SB 239: Criminal procedure: limitations of actions.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-06-19
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | August 30 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Assembly Rule 97. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | April 22 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and APPR. |
| Feb 12, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 14. |
| Feb 11, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Special Consent SB239 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 239
Author:(Chang) – As Amended Ver:June 19, 2019
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill changes the statute of limitations for the crime of unauthorized access to computers to three years from the discovery of the crime.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Costs (GF) possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually to California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) in increased incarceration costs. Unauthorized access to a computer pursuant to Penal Code section 502 is punishable by up to three years in county jail or state prison depending on the defendant’s prior criminal history. This bill extends the statute of limitation, increasing the likelihood of additional convictions.
- Possible cost pressures in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually (GF/Trial Court Trust Fund) for increased court costs, including possible trial costs given the bill increases the possibility of additional prosecutions for unauthorized access to a computer. A defendant charged with a misdemeanor or felony is entitled to no-cost legal representation and a jury trial. If 15 new misdemeanors are filed annually statewide and proceed to trial resulting in the use of two days of court time, at an estimated cost of approximately $7,644 for an eight-hour court day, the approximate cost to the trial courts would be $229,320.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
[SB 239] would allow the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code §502 as a civil prosecution for the same act, i.e. three years after the date of discovery rather than the date of the offense. Perpetrators of data breaches go to great lengths to conceal the effects of their crimes.
- Unauthorized access to computers. Generally, unauthorized access to a computer, computer system or computer network is an alternate misdemeanor-felony and punishable by imprisonment in county jail or state prison depending on the defendant’s criminal history, for up to three years and a base fine of up to $10,000.
- Statute of Limitations. The statute of limitations requires commencement of a prosecution within a certain period of time after the commission of a crime. A prosecution is initiated by filing an indictment or information, filing a complaint, certifying a case to superior court, or issuing an arrest or bench warrant. In general, the limitations period is related to the seriousness of the offense or the need for a longer period of investigation. Computer crimes are often not detected at the time of commission. This bill would extend the statute of limitations to three years from the discovery of the crime, likely increasing the number of prosecutions.
- Prior Legislation. AB 32 (Waldron), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2015, increased the base fine for felony convictions of specified computer crimes from a maximum of $5,000 to a maximum of $10,000.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
Counsel: Sandy Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 239
Author:(Chang) – As Amended Ver:June 19, 2019
SUMMARY: Provides that, notwithstanding any other statutes of limitations, for the crime of unauthorized access to computers, a criminal complaint may be filed within three years after the discovery of offense.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines numerous computer or electronic data offenses and imposes penalties ranging from an alternate felony/misdemeanor to an infraction based on the seriousness of the offense or based on the extent of harm caused by the defendant. These penalties apply where any person knowingly, among other things:
- Accesses and without permission alters, damages, deletes, destroys, or otherwise uses any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order to devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;
- Accesses and without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Accesses and without permission adds, alters, damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Without permission, disrupts or causes the disruption of computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services, to an authorized user of a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Disrupts or improperly accesses a government or public safety computer system.
- Provides or assists, without permission a means of accessing a computer, computer system, or computer network; and,
- Introduces any computer contaminant. (Pen. Code, § 502.)
- Accesses and without permission alters, damages, deletes, destroys, or otherwise uses any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order to devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;
- Provides that prosecution for crimes punishable by imprisonment for eight years or more must commence within six years after commission of the offense, unless otherwise provided by law. (Pen. Code, § 800.)
- Provides that prosecution for a felony punishable by imprisonment for less than eight years must commence within three years commission of the offense, except as specified. (Pen. Code, § 801.)
- Provides that prosecution for crimes involving fraud, breach of a fiduciary duty, embezzlement of funds from an elder or dependent adult, or misconduct by a public official does not start to run until the discovery of the offense and prosecution must be commenced within four years after discovery of the crime or within four years after completion, whichever is later. (Pen. Code, §§ 801.5 & 803, subd. (c).)
- Provides that the prosecution of a misdemeanor must commence within one year of the commission of the offense, unless otherwise provided by law. (Pen. Code, § 802 subd. (a).)
- States that, unless otherwise provided by law, a statute of limitations is not tolled or extended for any reason. (Pen. Code, § 803, subd. (a).)
- States that, for specified crimes, the statute of limitations does not begin to run until the offense has been discovered, or could have reasonably been discovered. (Pen. Code, § 803, subd. (e).)
- Provides that if more than one statute of limitations period applies to a crime, the time for commencing an action shall be governed by the period that expires later in time. (Pen. Code § 803.6, subd. (a).)
- States that a prosecution is commenced when one of the following occurs:
- An indictment or information is filed;
- A complaint charging a misdemeanor or infraction is filed;
- The defendant is arraigned on a complaint that charges him or her with a felony; or,
- An arrest warrant or bench warrant is issued. (Pen. Code, § 804.)
