Resources Defense Council
Physicians for Social Responsibility - Los Angeles
Republic Services INC.
Sierra Club California
OPPOSITION:
None Received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the California Council for Environmental & Economic Balance (CCEEB), “Based on the latest proposed amendments, CCEEB is supportive of AB 995 as the first step to meaningfully address issues raised by CCEEB and other stakeholders. While CCEEB supports AB 995 as proposed to be amended, we would note that additional work remains ahead of us to ensure the provisions of AB 995, and more, address the fundamental operational, regulatory and fiscal concerns with the Department.”
“In addition to the structural, programmatic and regulatory reforms AB 995 seeks to make, it would also provide for merely short-term fee increases within the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) to support the Department’s activities and development of the HWMP and Fee Task Force. Agreeing to these short-term fee increases does not come lightly for CCEEB and its members who are already straddled with increasing costs associated with DTSC oversight and permitting without corresponding DTSC responsiveness and timeliness of permitting and other regulatory decision making and reforms. Nonetheless, CCEEB members acknowledge the importance of a funded DTSC to make progress on these issues, but are clear in their expectation for meaningful progress to address the concerns raised.”
-- END --
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 995 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 995
Author: Cristina Garcia (D), Bloom (D), Carrillo (D), Kalra (D), Reyes (D) and Santiago (D), et al.
Amended: 7/2/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 8/11/20
AYES: Allen, Hill, Stern, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dahle, Skinner
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Hazardous waste
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST: This bill creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) and makes various other changes to the hazardous waste control laws.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires DTSC to enforce the standards within the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL) and the regulations adopted by DTSC pursuant to the HWCL. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) § 25180)
- Authorizes DTSC to deny, suspend, or revoke any permit, registration, or certificate applied for, or issued pursuant to the HWCL. (HSC § 25186)
- Authorizes DTSC to issue permits for the use and operation of one or more hazardous waste management units at a facility that meets the standards adopted pursuant to HWCL. (HSC § 25200 (a))
- Requires DTSC to impose conditions on each permit specifying the types of hazardous wastes that may be accepted for transfer, storage, treatment, or disposal. (HSC § 25200 (a))
This bill:
- Creates the Board within the CalEPA consisting of five members with three members appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the Senate, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Requires the Board, using a public process, to do all of the following:
- Review the DTSC’s duties and responsibilities in law, the current status of hazardous waste facility permits, the site mitigation program and remediation activities, and enforcement decisions for hazardous waste facilities and propose statutory, regulatory, and policy changes;
- Hear and decide appeals of hazardous waste facility permit decisions;
- Provide opportunities for public hearings on individual permitted or remediation sites, and, if necessary, direct the department to respond to or address public concerns and questions; and
- Set priorities for each program for each year at a public hearing, which the director shall carry out.
- Authorizes the Board to meet in Executive Session for any purpose authorized pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and requires the Board to adopt rules for conduct of its affairs in conformity with existing law.
- Provides that the Chairperson of the Board is appointed by the Governor and shall be full-time and the remaining members of the Board shall be half-time.
- Prohibits a member of the Board from participating in any action of the Board or attempt to influence any decision of which the Board member has a financial interest.
- Requires the Board to conduct at least six public hearings per year, with three of those hearings being held in locations outside the county of Sacramento.
- Establishes an office of ombudsperson in the Board to receive complaints and suggestions from the public, to evaluate complaints received, to report findings and make recommendations to DTSC and the Board, and to render assistance to the public.
- Requires the Secretary for CalEPA to convene a fee task force to review the existing fee structure supporting the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and the funding structure supporting the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 10, 2022, as part of the Governor’s Budget, on a fee system for the HWCA and a funding structure for the TSCA, as specified.
- Requires the Board to annually submit to the Secretary and the Legislature a review of the DTSC’s performance measured against the Board’s objectives.
- Requires DTSC to prepare the state hazardous waste management plan and present it to the Board for approval. Revises, adds, and repeals some the elements required to be in the plan and requires DTSC to conduct at least three public workshops, as provided.
- Requires DTSC to review, at least once every five years, the financial assurances required to operate a hazardous waste facility and the cost estimates used to establish the amount of financial assurances required. If DTSC’s review finds that the cost estimates are inadequate, requires the owner or operator to update the cost estimates and to adopt adequate financial assurances within 90 days of notification from DTSC.
- Requires DTSC to issue a final decision on a permit within 12 months of the expiration of the permit, or within five years of the expiration of a permit that expires before December 31, 2023, and for which an application for renewal was submitted at least 180 days before the expiration of the permit. If the department has not issued a final permit decision by the applicable deadline, this bill requires the department to, among other things, issue a report, to be released publicly, that includes the reasons why the final permit decision was not made on time and a proposed schedule for issuing the final permit decision.
- Requires DTSC, no later than 90 days after receiving an application for a hazardous waste facilities permit, to post on its internet website a timeline with the estimated dates of key milestones in the application review process, to note on its internet website that these dates are estimates, and to update the dates as needed.
- Requires DTSC, under specified circumstances, to request an owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility to submit to the department for review and approval a written cost estimate to cover activities associated with a corrective action based on available data, history of releases, and site activities, as specified. Requires the owner or operator to submit the corrective action cost estimate within 60 days of the department’s request. Requires the owner or operator, within 90 days of the approval of the imposition of a corrective action cost estimate, as specified, to fund the cost estimate or enter into a schedule of compliance for assurances of financial responsibility for completing the corrective action.
- Repeals the provision making implementation of the Pollution Prevention and Hazardous Waste Source Reduction and Management Review Act contingent upon, and limited to, the availability of funding on January 1, 2023.
Background
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management permitting program. DTSC is responsible for administering the hazardous waste facility permitting program established under the HWCL and the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The core activities of the permitting program include: review of RCRA and non-RCRA hazardous waste permit applications to ensure safe design and operation; issuance and denial of operating permits; issuance of post-closure permits; approval and denial of permit modifications; issuance and denial of emergency permits; review and approval of closure plans; oversight of approved closure plans; and, providing public involvement on issues related to permitted facilities.
- Recent criticism of DTSC. Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
Currently, the only time the public is involved in the permit process is when there is a draft permit decision released by DTSC. If a permit application takes 10 years to review, that means it could have been 20 years since the public has been provided information about the permit for the hazardous waste facility in their community. For example, the permit for the facility Phibro-Tech located in Santa Fe Springs was issued in 1991 and expired in 1996, a permit decision has not yet been made, and the last public meeting regarding the permit was over 23 years ago.
- Legislative Oversight. Specific incidents across California have exposed and continue to expose glaring failings in DTSC's implementation of its core programs as well as its support programs. The mishandling of the hazardous waste facility permitting and enforcement of the Exide and the Quemetco battery recycling facilities; neglected cost recovery efforts for cleanups across the state leading to an accumulation of 1,661 projects totaling almost $194 million in uncollected cleanup costs dating back 26 years; a growing backlog of applications to renew hazardous waste permits; delayed site remediation; failed public participation and transparency activities; and, personnel issues have all led to decreased stakeholder confidence and public trust in DTSC's ability to meet its mandate to protect public health and the environment.
Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: (a) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; (b) auditing cost recovery at the department; (c) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, (d) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain.
- Funding sources for DTSC. DTSC's funding comes primarily from the HWCA and the TSCA. HWCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery activities and fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. With the exception of the Activity Fee for Permitting, the rest of the fees were last amended in statute in 1998 or earlier. TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee. Revenues from the Environmental Fee constitutes 80 percent of TSCA with the rest making up the remaining 20 percent. The Environmental Fee was established in 1989 and is subject to an annual CPI adjustment.
Both HWCA and TSCA have been operating with a structural deficit. Expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. HWCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2018-19 with a $4.8 million shortfall and a projected -$24.8 million in 2019-20 absent remedial action. The Budget Act of 2019 provided HWCA with $27.5 million in General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. TSCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2019-20. The Budget Act of 2020 included $28.2 million in loans to cover the shortfall in both HWCA and TSCA.
A number of factors contribute to the operating structural deficit in both accounts. They include increasing legislative mandates, an outdated fee structure that no longer corresponds to the proportion of waste generated or disposed, increasing costs relating to the state obligated cost share for National Priority List sites, and a backlog of unresolved response costs worth approximately $194 million at over 1,600 cleanup sites over a 25-year period.
- Governor proposal. In January, the Governor proposed, as part of his 2020-21 Budget, trailer bill language that would create a Board of Environmental Safety, generally similar to AB 995, increase fees to support current hazardous waste and cleanup activities and provide authority to the Board to raise these fees. One key difference between the two proposals is that AB 995 requires the Secretary for CalEPA to convene a task force to review the fee structure for HWCA and TSCA. AB 995 requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature, by January 10, 2022, on how these funds could be modified to ensure they provide adequate funding to support DTSC’s programs.
Further, unlike the Governor’s proposed trailer bill, AB 995 also makes a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and makes improvements to the department’s financial assurances requirements.
