SB 217: Recreational and organizational camps.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-06-23
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 4, 2020 | August 4 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 29). Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 23, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | June 19 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | April 29 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | March 20 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Set for hearing March 20. |
| Feb 13, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 9. |
| Feb 6, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 29, 2020 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Health] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB217 Portantino et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 4, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 217
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:June 23, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Recreational and organizational camps.
SUMMARY: Requires a person who operates an organized or recreational camp to obtain a license issued by a local health agency (LHAs). Establishes various requirements for organized and recreational camps to comply, including: staffing and supervision requirements; criminal history background check; camp safety; establishment of emergency action plan; requirements for swimming and aquatic activities; archery; horseback riding; and, firearm activities. Permits a LHA to revoke or suspend a camp’s license; inspect a camp; and, assess civil penalties. Specifically, this bill:
- Finds and declares the need to establish a coordinated and comprehensive statewide system of licensing and oversight of recreational camps, to ensure children’s safety and well-being.
Definition of Terms. Defines various terms, including the following:
- Aquatics director to mean a water safety professional in charge of all swimming activities that occur at recreational camp swimming pools, bathing beaches, rivers, and all other aquatic facilities. Requires this person to supervise lifeguards, progressive swimming instructors, and counselors with bather supervision responsibilities during swimming activities and to implement the camp safety plan.
- Camp to mean both an organized camp and a recreational camp.
- Camp director means a person who is responsible for day-to-day decision making and supervision of recreational camp programs and camp staff.
- Camp operator means an individual, partnership, joint venture, or organization that owns, leases, rents, or operates an organized camp or recreational camp, or an individual, partnership, or joint venture that has care, charge, or control of an organized camp or a recreational camp.
- Health director means a person who is a physician, registered nurse, licensed vocational nurse, as specified, or a person who obtained the training under the California Child Day Care Act, as specified.
- High-risk activity means any recreational camp sport or other activity in which a mishap could result in serious injury or death. Includes in the definition of high-risk activity contact sports, motorsports, trapeze, horseback riding, hiking, scuba diving, archery, watercraft, rock climbing, climbing walls, firearms, archery, tomahawk and axe throwing, challenge courses, zip lining, and aquatic activities.
- License means a permit issued from the Department of Public Health (DPH) to legally operate a camp.
- Local agency means the LHA of a city, county, city and county or other local department or agency charged with the enforcement of this bill.
- Recreational camp means a site with a program and facilities established for the supervision of children 18 years of age and younger that meets all of the following requirements:
- Operates for at least five days during any season of the year;
- Operates for profit or nonprofit purposes, whether or not a fee is charged;
- Serves five or more children who are not members of the family or personal guests of the camp operator; and,
- Is not licensed by the State Department of Social Services (DSS) as a daycare facility.
- Staff means any person employed by a recreational camp, including a volunteer or independent contractor, who is present at the camp any time campers are present.
- Water safety instructor means a trained water safety professional at least 18 years of age who assists recreational campers in meeting their swim goals, refining swimming skills, and water safety. Requires a water safety instructor to hold a first aid certification and CPR certification.
Regulations
- Requires a local agency, instead of the existing DPH, to enforce building standards adopted by DPH.
- Requires the director of DPH to adopt rules and regulations establishing minimum standards for camps for every LHA to enforce within their jurisdiction.
- Requires each LHA to report to DPH whether each camp within its jurisdiction complies with the licensing and operational requirements established by this bill.
Recreational Camp Safety Advisory Council
- Establishes within state government the Recreational Camp Safety Advisory Council (council) to advise and consult on policy matters relating to recreational camp safety.
- Requires the council to consist of seven members appointed by the Governor, on or before January 1, 2022, and confirmed by the Senate. Specifies the members, as follows:
- One representative of for-profit recreational camps operated in California;
- One representative of nonprofit recreational camps operated in California;
- Two representatives of children’s interests who do not operate a camp;
- Two safety experts; and,
- One pediatric medical professional;
- Requires the following: the council to elect from among its members a chairperson; each council member to serve for a term of six years; vacancies to be filled by the Governor for the unexpired portion of the term; and, a majority of the appointed voting membership of the council to constitute a quorum.
- Requires the council to meet at least twice per year, and more often if necessary, on the call of the chairperson or the director.
- Prohibits the council members from receiving compensation, but are to be reimbursed for their reasonable traveling and other expenses incurred in the performance of their official duties.
- Adds the state Department of Industrial Relations to the list of entities that have regulatory jurisdiction over camps.
Camp Licensing
- Prohibits a person from operating a camp without a license issued by a LHA pursuant to this bill.
- Requires an applicant for a license for a camp to file an application with the LHA of the jurisdiction where the camp is located at least 90 days prior to the desired opening date, using a form provided by the LHA documenting all of the following information:
- The name, location, and mailing address of the camp operator;
- The name and address of the camp director;
- The dates the camp proposes to operate the during the calendar year;
- The camp’s written operating procedures and program details that describe specific items, including the following: the purpose and philosophy of the camp; admission policy of the camp; proposed fee schedule; security and emergency procedures; health and safety policies; emergency procedures; offsite trip policies; a copy of the emergency action plan, as specified; and, a recreational camp’s written operating procedures and program details that describes the specific information, including: the ages of children accepted; procedures for dropping off and picking up campers; discipline policies; parent notification and visitation policies; services offered for children with special needs; staff background checks, skills verifications, and responsibilities, as required; and, staff-to-camper supervision ratios; and onsite and offsite nonrisk and high-risk activities;
- For a recreational camp, a written statement by the camp director that they have reviewed the criminal history record check and other background information for all staff and volunteers, as specified;
- Documentation of the criminal history record check of the camp director and staff;
- Proof of insurance, as specified; and,
- Any other information deemed necessary by the director to demonstrate compliance with this bill.
Local Health Agency (LHA) Regulatory Authority
- Requires the LHA to have the sole authority to grant, suspend, or revoke licenses for camps pursuant to this bill.
- Requires a LHA to consider an applicant’s past history of compliance or noncompliance with this bill in evaluating an application for a license.
- Requires an applicant to allow the director or any agent or representative of the LHA to enter the premises of the camp to determine compliance with this bill.
- Requires a camp operator and camp director to comply with any conditions imposed by the LHA that are stated in the license.
- Requires a license for a recreational camp to state the maximum number of recreational campers authorized for the camp and the capacity not to be exceeded by the operator at any time.
- Requires the camp operator to post the license in a prominent place at the camp and make available to campers and parents or guardians of campers, specified information on the camp’s internet website.
- Prohibits transferring or assigning a license issued under this bill.
Licensing fees & expiration
- Requires the LHA to charge an application fee for new camps and an annual licensing fee for existing camps in an amount not to exceed the reasonable costs to the local agency for issuing licenses and conducting its duties pursuant to this part, or $1,250, whichever is less.
- States that a license expires upon any of the following events:
- One year after the date of issuance;
- At the close of a camp’s normal operating season;
- Upon a change of the camp operator;
- Upon a date stipulated in the license issued by the LHA; or,
- Upon revocation.
- States that a permit does not expire during the operating period except by revocation or suspension by the DPH.
Camp inspection
- Prohibits a LHA from issuing a license to operate a camp until it has inspected the camp and found it to meet all the requirements of this bill.
- Requires a LHA to make at least one unannounced inspection and one scheduled inspection during the year, and at any other time it has reason to believe a violation exists or upon the request or complaint of any person with legitimate reason for concern.
- Requires a copy of the inspection report to be completed and mailed or delivered to the operator within seven days of the day of inspection.
- Requires the camp operator and LHA to make the inspection report available within 10 days for review by the campers and parents or guardians of campers.
- Requires a written inspection to include, at a minimum, all of the following information:
- The name of the inspector;
- The date and time of the inspection or investigation;
- The location of the facility inspected;
- The date and time of any scheduled follow-up inspection;
- A listing of each specific provision that appears to be violated, as specified;
- A description of each condition constituting a violation; and,
- A reasonable time for any required correction.
- Permits the LHA, if an inspection reveals that any condition at a camp fails to comply with this bill so as to endanger or materially impair the health, safety, or well-being of the campers or the public, to take any of the following actions:
- Order the camp operator to correct the condition within an allotted time period;
- Temporarily suspend the operation pending a hearing;
- Order any building condemned and vacated, if appropriate; or,
- Order the camp program to be terminated in severe instances.
- Requires orders issued in 39) above to be served on the camp operator or their authorized agent.
- Requires the camp operator, if an inspection reveals conditions that endanger or materially impair the health, safety, or well-being of the campers or the public, to provide written notification to the campers and their parents or guardians, including the corrective action that must be taken.
- Requires a LHA to make the inspection report publicly available within 10 days of the inspection.
- Permits a LHA to levy a civil penalty on each camp that is not in compliance with any provision of this bill. States that the civil penalty not exceed $200 per day until the LHA finds the camp is in compliance with this bill.
- Requires DPH, in cooperation with the council, to adopt regulations establishing procedures for the imposition of civil penalties, which may include the revocation of a license to operate.
Emergency Action Plan
- Requires each camp to retain onsite, and submit to the LHA for approval as a part of its application for a license, a written site-specific emergency action plan approved by the camp director and camp operator.
- Requires the emergency action plan of each camp to contain procedures that address the following emergency situations:
- Natural disasters. Requires all campers and staff to be advised of the procedures contained in the natural disaster emergency action plan. Requires the natural disaster emergency plan to, at a minimum, provide arrangements for transporting individuals from the camp to emergency or other facilities;
- For recreational camps, lost campers and lost swimmers. Requires recreational campers, counselors, and staff to review the written lost camper and lost swimmer plans that are required to be kept on file;
- Fires. Requires the fire emergency action plan to require that fire drills be held at least every week. Requires the fire emergency action plan to be submitted in writing and be approved by the local fire department. Requires the plan to indicate the frequency of fire drills to be held during the camping season;
- Transportation emergencies;
- Severe illnesses and injuries;
- Strangers in camp;
- Aquatic emergencies, as appropriate for the site;
- Active shooters; and,
- Other emergency situations as appropriate for the site.
- Requires each camp operator of a recreational camp to establish procedures in the emergency action plan to address the following situations:
- Children who are registered and on the camp roll but fail to arrive for activities;
- Children who fail to arrive at the point of pickup upon the conclusion of the day’s activities; and,
- Children who appear at camp without having registered and without prior notification.
- Requires the emergency action plan to include specified procedures, including for evacuation of the campsite; control of vehicular traffic through the camp; and, communication from persons at the site of an emergency to emergency medical facilities, the nearest fire station, and camp staff.
- Requires camp staff to be trained in implementation of the procedures in the emergency action plan.
- Requires the emergency action plan to be made available to the public, including all campers and their parents or guardians.
Other requirements for camps/insurance requirements for camps
- Requires every camp facility to carry public liability insurance in an amount required by DPH.
- Requires an applicant to submit the amount of the insurance and the name and the address of the insurance provider. Requires the camp to post its insurance information in a public area at the camp.
- Requires camps operating their own transportation vehicles to carry insurance in compliance with the minimum limits required by law.
- Requires a camp to carry workers’ compensation and unemployment insurance, as required by law.
Listing of Camps
- Requires DPH to maintain a list of all camps licensed under this bill on its internet website.
- Requires each LHA to maintain a list of all camps licensed within its jurisdiction on its internet website.
- Requires DPH and the council, by March 31 of each year beginning with 2022, to submit a written report to the Legislature outlining all data collected as required by this bill. Requires DPH and each LHA to make the report available on their respective internet website. Requires the report to include all of the following information:
- Total amount of camp application and licensing fees collected;
- Total amount of expenditures for administration and enforcement activities conducted under this bill;
- The amount of camp application and licensing fees collected by each LHA;
- Total amount expended by each LHA;
- The amount of fees and penalties collected;
- Total number of camp inspections administered by local agencies and the amount of camp inspections administered by each local agency;
- Total number of inspections administered for each camp and the results of those inspections;
- Total number of violations cited by each LHA;
- Total number of camps and campers statewide and per county;
- Total number of unlicensed camps statewide;
- The number of campers for each camp;
- Total number of complaints received and processed pursuant to this bill and the frequency of each type of complaint;
- Total number of complaints received by each LHA;
- Total number of complaints referred to another enforcement agency; and,
- A breakdown of complaints received per camp and per county based on the following categories:
- Fatality or serious reports, as specified;
- Sexual predation or abuse;
- Harassment, bullying, or physical abuse by the camp or by other campers;
- Staff training, certifications, or effectiveness;
- Facilities and environment; and,
- Financial complaints.
