SB 144: Criminal fees.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-05-21
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 27, 2020 | August 3 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | July 9 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | June 25 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 26. Noes 8.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2019 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 31, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 22, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 21. |
| Jan 18, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 29, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB144 Mitchell et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 144 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 144
Author: Mitchell (D) and Hertzberg (D), et al.
Amended: 5/21/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach, Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
All of Us or None
American Civil Liberties Union
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
East Bay Community Law Center
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
Insight Center for Community Economic Development
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Policy Link
San Francisco Financial Justice Project
San Francisco Public Defender
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Youth Justice Coalition
DIGEST:
This bill eliminates numerous fees imposed on criminal offenses and Vehicle Code violations.
Existing law:
- Provides that in any case in which a party is provided legal assistance, either through the public defender or private counsel appointed by the court, upon the conclusion of the proceedings or upon the withdrawal of the public defender or private counsel, after a hearing on the matter the court may make a determination of the party to pay all or a portion of the cost of such legal assistance. If the court determines that the party has the ability to pay all or part of the cost, it shall order the party to pay the sum to the county in any installments and manner in which it believes reasonable and compatible with the party’s ability to pay. (Government Code § 27712)
- Provides that prior to furnishing counsel of legal assistance by the court, the court shall give notice to the defendant that after a hearing the court will make an ability to pay determination and that the person may be ordered to pay all or part of the costs of the legal assistance. (Government Code § 27753)
- Provides that any county whose officer or agent arrests a person is entitled to recover from the arrested person a criminal justice administrative fee for the administrative costs it incurs in conjunction with the arrest if the person is convicted of any criminal offense related to the arrest. The fee may be imposed as part of the judgment of conviction or as a condition of probation. (Government Code 29550 (c) (d))
- Allows any city, special district, school district, community college district, college, university or other local agency to collect the criminal justice administrative fee. (Penal Code §§ 29550.1; 29550.2; 299550.3)
- Provides that an administrative screening fee of $25 shall be collected from each person arrested and released on his own recognizance upon conviction of any criminal offense related to an arrest other than an infraction. The fee shall be deposited in the General Fund. (Government Code 29550 (f))
- Provides that a citation processing fee in the amount of $10 shall be collected from each person cited and released by any peace officer in the filed or at a jail facility upon conviction of any criminal offense, other than an infraction. The fee shall be deposited in the General Fund. (Government Code 29550 (f))
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision, a person who is sentenced to state prison or confined in a county jail shall pay a partial amount of the trial court filing fees and costs. To apply for an initial fee waiver, a person who is sentenced to state prison or confined in a county jail the person shall fill out the appropriate judicial council form. Existing law sets forth a process for determining if the person has an ability to pay and process for collecting the fees from the inmates accounts. (Government Code § 6835)
- Provides for a $4 fee imposed upon every conviction for a violation of the Vehicle Code or a local ordinance adopted pursuant to the Vehicle Code, except for parking tickets that go to fund Emergency Medical Air Transportation. This provision provides that the assessment of penalties shall stop on January 1, 2020, although fees imposed prior to that date shall still be collected after that date. This provision sunsets on January 1, 2022. (Government Code § 76000.10)
- Provides that any person who receives probation for child endangerment or infliction of corporal punishment on a child shall be required to complete no less than one year of child abuser’s treatment program and to pay for the full costs of the treatment program including any drug tests. The law further provides that the term of probation shall not be lifted until all reasonable fees due to the counseling program have been paid in full. (Penal Code §§ 273a; 273d; 273.1)
- Provides that every defendant shall be assessed a registration fee of $50 to be represented by the public defender. (Penal Code § 987.5)
- Creates a pretrial diversion program for specified drug offenses. (Penal Code § 1000 et seq)
- Provides that when a defendant completes pretrial diversion, or if pretrial diversion is terminated early, the defendant shall reimburse the probation department for the reasonable cost of any program investigation or progress report filed with the court. (Penal Code § 1000.3)
- Allows a judge to require the payment of an administrative fee, as part of enrollment in a diversion program, to cover the cost of any criminalistics laboratory analysis, not to exceed $500. In addition the court may require the payment of the actual costs of enrollment in diversion and a fee for the cost of supervising the divertee. (Penal Code §§ 1000.15; 1001.16)
- Provides that all persons receiving diversion shall pay a diversion restitution fee and allows the county board of supervisors to cover the actual administrative costs of collection of the restitution fee not to exceed 10% of the amount to be paid and the state shall pay the county agency collecting the fee 10% of the funds collected. (Penal Code § 1001.90)
- Provides that a person convicted of a crime shall pay restitution to the victim. The law allows a county to impose a fee to cover the actual administrative costs of collecting the restitution, not to exceed 10% of the amount owed. (Penal Code§ 1202.4)
- Allows for restitution to be collected from a person’s income and allows an employer to collect up to $5 against offenders to cover the cost of the first income deduction for restitution and $1 for each one after. (Penal Code § 1202.42)
- Provides that a probationer cannot be released to another state until the probationer has paid the reasonable costs of processing their request to move states. (Penal Code § 1203)
- Provides that a participant in home detention shall pay an administrative fee based on an ability to pay. Home detention can be terminated if an individual willfully fails to pay the fee. (Penal Code § 1203.016)
- Allows a county to set up a pretrial electronic monitoring program and authorizes administrative fees to be paid and a person to be returned to custody if they fail to pay the fee. (Penal Code § 1203.018)
- Provides that if the court orders restitution to the victim, the entity collecting the restitution may add a fee to cover the actual administrative costs of collection not to exceed 15% of the total amount paid. (Penal Code § 1203.1)
- Provides that a person convicted of a drug offense can be required to undergo drug testing while on probation and can be required to reasonable fees to pay for the testing. (Penal Code § 1203.1ab)
- Provides that person on probation can be charged the reasonable cost of any probation supervision including fees related to any pre-plea or re-sentence report, the cost of processing a judicial transfer and the cost of collection for installment payments. (Penal Code § 1203.1b)
- Requires a person who is required to install an ignition interlock device because of a DUI conviction shall be required to pay for the device based on an ability to pay determination. (Penal Code § 1203.1bb; Vehicle Code §§ 23573; 23575.3)
- Allows a county to seek reimbursement for the reasonable costs of county parole supervision. (Penal Code § 1203.1e)
- Allows counties or cities to seek reimbursement for the cost of incarceration in a county or city jail, based on an ability to pay determination. (Penal Code § 1203.1c)
- Provides that the court may order a defendant who is sentenced to state prison to pay the reasonable costs of imprisonment. (Penal Code § 1203.1m)