- An indictment or information is filed;
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “SB 239 would align the statute of limitations for felony computer hacking with similar forms of crimes by allowing for prosecution three years after the date of discovery, rather than the date of the offense. This bill would allow the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code §502 as a civil prosecution for the same act, i.e. three years after the date of discovery rather than the date of the offense. Perpetrators of data breaches go to great lengths to conceal the effects of their crimes. Unlike victims of physical crimes, victims of computer hacking are often unaware of its occurrence. As a result, by the time the crimes are discovered, it can be too late to prosecute them.”
- Statute of Limitations: The statute of limitations requires commencement of a prosecution within a certain period of time after the commission of a crime. A prosecution is initiated by filing an indictment or information, filing a complaint, certifying a case to superior court, or issuing an arrest or bench warrant. (Pen. Code, § 804.)
The statute of limitations serves several important purposes in a criminal prosecution, including staleness, prompt investigation, and finality. The statute of limitations protects persons accused of crime from having to face charges based on evidence that may be unreliable, and from losing access to the evidentiary means to defend against the accusation. With the passage of time, memory fades, witnesses die or otherwise become unavailable, and physical evidence becomes unobtainable or contaminated.
The statute of limitations also imposes a priority among crimes for investigation and prosecution. The deadline serves to motivate the police and to ensure against bureaucratic delays in investigating crimes. Additionally, the statute of limitations reflects society's lack of desire to prosecute for crimes committed in the distant past. The interest in finality represents a societal evaluation of the time after which it is neither profitable nor desirable to commence a prosecution.
These principals are reflected in court decisions. The United States Supreme Court has stated that statutes of limitations are the primary guarantee against bringing overly stale criminal charges. (United States v. Ewell (1966) 383 U.S. 116, 122.) There is a measure of predictability provided by specifying a limit beyond which there is an irrebuttable presumption that a defendant's right to a fair trial would be prejudiced. Such laws reflect legislative assessments of the relative interests of the state and the defendant in administering and receiving justice.
More recently, in Stogner v. California (2003) 539 U.S. 607, the Court underscored the basis for statutes of limitations: "Significantly, a statute of limitations reflects a legislative judgment that, after a certain time, no quantum of evidence is sufficient to convict. And that judgment typically rests, in large part, upon evidentiary concerns - for example, concern that the passage of time has eroded memories or made witnesses or other evidence unavailable." (Id. at p. 615.)
The failure of a prosecution to be commenced within the applicable period of limitation is a complete defense to the charge. The statute of limitations is jurisdictional and may be raised as a defense at any time, before or after judgment. (People v. Morris (1988) 46 Cal.3d 1, 13.) The defense may only be waived under limited circumstances. (See Cowan v. Superior Court (1996) 14 Cal.4th 367.)
The court is required to construe application of the statute of limitations strictly in favor of the defendants. (People v. Zamora (1976) 18 Cal.3d 538, 574; People v. Lee (2000) 82 Cal.App.4th 1352, 1357-1358.)
The amount of time in which a prosecuting agency may charge an alleged defendant varies based on the crime. In general, the limitations period is related to the seriousness of the offense as reflected in the length of punishment established by the Legislature. (People v. Turner (2005) 134 Cal.App.4th 1591, 1594-1595; see, e.g., Pen. Code, §§ 799-805.) After a comprehensive review of criminal statutes of limitation in 1984, the Law Revision Commission recommended that the length of a "limitations statute should generally be based on the seriousness of the crime." (17 Cal. Law Revision Com. Rep. (1984) p. 313.) The Legislature overhauled the entire statutory scheme with this recommendation in mind. In People v. Turner, supra, 134 Cal.App.4th 1591, the court summarized the recommendations of the Law Revision Commission:
The use of seriousness of the crime as the primary factor in determining the length of the applicable statute of limitations was designed to strike the right balance between the societal interest in pursuing and punishing those who commit serious crimes, and the importance of barring stale claims. It also served the procedural need to provid[e] predictability and promote uniformity of treatment for perpetrators and victims of all serious crimes. The commission suggested that the seriousness of an offense could easily be determined in the first instance by the classification of the crime as a felony rather than a misdemeanor. Within the class of felonies, a long term of imprisonment is a determination that it is one of the more serious felonies; and imposition of the death penalty or life in prison is a determination that society views the crime as the most serious. (People v. Turner, supra, 134 Cal.App.4th at pp. 1594-1595, citations omitted.)
There are, however, some statutes of limitations not necessarily based on the seriousness of the offense. The Legislature has acknowledged that some crimes by their design are difficult to detect and may be immediately undiscoverable upon their completion. So for example, crimes involving fraud, breach of a fiduciary duty, bribes to a public official or employee, and those involving hidden recordings have statutes of limitations which begin to run upon discovery that the crime was committed. (See Pen. Code, § 803, subd. (c), see also Pen. Code, § 803, subd. (e).)
This bill would provide that a charge for the crime of computer hacking may be filed be up to three year after discovery of the crime.