Camp Staff Requirements
- Requires each recreational camp to have a camp director who meets specific requirements, including the following minimum qualifications: is at least 25 years of age; possesses at least two years of previous experience working in an administrative staff of a camp; possesses a notice from DSS or other relevant agency that the director has not been subject of an investigation report; has never been convicted of a felony and verifies on a form provided by the local agency that the director has no criminal conviction record, as specified; and, has completed at least 10 hours of professional development in the area of early childhood education and development.
- Requires the camp director to be present at the camp during all operating hours. Permits a camp director to also serve as the camp operator.
Recreational Camp Counselor Requirements & Counselor Ratio Requirements
- Establishes minimum requirements for a camp counselor, including being at least 18 years of age and at least two years older than the recreational campers they supervise; have at least one season as a junior counselor or have at least six months of experience in a supervisory role with children; and, have satisfactorily completed a counselor orientation and training prior to the arrival of recreational campers, as specified.
- Requires the camp operator or camp director to verify the background and character of each prospective counselor through reasonable and diligent inquiries, including, but not limited to, character references.
- Requires junior counselors of a camp to meet the following minimum requirements: be at least 16 years of age; be at least two years older than the recreational campers they supervise, but shall never supervise campers without a counselor; and, have satisfactorily completed a junior counselor orientation and training program prior to the arrival of recreational campers.
- Establishes requirements for each counselor-in-training. States that no more than 10% of the total number of counselors may be counselors-in-training. States that a counselor-in-training may not independently supervise recreational campers, and is required to be supervised as a camper.
- Requires each recreational camp to have the following minimum ratio of counselors to recreational campers:
- One counselor for every 12 campers seven years of age or older;
- One counselor for every eight campers younger than seven years of age;
- A camp that includes offsite activities, when conducting those offsite activities, must have at least one counselor for every eight campers with a minimum of two counselors. Requires at least one of these counselor to be at least 21 years of age;
- During passive activities for campers seven years of age and older, a camp to provide at least one counselor for every 20 campers. Defines passive activity to mean an activity which takes place in a defined area where participants are spectators or have limited mobility and use limited equipment such as craft material or computers. Defines passive activities to include, but is not limited to, storytelling, coloring, viewing movies, singing, and playing board games; and,
- At an overnight camp, during hours when campers are sleeping, the supervision ratio may be modified by up to 20% based on the arrangement, size, and location of the sleeping area and potential for visual and verbal supervision. States that any modification may be described in the camp’s written operating procedures and program details, as specified.
- Requires counselors required under 64) above to be within the line of sight or close proximity to campers at all times.
- Permits junior counselors to be included in meeting up to 50% of the camper-to-staff ratios required in 64) above, but to always be under the direct supervision of a counselor.
- Requires each recreational camp serving campers with mild or severe disabilities to have a staffing plan in place to ensure specialized staffing to supervise children with disabilities.
Orientation and Training for Counselors
- Requires a camp operator to provide orientation and training for all counselors, junior counselors, and other applicable camp staff and volunteers. Requires the training and orientation to include, at a minimum, all of the following information:
- The duties imposed on mandated reporters under the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act, as specified;
- The camp’s organization, policies, and procedures in writing. Requires the policies to prohibit the use of cellular phones while staff is on duty, other than for emergency communication; and,
- Any necessary training specific to overseeing certain camp activities or any specialized training to meet the needs of campers with unique physical or behavioral needs, as applicable.
- Requires documentation of specific training components and attendance records for trainings to be maintained on premises and available to the public.
- Prohibits a recreational camp operator from assigning any person to supervise a camper unless that person has received the minimum orientation, as required.
- Requires a camp operator to inform all staff of their administrative roles in accordance with written camp policies. Requires, in the event of the absence of the camp director, the camp director or camp operator to appoint a designee to be at the camp at all times. Requires the designee to be able to adequately perform the duties and responsibilities of the camp director.
Staff and Volunteer Background
- Requires each staff member and volunteer to have a background free of conduct that bears adversely upon their ability to provide for the safety and well-being of campers. Requires the camp operator to determine whether each staff member and volunteer’s conduct, criminal or otherwise, disqualifies that person from employment or service at the camp.
- Requires a camp operator to follow written procedures for reviewing the background of each staff person and volunteer. Requires a camp operator to review specified information for each staff member for each camping season, including: prior work history, as specified; and, three positive reference checks, as specified.
- Requires an inquiry by the camp operator into each staff member’s prior criminal history, to include, at a minimum, all of the following:
- A sex offender registry information check. International staff who have not previously been in the United States and who are entering the country pursuant to a visa are exempt from this requirement;
- A criminal background report; and,
- For prospective staff whose permanent residence is not California, the camp operator, where practicable, to also obtain from the applicant’s state criminal information system, a criminal record check or its nationally recognized equivalent.
- Requires a camp operator, for each volunteer during each camping season, to check prior work or volunteer history, sex offender registry information check, and criminal background check.
- Requires a camp operator to maintain written documentation verifying the background and character of each staff person and volunteer for three years, or as required by law.
Recreational Camper Safety
- Requires a recreational camp to have written policies and procedures in place to protect campers from abuse and neglect while in the camp’s care and custody, including procedures for reporting any suspected incidents of child abuse or neglect in accordance with Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act, as specified.
- Requires discipline and guidance to be consistent and based upon current American Academy of Pediatrics Childcare Guidance on effective discipline or other guidance approved by DPH, and an understanding of the individual needs and development of a child.
- Requires the recreational camp operator to provide written policies and procedures to direct discipline to the goal of maximizing the growth and development of the children and for protecting the group and individuals within it.
- Prohibits a recreational camp from engaging in any of the following types of punishment:
- Corporal punishment, including spanking;
- Cruel or severe punishment, humiliation, or verbal abuse;
- Denial of food, water, or shelter; or,
- A child shall not be punished for soiling, wetting, or not using the toilet.
- Requires a recreational camp, during hours of operation, to allow access to parents and guardians, as specified.
- Requires during the hours of operation, the recreational camp’s most recent licensing, fire department, and health department inspection reports to be available to parents and legal guardians of recreational campers or their designee and to prospective parents and legal guardians considering the camp.
- Requires each recreational camper and staff member entering camp to furnish a health history of their health status that is completed and signed by the individual camper or staff member, or by the parent or guardian if the camper or staff member is under 18 years of age. Requires this history to be kept onsite as long as the camper or staff member is at camp and to include the following:
- A description of any health condition requiring medication, treatment, special restriction, or consideration while at the recreational camp;
- A record of immunizations including date of the last tetanus shot; and,
- A record of any allergies.
- Requires each staff member and recreational camper under 18 years of age to submit to the camp a signed statement by a parent or guardian to seek emergency medical treatment, except those minors in camp accompanied by a parent or guardian.
- Requires the health director employed by the recreational camp to be responsible for health supervision of recreational campers present at the recreational camp. Requires the health director to conduct a health screening for all staff prior to the arrival of campers, and all campers under 18 years of age who are unaccompanied by a parent or guardian, within 24 hours of arrival at camp.
- Requires the health director to maintain a log book that includes, at a minimum, all of the following information for each accident, injury, and illness:
- Name of the person treated;
- Dosage and intervals of any medication dispensed;
- First aid or medical treatment rendered;
- Name of the person administering the first aid or medical treatment;
- Date and time of treatment;
- Date the recreational camper’s parent or guardian was notified of the accident, illness, or injury;
- Name of the person who notified the camper’s parent or guardian of the accident, illness, or injury; and,
- A detailed description of the incident, including conditions that led to the incident or illness.
- Requires the health director, camp director, or camp operator to report all occurrences of foodborne illness, suspected foodborne illness, or any other reportable disease, as specified, to the appropriate county, city, or district health officer.
- Requires medication brought by a camper that requires the health director or qualified staff to dispense to meet the following requirements:
- In the original container and labeled as required in law;
- Accompanied by specific written instructions for dispensing the medication from a parent, legal guardian, or physician licensed; and,
- Stored in a locked container when unattended by the health director.
- Requires the recreational camp operator to employ at least one health director that is a designated California licensed physician, certified nurse practitioner, or physician assistant having documented pediatric training of at least two years.
- Requires the health director to develop a written camp health care policy, approved by the LHA. Requires the policy to include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
- Daily health supervision;
- Infection control;
- Medication storage and administration, including self-administration when appropriate;
- Procedures for using insect repellant;
- Conducting tick checks;
- Promoting allergy awareness;
- Handling health emergencies and accidents, including parental and guardian notifications;
- Available ambulance services; and,
- Provision for medical, nursing, and first aid services.
- Requires the health director to have the following additional duties:
- Assist in the development of the camp’s health care policy, as specified in b) below;
- Review and approve the camp’s health care policy on an annual basis;
- Approve any changes to the camp’s health care policy;
- Be available to the camp director or camp operator for consultation at all times;
- Develop, review, and approve first aid training for camp staff; and,
- Develop and sign written orders, including for prescription medication administration.
- Specifies that at camps in which the total number of campers and staff is less than 150, the camp director may assign the health director additional non-health-related duties, but must be made available at all times at the camp to render emergency first aid.
- Requires a health director to be present at all times in camps operated specifically for children with mild or severe disabilities, medical specialty camps, overnight camps where the total number of campers and staff is 150 or greater, and at any other camp when required by the LHA.
- Requires each camp to maintain a health record for each camper and for each staff person under 18 years of age; requires the health record to be readily available at all times in electronic or hard copy form that is secure from unauthorized access and to include, at a minimum: the camper’s or staff member’s name and home address, the name, address, and telephone number of the camper’s or staff member’s parent or guardian; a written authorization for emergency medical care signed by a parent or guardian; and copies of injury reports, if any.
- Requires a report to be completed on a form available from the LHA for each fatality or serious injury as a result of which a camper, staff member, or volunteer is sent home or brought to the hospital or physician’s office and where a positive diagnosis is made. Specifies reportable incidents to include, but are not limited to, incidents requiring any of the following: suturing; resuscitation; broken bones; admission to the hospital; or sexual abuse or misconduct.
- Requires a copy of each injury report to be sent to DPH and the council as soon as possible but no later than one calendar day after the occurrence of the injury.
- Specifies requirements if a LHA finds a hazard on camp property, as specified, including conducting inspection of the premises within three working days of posting the placard to assure compliance with terms of the order and must inspect the premises within two working days of notification that the hazard has been eliminated to remove them after verifying the correction.
- Specifies that any of the following violations constitute a public health hazard which requires the LHA to order immediate correction or to immediately institute action:
- Supervision of children is not in accordance with this bill, resulting in a camper’s exposure to unreasonable risk to their health or safety;
- Use of an unapproved or contaminated water supply source;
- Treatment of the water system, required for disinfection or removal of contaminants, is not continuous;
- Disinfection that is inadequate to destroy harmful microorganisms or to maintain a specified chlorine residual;
- Presence of cross-connections or other faults in the water distribution or plumbing systems that result, or may result, in the contamination of the potable water supply;
- Insufficient quantity of water to meet drinking or sanitary demands;
- Sewage on the ground surface in areas accessible to children;
- Implementation of the medical requirements of the camp health and safety plan not under the supervision of a camp health director;
- Failure to comply with any organized camp requirements, as specified;
- High-risk activity conducted without certified instructors or in a manner hazardous to campers or the general public;
- Overcrowding of sleeping quarters resulting in inadequate spacing of bunks or blockage of fire exits;
- Failure to supervise children in sleeping quarters;
- Failure to provide two fire exits where required or blockage of a required fire exit by locking or other obstruction;
- Failure to provide a fire alarm system in multistory buildings;
- Installation of stoves or heating equipment constituting a fire hazard or inadequate venting of fumes;
- Failure to properly store flammable liquids and toxic substances;
- Failure to maintain firefighting equipment in working order; or,
- Failure to properly store and administer medication.
- Requires each camp to maintain a medical log containing a record of all camper and staff health complaints and treatment. Specifies requirements for the medical log, including listing the date and time, name of patient, complaint, and treatment for each incident and an authorize staff member to sign entry into the medical log.
- Requires all medical records and logs to be readily available to the health director and other health personnel or upon request to the local agency. Requires the local agency to maintain the confidentiality of information relating to individual campers and staff.
- Requires the camp operator to provide a single facility identified as an infirmary or first aid facility, which is easily recognizable and accessible during the day and night.
- Requires first aid supplies to be readily available to the staff wherever the health director deems necessary. Requires first aid kits to meet American National Standards Institute, as specified.
- Requires an overnight camp to have a designated space for isolation of a child ill with a communicable disease or suspected of such illness or otherwise in need of quiet and rest, at a location suitably separated from the regular living and sleeping quarters, to ensure both quiet to the patient and safety to other persons. Requires the space to be suitably equipped, including a ventilation system capable of providing negative pressure. Requires an isolated child to be provided with adequate adult supervision. Requires the camp to notify the parent or guardian of an isolated child upon their isolation.
