ACA 11: The Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, and Victims of Wildfire or Natural Disasters Act.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-07-01
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Res. Chapter 31, Statutes of 2020. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 2 p.m. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Page 4954.) |
| Jun 25, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after June 27 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | Read third time. Adopted. (Ayes 29. Noes 5. Page 3847.) |
| Jun 24, 2020 | From committee: Be adopted. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 24). |
| Jun 23, 2020 | From committee: Be adopted, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Re-referred. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 22, 2020 | Joint Rules 61 and 62 suspended. (Ayes 29. Noes 10. Page 3799.) |
| Jun 20, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted, and re-refer to Com. on E. & C.A. Re-referred. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 14). Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F.R. and E. & C.A. |
| May 6, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Adopted. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted. (Ayes 27. Noes 0.) (April 29). |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Referred to Com. on BUDGET. |
| Feb 27, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 29. |
| Feb 26, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 26, 2020 | ACA 11 Mullin Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading ACA11 Mullin et al. By Galgiani | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2020 | Be adopted | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 23, 2020 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2019 | Be adopted, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Elections and Constitutional Amendments] | Senate Standing Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | ACA 11 Obernolte Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2019 | Be adopted. | Assembly Standing Committee on Budget |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | ACA 11 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: ACA 11
Author: Mullin (D), Burke (D), Friedman (D) and Mayes (I), et al.
Amended: 6/20/20 in Senate
Vote: 27
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/23/20
AYES: Umberg, Hertzberg, Leyva, Stern
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 6/24/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: The Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, and Victims of Wildfire or Natural Disasters Act
SOURCE: California Association of Realtors
California Professional Firefighters
DIGEST:
This constitutional amendment, if approved by the voters, allows base year value transfers for replacement properties without regard to the replacement property’s location or value; limits or repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership; directs the Director of the Department of Finance to determine any net revenue gain resulting from these changes; and allocates any revenue gain for fire suppression and to reimburse local agencies for revenue losses.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the California Constitution, that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution.
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is new construction or a change in ownership (Article XIIIA of the Constitution; Proposition 13, 1978).
- Establishes constitutional limits on assessed value inflationary growth of real property to 2% per year.
- Sets, generally, a property’s value as its sales price when purchased or at its fair market value when ownership changes (base year value).
- Requires an annual inflation adjustment to that value that does not exceed 2% (factored base year value), as specified.
- Permits qualified taxpayers to continue to pay property taxes at the factored base year value of his/her previous home (or other property types where the law allows) and not on the value of their newly purchased home, including:
- Taxpayers affected by disasters, defined as damaged by a major misfortune or calamity, and located in an area declared to be in a state of disaster.
- Disabled taxpayers and those over the age of 55, so long as the replacement home is of equal or lesser value and within the same county, or to another county if the incoming county accepts base-year value transfers. State law limits taxpayers to one transfer per lifetime, with one exception.
- Owners of contaminated property, or those displaced by eminent domain, acquisition by public entity, or inverse condemnation.
- Excludes from change-in-ownership reassessment transfers from parents to children for:
- Primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers.
- Up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
- Applies the parent-child exclusion from change-in-ownership to grandparents and grandchildren when all of the parents of that grandchild or those grandchildren, who qualify as the children of the grandparents, are deceased as of the date of the purchase or transfer.
This constitutional amendment:
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to allow base year value transfers for disabled taxpayers and those over the age of 55, as well as a victim of a wildfire or other natural disaster, regardless of the replacement property’s value or location, so long as the replacement property is purchased or constructed within two years of the date the original property is sold. To implement these provisions, the measure:
- Provides that if the replacement property is of equal or lesser value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the original property.
- Provides that if the replacement property is of equal or greater value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the replacement property, plus the difference in value between the sales price of the original property and the sales price of the replacement property is subsequently added to the base year value. For example, if the original property has a base year value of $230,000 sells for $500,000, and the taxpayer purchases a $750,000 replacement property, its new base year value is $480,000 ($750,000 – 500,000 = $250,000 + $230,000 = $480,000).
- Allows disabled taxpayers or those over 55 three transfers. Victims of wildfires and natural disasters default to the current one transfer limit.
- Requires taxpayers to file an application with the assessor to claim a transfer with contents identical to the application for current transfers.
- Applies beginning April 1, 2021.
- Limits the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership of a principal residence only if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee. It further:
- Provides that even if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee, and the property has a current market value of more than $1 million, the exclusion can only reduce assessed value by $1 million. For example, a home with a taxable value of $500,000 that could be sold at the date of transfer for $2 million, would have a new assessed value of $1 million.
- Applies these provisions to family farms, as defined.
- Requires the transferee to claim the homeowners’ or disabled veterans’ at the time of transfer to apply the exclusion. However, a transferee can apply the exclusion up to one year after the purchase or transfer, and receive a refund of previous taxes paid or owed between the date of the transfer and the date they file the claim.
- Directs the State Board of Equalization (BOE) to adjust the $1 million exclusion amount annually for inflation beginning on February 16, 2023.
- Repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion for up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property that is not the principal residence, effective February 15, 2021.
- Allocates any additional revenues or savings to the state to the California Fire Response Fund (CFRF) and the County Revenue Protection Fund, and continuously appropriate moneys to those purposes, as specified, by:
- Deeming the moneys in the fund revenues General Fund Revenues for purposes of the state’s appropriations limit.
- Requiring the Director of Finance to calculate additional revenues and net savings to the state resulting from the measure during the preceding fiscal year each September 1st between 2022 and 2027, as specified.
- Deeming the Director of Finance’s calculation final, and requiring the Director to certify the calculation no later than September 1 of each year.
- Further requiring the Director of Finance to multiply the amount calculated in the previous fiscal year by the increase in property tax revenues allocated to local agencies in that fiscal year, commencing on September 1, 2028, and each September 1 thereafter.
- Requiring the State Controller to transfer 75% of the amount certified by the Director of Finance for the applicable year to the CFRF.
- Directing the State Controller to transfer 15% of the amount to the County Revenue Protection Fund to reimburse counties with “negative gain.”
- Specifying that funds in the CFRF are subject to appropriation by the Legislature as specified. Funds must be used to expand fire suppression staffing in underfunded special districts that provide fire suppression staffing, and must not supplant existing state or local funds utilized for those purposes, and further:
- Allocates 20% to the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection to fund fire suppression staffing.
- Sends 80% to the Special District Fire Response Fund, a subaccount, for districts that provide fire protection services as follows:
- 50% for districts formed after July 1, 1978, and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise at least 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- 25%, for districts formed before July 1, 1978, are underfunded due to a disproportionately low share of property tax revenue and an increase in service level demands since July 1, 1978, and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise at least 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- 25% for districts that provide fire protection services and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise between 30% and 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- Directs the Legislature to take into account the following factors, in order of priority, when determining whether a special district is “underfunded:”
- The degree to which the district’s property tax revenue is insufficient to sustain adequate fire suppression, as measured against the population density, size of the service area, and number of taxpayers within the boundaries of the special district.
- Whether the special district, upon formation, received a property tax allocation in accordance with specified law.
- Geographic diversity.
- Funds be allocated in the form of grants with a term of not less than 10 years.
- That in any fiscal year after the first fiscal year of transfer that the amount transferred from the General Fund to the CFRF exceeds the amount transferred in the previous fiscal year by more than 10%, the State Controller shall not transfer the amount in excess of 10%; instead, the amount remains in the General Fund.
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to:
- Direct counties to annually determine the gain for each county and each local agency within the county as specified.
b) State that counties with a positive gain cannot received funds from the County Revenue Protection Fund, but a county with a negative gain is eligible for those funds.
c) Require the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to determine each eligible local agency’s aggregate gain every three years, based on the amounts determined by the counties, and provide reimbursements, as specified.
d) State at the end of the three-year period, CDTFA must transfer any remaining money from the County Revenue Protection Fund to the General Fund if each local agency that has a negative gain has been reimbursed.
e) Permit CDTFA to issue regulations pursuant to the Administrative Procedures Act to implement ACA 11.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- This constitutional amendment results in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $480,000 to $640,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
- The BOE estimates that the measure’s base year value transfer proposal would result in an average revenue loss of $1,560 per replacement property; the amount of transfers that would occur cannot be determined in advance. BOE indicates that the revenue impact from the measure’s second change, that to the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion, is indeterminable.
- However, the Legislative Analyst’s Office’s analysis of similar proposals indicates that those contained in this measure would result in a net increase in property tax revenue.
- BOE would incur increased administrative costs related to existing databases that would need to be modified to reflect the measure’s proposed changes. The aggregate one-time cost would minimally be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars. BOE’s other administrative costs would be minor and absorbable.
- The CDTFA is in the process of determining the administrative costs to implement its provisions of the measure. However, the resulting costs would be significant, and would come from the General Fund.
