SB 163: Health care coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-13
Existing law, the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, requires the State Department of Developmental Services to contract with regional centers to provide services and supports to individuals with developmental disabilities and their families. Existing law defines developmental disability for these purposes to include, among other things, autism.
Existing law, the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975, provides for the licensure and regulation of health care service plans by the Department of Managed Health Care and makes a willful violation of the act a crime. Existing law also provides for the regulation of health insurers by the Department of Insurance. Existing law requires a health care service plan contract or a health insurance policy to provide coverage for behavioral health treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, and defines behavioral health treatment to mean specified services and treatment programs, including treatment provided pursuant to a treatment plan that is prescribed by a qualified autism service provider and administered either by a qualified autism service provider or by a qualified autism service professional or qualified autism service paraprofessional who is supervised as specified. Existing law defines a qualified autism service provider to refer to a person who is certified or licensed and a qualified autism service professional to refer to a person who meets specified educational, training, and other requirements and is supervised and employed by a qualified autism service provider. Existing law defines a qualified autism service paraprofessional to mean an unlicensed and uncertified individual who meets specified educational, training, and other criteria, is supervised by a qualified autism service provider or a qualified autism service professional, and is employed by the qualified autism service provider. Existing law also requires a qualified autism service provider to design, in connection with the treatment plan, an intervention plan that describes, among other information, the parent participation needed to achieve the plans goals and objectives, as specified. Under existing law, these coverage requirements provide an exception for specialized health care service plans or health insurance policies that do not cover mental health or behavioral health services, accident only, specified disease, hospital indemnity, or Medicare supplement health insurance policies, and health care service plans and health insurance policies in the Medi-Cal program.
Existing federal law, the federal Paul Wellstone and Pete Domenici Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008 (MHPAEA), requires group health plans and health insurance issuers that provide both medical and surgical benefits and mental health or substance use disorder benefits to ensure that financial requirements and treatment limitations applicable to mental health or substance use disorder benefits are no more restrictive than the predominant requirements or limitations applied to substantially all medical and surgical benefits. Existing state law subjects nongrandfathered individual and small group health care service plan contracts and health insurance policies that provide coverage for essential health benefits to those provisions of the MHPAEA.
This bill would revise the definition of behavioral health treatment to require the services and treatment programs provided to be based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models. The bill would remove the exception for health care service plans and health insurance policies in the Medi-Cal program, consistent with the MHPAEA.
This bill also would expand the definition of a qualified autism service professional to include behavioral service providers who meet specified educational and professional or work experience qualifications. The bill would revise the definition of a qualified autism service paraprofessional by deleting the reference to an unlicensed and uncertified individual and by requiring the individual to comply with revised educational and training, or professional, requirements. The bill would also revise the definitions of both a qualified autism service professional and a qualified autism service paraprofessional to include the requirement that these individuals complete a background check.
This bill would require the intervention plan designed by the qualified autism service provider to include parent or caregiver participation, when clinically appropriate, that is individualized to the patient and takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities, as specified. The bill would specify that the lack of parent or caregiver participation shall not be used to deny or reduce medically necessary services and that the setting, location, or time of treatment not be used as the only reason to deny medically necessary services. Because a willful violation of the bills provisions by a health care service plan would be a crime, it would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
This act shall be known, and may be cited, as Lucas Law.
SEC. 2.Section 1374.73 of the Health and Safety Code, as amended by Section 1 of Chapter 385 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:1374.73.(a)(1)Every health care service plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage shall also provide coverage for behavioral health treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism no later than July 1, 2012. The coverage shall be provided in the same manner and shall be subject to the same requirements as provided in Section 1374.72.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), as of the date that proposed final rulemaking for essential health benefits is issued, this section does not require any benefits to be provided that exceed the essential health benefits that all health plans will be required by federal regulations to provide under Section 1302(b) of the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Public Law 111-148), as amended by the federal Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (Public Law 111-152).
(3)This section shall not affect services for which an individual is eligible pursuant to Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500) of the Welfare and Institutions Code or Title 14 (commencing with Section 95000) of the Government Code.
(4)This section shall not affect or reduce any obligation to provide services under an individualized education program, as defined in Section 56032 of the Education Code, or an individual service plan, as described in Section 5600.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 et seq.) and its implementing regulations.
(b)Every health care service plan subject to this section shall maintain an adequate network that includes qualified autism service providers who supervise or employ qualified autism service professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer behavioral health treatment. A health care service plan is not prevented from selectively contracting with providers within these requirements.
(c)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Behavioral health treatment means professional services and treatment programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models, including applied behavior analysis and other evidence-based behavior intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism and that meet all of the following criteria:
(A)The treatment is prescribed by a physician and surgeon licensed pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 2000) of, or is developed by a psychologist licensed pursuant to Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 2900) of, Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code.
(B)The treatment is provided under a treatment plan prescribed by a qualified autism service provider and is administered by one of the following:
(i)A qualified autism service provider.
(ii)A qualified autism service professional supervised by the qualified autism service provider.
(iii)A qualified autism service paraprofessional supervised by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional.
(C)The treatment plan has measurable goals over a specific timeline that is developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider for the specific patient being treated. The treatment plan shall be reviewed no less than once every six months by the qualified autism service provider and modified whenever appropriate, and shall be consistent with Section 4686.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code pursuant to which the qualified autism service provider does all of the following:
(i)Describes the patients behavioral health impairments or developmental challenges that are to be treated.
(ii)Designs an intervention plan that includes the service type, number of hours, and parent participation, when clinically appropriate, needed to achieve the plans goals and objectives, and the frequency at which the patients progress is evaluated and reported. When clinically appropriate, the plan shall include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. This clause does not limit the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patients therapy.
(iii)Provides intervention plans that utilize evidence-based practices, with demonstrated clinical efficacy in treating pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
(iv)Discontinues intensive behavioral intervention services when the treatment goals and objectives are achieved or no longer appropriate.
(D)The treatment plan is not used for purposes of providing or for the reimbursement of respite, daycare, or educational services and is not used to reimburse a parent for participating in the treatment program. The treatment plan shall be made available to the health care service plan upon request.
(2)Pervasive developmental disorder or autism shall have the same meaning and interpretation as used in Section 1374.72.
(3)Qualified autism service provider means either of the following:
(A)A person who is certified by a national entity, such as the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, with a certification that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute, and who designs, supervises, or provides treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, provided the services are within the experience and competence of the person who is nationally certified.
(B)A person licensed as a physician and surgeon, physical therapist, occupational therapist, psychologist, marriage and family therapist, educational psychologist, clinical social worker, professional clinical counselor, speech-language pathologist, or audiologist pursuant to Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code, who designs, supervises, or provides treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, provided the services are within the experience and competence of the licensee.
(4)Qualified autism service professional means an individual who meets all of the following criteria:
(A)Provides behavioral health treatment, which may include clinical case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a qualified autism service provider. The services shall be consistent with the experience, training, or education of the professional.
(B)Is supervised by a qualified autism service provider.
(C)Provides treatment pursuant to a treatment plan developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider.
(D)Is a behavioral service provider who meets one of the following criteria:
(i)Meets the education and experience qualifications described in Section 54342 of Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations for an associate behavior analyst, behavior analyst, behavior management assistant, behavior management consultant, or behavior management program.
(ii)Possesses a bachelor of arts or science degree and meets one of the following qualifications:
(I)One year of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment supervised by a qualified autism service provider and 12 semester units from an accredited institution of higher learning in either applied behavioral analysis or clinical coursework in behavioral health.
(II)Two years of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment supervised by a qualified autism service provider.
(III)The person is a registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist pursuant to Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 2900) of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(IV)The person is an associate clinical social worker registered with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4996.18 of the Business and Professions Code. An associate clinical social worker may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the associate clinical social worker has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. An associate clinical social worker in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(V)The person is a registered associate marriage and family therapist with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4980.44 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered associate marriage and family therapist may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered associate marriage and family therapist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered associate marriage and family therapist in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(VI)The person is a registered associate professional clinical counselor with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4999.42 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered associate professional clinical counselor may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered associate professional clinical counselor has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered associate professional clinical counselor in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(VII)The person is credentialed or certified by a national entity, including, but not limited to, the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, which is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute to provide applied behavior analysis or behavioral health treatment, which may include case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a qualified autism service provider.
(E)Has training and experience in providing services for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
(F)Is employed by the qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers responsible for the autism treatment plan.
(G)Has completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice, with subsequent notification to the persons employer pursuant to Section 11105.2 of the Penal Code.
(5)Qualified autism service paraprofessional means an individual who meets all of the following criteria:
(A)Is supervised by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional at a level of clinical supervision that meets professionally recognized standards of practice.
(B)Provides treatment and implements services pursuant to a treatment plan developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider.
(C)Meets one of the following:
(i)For applied behavioral analysis, the education and training qualifications described in Section 54342 of Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations.
(ii)For other evidence-based behavioral health treatments, all of the following qualifications:
(I)Possesses an associates degree or has completed two years of study from an accredited college or university with coursework in a related field of study.
(II)Has 40 hours of training in the specific form of behavioral health treatment developed by a qualified autism service provider and administered by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional competent in the form of behavioral health treatment to be practiced by the paraprofessional.
(III)Has adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a qualified autism service provider.
(iii)Is credentialed or certified in applied behavior analysis or behavioral health treatment for paraprofessionals or technicians by a national entity that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute.
However, upon successful completion of the training and education necessary for certification or a credential described in this clause, if the applicant is otherwise qualified under this section, the applicant may provide treatment and implement services for up to 180 days while in the process of obtaining the certification or credential.
(D)Has adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers.
(E)Is employed by the qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers responsible for the autism treatment plan.
(F)Has completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice with subsequent notification to the persons employer pursuant to Section 11105.2 of the Penal Code.
(d)This section shall not apply to a specialized health care service plan that does not deliver mental health or behavioral health services to enrollees.
(e)This section does not limit the obligation to provide services under Section 1374.72.
(f)As provided in Section 1374.72 and in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), in the provision of benefits required by this section, a health care service plan may utilize case management, network providers, utilization review techniques, prior authorization, copayments, or other cost sharing.
(g)(1)The setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the qualified autism service provider shall not be used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. The setting shall be consistent with the standard of care for behavioral health treatment. This subdivision does not require a health care service plan to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollees individualized educational program for the purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. This subdivision does not require a health care service plan to cover services rendered outside of the plans service area unless the services are urgently needed services, as described in subdivision (h) of Section 1345, or emergency services, as defined in Section 1317.1, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
(2)Parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged. However, the lack of parent or caregiver participation shall not be used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
SEC. 3.Section 10144.51 of the Insurance Code, as amended by Section 2 of Chapter 385 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:10144.51.(a)(1)Every health insurance policy shall also provide coverage for behavioral health treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism no later than July 1, 2012. The coverage shall be provided in the same manner and shall be subject to the same requirements as provided in Section 10144.5.
(2)Notwithstanding paragraph (1), as of the date that proposed final rulemaking for essential health benefits is issued, this section does not require any benefits to be provided that exceed the essential health benefits that all health insurers will be required by federal regulations to provide under Section 1302(b) of the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (Public Law 111-148), as amended by the federal Health Care and Education Reconciliation Act of 2010 (Public Law 111-152).
(3)This section shall not affect services for which an individual is eligible pursuant to Division 4.5 (commencing with Section 4500) of the Welfare and Institutions Code or Title 14 (commencing with Section 95000) of the Government Code.
(4)This section shall not affect or reduce any obligation to provide services under an individualized education program, as defined in Section 56032 of the Education Code, or an individual service plan, as described in Section 5600.4 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, or under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400 et seq.) and its implementing regulations.
(b)Pursuant to Article 6 (commencing with Section 2240) of Subchapter 2 of Chapter 5 of Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations, every health insurer subject to this section shall maintain an adequate network that includes qualified autism service providers who supervise or employ qualified autism service professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer behavioral health treatment. A health insurer is not prevented from selectively contracting with providers within these requirements.
(c)For the purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Behavioral health treatment means professional services and treatment programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models, including applied behavior analysis and other evidence-based behavior intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism, and that meet all of the following criteria:
(A)The treatment is prescribed by a physician and surgeon licensed pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 2000) of, or is developed by a psychologist licensed pursuant to Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 2900) of, Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code.
(B)The treatment is provided under a treatment plan prescribed by a qualified autism service provider and is administered by one of the following:
(i)A qualified autism service provider.
(ii)A qualified autism service professional supervised by the qualified autism service provider.
(iii)A qualified autism service paraprofessional supervised by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional.
(C)The treatment plan has measurable goals over a specific timeline that is developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider for the specific patient being treated. The treatment plan shall be reviewed no less than once every six months by the qualified autism service provider and modified whenever appropriate, and shall be consistent with Section 4686.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code pursuant to which the qualified autism service provider does all of the following:
(i)Describes the patients behavioral health impairments or developmental challenges that are to be treated.
(ii)Designs an intervention plan that includes the service type, number of hours, and parent participation, when clinically appropriate, needed to achieve the plans goals and objectives, and the frequency at which the patients progress is evaluated and reported. When clinically appropriate, the plan shall include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. This clause does not limit the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patients therapy.
(iii)Provides intervention plans that utilize evidence-based practices, with demonstrated clinical efficacy in treating pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
(iv)Discontinues intensive behavioral intervention services when the treatment goals and objectives are achieved or no longer appropriate.
(D)The treatment plan is not used for purposes of providing or for the reimbursement of respite, daycare, or educational services and is not used to reimburse a parent for participating in the treatment program. The treatment plan shall be made available to the insurer upon request.
(2)Pervasive developmental disorder or autism shall have the same meaning and interpretation as used in Section 10144.5.
(3)Qualified autism service provider means either of the following:
(A)A person who is certified by a national entity, such as the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, with a certification that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute, and who designs, supervises, or provides treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, provided the services are within the experience and competence of the person who is nationally certified.
(B)A person licensed as a physician and surgeon, physical therapist, occupational therapist, psychologist, marriage and family therapist, educational psychologist, clinical social worker, professional clinical counselor, speech-language pathologist, or audiologist pursuant to Division 2 (commencing with Section 500) of the Business and Professions Code, who designs, supervises, or provides treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, provided the services are within the experience and competence of the licensee.
(4)Qualified autism service professional means an individual who meets all of the following criteria:
(A)Provides behavioral health treatment, which may include clinical case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a qualified autism service provider. The services shall be consistent with the experience, training, or education of the professional.
(B)Is supervised by a qualified autism service provider.
(C)Provides treatment pursuant to a treatment plan developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider.
(D)Is a behavioral service provider who meets one of the following criteria:
(i)Meets the education and experience qualifications described in Section 54342 of Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations for an associate behavior analyst, behavior analyst, behavior management assistant, behavior management consultant, or behavior management program.
(ii)Possesses a bachelor of arts or science degree and meets one of the following qualifications:
(I)One year of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment supervised by a qualified autism service provider and 12 semester units from an accredited institution of higher learning in either applied behavioral analysis or clinical coursework in behavioral health.
(II)Two years of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment supervised by a qualified autism service provider.
(III)The person is a registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist pursuant to Chapter 6.6 (commencing with Section 2900) of Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(IV)The person is an associate clinical social worker registered with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4996.18 of the Business and Professions Code. An associate clinical social worker may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the associate clinical social worker has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. An associate clinical social worker in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(V)The person is a registered associate marriage and family therapist with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4980.44 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered associate marriage and family therapist may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered associate marriage and family therapist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered associate marriage and family therapist in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(VI)The person is a registered associate professional clinical counselor with the Board of Behavioral Sciences pursuant to Section 4999.42 of the Business and Professions Code. A registered associate professional clinical counselor may not supervise a qualified autism service paraprofessional until the registered associate professional clinical counselor has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing behavioral health treatment. A registered associate professional clinical counselor in complying with this section shall conform to all of the requirements for their registration.
(VII)The person is credentialed or certified by a national entity, including, but not limited to, the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, which is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute to provide applied behavior analysis or behavioral health treatment, which may include case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a qualified autism service provider.
(E)Has training and experience in providing services for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
(F)Is employed by the qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers responsible for the autism treatment plan.
(G)Has completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice, with subsequent notification to the persons employer pursuant to Section 11105.2 of the Penal Code.
(5)Qualified autism service paraprofessional means an individual who meets all of the following criteria:
(A)Is supervised by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional at a level of clinical supervision that meets professionally recognized standards of practice.