- Provides that if a person is over 26 years of age and is seeking the sealing of a juvenile record a court can charge up to $150. (Penal Code § 1203.45; Welfare and Institutions Code §903.3)
- Provides that a fee may be charged for transferring a probation case to another county. (Penal Code § 1203.9)
- Provides that the court may charge a $30 fee for setting up a payment plan for a fine. (Penal Code § 1205)
- Allows a defendant granted work furlough or home detention to be charged an administrative fee and application fee, although an offender cannot be denied based on an inability to pay. (Penal Code § 1208.2)
- Provides that a person convicted of a non-violent drug offense can be ordered to contribute to the cost of placement in a drug treatment program. (Penal Code § 1210.1)
- Provides that, based on an ability to pay, a chief probation officer may charge for the cost of supervising an offender on electronic monitoring. (Penal Code § 1210.15)
- Provides that if defendant is ordered to pay more than $50 in restitution they may also be ordered to pay 10% interest on outstanding principle. (Penal Code § 1214.5)
- Provides for a $300 civil penalty assessment by the court for a failure to appear. (Penal Code § 1214.1)
- Allows the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to charge a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution. (Penal Code §2085.5)
- Allows counties to collect a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution from a person on PRCS/Mandatory Custody or post-release from custody. (Penal Code §§2085.6; 2085.7)
- Provides that county, city or CDCR may recover costs for medical, dental, and hospital care for an incarcerated youth from the person who is responsible for the youth. (Penal Code § 3000.07)
- Allows for the temporary release of an inmate for a family emergency or for a purpose to prepare them for release and allows the county to charge the offender for expenses relating to that release. (Penal Code § 4024.2)
- Allows a person to be charged an administrative fee for participation in a work release program. (Penal Code § 4024.2)
- Allows CDCR to charge an administrative fee for a work furlough program. (Penal Code §6266)
- Authorizes a county to charge $15 for a written promise to appear. (Vehicle Code § 40508.5)
- Provides that if a defendant fails to make an installment payment for a Vehicle Code violation, the court may charge a fee for failure to appear. The defendant shall also pay a fee up to $35 for the administrative costs of a payment plan. (Vehicle Code § 40510.5)
- Provides that the court shall charge a $25 fee for a “fix it ticket.” (Vehicle Code § 40511)
This bill:
- Deletes the provision requiring an ability to pay determination for the use of a public defender and the provision requiring notice that such a determination will be made.
- Deletes the provision allowing for the recovery of costs associated with arrest.
- Deletes the $25 administrative processing fee and $10 citation processing fee.
- Provides that Emergency Medical Air Transportation fees shall cease to be recovered after January 1, 2020, and changes the sunset date to January 1, 2021.
- Deletes the $50 registration fee for representation by a public defender.
- Deletes the requirement that a defendant reimburse probation for the cost of reports associated with pretrial diversion.
- Deletes the fees for laboratory analysis, enrollment and supervision relating to diversion.
- Deletes the fee to cover the administrative cost of collecting the diversion restitution fee and the county share for collecting restitution.
- Deletes the ability of a county to collect a fee to cover the administrative costs of collecting restitution.
- Deletes the ability of an employer to collect up to $5 or $1 for an income deduction for restitution.
- Deletes the requirement that a probationer reimburse the costs for transfer to another state before being allowed to leave.
- Deletes the fees relating to home detention.
- Deletes the provisions allowing fees for pretrial electronic monitoring.
- Deletes the ability of the entity collecting restitution to add a fee to cover actual administrative costs.
- Deletes the requirement that a person convicted of a drug offense pay for drug testing.
- Deletes the fees related to the cost of probation supervision.
- Deletes the requirement that an offender pay for an ignition interlock and specifically states they are not responsible for the costs.
- Deletes the ability to recover for incarceration costs.
- Deletes the ability of a county to seek reimbursement for the reasonable costs of county parole supervision.
- Deletes the ability to collect state prison costs.
- Deletes the ability to collect a $150 fee to cover a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict.
- Deletes the $60 fee for a petition of the dismissal or an infraction or misdemeanor.
- Deletes the $150 fee for a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict for an 1170h offense.
- Deletes the ability to charge a person over 26 years of age the cost of sealing a juvenile record.
- Deletes the ability to charge a defendant for transferring a case to another county.
- Deletes the ability to charge a defendant $30 to set up a payment plan.
- Deletes the ability to charge a fee for work furlough or home detention.
- Deletes the ability to require a non-violent drug offender to contribute to the cost of treatment.
- Deletes the ability of probation to charge a person for electronic monitoring.
- Deletes the $300 civil penalty assessment for a failure to appear.
- Deletes the ability of the court to order payment of interest on restitution.
- Deletes the ability of CDCR to collect an administration fee to cover the actual cost of collecting restitution.
- Deletes the ability of the counties to collect a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution from a person on PRCS/Mandatory Custody.
- Deletes the ability to charge a responsible party for health care for incarcerated youth.
- Deletes the ability to charge for expenses relating to a temporary release of an inmate.
- Deletes the ability to charge for a work-release program.
- Deletes the ability of CDCR to charge an administrative fee for a work furlough program.
- Deletes the authorization to charge $15 for a written promise to appear.
- Deletes the ability to charge a fee for failure to make an installment payment or a fee to setup up the installment plan.
- Deletes the fee for a “fix it ticket.”
- Provides that as of January 1, 2020, a number of fees that are deleted by this bill are no longer enforceable or collectible and any amounts remaining unpaid shall be vacated.
- Makes a number of cross-reference and conforming changes.
Comments
According to the author, “SB 144 would end the assessment and collection of administrative fees imposed against people in the criminal justice system. By doing so, it would dramatically reduce the suffering caused by court-ordered debt and enhance the economic security of system-involved populations, stalking the first step towards ushering in an era of more just criminal justice policy that does not rely on stripping wealth from communities of color and low-income communities.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- State impact (direct): Major direct ongoing revenue loss to the state minimally in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually. A number of state funds and state entities would experience a revenue loss resulting from the enactment of this measure. Additionally, in some instances, the fee elimination would lead to unfunded positions and programs that still would be required to operate. This in turn would create cost pressures on the General Fund to backfill those losses. (General Fund, various funds)
- County impact: Major ongoing revenue loss to local governments in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually in the aggregate. Some local costs resulting from this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that the fees that would be eliminated by SB 144 allowed for sufficient cost recovery to pay for mandated programs or increased levels of service by the local agencies. Additionally, local costs associated with this measure may be subject, in part, to Proposition 30 funding-service conditions. (Local funds, General Fund)
Proposition 30 (2012) exempts the state from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “Public Safety Services” including the managing of local jails and the provision of services for, and supervision of, minor and adult offenders. The constitutional amendment, however, provides that legislation enacted after September 30, 2012 that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services transferred by the 2011 Realignment Legislation apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been adjudicated by the courts to date, but to the extent that this measure results in overall cost increases to the locals for programs and services determined to be included within the scope of Proposition 30, local agencies would not be obligated to provide those programs or levels of service above the level for which funding is provided by the state.
