SB 15: Property tax revenue allocations: Local-State Sustainable Investment Program.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-24
The Community Redevelopment Law authorized the establishment of redevelopment agencies in communities to address the effects of blight, as defined. Existing law dissolved redevelopment agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies, as defined, to wind down the affairs of the dissolved redevelopment agencies.
This bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to redevelopment.
It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation relating to redevelopment.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 16, 2019 | May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (April 22). |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HOUSING. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and HOUSING. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Housing] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 15 (Portantino) - Property tax revenue allocations: Local-State Sustainable Investment Program
Version: April 24, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 5 - 1, HOUSING 8 - 3 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
SB 15 would establish the Local-State Sustainable Investment Program (Program) to fund local affordable housing, housing infrastructure, neighborhood restoration, and specified public safety facilities. The bill would allocate ERAF revenues to local entities for those projects, and require state General Fund backfills to school entities for the associated loss of property tax revenues, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- General Fund impacts of up to $1 billion annually for up to 10 years when fully implemented. General Fund expenditures would be up to $200 million annually until the $1 billion cap is reached. Each project may receive funding for up to 10 years, and only first year allocations would count against the annual cap. The funding mechanism in this bill requires the Department of Finance (DOF) to direct county officials to divert property tax revenues from county Educational Revenue Augmentation Funds (ERAFs) to specified local entities with approved projects each year. Each ERAF shift may have a duration of up to 10 years. The General Fund generally backfills any reductions in the school share of local property tax revenues, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees, including amounts transferred from ERAFs.
- Unknown significant DOF costs to establish and administer the Program, likely over $1 million annually, and potentially several million depending on how DOF structures the Program. DOF would likely require new staff to establish parameters of the Program, provide technical assistance, evaluate and rank applications, award funding, and conduct ongoing monitoring, oversight, and administration activities. (General Fund)
- Unknown state-reimbursable local mandate costs associated with new requirements imposed on county auditors to administer ERAF shifts and property tax allocations. Ultimately, the Commission on State Mandates would determine whether certain duties mandated by the bill necessitate state reimbursement, should local entities file a successful test claim. (General Fund)
Background:
Prior to 2011, the Community Redevelopment Law allowed a local government to establish redevelopment agencies (RDAs) and capture all of the increase in property taxes that is generated within the project area beyond the base year value (referred to as “tax increment”) over a period of decades. Local communities used redevelopment as a tool to alleviate blight by diverting approximately $6 billion annually in property tax increment to pay for development projects, repairing infrastructure, and building affordable housing. Since approximately half of property tax revenues statewide are a dedicated source of funding for K-14 schools, redevelopment diverted significant revenues away from schools. Generally, the loss in school funding related to the tax increment dedicated for redevelopment purposes has been backfilled by the General Fund pursuant to the minimum funding guarantees specified in Proposition 98.
Citing a significant State General Fund deficit, Governor Brown’s 2011-12 budget proposed eliminating RDAs and returning billions of dollars of property tax revenues to schools, cities, and counties to fund core services. Among the statutory changes that the Legislature adopted to implement the 2011-12 budget, AB X1 26 (Blumenfield), Chap. 5/2011, dissolved all RDAs and established procedures for winding down RDA activity. Existing law requires successor agencies to dispose of former RDAs’ assets and properties, at an oversight board’s direction, in an expeditious manner aimed at maximizing value. Successor agencies are required to make any payments related to enforceable obligations, as specified in an adopted recognized obligation payment schedule and remit unencumbered balances of RDA funds and proceeds from asset sales to the county auditor-controller for distribution to local taxing entities in the county. Successor agencies cannot enter into new enforceable obligations.
Since the dissolution of RDAs in 2012, legislators have enacted several measures creating new tax increment financing tools to pay for local economic development. In 2014, the Legislature authorized the creation of EIFDs (SB 628, Beall), followed by Community Revitalization and Investment Authorities (CRIAs) in 2015 (AB 2, Alejo). Similar to EIFDs, CRIAs use tax increment financing to fund infrastructure projects, with two big differences: CRIAs may only be formed in economically depressed areas, but don’t require voter approval. Two years ago, the Legislature authorized the formation of Affordable Housing Authorities (AHAs), which may use tax increment financing exclusively for rehabilitating and constructing affordable housing and do not require voter approval to issue bonds (AB 1598, Mullin). Last year, SB 961 (Allen) removed the vote requirement for a subset of EIFDs to issue bonds and required these EIFDs to instead solicit public input. While these entities share fundamental similarities with RDAs in terms of using various forms of tax increment financing, none of these tools include the diversion of the school share of property tax revenues, thereby avoiding the significant state General Fund impacts of redevelopment.