(B)Provides treatment and implements services pursuant to a treatment plan developed and approved by the qualified autism service provider.
(C)Meets one of the following:
(i)For applied behavioral analysis, the education and training qualifications described in Section 54342 of Title 17 of the California Code of Regulations.
(ii)For other evidence-based behavioral health treatments, all of the following qualifications:
(I)Possesses an associates degree or has completed two years of study from an accredited college or university with coursework in a related field of study.
(II)Has 40 hours of training in the specific form of behavioral health treatment developed by a qualified autism service provider and administered by a qualified autism service provider or qualified autism service professional competent in the form of behavioral health treatment to be practiced by the paraprofessional.
(III)Has adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a qualified autism service provider.
(iii)Is credentialed or certified in applied behavior analysis or behavioral health treatment for paraprofessionals or technicians by a national entity that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute.
However, upon successful completion of the training and education necessary for certification or a credential described in this clause, if the applicant is otherwise qualified under this section, the applicant may provide treatment and implement services for up to 180 days while in the process of obtaining the certification or credential.
(D)Has adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers.
(E)Is employed by the qualified autism service provider or an entity or group that employs qualified autism service providers responsible for the autism treatment plan.
(F)Has completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice, with subsequent notification to the persons employer pursuant to Section 11105.2 of the Penal Code.
(d)This section shall not apply to a specialized health insurance policy that does not cover mental health or behavioral health services or an accident only, specified disease, hospital indemnity, or Medicare supplement policy.
(e)This section does not limit the obligation to provide services under Section 10144.5.
(f)As provided in Section 10144.5 and in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), in the provision of benefits required by this section, a health insurer may utilize case management, network providers, utilization review techniques, prior authorization, copayments, or other cost sharing.
(g)(1)The setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the qualified autism service provider shall not be used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. The setting shall be consistent with the standard of care for behavioral health treatment. This subdivision does not require a health insurer to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollees individualized educational program for the purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. This subdivision does not require a health insurer to cover services rendered outside of the health insurers service area unless the services are urgently needed services to prevent serious deterioration of a covered persons health resulting from unforeseen illness or injury for which treatment cannot be delayed until the covered person returns to the insurers service area, or emergency services, as defined in Section 1317.1 of the Health and Safety Code, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
(2)Parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged. However, the lack of parent or caregiver participation shall not be used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 13, 2020 | Stricken from file. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | In Senate. Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Vetoed by the Governor. |
| Sep 18, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 14. Noes 3.) (August 30). |
| Aug 21, 2019 | August 21 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| Jun 11, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 32. Noes 1.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2019 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (April 22). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HUMAN S. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on HUMAN S. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 3). |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | April 10 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and HUMAN S. |
| Jan 25, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 24. |
| Jan 24, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB163 Portantino et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2019 | SB 163 Portantino Senate Third Reading By Nazarian | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB163 Portantino | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Human Services] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 163 |
VETO
Bill No: SB 163
Author: Portantino (D), et al.
Amended: 9/5/19
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/3/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/22/19
AYES: Hurtado, Stone, Beall, Jackson, Pan, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 32-1, 5/22/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Moorlach
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0, 9/11/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-4, 9/9/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Health care coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
SOURCE: DIR/Floortime Coalition of California
DIGEST:
This bill revises and expands the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT) and expands the provider qualifications to include more provider types that can provide BHT under the mandate that health plans and insurers cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. This bill prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by a qualified autism services (QAS) provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. This bill requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Services Plan Act of 1975; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health and other insurers;; and, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to administer the Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1340, et seq., INS §106, et seq., and WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Requires every health plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage and health insurance policy to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. Requires the coverage to be provided in the same manner and to be subject to the same requirements as provided in California’s mental health parity law. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Defines BHT for purposes of 2) above as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavior analysis (ABA) and evidence-based intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism and that meet specified criteria regarding the treatment plan, the professionals who can prescribe and supervise treatment, and administer a treatment plan. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires every health plan or health insurer subject to 2) and 3) above to maintain an adequate network that includes QAS providers who supervise or employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires, only to the extent required by the federal government and effective no sooner than required by the federal government, BHT to be a covered Medi-Cal service for individuals under 21 years of age. [WIC §14132.56]
This bill:
- Revises and expands the definition of “BHT”, to include:
- Programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based (rather than behavior-based), and other evidence-based models; and,
- Requires the intervention plan to include parent or caregiver participation, when clinically appropriate, that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. Clarifies that this does not limit the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patient’s therapy.
- Revises the definition of “QAS provider” to include a person who is certified by the American National Standards Institute.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS professional” to add a registered psychological assistant, registered psychologist, association clinical social worker, registered associate marriage and family therapist, registered association professional clinical counselor and requires these registered individuals to conform to all of the requirements for their registration, and requires a completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice (DOJ), with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS paraprofessional” to delete that the individual can be unlicensed or uncertified, and, makes other changes including a completed background check performed by a DOJ approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Deletes an exemption for a health plan contract or health insurance policy in the Medi-Cal program from the requirement for health plans to cover BHT.
- Prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized educational program for purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s service area unless the services are urgently needed services, as defined, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
- States that parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged, but prohibits the lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services
Comments
According to the author, too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to ensure that Californians with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments. The choice of treatment should be left up to the physician or psychologist in consultation with the patient and the patient’s family, not the insurance company or the state. This critical decision must be made by the clinician who knows the patient best. Evidence-based practice relies on the best clinical judgement of the clinician which cannot occur with only one choice of treatment. Children with ASD are a vulnerable population and deserve our protection. Paraprofessionals who serve this population need to be adequately educated and trained and have undergone a thorough background check before entering a child’s home.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor one-time costs to the CDI (Insurance Fund). Costs to DMHC of $725,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $750,000 in 2020-21 and $800,000 to $850,000 annually thereafter (Managed Care Fund). Premium costs to CalPERS of about $85,000 per year (General Fund (GF)/ special/ federal/ local) and $3 million in private-sector costs. Medi-Cal costs will increase by approximately $800,000 (GF/federal). If this assumption is incorrect and this bill leads to an overall increase in utilization, costs could be significant. Market-rate costs per beneficiary of BHT services are estimated to be over $9,000 per year. Costs for the DOJ to process criminal background checks for QAS and QAS paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account).
DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (source)
Board of Behavioral Sciences
California Psychological Association
Cherry Crisp Entertainment and Productions
Child Development Institute
Descanso Medical Center for Development & Learning
Foothill Autism Alliance
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Newton Center for Affect Regulation
Professional Child Development Associates
The Arc California
The Frostig Center
United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Verdugo Hills Autism Project
Over 150 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 10/21/19)
America’s Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
California Association for Behavior Analysis
California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber of Commerce
California Consortium for Behavior Analysis
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (Coalition), this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code (Registered Psychological Assistant, Associate Clinical Social Worker, Associate Marriage and Family Therapist, and Associate Professional Clinical Counselor) to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based BHT under strict supervision. Many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. Paraprofessionals currently under Title 17 regulations must possess a minimum of a high school equivalency and 30 hours of ABA training. In order to foster greater consumer protection of a vulnerable population, this bill increases these requirements for BHT other than ABA by imposing a minimum standard of an Associate Degree or its equivalent and 40 hours of training developed and administered by a QAS Provider. Additionally, the Coalition indicates that parents across the state are also being denied coverage for BHT based on their particular circumstances, circumstances beyond their control. The strain of raising a child on the Spectrum often tears marriages apart. Single parent households are all too common. Yet insurance companies deny coverage if working single parents who cannot attend all therapy sessions do not fully participate in their child’s treatment.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Association of Health Plans (CAHP), this bill significantly expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services be provided at “any time or location,” and “ignores current medical literature’s recommendations and best practices” by creating a new definition for evidenced-based care. Health plans currently cover evidenced based autism services to enrollees that require care. Health plans are also required to meet network adequacy and time and distance standards that are enforced by DMHC. CHBRP estimates that this bill will increase costs by $4,317,000. For autism services, ABA is an evidenced treatment. Expanding health plans services to incorporate the patient or caregivers’ preferences into treatment determinations is counter-intuitive of evidenced-based practice principles. Modifications to the provider requirements in the bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. Maintaining affordable premiums is critical as policymakers strive to decrease the number of uninsured Californians. This is not the time for new benefit mandates that drive up the cost of care. The California Chamber of Commerce believes it is appropriate for issuers to make coverage for ABA contingent upon caregiver participation since research on the effectiveness of ABA shows unequivocally that it is critical to the success of the treatment. With the significant cost pressures already facing California businesses, the uncertainty in health care policy at the federal level, as well as the 2019 premium increase in excess of 8% and the cumulative increase of over 42% over the last five years, California should not increase costs of health care coverage for employers and enrollees.
GOVERNOR'S VETO MESSAGE:
I am returning Senate Bill 163 without my signature.
This bill seeks to change the qualification standards necessary to be a qualified autism service professional or paraprofessional. When the Legislature enacted SB 946 (Steinberg, Chapter 650, Statutes of 2011), it clearly anticipated subsequent action to develop a comprehensive structure to license providers of behavioral health treatment to individuals with autism spectrum disorder. A formal licensing scheme that includes clinical expertise and administrative oversight is a more appropriate venue to address qualification standards for practitioners, ensure quality of care, and provide effective consumer protection. I encourage the Legislature to complete the work begun by SB 946.
In addition, by removing the health plan coverage exemption for contracts in the Medi-Cal program, this bill inadvertently creates conflicting requirements within the Medi-Cal program that could result in unintentional delays in access to care and jeopardizes continued receipt of federal financial participation for behavioral health treatment.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-4, 9/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Cunningham, Obernolte
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Choi, Flora, Fong, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes, Patterson, Voepel
Prepared by: Teri Boughton / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
11/4/19 10:58:44
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 163 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 163
Author: Portantino (D), et al.
Amended: 9/5/19
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/3/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/22/19
AYES: Hurtado, Stone, Beall, Jackson, Pan, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 32-1, 5/22/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Morrell
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Moorlach
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-4, 9/9/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Healthcare coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
SOURCE: DIR/Floortime Coalition of California
DIGEST:
This bill revises and expands the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT) and expands the provider qualifications to include more provider types that can provide BHT under the mandate that health plans and insurers cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. This bill prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by a qualified autism services provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. This bill requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT.
Assembly Amendments
establish this bill as Luca’s law, require a registered psychological assistant, registered psychologist, association clinical social worker, registered associate marriage and family therapist, registered association professional clinical counselor to conform to all of the requirements for their registration, and specify parent participation included in the intervention plan is when clinically appropriate, and that the parent participation clause does not limit the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patient’s therapy
Existing law:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Services Plan Act of 1975; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health and other insurers;; and, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to administer the Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1340, et seq., INS §106, et seq., and WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Requires every health plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage and health insurance policy to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. Requires the coverage to be provided in the same manner and to be subject to the same requirements as provided in California’s mental health parity law. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Defines BHT for purposes of 2) above as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavior analysis (ABA) and evidence-based intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism and that meet specified criteria regarding the treatment plan, the professionals who can prescribe and supervise treatment, and administer a treatment plan. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires every health plan or health insurer subject to 2) and 3) above to maintain an adequate network that includes qualified autism services (QAS) providers who supervise or employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires, only to the extent required by the federal government and effective no sooner than required by the federal government, BHT to be a covered Medi-Cal service for individuals under 21 years of age. [WIC §14132.56]
This bill:
- Revises and expands the definition of “BHT”, to include:
- Programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based (rather than behavior-based), and other evidence-based models; and,
- Requires the intervention plan to include parent or caregiver participation, when clinically appropriate, that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. Clarifies that this does not limit the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patient’s therapy.
- Revises the definition of “QAS provider” to include a person who is certified by the American National Standards Institute.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS professional” to add a registered psychological assistant, registered psychologist, association clinical social worker, registered associate marriage and family therapist, registered association professional clinical counselor and requires these registered individuals to conform to all of the requirements for their registration, and requires a completed a background check performed by an agency approved by the Department of Justice (DOJ), with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS paraprofessional” to delete that the individual can be unlicensed or uncertified, and, makes other changes including a completed background check performed by a DOJ approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Deletes an exemption for a health plan contract or health insurance policy in the Medi-Cal program from the requirement for health plans to cover BHT.
- Prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized educational program for purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s service area unless the services are urgently needed services, as defined, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
- States that parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged, but prohibits the lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services
Comments
According to the author, too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to ensure that Californians with ASD will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments. The choice of treatment should be left up to the physician or psychologist in consultation with the patient and the patient’s family, not the insurance company or the state. This critical decision must be made by the clinician who knows the patient best. Evidence-based practice relies on the best clinical judgement of the clinician which cannot occur with only one choice of treatment. Children with ASD are a vulnerable population and deserve our protection. Paraprofessionals who serve this population need to be adequately educated and trained and have undergone a thorough background check before entering a child’s home.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor one-time costs to the CDI (Insurance Fund). Costs to DMHC of $725,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $750,000 in 2020-21 and $800,000 to $850,000 annually thereafter (Managed Care Fund). Premium costs to CalPERS of about $85,000 per year (General Fund (GF)/ special/ federal/ local) and $3 million in private-sector costs. Medi-Cal costs will increase by approximately $800,000 (GF/federal). If this assumption is incorrect and this bill leads to an overall increase in utilization, costs could be significant. Market-rate costs per beneficiary of BHT services are estimated to be over $9,000 per year. Costs for the DOJ to process criminal background checks for QAS and QAS paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account).
DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (source)
Board of Behavioral Sciences
California Psychological Association
Cherry Crisp Entertainment and Productions
Child Development Institute
Descanso Medical Center for Development & Learning
Foothill Autism Alliance
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Newton Center for Affect Regulation
Professional Child Development Associates
The Arc California
The Frostig Center
United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Verdugo Hills Autism Project
Over 150 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/19/19)
America’s Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
California Association for Behavior Analysis
California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber of Commerce
California Consortium for Behavior Analysis
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (Coalition), this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code (Registered Psychological Assistant, Associate Clinical Social Worker, Associate Marriage and Family Therapist, and Associate Professional Clinical Counselor) to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based BHT under strict supervision. Many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. Paraprofessionals currently under Title 17 regulations must possess a minimum of a high school equivalency and 30 hours of ABA training. In order to foster greater consumer protection of a vulnerable population, this bill increases these requirements for BHT other than ABA by imposing a minimum standard of an Associate Degree or its equivalent and 40 hours of training developed and administered by a QAS Provider. Additionally, the Coalition indicates that parents across the state are also being denied coverage for BHT based on their particular circumstances, circumstances beyond their control. The strain of raising a child on the Spectrum often tears marriages apart. Single parent households are all too common. Yet insurance companies deny coverage if working single parents who cannot attend all therapy sessions do not fully participate in their child’s treatment.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Association of Health Plans (CAHP), this bill significantly expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services be provided at “any time or location,” and “ignores current medical literature’s recommendations and best practices” by creating a new definition for evidenced-based care. Health plans currently cover evidenced based autism services to enrollees that require care. Health plans are also required to meet network adequacy and time and distance standards that are enforced by DMHC. CHBRP estimates that this bill will increase costs by $4,317,000. For autism services, ABA is an evidenced treatment. Expanding health plans services to incorporate the patient or caregivers’ preferences into treatment determinations is counter-intuitive of evidenced-based practice principles. Modifications to the provider requirements in the bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. Maintaining affordable premiums is critical as policymakers strive to decrease the number of uninsured Californians. This is not the time for new benefit mandates that drive up the cost of care. The California Chamber of Commerce believes it is appropriate for issuers to make coverage for ABA contingent upon caregiver participation since research on the effectiveness of ABA shows unequivocally that it is critical to the success of the treatment. With the significant cost pressures already facing California businesses, the uncertainty in health care policy at the federal level, as well as the 2019 premium increase in excess of 8% and the cumulative increase of over 42% over the last five years, California should not increase costs of health care coverage for employers and enrollees.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 66-4, 9/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Cunningham, Obernolte
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Choi, Flora, Fong, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes, Patterson, Voepel
Prepared by: Teri Boughton / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
9/9/19 22:52:02
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 163
Author:(Portantino)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes "Luca's Law" and revises existing requirements on health care service plans (health plans) and health insurers to cover behavioral health treatment (BHT) for pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) or autism. Expands the definition of BHT and allows the substitution of specified current education, work experience, and training qualifications to meet the criteria of a qualified autism service (QAS) professional or paraprofessional. Prohibits a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation, or on the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
Changes to Existing Law under this Bill:
- BHT. Existing law defines BHT as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavioral analysis (ABA) and evidence-based behavior intervention programs, which develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with a pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) or autism. This bill expands this definition to include programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models.