While Budget actions were taken in June to provide bridge funding to the DTSC for a year, efforts to move structural and fiscal reform through the Budget this year have ended.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
“AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, DTSC estimates ongoing costs of about $18 million annually (special fund) to implement this bill. The DOJ estimates ongoing cost pressure of $1.4 million annually (special fund) due to increased workload for its Environment Section and Natural Resources Law Section within DOJ’s Public Rights Division from representing the Board of Environmental Safety.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians Against Waste
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Clean Water Action
Military Services in California
Natural Resources Defense Council
Republic Services Inc.
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Resource Management Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia
Prepared by: Gabrielle Meindl / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
8/21/20 17:32:17
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 995 (Cristina Garcia) - Hazardous waste
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would create the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) and make various other changes to the hazardous waste control laws.
Fiscal Impact:
- DTSC estimates ongoing costs of about $18 million annually (special fund) to implement this bill.
- The DOJ estimates ongoing cost pressure of $1.4 million annually (special fund) due to increased workload for its Environment Section and Natural Resources Law Section within DOJ’s Public Rights Division from representing the Board of Environmental Safety.
Background:
- California Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL). The HWCL is the state's program that implements and enforces federal hazardous waste law in California and directs DTSC to oversee and implement the state's HWCL. Any person who stores, treats, or disposes of hazardous waste must obtain a permit from DTSC. The HWCL covers the entire management of hazardous waste, from the point the hazardous waste is generated, to management, transportation, and ultimately disposal into a state or federal authorized facility.
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management permitting program. DTSC is responsible for administering the hazardous waste facility permitting program established under the HWCL and the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The core activities of the permitting program include: review of RCRA and non-RCRA hazardous waste permit applications to ensure safe design and operation; issuance and denial of operating permits; issuance of post-closure permits; approval and denial of permit modifications; issuance and denial of emergency permits; review and approval of closure plans; oversight of approved closure plans; and, providing public involvement on issues related to permitted facilities.
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management enforcement program: DTSC’s inspection and enforcement responsibilities include its delegated authority under RCRA, California’s HWCL, and state laws pertaining to toxics in packaging, toxic substances in consumer products, and disposal of universal wastes such as electronic waste. Core activities of DTSC’s hazardous waste management program include: routine compliance inspections, which involve review of submitted data and reports as well as physical observation, testing, and evaluation of regulated facilities; and targeted compliance inspections, which involve review of specific units or processes in response to focused concerns or to inform permitting decisions, as well as analysis of current and historical compliance to inform those decisions.
- The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). CERCLA, or Superfund, provides a Federal "Superfund" to clean up uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites as well as accidents, spills, and other emergency releases of pollutants and contaminants into the environment. Through CERCLA, the US EPA was given authority to seek out those parties responsible for any release and assure their cooperation in the cleanup. The US EPA cleans up orphan sites when potentially responsible parties cannot be identified or located, or when they fail to act.
- Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substances Account Act (HSAA). State law provides DTSC with general administrative responsibility for overseeing the state’s responses to spills or releases of hazardous substances, and for hazardous waste disposal sites that pose a threat to public health or the environment. Additionally, DTSC ensures that the state meets the federal requirements that California pay 10 percent of cleanup costs for federal Superfund sites and 100 percent of the operation and maintenance costs after cleanup is complete. The HSAA provides DTSC with the authority, procedures, and standards to investigate, remove, and remediate contamination at sites; to issue and enforce a removal or remedial action order to any responsible party; and, to impose administrative or civil penalties for noncompliance with an order. Federal and state laws also authorize DTSC to recover costs and expenses it incurs in carrying out these activities.
- Recent criticism of DTSC. Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
Currently, the only time the public is involved in the permit process is when there is a draft permit decision released by DTSC. If a permit application takes 10 years to review, that means it could have been 20 years since the public has been provided information about the permit for the hazardous waste facility in their community. For example, the permit for the facility Phibro-Tech located in Santa Fe Springs was issued in 1991 and expired in 1996, a permit decision has not yet been made, and the last public meeting regarding the permit was over 23 years ago.
- Legislative Oversight. Specific incidents across California have exposed and continue to expose glaring failings in DTSC's implementation of its core programs as well as its support programs. The mishandling of the hazardous waste facility permitting and enforcement of the Exide and the Quemetco battery recycling facilities; neglected cost recovery efforts for cleanups across the state leading to an accumulation of 1,661 projects totaling almost $194 million in uncollected cleanup costs dating back 26 years; a growing backlog of applications to renew hazardous waste permits; delayed site remediation; failed public participation and transparency activities; and, personnel issues have all led to decreased stakeholder confidence and public trust in DTSC's ability to meet its mandate to protect public health and the environment.
Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: (1) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; (2) auditing cost recovery at the department; (3) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, (4) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain.
- DTSC Independent Review Panel (IRP). In 2015, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed SB 83 (Budget Committee, Chapter 24, Statutes of 2015), which established within DTSC a three-member IRP to review and make recommendations regarding improvements to DTSC's permitting, enforcement, public outreach, and fiscal management. The statute stipulates that IRP membership shall be comprised of a community representative, a person with scientific experience related to toxic materials, and a local government management expert. Pursuant to SB 83, the IRP was authorized until January 1, 2018. Over the course of its term, the IRP conducted 24 public meetings and released 11 progress and annual reports. On January 8, 2018 the IRP released its final report and recommendations concluding: "The Department has implemented, or is working on, most of the IRP’s recommendations and has achieved, or partially achieved, many of the IRP’s suggested performance metrics. However, there is more work to be done. In the absence of the IRP, the Governor and the Legislature should consider a DTSC governing board or other structural change to enhance transparency and accountability and regularly monitor the status of the IRP-suggested recommendations and performance metrics, as well as DTSC's ongoing initiatives and decision-making."
- Funding sources for DTSC. DTSC's funding comes primarily from the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). HWCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery activities and fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. With the exception of the Activity Fee for Permitting, the rest of the fees were last amended in statute in 1998 or earlier. TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee. Revenues from the Environmental Fee constitutes 80 percent of TSCA with the rest making up the remaining 20 percent. The Environmental Fee was established in 1989 and is subject to an annual CPI adjustment.
Both HWCA and TSCA has been operating with a structural deficit. expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. HWCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2018-19 with a $4.8 million shortfall and a projected -$24.8 million in 2019-20 absent remedial action. The Budget Act of 2019 provided HWCA with $27.5 million in General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. TSCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2019-20. The Budget Act of 2020 included $28.2 million in loans to cover the shortfall in both HSCA and TSCA.
A number of factors contribute to the operating structural deficit in both accounts. They include increasing legislative mandates, an outdated fee structure that no longer corresponds to the proportion of waste generated or disposed, increasing costs relating to the state obligated cost share for National Priority List sites, and a backlog of unresolved response costs worth approximately $194 million at over 1,600 cleanup sites over a 25-year period.
- Governor proposal. In January, the Governor proposed, as part of his 2020-21 Budget, trailer bill language that would create a Board of Environmental Safety, generally similar to AB 995, increase fees to support current hazardous waste and cleanup activities and provide authority to the Board to raise these fees. One key difference between the two proposals is that AB 995 would require the Secretary for CalEPA to convene a task force to review the fee structure for HWCA and TSCA. AB 995 requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature, by January 10, 2022, on how these funds could be modified to ensure they provide adequate funding to support DTSC’s programs.
Another important difference relates to Board member selection and confirmation. Under the Governor’s proposals, all five board members would be appointed by the Governor without making them subject to Senate confirmation. This provision could make the Board less likely to reflect the Legislature’s priorities. AB 995, on the other hand, allows for the Senate and Assembly to each appoint one member, and requires the Governor’s three appointees to be subject to Senate confirmation.
Lastly, unlike the Governor’s proposed trailer bill, AB 995 would also make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department’s financial assurances requirements.
While Budget actions were taken in June, action on the trailer bill was delayed until August.
- Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) Comments: According to the LAO’s 2020-21 Budget Report on Resources and Environmental Protection, released on February 25, 2020:
“Concept of Establishing a Board Has Merit. A board that holds regular public meetings could improve transparency and allow the public and stakeholders a regular venue to raise issues and discuss their concerns. The board structure could also help to promote greater accountability by requiring the DTSC director to regularly report on the department’s progress towards meeting outcome goals.”
“Board Could make DTSC’s Programs More Effective. Some elements of the proposal could make DTSC’s programs more effective and result in the public receiving improved services. In particular, the proposals to require that the board (1) review and approve the director’s annual priorities for each program and (2) provide the Secretary of CalEPA with an annual performance review appear to be directed towards improving the department’s performance.”
“New Structure Would Improve Accountability. The addition of the board would result in a government structure where the Legislature and the public could more easily identify the persons responsible for managing DTSC’s programs and hold them accountable. Annual goal setting, long‑term goal setting, and an annual performance review of DTSC by the board would establish a public process for identifying performance issues, determining who is responsible for them, and measuring the department’s progress towards addressing them. The creation of an ombudsman who would receive complaints from the public, render assistance, and make recommendations to the board and the director would increase the department’s accountability by creating an additional forum for the public to voice its concerns. In addition, providing a public hearing forum to appeal departmental permit decisions could result in a more transparent appeals process.”