Proposition 98, a constitutional amendment approved by the voters in 1988 and modified in 1990, establishes a minimum funding requirement for K-12 schools and community colleges, referred to as the minimum funding guarantee. The state meets the minimum guarantee through a combination of General Fund and local property tax revenues, as specified in the three main tests for calculating the guarantee.
Proposition 13 gave the state the authority to allocate the local property tax among local agencies, including school and community college districts. County auditors allocate property taxes to local agencies, based on specified formulas. In the early 1990s, in response to an economic recession and serious budget shortfalls, the state permanently redirected almost one-fifth of total statewide property tax revenue from cities, counties, and special districts to K-12 and community college districts as a mechanism to provide General Fund relief. Under the changes in property tax allocation laws, county auditors deposit the redirected property tax revenue into a countywide ERAF for schools. In 2017-18, cities, counties, and special districts deposited around $9.6 billion into county ERAFs. Because Proposition 98 obligates the state to ensure that school districts all receive a minimum guaranteed level of funding, local property tax contributions to ERAF reduce the state’s funding obligations for K-14 education. Before counties distribute property tax revenue from ERAF to nonbasic aid schools and community colleges, the county diverts some ERAF back to local agencies to account for two other specified funding formulas, (1) excess ERAF and (2) the Vehicle License Fee (VLF) swap.
Proposed Law:
SB 15 would establish the State-Local Sustainable Investment Program to fund specified housing, infrastructure, and public safety projects through a property tax shift that must be backfilled by the state General Fund. Specifically, this bill would do the following:
- Authorize a city, county, or specified joint powers agency (JPA) to apply for funding for projects that further the following purposes:
- At least 50% of funds must be used to increase the availability of affordable housing that is affordable to households making 120% of the area median income.
- The rehabilitation, construction, and maintenance of housing infrastructure.
- Support of local community planning and engagement efforts to revitalize and restore neighborhoods, including by repairing parks and aging infrastructure.
- To build public safety facilities, but specifically excluding correctional facilities.
- Require an applicant who has taken any action that has the following effects to use 100% of funding received under the Program for housing and infrastructure that supports housing:
- Has established or implemented any provision that limits necessary land use approvals or permitting, caps the number of units that can be approved or constructed within a specified period, or limits the applicant’s population.
- Imposes or enforces a moratorium on housing development, as specified.
- Requires voter approval of housing element updates, site rezoning, or general plan amendments necessary to comply with an updated housing element.
- Changes zoning to less-intensive uses or reduces the intensity of land use within existing zoning districts below what was allowed under the general plan as of January 1, 2018, as specified.
- Results in a determination that a jurisdiction’s housing element is out of compliance.
- Violates the terms of any state housing program in which the applicant is participating.
- Require DOF to review, and approve, modify, or deny applications for funding based on whether the project furthers the purposes noted above for eligible expenditures.
- As a condition of eligibility for funding, the bill requires an applicant (except rural applicants) to provide matching resources, as specified, and specifies that the applicant must not have violated the Housing Accountability Act, as specified.
- Require DOF to prioritize awarding funds to applicants that have enacted measures to reduce development costs, as specified.
- Authorize DOF to approve up to $200 million in funding for projects approved under the program per fiscal year until a cap of $1 billion is reached.
- Require at least 20% of projects approved each year to be in counties with populations of less than 200,000.
- Authorize DOF to approve funding for a project over a maximum of 10 years, and specify that only the amount approved for a given fiscal year applies to the annual cap.
- Require DOF to issue an order directing the county auditory to reduce the amount of property tax allocated from the applicant to ERAF by the amount approved for project funding, as specified.
- Require a General Fund backfill of any amounts that would otherwise have been allocated to schools, absent the ERAF shift.
Related Legislation:
SB 5 (Beall), which is currently pending in this Committee, would establish the Affordable Housing and Community Development Investment Program to fund local affordable housing, transit-oriented development, infill development, neighborhood revitalization, and specified infrastructure. The bill would allocate ERAF revenues to local entities for those projects, and require state General Fund backfills to school entities for the associated loss of property tax revenues, as specified.
AB 11 (Chiu), which is currently pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee, would enact the Community Redevelopment Law of 2019, and allow local agencies to create Affordable Housing and Infrastructure Agencies to fund affordable housing and other specified projects using property tax increment revenues.
Staff Comments:
The State Controller estimated that when RDAs were dissolved in 2012, they were obligated to spend approximately $1 billion annually on affordable housing as a result of the requirement to set-aside 20% of tax increment funding generated in a project area to increase the supply of low- and moderate-income housing. California is currently in the midst of a serious housing crisis, which has been exacerbated by the loss of RDA funds dedicated to affordable housing. Staff notes that SB 15, when fully implemented, will dedicate approximately $1 billion to the Program, at least half of which must be spent on housing that is affordable to households making 120% of the area median income. Staff notes that this threshold is generally considered a moderate-income affordability level in state-administered housing programs.
