SB 1237: Nurse-midwives: scope of practice.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-18
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 18, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 88, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 18, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 68. Noes 0. Page 5420.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 15. Noes 1.) (August 20). |
| Aug 18, 2020 | August 18 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Aug 11, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 16. Noes 1.) (August 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | July 27 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 35. Noes 1. Page 3876.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 22, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 3770.) (June 18). |
| Jun 11, 2020 | Set for hearing June 18. |
| Jun 9, 2020 | June 9 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 3, 2020 | Set for hearing June 9. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | Hearing rescheduled due to Capitol closure. |
| May 26, 2020 | Set for hearing June 1. |
| May 19, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 18, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0. Page 3550.) (May 18). |
| May 14, 2020 | Set for hearing May 18. |
| May 13, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Mar 18, 2020 | March 30 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 12, 2020 | Set for hearing March 30. |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 22. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Unfinished Business SB1237 Dodd et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2020 | SB 1237 Dodd Senate Third Reading By Burke | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 10, 2020 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2020 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1237 Dodd et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 9, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 18, 2020 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1237 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1237
Author: Dodd (D), et al.
Amended: 8/25/20
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 8-0, 5/18/20
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SENATE FLOOR: 35-1, 6/26/20
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Melendez, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Jones, Nielsen, Pan
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Not available
SUBJECT: Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
SOURCE: Black Women for Wellness Action Project
California Nurse-Midwives Association
DIGEST:
This bill removes the requirement for a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to practice midwifery according to standardized procedures or protocols with a physician; revises the provisions defining the practice of midwifery; authorizes a CNM to attend cases out of a hospital setting; authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices in accordance with standardized protocols with a physician; requires a CNM to provide specified disclosures to a patient; and, establishes new reporting and data collection requirements.
Assembly Amendments
add chaptering language, revise the participants on the advisory committee, establish new reporting and data collection requirements for out-of-hospital births and transfers, as specified; and, make other technical and clarifying changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) to provide for the licensure and regulation of the practice of nursing and authorizes the BRN to issue a certificate to practice nurse-midwifery to a person who meets educational standards established by the BRN or the equivalent of those educational standards. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2700 et seq.)
- Specifies that the practice of “midwifery” is the furthering or undertaking by a CNM, under the supervision of a licensed physician who has current practice or training in obstetrics, to assist a woman in childbirth so long as progress meets criteria accepted as normal and all complications are to be referred to a physician. (BPC § 2746.5(b))
- Authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second degree lacerations of the perineum in a licensed acute care hospital and a licensed alternate birth center, if certain requirements are met, including, but not limited to, that episiotomies are performed pursuant to protocols developed and approved by the supervising physician and surgeon. (BPC § 2746.52)
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices, including Schedule II-V controlled substances, pursuant to physician supervision, standardized procedures and protocols, and other conditions, as specified. (BPC § 2746.51)
This bill:
- Names the BRN’s current CNM committee the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee and requires the committee to be comprised of four NMs, two physicians, and one public member, as specified.
- Deletes the requirement for standardized procedures and protocols with a physician as part of a certificate to practice midwifery. States that the certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to attend cases of low-risk pregnancy consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, or its successor national professional organization, as approved by the BRN. Defines low risk pregnancy as one in which there is a single fetus, there is a cephalic presentation at onset of labor; the gestational age of the fetus is greater than or equal to 37 weeks and zero days and less than or equal to 42 weeks and zero days at the time of delivery, labor is spontaneous or induced, and the patient does not have a preexisting disease or condition, whether arising out of the pregnancy or otherwise, that adversely affects the pregnancy and the CNM is not qualified to independently address.
- Authorizes a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, obtain and administer diagnostic tests, order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and receive reports that are necessary to their practice as a CNM within their scope of practice. Allows CNM to perform and repair episiotomies, and to repair first and second degree lacerations of the perineum without standardized procedures and protocols with a physician, as specified. Prohibits a CNM from using vacuum or forceps, or performing any external cephalic version.
- States that the certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to practice with a physician under mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral and transfer of a patient’s care, signed by the both the CNM and a physician to either: (a) provide patient with care that falls outside the scope of services of a low-risk pregnancy, as specified; or (b) provide intrapartum care to a patient who has had a prior cesarean section or surgery that interrupts the myometrium.
- Requires a patient to be transferred to the care of a physician if a CNM does not have in place mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral, and transfer of a patient’s care signed by both the CNM and a physician, if the care falls outside the specified scope of services, or if the patient has had a prior cesarean section or surgery. Authorizes a patient that has been transferred from the care of a CNM to that of a physician to be returned to the care of the CNM after the physician has determined the condition or the circumstance that required the transfer has been resolved. Requires a CNM to refer all emergencies to a physician immediately, and authorizes a CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician is obtained.
- States that the certificate to practice midwifery authorizes the holder to attend pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting and authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs and devices when providing care in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Requires a CNM to provide a disclosure, both orally and in written form, to a prospective patient as part of the patient care plan, and to obtain informed consent and a signature, when providing care in a setting outside of a hospital, that outlines information about the CNM’s lack of supervision, licensure status, liability insurance status, arrangements for transfer, and the availability of statute regulating CNM practice.
- Requires data to be submitted to the DCA for all maternal or neonatal transfers to a hospital setting during labor or the immediate postpartum period, if the intended place of birth was an out-of-hospital setting at the onset of labor, or for any maternal, fetal, or neonatal death that occurred in the out-of-hospital setting during labor or the immediate postpartum period, if the intended birth care provider is a CNM in the out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Requires a CNM to report the outcome of a birth in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Establishes various reporting and data collection requirements related to labor and delivery services occurring in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Makes findings and declarations related to maternity care in California, including racial disparities.
- Adds chaptering language to avoid a conflict with AB 890 (Wood).
Background
Certified Nurse Midwives. CNMs are advanced practice registered nurses who have specialized education and training to provide primary care, prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including interconception care and family planning. These individuals are licensed by the BRN, have acquired additional training in the field of obstetrics, and are certified by the American College of Nurse Midwives.
Currently, the nurse-midwifery certificate authorizes the CNM to attend cases of normal childbirth, as well as immediate care for the newborn, but only according to standardized procedures and protocols with a licensed physician. A CNM may furnish drugs and devices after completing at least six months of physician supervised experience in the furnishing of drugs and devices and a course in pharmacology.
Protocols are a part of standardized procedures and are designed to describe the steps of medical care for given patient situations. Protocols are currently developed in consultation with a supervising physician, and CNMs are required to include the extent of supervision as part of those standardized procedures related to ordering or furnishing drugs or devices (BPC § 2746.51(A)(2)(B).
There are approximately 700 CNMs practicing in California. In 2017, it was reported that CNMs attended nearly 50,000 births across the state (out of the 470,000 births that occurred that year). Although CNMs are authorized to practice in birth centers and home-based settings, the majority provide client care in a hospital setting.
Standardizes procedures. Standardized procedures are developed collaboratively by nurses, physicians, and the administration of an organized health care system. The BRN and the Medical Board of California have jointly promulgated guidelines for standardized procedures (CCR, tit. 16, § 1474). They are based on the competence of the nurses providing the procedures and include record, referral, and setting requirements, among other patient protections. While supervision by a physician is required for CNMs to provide patient care, that supervision does not require the physical presence of a physician so currently, a CNM can work miles away from the actual location of the physician, and as long as the standardized procedures are in place, the CNM may deliver babies and provide other authorized practices by a CNM.
Studies and Access to Care. On March 11, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office released Analysis of California’s Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives, which analyzed whether the current physician supervision requirement is meeting its intended safety and quality objectives, without significantly increasing cost or decreasing access to health care services. Ultimately, part of the findings of that report noted that California’s current supervision requirement is “unlikely to improve safety and quality for low-risk pregnancies and births”. The LAO report, based on an analysis of various studies, did “not find evidence that the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care by nurse midwives is inferior to that of physicians in cases of low risk pregnancies and births.” The report also concluded, “states with physician supervision or collaboration agreement requirements do not have superior maternal and infant health outcomes than states without such requirements.” It notes that since the supervision requirements in statute do not clearly define the responsibilities of supervision, “the state’s requirement is unlikely to be more effective than other states’ similar requirements. Therefore, we find that California’s supervision requirement for nurse midwives is unlikely to improve safety and quality for low risk pregnancies and births.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill will result in one-time costs of $3.6 million for CDPH to develop and deploy a new web-based reporting system, as well as $400,000 annually to perform maintenance and support. The Committee notes that BRN does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and admini/stration costs.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/30/20)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-source)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-source)
2020 Mom
Academy of Lactation Policy and Practice INC.
Access Women's Health Justice
American Association of Birth Centers
American Civil Liberties Union/Northern California/Southern California/San Diego and Imperial Counties
American College of Nurse-midwives
Asian Americans Advancing Justice - California
Association of Women's Health and Neonatal Nursing
Beach Cities Midwifery & Women's Health Care
Best Start Birth Center
Black Wellness & Prosperity Center
CA Board of Registered Nursing
California Association of Nurse Anesthetists
California Black Women's Health Project
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Women's Law Center
Center on Reproductive Rights and Justice
Citizens for Choice
Every Neighborhood Partnership
Feminist Majority Foundation
Grow Midwives
Healthimpact
Healthy Children Project, INC.
If/When/How: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Medical Board of California
Midwives Alliance North America
Momsrising
Naral Pro-choice California
National Council of Jewish Women California
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
New Birth Services
Pacific Business Group on Health
The Praxis Project
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals
University of California
Urge: Unite for Reproductive & Gender Equity
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/20)
Bakersfield Birth Center
Better Birth Association of Harlem, NY
Big Valley Midwives
Birth Rights Solutions
Birthing Without Fear
Birthstream Midwifery Service
Birthwaves Midwifery
California Association of Licensed Midwives
California College of Midwives
California Families for Access to Midwives
Californians for Advancement of Midwifery
Coalition for Ethical Maternity Care
Cornerstone Doula Trainings
Full Moon Family Wellness & Birth Center
Golden State Midwifery and Birth Services
Hero Birth Services
ICOM (East Bay Midwives of Color)
International Cesarean Awareness Network
LGBTQ Perinatal Wellness Center
Little Acorn Doula Services
Long Beach Birth Workers of Color Collective
Midwives Alliance of North America
Nia Healing Center for Birth and Family Life
Roots of Labor Birth Collective
See Midwives
The Oakland Better Birth Foundation
Urban Village Birth Services
VBAC Facts
Welcome Home Community Birth Center
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters note that this bill will increase access to maternal health and improve maternal and newborn health outcomes.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of opponents note that this bill leaves a significant number of Californians ineligible for CNM care and rather than increasing access, represents a harmful barrier to care.
Prepared by: Sarah Mason & Elissa Silva / B., P. & E.D. / 916-651-4104
8/31/20 18:02:08
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1237
Author:(Dodd)
As Amended Ver:August 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Authorizes a certified nurse-midwife (CNM) to attend to low-risk pregnancies and perform related incidental functions without physician supervision; replaces the supervision requirement for higher-risk pregnancies with mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, as specified; requires the Board of Registered Nursing to establish a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee; establishes a disclosure and informed consent requirement; and establishes new reporting and data collection requirements.
Major Provisions
- Makes various legislative findings and declarations.
- Adds CNMs to anti-kickback provisions specific to physicians and clarifies which regulatory board would be involved in the discipline.
- Requires the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) to appoint a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee that consists of specified physicians and surgeons and makes various recommendations on CNM practice and discipline.
- Deletes the provision authorizing a CNM to attend cases of normal pregnancy under physician supervision, instead authorizing a CNM to attend cases of "low-risk pregnancy" and childbirth and to provide midwifery care for the newborn, consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, or its successor national professional organization, as approved by the BRN.
- Defines "low-risk pregnancy" as a pregnancy where the following conditions are met:
- There is a single fetus.
- There is a cephalic presentation at onset of labor.
- The gestational age of the fetus is greater than or equal to 37 weeks and zero days and less than or equal to 42 weeks and zero days at the time of delivery.
- Labor is spontaneous or induced.
- The patient has no preexisting disease or condition, whether arising out of the pregnancy or otherwise, that adversely affects the pregnancy and that the CNM is not qualified to independently address.
- Authorizes a CNM to practice with a physician and surgeon under mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral, and transfer of a patient's care, signed by both the CNM and a physician and surgeon as specified.
- Requires, if a CNM does not have in place mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, the patient to be transferred to the care of a physician and surgeon, as specified.
- Authorizes, after the CNM initiates the process of transfer due to a lack of mutually agreed upon policies and protocols, for a patient who otherwise meets the definition of a low-risk pregnancy but no longer meets specified because the gestational age of the fetus is greater than 42 weeks and zero days, if there is inadequate time to effect safe transfer to a hospital prior to delivery or transfer may pose a threat to the health and safety of the patient or the unborn child, the CNM may continue care of the patient consistent with the transfer plan contained in the patient care plan and informed consent required under this bill.
- Provides that a patient who has been transferred from the care of a CNM to that of a physician and surgeon may return to the care of the CNM after the physician and surgeon has determined that the condition or circumstance that required, or would require, the transfer from the care of the CNM is resolved.
- Requires a CNM to document all consultations, referrals, and transfers in the patient record.
- Requires a CNM to refer all emergencies to a physician and surgeon immediately and authorizes the CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician and surgeon is obtained.
- Aligns the authority for a CNM to furnish or order drugs, tests, or devices with the removal of physician supervision for low-risk pregnancies under this bill.
- Removes the physician supervision, standardized procedure, and settings requirement for the performance and repair of episiotomies and repair of first- and second-degree lacerations of the perineum.
- Requires, if the intended site of birth is outside a hospital settings, a CNM to make various disclosures, as part of a patient care plan, obtain specified informed consent, requires both to be signed by the CNM and patient, and requires a copy in the patient's medical record.
- Establishes various reporting and data collection requirements related to labor and deliver services occurring in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Makes numerous technical, clarifying, and conforming changes, including chaptering amendments for AB 890 (Wood), which is pending in the Senate.