- Parent Participation. Existing law provides BHT coverage for an intervention plan that includes parent participation that is needed to achieve the plan's goals and objectives. This bill would prohibit a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation if a hardship exists. Additionally, under this bill, when clinically appropriate, a plan would be required to include parent participation that is individualized and takes into account the ability of the parent to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. This bill also clarifies the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patient's therapy.
- Setting, Location, or Time of treatment. Existing law is silent to the setting, location, or time of treatment associated with the coverage of BHT services. This bill prohibits health plans and health insurers from denying medically necessary coverage based solely on the setting, location or time of treatment.
QAS Professional and Paraprofessional Qualifications. Existing law requires a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional to meet specific education and training requirements as determined by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) to be a vendor of a regional center. AB 1074 (Maienschein), Chapter 385, Statutes of 2017, eliminated the requirement for QAS professionals to be regional center vendors. This bill would expand the definition of who could qualify as a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional by allowing an alternative pathway if specified education, work experience and training qualifications are met without meeting the education and training qualifications as determined by DDS.
According to the Author:
Too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Other obstacles to coverage include a shortage of covered professionals, denials based on a lack of parental participation or the setting in which the services are provided, and a lack of qualified paraprofessionals. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to insure that Californians with Autism Spectrum Disorder will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments.
Arguments in Support:
The DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (coalition) states that this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based behavioral health treatment under strict supervision. According to the coalition, many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. This bill requires the treatment plan to maximize the individual parent's ability to participate. It also requires the setting, time and location of treatment to be determined in advance by the QAS provider directing care. By doing so, the best interests of the child, the insurance company and the State are all protected.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the California Association of Health Plans and Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies (CAHP and ACLHIC), as currently drafted, this bill would place in statute an alternate set of standards for applied behavioral analysis (ABA) professionals that do not align with the qualifications required for ABA certification, which is specifically referenced in the governing statute. Modifications to the provider requirements in this bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. CAHP and ACLHIC also write that this bill expands California's existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services to be provided at any time or location, and ignores current medical literature's recommendations regarding parent participation. The California Chamber of Commerce state that this bill undermines the ability of health care issuers to promote and manage the use of ABA for children with autism, and will add to the problem of rising health care costs, making it harder for Californians to access other important care.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor one-time costs to the California Department of Insurance (CDI) (Insurance Fund). Costs to the Department of Managed Health Care of $725,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $750,000 in 2020-21 and $800,000 to $850,000 annually thereafter (Managed Care Fund). Premium costs to CalPERS of about $85,000 per year (General Fund (GF)/ special/ federal/ local) and $3 million in private-sector costs. Medi-Cal costs will increase by approximately $800,000 (GF/federal). If this assumption is incorrect and this bill leads to an overall increase in utilization, costs could be significant. Market-rate costs per beneficiary of BHT services are estimated to be over $9,000 per year. Costs for the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account).
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 32-1-5
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Moorlach
ASM HEALTH: 11-0-4
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Bonta, Burke, Carrillo, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mayes, Bigelow, Flora, Waldron
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-3-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0001918
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 163
Author:(Portantino)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes "Luca's Law" and revises existing requirements on health care service plans (health plans) and health insurers to cover behavioral health treatment (BHT) for pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) or autism. Expands the definition of BHT and allows the substitution of specified current education, work experience, and training qualifications to meet the criteria of a qualified autism service (QAS) professional or paraprofessional. Prohibits a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation, or on the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
Changes to Existing Law under this Bill:
- BHT. Existing law defines BHT as professional services and treatment programs, including ABA and evidence-based behavior intervention programs, which develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with PDD or autism. This bill expands this definition to include programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models.
- Parent Participation. Existing law provides BHT coverage for an intervention plan that includes parent participation that is needed to achieve the plan's goals and objectives. This bill would prohibit a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation if a hardship exists. Additionally, under this bill, when clinically appropriate, a plan would be required to include parent participation that is individualized and takes into account the ability of the parent to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities. This bill also clarifies the right of a parent or caregiver to participate in the patient's therapy.
- Setting, Location, or Time of treatment. Existing law is silent to the setting, location, or time of treatment associated with the coverage of BHT services. This bill prohibits health plans and health insurers from denying medically necessary coverage based solely on the setting, location or time of treatment.
- QAS Professional and Paraprofessional Qualifications. Existing law requires a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional to meet specific education and training requirements as determined by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) to be a vendor of a regional center. AB 1074 (Maienschein), Chapter 385, Statutes of 2017, eliminated the requirement for QAS professionals to be regional center vendors. This bill would expand the definition of who could qualify as a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional by allowing an alternative pathway if specified education, work experience and training qualifications are met without meeting the education and training qualifications as determined by DDS.
According to the Author:
Too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Other obstacles to coverage include a shortage of covered professionals, denials based on a lack of parental participation or the setting in which the services are provided, and a lack of qualified paraprofessionals. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to insure that Californians with Autism Spectrum Disorder will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments.
Arguments in Support:
The DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (coalition) states that this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based behavioral health treatment under strict supervision. According to the coalition, many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. This bill requires the treatment plan to maximize the individual parent's ability to participate. It also requires the setting, time and location of treatment to be determined in advance by the QAS provider directing care. By doing so, the best interests of the child, the insurance company and the State are all protected.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the California Association of Health Plans and Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies (CAHP and ACLHIC), as currently drafted, this bill would place in statute an alternate set of standards for applied behavioral analysis (ABA) professionals that do not align with the qualifications required for ABA certification, which is specifically referenced in the governing statute. Modifications to the provider requirements in this bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. CAHP and ACLHIC also write that this bill expands California's existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services to be provided at any time or location, and ignores current medical literature's recommendations regarding parent participation. The California Chamber of Commerce state that this bill undermines the ability of health care issuers to promote and manage the use of ABA for children with autism, and will add to the problem of rising health care costs, making it harder for Californians to access other important care.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor one-time costs to the California Department of Insurance (CDI) (Insurance Fund). Costs to the Department of Managed Health Care of $725,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $750,000 in 2020-21 and $800,000 to $850,000 annually thereafter (Managed Care Fund). Premium costs to CalPERS of about $85,000 per year (General Fund (GF)/ special/ federal/ local) and $3 million in private-sector costs. Medi-Cal costs will increase by approximately $800,000 (GF/federal). If this assumption is incorrect and this bill leads to an overall increase in utilization, costs could be significant. Market-rate costs per beneficiary of BHT services are estimated to be over $9,000 per year. Costs for the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account).
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 32-1-5
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Morrell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Grove, Jones, Moorlach
ASM HEALTH: 11-0-4
YES: Wood, Aguiar-Curry, Bonta, Burke, Carrillo, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago
ABS, ABST OR NV: Mayes, Bigelow, Flora, Waldron
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-3-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0001695
Date of Hearing: August 21, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 163
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends and broadens an existing mandate that requires health plans and insurers to cover medically necessary behavioral health treatment (BHT) services for pervasive developmental disorder or autism (autism). Specifically, this bill:
- Expands the definition of BHT to require coverage of treatment programs based on developmental, relationship-based or other evidence-based models that develop or restore the functioning of an individual with autism, as specified.
- Prohibits lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used to deny or reduce medically necessary BHT.
- Prohibits health plans or health insurers from denying medically necessary BHT on the basis of setting, location or time of treatment.
- Modifies standards that apply to qualified autism service (QAS) paraprofessionals, QAS professionals and QAS providers—generally by allowing a greater diversity of service providers—and requires QAS professionals and paraprofessionals to submit to a Department of Justice (DOJ) background check.
- States it does not require coverage for services that are included in a patient’s individualized education program (IEP; a plan that describes a child's special education needs and services) that are necessary to access an education unless otherwise required or permitted by state and federal law.
- Strikes an exemption for Medi-Cal managed care, thereby applying the BHT mandate and the changes made by the bill to Medi-Cal managed care. (Note: Medi-Cal currently covers BHT in spite of the exemption.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor one-time costs to the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to review new form filings for compliance with changes to the definitions and incorporate those changes into insurer examinations (Insurance Fund).
- Costs to the Department of Managed Health Care of $725,000 in fiscal year 2019-20, $750,000 in 2020-21 and $800,000 to $850,000 annually thereafter to respond to consumer complaints, review health plans submission documents, enforce the provisions of the bill, and conduct legal review (Managed Care Fund).
- According to the California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP):
- Annual premium costs to CalPERS of about $85,000 per year (GF/ special/ federal/ local). Cost savings are split approximately 50-50 between state and local government.
- Private-sector costs include the following:
- Annual employer-funded premium costs in the private insurance market of approximately $2.3 million.
- Increased premium expenditures by employees and individuals purchasing insurance of $380,000 and increased total out-of-pocket expenses of $400,000.
- Based on the expanded definition of allowable treatment modalities, potential but indeterminate increases to Medi-Cal for behavioral health treatment services provided through Medi-Cal managed care plans (GF/federal). CHBRP estimates, based on an increase in hours due to the removal of coverage restrictions based on time, setting, location and parental participation, Medi-Cal costs will increase by approximately $800,000 (GF/federal).
CHBRP also assumes the expansion of service modalities would not result in an overall increase in the utilization of BHT services, but that one type of intervention may substitute for another currently covered intervention. If this assumption is incorrect and this bill leads to an overall increase in utilization, costs could be significant. Market-rate costs per beneficiary of BHT services are estimated to be over $9,000 per year.
- Costs for the DOJ to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account). The current cost for a DOJ criminal background check is $32 (applicants usually must also pay a fee to the entity that takes the fingerprint and sends it to the Department). The total cost to the DOJ to process criminal background checks depends on the number of applying providers.
- Since the bill does not require plans to pay for services that are included in an IEP, it is unclear whether this bill will lead to plan-covered services displacing services that would otherwise be funded by the public school system. To the extent this occurs, however, there could be reduced Proposition 98/GF cost pressure for special education services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill would ensure that children diagnosed with autism can access additional models of medically necessary treatment to increase their quality of life and functional independence. In addition, increasing access by changing provisions that describe the terms of coverage.
- Background. The state's BHT mandate (SB 946 (Steinberg), Chapter 650, Statutes of 2011), imposes a set of rules regarding BHT that health plans and health insurers in California must cover for individuals with autism. This current law also identifies the required qualifications of individuals who provide BHT, and permits individuals who are not licensed by the state to provide BHT as long as the detailed criteria set forth in the bill are met.
- Models of BHT. According to CHBRP, BHT for autism is on a continuum. On one side of the continuum are modalities based on behavioral theory, like applied behavioral analysis (ABA); on the other side are modalities based on developmental theory, like Developmental, Individual Differences Relationship-based Mode (DIR®/Floortime). In the middle are modalities based on theory that is both behavioral and developmental, like naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions (NDBI).
ABA is the most rigorously studied intervention. Currently, all plans cover ABA, while other models may or may not be covered.
- Medical Effectiveness. According to CHBRP, there is evidence of effectiveness for BHT modalities based on behavioral theory, based on developmental theory or based on both. There is evidence of effectiveness for BHT delivered in multiple settings. Although outcomes may improve with parent/caregiver involvement, there is evidence that BHT is effective when furnished only by providers.
- Related Legislation. There have been numerous legislative attempts to expand and modify the BHT mandate and provider qualifications in recent years. One bill, SB 1034 (Mitchell), of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, contained a number of provisions similar to those in this bill, including the prohibition on denying medically necessary BHT on the basis of parental participation or setting, location or time of treatment. SB 1034 was held on the Suspense File of this committee.
- Support. The DIR®/Floortime Coalition of California, the bill’s sponsor, states this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT. A number of other providers and autism and legal advocacy organizations support this bill.
- Oppose Unless Amended. The California Association of Applied Behavior Analysis (CalABA) is opposed unless amended to clarify the bill does not change requirements for current providers of ABA services.
- Opposition. Health plans and insurers are opposed, stating modifications to the provider requirements in this bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. They also say this bill expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services be provided at any time or location, and ignores current medical literature’s recommendations regarding parent participation. The California Chamber of Commerce states that this bill undermines the ability of health care issuers to promote and manage the use of ABA for children with autism, and will add to the problem of rising health care costs, making it harder for Californians to access other important care.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 163
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 32-1
SUBJECT: Health care coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
SUMMARY: Establishes “Luca’s Law” and revises existing requirements on health care service plans (health plans) and health insurers to cover behavioral health treatment (BHT) for pervasive developmental disorder (PDD) or autism. Expands the definition of BHT and allows the substitution of specified current education, work experience, and training qualifications to meet the criteria of a qualified autism service (QAS) professional or paraprofessional. Prohibits a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation, or on the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Revises the definition of BHT to mean professional services and treatment programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models, as specified.
- Requires an intervention plan to include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities.
- Expands the identified list of entities that can provide required certification to a QAS provider to include the American National Standards Institute (ANSI).
- Requires services provided by a QAS professional to be consistent with the provider’s experience, training, or education.
- Deletes the requirement that a QAS professional meet education and experience qualifications specified in regulation, and instead requires the QAS professional to either:
- Meet the education and experience qualifications specified in regulations; or,
- Have a bachelor’s of arts or science degree and one of the following qualifications:
- One year of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider and 12 semester units from an accredited institution of higher learning in either applied behavioral analysis (ABA) or clinical coursework in behavioral health;
- Two years of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider;
- Be registered as a psychological assistant (PA) or registered psychologist (RP), an associate clinical social worker (ACSW), a registered associate marriage and family therapist (RAMFT), or a registered associate professional clinical counselor (RAPCC), as specified; or,
- Possess a credential or certification by a national entity, including, but not limited to the Behavior Analyst Certification Board (BACB) that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies (NCCA) or the ANSI to provide ABA or BHT, which may include case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a QAS provider.
- Prohibits the registered PA, RP, ACSW, RAMFT, or RAPCC from supervising a QAS paraprofessional until the clinician has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT. Requires the registered PA, RP, ACSW, RAMFT or RAPCC to conform to all of their registration requirements.
- Deletes the terms “unlicensed and uncertified” in the definition of QAS paraprofessional and additionally requires the QAS paraprofessional to meet one of the following:
- For ABA, the education and training criteria set forth in regulations; or,
- For other evidence-based BHT, all of the following qualifications:
- Possesses an associate’s degree or has completed two years of study from an accredited college or university with coursework in a related field of study;
- Forty hours of training in the specific form of BHT developed by a QAS provider and administered by a QAS provider or QAS professional competent in the form of BHT to be practiced by the paraprofessional;
- Adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a QAS provider; or,
- Is credentialed or certified in ABA or BHT for paraprofessionals or technicians by a national entity that is accredited by the NCCA, or the ANSI.
- Permits a QAS paraprofessional to provide treatment and services for up to 180 days while in the process of obtaining certification or a credential, if training and education has been completed.
- Requires QAS professionals and paraprofessionals to have a background check performed by a Department of Justice (DOJ) approved agency, as specified.
- Prohibits the setting, location or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT.
- Specifies that a health plan or health insurer is not required to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized educational program, as specified.
- Specifies that a health plan or health insurer is not required to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s service area, unless the services are urgently needed services or emergency services, as defined, or unless the benefit plan otherwise expressly covers out-of-area services.
- Prohibits a lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
- Deletes the exemption for Medi-Cal managed care plans.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, under federal law, large group carriers that cover mental health or substance use disorders to ensure that financial requirements (such as copays and deductibles) and treatment limitations (such as visit limits) applicable to mental health benefits are no more restrictive than those applied to medical or surgical benefits (commonly referred to as the federal Paul Wellstone and Pete Dominici Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act of 2008).
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health insurers; and, the California Health Benefit Exchange (the Exchange or Covered California) to compare and make available through selective contracting health insurance for individual and small business purchasers as authorized under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act.
- Requires issuers of individual and small group coverage to, at a minimum, cover essential health benefits (EHBs) in the following 10 categories: ambulatory patient services; emergency services; hospitalization; maternity and newborn care; mental health and substance use disorder services, including BHT; prescription drugs; rehabilitative and habilitative services and devices; laboratory services; preventive and wellness services and chronic disease management; and, pediatric services, including oral and vision care.
