SB 189: Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-06-17
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | August 30 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 17, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | Referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2019 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 1, 2019 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | April 29 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jan 31, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 2. |
| Jan 30, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB189 Monning et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 189
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:June 17, 2019
Policy Committee: | Local Government | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the sunset date for the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) for two years, until June 30, 2022, alters its powers and responsibilities with a re-focus on winding down the affairs of the agency, outlines a limited set of powers and duties for a reconstituted board, and further details the FORA dissolution process.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- In fiscal year 2018-19, FORA received $2.8 million in local property tax revenues diverted from other local entities, including 15% of that amount from local schools. Extending FORA’s sunset by two years would result in increased General Fund expenditures of $420,000 annually over that period to offset, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees, the continued diversions from the local school share of property taxes to FORA.
- Extending FORA’s sunset will allow FORA to continue to collect, for two additional years, local property tax revenues, the Community Facilities District (CFD) tax and other fees from affected local agencies, particularly the cities of Marina and Seaside. Absent this bill, local agencies would otherwise retain those revenues for local purposes, including providing affordable housing.
- No reimbursable state mandate costs. The bill places new duties on the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) to implement FORA’s transition plan, but LAFCO operating costs are generally split among constituent local agencies. LAFCO itself is not eligible for mandate reimbursement, and the local agencies that support LAFCO activities can recover any increased costs through planning fees.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
When the [Fort Ord Military] base was closed in 1994, the California State Legislature established FORA to complete the planning, financing, and management of the former Fort Ord facility as described in the 1997 Reuse Plan developed by FORA.
FORA needs two additional years to allow local jurisdictions to implement adequate funding mechanisms to support projects identified in the FORA Transition Plan, as well as to ensure contracts are established for all Transition Plan Implementing Agreements. SB 189 will ensure that there will be no gap in funding for vital regional projects and obligations subject to the FORA Transition Plan once FORA is dissolved.
- Background. Established in 1917, Ford Ord closed in 1994 during the federal Base Realignment and Closure process. The base comprised 45-square miles in northwest Monterey County and included land within the City of Seaside, the City of Marina, and the unincorporated areas of Monterey County. The cities of Del Rey Oaks, Monterey and Sand City abutted the base.
Existing law establishes FORA, which is tasked with adopting a Fort Ord Reuse Plan (SB 899, Mello, 1994). FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997. The Final Base Reuse Plan for Fort Ord lays out the future land uses for the former Army base, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, public uses and open space. FORA has a governing body of 13 voting members and 11 non-voting members comprised of representatives from cities, Monterey County, special districts, public educational institutions, the military, and state and federal legislators. State law tasks FORA with completing the planning, financing and implementation of the base reuse plan.
FORA revenues are derived from multiple sources, including membership dues from the entities with representation on its board, a local Communities Facilities District (CFD) tax (which is only paid when developers pull building permits), and property tax revenues received as pass through payments from city and county redevelopment (RDA) successor agencies related to project areas within FORA’s boundaries, among others. Existing law specifies that when FORA dissolves, the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would be used to service specified debt incurred by the authority, with the remainder divided as follows: 54% to city or county RDAs, 38% to the county, and 8% to other affected tax agencies.
Initially, the state laws authorizing FORA were to become inoperative either when the board determined that 80% of the territory designated for development or reuse in the base reuse plan had been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2014, whichever occurred first. The Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) would have been responsible for ensuring FORA’s orderly dissolution. However, lawsuits, unexpected challenges relating to munitions removal and the economic downturn impeded FORA's ability to implement the base reuse plan by the original sunset date. By 2012, the base reuse plan was only 20% complete.
AB 1614 (Monning), Chapter 743, Statutes of 2012, extended FORA’s sunset date until June 30, 2020. AB 1614 required FORA’s board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first.
FORA's board voted to approve a transition plan in December 2018. In particular, the transition plan addresses the remaining regional issues of roads, water, habitat conservation and ordinance remediation. Local officials indicate local jurisdictions are finalizing implementation agreements that enable cooperative transition and allow FORA to sunset on June 30, 2020.
- Arguments in Support. The City of Monterey, in support, writes:
The City of Monterey supports a temporary extension of the legislation with the understanding of defining a timed hand over of responsibilities to newly formed joint power agencies between communities and (a) successor agency…FORA was created as a multi-jurisdictional agency with the objective to jointly develop a vacated military base. The fees generated on the land were calculated to attribute individual responsibilities to our communities in order to improve the overall economic and social health of our region. The County, the cities of Marina and Seaside have already accomplished a great deal with the help and support of the other jurisdictions including CSU Monterey Bay – it is now time to allow Monterey and Del Rey Oaks to take their turns.
- Arguments in Opposition. The City of Marina, in opposition, writes:
The cities of Marina and Seaside are expected to fund projects established by the FORA board located largely outside their jurisdictions and which show little, if any, benefit on regional traffic impacts and water augmentation, both critical concerns. In just the last five years, FORA has captured and spent more than $50 million generated form land sales and development fees from developments in the City of Marina on nonsensical priorities established by the FORA Board and divesting Marina of funds necessary for critical infrastructure within Marina’s Fort Ord footprint.
In this same five-year period, FORA did nothing to prioritize or allocate funds to remove the remaining 588 blighted and dilapidated military structures in Marina which are adjacent to and surround our high school, homes and parks. These structures are in plain sight, full of hazardous asbestos and lead, and are routinely slept in by the homeless. These estimated cost of removal is more that $35 million; monies Marina is unable to generate with the continuation of FOR A and diversion of funds.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 189
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:June 17, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution.