COMMENTS:
Background. CNMs are licensed registered nurses (RNs) with additional training in the field of obstetrics and certification by the American Midwifery Certification Board or an equivalent program. As a result of their additional training, they are considered advanced practice RNs.
As RNs, CNMs have the same scope of practice as non-advanced practice RNs. However, CNMs are also specifically authorized to perform midwifery services and attend childbirth as long as they practice under the supervision of a physician trained in obstetrics. Because supervision is not defined, it is often understood to mean standardized procedures, which are policies and protocols developed with a physician or within a health system. Under supervision or standardized procedures, CNMs attend to childbirths in many settings, including the home, birth centers, clinics, and hospitals.
This bill would remove the supervision requirement for "low-risk pregnancies" and establish alternate collaboration and relationship requirements with physicians, relatively consistent with a recent Legislative Analyst's Office report entitled Analysis of California's Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives. It also establishes a data reporting and collection requirement for out-of-hospital births.
CNMs and Abortions. Existing law authorizes a registered nurse or physician assistant to perform an abortion by medication or aspiration in the first trimester of pregnancy under standardized procedures or other relevant supervision. Some opponents of this bill argue that the relaxing of physician supervision requirements will lead to more abortions.
While this bill modifies the supervision requirements for attending pregnancies, it does not modify the requirements related to the performance of abortions. Specifically, this bill only pertains to a CNM's ability to attend childbirth, provide interconception care and family planning, and provide immediate care for newborns, none of which include the performance of abortions. An abortion is the ending of a pregnancy. This bill would not expand access to abortions via a CNM because it does not amend the limitations related to abortion standardized procedure requirements under current law.
According to the Author:
"[This bill] seeks to increase access to childbirth by establishing a collaborative model of care for certified nurse midwifery in California. [This bill] promotes team-based care, which has been shown to improve safety and quality of care. Supervision doesn't make sense anymore. It is not defined in California statute and does not require the physician to: be physically present, examine the patient, sign or review any charts, or oversee patient care in any way. Supervision forces nurse-midwives to concentrate in geographic areas where physicians physically practice, thereby reducing access particularly in rural counties and lower income communities. There is a direct link between race, access, and maternity outcomes in minority communities. Improving access to nurse-midwifery care has been named by leading organizations, such as the March of Dimes and the World Health Organization, as one of the most innovative strategies in addressing racial disparities in communities of color. Consistent with what 47 other states have already done, [this bill] will remove the 'physician permission to practice law' for nurse-midwives. It also defines what true collaborative care is between physicians and midwives and creates the foundation for consultation, collaboration and seamless transfer of care when needed. This is a first step toward truly integrating nurse-midwifery and obstetrical care, so that diverse patient needs can be attended to by a diverse provider group, working together toward shared goals."
Arguments in Support:
The California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-sponsor), Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-sponsor), NARAL Pro-Choice California (co-sponsor), United Nurses Association of California (co-sponsor), and other supporters generally support this bill, arguing it would "promote greater access to high-quality, high-value maternal health care for those who need it most."
The co-sponsors argue, and other supporters generally echo, that "Nurse-midwives have a vision of seamless, integrated care between nurse-midwives and physicians that will result in improved access to health services for those who need it most, reducing disparities in outcomes, thereby lowering health care costs, improving overall quality of care, and leading to greater innovation in health care delivery."
The Board of Registered Nursing has a support if amended position and would support this bill if amended to delete the physician requirement on the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee and the ability for the committee to provide recommendations to the board on disciplinary matters.
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of licensed midwives and consumers who generally support midwifery with less physician involvement oppose this bill. Specifically, California Families for Access to Midwives writes, and other opponents of the bill that support independent midwifery generally echo, that they "have strong concerns with putting paternalistic and oppressive restrictions on women's access to care in statute, because medical guidelines can and should evolve based on the latest research. Some sections of this language have the stipulation they are based on evidence and accepted practice, however these two things (evidence and accepted practice) can be at odds as the medical field often needs time to catch up to research…. As the COVID-19 pandemic escalates, as medical resources are diverted, and as hospitals are increasingly restricted to emergency triage, we need to ensure that birthing families receive evidence-based care that improves birth outcomes. More than ever, we need to cut through the red tape and enable all midwives to serve autonomously without legislative barriers to care. We urge you to expedite granting autonomy to nurse-midwives by removing the restrictive language [limiting unsupervised practice to low-risk pregnancies, requiring referrals, and requiring physician involvement in vaginal births after caesarian sections]."
Several groups also oppose this bill because they generally believe the modifications of the supervision requirement under the bill will expand access to abortions or allow the performance of abortions without physician supervision, including Alliance to Protect Children, California Catholic Conference, California Family Council, California Prolife Council and Right to Life Federation, California Right to Life Committee, INC., Californians for Life, Compassion Pregnancy Center & Clinic of the Monterey Bay, Con Mis Hijos No Te Metas - California Chapter, Eagle Forum of California, and Real Impact.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis of the August 24, 2020, version of this bill:
- General Fund contracting costs to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) of at least hundreds of thousands of dollars to develop a data collection system, as well as annual costs to perform maintenance and support.
- The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 35-1-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Melendez, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Jones, Nielsen, Pan
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 16-1-2
YES: Low, Arambula, Bloom, Chiu, Eggman, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting, Megan Dahle
NO: Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Flora
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 15-1-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Voepel
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0003396
Date of Hearing: August 18, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1237
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 16-1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill removes the physician supervision requirement for services delivered by a certified nurse-midwife (CNM). Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes a certified nurse-midwife (CNM) to attend to low-risk pregnancies and perform related incidental functions without physician supervision.
- Replaces the supervision requirement for higher-risk pregnancies with mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, as specified.
- Requires the Board of Registered Nursing to establish a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee.
- Establishes a disclosure and informed consent requirement.
- Establishes new reporting and data collection requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time GF costs of $3.6 million to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to develop and deploy a new web-based reporting system, as well as $400,000 annually to perform maintenance and support.
- The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Nurse-Midwives Association, Black Women for Wellness Action Project, NARAL Pro-Choice California, and United Nurses Association of California to expand access to midwifery care and remove supervision requirements, which they indicate pose barriers without increasing patient safety.
- Background. CNMs are licensed registered nurses (RNs) with additional training in the field of obstetrics and certification by the American Midwifery Certification Board or an equivalent program. CNMs are considered advanced practice RNs.
For purposes of midwifery, the author and sponsors argue that existing supervision and standardized procedure requirements are overly restrictive given the education and training of CNMs. Standardized procedures must be developed with a physician, or within an organized health system, and must follow guidelines established by the Medical Board and the Board of Registered Nursing in regulation. California is one of four states that have full statutory supervision requirements.
- LAO Report. On March 11, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office released “Analysis of California’s Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives,” which analyzed the current physician supervision requirement, taking into consideration cost, safety, quality and access to health care services. Based on an analysis of various studies, the LAO did not find support for the necessity of current supervision requirements.
This bill would remove physician supervision for low-risk pregnancies, generally consistent with the LAO’s recommendations. In place of supervision, the bill would instead require collaborative relationships with physicians and other providers. This bill would also require data reporting and collection of births outside of hospital settings.
- Prior Legislation. A number of recent bills have proposed changes to CNM requirements. None have passed. The bills include: AB 2682 (Burke), AB 1612 (Burke) and SB 457 (Bates), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, and AB 1306 (Burke), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session.
- Support. A large coalition of health care providers and health and reproductive justice advocacy organizations, as well as the Medical Board of California and the University of California, support this bill, indicating it will promote greater access to high-quality, high-value maternal health care for those who need it most.
- Support if Amended. The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) supports this bill if amended to allow the current committee structure to continue meeting the Board’s advisory needs for issues relating to nurse-midwifery, and to remove the requirement for the committee provide guidance on disciplinary matters.
- Opposition. A coalition of licensed midwives and consumers who generally support midwifery with less physician involvement oppose this bill. Opponents argue the looser requirements created by this bill are paternalistic and oppressive restrictions that will limit the types of women who will be able to seek midwifery care.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 27, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1237
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 35-1
SUBJECT: Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
SUMMARY: Authorizes a certified nurse-midwife (CNM) to attend to low-risk pregnancies and perform related incidental functions without physician supervision; replaces the supervision requirement for higher-risk pregnancies with mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, as specified; requires the Board of Registered Nursing to establish a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee; establishes a disclosure and informed consent requirement; and establishes new reporting and data collection requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Regulates and licenses the practice of nursing under the Nursing Practice Act, which is administered and enforced by the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN). (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2700-2838.4)
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to recognize the existence of overlapping functions between physicians and registered nurses and to permit additional sharing of functions within organized health care systems that provide for collaboration between physicians and registered nurses. These organized health care systems include, but are not limited to, licensed health facilities, clinics, home health agencies, physicians’ offices, and public or community health services. (BPC § 2725(a))
- Defines “the practice of nursing” as those functions, including basic health care, that help people cope with difficulties in daily living that are associated with their actual or potential health or illness problems or the relevant treatment, and that require a substantial amount of scientific knowledge or technical skill, including all of the following:
- Direct and indirect patient care services that ensure the safety, comfort, personal hygiene, and protection of patients; and the performance of disease prevention and restorative measures. (BPC § 2725(b)(1))
- Direct and indirect patient care services, including, but not limited to, the administration of medications and therapeutic agents, necessary to implement a treatment, disease prevention, or rehabilitative regimen ordered by and within the scope of licensure of a physician, dentist, podiatrist, or clinical psychologist, as defined by Section 1316.5 of the Health and Safety Code. (BPC § 2725(b)(2))
- The performance of skin tests, immunization techniques, and the withdrawal of human blood from veins and arteries. (BPC § 2725(b)(3))
- Observation of signs and symptoms of illness, reactions to treatment, general behavior, or general physical condition, and (A) determination of whether the signs, symptoms, reactions, behavior, or general appearance exhibit abnormal characteristics, and (B) implementation, based on observed abnormalities, of appropriate reporting, or referral, or standardized procedures, or changes in treatment regimen in accordance with standardized procedures, or the initiation of emergency procedures. (BPC § 2725(b)(4))
- Defines “standardized procedures” as either of the following:
- Policies and protocols developed by a licensed health facility through collaboration among administrators and health professionals including physicians and nurses. (BPC § 2725(c)(1))
- Policies and protocols developed through collaboration among administrators and health professionals, including physicians and nurses, by an organized health care system which is not a licensed health facility, subject to any guidelines for standardized procedures established by the Medical Board of California and the BRN. (BPC § 2725(c)(2))
- Establishes standardized procedure guidelines jointly promulgated by the Medical Board of California and the BRN. (California Code of Regulations (CCR), Title 16, § 1474)
- Requires standardized procedures to include a written description of the method used during development and approval. (CCR, tit. 16, § 1474(a))
- Specifies the required form and content of standardized procedures, including that they be in writing and signed, specify the authorized functions, establish procedure protocols, detail education and training requirements, provide for evaluation and of authorized nurses, provide for the maintenance of records of authorized nurses, establish the scope of physician supervision, set forth circumstances requiring physician consultation, state limitations on settings, specify patient record keeping requirements, and provide for periodic review of the standardized procedures. (CCR, tit. 16, § 1474(b))
- Authorizes the BRN to appoint a committee of qualified physicians and nurses, including, but not limited to, obstetricians and nurse-midwives, to develop the necessary standards relating to educational requirements, ratios of nurse-midwives to supervising physicians, and associated matters. (BPC § 2746.2)
- Authorizes a CNM, under the supervision of a licensed physician and surgeon, to attend cases of normal childbirth and to provide prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including family-planning care, for the mother, and immediate care for the newborn. (BPC § 2746.5(a))
- Defines “the practice of nurse-midwifery” as the furthering or undertaking by a certified person, under the supervision of a licensed physician and surgeon who has current practice or training in obstetrics, to assist a woman in childbirth so long as progress meets criteria accepted as normal, but not the assisting of childbirth by any artificial, forcible, or mechanical means, nor the performance of any version. (BPC § 2746.5(b))
- Specifies that physician “supervision” does not require the physical presence of the supervising physician. (BPC § 2746.5(c))
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices, including Schedule II-V controlled substances, pursuant to physician supervision, standardized procedures and protocols, and other conditions, as specified. (BPC § 2746.51)
- Authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second-degree lacerations of the perineum in a licensed acute care hospital and a licensed alternate birth center if certain requirements are met, including that episiotomies are performed pursuant to protocols developed and approved by the supervising physician and surgeon. (BPC § 2746.52)
- Establishes the Medical Board of California to regulate the practice of medicine and administer and enforce the Medical Practice Act. (BPC §§ 2000-2525.5)
- Restricts the practice of medicine, which includes any system or mode of treating the sick or afflicted, or diagnosis, treatment, operation for, or prescription for any ailment, blemish, deformity, disease, disfigurement, disorder, injury, or other physical or mental condition of any person, to specified licensees. (BPC § 2052)
- Specifically prohibits a person from performing an abortion unless licensed as a physician and surgeon, except that a registered nurse or physician assistant may perform an abortion by medication or aspiration techniques in the first trimester of pregnancy if authorized under the relevant practice act. (BPC § 2253)
THIS BILL:
- Makes various legislative findings and declarations.
- Adds CNMs to anti-kickback provisions specific to physicians and clarifies which regulatory board would be involved in the discipline.
- Requires the BRN to appoint a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee that meets the following:
- Makes recommendations to the BRN on all matters related to midwifery practice, education, appropriate standard of care, and other matters as specified by the BRN
- Provides recommendations or guidance on care when the BRN is considering disciplinary action against a certified nurse-midwife.
- Consists of four qualified nurse-midwives, two qualified physicians and surgeons, including, but not limited to, obstetricians or family physicians, and one public member, as specified.
- Deletes the provision authorizing a CNM to attend cases of normal pregnancy under physician supervision, instead authorizing a CNM to attend cases of “low-risk pregnancy” and childbirth and to provide midwifery care for the newborn, consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, or its successor national professional organization, as approved by the BRN.
- Defines “low-risk pregnancy” as a pregnancy where the following conditions are met:
- There is a single fetus.
- There is a cephalic presentation at onset of labor.
- The gestational age of the fetus is greater than or equal to 37 weeks and zero days and less than or equal to 42 weeks and zero days at the time of delivery.