The Legislature has enacted numerous measures to facilitate affordable housing production and address the housing shortage. The housing package of 2017 made an effort to promote higher density housing, streamline housing approval processes, and increase zoning for housing while providing more state enforcement power. This package included SB 2 (Atkins), which required recorders to collect a $75 fee on every real estate instrument, paper, or notice. That bill is expected to generate $200-$300 million annually to fund various housing programs. The package also included SB 3 (Beall), which placed a $3 billion bond before voters on the November 2018 ballot, which voters approved, to fund affordable housing programs. In addition, the voters approved Proposition 2 in 2018, which provides $2 billion for housing construction for chronically homeless persons experiencing a mental illness.
SB 15 would establish a mechanism that, when fully implemented, shifts up to $1 billion annually from local ERAFs to pay for projects approved under the Program for affordable housing, housing infrastructure, neighborhood restoration, and specified public safety facilities. This indirectly requires the state to make annual General Fund adjustments to match any reductions in ERAF that would otherwise be used to support schools. While school funding is held harmless, the bill would reduce the amount of General Fund revenues available to support other state programs and services.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 15 Hearing Date: 4/22/2019
Author: | Portantino | ||
Version: | 4/8/2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alison Hughes | ||
SUBJECT: Property tax revenue allocations: Local-State Sustainable Investment Program
DIGEST: This bill creates the Local-State Sustainable Investment Program (Program), which allows local agencies to build affordable housing, housing-related infrastructure, and public safety facilities.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes local governments to create Enhanced Infrastructure Financing Districts (EIFDs) to finance specified infrastructure projects and facilities.
- Authorizes a local government to create Community Revitalization and Investment Authorities (CRIA) to use tax increment revenue to improve infrastructure, assist businesses, and support affordable housing in disadvantaged communities.
- Authorizes a local government to establish an Affordable Housing Authority to fund affordable housing.
- Establishes the Neighborhood Infill and Transit Improvements Act, or NIFTI, in EIFD law and allows the infrastructure financing plan to contain a provision for the addition of any increase of the total receipts of local sales and use taxes (SUTs) and attribute those taxes to the NIFTI.
This bill:
- Establishes an application process for the Program, eligible uses for the funds made available by the bill, and a process for distributing funds.
- Allows a city or county, or a joint powers authority (JPA) that comprise the city and county to submit a request to the Department of Finance (DOF) to receive a portion of the county’s Education Revenue Augmentation Fund (ERAF) for specified projects. Once DOF receives the application, it can approve, deny, or modify an application.
- Authorizes the following eligible uses of funds:
- To increase the availability of affordable housing, meaning the predevelopment, development, acquisition, rehabilitation and preservation of units affordable to households making 120% of area median income.
- To increase the availability of high-quality jobs though the rehabilitation, construction, and maintenance of housing infrastructure.
- To promote strong neighborhoods by supporting local community planning and engagement efforts to revitalize and restore neighborhoods, including by repairing parks, and aging infrastructure.
- To build public safety facilities, which do not include correctional facilities.
- Requires at least 20% of funds go to counties with under 200,000 residents.
- Allows DOF to approve $200 million in projects in the first year, increasing in $200 million increments each year until reaching $1 billion after five years. When DOF approves a project, it shall direct the county auditor to reduce the amount of property tax revenue the applicant would otherwise have contributed to the county’s ERAF.
- Specifies that these reductions can only come from ERAF amounts that were going to be used for K-12 schools, which ensures that the General Fund backfills the lower property tax revenue to schools. Projects approved in a plan must not request funding for more than 10 years.
COMMENTS
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Redevelopment’s dissolution deprived many local agencies of the primary tool they used to eliminate physical and economic blight, finance new construction, improve public infrastructure, rehabilitate existing buildings, and increase the supply of affordable housing. California has consistently failed in meeting the state’s housing needs, especially in dealing with low-income affordable housing. California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis. California is home to many of the most expensive rental-housing markets in the country which has had a disproportionate impact on the middle class and the working poor. A major factor in this crisis is the state’s housing shortage. From 1954-1989, California constructed an average of more than 200,000 new homes annually. Since then, however, construction has dropped significantly. HCD estimates that approximately 1.8 million new housing units—180,000 new homes per year—are needed to meet the state’s projected population and housing growth by 2025. Due in part to this housing shortage, California has one of the highest supplemental poverty measures in the nation. Data from the U.S. Census Bureau shows approximately 19% of Californians, roughly 7.5 million people, live in poverty, placing California in the top three highest supplemental poverty rates in the nation along with Florida and Louisiana. Despite a strong economy, The California Budget and Policy Center has reported that median household rents in California have risen 13.2% from 2006 to 2016, while median annual earnings for full-time workers grew by only 4.1% during that period. California must strive to increase the supply of affordable housing or we will continue to struggle to bring millions out of poverty.”
