SB 247: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation management.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
Existing law establishes the Wildfire Safety Division within the Public Utilities Commission to, among other things, oversee and enforce electrical corporations compliance with wildfire safety requirements. Existing law requires the division to approve or deny each wildfire mitigation plan and plan updates submitted by an electrical corporation.
This bill would require an electrical corporation, within one month of the completion of a substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan, to notify the division of the completion. The bill would require the division to audit the completed work and would require the audit to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements. The bill would require the division to provide the audit to the electrical corporation and to provide the electrical corporation a reasonable time period to correct and eliminate deficiencies specified in the audit. The bill would authorize the division to engage an independent evaluator to conduct the audit. Within one year after the expiration of the time period to correct and eliminate deficiencies, the bill would require the independent evaluator to issue a report to the electrical corporation, the division, and the Safety and Enforcement Division of the commission specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements.
This bill would require each electrical corporation to notify the commission of the date when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management not less than 30 days before that date.
This bill would specify the qualifications for electrical line clearance tree trimmers performing work to comply with the vegetation management requirements in an electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan, and would require that qualified line clearance tree trimmers be paid no less than a specified prevailing wage rate.
(a)The Wildfire Safety Division shall approve or deny each wildfire mitigation plan and update submitted by an electrical corporation within three months of its submission, unless the division makes a written determination, including reasons supporting the determination, that the three-month deadline cannot be met. Each electrical corporations approved plan shall remain in effect until the division approves the electrical corporations subsequent plan. The division shall consult with the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection on the review of each wildfire mitigation plan and update. In rendering its decision, the division shall consider comments submitted pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 8386. Before approval, the division may require modifications of the plan. After approval by the division, the commission shall ratify the action of the division.
(b)The Wildfire Safety Divisions approval of a plan does not establish a defense to any enforcement action for a violation of a commission decision, order, or rule.
(c)Following approval of a wildfire mitigation plan, the Wildfire Safety Division shall oversee compliance with the plan consistent with the following:
(1)Three months after the end of an electrical corporations initial compliance period as established by the Wildfire Safety Division pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 8386, and annually thereafter, each electrical corporation shall file with the division a report addressing its compliance with the plan during the prior calendar year.
(2)(A)Before March 1, 2021, and before each March 1 thereafter, the Wildfire Safety Division, in consultation with the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, shall make available a list of qualified independent evaluators with experience in assessing the safe operation of electrical infrastructure.
(B)(i)Each electrical corporation shall engage an independent evaluator listed pursuant to subparagraph (A) to review and assess the electrical corporations compliance with its plan. The engaged independent evaluator shall consult with, and operate under the direction of, the Wildfire Safety Division of the commission. The independent evaluator shall issue a report on July 1 of each year in which a report required by paragraph (1) is filed. As a part of the independent evaluators report, the independent evaluator shall determine whether the electrical corporation failed to fund any activities included in its plan.
(ii)The Wildfire Safety Division shall consider the independent evaluators findings, but the independent evaluators findings are not binding on the division, except as otherwise specified.
(iii)The independent evaluators findings shall be used by the Wildfire Safety Division to carry out its obligations under Article 1 (commencing with Section 451) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 1.
(iv)The independent evaluators findings shall not apply to events that occurred before the initial plan is approved for the electrical corporation.
(3)The commission shall authorize the electrical corporation to recover in rates the costs of the independent evaluator.
(4)The Wildfire Safety Division shall complete its compliance review within 18 months after the submission of the electrical corporations compliance report.
(5)(A)An electrical corporation shall notify the Wildfire Safety Division, within one month after it completes a substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan, of the completion. Upon receiving the notice from the electrical corporation, the division shall, consistent with its authority pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 326, promptly audit the work performed by, or on behalf of, the electrical corporation. The audit shall specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements in the wildfire mitigation plan. The division shall provide the audit to the electrical corporation. The electrical corporation shall have a reasonable time, as determined by the division, to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit.
(B)The Wildfire Safety Division may engage its own independent evaluator, who shall be a certified arborist and shall have any other qualifications determined appropriate by the division, to conduct the audit specified in subparagraph (A). The independent evaluator shall consult with, and operate under the direction of, the division.