- Labor is spontaneous or induced.
- The patient has no preexisting disease or condition, whether arising out of the pregnancy or otherwise, that adversely affects the pregnancy and that the CNM is not qualified to independently address.
- Authorizes a CNM to practice with a physician and surgeon under mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral, and transfer of a patient’s care, signed by both the CNM and a physician and surgeon as follows:
- The CNM may, pursuant to the mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, do either of the following:
- Provide a patient with care that falls outside the scope of services allowed for a low-risk pregnancy.
- Provide intrapartum care to a patient who has had a prior cesarean section or surgery that interrupts the myometrium.
- If a physician and surgeon assumes care of the patient, the CNM may continue to attend the birth of the newborn and participate in physical care, counseling, guidance, teaching, and support, as indicated by the mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols signed by both the CNM and a physician and surgeon.
- After a CNM refers a patient to a physician and surgeon, the CNM may continue care of the patient during a reasonable interval between the referral and the initial appointment with the physician and surgeon.
- The CNM may, pursuant to the mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, do either of the following:
- Requires, if a CNM does not have in place mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols, the patient to be transferred to the care of a physician and surgeon to do either or both of the following:
- Provide a patient with care that falls outside the scope of services allowed for a low-risk pregnancy.
- Provide intrapartum care to a patient who has had a prior cesarean section or surgery that interrupts the myometrium.
- Authorizes, after the CNM initiates the process of transfer due to a lack of mutually agreed upon policies and protocols, for a patient who otherwise meets the definition of a low-risk pregnancy but no longer meets specified because the gestational age of the fetus is greater than 42 weeks and zero days, if there is inadequate time to effect safe transfer to a hospital prior to delivery or transfer may pose a threat to the health and safety of the patient or the unborn child, the CNM may continue care of the patient consistent with the transfer plan contained in the patient care plan and informed consent required under this bill.
- Provides that a patient who has been transferred from the care of a CNM to that of a physician and surgeon may return to the care of the CNM after the physician and surgeon has determined that the condition or circumstance that required, or would require, the transfer from the care of the CNM is resolved.
- Specifies that a CNM may attend pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting if consistent with the provisions of this bill.
- Clarifies that the provisions of this bill may not be interpreted to deny a patient’s right to self-determination or informed decision-making with regard to choice of provider or birth setting.
- Excludes from CNM scope the assistance of childbirth by vacuum or forceps extraction, or to any external cephalic version.
- Requires a CNM to document all consultations, referrals, and transfers in the patient record.
- Requires a CNM to refer all emergencies to a physician and surgeon immediately and authorizes the CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician and surgeon is obtained.
- Clarifies that the Nursing Practice Act does not authorize a CNM to practice medicine or surgery.
- Clarifies that the provisions of this bill do not require standardized procedures or permit any action in violation of the Nursing Practice Act.
- Clarifies that mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols are not required for care rendered for low-risk pregnancies.
- Aligns the authority for a CNM to furnish or order drugs, tests, or devices with the removal of physician supervision for low-risk pregnancies under this bill.
- Removes the physician supervision, standardized procedure, and settings requirement for the performance and repair of episiotomies and repair of first- and second-degree lacerations of the perineum.
- Requires, if the intended site of birth is outside a hospital settings, a CNM to disclose, as part of a patient care plan, and obtain informed consent for, the following:
- Information related to the CNM’s license, practice settings, and liability coverage.
- Information related to the limits of the CNM’s scope of practice, and transfer and referral requirements,
- The availability of the text of laws regulating CNMs and procedures for reporting complaints to the BRN.
- Information related to the patient relationship to the CNM and consulting physician.
- Requires the disclosure and consent to be signed by both the CNM and patient and requires a copy to be placed in the patient’s medical record.
- Authorizes the Nurse-Midwifery Committee, in consultation with the board, to recommend the form for the written disclosure and informed consent statement used by a certified nurse-midwife.
- Establishes various reporting and data collection requirements related to labor and deliver services occurring in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Makes numerous technical and conforming changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis of the June 18, 2020, version of this bill:
- The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs.
- The Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) anticipates a one-time cost of $250,000 to build a data collection system and $50,000 ongoing for system maintenance (Health Data and Planning Fund). There may be additional ongoing costs to OSHPD to manage data collection and reports. However, these additional costs are unknown as the type of data CNMs would be required to report to OSHPD is not specified. OSHPD currently builds, maintains, and produces reports on licensed midwives who assist in childbirths in out-of-hospital settings. Costs to OSHPD to implement the requirements of this bill may be similar to its reporting requirements for licensed midwives. OSHPD notes that it does not receive specific funding to support the licensed midwives data reporting.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Nurse-Midwives Association, Black Women for Wellness Action Project, NARAL Pro-Choice California, and United Nurses Association of California. According to the author, “[this bill] seeks to increase access to childbirth by establishing a collaborative model of care for certified nurse midwifery in California. [This bill] promotes team-based care, which has been shown to improve safety and quality of care. Supervision doesn’t make sense anymore. It is not defined in California statute and does not require the physician to: be physically present, examine the patient, sign or review any charts, or oversee patient care in any way. Supervision forces nurse-midwives to concentrate in geographic areas where physicians physically practice, thereby reducing access particularly in rural counties and lower income communities. There is a direct link between race, access, and maternity outcomes in minority communities. Improving access to nurse-midwifery care has been named by leading organizations, such as the March of Dimes and the World Health Organization, as one of the most innovative strategies in addressing racial disparities in communities of color. Consistent with what 47 other states have already done, [this bill] will remove the ‘physician permission to practice law’ for nurse-midwives. It also defines what true collaborative care is between physicians and midwives and creates the foundation for consultation, collaboration and seamless transfer of care when needed. This is a first step toward truly integrating nurse-midwifery and obstetrical care, so that diverse patient needs can be attended to by a diverse provider group, working together toward shared goals.”
Background. CNMs are licensed registered nurses (RNs) with additional training in the field of obstetrics and certification by the American Midwifery Certification Board or an equivalent program. As a result of their additional training, they are considered advanced practice RNs.
As RNs, CNMs have the same scope of practice as non-advanced practice RNs. However, CNMs are also specifically authorized to perform midwifery services and attend childbirth as long as they practice under the supervision of a physician trained in obstetrics. Because supervision is not defined, it is often understood to mean standardized procedures, which are policies and protocols developed with a physician or within a health system. Under supervision or standardized procedures, CNMs attend to childbirths in many settings, including the home, birth centers, clinics, and hospitals.
The Practice of Midwifery. Midwifery is a health care profession dealing with maternal care, similar to obstetrics. According to the World Health Organization, midwifery includes the care of a person during pregnancy, labor, and the postpartum/postnatal period, including care of the newborn. Midwifery providers aim to prevent health problems in pregnancy, detect abnormal conditions, seek medical assistance when necessary, and provide emergency services when medical help is unavailable.
On its own, midwifery care is not technically the practice of medicine. Medicine is the treatment of medical conditions. While pregnancy may create additional physical and emotional stress, under normal conditions it is not an illness or ailment requiring medical treatment. Therefore, medical services are not always necessary. Instead, midwifery providers monitor for abnormal conditions and provide preventive care.
Abnormal conditions are signals of a high-risk pregnancy, meaning there is a higher risk of complications requiring medical services to protect the mother or fetus. According to the federal National Institutes of Health (NIH), “high-risk pregnancy refers to anything that puts the mother or fetus at increased risk for poor health during pregnancy or childbirth. A pregnancy is considered high risk if the mother has chronic health conditions such as high blood pressure or diabetes, or if she weighs too much or too little. Any pregnancy where complications are more likely than normal is considered a high-risk pregnancy.”
While CNM’s are authorized to assist a mother in childbirth under normal conditions, they are also required to immediately refer all complications to a physician. Only physicians who are trained in obstetrics, maternal-fetal medicine (perinatology), or similar field may independently attend all stages of childbirth, including high-risk pregnancies, and provide any medically necessary services resulting from complications.
Physician Supervision. While RN’s may provide nursing services without supervision, most RNs practice alongside physicians and other providers as part of a care team. In hospital and other organized health settings, RNs, including CNMs, operate pursuant to administrative, medical staff, and standardized policies or procedures, even when within the RN’s scope of practice.
In licensing, supervision is a mechanism by which a licensed professional oversees the practice of another for purposes of training or consumer protection. For example, supervision may be required when the education, training, or experience of a licensee does not sufficiently prepare the licensee to perform independent services safely or competently. As a result, when RN’s provide medical or other non-nursing services that fall outside of an RN’s scope of practice, they practice under supervision or standardized procedures.
For purposes of midwifery however, the author and sponsors argue that existing supervision and standardized procedure requirements are overly restrictive given the education and training of CNMs. Standardized procedures must be developed with a physician, or within an organized health system, and must follow guidelines established by the Medical Board and the BRN in regulation.
At a minimum, standardized procedures must be in writing and signed, specify the authorized functions, establish procedure protocols, detail education and training requirements, provide for evaluation and of authorized nurses, provide for the maintenance of records of authorized nurses, establish the scope of physician supervision, set forth circumstances requiring physician consultation, state limitations on settings, specify patient record keeping requirements, and provide for periodic review of the standardized procedures.
According to the author and sponsors, despite this rigidity, standardized procedures and supervision do not provide require actual oversight of health care delivery. Therefore, they argue that standardized procedures and supervision unnecessarily restrict CNMs to geographic regions where qualified physicians are available to supervise.
LAO Report. On March 11, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office released Analysis of California’s Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives, which analyzed whether the current physician supervision requirement is meeting its intended safety and quality objectives, taking into consideration cost and access to health care services. One of the findings was that California’s supervision requirement is “unlikely to improve safety and quality for low-risk pregnancies and births”.
The recommendations focused on low-risk pregnancies because they are what CNMs are authorized to attend under current law. CNMs do not deliver twins on their own, do not perform cesarean sections, do not use vacuums or forceps or other mechanical means to deliver a baby, and do not deliver babies that are significantly premature or significantly post-term. They are already required to refer patients to a physician when complications arise.
The LAO report, based on an analysis of various studies, did “not find evidence that the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care by nurse midwives is inferior to that of physicians in cases of low risk pregnancies and births.” The report also concludes that “states with physician supervision or collaboration agreement requirements do not have superior maternal and infant health outcomes than states without such requirements.” It notes that since the supervision requirements in statute do not clearly define the responsibilities of supervision, “the state’s requirement is unlikely to be more effective than other states’ similar requirements. Therefore, we find that California’s supervision requirement for nurse midwives is unlikely to improve safety and quality for low risk pregnancies and births.” The report found “some evidence that access to nurse midwife services specifically, and women’s health care services generally, might be limited in California. For example, the recent high growth in earnings for nurse midwives suggests that demand for their services may exceed supply. We also find evidence of geographic disparities across the state in access to care by OB GYNs.”
The report agreed with the Federal Trade Commission’s finding that physician supervision requirements likely impede access and raise costs by giving physicians control over nurse midwives’ ability to independently deliver services. They cite research on the national level showing that patients in states without occupational restrictions on nurse midwives, such as physician oversight, tend to have greater access to nurse midwife services.
The report further advised that “removing the state’s physician supervision requirement could increase access to nurse midwife services, including in the rural and inland areas of the state that today have relatively more limited access to women’s health care services. In addition, we find that removing the requirement could improve the cost effectiveness of women’s health care services by increasing utilization of a less costly but capable provider and potentially lowering the medically unnecessary use of certain costly procedures, such as cesareans.”
Per the report, the LAO recommends removing the physician supervision requirement for CNMs, as it is “unlikely to be effective in achieving its objective of improving safety and quality.” LAO further recommends adding other alternative safeguards to ensure safety and quality like requiring CNMs to:
- Have relationships with physicians and other providers that would allow CNMs to continue to consult with them and refer their clients to these providers as necessary.
- Practice as a part of a health system (generally defined as a hospital, provider group, or health plan).
- Practice in a licensed or accredited facility.
- Maintain medical malpractice insurance.
- Meet minimal clinical experience standards (such as a minimum number of years of practice) in order to practice without oversight.
The report focused on a number of issues to reach its conclusion. One factor noted in the analysis was the lack of definition of supervision in California state law, making the supervisory practice inconsistent across practitioners and settings. Additionally, the report noted that in states without physician supervision requirements, the population of practicing CNMs was higher. The report further noted that there could be a higher portion of women who seek services of a CNM, but may not be able to access that care as supervision has led to a potential limited number of providers in California. It is important to note that the report analysis highlighted the need for additional research in the area of safety in homebirths and birth centers by CNMs as those settings are not where the majority of the CNMs practice.
This bill would remove physician supervision as currently defined for low-risk pregnancies, relatively consistent with the LAO’s recommendations. In place of supervision, the bill would instead require LAO recommendation 1) above, relationships with physician’s and other providers that would provide for collaborative care. This bill would also require data reporting and collection of births outside of hospital settings. While the other recommendations are not implemented, this bill limits the unsupervised practice to low-risk pregnancies and midwifery care that falls outside of the practice of medicine, which are consistent with the recommendations not included under this bill.
Healthforce Report. On October 19, 2019, the Healthforce Center at the University of California San Francisco released a report, California’s Midwives: How Scope of Practice Laws Impact Care. That report was part of a series conducted by the center looking at various professions and related scope of practice laws. The study noted that to ensure that women’s health care needs are met, national organizations recommend that the midwifery workforce increase and that midwives work within a system of care that fosters collaboration among licensed, independent providers. According to the report, “Recent research has found that states that required physician oversight of midwives between 2012 and 2016 had a lower concentration of midwives as compared with states that allowed autonomous practice; the research also found that counties in states with restrictive practice were less likely to have a midwife than counties in autonomous-practice states.” According to research analyzed in the paper, “midwife care results in comparable or improved health outcomes for low- and moderate-risk mothers and infants compared with physician care. Additionally, the literature suggests that midwives help improve access to care for underserved communities and can help achieve health care expenditure savings. The research also finds that restrictions on midwives’ scope of practice may limit their supply and, consequently, the utilization of midwives.”
