SB 1299: Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-25
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (August 20). |
| Aug 18, 2020 | August 18 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Aug 3, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 30, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 29). |
| Jul 28, 2020 | July 28 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | Referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Jun 24, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jun 24, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 3818.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 23, 2020 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Jun 22, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3771.) (June 18). |
| Jun 11, 2020 | Set for hearing June 18. |
| Jun 9, 2020 | June 9 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 3, 2020 | Set for hearing June 9. |
| May 26, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0. Page 3595.) (May 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 14, 2020 | Set for hearing May 26. |
| May 11, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Apr 1, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 5, 2020 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 24, 2020 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 25. |
| Feb 21, 2020 | Introduced. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 29, 2020 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2020 | Special Consent SB1299 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2020 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 9, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1299
Author:(Portantino)
As Amended Ver:August 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes a program, to be administered by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), to provide grants to local governments for production of workforce housing on idle commercial shopping center properties.
Major Provisions
- Requires HCD, upon appropriation of funding by the Legislature, to establish a program to provide grants to cities and counties that rezone idle or underutilized big box retailer or commercial shopping center properties to instead allow for the development of workforce housing for lower- and moderate-income households.
- Defines "workforce housing" as an owner-occupied or rental housing development where all of the units are offered at an affordable cost or rent to lower- and moderate-income households (up to 120 percent of Area Median Income (AMI)). All rental units must be income-restricted for at least 55 years and all owner-occupied units for at least 45 years.
- Requires a city or county, to be eligible for funding, to have:
- Rezoned one or more idle sites, as defined, to instead allow the development of workforce housing as a use by right;
- Required that the development be built utilizing specified labor standards, generally including a skilled and trained workforce paid prevailing wages;
- Approved and issued a certificate of occupancy for a workforce housing development on each site rezoned; and
- Applied to HCD for grant funds and provide documentation that the city or county has complied with all requirements in this bill.
- Requires the grant amount awarded to each eligible city or county be one lump sum equal to seven times the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the city or county's application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the application, subject to certain modifications.
COMMENTS:
Fiscalization of Land Use. "Fiscalization of land use" is the concept that some types of development provide more tax revenue than others, thereby influencing the decision of local decision makers. In California, the bias is towards commercial development, and away from residential development. Ever since the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, property taxes have constituted a diminishing source of revenue for governments. This situation was exacerbated in the early 1990s when the state effectively commandeered local property tax revenues to meets its obligation to the public schools through the Education Revenue Augmentation Fund. In many cases, the additional revenues a local government now earns from each new housing unit are insufficient to cover the added expense of providing services to the new residents of that home. Some of the fixed costs of infrastructure can be recouped through fees, but the on-going service costs remain at issue. Thus, a city council deciding the fate of a new housing development faces the unenviable dilemma of denying needed housing or reducing services to existing constituents.
At the same time, when a city council considers an alternate proposal to develop a parcel of land as a retail center, the fiscal incentives strongly support approval. Local governments receive a large portion of all sales tax revenue generated within their borders. The additional revenue received from a large retail facility—such as a big-box retailer, online distribution center, or a car dealer—easily outweighs the costs of providing services to the facility. Local government can use these surplus revenues to enhance services to its constituents. Not only can it be difficult to get approval for a new housing development on residentially-zoned land, but more land is zoned commercial in the hope that retail establishments can be attracted. The only real fiscal incentive local governments have to approve housing is to ensure there are enough residents to support the retailers.
Purpose of this Bill: This bill seeks to facilitate the development of more housing affordable to households making less than 120 percent of the median income. It does so by incentivizing local governments to facilitate the conversion of idle big box sites and commercial shopping centers into such housing, in the form of grants issued by HCD. These grants would be issued to cities that enable such housing by right on those sites, and on which such units are produced utilizing a workforce that meets specified labor provisions. The grants would be equivalent to the sales tax generated by the site over the seven years prior to the local government's grant application. By tying the grant directly to lost sales tax revenue, the bill attempts to directly address the issue of fiscalization of land use discussed above. The grant program is subject to appropriation of General Fund dollars, and would be scaled proportionately if appropriation is insufficient to cover all qualified grantees. No funding for this bill appropriated for this program in this year's state budget. If there had been appropriation this year, the funding could have served as a real incentive for local governments contemplated how to plan and rezone to fulfill their regional housing needs allocation. However, it will be at least a year at a minimum before this program is funded. In that period, most or all of the jurisdictions in the state will have completed their housing elements and specified and/or completed their rezoning, thereby deflating the incentive element of this program.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy. We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There's an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing. We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters argue that this bill will simultaneously help build moderate-income housing and reward cities that facilitate such housing. According to the Los Angeles County Business Federation, this bill "will give local governments the needed resources to compensate the sales tax revenues produced from these former retail sites that help provide the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed to provide services to their residents.
Arguments in Opposition:
Opponents argue that this bill is part of a general pattern of legislation that would override local control over zoning.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy. We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There's an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing. We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters argue that this bill will simultaneously help build moderate-income housing and reward cities that facilitate such housing. According to the Los Angeles County Business Federation, this bill "will give local governments the needed resources to compensate the sales tax revenues produced from these former retail sites that help provide the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed to provide services to their residents.
Arguments in Opposition:
Opponents argue that this bill is part of a general pattern of legislation that would override local control over zoning.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations:
- HCD estimates, subject to an appropriation by the Legislature, administrative costs of up to $1.2 million (General Fund (GF)) annually for 6 PY of staff time, assuming 75 grants are awarded annually, to provide technical assistance to developers and local governments, develop Notices of Funding Availability (NOFAs), review applications, and process funding agreements. Actual costs for ongoing administration of the program would depend upon the amount of funding available and the number of applications submitted by local governments for review by HCD. There would be additional one-time costs to develop and adopt guidelines.
- Unknown annual cost pressures, likely in the tens of millions of dollars (GF), in future fiscal years to provide funding for the grant program. It is difficult to estimate the amount of funding necessary to establish an effective program, as the characteristics of each site, such as the size of the commercial space and historical sales tax generation, are likely to vary significantly and would not be known until after applications are filed. For example, if a 100,000 square foot idle big box retailer site historically generated $300 per square foot in average annual sales, and 80% of sales were subject to the local share of sales and use tax, that site would be eligible for an annual grant of $619,200 for seven years. Grants for smaller commercial strip malls would likely be much smaller.
Further, program eligibility requires a city or county to engage in a process of identifying eligible idle retail sites, rezoning those sites, attracting a developer to design and construct a workforce housing project, and issuing a certificate of occupancy. All these requirements must occur prior to the local government applying for a grant and would likely take several years. Assuming a local government would not pursue this program until it is funded by the Legislature, there would likely be a multi-year delay between program funding availability and the receipt of the first grant application by HCD.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Melendez, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Stern
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 7-0-1
YES: Chiu, Diep, Gabriel, Gloria, Limón, Bonta, Quirk-Silva
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-5
YES: Gonzalez, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Megan Dahle, Diep, Fong, Voepel
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0003422
Date of Hearing: August 18, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1299
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:August 3, 2020
Policy Committee: | Housing and Community Development | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes a program, to be administered by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), to provide grants to local governments for production of workforce housing on idle commercial shopping center properties. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires HCD, upon appropriation of funding by the Legislature, to establish a program to provide grants to cities and counties that rezone idle or underutilized big box retailer or commercial shopping center properties to instead allow for the development of workforce housing for lower- and moderate-income households.
- Defines “workforce housing” as an owner-occupied or rental housing development where 100% of the total units are for lower-income households (20% may be for moderate income households), all units are offered at an affordable cost or rent, as defined, and all rental units are income-restricted for at least 55 years and all owner-occupied units for at least 45 years.
- Requires a city or county, to be eligible for funding, to have rezoned one or more idle sites, as defined, to instead allow the development of workforce housing as a use by right.
- Further requires a city or county, to be eligible for funding, to approve and issue a certificate of occupancy for a workforce housing development on each site rezoned, apply to HCD for grant funds and provide documentation that the city or county has complied with all requirements in this bill.
- Requires the grant amount awarded to each eligible city or county be equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the city or county’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the application, subject to certain modifications.
- Requires HCD to allocate the grant amount determined in “5” above to the city or county for each of the seven years following the date of the city or county’s application.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- HCD estimates, subject to an appropriation by the Legislature, administrative costs of up to $1.2 million (GF) annually for 6 PY of staff time, assuming 75 grants are awarded annually, to provide technical assistance to developers and local governments, develop Notices of Funding Availability (NOFAs), review applications, and process funding agreements. Actual costs for ongoing administration of the program would depend upon the amount of funding available and the number of applications submitted by local governments for review by HCD. There would be additional one-time costs to develop and adopt guidelines.