- Requires every health plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage and health insurance policy to also provide coverage for BHT for PDD or autism no later than July 1, 2012. Requires the coverage to be provided in the same manner and to be subject to the same requirements as provided in California’s mental health parity law.
- Defines BHT for purposes of 4) above as professional services and treatment programs, including ABA and evidence-based intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with PDD or autism and that meet specified criteria regarding the treatment plan, the professionals who can prescribe and supervise treatment, and administer a treatment plan.
- Defines BHT to mean specified services provided by, among others, a QAS professional or paraprofessional supervised and employed by a QAS provider. Defines a QAS professional to mean a person who, among other requirements, is a behavior service provider approved as a vendor by a California regional center to provide services as an associate behavior analyst, behavior analyst, behavior management assistant, behavior management consultant, or behavior management program pursuant to specified regulations adopted under the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act. Requires every health plan or health insurer subject to 4) above to maintain an adequate network that includes QAS providers who supervise or employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT.
- Provides that 4) above does not affect services for which an individual is eligible pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Act, or reduce any obligation to provide services under an individualized education program, individual services plan, or under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and its implementing regulations, as specified.
- Exempts from 4) above a specialized health plan or health insurance policy that does not deliver mental health or behavioral health services to enrollees, or an accident only, specified disease, hospital indemnity, or Medicare supplement policy, a health plan contract, or health insurance policy under the Medi-Cal program.
- Establishes the Medi-Cal program, administered by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), under which qualified low-income individuals receive health care benefits, including coverage for BHT services for individuals less than 21 years of age with autism.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- $3,000 (Insurance Fund) in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, and $9,000 in FY 2020-21, for the CDI to review new form filings for compliance with changes to the definitions and incorporate those changes into insurer examinations.
- $724,000 (Managed Care Fund – MCF) and 3.2 Personnel Years (PYs) in FY 2019-20; $760,000 (MCF) and 3.3 PYs in FY 2020-21; $856,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in 2021-22; and, $819,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in FY 2022-23, for the DMHC, and the same amount annually thereafter, to respond to consumer complaints, review health plans submission documents, enforcement costs, and legal review. All costs would be and covered through fees assessed on health plans. Potential but indeterminate increases to the cost of behavioral health treatment services provided through Knox-Keene licensed managed care plans.
- Unknown costs for the DOJ to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account). The current cost for a DOJ criminal background check is $32 (applicants usually must also pay a fee to the entity that takes the fingerprint and sends it to the DOJ). The total cost to the DOJ to process criminal background checks is unknown and depends on the number of applying providers. All costs incurred by the DOJ are reimbursed by applicants.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Other obstacles to coverage include a shortage of covered professionals, denials based on a lack of parental participation or the setting in which the services are provided, and a lack of qualified paraprofessionals. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to insure that Californians with Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD) will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments.
- BACKGROUND.
- ASD. According to the California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP), ASD is a developmental disability characterized by deficits in social interactions and communication, sensory processing, stereotypic (repetitive) behaviors or interests, and sometimes cognitive function. As reflected by the phrase “autism spectrum disorder,” the symptoms of ASD fall along a continuum, ranging from mild impairment to profound disability. To receive an ASD diagnosis, individuals often demonstrate symptoms in early childhood, with children typically becoming symptomatic as early as age one. The cause (or causes) of ASD is unknown, and research into genetic etiology, as well as environmental factors, continues to be explored. There is no cure for ASD; however, there is evidence that treatment, such as BHT, may improve some symptoms.
- BHT. This bill would alter an existing mandate to require DMHC-regulated health plans and CDI-regulated policies to cover a more expansive definition of BHT for people diagnosed with ASD. BHT aims to modify the behavior of individuals with ASD and improve their cognitive, language, and social functioning by assessing environmental stimuli and reinforcing appropriate responses. These services are generally delivered by QAS providers, professionals, and paraprofessionals. BHT treatment can also be described as a continuum from treatment modalities based primarily on behavioral theory (often referred to as ABA) to treatments based primarily on developmental theory. Existing law explicitly requires coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on behavioral theory. This bill would amend existing law to explicitly require coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on developmental theory. Treatments based on behavioral theory (ABA) fall at the behavioral end of the continuum. CHBRP’s analysis of this bill included the following description:
Continuum of Behavioral Theories and Treatment Modalities
Source: California Health Benefits Review Program, 2019.
- SB 946. SB 946 (Steinberg and Evans), Chapter 650, Statutes of 2011, imposes a set of rules regarding BHT that health plans and health insurers in California must cover for individuals with autism and PDD. SB 946 also identifies the required qualifications of individuals who provide BHT, and permits individuals who are not licensed by the state to provide BHT, as long as the detailed criteria set forth in the bill are met. SB 946 also required the DMHC to convene an Autism Advisory Task Force (Task Force) by February 1, 2012, to develop recommendations regarding medically necessary BHT for individuals with autism or PDD, as well as the appropriate qualifications, training and supervision for providers of such treatment. SB 946 also required the Task Force to develop recommendations regarding the education, training, and experience requirements that unlicensed individuals providing BHT must meet in order to obtain licensure from the state.
- Task Force. The charge of the Task Force was to make recommendations to inform state policymaking and guide future recommendations addressing specified subjects and develop recommendations regarding the education, training, and experience requirements that unlicensed individuals providing autism services must meet in order to secure a license from the state. The Task Force reached consensus on 54 of 55 recommendations and approved one recommendation by a vote of the majority. The Task Force concluded that all "top level" (undefined) providers should be licensed by the state, and set forth a process for establishing a new professional license for "Licensed Behavioral Health Practitioner." The Task Force recommended that the license requirement not take effect until three years after the license is established, and an interim commission be formed to implement the new license until a board is able to do so. The Task Force also recommended all providers of autism services to be registered with the state's TrustLine Registry or comparable system as a condition of employment by service organizations and contracting with health plans and health insurers. TrustLine uses the criminal history background check system to check the fingerprints of applicants, and checks for evidence of additional criminal records.
- Changes to Existing Law under this Bill:
- BHT. Existing law defines BHT as professional services and treatment programs, including ABA and evidence-based behavior intervention programs, which develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with PDD or autism. This bill expands this definition to include programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based, or other evidence-based models.
- Parent Participation. Existing law provides BHT coverage for an intervention plan that includes parent participation that is needed to achieve the plan’s goals and objectives. This bill would prohibit a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation if a hardship exists. Additionally, under this bill, a plan would be required to include parent participation that is individualized and takes into account the ability of the parent to participate in therapy sessions.
- Setting, Location, or Time of treatment. Existing law is silent to the setting, location, or time of treatment associated with the coverage of BHT services. This bill prohibits health plans and health insurers from denying medically necessary coverage based solely on the setting, location or time of treatment.
- QAS Professional and Paraprofessional Qualifications. Existing law requires a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional to meet specific education and training requirements as determined by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) to be a vendor of a regional center. AB 1074 (Maienschein), Chapter 385, Statutes of 2017, eliminated the requirement for QAS professionals to be regional center vendors. This bill would expand the definition of who could qualify as a QAS professional or QAS paraprofessional by allowing an alternative pathway if specified education, work experience and training qualifications are met without meeting the education and training qualifications as determined by DDS.
- CHBRP Analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson), Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002, requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996. SB 125 (Hernandez), Chapter 9, Statutes of 2015, added an impact assessment on EHBs, and legislation that impacts health insurance benefit designs, cost sharing, premiums, and other health insurance topics. CHBRP states in its analysis of this bill the following:
- Coverage Impacts and Enrollees Covered. CHBRP estimates no measurable change in benefit coverage among enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill in regards to definitions of qualified providers. Provider networks are compliant with the current mandate. Although the bill’s provisions could change provider networks due to the alterations in QAS definitions this bill would make, CHBRP does not anticipate measurable change within the first year of implementation. Currently, 100% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for modalities of BHT based on behavioral theory, 95% have coverage for hybrid modalities (behavioral and developmental), and 54% have coverage for modalities based on developmental theory. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill. Currently, 34% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for BHT that does not deny coverage for BHT based on lack of parental involvement. Additionally, 37% of enrollees currently have coverage for BHT regardless of the setting for the BHT. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill.
- EHBs. According to CHBRP, this bill would not trigger financial costs to the state for exceeding EHBs. First, this bill alters the terms and conditions of an existing benefit mandate law, but does not require an additional benefit to be covered. Second, the current law that this bill would alter expressly indicates that it ceases to function if it exceeds EHBs and this bill does not eliminate this clause of the current law. Thus, neither the current law nor the version this bill would create would function if deemed to exceed EHBs.
- Medical Effectiveness. Most studies of BHT are observational studies that compare a specific treatment modality to usual care. This makes it difficult to assess the relative effectiveness of modalities based on behavioral versus hybrid versus developmental theory (as described in the chart above). More studies of BHT modalities based on behavioral theory have been published than studies of BHT based on developmental theory or hybrid theories. However, regardless of the theoretical framework underpinning a BHT modality, most studies are observational studies which limits the ability to determine whether changes in outcomes experienced by people with ASD are due to receipt of the BHT modality the study assesses versus other factors that may affect outcomes. For the modalities based on behavioral theory (ABA):
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Discrete Trials Training improves intelligence quotient and adaptive behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Pivotal Response Training improves language and communication.
- For modalities based on both behavioral and developmental theory:
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Early Start Denver Model improves language.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Social Skills Group therapy improves social behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Project ImPACT improves communication.
- For modalities based on developmental theory (DSPM):
- There is a preponderance of evidence that DIR®/ Floortime™ improves communication, engagement, and relationships.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Treatment and Education of Autistic and Communications-Handicapped Children improves adaptive behavior and motor skills.
- There is limited evidence that Relationship Developmental Intervention improves communication, social interaction, and academic placement.
- Coverage Impacts and Enrollees Covered. CHBRP estimates no measurable change in benefit coverage among enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill in regards to definitions of qualified providers. Provider networks are compliant with the current mandate. Although the bill’s provisions could change provider networks due to the alterations in QAS definitions this bill would make, CHBRP does not anticipate measurable change within the first year of implementation. Currently, 100% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for modalities of BHT based on behavioral theory, 95% have coverage for hybrid modalities (behavioral and developmental), and 54% have coverage for modalities based on developmental theory. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill. Currently, 34% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for BHT that does not deny coverage for BHT based on lack of parental involvement. Additionally, 37% of enrollees currently have coverage for BHT regardless of the setting for the BHT. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill.
Although parent and caregiver involvement in BHT may result in greater improvements, BHT improves outcomes regardless of whether parents or caregivers are involved. There is a preponderance of evidence that BHT can be delivered effectively in multiple settings.
- Utilization. Currently, the average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD is 127.0. The change in the definition of BHT may alter the mix of used modalities, but is not expected to alter the total number of hours used. However, CHBRP projects an increase in BHT utilization due to this bill’s prohibition of denials related to parent/caregiver involvement and denials related to treatment setting, time, or location. Since BHT is most commonly used by children with ASD who are under eight years old, CHBRP projects that the increase in average annual number of hours of BHT will derive from an increase in the moderate users of BHT (10-25 hours per week) in that age range. Each provision will separately increase the overall usage hours of BHT among enrollees with ASD under eight years of age. Combined, they will raise the overall average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD to 129.1 hours.
- Impact on Expenditures. This bill would increase total net annual expenditures (premiums and enrollee expenses for covered and noncovered benefits) by $4,317,000 (0.0027%) for enrollees with DMHC-regulated plans and CDI-regulated policies. As the change in average premiums does not exceed 1% for any market segment, CHBRP would expect no measurable change in the number of uninsured persons due to the enactment of this bill.
- Public Health. Enrollees with ASD who already use BHT would increase their utilization by an average of 2.1 hours per year per BHT user in 2020. Based on the evidence, CHBRP finds that such an increase would not likely have a public health impact in the first year, postmandate. However, the increase in BHT hours may improve BHT outcomes such as intelligence quotient (IQ), language skills, socialization, and adaptive behaviors on an individual basis for some persons with ASD.
- Long-Term Impacts. After the small increase in utilization in the first 12 months, there is no indication in the research literature that the trends will change much over time. And the overall number of enrollees in DMHC-regulated plans or CDI-regulated policies using BHT with ASD is expected to remain generally constant over time. CHBRP therefore does not estimate any change in long-term impacts in utilization, as the rate of using BHT will also remain generally consistent over time. Over the long-term, the first-year cost increase findings would apply annually thereafter. However, the research literature has shown that BHT in children with autism improves their overall health and functioning over time, including gains made for adolescents. Therefore, it is likely that the health outcome gains in BHT in younger children with ASD will result in overall lower health care costs over their lifetimes, although this cannot be quantified. As more BHT is generally associated with better outcomes, it stands to reason that long-term outcomes of cognitive functioning, language, social functioning, and adaptive behaviors may be improved, on an individual basis, for those enrollees who make use of additional BHT hours due to the removal of alternative setting and parent participation barriers; however, CHBRP projects no public health impact in the long term due to the small increase in new hours of BHT per year (2.8 hours).
- SUPPORT. The DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (coalition) states that this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based behavioral health treatment under strict supervision. These requirements for these professionals, each of whom must possess a Master’s Degree and be working toward their Doctorate and professional license under direct supervision of a fully licensed health care professional, are clearly stated in the Business and Professions Code. According to the coalition, many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. Additionally, the coalition states that the paraprofessionals currently under Title 17 regulations must possess a minimum of a high school equivalency and 30 hours of ABA training. In order to foster greater consumer protection of a vulnerable population, this bill increases these requirements for behavioral health treatment other than ABA by imposing a minimum standard of an Associate Degree or its equivalent and 40 hours of training developed and administered by a QAS Provider. This bill requires the treatment plan to maximize the individual parent’s ability to participate. It also requires the setting, time and location of treatment to be determined in advance by the QAS provider directing care. By doing so, the best interests of the child, the insurance company and the State are all protected.
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. The California Association of Applied Behavior Analysis (CalABA) is opposed unless amended and requests clarifying amendments that are consistent with language already in this bill. As currently drafted, this bill would place in statute alternate set of standards for ABA professionals that do not align with the qualifications required for ABA certification by the BACB, which is specifically referenced in the governing mandate statute and is the only accredited certification that currently exists for the provider level. CalABA is concerned that this will create confusion in the marketplace and workforce by mixing requirements for other behavioral health providers with the specific qualifications required to maintain an ABA certification. According to CalABA, this has the potential to disrupt the professional to provider pipeline, which would make it difficult to attract “middle tier personnel” and create serious access issues for patients.
- OPPOSITION. According to the California Association of Health Plans and Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies (CAHP and ACLHIC), as currently drafted, this bill would place in statute an alternate set of standards for ABA professionals that do not align with the qualifications required for ABA certification by the BACB, which is specifically referenced in the governing statute. Modifications to the provider requirements in this bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. ABA is a proven therapy to treat autism and the inclusion of additional provider types will dilute the quality of autism services provided. CAHP and ACLHIC also write that this bill expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services to be provided at any time or location, and ignores current medical literature’s recommendations regarding parent participation. The California Chamber of Commerce state that this bill undermines the ability of health care issuers to promote and manage the use of ABA for children with autism, and will add to the problem of rising health care costs, making it harder for Californians to access other important care.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. ACR 98 (Wicks) urges DMHC, CDI, and the Attorney General to use their authority to ensure that health plans and health insurers subject to their authority comply with the federal mental health parity law.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- SB 399 (Portantino) of 2018, was similar to the introduced version of this bill and was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated:
“This bill would revise qualification standards for providers of behavioral health treatment for individuals with autism.
Standards for autism providers were updated last year. I'm not inclined to revise them again.”
- AB 1074 permits a QAS paraprofessional to be supervised by a QAS professional; indicates that BHT may include clinical case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a QAS provider, deletes a requirement that a behavioral service provider is approved as a vendor by a Regional Center based on provider definitions in specified regulations; and instead requires a behavioral service provider to meet the education and experience qualifications described in the specified regulations; and, makes other technical changes. Revises the definition of BHT for purposes of the Medi-Cal program to be those services administered by DHCS as described in the state plan approved by CMS.
- AB 796 (Nazarian), Chapter 493, Statutes of 2016, deletes the sunset date of coverage for BHT services.