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Create the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the CalEPA consisting of five members with three members appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the Senate, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Require the Board, using a public process, to do all of the following:
- Review the Department’s duties and responsibilities in law, the current status of hazardous waste facility permits, the site mitigation program and remediation activities, and enforcement decisions for hazardous waste facilities and propose statutory, regulatory, and policy changes;
- Hear and decide appeals of hazardous waste facility permit decisions;
- Provide opportunities for public hearings on individual permitted or remediation sites, and, if necessary, direct the department to respond to or address public concerns and questions; and
- Set priorities for each program for each year at a public hearing, which the director shall carry out.
- Provide that the members of the Board shall be appointed to fill certain qualifications, specifically:
- One Board member shall be an attorney admitted to practice law in this state who is qualified in the field of environmental law pertaining to hazardous waste, hazardous substances, or site remediation;
- One Board member shall be an environmental scientist qualified in the fields of toxicology, chemistry or industrial hygiene or a licensed geologist or licensed engineer, in an area specific to the statutory responsibilities of the Board;
- One Board member shall have expertise in public health;
- One Board member shall be qualified in the area of regulatory permitting; and,
- One Board member shall have expertise in cumulative impact assessment and management.
- Provide that Board members shall be appointed for a term of four years, however the terms shall be staggered with the first two initial members serving a term of two years and the other three initial members shall serve a four year term.
- Authorize the Board to meet in Executive Session for any purpose authorized pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and requires the Board to adopt rules for conduct of its affairs in conformity with existing law.
- Provide that the Chairperson of the Board is appointed by the Governor and shall be full-time and the remaining members of the Board shall be half-time.
- Prohibit a member of the Board from participating in any action of the Board or attempt to influence any decision of which the Board member has a financial interest.
- Require the Board to conduct at least six public hearings per year, with three of those hearings being held in locations outside the county of Sacramento.
- Establish an office of ombudsperson in the Board to receive complaints and suggestions from the public, to evaluate complaints received, to report findings and make recommendations to DTSC and the Board, and to render assistance to the public.
- Require the Secretary for Environmental Protection to convene a fee task force to review the existing fee structure supporting the Hazardous Waste Control Account and the funding structure supporting the Toxic Substances Control Account. Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 10, 2022, as part of the Governor’s Budget, on a fee system for the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and a funding structure for the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) that does all of the following:
- Provide protection for public health and safety and the environment;
- Provide adequate funding to ensure the remediation of contaminated sites, including the remediation and potential reuse of orphan sites;
- Provide adequate funding for oversight and proper enforcement;
- Provide adequate funding for the programs that protect consumers from potentially harmful chemicals in products or workplaces;
- Provide for a reasonable distribution of costs among the sectors that contribute to the need for management of hazardous waste in the state;
- Provide a level of funding that will enable the Board to appropriately implement and carry out its duties and responsibilities in a manner that is consistent with the objectives of those laws; and
- Consider increasing existing fees, decreasing existing fees, consolidating existing fees, eliminating fees, or creating new fees, as appropriate. The task force shall consider where tiered rates can be implemented to reflect greater regulatory costs associated with large volumes of hazardous waste in the areas of generation, transport, and treatment.
- Require the task force include representatives from the Legislative Analyst’s Office; appropriate policy committees of the Assembly and the Senate; fiscal committees of the Assembly and Senate; state employees; environmental organizations; environmental justice organizations; and payers of fees required pursuant to this chapter, including at least one federal permittee.
- Require the Board to annually submit to the Secretary and the Legislature a review of the Department’s performance measured against the Board’s objectives.
- Require DTSC to prepare the state hazardous waste management plan and present it to the Board for approval. Revises, adds, and repeals some the elements required to be in the plan and requires DTSC to conduct at least three public workshops, as provided.
- Require DTSC, on or before March 1, 2021, to post on its internet website the Spatial Prioritization Geographic Information Tool in order to provide the public with information on the location of contaminated groundwater in the state.
- Require DTSC to review, at least once every 5 years, the financial assurances required to operate a hazardous waste facility and the cost estimates used to establish the amount of financial assurances required. If DTSC’s review finds that the cost estimates are inadequate, requires the owner or operator to update the cost estimates and to adopt adequate financial assurances within 90 days of notification from DTSC.
- Require DTSC to issue a final decision on a permit within 12 months of the expiration of the permit, or within 5 years of the expiration of a permit that expires before December 31, 2023, and for which an application for renewal was submitted at least 180 days before the expiration of the permit. If the department has not issued a final permit decision by the applicable deadline, the bill would require the department to, among other things, issue a report, to be released publicly, that includes the reasons why the final permit decision was not made on time and a proposed schedule for issuing the final permit decision.
- Require DTSC to take certain actions if a final permit decision is not issued in accordance with the deadlines established above, including preparing a report on factors driving the delay and presenting the report to the Board.
- Require, for a hazardous waste facilities permit that will expire on or before January 1, 2023, the owner or operator of a facility intending to extend the term of that permit to submit a Part A and Part B application for a permit renewal at least 6 months before the fixed term of the permit expires. Further, requires, for a hazardous waste facilities permit that will expire after January 1, 2023, the owner or operator to submit a Part A and Part B application for a permit renewal at least 2 years before the fixed term of the permit expires.
- Require a permittee to submit a renewal application by these deadlines instead of the permit expiration date in order to be deemed extended until it is approved or denied.
- Require DTSC, no later than 90 days after receiving an application for a hazardous waste facilities permit, to post on its internet website a timeline with the estimated dates of key milestones in the application review process, to note on its internet website that these dates are estimates, and to update the dates as needed.
- Require DTSC, under specified circumstances, to request an owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility to submit to the department for review and approval a written cost estimate to cover activities associated with a corrective action based on available data, history of releases, and site activities, as specified. Requires the owner or operator to submit the corrective action cost estimate within 60 days of the department’s request. Requires the owner or operator, within 90 days of the approval of the imposition of a corrective action cost estimate, as specified, to fund the cost estimate or enter into a schedule of compliance for assurances of financial responsibility for completing the corrective action.
- Repeal the provision making implementation of the Hazardous Waste Reduction, Recycling, and Treatment Research and Demonstration Act of 1985 contingent upon, and limited to, the availability of funding on January 1, 2023.
- Repeal the provision making implementation of the Pollution Prevention and Hazardous Waste Source Reduction and Management Review Act contingent upon, and limited to, the availability of funding on January 1, 2023.
Related Legislation:
AB 2094 (Kalra, 2018). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2021, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities; hazardous waste generators; and, transporters. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2345 (Reyes, 2018). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have made statutory changes to improve the process for the permitting of hazardous waste facilities. This bill was later amended to require the California Energy Commission to require each large electrical corporation to establish a tariff or tariffs that provide for bill credits for electricity generated by eligible renewable generating facilities and exported to the electrical grid. This bill was held in Senate the Rules Committee.
AB 2606 (Fong). Would have required DTSC to process a hazardous waste facility renewal permit in an expedited manner if DTSC determines certain conditions apply. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 248 (Reyes, 2017). Would have made statutory changes to improve the permitting process for hazardous waste facilities. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1179 (Kalra, 2017). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2020, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities and for hazardous waste generators and transporters. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 774 (Leyva, 2017). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have created the California Toxic Substances Board within DTSC to provide oversight of California's hazardous waste management and the remediation of contaminated sites. This bill was later amended to require the California State University Trustees to oversee a competitive process to award funds to the Wildland and Wildland Urban Interface Wildfire Research Grant Program and appropriate $5 million from the General Fund to the Trustees in order to oversee the program. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 812 (De León, 2014). Would have modified the permitting process and public participation requirements for hazardous waste facilities. Would have established a Bureau of Internal Affairs to oversee DTSC and investigate departmental misconduct and a DTSC Citizen Oversight Committee to receive and review allegations of misconduct. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 995
Author: | Cristina Garcia, et al. | ||
Version: | 7/2/2020 | Hearing Date: | 8/11/2020 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Hazardous waste
DIGEST: Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) to provide policy direction to and oversight of the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) and makes various other changes to the hazardous waste control laws.
Due to the COVID-19 Pandemic and the unprecedented nature of the 2020 Legislative Session, all Senate Policy Committees are working under a compressed timeline. This timeline does not allow this bill to be referred and heard by more than one committee, as a typical timeline would allow.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires DTSC to enforce the standards within the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL) and the regulations adopted by DTSC pursuant to the HWCL. (Health and Safety Code Section (HSC) § 25180)
2) Authorizes DTSC to deny, suspend, or revoke any permit, registration, or certificate applied for, or issued pursuant to the HWCL. (HSC § 25186)
3) Authorizes DTSC to issue permits for the use and operation of one or more hazardous waste management units at a facility that meets the standards adopted pursuant to the Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL). (HSC § 25200 (a))
4) Requires DTSC to impose conditions on each permit specifying the types of hazardous wastes that may be accepted for transfer, storage, treatment, or disposal. (HSC § 25200 (a))
5) Establishes, pursuant to the Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substance Account Act (HSAA), a program to provide for response authority for releases of hazardous substances, including spills and hazardous waste disposal sites that pose a threat to the public health or the environment. (HSC § 25300 et seq.)