- Requires a camp operator to maintain all medical records relating to campers, staff, and volunteers for a minimum of three years.
- Requires the camp director, health director, aquatics director, all lifeguards, and all counselors to possess current CPR certifications and first aid certifications.
Organized Camp Safety Requirements
- Requires, during hours of operation, an organized camp’s most recent licensing, fire department, and health department inspection reports to be available to campers, prospective campers, and their respective parents or guardians.
- Requires, if a LHA finds a hazard on an organized camp property, the building or portion of the property constituting the hazard to be placarded against occupancy until the hazard is corrected.
- Requires LHAs to inspect the premises within three working days of posting the placard to assure compliance with terms of the order and to inspect the premises within two working days of notification that the hazard has been eliminated to remove them after verifying the correction.
- Requires that any of the following violations constitute a public health hazard, which requires the LHA to order immediate correction or to immediately institute action as provided in this section:
- Use of an unapproved or contaminated water supply source;
- Treatment of the water system, required for disinfection, or removal of contaminants is not continuous;
- Disinfection that is inadequate to destroy harmful microorganisms or to maintain a specified chlorine residual;
- Presence of cross-connections or other faults in the water distribution or plumbing systems that result, or may result, in the contamination of the potable water supply;
- Insufficient quantity of water to meet drinking or sanitary demands;
- Sewage on the ground surface in areas accessible to campers;
- Failure to provide two fire exits where required or blockage of a required fire exit by locking or other obstruction;
- Failure to provide a fire alarm system in multistory buildings;
- Installation of stoves or heating equipment constituting a fire hazard or inadequate venting of fumes;
- Failure to properly store flammable liquids and toxic substances; or,
- Failure to maintain firefighting equipment in working order.
High-Risk Activities
- Deems a recreational camp to conduct a high-risk activity if the activity poses an inherent risk of serious injury or death due to the nature of the activity, regardless of reasonable precautions and supervision.
- Requires a counselor or camp director to conduct high-risk activities only if they possess appropriate training, certification, and experience for the activity. Requires the camp operator to make adequate provisions to assure any special training necessary for camp staff to protect the safety and health of all campers, including those with disabilities.
- Prohibits a camp from operating any zip line, challenge course, or other mechanical device that meets the definition of an amusement ride unless the camp has obtained a permit to operate the zip line, challenge course, or other mechanical device from the Division of Occupational Safety and Health.
- Requires a recreational camp operator of a camp that includes a challenge course, climbing wall, swimming pool, horseback riding operation, zip-line, or other high-risk activity to comply with the following requirements for each camper fatality or injury:
- Cooperate fully with any investigation of incidents involving injury, death, illness, or sexual abuse of campers and staff and to provide all necessary information and access to conduct the investigation. Requires a camp operator to provide information in a timely manner, whether obtained pursuant to the investigation or otherwise, to the LHA upon request, in the form and manner requested;
- Upon receipt of injury reports, requires the LHA to conduct an investigation of the incident that comply with all of the following:
- A review of medical records and reports, witness interviews and statements, expert assessments, and the collection of physical evidence, observations and information from care providers, and any other information that is relevant to the incident;
- Interviews to be conducted by a qualified, objective individual in a private area which does not allow those not participating in the interview to overhear. At least one person conducting the interview must understand and be able to accommodate the unique needs or capabilities of the person being interviewed;
- Interviews to be conducted of each party or witness individually, not in the presence of other parties or witnesses or under circumstances in which other parties or witnesses may perceive any aspect of the interview;
- The person alleging the incident, or who is the subject of the incident, to be offered the opportunity to give their version of the incident; and,
- Requires all evidence to be adequately protected and preserved.
- Requires, upon completion of the investigation, a written report to be prepared which includes all relevant findings and information obtained in the investigation and details of steps taken to investigate the incident; and,
- Requires the investigation and written report to be completed and provided to the DPH within 45 days of when the incident was first reported.
- Requires the LHA, if any remedial action is necessary, including, but not limited to, suspension of the high-risk activity involved in the injury or fatality, to establish a plan in writing with the camp operator. Requires the plan to indicate the camp operator’s agreement to the remediation and identify a follow-up date and person responsible for monitoring the remedial action or suspension of the high-risk activity. Requires the plan to be provided, and any measures taken in response to such plan to be reported to DPH.
- Requires the camp operator, at the conclusion of an investigation of a reportable incident, to do all of the following:
- Assess the need for corrective actions;
- Report corrective action plans to the DPH and the council within 10 days of the conclusion of an investigation;
- Implement corrective action identified by the camp or required by the LHA. Requires corrective action plans to be implemented as soon as possible but within 90 days of the completion of an investigation, unless the camp has closed for the season; and, if closed for the season, the corrective action plans to be implemented when the camp reopens.
- Requires recreational camps with youth sports and high-risk activities to be subject to existing youth sports concussion protocols. Requires a recreational camp to provide to campers and parents a concussion and head injury information sheet to be signed by both the camper and the camper’s parent or guardian. Requires, on a yearly basis, the recreational camp to offer concussion and head injury education or related educational materials. Requires each camp operator, camp director, and other camp staff to be required to successfully complete the concussion and head injury education at least once, either online or in person, before supervising a camper participating in a sports activity.
Swimming and Aquatics Safety
- Requires each recreational camp that provides any aquatics activity to employ an aquatics director that meets specified requirements, including: be at least 21 years of age; possess specific experience requirements; possess certification as water safety instructor; and, possesses 20/20 corrected vision and at least 20/40 uncorrected vision.
- Requires an aquatics director to meet all of the following experience requirements:
- Possesses one season of previous experience as a camp aquatics director or in an aquatics supervisory role at a swimming pool or other swimming facility;
- Possesses two seasons of previous experience consisting cumulatively of at least 16 weeks as a camp-certified lifeguard or at a swimming pool or other swimming facility that had more than one lifeguard supervising it at a time;
- Possesses at least 24 weeks of previous experience as a certified lifeguard at a swimming pool or other swimming facility that had more than one lifeguard supervising it at a time; and,
- Meets the definition of lifeguard.
- Requires the camp aquatic director to, at least annually, review the camp’s emergency action plan for swimming, including the lost swimmer plans.
Lifeguards and Swimming and Other Aquatics Activities
- Requires lifeguards to actively supervise participants in the recreational camp’s aquatic activities as required in the camp’s approved emergency action plan. Prohibits a lifeguard while on duty at the pool or other swimming facility from engaging in duties or activities which distract them from the direct supervision of the water.
- Specifies requirements that a lifeguard must meet, including, possessing: at least 12 weeks as a certified lifeguard or at a swimming pool or swimming facility that had more than one lifeguard supervising; certification as a water safety instructor from a training course for lifeguard supervision and management approved by the local agency; 20/20 corrected vision and at least 20/40 uncorrected vision; and, is physically sound sufficient to supervise campers
- Requires swimming and other aquatics activities at recreational camps to be supervised by one lifeguard for every 12 campers in the water or near the water. Requires the camp to supervise individual campers identified as non-swimmers by one lifeguard for every five non-swimmers in the water or near the water.
- Requires every pool or swimming facility to have at least one raised lifeguard station with an unobstructed view of the swimming area and lifesaving equipment for every 25 campers.
- Requires the aquatics director to do all of the following:
- Directly supervise all aquatics activities involving 30 or more campers; and,
- Directly supervise all offsite aquatics activities.
- Permits the aquatics director to count as one of the lifeguards required under 122) above. Permits supervision of swimming, if not provided by recreational camp staff, to be provided through a contractual agreement between the camp and the operator of the swimming venue, provided the swimming venue provides supervision as required under 122) above with a lifeguard that meets the training and certification requirements, as specified.
- Requires the swimming area of each recreational camp to designate non-swimmer and swimmer areas.
- Requires campers designated as non-swimmers pursuant to the swimming assessment to be subject to both of the following: the camp to confine non-swimmers to an appropriate area; and, to be readily distinguishable from swimmers, unless they are restricted from entering the swimmer area by a physical barrier or are in a separate area for non-swimmers.
- Requires a counselor or lifeguard to conduct a head count check every three minutes.
- Requires an aquatics representative authorized by the LHA to test the aquatics director and all lifeguards before commencement of recreational camp season, regardless of whether or not they possess current lifeguard, water safety instruction, or other aquatics safety certifications.
- Requires each recreational camp that offers any aquatics activity to develop a lost swimmer plan, which details all procedures to be followed when a swimmer is missing. Requires the lost swimmer plan to be included in the camp’s emergency plan approved by the local agency.
- Requires the procedures of the lost swimmer plan to be implemented whenever a buddy check fails to account for all swimmers and anytime a swimmer is reported missing.
- Requires an aquatics director to conduct a swimming assessment of each camper before allowing any recreational camper to engage in aquatics activities based on American Red Cross, YMCA, or other swim proficiency tests approved by DPH. Requires this assessment to be relevant to the specific type of water and water activities of the camp. Prohibits a camper that refuses to participate in the swimming assessment from entering the water.
- Requires a record of camper swimming levels to be available at all aquatic sites.
- Deems the following as non-swimmers:
- Any camper that has not passed an American Red Cross Level 3, YMCA Minnow swim proficiency test, or other equivalent classification as approved by DPH; or,
- Any camper that has been determined to have a physical, psychological, medical, or cognitive disability that could have a negative impact on their swimming ability.
- Requires a recreational camp that offers aquatics activities to do all of the following:
- Offer swim lessons to all non-swimmers. Gives sole discretion to the camp operator to offer such lessons at an additional fee of their choosing;
- Require that non-swimmers wear United States Coast Guard approved personal floatation devices at all times, as specified;
- Install a “buddy system” in which all swimmers are paired with another swimmer of similar ability. States that if a swimmer is paired with a non-swimmer, both campers to remain in the shallow area where the water level does not exceed chest height of the non-swimmer. Requires swim buddies to always be within clear view of one another while in the water; and requires buddy checks every five minutes; and,
- Keep a swim log system that identifies each camper by name, swimming ability, and the swim area to which the camper is assigned; specifies this system to record the entry to and exit from the swim area for each camper;
- Prohibits a camp from allowing any of the following:
- A camper to dive head-first from a pool deck into fewer than eight feet of water;
- A camper to jump feet-first from a pool deck into fewer than five feet of water; or,
- A camper to run on a pool deck.
- Prohibits a recreational camp from permitting any outdoor swimming between sunset and sunrise. Requires lighting for indoor and nighttime swimming pool use to be detailed in the operating plan and approved by the local agency; and,
- Prohibits a recreational camp from offering any aquatics activity at a residential swimming pool.
Surveillance cameras
- Requires all camp swimming pools to be surrounded by as many surveillance cameras as needed to cover the entire expanse of the pool.
- Requires the camp operator to submit the video footage of each aquatics-related incident involving a camper to a LHA.
- Requires permanent swimming areas to have supervised entrances and exits.
- Requires swimming pools to be protected by protective fencing at least six feet in height and with locks; and, for the swimming pool entrance gates to be locked except during periods when a lifeguard is on duty.
- Requires each onsite swimming facility to provide float lines.
- Requires all camp swimming pools to provide water depth markers.
- Requires all floats, platforms, and decking to be in good repair; and for clearly visible depth and other markings to be provided.
- Requires diving areas to comply with specific requirements, as specified.
Natural Water Facility/Activity
- Defines a natural water facility to include a lake, stream, river, ocean, or any other natural body of water.
- Requires a camp that offers any aquatics activity at a natural water facility to develop a plan that is submitted to the LHA for the use of the natural water facility for swimming or boating that meets specific requirements.
- Requires a camp that uses a natural water facility for swimming to be equipped with at least one lifeboat or equivalent water safety device that is suited to the size, location, and use of the water facility, population of the camp, and dangers inherent to the water facility as determined by the local agency. Requires the water safety device to, at a minimum, meet specific requirements: be used for no other purpose than for saving lives or for other emergencies; be kept in good repair and readily accessible to the areas of potential use; and, meet the requirements established for boat safety, as specified.
- Requires a camp to document careful soundings of depth of water, location of eddies and pools, and determinations of the presence and nature of dangerous currents, sunken logs, rocks, and obstructions in each natural water facility. Specifies signage requirements.
- Requires the minimum lifeguard-to-camper ratios to apply at each natural water facility. Prohibits swimming in a natural water facility without the requisite number of lifeguards on duty.
- States that recreational camps, during a hike or other similar camp activity, entering any natural water facility for the purpose of crossing or for personal hygiene is considered swimming. Specifies procedures for incidental water immersion to be included in the camp’s emergency action plan and approved by the LHA; prohibits incidental water immersion when the water’s depth cannot be determined or when the water’s depth or current does not ensure a safe crossing. Requires a trip or activity leader to be familiar with safe water flow characteristics and camp safety plan procedures for any body of water entered and for staff to test the entire area in which incidental immersion will occur prior to campers entering the water.