SUMMARY: Extends the repeal date for the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) for two years and makes a number of changes to FORA’s governing statutes to wind down the agency. Specifically, this bill:
- Extends FORA’s operations until June 30, 2022, and alters FORA’s composition, powers and duties, beginning on July 1, 2020, as follows:
- Alters FORA’s member agencies by eliminating the cities of Carmel, Sand City, Pacific Grove, and Salinas and retaining the County of Monterey (Monterey County) and the cities of Del Rey Oaks, Marina, Monterey, and Seaside;
- Makes the following changes to the FORA Board of Directors (Board):
- Reduces the 13-member Board to five members, eliminating seats for the cities of Carmel, Sand City, Pacific Grove, and Salinas, and removes weighted votes for the cities of Marina and Seaside (two votes each), and Monterey County (three votes). The reconstituted Board consists of Monterey County and the cities of Del Rey Oaks, Marina, Monterey, and Seaside, each with one vote;
- Requires a vote of a majority of the total membership of the Board to pass or act upon any matter properly before the Board, and requires each member of the Board to have one vote;
- Removes all ex officio nonvoting members except representatives designated by the United States (US) Army and the Chancellor of the California State University (CSU), and adds a representative designated by the Marina Coast Water District;
- Eliminates the Board’s authority to appoint or remove ex officio nonvoting members, and to appoint additional advisory committees to provide the Board with analysis;
- Eliminates fees that member agencies and non-voting members pay to FORA;
- Makes the following changes to FORA’s planning and development powers and duties:
- Prohibits additions to the Fort Ord Reuse Plan (Reuse Plan), including the capital improvement program (CIP);
- Eliminates the following:
- Requirements that: each county or city with territory occupied by Fort Ord submit to the Board its general plan or amendments to it; these plans satisfy specified conditions; and, the Board certify portions of the general plan applicable to the territory of Fort Ord for purposes of consistency with the Reuse Plan;
- A requirement that the county and cities submit zoning ordinances and other zoning actions to the Board for approval;
- Rules governing changes to the Reuse Plan that affect territory in only one member agency’s jurisdiction;
- Provisions prohibiting a county or city from approving development projects or changes of use within the area of Fort Ord that are not consistent with Reuse Plan, related Board oversight over development projects, and the Board’s authority to charge fees related to Reuse Plan change reviews;
- The Board’s responsibility to prepare environment impact reports (EIRs) for the Reuse Plan in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA);
- A provision allowing the Board to construct or otherwise act to improve a local public capital facility only with the consent of the city or county with land use authority over the area where the facility is or will be located;
- A provision allowing a city or county or a local redevelopment agency (RDA) to construct or otherwise act to improve a basewide public capital facility only with the consent of the Board;
- Provisions related to the transfer of the Fritzsche Army Airfield to the City of Marina, and the transfer of Army golf courses to the City of Seaside; and,
- Eliminates the Board’s authority to issue bonds to finance basewide public facilities.
- Enacts the following provisions from July 1, 2020, until June 30, 2022, to wind down FORA:
- Requires, by June 30, 2022, FORA to negotiate and secure successor agencies to implement all obligations under the transition plan;
- Alters a requirement that the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) provide for the orderly dissolution of FORA by specifying that this action occur once an agreement with a successor agency has been finalized;
- Requires, upon dissolution of FORA, all remaining Community Facilities District (CFD) revenues to be transferred to Monterey County;
- Requires Monterey County to disburse CFD revenues to each underlying land use jurisdiction on a pro rata basis, based on the source of the revenue or another equitable method that Monterey County determines is reasonable;
- Requires, if FORA has any remaining outstanding debt at the time of its dissolution, property tax revenues to continue to be paid to Monterey County in accordance with provisions governing the Redevelopment Agency of Fort Ord (RAFO) related to the distribution of tax increment revenue upon FORA’s dissolution, as specified. Upon this retirement of debt or FORA’s dissolution, whichever occurs later, any remaining property tax revenues shall be transferred to the auditor-controller of Monterey County for appropriate distribution;
- Provides that, if Monterey County succeeds to any FORA financial obligation as a result of the disbursement of remaining revenues or the retirement of debt, this obligation shall not constitute a debt or liability of the county, or any other member agency, but shall be payable solely from the remaining revenues provided for purposes of that obligation in the transition plan; and,
- Allows Monterey County, before disbursing revenues as provided in this bill, to deduct an amount equal to the reasonable cost of administering this bill out of remaining FORA revenues to be disbursed.
- Provides that, on and after July 1, 2020, all of the following shall apply:
- FORA may do all of the following:
- Implement the transition plan;
- Manage the CFD boundaries;
- Make appropriate revisions to the boundaries of the CFD established by the Board as replacement funding mechanisms are created by underlying land use jurisdictions pursuant to b), below. Revisions shall be made by filing an amended map of the CFD;
- Collect and disburse CFD revenues;
- Collect and disburse property tax revenues;
- Disburse CFD and property tax revenues for the purposes of the habitat conservation plan, transportation, transit, and water supply pursuant to the FORA Act, as specified;
- Continue as the local reuse authority for purposes of the federal government and property transfers, including receipt of federal grant funding; and,
- Ensure that all pledges, contracts, or obligated payments are funded and appropriately carried out;
- Allows any underlying land use jurisdiction to adopt a substitute funding mechanism in lieu of the CFD established by the Board, in which case the Board shall adjust the boundaries of the CFD accordingly;
- Requires an underlying land use jurisdiction that adopts a substitute funding mechanism pursuant to this bill to commit, either in that substitute funding mechanism or otherwise in a written agreement, to continue funding regional needs in the former Fort Ord on a pro rata basis, to FORA’s satisfaction. For purposes of this requirement, “regional needs” includes, but is not limited to, habitat conservation, transportation, transit, and water supply augmentation; and,
- Requires the transition plan adopted by the Board for organizational changes to be exempt from CEQA, as specified.
- FORA may do all of the following:
- Finds and declares that the transition plan, adopted by FORA, will ensure that ongoing, mandated requirements continue to be funded and addressed within the region covered by FORA, which will collect and distribute revenue for the limited environmental and infrastructure mission.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes FORA and vests it with various responsibilities for the reuse of the former Ford Ord military base, including collecting and disbursing revenue and overseeing land use decisions on the base, and provides the FORA board with specific powers to carry out these responsibilities, including the ability to override certain land use changes.
- Provides the FORA Board the authority to levy assessments, reassessments, or special taxes, and issue bonds to finance public facilities, including CFD taxes pursuant to the Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act.