- Loss of Redevelopment Funds. Article XVI, Section 16 of the California Constitution authorizes the Legislature to provide for the formation of redevelopment agencies (RDAs) to eliminate blight in an area by means of a self-financing schedule that pays for the redevelopment project with tax increment derived from any increase in the assessed value of property within the redevelopment project area (or tax increment). Prior to Proposition 13 of 1978, very few RDAs existed; however after its passage, RDAs became a source of funding for a variety of local infrastructure activities. Eventually, RDAs were required to set-aside 20% of funding generated in a project area to increase the supply of low and moderate-income housing in the project areas. At the time RDAs were dissolved, the Controller estimated that statewide, RDAs were obligated to spend $1 billion on affordable housing.
Since the dissolution of RDAs in 2012, legislators have enacted several measures creating new tax increment financing tools to pay for local economic development. In 2014, the Legislature authorized the creation of EIFDs (SB 628, Beall), followed by CRIAs in 2015 (AB 2, Alejo). Similar to EIFDs, CRIAs use tax increment financing to fund infrastructure projects, with two big differences: CRIAs may only be formed in economically depressed areas, but don’t require voter approval. Two years ago, the Legislature authorized the formation of Affordable Housing Authorities (AHAs), which may use tax increment financing exclusively for rehabilitating and constructing affordable housing and do not require voter approval to issue bonds (AB 1598, Mullin). Last year, SB 961 (Allen) removed the vote requirement for a subset of EIFDs to issue bonds and required these EIFDs to instead solicit public input. While these entities share fundamental similarities with RDAs in terms of using various forms of tax increment financing, they differ in one important aspect: not having access to the school’s share of property tax revenue.
- ERAF Background. Each year, the state estimates how much each K-12 school and community college district will receive in local property tax revenue (and student fee revenue in the case of community colleges); the annual budget act appropriates state General Fund monies to “make up the difference” and fund the district’s revenue limit or apportionment at the intended level. Frequently, however, the actual property tax revenues allocated to school districts may be less than anticipated. The state’s education finance system addresses these shortfalls differently for different types of educational entities. For K-12 districts, all funding shortfalls are backfilled automatically with additional state aid. In contrast, explicit state action is required to backfill community college funding shortfalls.
In 1992-93 and 1993-94, in response to serious budgetary shortfalls, the state permanently redirected almost one-fifth of total statewide property tax revenue from cities, counties, and special districts to K-12 and community college districts. Under the changes in property tax allocation laws, the redirected property tax revenue is deposited into a countywide fund for schools, ERAF. The property tax revenue from ERAF is distributed to non-basic aid schools and community colleges, reducing the state’s funding obligations for K-14 education. In 2017-18, cities, counties, and special districts deposited around $9.6 billion into county ERAFs. Funds deposited into county ERAFs are distributed back to back to schools and local agencies, as specified.
- Money for locals to build housing. California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis, largely due to a shortage of housing stock, primarily for lower-income households. This bill creates an ongoing revenue source for locals to create affordable housing, housing-related infrastructure, and public safety facilities by indirectly requiring the General Fund to backfill any reductions to the ERAF. It also states that the backfills shall ensure that schools receive the same level of revenue as they would have in absence of the bill.
- Missing pieces. While this bill creates a framework for providing funding to locals, it is missing mechanics to make it operate and guardrails to ensure the funds are used. For example, this bill does not specify the information local agencies need to include when DOF considers their application, nor does it provide much guidance as to how projects are evaluated or whether certain priorities, such as the number of affordable housing units proposed for construction, will make some projects more competitive than others. Additionally, some RDAs were criticized for using the funds for unauthorized purposes, and this bill does not provide a method for reporting to the state or protections as to the use of funds. The Committee may wish to consider whether this bill provides enough detail regarding how this program would work.
- Sharing the burden. The Legislature has enacted numerous measures to facilitate affordable housing production and address the housing shortage. The housing package of 2017 made an effort to promote higher density housing, streamline housing approval processes, and increase zoning for housing while providing more state enforcement power. This package included SB 2 (Atkins), which required recorders to collect a $75 fee on every real estate instrument, paper, or notice. Once collected, these fees will fund various housing programs. The package also included SB 3 (Beall), which placed a $3 billion bond before voters on the November 2018 ballot, which voters approved, to fund affordable housing programs. Additionally, in 2018, the voters approved Proposition 2, which provides $2 billion for housing construction for chronically homeless persons experiencing a mental illness.