6) Creates, under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA), a Federal "Superfund" to clean up uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites, as well as accidents, spills, and other emergency releases of pollutants and contaminants into the environment. Provides the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) with the authority to seek out those parties responsible for any release and assure their cooperation in the cleanup. (42 United States Code (U.S.C.) § 9601 et seq.)
This bill:
- Creates the Board of Environmental Safety (Board) within the CalEPA consisting of five members with three members appointed by the Governor, subject to confirmation by the Senate, one member appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, and one member appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
- Requires the Board, using a public process, to do all of the following:
- Review the Department’s duties and responsibilities in law, the current status of hazardous waste facility permits, the site mitigation program and remediation activities, and enforcement decisions for hazardous waste facilities and propose statutory, regulatory, and policy changes;
- Hear and decide appeals of hazardous waste facility permit decisions;
- Provide opportunities for public hearings on individual permitted or remediation sites, and, if necessary, direct the department to respond to or address public concerns and questions; and
- Set priorities for each program for each year at a public hearing, which the director shall carry out.
- Provides that the members of the Board shall be appointed to fill certain qualifications, specifically:
- One Board member shall be an attorney admitted to practice law in this state who is qualified in the field of environmental law pertaining to hazardous waste, hazardous substances, or site remediation;
- One Board member shall be an environmental scientist qualified in the fields of toxicology, chemistry or industrial hygiene or a licensed geologist or licensed engineer, in an area specific to the statutory responsibilities of the Board;
- One Board member shall have expertise in public health;
- One Board member shall be qualified in the area of regulatory permitting; and,
- One Board member shall have expertise in cumulative impact assessment and management.
- Provides that Board members shall be appointed for a term of four years, however the terms shall be staggered with the first two initial members serving a term of two years and the other three initial members shall serve a four year term.
- Authorizes the Board to meet in Executive Session for any purpose authorized pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and requires the Board to adopt rules for conduct of its affairs in conformity with existing law.
- Provides that the Chairperson of the Board is appointed by the Governor and shall be full-time and the remaining members of the Board shall be half-time.
- Prohibits a member of the Board from participating in any action of the Board or attempt to influence any decision of which the Board member has a financial interest.
- Requires the Board to conduct at least six public hearings per year, with three of those hearings being held in locations outside the county of Sacramento.
- Establishes an office of ombudsperson in the Board to receive complaints and suggestions from the public, to evaluate complaints received, to report findings and make recommendations to DTSC and the Board, and to render assistance to the public.
- Requires the Secretary for Environmental Protection to convene a fee task force to review the existing fee structure supporting the Hazardous Waste Control Account and the funding structure supporting the Toxic Substances Control Account. Requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature by January 10, 2022, as part of the Governor’s Budget, on a fee system for the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and a funding structure for the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) that does all of the following:
- Provides protection for public health and safety and the environment;
- Provides adequate funding to ensure the remediation of contaminated sites, including the remediation and potential reuse of orphan sites;
- Provides adequate funding for oversight and proper enforcement;
- Provides adequate funding for the programs that protect consumers from potentially harmful chemicals in products or workplaces;
- Provides for a reasonable distribution of costs among the sectors that contribute to the need for management of hazardous waste in the state;
- Provides a level of funding that will enable the Board to appropriately implement and carry out its duties and responsibilities in a manner that is consistent with the objectives of those laws; and
- Considers increasing existing fees, decreasing existing fees, consolidating existing fees, eliminating fees, or creating new fees, as appropriate. The task force shall consider where tiered rates can be implemented to reflect greater regulatory costs associated with large volumes of hazardous waste in the areas of generation, transport, and treatment.
- Requires the task force include representatives from the Legislative Analyst’s Office; appropriate policy committees of the Assembly and the Senate; fiscal committees of the Assembly and Senate; state employees; environmental organizations; environmental justice organizations; and payers of fees required pursuant to this chapter, including at least one federal permittee.
- Requires the Board to annually submit to the Secretary and the Legislature a review of the Department’s performance measured against the Board’s objectives.
- Requires DTSC to prepare the state hazardous waste management plan and present it to the Board for approval. Revises, adds, and repeals some the elements required to be in the plan and requires DTSC to conduct at least three public workshops, as provided.
- Requires DTSC, on or before March 1, 2021, to post on its internet website the Spatial Prioritization Geographic Information Tool in order to provide the public with information on the location of contaminated groundwater in the state.
- Requires DTSC to review, at least once every 5 years, the financial assurances required to operate a hazardous waste facility and the cost estimates used to establish the amount of financial assurances required. If DTSC’s review finds that the cost estimates are inadequate, requires the owner or operator to update the cost estimates and to adopt adequate financial assurances within 90 days of notification from DTSC.
- Requires DTSC to issue a final decision on a permit within 12 months of the expiration of the permit, or within 5 years of the expiration of a permit that expires before December 31, 2023, and for which an application for renewal was submitted at least 180 days before the expiration of the permit. If the department has not issued a final permit decision by the applicable deadline, the bill would require the department to, among other things, issue a report, to be released publicly, that includes the reasons why the final permit decision was not made on time and a proposed schedule for issuing the final permit decision.
- Requires DTSC to take certain actions if a final permit decision is not issued in accordance with the deadlines established above, including preparing a report on factors driving the delay and presenting the report to the Board.
- Requires, for a hazardous waste facilities permit that will expire on or before January 1, 2023, the owner or operator of a facility intending to extend the term of that permit to submit a Part A and Part B application for a permit renewal at least 6 months before the fixed term of the permit expires. Further, requires, for a hazardous waste facilities permit that will expire after January 1, 2023, the owner or operator to submit a Part A and Part B application for a permit renewal at least 2 years before the fixed term of the permit expires.
- Requires a permittee to submit a renewal application by these deadlines instead of the permit expiration date in order to be deemed extended until it is approved or denied.
- Requires DTSC, no later than 90 days after receiving an application for a hazardous waste facilities permit, to post on its internet website a timeline with the estimated dates of key milestones in the application review process, to note on its internet website that these dates are estimates, and to update the dates as needed.
- Requires DTSC, under specified circumstances, to request an owner or operator of a hazardous waste facility to submit to the department for review and approval a written cost estimate to cover activities associated with a corrective action based on available data, history of releases, and site activities, as specified. Requires the owner or operator to submit the corrective action cost estimate within 60 days of the department’s request. Requires the owner or operator, within 90 days of the approval of the imposition of a corrective action cost estimate, as specified, to fund the cost estimate or enter into a schedule of compliance for assurances of financial responsibility for completing the corrective action.
- Repeals the provision making implementation of the Hazardous Waste Reduction, Recycling, and Treatment Research and Demonstration Act of 1985 contingent upon, and limited to, the availability of funding on January 1, 2023.
- Repeals the provision making implementation of the Pollution Prevention and Hazardous Waste Source Reduction and Management Review Act contingent upon, and limited to, the availability of funding on January 1, 2023.
Background
- California Hazardous Waste Control Law (HWCL). The HWCL is the state's program that implements and enforces federal hazardous waste law in California and directs DTSC to oversee and implement the state's HWCL. Any person who stores, treats, or disposes of hazardous waste must obtain a permit from DTSC. The HWCL covers the entire management of hazardous waste, from the point the hazardous waste is generated, to management, transportation, and ultimately disposal into a state or federal authorized facility.
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management permitting program. DTSC is responsible for administering the hazardous waste facility permitting program established under the HWCL and the federal Resource Conservation and Recovery Act (RCRA). The core activities of the permitting program include: review of RCRA and non-RCRA hazardous waste permit applications to ensure safe design and operation; issuance and denial of operating permits; issuance of post-closure permits; approval and denial of permit modifications; issuance and denial of emergency permits; review and approval of closure plans; oversight of approved closure plans; and, providing public involvement on issues related to permitted facilities.
- DTSC’s hazardous waste management enforcement program: DTSC’s inspection and enforcement responsibilities include its delegated authority under RCRA, California’s HWCL, and state laws pertaining to toxics in packaging, toxic substances in consumer products, and disposal of universal wastes such as electronic waste. Core activities of DTSC’s hazardous waste management program include: routine compliance inspections, which involve review of submitted data and reports as well as physical observation, testing, and evaluation of regulated facilities; and targeted compliance inspections, which involve review of specific units or processes in response to focused concerns or to inform permitting decisions, as well as analysis of current and historical compliance to inform those decisions.
- The Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA). CERCLA, or Superfund, provides a Federal "Superfund" to clean up uncontrolled or abandoned hazardous waste sites as well as accidents, spills, and other emergency releases of pollutants and contaminants into the environment. Through CERCLA, the US EPA was given authority to seek out those parties responsible for any release and assure their cooperation in the cleanup. The US EPA cleans up orphan sites when potentially responsible parties cannot be identified or located, or when they fail to act.