- Unknown annual cost pressures, likely in the tens of millions of dollars (GF), in future fiscal years to provide funding for the grant program. Since the bill requires grants to be awarded for seven consecutive years, the cost pressures could grow annually in order to fund the second through seventh years of grants and to award new grants in future years, depending on how the program is structured. Absent an upfront allocation of funds to HCD sufficient to fund the grants for at least seven years, it appears unlikely a city or county would use this program.
It is difficult to estimate the amount of funding necessary to establish an effective program, as the characteristics of each site, such as the size of the commercial space and historical sales tax generation, are likely to vary significantly and would not be known until after applications are filed. For example, if a 100,000 square foot idle big box retailer site historically generated $300 per square foot in average annual sales, and 80% of sales were subject to the local share of sales and use tax, that site would be eligible for an annual grant of $619,200 for seven years. Grants for smaller commercial strip malls would likely be much smaller.
Further, program eligibility requires a city or county to engage in a process of identifying eligible idle retail sites, rezoning those sites, attracting a developer to design and construct a workforce housing project, and issuing a certificate of occupancy. All these requirements must occur prior to the local government applying for a grant and would likely take several years. Assuming a local government would not pursue this program until it is funded by the Legislature, there would likely be a multi-year delay between program funding availability and the receipt of the first grant application by HCD.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bills seeks to provide an incentive for cities and counties to build affordable housing on idle retail sites by providing a sales tax rebate for seven years, equivalent to the average amount generated on the site in the prior seven years, after the land is rezoned and the housing project completed.
- Background. Existing law requires cities and counties to prepare a general plan comprised of seven mandatory elements, including a housing element that identifies existing and projected housing needs. The housing element must include an inventory of adequate sites zoned for housing at all income levels and to accommodate a jurisdiction’s share of the regional housing needs that is sufficient to account for population growth and to overcome existing housing deficiencies over the planning period.
If the city or county does not have enough sites within its existing inventory of residentially zoned land to accommodate its share of the regional housing needs, it must adopt a program to rezone land within the first three years of the planning period. Housing elements must be updated every eight years in urban areas, and every five years in more rural areas.
- Use by Right. Existing law defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). A local government may require a by-right housing development to undergo design review, but cannot require CEQA review. To be eligible for a grant under this bill, a local government must allow the workforce housing development to be a use by right on the rezoned land.
- Fiscal incentives. In California, the sales and use tax generated by a retail facility typically far outweighs the cost of providing services to that facility. In contrast, the property tax generated by housing developments typically does not. This phenomenon, often called the fiscalization of land use, makes zoning for and attracting retail establishments more fiscally attractive to local officials than zoning for housing. This bill tries to encourage zoning for housing by addressing this fiscal inequity. It does so by allowing the amount of sales tax that likely would have been generated by a continued retail use on now idle land to be awarded as a grant to a local government that rezones the land for workforce housing instead.
- Policy Committee Amendments. The author agreed to a set of amendments in the Assembly Housing Committee that add labor-related requirements to the bill regarding the use of prevailing wage, project labor agreements and a skilled-and-trained workforce. As a result of this agreement, several labor advocates testified to removing their opposition to the bill. Those amendments will be adopted if and when this bill passes off this committee’s suspense file.
- Related Legislation.
AB 3107 (Bloom), of this legislative session, would require cities and counties to allow housing as an authorized use on commercially-zoned land, until January 1, 2030, under specified circumstances. AB 3107 is pending in the Senate Housing Committee.
SB 1385 (Caballero), of this legislative session, enacts the Neighborhood Homes Act, which requires a housing development project to be deemed an authorized use on a neighborhood lot zoned for office or retail commercial use. SB 1385 failed passage in the Assembly Local Government Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 29, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1299
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:June 18, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 39-0
SUBJECT: Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
SUMMARY: Upon appropriation of funds from the state General Fund, provides grants to local governments for production of moderate-income housing on idle commercial shopping centers. Specifically, this bill:
- Includes the following definitions:
- Defines “big box retailer” as a store of greater than 75,000 square feet of gross buildable area that generates or previously generated sales or use taxes;
- Defines “commercial shopping center” as a group of two or more stores that maintain a common parking lot for patrons of those stores;
- Defines “idle” as at least 80 percent of the leased or rentable square footage of the big box retailer or commercial shopping center site is not occupied for at least a 12-month period; and
- Defines “sales and use tax revenue” as the cumulative amount of revenue generated by taxes imposed by a local government, as specified.
- Upon appropriation, requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to administer a program to provide grants to local governments upon completion of moderate-income housing on sites that contained idle big box retailers or commercial shopping centers, as follows:
- To be eligible for funding, the local government must have:
- Rezoned one or more idle sites used for a big box retailer or commercial shopping center to allow moderate-income housing (between 80-120 percent of Area Median Income (AMI)) as a use by right, in that cannot be denied by the local government by right and is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA);
- Approve and issue a certificate of occupancy for a moderate-income housing development on each site rezoned for which the local government seeks a grant; and
- Apply to HCD for an allocation of grant funds and provide documentation that it has complied with the requirements in this bill.
- For each calendar year in which funds are made available, HCD must issue a notice of funding availability (NOFA) for the distribution of funds for the following 12-month period.
- Requires HCD to allocate the determined grant amount to each local government for each of the seven years following the date of the local government’s application.
- Provides that the amount granted to each eligible local government must be as follows:
- The annual grant amount must equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application. This amount must be reduced in proportion to the percentage of the square footage of the development that is used for a use other than moderate-income housing; and
- If, for any NOFA, the amount of funds made available for purposes of this program is insufficient to provide each eligible local government with the full amount specified above, based on the number of applications received, HCD must reduce the amount of grant funds awarded to each eligible local government proportionally.
- To be eligible for funding, the local government must have:
- Enables HCD to review, adopt, amend, and repeal guidelines to implement uniform standards or criteria that supplement or clarify the terms, references, or standards set forth in this chapter, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Permit Streamlining Act within Planning and Zoning Law, which sets forth various time limits within which and grounds by which state and local government agencies must either approve or disapprove permits (Government Code Section 65920 through 65964.1).
- Defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit, or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of the CEQA. A local government may require a housing development to undergo design review, however it shall not constitute a project for CEQA (Government Code Section 65583.2).
- Provides by right housing approvals for projects that meet certain environmental, affordable housing, and labor standards, based on project size and jurisdiction (Government Code Section 65913.4).
- Defines “moderate-income” as persons and families whose income is between 80 and 120 percent of AMI (Health and Safety Code Section 50093).
- Establishes Housing Element law (Government Code Section 65580 through 65589.11), which:
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing to be determined through the regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) process, which is composed of three main stages: (a) the Department of Finance and the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) develop regional housing needs estimates; (b) councils of government (COGs) allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and (c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires that cities and counties produce, and HCD certify, a housing element to help fulfill the state’s housing goals. In metropolitan areas, these housing elements are required every eight years.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy. We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There’s an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing. We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction.”
Background:
California’s Housing Crisis: The cost of housing in California is twice the national average, and higher than any state excluding Hawai’i. Only 28 percent of households can buy the median priced home. Over half of renters and 80 percent of low-income renters are rent-burdened, meaning they pay over 30 percent of their income towards rent. The state has over 150,000 persons experiencing homeless, the highest in the nation.
According to the Legislative Analyst Office, “a collection of factors drive California’s high cost of housing. First and foremost, far less housing has been built in California’s coastal areas than people demand. As a result, households bid up the cost of housing in coastal regions. In addition, some of the unmet demand to live in coastal areas spills over into inland California, driving up prices there too.” A 2016 McKinsey study determined that California’s housing deficit is over two million units. According to HCD, there needs to be 180,000 units built per year to maintain housing costs. By contrast, housing production averaged less than 80,000 new homes annually over the last 10 years.
Housing needs and approvals process. Every city and county in California is required to develop a general plan that outlines the community’s vision of future development through a series of policy statements and goals. A community’s general plan lays the foundation for all future land use decisions, as these decisions must be consistent with the plan. General plans are comprised of several elements that address various land use topics. Seven elements are mandated by state law: land use, circulation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, and safety. Each community’s general plan must include a housing element, which outlines a long-term plan for meeting the community’s existing and projected housing needs. The housing element demonstrates how the community plans to accommodate its “fair share” of its region’s housing needs, which is completed through the regional housing needs allocation process. To do so, each community establishes an inventory of sites designated for new housing that is sufficient to accommodate its fair share. Communities also identify regulatory barriers to housing development and propose strategies to address those barriers. State law requires cities and counties to update their housing elements every eight years. The next round of housing elements, known as the “sixth cycle,” are due in the state’s major metropolitan areas in 2021 or 2022.
Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. To be built, new housing must comply with zoning as well as other standards and criteria established by local governments, and receive one or more permits from local planning departments and approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials.
In recent years, the Legislature has passed numerous bills intended to improve and streamline the approval process for housing. These include bills that cover similar ground as SB 1299 proposes to, such as SB 35 (Wiener, Mitchell), that established a process for housing projects to be approved by right if they meet objective environmental criteria, affordable housing requirements, and labor standards for construction workers. It also includes AB 73 (Chiu) and SB 540 (Roth), which created a grant programs for cities that facilitate streamlined and ministerial housing that meet locational criteria, affordable housing requirements, and labor standards for construction workers.
Fiscalization of Land Use. “Fiscalization of land use” is the concept that some types of development provide more tax revenue than others, thereby influencing the decision of local decision makers. In California, the bias is towards commercial development, and away from residential development. Ever since the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, property taxes have constituted a diminishing source of revenue for governments. This situation was exacerbated in the early 1990s when the state effectively commandeered local property tax revenues to meets its obligation to the public schools through the Education Revenue Augmentation Fund. In many cases, the additional revenues a local government now earns from each new housing unit are insufficient to cover the added expense of providing services to the new residents of that home. Some of the fixed costs of infrastructure can be recouped through fees, but the on-going service costs remain at issue. Thus, a city council deciding the fate of a new housing development faces the unenviable dilemma of denying needed housing or reducing services to existing constituents.
At the same time, when a city council considers an alternate proposal to develop a parcel of land as a retail center, the fiscal incentives strongly support approval. Local governments receive a large portion of all sales tax revenue generated within their borders. The additional revenue received from a large retail facility—such as a big-box retailer, online distribution center, or a car dealer—easily outweighs the costs of providing services to the facility. Local government can use these surplus revenues to enhance services to its constituents. Not only can it be difficult to get approval for a new housing development on residentially-zoned land, but more land is zoned commercial in the hope that retail establishments can be attracted. The only real fiscal incentive local governments have to approve housing is to ensure there are enough residents to support the retailers.
Purpose of this Bill:
This bill seeks to facilitate the development of more housing affordable to households making a moderate income. It does so by incentivizing local governments to facilitate the conversion of idle big box sites and commercial shopping centers into such housing, in the form of grants issued by HCD. These grants would be issued to cities that enable such housing by right on those sites, and on which such units are produced. The grants would be equivalent to the sales tax generated by the site over the seven years prior to the local government’s grant application. By tying the grant directly to lost sales tax revenue, the bill attempts to directly address the issue of fiscalization of land use discussed above. The grant program is subject to appropriation of General Fund dollars, and would be scaled proportionately if appropriation is insufficient to cover all qualified grantees. No funding for this bill was included in this year’s budget.
Arguments in Support: Supporters argue that this bill will simultaneously help build moderate-income housing and reward cities that facilitate such housing. According to the Los Angeles County Business Federation, this bill will “will give local governments the needed resources to compensate the sales tax revenues produced from these former retail sites that help provide the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed to provide services to their residents.
Arguments in Opposition: Opponents argue that this bill would should include labor standards in return for the incentives provided by the bill. According to the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, “We should not have to sacrifice the middle-class wages and benefits of construction workers to provide incentives to developers to build affordable housing.”
Staff Comments:
The underlying principles of this bill are laudable – to facilitate the development of much needed housing for the middle class while addressing the issue of fiscalization of land use. However, there are a number of issues with this bill that will make its underlying vision difficult to realize.
The foremost setback to this bill is that funding was not appropriated for this program in this year’s state budget. If there had been appropriation this year, the funding could have served as a real incentive for local governments contemplated how to plan and rezone to fulfill their regional housing needs allocation. However, it will be at least a year at a minimum before this program is funded. In that period, most or all of the jurisdictions in the state will have completed their housing elements and specified and/or completed their rezoning, thereby deflating the incentive element of this program.
Additionally, this bill does not incent the kind of housing that is most needed in the state of California, which is for low-income households. In October 2019, the California Housing Partnership Corporation (CHPC) published a report that compared the median asking rent data on Craigslist for two-bedroom apartments with regionally adjusted 2019 area median incomes. The report found that very low-income households earning 50 percent AMI can afford modest rents in only one county in California; household earning 80 percent AMI could afford modest rents in 29 counties; and households with median incomes earning 100 percent AMI could afford modest rents in all but six counties, primarily in the State’s high-cost coastal regions. Over 80 percent of low-income renters are rent burdened, in that they sacrifice other essential needs to pay for housing. These are the households that are most in need and at risk of homelessness, and therefore the logical beneficiaries of limited state dollars.
Furthermore, while the bill defines housing for moderate-income persons and families as “workforce housing,” due to the hourglass nature of the modern economy, Census data reveals that only about 10 percent the state’s workforce makes between 80 and 120 percent of AMI. In many parts of the state, teachers, licensed vocational nurses, and paralegals, for example, earn less than 80 percent AMI. This is particularly true in high cost and coastal areas of the state.
Another complicating factor is that, in most of the state, the price of market rate housing substantially exceeds 120 percent of AMI. While the incentive of by right housing will meaningfully reduce costs, it is likely insufficient to bridge the gap between the market rate and sales prices or rents affordable to moderate-income households. Therefore, additional public subsidies would be required to facilitate the construction of moderate-income housing. There are limited programs in the state that provide such subsidies. One is the California Housing Finance Agency’s recent Mixed-Income Program, which builds housing at 30 percent to 120 percent AMI. However, the vast proportion of those units are for households making under 80 percent AMI.
In recognition that the bill as written does not incentivize the type of housing that is the greatest need in the state, the Committee may wish to recommend amending the bill to require that to qualify for a grant, that the range of qualifying units is expanded to include all households making less than 120 percent AMI, as long as the unit is initially made available at at least 20 percent below the market rate. Additionally, to ensure that any units provided in such projects truly serve the intended demographic for the long term, the Committee may wish to recommend amending the bill to require deed restrictions for all units of 45-years for-for sale units and 55-years for rental units.
Committee Amendments: As outlined above, the committee may wish to consider amending the bill as follows:
- Expand the range of qualifying units to include all households making less than 120 percent area median income, as long as the unit is initially made available at at least 20 percent below the market rate; and
- Require deed restrictions for all units of 45-years for for-sale units and 55-years for rental units.
Related Legislation:
SB 35 (Wiener, Mitchell), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017. Requires in jurisdictions that have not met their Regional Housing Needs Assessment to allow for a ministerial, streamlined process for housing approvals.
AB 73 (Chiu), Chapter 371, Statutes of 2017. Provides state financial incentives to cities and counties that create a zoning overlay district with streamlined zoning. Development projects must use prevailing wage and include a minimum amount of affordable housing.
SB 540 (Roth), Chapter 369, Statutes of 2017. Authorizes the state to provide planning funds to a city or county to adopt a specific housing development plan that minimizes project level environmental review and requires affordable housing and labor standards.
SB 1385 (Caballero) (2020). This bill would enable housing development on land that zoned for retail or office uses, and provides a ministerial and streamlined process on this land where there is at least 50 percent vacancy. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Committee on Local Government.
AB 3107 (Bloom) (2020). This bill would allow the housing to be built in areas designated by a general plan element to allow commercial development, as long as the housing has at least 20 percent of its units reserved for low income households. This bill is pending hearing in the Senate Committee on Housing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED) (Sponsor)
A Better Way Forward to House California
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
City of Cupertino
City of Laguna Niguel
City of Lake Forest
Comstock Hills Homeowners Association
Franklin Corridor Coalition
Grayburn Avenue Block Club
Hollywood Chamber of Commerce
Livable California
Livable Riverside and Moreno Valley
Los Angeles County Division of the League of California Cities
Orange County Business Council
Shadow Hills Property Owners Association
Western Quadrant of North Leimert Park
Opposition
City of Redondo Beach
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Oppose Unless Amended
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California State Council of Laborers
District Council16, International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, AFL-CIO
International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, Western States Section
Analysis Prepared by: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Date of Hearing: July 28, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1299
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:June 18, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 39-0
SUBJECT: Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
SUMMARY: Upon appropriation of funds from the state General Fund, provides grants to local governments for production of moderate-income housing on idle commercial shopping centers. Specifically, this bill:
- Includes the following definitions:
- Defines “big box retailer” as a store of greater than 75,000 square feet of gross buildable area that generates or previously generated sales or use taxes;
- Defines “commercial shopping center” as a group of two or more stores that maintain a common parking lot for patrons of those stores;
- Defines “idle” as at least 80 percent of the leased or rentable square footage of the big box retailer or commercial shopping center site is not occupied for at least a 12-month period; and
- Defines “sales and use tax revenue” as the cumulative amount of revenue generated by taxes imposed by a local government, as specified.