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/24/20)
California Association of Realtors (co-source)
California Professional Firefighters (co-source)
California Business Properties Association
California Business Roundtable
California Farm Bureau Federation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/24/20)
Bob Dutton, San Bernardino County Assessor Clerk-Recorder
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
Tom Bordonaro, Jr., San Luis Obispo County Assessor
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In a letter supporting ACA 11, the California Professional Firefighters stated, in part, the following:
ACA 11 is a compromise measure to replace a measure qualified for the November ballot, ensuring that funding for fire protection and local government revenues are protected, and allowing for flexibility and reform in California’s property tax formulas, while leaving the protections of Proposition 13 intact. This measure contains several provisions intended to increase the stock of available housing and provide protections to vulnerable Californians in the housing market, while creating protected funding for underfunded fire districts throughout the state and ensuring that counties and local governments receive equal and equitable funding through the provisions.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In a letter opposing ACA 11, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part, the following:
ACA 11, if approved by the voters on the November 2020 ballot, would limit the ability of parents to transfer their Proposition 13 tax base to their children unless the child decides to live in the home as their primary residence. The measure also eliminates a $1 million property tax exemption for parent to child transfers beyond the primary residence, which could include investment property or commercial buildings. Either of these situations could result in a potentially significant property tax increase of California property owners.
Prepared by: Darren Chesin / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
6/25/20 0:11:01
**** END ****
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:ACA 11
Author:(Mullin, et al.)
As Amended Ver:June 20, 2020
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
If approved by the voters, would enact the "Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, Wildfire and Natural Disasters Act," which allows property tax base year value transfers for replacement properties without regard to the replacement property's location or value; limits or repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership; directs the Director of Finance to determine any state-accrued revenues and savings resulting from these changes; and allocates 75% of that amount for fire suppression staffing and 15% to reimburse eligible local agencies that incur a net revenue loss from this measure's provisions.
The Senate Amendments:
- Delete the Assembly version of this constitutional amendment and, instead:
- Allow, operative April 1, 2021, homeowners who are over 55 years, severely disabled, or the victim of a disaster, to transfer the base year value of their home to a replacement home located anywhere in California that is purchased within 2 years of the sale of their original home.
- Allow homeowners to purchase a replacement home of greater value than their original home, with an additional adjustment to account for the value difference.
- Allow homeowners who are over 55 years or disabled to transfer their base year value up to three times.
- Repeal the existing parent-child and grandparent-grandchild change in ownership exclusion on February 16, 2021.
- Create a new parent-child and grandparent-grandchild change in ownership exclusion that is narrower in scope for transfers occurring on or after February 16, 2021. Specifically, these provisions:
- Allow the exclusion only if the real property is: (1) a family home (or family farm) of the transferor, and (2) the property continues as the family home (or family farm) of the transferee; and,
- Limit the amount of the exclusion to the first $1 million of value that would be added upon reassessment of a family home (or family farm).
- Eliminate the exclusion for all other transfers of real property between parents and children and grandparents and grandchildren, such as rental property, second homes, and commercial property.
- Allow the transferee to receive the property tax benefit of the exclusion by claiming the homeowners' exemption or disabled veterans' exemption at the time of the purchase or transfer of the family home (or family farm) or within one year of the purchase or transfer.
- Establish the California Fire Response Fund to provide fire suppression staffing funding and the County Revenue Protection Fund for the purpose of reimbursing eligible local agencies that incur a net revenue loss related to these property tax provisions.
COMMENTS:
Expanding and restricting property tax benefits: This measure provides additional property tax benefits to eligible homeowners who want to move while eliminating other property tax benefits currently provided to families through the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild change in ownership exclusion. First, this constitutional amendment lifts restrictions to allow more homeowners to take advantage of base year value transfers available under existing law. Second, this constitutional amendment repeals the existing parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion and replaces that exclusion with a narrower exclusion that allows this tax benefit only if the property is a principal residence and the transferee will live in the home as their principal residence (i.e., family home and/or family farm). This constitutional amendment also caps the amount of relief provided to the principal residence according to a formula that limits the amount of the exclusion available to the first $1 million of value that would otherwise be added.
California's property tax system creates a disincentive for homeowners to move because of the resulting Proposition 13 property tax implications: California has an acquisition-value based system that can cause a reduction in mobility; this phenomenon is known as a "moving penalty" or "lock-in effect." Specifically, the current tax system discourages a property owner from moving to a home that better meets their needs because moving to a new property triggers a reassessment of that property to its full market value and, in some cases, substantially higher property taxes than the homeowner previously paid. While existing law offers base year value portability, not all homeowners who would like to move qualify for this tax benefit due to the requirement that the new home be of equal or lesser value and/or they would like to move to a different county where this tax benefit is not offered.
This constitutional amendment allows age 55+ or disabled homeowners, and disaster-impacted homeowners, to move anywhere in California and take their Proposition 13 tax savings with them via a base year value transfer. Currently, age 55+ or disabled homeowners are limited to an once-in-a-lifetime transfer within the county they reside (Proposition 60, 1986) and to 10 other counties that have agreed to participate in this program for out-of-county transfers (Proposition 90, 1998). For disaster-impacted homeowners, 11 counties allow out-of-county transfers. In addition, this constitutional amendment removes the requirement that the new home be of equal-or-lesser value and instead allows an adjustment to add the value difference for a new home of greater value to the transferred base year value. For many existing homeowners, this constitutional amendment removes the consideration of the property tax savings loss from the homeowner's decision-making process to sell their current home and buy a new home.
Existing law allows families to pass down property tax savings that have accrued under Proposition 13: In 1986, the Legislature enacted the parent-child exclusion, which was then approved by voters via Proposition 58 (ACA 2) and in 1996 expanded that exclusion to also include grandparent-grandchild transfers in limited instances via Proposition 193 (ACA 17). In October 2017, the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) published "The Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion," which undertook a detailed review of this tax benefit and indicated that the Legislature may want to revisit the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion and reconsider its desired policy goals. The LAO stated:
The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents' lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner‑occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.
The LAO estimated that the current exclusion applies to between 60,000 and 80,000 properties statewide each year, or about 10% of total property transfers. Additionally, the LAO states that 5% of all property transfers in the state in the last decade have received the exclusion, the vast majority of which are single-family homes. The LAO explains that the inheritance exclusions appear to be encouraging children to hold on to their parents' homes to use as rentals or for other purposes instead of putting them on the market. The LAO notes that this could be exacerbating challenges for home buyers created by the state's tight housing markets and states on net, the shift of homes from the for‑sale market to the rental market likely results in fewer Californians being homeowners and more being renters.
Limiting the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion to family homes used as a primary residence for continued use as a primary residence: This constitutional amendment limits the exclusion on primary residences to require a child or grandchild who inherits a family home to actually live in the home in order to enjoy this tax benefit. If this condition is not met, then the former family home would be reassessed to its current market value. This constitutional amendment also eliminates the exclusion on all other property transfers. Under current law, up to $1 million in other property that is not the principal residence qualifies for the exclusion and no value limit applies to the principal residence. Under this constitutional amendment, children or grandchildren inheriting real property that is a rental property, second home, or commercial property may find it necessary to sell the property if they cannot afford to pay property taxes based on current market value.
The California Fire Response Fund and the County Revenue Protection Fund: This constitutional amendment directs the Director of Finance (DOF) to determine any state-accrued revenues and savings resulting from this measure's changes assuming that income tax revenues will increase related to additional sales of property and assuming that the state's funding obligation to schools will decrease as a result of increased property tax revenue. The income tax component would appear difficult for the DOF to determine, lacking any reporting requirements, and this constitutional amendment requires the DOF to use actual data or best available estimates where actual data is not available.
The two funds this constitutional amendment creates would be supported by a transfer from the General Fund based on the DOF's calculations noted above, with 75% to the California Fire Response Fund and 15% to the County Revenue Protection Fund. The funds in the California Fire Response Fund are subject to appropriation by the Legislature according to a specified methodology, which states funds must be used to expand fire suppression staffing in underfunded special districts that provide fire suppression staffing, and must not supplant existing state or local funds utilized for those purposes.
Related to the County Revenue Protection Fund, this constitutional amendment directs counties and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to determine this measure's revenue impact for each of California's 58 counties, 482 cities, and 2,300 special districts, which will be cumbersome. This measure intends to provide a mechanism to counteract an overall negative financial impact to any local agency by directing the CDTFA to reimburse each agency that incurs a "negative gain" from this fund. However, if there are insufficient moneys in the fund to cover the total amount of reimbursements, eligible local agencies would receive only a pro-rata distribution. Reimbursements would be provided on a three-year cycle. Counties would incur ongoing administrative responsibilities and associated costs to track the revenue impact from implementing this measure's changes. Related to the parent-child exclusion, calculating the revenue gain from this provision could be challenging where this measure eliminates the exclusion, since no claim would be filed to identify the family relationship. Thus, counties and CDTFA may lack the data needed to accurately calculate these gains.
Sponsors: This constitutional amendment is sponsored by the California Association of Realtors and the California Professional Firefighters.
According to the Author:
The author notes the following in support of this constitutional amendment:
ACA 11 seeks to provide much needed housing relief for our state's most vulnerable populations, while also creating a stable revenue source for both Special Districts that provide fire protection and local governments to improve services to their communities.
ACA 11 seeks to replace the ballot measure entitled "Changes Requirements for Transferring Property Tax Base to Replacement Property. Expands Business Property Reassessment. Initiative Constitutional Amendment," which became eligible for the November General Election February 2020.