- Requires a recreational camp to ensure that the bottom of all natural water facility diving areas are cleared of stumps, rocks, and other obstacles.
Supervision Requirements for Watercraft Activities
- Requires all watercraft activities at recreational camps to be supervised by a minimum of one counselor for every 10 campers in a watercraft.
- Requires each supervising counselor to hold a lifeguard certification from a source authorized by DPH, a certification in small craft safety and basic water rescue, or an equivalent certification recognized DPH that demonstrates water rescue procedures specific to the type of water and activities conducted. Requires each counselor, in addition to obtaining certification, to obtain evidence of previous training and experience with the type of water activity totaling at least 20 hours on the water.
- Requires all watercraft activities carried out by recreational camps on whitewater or hazardous saltwater or freshwater, regardless of the number of campers, to have a minimum of two counselors, each in separate watercraft, supervising the activity.
- Requires each recreational camper to be designated as water safe before being participating in whitewater, hazardous saltwater, or hazardous freshwater boating activities.
- Requires whitewater activities for recreational camps to be carried out on water determined to be no more difficult than Class III, as specified. Prohibits a camp from providing any whitewater activity on unclassified whitewater.
- Requires the following: all recreational camp staff and participants engaging in watercraft activities to wear personal floatation devices; each motorized watercraft for use to be registered with the Department of Motor Vehicles and display its registration number, as specified; and, procedures and conditions for the use of non-motorized boats to be included in the camp’s emergency action plan.
- Requires scuba diving activities at recreational camps to be supervised by a certified counselor, as specified. Requires practices and equipment for scuba diving to be included in the approved camp’s emergency action plan.
Other High-Risk Recreational Camp Activities: Firearm activities
- Requires all firearm activities at recreational camps to be directly supervised by an individual who possesses a current National Rifle Association Instructor certification and maintains compliance with licenses to carry firearms.
- Requires a ratio of one counselor for every 10 campers on a firearm range to be maintained at all times.
- Requires firearms to be kept in good condition and stored in a locked cabinet when not in use. Requires ammunition to be stored in a locked facility in a location separate from the firearms. Requires the key to be in the possession of the camp director or their qualified designee who is at least 21 years of age.
- Requires a camp firearm range to comply with all of the following:
- Be located sufficiently away from other activity areas beyond the potential of harm to any camper;
- Be clearly marked to warn a passerby away from the danger area;
- The shooting area to be large enough to provide at least 100 yards of clearance behind each target;
- All campers to fire from a common firing line. Requires a ready line to be marked at a sufficiently safe distance behind the firing line, and only those ready to fire can be on the firing line. Requires the following: those waiting to fire to remain behind the ready line; campers and staff to stay behind the firing line at all times except when ordered by the range instructor to retrieve targets and only when all firearms have been safely stored;
- All rifles to be unloaded with actions open, and to be verified to be unloaded by the range instructor, prior to any camper or staff member crossing the firing line, at the conclusion of instruction, or at any other time the range instructor directs;
- Backstops to be used to contain bullets within the range; and,
- Large warning signs atop the backstop, facing away from the firing line, and containing a “keep out” label. Requires a red firing flag to be displayed when the range is in use.
- Requires all firearms activities to be limited to the use of a non-large-capacity rifle loaded with a single shot.
- Requires campers and instructors to utilize approved shooting safety glasses and ear protection when engaging in shooting activities.
- Requires firearm activities to be limited to the following campers:
- Campers seven years of age and older may participate in firearm activities using BB guns;
- Campers 10 years of age and older may participate in firearm activities using pellet guns; and,
- Campers 11 years of age and older may participate in firearm activities using .22-caliber rimfire, bolt-action rifles, shotguns, and muzzle-loading rifles.
- Requires campers to be instructed in safe rifle range procedures before participating in any firearm activity.
Other High-Risk Recreational Camp Activities: Archery
- Requires a recreational camp that provides archery as a camp activity to ensure all of the following requirements are met:
- Archery equipment to be kept in good condition and stored under lock and key when not in use. Requires the key to be in the possession of the camp director or their qualified designee who is at least 21 years of age;
- The archery range to be located in an area well away from other program activities beyond the potential of harm to any camper;
- Archery ranges to be clearly marked to warn a passerby away from the danger area;
- The archery range area to be large enough to provide at least 50 feet of clearance behind each target or an archery net behind each target;
- All bowmen to fire from a common firing line. Requires a ready line to be marked at a sufficiently safe distance behind the firing line;
- The archery range to not endanger any person or persons in other program activities and to be clearly marked to warn passing campers away from the danger area; and,
- The camp to ensure at least one archery counselor supervises every 10 campers on the firing line.
- Requires all archery counselors to possess training in archery.
Horseback riding
- Requires a recreational camp that offers horseback riding as a camp activity to comply with all of the following:
- A competent, certified riding instructor to determine the riding experience and level of skill of each camper and take these into account in assigning horses and determining whether the camper shall ride in the ring or on a trail;
- Each camper to wear a hard hat at all times;
- Riders shall wear shoes with heels, or closed stirrups;
- At least one experienced counselor to be assigned for every 10 horseback riders for a trail excursion, with a minimum of two staff members; and,
- Horses to be boarded in a stable.
- Conforms existing law provisions that requires camps to comply with the food handler requirements of the California Retail Food Code.
- Requires a camp operator, camp director, or other staff of a camp as defined by this bill to be mandated reporters for purposes of the Child Abuse Neglect Reporting Act, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the State Public Health Officer to establish rules and regulations for organized camps.
- Establishes requirements for the operation, regulation and enforcement of organized camps.
- Defines an organized camp as a site with program and facilities established for the primary purposes of providing an outdoor group living experience with social, spiritual, educational, or recreational objectives, for five or more days during one or more seasons of the year.
- Excludes from the definition of an organized camp a motel, tourist camp, trailer park, resort, hunting camp, auto court, labor camp, penal or correctional camp, childcare institution, or home finding agency.
- Defines a camper as a person in an organized camp who is a participant in the regular program and training of an organized camp, and who may take duties relating to such program and training.
- Requires the State Fire Marshall to adopt minimum fire safety regulations for organized camps.
- Requires LHAs to enforce the building standards published in the State Building Standards Code related to organized camps.
- Prohibits an organized camp from operating unless it satisfies the minimum standards for organized camps as prescribed by building standards pursuant to the State Building Standards Code.
- Establishes the California Child Day Care Act, administered by DSS, which regulates and license child care facilities in California.
EXISTING STATE REGULATIONS OF ORGANIZED CAMPS:
- Defines “health screening” to mean an examination to identify observable evidence of illness, injury, or communicable disease; to review and update each person's health history; and to identify current medical treatment (including medication), allergies or dietetic restrictions.
- Defines “health supervisor” to mean a person who is either a physician, registered nurse, licensed vocational nurse who is licensed pursuant to Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code or a person who is trained in accordance with section 1596.866 of the Health and Safety Code.
Requirements for Organized Camps
- Requires a site operator, on an annual basis and at change of ownership the site operator to submit to the local health officer (LHO):
- A written verification that the camp is accredited by the American Camp Association, (formerly the American Camping Association); or,
- A written description of operating procedures that describes the program of organized and supervised activities of the camp in the following areas:
- Supervisor qualifications and training;
- Staff skill verification criteria and process;
- Participant eligibility requirements (if any);
- Staff-to-participant supervision ratios;
- Equipment needed;
- Safety procedures;
- Emergency procedures specific to location;
- Environmental hazards;
- Access and equipment control; and,
- Equipment and maintenance repair.
- A written statement by the director (person responsible for the day to day operation/supervision of the camp) that the director has reviewed the criminal history record check and voluntary disclosure statement as described in section 30751 for all individuals for which it is required by section 30751(a), and documentation of the criminal history record check of the Director.
Building Structures
- Requires plans and specifications for every building or structure to be approved by the LHO prior to start of any construction;
- Permits DPH or LHO to contract with the Office of the State Architect of the Department of General Services or any private or other governmental agency for the review of design and performance of inspection of construction of camp buildings and structures, as specified.
Repair, Safety, Maintenance and Sanitation
- Requires every building, structure, tent, tent structure, cabin, and premises to be kept in good repair, and to be maintained in a safe and sanitary condition, clean and free from accumulations of paper, rubbish, or standing water, satisfactory to the local health officer.
- Requires all appliances, equipment, devices, facilities, electrical, mechanical, plumbing, refrigerating and ventilating systems to be kept in good repair, and to be maintained in a safe and sanitary condition satisfactory to the LHO.
- Requires, when provided, mattresses, mattress covers, blankets, sheets, pillows, and/or sleeping bags to be maintained sanitary and in good condition. Requires blankets, sheets, pillows, and/or sleeping bags to be laundered and/or sanitized prior to issuance to a camper. Mattresses shall be covered with waterproof material or washable covers so as to be easily cleaned and sanitized.
Food Service Facilities
- Requires food service facilities to comply with the California Retail Food Code.
Swimming and Bathing
- Requires all swimming pools, pools, wading pools and special purpose pools which are located in or provided for any camp to be designed, constructed, maintained, and operated in accordance with specific requirements.
Lake, Stream, River or Ocean Swimming
- Requires a plan for the use of any lake, stream, river or the ocean by any camp for swimming or boating to be:
- Developed and maintained by the director;
- Submitted to the local health officer prior to use; and
- Implemented in accordance with any special conditions that may be specified in writing by the local health officer to protect health and safety.
- Requires any camp which uses places such as lakes, streams, rivers or the ocean for swimming shall be equipped with at least one lifeboat or equivalent water safety device that is suited to the size, location and use of the water facility, population of the camp, and dangers inherent to the water facility as determined by the director of the camp and to:
- Be used for no other purpose than for saving lives or for other emergencies;
- Be kept in good repair and readily accessible to the areas of potential use, and,
- Comply with Harbors and Navigation Code regulations, as specified.
- Requires a camp to maintain careful soundings of depth of water and location of eddies and pools and determinations of the presence and nature of dangerous currents, sunken logs, rocks and obstructions in the lake, stream or river have been made and:
- Legible signs indicating in plain letters, the depth of water, the location of pools or eddies, and the presence and direction of currents of water shall be posted at any lake, stream or river used by a camp for camper swimming; and,
- The signs to be visible from the swimming or bathing area during the season when bathing and swimming are permitted.
- Requires lifeguard services meet existing minimum qualifications, as specified.
- Requires a designated aquatics supervisor to be at least 18 years of age and who possesses an American Red Cross Lifeguard Certificate, YMCA Swim Lifesaving Certificate or its equivalent certificate.
- Requires lifeguard service to be provided at a ratio of 1 lifeguard for each 25 campers in the water.
Health Supervision Requirements
- Requires every camper and each staff member entering camp to furnish a health history of his or her health status that is completed and signed by the individual camper or staff member, or by the parent or guardian if the camper or staff member is under the age of 18. Requires the history to be kept on-site as long as the camper or staff member is at camp and to include the following:
- A description of any health condition requiring medication, treatment, special restriction or consideration while at camp;
- A record of immunizations including date of the last tetanus shot; and,
- A record of any allergies.
- Requires a signed statement by a parent or guardian to seek emergency medical treatment to be provided for each staff member or camper, except those minors accompanied in camp by a parent or guardian. Permits the LHO, when necessary for the protection of the health of campers and staff members, to require special inoculations and testing for each camper and staff member entering camp.
- Requires a full-time adult health supervisor charged with health supervision at the camp when campers are present.
- Requires health screening to be conducted under the supervision of the health supervisor by qualified staff that specific requirements for:
- All staff prior to the arrival of campers; and,
- All campers under the age of 18 who are unaccompanied by a parent or guardian within 24 hours of arrival at camp.
- Requires, if a physician is not on site when campers are present, arrangements to be made for a physician to be available on an on-call basis. Requires an infirmary (tentage or other shelter), with provision for isolating patients, to be provided. Requires advance arrangements to be made for the immediate removal of seriously sick or injured campers or staff members to a point of adequate medical care, on recommendation of a physician. States that these provisions do not apply to intermittent short-term organized camps operating less than 72 hours except when required by the LHO for the protection of the health of campers and adult supervisors.
- Requires a medical logbook to be maintained by the health supervisor which includes at least the following information for each accident, injury or illness:
- Name of the person treated;
- Dosage and intervals of any medication dispensed;
- First aid or medical treatment rendered;
- Name of the person administering the first aid or medical treatment;
- Date and time of treatment; and,
- Date parent/guardian notified of accident, illness or injury.