- Upon appropriation, requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to administer a program to provide grants to local governments upon completion of moderate-income housing on sites that contained idle big box retailers or commercial shopping centers, as follows:
- To be eligible for funding, the local government must have:
- Rezoned one or more idle sites used for a big box retailer or commercial shopping center to allow moderate-income housing (between 80-120 percent of Area Median Income (AMI)) as a use by right, in that cannot be denied by the local government by right and is not subject to the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA);
- Approve and issue a certificate of occupancy for a moderate-income housing development on each site rezoned for which the local government seeks a grant; and
- Apply to HCD for an allocation of grant funds and provide documentation that it has complied with the requirements in this bill.
- For each calendar year in which funds are made available, HCD must issue a notice of funding availability (NOFA) for the distribution of funds for the following 12-month period.
- Requires HCD to allocate the determined grant amount to each local government for each of the seven years following the date of the local government’s application.
- Provides that the amount granted to each eligible local government must be as follows:
- The annual grant amount must equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application. This amount must be reduced in proportion to the percentage of the square footage of the development that is used for a use other than moderate-income housing; and
- If, for any NOFA, the amount of funds made available for purposes of this program is insufficient to provide each eligible local government with the full amount specified above, based on the number of applications received, HCD must reduce the amount of grant funds awarded to each eligible local government proportionally.
- To be eligible for funding, the local government must have:
- Enables HCD to review, adopt, amend, and repeal guidelines to implement uniform standards or criteria that supplement or clarify the terms, references, or standards set forth in this chapter, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Permit Streamlining Act within Planning and Zoning Law, which sets forth various time limits within which and grounds by which state and local government agencies must either approve or disapprove permits (Government Code Section 65920 through 65964.1).
- Defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit, or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of the CEQA. A local government may require a housing development to undergo design review, however it shall not constitute a project for CEQA (Government Code Section 65583.2).
- Provides by right housing approvals for projects that meet certain environmental, affordable housing, and labor standards, based on project size and jurisdiction (Government Code Section 65913.4).
- Defines “moderate-income” as persons and families whose income is between 80 and 120 percent of AMI (Health and Safety Code Section 50093).
- Establishes Housing Element law (Government Code Section 65580 through 65589.11), which:
- Provides that each community’s fair share of housing to be determined through the regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) process, which is composed of three main stages: (a) the Department of Finance and the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) develop regional housing needs estimates; (b) councils of government (COGs) allocate housing within each region based on these estimates (where a COG does not exist, HCD makes the determinations); and (c) cities and counties incorporate their allocations into their housing elements.
- Requires that cities and counties produce, and HCD certify, a housing element to help fulfill the state’s housing goals. In metropolitan areas, these housing elements are required every eight years.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author’s Statement: According to the author, “HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy. We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There’s an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing. We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction.”
Background:
California’s Housing Crisis: The cost of housing in California is twice the national average, and higher than any state excluding Hawai’i. Only 28 percent of households can buy the median priced home. Over half of renters and 80 percent of low-income renters are rent-burdened, meaning they pay over 30 percent of their income towards rent. The state has over 150,000 persons experiencing homeless, the highest in the nation.
According to the Legislative Analyst Office, “a collection of factors drive California’s high cost of housing. First and foremost, far less housing has been built in California’s coastal areas than people demand. As a result, households bid up the cost of housing in coastal regions. In addition, some of the unmet demand to live in coastal areas spills over into inland California, driving up prices there too.” A 2016 McKinsey study determined that California’s housing deficit is over two million units. According to HCD, there needs to be 180,000 units built per year to maintain housing costs. By contrast, housing production averaged less than 80,000 new homes annually over the last 10 years.
Housing needs and approvals process. Every city and county in California is required to develop a general plan that outlines the community’s vision of future development through a series of policy statements and goals. A community’s general plan lays the foundation for all future land use decisions, as these decisions must be consistent with the plan. General plans are comprised of several elements that address various land use topics. Seven elements are mandated by state law: land use, circulation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, and safety. Each community’s general plan must include a housing element, which outlines a long-term plan for meeting the community’s existing and projected housing needs. The housing element demonstrates how the community plans to accommodate its “fair share” of its region’s housing needs, which is completed through the regional housing needs allocation process. To do so, each community establishes an inventory of sites designated for new housing that is sufficient to accommodate its fair share. Communities also identify regulatory barriers to housing development and propose strategies to address those barriers. State law requires cities and counties to update their housing elements every eight years. The next round of housing elements, known as the “sixth cycle,” are due in the state’s major metropolitan areas in 2021 or 2022.
Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. To be built, new housing must comply with zoning as well as other standards and criteria established by local governments, and receive one or more permits from local planning departments and approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials.
In recent years, the Legislature has passed numerous bills intended to improve and streamline the approval process for housing. These include bills that cover similar ground as SB 1299 proposes to, such as SB 35 (Wiener, Mitchell), that established a process for housing projects to be approved by right if they meet objective environmental criteria, affordable housing requirements, and labor standards for construction workers. It also includes AB 73 (Chiu) and SB 540 (Roth), which created a grant programs for cities that facilitate streamlined and ministerial housing that meet locational criteria, affordable housing requirements, and labor standards for construction workers.
Fiscalization of Land Use. “Fiscalization of land use” is the concept that some types of development provide more tax revenue than others, thereby influencing the decision of local decision makers. In California, the bias is towards commercial development, and away from residential development. Ever since the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, property taxes have constituted a diminishing source of revenue for governments. This situation was exacerbated in the early 1990s when the state effectively commandeered local property tax revenues to meets its obligation to the public schools through the Education Revenue Augmentation Fund. In many cases, the additional revenues a local government now earns from each new housing unit are insufficient to cover the added expense of providing services to the new residents of that home. Some of the fixed costs of infrastructure can be recouped through fees, but the on-going service costs remain at issue. Thus, a city council deciding the fate of a new housing development faces the unenviable dilemma of denying needed housing or reducing services to existing constituents.
At the same time, when a city council considers an alternate proposal to develop a parcel of land as a retail center, the fiscal incentives strongly support approval. Local governments receive a large portion of all sales tax revenue generated within their borders. The additional revenue received from a large retail facility—such as a big-box retailer, online distribution center, or a car dealer—easily outweighs the costs of providing services to the facility. Local government can use these surplus revenues to enhance services to its constituents. Not only can it be difficult to get approval for a new housing development on residentially-zoned land, but more land is zoned commercial in the hope that retail establishments can be attracted. The only real fiscal incentive local governments have to approve housing is to ensure there are enough residents to support the retailers.
Purpose of this Bill:
This bill seeks to facilitate the development of more housing affordable to households making a moderate income. It does so by incentivizing local governments to facilitate the conversion of idle big box sites and commercial shopping centers into such housing, in the form of grants issued by HCD. These grants would be issued to cities that enable such housing by right on those sites, and on which such units are produced. The grants would be equivalent to the sales tax generated by the site over the seven years prior to the local government’s grant application. By tying the grant directly to lost sales tax revenue, the bill attempts to directly address the issue of fiscalization of land use discussed above. The grant program is subject to appropriation of General Fund dollars, and would be scaled proportionately if appropriation is insufficient to cover all qualified grantees. No funding for this bill was included in this year’s budget.
Arguments in Support: Supporters argue that this bill will simultaneously help build moderate-income housing and reward cities that facilitate such housing. According to the Los Angeles County Business Federation, this bill will “will give local governments the needed resources to compensate the sales tax revenues produced from these former retail sites that help provide the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed to provide services to their residents.
Arguments in Opposition: Opponents argue that this bill would should include labor standards in return for the incentives provided by the bill. According to the State Building and Construction Trades Council of California, “We should not have to sacrifice the middle-class wages and benefits of construction workers to provide incentives to developers to build affordable housing.”
Staff Comments:
The underlying principles of this bill are laudable – to facilitate the development of much needed housing for the middle class while addressing the issue of fiscalization of land use. However, there are a number of issues with this bill that will make its underlying vision difficult to realize.
The foremost setback to this bill is that funding was not appropriated for this program in this year’s state budget. If there had been appropriation this year, the funding could have served as a real incentive for local governments contemplated how to plan and rezone to fulfill their regional housing needs allocation. However, it will be at least a year at a minimum before this program is funded. In that period, most or all of the jurisdictions in the state will have completed their housing elements and specified and/or completed their rezoning, thereby deflating the incentive element of this program.