A New Way of Life (co-source)
All of Us or None (co-source)
American Civil Liberties Union (co-source)
Anti-Recidivism Coalition (co-source)
East Bay Community Law Center (co-source)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights (co-source)
Homeboy Industries (co-source)
Insight Center for Community Economic Development (co-source)
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children (co-source)
Policy Link (co-source)
San Francisco Financial Justice Project (co-source)
San Francisco Public Defender (co-source)
Western Center on Law and Poverty (co-source)
Youth Justice Coalition (co-source)
Alameda County Community Food Bank
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
California Catholic Conference
California Coalition for Women Prisoners
California Partnership
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Center for Employment Opportunities
Center for Responsible Lending
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Children’s Defense Fund-California
City and County of San Francisco
Community Coalition
Community Health Councils
Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto
Courage Campaign
Disability Rights California
Drug Policy Alliance
Fines & Fees Justice Center
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
GACE Institue
Harriet Buhai Center for Family Law
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Immigrant Legal Resource Center
Indivisible East Bay
Initiate Justice
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area
League of Women Voters California
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Pacific Juvenile Defender Center
People for Mobility Justice
Prisoner Hunger Strike Solidarity Coalition
Public Counsel
Rise Together
Root and Rebound
Rubicon Programs
Safe Return Project
Showing Up for Racial Justice
Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition
Starting Over, Inc.
The Debt Collective
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Underground Scholars Initiative
United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council
Youth Justice Coalition
Number of individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/28/19)
California State Association of Counties
California State Sheriffs’ Association
Chief Probation Officers of California
Coalition of Ignition Interlock Manufacturers
County of Santa Barbara
Mothers Against Drunk Driving
Rural County Representatives of California
Urban Counties of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the sponsors:
At every point in the criminal legal process, California state law authorizes counties to charge administrative fees. From booking and arrest to representation by a public defender and probation supervision, an individual can face a host of fees, including for the collection of such fees. Although state law authorizes such fees, local jurisdictions decide which fees to impose and in what amounts. Currently, 56 of 58 California counties charge one or more administrative fees. The fee types, amounts, and burdens on individuals vary widely by county and even courtroom. Once imposed, the “court shall order or the probation officer shall set payments” to be made on a monthly basis. “Execution may be issued on the order issued pursuant to this section in the same manner as a judgment in a civil action.” An order shall not be enforced by contempt, but if an individual fails to repay their debt in full or make payments on time, a county can refer the debt to the state Franchise Tax Board which can intercept tax refunds and garnish wages until the debt is paid in full.
***
Years of research on fines and fees in California, including a review of state law, county policies and practices, state and local data, and the experiences of individuals in the criminal justice system, have found that these fees are unjust, high pain, and low gain.
Low-income people of color are overrepresented at every stage in the criminal legal system, even when controlling for alleged criminal behavior. According to data from the California Department of Justice, people of color are grossly overrepresented in our criminal justice system. Due to over policing and targeted policing in communities of color, they are punished more frequently and harshly at a variety of discretion points. They are more likely to be arrested, incarcerated, and put on probation, and they serve longer jail and probation terms. As a result, they are more likely to face higher fee burdens and the collateral consequences that stem from being unable to pay off related debt. Further, a recent study found that the lack of black representation in local government is connected to the use of fines and court fees as a source of local revenue.
Fees are incredibly burdensome and create financial hardship and limit
employment prospects for individuals seeking to reenter their communities. The fees disproportionately harm low-income people and people of color. Studies have found that criminal justice debt correlates with a greater likelihood of recidivism, even after controlling for case characteristics and demographics. These negative outcomes only make reentry harder….
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California State Association of Counties, Chief Probation Officers of California, Urban Counties of California, and the Rural County Representatives of California:
Our organizations share a commitment to help offenders successfully transition back into their communities and overcome obstacles to making positive changes. We recognize that today’s system of assessing criminal fees is overly complex, and its financial and legal implications are often crippling for those who can least afford them. The associated debt often works as a considerable impediment to successful integration and full participating in family, community, and work responsibilities. An in-depth policy conversation about these implication is certainly warranted.
Our organizations’ position to SB 144 is not grounded in response to the proposed restructuring or eliminating fines and fees. It is, however, tied to the significant and permanent redirection of funding sources that support a diverse set of local programs and services. We cannot support changes to the system that would directly result in program elimination or service disruptions at the county level. A conversation about abolishing fee authority must be accompanied by a comprehensive assessment of the resulting fiscal impacts on agencies and organizations that today receive associated revenue. For decades, the Legislature has funded a wide array of criminal justice programs using fine and fee revenue. Many such examples date back to the 1990s when the state was facing a multi-billion-dollar deficit. As numerous and diverse programs and reforms have been enacted by the State, many of which are tied on an associated fee or fine as a funding source, counties rely on the current funding structure now in place. Funding is critical to ensuring counties can continue to carry out a number of these programs.
Senate Bill 144 eliminates all criminal justice fees. Removal of specified fees for probation services alone, for example, would likely result in the loss of tens of millions of dollars in probation funding, funding that currently supports vital programs and practices as well as probation positions. The loss
of positions would mean impacts on court related services we provide, an increase in caseload sizes and impacts on evidenced-based program delivery.
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
5/28/19 10:21:23
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 144 (Mitchell) - Criminal fees
Version: March 27, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Bill Summary:
SB 144 would eliminate a number of administrative fees imposed on a person related to involvement in the criminal justice system.
Fiscal Impact:
- State impact (direct): Major direct ongoing revenue loss to the state minimally in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually. A number of state funds and state entities would experience a revenue loss resulting from the enactment of this measure. Additionally, in some instances, the fee elimination would lead to unfunded positions and programs that still would be required to operate. This in turn would create cost pressures on the General Fund to backfill those losses. (General Fund, various funds)
- County impact: Major ongoing revenue loss to local governments in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually in the aggregate. Some local costs resulting from this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that the fees that would be eliminated by SB 144 allowed for sufficient cost recovery to pay for mandated programs or increased levels of service by the local agencies. Additionally, local costs associated with this measure may be subject, in part, to Proposition 30 funding-service conditions. (Local funds, General Fund)
Proposition 30 (2012) exempts the state from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “Public Safety Services” including the managing of local jails and the provision of services for, and supervision of, minor and adult offenders. The constitutional amendment, however, provides that legislation enacted after September 30, 2012 that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services transferred by the 2011 Realignment Legislation apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been adjudicated by the courts to date, but to the extent that this measure results in overall cost increases to the locals for programs and services determined to be included within the scope of Proposition 30, local agencies would not be obligated to provide those programs or levels of service above the level for which funding is provided by the state.