- Requires the health supervisor or the site operator to report all occurrences of foodborne illness, suspected foodborne illness, or any other reportable diseases to the LHO for the camp location.
- Requires all medication brought to a camp by campers that needs to be dispensed by the health supervisor or qualified staff to be:
- In the original container and labeled, as specified;
- In containers accompanied by specific written dispensing instructions from a parent, legal guardian, or physician; and,
- Stored in a locked container when unattended by the Health Supervisor.
- Requires a written health care plan developed and maintained by the health supervisor to be used at the camp. Requires the health plan to include:
- The responsibilities and authority of the Health Supervisor and other qualified health staff that provide health care including first aid;
- The procedures for camp health care and sanitation;
- A record keeping process;
- A plan for provisions and maintenance of supplies and equipment;
- The relationships and agreements with local medical personnel, hospitals, and providers of emergency care and other emergency care providers; and,
- A plan to prevent and control the spread of pandemic flu or other communicable diseases among campers.
- Defines a health supervisor as a person who is either a physician, registered nurse, licensed vocational nurse or a director or teacher at a day care center, as specified.
Staffing Supervision
- Requires every camp, when campers are present, to have a director at the camp in charge who is at least 25 years of age and has at least two seasons of administrative or supervisory experience in camp activities.
- Requires the director to provide staff for the care, protection, and supervision of the campers.
- Prohibits the director and all camp counselors from having direct unsupervised contact with campers without first obtaining a satisfactory criminal history record check from the California Department of Justice, Bureau of Criminal Identification, or U.S. Department of Justice National Sex Offender Public Registry, and a voluntary disclosure statement that contains the same information as standard HR-4 Staff Screening of the Accreditation Standards for Camp Programs and Services, American Camp Association (2007 Edition), as specified.
- Requires, when campers are present, that at least one counselor who is a high school graduate or who is at least 18 years of age, for each 10 campers under 16 years of age.
- Requires the health supervisor to verify that all counselors have been trained in the principles of first aid and cardiopulmonary resuscitation.
- States that the supervision requirements does not apply to intermittent organized short-term camps.
Firearms
- Requires all firearms and ammunition, when not in used for organized camp activities, to be stored in a cabinet designated for this use and locked. Requires the key to be in the possession of the director or qualified designee.
Emergency Plan
- Requires each camp to retain on site a written site specific plan, approved by the director, outlining procedures which deal with the following emergency situations:
- Natural disasters.
- Lost campers.
- Fires.
- Transportation emergencies.
- Severe illnesses and injuries.
- Strangers in camp.
- Aquatic emergencies as appropriate for the site; and,
- Other emergency situations as appropriate for the site.
- Requires the plan to include procedures for:
- Evacuation of the camp site,
- Control of vehicular traffic through the camp, and
- Communication from persons at the site of an emergency to the emergency medical facilities, the nearest fire station, and both administrative and health staff of the camp.
- Requires camp staff to be trained in implementation of the procedures set forth in the emergency plan.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill, as amended on June 23, 2020, has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author: “Millions of children are in the care of thousands of unregulated, unlicensed California camps. Children have died or been catastrophically injured, suffered sexual predation and succumbed to a wide variety of health and safety abuses, yet the State of California continues to be one of only 12 states in America that has failed to require day camp licensing, let alone its inadequate oversight of overnight (resident) camp operations. Camp inspections, if administered at all, primarily focus on building or facilities code compliance, not personnel or programming.
Camp operators are not required to have any experience caring for children or building relevant programming. They can hire whomever they want without scrutiny. They can provide as little training as they choose. And, they can also withhold critical information from parents and guardians, preventing them from making fully informed decisions. Camp operators have also become savvy at exploiting loopholes, structuring themselves in such a way that avoids oversight. Because current law does not require health officials to demand corrective actions, non-compliant camps do not have to remediate unsafe practices. There are no penalties associated with hazardous (and even fatal) programs. Day camps are operating in our state right now without enforceable mandates to ensure precautions are taken to limit the spread of COVID-19. Camps around the country are already experiencing COVID-19 outbreaks.”
- BACKGROUND.
- Role of LHAs. This bill would require LHAs to license and have overall regulatory authority over organized and recreational camps. LHAs have a broad mandate to take measures necessary to preserve and protect public health. LHAs administer many of the programs identified under DPH, and LHAs have a fundamental role as the front line for delivery of public health services to California’s communities. The structure and size of LHAs vary by jurisdiction, and some include operations such as public hospitals, primary care clinics, and animal control services. Select core functions include:
- Infectious disease control. LHAs prevent and control the spread of infectious diseases through immunizations, epidemiologic surveillance, disease investigation, laboratory testing and response activities;
- Emergency preparedness and response. LHAs work to ensure communities are informed, supplies and medications are accessible, and that there is capacity to expand medical services in large events. In addition, LHAs utilize public health labs to investigate and identify potential bioterrorism threats. In the event of a disaster, LHAs may staff shelters and screen for infectious diseases and address the needs for medically fragile residents; and,
- Maternal, child, and adolescent health. LHAs work to identify, disseminate, and promote emerging and evidence-based information about early interventions in prenatal and early childhood periods that promote lifelong health, positive social-emotional development, and reduce health disparities.
- Organized camps. The current definition of an organized camp applies only to sites that are established to provide an outdoor group living experience for five or more days a year, and ostensibly house campers overnight. An alternative to these overnight camps, or “resident camps” is day camps or recreational camps as this bill defines, which are generally local and do not provide multiple overnight stays for campers. Day camps often do not have a fixed site, and instead operate in parks, beaches, churches, schools, Boys and Girls Clubs, or YMCA facilities, and are therefore not subject to the laws that regulate organized camps, as currently defined.
- Accreditation. As stated in existing regulations above, organized camps must annually submit to the LHO a written verification that the organized camp is accredited by the American Camp Association (ACA) or a written description of operating procedures, as specified. According to information published in the ACA’s internet website, the camp industry is an $18 billion industry, and according to 2017 data, more than 14,000 day and resident camps exist in the country; 8,400 are resident (overnight) and 5,600 are day camps. Each year more than 14 million children and adults attend camp; 44% of camps offer specialized programs for individuals with disabilities; 86% of camps offer recreational swimming; 63% offer camping skills; 47% offer climbing/rappelling; 34% offer horseback riding; 75% teambuilding; 41% community service; 23% farming/ranching/gardening, and, 21% wilderness trips. Additionally, ACA states that 49% of camps report some relationship to schools or school curricula. One out of every five camps partner directly with schools as part of their academic programs during the school year.
ACA collaborates with experts from the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Red Cross, and other youth-serving agencies to assure that current practices at camps reflect the most up-to-date, research-based standards in camp operation from staff qualifications and training to emergency management. Camps and ACA form a partnership that promotes growth and fun in an environment committed to safety. ACA accreditation typically goes beyond basic licensing requirements particularly in the following areas:- Staff-to-camper ratios that are appropriate for different age groups;
- Goals for camp activities that are developmentally based;
- Emergency transportation available at all times; and,
- First-aid facilities and trained staff available when campers are present.
- Day care centers. There have been concerns that organizations have been operating as day camps in an effort to circumvent strict licensing requirements of day care centers. Some counties, in an attempt to regulate day camps, have classified them as day care centers. Day care center regulations differ significantly from organized camp regulations, in terms of staffing requirements, child population allowances, and operating hours. For example, day care center regulations prohibit more than 12 children from receiving care in the same place at the same time, and require that the program be operated only during normal school hours. Most organized day camps do not meet child care center regulations, and the author suggests that it has led to some day camps being shut down.
- Public Health Workforce. This bill would require LHAs to establish a regulatory program for the licensing of camps which would require staffing specific to this licensing program. However, it should be noted that public health agencies and their workforce have been struggling for years due mostly to underfunding. According to the Final Report of the California Future Health Workforce Commission, California (report) the public health workforce in California is chronically underfunded, and most local public health agencies lack personnel with expertise in key areas, such as epidemiology, and the essential skills to design, implement, and evaluate comprehensive approaches to community health improvement. Many LHAs report challenges in recruiting and retaining well-qualified workers, citing a lack of tools for recruiting, limited options for advancement, and instability of funded positions.
The report points out the following: At the state level, 61% of managers and supervisors, and 44% of nonsupervisory staff, are currently eligible for retirement. DPH estimates that two-thirds of its workforce will retire in the next five years. Both state and local public health agencies face increasing competition with the private sector, which provides higher pay, and amenities such as updated technology. Local public health agencies have an increasing demand for skilled professionals in areas such as epidemiology to better design and monitor evidence-based interventions that optimize use of available resources. A 2005 study found that only 25% of local public health agencies employed people with epidemiological expertise; patterns of public sector funding since suggest that these percentages have not increased substantially. Many LHAs report challenges in recruiting and retaining well-qualified workers, citing a lack of tools for recruiting, limited options for advancement, and instability of funded positions. Moreover, approximately 95% of current funding for government public health is tied to categorical programs, leaving very few resources for the design, implementation, and evaluation of comprehensive strategies to improve health and well-being. - Pandemic Response. LHAs around the country have lead on the frontlines of the COVID-19 response as they do everything possible and put their own safety at risk to protect the health of their communities. LHAs are playing a critical role in testing, tracing, and tracking the spread of the corona virus; providing up-to-date health information and education to communities; collaborating with mental and behavioral health organizations to reduce anxiety and promote well-being in these uncertain times; and offering resources to help battle stigma and discrimination. According to a Health Affairs blog entitled “No Longer Invisible: The Critical Role of LHAs in Responding to COVID-19,” despite intense media coverage of the pandemic, there has been limited public recognition of the role of LHAs in preparing for and responding to crises such as COVID-19. LHAs are engaged in many activities that are necessary to slow the epidemic and minimize its impact on communities. However, while LHAs are critical to COVID-19 response, “they are chronically underfunded, with limited investment in the public health workforce. Funding is siloed, with grants typically supporting activities on projects to address specific disease areas such as obesity or opioids rather than basic public health functions. Although federal emergency funding for COVID-19 will trickle down to LHAs, the current model of receiving emergency disaster relief funding is both inefficient and unsustainable. Focused attention is needed to address workforce training and bolster recruitment and retention because a recent survey suggests that approximately one-fifth of the LHA workforce is considering leaving their position in the next year for reasons other than retirement.”
- Role of LHAs. This bill would require LHAs to license and have overall regulatory authority over organized and recreational camps. LHAs have a broad mandate to take measures necessary to preserve and protect public health. LHAs administer many of the programs identified under DPH, and LHAs have a fundamental role as the front line for delivery of public health services to California’s communities. The structure and size of LHAs vary by jurisdiction, and some include operations such as public hospitals, primary care clinics, and animal control services. Select core functions include:
- SUPPORT. According the American Academy of Pediatrics, this bill would establish standards and a licensing process for these camps correcting this omission in state law and bring camps in line with other regulated services such as daycare facilities to help keep California children safe. It states that thousands of California camps are not licensed or properly inspected. Currently, counties do not inspect camps or enforce oversight for background checks, emergency action plans or proper health and safety inspections, other than those inspections directly related to facilities which vary widely by county. Many of these camps offer high-risk activities including riflery, archery, fencing, zip lines, horseback riding, tomahawk throwing, steep rock climbing, and aquatics. Unlicensed camps have not been required to provide criminal background checks, emergency action plans, training and certifications resulting in tragedies.
- CONCERNS. The Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) states that camps owned or operated by Local Educational Agencies should be exempted from this bill. LAUSD states that the licensing requirements in this bill would be duplicative, increase costs, delay the operation of existing programs, and place and unnecessary burden on local school districts.
Touchstone Climbing and the Plante Granite Climbing, Yoga and Fitness are concern about the broad definition of recreational camps implies that any business offering youth instructional services, including coaching programs and charity programs, would be deemed a camp and subject to a myriad of regulations. - OPPOSITION. Several camps are opposed to this bill. According to the Sacramento State Aquatic Center and ASI Peak Adventures at Sacramento State University, this bill would impact the services they provider to area youth and the community. They both state that this bill would add constraints not only fiscally but programmatically and would prevent a needed resource from being accessed.
Western Association of Independent Camps, California Waterfowl Association, Boy Scouts of America Greater Los Angeles Area Council, California Inland Empire Council Boy Scouts of America, Camp Kinneret, Long Beach Area Council Boy Scouts of America, Camp Tawonga all state that this bill places unreasonable requirements and restrictions on camps. For example, this bill would extend licensing requirements on camps or every youth program, including those offering dance lessons, karate classes, troop scout meetings and soccer camps, and could completely overwhelm LHAs with little meaningful oversight for any programs. They also state that examples of onerous provisions include: requirement that camps could not hire young people to work at camp unless they have been previous campers, which is not necessarily indicative of a good employee; and, it puts requirements on aquatics that would be impossible to meet. Additionally, they state that although this bill identifies a potential gap in the state’s duty to protect its youth who attend camps, this duty should be further explored. The current version of this bill is difficult to interpret, misses safety concerns common to other codes, imposes unrealistic demands on camps and regulatory agents which are not supported by evidence and has some components that are at odds with common standards.