- Ex Post Facto: In Stogner v. United States, supra, 539 U.S. 607 the Supreme Court ruled that a law enacted after expiration of a previously applicable limitations period violates the Ex Post Facto Clause when it is applied to revive a previously time-barred prosecution. (Id. at pp. 610-611, 616.) However, extension of an existing statute of limitations is not ex post facto as long as the prior limitations period has not expired. (Id. at pp. 618-619.)
Under these principles, the extended statute of limitations provided for in this bill could not be applied to cases in which the period has expired. - Argument in Support: According to the Conference of California Bar Associations, the sponsor of this bill, “SB 239 will align the statute of limitations for felony computer hacking with those of similar crimes by permitting prosecution three years after the date of discovery of the offense. Currently the statute of limitations runs from the date the offense occurred.
“Perpetrators of data breaches go to great lengths to conceal the effects of their crimes, and the victims often are unaware that a crime has been committed. For example, the 2013 Yahoo email hack that compromised over a billion accounts was not discovered until 2016, too late to prosecute under the current statute. As a result, under current law, by the time the crimes are discovered, it can be too late to prosecute them as felonies.
“The statute of limitations for ‘white-collar’ crimes that involve a breach of trust (e.g., grand theft, identity theft, fraud, forgery, perjury, etc.) is four years after discovery of the offense, or four years after its completion, whichever is later. (Pen. Code §§801.5, 803(c).) Similarly, the statute of limitations for computer hacking is three years after discovery, if prosecuted civilly. (Pen. Code, §502(e)(5).) But, the statute of limitations for computer hacking prosecuted as a felony commences from the date of the offense, not the date of discovery (See Pen. Code, §§502(d)(1), 801.). This is both inconsistent, counterintuitive, and impedes felony prosecution of major computer hacks because of the delay caused by difficulty in ascertaining that one has been hacked and determining the identity of the perpetrator.
“SB 239 will address this inconsistency by establishing the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code section 502 as a civil prosecution for the same act, i.e. three years after the date of discovery rather than the date of the offense. This is a reasonable change in the law that will enhance public protection from large-scale hacking schemes.” - Related Legislation: AB 814 (Chau), would clarify that existing law prohibits a person, business or government agency including a law enforcement agency, from hacking or otherwise accessing without authorization, computer data and computer systems in a motor vehicle. AB 814 is pending vote on the Senate Floor.
- Prior Legislation: AB 32 (Waldron) Chapter 614, Statutes of 2015, increased the base fine for felony convictions of specified computer crimes from a maximum of $5,000 to a maximum of $10,000.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AARP California
California District Attorneys Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Conference of California Bar Associations
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 239 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 239
Introduced: 2/11/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/9/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Criminal procedure: limitations of actions
SOURCE: Conference of California Bar Associations
DIGEST:
This bill amends the statute of limitations for felony offenses related to unlawful access of computer services and systems.
Existing law:
- Provides that prosecution for crimes punishable by imprisonment for eight years or more and not otherwise covered must be commenced within six years after commission of the offense. (Pen. Code § 800.)
- Provides that prosecution for other felonies punishable by less than eight years must be commenced within three years after commission of the offense. (Pen. Code § 801.)
- Provides that prosecution for crimes involving fraud, breach of a fiduciary duty, embezzlement of funds from an elder or dependent adult, or misconduct by a public official does not start to run until the discovery of the offense and prosecution must be commenced within four years after discovery of the crime or within four years after completion, whichever is later. (Pen. Code § 801.5 & 803, subd. (c).)
- States that prosecution for a misdemeanor shall be commenced within one year after the commission of the offense, unless otherwise specified. (Pen. Code, § 802, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that the statute of limitations for misdemeanors related to unlawful business practices and license violations is within three years after discovery of the commission of the offense, or within three years after completion of the offense, whichever is later. (Pen. Code § 802, subd. (e).)
- Provides that unless provided, as specified, a limitation of time is not tolled or extended for any reason. (Pen. Code § 803, subd. (a).)
- Provides that if more than one statute of limitations period applies to a crime, the time for commencing an action shall be governed by the period that expires later in time. (Pen. Code § 803.6, subd. (a).)
- States that, except as otherwise provided, prosecution for an offense is commenced when any of the following occurs:
- An indictment or information is filed;
- A complaint is filed charging a misdemeanor or infraction;
- The defendant is arraigned on a complaint that charges the defendant with a felony; or,
- An arrest warrant or bench warrant is issued, provided the warrant names or describes the defendant with the same degree of particularity required for an indictment, information, or complaint. (Pen. Code §804.)
- States that for purposes of determining the applicable limitation of time the following apply:
- An offense is deemed punishable by the maximum punishment prescribed by statute for the offense, regardless of the punishment actually sought or imposed. Any enhancement of punishment prescribed by statute shall be disregarded in determining the maximum punishment prescribed by statute for an offense;
- The limitation of time applicable to an offense that is necessarily included within a greater offense is the limitation of time applicable to the lesser included offense, regardless of the limitation of time applicable to the greater offense. (Pen. Code § 805.)