Author Amendments:
Strike specified fee eliminations and make technical changes.
Committee Amendments:
Strike specified fee eliminations.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 144 (Mitchell) - Criminal fees
Version: March 27, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 144 would eliminate a number of administrative fees imposed on a person related to involvement in the criminal justice system.
Fiscal Impact:
- State impact (direct): Major direct ongoing revenue loss to the state minimally in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually. A number of state funds and state entities would experience a revenue loss resulting from the enactment of this measure. Additionally, in some instances, the fee elimination would lead to unfunded positions and programs that still would be required to operate (e.g., the interlock ignition device (IID) program by the Department of Motor Vehicle (DMV)). This in turn would create cost pressures on the General Fund to backfill those losses. (General Fund, various funds)
Following are a few examples of the impact:
The elimination of certain court administrative fees would have a minimum impact of approximately $150 million annually on the courts. Moreover, based on 2017-18 revenue data, ending the civil penalty assessment would translate to a loss of roughly $105 million. The courts do not track the collection of all the fees impacted by this measure, so these figures do not represent the total loss that the judicial branch would experience.
Looking at just one aspect of how this bill would impact the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, it would experience an impact of around $2.2 million with the loss of the administrative fee from inmates’ and parolees’ restitution fines. These monies, in part, go to fund 7.0 staff positions in the Office of Victim and Survivor Rights and Services to assist victims and payers with restitution matters. Similarly, this measure would render insolvent the Domestic Violence Training and Education Fund that is operated by the Department of Public Health to fund local grants and 2.0 staff positions on public health approaches to domestic violence prevention.
- County impact: Major ongoing revenue loss to local governments in the hundreds of millions of dollars annually in the aggregate. Some local costs resulting from this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that the fees that would be eliminated by SB 144 allowed for sufficient cost recovery to pay for mandated programs or increased levels of service by the local agencies. Additionally, local costs associated with this measure may be subject, in part, to Proposition 30 funding-service conditions. (Local funds, General Fund*)
Proposition 30 (2012) exempts the state from mandate reimbursement for realigned responsibilities for “Public Safety Services” including the managing of local jails and the provision of services for, and supervision of, minor and adult offenders. The constitutional amendment, however, provides that legislation enacted after September 30, 2012 that has an overall effect of increasing the costs already borne by a local agency for public safety services transferred by the 2011 Realignment Legislation apply to local agencies only to the extent that the state provides annual funding for the cost increase. The provisions of Proposition 30 have not been adjudicated by the courts to date, but to the extent that this measure results in overall cost increases to the locals for programs and services determined to be included within the scope of Proposition 30, local agencies would not be obligated to provide those programs or levels of service above the level for which funding is provided by the state.
The actual impact to each county would vary, depending on a number of factors, including which fees are charged currently (as some counties waive certain fees), the collection practices of the county, the cost of fee collection—while some counties spend more to collect than they recoup, other counties/county agencies recoup more than the cost to collect (e.g., Fresno County spends approximately $235,000 to collect approximately $900,000 in probation-related fees)—and the number of people in a county who would be subject to the services and programs for which the administrative fees would pay.
An informal survey of a handful of counties showed the collection of the following amounts (which would be eliminated under this measure):
- Probation-related fees: $24.7 million (partial numbers from 16 counties)
- Public Defender fees: $1.5 million (partial numbers from 13 counties)
- Sheriff-related fees: $2.4 million (partial numbers from 8 counties)
- Looking at just some of the work furlough fees, Sacramento County collects $3.7 million and Santa Clara County collects $1.5 million.
Looking at one specific example of the local impact of SB 144, Los Angeles County would lose about $2.5 million with the elimination of the $15 fee a county is authorized to impose on a person who violates a written promise to appear in court or who otherwise fails to comply with a valid court order. These monies go specifically to pay for the county-wide warrant system.
Background:
There are various fees imposed on individuals upon a criminal arrest, prosecution, or conviction. Generally, these fees are related to the cost of administering the criminal justice system, including administering probation and diversion programs, collecting restitution orders, processing arrests and citations, administering drug testing, incarcerating individuals, facilitating medical visits, sealing or expunging criminal records, punishing the lack of a person’s appearance in court, monitoring a person while on parole, and using an IID as a condition to drive and to reinstate driving privileges.
Additionally, county public defenders’ offices are required to defend any person who is charged with the commission of a crime but is not financially able to hire an attorney. At the conclusion of a trial, the court may make a determination of a defendant’s present ability to pay all or a portion of the cost of the public defender; this may include an examination and determination by the court of whether the defendant owns real estate or other assets upon which a lien may be imposed. If the court finds that the defendant has the financial ability to pay, the court must order the defendant to pay all or a part of the costs the court believes reasonable and compatible with the defendant’s financial ability.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Eliminate a number of fees and an assessment imposed on a person related to involvement in the criminal justice system and the ability to collect these fees.
- Make any unpaid balance of a court-imposed cost unenforceable and uncollectable and would require the court to vacate a judgment imposing those costs.
- Eliminate the ability of the court to impose a lien on a defendant’s property and make a post-trial determination of the defendant’s ability to pay and to order the defendant to pay the costs of the public defender.
- Eliminate the ability of the court to require a person convicted of a nonviolent drug possession offense to contribute to the cost of that person’s placement in a drug treatment program, as allowed by Proposition 36 (2000).
- Eliminate the ability of the court to impose a civil assessment of up to $300 against a defendant who fails to appear in court, after notice and without good cause, or who fails to pay any part of a court-ordered fine.
- Eliminate the requirement that a person on parole after the conviction of a registerable sex offense pay the costs associated with being monitored by a global positions system, as required by Proposition 83 (2006).
- Eliminate the requirement that a person who is required to use an IID because of the conviction of a specified offense to pay the costs of the IID.
- Eliminate the requirement that a person who is required to use an IID to pay DMV the fee to cover the costs of operating the IID program.
Related Legislation:
SB 545 (Hill, 2019) would require the use of an IID for all persons convicted of a first driving under the influence of alcohol DUI offense and would require an extension of the IID use requirement if a person had a failed start, as defined, within 60 days prior to the end of the requirement. SB 545 is pending on the Suspense File of this Committee.
AB 2533 (Stone, Ch. 764, Stats. 2018) provided that a state prison inmate who has maintained an inmate trust account with $25 or less for 30 consecutive days be deemed indigent and receive basic supplies necessary for maintaining personal hygiene.