- Allows FORA to receive property tax revenues as pass through payments from city and county RDA successor agencies related to project areas within FORA’s boundaries.
- Specifies that, when FORA dissolves, the property tax revenues allocated to FORA will be used to service specified debt incurred by FORA, with the remainder divided as follows: 54% to city or county RDAs, 38% to the county, and 8% to other affected tax agencies.
- Authorizes FORA to operate until the Board determines that 80% of the territory that is designated for development or reuse in the Reuse Plan has been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2020, whichever occurs first.
- Requires FORA’s Board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill contains:
- Unknown, potentially significant increase in General Fund expenditures, likely in the low hundreds of thousands in 2020-21 and 2021-22. Absent the bill, a portion of the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would likely be reallocated to local school entities, beginning in 2020-21. This shift in property tax revenues from FORA to schools would result in a commensurate decrease in General Fund spending, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees. Extending FORA’s sunset by two years would result in increased General Fund expenditures over that period to offset continued diversions from the local school share of property taxes to FORA.
- No reimbursable state mandate costs. The bill places new duties on the Monterey County LAFCO to implement FORA’s transition plan, but LAFCO operating costs are generally split among constituent local agencies. LAFCO itself is not eligible for mandate reimbursement, and the local agencies that support LAFCO activities can recover any increased costs through planning fees.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Established in 1917, Ford Ord closed in 1994 during the federal Base Realignment and Closure process. The base comprised an area of about 44 square miles in northwest Monterey County. Of these 28,000 acres, 4,100 acres were within the City of Seaside, 3,400 acres were within the City of Marina, and 20,000 acres were within unincorporated areas of Monterey County. The cities of Del Rey Oaks, Monterey, and Sand City abutted the base.
When the closure was announced, including a desire of the federal government to hand over the land to a single entity, local agencies attempted to form a Joint Powers Agency to accept and manage the former base lands. However, these efforts stalled. With rapidly approaching land transfers scheduled for April of 1994, SB 899 (Mello), Chapter 64, Statutes of 1994, created FORA to facilitate the transfer and reuse of the former military base. SB 899 established FORA’s powers, duties, jurisdiction, governance structure, and other matters. FORA’s original members included Monterey County and the cities of Carmel, Del Rey Oaks, Marina, Sand City, Monterey, Pacific Grove, Salinas, and Seaside. Each member agency was allotted one seat on the FORA Board, with the exceptions of Monterey County (three seats) and the cities of Marina and Seaside (two seats each).
SB 899 required the FORA Board to prepare, adopt, review, revise from time to time, and maintain a plan for the future use and development of the former base. This Reuse Plan was required to contain the following elements: land use, transportation, conservation, recreation, and a CIP that included the identification of base-wide facilities and local facilities. SB 899 also allowed FORA to use a number of financing mechanisms, including the creation of a CFD via the Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act. SB 899 also authorized the FORA Board to establish an RDA. (RAFO was eventually created via SB 1600 (Mello), Chapter 1169, Statutes of 1994.) SB 899 vested FORA with additional powers and duties to carry out its mission.
SB 899 provided that FORA was to become inoperative when the FORA Board determined that 80% of the Fort Ord territory designated for development or reuse in the Reuse Plan had been developed or reused, or June 30, 2014, whichever occurred first. The bill contained a repeal date of January 1, 2015. SB 899 also required the Monterey County LAFCO to “provide for the orderly dissolution of the authority including ensuring that all contracts, agreements, and pledges to pay or repay money entered into by the authority are honored and properly administered, and that all assets of the authority are appropriately transferred.”
FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997. This plan lays out the future land uses for the 45-square mile former Army base, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, public uses, and open space.
- First FORA Extension. As FORA neared its original sunset, AB 1614 (Monning), Chapter 743, Statutes of 2012, was introduced. According to the Assembly Local Government Committee analysis of AB 1614, “Delay and restrictions are probably the most important and costly factors affecting reuse of the former Fort Ord. The biggest unforeseen problem that was encountered was a regional community interest lawsuit against the Army regarding its munitions removal processing, which delayed property transfers for five years. This caused the delay of early project approvals and resulted in all of the reuse projects being subjected to the economic recession of the past decade. Other factors contributing to the goals of FORA’s recovery not being met were that the scope of the munitions and explosives remediation was greater and more costly than anticipated, and that federal and state Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) approval delays precluded progress. The current economic cycle is further exacerbating the delay. Due to all of these circumstances, FORA’s June 30, 2014, sunset date, which anticipated that 80% of the reuse recovery plan would be completed, cannot be achieved. Fort Ord reuse is currently 17-20% complete – not near the expected 80%.”
AB 1614 extended FORA’s operative date to June 30, 2020, and its repeal date to January 1, 2021. It also required the FORA Board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO on or before December 30, 2018, and required the transition plan to assign assets and liabilities, designate responsible successor agencies, and provide a schedule of remaining obligations.
FORA’s Board voted to approve a transition plan in December 2018. This transition plan assigns FORA’s assets and liabilities in the event it dissolves. Despite the upcoming sunset of FORA, only 40% to 50% of the territory designated for development has been developed or reused.
- Bill Summary and Author’s Statement. This bill extends FORA for two additional years, alters its powers and responsibilities with a re-focus on winding down the affairs of the agency, outlines a limited set of powers for the reconstituted Board, and further details the FORA dissolution process.
According to the author, “Since its establishment in 1917, the Fort Ord Military Base has been an integral part of the Monterey Bay region’s economy. When the base was closed in 1994, the California State Legislature established FORA to complete the planning, financing, and management of the former Fort Ord facility as described in the 1997 Reuse Plan developed by FORA.
“FORA needs two additional years to allow local jurisdictions to implement adequate funding mechanisms to support projects identified in the FORA Transition Plan, as well as to ensure contracts are established for all Transition Plan Implementing Agreements. SB 189 will ensure that there will be no gap in funding for vital regional projects and obligations subject to the FORA Transition Plan once FORA is dissolved.”
This bill is sponsored by the author.