- Provides that the following conduct is an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by 16 months, two or three years in county jail and a fine of up to $10,000 or up to one year in county jail and by a fine of up to $1,000:
- Knowingly accesses and without permission alters, damages, deletes, destroys, or otherwise uses any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order to either (1) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (2) wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission adds, alters, damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an authorized user of a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of government computer services or denies or causes the denial of government computer services to an authorized user of a government computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission adds, alters, damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network; and,
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of public safety infrastructure computer system computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an authorized user of a public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network. (Pen. Code, § 502.)
- Provides that a person who knowingly and without permission uses or causes to be used computer services shall be punished as follows:
- For the first violation that does not result in injury, and where the value of the computer services used does not exceed $950, as a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year; or
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount greater than $5,000 or in an injury, or if the value of the computer services used exceeds $950, or for any second or subsequent violation, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000 and by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years, or by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
- Provides that a person who (A) knowingly and without permission provides or assists in providing a means of accessing a computer, computer system or computer network, (B) knowingly and without permission accesses or causes to be accessed a computer, computer system or computer network, or (C) knowingly and without permission provides or assists in providing a means of accessing a computer, computer system, or public safety infrastructure computer, computer system or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000;
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount not greater than $5,000, or for a second or subsequent violation, as a misdemeanor by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and imprisonment in county jail for up to one year; or,
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount greater than $5,000, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000 and by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years, or by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
- Provides that a person who either (A) knowingly introduces any computer contaminant into any computer, computer system, or computer network, or (B) knowingly introduces any computer contaminant into any public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, as a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year; or,
- For any violation that results in injury, or for a second or subsequent violation, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000, and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years. (Id.)
- Provides that any person who knowingly and without permission uses the Internet domain name or profile of another individual, corporation, or entity in connection with the sending of one or more electronic mail messages or posts and thereby damages or causes damage to a computer, computer data, computer system, or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000; or,
- For any violation that results in injury, or for a second or subsequent violation, as misdemeanor by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
- Authorizes the owner or lessee of the computer, computer system, computer network, computer program, or data who suffers damage or loss due to a violation of Penal Code Section 502 to bring a civil action against the violator for compensatory damages and injunctive or other equitable relief. (Pen. Code § 502, subd. (e)(1).)
- Provides that any civil action seeking for a violation of Penal Code section 502 must be initiated within three years of the date of the act complained of, or the date of the discovery of the damage, whichever is later. (Pen. Code § 502, subd. (e)(5).)
This bill amends the statute of limitations for felony violations of Penal Code Section 502, which currently is currently three years after the commission of the offense to three years after discovery of the commission of the offense, or three years after the completion of the offense, whichever date is later.
Comments
According to the author:
Under existing law, the statute of limitations for certain crimes that involve a breach of trust (e.g., grand theft, identity theft, fraud, forgery, perjury, etc.) is four years after discovery of the offense, or four years after its completion, whichever is later.
Similarly, the statute of limitations for computer hacking is three years after discovery, if prosecuted civilly. But, the statute of limitations for computer hacking prosecuted as a felony commences from the date of the offense, not the date of discovery, which is inconsistent and counterintuitive. For example, the hacking attacks on Yahoo, which compromised more than 1.5 billion user accounts, occurred in 2013 and 2014 but weren’t revealed until 2016.
Because computer criminals often take great steps in attempting to conceal their crimes, it may be too late to prosecute and hold the criminals accountable for their actions once they are discovered.
SB 239 would align the statute of limitations for felony computer hacking with similar forms of crimes by allowing for prosecution three years after the date of discovery, rather than the date of the offense. This bill would allow the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code section 502 as a civil prosecution for the same act, i.e. three years after the date of discovery rather than the date of the offense.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- State prison: Unknown, potential increase in state costs for new commitments to state prison that otherwise would not have resulted in incarceration. The proposed FY 2019-20 per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $83,064 annually. The actual costs would depend on how many defendants are sentenced to prison for a computer crime relevant to this bill after the current statute of limitations has lapsed. (General Fund)
- Court: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants that would be time barred under current law. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Governor's proposed FY 2019-20 Budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
* Trial Court Trust Fund
Conference of California Bar Associations (source)
California District Attorneys Association
California State Sheriffs’ Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
None received
Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. /
5/18/19 12:53:13
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 239 (Chang) - Criminal procedure: limitations of actions
Version: February 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 22, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 239 would extend the statute of limitations, as specified, for felony crimes related to unauthorized access to computers, computer systems, or networks, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- State prison: Unknown, potential increase in state costs for new commitments to state prison that otherwise would not have resulted in incarceration. The proposed FY 2019-20 per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $83,064 annually. The actual costs would depend on how many defendants are sentenced to prison for a computer crime relevant to this measure after the current statute of limitations has lapsed. (General Fund)
- Court: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants that would be time barred under current law. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Governor's proposed FY 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Public Safety:
Statutes of limitations require commencement of a prosecution within a certain period of time after the commission of a crime. A prosecution is initiated by filing an indictment or information, filing a complaint, certifying a case to superior court, or issuing an arrest or bench warrant. (Penal Code § 804.) The failure of a prosecution to be commenced within the applicable period of limitation is a complete defense to the charge. The statute of limitations is jurisdictional and may be raised as a defense at any time, before or after judgment. (People v. Morris (1988) 46 Cal.3d 1, 13.) The defense may only be waived under limited circumstances. (See Cowan v. Superior Court (1996) 14 Cal.4th 367.)