Additionally, this bill does not incent the kind of housing that is most needed in the state of California, which is for low-income households. In October 2019, the California Housing Partnership Corporation (CHPC) published a report that compared the median asking rent data on Craigslist for two-bedroom apartments with regionally adjusted 2019 area median incomes. The report found that very low-income households earning 50 percent AMI can afford modest rents in only one county in California; household earning 80 percent AMI could afford modest rents in 29 counties; and households with median incomes earning 100 percent AMI could afford modest rents in all but six counties, primarily in the State’s high-cost coastal regions. Over 80 percent of low-income renters are rent burdened, in that they sacrifice other essential needs to pay for housing. These are the households that are most in need and at risk of homelessness, and therefore the logical beneficiaries of limited state dollars.
Furthermore, while the bill defines housing for moderate-income persons and families as “workforce housing,” due to the hourglass nature of the modern economy, Census data reveals that only about 10 percent the state’s workforce makes between 80 and 120 percent of AMI. In many parts of the state, teachers, licensed vocational nurses, and paralegals, for example, earn less than 80 percent AMI. This is particularly true in high cost and coastal areas of the state.
Another complicating factor is that, in most of the state, the price of market rate housing substantially exceeds 120 percent of AMI. While the incentive of by right housing will meaningfully reduce costs, it is likely insufficient to bridge the gap between the market rate and sales prices or rents affordable to moderate-income households. Therefore, additional public subsidies would be required to facilitate the construction of moderate-income housing. There are limited programs in the state that provide such subsidies. One is the California Housing Finance Agency’s recent Mixed-Income Program, which builds housing at 30 percent to 120 percent AMI. However, the vast proportion of those units are for households making under 80 percent AMI.
In recognition that the bill as written does not incentivize the type of housing that is the greatest need in the state, the Committee may wish to recommend amending the bill to require that to qualify for a grant, that the range of qualifying units is expanded to include all households making less than 120 percent AMI, as long as the unit is initially made available at at least 20 percent below the market rate. Additionally, to ensure that any units provided in such projects truly serve the intended demographic for the long term, the Committee may wish to recommend amending the bill to require deed restrictions for all units of 45-years for-for sale units and 55-years for rental units.
Committee Amendments: As outlined above, the committee may wish to consider amending the bill as follows:
- Expand the range of qualifying units to include all households making less than 120 percent area median income, as long as the unit is initially made available at at least 20 percent below the market rate; and
- Require deed restrictions for all units of 45-years for for-sale units and 55-years for rental units.
Related Legislation:
SB 35 (Wiener, Mitchell), Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017. Requires in jurisdictions that have not met their Regional Housing Needs Assessment to allow for a ministerial, streamlined process for housing approvals.
AB 73 (Chiu), Chapter 371, Statutes of 2017. Provides state financial incentives to cities and counties that create a zoning overlay district with streamlined zoning. Development projects must use prevailing wage and include a minimum amount of affordable housing.
SB 540 (Roth), Chapter 369, Statutes of 2017. Authorizes the state to provide planning funds to a city or county to adopt a specific housing development plan that minimizes project level environmental review and requires affordable housing and labor standards.
SB 1385 (Caballero) (2020). This bill would enable housing development on land that zoned for retail or office uses, and provides a ministerial and streamlined process on this land where there is at least 50 percent vacancy. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Committee on Local Government.
AB 3107 (Bloom) (2020). This bill would allow the housing to be built in areas designated by a general plan element to allow commercial development, as long as the housing has at least 20 percent of its units reserved for low income households. This bill is pending hearing in the Senate Committee on Housing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED) (Sponsor)
A Better Way Forward to House California
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
City of Cupertino
City of Laguna Niguel
City of Lake Forest
Comstock Hills Homeowners Association
Franklin Corridor Coalition
Grayburn Avenue Block Club
Hollywood Chamber of Commerce
Livable California
Livable Riverside and Moreno Valley
Los Angeles County Division of the League of California Cities
Orange County Business Council
Shadow Hills Property Owners Association
Western Quadrant of North Leimert Park
Opposition
City of Redondo Beach
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Oppose Unless Amended
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California State Council of Laborers
District Council16, International Union of Painters and Allied Trades, AFL-CIO
International Brotherhood of Boilermakers, Western States Section
Analysis Prepared by: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1299 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1299
Author: Portantino (D), et al.
Amended: 6/18/20
Vote: 21
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 10-0, 5/26/20
AYES: Wiener, Morrell, Caballero, Durazo, McGuire, Moorlach, Roth, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/18/20
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Levya, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill requires the California Housing and Community Development Department (HCD) to administer a program to provide grants to local governments that rezone idle sites used for a big box commercial shopping center to instead allow the development of workforce housing, as defined.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit, or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). A local government may require a housing development to undergo design review, however it shall not constitute a project for CEQA.
- Defines “very low-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 50% area median income (AMI).
- Defines “low-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 80% AMI.
- Defines “moderate-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 120% of AMI.
- Requires a local jurisdiction to give public notice of a hearing whenever a person applies for a zoning variance, special use permit, conditional use permit, zoning ordinance amendment, or general or specific plan amendment.
- Requires the board of zoning adjustment or zoning administrator to hear and decide applications for conditional uses or other permits when the zoning ordinance provides therefor and establishes criteria for determining those matters, and applications for variances from the terms of the zoning ordinance.
- Provides that supportive housing, in which 100% of units are dedicated to low-income households (up to 80% area median income, or AMI) and are receiving public funding to ensure affordability, shall be a use by right in all zones where multifamily and mixed uses are allowed, as specified.
- Requires “low-barrier navigation centers” to be a use-by-right, until January 1, 2027, as defined, in areas zoned for mixed uses and nonresidential zones permitting multifamily uses if the development meets certain requirements.
This bill:
- Defines “big box retailer” as a store of greater than 75,000 square feet of gross buildable area that generates or previously generated sales or use taxes.
- Defines “commercial shopping center” as a group of two or more stores that maintain a common parking lot for patrons of those stores.
- Defines “idle” as at least 80% of the leased or rentable square footage of the big box retailer or commercial shopping center site is not occupied for at least a 12-month period.
- Defines “sales and use tax revenue” as the cumulative amount of revenue generated by taxes imposed by a local government, as specified.
- Defines “workforce housing” as an owner occupied or rental housing development with an affordable housing cost or affordable rent to households with a household income greater than or equal to 80% AMI, but no more than 120% AMI.
- Requires HCD to administer a program to provide incentives in the form of grants to local governments that rezone idle sites used for a big box commercial shopping center and instead allow the development of workforce housing.
- For each calendar year in which funds are made available, HCD shall issue a notice of funding availability (NOFA) for the distribution of funds for the following 12-month period.
- HCD shall allocate the determined grant amount to each local government for each of the seven years following the date of the local government’s application.
- Requires a local government, in order to be eligible for funding, to do all of the following:
- Rezone one or more idle sites used for a big box retailer or commercial shopping center to allow workforce housing as a use by right.
- Approve and issue a certificate of occupancy for a workforce housing development on each site rezoned for which the local government seeks a grant.
- Apply to HCD for an allocation of grant funds and provide documentation that it has complied with the requirements in this bill.
- Provides that the amount granted to each eligible local government shall be as follows:
- The annual grant amount shall be equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application.
- For any idle big box retailer or commercial shopping center site rezoned to allow mixed uses, the amount of grant shall be reduced in proportion to the percentage of the square footage of the development that is used for a use other than workforce housing.
- If, for any NOFA, the amount of funds made available for purposes of this chapter is insufficient to provide each eligible local government with the full amount specified in a) and b) above, based on the number of applications received, HCD shall reduce the amount of grant funds awarded to each eligible local government proportionally.
Comments
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy.
“We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There’s an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing. We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction.”
- Housing needs and approvals generally. Every city and county in California is required to develop a general plan that outlines the community’s vision of future development through a series of policy statements and goals. A community’s general plan lays the foundation for all future land use decisions, as these decisions must be consistent with the plan. General plans are comprised of several elements that address various land use topics. Seven elements are mandated by state law: land use, circulation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, and safety. Each community’s general plan must include a housing element, which outlines a long-term plan for meeting the community’s existing and projected housing needs. The housing element demonstrates how the community plans to accommodate its “fair share” of its region’s housing needs, which is completed through the regional housing needs allocation process. To do so, each community establishes an inventory of sites designated for new housing that is sufficient to accommodate its fair share. Communities also identify regulatory barriers to housing development and propose strategies to address those barriers. State law requires cities and counties to update their housing elements every eight years.