In 2016 and 2018, several jurisdictions across the state took action and adopted local measures to fund affordable housing construction, either through general obligation bonds or the creation of a permanent funding stream. On the other hand, some jurisdictions have taken actions to stymie housing development either through local initiative processes or through actions by the local city council. Given the severity of the crisis, identifying funding solutions must be a shared responsibility and locals have control over how quickly they approve housing and can take steps to reduce housing costs. Further, with finite resources available, the state should not reward jurisdictions that have otherwise sought to stymie housing production. The author will accept amendments that require the following: a) in order to receive funding, non-rural jurisdictions provide a match, including financial, in kind land dedication, and public-private funds; b) the Program will prioritize projects in jurisdictions that have enacted local measures to reduce development costs, including but not limited to accelerating housing approvals, the average permitting time is less than a year, reduced fees for ADUs, and dense zoning near transit; c) jurisdictions that have passed measures that cap population or place limits on growth, enacted housing moratoria, required housing-related zoning decisions be approved by the electorate, engaged in downzoning, failed to comply with housing element law, or violated state housing programs may only use the funds from the Program for housing and infrastructure that supports housing; and d) jurisdictions that have violated the Housing Accountability Act or Density Bonus Law in the last five years, or since 2018, whichever is more recent, will be ineligible for funding.
7) Opposition. The California Teachers Association opposes this bill because it shifts property tax revenues away from ERAF used to support K-14 schools, and allocates them instead for other purposes, including the increase of affordable housing. The CTA does not believe that the methods created under this bill would create affordable housing in a way that would protect California’s schools from unintentional harm.
8) Incoming! This bill was heard in the Governance and Finance Committee on April 10th, 2019. Due to time constraints, committee amendments agreed to in that committee will be taken in this committee. The amendments agreed to require at least 50% of funds be spent on affordable housing.
9) Double-referral. This bill passed out of the Governance and Finance Committee on April 10th, 2019 with a 6-0 vote.
Related Legislation:
SB 5 (Beall, 2019) — creates the Affordable Housing and Community Development Investment Program, which funds affordable housing and housing-related infrastructure. This bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 532 (Portantino, 2019) — allows successor agencies to use a portion of bond proceeds for affordable housing, as specified. This bill will be heard today in this committee.
AB 1568 (Bloom, Chapter 562, Statutes of 2017) — allowed an EIFD to allocate sales taxes for affordable housing on infill sites.
AB 2 (Alejo, Chapter 319, Statutes of 2015) — authorized local governments to create Community Revitalization and Investment Authorities (CRIA) to use tax increment revenue to improve the infrastructure, assist businesses, and support affordable housing in disadvantaged communities. It required that at least 25% of all tax increment revenues that are allocated to the CRIA from any participating entity must be deposited into a separate Low- and Moderate-Income Housing Fund and used by the CRIA for the purposes of increasing, improving, and preserving the community's supply of low- and moderate-income housing available at affordable housing cost.
SB 628 (Beall, Chapter 785, Statutes of 2014) — allowed local agencies to create enhanced infrastructure financing districts (EIFDs) to finance specified infrastructure projects and facilities.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
April 17, 2019.)
SUPPORT:
None received.
OPPOSITION:
California Teachers Association
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 15 | Hearing Date: | 4/10/19 |
Author: | Portantino | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 3/20/19 As proposed to be amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Peterson | ||
Local-State Sustainable INvestment Program
Allows local agencies to reduce contributions of local property tax revenue to schools to build affordable housing, related infrastructure, and public safety facilities.
Background
Redevelopment agencies. From the early 1950s until they were dissolved in 2011, California redevelopment agencies (RDAs) used property tax increment financing to pay for economic development projects in blighted areas. Generally, property tax increment financing involves a city or county forming a tax increment-financing district to issue bonds and use the bond proceeds to pay project costs within the boundaries of a specified project area. To repay the bonds, the district captures increased property tax revenues that are generated when projects financed by the bonds increase assessed property values within the project area. To calculate the increased property tax revenues captured by the district, the amount of property tax revenues received by any local agency that receives a share of property tax revenues from property within a project area is “frozen” at the amount it received from that property prior to the project area’s formation. In future years, as the project area's assessed valuation grows above the frozen base, the resulting additional property tax revenues—the increment—flows to the tax increment financing district instead of other local agencies. After the bonds have been fully repaid, the district is dissolved, ending the diversion of tax increment revenues from participating local agencies. Property tax revenues then flow back to each local agency that receives a share of the property tax.
Citing a significant State General Fund deficit, Governor Brown’s 2011-12 budget proposed eliminating RDAs and returning billions of dollars of property tax revenues to schools, cities, and counties to fund core services. Among the statutory changes that the Legislature adopted to implement the 2011-12 budget, AB X1 26 (Blumenfield, 2011) dissolved all RDAs. The California Supreme Court's 2011 ruling in California Redevelopment Association v. Matosantos upheld AB X1 26, but invalidated AB X1 27 (Blumenfield, 2011), which would have allowed most RDAs to avoid dissolution. In response, the California Redevelopment Association (CRA) challenged the two measures. The Supreme Court denied the petition for peremptory writ of mandate with respect to AB X1 26, but granted it with respect to ABX1 27. As a result, all RDAs dissolved as of February 1, 2012. At the time of dissolution, over 400 RDAs statewide were diverting 12% of property taxes, over $5.6 billion yearly.