- SB 1034 (Mitchell) of 2016 would have eliminated the sunset date on the health insurance mandate to cover BHT for PDD or autism, and prohibited health plans or health insurers from excluding medically necessary BHT on the basis of setting, location, time of treatment, or lack of parent or caregiver participation. SB 1034 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1715 (Holden) of 2016 would have established the Behavior Analyst Act (BAA), which provides for the licensure, registration, and regulation of behavior analysts and assistant behavior analysts, and would have required the California Board of Psychology, until January 1, 2022, to administer and enforce. AB 1714 died in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
- SB 479 (Bates) of 2015 would have established the BAA which requires a person to apply for and obtain a license from the Board of Psychology prior to engaging in the practice of behavior analysis, as defined, either as a behavior analyst or an assistant behavior analyst, and meet certain educational and training requirements. SB 479 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 2041 (Jones) of 2014 would have required that a regional center classify a vendor as a behavior management consultant or behavior management assistant if the vendor designs or implements evidence-based BHT, has a specified amount of experience in designing or implementing that treatment, and meets other licensure and education requirements. AB 2041 died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- SB 126 (Steinberg), Chapter 680, Statutes of 2013, extends until January 1, 2017, the sunset date of the benefit mandate to cover BHT for PDD or autism and required health plans and insurers to maintain adequate networks of these service providers.
- SB 946 requires until July 1, 2014, health plans and health insurance policies to cover BHT for PDD or autism, requires health plans and insurers to maintain adequate networks of autism service providers, established a task force in DMHC, and makes other technical changes to existing law regarding HIV reporting and mental health services payments.
- AB 1453 (Monning), Chapter 854, Statutes of 2012, and SB 951 (Hernandez), Chapter 866, Statutes of 2012, establish California's EHBs.
- SB 770 (Steinberg) of 2010 would have required health plans and insurance policies to provide coverage for BHT. SB 770 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 166 (Steinberg) of 2011 would have required health plans licensed by DMHC and health insurers licensed by CDI to provide coverage for BHT for autism. SB 166 was held in the Senate Health Committee.
- AB 1205 (Berryhill) of 2011 would have required the Board of Behavioral Sciences to license behavioral analysts and assistant behavioral analysts, on and after January 1, 2015, and included standards for licensure such as specified higher education and training, fieldwork, passage of relevant examinations, and national board accreditation. AB 1205 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee on the suspense file.
- POLICY COMMENT. Current law requires specified providers to meet the education, training, and experience qualifications described in existing law and specified regulations. This bill authorizes the substitution of education, work experience, and training qualifications in current law with additional qualifications to meet the criteria of a QAS professional or paraprofessional to be determined by DMHC and CDI. While DMHC and CDI are tasked with regulating health plans and health insurers, these entities may not be the appropriate entities to make determinations of provider qualifications.
- COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. To address concerns of requiring an intervention plan to include parent participation, the Committee proposes to clarify that parent participation will be allowed if clinically appropriate as follows:
Designs an intervention plan that includes the service type, number of hours, and parent participation, when clinically appropriate, needed to achieve the plan’s goal and objectives, and the frequency at which the patient’s progress is evaluated and reported. When clinically appropriate, the plan shall include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Dir/Floortime Coalition Of California (sponsor)
Arc Of California
Autism Behavior Services, Inc.
Board Of Behavioral Sciences
California Psychological Association
Center for Autism
Cherry Crisp Entertainment & Productions
Child Development Institute
Descanso Medical Center for Development & Learning
Disability Rights California
Foothill Autism Alliance
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
Interdisciplinary Council on Development and Learning
Keany Associates Developmental Services
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers
National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter
Newton Center for Affect Regulation
Profectum
Professional Child Development Associates
Qualified Applied Behavior Analysis Credentialing Board
San Gabriel Valley Psychological Association
Silvia Irwin, PhD
The Frostig Center
UCSF – Multidisciplinary Assessment Center
Verdugo Hills Autism Project
Numerous individuals
Oppose
America's Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life & Health Insurance Companies
California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Dependency Lawyers, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Kristene Mapile / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 163 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 163
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/3/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove
SENATE HUMAN SERVICES COMMITTEE: 6-0, 4/22/19
AYES: Hurtado, Stone, Beall, Jackson, Pan, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Health care coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
SOURCE: DIR/Floortime Coalition of California
DIGEST:
This bill revises and expands the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT) and expands the provider qualifications to include more provider types that can provide BHT under the mandate that health plans and insurers cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. This bill prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by a qualified autism services provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Services Plan Act of 1975; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health and other insurers;; and, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to administer the Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1340, et seq., INS §106, et seq., and WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Requires every health plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage and health insurance policy to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. Requires the coverage to be provided in the same manner and to be subject to the same requirements as provided in California’s mental health parity law. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Defines BHT for purposes of 2) above as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavior analysis (ABA) and evidence-based intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism and that meet specified criteria regarding the treatment plan, the professionals who can prescribe and supervise treatment, and administer a treatment plan. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires every health plan or health insurer subject to 2) and 3) above to maintain an adequate network that includes qualified autism services (QAS) providers who supervise or employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires, only to the extent required by the federal government and effective no sooner than required by the federal government, BHT to be a covered Medi-Cal service for individuals under 21 years of age. [WIC §14132.56]
This bill:
- Revises and expands the definition of “BHT”, to include:
- Programs based on behavioral, developmental, relationship-based (rather than behavior-based), and other evidence-based models; and,
- Requires the intervention plan to include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities.
- Revises the definition of “QAS provider” to include a person who is certified by the American National Standards Institute.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS professional” and requires a completed a background check performed by a Department of Justice (DOJ) approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS paraprofessional” to delete that the individual can be unlicensed or uncertified, and, makes other changes including a completed background check performed by a DOJ approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Deletes an exemption for a health plan contract or health insurance policy in the Medi-Cal program from the requirement for health plans to cover BHT.
- Prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized educational program for purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s service area unless the services are urgently needed services, as defined, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
- States that parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged, but prohibits the lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
Background
Autism spectrum disorder. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), a guide created by the American Psychiatric Association used to diagnose mental disorders, people with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) have difficulty with communication and interaction with other people, restricted interests and repetitive behaviors, and symptoms that hurt the person’s ability to function properly in school, work, and other areas of life. Autism is known as a “spectrum” disorder because there is wide variation in the type and severity of symptoms people experience. Although ASD can be a lifelong disorder, treatments and services can improve a person’s symptoms and ability to function. The California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP) estimates that in 2016, the prevalence of ASD in California children (aged zero to nine years) is about 160 in 10,000.
- BHT. According to CHBRP, BHT aims to modify the behavior of individuals with ASD and improve their cognitive, language, and social functioning by assessing environmental stimuli and reinforcing appropriate responses. These services are generally delivered by QAS providers, professionals, and paraprofessionals. BHT treatment can also be described as a continuum from treatment modalities based primarily on behavioral theory (often referred to as ABA) to treatments based primarily on developmental theory. Existing law explicitly requires coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on behavioral theory. This bill would amend existing law to explicitly require coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on developmental theory.
- California Health Benefits Review Program analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson, Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002) requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996, and reviewed this bill. Key findings include:
- Coverage impacts and enrollees covered. Currently, 100% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for modalities of BHT based on behavioral theory, 95% have coverage for hybrid modalities (behavioral and developmental), and 54% have coverage for modalities based on developmental theory. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill. Currently, 34% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for BHT that does not deny coverage for BHT based on lack of parental involvement. Additionally, 37% of enrollees currently have coverage for BHT regardless of the setting for the BHT. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill.
- Medical effectiveness. Most studies of BHT are observational studies that compare a specific treatment modality to usual care. This makes it difficult to assess the relative effectiveness of modalities based on behavioral versus hybrid versus developmental theory. More studies of BHT modalities based on behavioral theory have been published than studies of BHT based on developmental theory or hybrid theories. However, regardless of the theoretical framework underpinning a BHT modality, most studies are observational studies which limits the ability to determine whether changes in outcomes experienced by people with ASD are due to receipt of the BHT modality the study assesses versus other factors that may affect outcomes.
For the modalities based on behavioral theory or ABA:
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Discrete Trials Training improves intelligence quotient and adaptive behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Pivotal Response Training improves language and communication.
For modalities based on both behavioral and developmental theory:
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Early Start Denver Model improves language.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Social Skills Group therapy improves social behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Project ImPACT improves communication.
For modalities based on developmental theory:
- There is a preponderance of evidence that DIR®/ Floortime™ improves communication, engagement, and relationships.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that TEACCH improves adaptive behavior and motor skills.
- There is limited evidence that Relationship Developmental Intervention improves communication, social interaction, and academic placement.
Although parent and caregiver involvement in BHT may result in greater improvements, BHT improves outcomes regardless of whether parents or caregivers are involved. There is a preponderance of evidence that BHT can be delivered effectively in multiple settings.
- Utilization. Currently, the average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD is 127.0. The change in the definition of BHT may alter the mix of used modalities, but is not expected to alter the total number of hours used. However, CHBRP projects an increase in BHT utilization due to this bill’s prohibition of denials related to parent/caregiver involvement and denials related to treatment setting, time, or location.
- Impact on expenditures. This bill increases total net annual expenditures (premiums and enrollee expenses for covered and noncovered benefits) by $4,317,000 (0.0027%) for enrollees with DMHC-regulated plans and CDI-regulated policies.
Comments
According to the author, too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to ensure that Californians with ASD will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments. The choice of treatment should be left up to the physician or psychologist in consultation with the patient and the patient’s family, not the insurance company or the state. This critical decision must be made by the clinician who knows the patient best. Evidence-based practice relies on the best clinical judgement of the clinician which cannot occur with only one choice of treatment. Children with ASD are a vulnerable population and deserve our protection. Paraprofessionals who serve this population need to be adequately educated and trained and have undergone a thorough background check before entering a child’s home.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- $3,000 (Insurance Fund) in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, and $9,000 in FY 2020-21, for the CDI to review new form filings for compliance with changes to the definitions and incorporate those changes into insurer examinations.
- $724,000 (Managed Care Fund – MCF) and 3.2 Personnel Years (PYs) in FY 2019-20; $760,000 (MCF) and 3.3 PYs in FY 2020-21; $856,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in 2021-22; and, $819,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in FY 2022-23, for the DMHC, and the same amount annually thereafter, to respond to consumer complaints, review health plans submission documents, enforcement costs, and legal review. All costs would be and covered through fees assessed on health plans. Potential but indeterminate increases to the cost of behavioral health treatment services provided through Knox-Keene licensed managed care plans.
- Unknown costs for the DOJ to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account). The current cost for a DOJ criminal background check is $32 (applicants usually must also pay a fee to the entity that takes the fingerprint and sends it to the DOJ). The total cost to the DOJ to process criminal background checks is unknown and depends on the number of applying providers. All costs incurred by the DOJ are reimbursed by applicants.
DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (source)
Board of Behavioral Sciences
California Psychological Association
Cherry Crisp Entertainment and Productions
Child Development Institute
Descanso Medical Center for Development & Learning
Foothill Autism Alliance
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Newton Center for Affect Regulation
Professional Child Development Associates
The Arc California
The Frostig Center
United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Verdugo Hills Autism Project
Over 150 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
America’s Health Insurance Plans
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
California Association for Behavior Analysis
California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber of Commerce
California Consortium for Behavior Analysis
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (Coalition), this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code (Registered Psychological Assistant, Associate Clinical Social Worker, Associate Marriage and Family Therapist, and Associate Professional Clinical Counselor) to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based BHT under strict supervision. Many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. Paraprofessionals currently under Title 17 regulations must possess a minimum of a high school equivalency and 30 hours of ABA training. In order to foster greater consumer protection of a vulnerable population, this bill increases these requirements for BHT other than ABA by imposing a minimum standard of an Associate Degree or its equivalent and 40 hours of training developed and administered by a QAS Provider. Additionally, the Coalition indicates that parents across the state are also being denied coverage for BHT based on their particular circumstances, circumstances beyond their control. The strain of raising a child on the Spectrum often tears marriages apart. Single parent households are all too common. Yet insurance companies deny coverage if working single parents who cannot attend all therapy sessions do not fully participate in their child’s treatment.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Association of Health Plans (CAHP), this bill significantly expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services be provided at “any time or location,” and “ignores current medical literature’s recommendations and best practices” by creating a new definition for evidenced-based care. Health plans currently cover evidenced based autism services to enrollees that require care. Health plans are also required to meet network adequacy and time and distance standards that are enforced by DMHC. CHBRP estimates that this bill will increase costs by $4,317,000. For autism services, ABA is an evidenced treatment. Expanding health plans services to incorporate the patient or caregivers’ preferences into treatment determinations is counter-intuitive of evidenced-based practice principles. Modifications to the provider requirements in the bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. Maintaining affordable premiums is critical as policymakers strive to decrease the number of uninsured Californians. This is not the time for new benefit mandates that drive up the cost of care. The California Chamber of Commerce believes it is appropriate for issuers to make coverage for ABA contingent upon caregiver participation since research on the effectiveness of ABA shows unequivocally that it is critical to the success of the treatment. With the significant cost pressures already facing California businesses, the uncertainty in health care policy at the federal level, as well as the 2019 premium increase in excess of 8% and the cumulative increase of over 42% over the last five years, California should not increase costs of health care coverage for employers and enrollees.
Prepared by: Teri Boughton / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
5/20/19 13:42:10
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 163 (Portantino) - Healthcare coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
Version: April 9, 2019 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 8 - 0, HUMAN S. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
SB 163 would make several changes to the existing mandate for health plans and insurers to provide coverage for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- $3,000 (Insurance Fund) in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, and $9,000 in FY 2020-21, for the Department of Insurance (CDI) to review new form filings for compliance with changes to the definitions and incorporate those changes into insurer examinations.
- $724,000 (Managed Care Fund – MCF) and 3.2 PYs in FY 2019-20; $760,000 (MCF) and 3.3 PYs in FY 2020-21; $856,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in 2021-22; and, $819,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in FY 2022-23, for the Department of Managed Health Care, and the same amount annually thereafter, to respond to consumer complaints, review health plans submission documents, enforcement costs, and legal review. All costs would be and covered through fees assessed on health plans. Potential but indeterminate increases to the cost of behavioral health treatment services provided through Knox-Keene licensed managed care plans.
- Unknown costs for the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account). The current cost for a Department of Justice criminal background check is $32 (applicants usually must also pay a fee to the entity that takes the fingerprint and sends it to the Department). The total cost to the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks is unknown and depends on the number of applying providers. All costs incurred by the Department are reimbursed by applicants.
Author Amendments:
The author amendments define “behavioral health treatment”, for purposes of the bill, to include professional services and treatment programs based on “relationship-based” models, and clarify parent participation provisions.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 163 (Portantino) - Healthcare coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
Version: April 9, 2019 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 8 - 0, HUMAN S. 6 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
SB 163 would make several changes to the existing mandate for health plans and insurers to provide coverage for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
Fiscal Impact:
- $3,000 (Insurance Fund) in fiscal year (FY) 2019-20, and $9,000 in FY 2020-21 for the Department of Insurance (CDI) to review new form filings for compliance with changes to the definitions and incorporate those changes into insurer examinations.
- The DMHC estimates the total cost of this bill to be approximately $724,000 (Managed Care Fund – MCF) and 3.2 PYs in FY 2019-20; $760,000 (MCF) and 3.3 PYs in FY 2020-21; $856,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in 2021-22; and, $819,000 (MCF) and 3.8 PYs in FY 2022-23, and the same amount annually thereafter, to respond to consumer complaints, review health plans submission documents, enforcement costs, and legal review. All costs would be and covered through fees assessed on health plans. Potential but indeterminate increases to the cost of BHT services provided through Knox-Keene licensed managed care plans. Please see Staff Comments for more detailed information for resource personnel.
- According to the California Health Benefits Review Program, this bill would increase total net annual expenditures (premiums and enrollee expenses for covered and noncovered benefits) by $4.32 million (0.0027%) for enrollees with DMHC-regulated plans and CDI-regulated policies.
- Unknown costs for the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks for qualified autism service and qualified autism service paraprofessionals (Fingerprint Fees Account). The current cost for a Department of Justice criminal background check is $32 (applicants usually must also pay a fee to the entity that takes the fingerprint and sends it to the Department). The total cost to the Department of Justice to process criminal background checks is unknown and depends on the number of applying providers. All costs incurred by the Department are reimbursed by applicants.