- Zoning ordinances generally. Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. In addition, before building new housing, housing developers must obtain one or more permits from local planning departments and must also obtain approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. A zoning ordinance may be subject to CEQA if it will have a significant impact upon the environment. The adoption of ADU ordinances, however, are explicitly exempt from CEQA. There are also some several statutory exemptions that provide limited environmental review for projects that are consistent with a previously adopted general plan, community plan, specific plan, or zoning ordinance.
- Streamlined Approval Processes. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to review under CEQA while projects permitted ministerially generally are not.
- Need for more residential zoning. The concept of the “fiscalization of land use” is familiar to many. Ever since the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, property taxes have constituted a diminishing source of revenue for governments. This situation was exacerbated in the early 1990s when the state effectively commandeered local property tax revenues to meets its obligation to the public schools through the Education Revenue Augmentation Fund. In many cases, the additional revenues a local government now earns from each new housing unit are insufficient to cover the added expense of providing services to the new residents of that home. Some of the fixed costs of infrastructure can be recouped through fees, but the on-going service costs remain at issue. Thus, a city council deciding the fate of a new housing development faces the unenviable dilemma of denying needed housing or reducing services to existing constituents. As one might expect, new housing developments tend to be the loser.
At the same time, when a city council considers an alternate proposal to develop a parcel of land as a retail center, the fiscal incentives strongly support approval. Local governments receive a large portion of all sales tax revenue generated within their borders. The additional revenue received from a large retail facility—such as a big-box retailer, online distribution center, or a car dealer—easily outweighs the costs of providing services to the facility. Local government can use these surplus revenues to enhance services to its constituents. As a result, housing is subject to a double whammy. Not only can it be difficult to get approval for a new housing development on residentially-zoned land, but more land is zoned commercial in the hope that retail establishments can be attracted. The only real fiscal incentive local governments have to approve housing is to ensure there are enough residents to support the retailers.
This bill seeks to incentivize local governments to convert idle retail sites into housing affordable to households at 80% - 120% AMI by requiring HCD to issue grants to cities that rezone commercial sites to make residential an allowable use. In order to receive a grant, a city must rezone the site as a use by right, approve a housing development project, and issue a certificate of occupancy. A city will only receive a grant for developments that include housing affordable to households earning 80% - 120% AMI and the grant will be proportionate to the amount of housing available for those households if the development also includes a commercial component. The grant is equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application. The goal is to offset the lost sales tax revenue that would have been generated from a commercial property.
- Is workforce housing the most necessary? California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis, largely due to a shortage of housing stock, primarily for lower-income households. As more and more families feel the financial burden of monthly housing costs, and scarce resources at the state level, there has been a focus on easing the burden for moderate-income households (80% - 120% AMI). In October 2019, the California Housing Partnership Corporation (CHPC) published a report that compared the median asking rent data on Craigslist for two-bedroom apartments with regionally adjusted 2019 area median incomes. The report found that very low-income households earning 50% AMI can afford modest rents in only one county in California; households earning 60% AMI could afford modest rents in 11 counties; 80% AMI could afford modest rents in 29 counties; and households with median incomes earning 100% AMI could afford modest rents in all but 6 counties, primarily in the State’s high-cost coastal regions.
Generally, when low-income households experience severe cost burden and spend most of their income on housing, families have to cut back on essentials such as food, healthcare, childcare, and transportation. These families are often those that are closest to becoming homeless. While CHPC recommends prioritizing assistance to households with the lowest income, they note that there are moderate income households in specific neighborhoods and counties that need help. CHPC recommends assistance for households earning more than 80% AMI should generally be limited to areas of the state where median income households cannot afford modest rents, particularly in the six higher cost coastal counties.
The author intends for this bill to help working families find and maintain affordable housing. In many parts of the state, teachers, licensed vocational nurses, and paralegals, for example, earn less than 80% AMI. This is particularly true in high cost and coastal areas of the state. As currently written, those populations will not be served by this bill.
- Appropriations Amendments. This bill was amended to give HCD guideline authority to implement this program and adds coauthors.
- Oppositions. Several labor groups write in opposition to this bill and request worker protections and training standards that include both prevailing wage coverage and skilled and trained workforce requirements so that any unintended consequence that exploits the workforce that will build the housing under this bill is not created. They write that these two requirements provide middle-class wages and benefits to construction workers as well as also help put local construction workers and apprentices to work.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- HCD administrative costs of up to $1.2 million annually (up to 6 PY of staff time) following the appropriation of funding for the program in a future fiscal year. There would be one-time costs to develop and adopt guidelines, and ongoing administrative costs to provide technical assistance to developers and local governments, develop NOFAs, review applications, and process funding agreements. Actual costs for ongoing administration of the program would depend upon the amount of funding available and the number of applications submitted by local jurisdictions for review by HCD. (General Fund)
- Unknown annual cost pressures, likely in the tens of millions annually, in future fiscal years to provide funding for the grant program. Since this bill requires grants to be awarded for seven consecutive years, the cost pressures could grow annually in order to fund the second through seventh year of grant funds and to award new grants in future years, depending on how the program is structured. (General Fund)
SUPPORT: (Verified 6/18/20)
Bizfed Central Valley
Building Industry Association of Southern California, Inc.
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
City of Thousand Oaks
Employers Group
League of California Cities
Los Angeles Business Council
Los Angeles County Business Federation
New Livable California Dba Livable California
Orange County Business Council
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce and Civic Association
Southland Regional Association of Realtors
Seven Individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/18/20)
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
International Union of Elevator Constructors, Local 18
International Union of Elevator Constructors, Local 8
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Prepared by: Alison Hughes / HOUSING / (916) 651-4124
6/23/20 17:14:01
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1299 (Portantino) - Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
Version: April 1, 2020 | Policy Vote: HOUSING 10 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: June 18, 2020 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
SB 1299 would establish a program administered by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), upon appropriation of funding by the Legislature, to provide grants to cities and counties that rezone idle or underutilized big box retailer or commercial shopping center properties and instead provide for the development of workforce housing, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on June 18, 2020
Fiscal Impact:
- HCD administrative costs of up to $1.2 million annually (up to 6 PY of staff time) following the appropriation of funding for the program in a future fiscal year. There would be one-time costs to develop and adopt guidelines, and ongoing administrative costs to provide technical assistance to developers and local governments, develop Notices of Funding Availability (NOFAs), review applications, and process funding agreements. Actual costs for ongoing administration of the program would depend upon the amount of funding available and the number of applications submitted by local jurisdictions for review by HCD. (General Fund)
- Unknown annual cost pressures, likely in the tens of millions annually, in future fiscal years to provide funding for the grant program. Since the bill requires grants to be awarded for seven consecutive years, the cost pressures could grow annually in order to fund the second through seventh year of grant funds and to award new grants in future years, depending on how the program is structured. (General Fund)
Author Amendments:
The author’s amendments would do the following:
- Simplify the guideline adoption process by specifying that any guidelines or terms adopted by HCD to implement the program would not be subject to the requirements of the Administrative Procedures Act.
- Add Senators Beall and Galgiani as co-authors.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1299 (Portantino) - Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
Version: April 1, 2020 | Policy Vote: HOUSING 10 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: June 9, 2020 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
SB 1299 would establish a program administered by the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD), upon appropriation of funding by the Legislature, to provide grants to cities and counties that rezone idle or underutilized big box retailer or commercial shopping center properties and instead provide for the development of workforce housing, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- HCD administrative costs in the range of $1 million to $1.5 million annually following the appropriation of funding for the program in a future fiscal year. There would be one-time costs to develop and adopt guidelines, and ongoing administrative costs to provide technical assistance to developers and local governments, develop Notices of Funding Availability (NOFAs), review applications, and process funding agreements. Actual costs for ongoing administration of the program would depend upon the amount of funding available and the number of applications submitted by local jurisdictions for review by HCD. (General Fund)
- Unknown annual cost pressures, likely in the tens of millions annually, in future fiscal years to provide funding for the grant program. Since the bill requires grants to be awarded for seven consecutive years, the cost pressures could grow annually in order to fund the second through seventh year of grant funds and to award new grants in future years, depending on how the program is structured. (General Fund)
Background:
Existing law requires cities and counties to prepare a general plan comprised of seven mandatory elements, including a housing element that identifies existing and projected housing needs. The housing element must include an inventory of adequate sites zoned for housing at all income levels and to accommodate a jurisdiction’s share of the regional housing needs that is sufficient to account for population growth and to overcome existing housing deficiencies over the planning period. If the city or county does not have enough sites within its existing inventory of residentially zoned land to accommodate its share of the regional housing needs, it must adopt a program to rezone land within the first three years of the planning period. Housing elements must be updated every eight years in urban areas, and every five years in more rural areas. For purposes of determining housing affordability, existing law defines “very low-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 50% of the area median income (AMI), “low-income” as not exceeding 80% of AMI, and “moderate income” as not exceeding 120% of AMI.