The Legislature enacted the current statutory scheme regarding statutes of limitations for crimes in 1984 in response to a report of the California Law Revision Commission:
The Commission identified various factors to be considered in drafting a limitations statute. These factors include: (a) The staleness factor. A person accused of crime should be protected from having to face charges based on possibly unreliable evidence and from losing access to the evidentiary means to defend. (b) The repose factor. This reflects society's lack of a desire to prosecute for crimes committed in the distant past. (c) The motivation factor. This aspect of the statute imposes a priority among crimes for investigation and prosecution. (d) The seriousness factor. The statute of limitations is a grant of amnesty to a defendant; the more serious the crime, the less willing society is to grant that amnesty. (e) The concealment factor. Detection of certain concealed crimes may be quite difficult and may require long investigations to identify and prosecute the perpetrators.
The Commission concluded that a felony limitations statute generally should be based on the seriousness of the crime. Seriousness is easily determined based on classification of a crime as felony or misdemeanor and the punishment specified, and a scheme based on seriousness generally will accommodate the other factors as well. Also, the simplicity of a limitations period based on seriousness provides predictability and promotes uniformity of treatment.
The United States Supreme Court has stated that statutes of limitations are the primary guarantee against bringing overly stale criminal charges. (United States v. Ewell (1966) 383 U.S. 116, 122.) There is a measure of predictability provided by specifying a limit beyond which there is an irrebutable presumption that a defendant's right to a fair trial would be prejudiced. Such laws reflect legislative assessments of relative interests of the state and the defendant in administering and receiving justice: “Significantly, a statute of limitations reflects a legislative judgment that, after a certain time, no quantum of evidence is sufficient to convict. And that judgment typically rests, in large part, upon evidentiary concerns – for example, concern that the passage of time has eroded memories or made witnesses or other evidence unavailable. (Stogner v. California (2003) 539 U.S. 607, 615.)
Generally, the statute of limitations for misdemeanor offenses requires commencement of prosecution within one year of the commission of the offense (Pen. Code § 802) and for felony offenses, within three years of the commission of the offense (Pen. Code § 801). There are specified exceptions that either provides for a longer statute of limitations (Pen. Code, §§ 801.5, 802), tolls the time that the statute starts to run such as when the crime is discovered (Pen. Code § 803), or provides no statute of limitations at all (Pen. Code § 799). [Footnote omitted.]
Generally, unauthorized access to a computer, computer system, or computer network, when a felony, is punishable by imprisonment pursuant to the 2011 Realignment Legislation for 16 months, two years, or three years and a base fine of up to $10,000.
Proposed Law:
This bill would allow felony prosecution of specified crimes related to unauthorized access to any data, computer, computer system, or computer network to begin the later of (1) within three years after the discovery of the commission of the offense or (2) within three years after the completion of the offense.
Related Legislation:
AB 32 (Waldron, Ch. 614, Stats. 2015) increased the base fine for felony convictions of specified computer crimes from a maximum of $5,000 to a maximum of $10,000.
AB 1649 (Waldron, Ch. 379, Stats. 2014) specified the penalties for any person who disrupts or causes the disruption of, adds, alters, damages, destroys, provides or assists in providing a means of accessing, or introduces any computer contaminant into a "government computer system" or a "public safety infrastructure computer system," as specified, and changed and added the definition of specified terms.
Staff Comments:
The fiscal impact of this bill cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors, including, but not limited to, judicial and prosecutorial discretion, the criminal history of the defendant, and the factors unique to each case. To the extent even one additional defendant is committed to state prison as a result of this bill, state incarceration costs would surpass the Suspense File threshold. Additionally, as the crime created by this bill is punishable with the potential for incarceration, certain rights to the defendants are attached to the proceedings, including the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier court proceedings. Consequently, to the extent that the court adjudicates more than three felony offenses related to unauthorized computer access, on average, that otherwise would have been time barred but for this measure, costs to the court resulting from this bill would be significant.