(C)Within one year of the expiration of the time period for an electrical corporation to correct and eliminate any deficiency identified in the audit, the independent evaluator shall issue a report to the electrical corporation, the Wildfire Safety Division, and the Safety and Enforcement Division of the commission specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in the electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan. The report shall be made publicly available. The division shall include the report in its compliance review prepared pursuant to paragraph (4).
(6)Each electrical corporation shall reimburse the Wildfire Safety Division for its costs to implement this section with respect to that electrical corporation.
(d)An electrical corporation shall not divert revenues authorized to implement the plan to any activities or investments outside of the plan. An electrical corporation shall notify the commission by advice letter of the date when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management in its wildfire mitigation plan not less than 30 days before that date.
(e)The commission shall not allow a large electrical corporation to include in its equity rate base its share, as determined pursuant to the Wildfire Fund allocation metric specified in Section 3280, of the first five billion dollars ($5,000,000,000) expended in aggregate by large electrical corporations on fire risk mitigation capital expenditures included in the electrical corporations approved wildfire mitigation plans. An electrical corporations share of the fire risk mitigation capital expenditures and the debt financing costs of these fire risk mitigation capital expenditures may be financed through a financing order pursuant to Section 850.1 subject to the requirements of that financing order.
(f)This section does not impose any liability on the Wildfire Safety Division regarding the performance of its duties.
SEC. 2.Section 8386.6 is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:8386.6.(a)All electrical line clearance tree trimmers performing work to comply with the vegetation management requirements in an electrical corporations wildfire mitigation plan shall be qualified line clearance tree trimmers, or trainees under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers, as provided in the High-Voltage Electrical Safety Orders (Group 2 (commencing with Section 2700) of Subchapter 5 of Chapter 4 of Division 1 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations) of the Department of Industrial Relations.
(b)All qualified line clearance tree trimmers shall be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman as determined by the Director of Industrial Relations.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 406, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 18, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 40. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 21, 2019 | August 21 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | August 14 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (July 8). |
| Jul 2, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (June 26). |
| Jun 12, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on U. & E. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on U. & E. and NAT. RES. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 36. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 23). |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on N.R. & W. (Ayes 11. Noes 1.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on E., U. & C. and N.R. & W. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 12, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 14. |
| Feb 11, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB247 Dodd Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 9, 2019 | SB 247 Dodd Senate Third Reading By Wood | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Utilities and Energy |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB247 Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources and Water] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 247 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 247
Amended: 9/3/19
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 11-1, 4/10/19
AYES: Hueso, Bradford, Chang, Dodd, Hertzberg, Hill, McGuire, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Wiener
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/23/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Borgeas, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0, 5/21/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 9/9/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation: management
SOURCE: Coalition of California Utility Employees
DIGEST:
This bill proposes several changes related to the vegetation management requirements of electrical corporations, including: requiring specified notifications to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) Wildfire Safety Division (WSD) about the vegetation management conducted; requiring specified audits by the WSD; authorizing the WSD to engage an independent evaluator and issue a report; specifying qualifications and prevailing wages for line clearance tree trimmers, and other requirements.
Assembly Amendments
recast this bill under the jurisdiction of the CPUC WSD and within the Public Utilities Code, instead of California Department of Fire and Forestry Protection (Cal FIRE) and the Public Resources Code, make specified changes to the timing of the required notifications, tie the prevailing wage of the tree trimmers to that of utility lineman, remove the requirement of a two-way balancing account, and make other technical amendments.
Existing law:
- Establishes the CPUC has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. (California Constitution, Article 12, §§3 and 4)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities §451)
- Requires each electrical corporation, local publicly owned electric utility, and electrical cooperative to construct, maintain, and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment. Requires each electrical corporation to annually prepare a wildfire mitigation plan and to submit its plan to the commission for review and approval, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §8386)
- Requires the CPUC and Cal FIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding (MOU) to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data. (Public Utilities Code §8386.5)
- Establishes the WSD within the CPUC to, among other things, oversee and enforce electrical corporations’ compliance with wildfire safety requirements. Requires the WSD to approve or deny each wildfire mitigation plan and plan updates submitted by an electrical corporation. (Public Utilities Code §326)
This bill:
- Requires an electrical corporation, within one month of the completion of each substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan, to notify the WSD of the completion.