Existing law defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit, or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). A local government may require a “by right” housing development to undergo design review, but it does not constitute a project for CEQA purposes.
Proposed Law:
SB 1299 would require HCD to administer a program, upon appropriation of funds by the Legislature, to provide grants to cities and counties that rezone specified idle big box retailer or commercial shopping center sites to allow for the development of workforce housing for households with an income of 80% to 120% of the AMI. Specifically, this bill would:
- Define “idle” to mean that at least 80% of the leased or rentable square footage is not occupied for at least a 12-month calendar period on the site of a big box retailer of at least 75,000 square feet or a commercial shopping center comprised of two or more stores that maintain a common parking lot for store patrons, as specified.
- Require HCD, in each calendar year in which funding is appropriated, to allocate a grant to a city or county that has: (1) rezoned one or more specified idle commercial sites to allow for workforce housing as a use by right; (2) approved and issued a certificate of occupancy for a housing development on a specified rezoned site, and (3) provided HCD with documentation proving compliance with eligibility requirements.
- Require HCD to issue a NOFA for each year in which funds are appropriated for the distribution of funds during the 12-month period following issuance, and require HCD to accept applications at the end of the 12-month period.
- Specify that the annual amount of the grant must be equal to the average annual amount of specified local sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site over the previous seven years (the local Bradley Burns Sales and Use Tax, and the local Transactions and Use Tax amounts).
- Require HCD to allocate grants to each eligible local government annually for each of the seven years following the application date.
- Require HCD to reduce the amount of the grant for sites rezoned to allow for mixed uses in proportion to the percentage of the development’s square footage that is used for something other than workforce housing, as specified.
- Require HCD to reduce the grant amount allocated to each local government by a proportionate share if the total amount of grant funding available in any NOFA is insufficient to provide each local entity with the full amount.
- Authorize HCD to adopt guidelines for purposes of this grant program in accordance with the Administrative Procedures Act (APA).
Related Legislation:
SB 1385 (Caballero), which is also being heard in this Committee today, would enact the Neighborhood Homes Act, which requires a specified housing development project to be deemed an authorized use on a neighborhood lot that is zoned for office or retail commercial use under a local zoning code or general plan.
AB 3107 (Bloom), which is pending on the Assembly Floor, would require cities and counties to allow housing as an authorized use on commercially-zoned land until January 1, 2030 under specified circumstances.
Staff Comments:
The Senate Housing Committee analysis notes that: “This bill seeks to incentivize local governments to convert idle retail sites into housing affordable to households at 80% - 120% AMI by requiring HCD to issue grants to cities that rezone commercial sites to make residential an allowable use. In order to receive a grant, a city must rezone the site as a use by right, approve a housing development project, and issue a certificate of occupancy. A city will only receive a grant for developments that include housing affordable to households earning 80% - 120% AMI and the grant will be proportionate to the amount of housing available for those households if the development also includes a commercial component. The grant is equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application. The goal is to offset the lost sales tax revenue that would have been generated from a commercial property.”
HCD estimates that establishing and administering this grant program would require 7 PY of additional staff at a cost of approximately $1.5 million annually, based on the assumption that the department would award 75 grants in a year in which funding is appropriated for the program. Actual administrative costs and staffing needs would likely depend upon the amount of available funding and the demand for the program. Staff notes that the implementation of the program is contingent upon an appropriation of funding by the Legislature. Furthermore, program eligibility requires a city or county to engage in a time-consuming process of identifying eligible idle retail sites, rezoning those sites, attracting a developer to design and construct a workforce housing project, and issuing a certificate of occupancy. Assuming this process would likely take a minimum of several years, it seems unlikely that there the bill would result in a state fiscal impact in the near term.
This bill creates significant cost pressures in future fiscal years to provide funding for this new grant program. It is difficult to estimate the amount of funding necessary to establish an effective program, as the characteristics of each site, such as the size of the commercial space and historical sales tax generation, are likely to vary significantly and would not be known until after applications are filed. For illustrative purposes, if a 100,000 square foot idle big box retailer site historically generated $300 per square foot in average annual sales, and 80% of sales were subject to the local share of sales and use tax (1.25% for Bradley Burns Local Sales and Use Tax and a statewide average of 1.33% for the local Transactions and Use Tax), that site would be eligible for an annual grant of $619,200 for seven years. Grants for smaller commercial strip malls would likely be much smaller. Staff estimates this bill would create cost pressures in the tens of millions annually.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 1299 Hearing Date: 5/26/2020
Author: | Portantino | ||
Version: | 4/1/2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alison Hughes | ||
SUBJECT: Housing development: incentives: rezoning of idle retail sites
DIGEST: This bill requires the California Housing and Community Development Department (HCD) to administer a program to provide grants to local governments that rezone idle sites used for a big box commercial shopping center to instead allow the development of workforce housing, as defined.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “use by right” as prohibiting a local government from requiring a conditional use permit, planned unit development permit, or other discretionary local government review or approval that would constitute a “project” for purposes of CEQA. A local government may require a housing development to undergo design review, however it shall not constitute a project for CEQA.
- Defines “very low-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 50% AMI.
- Defines “low-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 80% AMI.
- Defines “moderate-income” as persons and families whose income does not exceed 120% of AMI.
- Requires a local jurisdiction to give public notice of a hearing whenever a person applies for a zoning variance, special use permit, conditional use permit, zoning ordinance amendment, or general or specific plan amendment.
- Requires the board of zoning adjustment or zoning administrator to hear and decide applications for conditional uses or other permits when the zoning ordinance provides therefor and establishes criteria for determining those matters, and applications for variances from the terms of the zoning ordinance.
- Provides that supportive housing, in which 100% of units are dedicated to low-income households (up to 80% area median income, or AMI) and are receiving public funding to ensure affordability, shall be a use by right in all zones where multifamily and mixed uses are allowed, as specified.
- Requires “low-barrier navigation centers” to be a use-by-right, until January 1, 2027, as defined, in areas zoned for mixed uses and nonresidential zones permitting multifamily uses if the development meets certain requirements.
This bill:
- Defines “big box retailer” as a store of greater than 75,000 square feet of gross buildable area that generates or previously generated sales or use taxes.
- Defines “commercial shopping center” as a group of two or more stores that maintain a common parking lot for patrons of those stores.
- Defines “idle” as at least 80% of the leased or rentable square footage of the big box retailer or commercial shopping center site is not occupied for at least a 12-month period.
- Defines “sales and use tax revenue” as the cumulative amount of revenue generated by taxes imposed by a local government, as specified.
- Defines “workforce housing” as an owner occupied or rental housing development with an affordable housing cost or affordable rent to households with a household income greater than or equal to 80% area median income (AMI), but no more than 120% AMI.
- Requires HCD to administer a program to provide incentives in the form of grants to local governments that rezone idle sites used for a big box commercial shopping center and instead allow the development of workforce housing.
- For each calendar year in which funds are made available, HCD shall issue a notice of funding availability (NOFA) for the distribution of funds for the following 12-month period.
- HCD shall allocate the determined grant amount to each local government for each of the seven years following the date of the local government’s application.
- Requires a local government, in order to be eligible for funding, to do all of the following:
- Rezone one or more idle sites used for a big box retailer or commercial shopping center to allow workforce housing as a use by right.
- Approve and issue a certificate of occupancy for a workforce housing development on each site rezoned for which the local government seeks a grant.
- Apply to HCD for an allocation of grant funds and provide documentation that it has complied with the requirements in this bill.
- The amount granted to each eligible local government shall be as follows:
- The annual grant amount shall be equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application.
- For any idle big box retailer or commercial shopping center site rezoned to allow mixed uses, the amount of grant shall be reduced in proportion to the percentage of the square footage of the development that is used for a use other than workforce housing.
- If, for any NOFA, the amount of funds made available for purposes of this chapter is insufficient to provide each eligible local government with the full amount specified in (a) and (b) above, based on the number of applications received, HCD shall reduce the amount of grant funds awarded to each eligible local government proportionally.
COMMENTS
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “HCD estimates that the state needs upwards of 200,000 housing units per year in order to maintain a healthy housing sector. Currently, the industry is producing less than half of that amount. This scarcity has driven our housing costs to be the highest in the nation prohibiting occupations like teachers, nurses, public safety officers and younger professionals the ability to afford owning a home, essential for building a stronger and vibrant economy. It is imperative that we encourage creative solutions to build more housing to correct this imbalance.