Background:
Current state law (SB 88, Thompson, Statutes of 1999) requires health plans and health insurers who provide hospital, medical, or surgical coverage to provide coverage for the diagnosis and treatment of severe mental illness (as specified in statute). In addition, health plans and health insurers are required to provide additional coverage for serious emotional disturbances of a child. Current state law (SB 946, Steinberg, Statutes of 2011) specifically requires health plans and health insurers to cover behavioral health therapy for pervasive development disorder or autism. The statutory sunset in SB 946 was eliminated in AB 796 (Nazarian, Statutes of 2016).
Behavioral health treatment (BHT) for autistic spectrum disorder (ASD) is on a continuum — from modalities based on behavioral theory, like applied behavioral analysis, to modalities based on developmental theory, like developmental social pragmatic model. In the middle are modalities based on theory that is both behavioral and developmental, like naturalistic developmental behavioral interventions.
Proposed Law:
This bill includes the following provisions, among others:
- Revises the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT), as it pertains to coverage requirements for health care service plans (HCSPs) and health insurers.
- Requires BHT services and treatment programs provided to be based on behavioral, developmental, behavior-based, or other evidence-based models.
- Expands on qualifications necessary, including a background check by a DOJ approved agency, to be a qualified autism service professional or a qualified autism service paraprofessional, and would require both qualified autism service professionals and qualified autism service paraprofessionals to complete a background check.
- Requires the intervention plan, when clinically appropriate, to include parent or caregiver participation and takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions, and would specify that the lack of parent or caregiver participation could not be used to deny or reduce medically necessary services, in addition to other criteria.
- Removes the exception for HCSPs and health insurance policies in the Medi-Cal program, making the bill’s requirements applicable to Knox-Keene licensed Medi-Cal managed care health plans (MCPs) regulated by the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC).
- Prohibits a health plan or insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on only a lack of parent or caregiver participation, the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified.
Related Legislation:
- SB 399 (Portantino, 2018) would have revised existing requirements on health plans and health insurers to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, and would have prohibited a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation, or on the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified. Governor Brown vetoed the bill, citing his lack of inclination to revise standards for autism providers that were recently updated in 2017.
Staff Comments:
AB 1996 (Thomson, Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002) requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. The California Health Benefits Review Program, was enacted under this bill, to provide the Legislature fiscal, medical, and public health impacts of proposed health insurance benefit mandates and repeals. The CHBRP report on this bill found:
- Enrollees with ASD who already use BHT would increase their utilization by an average of 2.1 hours per year per BHT user in 2020. Based on the evidence, CHBRP finds that such an increase would not likely have a public health impact in the first year, postmandate. However, the increase in BHT hours may improve BHT outcomes such as intelligence quotient (IQ), language skills, socialization, and adaptive behaviors on an individual basis for some persons with ASD.
- Postmandate, 66% of enrollees would no longer be denied BHT coverage due to lack of parental involvement and 63% would no longer be denied BHT coverage due to setting. In addition, all enrollees would gain coverage for BHT based on developmental theory.
- Research literature has shown that BHT in children with autism improves their overall health and functioning over time, including gains made for adolescents. Therefore, it is likely that the health outcome gains in BHT in younger children with ASD will result in overall lower health care costs over their lifetimes, although this cannot be quantified.
For more detail on DMHC’s anticipated personnel and resource impacts:
- The DMHC’s Help Center (HC) anticipates additional workload to address an increased volume of consumer complaints involving Medi-Cal Managed Care enrollees following the implementation of SB 163. The DMHC estimates costs for HC to be approximately $199,000 and 1.2 PYs in FY 2019-20, $209,000 and 1.2 PYs in FY 2020-21, $199,000 and 1.2 PYs in FY 2021-22 and the same amount annually thereafter.
- The DMHC’s Office of Plan Monitoring (OPM) anticipates additional workload to develop guidance for health care service plan submissions and review plan documents for compliance with the requirements set forth in SB 163. The DMHC estimates costs for OPM to be approximately $419,000 and 1.5 PYs in FY 2019-20, $164,000 and 0.3 PY in FY 2020-21, $162,000 and 0.3 PY in FY 2021-22 and the same amount annually thereafter. These amounts include $112,000 in FY 2019-20 and $104,000 starting in FY 2020-21 for consultant funding to assist OPM with the implementation of this bill and ongoing review of plan documents for compliance with Section 1374.27.
- The DMHC’s Office of Enforcement (OE) anticipates additional workload for one referral per year from OPM and 14 referrals per year from the Help Center, starting in FY 2020-21. The DMHC estimates costs for OE to be approximately $323,000 and 1.4 PYs in FY 2020-21, $495,000 and 2.3 PYs in FY 2021-22, $458,000 and 2.3 PYs in FY 2022-23 and the same amount annually thereafter. These amounts include $45,000 in FY 2020-21 for an expert witness consultant and $37,000 in FY 2021-22 for trial-related costs.
- The DMHC’s Office of Legal Services (OLS) anticipates short-term workload to conduct legal research and prepare one legal memoranda to clarify the law during the first year of implementation and two additional legal memoranda to provide clarification of the requirements set forth in SB 163. The DMHC estimates costs for OLS to be approximately $42,000 and 0.2 PY in FY 2019-20 and $64,000 and 0.4 PY in FY 2020-21 only.
- The DMHC’s Office of Plan Licensing (OPL) anticipates short-term workload to review health care service plan documents and contracts for compliance with the behavioral health and qualified autism service provider requirements set forth in SB 163. The DMHC estimates costs for OPL to be approximately $64,000 and 0.3 PY in FY 2019-20 only.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Senator Hurtado, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 163
Author: | Portantino | ||
Version: | April 9, 2019 | Hearing Date: | April 22, 2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Marisa Shea | ||
Subject: Healthcare coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
SUMMARY
This bill expands the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT) and expands the provider qualifications to include additional qualified autism service (QAS) provider types that can provide BHT under the mandate that health plans and insurers cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. This bill also prohibits a health plan or insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on only a lack of parent or caregiver participation, the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified.
ABSTRACT
Existing Law:
- Establishes the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, which states that California is responsible for providing an array of services and supports sufficiently complete to meet the needs and choices of each person with developmental disabilities, regardless of age or degree of disability, and at each stage of life and to support their integration into the mainstream life of the community. (WIC 4500, et seq.)
- Establishes a system of nonprofit Regional Centers, overseen by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS), to provide fixed points of contact in the community for all persons with developmental disabilities and their families, to coordinate services and supports best suited to them throughout their lifetime. (WIC 4620)
- Establishes an Individual Program Plan (IPP) and defines that planning process as the vehicle to ensure that services and supports are customized to meet the needs of consumers who are served by regional centers. (WIC 4512(b))
- Requires every health care service plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage to also provide coverage for BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, as specified. (WIC 1374.73. (a) (1))
- Requires that every health care service plan maintain an adequate network that includes QAS providers who supervise and employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT. Nothing shall prevent a health care service plan from selectively contracting with providers within these requirements. (WIC 1374.73 (b))
- Defines BHT, for purposes of payment under a health care service plan contract or a health insurance policy, as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavior analysis and evidence-based behavior intervention programs, which develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism. (HSC 1374.73(c)(1); INS 10144.51(c)(1))
- Further requires treatment be prescribed by a physician or surgeon, as specified, and that it be provided by a qualified autism provider, or a qualified autism professional paraprofessional who is supervised and employed by a qualified autism provider. (HSC 1374.73(c)(1); INS 10144.51(c)(1))
- Includes in the definition of a "QAS professional" a behavioral service provider approved as a vendor by a California regional center to provide services as an Associate Behavior Analyst, Behavior Analyst, Behavior Management Assistant, Behavior Management Consultant, or Behavior Management Program as defined. (HSC 1374.73 (c)(4)(D); INS 10144.51(c)(4)(D))
- Defines in state regulations, for purposes of regional center vendorization, Behavior Management Assistant, Behavior Management Consultant, Behavior Analyst and Associate Behavior Analyst and requires education or experience in Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA), as specified. (17 CCR §54342)
This Bill:
- Expands the definition of BHT to include professional services and treatment programs based on behavioral, developmental, behavior-based, or other evidence-based models.
- Provides that an intervention plan may include parent or caregiver participation that is clinically appropriate, individualized to the patient, and takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities.
- Requires that the services provided by a QAS professional be consistent with the experience, training, or education of the professional.
- Expands a QAS professional to include behavioral service providers who meet one of the following criteria:
- Meets the education and experience qualifications described in existing California Code of Regulations, as provided, for an associate behavior analyst, behavior analyst, behavior management assistant, behavior management consultant, or behavior management program;
- Possesses a bachelor of arts or science degree and meets one of the following qualifications:
- One year of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider and 12 semester units from an accredited institution of higher learning in either applied behavioral analysis or clinical coursework in behavioral health;
- Two years of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider;
- The person is a registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist, as provided;
- The person is an associate clinical social worker registered with the Board of Behavioral Sciences, as provided;
- The person is a registered associate marriage and family therapist with the Board of Behavior Sciences, as provided;
- The person is a registered associate professional clinical counselor with the Board of Behavioral Sciences as provided;
- The person is credentialed or certified by a national entity, including, but not limited to, the Behavior Analyst Certification Board;
- Has training and experience in providing services for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
- Requires a QAS professional and paraprofessionals to have completed a background check performed by a Department of Justice approved agency, with subsequent notification provided to the person’s employer, as provided.
- Provides that a registered psychological assistant, registered psychologist, registered associate clinical social worker, a registered associate marriage and family therapist, or a registered associate professional clinical counselor may not supervise a QAS paraprofessional until the registered psychological assistant, registered psychologist, registered associate clinical social worker, a registered associate marriage and family therapist, or a registered associate professional clinical counselor has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT.
- For evidence-based BHT, expands the meaning of QAS paraprofessional to include individuals who meet all of the following qualifications:
- Possesses an associate’s degree or has completed two years of study from an accredited college or university with coursework in a related field of study;
- Has 40 hours of training in a specific form of behavioral health treatment developed by a QAS provider and administered by a QAS provider or QAS professional competent in the form of BHT to be practiced by the paraprofessional; and
- Has adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by the QAS provider.
- Expands the meaning of QAS paraprofessional to include an individual who is credentialed or certified in applied behavior analysis or BHT for paraprofessionals or technicians by a national entity that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute, and allows individuals otherwise qualified to provide treatment and implement services for up to 180 days while in the process of obtaining the certification or credential.
- Specifies that the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider shall not be used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services, and requires the setting be consistent with the standard of care for BHT. Further provides that a health care service plan does not have to provide reimbursement for services deliver by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized education program or to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s services area unless the services outside the service area are urgently needed or emergency services, as provided.
- Provides that caregiver participation should be encouraged, but lack of parent or caregiver participation shall not be used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
FISCAL IMPACT
This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
BACKGROUND AND DISCUSSION
Purpose of the Bill:
According to the author, “too many Californians with Autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for Autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal.” The author believes “changes to existing law are needed in order to ensure that Californians with Autism receive coverage for medically necessary treatments."
Autism
Autism is a neurodevelopmental disorder characterized by difficulty in language, social interaction, and by the presence of repetitive and stereotyped behaviors. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) describes autism as the most severe form of a range of conditions that together make up Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD). According to the National Institute for Mental Health (NIMH), autism is known as a “spectrum” disorder because there is wide variation in the type and severity of symptoms people experience.
The most notable feature of ASD is impaired social interaction, according to the NIH. As described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), a guide created by the American Psychiatric Association, people with ASD have difficulty with communication and interaction with other people, restricted interests and repetitive behaviors, and symptoms that hurt the person’s ability to function properly in school, work, and other areas of life. An infant with ASD may not respond to people or may focus intently on one item to the exclusion of others for long periods of time. Children with ASD may avoid eye contact with other people, or not respond to verbal commands or conversation. They cannot interpret facial expressions or changes in voice inflection so they do not understand what others are thinking or feeling.
ASD is said to be a developmental disorder because symptoms generally appear during the first two years of life, however it may be diagnosed at any age. It is thought to be a lifelong disorder, although treatments and services can improve a person’s symptoms and ability to function. ASD occurs in all ethnic and socioeconomic groups and affects every age group. Males are four times more likely to have ASD than females. DDS data shows that as of December 2018 approximately 110,854 of the state’s 347,506 developmental services consumers have an ASD or pervasive developmental disorder diagnosis. Additionally, DDS reports that among those consumers receiving services for ASD, 37 percent identified as Latino, 30 percent identified as white, 9 percent identified as Asian, and 7 percent identified as black.
Agency for Health Care Research and Quality
Autism, as a condition, is relatively new in the field of scientific intervention. For years, researchers and health providers debated the merits of various forms of BHT. The federal Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality within the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services conducts systematic reviews on emerging treatments to provide clinicians with information and context on the usefulness of these new treatments. In 2014, the Agency published a 513-page report entitled, “Therapies for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: Behavioral Interventions Update.”[1]
The report concluded that while a growing evidence base “suggests that behavioral interventions can be associated with positive outcomes for children with ASD … a need remains for studies of interventions across settings and continued improvements in methodological rigor. Substantial scientific advances are needed to enhance our understanding of which interventions are most effective for specific children with ASD and to isolate elements or components of interventions most associated with effects.” The report underscores a debate about which therapies are evidence-based and whether to approve state and federal funding for emerging therapies.
Treatment Modalities
Applied Behavioral Analysis
The most recognized form of behavioral treatment for autism is Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA), a scientifically validated method of treatment which focuses on positive reinforcement and intensive teaching to bring about a change in behavior. ABA has been acknowledged as effective by the US Surgeon General, the US Department of Education and others. Although ABA can be used with both children and adults, it is commonly associated with intensive treatment of young children who have autism. Through repetitive intervention and positive feedback, children are taught communication, social skills, play, self-care and other skills appropriate for school-based learning.
Studies have demonstrated that many children with autism experience significant improvements in learning, reasoning, communication and adaptability when they participate in high-quality ABA programs. Studies have also shown that some children who participate in early, intensive ABA for two or more years before they are school aged can acquire sufficient skills to participate in regular classrooms with little or no support.
Early Start Denver Model
ABA encompasses several different treatment modalities, and there are also other interventions that have been scientifically studied and found to be effective. One of those is the Early Start Denver Model, which is a relationship-based intervention provided in the home by trained therapists and parents during natural play and daily routines. Researchers at the UC Davis MIND Institute have been studying this model’s effectiveness.
Floortime
Sponsors of this bill, DIR/Floortime, Inc, implement a practice concept that centers around meeting children at their level – literally by playing on the floor with them. In Floortime, therapists and parents interact with children through the activities each child enjoys. They follow the child's lead and play the child’s games. Therapists then teach parents how to direct their children into increasingly complex interactions. For example, if the child is tapping a toy truck, the parent might tap a toy car in the same way, according to an example on the Autism Speaks website. The parent might then put the car in front of the child’s truck or add language to the game to further communication. Floortime may be used with other behavioral interventions.
Group Orientation for Applied Behavioral Analysis
Prior to July 2009, ABA treatment in California included an in-home parental education and orientation component designed to familiarize families with autism spectrum disorder and the ABA treatment. That was changed amid the Great Recession to instead require a regional center to consider “the use of group training for parents on behavioral intervention techniques in lieu of some or all of the in-home parent training component of the behavioral intervention services.” (WIC 4685) Parents still need to be present during the in-home training for their children to ensure consistency of responses to the child between the trainer and parent. The group orientation legislation has been applied variously by regional centers, and at least several have viewed the language as a mandate to provide orientation classes to parents as a prerequisite to providing services to children. Currently, several regional centers require multiple sessions for parents prior to a child beginning ABA services at home.
Advocates say this requirement can cause significant delays – or a loss of services – for families in accessing services if both parents work, or there are other children in the home who need care, or the transportation to the orientation classes is difficult, or there are language barriers, among other challenges. This bill seeks to address this issue by prohibiting denial of medically necessary ABA treatment because a family cannot attend at a certain time or in a certain location, or because a parent cannot participate in therapy.
California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP)
The Health Benefits Review program was authorized by the Legislature and established in 2002 to respond to Legislative requests for an independent analysis of the medical, financial and public health impacts of proposed health insurance benefit mandates and repeals. Staffed by the University of California Office of the President, the program works with a task force of faculty from several UC campuses and actuarial consultants. A CHBRP analysis of this bill is pending, and will be evaluated in the Senate Health Committee, should this bill be passed by this committee.
National Standards Project
In 2007 and again in 2015, the National Autism Center convened a panel of autism researchers to evaluate, as a team, the effectiveness of various behavioral therapies to address autism and related conditions.