Other States. California is one of four states that have full statutory supervision requirements (Nebraska, North Carolina, and Florida). However, Florida recently removed the physician supervision requirement due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Of the states without full statutory supervision, states and the District of Columbia authorize CNMs to practice without physician supervision. Other states have partial supervision requirements that limit the services CNMs can provide and where they can provide them.
CNMs and Abortions. Existing law authorizes a registered nurse or physician assistant to perform an abortion by medication or aspiration in the first trimester of pregnancy under standardized procedures or other relevant supervision. Some opponents of this bill argue that the relaxing of physician supervision requirements will lead to more abortions.
While this bill modifies the supervision requirements for attending pregnancies, it does not modify the requirements related to the performance of abortions. Specifically, this bill only pertains to a CNM’s ability to attend childbirth, provide interconception care and family planning, and provide immediate care for newborns, none of which include the performance of abortions. An abortion is the ending of a pregnancy. This bill would not expand access to abortions via a CNM because it does not amend the limitations related to abortion standardized procedure requirements under current law.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 2682 (Burke) of 2018 would have authorized a CNM to attend cases of normal pregnancy and childbirth without the supervision of a physician and surgeon, required BRN to establish a nurse-midwifery practice committee, and made conforming changes to child birth attendance requirements for naturopathic doctors. Note: AB 2682 died pending a hearing in the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development.
SB 457 (Bates) of 2017 would have revised the requirements for physicians and surgeons, LMs, and CNMs who attend cases of pregnancy and out-of-hospital childbirth, including specifying risk factors, referral requirements, and settings. Note: SB 457 died pursuant to Joint Rule 56.2 in the Senate Committee on Business and Professions.
AB 1612 (Burke) of 2017 would have authorized a CNM to furnish and order drugs and devices related to care rendered in a home under standardized procedures and protocols; authorized a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, to obtain and administer drugs and diagnostic tests, to order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and to receive reports that are necessary to his or her practice and consistent with nurse-midwifery education preparation; authorized a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second degree lacerations of the perineum, in a licensed acute care center, as specified, in a home setting and in a birth center accredited by a national accrediting body approved by the BRN; required a CNM when performing those procedures, to ensure that all complications are referred to a physician and surgeon immediately. None: AB 1612 died pending a hearing in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
AB 1306 (Burke) of 2016 would have removed specified physician and surgeon supervision requirements for CNMs, increased educational requirements, modified practice parameters, established a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee within the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN), and subjected CNMs to the ban on the corporate practice of medicine, as specified, among other changes. Note: AB 1306 failed passage on the Assembly floor when the Assembly did not concur in Senate amendments on a vote of 31-21-28.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-sponsor), Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-sponsor), NARAL Pro-Choice California (co-sponsor), United Nurses Association of California (co-sponsor), and other supporters generally support this bill, arguing it would “promote greater access to high-quality, high-value maternal health care for those who need it most.”
The co-sponsors argue, and other supporters generally echo, that:
- “Nurse-midwifery care saves healthcare dollars. An integrated system of care in which every woman receives the right level of care at the right time leads to cost savings. Fewer unnecessary medical interventions and Cesarean births means fewer complications and better outcomes, all resulting in lower healthcare costs.”
- “Currently, the United States is the most dangerous place to give birth in the developed world. While California has made great strides to reduce maternal mortality, we still have rates of maternal and infant mortality and morbidity far higher than other countries with similar wealth. These rates are even further exacerbated for black women, who are 3 to 4 times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes and childbirth than white women, and black babies who are 4 times more likely to die before their first birthday. The evidence is clear: implicit and explicit bias within the current system of care, and the downstream effects, such as lack of access to timely, culturally sensitive, early perinatal care are important contributing factors. Covid-19, as we have seen in recent weeks, is exacerbating race-based disparities. We need access to nurse-midwives at this critical juncture.”
- “Nurse-Midwifery is primed to expand access to maternal health care, with nurse-midwives already attending at least 50,000 births in California annually. About 97% of all CNM-attended births take place in a hospital setting, and 3% occur in the birth center or home birth settings. Removing the supervision requirement would allow significant scale-up of nurse-midwifery in California over the coming years, and the creation of innovative practice models to deliver care to women wherever they are, and whenever they need it.”
- “California is 1 of only 4 states to still require physician supervision of nurse-midwives [as drafted in California]. The current physician supervision rule creates many barriers to care. It tethers CNMs geographically and economically to where obstetricians already practice, without providing any actual oversight. This worsens the maldistribution of maternal health care providers in areas where the most vulnerable populations already lack access to care, and during a time when California is facing a dangerous OB/GYN shortage across the state.
Integrated, team-based care is the future of maternal health care in California. The strength of nurse- midwifery lies in the collaborative nature of practice. Nurse-midwives believe in a diverse care team to meet the diverse needs of every woman. [This bill] bolsters collaboration with physicians and encourages the team-based model of care by replacing supervision language with specific language around consultation, collaboration, and referral – the very language that both the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the American College of Nurse-Midwives embrace.
Women in California want greater access to nurse-midwifery care. According to the 2018 Listening to Mothers in California Survey, supported by the California Health Care Foundation, just 9% of California women have been able to utilize a midwife's services, but 54% of women in California ‘definitely want or would consider a midwife in their next birth.’ Women have a fundamental right to birth with the provider of their choosing, in the setting they choose, regardless of geographic location, socioeconomic status, race, or other demographic.
- “Supervision means permission to practice. This is an anti-competitive rule that thwarts competition and health care innovation. The Federal Trade Commission notes the following: ‘Physician supervision requirements raise competition concerns because they effectively give one group of health care professionals the ability to restrict access to the market by a competing group of health care professionals, thereby denying health care consumers the benefits of greater competition.’
Nurse-midwives have a vision of seamless, integrated care between nurse-midwives and physicians that will result in improved access to health services for those who need it most, reducing disparities in outcomes, thereby lowering health care costs, improving overall quality of care, and leading to greater innovation in health care delivery.”
The Board of Registered Nursing has a support if amended position, and would support this bill if amended as follows:
- “The bill would require the committee consist of 4 qualified nurse-midwives, 2 qualified physicians and surgeons, including, but not limited to, obstetricians or family physicians, and one public member. We suggest that this amendment relating to the makeup of the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee be removed, as the committee’s current structure is meeting the Board’s advisory needs for issues relating to nurse-midwifery. Moreover, the Board believes that the mandatory inclusion of two physicians and surgeons on the committee is inappropriate.”
- “[This bill] requires the committee to provide recommendations or guidance on care when the Board is considering disciplinary action against a certified nurse-midwife. This requirement presents numerous issues (only some of which are identified here). First, in general, the text of [this bill] identifies specific problems that the bill seeks to address with regard to some of the proposed statutory changes – for example, it cites a lack of access to obstetric care in underserved regions as a justification for allowing nurse-midwives to attend to low-risk pregnancies and to provide care without direct supervision; however, the bill does not identify any problem nor any policy reason that justifies requiring the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee to review and opine on disciplinary matters. Second, many of the Board’s disciplinary cases against nurse-midwives are based on conduct or actions that are not matters of highly technical nurse-midwife practice – for example, cases based on violent crimes or sexual misconduct. While the conduct at issue in discipline cases must bear some nexus to the practice of nursing, it is often not necessary that a specialized committee with expertise in nurse-midwifery review and opine on such cases. In cases where such specialized knowledge of nurse-midwifery practice is required, evidence on the standard of care is generally provided by the parties’ respective expert witnesses. Third, the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee would be required to conduct meetings in accordance with the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act; requiring the committee to provide guidance to the Board on disciplinary matters involving nurse-midwives could potentially make it more difficult for the Board to meet the procedural deadlines contained in the Administrative Procedure Act, due to the added challenges of arranging a committee meeting as a prerequisite to a Board meeting at which such cases will be heard. The BRN respectfully requests that the requirement that the committee provide guidance on disciplinary matters be removed.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
A coalition of licensed midwives and consumers who generally support midwifery with less physician involvement oppose this bill. Specifically, California Families for Access to Midwives writes, and other opponents of the bill that support independent midwifery generally echo that:
- They “have strong concerns with putting paternalistic and oppressive restrictions on women’s access to care in statute, because medical guidelines can and should evolve based on the latest research. Some sections of this language have the stipulation they are based on evidence and accepted practice, however these two things (evidence and accepted practice) can be at odds as the medical field often needs time to catch up to research.”
- “[D]ecision-making around health care should be between a pregnant person and their care provider after weighing their personal risks and situation. Nowhere else do such medical details exist in statute and it is no coincidence that the one place this exists is related to pregnant bodies and their care. Besides this being a concern related to self-determination and bodily autonomy, this is related to quality of care, as it can lead to dangerous situations where a pregnant person may be left without a provider at an advanced stage in their pregnancy because it becomes illegal for their current provider to continue to care for them. A midwife would be placed in the untenable position to abandon their client or break the law. As the implementation of AB 1308 has made evident, NO physicians whatsoever are willing to take transferring patients who are in the late stages of pregnancy. Birthing families are falling through the cracks.”
- “We urge you to remove the following language that restricts in a blanket way any access to out-of-hospital midwifery care from pregnant people who:
- Have a pre-existing maternal disease or condition creating risks higher than that of a low-risk pregnancy or birth, based on current evidence and accepted practice.
- Have disease arising from or during the pregnancy creating risks higher than that of a low-risk pregnancy or birth, based on current evidence and accepted practice.
- Don’t have a singleton fetus.
- Have a cephalic presentation at the onset of labor.
- The gestational age of the fetus is not 37 weeks or under 42 weeks.
- Labor is spontaneous or induced in an outpatient setting.
This language, particularly, the first two sections is so general that it can be interpreted to restrict pregnant people from giving birth with a midwife as primary care provider due to slightly higher risks but risks that a reasonable person may still accept, such as having undergone IVF to achieve pregnancy, being over the age of 40, or being obese.”
- “[W]e would also staunchly oppose any amendment that restricts access to Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (VBAC). The aforementioned language creates incredibly problematic legislative barriers to care and borders on the violation of the rights of patients. These health concerns should be handled through evidence-based regulation as they are with every other healthcare profession, and not fossilized in statute.”
- “As the COVID-19 pandemic has demonstrated worldwide, medical protocols absolutely must change quicker than the legislative process can possibly enact. We see today, midwives are also on the frontlines of this pandemic, providing essential health care services in hospitals, birth centers, and at home . In a pandemic, access to out-of-hospital birth is more crucial than ever as we collectively seek to minimize transmission and conserve strained hospital resources. As with past epidemics, an upsurge of pregnant people are now turning to out-of-hospital birth to reduce the risk of exposure, to avoid medical interventions, and to avoid stringent medical protocols that limit partners and support people in the delivery room; other pregnant people are preparing for unassisted birth in case the hospitals are full; and yet other pregnant people are submitting to cascading, hospital outcome-driven medical interventions that demonstrably worsen birth outcomes and increase mortality rates. In the US, we have historically faced a shortage of maternity care and abominable maternal/fetal mortality rates with disparities manifest in underserved communities. As the COVID-19 pandemic escalates, as medical resources are diverted, and as hospitals are increasingly restricted to emergency triage, we need to ensure that birthing families receive evidence-based care that improves birth outcomes. More than ever, we need to cut through the red tape and enable all midwives to serve autonomously without legislative barriers to care. We urge you to expedite granting autonomy to nurse-midwives by removing the restrictive language above.”
Several groups also oppose this bill because they generally believe the modifications of the supervision requirement under the bill will expand access to abortions or allow the performance of abortions without physician supervision, including Alliance to Protect Children, California Prolife Council and Right to Life Federation, California Right to Life Committee, INC., Compassion Pregnancy Center & Clinic of the Monterey Bay, Con Mis Hijos No Te Metas - California Chapter, Eagle Forum of California, Real Impact, California Family Council, Californians for Life,
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
Data Reporting. This bill establishes data reporting requirements for purposes of compliance and data collection for out-of-hospital births and transfers. The author and sponsors are working with the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD), the California Department of Public Health (CPDH), and other stakeholders, including the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, District IX and the California Medical Association to further refine the reporting requirement to ensure it is implemented as intended.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Nurse Midwives Association (co-sponsor)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-sponsor)
NARAL Pro-Choice California (co-sponsor)
United Nurses Associations of California/Union of Health Care Professionals (co-sponsor)
2020 Mom
Academy of Lactation Policy and Practice INC.
Access Women's Health Justice
American Association of Birth Centers
American Civil Liberties Union/Northern CA/Southern CA/San Diego and Imperial Counties
American College of Nurse-Midwives
American Nurses Association/California
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of Women's Health and Neonatal Nursing
Beach Cities Midwifery & Women's Health Care
Beach Cities Midwifery and Women's Healthcare
Best Start Birth Center
Black Wellness & Prosperity Center
Business & Professional Women of Nevada County
California Association for Nurse Practitioners
California Association of Nurse Anesthetists
California Black Women's Health Project
California Board of Registered Nursing (if amended)
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Pan - Ethnic Health Network
California Women's Law Center
Center on Reproductive Rights and Justice
Citizens for Choice
Every Neighborhood Partnership
Feminist Majority Foundation
Grow Midwives
HealthImpact
Healthy Children Project, INC.
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice\
March of Dimes
Maternal and Child Health Access
Medical Board of California
MomsRising
National Council of Jewish Women CA
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
New Birth Services
Pacific Business Group on Health
Pacifica Family Maternity Center
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
South Coast Midwifery & Womens Health Care
Stonewall Democratic Club
The Children’s Partnership
The Praxis Project
The Women's Foundation of California
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
University of California
Urge: Unite for Reproductive & Gender Equity
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Women's Health Specialists
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Alliance to Protect Children
Bakersfield Birth Center INC.
California Association of Licensed Midwives
California Families for Access to Midwives (unless amended)
California Family Council (unless amended)
California Prolife Council and Right to Life Federation
California Right to Life Committee, INC.
Californians for Life
Californians for the Advancement of Midwifery
Compassion Pregnancy Center & Clinic of the Monterey Bay
Con Mis Hijos No Te Metas - California Chapter
Eagle Forum of California
Intergalactic Council of Midwives (unless amended)
Midwives Alliance North America
Oakland Better Birth Foundation (unless amended)
Real Impact.