We see an opportunity through the growth of e-commerce and the idling of commercial retail sites. There’s an opportunity to convert idle retail sites to workforce housing.
We want to create a pilot program that encourages local governments to partner with the industry to build housing on these sites and reward the local government with a sales tax rebate when these projects are rezoned, completed and have been issued a certificate of occupancy. These rebates will give local governments the resources to replace the sales tax revenues that came from these former retail sites to pay for the necessary public safety and essential infrastructure needed for these new residential properties to operate in their local jurisdiction.”
- Housing needs and approvals generally. Every city and county in California is required to develop a general plan that outlines the community’s vision of future development through a series of policy statements and goals. A community’s general plan lays the foundation for all future land use decisions, as these decisions must be consistent with the plan. General plans are comprised of several elements that address various land use topics. Seven elements are mandated by state law: land use, circulation, housing, conservation, open-space, noise, and safety. Each community’s general plan must include a housing element, which outlines a long-term plan for meeting the community’s existing and projected housing needs. The housing element demonstrates how the community plans to accommodate its “fair share” of its region’s housing needs, which is completed through the regional housing needs allocation (RHNA) process. To do so, each community establishes an inventory of sites designated for new housing that is sufficient to accommodate its fair share. Communities also identify regulatory barriers to housing development and propose strategies to address those barriers. State law requires cities and counties to update their housing elements every eight years.
- Zoning ordinances generally. Cities and counties enact zoning ordinances to implement their general plans. Zoning determines the type of housing that can be built. In addition, before building new housing, housing developers must obtain one or more permits from local planning departments and must also obtain approval from local planning commissions, city councils, or county board of supervisors. A zoning ordinance may be subject to CEQA if it will have a significant impact upon the environment. The adoption of ADU ordinances, however, are explicitly exempt from CEQA. There are also some several statutory exemptions that provide limited environmental review for projects that are consistent with a previously adopted general plan, community plan, specific plan, or zoning ordinance.
- Streamlined Approval Processes. Some housing projects can be permitted by city or county planning staff ministerially or without further approval from elected officials. Projects reviewed ministerially require only an administrative review designed to ensure they are consistent with existing general plan and zoning rules, as well as meet standards for building quality, health, and safety. Most large housing projects are not allowed ministerial review. Instead, these projects are vetted through both public hearings and administrative review. Most housing projects that require discretionary review and approval are subject to review under CEQA while projects permitted ministerially generally are not.
- Need for more residential zoning. The concept of the “fiscalization of land use” is familiar to many. Ever since the passage of Proposition 13 in 1978, property taxes have constituted a diminishing source of revenue for governments. This situation was exacerbated in the early 1990s when the state effectively commandeered local property tax revenues to meets its obligation to the public schools through the Education Revenue Augmentation Fund (ERAF). In many cases, the additional revenues a local government now earns from each new housing unit are insufficient to cover the added expense of providing services to the new residents of that home. Some of the fixed costs of infrastructure can be recouped through fees, but the on-going service costs remain at issue. Thus, a city council deciding the fate of a new housing development faces the unenviable dilemma of denying needed housing or reducing services to existing constituents. As one might expect, new housing developments tend to be the loser.
At the same time, when a city council considers an alternate proposal to develop a parcel of land as a retail center, the fiscal incentives strongly support approval. Local governments receive a large portion of all sales tax revenue generated within their borders. The additional revenue received from a large retail facility—such as a big-box retailer, online distribution center, or a car dealer—easily outweighs the costs of providing services to the facility. Local government can use these surplus revenues to enhance services to its constituents. As a result, housing is subject to a double whammy. Not only can it be difficult to get approval for a new housing development on residentially-zoned land, but more land is zoned commercial in the hope that retail establishments can be attracted. The only real fiscal incentive local governments have to approve housing is to ensure there are enough residents to support the retailers.
This bill seeks to incentivize local governments to convert idle retail sites into housing affordable to households at 80% - 120% AMI by requiring HCD to issue grants to cities that rezone commercial sites to make residential an allowable use. In order to receive a grant, a city must rezone the site as a use by right, approve a housing development project, and issue a certificate of occupancy. A city will only receive a grant for developments that include housing affordable to households earning 80% - 120% AMI and the grant will be proportionate to the amount of housing available for those households if the development also includes a commercial component. The grant is equal to the average amount of annual sales and use tax revenue generated by each idle site identified in the local government’s application over the seven years immediately preceding the date of the local government’s application. The goal is to offset the lost sales tax revenue that would have been generated from a commercial property.
- Is workforce housing the most necessary? California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis, largely due to a shortage of housing stock, primarily for lower-income households. As more and more families feel the financial burden of monthly housing costs, and scarce resources at the state level, there has been a focus on easing the burden for moderate-income households (80% - 120% AMI). In October 2019, the California Housing Partnership Corporation (CHPC) published a report that compared the median asking rent data on Craigslist for two-bedroom apartments with regionally adjusted 2019 area median incomes. The report found that very low-income households earning 50% AMI can afford modest rents in only one county in California; households earning 60% AMI could afford modest rents in 11 counties; 80% AMI could afford modest rents in 29 counties; and households with median incomes earning 100% AMI could afford modest rents in all but 6 counties, primarily in the State’s high-cost coastal regions.
Generally, when low-income households experience severe cost burden and spend most of their income on housing, families have to cut back on essentials such as food, healthcare, childcare, and transportation. These families are often those that are closest to becoming homeless. While CHPC recommends prioritizing assistance to households with the lowest income, they note that there are moderate income households in specific neighborhoods and counties that need help. CHPC recommends assistance for households earning more than 80% AMI should generally be limited to areas of the State where median income households cannot afford modest rents and where government intervention is most needed, particularly in the six higher cost coastal counties.
The author intends for the bill to help working families find and maintain affordable housing. In many parts of the state, teachers, licensed vocational nurses, and paralegals, for example, earn less than 80% AMI. This is particularly true in high cost and coastal areas of the state. Given that the need for affordable housing is not limited to moderate-income earners, the author moving forward may wish to consider expanding the eligible households to include grants to cities for zoning and developing low-income households (i.e. 0% AMI – 120% AMI).
- Competitive Program. While locals traditionally have been incentivized to build more commercial properties than residential, recent legislative changes may strongly incent locals to rezone commercial sites to residential on the natural. In 2018, the Legislature passed two key bills, SB 828 (Wiener, Chapter 974) and AB 1771 (Bloom, Chapter 989) that made a number of changes to the regional housing needs allocation process that increased transparency and accountability of that process. As a result, many local jurisdictions are seeing increases in the numbers of housing units that their housing elements must accommodate for the next planning cycle.
If many jurisdictions are already contemplating making these kinds of zoning changes, this program may become competitive. Moving forward, the author may wish to consider adding some additional requirements for cities to meet in order to be eligible to receive funding, including but not limited to, requiring the adoption of a compliant housing element, requiring the submission of statutorily required annual housing reports, requiring no violations of state housing law (such as the Housing Accountability Act or Density Bonus Law) within the last five years, and requiring no local ordinances or voter approved limitations on housing development or population restrictions.
- Show me the money. While this bill contemplates the creation of a new grant program, the bill does not appropriate any funding to support it.
Related Legislation:
SB 1385 (Caballero, 2020) — establishes the Neighborhood Homes Act, which provides that specified housing development project shall be deemed an authorized use on a neighborhood lot that is zoned for office or retail commercial use under a local agency’s zoning code or general plan. This bill is in the Governance and Finance Committee.
AB 101 (Budget and Fiscal Review, Chapter 159, Statutes of 2019) — among other things, required “low-barrier navigation centers” to be a use-by-right, until January 1, 2027, as defined, in areas zoned for mixed uses and nonresidential zones permitting multifamily uses if the development meets certain requirements.
AB 2162 (Chiu, Chapter 753, Statues of 2018) — streamlined affordable housing developments that include a percentage of supportive housing units and onsite services
SB 35 (Wiener, Chapter 366, Statutes of 2017) — created a streamlined, ministerial approval process for infill developments in localities that have failed to meet their regional housing needs assessment (RHNA) numbers.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
May 20, 2020.)
SUPPORT:
Building Industry Association of Southern California, Inc.
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
Employers Group
League of California Cities
Los Angeles Business Council
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZFED)
Orange County Business Council
Pasadena Chamber of Commerce and Civic Association
Southland Regional Association of Realtors
OPPOSITION:
None received.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):