ACA 11 continues to protect seniors, persons with disabilities, families, and victims of wildfire by limiting property tax increases on primary residences, as originally intended under Propositions 60 and 90, and Propositions 58 and 193. ACA 11 also expands these protections to include wildfire victims and removes unfair location restrictions from Propositions 60 and 90. Removing these restrictions will allow our most vulnerable residents to move closer to family or medical care, to a senior or retirement community, or to replace a damaged home anywhere within California.
ACA 11 also protects the Constitutional right of parents and grandparents to pass the family home to their children, ensuring that their heirs can afford to move into that home as their primary residence.
Out-of-state investors, non-California residents, and trust fund heirs have used Propositions 58 and 193 on vacation homes, investment property, and beachfront rentals. By closing these unintended loopholes, the state will be able to generate hundreds of millions of dollars for local governments to fund fire protection, emergency services, and other critical local programs to support the homeless and provide mental health services or to help fund the development of new affordable housing projects throughout California.
California's persistent housing shortage, which places an upward pressure on housing costs, has created an unprecedented affordability crisis for California's working families. The state has the 49th lowest ratio of housing units per resident and our state's vacancy rate in 2019 was just 4.4%. Home purchase prices and rents statewide continue to rise faster than wages, which results in housing costs making up a greater percentage of a family's monthly budget. ACA 11 will open up tens of thousands of new housing opportunities throughout California for renters and first-time homeowners. As a result of increased demand, ACA 11 will spur housing construction at all income levels to accommodate the demand for housing statewide.
By ending a tax benefit for converting inherited properties into rental properties, ACA 11 could help ameliorate the state's affordable housing crisis by ending the significant incentive to hold these properties off the home sales market.
Arguments in Support:
ACA 11 is a compromise measure to replace a measure qualified for the November ballot, ensuring that funding for fire protection and local government revenues are protected, and allowing for flexibility and reform in California's property tax formulas, while leaving the protections of Proposition 13 intact. This measure contains several provisions intended to increase the stock of available housing and provide protections to vulnerable Californians in the housing market, while creating protected funding for underfunded fire districts throughout the state and ensuring that counties and local governments receive equal and equitable funding through the provisions.
Arguments in Opposition:
ACA 11, if approved by the voters on the November 2020 ballot, would limit the ability of parents to transfer their Proposition 13 tax base to their children unless the child decides to live in the home as their primary residence. The measure also eliminates a $1 million property tax exemption for parent to child transfers beyond the primary residence, which could include investment property or commercial buildings. Either of these situations could result in a potentially significant property tax increase of California property owners.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this constitutional amendment will have the following fiscal effect:
- One-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State in the hundreds of thousands of dollars for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot. Over the last three election cycles, the printing and mailing costs per page averaged around $80,000.
- Additional state and local fiscal effects should California voters approve this measure. These costs include:
- Annual property tax losses in the range of tens of millions of dollars to more than $100 million because of an increase in the number of base year transfers. It is unknown how many homeowners over the age of 55 would qualify for a base year transfer under the additional eligibility standards established by this measure. Approximately 80,000 homeowners move to different houses each year without receiving a property tax break, and some share of these homeowners would benefit from this measure. Moreover, property tax revenue losses would be greater in years when significant wildfire events or other natural disasters adversely affect a large number of homeowners. Property tax losses will vary significantly by county.
- Annual property tax revenue gains in the range of tens of millions of dollars to hundreds of millions of dollars because of the narrowed inheritance exclusion. Each year between 60,000 and 80,000 inherited properties are excluded from reassessment, and this measure would require reassessment on some portion of these properties. Property tax gains will vary significantly by county.
- An unknown impact on state revenues and expenditures. This measure is likely to increase home sales, thereby increasing income tax revenues by an unknown amount. Moreover, an increase in property tax revenue going to schools will decrease state funding for schools by a corresponding amount.
- An increase in General Fund costs to support the California Fire Response Fund and the County Revenue Protection Fund. The amount transferred to both funds would depend on this measure's impact on state revenues and savings. As indicated above, the net state fiscal effect is unknown and would need to be calculated by DOF. However, it is likely this measure will lead to a transfer of at least tens of millions of dollars each year.
VOTES:
ASM BUDGET: Vote not relevant
YES:
ABS, ABST OR NV:
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Vote not relevant
YES:
ABS, ABST OR NV:
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 20, 2020
CONSULTANT: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0003154
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
ACA 11 (Mullin) - The Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, and Victims of Wildfire or Natural Disasters Act
Version: | Policy Vote: E. & C.A. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
ACA 11 would, if approved by the voters, (1) allow specified base year value transfers for replacement properties without regard to their location or value, (2) limit or repeal the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership, (3) direct the Director of Finance to determine any net revenue gain resulting from these changes, and (4) allocate any revenue gain for fire suppression and to reimburse local agencies for revenue losses.
Fiscal Impact:
- This measure would result in one-time General Fund costs to the Secretary of State (SOS) in the range of $480,000 to $640,000, likely in 2020-21, for printing and mailing costs to place the measure on the ballot in a statewide election. Actual costs may be higher or lower, depending on the length of required elements and the overall size of the ballot.
- The Board of Equalization (BOE) estimates that the measure’s base year value transfer proposal would result in an average revenue loss of $1,560 per replacement property; the amount of transfers that would occur cannot be determined in advance. BOE indicates that the revenue impact from the measure’s second change, that to the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion, is indeterminable.
- However, the Legislative Analyst’s Office’s (LAO) analysis of similar proposals indicates that those contained in this measure would result in a net increase in property tax revenue (see Staff Comments).
- BOE would incur increased administrative costs related to existing databases that would need to be modified to reflect the measure’s proposed changes. The aggregate one-time cost would minimally be in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars. BOE’s other administrative costs would be minor and absorbable.
- The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) is in the process of determining the administrative costs to implement its provisions of the bill. However, the resulting costs would be significant, and would come from the General Fund (see Staff Comments).
Background:
The California Constitution provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law. Specifically, under Proposition 13 (1978), the Constitution (1) limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1 percent of full cash value, and (2) directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is a change in ownership. Proposition 13 also set a constitutional limit on assessed value inflationary growth of real property of two percent per year. A property’s Proposition 13 protected value is referred to as its "base year value."
By its design, Proposition 13 provides property owners in California with substantial protections from higher property tax rates and annual reassessments. However, because it generally set a property’s taxable value at its aforementioned purchase price plus growth of up to two percent annually, taxpayers who sell their homes and subsequently purchase new ones will likely pay higher property taxes, thereby creating a tax disincentive on those seeking to acquire new housing. In other words, because real estate values generally appreciate at a rate greater than two percent per year, when an event occurs triggering a reassessment of property to its current market value, the reassessed value (i.e., its new base-year value) and resulting property tax owed will likely be higher.
In response, current property tax law provides for various situations where the base-year value of a property is either: (1) retained, notwithstanding that new construction has taken place or that the property has changed ownership, or (2) transferred to another property, notwithstanding that the property has changed ownership. These special situations are (1) provided pursuant to various constitutional amendments modifying the original Proposition 13 framework, and (2) serve to avoid the otherwise required reassessment of a property to its current market value. Base-year value transfer benefits taxpayers according to both the amount of time they have lived in their current residences (which generally results in a difference between assessed value for tax purposes and market value that grows each year due Proposition 13’s two percent cap on assessed valuation growth), and the purchase price of the replacement.
The Legislature specifically enacted two such change in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and then grandparents and grandchildren, which were then approved by voters. Proposition 58 (1986) exempted from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children, which voters subsequently extended to grandchildren a decade later (Proposition 193), so long as the grandparent is deceased. These exclusions apply to all inherited primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers. They also apply to up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
In 1986, voters amended the California Constitution by passing Proposition 56 to allow base-year value transfers for certain disasters. Current law allows the transfer when, among other things, (1) the property sustains physical damage amounting to more than 50 percent of its full cash value immediately prior to the disaster, (2) the replacement property is located in the same county as the damaged property and is acquired or newly constructed within five years after the disaster, and is comparable to the damaged property in size, utility, and function, and (3) the market value of the replacement property does not exceed 120 percent of the fair market value of the replaced property in its pre-damaged condition.
In 1993, voters passed Proposition 171, which additionally allowed taxpayers to transfer base -ear values to other counties when their property is damaged by a major misfortune or calamity and located in an area declared by the Governor to be in a state of disaster. However, this proposition only allowed transfers to other counties for a taxpayer’s principal place of residence, and solely when the board of supervisors in the county where the replacement property is located has adopted an ordinance making this benefit available. Additionally, replacement homes must be purchased within three years rather than five years. Eleven counties have such an ordinance
In November 1986, voters approved Proposition 60 to amend the Constitution to let homeowners over the age of 55 transfer their base-year value to a replacement home of equal or lesser value within the same county under specified circumstances.
Two years later, in November 1988, voters expanded base-year value transfer availability to allow transfers to counties that adopt ordinances allowing the transfer (inter-county transfers). In 2018, ten counties allowed these out-of-county transfers.
Proposed Law:
This measure, if approved by the voters, would do the following:
- Create a new section of the California Constitution, beginning on April 1, 2021, to allow base-year value transfers for disabled taxpayers, those over the age of 55, and victims of a wildfire or other natural disaster, regardless of the replacement property’s value or location, so long as the replacement property is purchased or constructed within two years of the date the original property is sold, as specified. To implement these provisions, the measure, among other things, would:
- Provide that if the replacement property is of equal or lesser value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the original property.