With respect to the prison population, California is subject to a federal court order to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5 percent of design capacity. The state has undertaken efforts to implement a durable remedy to reduce and avoid prison overcrowding. On April 3, 2019, 117,564 inmates were detained in the state’s thirty-five adult institutions and camps, 6,443 were housed in in-state contract beds, and 1,060 inmates were held in an out-of-state facility. The prison population changes daily as new inmates are admitted and others are released, but, on that date, the state’s prison population was approximately 134.0 percent of design capacity. By potentially increasing the inmate population in in-state institutions, this bill could make it more difficult for the state to comply with the court order.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 239 Hearing Date: April 9, 2019
Author: | Chang | ||
Version: | February 11, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Criminal Procedure: Limitations of Actions
HISTORY
Source: Conference of California Bar Associations
Prior Legislation: SB 610 (Nguyen), Ch. 74, Stats. 2017
SB 1088 (Nguyen), vetoed, 2016
AB 32 (Waldron), Ch. 614, Stats. 2015
AB 1649 (Waldron), Ch. 379, Stats. 2014
AB 22 (Torres), Ch. 70, Stats. 2009
AB 2727 (Wesson), Ch. 635, Stats. 2000
AB 2232 (Oller), Ch. 634, Stats. 2000
SB 451 (Maddox), Ch. 254, Stats. 1999
SB 255 (Davis), Ch. 1499, Stats. 1987
Support: California District Attorneys Association; California State Sheriffs’ Association
Opposition: None known
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to amend the statute of limitations for felony offenses related to unlawful access of computer services and systems.
Existing law provides that prosecution for crimes punishable by imprisonment for eight years or more and not otherwise covered must be commenced within six years after commission of the offense. (Pen. Code, § 800.)
Existing law provides that prosecution for other felonies punishable by less than eight years must be commenced within three years after commission of the offense. (Pen. Code, § 801.)
Existing law provides that prosecution for crimes involving fraud, breach of a fiduciary duty, embezzlement of funds from an elder or dependent adult, or misconduct by a public official does not start to run until the discovery of the offense and prosecution must be commenced within four years after discovery of the crime or within four years after completion, whichever is later. (Penal Code § 801.5 & 803, subd. (c).)
Existing law states that prosecution for a misdemeanor shall be commenced within one year after the commission of the offense, unless otherwise specified. (Pen. Code, § 802, subd. (a).)
Existing law specifies that the statute of limitations for misdemeanors related to unlawful business practices and license violations is within three years after discovery of the commission of the offense, or within three years after completion of the offense, whichever is later. (Pen. Code, § 802, subd. (e).)
Existing law provides that unless provided, as specified, a limitation of time is not tolled or extended for any reason. (Penal Code § 803, subd. (a).)
Existing law provides that if more than one statute of limitations period applies to a crime, the time for commencing an action shall be governed by the period that expires later in time. (Penal Code § 803.6, subd. (a).)
Existing law states that, except as otherwise provided, prosecution for an offense is commenced when any of the following occurs:
- An indictment or information is filed;
- A complaint is filed charging a misdemeanor or infraction;
- The defendant is arraigned on a complaint that charges the defendant with a felony; or,
- An arrest warrant or bench warrant is issued, provided the warrant names or describes the defendant with the same degree of particularity required for an indictment, information, or complaint. (Pen. Code, §804.)
Existing law states that for purposes of determining the applicable limitation of time the following apply:
- An offense is deemed punishable by the maximum punishment prescribed by statute for the offense, regardless of the punishment actually sought or imposed. Any enhancement of punishment prescribed by statute shall be disregarded in determining the maximum punishment prescribed by statute for an offense;
- The limitation of time applicable to an offense that is necessarily included within a greater offense is the limitation of time applicable to the lesser included offense, regardless of the limitation of time applicable to the greater offense. (Pen. Code, § 805.)
Existing law provides that the following conduct is an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by 16 months, two or three years in county jail and a fine of up to $10,000 or up to one year in county jail and by a fine of up to $1,000:
- Knowingly accesses and without permission alters, damages, deletes, destroys, or otherwise uses any data, computer, computer system, or computer network in order to either (A) devise or execute any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B) wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission takes, copies, or makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or computer network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether existing or residing internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission adds, alters, damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an authorized user of a computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of government computer services or denies or causes the denial of government computer services to an authorized user of a government computer, computer system, or computer network;
- Knowingly accesses and without permission adds, alters, damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network; and,
- Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the disruption of public safety infrastructure computer system computer services or denies or causes the denial of computer services to an authorized user of a public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network. (Pen. Code, § 502.)
Existing law provides that a person who knowingly and without permission uses or causes to be used computer services shall be punished as follows:
- For the first violation that does not result in injury, and where the value of the computer services used does not exceed $950, as a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year; or
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount greater than $5,000 or in an injury, or if the value of the computer services used exceeds $950, or for any second or subsequent violation, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000 and by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years, or by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
Existing law provides that a person who (A) knowingly and without permission provides or assists in providing a means of accessing a computer, computer system or computer network, (B) knowingly and without permission accesses or causes to be accessed a computer, computer system or computer network, or (C) knowingly and without permission provides or assists in providing a means of accessing a computer, computer system, or public safety infrastructure computer, computer system or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000;
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount not greater than $5,000, or for a second or subsequent violation, as a misdemeanor by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and imprisonment in county jail for up to one year; or,
- For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an amount greater than $5,000, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000 and by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years, or by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
Existing law provides that a person who either (A) knowingly introduces any computer contaminant into any computer, computer system, or computer network, or (B) knowingly introduces any computer contaminant into any public safety infrastructure computer system computer, computer system, or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, as a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year; or,
- For any violation that results in injury, or for a second or subsequent violation, as an alternate felony-misdemeanor punishable by a fine not exceeding $10,000, and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by imprisonment in county jail for 16 months, or two or three years. (Id.)