SB 185 (Hertzberg, 2017) would have reformed court procedures and fine determinations related to infraction offenses. SB 185 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 190 (Mitchell, Ch. 678, Stats. 2017) repealed the authority of local agencies to assess and collect fees against families of person subject to the juvenile delinquency system.
Staff Comments:
As laid out in the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Public Safety, SB 144 would eliminate—and, starting January 1, 2020, prevent the collection of—the following fees:
County fees:
- The public defender fee, including registration fee—a determination is made about whether a person can pay part of the public defender costs.
- Cost relating to the arrest of a person
- Administrative screening and citation fee
- Amnesty fee
Probation and specialty program fees:
- Reimbursement for probation monitoring of offenders in certain programs
- Costs of laboratory analysis related to diversion
- Home detention administrative fees
- Pretrial electronic monitoring fees
- Probation costs of removing offender from custody
- Drug testing while on probation
- Reasonable cost of probation
- Fees associated with a change of county
- Work furlough administration and application fee
- Electronic monitoring administration and application fee
- Work release administrative fee
Court fees:
- Administrative court fees for various petitions and motions, including change of plea, motion to dismiss a misdemeanor, petition to set aside a plea, motion to seal a juvenile record (by a person over 26)
- Civil penalty assessment for failure to appear
- Traffic fine installment plan collection fee
- Fee to help oversee traffic violator schools
IID program fee
Fees relating to incarceration:
- Reimbursement for incarceration in jail or prison
- Co-pay for medical visits in jail or prison
- Collection for healthcare costs of a juvenile to be paid by responsible party
Restitution-related costs:
- Fees to cover administrative costs to collect restitution by various entities.
- Administrative costs to cover income deduction by an employer
Fees relating to programs required by the nature of the conviction:
- Fee for animal ordinance class
- Fee for Static Risk Assessment for sex offenders
- Sex offender program fees
- $500 domestic violence fee
- Domestic violence program fees
- Drug treatment programs
- Drug diversion programs
- Treatment of a child in a child neglect case
- Hazardous clean-up costs related to drug offenses
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 144 Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Author: | Mitchell | ||
Version: | March 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Criminal Fees
HISTORY
Source: Debt Free Justice Coalition
Prior Legislation: SB 185 (Hertzberg) Held Assembly Appropriations 2017
SB 190 (Mitchell) Chapter 678, Stats. 2017
Support: Alameda County Community Food Bank; Asian Americans Advancing Justice; California Catholic Conference; California Coalition for Women Prisoners; California Partnership; Californians United for a Responsible Budget; Center for Employment Opportunities; Center for Responsible Lending; Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice; Children’s Defense Fund-California; City and County of San Francisco; Community Health Councils; Community Coalition; Community Legal Services in East Palo Alto; Courage Campaign; the Debt Collective; Disability Rights California; Drug Policy Alliance; Fines & Fees Justice Center; Friends Committee on Legislation of California; Harriet Buhai Center for Family Law; Housing and Economic Rights Advocates; Immigrant Legal Resource Center; Indivisible East Bay; Initiate Justice; John Burton Advocates for Youth; Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area; League of Women Voters California; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children; Pacific Juvenile Defender Center; People for Mobility Justice; Public Counsel; Rise Together; Root and Rebound; Rubicon Programs; Safe Return Project; Showing Up for Racial Justice; Sister Warriors Freedom Coalition; Starting Over, Inc.; UDW/AFSCME Local 3930; Underground Scholars Initiative; United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council; Youth Justice Coalition; a number of individuals
Opposition: California State Sheriffs’ Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is eliminate numerous fees imposed on criminal offenses and Vehicle Code violations.
Existing law provides that the state and each city shall accept personal checks, in addition to any other authorized form of payment in payment for any license, permit, or fee, or in payment of any obligation owing to the public agency or trust deposit. If any check is returned without payment for any reason a reasonable charge for the returned checks, not exceeding the actual costs incurred, may be imposed. (Government Code § 6157)
This bill provides that the returned check fee may not be imposed in regard to a payment arising from a criminal proceeding.
Existing law provides that in any case in which a party is provided legal assistance, either through the public defender or private counsel appointed by the court, upon the conclusion of the proceedings or upon the withdrawal of the public defender or private counsel, after a hearing on the matter the court may make a determination of the party to pay all or a portion of the cost of such legal assistance. If the court determines that the party has the ability to pay all or part of the cost, it shall order the party to pay the sum to the county in any installments and manner in which it believes reasonable and compatible with the party’s ability to pay. (Government Code § 27712)
This bill deletes the provision requiring an ability to pay determination for the use of a public defender.
Existing law provides that prior to furnishing counsel of legal assistance by the court, the court shall give notice to the defendant that after a hearing the court will make an ability to pay determination and that the person may be ordered to pay all or part of the costs of the legal assistance. (Government Code § 27753)
This bill deletes that provision.
Existing law provides that any county whose officer or agent arrests a person is entitled to recover from the arrested person a criminal justice administrative fee for the administrative costs it incurs in conjunction with the arrest if the person is convicted of any criminal offense related to the arrest. The fee may be imposed as part of the judgment of conviction or as a condition of probation. (Government Code 29550 (c) (d))
Existing law also allows any city, special district, school district, community college district, college, university or other local agency to collect the criminal justice administrative fee. (Penal Code §§ 29550.1; 29550.2; 299550.3)
This bill deletes the provision allowing for the recovery of costs associated with arrest.
Existing law provides that an administrative screening fee of $25 shall be collected from each person arrested and released on his own recognizance upon conviction of any criminal offense related to an arrest other than an infraction. The fee shall be deposited in the General Fund. (Government Code 29550 (f))
Existing law provides that a citation processing fee in the amount of $10 shall be collected from each person cited and released by any peace officer in the filed or at a jail facility upon conviction of any criminal offense, other than an infraction. The fee shall be deposited in the General Fund. (Government Code 29550 (f))
This bill deletes the $25 administrative processing fee and $10 citation processing fee.
Existing law provides that notwithstanding any other provision, a person who is sentenced to state prison or confined in a county jail shall pay a partial amount of the trial court filing fees and costs. To apply for an initial fee waiver, a person who is sentenced to state prison or confined in a county jail the person shall fill out the appropriate judicial council form. Existing law sets forth a process for determining if the person has an ability to pay and process for collecting the fees from the inmates accounts. (Government Code § 6835)
This bill deletes the provision relating to court filing fees and instead provides that notwithstanding any other law, a person who is sentenced to state prison or confined in a county jail shall not be required to pay any trial court filing fees or costs related to the person’s underlying conviction for which the person is incarcerated.