VBAC Facts
Welcome Home Community Birth Center, INC (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1237 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1237
Author: Dodd (D), et al.
Amended: 6/18/20
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 8-0, 5/18/20
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SUBJECT: Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
SOURCE: Black Women for Wellness Action Project
California Nurse-Midwives Association
DIGEST:
This bill removes the requirement for physician and surgeon supervision for a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to practice midwifery; revises the provisions defining the practice of midwifery; authorizes a CNM to attend cases out of a hospital setting; authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices in accordance with standardized protocols; and, requires a CNM to provide specified disclosures to a patient.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) to provide for the licensure and regulation of the practice of nursing and authorizes the BRN to issue a certificate to practice nurse-midwifery to a person who meets educational standards established by the BRN or the equivalent of those educational standards. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2700 et seq.)
- Specifies that the practice of “midwifery” is the furthering or undertaking by a CNM, under the supervision of a licensed physician who has current practice or training in obstetrics, to assist a woman in childbirth so long as progress meets criteria accepted as normal and all complications are to be referred to a physician. (BPC § 2746.5(b))
- Authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second degree lacerations of the perineum in a licensed acute care hospital and a licensed alternate birth center, if certain requirements are met, including, but not limited to, that episiotomies are performed pursuant to protocols developed and approved by the supervising physician and surgeon. (BPC § 2746.52)
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices, including Schedule II-V controlled substances, pursuant to physician supervision, standardized procedures and protocols, and other conditions, as specified. (BPC § 2746.51)
This bill:
- Names the BRN’s current CNM committee the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee and specifies that the majority of committee members are CNMs while 40 percent are physicians.
- Deletes the requirement for supervision by a licensed physician as part of a certificate to practice midwifery. States that the certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to attend cases of low-risk pregnancy consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, or its successor national professional organization, as approved by the BRN. Defines low risk pregnancy as one in which there is a single fetus, there is a cephalic presentation at onset of labor; the gestational age of the fetus is greater than or equal to 37 weeks and zero days and less than or equal to 42 weeks and zero days at the time of delivery, labor is spontaneous or induced, and the patient does not have a preexisting disease or condition, whether arising out of the pregnancy or otherwise, that adversely affects the pregnancy and the CNM is not qualified to independently address.
- Authorizes a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, obtain and administer diagnostic tests, order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and receive reports that are necessary to their practice as a CNM within their scope of practice. Allows CNM to perform and repair episiotomies, and to repair first and second degree lacerations of the perineum without physician supervision, as specified. Prohibits a CNM from using vacuum or forceps, or performing any external cephalic version.
- Deletes the definition of supervision for purposes of practicing nurse-midwifery. States that the certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to practice with a physician under mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral and transfer of a patient’s care, signed by the both the CNM and a physician to either: (a) provide patient with care that falls outside the scope of services of a low-risk pregnancy, as specified; or (b) provide intrapartum care to a patient who has had a prior cesarean section or surgery that interrupts the myometrium.
- Requires a patient to be transferred to the care of a physician if a CNM does not have in place mutually agreed-upon policies and protocols that delineate the parameters for consultation, collaboration, referral, and transfer of a patient’s care signed by both the CNM and a physician, if the care falls outside the specified scope of services, or if the patient has had a prior cesarean section or surgery. Authorizes a patient that has been transferred from the care of a CNM to that of a physician to be returned to the care of the CNM after the physician has determined the condition or the circumstance that required the transfer has been resolved. Requires a CNM to refer all emergencies to a physician immediately, and authorizes a CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician is obtained.
- States that the certificate to practice midwifery authorizes the holder to attend pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting and authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs and devices when providing care in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Requires a CNM to provide a disclosure, both orally and in written form, to a prospective patient as part of the patient care plan, and to obtain informed consent and a signature, when providing care in a setting outside of a hospital, that outlines information about the CNM’s lack of supervision, licensure status, liability insurance status, arrangements for transfer, and the availability of statute regulating CNM practice.
- Requires a CNM to report the outcome of a birth in an out-of-hospital setting, as specified.
- Makes findings and declarations related to maternity care in California, including racial disparities.
Background
Certified Nurse Midwives. CNMs are advanced practice registered nurses who have specialized education and training to provide primary care, prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including interconception care and family planning. These individuals are licensed by the BRN, have acquired additional training in the field of obstetrics, and are certified by the American College of Nurse Midwives.
Currently, the nurse-midwifery certificate authorizes the CNM to attend cases of normal childbirth, as well as immediate care for the newborn, but only under the supervision of a licensed physician. A CNM may furnish drugs and devices after completing at least six months of physician supervised experience in the furnishing of drugs and devices and a course in pharmacology.
Protocols are a part of standardized procedures and are designed to describe the steps of medical care for given patient situations. Protocols are currently developed in consultation with a supervising physician, and CNMs are required to include the extent of that supervisions as part of those standardized procedures related to ordering or furnishing drugs or devices (BPC § 2746.51(A)(2)(B).
There are approximately 700 CNMs practicing in California. In 2017, it was reported that CNMs attended nearly 50,000 births across the state (out of the 470,000 births that occurred that year). Although CNMs are authorized to practice in birth centers and home-based settings, the majority provide client care in a hospital setting.
Supervision. Standardized procedures are developed collaboratively by nurses, physicians, and the administration of an organized health care system. The BRN and the Medical Board of California have jointly promulgated guidelines for standardized procedures (CCR, tit. 16, § 1474). They are based on the competence of the nurses providing the procedures and include record, referral, and setting requirements, among other patient protections. While supervision by a physician is required for CNMs to provide patient care, that supervision does not require the physical presence of a physician so currently, a CNM can work miles away from the actual location of the physician, and as long as the standardized procedures are in place, the CNM may deliver babies and provide other authorized practices by a CNM.
Studies and Access to Care. On March 11, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office released Analysis of California’s Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives, which analyzed whether the current physician supervision requirement is meeting its intended safety and quality objectives, without significantly increasing cost or decreasing access to health care services. Ultimately, part of the findings of that report noted that California’s current supervision requirement is “unlikely to improve safety and quality for low-risk pregnancies and births”. The LAO report, based on an analysis of various studies, did “not find evidence that the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care by nurse midwives is inferior to that of physicians in cases of low risk pregnancies and births.” The report also concludes that “states with physician supervision or collaboration agreement requirements do not have superior maternal and infant health outcomes than states without such requirements.” It notes that since the supervision requirements in statute do not clearly define the responsibilities of supervision, “the state’s requirement is unlikely to be more effective than other states’ similar requirements. Therefore, we find that California’s supervision requirement for nurse midwives is unlikely to improve safety and quality for low risk pregnancies and births.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, BRN does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs. The Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development anticipates a one-time cost of $250,000 to build a data collection system and $50,000 ongoing for system maintenance and acknowledges potential additional ongoing costs to manage data collection and reports.
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/19/20)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-source)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-source)
2020 Mom
Academy of Lactation Policy and Practice Inc.
American Association of Birth Centers
American Civil Liberties Union/northern California/southern California/san Diego and Imperial Counties
American College of Nurse-midwives
Association of Women's Health and Neonatal Nursing
Beach Cities Midwifery & Women's Health Care
Best Start Birth Center
Black Wellness & Prosperity Center
California Association of Nurse Anesthetists
California Black Women's Health Project
California Board of Registered Nursing
California Health Coalition Advocacy
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Women's Law Center
Center on Reproductive Rights and Justice
Citizens for Choice
Every Neighborhood Partnership
Feminist Majority Foundation
Grow Midwives
HealthImpact
Healthy Children Project, Inc.
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Medical Board of California
Midwives Alliance North America
Momsrising
Naral Pro-choice California
National Council of Jewish Women California
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
New Birth Services
Pacific Business Group on Health
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
The Praxis Project
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
United Nurses Associations of California/union of Health Care Professionals
Urge: Unite for Reproductive & Gender Equity
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc.
Women’s Foundation California/Women’s Policy Institute
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/19/20)
American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX
California Association of Licensed Midwives
California Families for Access to Midwives
Californians for the Advancement of Midwifery
Intergalactic Council of Midwives
Welcome Home Community Birth Center, Inc.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters note that this bill will increase access to maternal health and improve maternal and newborn health outcomes.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents note concerns about restricting access to patient choice in certain healthcare settings while supporting the removal of physician supervision of nurse-midwifery.
Prepared by: Sarah Mason and Elissa Silva / B., P. & E.D. /
6/23/20 17:13:58
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1237 (Dodd) - Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
Version: May 19, 2020 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 8 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 18, 2020 | Consultant: Janelle Miyashiro |
Bill Summary:
SB 1237 (1) removes the requirement for physician and surgeon supervision for a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to practice midwifery; (2) revises the provisions and definitions of the practice of midwifery; (3) authorizes a CNM to attend cases out of a hospital setting, as specified; (4) authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices in accordance with standardized protocols; and, (5) requires a CNM to provide specified disclosures to a patient.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on June 18, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
The Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, however there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs.
The Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD) anticipates a one-time cost of $250,000 to build a data collection system and $50,000 ongoing for system maintenance (Health Data and Planning Fund). There may be additional ongoing costs to OSHPD to manage data collection and reports. However, these additional costs are unknown as the type of data CNMs would be required to report to OSHPD is not specified. OSHPD currently builds, maintains, and produces reports on licensed midwives who assist in childbirths in out-of-hospital settings. Costs to OSHPD to implement the requirements of this bill may be similar to its reporting requirements for licensed midwives. OSHPD notes that it does not receive specific funding to support the licensed midwives data reporting.
Author Amendments:
- Remove definitions for “consultation,” “comanagement,” “referral,” and “transfer.”
- Define “low-risk pregnancy” and conform CNM care guidelines to that definition.
- Authorize a CNM, under a signed agreement with a physician or surgeon, to:
- Provide care to a patient who is not considered a low-risk pregnancy.
- Provide intrapartum care to a patient who has had a prior cesarean section or other surgery, as specified.
- If a physician or surgeon assumes care of a patient:
- Authorize a CNM to continue to attend the birth of the newborn and participate in the patient’s care under agreed upon policies and protocols signed by both the CNM and physician or surgeon.
- Authorize a CNM to continue care of a patient during the interval between referral and the initial appointment with a physician or surgeon.
- Require a CNM to transfer a patient to the care of a physician or surgeon if the CNM does not have a signed agreement with a physician or surgeon, as specified.
- Provide that a CNM may practice in an out-of-hospital setting in accordance with the above provisions.
- Stipulate a patient’s right to self-determination or informed decision making with regard to choice of provider or birth setting.
- Authorize CNMs to furnish or order drugs or devices without signed protocols and procedures within specified parameters.
- Require a CNM to report the outcome of a birth in an out-of-hospital setting to OSHPD.
- Make other various technical and clarifying changes.
- Modify findings and declarations.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1237 (Dodd) - Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
Version: May 19, 2020 | Policy Vote: B., P. & E.D. 8 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: June 9, 2020 | Consultant: Janelle Miyashiro |
Bill Summary:
SB 1237 (1) removes the requirement for physician and surgeon supervision for a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to practice midwifery; (2) revises the provisions and definitions of the practice of midwifery; (3) authorizes a CNM to attend cases out of a hospital setting, as specified; (4) authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices in accordance with standardized protocols; and, (5) requires a CNM to provide specified disclosures to a patient.
Fiscal Impact:
While the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) does not anticipate a substantial fiscal impact as a result of this bill, there may be additional unanticipated indeterminable cost pressures to the BRN for expanded enforcement and workload requirements. Fees and assessments from licensees may offset ongoing enforcement and administration costs.
Background:
CNMs are advanced practice registered nurses who have specialized education and training to provide primary care, prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including intercontraception care and family planning. These individuals are licensed by the BRN, have acquired additional training in the field of obstetrics, and are certified by the American College of Nurse Midwives. In order to obtain a certificate to practice as a CNM, the applicant must provide proof to the BRN that they have either graduated from a BRN approved program in nurse-midwifery or satisfied equivalence standards as set forth in the BRN’s regulations (Title 16 California Code of Regulations § 1460).
The nurse-midwifery certificate authorizes the CNM to attend cases of normal childbirth, as well as immediate care for the newborn, but only under the supervision of a licensed physician. A CNM may furnish drugs and devices after completing at least six months of physician supervised experience in the furnishing of drugs and devices and a course in pharmacology. “Furnishing” is the ordering of a drug or device in accordance with standardized procedure or protocol.
Protocols are a part of standardized procedures and are designed to describe the steps of medical care for given patient situations. Protocols are currently developed in consultation with a supervising physician, and CNMs are required to include the extent of that supervisions as part of those standardized procedures related to ordering or furnishing drugs or devices (BPC § 2746.51(A)(2)(B).
There are approximately 700 CNMs practicing in California. In 2017, it was reported that CNMs attended nearly 50,000 births across the state (out of the 470,000 births that occurred that year). Of those births by a CNM, 98% were done in a hospital setting. Although CNMs are also authorized to practice in birth centers and home-based settings, the majority provide client care in a hospital.
Proposed Law:
This bill:
- Modifies the definition of “licensee” to include a certified nurse-midwife acting within their scope of practice.
- Includes CNMs in the prohibition of referring a person for laboratory, diagnostic nuclear medicine, radiation oncology, physical therapy, physical rehabilitation, psychometric testing, home infusion therapy, or diagnostic imaging goods or services if the CNM or their immediate family has a financial interest with the person or in the entity that receives the referral, and specifies that the BRN is responsible for disciplinary action should a violation occur.
- Authorizes the BRN to appoint a committee of qualified physicians and nurses to the Committee and:
- Make recommendations to the BRN on all matters related to midwifery practice, education, appropriate standards of care, and other matter as specified by the BRN.
- Authorizes the Committee to make recommendations on disciplinary actions.
- Specifies that Committee membership to include qualified nurses, physicians, and surgeons, including but not limited to obstetricians or family physicians.
- Specifies a majority of the Committee members be nurse-midwives and at least 40% of the Committee be physicians and surgeons.
- Authorizes the Committee to continue to make recommendations even if it is not able to appoint Committee members as specified.