- Carpenter-Presley-Tanner Hazardous Substances Account Act (HSAA). State law provides DTSC with general administrative responsibility for overseeing the state’s responses to spills or releases of hazardous substances, and for hazardous waste disposal sites that pose a threat to public health or the environment. Additionally, DTSC ensures that the state meets the federal requirements that California pay 10 percent of cleanup costs for federal Superfund sites and 100 percent of the operation and maintenance costs after cleanup is complete. The HSAA provides DTSC with the authority, procedures, and standards to investigate, remove, and remediate contamination at sites; to issue and enforce a removal or remedial action order to any responsible party; and, to impose administrative or civil penalties for noncompliance with an order. Federal and state laws also authorize DTSC to recover costs and expenses it incurs in carrying out these activities.
- Recent criticism of DTSC. Over the past decade or so, DTSC has received complaints from the public about its permitting program and held meetings with the public, the regulated community, and stakeholders to identify and understand concerns about its permitting program. Community groups that live near hazardous waste facilities are concerned that DTSC is not properly enforcing state and federal law and allowing facilities to operate with an expired permit or have numerous violations of state law and regulation. Additionally, the regulated community is concerned about the length of time it takes DTSC to process a permit, with processing a permit extending years beyond the expiration date of their permit, as well as the costs associated with processing a permit.
Currently, the only time the public is involved in the permit process is when there is a draft permit decision released by DTSC. If a permit application takes 10 years to review, that means it could have been 20 years since the public has been provided information about the permit for the hazardous waste facility in their community. For example, the permit for the facility Phibro-Tech located in Santa Fe Springs was issued in 1991 and expired in 1996, a permit decision has not yet been made, and the last public meeting regarding the permit was over 23 years ago.
- Legislative Oversight. Specific incidents across California have exposed and continue to expose glaring failings in DTSC's implementation of its core programs as well as its support programs. The mishandling of the hazardous waste facility permitting and enforcement of the Exide and the Quemetco battery recycling facilities; neglected cost recovery efforts for cleanups across the state leading to an accumulation of 1,661 projects totaling almost $194 million in uncollected cleanup costs dating back 26 years; a growing backlog of applications to renew hazardous waste permits; delayed site remediation; failed public participation and transparency activities; and, personnel issues have all led to decreased stakeholder confidence and public trust in DTSC's ability to meet its mandate to protect public health and the environment.
Over the last five years, the Legislature has conducted numerous hearings on DTSC's internal controls, its business practices, and its basic statutory obligations. In those hearings, the budget and policy committees have evaluated the following four main areas: (1) reviewing and monitoring the department's strategic plan and reorganization; (2) auditing cost recovery at the department; (3) providing staffing to improve permit backlogs and business operations; and, (4) improving enforcement at the department.
Numerous statutory changes have been made to clarify and strengthen DTSC's statutes to help DTSC better achieve its mandates, and budget augmentations have been made to give DTSC resources to reduce backlogs and address outstanding programmatic failings. However, many of the underlying concerns about transparency, accountability, and long-term stability of DTSC programs remain.
- DTSC Independent Review Panel (IRP). In 2015, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed SB 83 (Budget Committee, Chapter 24, Statutes of 2015), which established within DTSC a three-member IRP to review and make recommendations regarding improvements to DTSC's permitting, enforcement, public outreach, and fiscal management. The statute stipulates that IRP membership shall be comprised of a community representative, a person with scientific experience related to toxic materials, and a local government management expert. Pursuant to SB 83, the IRP was authorized until January 1, 2018. Over the course of its term, the IRP conducted 24 public meetings and released 11 progress and annual reports. On January 8, 2018 the IRP released its final report and recommendations concluding: "The Department has implemented, or is working on, most of the IRP’s recommendations and has achieved, or partially achieved, many of the IRP’s suggested performance metrics. However, there is more work to be done. In the absence of the IRP, the Governor and the Legislature should consider a DTSC governing board or other structural change to enhance transparency and accountability and regularly monitor the status of the IRP-suggested recommendations and performance metrics, as well as DTSC's ongoing initiatives and decision-making."
- Funding sources for DTSC. DTSC's funding comes primarily from the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA). HWCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery activities and fees paid by various hazardous waste generators, transporters, and facilities. With the exception of the Activity Fee for Permitting, the rest of the fees were last amended in statute in 1998 or earlier. TSCA is a repository for revenues from cost recovery, penalties, interest, and the Environmental Fee. Revenues from the Environmental Fee constitutes 80 percent of TSCA with the rest making up the remaining 20 percent. The Environmental Fee was established in 1989 and is subject to an annual CPI adjustment.
Both HWCA and TSCA has been operating with a structural deficit. expenditures out of HWCA and TSCA have exceeded revenues for many years. HWCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2018-19 with a $4.8 million shortfall and a projected -$24.8 million in 2019-20 absent remedial action. The Budget Act of 2019 provided HWCA with $27.5 million in General Fund to backfill the shortfall and maintain existing operations. TSCA became insolvent in fiscal year 2019-20. The Budget Act of 2020 included $28.2 million in loans to cover the shortfall in both HSCA and TSCA.
A number of factors contribute to the operating structural deficit in both accounts. They include increasing legislative mandates, an outdated fee structure that no longer corresponds to the proportion of waste generated or disposed, increasing costs relating to the state obligated cost share for National Priority List sites, and a backlog of unresolved response costs worth approximately $194 million at over 1,600 cleanup sites over a 25-year period.
- Governor proposal. In January, the Governor proposed, as part of his 2020-21 Budget, trailer bill language that would create a Board of Environmental Safety, generally similar to AB 995, increase fees to support current hazardous waste and cleanup activities and provide authority to the Board to raise these fees. One key difference between the two proposals is that AB 995 would require the Secretary for CalEPA to convene a task force to review the fee structure for HWCA and TSCA. AB 995 requires the Secretary to provide recommendations to the Legislature, by January 10, 2022, on how these funds could be modified to ensure they provide adequate funding to support DTSC’s programs.
Another important difference relates to Board member selection and confirmation. Under the Governor’s proposals, all five board members would be appointed by the Governor without making them subject to Senate confirmation. This provision could make the Board less likely to reflect the Legislature’s priorities. AB 995, on the other hand, allows for the Senate and Assembly to each appoint one member, and requires the Governor’s three appointees to be subject to Senate confirmation.
Lastly, unlike the Governor’s proposed trailer bill, AB 995 would also make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department’s financial assurances requirements.
While Budget actions were taken in June, action on the trailer bill was delayed until August.
- Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) Comments: According to the LAO’s 2020-21 Budget Report on Resources and Environmental Protection, released on February 25, 2020:
“Concept of Establishing a Board Has Merit. A board that holds regular public meetings could improve transparency and allow the public and stakeholders a regular venue to raise issues and discuss their concerns. The board structure could also help to promote greater accountability by requiring the DTSC director to regularly report on the department’s progress towards meeting outcome goals.”
“Board Could make DTSC’s Programs More Effective. Some elements of the proposal could make DTSC’s programs more effective and result in the public receiving improved services. In particular, the proposals to require that the board (1) review and approve the director’s annual priorities for each program and (2) provide the Secretary of CalEPA with an annual performance review appear to be directed towards improving the department’s performance.”
“New Structure Would Improve Accountability. The addition of the board would result in a government structure where the Legislature and the public could more easily identify the persons responsible for managing DTSC’s programs and hold them accountable. Annual goal setting, long‑term goal setting, and an annual performance review of DTSC by the board would establish a public process for identifying performance issues, determining who is responsible for them, and measuring the department’s progress towards addressing them. The creation of an ombudsman who would receive complaints from the public, render assistance, and make recommendations to the board and the director would increase the department’s accountability by creating an additional forum for the public to voice its concerns. In addition, providing a public hearing forum to appeal departmental permit decisions could result in a more transparent appeals process.”
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “For years the Legislature has been raising a wide range of issues with the performance of DTSC including extremely long permit process times, poor enforcement, delayed site remediation, and a failure to respond to public concerns. We have made numerous legislative efforts to improve different aspects of DTSC programs, but previous administrations have either vetoed such efforts or asked the Legislature to hold-off while internal efforts to improve the function of DTSC were underway. Unfortunately, none of these internal efforts have resulted in substantial improvements in DTSC's operations, which is why I introduced AB 995.
“In addition to the programmatic problems, last year DTSC was faced with substantial structural deficit in the Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) that necessitated the appropriation of $27.5 million from the General Fund to cover their regulatory costs for just last fiscal year, HWCA also needed $19.5 million in this fiscal year. The Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) is also in severe structural imbalance, needing $7.7 million this year which has been negatively affecting the remediation of orphan sites throughout the state, thereby creating public health risks and preventing the reuse of those lands.