- Provide that if the replacement property is of equal or greater value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the replacement property, plus the difference in value between the sales price of the original property and the sales price of the replacement property.
- Allow disabled taxpayers or those over 55 three such transfers. Victims of wildfires and natural disasters would default to the current one transfer limit.
- Create a new section of the California Constitution to limit the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership of a principal residence only if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee. The new section further (1) provides that if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee, and the property has a current market value of more than $1 million, the exclusion can only reduce assessed value by $1 million, (2) applies these provisions to family farms, as defined, (3) directs BOE to adjust the $1 million exclusion amount annually for inflation beginning on February 16, 2023, as specified, and (4) repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion for up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property that is not the principal residence, effective February 15, 2021.
- Create a new section of the California Constitution to allocate any additional revenues or savings to the state to the California Fire Response Fund and the County Revenue Protection Fund, and continuously appropriate moneys to those purposes, as specified. The new section would implement these provisions by: (1) deeming the moneys in the fund revenues General Fund Revenues for purposes of the state’s appropriations limit, (2) requiring the Director of Finance to calculate additional revenues and net savings to the state resulting from the measure during the preceding fiscal year each September 1st between 2022 and 2027 using the best data or available estimates if data is not available, (3) further requiring the Director of Finance to multiply the amount calculated in the previous fiscal year by the increase in property tax revenues allocated to local agencies in that fiscal year, commencing on September 1, 2028, and each September 1 thereafter, (4) directing the State Controller to transfer 75 percent of the amount certified by the Director of Finance for the applicable year to the California Fire Response Fund, and to transfer 15 percent of the amount to the County Revenue Protection Fund to reimburse counties with “negative gain,” and (5) specifying funds in the California Fire Response Fund are subject to appropriation by the Legislature according to a specified methodology, which states funds must be used to expand fire suppression staffing in underfunded special districts that provide fire suppression staffing, and must not supplant existing state or local funds utilized for those purposes, as directed.
- Create a new section of the California Constitution to direct counties to annually determine the gain for each county and each local agency within the county, as specified.
Counties with a positive gain cannot received funds from the County Revenue Protection Fund, but a county with a negative gain is eligible for those funds.
CDTFA would be required to determine each eligible local agency’s aggregate gain every three years, based on the amounts determined by the counties, and provide reimbursements. However, if there are insufficient moneys in the fund, CDTFA allocates available funds based on each local agency’s pro rata share based on that agency’s reimbursement as a percentage of total reimbursements. At the end of the three-year period, CDTFA must transfer any remaining money from the County Revenue Protection Fund to the General Fund if each local agency that has a negative gain has been reimbursed.
Related Legislation:
- SCA 2 (Galgiani) is substantially similar to this measure, and is currently pending in the Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee.
- SCA 3 (Hill, 2019) would provide that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion only apply when only the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence. The measure is currently on the inactive file on the Senate Floor.
- SCA 4 (Galgiani, 2019) would (1) expand the Constitution’s current base-year value transfer authority, and (2) limit the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild transfers in a similar but not identical way as this measure. The measure is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
Staff Comments:
SOS indicates that printing and mailing costs associated with placing a measure on the statewide ballot are approximately $80,000 per page, depending on the length of the ballot. The fiscal estimates noted above reflect the addition of 6-8 pages in the Voter Information Guide. Actual costs would depend upon the length of the title and summary, analysis by the LAO, proponent and opponent arguments, and text of the proposal.
BOE would incur increased administrative costs as a result of the measure. These costs largely reflect needed database changes. Specifically, BOE maintains a database that tracks the one-time-only base-year transfer limitation, and would incur one-time costs of up to $53,000 to reprogram this database, if tracking will be required to ensure that the base year value from the original property is not transferred more than three times. Additionally, BOE maintains a second database that tracks a transferor's $1 million lifetime limit for property other than principal residences. BOE would incur costs to reprogram this database if a limitation is placed on a transferor's ability to use the principal residence exclusion; the magnitude of the costs is still being determined. Finally, BOE would also incur absorbable costs to update forms, publications, and its website, and address ongoing implementation issues.
BOE notes that the precise revenue impact of the measure’s changes is difficult to estimate. As noted previously, the measure allows three base-year value transfers for homeowners over 55, disabled or victims of a Governor-declared disaster to a replacement home anywhere in California and of any value. BOE indicates that these changes to existing law would likely result in significantly more claims granted annually; however, the magnitude of the increase in unknown. As an alternative, BOE has calculated the average revenue impact for every additional claim granted.
Specifically, BOE begins by utilizing California Association of Realtors data. In May 2020, the statewide median home price was $588,000. BOE’s own data indicates that the average assessed value of a property receiving the homeowners’ exemption in 2019-20 was $432,000. Therefore, where the transfer is granted, the estimated amount of assessed value difference per home on average is $156,000. Thus, at the basic one percent property tax rate, the revenue loss would be $1,560 per replacement home.
BOE indicates that the revenue of impact of the measure’s other major change is indeterminable. Specifically, its Property Tax Department data indicates that there are 64,000 parent/child and grandparent/grandchild claims granted on average annually. However, BOE cannot determine (1) the values of the properties transferred, (2) which transferred homes subsequently became the transferees' primary residence, or (3) how many properties were considered "other real property" (whose exclusion would be eliminated under the proposal). Consequently, BOE concludes that the revenue impact of this proposed change made by ACA 11 is indeterminable.
Thus, the revenue impacts of this measure’s two major changes (expanding base-year value transfers and narrowing the inheritance reassessment exclusion) are at least partially offsetting. In other words, the former would lead to a reduction in property tax revenues, while the latter result in an increase in such revenues. BOE does not arrive at a conclusion regarding the net impact of the two changes taken together.
However, the LAO has completed an analysis of an initiative with similar proposals, one that has already qualified for the November, 2020 ballot. The LAO concludes that, overall, the provisions in ACA 11 would lead to an increase in revenues.
The LAO concludes that, since the measure would narrow the inheritance reassessment exclusion, it would result in more properties being reassessed at that time. The LAO estimates that under current law, between 60,000 and 80,000 inherited properties statewide are excluded from reassessment each year. Its research indicates that roughly two-thirds of these properties are not used as primary residences. Further, the LAO calculates that roughly one-fifth of the tax benefit on inherited primary residences went to those who received a benefit greater than $1 million. Both of these types of inherited properties would experience an increase in their taxable value under ACA 11. This suggests the measure could lead to increases in property tax payments for up to 60,000 properties each year, which, in turn would increase property tax revenues for local governments. In the first few years, the LAO estimates that schools and other local governments each probably would gain over $100 million per year. Over time, these gains would increase, resulting in schools and other local governments each eventually gaining about $1 billion per year.
In contrast, the LAO estimates that expanding opportunities for base-year transfers would reduce property tax revenues. The changes to the special rules for eligible homeowners could have multiple specific effects on property tax revenue:
- Currently, roughly 80,000 homeowners who are over 55 move to different houses each year without receiving a property tax break; most of them pay higher property taxes as a result. Under this measure, these individuals could apply for a lower property tax bill, which would reduce property tax revenue. The magnitude of the revenue reduction would depend on what share of eligible movers apply to use the special rules.
- As noted previously this measure would cause more people to sell their homes and buy different homes because it gives them a tax incentive to do so. The LAO notes that number of movers could increase by a few tens of thousands. More people being interested in buying and selling homes would have an effect on home prices and home building, which in turn would produce more property tax revenue.
The LAO calculates that the revenue losses from people who would have moved anyway would exceed the gains from higher home prices and home building. Thus, this portion of the measure would reduce property taxes for local governments. In the first few years, the LAO calculates that schools and other local governments each probably would annually lose tens of millions of dollars. Over time, these losses would grow, resulting in schools and other local governments each losing hundreds of million dollars per year.
Thus like BOE, the LAO estimates that some parts of ACA 11 would decrease property tax revenues for local governments, while other parts would increase them. Overall, the LAO notes that it is likely that revenue gains would exceed revenue losses. In the first few years, local governments collectively could gain tens of millions of dollars annually, reaching a few hundred million dollars per year over time.
Additionally, since the measure would increase home sales, it also likely would increase the number of taxpayers required to pay income taxes on the profits from the sale of their homes. The LAO calculates that this effect would increase state income tax revenues by tens of millions of dollars per year.
As noted above, the measure would require CDTFA to (1) determine each eligible local agency’s aggregate gain every three years, based on the amounts determined by the counties, and (2) provide reimbursements. The department was created in 2017 to administer the non-Constitutional functions of BOE. Consequently, CDTFA’s primary expertise lies elsewhere other than property tax functions, and department staff likely do not possess the experience to determine ACA 11’s revenue effects for all of California’s local agencies.
Also as noted above, the measure would require the Department of Finance to calculate the state revenue benefit from its provisions. While, again, it is likely that additional income tax revenues would result, for any individual taxpayer, it would be difficult to calculate the marginal impact (the additional amount of tax revenue relative to what would have occurred absent ACA 11).