RDAs’ dissolution deprived many local agencies of the primary tool they used to eliminate physical and economic blight, finance new construction, improve public infrastructure, rehabilitate existing buildings, and increase the supply of affordable housing. Until their dissolution, state law required RDAs to set-aside 20 percent of funding generated in a project area to increase the supply of low- and moderate-income housing. At the time RDAs were dissolved, the Controller estimated that statewide, RDAs were obligated to spend $1 billion on affordable housing.
Previous attempts to replace RDAs. After the Supreme Court’s 2011 Matosantos decision dissolved all RDAs, legislators enacted several measures creating new tax increment financing tools to pay for local economic development. In 2014, the Legislature authorized the creation of EIFDs (SB 628, Beall), quickly followed by Community Revitalization and Investment Authorities (CRIAs) in 2015 (AB 2, Alejo). Similar to EIFDs, CRIAs use tax increment financing to fund infrastructure projects, with two big differences: CRIAs may only be formed in economically depressed areas, but do not require voter approval. Two years ago, the Legislature authorized the formation of Affordable Housing Authorities (AHAs), which may use tax increment financing exclusively for rehabilitating and constructing affordable housing and also do not require voter approval to issue bonds (AB 1598, Mullin). Last year, SB 961 (Allen) removed the vote requirement for a subset of EIFDs to issue bonds and required these EIFDs to instead solicit public input. While these entities share fundamental similarities with RDAs in terms of using various forms of tax-increment financing, they differ in one important aspect: they not having access to the school’s share of property tax revenue.
Educational revenue augmentation funds. Proposition 13 gave the state authority to allocate the local property tax among local agencies, schools, and community college districts. Each year, the state estimates how much each district will receive in local property tax revenue (and student fee revenue in the case of community colleges). Then, the annual Budget Act appropriates state General Fund to “make up the difference” and fund the district’s revenue limit or apportionment at the intended level. Frequently, however, the actual property tax revenues allocated to school districts may be less than the state and local agencies anticipate. The state’s education finance system addresses these shortfalls differently for different types of educational entities. For K-12 districts that require additional funding to meet the minimum guaranteed level of funding, known as nonbasic aid school districts, all funding shortfalls are backfilled automatically with additional state aid. In contrast, basic aid districts do not require state aid to meet the minimum guaranteed level of funding because local property tax revenue is sufficient. Explicit state action is required to backfill community college funding shortfalls.
In 1992-93 and 1993-94, in response to serious budgetary shortfalls, the state permanently redirected almost one-fifth of total statewide property tax revenue from cities, counties, and special districts to K-12 and community college districts. Under the changes in property tax allocation laws, county auditors deposit the redirected property tax revenue into a countywide fund for schools, also known as a county’s Educational Revenue Augmentation Fund (ERAF). In 2017-18, cities, counties, and special districts deposited around $9.6 billion into county ERAFs. Since Proposition 98 obligates the state to ensure that all school districts receive a minimum guaranteed level of funding, the contributions to ERAF reduce the state’s funding obligations for K-14 education. Before counties distribute property tax revenue from ERAF to nonbasic aid schools and community colleges, the county diverts some ERAF back to local agencies to account for two other funding formulas, (1) excess ERAF and (2) the Vehicle License Fee (VLF) swap.
Excess ERAF. In the late 1990s, some county auditors reported that their ERAF accounts had more revenue than necessary to offset all state aid to nonbasic aid K-12 and community college districts. In response, the Legislature required that some of these surplus funds instead be used for countywide special education programs, and any remaining funds be returned to cities, counties, and special districts in proportion to the amount of property taxes they contributed to ERAF. The ERAF funds returned to noneducational local agencies are known as “excess ERAF.” In 2017-18, nearly $600 million was returned to local agencies in the form of excess ERAF.
VLF Swap. Californians pay a fee to operate motor vehicles, also known as the VLF. Revenues serve various purposes including funding local agencies’ core services. In the early 2000s, the state reduced the VLF and, as a result, local agencies lost revenue. The state backfilled this lost revenue from the General Fund. The VLF swap was a negotiated agreement between the state, cities, and counties to replace a state-controlled reimbursement subject to annual appropriation with a locally administered revenue source resulting in a more reliable fund source for these local agencies. Specifically, the VLF swap replaced the General Fund VLF backfill with property taxes redirected at the county level from (1) ERAF and, if ERAF revenues are not sufficient, from (2) nonbasic aid K-12 and community college districts, with all reductions in revenue to K-12 and community college districts offset by additional state aid. The VLF swap shifts billions of dollars annually from ERAF to non-school local agencies.