Existing law provides that each superior court shall adopt a written policy consisted with rules adopted by or trial court financial policies and procedures authorized by, the Judicial Council governing the acceptance of checks and money orders in payments of any fees, fines or bail deposits. If any check is returned to the payee without payment, a reasonable charge for the returned check, not to exceed the actual costs incurred, may be imposed to recover the processing and collection costs. This charge may be added to the underlying obligation. (Government Code § 71386)
This bill deletes the ability to collect for the cost of a returned check.
Existing law provides for a $4 fee imposed upon every conviction for a violation of the Vehicle Code or a local ordinance adopted pursuant to the Vehicle Code, except for parking tickets that go to fund Emergency Medical Air Transportation. This provision provides that the assessment of penalties shall stop on January 1, 2020, although fees imposed prior to that date shall still be collected after that date. This provision sunsets on January 1, 2022. (Government Code § 76000.10)
This bill provides that Emergency Medical Air Transportation fees shall cease to be recovered after January 1, 2020 and changes the sunset date to January 1, 2021.
Existing law provides that in addition to any other penalty or liability, a person convicted of the manufacture, sale, possession for sale, possession, transportation or disposal of any hazardous substance that is a controlled substance or a chemical used in or a byproduct of the manufacture of a controlled substance shall pay a penalty equal to the amount the it cost the local or state agency to remove and dispose of the substance.. (Health and Safety Code § 11374.5)
This bill deletes the ability to charge for controlled substance clean-up.
Existing law provides that a the prosecuting attorney in a criminal proceeding, upon conviction, may seek recovery for all clean-up expenses related to a controlled substance conviction from or any person who manufactures or cultivates a controlled substance, aids or abets the manufacture of a controlled substance and provides a procedure for granting or denying the recovery of expenses. (Health and Safety Code § 11470.2)
This bill removes the ability of the prosecuting attorney to seek recovery clean-up expenses related to a controlled substance conviction.
This bill provides that on and after January 1, 2020 the unpaid balance of any court-imposed costs pursuant to Health and Safety Code Section 11374.5 and 11470.2 is unenforceable, uncollectible and any portion of a judgement imposing those costs shall be vacated.
Existing law provides that any person who receives probation for child endangerment or infliction of corporal punishment on a child shall be required to complete no less than one year of child abuser’s treatment program and to pay for the full costs of the treatment program including any drug tests. The law further provides that the term of probation shall not be lifted until all reasonable fees due to the counseling program have been paid in full. (Penal Code §§ 273a; 273d; 273.1)
This bill deletes the provision requiring fees for the child abuser’s treatment program be paid in full before probation is lifted.
Existing law provides that when a person receives probation for a violation of a protective order, in lieu of a fine the person may be required to make payments to a battered women’s shelter or to a shelter for abused elder persons or dependent adults up to a maximum of $5,000 or reimburse the victim for reasonable costs of counseling and other reasonable expenses that the court finds are the direct result of the defendant’s offense. (Penal Code § 273.6)
This bill removes the option to make a payment to a domestic violence or elder abuse shelter.
Existing law provides that the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) shall assess all sex offenders prior to release. If a person is not assessed they can be assessed while on probation. The law allows the person to request a risk assessment and if they request the assessment they shall be required to pay for the assessment. (Penal Code § 290.06)
This bill removes the requirement that a person who requests a risk assessment pays for the assessment.
Existing law provides that a person who fails to comply with requirements regarding live animal markets can take a course relating to live animal markets in lieu of paying a fine and the local agency may charge up to $100 for the course. (Penal Code § 597.3)
This bill deletes the requirement that a person pay for the live animal course.
Existing law provides that every defendant shall be assessed a registration fee of $50 to be represented by the public defender. (Penal Code § 987.5)
This bill deletes the $50 registration fee for representation by a public defender.
Existing law creates a pretrial diversion program for specified drug offenses. (Penal Code § 1000 et seq)
Existing law provides that when a defendant completes pretrial diversion, or if pretrial diversion is terminated early, the defendant shall reimburse the probation department for the reasonable cost of any program investigation or progress report filed with the court. (Penal Code § 1000.3)
This bill deletes the requirement that a defendant reimburse probation for the cost of reports associated with pretrial diversion.
Existing law allows a judge to require the payment of an administrative fee, as part of enrollment in a diversion program, to cover the cost of any criminalistics laboratory analysis, not to exceed $500. In addition the court may require the payment of the actual costs of enrollment in diversion and a fee for the cost of supervising the divertee. (Penal Code §§ 1000.15; 1001.16)
This bill deletes the fees for laboratory analysis, enrollment and supervision relating to diversion.
Existing law provides that all persons receiving diversion shall pay a diversion restitution fee and allows the county board of supervisors to cover the actual administrative costs of collection of the restitution fee not to exceed 10% of the amount to be paid and the state shall pay the county agency collecting the fee 10% of the funds collected. (Penal Code § 1001.90)
This bill deletes the fee to cover the administrative cost of collecting the diversion restitution fee and the county share for collecting restitution.
Existing law provides that a person convicted of a crime shall pay restitution to the victim. The law allows a county to impose a fee to cover the actual administrative costs of collecting the restitution, not to exceed 10% of the amount owed. (Penal Code§ 1202.4)
This bill deletes the ability of a county to collect a fee to cover the administrative costs of collecting restitution.
Existing law allows for restitution to be collected from a person’s income and allows an employer to collect up to $5 against offenders to cover the cost of the first income deduction for restitution and $1 for each one after. (Penal Code § 1202.42)
This bill deletes the ability of an employer to collect up to $5 or $1 for an income deduction for restitution.
Existing law provides that a probationer cannot be released to another state until the probationer has paid the reasonable costs of processing their request to move states. (Penal Code § 1203)
This bill deletes the requirement that a probationer reimburse the costs for transfer to another state before being allowed to leave.
Existing law provides that a participant in home detention shall pay an administrative fee based on an ability to pay. Home detention can be terminated if an individual willfully fails to pay the fee. (Penal Code § 1203.016)
This bill deletes the fees relating to home detention.
Existing law allows a county to set up a pretrial electronic monitoring program and authorizes administrative fees to be paid and a person to be returned to custody if they fail to pay the fee. (Penal Code § 1203.018)
This bill deletes the provisions allowing fees for pretrial electronic monitoring.
Existing law allows for probation for specified sex crimes if certain conditions are met including making all counseling and program appointments and that the offender pay all the program fees. (Penal Code § 1203.66)
This bill deletes the requirement that a sex offender must pay all fees to receive probation.