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: ACA Hearing Date: 6/23/20
Author: | |||
Version: | 6/20/20 | ||
Urgency: |
| Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Colin Grinnell | ||
Subject: The Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, and Victims of Wildfire or Natural Disasters Act
DIGEST
This measure, if approved by the voters, would enact the “Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, Wildfire and Natural Disasters Act,” which allows base year value transfers for replacement properties without regard to the replacement property’s location or value; limits or repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership; directs the Director of Finance to determine any net revenue gain resulting from these changes; and allocates any revenue gain for fire suppression and to reimburse local agencies for revenue losses.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law (Article XIII of the California Constitution).
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to set assessed values at 1975 market value levels and only reappraise property thereafter if there is new construction or a change in ownership (Article XIIIA of the Constitution; Proposition 13, 1978).
- Establishes constitutional limits on assessed value inflationary growth of real property to 2% per year.
- Generally sets a property’s value as its sales price when purchased or, when there is no sales price, at its fair market value when ownership changes (base year value).
- Requires an annual inflation adjustment to that value that does not exceed 2% (factored base year value), based upon the California Consumer Price Index for all items as calculated by the Department of Industrial Relations.
- Permits qualified taxpayers to continue to pay property taxes at the factored base year value of his/her previous home (or other property types where the law allows) and not on the value of their newly purchased home, including:
- Taxpayers affected by disasters, defined as damaged by a major misfortune or calamity, and located in an area declared to be in a state of disaster by the Governor.
- Disabled taxpayers and those over the age of 55, so long as the replacement home is of equal or lesser value and within the same county, or to another county if the incoming county enacts an ordinance accepting base-year value transfers. State law limits taxpayers to one transfer per lifetime, with one exception.
- Owners of contaminated property, or those displaced by eminent domain, acquisition by public entity, or inverse condemnation.
- Excludes from change-in-ownership reassessment transfers from parents to children for:
- Primary residences, regardless of value or number of transfers.
- Up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property, such as second homes or business properties.
- Applies the parent-child exclusion from change-in-ownership to grandparents and grandchildren when all of the parents of that grandchild or those grandchildren, who qualify as the children of the grandparents, are deceased as of the date of the purchase or transfer.
This bill:
- Enacts the “Home Protection for Seniors, Severely Disabled, Families, Wildfire and Natural Disasters Act.”
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to allow base year value transfers for disabled taxpayers and those over the age of 55, as well as a victim of a wildfire or other natural disaster, regardless of the replacement property’s value or location, so long as the replacement property is purchased or constructed within two years of the date the original property is sold. To implement these provisions, the measure:
- Provides that if the replacement property is of equal or lesser value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the original property.
- Provides that if the replacement property is of equal or greater value of the original property, its taxable value is equal to that of the replacement property, plus the difference in value between the sales price of the original property and the sales price of the replacement property is subsequently added to the base year value. For example, if the original property has a base year value of $230,000 sells for $500,000, and the taxpayer purchases a $750,000 replacement property, its new base year value is $480,000 ($750,000 – 500,000 = $250,000 + $230,000 = $480,000).
- Allows disabled taxpayers or those over 55 three transfers. Victims of wildfires and natural disasters default to the current one transfer limit.
- Requires taxpayers to file an application with the assessor to claim a transfer with contents identical to the application for current transfers.
- Applies beginning April 1, 2021.
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to limit the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership of a principal residence only if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee. The new section further:
- Provides that even if the property continues as the primary residence of the transferee, and the property has a current market value of more than $1 million, the exclusion can only reduce assessed value by $1 million. For example, a home with a taxable value of $500,000 that could be sold at the date of transfer for $2 million, would have a new assessed value of $1 million.
- Applies these provisions to family farms, as defined.
- Requires the transferee to claim the homeowners’ or disabled veterans’ at the time of transfer to apply the exclusion. However, a transferee can apply the exclusion up to one year after the purchase or transfer, and receive a refund of previous taxes paid or owed between the date of the transfer and the date they file the claim.
- Directs the State Board of Equalization (BOE) to adjust the $1 million exclusion amount annually for inflation beginning on February 16, 2023.
- Repeals the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion for up to $1 million in aggregate value of all other types of property that is not the principal residence, effective February 15, 2021.
- Defines several terms.
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to allocate any additional revenues or savings to the state to the California Fire Response Fund and the County Revenue Protection Fund, and continuously appropriate moneys to those purposes, as specified. The new section implements these provisions by:
- Deeming the moneys in the fund revenues General Fund Revenues for purposes of the state’s appropriations limit.
- Requiring the Director of Finance to calculate additional revenues and net savings to the state resulting from the measure during the preceding fiscal year each September 1st between 2022 and 2027 using the best data or available estimates if data is not available.
- Deeming the Director of Finance’s calculation final, and requiring the Director to certify the calculation no later than September 1 of each year.
- Further requiring the Director of Finance to multiply the amount calculated in the previous fiscal year by the increase in property tax revenues allocated to local agencies in that fiscal year, commencing on September 1, 2028, and each September 1 thereafter.
- Directing the Controller to transfer 75% of the amount certified by the Director of Finance for the applicable year to the California Fire Response Fund.
- Directing the Controller to transfer 15% of the amount to the County Revenue Protection Fund to reimburse counties with “negative gain.”
- Specifying that funds in the California Fire Response Fund are subject to appropriation by the Legislature according to a specified methodology, which states funds must be used to expand fire suppression staffing in underfunded special districts that provide fire suppression staffing, and must not supplant existing state or local funds utilized for those purposes, and further:
- Allocates 20% to the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection to fund fire suppression staffing.
- Sends 80% to the Special District Fire Response Fund, a subaccount, for districts that provide fire protection services in accordance with the following criteria:
- 50% for districts formed after July 1, 1978, and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise at least 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- 25%, for districts formed before July 1, 1978, are underfunded due to a disproportionately low share of property tax revenue and an increase in service level demands since July 1, 1978, and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise at least 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- 25% for districts that provide fire protection services and employ full-time or full-time-equivalent station-based personnel who are immediately available to comprise between 30% and 50% of an initial full alarm assignment.
- Directs the Legislature to take into account the following factors, in order of priority, when determining whether a special district is “underfunded:”
- The degree to which the district’s property tax revenue is insufficient to sustain adequate fire suppression, as measured against the population density, size of the service area, and number of taxpayers within the boundaries of the special district.
- Whether the special district, upon formation, received a property tax allocation in accordance with Chapter 282 of the Statutes of 1979.
- Geographic diversity.
- Funds be allocated in the form of grants with a term of not less than 10 years.
- That in any fiscal year after the first fiscal year of transfer that the amount transferred from the General Fund to the California Fire Response Fund exceeds the amount transferred in the previous fiscal year by more than 10%, the Controller shall not transfer the amount in excess of 10%; instead, the amount remains in the General Fund.
- Creates a new section of the California Constitution to:
- Direct counties to annually determine the gain for each county and each local agency within the county by:
- Adding the additional revenues from reassessments of original residents of outgoing transfers authorized by ACA 11, then
- Subtracting revenue decrease resulting from incoming transfers from other counties, and then
- Adding revenue resulting from ACA 11’s changes to the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership.
- Direct counties to annually determine the gain for each county and each local agency within the county by:
b) State that counties with a positive gain cannot received funds from the County Revenue Protection Fund, but a county with a negative gain is eligible for those funds.
c) Require the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to determine each eligible local agency’s aggregate gain every three years, based on the amounts determined by the counties, and provide reimbursements. However, if there are insufficient moneys in the fund, CDTFA allocates available funds based on each local agency’s pro rata share based on that agency’s reimbursement as a percentage of total reimbursements.
d) State at the end of the three-year period, CDTFA must transfer any remaining money from the County Revenue Protection Fund to the General Fund if each local agency that has a negative gain has been reimbursed.
e) Permit CDTFA to issue regulations pursuant to the Administrative Procedures Act to implement ACA 11.
- Defines several terms.
- Makes legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
BACKGROUND
Base year value transfers. Proposition 13 provided property owners in California with substantial protections from higher property tax rates and annual reassessments. However, because the initiative generally set a property’s taxable value at its purchase price plus growth of up to 2% per year, taxpayers who sold their homes and purchased new ones will likely pay higher property taxes, thereby levying a tax penalty on those seeking to acquire housing that more closely meet their demands. For example, a four-bedroom single family home may be more house than an empty-nest couple needs, but purchasing a two-bedroom condominium may lead to a tax increase, especially if the taxpayer’s current home has appreciated in value significantly during the time they owned it. Proposition 60 and 90 removed that incentive and allowed persons over 55 and the disabled to move without the tax consequence, so long as the value of the replacement home met the definition of “equal or lesser value” in statute.
Base year value transfer benefits taxpayers according to (1) the amount of time they have lived in their current residences, which generally results in a difference between assessed value for tax purposes and market value that grows each year due Proposition 13’s 2% cap on assessed valuation growth, and (2) the purchase price of the replacement. If the taxpayer’s home has appreciated in value, the higher the price of the replacement property can be under the current 110% if 2 years % restriction and still be eligible for a transfer. For example, a taxpayer who purchased their residence for $100,000 in 1975 now has a base year value under Proposition 13 that cannot exceed $230,000 under the 2% cap, regardless of its current market value. If that taxpayer sold their residence for $400,000 and purchased a new one for $440,000, a base year value transfer allows them to continue to pay property taxes based on the $230,000 value, not $440,000, which at the 1% rate results in $2,100 in annual tax savings ($440,000 - $230,000 = $210,000 x 1% = $2,100).