- Defines the following:
- “Consultation” to mean a request for the professional advice or opinion of a physician or another member of a health care team regarding a patient’s care while maintaining primary management responsibility for the patient’s care.
- “Co-management” as the joint management by a CNM and a physician and surgeon of a patient who has become more medically, gynecologically, or obstetrically complicated.
- “Referral” to mean the direction of a patient to a physician or healing arts licensee for management of a particular problem or aspect of the patient’s care.
- “Transfer” to mean the transfer of primary management responsibility of a patient’s care from a CNM to another healing arts licensee or facility.
- Removes the requirement for supervision by a licensed physician as part of a certificate to practice midwifery.
- Adds specified care guidelines consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives or any successor national professional organization as approved by the BRN.
- Requires a practicing CNM to emphasize informed consent, preventive care and early detection and referral of complications to physicians.
- Redefines the practice to include consultation, co-management, or referral as indicated by the health status of the patient and the resources and medical personnel available in the setting of care subject to the following:
- The certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to work collaboratively with a physician to co-manage care for a patient with more complex health needs.
- The scope of co-management may encompass the physical care of the patent, including birth, by the CNM, according to a mutually agreed upon plan of care with the physician and surgeon.
- If the physician must assume a lead role in the care of the patient due to an increased risk status, the CNM may continue to participate in care, counseling, guidance, teaching and support, according to a mutually agreed upon plan.
- After a CNM refers a patient to a physician, the CNM may continue to care for the patient during a reasonable interval between the referral and the initial appointment with the physician.
- A patient must be transferred from the primary management responsibility of the CNM to that of a physician or surgeon for the management of a problem or aspect of the patient’s care that is outside the scope of CNM’s education, training, or experience.
- A patient that has been transferred from the primary management responsibility of a CNM may return to the care of the CNM after resolution of any problem that required the transfer, as specified.
- Deletes the definition of “supervision” for purposes of practicing nurse-midwifery.
- Authorizes a CNM to attend the pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting if all of the following conditions apply:
- Neither a pre-existing maternal disease or condition, or disease arising from or during pregnancy creating higher than that of a low-risk pregnancy or birth based on current evidence and accepted practice are present;
- There is a singleton fetus;
- There is cephalic presentation at the onset of labor;
- The gestational age of the fetus is at least 37 completed weeks of pregnancy and less than 42 completed weeks at the onset of labor; and
- Labor is spontaneous or induced in an outpatient setting.
- Prohibits CNMs to assist childbirth by vacuum, forceps extraction, or performance of any external cephalic version.
- Requires CNMs to document all consultations, referrals, and transfers in a patient record.
- Requires CNMs to refer all emergencies to a physician and surgeon immediately and authorizes a CNM to provide emergency care until the specified assistance is obtained.
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs and devices when providing care in an out-of-hospital setting.
- Deletes the requirement that a CNM’s protocol for furnishing drugs or devices contain the extent of the physician supervision.
- Deletes the requirement that the furnishing and ordering of drugs or devices be done under the supervision of a physician, as specified.
- Authorizes a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, obtain and administer diagnostic tests, order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and receive reports that are necessary to their practice as a CNM within their scope of practice.
- Deletes the current requirements for a CNM to perform episiotomies and repair first and second degree lacerations, and authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies, and to repair first and second degree lacerations of the perineum without physician supervision, as specified.
- Requires a CNM to provide a disclosure orally and in written form to a prospective patient as part of the patient care plan and obtain informed consent for all of the following when providing care in a setting outside of a hospital:
- The patient is retaining a CNM and the CNM is not supervised by a physician;
- The CNM’s licensure status, licensure number, and practice setting in which the CNM practices;
- If the CNM does or does not have liability insurance;
- There are conditions that are outside the of the scope of practice of a CNM, that will result in a referral for a consultation, or transfer of care to a physician;
- The specific arrangements for the referral of complications to a physician for consultation;
- The specific arrangements for the transfer of care during the prenatal period, the intrapartum and postpartum periods, as specified, and access to appropriate emergency medical services for mother and baby if necessary and recommendations for preregistration at a hospital that has obstetric emergency services and is most likely to receive the transfer;
- If during the course of care, the patient is informed that the patient has or may have a condition indicating the need for a mandatory transfer, the CNM must indicate the transfer;
- The availability of the text of laws regulating CNM practices and procedures, for reporting complaints to the BRN, which may be found on the BRN’s internet website; and,
- Consultation with a physician does not alone create a physician-patient relationship or any other relationship with the physician. That CNM is independently licensed and practicing midwifery and in that regard is solely responsible for the services the CNM provides.
- Specifies that the disclosure and consent requirements must be signed by both the patient and the CNM and a copy placed in the patient medical record.
- Authorizes the Committee to recommend the form for the written disclosure and informed consent.
- Specifies disclosure requirements by a CNM are not required in a hospital setting.
- Makes findings and declarations related to maternity care in California, including racial disparities.
- Makes other technical changes.
Staff Comments:
Regulation Promulgation. Although not explicitly specified, the BRN may need to promulgate regulations relating to a new type of CNM practice in the home or otherwise out-of-hospital settings. Specifically, the bill requires the new CNM standard of practice established to be consistent with the Core Competencies for Basic Midwifery Practice adopted by the American College of Nurse-Midwives, or its successor national professional organization, as approved by the BRN. Further, the bill establishes conditions relating to the attendance of birth that are not present under current statute or regulation. While these conditions may be consistent with current practice and standardized procedures, this may depart from the BRN’s current regulations and result in an indeterminate fiscal impact on the BRN’s operations.
Nurse Midwifery Advisory Committee. The BRN is currently authorized to appoint a committee of qualified physicians and nurses, including, but not limited to, obstetricians and nurse-midwives, to develop the necessary standards relating to educational requirements, ratios of nurse-midwives to supervising physicians, and associated matters. The BRN reports that this committee meets between 2-3 times annually. This bill additionally authorizes the BRN to appoint a committee with specified membership makeup to be called the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee and requires the Committee to, among other things, make recommendations to the BRN on all matters related to midwifery practice, education, and appropriate standards of care. The BRN has not provided a fiscal estimate for the expanded Committee proposed in this bill. To the extent that this Committee requires additional resources, including but not limited to, short-term workload to update guidances or per diem and travel expenses for Committee members, this bill may create additional indeterminate cost pressures.
IT Fiscal Impact. The BRN also reports that several new enforcement codes and a new modifier will need to be created in the BreEZe system to comply with the proposed provisions of the bill. The fiscal estimate of these modifications is reported to be $3,000, and the BRN reports this cost will be absorbable by the redirection of existing maintenance resources.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 1237 Hearing Date: May 18, 2020
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | Elissa Silva | ||
Subject: Nurse-midwives: scope of practice
SUMMARY:
Removes the requirement for physician and surgeon supervision for a certified nurse midwife (CNM) to practice midwifery; revises the provisions defining the practice of midwifery; authorizes a CNM to attend cases out of a hospital setting; authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices in accordance with standardized protocols; and, requires a CNM to provide specified disclosures to a patient.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN) to provide for the licensure and regulation of the practice of nursing and authorizes the BRN to issue a certificate to practice nurse-midwifery to a person who meets educational standards established by the BRN or the equivalent of those educational standards. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 2700 et seq.)
- Authorizes the holder of a nurse-midwifery certificate (CNM) to practice midwifery under the supervision of a licensed physician, to attend cases or normal childbirth, and to provide prenatal, intrapartum, and post-partum care, including family-planning care for the mother and immediate care of the newborn. (BPC § 2746.5(a))
- Specifies that the practice of “midwifery” is the furthering or undertaking by a CNM, under the supervision of a licensed physician who has current practice or training in obstetrics, to assist a woman in childbirth so long as progress meets criteria accepted as normal and all complications are to be referred to a physician. (BPC § 2746.5(b))
- States that the practice of midwifery does not include the assisting of childbirth by any artificial, forcible, or mechanical means. (BPC § 2746.5(d))
- States that physician “supervision” shall not be construed to require the physical presence of the supervising physician. (BPC § 2746.5 (c))
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish and order drugs or devices incidentally to the provision of family planning services, routine health care or perinatal care, and care rendered consistently with the CNM's educational preparation in specified facilities and clinics, and only in accordance with standardized procedures and protocols, as specified. (BPC § 2746.51 et seq.)
- Authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second degree lacerations of the perineum in a licensed acute care hospital and a licensed alternate birth center, if certain requirements are met, including, but not limited to, that episiotomies are performed pursuant to protocols developed and approved by the supervising physician and surgeon. (BPC § 2746.52)
- Authorizes the BRN to appoint a Nurse-Midwifery Committee of qualified physicians and nurses, including, but not limited to, obstetricians and nurse-midwives, to develop the necessary standards relating to educational requirements, ratios of nurse-midwives to supervising physicians, and associated matters. (BPC § 2746.2)
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices, including Schedule II-V controlled substances, pursuant to physician supervision, standardized procedures and protocols, and other conditions, as specified. (BPC § 2746.51)
- Prohibits a physician from referring a person for laboratory, diagnostic nuclear medicine, radiation oncology, physical therapy, physical rehabilitation, psychometric testing, home infusion therapy, or diagnostic imaging goods or services if the physician or his or her immediate family has a financial interest with the person or in the entity that receives the referral. (BPC § 650.01)
This bill:
- Prohibits CNMs from referring a person for laboratory, diagnostic nuclear medicine, radiation oncology, physical therapy, physical rehabilitation, psychometric testing, home infusion therapy, or diagnostic imaging goods or services if the CNM or his or her immediate family has a financial interest with the person or in the entity that receives the referral, and specifies that the BRN is responsible for disciplinary action should a violation occur.
- Revises the participants on the BRN’s committee on nurse midwives and requires the majority of committee members to be nurse midwives, and formally names the committee, the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee.
- Defines “consultation” to mean a request for the professional advice or opinion of a physician or another member of a health care team regarding a patient’s care while maintaining primary management responsibility for the patient’s care.
- Defines “co-management” as the joint management by a CNM and a physician and surgeon of a patient who has become more medically, gynecologically, or obstetrically complicated.
- Defines “referral” to mean the direction of a patient to a physician or healing arts licensee for management of a particular problem or aspect of the patient’s care.
- Defines “transfer” to mean the transfer of primary management responsibility of a patient’s care from a CNM to another healing arts licensee or facility.
- Deletes the requirement for supervision by a licensed physician as part of a certificate to practice midwifery.
- Adds specified care guidelines to the practice of midwifery under a certificate to practice.
- Requires a practicing CNM to emphasize informed consent, preventive care and early detection and referral of complications to physicians.
- Deletes the current definition of what constitutes practice of nurse-midwifery and redefines the practice to include consultation, co-management, or referral as indicated by the health status of the patient and the resources and medical personnel available in the setting of care subject to the following:
- The certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the holder to work collaboratively with a physician to co-manage care for a patient with more complex health needs;
- The scope of comanagement may encompass the physical care of the patent, including birth, by the CNM, according to a mutually agreed upon plan of care with the physician;
- If the physician must assume a lead role in the care of the patient due to an increased risk status, the CNM may continue to participate in care, counseling, guidance, teaching and support, according to a mutually agreed upon plan.
- After a CNM refers a patient to a physician, the CNM may continue to care for the patient during a reasonable interval between the referral and the initial appointment with the physician;
- A patient must be transferred from the primary management responsibility of the CNM to that of a physician for the management of a problem or aspect of the patient’s care that is outside the scope of CNM’s education, training and experience; and,
- A patient that has been transferred from the primary management responsibility of a CNM may return to the care of the CNM after resolution of any problem that required the transfer, as specified,
- Deletes the definition of “supervision” for purposes of practicing nurse-midwifery.
- States that a certificate to practice nurse-midwifery authorizes the CNM to attend pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting if all of the following conditions apply:
- Neither a pre-existing maternal disease or condition, or disease arising from or during pregnancy creating higher than that of a low-risk pregnancy or birth based on current evidence and accepted practice are present;
- There is a singleton fetus;
- There is cephalic presentation at the onset of labor;
- The gestational age of the fetus is at least 37 completed weeks of pregnancy and less than 42 completed weeks at the onset of labor; and,
- Labor is spontaneous or induced in an outpatient setting.
- Prohibits a CNM from using vacuum or forceps, or performing any external cephalic version.
- Requires a CNM to maintain clinical practice guidelines that delineate the parameters for consultation, comanagement, referral, and transfer of a patient’s care.
- Requires a CNM to document all consultations, referrals and transfers in the patient record.
- Requires a CNM to refer all emergencies to a physician immediately.
- Authorizes a CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician is obtained.
- Authorizes a CNM to furnish or order drugs and devices when providing care in an out-of-hospital setting.
- Deletes the requirement that a CNM’s protocol for furnishing drugs or devices contain the extent of the physician supervision.
- Deletes the requirement that the furnishing and ordering of drugs or devices be done under the supervision of a physician, as specified.
- Authorizes a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, obtain and administer diagnostic tests, order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and receive reports that are necessary to their practice as a CNM within their scope of practice.
- Deletes the current requirements for a CNM to perform episiotomies and repair first and second degree lacerations, and allows CNM to perform and repair episiotomies, and to repair first and second degree lacerations of the perineum without physician supervision.
- Requires a CNM to provide a disclosure orally and in written form to a prospective patient as part of the patient care plan and obtain informed consent for all of the following when providing care in a setting outside of a hospital:
- The patient is retaining a CNM and the CNM is not supervised by a physician;
- The CNM’s licensure status, licensure number, and practice setting in which the CNM practices;
- If the CNM does or does not have liability insurance;
- There are conditions that are outside the of the scope of practice of a CNM, that will result in a referral for a consultation, or transfer of care to a physician;
- The specific arrangements for the referral of complications to a physician for consultation;
- The specific arrangements for the transfer of care during the prenatal period, the intrapartum and postpartum periods, as specified, and access to appropriate emergency medical services for mother and baby if necessary and recommendations for preregistration at a hospital that has obstetric emergency services and is most likely to receive the transfer;
- If during the course of care, the patient is informed that the patient has or may have a condition indicating the need for a mandatory transfer, the CNM must indicate the transfer;
- The availability of the text of laws regulating CNM practices and procedures, for reporting complaints to the BRN, which may be found on the BRN’s internet website; and,
- Consultation with a physician does not alone create a physician-patient relationship or any other relationship with the physician. That CNM is independently licensed and practicing midwifery and in that regard is solely responsible for the services the CNM provides.