“AB 995 creates the Board of Environmental Safety a policy setting and permit appeals body that will consist of five members, make a number of statutory changes to deadlines within the permitting process to ensure timely response by both the permit applicants and DTSC, and would make improvements to the department's financial assurances requirements. Lastly, AB 995 would create a fee task force led by the Secretary of CalEPA charged with making a comprehensive evaluation of DTSC's fee structure to identify a funding structure that would provide sufficient resources for DTSC to carry out its statutory mandates.
“We strongly share the Administration's belief that programmatic improvements to DTSC will not be achieved unless and until DTSC has sufficient fiscal resources to achieve its statutory mandates. But at the same time the legislature must be able to anticipate improved performance by the department with sufficient funding.
“The current poor condition of DTSC will continue to put disadvantaged communities in danger. Many of these communities are similar to those that lack safe and affordable drinking water, which is why we believe we share a common goal of protecting these communities for this generation and the next. DTSC must be reformed if we want to properly care for our most vulnerable populations that have been exposed to toxics from decades. If we are going to truly start to address the systemic racism in our systems, we need to take action now to fix a department that's in charge of protecting the public's health, especially those in low income communities of color where we are most likely to be over burdened with these toxics. DTSC's inefficiencies and the inability to address this is cutting black and brown and poor people's life's short in addition to making us live with chronic diseases. We optimistically hope that the Administration will look to AB 995 as we continue to negotiate and will work together along with stakeholders to fully reshape this entity into one that can oversee the management of hazardous waste in the state in a transparent manner that is fully protective of communities and public health.”
- Worthy Proposal. Effective regulation of hazardous waste is essential for the protection of public health and the environment. Over the last several years, there has been a number of internal and external efforts to improve DTSC’s ability to adequately meet its core mission and statutory mandates. Despite these efforts, the Department continues not to meet public expectations, especially in regards to clean-up and permitting activities.
The establishment of a Board could provide strategic guidance for DTSC, which the IRP found to be lacking and a board structure would bring some transparency to DTSC's decision-making process. Holding public meetings to discuss regulatory work, the status of cleanup sites, or why a permit decision has been delayed for a decade or longer will at least provide stakeholders with access to information they otherwise would not have.
DTSC’s difficulties are a result of multiple factors, though undoubtedly a major factor is the shortage of funding in both HWCA and TSCA. The fees that feed into these funds have not been adjusted for over 20 years and do not reflect significant program expansions and new mandates. Both HWCA and TSCA are in need of funding from the General Fund in order to backfill the deficit. Absent any changes, both accounts will continue to need funding from the General Fund to stay balanced. However, by doing so, the state would continue to subsidize fee payers with taxpayer dollars.
While the Administration’s proposal is well-intended, the proposal falls short on several fronts. The creation of a board in and of itself is not going to resolve the many longstanding operational shortfalls at DTSC. Without making changes to some of the programmatic controls contemplated in AB 995, the creation of a Board would not resolve the permit backlogs nor the deficient financial assurances currently in place.
Smartly, AB 995 proposes several additional elements that distinguish it from the Administration’s proposal: it creates a fee taskforce in order to evaluate the appropriate fee structure at DTSC, including ensuring adequate funding for the programs that protect consumers from potentially harmful chemicals in products; proposes statutory changes to improve and speed up the permitting process; ensures the proper financial assurances are in place; and re-establishes the Pollution Prevention Program.
The Committee may wish to support this reasonable, well-thought through, and needed proposal.
- Board Appointment Provisions. As noted earlier, one of the key differences between this bill and the Governor’s proposed trailer bill relates to Board member selection and confirmation. Under the Governor’s proposals, all five board members would be appointed by the Governor without making them subject to Senate confirmation. AB 995, on the other hand, allows for the Senate and Assembly to each appoint one member, and requires the Governor’s three appointees to be subject to Senate confirmation.
As the author continues negotiations with the Administration on marrying these proposals, the Committee may wish to direct the author to ensure that the Legislative appointments are retained, Senate Committee, Budget, and leadership staff continue to be included in discussions, and also consider adding further clarity to the Board appointments as follows:- Specify which category of appointee the Senate and the Assembly should have and consider a rotation of these categories;
- Clarify whether the Senate is to fill a vacancy left by the Governor and the Speaker, or just the Governor’s vacancy; and
- Identify which category of appointment shall get the shorter initial term.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2094 (Kalra, 2018). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2021, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities; hazardous waste generators; and, transporters. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2345 (Reyes, 2018). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have made statutory changes to improve the process for the permitting of hazardous waste facilities. This bill was later amended to require the California Energy Commission to require each large electrical corporation to establish a tariff or tariffs that provide for bill credits for electricity generated by eligible renewable generating facilities and exported to the electrical grid. This bill was held in Senate the Rules Committee.
AB 2606 (Fong). Would have required DTSC to process a hazardous waste facility renewal permit in an expedited manner if DTSC determines certain conditions apply. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 248 (Reyes, 2017). Would have made statutory changes to improve the permitting process for hazardous waste facilities. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1179 (Kalra, 2017). Would have required DTSC to, on or before January 1, 2020, adopt regulations establishing inspection frequencies for permitted hazardous waste treatment, storage, and disposal facilities and for hazardous waste generators and transporters. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 774 (Leyva, 2017). As it was heard before the ESTM Committee, would have created the California Toxic Substances Board within DTSC to provide oversight of California's hazardous waste management and the remediation of contaminated sites. This bill was later amended to require the California State University Trustees to oversee a competitive process to award funds to the Wildland and Wildland Urban Interface Wildfire Research Grant Program and appropriate $5 million from the General Fund to the Trustees in order to oversee the program. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 812 (De León, 2014). Would have modified the permitting process and public participation requirements for hazardous waste facilities. Would have established a Bureau of Internal Affairs to oversee DTSC and investigate departmental misconduct and a DTSC Citizen Oversight Committee to receive and review allegations of misconduct. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Environmental Justice Alliance.
California League of Conservation Voters
Californians Against Waste
Center on Race, Poverty & the Environment
Clean Water Action
Natural Resources Defense Council
OPPOSITION:
California Resource Management Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 995
Author:(Ting)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands eligibility for Transitional Housing Program-Plus (THP-Plus) to youth who exited foster care on or after their 16th birthday, requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to, upon appropriation, annually allocate funding to counties for purposes of expanding their existing THP-Plus, and requires counties to enter into memoranda of understanding (MOU) with local Continuums of Care (CoCs) to foster collaboration and communication as a condition of receiving THP-Plus expansion funds.
Major Provisions
- Expands eligibility for THP-Plus by permitting former foster youth to access transitional housing services, as specified, if they exited foster care after their 16th birthday, versus after their 18th birthday, as is current law.
- Requires CDSS to, subject to an appropriation, annually allocate funding to counties to expand their existing THP-Plus to address the unmet housing and service needs of former foster youth, and based on a statewide analysis of unmet need, as specified.
- Defines "continuum of care" (CoC) as a group organized to serve homeless and formerly homeless veterans, and homeless and formerly homeless persons to the extent these groups are represented within the geographic area and are available to participate, as defined in current federal law.
- Defines "coordinated entry system" (CES) as a centralized or coordinated assessment system developed pursuant to current federal law.
- Requires counties, in order to receive THP-Plus expansion funds, to enter into an MOU with the local CoC to foster communication and collaboration, and, further, requires the MOU to include certain processes and information, as specified.
- Specifies that funding received by a county pursuant to the provisions of this bill shall supplement, and not supplant, a county's existing THP-Plus services, as specified.
COMMENTS:
Extended foster care: AB 12 (Beall), Chapter 559, Statutes of 2010, known as the California Fostering Connections to Success Act, extended foster care benefits for eligible youth (referred to as nonminor dependents, or NMDs) aging out of the foster care system. AB 12 provided services and supports to transition-age youth until they reach 21 years of age, and afforded these youth the opportunity to experience independent living in supervised living environments, as well as the ability to obtain educational and employment training to better prepare them to transition into adulthood and self-sufficiency.
Housing needs of foster youth: To provide for the housing needs of current and former foster youth, California provides several housing programs. The Transitional Housing Placement Program (THPP) provides safe living environments to foster youth who are at least 16-years old, but not more than 18-years old, while Transitional Housing Placement Program + Foster Care (THP+FC) provides NMDs with certain placement options based on a Transitional Independent Living Plan (TILP). For former foster youth who are between the ages of 18 and 24, California offers the THP-Plus, which provides youth with up to 24 months of supportive housing while receiving a wide range of supportive services, including job training, educational supports, and counseling.
Need for this bill: Current law requires a youth to have exited foster care on or after their 18th birthday in order to qualify for THP-Plus; the provisions of this bill would expand eligibility for THP-Plus to youth who exited foster care on or after their 16th birthday. The provisions of this bill seek to exercise the state's flexibility in determining eligibility criteria for participation in THP-Plus in order to ensure more youth are eligible to receive THP-Plus services and supports.