In June 1986, voters amended the California Constitution to allow base year values transfers for certain disasters (Proposition 50, 1986). Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) §69 implements Proposition 50 to allow the transfer when:
- The damaged property sustains physical damages amounting to more than 50% of its full cash value immediately prior to the disaster;
- The replacement property is located in the same county as the damaged property and is acquired or newly constructed within five years after the disaster;
- The replacement property is comparable to the damaged property in size, utility, and function. For example, a residential property can be replacement property for a damaged residence, but not for a commercial, agricultural, or industrial property;
- The market value of the replacement property does not exceed 120% of the fair market value of the replaced property in its pre-damaged condition. Property owners can still receive the disaster relief in cases where the value of the replacement property exceeds the 120% limitation, but any amount over this threshold is assessed at full market value and added to the transferred base year value; and,
- The buyer of the replacement property was the owner of the damaged property at the time of damage.
Homes only. In November 1993, voters additionally allowed taxpayers to transfer base year values to other counties when their property is damaged by a major misfortune or calamity and located in an area declared to be in a state of disaster by the Governor (Proposition 171). However, Proposition 171 only allowed transfers to other counties for a taxpayer’s principal place of residence, and solely when the board of supervisors in the county where the replacement property is located has adopted an ordinance making this benefit available. Additionally, replacement homes must be purchased within three years rather than five years. Eleven counties have such an ordinance: Contra Costa, Los Angeles, Modoc, Orange, San Diego, San Francisco, Santa Clara, Solano, Sonoma, Sutter, and Ventura. Revenue and Taxation Code §69.3 implements Proposition 171's provisions for base year value transfers for out-of-county replacement homes.
In November 1986, voters approved Proposition 60 to amend the Constitution to let a homeowner over the age of 55 transfer his/her base year value to a base year value to a replacement home of equal or lesser value within the same county under specified circumstances.
Two years later, in November 1988, voters expanded base year value transfer availability to allow transfers to counties that adopt ordinances allowing the transfer (intercounty transfers). In 2018, ten counties allowed these out-of-county transfers: Alameda, Los Angeles, Orange, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, San Mateo, Santa Clara, Tuolumne, and Ventura. (Proposition 90, 1988). In June 1990, voters approved Proposition 110 to allow disabled individuals regardless of age to transfer base year values to a purchased or newly constructed replacement property. (Proposition 110, 1990).
R&TC §69.5 provides further details to implement all three propositions for individuals over the age of 55 and disabled persons. Among the conditions, the property must be eligible for the homeowners’ exemption, and the replacement property must be purchased or newly constructed within two years of the sale of the original property. This law limits base year value transfers to one per taxpayer; however, the Legislature added a sole exception to the one-time limit for a taxpayer who claims the benefit first as a person 55 years of age or older, and subsequently becomes disabled (SB 1692 (Petris), Chapter 897, Statutes of 1996). In that case, the taxpayer can transfer the base year value from the original home twice; however, the law does not similarly treat a taxpayer who initially claims the transfer a disabled person cannot then subsequently claim another benefit after they turn 55. The Legislature approved SB 246 (Bates of 2017), which would have allowed a second transfer for a disabled person after they turn 55; however, Governor Brown vetoed the measure.
Parent-Child Transfers. The Legislature enacted two change in ownership exclusions for transfers between parents and children, and then grandparents and grandchildren, which were then approved by voters. Proposition 58 (1986) exempted from change in ownership transfers of property from parents to children (ACA 2, Hanigan), which voters extended to grandchildren ten years later, so long as the grandparent is deceased (Proposition 193, 1996; ACA 17, Knowles).
In October, 2017, the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) published “the Property Tax Inheritance Exclusion,” indicating that the Legislature may want to review the exclusion. LAO wrote:
“The decision to create an inherited property exclusion has been consequential. Hundreds of thousands of families have received tax relief under these rules. As a result, local government property tax collections have been reduced by a few billion dollars per year. Moreover, allowing children to inherit their parents’ lower property tax bill has exacerbated inequities among owners of similar properties. It also appears to have encouraged the conversion of some homes from owner occupied primary residences to rentals and other uses. In light of these consequences, the Legislature may want to revisit the inheritance exclusion.”
In August, 2018, the Los Angeles Times identified several homes owned by prominent, wealthy individuals who were subsequently renting out homes after applying the exclusion on residences inherited from their parents. The article stated that in Los Angeles County, as many as 63% of homes subject to the exclusion were used as second residences or rental properties last year.
COMMENTS
1) According to the author: ACA 11 seeks to provide much needed housing relief for our state’s most vulnerable populations, while also creating a stable revenue source for both Special Districts that provide fire protection and local governments to improve services to their communities.
ACA 11 seeks to replace the ballot measure entitled “Changes Requirements for Transferring Property Tax Base to Replacement Property. Expands Business Property Reassessment. Initiative Constitutional Amendment,” which became eligible for the November General Election April 2019.
ACA 11 continues to protect seniors, persons with disabilities, families, and victims of wildfire by limiting property tax increases on primary residences, as originally intended under Propositions 60 and 90, and Propositions 58 and 193. SCA 2 also expands these protections to include wildfire victims and removes unfair location restrictions from Propositions 60 and 90. Removing these restrictions will allow our most vulnerable residents to move closer to family or medical care, to a senior or retirement community, or to replace a damaged home anywhere within California.
ACA 11 also protects the Constitutional right of parents and grandparents to pass the family home to their children, ensuring that their heirs can afford to move into that home as their primary residence.
Out-of-state investors, non-California residents, and trust fund heirs have used Propositions 58 and 193 on vacation homes, investment property, and beachfront rentals. By closing these unintended loopholes, the state will be able to generate hundreds of millions of dollars for local governments to fund fire protection, emergency services, and other critical local programs to support the homeless and provide mental health services or to help fund the development of new affordable housing projects throughout California.
California’s persistent housing shortage, which places an upward pressure on housing costs, has created an unprecedented affordability crisis for California’s working families. The state has the 49th lowest ratio of housing units per resident and our states vacancy rate in 2019 was just 4.4%. Home purchase prices and rents statewide continue to rise faster than wages, which results in housing costs making up a greater percentage of a family’s monthly budget. SCA 2 will open up tens of thousands of new housing opportunities throughout California for renters and first-time homeowners. As a result of increased demand, SCA 2 will spur housing construction at all income levels to accommodate the demand for housing statewide.
2) Inequality. According the Pew Charitable Trust, the growth in income in recent decades has tilted to upper-income households. The Public Policy Institute of California’s (PPIC’s) “Just the Facts: Income Inequality” from January, 2020 reports that “while California’s economy outperforms the nation’s, its level of income inequality exceeds that of all but five states. Families at the top of the income distribution in California have 12.3 times the income of families at the bottom.” PPIC adds that the wealth gap is correlated with race, as African American and Latino families make up 12% of those with incomes above the 90th percentile, despite comprising 43% of all families in California, due to the fact that African American and Latino adults are overrepresented in low-wage jobs and have higher unemployment rates, and African American adults are less likely to be in the labor force. A family’s wealth is largely contingent on their home value; Deloitte’s report “The Future of Wealth in the United States” states that residential property alone constitutes nearly 58% of nonfinancial assets on household balance sheets in the United States. In many parts of the United States, discriminatory housing policies such as redlining and predatory lending have significantly hindered the ability of African American and Latino families to own and acquire a home that will appreciate in value over time, thereby building wealth.
PPIC adds that wealth inequalities are worse than income inequalities:
“In California, 20% of all net worth is concentrated in the 30 wealthiest zip codes, home to just 2% of Californians. African American and Latino families have much lower wealth levels compared white families; nationwide, the typical (median-wealth) white family has more than eight times the wealth of a typical African American or Latino family. While homeownership is an important component of wealth—and white and Asian families are more likely than others to own homes—other income-producing assets also play a major role in California’s wealth gap.”
Base year value transfers benefit existing homeowners by reducing the taxes they would have paid according to how long they have owned their current residence, and how much their home’s market value has appreciated. Current law restricts base year value transfers to replacement properties of equal or lesser value, a restriction ACA 11 would constitutionally eliminate, therefore extending an already powerful tax benefit that primarily benefits those who have already accrued housing wealth. Additionally, ACA 11 does not set any restriction on a taxpayer’s income or their housing value to apply its expanded benefits.
3) Old and young. Proposition 13’s tax benefits grow the longer the taxpayer stays in their home, as an incumbent homeowner’s assessed value can only grow by 2% per year. For example, taxpayer who purchased their residence for $100,000 in 1975 now has a base year value under Proposition 13 that cannot exceed $230,000 under the 2% cap in annual inflationary growth, when the median home price has almost doubled since 2012. Assuming a new homebuyer purchases a similar house next door to an incumbent neighbor, they may pay many times the annual amount of property tax despite being eligible for the same level of public services paid for by those taxes. Additionally, except for disabled individuals and victims of natural disasters, only taxpayers over the age of 55 can apply a base year value transfer. Homebuyers over 55 can incorporate the tax savings when bidding on a new home against younger homebuyers, who cannot, and also must often service student loan debt. ACA 11 would allow base year value transfers without regard to the location and value of the replacement property, further bolstering the purchasing power of those over 55, as well as increasing from one to three the number of transfers a taxpayer can make.