- Arguments in Support. The City of Monterey, in support, writes, “The City of Monterey supports a temporary extension of the legislation with the understanding of defining a timed hand over of responsibilities to newly formed joint power agencies between communities and (a) successor agency…FORA was created as a multi-jurisdictional agency with the objective to jointly develop a vacated military base. The fees generated on the land were calculated to attribute individual responsibilities to our communities in order to improve the overall economic and social health of our region. The County, the cities of Marina and Seaside have already accomplished a great deal with the help and support of the other jurisdictions including CSU Monterey Bay – it is now time to allow Monterey and Del Rey Oaks to take their turns.”
The United Veterans Council of Monterey County, in support, writes, “We believe that the extension of FORA as proposed in SB 189 is critical to the successful and complete transition of historic Ft. Ord to civilian uses. There are many programs and projects that are not yet finished but are required under provisions of the Base Reuse Plan. Among these are complete funding of the Habitat Management Plan, completion of the approved Ft. Ord Trail and Greenway Plan, transportation corridors which are mandated by the FORA EIR as well as numerous agreements relative to the smooth transition to local land use jurisdictions. Most of these projects and agreements will require funding mechanisms which are not yet established and may not be in place prior to June 2020. The CFD operating under FORA’s establishing documents is the only real source of this funding. More time is required for the various jurisdictions to complete their individual funding strategies.
“The proposed reduction in size and scope proposed under SB 189 significantly lessons the power and authority of FORA while leaving in place the necessary funding source for equitable transition. Land use jurisdictions will have control over their own lands with some funding provided from FORA. The abrupt end currently foreseen without SB 189 will create local chaos while the County and cities scramble to meet their responsibilities without adequate funding in place. That neither enhances the process not upholds the spirit of the legislation that created FORA. We urge you to take the prudent course of action to allow the time required to carefully complete financing arrangements…This action will provide certainty during a time when thoughtfulness and careful consideration are what is required.”
- Arguments in Opposition. The City of Marina, in opposition, writes, “FORA was created in 1994 to address the regional needs created by the closure of the former Fort Ord. The creation of CSU Monterey Bay, the removal of munitions, dedication of over 80% of the former Fort Ord property into open space and habitat management areas, and the construction of over $60 million dollars of primarily regional road projects have been great successes of the FORA Board and the Base Reuse Plan.
“Now is the time for the Board to step aside and allow Marina and Seaside as well as the other Fort Ord land jurisdictions cities of Del Rey Oaks, Monterey and Monterey County the ability to fully move forward to address these remaining critical problems of infrastructure, blight, affordable housing, job creation and economic development. These remaining challenges are best solved by our local elected officials on the front lines working with our local businesses and citizens, still working cooperatively with our regional neighbors but able to set priorities that work best for us locally and with the ability now to use all the financial and land tools provided to us by the Legislature.
“FORA has adopted the required transition plan to prepare for its dissolution and the member agencies are proceeding with implementation of the transition plan. The extension of FORA to implement the transition plan is unnecessary. The underlying land use jurisdictions are prepared to work together during the next year to address issues related to the funding of regional needs. If necessary, the underlying land use jurisdictions can create joint powers authorities to address these needs. Thus, the continuation of a state created regional entity with extensive powers only serves to extend an additional layer of bureaucracy over the continued implementation of the base reuse.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State University, Monterey Bay President Eduardo Ochoa
City of Monterey
County of Monterey (if amended)
The United Veterans Council of Monterey County
Opposition
City of Marina
City of Seaside (prior version)
League of Women Voters of Monterey County (prior version)
Monterey County Supervisor Jane Parker (prior version)
Analysis Prepared by: Angela Mapp / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 189 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 189
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution
DIGEST:
This bill extends the Fort Ord Reuse Authority, until June 30, 2022, and outlines a limited set of powers for its board until its dissolution.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) to adopt a Fort Ord Reuse Plan (SB 899, Mello, 1994). FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997. The Final Base Reuse Plan for Fort Ord lays out the future land uses for the 45-square mile former Army base, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, public uses, and open space.
- Requires the Final Base Reuse Plan to include a five-year capital improvement program outlining the types of facilities FORA intends to finance.
- Creates the FORA governing body including 13 voting members and 11 non-voting members comprised of representatives from cities, Monterey County, special districts, public educational institutions, the military, and state and federal legislators.
- Provides the FORA board with various responsibilities, including to collect and disburse revenue and oversee land use decisions on the base, and, provides the FORA board with specific powers to carry out those responsibilities, including the ability to override certain land use changes.
- Provides the FORA board the authority to levy assessments, reassessments, or special taxes, and issue bonds to finance public facilities, including Community Facilities District taxes pursuant to the Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act.
- Allows FORA to receive property tax revenues as pass through payments from city and county redevelopment (RDA) successor agencies related to project areas within FORA’s boundaries.
- Specifies that when FORA dissolves, the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would be used to service specified debt incurred by the authority, with the remainder divided as follows: 54% to city or county RDAs, 38% to the county, and 8% to other affected tax agencies.
- Authorizes FORA to operate until either when the board determines that 80% of the territory that is designated for development or reuse in the base reuse plan had been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2020, whichever occurred first (AB 1614, Monning, Chapter 743, Statutes of 2012).
- Requires FORA’s board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first.
This bill:
- Extends FORA’s authorization until June 30, 2022.
- Restricts the FORA board in the following ways beginning on July 1, 2020:
- Reduces the size of FORA's board from 13 to five members and converts the remaining members to non-voting members.
- Removes the board’s ability to add or remove non-voting members.
- Removes member agency and non-voting member fees.
- Removes the board’s ability to appoint additional committees to provide the board with analysis.
- Eliminates the requirement that each city or the county must submit its general plan to the board.
- Eliminates the requirement that the board must certify part of the General Plan and amendments related to Fort Ord property.
- Eliminates the requirement that the county and city must submit zoning ordinances and other zoning actions to the board for approval.
- Removes FORA oversight over development review appeals.
- Removes the ability with two-thirds vote to override changes that only impact one jurisdiction.