Existing law provides that specified sex offenders shall be ordered to be placed in an approved sex offender management program and the person shall be ordered to pay the expense of attending the program. (Penal Code § 1203.67)
This bill deletes the requirement that a sex offender pay the expense of attending a sex offender management program.
Existing law provides that when a person is granted probation for Domestic Violence, among other things a person shall pay a minimum fee of $500, unless the court finds the defendant does not have the ability to pay and reduces or waives the fee. A person shall also be ordered to attend and pay the fees for a batter’s intervention program. Finally, in lieu of a fine, probation may require a defendant to make payments to a battered women’s shelter in an amount up to $5,000 and/or reimburse the victim for reasonable expenses.
This bill deletes the $500 fee for a domestic violence conviction, deletes the requirement that a person pay for the program fees and deletes the $5,000 payment to the domestic violence shelter but keeps the reimbursement the victim for reasonable expenses.
Existing law provides that if the court orders restitution to the victim, the entity collecting the restitution may add a fee to cover the actual administrative costs of collection not to exceed 15% of the total amount paid. (Penal Code § 1203.1)
This bill deletes the ability of the entity collecting restitution to add a fee to cover actual administrative costs.
Existing law provides that probation may remove a person from custody for a period of 3 days under specified circumstances and the probation officer may require the inmate to reimburse the county in whole or in part for expenses. (Penal Code 1203.1a)
This bill deletes the 3 day limitation on the removal of a person from custody and removes the ability of probation to seek reimbursement of costs.
Existing law provides that a person convicted of a drug offense can be required to undergo drug testing while on probation and can be required to reasonable fees to pay for the testing. (Penal Code § 1203.1ab)
This bill deletes the requirement that a person convicted of a drug offense pay for drug testing.
Existing law provides that person on probation can be charged the reasonable cost of any probation supervision including fees related to any pre-plea or re-sentence report, the cost of processing a judicial transfer and the cost of collection for installment payments. (Penal Code § 1203.1b)
This bill deletes the fees related to the cost of probation supervision.
Existing law requires a person who is required to install an ignition interlock device because of a DUI conviction shall be required to pay for the device based on an ability to pay determination. (Penal Code § 1203.1bb; Vehicle Code §§ 23573; 23575.3)
This bill deletes the requirement that an offender pay for an ignition interlock and specifically states they are not responsible for the costs.
Existing law allows counties or cities to seek reimbursement for the cost of incarceration in a county or city jail, based on an ability to pay determination. (Penal Code § 1203.1c)
This bill deletes the ability to recover for incarceration costs.
Existing law allows a county to seek reimbursement for the reasonable costs of county parole supervision. (Penal Code § 1203.1e)
This bill deletes the ability of a county to seek reimbursement for the reasonable costs of county parole supervision.
Existing law provides that in child abuse and neglect cases, the court may order the defendant to pay the costs of any medical examination determining the extent of the abuse or neglect. (Penal Code § 1203.1h)
This bill deletes the ability to recover the cost of a medical examination in a child abuse or neglect case.
Existing law provides that when a person is convicted to fa violation of any building standards, and is ordered to serve all or part of the sentence under house arrest, the defendant may be required to pay the costs of the police officer standing guard in the area in which the defendant is confined. (Penal Code § 1203.1i)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a defendant for the cost of a police officer standing guard.
Existing law provides that the court may order a defendant who is sentenced to state prison to pay the reasonable costs of imprisonment. (Penal Code § 12031m)
This bill deletes the ability to collect state prison costs.
Existing law provides for a fee of $150 to cover a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict. (Penal Code § 1203.4)
This bill deletes the ability to collect a $150 fee to cover a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict.
Existing law provides for a fee of $60 to petition for a dismissal of an infraction or misdemeanor. (Penal Code § 1203.4a)
This bill deletes the $60 fee for a petition of the dismissal or an infraction or misdemeanor.
Existing law provides for a fee of $150 for a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict for an 1170h offense. (Penal Code § 1203.42)
This bill deletes the $150 fee for a petition to change a plea or set aside a verdict for an 1170h offense.
Existing law provides that if a person is over 26 years of age and is seeking the sealing of a juvenile record a court can charge up to $150. (Penal Code § 1203.45; Welfare and Institutions Code §903.3)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a person over 26 years of age the cost of sealing a juvenile record.
Existing law provides that a fee may be charged for transferring a probation case to another county. (Penal Code § 1203.9)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a defendant for transferring a case to another county.
Existing law provides that the court may charge a $30 fee for setting up a payment plan for a fine. (Penal Code § 1205)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a defendant $30 to set up a payment plan.
Existing law allows a defendant granted work furlough or home detention to be charged an administrative fee and application fee, although an offender cannot be denied based on an inability to pay. (Penal Code § 1208.2)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a fee for work furlough or home detention.
Existing law provides that a county may charge a fee to administer a program that lets a person serve a sentence on weekends. (Penal Code § 1209)
This bill deletes the ability to charge an administrative fee for a program that lets a person serve a sentence on weekends.
Existing law provides that a person convicted of a non-violent drug offense can be ordered to contribute to the cost of placement in a drug treatment program. (Penal Code § 1210.1)
This bill deletes the ability to require a non-violent drug offender to contribute to the cost of treatment.
Existing law provides that, based on an ability to pay, a chief probation officer may charge for the cost of supervising an offender on electronic monitoring. (Penal Code § 1210.15)
This bill deletes the ability of probation to charge a person for electronic monitoring.
Existing law provides for a $300 civil penalty assessment by the court for a failure to appear. (Penal Code § 1214.1)
This bill deletes the $300 civil penalty assessment for a failure to appear.
Existing law provides that if defendant is ordered to pay more than $50 in restitution they may also be ordered to pay 10% interest on outstanding principle. (Penal Code § 1214.5)
This bill deletes the ability of the court to order payment of interest on restitution.
Existing law provides that an administrative screening fee of $25 shall be collected from each person arrested and released on their own recognizance upon conviction of any offense related to the arrest other than an infraction and a $10 citation processing fee shall be collected from each person cited and released by any peace officer. (Penal Code § 1463.07)
This bill deletes the $25 and $10 fees related to release of a person on their own recognizance.
Existing law allows the Board of Supervisors to authorize a fee of up to $50 to cover the cost of testing for alcohol content in relation to a DUI. (Penal Code § 1463.14)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a fee for the cost of blood alcohol testing in relation to a DUI.
Existing law allows CDCR to charge a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution. (Penal Code §2085.5)
This bill deletes the ability of CDCR to collect an administration fee to cover the actual cost of collecting restitution.
Existing law allows counties to collect a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution from a person on PRCS/Mandatory Custody or post-release from custody. (Penal Code §§2085.6; 2085.7
This bill deletes the ability of the counties to collect a 10% fee to cover the actual costs of collecting restitution from a person on PRCS/Mandatory Custody.