4) Good deal. The combination of the Proposition 13 method of property taxation and the grandparent-grandchild/parent-child exclusion can be highly beneficial, with benefits that grow the longer the same family owns the property. Most properties’ assessed valuation is below its market value because of the 2% cap on inflationary property value growth, so a typical property in the state is about two‑thirds of its market value, according to LAO. LAO adds that the exclusion that ACA 11 limits is applied to between 60,000 and 80,000 properties statewide each year, or about 10% of total property transfers. Additionally, LAO states that 5% of all property transfers in the state in the last decade apply the exclusion, the vast majority of which are single-family homes. LAO also states that the exclusion has a significant cost, estimating that exclusions reduced statewide property tax revenues by around $1.5 billion from what they would be in the absence of the exclusion in 2015-16. Additionally, the exclusion can be applied to the same property an infinite number of times, thereby providing a benefit that increases the more the value of the property grows and the longer the same family holds it.
5) Young and old. As mentioned above, older generations can transfer their principal residence and up to $1 million in other property to their lineal descendants without a reassessment, passing along the savings that have accrued under California’s Proposition 13 method of property taxation. ACA 11 adds a key requirement for future transfers of principal residences: the descendants must live in that residence to enjoy the tax benefit. If the descendants do not, property taxes could increase significantly. As a result, many descendants who cannot or do not wish to relocate may have to sell the homes where their parents or grandparents raised them, or come up with other funds sufficient to pay the additional taxes. However, by ending a tax benefit for converting inherited properties into rental properties, ACA 11 could help ameliorate the state’s affordable housing crisis by ending the significant incentive to hold these properties off the home sales market. ACA 11 would also repeal the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership for up to $1 million in property that is not the principal residence. As a result, children or grandchildren inheriting a property that is used for a business, rental housing, or for investment purposes may be forced to sell it if they cannot pay property taxes based on current market values.
6) Enforceable? Under ACA 11, transferees could continue to apply the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusion from change in ownership so long as they claim the homeowners’ exemption, a $7,000 reduction in taxable value when the home is the principal place of residence of the owner on January 1st of the year the exemption is claimed. The property must be the taxpayer's true, fixed and permanent home, and principal establishment to which they intend to return if absent. Assessors use vehicle registration, voter registration, bank accounts, and state income tax filings to determine whether a property qualifies. Once granted, the exemption continues until the taxpayer notifies the assessor or ownership changes. However, ACA 11 does not specify whether the transfer still applies if the transferee stops using the property as their principal residence; they need only claim the exemption at the time of the transfer or the one-year period thereafter. SCA 3 (Hill) contained language that ACA 11 does not that would reverse the exclusion, and require the assessor to revalue the property:
If the transferee subsequently ceases to use the residence as his or her principal residence, the exclusion provided for in this subdivision shall no longer apply, and the residence shall be assessed at its full cash value as of the date of the transfer from the parent or grandparent to the transferee, as adjusted in accordance with subdivision (b).
7) Crunching the numbers. ACA 11 requires the Director of Finance to calculate the state revenue benefit from its provisions, assuming that additional sales of homes will boost income taxes, and higher property taxes accruing from its expanded base year value transfers and changes to the parent-child, grandparent-grandchild exclusions from change in ownership. However, it will be difficult for the Director to do so. First, the first $250,000 (single)/$500,000 (joint) from the sale of the principal residence is currently excluded from income for state tax purposes. Realtors who sell more homes due to ACA 11 may earn more income, but it will be hard to determine what the baseline income they would have made but for the measure. Additionally, ACA 11 directs counties and CDTFA to determine its revenue effect for each of California’s 58 counties, 482 cities, and 2,300 special districts, which will be cumbersome. The measure also only directs counties to calculate revenue loss from transfers incoming from other counties, not revenues gained or lost resulting from transfers within the same county where the replacement property is of greater value than the original property, a current constitutional requirement ACA 11 supersedes, which will likely affect revenue. Lastly, while taxpayers currently submit claims when applying the $1 million change in ownership exclusion for inherited property, they will not if ACA 11 eliminates the exclusion, so counties and CDTFA may lack the data needed to accurately calculate these gains.
8) Options. Taxpayers whose property is substantially damaged in a wildfire or other natural disaster currently have five years to transfer their base year value to a comparable property within the same county, so long as the replacement property’s cost is within 120% of the value of their damage property. Taxpayers can also transfer the base year value from their home to another county so long as the incoming county elects to participate, subject to the same restrictions. ACA 11 would allow these taxpayers to transfer base year values to replacement properties with a cost of more than 120% of their original property, but they would have only two years instead of five to do so.
9) CDTFA? ACA 11 requires the CDTFA to determine each eligible local agency’s aggregate gain every three years, based on the amounts determined by the counties, and provide reimbursements. Formed by the Legislature in 2017 to assume the non-Constitutional functions of the BOE, CDTFA does not perform many property tax functions. As a result, CDTFA may lack the expertise or resources to determine ACA 11’s revenue effects for all of California’s local agencies.
10) Clarity. Several provisions of ACA 11 would benefit from further clarity.
- Is the $1 million exclusion for the family farms in addition to the $1 million for principal residences, for a total of $2 million, or is the total exclusion $1 million for either or both?
- What are the property tax revenues allocated to local agencies in Section 2.2 (b)(2)?
- Is a ten-year grant for a special district allocated in equal amounts each year? If a special district does not obtain a grant in the first year, can it then only be awarded one out of the growth in amounts transferred by the Controller? Do grants continue at previously authorized levels if the Director of Finance calculates ACA 11 results in a loss or a lower amount of growth than the previous year?
- Should CDTFA and county auditors determine the location of transfers by tax rate area when determining “gain” for cities, school and special districts?
- Is CDTFA required to use a county’s determination of gain for each local agency? Under what circumstances should it not?
- Does every local agency need to be reimbursed for all of negative gains before CDTFA remits moneys from the County Revenue Protection Fund to the General Fund? The measure only states that the remittance occurs “if each local agency that has a negative gain has been reimbursed.”
- If a fire district receives a grant from the California Fire Response Fund, is it ineligible for a reimbursement from the County Revenue Protection fund if its grant exceeds its negative gain?
- Argument in Support. In a letter supporting ACA 11, the California Professional Firefighters stated, in part, the following:
ACA 11 is a compromise measure to replace a measure qualified for the November ballot, ensuring that funding for fire protection and local government revenues are protected, and allowing for flexibility and reform in California’s property tax formulas, while leaving the protections of Proposition 13 intact. This measure contains several provisions intended to increase the stock of available housing and provide protections to vulnerable Californians in the housing market, while creating protected funding for underfunded fire districts throughout the state and ensuring that counties and local governments receive equal and equitable funding through the provisions.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SCA 2 (Galgiani) of 2020, substantially identical to ACA 11. Currently pending in the Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee.
SCA 3 (Hill) of 2019, provides that the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild exclusion only apply when only the transferee uses the residence as his or her principal residence. The measure is currently on the inactive file on the Senate Floor.
SCA 4 (Galgiani) of 2019, expands the Constitution’s current base year value transfer authority, and limits the parent-child and grandparent-grandchild transfers in a similar but not identical way as this measure. The measure is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
PRIOR ACTION
Senate Budget and Fiscal Review: |
|
Assembly Floor: | 76 - 0 |
Assembly Budget Committee: |
|
Note: Prior votes do not reflect the current version of this bill.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: California Professional Firefighters
California Association of Realtors
Support: None received
Oppose: None received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON BUDGET AND FISCAL REVIEW
Senator Holly Mitchell, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: ACA 11 Hearing Date: August 14, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | February 26, 2019 As amended | ||
Urgency: |
| Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Jennifer Troia | ||
Subject: Office of the Legislative Analyst
Summary:
Specifies that expenditures of the Office of the Legislative Analyst shall not be included in the cap on “total aggregate expenditures of the Legislature” pursuant to Article IV, Section 7.5 of the California Constitution.
Background:
The Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) has provided non-partisan fiscal and policy advice to the Legislature for approximately 78 years. The LAO is known for fiscal and programmatic expertise and for nonpartisan analyses of the state budget. The LAO also responds to requests for information by Legislators, forecasts state revenues and expenditures, and publishes statutorily required and other special reports. Since the enactment of the Political Reform Act by the voters in 1974 (Proposition 9), the LAO has also been responsible for publicly providing impartial analyses of all statewide propositions. Prior to the enactment of Proposition 140 in 1990 (discussed further below), the LAO additionally analyzed all legislation that contained an appropriation.
Findings and declarations in this measure recognize that the LAO has assisted the Legislature in counterbalancing the power of the executive branch and achieving budgetary savings. Through its analyses of initiatives and ballot propositions—as well as through all its other public documents—the LAO has also assisted the people of California in their understanding of state government. According to the author, this measure would remove barriers that inhibit the LAO from expanding its role in oversight and research because of a cap on its expenditures.