- Removes the board’s oversight over development projects to ensure base wide consistency.
- Removes the board’s ability to charge fees related to development reviews.
- Removes the board’s responsibility to prepare environment impact reports for the reuse plan in compliance with California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
- Removes the board’s ability to make changes to the Final Base Reuse Plan, including adding projects to the capital improvement program.
- Removes the board’s ability to issue bonds to finance basewide public facilities.
- Outlines the specific powers the FORA board has from July 1, 2020, until June 30, 2022:
- Requires each board member and alternate board member be a member of the legislative body making the appointment, except for those appointed by the Monterey County Board of Supervisors, who can appoint a board member or county staff.
- Require a majority vote of the board for any action.
- Negotiate and secure successor agencies for all obligations in the transition plan.
- Implement the transition plan.
- Make appropriate revisions to Community Facilities District (CFD) boundaries.
- Collect and disburse CFD revenues and property tax revenues, including revenues to fund the habitat conservation plan as well as transportation, transit, and water projects.
- Continue as a local reuse authority for the purpose of federal government property transfers.
- Ensure pledges, contracts, and obligated payments are funded.
- Requires, upon FORA’s dissolution:
- Transfer of all remaining CFD revenues to the County of Monterey for it to distribute to local agencies on a pro rata basis.
- Transfer of property tax revenues collected to the County of Monterey in amounts necessary to retire existing obligations.
- Transfer of any remaining property tax revenue, upon retirement of existing obligations, to the County of Monterey for appropriate distribution.
- The requirement that the County of Monterey does not have to use General Fund revenue to pay off FORA's liabilities.
- Permits the County of Monterey to deduct a reasonable proportion of revenues collected to pay for administrative costs associated with these responsibilities.
- Exempts the transition plan from CEQA because it meets the qualifications for an exemption as a change in organization
Background
The end of the Cold War forced the Department of Defense to adjust to new geopolitical realities. Federal officials closed or realigned nearly three dozen military bases in California. To coordinate the transition of the former army base located at Fort Ord in Monterey County, the Legislature enacted the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Act, which created FORA. Initially, the state laws authorizing FORA became inoperative either when the board determines that 80% of the territory that is designated for development or reuse in the base reuse plan had been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2014, whichever occurred first. However, lawsuits, unexpected challenges relating to munitions removal, and the economic downturn impeded FORA's ability to implement the base reuse plan by the original sunset date. By 2012, the base reuse plan was only 20 percent complete. AB 1614 extended FORA’s sunset date until June 30, 2020. AB 1614 also required FORA’s board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first. FORA's board voted to approve a transition plan in December 2018. Despite the upcoming sunset of FORA, only 40% to 50% of the territory designated for development has been developed or reused.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Since its establishment in 1917, the Fort Ord Military Base has been an integral part of the Monterey Bay region’s economy. When the base was closed in 1994, the California State Legislature established Fort Ord Redevelopment Agency (FORA) to complete the planning, financing, and management of the former Fort Ord facility as described in the 1997 Reuse Plan developed by FORA. FORA needs two additional years to allow local jurisdictions to implement adequate funding mechanisms to support projects identified in the FORA Transition Plan, as well as to ensure contracts are established for all Transition Plan Implementing Agreements. SB 189 will ensure that there will be no gap in funding for vital regional projects and obligations subject to the FORA Transition Plan once FORA is dissolved.”
- Don’t make the same mistake twice. The Legislature already extended the FORA Act once. When the Legislature first considered extending the FORA Act, various organizations raised concerns about FORA management, the time it took the board to complete projects, and whether its governance structure would ensure the successful revitalization of Fort Ord in a timely fashion. Under SB 189, FORA would no longer be able to make changes to its capital improvement program or issue bonds, and this bill heavily restricts other FORA powers, putting greater responsibility on the shoulders of local governments. It is not clear whether local governments will have the same goals as the board and complete all projects in the final base reuse plan. While FORA’s continued operation could provide a way to ensure regional collaboration continues, the Legislature may wish to consider whether an additional extension of FORA is justified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially significant increase in General Fund expenditures, likely in the low hundreds of thousands in 2020-21 and 2021-22. Absent the bill, a portion of the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would likely be reallocated to local school entities, beginning in 2020-21. This shift in property tax revenues from FORA to schools would result in a commensurate decrease in General Fund spending, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees. Extending FORA’s sunset by two years would result in increased General Fund expenditures over that period to offset continued diversions from the local school share of property taxes to FORA.
- No reimbursable state mandate costs. This bill places new duties on the Monterey County LAFCO to implement FORA’s transition plan, but LAFCO operating costs are generally split among constituent local agencies. LAFCO itself is not eligible for mandate reimbursement, and the local agencies that support LAFCO activities can recover any increased costs through planning fees.
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
City of Marina
City of Seaside
Prepared by: Jonathan Peterson / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/20/19 13:42:11
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 189 (Monning) - Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution
Version: May 17, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Bill Summary:
SB 189 would extend the sunset on the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) until June 30, 2022, restrict the powers and duties of the governing board, outline a limited set of powers and duties for the new board, and exempt the FORA transition plan from CEQA, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant increase in General Fund expenditures, likely in the low hundreds of thousands in 2020-21 and 2021-22. Absent the bill, a portion of the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would likely be reallocated to local school entities, beginning in 2020-21. This shift in property tax revenues from FORA to schools would result in a commensurate decrease in General Fund spending, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees. Extending FORA’s sunset by two years would result in increased General Fund expenditures over that period to offset continued diversions from the local school share of property taxes to FORA.
- No reimbursable state mandate costs. The bill places new duties on the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) to implement FORA’s transition plan, but LAFCO operating costs are generally split among constituent local agencies. LAFCO itself is not eligible for mandate reimbursement, and the local agencies that support LAFCO activities can recover any increased costs through planning fees.
Author Amendments:
- Clarify that the changes in the bill are operative on July 1, 2020 (the current FORA sunset date), rather than January 1, 2020.
- Eliminate the FORA board’s authority to issue bonds as of July 1, 2020.
- Prohibit additions to the “Fort Ord Base Reuse Plan” after July 1, 2020, including the capital improvement program.
- Make other clarifying changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 189 (Monning) - Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution
Version: April 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2019 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Bill Summary:
SB 189 would extend the sunset on the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) until June 30, 2022, restrict the powers and duties of the governing board, outline a limited set of powers and duties for the new board, and exempt the FORA transition plan from CEQA, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially significant increase in General Fund expenditures, likely in the low hundreds of thousands in 2020-21 and 2021-22. Absent the bill, a portion of the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would likely be reallocated to local school entities, beginning in 2020-21. This shift in property tax revenues from FORA to schools would result in a commensurate decrease in General Fund spending, pursuant to the Proposition 98 minimum funding guarantees. Extending FORA’s sunset by two years would result in increased General Fund expenditures over that period to offset continued diversions from the local school share of property taxes to FORA. In addition, if FORA were to issue bonds securitized by future property tax revenues before July of 2022, there could be longer term diversions of property tax revenues to pay for those obligations for 30 years, resulting in ongoing increases in General Fund spending to keep schools whole. See staff comments.
- No reimbursable state mandate costs. The bill places new duties on the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) to implement FORA’s transition plan, but LAFCO operating costs are generally split among constituent local agencies. LAFCO itself is not eligible for mandate reimbursement, and the local agencies that support LAFCO activities can recover any increased costs through planning fees.
Background:
Existing law establishes FORA, which is tasked with adopting a Fort Ord Reuse Plan (SB 899, Mello, 1994). FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997. The Final Base Reuse Plan for Fort Ord lays out the future land uses for the 45-square mile former Army base, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, public uses, and open space. FORA has a governing body of 13 voting members and 11 non-voting members comprised of representatives from cities, Monterey County, special districts, public educational institutions, the military, and state and federal legislators. State law tasks FORA with completing the planning, financing, and implementation of the base reuse plan.
FORA revenues are derived from multiple sources, including membership dues from the entities with representation on its board, a local Communities Facilities District (CFD) tax (which is only paid when developers pull building permits), and property tax revenues received as pass through payments from city and county redevelopment (RDA) successor agencies related to project areas within FORA’s boundaries, among others. Existing law specifies that when FORA dissolves, the property tax revenues allocated to FORA would be used to service specified debt incurred by the authority, with the remainder divided as follows: 54% to city or county RDAs, 38% to the county, and 8% to other affected tax agencies.
Initially, the state laws authorizing FORA became inoperative either when the board determines that 80% of the territory that is designated for development or reuse in the base reuse plan had been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2014, whichever occurred first. The Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) would have been responsible for ensuring FORA’s orderly dissolution. However, lawsuits, unexpected challenges relating to munitions removal, and the economic downturn impeded FORA's ability to implement the base reuse plan by the original sunset date. By 2012, the base reuse plan was only 20 percent complete. AB 1614 (Monning, 2012) extended FORA’s sunset date until June 30, 2020. AB 1614 also required FORA’s board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first. FORA's board voted to approve a transition plan in December 2018. This transition plan assigns FORA's assets and liabilities in the event it dissolves. Despite the upcoming sunset of FORA, only 40% to 50% of the territory designated for development has been developed or reused.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend FORA for two additional years, significantly restrict its board’s powers and responsibilities, outline a limited set of powers for the new board, detail the FORA dissolution process, and exempt the FORA transition plan from CEQA.
To restrict the current board’s powers, SB 189 would do the following:
- Reduce the size of FORA's board from 13 to 5 members, convert the remaining members to non-voting members, remove the board’s ability to add or remove non-voting members, and delete member agency and non-voting member fees.
- Remove the board’s authority to appoint additional committees, as specified.
- Remove the ability with 2/3 vote to override changes that only impact one jurisdiction.
- Eliminate the requirement that each city or the county must submit its general plan and zoning ordinances and actions to the board, and the requirement that the board certify general plan provisions related to Fort Ord property.
- Remove FORA oversight over development review appeals and the authority to charge fees related to development reviews.
- Remove the board’s oversight over development projects to ensure base wide consistency.
- Remove the board’s responsibility to prepare environment impact reports for the reuse plan in compliance with CEQA.
SB 189 would provide FORA board the authority to do the following from January 1, 2020 until June 30, 2022:
- Require a majority vote of the board for any action.
- Negotiate and secure successor agencies for all obligations in the transition plan.
- Implement the transition plan.
- Make appropriate revisions to CFD boundaries.
- Collect and disburse CFD revenues and property tax revenues for the purpose of habitat conservation plan, transportation, transit, and water supply.
- Continue as a local reuse authority for the purpose of federal government property transfers.
- Ensure pledges, contracts, and obligated payments are funded.
Upon dissolution, SB 189 would require the transfer of all remaining CFD revenues to Monterey County for redistribution to local agencies on a pro rata basis. Property tax revenues would be used to pay any outstanding principal and interest on debt, with remaining amounts transferred to the county auditor-controller for appropriate distribution, as specified. The bill authorizes Monterey County to deduct its costs in administering the FORA dissolution prior to distributing any funds, and specifies that any outstanding debts not covered by authority revenues would not succeed to the County.
SB 189 includes language exempting the transition plan from CEQA because it meets the qualifications for an exemption as a change in organization.
Staff Comments:
This bill allows FORA to continue operations for two years, including the authority to obligate its funding streams, and requires that any property tax revenues would continue to be used to pay off any outstanding debt after dissolution. This bill would likely result in General Fund impacts in the low hundreds of thousands over the two-year continued operative period of FORA, and impacts could extend through 2047 if the board issued new debt over those two years that is secured by its property tax revenues.
As noted above, FORA receives property tax revenues as pass through payments from RDA successor agencies in the Cities of Seaside and Marina, as well as Monterey County. FORA received approximately $2.3 million in property tax revenues from these entities in 2017-18, and approximately $2.63 million in 2018-19. Under current law, 54% of these revenues would be redistributed to the RDA successor agencies following the current dissolution date of June 30, 2020. Those redistributed revenues would be used first to pay off any remaining obligations on those successor agencies’ Recognized Obligation Payment Schedules (ROPs), pursuant to the RDA dissolution statutes. After satisfying those obligations, residual amounts are reallocated to all local agencies. According to Monterey County tax officials, 65.86% of residual property taxes would be reallocated to local school entities (K-12 schools, Community College Districts, County Office of Education, and the Educational Revenue Augmentation Fund). Staff notes that the amounts requested by RDA successor agencies for ROPs obligations fluctuates from year to year, so the amount of property taxes that would be allocated to schools upon dissolution is unknown, but could be in the hundreds of thousands in a given year. Any amount that would be available for allocation to schools would typically offset state General Fund expenditures for schools pursuant to Proposition 98’s minimum funding guarantees. As such, this bill’s extension of FORA would result in continued General Fund expenditures for two years that would otherwise be realized as state savings if the board were to sunset next year.
Staff notes that General Fund impacts could continue through 2047 (the final year in which RDA successor agencies can receive tax increment to pay off debt), to the extent the FORA board issued new bonds before June 30, 2022 that are secured by the allocation of property tax revenues.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 189 | Hearing Date: | 4/10/19 |
Author: | Monning | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 4/1/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Peterson | ||
Fort Ord Reuse Authority: member agencies: land use and zoning: dissolution
Extends the Fort Ord Reuse Authority, until June 30, 2022, and outlines a limited set of powers for its board until its dissolution.
Background
Fort Ord Reuse Authority. The end of the Cold War forced the Department of Defense to adjust to new geopolitical realities. Federal officials closed or realigned nearly three dozen military bases in California. To coordinate the transition of the former army base located at Fort Ord in Monterey County, the Legislature enacted the Fort Ord Reuse Authority Act, which created the Fort Ord Reuse Authority (FORA) to adopt a Fort Ord Reuse Plan (SB 899, Mello, 1994). FORA adopted its Final Base Reuse Plan in 1997. The Final Base Reuse Plan for Fort Ord lays out the future land uses for the 45-square mile former Army base, including areas for housing, commerce, recreation, public uses, and open space.
FORA has a governing body of 13 voting members and 11 non-voting members comprised of representatives from cities, Monterey County, special districts, public educational institutions, the military, and state and federal legislators. State law tasks FORA with completing the planning, financing, and implementation of the base reuse plan.
The FORA Act provides its board various responsibilities, including to:
- Collect and disburse revenue, including Community Facilities District (CFD) revenue and revenue from its redevelopment successor agency (RDA).
- Add or remove non-voting members.
- Appoint additional committees to provide the board with analysis.
- Oversee each city and the county’s general plan related to Ford Ord property.
- Approve city and county zoning ordinances and actions.
- Preparing environment impact reports for the reuse plan in compliance in compliance with the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
To carry out these responsibilities, FORA can:
- Exercise oversight of local development review appeals.
- Override a jurisdiction’s land use changes with a two-thirds vote.
- Exercise oversight of development of projects to ensure base wide consistency.
- Charge fees related to development reviews.
- Prepare environment impact reports for the reuse plan in compliance with CEQA.
FORA revenue. FORA receives revenue from a few different sources. These include (1) a Community Facilities District (CFD) tax, (2) property tax revenue from the Fort Ord redevelopment agency (RDA), and (3) dues from both regular members and non-voting members.
CFD tax. The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act allows counties, cities, special districts, and school districts to levy special taxes (parcel taxes) to finance a wide variety of public works, including parks, recreation centers, schools, libraries, child care facilities, and utility infrastructure. A Mello-Roos CFD issues bonds against these special taxes to finance specified public works projects. Local agencies can structure CFDs in different ways. In the case of FORA, the authority only collects the tax once a developer pulls (requests and receives) a building permit on an entitled development. An entitled development refers to a property that received a discretionary land use approval from the underlying land use jurisdiction, potentially including subdivision map approval or use permits. If a developer does not pull a building permit, FORA does not collect the revenue.
Fort Ord RDA. SB 1600 (Mello, 1994) created an RDA specific to Fort Ord to eliminate “blight” in an around the former military base. Since the RDA’s creation, FORA has received a portion of property tax revenue generated within the area of the former military base. Despite the state’s decision to dissolve RDAs in 2011, FORA continues to receive a portion of property tax revenue to pay off remaining RDA obligations. SB 1600 outlines a process to pay off remaining obligations in the event of FORA’s dissolution.
Dues. FORA receives dues from member agencies and non-voting board members. Annually, each board member contributes $14,000 to FORA operations, while each non-voting member contributes $7,000.
FORA dissolution. Initially, the state laws authorizing FORA became inoperative either when the board determines that 80% of the territory that is designated for development or reuse in the base reuse plan had been developed or reused in a manner consistent with the plan, or on June 30, 2014, whichever occurred first. After this point, the Monterey County Local Agency Formation Commission (LAFCO) would have been responsible for ensuring FORA’s orderly dissolution, including that all contracts and agreements were honored and properly administered, and that all assets of the authority were appropriately transferred. However, lawsuits, unexpected challenges relating to munitions removal, and the economic downturn impeded FORA's ability to implement the base reuse plan by the original sunset date. By 2012, the base reuse plan was only 20 percent complete, and various parties worried that allowing FORA’s statutory authority to expire in 2014 would have made it more difficult to complete the remaining implementation work.
In response to these concerns, AB 1614 (Monning, 2012) extended FORA’s sunset date until June 30, 2020. AB 1614 also required FORA’s board to approve and submit a transition plan to the Monterey County LAFCO by December 30, 2020, or 18 months before FORA’s sunset, whichever occurs first. FORA's board voted to approve a transition plan in December 2018. This transition plan assigns FORA's assets and liabilities in the event it dissolves. Despite the upcoming sunset of FORA, only 40% to 50% of the territory designated for development has been developed or reused.
The author wants to extend the FORA Act, but only to provide additional time for a smaller board with fewer powers to continue to generate revenue and ensure a transition of power back to local agencies.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 189 extends, until June 30, 2022, FORA’s authorization, significantly restricts its board’s powers and responsibilities, outlines a limited set of powers for the new board, details the FORA dissolution process, and exempts the FORA transition plan from CEQA.
Powers removed from FORA's board. To restrict the current board’s powers, SB 189 does the following:
- Reduces the size of FORA's board from 13 to 5 members and converts the remaining members to non-voting members.
- Removes the board’s ability to add or remove non-voting members.
- Removes member agency and non-voting member fees.
- Removes the board’s ability to appoint additional committees to provide the board with analysis.
- Eliminates the requirement that each city or the county must submit its general plan to the board.
- Eliminates the requirement that the board must certify part of the General Plan and amendments related to Fort Ord property.
- Eliminates the requirement that the county and city must submit zoning ordinances and other zoning actions to the board for approval.
- Removes FORA oversight over development review appeals.
- Removes the ability with 2/3 vote to override changes that only impact one jurisdiction.
- Removes the board’s oversight over development projects to ensure base wide consistency.
- Removes the board’s ability to charge fees related to development reviews.
- Removes the board’s responsibility to prepare environment impact reports for the reuse plan in compliance with CEQA.
FORA’s new set of powers. SB 189 gives the board, until June 30, 2022, authority to do the following:
- Require a majority vote of the board for any action.
- Negotiate and secure successor agencies for all obligations in the transition plan.
- Implement the transition plan.
- Make appropriate revisions to CFD boundaries.
- Collect and disburse CFD revenues and property tax revenues, including revenues to fund the habitat conservation plan as well as transportation, transit, and water projects.
- Continue as a local reuse authority for the purpose of federal government property transfers.
- Ensure pledges, contracts, and obligated payments are funded.
FORA dissolution process. Upon dissolution, SB 189 requires:
- The transfer of all remaining CFD revenues to the County of Monterey for it to distribute to local agencies on a pro rata basis.
- The flow of property tax revenues from the RDA to the County of Monterey in amounts necessary to retire existing obligations.
- The requirement that the County of Monterey does not have to use General Fund revenue to pay off FORA's liabilities.
CEQA exemption. SB 189 includes language exempting the transition plan from CEQA because it meets the qualifications for an exemption as a change in organization.
The measure contains definitions, legislative findings, and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Since its establishment in 1917, the Fort Ord Military Base has been an integral part of the Monterey Bay region’s economy. When the base was closed in 1994, the California State Legislature established Fort Ord Redevelopment Agency (FORA) to complete the planning, financing, and management of the former Fort Ord facility as described in the 1997 Reuse Plan developed by FORA. FORA needs two additional years to allow local jurisdictions to implement adequate funding mechanisms to support projects identified in the FORA Transition Plan, as well as to ensure contracts are established for all Transition Plan Implementing Agreements. SB 189 will ensure that there will be no gap in funding for vital regional projects and obligations subject to the FORA Transition Plan once FORA is dissolved.”
2. Don’t make the same mistake twice. The Legislature already extended the FORA Act once. When the Legislature first considered extending the FORA Act, various organizations raised concerns about FORA management, the time it took the board to complete projects, and whether its governance structure would ensure the successful revitalization of Fort Ord in a timely fashion. SB 189 heavily restricts what FORA can do putting more responsibility on the shoulders of local governments. It is not clear whether local governments will have the same goals as the board and complete all projects in the final base reuse plan. While FORA continued operation could provide a way to ensure regional collaboration continues, the Committee may wish to consider whether an additional extension of FORA is justified.
3. FORA dissolution. If FORA sunsets without any additional statutory changes, a few things happen. First, revenue from the CFD tax on entitled properties may disappear: when FORA dissolves, its tax would disappear with it, unless extended by voters. State law does not provide a mechanism to transfer the tax to another entity. Once local agencies entitle developments, they cannot add additional taxes on that development. Unless the developer and the underlying land use authority agreed to a new tax on an already entitled development, once FORA dissolves, the potential revenue from the CFD could disappear. Currently, FORA estimates that it could generate as much as $72 million if developers pulled all building permits on already entitled developments. Since FORA only collects CFD revenue when the developer pulls a building permit, there is no guarantee that FORA was ever going to collect that entire amount. FORA member agencies would have to negotiate with developers to replace revenue lost on entitled developments, which the developer would not be obligated to agree to. Alternatively, land use jurisdictions could replace FORA’s tax with another funding mechanism.
4. Dead man walking. The bill extends FORA’s operation until June 30, 2022. After that point, the authority ensuring regional collaboration dissolves. The reason for FORA’s establishment was to ensure that region-wide priorities took precedent over those of any particular city or the county. While various parties expressed concerns about FORA’s effectiveness over the years, once it goes away, the authority that brought all interested parties to the table goes away with it. Cities, counties, California State University-Monterey Bay, the military, among others, will have to develop new strategies for ensuring regional projects, such as transportation, habitat, and water, continue to have the regional impact the original base reuse plan intended. The Committee may wish to consider whether the extension of the sunset date is sufficient, and whether the powers the board will have once SB 189 goes into effect adequately provide for the continued revitalization of Fort Ord.
5. Let’s get technical. Committee staff recommend the following technical amendments:
- On Page 5, Line 13, add “pursuant to The Mello-Roos Community Facilities Act of 1982 (Chapter 2.5 (commencing with Section 53311) of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5).
- On Page 5, Line 30, remove “California State University.”
- On Page 15, Line 6, after “revenues,” add “defined in paragraphs (4) and (5).”
- On Page 15, Line 12, replace “payment” with “payments.”
- On Page 15, Line 26, replace “transitional plan” with “transition plan.”
6. Related legislation. SB 533 (Monning, 2019) deems projects within Fort Ord as public works, requires these projects to pay prevailing wages, and outlines an enforcement process for these provisions. The Senate Rules Committee has referred this bill to the Senate Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement.
Support and Opposition
(4/5/19)
Support: Unknown.
Opposition: City of Marina.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):