Existing law provides that any person who knowingly and without permission uses the Internet domain name or profile of another individual, corporation, or entity in connection with the sending of one or more electronic mail messages or posts and thereby damages or causes damage to a computer, computer data, computer system, or computer network shall be punished as follows:
- For a first violation that does not result in injury, an infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding $1,000; or,
- For any violation that results in injury, or for a second or subsequent violation, as misdemeanor by a fine not exceeding $5,000 and by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year. (Id.)
Existing law authorizes the owner or lessee of the computer, computer system, computer network, computer program, or data who suffers damage or loss due to a violation of Penal Code section 502 to bring a civil action against the violator for compensatory damages and injunctive or other equitable relief. (Pen. Code, § 502, subd. (e)(1).)
Existing law provides that any civil action seeking for a violation of Penal Code section 502 must be initiated within three years of the date of the act complained of, or the date of the discovery of the damage, whichever is later. (Pen. Code, § 502, subd. (e)(5).)
This bill amends the statute of limitations for felony violations of Penal Code section 502, which currently is currently three years after the commission of the offense to three years after discovery of the commission of the offense, or three years after the completion of the offense, whichever date is later.
COMMENTS
- Need for this Bill
According to the author of this bill:
Under existing law, the statute of limitations for certain crimes that involve a breach of trust (e.g., grand theft, identity theft, fraud, forgery, perjury, etc.) is four years after discovery of the offense, or four years after its completion, whichever is later.
Similarly, the statute of limitations for computer hacking is three years after discovery, if prosecuted civilly. But, the statute of limitations for computer hacking prosecuted as a felony commences from the date of the offense, not the date of discovery, which is inconsistent and counterintuitive. For example, the hacking attacks on Yahoo, which compromised more than 1.5 billion user accounts, occurred in 2013 and 2014 but weren’t revealed until 2016.
Because computer criminals often take great steps in attempting to conceal their crimes, it may be too late to prosecute and hold the criminals accountable for their actions once they are discovered.
SB 239 would align the statute of limitations for felony computer hacking with similar forms of crimes by allowing for prosecution three years after the date of discovery, rather than the date of the offense. This bill would allow the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code section 502 as a civil prosecution for the same act, i.e. three years after the date of discovery rather than the date of the offense.
- Statutes of Limitations
Statutes of limitations require commencement of a prosecution within a certain period of time after the commission of a crime. A prosecution is initiated by filing an indictment or information, filing a complaint, certifying a case to superior court, or issuing an arrest or bench warrant. (Penal Code § 804.) The failure of a prosecution to be commenced within the applicable period of limitation is a complete defense to the charge. The statute of limitations is jurisdictional and may be raised as a defense at any time, before or after judgment. (People v. Morris (1988) 46 Cal.3d 1, 13.) The defense may only be waived under limited circumstances. (See Cowan v. Superior Court (1996) 14 Cal.4th 367.)
The Legislature enacted the current statutory scheme regarding statutes of limitations for crimes in 1984 in response to a report of the California Law Revision Commission:
The Commission identified various factors to be considered in drafting a limitations statute. These factors include: (a) The staleness factor. A person accused of crime should be protected from having to face charges based on possibly unreliable evidence and from losing access to the evidentiary means to defend. (b) The repose factor. This reflects society's lack of a desire to prosecute for crimes committed in the distant past. (c) The motivation factor. This aspect of the statute imposes a priority among crimes for investigation and prosecution. (d) The seriousness factor. The statute of limitations is a grant of amnesty to a defendant; the more serious the crime, the less willing society is to grant that amnesty. (e) The concealment factor. Detection of certain concealed crimes may be quite difficult and may require long investigations to identify and prosecute the perpetrators.
The Commission concluded that a felony limitations statute generally should be based on the seriousness of the crime. Seriousness is easily determined based on classification of a crime as felony or misdemeanor and the punishment specified, and a scheme based on seriousness generally will accommodate the other factors as well. Also, the simplicity of a limitations period based on seriousness provides predictability and promotes uniformity of treatment.[1]
The United States Supreme Court has stated that statutes of limitations are the primary guarantee against bringing overly stale criminal charges. (United States v. Ewell (1966) 383 U.S. 116, 122.) There is a measure of predictability provided by specifying a limit beyond which there is an irrebutable presumption that a defendant's right to a fair trial would be prejudiced. Such laws reflect legislative assessments of relative interests of the state and the defendant in administering and receiving justice: “Significantly, a statute of limitations reflects a legislative judgment that, after a certain time, no quantum of evidence is sufficient to convict. And that judgment typically rests, in large part, upon evidentiary concerns – for example, concern that the passage of time has eroded memories or made witnesses or other evidence unavailable. (Stogner v. California (2003) 539 U.S. 607, 615.)