According to the Author:
"Nearly 40% of former foster youth will become homeless. To address this vulnerability, in 2011, the California State Legislature created THP-Plus – the state's only housing program for youth transitioning out of foster care. [This bill] will reduce homelessness among former foster youth by building on THPP's success – increasing access to this vital program."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters state that this bill will reduce homelessness among former foster youth by expanding access to THP-Plus and improving the program's coordination with the local homeless response system.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill may result in the following costs: 1) ongoing costs to CDSS of approximately $3 million to expand eligibility to former foster youth who exited the system while aged 16 or 17 years (this assumes approximately 104 young persons will be served at a monthly cost per participant of $2,403. These costs could be significantly higher depending on the actual number of youth served); 2) one-time costs to counties of approximately $1.4 million ($985,000 General Fund [GF]) to establish MOUs with their local CoC (this estimate assumes $25,000 [GF] per county).
VOTES:
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 8-0-0
YES: Reyes, Mathis, Berman, Choi, Friedman, Gipson, Maienschein, Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0000908
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 995
Author:(Ting) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands eligibility for Transitional Housing Program-Plus (THP-P) to any youth who exited foster care on or after the youth’s 16th birthday, requires the California Department of Social Services (DSS) to, upon appropriation, annually allocate funding to counties for purposes of expanding their existing THP-P, and requires counties to enter into memoranda of understanding (MOU) with local Continuums of Care to foster collaboration and communication as a condition of receiving THP-P expansion funds.
This bill also states legislative intent to appropriate $5 million annually to DSS for allocation to counties to augment their existing THP-P programs.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing costs to DSS of approximately $3 million to expand eligibility to former foster youth who exited the system while aged 16 or 17 years. This assumes approximately 104 young persons will be served at a monthly cost per participant of $2,403. These costs could be significantly higher depending on the actual number of youth served.
- One-time costs to counties of approximately $1.4 million ($985,000 GF) to establish MOUs with their local Continuum of Care. This estimate assumes $25,000 (GF) per county.
- Cost pressures to appropriate $5 million (GF) annually to DSS for allocation to counties to augment their existing THP-P.
(The existing program expansion piece of this proposal is also being pursued in the legislative budget process.)
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to provide additional housing options for 16- and 17-year-old former foster youth by lowering the eligible age for THP-P from 18 years of age to 16 years of age. According to the author:
Nearly 40% of former foster youth will become homeless. To address this vulnerability, in 2011, the California State Legislature created THP-P – the state’s only housing program for youth transitioning out of foster care. [This bill] will reduce homelessness among former foster youth by building on THPP’s success – increasing access to this vital program.
- Background. To provide for the housing needs of current and former foster youth, California provides several housing programs. For current foster youth and nonminor dependents (NMDs), the Transitional Housing Placement Program (THPP) provides safe living environments to foster youth who are 16-years to 18-years old, while Transitional Housing Placement Program + Foster Care (THP+FC) provides NMDs with certain placement options based on a Transitional Independent Living Plan.
For former foster youth between the ages of 18 and 24 years, California offers the Transitional Housing Program-Plus (THP-P), which provides youth with up to 24 months of supportive housing while receiving a wide range of supportive services, including job training, educational supports and counseling. Like other programs, acceptable housing for THP-P includes residential units such as apartments, condominiums and college dormitories, but does not include shelters and temporary accommodations with friends or family members.
THP-P is an entirely state-funded program and eligibility criteria are determined entirely by the state. In fiscal year 2017-18, 47 counties operated at least one THP-P program. Statewide, 64% of participants were female, 36% were male and 93% of participants were between 21 and 24 years old.
Existing law requires a youth to have exited foster care on or after the youth’s 18th birthday in order to qualify for THP-P. The provisions of this bill would expand eligibility for THP-P to a youth who exited foster care on or after the youth’s 16th birthday, thereby including certain youth who, for various reasons, exited the foster care system prior to turning 18.
- Youth Homelessness. The 2018 Point-in-Time count conducted by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) found that, on a single night in January 2018, there were approximately 36,391 unaccompanied youth nationwide experiencing homelessness under the age of 25, with one-third of all unaccompanied youth (12,396 individuals) living in California.
Youth who age out of the foster care system are at high risk of becoming homeless. A 2013 study published in the Journal of Public Health found that between 31% and 46% of former foster youth had been homeless at least once by age 26.
- Prior Legislation.
AB 612 (Mitchell), Chapter 731, Statutes of 2017, made a number of changes to the program rules and educational requirements for transitional housing programs available to minors and NMDs in foster care.
SB 1252 (Torres), Chapter 774, Statutes of 2014, authorized a county to choose to extend THP-Plus to former foster youth not more than 25 years of age and for a total of 36 cumulative months if the former foster youth is completing secondary education or is enrolled in an institution that provides postsecondary education.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Eloise Gómez Reyes, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 995 (
Author:Ting) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
SUBJECT: Transitional Housing Program-Plus
SUMMARY: Expands eligibility for Transitional Housing Program-Plus (THPP) to youth who exited foster care on or after their 16th birthday, requires the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to, upon appropriation, annually allocate funding to counties for purposes of expanding their existing THPP, and requires counties to enter into memoranda of understanding (MOU) with local Continuums of Care (CoCs) to foster collaboration and communication as a condition of receiving THPP expansion funds. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands eligibility for THPP by permitting former foster youth to access transitional housing services, as specified, if they exited foster care after their 16th birthday, versus after their 18th birthday as is current law.
- States Legislative intent to appropriate $5 million annually to CDSS for purposes of implementing provisions of this bill requiring an expansion of existing THPP.
- Requires CDSS, beginning in fiscal year 2019-20 and subject to an appropriation by the Legislature, to annually allocate funding to counties to expand their existing THPP to address the unmet housing and service needs of former foster youth, as specified.
- Requires the funds provided pursuant to the provisions of this bill for expansion of THPP to be allocated based on a statewide analysis of unmet need using existing data sources.
- Defines “continuum of care” (CoC) as a group organized to serve homeless and formerly homeless veterans, and homeless and formerly homeless persons to the extent these groups are represented within the geographic area and are available to participate, as defined in current federal law.
- Defines “coordinated entry system (CES)” as a centralized or coordinated assessment system developed pursuant to current federal law.
- Requires counties, in order to receive THPP expansion funds, to enter into an MOU with the local CoC to foster communication and collaboration, and, further, requires the MOU to include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
- A process by which youth who come through the CES are screened for eligibility for extended foster care and THPP;
- A process by which youth exiting THPP and who are in need of ongoing housing support are referred to their local CoC or a local provider authorized to conduct assessments for the CES; and,
- The specification of regular intervals of communication between the county and the CoC.
- Specifies that funding received by a county pursuant to the provisions of this bill shall supplement, and not supplant, a county’s existing THPP services, as specified.
- Makes technical and conforming changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes a state and local system of child welfare services, including foster care, for children who have been adjudged by the court to be at risk or have been abused or neglected, as specified. (Welfare and Institutions Code [WIC] Section 202)
- Provides for extended foster care funding for youth until age 21, as well as adopts other changes to conform to the federal Fostering Connections to Success Act. (WIC 241.1, 303, 366.3, 388, 391, 450, 11400, 11402, 11403)
- Defines “nonminor dependent” as a current or former foster youth who is between 18 and 21 years old, in foster care under the responsibility of the county welfare department, county probation department, or Indian Tribe, and participating in a transitional independent living plan, as specified. (WIC 11400 (v))
- Defines “Transitional Housing Program-Plus” as a provider certified by the applicable county, as specified, to provide transitional housing services to former foster youth who have exited the foster care system on or after their 18th birthday. (WIC 11400 (s))
- Requires CDSS, no later than July 31, 2013, to establish certification standards and procedures for the Transitional Housing Placement program for nonminor dependents, in consultation with various stakeholders, as specified. (WIC 16522 (c))
- Deems certain youth as eligible for transitional housing, including a former foster youth at least 18 years of age and not more than 24 years of age who has exited from the foster care system on or after their 18th birthday and elects to participate in THPP if they have not received certain services for more than a total of 24 months, as specified. (WIC 11403.2 (a)(2))
- Requires a THPP that provides transitional housing services to eligible former foster youth who have exited from the foster care system on or after their 18th birthday be paid a monthly rate that is 70% of the average foster care expenditures for foster youth 16 to 18 years of age, inclusive, in group home care in the county in which the program operates. (WIC 11403 (a)(1)(A))
- Defines “Continuum of Care” as the group organized to carry out certain responsibilities, as specified, and that is composed of representatives of organizations, including nonprofit homeless providers, victim service providers, and faith-based organizations, among others, that serve homeless and formerly homeless veterans, and homeless and formerly homeless persons to the extent these groups are represented within the geographic area and are available to participate. (24 Code of Federal Regulations [CFR] 578.3)
- Requires a CoC to, in consultation with recipients of Emergency Solutions Grants program funds within the geographic area, established and operate either a centralize or coordinated assessment system that provides an initial, comprehensive assessment of the needs of individuals and families for housing and services. (24 CFR 578.7 (a)(8))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Child welfare services: California’s Child Welfare Services (CWS) system exists to protect children from abuse and neglect, and in doing so, provides for their health, safety, and overall well-being. When suspicions of abuse or neglect arise, often as a result of a report by a mandated reporter like a doctor or teacher, Child Protective Services is tasked with investigating the report. If the allegation of abuse or neglect is substantiated, it is then determined whether it is in the best interest of the child to remain in their parent’s custody or be placed within the CWS system. If a child is suspected to be at risk of neglect, abuse, or abandonment, the juvenile court holds legal jurisdiction, and the CWS system appoints a social worker to ensure that the needs of a youth are met. As of October 2018, there were 59,487 youth between the ages of 0 and 21 placed in California’s CWS system.