- Requires the WSD to audit the completed work and would require the audit to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements.
- Requires the WSD to provide the audit to the electrical corporation and to provide the electrical corporation a reasonable time period to correct and eliminate deficiencies specified in the audit.
- Authorizes the WSD to engage an independent evaluator to conduct the audit.
- Requires the independent evaluator to issue a report to the electrical corporation, the WSD, and the Safety and Enforcement Division of the CPUC specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements, within one year after the expiration of the time period to correct and eliminate deficiencies.
- Requires each electrical corporation to notify the CPUC of the date when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligation to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management not less than 30 days before that date.
- Specifies the qualifications for electrical line clearance tree trimmers performing work to comply with the vegetation management requirements in an electrical corporation’s wildfire mitigation plan, and would require that qualified line clearance tree trimmers be paid a specified prevailing wage rate.
Background
Vegetation management and electric utilities. Electric utility companies trim and remove trees near high voltage power lines for public safety, fire prevention, and electric reliability. There are a number of laws and regulations governing vegetation management, including: California Public Resources Code Sections: 4293 Power Line Clearance Required; 4292 Power Line Hazard Reduction; 4291 Reduction of Fire Hazards around Buildings; and 4171 Public Nuisances. Additionally, there are a number of CPUC orders and California Code of Regulations, including General Order 95, California Code of Regulations Title 14, and others. Additionally, federal reliability rules require specified clearances between vegetation and transmission lines.
CPUC and Cal FIRE MOU. The CPUC has a MOU with the Cal FIRE, and has long worked with Cal FIRE on improving wildfire mitigation. Per statute, electric utilities must file wildfire mitigation plans with specified information. Investor-owned electric utilities have been required to develop wildfire mitigation plans since 2017, per SB 1028 (Hill, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016). SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) modified those existing requirements in a number of ways, including requiring a more nuanced and detailed list of information that the utilities must provide in their plans. In addition, the CPUC will review the plans, modify the plans when necessary, and eventually adopt plans. Statute also requires the CPUC to pursue enforcement actions for non-compliance with the plans. Earlier this year, the CPUC reviewed the first round of wildfire mitigation plans since SB 901 was adopted with the expectation for continual improvement in future plans and reviews.
Cost recovery for vegetation management. Electric utilities generally receive authorization for funding for vegetation management in their general rate cases (GRCs) with new authorization every three years. The GRCs approve spending for broad categories of funding and occasionally for specific projects. Generally, spending for vegetation management is tracked in a one-way balancing account, which means that if the utility does not spend all the authorized funds, the unused funds are returned to ratepayers and the utility is not authorized to spend more than what has been budgeted. Additionally, utilities are generally prohibited from diverting funds to other spending areas or to profits. As required by statute in Public Utilities Code Section 451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for recovery of costs that is deemed “just and reasonable.” The review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the primary purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator.
Wildfire bills signed. Earlier this summer, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed legislation to establish the WSD within the CPUC and charges it with reviewing each electrical corporations’ for either approval or denial within three months of its submission. The statutes also require the WSD, in consultation with Cal FIRE, to make available a list of qualified independent evaluators. Additionally, electrical corporations are required to engage an independent evaluator to review and assess the electric utility’s compliance with its wildfire mitigation plan.
Comments
SB 247. This bill proposes several changes related to the vegetation management requirements of electrical corporations, including: requiring specified notifications to the CPUC WSD about the vegetation management conducted; requiring specified audits by the WSD; authorizing the WSD to engage an independent evaluator and issue a report; specifying qualifications and prevailing wages for line clearance tree trimmers, and other requirements.