Studies were chosen for scientific rigor and adherence to the question of therapeutic effectiveness. Ultimately, each of the therapeutic intervention models was categorized into one of three categories for children, adolescents and adults under 22 years of age:
- Established interventions have been thoroughly researched and have sufficient evidence to be considered effective.
The 14 established interventions for children include behavioral interventions (such as ABA), cognitive behavioral intervention package, comprehensive behavioral treatment for young children, parent training, and others.
- Emerging Interventions have some evidence of effectiveness, but not enough for researchers to be confident they are truly effective.
The 18 emerging interventions for children included Developmental Relationship-based treatment, social communication intervention, music therapy and others.
- Unestablished Interventions showed no sound evidence of effectiveness. Researchers noted there is little or no evidence that allows us to draw firm conclusions about their effectiveness with individuals with ASD. “There is no reason to assume these interventions are effective. Further, there is no way to rule out the possibility these interventions are ineffective or harmful.”[2]
The 13 unestablished interventions for children included DIR/Floortime, sensory intervention package, shock therapy, social cognition intervention, and others.
Related/Prior Legislation:
SB 399 (Portantino, 2018) would have broadened the eligibility criteria to become a “QAS professional” and would have authorized the substitution of specified education, work experience, and training qualifications to meet the criteria of a “QAS professional.” SB 399 would also have eliminated the requirement for a professional or paraprofessional to be directly employed by a qualified autism provider and would have prohibited the lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used to deny or reduce medically necessary behavioral health treatment, among other changes. SB 399 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
AB 1074 (Maienschein, 2017) is substantially similar to this bill. It requires a QAS professional or a QAS paraprofessional to be supervised by a QAS provider, and makes other parallel changes. However it does not include the language of this bill which broadens the definition of provider categories, or extend the mandated timeline for review of the treatment plan.
SB 796 (Nazarian, Chapter 493, Statutes of 2016) contained similar language, as well as deleting the sunset date on requiring health plans and insurers to pay for behavioral health treatment. Only the sunset date deletion was passed and signed into law.
SB 1034 (Mitchell, 2016) would have modified the requirements of a QAS professional and would have required that a treatment plan be reviewed no more than once every 6 months, unless a shorter period is recommended by the QAS provider. The bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2041 (Jones, 2014) would have expanded the scope of treatment providers in the regional center vendor system to include a behavior management consultant or behavior management assistant, with specified requirements. The bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 946 (Steinberg, Chapter 650, statutes of 2011) requires health plans and health insurance policies to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, requires health plans and insurers to maintain adequate networks of autism service providers, establishes a task force in DMHC, sunsets the autism mandate provisions on July 1, 2014, and makes other technical changes to existing law regarding HIV reporting and mental health services payments.
SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Arguments in Support:
The California Psychological Association writes:
“SB 163 seeks to expand the types of services and types of providers included in the current autism insurance mandate. The bill will remove statutory obstacles and require health insurance coverage for all forms of Behavioral Health Treatment. SB 163 further details qualifications and requirements for a Qualified Autism Service Professional and Paraprofessional. This bill recognizes that not all patients benefit from one treatment modality and expands services to all evidence-based behavioral health treatments.”
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Association for Behavior Analysis (CalABA) writes:
“We applaud the efforts of the author and sponsors to increase access to behavioral health services for individuals with autism and their families, but believe that the current language has negative unintended consequences. As written, this bill significantly alters the eligibility requirements for practitioners serving this vulnerable population. We believe that many of the issues raised through this legislation can, and should, be addressed through legislation providing a comprehensive licensing framework for individual providing these services. Without sufficient minimum standards to practice competently in place, consumers will be at increasing risk of the erosion of quality of service.”
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Health Committee: | 8-0 |
POSITIONS
Support:
Dir/Floortime Coalition of California (Sponsor)
California Psychological Association
Cherry Crisp Entertainment and Productions
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
Professional Child Development Associates
The Interdisciplinary Council on Development and Learning
The Newton Center for Affect Regulation
(144 individuals)
Oppose:
America's Health Insurance Plans (AHIP); California Association for Behavior Analysis;
Association of California Life & Health Insurance Companies
California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber Of Commerce
-- END --
Weitlauf AS, et al, “Therapies for Children with Autism Spectrum Disorder: Behavioral Interventions Update.” Comparative Effectiveness Review No. 137. ↑
“Findings and Conclusions: National Standards Project, Phase 2: Addressing the Need for Evidence-based Practice Guidelines for Autism Spectrum Disorder,” National Autism Center, 2015, p. 72 ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
BILL NO: SB 163
AUTHOR: | Portantino | ||
VERSION: | January 24, 2019 | ||
HEARING DATE: | April 3, 2019 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Teri Boughton | ||
SUBJECT: Healthcare coverage: pervasive developmental disorder or autism
SUMMARY:
Expands the definition of behavioral health treatment (BHT) and expands the provider qualifications to include more provider types that can provide BHT under the mandate that health plans and insurers cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. Prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by a qualified autism services provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Department of Managed Health Care (DMHC) to regulate health plans under the Knox-Keene Health Care Services Plan Act of 1975; the California Department of Insurance (CDI) to regulate health and other insurers; Covered California as California’s health benefit exchange for individual and small business purchasers as authorized under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA); and, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to administer the Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1340, et seq., INS §106, et seq., GOV §100500 -100522, and WIC §14000, et seq.]
- Establishes as California's essential health benefits (EHBs) benchmark the Kaiser Small Group Health Maintenance Organization, existing California mandates, and ten ACA mandated benefits, which include BHT. [HSC §1367.005 and INS §10112.27]
- Requires every health plan contract that provides hospital, medical, or surgical coverage and health insurance policy to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism. Requires the coverage to be provided in the same manner and to be subject to the same requirements as provided in California’s mental health parity law. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Defines BHT for purposes of 3) above as professional services and treatment programs, including applied behavior analysis (ABA) and evidence-based intervention programs, that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism and that meet specified criteria regarding the treatment plan, the professionals who can prescribe and supervise treatment, and administer a treatment plan. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Exempts from 3) above a specialized health plan or health insurance policy that does not deliver mental health or behavioral health services to enrollees, or an accident only, specified disease, hospital indemnity, or Medicare supplement policy, a health plan contract or health insurance policy under Medi-Cal program. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Provides that 3) above does not affect services for which an individual is eligible pursuant to the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Act, or reduce any obligation to provide services under an individualized education program, individual services plan, or under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act and its implementing regulations, as specified. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires every health plan or health insurer subject to 3) above to maintain an adequate network that includes qualified autism services (QAS) providers who supervise or employ QAS professionals or paraprofessionals who provide and administer BHT. [HSC §1374.73 and INS §10144.51]
- Requires, only to the extent required by the federal government and effective no sooner than required by the federal government, BHT to be a covered Medi-Cal service for individuals under 21 years of age. [WIC §14132.56]
- Defines BHT for purposes of Medi-Cal as professional services and treatment programs, including ABA and evidence-based intervention programs that develop or restore, to the maximum extent practicable, the functioning of an individual with pervasive developmental disorder or autism, and are administered by DHCS as described in the approved state plan. [WIC §14132.56]
- Defines, under the California Early Intervention Services Act, evidence-based practice as a decision making process which integrates the best available scientifically rigorous research, clinical expertise, and individual’s characteristics. Evidence-based practice is an approach to treatment rather than a specific treatment. Evidence-based practice promotes the collection, interpretation, integration, and continuous evaluation of valid, important, and applicable individual- or family-reported, clinically-observed, and research-supported evidence. The best available evidence, matched to infant or toddler circumstances and preferences, is applied to ensure the quality of clinical judgments and facilitates the most cost-effective care. [GOV §95021]
This bill:
- Expands the definition of “BHT”, to include:
- Programs based on behavioral, developmental, behavior-based, and other evidence-based models;
- Requires, when clinically appropriate, the intervention plan to include parent or caregiver participation that is individualized to the patient and that takes into account the ability of the parent or caregiver to participate in therapy sessions and other recommended activities; and,
- “Evidence-based practice” means a decision making process that integrates the best available scientifically rigorous research, clinical expertise, and individual’s characteristics. Evidence-based practice promotes the collection, interpretation, integration, and continuous evaluation of valued, important, and applicable individual- or family-reported, clinically observed, and research-supported evidence. The best available evidence, matched to consumer circumstances and preferences, is applied to ensure the quality of clinical judgement and facilitate the most cost-effective care.
- Revises the definition of “QAS provider” to include a person who is certified by the American National Standards Institute.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS professional” as follows, to:
- Require services to be consistent with the experience, training, or education of the professional;
- Allow a behavioral service provider who possesses a bachelor of arts or science degree and meets one of the following qualifications:
- One year of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider and 12 semester units from an accredited institution of higher learning in either ABA or clinical coursework in behavioral health;
- Two years of experience in designing or implementing BHT supervised by a QAS provider;
- A registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist, as specified, that may not supervise a QAS paraprofessional until the registered psychological assistant or registered psychologist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT;
- An associate clinical social worker registered with the Board of Behavioral Sciences, as specified, that may not supervise a QAS paraprofessional until the associate clinical social worker has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT;
- A registered associate marriage and family therapist with the Board of Behavioral Sciences, as specified, that may not supervise a QAS paraprofessional until the registered associate marriage and family therapist has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT;
- A registered associate professional clinical counselor with the Board of Behavioral Sciences, as specified, that may not supervise a QAS paraprofessional until the registered associate professional clinical counselor has obtained at least 500 hours of experience in designing or implementing BHT; or,
- An individual credentialed or certified by a national entity, including, but not limited to, the Behavior Analyst Certification Board, which is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute to provide ABA or BHT, which may include case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a QAS provider.
- Require a completed a background check performed by a Department of Justice approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Revises the criteria in the definition of “QAS paraprofessional” to delete that the individual can be unlicensed or uncertified, and:
- Add for other evidence-based BHT all of the following qualifications:
- An associate’s degree or completion of two years of study from an accredited college or university with coursework in a related field of study;
- 40 hours of training in the specific form of BHT developed by a QAS provider or QAS professional competent in the form of BHT to be practiced by the paraprofessional; and,
- Adequate education, training, and experience, as certified by a QAS provider.
- Allow an individual who is credentialed or certified in ABA or BHT for paraprofessionals or technicians by a national entity that is accredited by the National Commission for Certifying Agencies or the American National Standards Institute, and allow upon successful completion of the training and education necessary for certification or a credential, an applicant who is otherwise qualified under this bill, to provide treatment and implement services for up to 180 days while in the process of obtaining the certification or credential; and,
- Require a completed background check performed by a Department of Justice approved agency, with subsequent notification to the person’s employer, as specified.
- Add for other evidence-based BHT all of the following qualifications:
- Deletes an exemption for a health plan contract or health insurance policy in the Medi-Cal program from the requirement for health plans to cover BHT.
- Prohibits the setting, location, or time of treatment recommended by the QAS provider from being used as the only reason to deny or reduce coverage for medically necessary services. Requires the setting to be consistent with the standard of care for BHT. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to provide reimbursement for services delivered by school personnel pursuant to an enrollee’s individualized educational program for purpose of accessing educational services, unless otherwise required or permitted by federal and state law. States that this does not require a health plan or insurer to cover services rendered outside of the plan’s service area unless the services are urgently needed services, as defined, or unless the benefit plan expressly covers out-of-area services.
- States that parent or caregiver participation may be associated with greater improvements in functioning and should be encouraged, but prohibits the lack of parent or caregiver participation from being used as a basis for denying or reducing coverage of medically necessary services.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, too many Californians with autism are being denied coverage for physician and psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT. Current California law requires that health insurance cover all physician or psychologist prescribed evidence-based BHT for autism however in practice there are many hurdles to that goal. In most cases, coverage is only being offered for one form of BHT. Changes to the existing law are needed in order to ensure that Californians with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) will receive coverage for medically necessary treatments. The choice of treatment should be left up to the physician or psychologist in consultation with the patient and the patient’s family, not the insurance company or the state. This critical decision must be made by the clinician who knows the patient best. Evidence-based practice relies on the best clinical judgement of the clinician which cannot occur with only one choice of treatment. Children with ASD are a vulnerable population and deserve our protection. Paraprofessionals who serve this population need to be adequately educated and trained and have undergone a thorough background check before entering a child’s home.
- Background on autism spectrum disorder. According to the National Institute for Mental Health, ASD is a developmental disorder that affects communication and behavior. Although autism can be diagnosed at any age, it is said to be a “developmental disorder” because symptoms generally appear in the first two years of life. According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-5), a guide created by the American Psychiatric Association used to diagnose mental disorders, people with ASD have difficulty with communication and interaction with other people, restricted interests and repetitive behaviors, and symptoms that hurt the person’s ability to function properly in school, work, and other areas of life. Autism is known as a “spectrum” disorder because there is wide variation in the type and severity of symptoms people experience. ASD occurs in all ethnic, racial, and economic groups.
Although ASD can be a lifelong disorder, treatments and services can improve a person’s symptoms and ability to function. About one in 59 children has been identified with ASD according to estimates from Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s (CDC’s) Autism and Developmental Disabilities Monitoring Network. The California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP) estimates that in 2016, the prevalence of ASD in California children (aged 0 to 9 years) is about 160 in 10,000. This figure is close to the 2014 national prevalence estimates of 168 in 10,000 children aged eight years. Although U.S. surveys report a greater prevalence of ASD among white children than among black and Latino children, these estimates are known to be influenced by disparities in access to health care for diagnosis, data source (e.g., self-report, medical record review, etc.), and patient geographic location. In California, among those with ASD served by the Department of Developmental Services (DDS) (the largest California-specific dataset for ASD), Latinos outnumbered whites. Specifically, DDS reported that among those receiving DDS services for ASD, Latinos accounted for 37% of recipients, followed by whites (30%), Asians (9%), and blacks (7%) (DDS, 2018b). However, the proportion of individuals receiving DDS services who are enrollees in DMHC-regulated plans or CDI-regulated policies is unknown. The racial/ethnic distribution of children with ASD within the privately insured population is also unknown. - BHT. According to CHBRP, BHT aims to modify the behavior of individuals with ASD and improve their cognitive, language, and social functioning by assessing environmental stimuli and reinforcing appropriate responses. These services are generally delivered by QAS providers, professionals, and paraprofessionals. As illustrated below, BHT treatment can also be described as a continuum from treatment modalities based primarily on behavioral theory (often referred to as ABA) to treatments based primarily on developmental theory. Existing law explicitly requires coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on behavioral theory. This bill would amend existing law to explicitly require coverage for BHT treatment modalities based on developmental theory.
Continuum of Behavioral Theories and Treatment Modalities
Source: California Health Benefits Review Program, 2019.
- California Health Benefits Review Program (CHBRP) analysis. AB 1996 (Thomson, Chapter 795, Statutes of 2002) requests the University of California to assess legislation proposing a mandated benefit or service and prepare a written analysis with relevant data on the medical, economic, and public health impacts of proposed health plan and health insurance benefit mandate legislation. CHBRP was created in response to AB 1996, and reviewed this bill. Key findings include:
- Coverage impacts and enrollees covered. Currently, 100% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for modalities of BHT based on behavioral theory, 95% have coverage for hybrid modalities (behavioral and developmental), and 54% have coverage for modalities based on developmental theory. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill. Currently, 34% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for BHT that does not deny coverage for BHT based on lack of parental involvement. Additionally, 37% of enrollees currently have coverage for BHT regardless of the setting for the BHT. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill.
- Essential health benefits. For two reasons, this bill would not trigger financial costs to the state for exceeding EHBs. First, this bill alters the terms and conditions of an existing benefit mandate law, but does not require an additional benefit to be covered. Second, the current law that this bill would alter expressly indicates that it ceases to function if it exceeds EHBs and this bill does not eliminate this clause of the current law. Thus, neither the current law nor the version this bill would create would function if deemed to exceed EHBs.