- Specifies that the disclosure and consent must be signed by both the patient and the CNM and a copy placed in the patient medical record;
- Authorizes the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee to recommend the form for the written disclosure and informed consent.
- Makes findings and declarations related to maternity care in California, including racial disparities.
- Makes other technical changes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by California Nurse-Midwives Association and the Black Women for Wellness Action Project. According to the Author, “The United States has some of the highest maternal and infant mortality in the industrialized world, and even though California has made great strides to reduce the rates, we still have rates of maternal and infant mortality and morbidity far higher than other countries that have similar wealth. These rates are even further exacerbated for black women, who are 3 to 4 times more likely to die from childbirth than white women and black babies who are 4 times more likely to die before their first birthday. Evidence has pointed out that some of the factors that contribute to high rates of infant and maternal mortality are lack of access to timely, culturally sensitive early perinatal care perinatal, neonatal care. In addition, access to care in California is even more of a threat with studies showing that at least 9 counties have no OB/GYN at all and that large counties in Northern and Southern CA are projected to have critical shortages of maternity care providers by 2025.”
- Background.
Certified Nurse Midwives. CNMs are advanced practice registered nurses who have specialized education and training to provide primary care, prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including interconception care and family planning. These individuals are licensed by the BRN, have acquired additional training in the field of obstetrics, and are certified by the American College of Nurse Midwives. In order to obtain a certificate to practice as a CNM, the applicant must provide proof to the BRN that they have either graduated from a BRN approved program in nurse-midwifery or satisfied equivalence standards as set forth in the BRN’s regulations (Title 16 California Code of Regulations § 1460).
The nurse-midwifery certificate authorizes the CNM to attend cases of normal childbirth, as well as immediate care for the newborn, but only under the supervision of a licensed physician. A CNM may furnish drugs and devices after completing at least six months of physician supervised experience in the furnishing of drugs and devices and a course in pharmacology. “Furnishing” is the ordering of a drug or device in accordance with standardized procedure or protocol.
Protocols are a part of standardized procedures and are designed to describe the steps of medical care for given patient situations. Protocols are currently developed in consultation with a supervising physician, and CNMs are required to include the extent of that supervisions as part of those standardized procedures related to ordering or furnishing drugs or devices (BPC § 2746.51(A)(2)(B).
There are approximately 700 CNMs practicing in California. In 2017, it was reported that CNMs attended nearly 50,000 births across the state (out of the 470,000 births that occurred that year). Of those births by a CNM, 98% were done in a hospital setting. Although CNMs are also authorized to practice in birth centers and home-based settings, the majority provide client care in a hospital.
As currently drafted, this bill deletes the requirement that in order to practice midwifery, a CNM must be subject to physician supervision, and instead provides the CNM authority practice independently, in various settings, as long as the CNM maintains clinical practice guidelines that outline the appropriate action for consultation, comanagement, referral, and transfer of a patient’s care when the patient’s condition is beyond the CNM’s training and experience.
This bill lays out the specific practice guidelines a CNM must utilize in the event a patient’s condition is beyond their training and experience. This bill will allow CNMs to practice without supervision as long as the CNM works collaboratively with a physician in those cases that result in more complex healthcare needs for their patient. CNMs will be required to transfer care of a patient to a physician for the management of a problem that is outside of the scope of the CNM’s training, education, and expertise. This bill would allow a patient’s primary care to be transferred back to the CNM in the event the medical problem which required the transfer was resolved. Further, this bill lays out the process by which a CNM would continue to co-manage, with the physician, the care of a patient with more complex needs. This bill requires CNMs to refer all emergencies to a physician immediately, but allow the CNM to provide emergency care until the assistance of a physician and surgeon is obtained. Although a CNM may need to refer a patient to a physician, the provisions of this bill allow for the CNM to maintain a relationship with the patient, as specified.
Related to the furnishing and ordering of drugs or devices, this bill would maintain the majority of the current requirements for establishing protocols and procedures for a CNM to order or furnish drugs, and a CNM would be authorized to procure supplies, devices, order diagnostic tests, and receive reports that are necessary for their practice.
Although CNMs are authorized to practice in home-settings, the majority of CNM practice is in a hospital setting. This bill would authorizes a CNM to attend pregnancy and childbirth in an out-of-hospital setting if specified conditions are met, including that the gestational age of the fetus is within a specified range.
BRN Committee. Per BPC 2746.2, the BRN is authorized, but not required, to appoint a committee of qualified physicians and nurses, including, but not limited to, obstetricians and nurse-midwives, to develop standards related to educational requirements, ratios of nurse-midwives to supervising physicians, and associated matters.
The BRN adopted regulations to require itself to appoint a committee. The committee is currently comprised of at least one CNM and one physician, at least one public member and may include such other members as deemed appropriate. As noted in the regulations, “the purpose of this committee is to advise the [BRN] on all matters pertaining to nurse-midwifery as established by the board, and, if necessary, to assist the board or its designated representatives in the evaluation of applications for nurse-midwifery certification.” According to the BRN, the committee meets between 2-3 times annually.
This bill would maintain the existing authority for the BRN to appoint a committee, however, the Committee would formally be named the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee and would not be mandated to focus on supervision or ratios as specified in current statute. While the committee would maintain a representation of physicians, including family physicians, the committee membership would be mandated to be a majority CNMs.
Supervision. Standardized procedures are developed collaboratively by nurses, physicians, and the administration of an organized health care system. The BRN and the Medical Board of California have jointly promulgated guidelines for standardized procedures (CCR, tit. 16, § 1474). They are based on the competence of the nurses providing the procedures and include record, referral, and setting requirements, among other patient protections. While supervision by a physician is required for CNMs to provide patient care, that supervision does not require the physical presence of a physician. Meaning, a CNM can work miles away from the actual location of the physician, and as long as the standardized procedures are in place, the CNM may deliver babies and provide other authorized practices by a CNM.
CNMs are authorized to prescribe under protocols, however, a physician must be available via a telephone at the time of a patient’s visit and physicians are limited to supervising no more than 4 CNMs at a time. While this bill would maintain the development of procedures between a CNM and a physician, the prescribing authority is no longer dependent upon a physician’ supervision.
Other States. Although CNMs are practicing in all 50 states, their practice authority varies. California is one of only four states that requires physician supervision. The other three are Nebraska, Florida, and North Carolina. In 19 other states, CNMs are required to have some form of a collaboration agreement, and 27 states allow for independent practice.
Licensed Midwives. California has two regulated professionals who provide midwifery services, CNMs and Licensed Midwives (LMs). A LM is an individual who has been issued a license to practice midwifery by the Medical Board of California (MBC) under the LM Act. LMs who have achieved the required educational and clinical experience in midwifery (including completing a three-year postsecondary education program in an accredited midwifery school approved by the MBC) or met the challenge requirements (obtaining credit by examination for previous education and clinical experience –this option is no longer available as of January 1, 2015), must pass the North American Registry of Midwives’ comprehensive examination. After successful completion of this examination, prospective applicants are designated as a “certified professional midwife” and are eligible to submit an application for license as an LM.
LMs are authorized to attend cases of normal pregnancy and childbirth and to provide prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including family-planning care, for the mother and immediate care for the newborn. LMs can also directly obtain supplies and devices, obtain and administer drugs and diagnostic tests, order testing and receive reports that are necessary to his or her practice of midwifery and consistent with his or her scope of practice. LMs can practice in a home, birthing clinic or hospital environment. There are about 300 LMs in California.
MBC receives guidance on midwifery issues through a Midwifery Advisory Council (MAC). The MAC is made up of LMs (pursuant to BPC § 2509, at least half of the MAC members are LMs), a physician, and two non-physician public members.
AB 1308 (Bonilla, Chapter 665, Statutes of 2013) removed the statutory requirement for a LM to practice under the supervision of a physician and surgeon and instead specified that a midwife may assist in “normal” pregnancy and birth. MBC has been working for a number of years with stakeholders through the MAC and a specified task force in order to define “normal” in regulations, for purposes of clarifying births an LM can attend, as required under AB 1308. Until MBC adopts regulations, LMs are not able to be a “comprehensive perinatal provider” for purposes of providing comprehensive perinatal services to Medi-Cal beneficiaries in the Comprehensive Perinatal Services Program (CPSP). (SB 407 (Morrell, Chapter 313, Statutes of 2015) authorized a health care provider to employ or contract with licensed midwives for the purpose of providing comprehensive perinatal services in the CPSP.)
- Studies and Access to Care. On March 11, 2020, the Legislative Analyst’s Office released Analysis of California’s Physician-Supervision Requirement for Certified Nurse Midwives, which analyzed whether the current physician supervision requirement is meeting its intended safety and quality objectives, without significantly increasing cost or decreasing access to health care services. Ultimately, part of the findings of that report noted that California’s supervision requirement is “unlikely to improve safety and quality for low-risk pregnancies and births”.
Notably, low-risk pregnancies are the focus of these recommendations, since these are the clients and births that CNMs attend under current law. CNMs do not deliver twins on their own, do not perform cesarean sections, do not use vacuums or forceps or other mechanical means to deliver a baby, and do not deliver babies that are significantly premature or significantly post-term. They are already required to refer patients to a physician when complications arise.
The LAO report, based on an analysis of various studies, did “not find evidence that the safety and quality of maternal and infant health care by nurse midwives is inferior to that of physicians in cases of low risk pregnancies and births.” The report also concludes that “states with physician supervision or collaboration agreement requirements do not have superior maternal and infant health outcomes than states without such requirements.” It notes that since the supervision requirements in statute do not clearly define the responsibilities of supervision, “the state’s requirement is unlikely to be more effective than other states’ similar requirements. Therefore, we find that California’s supervision requirement for nurse midwives is unlikely to improve safety and quality for low risk pregnancies and births.” The report found “some evidence that access to nurse midwife services specifically, and women’s health care services generally, might be limited in California. For example, the recent high growth in earnings for nurse midwives suggests that demand for their services may exceed supply. We also find evidence of geographic disparities across the state in access to care by OB GYNs.”
As noted in the report, it agrees with the Federal Trade Commission’s finding that physician supervision requirements likely impede access and raise costs by giving physicians control over nurse midwives’ ability to independently deliver services. They cite research on the national level showing that patients in states without occupational restrictions on nurse midwives, such as physician oversight, tend to have greater access to nurse midwife services.
The report advises that “removing the state’s physician supervision requirement could increase access to nurse midwife services, including in the rural and inland areas of the state that today have relatively more limited access to women’s health care services. In addition, we find that removing the requirement could improve the cost effectiveness of women’s health care services by increasing utilization of a less costly but capable provider and potentially lowering the medically unnecessary use of certain costly procedures, such as cesareans.”
LAO recommends removing the physician supervision requirement for CNMs, as it is “unlikely to be effective in achieving its objective of improving safety and quality.” LAO further recommends adding other alternative safeguards to ensure safety and quality like requiring CNMs to:
- Have relationships with physicians and other providers that would allow certified nurse midwives to continue to consult with them and refer their clients to these providers as necessary.
- Practice as a part of a health system (generally defined as a hospital, provider group, or health plan).
- Practice in a licensed or accredited facility.
- Maintain medical malpractice insurance.
- Meet minimal clinical experience standards (such as a minimum number of years of practice) in order to practice without oversight.
The report focused on a number of issues to reach its conclusion. One factor noted in the analysis was the lack of definition of supervision in California state law, making the supervisory practice inconsistent across practitioners and settings. Additionally, the report noted that in states without physician supervision requirements, the population of practicing CNMs was higher. The report further noted that there could be a higher portion of women who seek services of a CNM, but may not be able to access that care as supervision has led to a potential limited number of providers in California. It is important to note that the report analysis highlighted the need for additional research in the area of safety in homebirths and birth centers by CNMs as those settings are not where the majority of the CNMs practice.
On October 19, 2019, the Healthforce Center at the University of California San Francisco released a report, California’s Midwives: How Scope of Practice Laws Impact Care. That report was part of a series conducted by the center looking at various professions and related scope of practice laws. The study noted that to ensure that women’s health care needs are met, national organizations recommend that the midwifery workforce increase and that midwives work within a system of care that fosters collaboration among licensed, independent providers. According to the report, “Recent research has found that states that required physician oversight of midwives between 2012 and 2016 had a lower concentration of midwives as compared with states that allowed autonomous practice; the research also found that counties in states with restrictive practice were less likely to have a midwife than counties in autonomous-practice states.” According to research analyzed in the paper, “midwife care results in comparable or improved health outcomes for low- and moderate-risk mothers and infants compared with physician care. Additionally, the literature suggests that midwives help improve access to care for underserved communities and can help achieve health care expenditure savings. The research also finds that restrictions on midwives’ scope of practice may limit their supply and, consequently, the utilization of midwives.”
- COVID-19 and the Health Care Crisis of 2020. The World Health Organization has designated 2020, as the “year of the nurse and the midwife” and noted on its internet website that “Nurses and midwives play a vital role in providing health services…They are often, the first and only point of care in their communities. The world needs 9 million more nurses and midwives if it is to achieve universal health coverage by 2030.”
There have been numerous news headlines over the past few weeks that depict a surge in demand for the services of midwives, as concerns of pregnant women rise over hospital and patient safety, stay at home orders and concerns over capacity and supplies as a result of the recent pandemic. As more information and data is compiled related to the care and treatment of pregnant women during the pandemic, there will likely be additional future research necessary that will share how COVID-19 impacted hospital births, who treated these patients, and concerning outcomes from those births will likely be scrutinized in the future, along with the reality that the pandemic likely transformed maternal care.
- Current Related Legislation. AB 890 (Wood) would authorizes a nurse practitioner (NP) to provide specified services, without physician supervision if the NP meets additional education, examination, and training requirements; establishes a new Advanced Practice Registered Nursing (APRN) Board to regulate independent NPs; and establishes regulatory requirements for independent practice. (Status: This bill is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Rules.)