The International Health, Racquet & Sportsclub Association states in its opposition that this bill is overly broad and ambiguous and could lead to the dissolution of a large number of California children’s camps. - OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. County of Humboldt, County of Santa Clara, California State Association of Counties, Urban Counties of California, Rural County Representatives of California, County Health Executives Association of California, Health Officers Association of California, the California Conference of Directors of Environmental Health state that this bill as currently written places the sole oversight of recreational day camps on LHAs, including disciplines that are beyond their scope, such as child supervision and safety. They request that this bill should instead create a taskforce of relevant stakeholders to convene and provide recommendations to the Legislature on a regulatory structure that affords greater safety to children and families.
The California Park and Recreation Society and California Special Districts Association which represent municipal parks departments and special districts requests an exemption from this bill.
The California Alliance of Boys and Girls Club and California State Alliance of YMCAs state that this bill should also incorporate well-established accreditation guidelines (like the ACA) into any additional regulation of camps.
The California Association of Museums requests an exemption for programs operated by museums. - RELATED LEGISLATION. SB 955 (Portantino) is substantially similar to the provisions of this bill, and was triple referred to the following Senate Committees: Health, Governance and Finance and Judiciary. SB 955 was not set for a hearing in Senate Health Committee due to the shortened Legislative calendar as a result of the COVID-10 pandemic.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 1964 (Maienschein) of 2018 would have revised the definition of organized camp to include both organized resident camps and organized day camps and establishes definitions and requirements for these camps, as specified. AB 1964 was held in the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
- SB 476 (Mendoza), of 2015, would have redefined organized camps and separates them into two types: resident camps and day camps and would have required organized day camps to follow existing public health and safety codes and regulations. SB 476 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 443 (Walters), of 2013, would have defined organized camps and organized day camps and would have established requirements regarding their operation. SB 443 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 1087 (Walters), Chapter 652, Statutes of 2012, increases the time in which an organization participating in the Safe Neighborhoods Partnership program can operate without a license. SB 1087 also exempts organized camps from licensure required for day care centers.
- SB 737 (Walters), of 2011, was substantially similar to SB 443 (Walters) of 2013. SB 737 was vetoed. In his veto message, the Governor Schwarzenegger stated, “I agree with the author's intent to clarify and simply the regulation of organized camps, but this measure does not achieve this goal. I am directing the Department of Public Health and Department of Social Services to work with the author and interested advocates to resolve this issue in the coming year.”
- AB 1964 (Maienschein) of 2018 would have revised the definition of organized camp to include both organized resident camps and organized day camps and establishes definitions and requirements for these camps, as specified. AB 1964 was held in the Assembly Appropriations suspense file.
- POLICY COMMENTS
- Task Force. This bill establishes robust regulatory structure and requirements for camps, specifically day camps (or recreational camps as this bill defines), which are not currently subject to any state licensing, enforcement or other regulatory requirements. SB 955 (Portantino), a substantially similar bill, was introduced in the Senate and was referred to the Senate Committees on Health, Governance and Finance, and Judiciary but was not set for a hearing due to the shortened Legislative calendar brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic. This bill’s first policy hearing is with Assembly Health Committee and given the lack of vetting and discussion on the numerous requirements that would be imposed on camps, the Committee may wish to instead create a task force that will submit recommendations to the Legislature on how to regulate these camps.
- Licensing. This bill would require any person that operates a camp to get a license issued by a LHD. Any licensing scheme involves extensive regulatory requirements that needs to be fully developed for proper implementation. Some issues that need further exploration and evaluation, and may benefit from recommendations of a task force, include:
- Revocation and Suspension. This bill grants LHAs the sole authority to suspend, or revoke licenses for camps. However, it provides limited guidance on how the processes for revocation or suspension could occur. Moreover, this bill is silent on whether LHAs have authority to close camps with revoked licenses and conditions for re-opening, if any. As such, the Committee may wish to further define the requirements or minimum standards for the revocation or suspension of a license.
- Investigations, Handling of Complaints, and Commencement of Actions against Camps. Under this bill, LHAs will conduct the investigations, collect physical evidence, handle complaints and commence actions against camps for violations. Examples of these violations include sexual predation or abuse, harassment, bullying, and physical abuse. These are penal code violations that involve analysis of a crime and proper handling of potential evidence. These types of investigations are generally done by investigators with peace officer status (for example, healing arts boards that license health care practitioners), because of the nature of the crime and legal issues involved; however this bill is silent on who or how these types of investigations should be conducted.
- Due Process. This bill allows an LHA to temporarily suspend the operation of a camp pending a hearing, but it is silent on whether a hearing or appeal process is also available when a license is revoked, and whether other due process requirements are available.
- Civil Penalties. This bill states that a “civil penalty shall not exceed $200 per day.” The Committee may wish to explore whether this fine is appropriate and sufficient for all types of violations under this bill.
- Licensing Fees. This bill permits LHAs to charge an application fee and renewal fee not to exceed the reasonable costs to the local agency for issuing licenses and conducting its duties under this bill or $1, 250, whichever is less. It is unclear if there was basis for the licensing fees established by this bill. This bill’s intent seems to be that the licensing fees has to sustain the licensing program, however it is unclear if the fees imposed by this bill is sufficient. The Committee may wish to explore whether a licensing fee analysis needs to be conducted to ensure the program is sustainable.
- Role of DPH. This bill includes provisions that applies to DPH but needs further clarification. For example, for high-risk activities, this bill requires the LHAs to conduct the investigation of camper fatality injury, write reports for these incidents, and provide remedial plans to DPH but is silent on what DPH should do with this information. As such, the Committee may wish to further clarify to role of DPH in the bill’s enforcement, if any.
- Authority Over Unlicensed Camps. This bill gives LHAs licensing authority over camps, but does not expressly grant LHAs authority over unlicensed activity/camps. The Committee may wish to clarify LHAs authority over unlicensed camps, including their inspection and enforcement authority to investigate unlicensed activity.
- Health Director. This bill requires camps to “employ” at least one health director that is a licensed physician, certified nurse practitioner or physician assistant with documented pediatric training of at least two years who must be “present at all times.” Current regulations for organized camps requires that if a physician is not onsite when campers are present, arrangements shall be made for a physician to be available on an on-call basis. The Committee may wish to consider whether the existing requirements to have a physician on call should apply to this bill.
- Council. This bill requires the Council to be appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate. The Committee may wish to clarify whether the Council appointments need this type of formality; and how this process could delay the establishment of the Council.
- Staffing Requirements. This bill establishes various camp, counselor, swimmer, and, nonswimmer ratio requirements. However, it is unclear how the staffing ratio requirements were developed, and whether they are consistent or goes beyond industry standards.
- Negative Pressure Room. This bill requires an overnight camp to have a designated isolation room that is suitably equipped, including a ventilation system capable of providing negative pressure. Negative pressure rooms are used in hospitals and medical centers to prevent cross-contamination from room to room to isolate patients with airborne contagious diseases, including COVID-19. Negative pressure rooms are costly and it is not clear if camps can afford and have the appropriate space for negative pressure rooms. The Committee may wish to evaluate the need to require negative pressure rooms for overnight camps.
- Surveillance cameras. This bill would also require camp swimming pools to be surrounded by as many surveillance cameras as needed to cover the entire expanse of the pool. Surveillance cameras are important tools to prevent accidents but it is not clear if the requirement to have “as many surveillance cameras as needed” is overly burdensome, and if this bill would require camps to have someone watching these cameras at all times. Additionally, footage from surveillance cameras can also be used as legal evidence, and if so, are there privacy, consent and disclosure requirements that must be considered?
- Impact on Camps. Many of the opponents state that this bill will severely impact camps because of the costs associated with compliance and some claim that this bill could potentially drive numerous day camps out of business. The Committee may wish to ask the author to respond to these claims.
- Task Force. This bill establishes robust regulatory structure and requirements for camps, specifically day camps (or recreational camps as this bill defines), which are not currently subject to any state licensing, enforcement or other regulatory requirements. SB 955 (Portantino), a substantially similar bill, was introduced in the Senate and was referred to the Senate Committees on Health, Governance and Finance, and Judiciary but was not set for a hearing due to the shortened Legislative calendar brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic. This bill’s first policy hearing is with Assembly Health Committee and given the lack of vetting and discussion on the numerous requirements that would be imposed on camps, the Committee may wish to instead create a task force that will submit recommendations to the Legislature on how to regulate these camps.
- DRAFTING CONCERNS. The author may wish to clarify various drafting issues with this bill, including the following:
- Definition of license. This bill defines a license to mean a permit issued by DPH to legally operate a camp. However, in Section 18897.10, the bill states that “a person shall not operate a camp, or cause or allow the same to be operated without a license issued by a local health agency.” The author may wish to clarify the definition of license to reflect the intent of the bill.
- Emergency Procedures. On page 12, lines 33-35, the bill refers to the requirement that the camp’s operating procedures must describe “emergency procedures” twice. The author may wish to clarify if there are differences in these emergency procedures.
- Inspections. On page 14, lines 34-38, a LHA is required to conduct an inspection upon the request or complaint of any person with “legitimate reason for concern.” Legitimate reason for concern is vague and overbroad. The author may wish to clarify these terms or create a more objective standard.
- Role of Council. On page 15, lines 36-38, this bill requires DPH, in cooperation with the Council, to adopt regulations establishing procedures for the imposition of civil penalties. The author may wish to clarify his intent on how DPH should cooperate with the Council which is an advisory body in adopting regulations.
- Financial complaints. On page18, line 26, DPH and the Council in their report to the Legislature beginning in 2022, must include a breakdown of complaints, including “financial complaints.” The author may wish to clarify what constitutes financial complaints for purposes of this bill.
- District Health Officer. On page 25, line 7-8, this bill refers to a district health officer. However, there is no such designation in the state. The author may wish to delete this.
- Health director. On page 7, lines 20-25, the bill defines a health director as a physician, registered nurse, licensed vocational nurse, or a person with qualified training under the California Child Day Care Act, as specified. However, on page 25, lines 18-21, the bill requires a recreational camp to hire at least one health director who is a licensed physician, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant. The author may wish to clarify which health care practitioners would qualify as a health director.
- Code reference. On page 38, lines 26-29, the bill requires the recreational camp to meet minimum lifeguard-to-camper ratios established in Section 18897.52. However, Section 18897.52 relates to youth sports concussion protocols. The author may wish to add the appropriate code section.
- PROPOSED AMENDMENTS. The Committee proposes to delete the provisions of this bill and instead require the Secretary of the State Health and Human Services Agency to convene the California Camp Safety Task Force (Task Force) on January 1, 2021 and require the Task Force to submit recommendations to the Legislature by February 15, 2022 on options to create the regulatory scheme for days camps and strengthen the regulations of overnight camps.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Opposition
Alliance Redwoods Conference Grounds
Associated Students/Sacramento State Aquatic Center
Associated Students/Sacramento State Peak Adventures
Benevolent Enterprises/Camp Morning Star
Bnei Akiva of Los Angeles
California Arts Advocates
California Bowmen Hunters – State Archery Association
California Deer Association
California Hawking Club
California Houndsmen for Conservation
California Inland Empire Council - Boy Scouts of America
California Rifle & Pistol Association
California Sportsman’s Lobby
California Waterfowl Association
Calvin Crest Conferences
Cal-Ore Wetlands and Waterfowl Council
Camp Alandale
Camp Alonim/American Jewish University
Camp Arev
Camp Kinneret
Camp Tawonga
Camp Unalayee
Climbing Wall Association
Forest Home Christian Conference Center
Gold Arrow Camp
Golden Empire Council - Boy Scouts of America
Golden Gate Area Council - Boy Scouts of America
Congressional Sportsmen’s Foundation
Greater Los Angeles Area Council - Boy Scouts of America
Habonim Dror Camp Gilboa
Hartland Christian Camp
Hartstone Bible Conference
Indian Hills Camp
International Health, Racquet & Sports Club Association
JH Ranch
Koinonia Conference Grounds
Lighthouse for the Blind and Visually Impaired
Long Beach Area Council - Boy Scouts of America
Nor-Cal Guides & Sportsmen’s Association
Oshman Family Jewish Community Center
Outdoor Sportsmen’s Coalition of California
Outward Bound California
Pacific Skyline Council - Boy Scouts of America
Pali Adventures
Palomar Christian Conference Center
Presbytery of San Joaquin
Regular Baptist Conference of Southern California/Victory Ranch
Rocky Mountain Elk Foundation
Safari Club International – California Chapters
Safari Club International – San Francisco Bay Chapter
Sequoia Council - Boy Scouts of America
Suisun Resource Conservation District
The Stronghold Climbing Gym
Tulare Basin Wetlands Association
University Student Union, California State University Northridge
URJ 6 Points Sci Tech Academy
San Diego County Wildlife Association
The Black Brant Group
Ventura County Council - Boy Scouts of America
Western Association of Independent Camps
Wild Sheep Foundation – California Chapter
Numerous individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Rosielyn Pulmano / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 217 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 217
Author: Portantino (D) and Roth (D), et al.