CPUC and Cal FIRE. As noted above, Cal FIRE and the CPUC currently have an existing MOU for wildfire mitigation-related activities. Generally, the CPUC has an auditing function of utilities, but does not necessarily inspect electric lines directly and does not currently have the staff or resources to conduct these inspections. Cal FIRE also may lack some of the human or capital resources to undertake utility vegetation management inspections and tree trimming work. Cal FIRE also provides a significant portion of the utilities’ power lines and related equipment is not in a state responsibility area, which is where Cal FIRE’s statutory responsibilities are focused. In the recently released Budget adopted, the Governor proposed significant funding for the CPUC to increase its oversight of the electric IOU’s wildfire mitigation plans ($41 million), including a proposal to have a “swat team” of inspectors. The debate as to whether CPUC or Cal FIRE should handle these responsibilities was addressed in the wildfire-related bills adopted in July whereby the WSD was established within the CPUC with the responsibilities to review the electric utilities’ wildfire mitigation plans, as well as requirements to transfer these functions, effective July 1, 2021, to a new Office of Energy Infrastructure and Safety within the Resources Agency.
Audits by WSD. This bill requires audits of the vegetation management conducted by electric utilities, with specified information, to ensure the utilities vegetation management is complying with the adopted Wildfire Mitigation Plan. Recently, concerns have been raised about the adequacy of the vegetation management by electric utilities with specific concerns raised about deficiencies with Pacific Gas & Electric’s (PG&E’s) vegetation removal efforts. This bill attempts to ensure that boots-on-the-ground can inspect and ensure the electric utilities are adequately conducting the clearances they have identified in their plans.
Trained workforce. The requirements for the qualifications of the workers conducting the vegetation management as proposed in this bill could result in reduced ability by the utility to address all its vegetation management needs. The sponsor of this bill notes the work is dangerous where injuries and deaths happen far too often and necessitate the need for the specified trained workforce. The sponsor, Coalition of California Utility Employees, notes that some of the existing workforce may not report injuries due to their immigration status. In addition to the required qualifications, this bill also requires clearance tree trimmers to be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman, as determined by the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR). According to the DIR’s Web site:
The prevailing wage rate is the basic hourly rate paid on public works projects to a majority of workers engaged in a particular craft, classification or type of work within the locality and in the nearest labor market area (if a majority of such workers are paid at a single rate). If there is no single rate paid to a majority, then the single or modal rate being paid to the greater number of workers is prevailing.
The DIR also states: “the prevailing wage rates are usually based on rates specified in collective bargaining agreements.” However, this bill ties the wage rate from one trade to another, which seems atypical. The sponsor responds that the tie to the linemen wage is needed because “the current tree trimmer wage rate is very low because of the nature of the workforce. As an immigrant, frequently undocumented workforce, it has been very hard to even get them to report injuries for fear of being fired. They cannot be organized to take collective job action and as a result, they have no bargaining power. Consequently, the existing contracts have very low wage rates. We would not want those low rates to become the sanctioned prevailing wage rate.”
Impacts to ratepayers. This bill requires an electric corporation to notify the CPUC of the date it projects it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management in its wildfire mitigation plan. Unlike a previous version, this bill no longer authorizes the electric utility to keep spending ratepayer funds after its authorized amount.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1054 (Holden, Chapter 79, Statutes of 2019) made numerous provisions related to addressing wildfires caused by electric utility infrastructure, including: bolstering safety oversight and processes, recasting recovery of costs from damages to third-parties, including the authorization for an electrical corporation and ratepayer jointly funded Wildfire Fund to address future damages, and changes to provisions concerning the workforce of a change of ownership of a full or portion of an electrical or gas corporation.
AB 111 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 81, Statutes of 2019) required, by January 1, 2020, the CPUC to establish the WSD within the CPUC and requires all functions of the WSD to be transferred to Office of Energy Infrastructure Safety, effective July 1, 2021.
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including funding for mutual aid, fuel reduction and forestry policies, wildfire mitigation plans by electric utilities, and cost recovery by electric corporations of wildfire-related damages.
SB 1028 (Hill, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016) required electric CPUC-regulated utilities to file annual wildfire mitigation plans and requires the CPUC to review and comment on those plans.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill assigns new responsibilities to Cal FIRE—to audit the work of each electrical corporation and report on that audit. Clearly, these new responsibilities entail new costs for Cal FIRE.
Cal FIRE, for its part, takes an expansive view of these new responsibilities. According to Cal FIRE, implementation of this bill would require 214 personnel years (PY) and cost $36.8 million in fiscal year 2020-21, $46.3 million in fiscal year 2021-22 and $44.7 million annually thereafter. