SB 222: Discrimination: veteran or military status.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-08
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 601, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 8, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 10 a.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 36. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 36. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Joint Rule 61(a)(14) suspended. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (August 14). |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 7, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 33. Noes 1.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 8, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 10. |
| Feb 7, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB222 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | SB 222 Hill Senate Third Reading By Gloria | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB222 Hill et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 222 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 222
Amended: 9/9/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 33-1, 5/6/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Borgeas, Moorlach, Morrell
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 48-0, 9/13/19
(ROLL CALL NOT AVAILABLE)
SUBJECT: Discrimination: veteran or military status
DIGEST:
This bill underscores that housing discrimination on account of military or veteran status is unlawful in California by explicitly stating so within the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). In addition, by defining a Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (VASH) voucher as a source of income for purposes of FEHA, this bill prohibits landlords from discriminating against a tenant on the basis that the tenant pays part or all of the rent using a VASH voucher.
Assembly Amendments
(1) assure that the intent of the bill is accomplished by specifying that, for the purposes of source of income discrimination, VASH voucher rent payments made directly to a landlord are considered part of a tenant’s income; and (2) address chaptering out issues.
Existing law:
- States, as part of the FEHA, that it is against public policy to discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information in housing accommodations. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
- Declares that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, genetic information, or any other specified basis is a civil right. (Gov. Code § 12921.)
- Makes it unlawful for the owner of any housing accommodation to discriminate against or harass any person because of the race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information of that person. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Specifies certain acts that constitute unlawful discrimination, including either of the following:
- Using a financial or income standard in the rental of housing that fails to account for the aggregate income of persons residing together or proposing to reside together on the same basis as the aggregate income of married persons residing together or proposing to reside together; or
- In instances where there is a government rent subsidy, using a financial or income standard in assessing eligibility for the rental of housing that is not based on the portion of the rent to be paid by the tenant. (Gov. Code § 12955 (n), (o).)
- Provides that it shall not constitute discrimination based on source of income to make a written or oral inquiry concerning the level or source of income. (Gov. Code § 12955 (p).)
- Provides that a person intends to unlawfully discriminate if one of the protected classes played a motivating factor in committing a discriminatory housing practice, as specified. A violation can be found when the act has the effect of unlawfully discriminating, regardless of the intent, as specified. (Gov. Code § 12955.8.)
- Defines “source of income” to mean lawful, verifiable income paid directly to a tenant or paid to a representative of a tenant, but specifies that a landlord is not considered a representative of a tenant. (Gov. Code § 12927, 12955 (p).)
This bill:
- Adds “military and veteran status” to the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination in FEHA.
- Defines a VASH voucher as a source of income, including when voucher payments are made directly to the landlord, thus making it unlawful for a landlord to discriminate against tenants who use VASH vouchers to pay for part or all of their rent.
- Contains chaptering out provisions.
Comments
Homelessness among military veterans is a major problem. According to the U.S. Veterans Administration (VA) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), as of 2012 there were approximately 62,619 homeless veterans nationwide, of which about a quarter were located in California.[1] While the California Department of Veterans Affairs reports that the number of homeless veterans in the state “has been nearly cut in half” in recent years, there is general agreement that the homelessness rate among veterans remains unacceptably high. (Ibid.)
The high cost of housing is one major part of the problem. According to a 2013 National Low-Income Housing Coalition study on the topic, 1.5 million veteran households suffered from severe housing cost burden in 2011, spending more than 50 percent of their income on housing.[2] There were also significant disparities among veteran households, with veteran households headed by a racial minority, females, and those with a disability more likely to be cost burdened than their counterparts. (Ibid.)
Medical and psychological conditions act as further barriers to stable housing. According to the California Department of Veterans Affairs:
Veterans often suffer from conditions that make it difficult to find and maintain gainful employment and pay for housing. Along with the high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traumatic brain injury (TBI), the VA has found that approximately 55% of homeless veterans suffer from mental health issues, 70% are affected by substance abuse issues, and 40% of female homeless veterans report experience [sic] severe forms of mental illness, mostly due to higher rates of military sexual trauma (MST).[3]
VASH vouchers aim to address both of these challenges simultaneously. VASH vouchers subsidize rental payments for homeless veterans and come along with supportive services in the form of case management and clinical services. VASH vouchers can serve as an important tool for combatting homelessness among veterans, therefore. HUD awarded 1,882 VASH vouchers to California veterans in 2018.[4]
Under existing California law, however, landlords are not obligated to consider applicants with VASH vouchers, and many evidently will not. The Los Angeles Housing Authority reports data showing, for instance, that HUD-VASH housing vouchers have the lowest success rate among the housing vouchers the Authority issues, where “success” is defined as placing the voucher recipient in a rental unit. The success rate for general (non-veteran) Housing Choice Voucher recipients is 60 percent. The success rate for the Authority’s other non-veteran housing vouchers is 67 percent. By comparison, the success rate for HUD-VASH vouchers is a mere 33 percent.[5]
A National Public Radio story on the issue observed that the fact that California currently allows landlords to refuse to rent to HUD-VASH voucher holders “is seen as one reason that Los Angeles has the largest number of homeless vets nationwide, a number that rose last year.”[6]
This bill defines a VASH voucher as a “source of income” for purposes of the FEHA. Since FEHA prohibits housing discrimination based on source of income (Gov. Code § 12955(a)), this bill has the effect of making it unlawful for landlords to refuse to rent to a tenant merely because the tenant proposes to pay part or all of the rent through the use of a VASH voucher. A landlord would retain the authority to screen and to reject prospective tenants on any other lawful basis.
Landlord requirements associated with VASH vouchers
From the landlord’s perspective, renting to a tenant who will pay part or all of the rent with a VASH voucher is not as simple as just moving the person in and accepting rent payments. Before the federal government will subsidize rent payments to a landlord on behalf of a tenant, the landlord must comply with certain requirements. In summary form, those requirements are:
- The landlord must apply to the local public housing authority to be put on the list of approved HUD-VASH properties;
- The landlord must attend an informational session regarding the landlord’s rights and responsibilities as a participant in the HUD-VASH program;
- The landlord must schedule a HUD Housing Quality Standards inspection to ensure the property meets minimum residential housing codes; and
- The landlord and tenant must a sign a lease that complies with HUD-VASH lease requirements.[7]
Since this bill prohibits landlords from refusing to rent to a VASH voucher holder on that basis alone, landlords could no longer avoid exposure to the possibility of having to go through the steps outlined above by categorically refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders.
Going through these steps does represent some additional administrative burdens for a landlord in comparison with a standard, unsubsidized lease. If the process delays a tenant’s move-in date, going through these steps might result in some lost rental income. The opponents of this bill assert that:
[t]he Section 8 approval process for a rental property owner to participate is extremely time consuming and difficult to understand, with little assistance available to owners through the housing authorities. It includes a very lengthy document preparation process that owners and tenants must complete. Many small rental property owners simply do not have the resources to maneuver the long and complicated process.
On the other hand, many aspects of the VASH process for a landlord simply hold them accountable for things they are already legally required to do.
For example, to pass a HUD housing inspection on the first try, the VA recommends that landlords ensure that their rental properties have: working smoke alarm(s); proper ventilation in bathrooms (window or fan); connected utilities; a functional stove and refrigerator; a window in every bedroom that can stay open without props; a working water heater discharge line and pop/relief valves; handrails for steps; and secure railings for porches and balconies. By the same token, landlords are encouraged to make sure their rental properties do not have: broken or missing locks; broken or missing windows; bugs or vermin; tripping hazards on the floor; exposed electrical wiring; and chipping or peeling paint inside or outside.[8]
These are the nearly identical to the sort of bare minimum conditions that a landlord must maintain under California’s warranty of habitability. (Civ. Code § 1941.1.) Outside of the subsidized housing voucher context, however, only a few local government programs proactively inspect rental housing to ensure that it complies with these basic requirements. Thus, participating in subsidized housing programs like the VASH vouchers subjects landlords to greater accountability for providing and maintaining basic housing conditions for their tenants.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing for increased complaints of housing discrimination against tenants using VASH vouchers.
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
American Legion-Department of California
AMVETS-Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California Association of Veterans Service Agencies
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teachers Association
City of Los Angeles
City of Santa Monica
Military Officers Association of America-California Council of Chapters
Santa Clara County
Vietnam Veterans of America-California State Council
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/12/19)
California Association of Realtors
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
U.S. veterans and those currently serving in the armed forces are protected from employment discrimination by the California Fair Employment and Housing Act. However, the law does not specifically include veterans or military personnel among those who are protected from housing discrimination. SB 222 would address this gap by adding veterans and military personnel as a protected class in statutes relating to housing discrimination.
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
In support of this bill, the California Association of Veterans Service Agencies (CAVSA) writes:
CAVSA’s member agencies clearly understand the overwhelming issues confronting our veteran population and the dramatic need to protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill unless amended, the California Association of Realtors writes:
Under SB 222 […], every residential property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority requiring they accept tenants who use Section 8 HUD-VASH housing vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates. […] Many property owners, particularly small landlords with only one rental unit, struggle with those complex rules and regulations, which compromise their ability to provide quality housing at reasonable rents.
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/13/19 19:33:31
**** END ****
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Housing Instability Among Our Nations’ Veterans (Nov. 2013) National Low Income Housing Coalition, p. 1, http://nlihc.org/sites/default/files/NLIHC-Veteran-Report-2013.pdf (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
HUD and VA Secretaries Announce Housing Initiatives to Support Homeless Veterans (Oct. 3, 2018) https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/HUD_No_18_113 (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Success Rates CY2016, Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, on file with the Committee. ↑
Quil Lawrence, Washington State Attorney General: Housing Discrimination Against Veterans Is Evident (Mar. 5, 2018) National Public Radio www.npr.org/2018/03/05/590974647/washington-state-attorney-general-housing-discrimination-against-veterans-is-evi (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
See How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.va.gov/homeless/landlords.asp (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, supra U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. ↑
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 222
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:September 9, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits discrimination in housing accommodations based on military or veteran status. Also prohibits landlords and housing owners from discriminating against tenants who receive Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing vouchers.
Major Provisions
- Adds veteran or military status to the protected categories under numerous provisions of state law barring housing discrimination.
- Authorizes the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH), upon the request of certain parties, to provide assistance to communities and persons in resolving disputes, disagreements, or difficulties relating to discriminatory practices based upon military or veteran status
- Expands the definition of "source of income" protected from discrimination by landlords and housing owners under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to include federal Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (HUD-VASH) vouchers.
COMMENTS:
Veterans across the state face numerous challenges related to their physical health, mental health, and housing. FEHA prohibits employment discrimination based on veteran or military status, but largely does not prohibit housing discrimination based on these statuses. This bill amends FEHA to include military or veteran status as protected classes under its housing anti-discrimination provisions. Additionally, under current law, landlords may refuse to rent to a prospective tenant solely based on the tenant's use of a HUD-VASH voucher. This bill amends existing law prohibiting discrimination based on source of income to ensure that HUD-VASH vouchers could not be the sole reason for turning away a tenant.
Discrimination based on veteran or military status. While the Unruh Civil Rights Act broadly prohibits discrimination due to any arbitrary basis, explicitly codifying "military or veteran status" as a protected class can help ensure uniformity in the law, particularly since "military and veteran status" is already a protected class under state employment discrimination statutes.
Background on the HUD-VASH voucher program. Since 1992, the HUD-VASH program has sought to provide veterans with supportive services and housing assistance through a collaboration between the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) as part of the Housing Choice Voucher Program (commonly referred to as "Section 8"). There are a very limited number of HUD-VASH vouchers available in the state; slightly over 13,200 HUD-VASH vouchers were in use in California as of March 31, 2018.
By expanding the definition of "source of income" to include HUD-VASH vouchers, this measure would create a right for voucher holders to apply for rental housing. If a landlord turned down a rental application from a HUD-VASH voucher holder, the landlord would need a nondiscriminatory reason for the denial, just as the landlord would have to have a nondiscriminatory reason for refusing to rent to a person on the basis of their gender, sexual orientation, race, national origin, and so on.
This measure passed the Legislature last year, but was vetoed. SB 1427 (Hill) of 2018, a virtually-identical measure by the same author, was vetoed by then-Governor Brown.
The bill would not be preempted by federal law if it were enacted. The United States Housing Act makes no mention of landlord voluntariness as one of its purposes. It is therefore difficult to perceive how state laws banning voucher discrimination would conflict with the federal government's purposes in enacting the HUD-VASH program. To sum, the bill appears well-insulated from charges of federal preemption.
According to the Author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that veterans with HUD-VASH vouchers face unique struggles with finding housing. The California Association of County Veterans Service Officers notes:
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Association of Realtors opposes the provisions of this bill that would prohibit landlords from refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders, writing:
Under current law, participation by a rental property owner in the…Section 8 HUD-VASH program is voluntary. Under SB 222, which redefines "source of income" to include the Section 8 HUD-VASH program, every residential rental property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority upon receiving an application from a tenant who uses Section 8 HUD-VASH vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) for increased complaints of housing discrimination against tenants using VASH vouchers.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 33-1-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Moorlach, Morrell
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 9, 2019
CONSULTANT: Jith Meganathan / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001315
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 222
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits discrimination in housing accommodations based on military or veteran status. Also prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants who receive Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing vouchers.
Major Provisions
- Adds veteran or military status to the protected categories under numerous provisions of state law barring housing discrimination.
- Authorizes the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH), upon the request of certain parties, to provide assistance to communities and persons in resolving disputes, disagreements, or difficulties relating to discriminatory practices based upon military or veteran status
- Expands the definition of "source of income" protected from discrimination under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to include federal Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (HUD-VASH) vouchers.
COMMENTS:
Veterans across the state face numerous challenges related to their physical health, mental health, and housing. FEHA prohibits employment discrimination based on veteran or military status, but largely does not prohibit housing discrimination based on these statuses. This bill amends FEHA to include military or veteran status as protected classes under its housing anti-discrimination provisions. Additionally, under current law, landlords may refuse to rent to a prospective tenant solely based on the tenant's use of a HUD-VASH voucher. This bill amends existing law prohibiting discrimination based on source of income to ensure that HUD-VASH vouchers could not be the sole reason for turning away a tenant.
Discrimination based on veteran or military status. While the Unruh Civil Rights Act broadly prohibits discrimination due to any arbitrary basis, explicitly codifying "military or veteran status" as a protected class can help ensure uniformity in the law, particularly since "military and veteran status" is already a protected class under state employment discrimination statutes.
Background on the HUD-VASH voucher program. Since 1992, the HUD-VASH program has sought to provide veterans with supportive services and housing assistance through a collaboration between the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) as part of the Housing Choice Voucher Program (commonly referred to as "Section 8"). There are a very limited number of HUD-VASH vouchers available in the state; slightly over 13,200 HUD-VASH vouchers were in use in California as of March 31, 2018.
By expanding the definition of "source of income" to include HUD-VASH vouchers, this measure would create a right for voucher holders to apply for rental housing. If a landlord turned down a rental application from a HUD-VASH voucher holder, the landlord would need a nondiscriminatory reason for the denial, just as the landlord would have to have a nondiscriminatory reason for refusing to rent to a person on the basis of their gender, sexual orientation, race, national origin, and so on.
This measure passed the Legislature last year, but was vetoed. SB 1427 (Hill) of 2018, a virtually-identical measure by the same author, was vetoed by then-Governor Brown.
The bill would not be preempted by federal law if it were enacted. The United States Housing Act makes no mention of landlord voluntariness as one of its purposes. It is therefore difficult to perceive how state laws banning voucher discrimination would conflict with the federal government's purposes in enacting the HUD-VASH program. To sum, the bill appears well-insulated from charges of federal preemption.
According to the Author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that veterans with HUD-VASH vouchers face unique struggles with finding housing. The California Association of County Veterans Service Officers notes:
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Association of Realtors opposes the provisions of this bill that would prohibit landlords from refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders, writing:
Under current law, participation by a rental property owner in the…Section 8 HUD-VASH program is voluntary. Under SB 222, which redefines "source of income" to include the Section 8 HUD-VASH program, every residential rental property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority upon receiving an application from a tenant who uses Section 8 HUD-VASH vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) for increased complaints of housing discrimination against tenants using VASH vouchers.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 33-1-4
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Moorlach, Morrell
ASM JUDICIARY: 11-0-1
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 27, 2019
CONSULTANT: Jith Meganathan / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001315
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 222
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits discrimination in housing accommodations based on military or veteran status. This bill also prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants who receive Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (VASH) vouchers.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) for increased complaints of housing discrimination against tenants using VASH vouchers.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
- Housing Discrimination. Existing law prohibits housing discrimination against a tenant because of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability or genetic information. “Source of income” is defined as lawful, verifiable income paid directly to a tenant or paid to a representative of a tenant. This bill would add “military or veteran status” to the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination under FEHA and other state anti-discrimination statutes. While the Unruh Civil Rights Act broadly prohibits discrimination due to any arbitrary basis, explicitly codifying “military or veteran status” as a protected class may help ensure uniformity in the law, particularly since “military and veteran status” is already a protected class under state employment discrimination statutes.
- VASH Vouchers. Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supported Housing (HUD-VASH) vouchers provide rental assistance, case management and clinical services to homeless veterans and their families. While source of income discrimination is illegal under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), the law has been interpreted to exclude vouchers like HUD-VASH. This means landlords can refuse to rent to a homeless veteran solely on the basis of their use of an HUD-VASH voucher.
- Related Legislation. SB 329 (Mitchell) prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants who rely upon housing assistance paid directly to landlords, such as a Section 8 voucher. SB 329 is pending on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 222
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 27, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 33-1
SUBJECT: Discrimination: HOUSING: veteran or military status
KEY ISSUES:
- Due to high rates of homelessness and a lack of affordable housing for veterans, SHOULD existing prohibitions against discrimination IN HOUSING ON THE BASIS OF source of income be extended to include veterans affairs supportive housing vouchers?
- SHOULD it also be illegal to discriminate in housing based on an individual’s military or veteran status?
SYNOPSIS
Veterans across the state face high rates of housing insecurity and homelessness. While many veterans are eligible to receive Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (HUD-VASH) vouchers to assist with rent payments, current law permits landlords to refuse to rent to an individual with such a housing voucher. This measure seeks to prohibit landlords from turning away a prospective tenant based on their potential use of HUD-VASH vouchers as a source of income. This bill would also add military and veteran status to the protected classes enumerated under the Fair Employment and Housing Act and other state housing anti-discrimination laws.
The analysis reviews how this bill does not force a landlord to contract with a housing authority. It also analyzes issues of federal preemption and concludes that this bill is not preempted by federal law. The text of this bill is virtually identical to that of last year’s SB 1427 (Hill, 2018), which was vetoed by then-Governor Brown. An assortment of veterans and labor organizations, together with the City of Santa Monica and Santa Clara County, support the bill. The California Association of Realtors is opposed to the bill’s HUD-VASH anti-discrimination provisions.
SUMMARY: Prohibits discrimination in housing accommodations based on military or veteran status. Also prohibits landlords from discriminating against tenants who receive Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing vouchers. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes the following uncodified findings and declarations:
- “[H]ousing for veterans is of critical importance and that California must make it a priority to ensure that there is an adequate supply of housing for veterans.”
- “[V]eterans are a priority and that we must ensure that they have all housing options available, which merits amendment to California law relating to source of income and federal Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing vouchers.”
- Expands the definition of “source of income” under the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to include a federal Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (HUD-VASH) voucher.
- Clarifies that a landlord who receives lawful, verifiable income under a HUD-VASH voucher can be considered a representative of the tenant under FEHA.
- Adds veteran or military status to the protected categories under numerous provisions of state law barring housing discrimination.
- Authorizes the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH), upon the request of certain parties, to provide assistance to communities and persons in resolving disputes, disagreements, or difficulties relating to discriminatory practices based upon military or veteran status.
EXISTING LAW:
- Declares it to be against public policy to discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information in housing accommodations. (Government Code Section 12920. All other statutory references are to the Government Code unless otherwise specified.)
- Provides that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, genetic information, or any other basis prohibited by Section 51 of the Civil Code is hereby recognized as and declared to be a civil right. (Section 12921 (b).)
- Defines “source of income” for housing accommodations to mean lawful, verifiable income paid directly to a tenant or paid to a representative of a tenant while specifying that a landlord is not considered a representative of a tenant. (Sections 12927 (i); 12955 (p).)
- Establishes DFEH in the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency with the powers and duties to, among other things, receive, investigate, conciliate, mediate, and/or prosecute complaints relating to housing discrimination. (Sections 12901, 12930.)
- Allows DFEH to assist communities and individuals with disputes, disagreements, or difficulties relating to discriminatory practices based on race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, familial status, age, or sexual orientation that impair the rights of persons in those communities under the Constitution or laws of the United States or of this state. (Section 12931.)
- Prohibits various discriminatory housing accommodation practices based on any of the following: source of income, race, color, religion, sex gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, disability, or genetic information. (Sections 12955.)
- Describes the standards of proof for an intentional violation, and for a violation causing a discriminatory effect, of various FEHA provisions that bar housing discrimination. (Section 12955.8.)
- Requires that any declaration, governing document, or deed related to a common interest development include written notice about prohibitions on restrictions based on race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, familial status, marital status, disability, genetic information, national origin, source of income, or ancestry. (Section 12956.1.)
- Outlines the procedures for changing an unlawfully restrictive covenant that creates exclusions based on a protected category. (Section 12956.2.)
- Provides, pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, that all persons within the jurisdiction of the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. (Civil Code Section 51 (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Veterans across the state face numerous challenges related to their physical health, mental health, and housing. FEHA prohibits employment discrimination based on veteran or military status, but largely does not prohibit housing discrimination based on these statuses. This bill amends FEHA to include military or veteran status as protected classes under its housing anti-discrimination provisions. Additionally, under current law, landlords may refuse to rent to a prospective tenant solely based on the tenant’s use of a HUD-VASH voucher. This bill amends existing law prohibiting discrimination based on source of income to ensure that HUD-VASH vouchers could not be the sole reason for turning away a tenant. According to the author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
Under the CA Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) veterans and military personnel are a protected class in employment discrimination but they are not protected with regard to housing discrimination. Without clear protections in FEHA veteran and military personnel are susceptible to housing discrimination. For example, the Department of Fair Employment and Housing recently settled a lawsuit against a landlord who refused to rent a condominium unit because one of the tenants was a Marine. […]
Department of Housing and Urban Development Veterans Affairs Supported Housing (HUD-VASH) vouchers provide rental assistance, case management, and clinical services to homeless veterans and their families. While source of income discrimination is illegal under the FEHA, the law has been interpreted to exclude vouchers like HUD-VASH. This means landlords can refuse to rent to a homeless veteran solely on the basis of their use of a HUD-VASH voucher.
Housing issues faced by California veterans. The U.S. Veterans Administration and the Department of Housing and Urban Development reported that, in 2012, there were approximately 62,619 homeless veterans nationwide. At that time, California had the highest number of homeless veterans, representing a quarter of all homeless veterans in the U.S. (See Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, available at https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx.) These veterans, having completed their military service and returned to civilian life, were left either without stable housing or homeless.
While ever-increasing housing costs affect both veteran and non-veteran populations, there are many issues unique to the veteran population that contribute to their higher rates of housing insecurity and homelessness. For example, the California Department of Veterans Affairs website notes that 55 percent of homeless veterans suffer from mental health conditions while 7 in 10 veterans struggle with substance abuse disorders. (Ibid.)
Discrimination based on veteran or military status. This bill would add “military or veteran status” to the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination under FEHA and other state anti-discrimination statutes. While the Unruh Civil Rights Act broadly prohibits discrimination due to any arbitrary basis, explicitly codifying “military or veteran status” as a protected class can help ensure uniformity in the law, particularly since “military and veteran status” is already a protected class under state employment discrimination statutes.
A recent case of housing discrimination against a veteran demonstrates the need for such protections. In the case, a Marine and his family sought to rent a condominium but were refused due to his military status. DFEH recently resolved the Marine’s complaint, issuing a press release which announced as follows:
[A] landlord violated the state’s civil rights laws when he refused to rent an Orange County condominium unit to Viridiana Mendez and her family because her husband, Albert Quintanilla, is a United States Marine. The complaints alleged the landlord violated the Unruh Civil Rights Act, which prohibits businesses from discriminating on the basis of occupation or any other “arbitrary” basis, and the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), which prohibits owners of housing accommodations from discriminating on the basis of the source of a person’s income.
Ms. Mendez inquired about renting the condominium unit in April 2016, intending to share it with her husband and their minor daughter. Ms. Mendez was questioned by the landlord and his wife. According to Ms. Mendez, the landlord expressed no reservations about renting to her until he learned that Mr. Quintanilla is a Marine and that the family might leave the unit before the end of the full lease term if he received orders to deploy overseas. He then allegedly told her he would not rent to her or even give her a rental application because of her husband’s military service.
Additionally, a recent audit study conducted by the Washington State Attorney General found that prospective tenants using HUD-VASH vouchers were often turned away. In the audit, employees at the Washington State Attorney General’s office posed as prospective tenants who wished to use HUD-VASH vouchers to rent a unit. Out of the 50 landlords contacted, 20 percent of them refused to accept HUD-VASH vouchers as a form of rent. (Lawrence, Washington State Attorney General: Housing Discrimination against Veterans Is Evident, National Public Radio (Mar. 5, 2018) available at https://www.npr.org/2018/03/05/590974647/washington-state-attorney-general-housing-discrimination-against-veterans-is-evi.)
Background on the HUD-VASH voucher program. Since 1992, the HUD-VASH program has sought to provide veterans with supportive services and housing assistance through a collaboration between the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) as part of the Housing Choice Voucher Program (commonly referred to as “Section 8”). The HUD websites states:
[The] program combines Housing Choice Voucher rental assistance for homeless Veterans with case management and clinical services provided by the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA). VA provides these services for participating Veterans at VA medical centers (VAMCs) and community-based outreach clinics.
Every year since 2008, HUD and VA have awarded HUD-VASH vouchers based on geographic need and public housing agency (PHA) administrative performance. (HUD-VASH Vouchers, available at https://www.hud.gov/program_offices/public_indian_housing/programs/hcv/vash.)
The VA website provides additional details on the program:
VA case managers may connect these Veterans with support services such as health care, mental health treatment and substance use counseling to help them in their recovery process and with their ability to maintain housing in the community. Among VA homeless continuum of care programs, HUD-VASH enrolls the largest number and largest percentage of Veterans who have experienced long-term or repeated homelessness. (Homeless Veterans, available at https://www.va.gov/homeless/hud-vash.asp.)
To qualify for a HUD-VASH voucher, a veteran must be eligible to receive medical benefits from the VA and must also not be listed on a sex offender registry. The program is primarily targeted at getting chronically homeless veterans into permanent housing. For the initial time period that a voucher is provided, the veteran must receive supportive services too. The HUD exchange website describes that eligibility as follows:
Beneficiaries are selected based on certain requirements including health care eligibility, homelessness status, and income. Since 2008, beneficiaries are no longer required to be chronically mentally ill or have chronic substance abuse disorders. However, chronically homeless veterans are a target population for HUD-VASH. (HUD-VASH Eligibility Requirements, available at https://www.hudexchange.info/programs/hud-vash/hud-vash-eligibility-requirements/)
There are a very limited number of HUD-VASH vouchers available in the state–slightly over 13,200 HUD-VASH vouchers were in use in California as of March 31, 2018. (National Homeless Information Project, VASH Utilization, available at https://www.nhipdata.org/local/upload/file/Jan%20to%20Mar%202018%20VASH%20data.pdf.)
This bill would not force any landlord to contract with a housing authority. Last year’s SB 1427 (Hill, 2018), a virtually-identical measure by the same author, was vetoed by then-Governor Brown. In a message accompanying his veto, the former Governor explained:
We should support our veterans and military personnel, but this bill goes too far. Specifically, it forces landlords and property owners to take part in what has always been a voluntary federal program with numerous requirements. These include registration with a local housing authority, participation in training, property inspections and modification of leases to conform with federal standards.
I don't believe a mandate to comply with all these requirements is warranted.
Committee staff are puzzled by ex-Governor Brown’s characterization of SB 1427 (and by implication, the instant bill) as imposing a “mandate” on landlords.
By expanding the definition of “source of income” to include HUD-VASH vouchers, this measure would create a right for voucher holders to apply for rental housing. If a landlord turned down a rental application from a HUD-VASH voucher holder, the landlord would need a nondiscriminatory reason for the denial; just as the landlord would have to have a nondiscriminatory reason for refusing to rent to a person on the basis of their gender, sexual orientation, race, national origin, and so on. Turning down an application from a person in a protected category might increase the risk that a landlord is sued, but an increased fear of litigation is not a mandate.
If this bill were enacted, here is a summary of how the rental application process would typically work:
- A landlord with a housing unit to rent would be forbidden to use phrases like “No Section 8” or “No Military” in any rental listing or otherwise categorically rule out renting to a HUD-VASH voucher holder. However, the landlord would be free to set the monthly rent as high as the landlord wished, even if that rent would exceed the payment standard set by the local housing authority. The landlord would also be free to state this rent in any advertising for the unit.
- A HUD-VASH voucher holder who was interested in renting the unit would submit a rental application. If the rental application asked for the voucher holder’s source of income, the voucher holder would list the voucher along with any other household income.
- The landlord would be required to administer the same tenant screening process to the HUD-VASH voucher holder as the landlord does to every other applicant. The landlord could meet the voucher holder personally if the landlord was meeting the other prospective tenants personally. The landlord could determine whether the voucher holder could afford the rent, had acceptable credit, had a criminal background, and so forth. However, the landlord could not screen out the voucher holder simply because of the voucher subsidy—any more than the landlord could screen out an applicant simply because they were African-American, or from Laos, or married to a person of the same gender, or had a traditionally-Latino surname.
- The landlord would agree to rent the unit to the applicant who best satisfied the landlord’s lawful screening criteria. That would be the HUD-VASH voucher holder if, for example, the voucher holder had the most reliable source of income (when including the voucher), better credit, and little or no criminal history relative to the other applicants. In this case—and only in this case—the landlord would be required to rent the unit to the voucher holder.
- The local housing authority would inspect the unit to make sure that it satisfied federally-required habitability standards. The standards are not onerous and include fundamentals like “a flush toilet in proper operating condition” and “free[dom] from dangerous levels of…carbon monoxide.” (See 24 CFR 982.401.) If the landlord chose not to make repairs requested by the housing authority, the landlord would not have to rent to the voucher holder. However, if the landlord soon after made the repairs and then rented the unit to a non-voucher holder, this would likely be construed as illegal discrimination.
- Simultaneously with the inspection, the housing authority would conduct a rent reasonableness test to determine whether the rent being sought by the landlord was comparable to the rent for similar units in the area. If the rent were to be found unreasonably high, the landlord could not rent the unit to the HUD-VASH voucher holder.
- When the unit satisfied the housing authority’s standards, the landlord and the local housing authority would enter into a Housing Assistance Payment contract. The HUD-VASH voucher holder would also have to pay the same security deposit that the landlord would charge to any other tenant as a condition of tenancy.
- The HUD-VASH voucher holder would thereafter pay their share of the monthly rent to the landlord, with the balance being paid by the local housing authority.
The bill would not be preempted by federal law if it were enacted. Courts have generally recognized three forms of federal preemption of state law: express preemption, field preemption, and conflict preemption. Express preemption occurs when a federal statute contains a provision that explicitly “withdraw[s] specified powers from the States.” (Arizona v. United States (2012) 567 U.S. 387, 399.) Field preemption occurs when the “intent to displace state law altogether can be inferred from a framework of [federal] regulation so pervasive […] that Congress left no room for the States to supplement it or where there is a federal interest […] so dominant that the federal system will be assumed to preclude enforcement of state laws on the same subject.” (Ibid., internal quotations omitted.) Conflict preemption generally occurs in situations where it is physically impossible to comply with both federal and state regulations, or where state law “stands as an obstacle to the accomplishment and execution of the full purposes and objectives of Congress.” (Ibid.)
This bill does not appear to run afoul of any of these three forms of preemption. First, there is no express federal preemption of state and local voucher nondiscrimination laws, whether in statute or in regulation. Massachusetts and New Jersey enacted statutes outlawing discrimination against Section 8 voucher holders in the 1980s. Both Congress and HUD have had ample time to bar states from enacting such statutes if they so wished. Their silence speaks volumes.
Second, there is no evidence of federal field preemption. The idea that landlord participation in the Section 8 program—and by inference, the HUD-VASH program—is voluntary is generally inferred from regulatory pronouncement such as, “If the family finds a unit, and the owner is willing to lease the unit under the program, the family may request [housing authority] approval of the tenancy” (24 CFR Section 982.302), rather than anything resembling “pervasive” federal regulation around the topic of voluntariness.
Finally, as for conflict preemption, the purposes of the Section 8 program, the HUD-VASH program, and of federal housing assistance more broadly, include the following:
- “[A]ssist[ing] States and political subdivisions of States to remedy the unsafe housing conditions and the acute shortage of decent and safe dwellings for low-income families….” (42 U.S.C. Section 1437 (a)(1)(A).)
- “[A]ssist[ing] States and political subdivisions of States to address the shortage of housing affordable to low-income families….” (42 U.S.C. Section 1437 (a)(1)(B).)
- “[A]iding low-income families in obtaining a decent place to live and of promoting economically mixed housing…” (42 U.S.C. Section 1437f (a).)
The United States Housing Act makes no mention of landlord voluntariness as one of its purposes. It is therefore difficult to perceive how state laws banning voucher discrimination would conflict with the federal government’s purposes in enacting the HUD-VASH program. To sum, the bill appears well-insulated from charges of federal preemption.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters note that veterans with HUD-VASH vouchers face unique struggles with finding housing. Writing in support of the bill, the California Association of Veterans Service Agencies notes:
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
The City of Santa Monica, also a bill supporter, adds:
VASH vouchers…provide homeless veterans with rental assistance along with access to wraparound services. Despite the availability of this valuable asset VASH vouchers have a stunningly low success rate. According to the Los Angeles Housing Authority, a VASH voucher will successfully get an individual into a rental unit 33% of the time whereas the success rate for a general Section 8 voucher is 60%.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Association of Realtors opposes the provisions of this bill that would prohibit landlords from refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders. They write:
Under current law, participation by a rental property owner in the…Section 8 HUD-VASH program is voluntary. Under SB 222, which redefines “source of income” to include the Section 8 HUD-VASH program, every residential rental property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority upon receiving an application from a tenant who uses Section 8 HUD-VASH vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates.
Related Legislation: SB 329 (Mitchell) would extend FEHA’s housing nondiscrimination provisions to recipients of local, state, and federal housing subsidies, including VASH vouchers and Housing Choice Vouchers (aka “Section 8”) more broadly.
SB 521 (Portantino) would provide a tax credit to landlords who rent property to Section 8 and VASH voucher holders. SB 521 is not mutually exclusive with the instant bill; in fact, the two bills would reinforce each other. SB 521 is scheduled to be heard in the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee.
SB 644 (Glazer) would prohibit, with certain exceptions, active service members from having to pay a security deposit of more than one month’s rent for an unfurnished rental property and two months’ rent for a furnished rental property. SB 644 would rely on this bill’s antidiscrimination provisions as an enforcement mechanism. SB 644 is pending hearing in the Assembly Veterans Affairs Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
American Legion, Department of California
AMVETS, Department of California
California Association of Veteran Service Agencies
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teachers Association
City of Santa Monica
County of Santa Clara
Military Officers Association of America, California Council of Chapters
Vietnam Veterans of America, California State Council
Opposition
California Association of Realtors
Analysis Prepared by: Jith Meganathan / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 222 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 222
Introduced: 2/7/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Discrimination: veteran or military status
DIGEST: This bill underscores that housing discrimination on account of military or veteran status is unlawful in California by explicitly stating so within the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). In addition, by defining a Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (VASH) voucher as a source of income for purposes of FEHA, this bill prohibits landlords from discriminating against a tenant on the basis that the tenant pays part or all of the rent using a VASH voucher.
Existing law:
- States, as part of the FEHA, that it is against public policy to discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information in housing accommodations. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
- Declares that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, genetic information, or any other specified basis is a civil right. (Gov. Code § 12921.)
- Makes it unlawful for the owner of any housing accommodation to discriminate against or harass any person because of the race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information of that person. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Specifies certain acts that constitute unlawful discrimination, including either of the following:
- Using a financial or income standard in the rental of housing that fails to account for the aggregate income of persons residing together or proposing to reside together on the same basis as the aggregate income of married persons residing together or proposing to reside together; or
- In instances where there is a government rent subsidy, using a financial or income standard in assessing eligibility for the rental of housing that is not based on the portion of the rent to be paid by the tenant. (Gov. Code § 12955 (n), (o).)
- Provides that it shall not constitute discrimination based on source of income to make a written or oral inquiry concerning the level or source of income. (Gov. Code § 12955 (p).)
- Provides that a person intends to unlawfully discriminate if one of the protected classes played a motivating factor in committing a discriminatory housing practice, as specified. A violation can be found when the act has the effect of unlawfully discriminating, regardless of the intent, as specified. (Gov. Code § 12955.8.)
- Defines “source of income” to mean lawful, verifiable income paid directly to a tenant or paid to a representative of a tenant, but specifies that a landlord is not considered a representative of a tenant. (Gov. Code § 12927, 12955 (p).)
This bill:
- Adds “military and veteran status” to the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination in FEHA.
- Defines a VASH voucher as a source of income, thus making it unlawful for a landlord to discriminate against tenants who use VASH vouchers to pay for part or all of their rent.
Comments
Homelessness among military veterans is a major problem. According to the U.S. Veterans Administration (VA) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), as of 2012 there were approximately 62,619 homeless veterans nationwide, of which about a quarter were located in California.[1] While the California Department of Veterans Affairs reports that the number of homeless veterans in the state “has been nearly cut in half” in recent years, there is general agreement that the homelessness rate among veterans remains unacceptably high. (Ibid.)
The high cost of housing is one major part of the problem. According to a 2013 National Low-Income Housing Coalition study on the topic, 1.5 million veteran households suffered from severe housing cost burden in 2011, spending more than 50 percent of their income on housing.[2] There were also significant disparities among veteran households, with veteran households headed by a racial minority, females, and those with a disability more likely to be cost burdened than their counterparts. (Ibid.)
Medical and psychological conditions act as further barriers to stable housing. According to the California Department of Veterans Affairs:
Veterans often suffer from conditions that make it difficult to find and maintain gainful employment and pay for housing. Along with the high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traumatic brain injury (TBI), the VA has found that approximately 55% of homeless veterans suffer from mental health issues, 70% are affected by substance abuse issues, and 40% of female homeless veterans report experience [sic] severe forms of mental illness, mostly due to higher rates of military sexual trauma (MST).[3]
VASH vouchers aim to address both of these challenges simultaneously. VASH vouchers subsidize rental payments for homeless veterans and come along with supportive services in the form of case management and clinical services. VASH vouchers can serve as an important tool for combatting homelessness among veterans, therefore. HUD awarded 1,882 VASH vouchers to California veterans in 2018.[4]
Under existing California law, however, landlords are not obligated to consider applicants with VASH vouchers, and many evidently will not. The Los Angeles Housing Authority reports data showing, for instance, that HUD-VASH housing vouchers have the lowest success rate among the housing vouchers the Authority issues, where “success” is defined as placing the voucher recipient in a rental unit. The success rate for general (non-veteran) Housing Choice Voucher recipients is 60 percent. The success rate for the Authority’s other non-veteran housing vouchers is 67 percent. By comparison, the success rate for HUD-VASH vouchers is a mere 33 percent.[5]
A National Public Radio story on the issue observed that the fact that California currently allows landlords to refuse to rent to HUD-VASH voucher holders “is seen as one reason that Los Angeles has the largest number of homeless vets nationwide, a number that rose last year.”[6]
This bill defines a VASH voucher as a “source of income” for purposes of the FEHA. Since FEHA prohibits housing discrimination based on source of income (Gov. Code § 12955(a)), this bill has the effect of making it unlawful for landlords to refuse to rent to a tenant merely because the tenant proposes to pay part or all of the rent through the use of a VASH voucher. A landlord would retain the authority to screen and to reject prospective tenants on any other lawful basis.
Landlord requirements associated with VASH vouchers
From the landlord’s perspective, renting to a tenant who will pay part or all of the rent with a VASH voucher is not as simple as just moving the person in and accepting rent payments. Before the federal government will subsidize rent payments to a landlord on behalf of a tenant, the landlord must comply with certain requirements. In summary form, those requirements are:
- The landlord must apply to the local public housing authority to be put on the list of approved HUD-VASH properties;
- The landlord must attend an informational session regarding the landlord’s rights and responsibilities as a participant in the HUD-VASH program;
- The landlord must schedule a HUD Housing Quality Standards inspection to ensure the property meets minimum residential housing codes; and
- The landlord and tenant must a sign a lease that complies with HUD-VASH lease requirements.[7]
Since this bill prohibits landlords from refusing to rent to a VASH voucher holder on that basis alone, landlords could no longer avoid exposure to the possibility of having to go through the steps outlined above by categorically refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders.
Going through these steps does represent some additional administrative burdens for a landlord in comparison with a standard, unsubsidized lease. If the process delays a tenant’s move-in date, going through these steps might result in some lost rental income. The opponents of this bill assert that:
[t]he Section 8 approval process for a rental property owner to participate is extremely time consuming and difficult to understand, with little assistance available to owners through the housing authorities. It includes a very lengthy document preparation process that owners and tenants must complete. Many small rental property owners simply do not have the resources to maneuver the long and complicated process.
On the other hand, many aspects of the VASH process for a landlord simply hold them accountable for things they are already legally required to do.
For example, to pass a HUD housing inspection on the first try, the VA recommends that landlords ensure that their rental properties have: working smoke alarm(s); proper ventilation in bathrooms (window or fan); connected utilities; a functional stove and refrigerator; a window in every bedroom that can stay open without props; a working water heater discharge line and pop/relief valves; handrails for steps; and secure railings for porches and balconies. By the same token, landlords are encouraged to make sure their rental properties do not have: broken or missing locks; broken or missing windows; bugs or vermin; tripping hazards on the floor; exposed electrical wiring; and chipping or peeling paint
inside or outside.[8]
These are, of course, the sort of bare minimum conditions that a landlord must maintain under California’s warranty of habitability. (Civ. Code § 1941.1.) Outside of the subsidized housing voucher context, however, no government entity proactively inspects rental housing to ensure that it complies with these basic requirements. Thus, participating in subsidized housing programs like the VASH vouchers subjects landlords to greater accountability for providing and maintaining basic housing conditions for their tenants.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
American Legion-Department of California
AMVETS-Department of California
California Association of County Veterans Service Officers
California Association of Veterans Service Agencies
California State Commanders Veterans Council
California Teachers Association
City of Santa Monica
Military Officers Association of America-California Council of Chapters
Santa Clara County
Vietnam Veterans of America-California State Council
California Association of Realtors
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
U.S. veterans and those currently serving in the armed forces are protected from employment discrimination by the California Fair Employment and Housing Act. However, the law does not specifically include veterans or military personnel among those who are protected from housing discrimination. SB 222 would address this gap by adding veterans and military personnel as a protected class in statutes relating to housing discrimination.
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
In support of this bill, the California Association of Veterans Service Agencies (CAVSA) writes:
CAVSA’s member agencies clearly understand the overwhelming issues confronting our veteran population and the dramatic need to protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
In further support, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO writes:
As veterans make up a disproportionate share of the homeless population, we must eliminate barriers that impede veterans from receiving adequate housing. Military serve is often fraught with adversity. Veterans should not have to face similar adversity in finding housing when they return from service.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill unless amended, the California Association of Realtors writes:
Under SB 222 […], every residential property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority requiring they accept tenants who use Section 8 HUD-VASH housing vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates. […] Many property owners, particularly small landlords with only one rental unit, struggle with those complex rules and regulations, which compromise their ability to provide quality housing at reasonable rents.
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/1/19 16:19:19
**** END ****
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Housing Instability Among Our Nations’ Veterans (Nov. 2013) National Low Income Housing Coalition, p. 1, http://nlihc.org/sites/default/files/NLIHC-Veteran-Report-2013.pdf (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
HUD and VA Secretaries Announce Housing Initiatives to Support Homeless Veterans (Oct. 3, 2018) https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/HUD_No_18_113 (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Success Rates CY2016, Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, on file with the Committee. ↑
Quil Lawrence, Washington State Attorney General: Housing Discrimination Against Veterans Is Evident (Mar. 5, 2018) National Public Radio www.npr.org/2018/03/05/590974647/washington-state-attorney-general-housing-discrimination-against-veterans-is-evi (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
See How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.va.gov/homeless/landlords.asp (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, supra U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 222 (Author:Hill)
Version: February 7, 2019
Hearing Date: April 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Discrimination: veteran or military status
DIGEST
This bill underscores that housing discrimination on account of military or veteran status is unlawful in California by explicitly stating so within the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). In addition, by defining a Veterans Affairs Supportive Housing (VASH) voucher as a source of income for purposes of FEHA, the bill prohibits landlords from discriminating against a tenant on the basis that the tenant pays part or all of the rent using a VASH voucher.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The high cost of housing, medical needs, and psychological conditions can all act as barriers to stable housing for veterans. VASH vouchers aim to address these barriers by subsidizing rental payments for homeless veterans while simultaneously providing supportive services in the form of case management and clinical services. VASH vouchers can therefore be an important tool for combatting homelessness among veterans. Under existing California law, however, landlords are not obligated to consider applicants with VASH vouchers and many evidently will not. This bill would define a VASH voucher as a source of income for purposes of the FEHA. Since FEHA prohibits housing discrimination based on source of income, (Gov. Code § 12955(a)), the bill would have the effect of making it unlawful for landlords to refuse to rent to a tenant on the sole basis that the tenant pays part or all of the rent through the use of a VASH voucher. At the same time, the bill would incorporate military or veteran status into the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination by FEHA, thus adding an additional layer to existing laws against such discrimination in California.
The bill is author-sponsored. It is supported by veterans’ service groups and homelessness prevention advocates. It is opposed by landlord associations who assert that participation in the VASH program is onerous and ought to be voluntary for landlords.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- States, as part of the FEHA, that it is against public policy to discriminate on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information in housing accommodations. (Gov. Code § 12920.)
- Declares that the opportunity to seek, obtain, and hold housing without discrimination because of race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, genetic information, or any other specified basis is a civil right. (Gov. Code § 12921.)
- Makes it unlawful for the owner of any housing accommodation to discriminate against or harass any person because of the race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information of that person. (Gov. Code § 12955.)
- Specifies certain acts that constitute unlawful discrimination, including either of the following:
- using a financial or income standard in the rental of housing that fails to account for the aggregate income of persons residing together or proposing to reside together on the same basis as the aggregate income of married persons residing together or proposing to reside together; or
- in instances where there is a government rent subsidy, using a financial or income standard in assessing eligibility for the rental of housing that is not based on the portion of the rent to be paid by the tenant. (Gov. Code § 12955 (n), (o).)
- Provides that it shall not constitute discrimination based on source of income to make a written or oral inquiry concerning the level or source of income. (Gov. Code § 12955 (p).)
- Provides that a person intends to unlawfully discriminate if one of the protected classes played a motivating factor in committing a discriminatory housing practice, as specified. A violation can be found when the act has the effect of unlawfully discriminating, regardless of the intent, as specified. (Gov. Code § 12955.8.)
- Defines “source of income” to mean lawful, verifiable income paid directly to a tenant or paid to a representative of a tenant, but specifies that a landlord is not considered a representative of a tenant. (Gov. Code § 12927, 12955 (p).)
This bill:
- Adds “military and veteran status” to the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination in FEHA.
- Defines a VASH voucher as a source of income, thus making it unlawful for a landlord to discriminate against tenants who use VASH vouchers to pay for part or all of their rent.
COMMENTS
- Background
Homelessness among military veterans is a major problem. According to the U.S. Veterans Administration (VA) and the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD), as of 2012 there were approximately 62,619 homeless veterans nationwide, of which about a quarter were located in California.[1] While the California Department of Veterans Affairs reports that the number of homeless veterans in the state “has been nearly cut in half” in recent years, there is general agreement that the homelessness rate among veterans remains unacceptably high. (Ibid.)
The high cost of housing is one major part of the problem. According to a 2013 National Low-Income Housing Coalition study on the topic, 1.5 million veteran households suffered from severe housing cost burden in 2011, spending more than 50 percent of their income on housing.[2] There were also significant disparities among veteran households, with veteran households headed by a racial minority, females, and those with a disability more likely to be cost burdened than their counterparts. (Ibid.)
Medical and psychological conditions act as further barriers to stable housing. According to the California Department of Veterans Affairs:
Veterans often suffer from conditions that make it difficult to find and maintain gainful employment and pay for housing. Along with the high rates of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and traumatic brain injury (TBI), the VA has found that approximately 55% of homeless veterans suffer from mental health issues, 70% are affected by substance abuse issues, and 40% of female homeless veterans report experience [sic] severe forms of mental illness, mostly due to higher rates of military sexual trauma (MST).[3]
VASH vouchers aim to address both of these challenges simultaneously. VASH vouchers subsidize rental payments for homeless veterans and come along with supportive services in the form of case management and clinical services. VASH vouchers can serve as an important tool for combatting homelessness among veterans, therefore. HUD awarded 1,882 VASH vouchers to California veterans in 2018.[4]
Under existing California law, however, landlords are not obligated to consider applicants with VASH vouchers, and many evidently will not. The Los Angeles Housing Authority reports data showing, for instance, that HUD-VASH housing vouchers have the lowest success rate among the housing vouchers the Authority issues, where “success” is defined as placing the voucher recipient in a rental unit. The success rate for general (non-veteran) Housing Choice Voucher recipients is 60 percent. The success rate for the Authority’s other non-veteran housing vouchers is 67 percent. By comparison, the success rate for HUD-VASH vouchers is a mere 33 percent.[5]
A National Public Radio story on the issue observed that the fact that California currently allows landlords to refuse to rent to HUD-VASH voucher holders “is seen as one reason that Los Angeles has the largest number of homeless vets nationwide, a number that rose last year.”[6]
Washington State Attorney General Bob Ferguson takes the position that it is unlawful discrimination under that state’s laws for a landlord to refuse to rent to a tenant because that tenant will pay using a VASH voucher. In March 2018, Ferguson’s office conducted a sting operation in which it contacted landlords posing as a prospective tenant who would be paying with a VASH voucher. Out of 50 landlords contacted, ten of them responded that they do not accept VASH voucher holders under any circumstance.[7]
This bill would define a VASH voucher as a “source of income” for purposes of the FEHA. Since FEHA prohibits housing discrimination based on source of income (Gov. Code § 12955(a)), the bill would have the effect of making it unlawful for landlords to refuse to rent to a tenant merely because the tenant proposes to pay part or all of the rent through the use of a VASH voucher. A landlord would retain the authority to screen and to reject prospective tenants on any other lawful basis.
2. Comparison to employment discrimination law
At the same time, the bill would incorporate military or veteran status into the list of characteristics protected against housing discrimination by FEHA, thus adding an additional layer to existing protections against such discrimination under California law. The Fair Employment and Housing Act, as the name implies, protects Californians’ civil rights in the workplace and in housing.
On the employment side of the ledger, FEHA’s provisions explicitly protect people from discrimination and harassment on account of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. (Gov. Code § 12940(a) and (j).) On the housing side, by contrast, the relevant statute says that those providing housing accommodations shall not discriminate “because of the race, color, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, sexual orientation, marital status, national origin, ancestry, familial status, source of income, disability, or genetic information.” (Gov. Code § 12955(a).) Military or veteran status is noticeably absent in the latter list of protected identities.
By inserting “military and veteran status” into FEHA’s provisions regarding housing discrimination, this bill would bring California’s housing discrimination laws into greater harmony with our employment discrimination laws.
3. Unruh Act coverage of housing discrimination against servicemembers and veterans
While military and veteran status is not mentioned in the FEHA provisions outlawing housing discrimination, such discrimination is prohibited by other California law.
Most notably, Civil Code Section 51, known as the Unruh Civil Rights Act, states that:
[a]ll persons within the jurisdiction of this state are free and equal, and no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever. (Civ. Code § 51(b).)
Businesses that provide housing accommodations are one type of business enterprise encompassed by the Unruh Civil Rights Act. Flowers v. John Burnham & Co. (1971) 21 Cal.App.3d 700.). In addition, despite the enumeration of specific protected characteristics within the statute, California courts have ruled that the protections afforded by the Unruh Civil Rights Act are not “confined only to a limited category of protected classes, but rather protect all persons from any arbitrary discrimination by a business establishment.” Marina Point, Ltd. v. Wolfson (1982) 30 Cal.3d 721, 730.) Thus, as discrimination based on military or veteran status may be seen as arbitrary in the context of housing accommodation, the Unruh Civil Rights Act already bans such discrimination.
Using the Unruh Civil Rights Act in this way and also drawing upon FEHA’s prohibition on discrimination based on source of income, the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) has already had some success in combating housing discrimination based on military status. In August 2017, DFEH reported that it:
settled complaints that a landlord violated the state’s civil rights laws when he refused to rent an Orange County condominium unit to Viridiana Mendez and her family because her husband, Albert Quintanilla, is a United States Marine. […]
Ms. Mendez inquired about renting the condominium unit in April 2016, intending to share it with her husband and their minor daughter. Ms. Mendez was questioned by the landlord and his wife. According to Ms. Mendez, the landlord expressed no reservations about renting to her until he learned that Mr. Quintanilla is a Marine and that the family might leave the unit before the end of the full lease term if he received orders to deploy overseas. He then allegedly told her he would not rent to her or even give her a rental application because of her husband’s military service.
The settlement requires the landlord to pay Ms. Mendez $4,500 and undergo training on fair housing laws.[8]
Thus, though this bill will enshrine “military and veteran” status among the characteristics explicitly protected against housing discrimination by FEHA, such discrimination is already unlawful under California law.
4. About VASH vouchers
The VA describes the VASH voucher program as follows:
HUD-VASH is a collaborative program between HUD and VA combines [sic] HUD housing vouchers with VA supportive services to help Veterans who are homeless and their families find and sustain permanent housing.
Through public housing authorities, HUD provides rental assistance vouchers for privately owned housing to Veterans who are eligible for VA health care services and are experiencing homelessness. VA case managers may connect these Veterans with support services such as health care, mental health treatment and substance use counseling to help them in their recovery process and with their ability to maintain housing in the community. Among VA homeless continuum of care programs, HUD-VASH enrolls the largest number and largest percentage of Veterans who have experienced long-term or repeated homelessness. As of Sept. 30, 2015, HUD had allocated more than 78,000 vouchers to help house Veterans across the country.
A 2016 Orange County Register article aptly described HUD-VASH vouchers as “Section 8 Housing vouchers dressed up in camouflage,”[9] though it is important to note that Section 8 vouchers,[10] which are available on a limited basis to eligible low-income households, do not come with supportive services.
5. Landlord requirements associated with VASH vouchers
From the landlord’s perspective, renting to a tenant who will pay part or all of the rent with a VASH voucher is not as simple as just moving the person in and accepting rent payments. Before the federal government will subsidize rent payments to a landlord on behalf of a tenant, the landlord must comply with certain requirements. In summary form, those requirements are:
- the landlord must apply to the local public housing authority to be put on the list of approved HUD-VASH properties;
- the landlord must attend an informational session regarding the landlord’s rights and responsibilities as a participant in the HUD-VASH program;
- the landlord must schedule a HUD Housing Quality Standards inspection to ensure the property meets minimum residential housing codes; and
- the landlord and tenant must a sign a lease that complies with HUD-VASH lease requirements.[11]
Since this bill would prohibit landlords from refusing to rent to a VASH voucher holder on that basis alone, landlords could no longer avoid exposure to the possibility of having to go through the steps outlined above by categorically refusing to rent to VASH voucher holders.