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/10/19
AYES: Leyva, Wilk, Chang, Durazo, Glazer, McGuire, Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Special education: individuals with exceptional needs
DIGEST:
This bill creates the Early Intervention Grant Program to increase inclusive access to early education programs for children with exceptional needs and expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten to include children with exceptional needs turning five years old at any time during the school year.
Existing law:
- Establishes a “census-based” funding system for the allocation of state special education funds, providing most funding supporting special education programs on the basis of the average daily attendance (ADA), multiplied by a funding rate unique to each Special Education Local Plan Areas.
- Requires local educational agencies to provide specially defined instruction, and related services, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of children with exceptional needs. These services are in addition to what a non-special education student receives and are required for children with disabilities from age 3 to 22, or until they graduate from high school.
- Defines “transitional kindergarten” as the first year of a two-year kindergarten program that uses a modified kindergarten curriculum that is age and developmentally appropriate.
- Specifies that, as a condition of a school district or charter school receiving a state apportionment for transitional kindergarten students, a child shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday is between September 2 and December 2.
- Allows a school district or charter school to admit a child to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday will be after December 2, as specified. Such children do not generate ADA for state funding purposes until they turn five years old.
This bill:
- Expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten, beginning in the 2019-20 school year, by specifying that a child who will have their fifth birthday after December 2 and during the same school year and who is an individual with exceptional needs shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten, with the approval of the parent or guardian, subject to the following conditions:
- The governing board of the school district or charter school determines that the admittance is in the best interests of the child to the extent permitted under a child’s individualized education program (IEP).
- The parent or guardian is given information regarding the advantages and disadvantages and any other explanatory information about the effect of this early admittance.
- Establishes the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program for the purpose of increasing inclusive access to early education programs and supporting young children with special needs.
- Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to allocate $4,000 per child within a school district of residence meeting the following criteria:
- Is three or four years old.
- Meets the definition of an individual with exceptional needs.
- Is receiving a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, except that a child enrolled in transitional kindergarten must meet the eligibility criteria for transitional kindergarten outlined above.
- Prohibits any school district from admitting a child meeting the definition of an individual with exceptional needs into a regular education program if that admittance would violate the child’s IEP, as required by Section 1414(d) of Title 20 of the United States Code.
- Specifies that grant funding apportioned to school districts must be used solely to provide services for individuals with exceptional needs pursuant to an IEP.
- Requires, as a condition of receiving funds, a school district to coordinate with its special education local plan area to provide data to the SPI on the number of children with an IEP in each type of care setting, the percentage of children who received a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, the expenditure of grant funds, and other outcome-related measures as determined by the SPI.
- Requires the SPI to report the aforementioned data to the appropriate fiscal and policy committees of the Legislature, the Department of Finance, the state board, and the Legislative Analyst’s Office by March 1 of each year.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “…approximately 50,000 children age 3 and 4 have been identified as having a disability. State Preschool and Head Start serve approximately 15,000 of these children. Of the 15,000, state preschool’s serve less than 3,000 of these students. California does not do enough to support students with disabilities, which detrimentally affects this already marginalized group.”
“Current law requires Special Education Local Plan Areas (SELPAs) to serve children with disabilities from age 3 or older. The AB 602 formula for Special Education funding provides SELPAs with funding based on a census model and uses the count of K-12 attendance including Transitional Kindergarten (TK). Children not included in TK are not included in the attendance count for purposes of generating funding.”
“Research supports the importance of quality early education programs for children with disabilities both for the potential to improve outcomes for children at earlier ages and to result in financial savings to school districts over the long-term.”
- Special education funding history. In 1975, California developed its Master Plan for Special Education, which expanded the types of services schools were required to provide students with disabilities. In that same year, Congress passed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. The Master Plan also required all districts to join SELPAs responsible for coordinating special education among its member districts. Lastly, the Master Plan introduced a simplified funding system (J-50 system) based on the following three types of special education services: (1) special day classes attended only by students with disabilities, (2) resource specialists providing pull-out instructional support, and (3) designated instruction and services supplementing general instruction.
Under the J-50 funding system, schools received one rate for each special day class they operated, another rate for each resource specialist, and another for each employee providing designated instruction and services. Each SELPA’s rates were set based on a statewide survey of special education costs in 1979-80, which no longer reflected the full range of services offered by the mid-1990s. In response, the state adopted a new special education system based on overall attendance (AB 602 system) which is still used today.
- Current special education funding system. Since the enactment of AB 602 in 1998, the state has funded SELPAs based on their overall attendance of students in kindergarten through grade 12, regardless of how many of these students are eligible for special education services, the specific disabilities of those students, or what types of services those students receive. This census-based approach was intended to eliminate the complexity and perverse incentives of the previous system.
When the AB 602 system was first introduced, the state set each SELPA’s per-student funding rate equal to its total funding in the last year under the previous system divided by its total student population in that year. Because funding rates varied notably under the previous system, the new rates established under AB 602 also varied notably.
Although funding rates remain unequal, AB 602 has largely achieved the state’s original goals of simplifying funding and encouraging instructional innovation. Regarding simplicity, schools no longer complete complicated paperwork based on intricate formulas before they receive state funding. Regarding innovation, the proportion of students with severe disabilities being served in mainstream settings has doubled since the late 1990s (from 15 to 30 percent).
- Inclusive educational settings for preschool-age children with disabilities. Research confirms that most 3- to 5-year-olds with disabilities learn best when they attend preschools alongside their peers without disabilities to the greatest extent possible. These inclusive settings provide language and behavioral models that assist in children’s development and help all children learn to be productively engaged with diverse peers. However, only one in five preschool-aged children with identified disabilities is enrolled in such settings as general education preschools are not available in every part of the state. The result is that, in many cases, students with disabilities are only offered more restrictive, isolated, and costly program settings. By not being educated with their nondisabled peers, these children often fail to attain the skills they need to succeed in school, and the schools incur a greater expense because of the additional services these students will require later.
State and federal laws require local educational agencies (LEAs) to provide services for three- and four-year-olds with exceptional needs. While some federal and local funds are available to assist with the costs for providing special education services for preschool-age children, no state funding is specifically provided through AB 602 for this purpose. It is estimated that LEAs spent approximately $500 million in 2014-15 for special education preschool services.
This bill establishes an early intervention grant program, providing $4,000 per preschool-age child and requiring school districts, as a condition of receiving funding, to provide inclusive and flexible preschool programs.
- Transitional kindergarten. Transitional kindergarten is the first year of a two-year kindergarten program that uses a modified kindergarten curriculum that is age and developmentally appropriate. Transitional kindergarten currently serves “older” four-year-olds and “young” five-year-olds who have their fifth birthday after the cut-off date for kindergarten (between September 2 and December 2). Eligibility for transitional kindergarten is limited to this cohort of students because they would have been eligible for kindergarten under the previous entry-age.
Most local educational agencies provide a four-hour or longer Transitional Kindergarten program. A report submitted by the California Department of Education, “Kindergarten in California: Implementation Evaluation of Transitional Kindergarten and Kindergarten Public School Programs in California” reported that approximately 70 percent of children eligible for transitional kindergarten attended a program in the 2015-16 school year. Of these attendees, 57 percent were from socioeconomically-disadvantaged families and 36 percent were learning English. Unlike preschool or other early education programs, transitional kindergarten teachers must meet the same requirements as kindergarten teachers, including being fully credentialed.
This bill expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten to all four year olds identified for special education services, expanding the array of preschool programs available to these children and increasing ADA for districts. This increase in ADA would generate additional funding for districts through all of the attendance-based state funding programs, including the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and the special education program (AB 602) discussed above.
- Governor’s special education concentration grant proposal. The 2019-20 Governor’s Budget includes a proposal to create special education concentration grants for local educational agencies (LEAs) with high percentages of students that are both disabled and low-income, in foster care, or learning English. Eligible LEAs can use these grants to fund services not currently included in an individualized education program.
This bill differs from the Governor’s proposal by providing funding to school districts based on the number of preschool-age children with disabilities they serve, with the goal of intensifying early interventions so fewer special education services will be needed later. The Governor’s proposal, on the other hand, would target funding to those districts already receiving additional funding under the LCFF (those serving low-income, foster, and English learning students) and those that identify a higher than average proportion of students with disabilities.
Would the Governor’s proposal create a disincentive for LEAs to provide early interventions aimed at reducing special education services long-term given that a reduction in special education students would result in a reduction in funding? Would the Governor’s lack of restricting the use of grant funds to special education services only result in districts supplanting school readiness programs that they were already planning to offer? Lastly, is the correlation between low-income, foster, and English-learning students and special education identification strong enough to warrant these factors being tied together in a funding formula?
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- This bill’s establishment of the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program would be contingent upon an appropriation. However, assuming between 24,000 and 33,000 students are eligible to receive a program grant, this bill would create Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure ranging from approximately $227 million to $450 million each year. This estimate factors in the base increases to the LCFF and special education program funding (AB 602) resulting from the new TK average daily attendance (ADA). A precise amount would depend on the actual increase in newly eligible TK students.
- Over the long-term, this bill’s provisions are expected to produce financial savings to school districts resulting from the additional investment in early interventions for children with disabilities at an earlier age (so fewer and more costly special education services will be needed later).
Avid Center
California Association of Private Special Education Schools
California Association of School Psychologists
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California School Employees Association
California State PTA
Central Valley Education Coalition
Disability Rights California
Fresno County Office of Education
Riverside County Office of Education
Pasadena Unified School District
Placer County Office of Education
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools
Simi Valley Unified School District
Small School Districts Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/15/19)
None received
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. /
5/20/19 11:04:19
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 217 (Portantino) - Special education: individuals with exceptional needs
Version: April 1, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill would create the Early Intervention Grant Program to increase inclusive access to early education programs for children with exceptional needs and also expand eligibility for transitional kindergarten (TK) to include children with exceptional needs turning five years old at any time during the school year.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- The bill’s establishment of the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program would be contingent upon an appropriation. However, assuming between 24,000 and 33,000 students are eligible to receive a program grant, this bill would create Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure ranging from approximately $227 million to $450 million each year. This estimate factors in the base increases to the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and special education program funding (AB 602) resulting from the new TK average daily attendance (ADA). A precise amount would depend on the actual increase in newly eligible TK students.
- Over the long-term, the bill’s provisions are expected to produce financial savings to school districts resulting from the additional investment in early interventions for children with disabilities at an earlier age (so fewer and more costly special education services will be needed later).
Committee Amendments:
Clarify that the bill’s provisions would be subject to an appropriation.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 217 (Portantino) - Special education: individuals with exceptional needs
Version: April 1, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 29, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill would create the Early Intervention Grant Program to increase inclusive access to early education programs for children with exceptional needs and also expand eligibility for transitional kindergarten (TK) to include children with exceptional needs turning five years old at any time during the school year.
Fiscal Impact:
- The bill’s establishment of the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program would be contingent upon an appropriation. However, assuming between 24,000 and 33,000 students are eligible to receive a program grant, this bill would create Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure ranging from approximately $227 million to $450 million each year. This estimate factors in the base increases to the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and special education program funding (AB 602) resulting from the new TK average daily attendance (ADA). A precise amount would depend on the actual increase in newly eligible TK students.
- Over the long-term, the bill’s provisions are expected to produce financial savings to school districts resulting from the additional investment in early interventions for children with disabilities at an earlier age (so fewer and more costly special education services will be needed later).
Background:
Existing law establishes a “census-based” funding system for the allocation of state special education funds, providing most funding supporting special education programs on the basis of the average daily attendance (ADA), multiplied by a funding rate unique to each Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA).
Existing law requires local educational agencies (LEAs) to provide specially defined instruction, and related services, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of children with exceptional needs. These services are in addition to what a non-special education student receives and are required for children with disabilities from age 3 to 22, or until they graduate from high school.