Existing law provides that county, city or CDCR may recover costs for medical, dental, and hospital care for an incarcerated youth from the person who is responsible for the youth. (Penal Code § 3000.07)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a responsible party for health care for incarcerated youth.
Existing law allows a county jail to charge $3 for an inmate health visit and CDCR to charge $5 for an inmate health visit (Penal Code §§ 4011.2; 5007.5)
This bill deletes the ability of a jail or CDCR to charge a copay for an inmate health visit
Existing law allows for the temporary release of an inmate for a family emergency or for a purpose to prepare them for release and allows the county to charge the offender for expenses relating to that release. (Penal Code § 4024.2)
This bill deletes the ability to charge for expenses relating to a temporary release of an inmate.
Existing law allows a person to be charged an administrative fee for participation in a work release program. (Penal Code § 4024.2)
This bill deletes the ability to charge for a work-release program.
Existing law allows CDCR to charge an administrative fee for a work furlough program. (Penal Code §6266)
This bill deletes the ability of CDCR to charge an administrative fee for a work furlough program.
Existing law authorizes a county to charge $15 for a written promise to appear. (Vehicle Code § 40508.5)
This bill deletes the authorization to charge $15 for a written promise to appear.
Existing law allows the superior court to establish a $10 fee for the administrative cost of recording prior Vehicle Code violations. (Vehicle Code § 40508.6)
This bill deletes the authorization got charge a $10 fee for recording violations of the Vehicle Code.
Existing law provides that if a defendant fails to make an installment payment for a Vehicle Code violation, the court may charge a fee for failure to appear. The defendant shall also pay a fee up to $35 for the administrative costs of a payment plan. (Vehicle Code § 40510.5)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a fee for failure to make an installment payment or a fee to setup up the installment plan.
Existing law provides that the court shall charge a $25 fee for a “fix it ticket.” (Vehicle Code § 40511)
This bill deletes the fee for a “fix it ticket.”
Existing law provides that the court shall determine a person’s ability to pay and allows for the court and probation to collects costs that are associated with that determination. (Vehicle Code § 42003)
This bill deletes the ability of the court to collect costs associated with an ability to pay determination.
Existing law provides that a court clerk can collect a fee up to $35 to cover the administrative costs for processing an installment payment plans for the cost of traffic school. (Vehicle Code §42007)
This bill deletes the ability to charge a fee to cover the administrative costs for processing an installment plan for the cost of traffic violator school.
Existing law allows the court to add a $49 fee for traffic school to help defray the cost of monitoring traffic violator schools (Vehicle Code § 42007.1)
This bill deletes the $49 fee for traffic school.
Existing law allows a county to charge a $50 fee for administering an amnesty program (Vehicle Code § 42008.8)
This bill deletes the $50 fee for administering an amnesty program.
This bill provides that as of January 1, 2020, a number of fees that are deleted by this bill are no longer enforceable or collectible and any amounts remaining unpaid shall be vacated.
This bill makes a number of cross-reference and conforming changes.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
SB 144 would end the assessment and collection of administrative fees imposed against people in the criminal justice system. By doing so, it would dramatically reduce the suffering caused by court-ordered debt and enhance the economic security of system-involved populations, stalking the first step towards ushering in an era of more just criminal justice policy that does not rely on stripping wealth from communities of color and low-income communities
2. County Fees
This bill eliminates a number of fees that are designed to help defray various costs to the counties including:
- The public defender fee, including registration fee—a determination is made about whether or not a person can pay part of the public defender costs.
- Cost relating to the arrest of a person.
- Administrative screening and citation fee
- Amnesty fee
How many of these fees are currently collected by counties? Will the counties be able to absorb these costs?
3. Fees related to probation and specialty programs
This bill eliminates a number of fees directly related to probation or programs run by probation including:
- Reimbursement for probation monitoring of offenders in certain programs.
- Costs of laboratory analysis related to diversion
- Home detention administrative fees
- Pretrial electronic monitoring fees
- Probation costs of removing offender from custody
- Drug testing while on probation
- Reasonable cost of probation
- Fees associated with a change of county
- Work furlough administration and application fee
- Electronic Monitoring administration and application fee
- Work release administrative fee
Should all these fees be eliminated? If these fees are eliminated will programs relating to alternative custody situations still be available in all counties?
4. Court Fees
This bill eliminates a number of fees that are collected by the courts including:
- Courts administrative costs for various petitions and motions including change of plea, motion to dismiss a misdemeanor, petition to set aside a plea, motion to seal a juvenile record (by a person over 26)
- Civil penalty assessment for failure to appear
- Traffic fine installment plan collection fee
- Traffic violator school fee-to help oversee traffic violator schools
Should all these fees be eliminated?
5. Ignition Interlock fees
Existing law mandates a person convicted of a repeat DUI install an ignition interlock device (IID) on their car for a specified period of time. The law provides that charges should be based on an ability to pay. This bill eliminates all costs associated with an IID and expressly provides that a person does not have to pay for their IID. IIDs are installed by private businesses. Who will pay for the installation and maintenance?
6. Fees relating to incarceration
This bill eliminates fees that are specifically related to incarceration including:
- Reimbursement for incarceration in jail or prison.
- Co-pay for medical visits in jail or prison
- Collection for healthcare costs of a juvenile to be paid by responsible party
In historical discussions on co-pays for medical visits, it was asserted that a minimum payment kept people from going to the doctor when it was not necessary. Should co-pays be eliminated?
7. Restitution related costs
This bill eliminates fees associated with collecting restitution:
- Fees to cover administrative costs to collect restitution by various entities.
- Administrative costs to cover income deduction by an employer.
Should those that help collect restitution be able to collect their costs? What about a private employer—what incentive do they have to collect restitution by an income deduction if they cannot recover their costs?
8. Fees relating to programs required by the nature of the conviction
This bill eliminates a number of fees that arise because of specific type of offense including:
- Fee Animal ordinance class
- Fee for Static Risk Assessment for sex offenders
- Sex offender program fees
- $500 domestic Violence fee
- Domestic Violence Program fees
- Drug treatment programs
- Drug diversion programs
- Treatment of a child in a child neglect case.
- Hazardous clean-up costs related to drug offenses.
Does a person who is ordered to a specific type of class, or program get any benefit by paying some of the costs of the program? Some of the programs are run by private providers, if the offenders do not pay the costs who will take on these costs?
9. Fees no longer collectible as of January 1, 2020
This bill makes it clear that as of January 1, 2020 the eliminated fees are no longer collectible and any past due fees will no longer be able to be collected.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):