- Prior Related Legislation. AB 2682 (Burke of 2018) would have authorized a CNM to attend cases of normal pregnancy and childbirth without the supervision of a physician and surgeon, required BRN to establish a nurse-midwifery practice committee, and made conforming changes to child birth attendance requirements for naturopathic doctors. (Status: The bill was never heard in this committee).
SB 457 (Bates) of 2017 would have established a framework for out-of-hospital childbirths by repealing and revising and recasting provisions of the Licensed Midwifery Practice Act of 1993. Would have authorized physicians and surgeons, licensed midwives (LMs) CNMs to only attend cases of pregnancy and out-of-hospital childbirths according to certain circumstances. Provided that LMs can only attend out-of-hospital childbirths. Granted CNMs the authority to practice without physician and surgeon supervision only for out-of-hospital childbirths. Required reporting to the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development from hospitals and licensees attending out-of-hospital childbirths. (Status: The bill was never heard in this committee.)
AB 1612 (Burke) would have authorized a CNM to furnish and order drugs and devices related to care rendered in a home under standardized procedures and protocols; authorizes a CNM to directly procure supplies and devices, to obtain and administer drugs and diagnostic tests, to order laboratory and diagnostic testing, and to receive reports that are necessary to his or her practice and consistent with nurse-midwifery education preparation; authorizes a CNM to perform and repair episiotomies and to repair first-degree and second degree lacerations of the perineum, in a licensed acute care center, as specified, in a home setting and in a birth center accredited by a national accrediting body approved by the BRN; requires a CNM when performing those procedures, to ensure that all complications are referred to a physician and surgeon immediately. (Status: This bill was held under submission in the Assembly Committee on Appropriations).
SB 1306 (Burke) of 2016 removes certain physician supervision requirements for a CNM, increases educational requirements, modifies practice parameters, establishes a Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee within the Board of Registered Nursing (BRN), and subjects CNMs to the ban on the corporate practice of medicine, as specified, among other changes. (Status: This bill failed passage on the Assembly Floor).
SB 1308 (Bonilla, Chapter 665, Statutes of 2013) authorized a LM to directly obtain supplies and devices, obtain and administer drugs and diagnostic tests, order testing and receive reports that are necessary to his/her practice of midwifery and consistent with his/her scope of practice; expanded the disclosures required to be made by a midwife to a prospective client to include the specific procedures that warrant consultation with a physician and surgeon; and made other correcting and conforming changes.
SB 1950 (Figueroa, Chapter 1085, Statutes of 2002) required the MBC to adopt regulations defining the appropriate standard of care and level of supervision required for the practice of midwifery.
SB 1479 (Figueroa, Chapter 303, Statutes of 2000) expanded the disclosures required to be given by LMs and also required midwives to register birth certificates for home births.
SB 350 (Killea, Chapter 1280, Statutes of 1993) enacted the Licensed Midwifery Practice Act of 1993 to provide for the licensing and regulation of non-nurse and non-physician assistant midwives by the MBC.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters note that California is one of only four states to still require physician supervision of CNMs. Supporters believe that the current physician supervision rule creates many barriers to care and note that, most significantly, this rule tethers CNMs geographically and economically to where obstetricians already practice. Supporters state that this worsens the maldistribution of maternal health care providers in areas where the most vulnerable populations already lack access to care, during a time when we have large disparities in birthing outcomes.
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Medical Association and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists are opposed to this bill, noting that, “SB 1237 would remove the requirement that a [CNM] practice under the supervision of a physician and surgeon and would instead authorize a [CNM] to attend cases of normal pregnancy and childbirth and to provide prenatal, intrapartum, and postpartum care, including gynecologic and family-planning services, interconception care, and immediate care of the newborn.”
The California Association of Licensed Midwives (CALM) states that “While CALM strongly supports the removal of physician supervision of nurse-midwifery care from California statute, we do not believe that the rights of birthing families should be the price exchanged for autonomous practice. Indeed, such language is drawn directly from California’s licensed midwife statute, and our members see first-hand on a regular basis the damaging effects on patient care that arbitrary and non-evidence based barriers to access create.”
- Proposed Author’s Amendments. Pursuant to continued discussions with interested parties, the Author has proposed amendments to make certain clarifying changes in the findings and declarations related to the practice of nurse midwifery, to make various minor and technical clarifications, and to specify that the Nurse-Midwifery Committee is to be comprised of at least 40 percent physician members, but still be authorized to meet if that 40 percent cannot be achieved. The Committee composition is discussed below.
- Policy Issues for Consideration.
Outpatient Settings. As currently drafted, this bill would authorize a CNM to provide services, without physician supervision, to a patient in an out-of-hospital setting, as long certain conditions are met, including, that the labor is spontaneous or induced in an outpatient setting. However, what is considered an “outpatient setting” under this bill is unclear. While this language appears to be modeled after provisions in the LM Act, clarifications as to the setting included in this term could be beneficial. As such, the Author should continue working with interested parties, committee staff, and agencies to ensure that “outpatient setting” reflects the various locations an individual may give birth and may be attended by a CNM.
Furnishing or ordering of drugs and devices. As currently drafted, this bill would maintain that in order for a CNM to furnish or order drugs or devices, they would need to have collaboratively developed protocols with a physician. If this bill seeks to provide CNMs with independent practice authority, it is unclear why this level of supervision may still be necessary. Could this lead to unintended barriers for access to care? The Author should continue to refine the requirements that are necessary to ensure patient safety and ensure appropriate furnishing of medications by a CNM.
Disclosures. This bill was recently amended to require a CNM practicing in an out-of-hospital setting provide a voluminous disclosure document to a patient, in both oral and written form, and obtain informed consent prior to practice.
While disclosures can certainly be beneficial and informative for patients in determining their best care options, some of the proposed prescribed requirements may be more confusing than helpful, including providing patients information about “The arrangements for the referral of complications to a physician and surgeon for consultation, where the CNM shall not be required to identify a specific physician and surgeon.” This appears to conflict with the provisions of this bill which require a CNM’s practice guidelines delineate the procedures for comanagement and referral of care.
Additionally, the authority for the Nurse-Midwifery Advisory Committee to recommend a standardized form for the disclosures could be complicated by the specificity of the required disclosure on “The specific arrangements for the transfer of care during the prenatal period, hospital transfer during the intrapartum and postpartum periods, and access to appropriate emergency medical services for mother and baby if necessary, and recommendations for preregistration at a hospital that has obstetric emergency services and is most likely to receive the transfer.” It is not clear how this could be easily standardized, given that CNMs’ physician recommendations and referrals may vary from CNM to CNM and by condition of a patient.
The new language also requires CNMs to obtain informed consent for all of the various disclosures required. There are various areas of the law providing definitions of informed consent, a requirement that carries legal significance and certainly goes beyond mere disclosure. For example:
- Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instruction Number 532:
“Informed Consent—Definition
A patient’s consent to a medical procedure must be “informed.” A patient gives an “informed consent” only after the [insert type of medical practitioner] has adequately explained the proposed treatment or procedure.
[A/An] [insert type of medical practitioner] must explain the likelihood of success and the risks of agreeing to a medical procedure in language that the patient can understand. [A/An] [insert type of medical practitioner] must give the patient as much information as [he/she] needs to make an informed decision, including any risk that a reasonable person would consider important in deciding to have the proposed treatment or procedure, and any other information skilled practitioners would disclose to the patient under the same or similar circumstances. The patient must be told about any risk of death or serious injury or significant potential complications that may occur if the procedure is performed. [A/An] [insert type of medical practitioner] is not required to explain minor risks that are not likely to occur.” (1 CACI 532 (2019))
- From the Welfare and Institutions Code:
“For purposes of this chapter, “written informed consent” means that a person knowingly and intelligently, without duress or coercion, clearly and explicitly manifests consent to the proposed therapy to the treating physician and in writing on the standard consent form prescribed in Section 5326.4.” (Welfare and Institutions Code § 5326.5.)
- From the Health and Safety Code:
“As used in this chapter, “informed consent” means the authorization given pursuant to Section 24175 to have a medical experiment performed after each of the following conditions have been satisfied:
(a) The subject or subject’s conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified in Section 24175, is provided with a copy of the experimental subject’s bill of rights, prior to consenting to participate in any medical experiment, containing all the information required by Section 24172, and the copy is signed and dated by the subject or the subject’s conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified in Section 24175.
(b) A written consent form is signed and dated by the subject or the subject’s conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified in Section 24175.
(c) The subject or subject’s conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified in Section 24175, is informed both verbally and within the written consent form, in nontechnical terms and in a language in which the subject or the subject’s conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified in Section 24175, is fluent, of the following facts of the proposed medical experiment, which might influence the decision to undergo the experiment, including, but not limited to:
(1) An explanation of the procedures to be followed in the medical experiment and any drug or device to be utilized, including the purposes of the procedures, drugs, or devices. If a placebo is to be administered or dispensed to a portion of the subjects involved in a medical experiment, all subjects of the experiment shall be informed of that fact; however, they need not be informed as to whether they will actually be administered or dispensed a placebo.
(2) A description of any attendant discomfort and risks to the subject reasonably to be expected.
(3) An explanation of any benefits to the subject reasonably to be expected, if applicable.
(4) A disclosure of any appropriate alternative procedures, drugs, or devices that might be advantageous to the subject, and their relative risks and benefits.
(5) An estimate of the expected recovery time of the subject after the experiment.
(6) An offer to answer any inquiries concerning the experiment or the procedures involved.
(7) An instruction to the subject that he or she is free to withdraw his or her prior consent to the medical experiment and discontinue participation in the medical experiment at any time, without prejudice to the subject.
(8) The name, institutional affiliation, if any, and address of the person or persons actually performing and primarily responsible for the conduct of the experiment.
(9) The name of the sponsor or funding source, if any, or manufacturer if the experiment involves a drug or device, and the organization, if any, under whose general aegis the experiment is being conducted.
(10) The name, address, and phone number of an impartial third party, not associated with the experiment, to whom the subject may address complaints about the experiment.
(11) The material financial stake or interest, if any, that the investigator or research institution has in the outcome of the medical experiment. For purposes of this section, “material” means ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or more in securities or other assets valued at the date of disclosure, or in relevant cumulative salary or other income, regardless of when it is earned or expected to be earned.
(d) The written consent form is signed and dated by any person other than the subject or the conservator or guardian, or other representative of the subject, as specified in Section 24175, who can attest that the requirements for informed consent to the medical experiment have been satisfied.
(e) Consent is voluntary and freely given by the human subject or the conservator or guardian, or other representative, as specified by Section 24175, without the intervention of any element of force, fraud, deceit, duress, coercion, or undue influence.” (HSC § 24173.)
- The Medical Practice Act is fairly limited as to where informed consent is required, with primarily certain major procedures (breast implants, sterilization, breast cancer treatment, IVF and sperm/ova retrieval) establishing this threshold for a prescriber to obtain. Informed consent is also required prior to treating a patient with DMSO, a clear odorless liquid, a by-product of the paper making process, approved by the FDA to treat interstitial cystitis, a bladder health issue which has been the source of research for a number of years and may provide benefit to patients experiencing other medical conditions.
- Doctors of chiropractic are required to obtain written informed consent prior to initiating clinical care, a requirement established through regulations promulgated by the Board of Chiropractic Examiners, which is comprised of a majority of practitioners.
While prior efforts to provide independent practice authority to CNMs have required patients to be given certain specified information, the informed consent threshold has only previously been considered in one bill which was never heard in a Senate policy committee. Language noting that “the practice of nurse-midwifery care emphasizes informed consent” is consistent but the Author should provide information as to what informed consent means for practitioners and patients, and should continue working with stakeholders to determine the impacts of this requirement, including whether this conforms to current practice.
Committee composition and requirements proposed by the Author. As currently drafted, this bill allows a Nurse Midwifery Advisory Committee to be established and specifies that this body may include, but is not limited to, qualified nurses and qualified physicians and surgeons, including family physicians and others.
As noted in 9) above the Author proposes to require the Nurse Midwifery Advisory Committee membership to be 40 percent of physicians and surgeons. The proposed language would also permit this committee to “continue to make recommendations to the BRN if, the committee is unable, despite good faith efforts, to solicit and appoint committee members.”
It would be helpful to understand the added patient value and ability for broad participation that the proposed composition allows for. An advisory body aimed at addressing CNM practice which includes almost a majority of physicians and surgeons, an entirely different profession, regulated by a separate practice act and licensing board, may prove to be a challenge in effectively carrying out its work, given that the existing committee has been hampered by an inability to have full physician membership. Further, while the 40% of threshold designates “physicians”, it does not specify that any of those practitioners have specialty board recognition or experience in certain disciplines like family practice or obstetrics which could certainly enhance discussions about safe and proper maternal and fetal care. The Author should continue working to evaluate the necessary expertise for the Nurse Midwifery Advisory Committee in order to effectively advise BRN on important CNM practice issues.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Black Women for Wellness (co-sponsor)
California Nurse Midwives Association (co-sponsor)
2020 Mom
Academy of Lactation Policy and Practice INC.
American Association of Birth Centers
American Civil Liberties Union/northern California/southern California/san Diego and Imperial Counties
American College of Nurse-midwives
Association of Women's Health and Neonatal Nursing
Beach Cities Midwifery & Women's Health Care
Best Start Birth Center
Black Wellness & Prosperity Center
Black Women for Wellness
California Association of Nurse Anesthetists (CANA)
California Black Women's Health Project
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Nurse Midwives Association (CNMA)
California Women's Law Center
Center on Reproductive Rights and Justice (CRRJ)
Citizens for Choice
Every Neighborhood Partnership
Feminist Majority Foundation
Grow Midwives
Healthimpact
Healthy Children Project, INC.
If/when/how: Lawyering for Reproductive Justice
Midwives Alliance North America
Momsrising
Naral Pro-choice California
National Council of Jewish Women (NCJW) CA
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
New Birth Services
Pacific Business Group on Health
The Praxis Project
Training in Early Abortion for Comprehensive Healthcare
United Nurses Associations of California/union of Health Care Professionals
Urge: Unite for Reproductive & Gender Equity
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Opposition:
American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District Ix
California Association of Licensed Midwives
California Medical Association
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):