California’s housing crisis. California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis. California is home to 21 of the 30 most expensive rental housing markets in the country, which has had a disproportionate impact on the middle class and the working poor. Housing units affordable to low-income earners, if available, are often in serious states of disrepair. The Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) estimates that approximately 2.7 million lower-income households are rent-burdened (meaning they spend at least 30 percent of their income on rent), 1.7 million of which are severely rent-burdened (spending at least 50 percent of their income on rent). According to a 2015 study by the California Housing Partnership Corporation, California has a shortfall of 1.5 million affordable homes and 13 of the 14 least affordable metropolitan areas in the country.
A major factor in this crisis is the state’s housing shortage. From 1954-1989, California constructed an average of more than 200,000 new homes annually, with multifamily housing accounting for the largest share of housing production. Since then, however, construction has dropped significantly. HCD estimates that approximately 1.8 million new housing units—180,000 new homes per year—are needed to meet the state’s projected population and housing growth by 2025. Even when housing production rose in the mid-2000’s, it never reached the 180,000 mark, and over the last 10 years construction averaged just 80,000 new homes per year.
The Legislature has enacted numerous measures to facilitate affordable housing production and address the housing shortage. The housing package of 2017 made an effort to promote higher density housing, streamline housing approval processes, and increase zoning for housing while providing more state enforcement power. This package included SB 2 (Atkins), which required recorders to collect a $75 fee on every real estate instrument, paper, or notice. Once collected, these fees will fund various housing programs. The package also included SB 3 (Beall), which placed a $3 billion bond before voters on the November 2018 ballot, which voters approved, to fund affordable housing programs. Legislation in 2018 sought to further increase housing production by reforming the Regional Housing Needs Assessment process.
The author wants to dedicate ongoing revenues, by allowing local agencies to pay less into ERAF, for affordable housing, increasing job availability through building related infrastructure, revitalizing neighborhoods, and building public safety facilities.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 15 establishes an application process, eligible uses for the funds made available by the bill, and a process for distributing funds.
Application process. SB 15 allows a city or county, or a joint powers authority (JPA) that comprise the city and county to submit a request to the Department of Finance (DOF) to receive a portion of the county’s ERAF for the projects that meet the categories outlined below. Once DOF receives the application, it can approve, deny, or modify an application.
Funding purposes. Eligible uses of SB 15 funds are:
- To increase the availability of affordable housing, meaning the predevelopment, development, acquisition, rehabilitation and preservation of units affordable to households making 120% of area median income.
- To increase the availability of high-quality jobs though the rehabilitation, construction, and maintenance of housing infrastructure.
- To promote strong neighborhoods by supporting local community planning and engagement efforts to revitalize and restore neighborhoods, including by repairing parks, and aging infrastructure.
- To build public safety facilities, which do not include correctional facilities.
At least 20 percent of funds must go to counties with under 200,000 residents.
Funding mechanics. SB 15 allows DOF to approve $200 million in projects in the first year, increasing in $200 million increments each year until reaching $1 billion after five years. When DOF approves a project, it directs the county auditor to reduce the amount of property tax revenue the applicant would otherwise have contributed to the county’s ERAF. The bill specifies that these reductions can only come from ERAF amounts that were going to be used for K-12 schools, which ensures that the General Fund backfills the lower property tax revenue to schools. Projects approved in a plan must not request funding for more than 10 years.
The measure defines its terms and includes various findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Redevelopment’s dissolution deprived many local agencies of the primary tool they used to eliminate physical and economic blight, finance new construction, improve public infrastructure, rehabilitate existing buildings, and increase the supply of affordable housing. California has consistently failed in meeting the state’s housing needs, especially in dealing with low-income affordable housing. California is in the midst of a serious housing crisis. California is home to many of the most expensive rental-housing markets in the country which has had a disproportionate impact on the middle class and the working poor. A major factor in this crisis is the state’s housing shortage. From 1954-1989, California constructed an average of more than 200,000 new homes annually. Since then, however, construction has dropped significantly. HCD estimates that approximately 1.8 million new housing units—180,000 new homes per year—are needed to meet the state’s projected population and housing growth by 2025. Due in part to this housing shortage, California has one of the highest supplemental poverty measures in the nation. Data from the U.S. Census Bureau shows approximately 19% of Californians, roughly 7.5 million people, live in poverty, placing California in the top three highest supplemental poverty rates in the nation along with Florida and Louisiana. Despite a strong economy, The California Budget and Policy Center has reported that median household rents in California have risen 13.2 percent from 2006 to 2016, while median annual earnings for full-time workers grew by only 4.1 percent during that period. California must strive to increase the supply of affordable housing or we will continue to struggle to bring millions out of poverty.”