- Medical effectiveness. Most studies of BHT are observational studies that compare a specific treatment modality to usual care. This makes it difficult to assess the relative effectiveness of modalities based on behavioral versus hybrid versus developmental theory. More studies of BHT modalities based on behavioral theory have been published than studies of BHT based on developmental theory or hybrid theories. However, regardless of the theoretical framework underpinning a BHT modality, most studies are observational studies which limits the ability to determine whether changes in outcomes experienced by people with ASD are due to receipt of the BHT modality the study assesses versus other factors that may affect outcomes. For the modalities based on behavioral theory or ABA:
- Coverage impacts and enrollees covered. Currently, 100% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for modalities of BHT based on behavioral theory, 95% have coverage for hybrid modalities (behavioral and developmental), and 54% have coverage for modalities based on developmental theory. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill. Currently, 34% of enrollees with health insurance that would be subject to this bill have coverage for BHT that does not deny coverage for BHT based on lack of parental involvement. Additionally, 37% of enrollees currently have coverage for BHT regardless of the setting for the BHT. Postmandate, 100% of enrollees would have coverage for BHT that is compliant with this bill.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Discrete Trials Training improves intelligence quotient and adaptive behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Pivotal Response Training improves language and communication.
For modalities based on both behavioral and developmental theory (NDBI):
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Early Start Denver Model improves language.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that Social Skills Group therapy improves social behavior.
- There is limited evidence that Project ImPACT improves communication.
For modalities based on developmental theory (DSPM):
- There is a preponderance of evidence that DIR®/ Floortime™ improves communication, engagement, and relationships.
- There is a preponderance of evidence that TEACCH improves adaptive behavior and motor skills.
- There is limited evidence that Relationship Developmental Intervention improves communication, social interaction, and academic placement.
Although parent and caregiver involvement in BHT may result in greater improvements, BHT improves outcomes regardless of whether parents or caregivers are involved. There is a preponderance of evidence that BHT can be delivered effectively in multiple settings.
- Utilization. Currently, the average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD is 127.0. The change in the definition of BHT may alter the mix of used modalities, but is not expected to alter the total number of hours used. However, CHBRP projects an increase in BHT utilization due to this bill’s prohibition of denials related to parent/caregiver involvement and denials related to treatment setting, time, or location. Since BHT is most commonly used by children with ASD who are under eight years old, CHBRP projects that the increase in average annual number of hours of BHT will derive from an increase in the moderate users of BHT (10-25 hours per week) in that age range. Each provision will separately increase the overall usage hours of BHT among enrollees with ASD under eight years. Combined, they will raise the overall average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD to 129.1 hours.
- Impact on expenditures. This bill would increase total net annual expenditures (premiums and enrollee expenses for covered and noncovered benefits) by $4,317,000 (0.0027%) for enrollees with DMHC-regulated plans and CDI-regulated policies.
- Public health. Enrollees with ASD who already use BHT would increase their utilization by an average of 2.1 hours per year per BHT user in 2020. Based on the evidence, CHBRP finds that such an increase would not likely have a public health impact in the first year, postmandate. However, the increase in BHT hours may improve BHT outcomes such as intelligence quotient, language skills, socialization, and adaptive behaviors on an individual basis for some persons with ASD.
- Utilization. Currently, the average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD is 127.0. The change in the definition of BHT may alter the mix of used modalities, but is not expected to alter the total number of hours used. However, CHBRP projects an increase in BHT utilization due to this bill’s prohibition of denials related to parent/caregiver involvement and denials related to treatment setting, time, or location. Since BHT is most commonly used by children with ASD who are under eight years old, CHBRP projects that the increase in average annual number of hours of BHT will derive from an increase in the moderate users of BHT (10-25 hours per week) in that age range. Each provision will separately increase the overall usage hours of BHT among enrollees with ASD under eight years. Combined, they will raise the overall average annual hours of BHT per 1,000 enrollees with ASD to 129.1 hours.
- Task Force. The Autism Advisory Task Force was established pursuant to SB 946 (Steinberg, Chapter 650, Statutes of 2011) to make recommendations to inform state policymaking and develop recommendations regarding the education, training, and experience requirements that unlicensed individuals providing autism services shall meet in order to secure a license from the state. A guiding principle of the task force was that every individual with autism or pervasive developmental disorder is unique. According to the task force report, individuals have different combinations of characteristics, different needs for assistance, and respond differently to treatment. Therefore, behavioral health interventions need to be highly individualized. Since treatment selection should be made by a team of individuals who can consider the unique needs and history of the individual with autism or pervasive developmental disorder, the task force determined that it would not be informative to state policy makers to merely develop a list of behavioral health treatments that are determined to be effective, based solely on current scientific literature. Since scientific research and findings naturally advance, the task force determined that the choice of behavioral health treatment should be grounded in scientific evidence, clinical practice guidelines, and/or evidence-based practice.
- Providers should be licensed. The task force report concludes that all "top level" providers should be licensed by the state, and set forth a process for establishing a new professional license for "Licensed Behavioral Health Practitioner." The task force recommended that the license requirement not take effect until three years after the license is established, and an interim commission be formed to implement the new license until a board is able to do so. The task force also recommended all providers of autism services be registered with the state's TrustLine Registry or comparable system as a condition of employment by service organizations and contracting with health plans and health insurers. TrustLine uses the criminal history background check system to check the fingerprints of applicants, and checks for evidence of additional criminal records.
- Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Human Services Committee.
- Related legislation. SB 11 (Beall) would require on-formulary, lowest tier coverage of prescription medications approved by the FDA for treatment of substance use disorders. SB 11 is set for hearing on April 24, 2019 in this Committee.
SB 583(Jackson) would expand coverage for clinical trials to include a clinical trial relating to the prevention, detection, or treatment of a life-threatening disease or condition, as defined, and include a trial funded by, among others, a qualified nongovernmental research entity. SB 583 is set for hearing on April 24, 2019 in this Committee.
SB 600 (Portantino) would clarify coverage for standard fertility preservation services when a medically necessary treatment may cause iatrogenic infertility to an enrollee or insured. SB 600 is set for hearing on April 24, 2019 in this Committee.
SB 746 (Bates) would require that coverage for chemotherapy or radiation therapy for the treatment of cancer includes coverage for anticancer medical devices. SB 746 is set for hearing on April 24, 2019 in this Committee.
AB 598(Bloom) would require coverage for hearing aids, as defined, for an enrollee or insured under 18 years of age, as specified. AB 598 has not been set yet in the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 651 (Grayson) would require when an the enrollee, insured, or subscriber receives covered services from a noncontracting air ambulance provider, to pay no more than the same cost sharing that the enrollee, insured, or subscriber would pay for the same covered services received from a contracting air ambulance provider. AB 651 has not been set yet in the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 744 (Aguiar-Curry) would require reimbursement of a healthcare provider for the diagnosis, consultation, or treatment of an enrollee, subscriber, insured, or policyholder delivered through telehealth services on the same basis and to the same extent as the same service provided through in-person diagnosis, consultation, or treatment. AB 744 is set for in the Assembly Health Committee on April 23, 2019.
AB 767(Wicks) would require coverage for in vitro fertilization, as a treatment of infertility, and mature oocyte cryopreservation. AB 767 is set for in the Assembly Health Committee on April 23, 2019.
AB 993 would allow health plans to include HIV specialists as eligible primary care providers (PCPs), if the provider requests PCP status and meets the health insurer’s eligibility criteria. AB 993 is set for hearing on April 9, 2019 in the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 1246 (Limon) would require large group health insurance policies to include coverage for medically necessary basic health care services and, to the extent the policy covers prescription drugs, coverage for medically necessary prescription drugs. AB 651 has not been set yet in the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 1611(Chiu) would require provide that if an enrollee or insured receives covered services from a noncontracting hospital, the enrollee or insured is prohibited from paying more than the same cost sharing that the enrollee or insured would pay for the same covered services received from a contracting hospital. AB 1611 is set for in the Assembly Health Committee on April 23, 2019.
AB 1676 (Maienschein) would require coverage for a telehealth consultation program that provides providers who treat children and pregnant and postpartum persons with access to a psychiatrist, as specified, in order to more quickly diagnose and treat children and pregnant and postpartum persons suffering from mental illness. AB 1676 is set for in the Assembly Health Committee on April 23, 2019.
- Prior legislation. SB 399 (Portantino of 2018) revises existing requirements on health care service plans (health plans) and health insurers to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, such as allowing the substitution of specified current education, work experience, and training qualifications to meet the criteria of a QAS professional or paraprofessional. Prohibits a health plan and health insurer from denying or reducing medically necessary BHT based on a lack of parent or caregiver participation, or on the setting, location, or time of treatment, as specified. SB 399 was vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message, the Governor states: “This bill would revise qualification standards for providers of BHT for individuals with autism. Standards for autism providers were updated last year. I'm not inclined to revise them again.”
AB 1074 (Maienschein, Chapter 385, Statutes of 2017) permits a QAS paraprofessional to be supervised by a QAS professional; indicates that behavioral health treatment may include clinical case management and case supervision under the direction and supervision of a QAS provider, deletes a requirement that a behavioral service provider is approved as a vendor by a Regional Center based on provider definitions in specified regulations; and instead requires a behavioral service provider to meet the education and experience qualifications described in the specified regulations; and, makes other technical changes.
AB 796 (Nazarian, Chapter 493, Statutes of 2016) eliminates the sunset date on the health insurance mandate to cover behavioral health treatment for pervasive developmental disorder or autism.
SB 1034 (Mitchell of 2016) would have eliminated the sunset date on the health insurance mandate to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, and made other revisions to the law such as prohibiting denials for medically necessary behavioral health treatment based on the setting, location or time of the treatment. SB 1034 was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
AB 1715 (Holden of 2016) would have established the Behavior Analyst Act (Act), which provides for the licensure, registration, and regulation of behavior analysts and assistant behavior analysts, and requires the California Board of Psychology, until January 1, 2022, to administer and enforce the Act. Hearing canceled at the request of the author in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
SB 479 (Bates of 2015) would have established the Behavior Analyst Act, which provided for the licensure, registration, and regulation of behavior analysts and assistant behavior analysts, and required the California Board of Psychology, until January 1, 2021, to administer and enforce the Act. SB 479 was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
AB 2041 (Jones of 2014) would have required that a regional center classify a vendor as a behavior management consultant or behavior management assistant if the vendor designs or implements evidence-based BHT, has a specified amount of experience in designing or implementing that treatment, and meets other licensure and education requirements. AB 2041 would have required DDS to amend its regulations as necessary to implement the provisions of the bill. AB 2041 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
SB 126 (Steinberg, Chapter 680, Statutes of 2013) extends, until January 1, 2017, the sunset date of an existing state health benefit mandate that requires health plans and health insurance policies to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism and requires plans and insurers to maintain adequate networks of these service providers.
SB 946 (Steinberg, Chapter 650, Statutes of 2011) requires health plans and health insurance policies to cover BHT for pervasive developmental disorder or autism, requires health plans and insurers to maintain adequate networks of autism service providers, establishes a task force in DMHC, sunsets the autism mandate provisions on July 1, 2014, and makes other technical changes to existing law regarding HIV reporting and mental health services payments.
SB 770 (Steinberg of 2010) would have required health plans and insurance policies to provide coverage for BHT. SB 770 was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
SB 166 (Steinberg of 2011) would have required health care service plans licensed by DMHC and health insurers licensed by CDI to provide coverage for BHT for autism. Hearing was canceled at the request of the author in the Senate Health Committee.
AB 1205 (Berryhill of 2011) would have required the Board of Behavioral Sciences to license behavioral analysts and assistant behavioral analysts, on and after January 1, 2015, and included standards for licensure such as specified higher education and training, fieldwork, passage of relevant examinations, and national board accreditation. AB 1205 was held on the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
- Support. According to the DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (Coalition) this bill will help families in need of evidence-based BHT by allowing health professionals already California licensed or registered under the provisions of the Business and Professions Code (Registered Psychological Assistant, Associate Clinical Social Worker, Associate Marriage and Family Therapist, and Associate Professional Clinical Counselor) to be covered for providing medically necessary, physician prescribed, evidence-based BHT under strict supervision. Many of these professionals are already providing services to developmentally disabled children through the regional center system. Paraprofessionals currently under Title 17 regulations must possess a minimum of a high school equivalency and 30 hours of ABA training. In order to foster greater consumer protection of a vulnerable population, this bill increases these requirements for BHT other than ABA by imposing a minimum standard of an Associate Degree or its equivalent and 40 hours of training developed and administered by a QAS Provider.
Additionally, the Coalition indicates that parents across the state are also being denied coverage for BHT based on their particular circumstances, circumstances beyond their control. The strain of raising a child on the Spectrum often tears marriages apart. Single parent households are all too common. Yet insurance companies deny coverage if working single parents who cannot attend all therapy sessions do not fully participate in their child’s treatment. Similarly, since children often cannot travel to the therapist, therapy must be done at the child’s location. This could be an after-school, on school site, daycare setting. Yet because it is at a school site, insurance companies can and do deny coverage even though the prescribed treatment is medically necessary and not education related. Similarly, far too often, insurance companies interrupt precious school time by requiring BHT during school hours. Questions regarding parental participation and the location, time and setting of treatment are important. The Coalition recognizes and agrees that parental participation is an important and vital component of any BHT, but also recognizes that medically necessary health coverage should not be withheld simply on the basis of the parent’s inability to fully participate or the child’s location. Again, if insurance coverage is denied for these reasons it forces the parent to seek coverage from their regional center. This bill requires the treatment plan to maximize the individual parent’s ability to participate. It also requires the setting, time and location of treatment to be determined in advance by the QAS Provider directing care. While the Coalition would never advocate selection of a form of therapy solely on costs, in the short term, alternative forms of evidence-based BHT are almost always less expensive than ABA. In the long term, forcing an inappropriate form of therapy on a child will guarantee that the therapy will be needed for a much longer period of time. Insurance companies are rightly concerned about the long-term cost of providing expensive BHT. By providing the appropriate form of therapy, the effectiveness of the therapy will be increased, the duration of that therapy will be reduced, and long-term costs lowered. - Opposition. According to the California Association of Health Plans (CAHP), this bill significantly expands California’s existing behavioral health coverage requirement by mandating autism services be provided at “any time or location,” and “ignores current medical literature’s recommendations and best practices” by creating a new definition for evidenced-based care. Health plans currently cover evidenced based autism services to enrollees that require care. Health plans are also required to meet network adequacy and time and distance standards that are enforced by DMHC. CHBRP estimates that this bill will increase costs by $4,317,000. For autism services, ABA is an evidenced treatment. Expanding health plans services to incorporate the patient or caregivers’ preferences into treatment determinations is counter-intuitive of evidenced-based practice principles. Modifications to the provider requirements in the bill will decrease the quality of care by expanding who can qualify as a provider. Maintaining affordable premiums is critical as policymakers strive to decrease the number of uninsured Californians. This is not the time for new benefit mandates that drive up the cost of care.
The California Chamber of Commerce believes it is appropriate for issuers to make coverage for ABA contingent upon caregiver participation since research on the effectiveness of ABA shows unequivocally that it is critical to the success of the treatment. In addition, this bill could result in the shift of costs from schools to the private insurance market, and the potential cost of this bill must be considered in context as state lawmakers have introduced at least 14 other benefit mandate bills this year that could increase premiums for employers and enrollees. With the significant cost pressures already facing California businesses, the uncertainty in health care policy at the federal level, as well as the 2019 premium increase in excess of 8% and the cumulative increase of over 42% over the last 5 years, California should not increase costs of health care coverage for employers and enrollees.
- Policy Comment.
- Multiple Mandates and Market uncertainty. California’s existing coverage mandates including EHB already provide very comprehensive benefit coverage. The Committee will be hearing multiple bills this year that will have small to large relative impacts on health insurance premiums. This bill is one of six Senate Bills to be considered. While many policy arguments can be made to advance all of these bills, committee members may also wish to consider the cumulative effect of these bills and the tradeoffs associated with increasing health insurance premiums in the context of the already high cost of health insurance, another potential restructuring of health insurance markets nationally and in California because of actions taking place at the federal level to repeal the ACA, and in consideration of the Governor’s budget proposal, and other legislation, to provide state financial assistance and to require Californians to purchase health insurance.
- Provider standards. This bill includes extensive provisions about criteria for professionals and paraprofessionals who may provide BHT. It is important to remember that the provisions of law that this bill amends are health insurance mandate provisions and not necessarily intended to address provider industry standards. The SB 946 task force recommended the establishment of a professional license for behavioral health practitioners which may be a more appropriate mechanism for developing and implementing such standards.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: DIR/Floortime Coalition of California (sponsor)
California Psychological Association
Cherry Crisp Entertainment and Productions
Golden Steps Pediatric Therapy
Greenhouse Therapy Center
Newton Center for Affect Regulation
Professional Child Development Associates
Over 150 Individuals
Oppose: California Association of Health Plans
California Chamber of Commerce
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):