Going through these steps does represent some additional administrative burdens for a landlord in comparison with a standard, unsubsidized lease. If the process delays a tenant’s move-in date, going through these steps might result in some lost rental income. The opponents of the bill assert that:
[t]he Section 8 approval process for a rental property owner to participate is extremely time consuming and difficult to understand, with little assistance available to owners through the housing authorities. It includes a very lengthy document preparation process that owners and tenants must complete. Many small rental property owners simply do not have the resources to maneuver the long and complicated process.
On the other hand, many aspects of the process for a landlord simply hold them accountable for things they are already legally required to do.
For example, to pass a HUD housing inspection on the first try, the VA recommends that landlords ensure that their rental properties have: working smoke alarm(s); proper ventilation in bathrooms (window or fan); connected utilities; a functional stove and refrigerator; a window in every bedroom that can stay open without props; a working water heater discharge line and pop/relief valves; handrails for steps; and secure railings for porches and balconies. By the same token, landlords are encouraged to make sure their rental properties do not have: broken or missing locks; broken or missing windows; bugs or vermin; tripping hazards on the floor; exposed electrical wiring; and chipping or peeling paint inside or outside.[12]
These are, of course, the sort of bare minimum conditions that a landlord must maintain under California’s warranty of habitability. (Civ. Code § 1941.1.) Outside of the subsidized housing voucher context, however, no government entity proactively inspects rental housing to ensure that it complies with these basic requirements. Thus, participating in subsidized housing programs like the VASH vouchers subjects landlords to greater accountability for providing and maintaining basic housing conditions for their tenants.
6. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
SB 222 would protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
U.S. veterans and those currently serving in the armed forces are protected from employment discrimination by the California Fair Employment and Housing Act. However, the law does not specifically include veterans or military personnel among those who are protected from housing discrimination. SB 222 would address this gap by adding veterans and military personnel as a protected class in statutes relating to housing discrimination.
Veterans and military personnel face significant housing challenges. California has the largest number of veterans experiencing homelessness at 9,612. Homeless veterans in California represented 24 percent of the national homeless veteran population. SB 222 will ensure veterans and military personnel are not discriminated against in housing and are not denied housing because of how they pay their rent.
In support of the bill, the California Association of Veterans Service Agencies (CAVSA) writes:
CAVSA’s member agencies clearly understand the overwhelming issues confronting our veteran population and the dramatic need to protect veterans and military personnel from housing discrimination and ensure that landlords cannot deny homeless veterans housing based solely on the fact that they receive a rental assistance voucher.
In further support, the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO writes:
As veterans make up a disproportionate share of the homeless population, we must eliminate barriers that impede veterans from receiving adequate housing. Military serve is often fraught with adversity. Veterans should not have to face similar adversity in finding housing when they return from service.
7. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill unless amended, the California Association of Realtors writes:
Under SB 222 […], every residential property owner will be effectively forced to enter into a contract with the local housing authority requiring they accept tenants who use Section 8 HUD-VASH housing vouchers to pay a portion of their rent. Unfortunately, because housing authorities are understaffed, it can take as long as 60 days before all required applications are submitted, mandatory inspections are made, and obligatory contracts are signed. During that time, the unit sits vacant at a substantial loss to the property owner. Instead of fixing the Section 8 HUD-VASH program by remedying this and other problems to attract more landlords to voluntarily participate in the program, SB 222 creates new mandates. […] Many property owners, particularly small landlords with only one rental unit, struggle with those complex rules and regulations, which compromise their ability to provide quality housing at reasonable rents.
SUPPORT
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Association of Veterans Service Agencies
OPPOSITION
California Association of Realtors
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 329 (Mitchell, 2019) expands the definition of “source of income,” a category protected against discrimination under FEHA to include all forms of housing assistance vouchers including, but not limited to, VASH vouchers. SB 329 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Committee on Judiciary.
SB 644 (Glazer, 2019) lowers the maximum amount that a landlord can charge active duty military service members, as defined, for a security deposit on residential rental housing. SB 644 is in the Senate Veterans Affairs Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1247 (Hill, 2018) was nearly identical to this bill. In his message vetoing SB 1247, then Governor Jerry Brown wrote: “We should support our veterans and military personnel, but this bill goes too far. Specifically, it forces landlords and property owners to take part in what has always been a voluntary federal program with numerous requirements. These include registration with a local housing authority, participation in training, property inspections and modification of leases to conform with federal standards. I don’t believe a mandate to comply with all these requirements is warranted.”
SB 1500 (Committee on Veterans Affairs, Ch. 117, Stats. 2018), among other things, updated and expanded prohibitions on employment discrimination against members of the military, as well as discrimination against uniformed military personnel in the provision of public accommodations.
AB 1710 (Committee on Veterans Affairs, Ch. 591, Stats. of 2017) expands existing protections for military servicemembers in their civilian workplaces to include protection against hostile work environments.
SB 1053 (Leno, 2016) would have expanded the definition of “source of income” within FEHA to include lawful, verifiable income paid to a housing owner or landlord on behalf of a tenant, including federal, state, or local public assistance and federal, state, or local housing subsidies. SB 1053 was held on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 556 (Salas, Ch. 691, Stats. 2013) added “military and veteran status,” as defined, to the list of categories protected from employment discrimination under the FEHA.
SB 1252 (Corbett, Ch. 524, Stats. 2010) made technical revisions to several provisions of the FEHA, including consistently listing “source of income” as a characteristic that is protected from housing discrimination in various sections of the act.
SB 1145 (Burton, Ch. 568, Stats. 2004), among other things, removed the sunset date and thereby extended indefinitely a provision adopted in SB 1098 (Burton, Ch. 590, Stats. 1999), which prohibited discrimination under the FEHA on the basis of a person’s source of income, as specified.
SB 1098 (Burton, Ch. 590, Stats. 1999) prohibited, until January 1, 2005, discrimination under the FEHA on the basis of a person’s source of income, the failure to account for the aggregate income of co-residents, or the failure to exclude a government rent subsidy from that portion of the rent to be paid by the tenant in assessing his or her eligibility for rental housing.
**************
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Housing Instability Among Our Nations’ Veterans (Nov. 2013) National Low Income Housing Coalition, p. 1, http://nlihc.org/sites/default/files/NLIHC-Veteran-Report-2013.pdf (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Homeless Veterans Outreach and Support, California Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.calvet.ca.gov/VetServices/Pages/Homeless-Veterans-Outreach-Awareness.aspx (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
HUD and VA Secretaries Announce Housing Initiatives to Support Homeless Veterans (Oct. 3, 2018) https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/HUD_No_18_113 (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Success Rates CY2016, Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles, on file with the Committee. ↑
Quil Lawrence, Washington State Attorney General: Housing Discrimination Against Veterans Is Evident (Mar. 5, 2018) National Public Radio www.npr.org/2018/03/05/590974647/washington-state-attorney-general-housing-discrimination-against-veterans-is-evi (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Quil Lawrence, Washington State Attorney General: Housing Discrimination Against Veterans Is Evident (Mar. 5, 2018) National Public Radio https://www.npr.org/2018/03/05/590974647/washington-state-attorney-general-housing-discrimination-against-veterans-is-evi (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Department of Fair Employment and Housing Settles Complaints Against Landlord for Alleged Discrimination Against Military Family (Aug. 14, 2017) Department of Fair Employment and Housing https://www.dfeh.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/sites/32/2017/08/Mendez-PR20170814.pdf (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
Christopher Gilbertson, America’s Veterans Deserve Better in O.C. (Jan. 4, 2016) Orange County Register https://www.ocregister.com/2016/01/04/americas-veterans-deserve-better-in-oc/ (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
“Section 8 voucher” is a commonly used term for what are technically Housing Choice Vouchers. ↑
See How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs https://www.va.gov/homeless/landlords.asp (as of Apr. 1, 2019). ↑
How Landlords can Help End Veteran Homelessness, supra U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):