2. What are we getting for our money? By reducing the amount of local property tax revenue going to schools, SB 15 indirectly requires the General Fund to backfill any reductions to nonbasic aid schools. While these backfills ensure that schools receive the same level of revenue as they would have in absence of the bill, like any General Fund expenditure, SB 15 results in less General Fund revenue available to support other programs and services. This reduction in revenue may be warranted: affordable housing remains such a high priority for the state, and SB 15 allows these funds to be spent on housing. However, it does not require any funds to be spent on housing. The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to require at least 50 percent of overall funding to go to affordable housing to ensure a majority are used for one of the state’s highest priorities.
3. Schools impact. SB 15 states that any property tax revenue that would have otherwise been allocated to schools has to be backfilled by the General Fund. While the bill intends to hold schools harmless, it does not outline any particular mechanism to make schools whole. Given the additional pressure on the General Fund explained above, the state would have fewer resources to address fiscal emergencies, and therefore be more likely to suspend the Proposition 98 guarantee. On the other hand, all General Fund expenditures require balancing current needs with future fiscal pressures. While the amount of General Fund dedicated on this program could put additional pressure on the state budget and schools, the committee may wish to consider whether SB 15’s potential impacts on school finance are worth its benefits for affordable housing.
4. Something for nothing. Article XIII A of the California Constitution generally prohibits the state from requiring local agencies to spend local property tax revenue in a particular manner. SB 15 requires local agencies who apply to spend the additional local property tax revenue they otherwise would not receive in accordance with the provisions of the bill, but a court could consider these conditional applications to be in violation of limits on the state’s ability to direct the use of property tax revenue. While the Legislature could decide to suspend future ERAF reductions from being distributed without any constraints on their use, it is unclear whether funds already made available to local agencies would have to be repaid.
5. Insufficient ERAF. ERAF is a complicated funding source used to fund not only schools, but also fund excess ERAF contributions and the VLF swap. Local agencies rely on these shifts to fund core services. If ERAF is not sufficient to fund all of these obligations, a county can become an “insufficient ERAF” county. If this occurs, the state has to first redirect nonbasic aid schools’ property tax revenue, which is then backfilled by the General Fund. It is possible that SB 15 will result in the amount of money in a given county’s ERAF to be reduced to zero, making it impossible to award reductions in ERAF in some years. Specifically, if increases in property tax revenues outpace the growth in other state revenues, more schools could become basic aid districts, reducing the amount that local agencies contribute to ERAF in the first place. While estimates indicate that as much as $10 billion may be available in ERAF funds before insufficient ERAF is reached statewide, SB 15’s funding mechanism may fail in certain counties in some years.
6. Another way? This bill seeks to use ERAF funding and leverage the constitutional guarantee for education funding to provide funding for affordable housing and related infrastructure. While this is a creative way to fund these programs, it is unclear how successful local agencies will be using this revenue source. SB 15’s funding mechanism is relatively untested: a somewhat similar mechanism has only been used in San Francisco for a relatively small dollar amount. Every year, the Legislature funds affordable housing and infrastructure in many ways, often in the form of one-time funding in the annual budget. Affordable housing and related infrastructure projects could be financed through existing programs or a more direct grant program. However, given the volatility of state revenues, creating such a program may not be sufficiently stable to finance longer-term projects.
7. Connecting the dots. SB 15 outlines a process for local agencies to finance various projects, but does not include each and every detail necessary to make this mechanism work efficiently. For example, SB 15 does not specify the information local agencies need to include when DOF considers their application. In addition, SB 15 does not provide much guidance as to how projects are evaluated, and whether certain priorities, such as the number of affordable housing units proposed for construction, will make some projects more competitive than others. The Committee may wish to consider whether SB 15 provides enough detail regarding how this program would work.
8. Mandate. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies for the costs of new or expanded state mandated local programs. Because SB 15 requires local agencies to perform various activities related to operating this program, Legislative Counsel says that it imposes a new state mandate. The measure states that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill imposes a reimbursable mandate, reimbursement must be made pursuant to existing statutory provisions.
9. Double-referred. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double-referral of SB 15—first to the Senate Governance & Finance Committee, which has jurisdiction over bills relating to local government finance issues, and then to the Senate Housing Committee, which has jurisdiction over bills relating to housing policy.
10. Related legislation. Various attempts have been made over the years to bring back RDAs. This year, SB 5 (Beall) allows local agencies to reduce contributions of local property tax revenue to schools to build affordable housing and related infrastructure. The State General Fund would backfill these reductions. Also, AB 11 (Chiu) would create Affordable Housing and Infrastructure Agencies and allow local agencies to freeze property tax revenue in an area and allocate any additional property tax revenue to the agency for various uses and set aside funds for affordable housing.
Support and Opposition
(4/5/19)
Support: Unknown.
Opposition: California Special Districts Association; California State Association of Counties; California Teachers Association; County of Santa Clara; Urban Counties of California.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):