Existing law defines “transitional kindergarten” as the first year of a two-year kindergarten program that uses a modified kindergarten curriculum that is age and developmentally appropriate. The law specifies that, as a condition of a school district or charter school receiving a state apportionment for transitional kindergarten students, a child shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday is between September 2 and December 2. Existing law allows a school district or charter school to admit a child to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday will be after December 2, as specified. These children do not generate ADA for state funding purposes until they turn five years old.
Proposed Law:
This bill expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten, beginning in the 2019-20 school year, by specifying that a child who will have their fifth birthday after December 2 and during the same school year and who is an individual with exceptional needs shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten, with the approval of the parent or guardian, subject to the following conditions:
- The governing board of the school district or charter school determines that the admittance is in the best interests of the child to the extent permitted under a child’s individualized education program (IEP).
- The parent or guardian is given information regarding the advantages and disadvantages and any other explanatory information about the effect of this early admittance.
This bill establishes the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program for the purpose of increasing inclusive access to early education programs to the extent permitted under a child’s (IEP) and supporting young children with special needs. This bill requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to allocate $4,000 per child within a school district of residence meeting the following criteria: 1) is three or four years old; 2) meets the definition of an individual with exceptional needs; and 3) is receiving a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, except that a child enrolled in TK must meet the eligibility criteria for TK, as specified.
This bill prohibits any school district from admitting a child meeting the definition of an individual with exceptional needs into a regular education program if that admittance would violate the child’s IEP, as required by Section 1414(d) of Title 20 of the United States Code.
This bill specifies that grant funding apportioned to school districts must be used solely to provide services for individuals with exceptional needs pursuant to an IEP.
This bill requires, as a condition of receiving funds, a school district to coordinate with its SELPA to provide data to the SPI on the number of children with an IEP in each type of care setting, the percentage of children who received a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, the expenditure of grant funds, and other outcome-related measures as determined by the SPI. This bill requires the SPI to report this data to the appropriate fiscal and policy committees of the Legislature, the Department of Finance, the state board, and the Legislative Analyst’s Office by March 1 of each year.
Staff Comments:
Since the enactment of AB 602 in 1998, the state has funded SELPAs based on their overall attendance of students in kindergarten through grade 12, regardless of how many of these students are eligible for special education services, the specific disabilities of those students, or what types of services those students receive. This census-based approach was intended to eliminate the complexity and perverse incentives of the previous system. State and federal law require LEAs to provide services for three- and four-year-olds with exceptional needs. While some federal and local funds are available to assist with the costs for providing special education services for these children, no state funding is specifically provided through AB 602 for this purpose.
This bill would establish an early intervention grant program, providing $4,000 per preschool-age child and requiring school districts, as a condition of receiving funding, to provide inclusive and flexible preschool programs. This bill would also expand eligibility for transitional kindergarten to all four year olds identified for special education services, expanding the array of preschool programs available to these children and increasing ADA for districts. This increase in ADA would generate additional funding for districts through all of the attendance-based state funding programs, including the LCFF and the special education program (AB 602) funding.
The bill’s establishment of the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program would be contingent upon an appropriation. Assuming between 24,000 and 33,000 students are eligible, this bill would create Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure ranging from approximately $227 million to $450 million each year. This estimate assumes an increase in new TK students, potential growth in special education students, and an increase in identification rates. This estimate also factors in the base increases to the LCFF and AB 602 funding that would result from the new TK ADA. Over the long-term, the bill’s provisions are expected to produce financial savings to school districts resulting from the additional investment in early interventions for children with disabilities at an earlier age (so fewer and more costly special education services will be needed later).
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 217 Hearing Date: April 10, 2019
Author: | Portantino & Roth | |||||
Version: | April 1, 2019 | |||||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes | |||
Consultant: | Ian Johnson | |||||
Subject: Special education: individuals with exceptional needs.
SUMMARY
This bill creates the Early Intervention Grant Program to increase inclusive access to early education programs for children with exceptional needs and expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten to include children with exceptional needs turning five years old at any time during the school year.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Establishes a “census-based” funding system for the allocation of state special education funds, providing most funding supporting special education programs on the basis of the average daily attendance (ADA), multiplied by a funding rate unique to each Special Education Local Plan Areas.
- Requires local educational agencies to provide specially defined instruction, and related services, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of children with exceptional needs. These services are in addition to what a non-special education student receives and are required for children with disabilities from age 3 to 22, or until they graduate from high school.
- Defines “transitional kindergarten” as the first year of a two-year kindergarten program that uses a modified kindergarten curriculum that is age and developmentally appropriate.
- Specifies that, as a condition of a school district or charter school receiving a state apportionment for transitional kindergarten students, a child shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday is between September 2 and December 2.
- Allows a school district or charter school to admit a child to transitional kindergarten if their fifth birthday will be after December 2, as specified. Such children do not generate ADA for state funding purposes until they turn five years old.
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Expands eligibility for transitional kindergarten, beginning in the 2019-20 school year, by specifying that a child who will have their fifth birthday after December 2 and during the same school year and who is an individual with exceptional needs shall be admitted to transitional kindergarten, with the approval of the parent or guardian, subject to the following conditions:
- The governing board of the school district or charter school determines that the admittance is in the best interests of the child to the extent permitted under a child’s individualized education program (IEP).
- The parent or guardian is given information regarding the advantages and disadvantages and any other explanatory information about the effect of this early admittance.
- Establishes the Special Education Early Intervention Grant Program for the purpose of increasing inclusive access to early education programs and supporting young children with special needs.
- Requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI), subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, to allocate $4,000 per child within a school district of residence meeting the following criteria:
- Is three or four years old.
- Meets the definition of an individual with exceptional needs.
- Is receiving a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, except that a child enrolled in transitional kindergarten must meet the eligibility criteria for transitional kindergarten outlined above.
- Prohibits any school district from admitting a child meeting the definition of an individual with exceptional needs into a regular education program if that admittance would violate the child’s IEP, as required by Section 1414(d) of Title 20 of the United States Code.
- Specifies that grant funding apportioned to school districts must be used solely to provide services for individuals with exceptional needs pursuant to an IEP.
- Requires, as a condition of receiving funds, a school district to coordinate with its special education local plan area to provide data to the SPI on the number of children with an IEP in each type of care setting, the percentage of children who received a majority of special education and related services in the regular education program, the expenditure of grant funds, and other outcome-related measures as determined by the SPI.
- Requires the SPI to report the aforementioned data to the appropriate fiscal and policy committees of the Legislature, the Department of Finance, the state board, and the Legislative Analyst’s Office by March 1 of each year.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “…approximately 50,000 children age 3 and 4 have been identified as having a disability. State Preschool and Head Start serve approximately 15,000 of these children. Of the 15,000, state preschool’s serve less than 3,000 of these students. California does not do enough to support students with disabilities, which detrimentally affects this already marginalized group.”
“Current law requires Special Education Local Plan Areas (SELPAs) to serve children with disabilities from age 3 or older. The AB 602 formula for Special Education funding provides SELPAs with funding based on a census model and uses the count of K-12 attendance including Transitional Kindergarten (TK). Children not included in TK are not included in the attendance count for purposes of generating funding.”
“Research supports the importance of quality early education programs for children with disabilities both for the potential to improve outcomes for children at earlier ages and to result in financial savings to school districts over the long-term.”
- Special education funding history. In 1975, California developed its Master Plan for Special Education, which expanded the types of services schools were required to provide students with disabilities. In that same year, Congress passed the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act. The Master Plan also required all districts to join SELPAs responsible for coordinating special education among its member districts. Lastly, the Master Plan introduced a simplified funding system (J-50 system) based on the following three types of special education services: (1) special day classes attended only by students with disabilities, (2) resource specialists providing pull-out instructional support, and (3) designated instruction and services supplementing general instruction.
Under the J-50 funding system, schools received one rate for each special day class they operated, another rate for each resource specialist, and another for each employee providing designated instruction and services. Each SELPA’s rates were set based on a statewide survey of special education costs in 1979-80, which no longer reflected the full range of services offered by the mid-1990s. In response, the state adopted a new special education system based on overall attendance (AB 602 system) which is still used today.
- Current special education funding system. Since the enactment of AB 602 in 1998, the state has funded SELPAs based on their overall attendance of students in kindergarten through grade 12, regardless of how many of these students are eligible for special education services, the specific disabilities of those students, or what types of services those students receive. This census-based approach was intended to eliminate the complexity and perverse incentives of the previous system.
When the AB 602 system was first introduced, the state set each SELPA’s per-student funding rate equal to its total funding in the last year under the previous system divided by its total student population in that year. Because funding rates varied notably under the previous system, the new rates established under AB 602 also varied notably.
Although funding rates remain unequal, AB 602 has largely achieved the state’s original goals of simplifying funding and encouraging instructional innovation. Regarding simplicity, schools no longer complete complicated paperwork based on intricate formulas before they receive state funding. Regarding innovation, the proportion of students with severe disabilities being served in mainstream settings has doubled since the late 1990s (from 15 to 30 percent).
- Inclusive educational settings for preschool-age children with disabilities. Research confirms that most 3- to 5-year-olds with disabilities learn best when they attend preschools alongside their peers without disabilities to the greatest extent possible. These inclusive settings provide language and behavioral models that assist in children’s development and help all children learn to be productively engaged with diverse peers. However, only one in five preschool-aged children with identified disabilities is enrolled in such settings as general education preschools are not available in every part of the state. The result is that, in many cases, students with disabilities are only offered more restrictive, isolated, and costly program settings. By not being educated with their nondisabled peers, these children often fail to attain the skills they need to succeed in school, and the schools incur a greater expense because of the additional services these students will require later.
State and federal laws require local educational agencies (LEAs) to provide services for three- and four-year-olds with exceptional needs. While some federal and local funds are available to assist with the costs for providing special education services for preschool-age children, no state funding is specifically provided through AB 602 for this purpose. It is estimated that LEAs spent approximately $500 million in 2014-15 for special education preschool services.
This bill would establish an early intervention grant program, providing $4,000 per preschool-age child and requiring school districts, as a condition of receiving funding, to provide inclusive and flexible preschool programs.
- Transitional kindergarten. Transitional kindergarten is the first year of a two-year kindergarten program that uses a modified kindergarten curriculum that is age and developmentally appropriate. Transitional kindergarten currently serves “older” four-year-olds and “young” five-year-olds who have their fifth birthday after the cut-off date for kindergarten (between September 2 and December 2). Eligibility for transitional kindergarten is limited to this cohort of students because they would have been eligible for kindergarten under the previous entry-age.
Most local educational agencies provide a four-hour or longer Transitional Kindergarten program. A report submitted by the California Department of Education, “Kindergarten in California: Implementation Evaluation of Transitional Kindergarten and Kindergarten Public School Programs in California” reported that approximately 70 percent of children eligible for transitional kindergarten attended a program in the 2015-16 school year. Of these attendees, 57 percent were from socioeconomically-disadvantaged families and 36 percent were learning English. Unlike preschool or other early education programs, transitional kindergarten teachers must meet the same requirements as kindergarten teachers, including being fully credentialed.
This bill would expand eligibility for transitional kindergarten to all four year olds identified for special education services, expanding the array of preschool programs available to these children and increasing average daily attendance (ADA) for districts. This increase in ADA would generate additional funding for districts through all of the attendance-based state funding programs, including the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and the special education program (AB 602) discussed above.
- Governor’s special education concentration grant proposal. The 2019-20 Governor’s Budget includes a proposal to create special education concentration grants for local educational agencies (LEAs) with high percentages of students that are both disabled and low-income, in foster care, or learning English. Eligible LEAs can use these grants to fund services not currently included in an individualized education program.
This bill differs from the Governor’s proposal by providing funding to school districts based on the number of preschool-age children with disabilities they serve, with the goal of intensifying early interventions so fewer special education services will be needed later. The Governor’s proposal, on the other hand, would target funding to those districts already receiving additional funding under the LCFF (those serving low-income, foster, and English learning students) and those that identify a higher than average proportion of students with disabilities.
Would the Governor’s proposal create a disincentive for LEAs to provide early interventions aimed at reducing special education services long-term given that a reduction in special education students would result in a reduction in funding? Would the Governor’s lack of restricting the use of grant funds to special education services only result in districts supplanting school readiness programs that they were already planning to offer? Lastly, is the correlation between low-income, foster, and English-learning students and special education identification strong enough to warrant these factors being tied together in a funding formula?
SUPPORT
AVID Center
California Association of Private Special Education Schools
California Association of School Psychologists
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California School Employees Association
California State PTA
Central Valley Education Coalition
Disability Rights California
Fresno County Office of Education
Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Pasadena Unified School District
Placer County Office of Education
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools
Simi Valley Unified School District
Small School Districts Association
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):