Generally, the statute of limitations for misdemeanor offenses requires commencement of prosecution within one year of the commission of the offense (Pen. Code § 802) and for felony offenses, within three years of the commission of the offense (Pen. Code § 801). There are specified exceptions that either provides for a longer statute of limitations (Pen. Code, §§ 801.5, 802), tolls the time that the statute starts to run such as when the crime is discovered (Pen. Code § 803), or provides no statute of limitations at all (Pen. Code § 799).
This bill specifies for computer crimes listed in Penal Code section 502, if charged as a felony the statute of limitations is three years after discovery of the commission of the offense or within three years after the completion of the offense, whichever date is later. As stated by the author of this bill, the purpose of this change is to allow the same statute of limitations for a felony violation of Penal Code section 502 as a civil prosecution for the same act. This timeframe is also similar to statutes of limitations for fraud-related offenses and specified misdemeanors related to unlawful business practices and license violations (4 years, and 3 years respectively, after the date of discovery of the offense or after the completion of the offense, whichever is later). (Pen. Code, §§ 801.5, 803, 802, subd. (e).)
The effect of this change is that the statute of limitations would be longer than the current limit and potentially allow prosecution of cases many years after the crime was committed depending on when the crime is discovered. However, courts have interpreted the date of discovery provision of statutes of limitations to require due diligence in the investigative efforts of the crime. (People v. Zamora (1976) 18 Cal.3d 538, 561; People v. Lopez (1997) 52 Cal.App.4th 233, 246.) Thus, “discovery of the offense” is not synonymous with the date that the victim gained actual knowledge of the crime. (People v. Zamora, supra, 18 Cal.3d at 571.) “The crucial determination is whether law enforcement authorities or the victim had actual notice of circumstances sufficient to make them suspicious of fraud thereby leading them to make inquiries which might have revealed the fraud. (Id. at 572, original italics.) The identity of the perpetrator of the crime is not an element of the discovery issue. (People v. Crossman (1986) 210 Cal. App. 3d 476, 481.) So while it is possible that the crimes affected by this bill could be prosecuted many years after their commission, the prosecutor would have the burden to prove by a preponderance of the evidence that the prosecution of the crime began within the required time which includes consideration of when the victim or law enforcement was aware of facts that would have alerted a reasonably diligent person in the same circumstances that a crime may have been committed. (CALCRIM No. 3410.)
- Ex Post Facto
In Stogner v. California, supra, 539 U.S. 607 the Supreme Court ruled that a law enacted after expiration of a previously applicable limitations period violates the Ex Post Facto Clause when it is applied to revive a previously time-barred prosecution. (Id. at pp. 610-611, 616.) However, extension of an existing statute of limitations is not ex post facto as long as the prior limitations period has not expired. (Id. at pp. 618-619.) Existing statutory law also provides that any change in the time period for the commencement of prosecution applies to any crime if prosecution for the crime was not barred on the effective date of the change by the statute of limitations in effect immediately prior to the effective date of the change. (Pen. Code § 803.6, subd. (b).)
Under these principles, the extended statute of limitations provided for in this bill cannot be applied to cases in which the statute of limitations period has expired.
- Argument in Support
According to the Conference of California Bar Associations (CCBA), the sponsor of this bill:
Perpetrators of data breaches go to great lengths to conceal the effects of their crimes, and the victims often are unaware that a crime has been committed. For example, the 2013 Yahoo email hack that compromised over a billion accounts was not discovered until late 2016, too late to prosecute under the current statute. As a result, under current law, by the time the crimes are discovered, it can be too late to prosecute them as felonies.
The statute of limitations for ‘white collar’ crimes that involve breach of trust (e.g. grand theft, identity theft, fraud, forgery, perjury, etc.) is four years after discovery of the offense, or four years after its completion, whichever is later. (Pen. Code §§ 801.5, 803(c).) Similarly, the statute of limitations for computer hacking is three years after discovery, if prosecuted civilly. (Pen. Code, § 502(e)(5).) But, the statute of limitations for computer hacking prosecuted as a felony commences from the date of the offense, not the date of discovery (See Pen. Code, §§502(d)(1), 801.) This is both inconsistent, counterintuitive, and impedes felony prosecution of major computer hacks because of the delay caused by difficulty in ascertaining that one has been hacked and determining the identity of the perpetrator.
-- END –
1 Witkin Cal. Crim. Law Defenses, Section 214 (3rd Ed. 2004), citing 17 Cal. Law Rev. Com. Reports, pp.308-314. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):