Extended foster care: AB 12 (Beall), Chapter 559, Statutes of 2010, known as the California Fostering Connections to Success Act, was signed by Governor Schwarzenegger in September 2010 and extended foster care benefits for eligible youth (referred to as nonminor dependents, or NMDs) aging out of the CWS system. Prior to the passage of AB 12, youth aged out of the foster care system at 18-years-old and were instead required to navigate the challenges of young adulthood, including obtaining education, stable housing, and employment, without the support of the CWS system. In recognition of the difficulties faced by these youth, AB 12 provided services and supports to transition-age youth until they reach 21 years of age and afforded these youth the opportunity to experience independent living in supervised living environments and the ability to obtain educational and employment training to better prepare them to transition into adulthood and self-sufficiency.
At the six month hearing prior to a youth turning 18 years old, the youth’s social worker or probation officer must have a plan to ensure that the youth will meet at least one of the following participation criteria:
- Be enrolled in a high school or equivalent program;
- Be enrolled in a college, community college, or vocational program;
- Be employed at least 80 hours a month;
- Participate in a program or activity designed to remove barriers to employment; or,
- Be unable to do one of the above requirements due to a medical condition.
NMDs must also sign an agreement to remain in foster care within six months of turning 18, reside in an eligible placement, and agree to work with their social worker to meet the goals of their transitional living plan.
Youth homelessness: The 2018 Point in Time (PIT) count conducted by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) found that on a single night in January 2018, there were approximately 36,391 unaccompanied youth experiencing homelessness under the age of 25, with one-third of all unaccompanied youth (12,396 individuals) living in California. For youth, homelessness can mean living in cars, shelters, or couch surfing with friends; due to an increased susceptibility to exploitation and violence, youth experiencing homelessness may develop substance use issues or engage in survival sex in exchange for shelter or food.
Youth who age out of the foster care system are at high risk of becoming homeless; a 2013 study published in the Journal of Public Health found that between 31% and 46% of former foster youth had been homeless at least once by age 26. According to the study, the odds of becoming homeless by age 19 were higher for youth who had been physically abused before entering foster care, had run away more than once while in foster care, had engaged in delinquent behaviors, were placed in a group care setting at baseline, and did not feel very close to a biological parent or grandparent.
Addressing homelessness at the local level: The COC Program was designed and is overseen by HUD to provide funding to nonprofit providers and local governments in order to quickly rehouse individuals and families experiencing homelessness. The program seeks to minimize trauma, promote access to services and supports, and eventually enable individuals experiencing homelessness to move towards self-sufficiency and permanent, stable housing. CoCs are required to be comprised of representatives of organizations throughout the community, such as businesses, advocates, public housing, hospitals, social services providers, law enforcement, and affordable housing developers, among others. By bringing together the unique experiences and perspectives of these various agencies, a CoC is able to collaborate to best serve the needs of individuals experiencing homelessness. Tools used by CoCs to address homelessness include the Homeless Management Information System (HMIS), which allows a CoC to collect, store, and report certain information about clients, including the provision of housing and services to individuals and families experiencing homelessness, and CES, which is essentially a network of supportive services developed to ensure individuals experiencing homelessness are quickly assessed for, and referred and connected to, housing needs and supports.
Housing supports specifically for foster-involved youth: To provide for the housing needs of current and former foster youth, California provides several housing programs. The THPP provides safe living environments to foster youth who are at least 16-years old, but not more than 18-years old, while Transitional Housing Placement Program + Foster Care (THP+FC) provides NMDs with certain placement options based on a Transitional Independent Living Plan (TILP).
For former foster youth who are between the ages of 18 and 24, California offers the THPP, which provides youth with up to 24 months of supportive housing while receiving a wide range of supportive services, including job training, educational supports, and counseling. THPP participants are required to be actively pursuing the requirements of their TILP, report any changes in the conditions outlined in the TILP (e.g. a change in address or living arrangement), and, for some youth, must be completing secondary education or be enrolled in a postsecondary institution. Like other programs, acceptable housing for THPP includes residential units such as apartments, condominiums, and college dormitories, and does not include shelters and temporary accommodations with friends or family members.
According to the THP+FC and THP-Plus Annual Report issued by the John Burton Advocates for Youth in October 2018, as of June 30, 2018, there were 1,946 youth served by THPP, which is a 15% increase since Fiscal Year (FY) 2015-16. Since FY 2015-16, three additional counties, including Alameda, San Diego, and San Mateo began operating THPP such that as of FY 2017-18, 47 counties operated at least one THPP program. The report also indicated that spending on THPP has increased by 11% ($2.7 million) from $25.6 million in FY 2014-15 to $28.3 million in FY 2016-17. In FY 2017-18, 64% of participants were female, 36% were male, and 93% of participants were between 21- and 24-years-old.
Need for this bill: Current law requires a youth to have exited foster care on or after their 18th birthday in order to qualify for THPP; the provisions of this bill would expand eligibility for THPP to youth who exited foster care on or after their 16th birthday, thereby capturing certain youth who, for various reasons, exited the foster care system prior to turning 18. It should also be noted that THPP is an entirely state-funded program, meaning eligibility criteria are determined entirely by the state, whereas eligibility for extended foster care, and therefore access to THP+FC, is determined by federal law, which requires a youth to be in foster care on their 18th birthday. The provisions of this bill seek to exercise the state’s flexibility in determining eligibility criteria for participation in THPP in order to ensure more youth are eligible to receive the services and supports provided through the supportive housing program.
According to the author, “Nearly 40% of former foster youth will become homeless. To address this vulnerability, in 2011, the California State Legislature created THPP – the state’s only housing program for youth transitioning out of foster care. [This bill] will reduce homelessness among former foster youth by building on THPP’s success – increasing access to this vital program.”
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 531 (Friedman) of 2019 allows certain approved caregivers to convert to a host family without additional certification, requires counties to examine a county’s ability to meet the emergency housing needs of nonminor dependents, and allows a county welfare agency to, upon appropriation in the annual Budget Act, request funds for the purpose of providing housing navigation services to youth, among other things. AB 531 is currently awaiting hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 612 (Mitchell), Chapter 731, Statutes of 2017, made a number of changes to the program rules and educational requirements for transitional housing programs available to minors and NMDs in foster care.
SB 1252 (Torres), Chapter 774, Statutes of 2014, authorized a county to choose to extend THP-Plus to former foster youth not more than 25 years of age and for a total of 36 cumulative months if the former foster youth is completing secondary education or is enrolled in an institution that provides postsecondary education.
AB 12 (Beall), Chapter 559, Statutes of 2010, the California Fostering Connections to Success Act, enabled youth aging out of foster care to opt into extended foster care between the ages of 18 and 21.
AB 427 (Hertzberg), Chapter 125, Statutes of 2001, established the Foster Youth Transitional Housing Fund to pay for transitional housing costs for foster and emancipated youth.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Advanced Consulting, LLC
Alameda County Office of Education
Alliance for Children's Rights
Alternative Family Services
Aspiranet
Association of Community Human Service Agencies
Berkeley City College
Bill Wilson Center
Boys Republic
Bridge of Faith
Butte College Inspiring Scholars Program
California Alliance of Child and Family Services
California Catholic Conference
Casa de Amparo
Cerritos College
Children Now
Children's Law Center of California
Children's Legal Services of San Diego
County of Butte
County of Humboldt
Covenant Community Services
CSU Bakersfield's Guardian Scholars Program
CSU Chico PATH Scholars Program
Cuyamaca College
David & Margaret Youth and Family Services
Encompass Community Services
Environmental Alternatives
First Place for Youth
Foster Care Counts
Fred Finch Youth Center
iFOSTER
Imperial Valley Regional Occupational Program
Jovenes
Larkin Street Youth Services
Los Angeles Child Guidance Clinic
LSS of Northern California
Maryvale
Mission College
Moreno Valley College
New Alternatives
Olive Crest
On Their Own Transitional Housing
Orange Coast College
Prosperity Way
Redwood Community Action Agency - Youth Services Bureau
Reedley College
Riverside City College
Riverside Community College District
San Joaquin County Independent Living Program
Side By Side
Sonoma County Human Services Department
St. Anne's
Stanislaus County Community Services Agency
Star Vista
The Village Family Services
Uplift Family Services
Victor Valley College
Volunteers of America
Walden Family Services
Whole Person Learning
YMCA of San Diego County, Youth and Family Services
Youth for Change
Youth Services Network
Two private citizens
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):