The voters established the cap on expenditures for the Legislature in 1990, through Proposition 140. More specifically, Article IV, Section 7.5 of the California Constitution, limits expenditures for the Legislature to an amount set in the 1989-90 fiscal year, adjusted by the rate calculated for the State Appropriation Limit. Expenditures for the LAO count toward this expenditure cap. As a result, after the passage of Proposition 140, the LAO staff was reduced from 105 to 45 positions.
In 1992, the Legislature placed Proposition 158 on the ballot. Proposition 158 would have renamed the Legislative Analyst the “California Analyst” and excluded the office from the legislative expenditure limit calculation. The voters defeated Proposition 158. The author of ACA 11 argues, however, that given subsequent growth in state funding and programs, it is time to revisit this question in order to ensure better oversight of California government.
Proposed Law:
This measure would:
- Recognize the Office of the Legislative Analyst in the state Constitution and require it to assist the Legislature in its fiscal and policy functions;
- Require the Joint Legislative Budget Committee to appoint the Legislative Analyst and employees of the office, consistent with existing statutory provisions and rules of the Legislature; and
- Exclude expenditures of the Office of the Legislative Analyst from provisions of the California Constitution that limit the total annual amount of expenditures for the compensation of members and employees of, and the operating expenses and equipment for, the Legislature.
Fiscal Effect:
This measure would have no immediate cost, although it may allow greater discretion to increase the budget for the LAO in future years.
Support:
None on file
Opposed:
None on file
Comments:
The Legislature established the LAO in 1941 to provide the legislative branch with non-partisan fiscal and policy analysis and advice. At the time, the state’s population was around 7 million people and the total state budget for 1941-1943 was around $553 million. At present, the LAO has a staff of 54, including 43 analysts and approximately 11 support staff. This is approximately the same number of analysts the office had in 1966, when the enacted state budget totaled $4.59 billion. By comparison, the enacted state budget for 2018-19 is $201.37 billion, and the number and complexity of state programs requiring oversight have grown correspondingly. The cap on expenditures for the Legislature established by Proposition 140 has limited the ability of the LAO staff to keep pace with this growth of the state’s budget and economy. According to the author of ACA 11: “This Constitutional amendment would provide the LAO with the necessary resources to support the Legislature’s oversight role as a coequal branch of government. This is critical to keeping state spending in check and ensuring that taxpayer money is spent as efficiently as possible.”
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:ACA 11
Author:(Obernolte and Ting)
As Introduced Ver:February 26, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Exempts the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) from the Proposition 140 provision that caps expenditures for the Legislature.
Major Provision
Removes the Legislative Analyst's Office from the Proposition 140 cap on Legislative expenditures.
COMMENTS:
This measure is intended to remove Constitutional barriers that inhibit the Legislative Analyst's Office from expanding its role in oversight and research because of a cap on its expenditures. According to the author, "This Constitutional amendment would provide the LAO with the necessary resources to support the Legislature's oversight role as a coequal branch of government. This is critical to keeping state spending in check and ensuring that taxpayer money is spent as efficiently as possible."
Currently, the Legislative Analyst's Office is limited by the funding it receives from the Senate and the Assembly and has grown by the State Appropriations Limit, without regard to the actual workload needs or demands of the office. This measure would remove that cap, allowing the office to increase its oversight, research, and evaluation roles beyond its current focus on budget and analyzing ballot initiatives.
The Legislative Analyst's Office is one of the oldest and dedicated public policy analysis units in the world. In 1941, the Legislature passed Joint Rule 36, which established the Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) and the position of Legislative Auditor (later changed to Legislative Analyst). Over the next five decades, the Legislative Analyst's Office evolved, adding the responsibility to evaluate ballot initiatives with the Political Reform Act of 1974 (Proposition 9). At its height, LAO staff assisted the Legislature with both the development of the budget and in the creation of policy bills. The office was a world-renown example of non-partisan policy advice and served as the inspiration for the federal Congressional Budget Office.
In 1990, voters approved Proposition 140, which imposed term-limits on members of the Legislature and also capped and reduced legislative operations funding by 38%. As a result, the Legislative Analyst's Office shrunk from 105 to 45 positions. The office ceased assisting with the analysis of bills and refocused efforts on assisting with the budget process.
In 1992, the Legislature placed Proposition 158 on the ballot. This measure would have renamed the Legislative Analyst to the "California Analyst" and excluded the office from the Proposition 140 calculation so that the office could again grow. This measure was defeated by voters with 60% of the voters opposing the effort.
The author of this measure argues that given the growth in state funding and programs, it is time to revisit this question to ensure better oversight of California government. Even at its height, the Legislative Analyst's Office's resources were only a fraction of the staffing provided to support the Administration. In 1990, the Department of Finance had 374 positions compared to the Legislative Analyst's Office's 105 positions to oversee an overall state budget of $72 billion.
Since that time, this imbalance has only gotten worse, with the $314 billion total budget covered by a proposed 448 staff at Department of Finance, compared to 51 staff at the Legislative Analyst's Office. Fewer than four staff at the LAO are assigned to cover California's largest department, the $100.9 billion Department of Health Care Services, which serves over 13 million Californians.
According to the Author:
This Constitutional amendment would provide the LAO with the necessary resources to support the Legislature's oversight role as a coequal branch of government. This is critical to keeping state spending in check and ensuring that taxpayer money is spent as efficiently as possible.
Arguments in Support:
The Legislature does not have the analytic staff resources to provide oversight of state expenditures. Since the passage of Proposition 140, state government has grown by over 434%, but LAO staff was cut by 57% and has since remained flat. As a result, the LAO's capacity to provide oversight has diminished over time.
Arguments in Opposition:
Voters considered an almost identical measure in 1992, Proposition 158, which was rejected by a 60% of the vote. The Legislature should rely on its existing resources to conduct oversight.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
This measure would have no immediate cost, but would allow the discretion to increase funding for the Legislative Analyst's Office in future years.
VOTES:
ASM BUDGET: 27-0-4
YES: Ting, Obernolte, Bloom, Brough, Chiu, Cooper, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Limón, Mathis, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Mark Stone, Weber, Wicks, Wood
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Melendez, Reyes, Blanca Rubio
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 26, 2019
CONSULTANT: Christian Griffith / BUDGET / (916) 319-2099 FN: 0000320
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUDGET
Philip Y. Ting, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:ACA 11 (
Author:Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 26, 2019
SUBJECT: Office of the Legislative Analyst
SUMMARY: Exempts the Legislative Analyst’s Office from the Proposition 140 provision that caps expenditures for the Legislature.
EXISTING LAW: Article IV, Section 7.5 of the California Constitution, limits the expenditure for the Legislature to an amount set in the 1989-90 fiscal year, adjusted by the rate calculated for the State Appropriation Limit.
FISCAL EFFECT: This measure would have no immediate cost, but would allow the discretion to increase funding for the Legislative Analyst’s Office in future years.
COMMENTS:
This measure is intended to remove Constitutional barriers that inhibit the Legislative Analyst’s Office from expanding its role in oversight and research because of a cap on its expenditures. According to the author, “This Constitutional amendment would provide the LAO with the necessary resources to support the Legislature’s oversight role as a coequal branch of government. This is critical to keeping state spending in check and ensuring that taxpayer money is spent as efficiently as possible.”
Currently, the Legislative Analyst’s Office is limited by the funding it receives from the Senate and the Assembly and has grown by the State Appropriations Limit, without regard to the actual workload needs or demands of the office. This measure would remove that cap, allowing the office to increase its oversight, research, and evaluation roles beyond its current focus on budget and analyzing ballot initiatives.
The Legislative Analyst’s Office is one of the oldest dedicated public policy analysis units in the world. In 1941, the Legislature passed Joint Rule 36, which established the Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) and the position of Legislative Auditor (later changed to Legislative Analyst). Over the next five decades, the Legislative Analyst’s Office evolved, adding the responsibility to evaluate ballot initiatives with the Political Reform Act of 1974 (Proposition 9). At its height, LAO staff assisted the Legislature with both the development of the budget and in the creation of policy bills. The office was a world-renown example of non-partisan policy advice and served as the inspiration for the federal Congressional Budget Office.
In 1990, voters approved Proposition 140, which imposed term-limits on members of the Legislature and also capped and reduced legislative operations funding by 38 percent. As a result, the Legislative Analyst’s Office shrunk from 105 to 45 positions. The office ceased assisting with the analysis of bills and refocused efforts on assisting with the budget process.
In 1992, the Legislature placed Proposition 158 on the ballot. This measure would have renamed the Legislative Analyst to the “California Analyst” and excluded the office from the Proposition 140 calculation so that the office could again grow. This measure was defeated by voters with 60 percent of the voters opposing the effort.
The author of ACA 11 argues that given the growth in state funding and programs, it is time to revisit this question to ensure better oversight of California government. Even at its height, the Legislative Analyst’s Office’s resources were only a fraction of the staffing provided to support the Administration. In 1990, the Department of Finance had 374 positions compared to the Legislative Analyst’s Office’s 105 positions to oversee an overall state budget of $72 billion.
Since that time, this imbalance has only gotten worse, with the $314 billion total budget covered by a proposed 448 staff at Department of Finance, compared to 51 staff at the Legislative Analyst’s Office. Fewer than four staff at the LAO are assigned to cover California’s largest department, the $100.9 billion Department of Health Care Services, which serves over 13 million Californians.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file.
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Christian Griffith / BUDGET / (916) 319-2099
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):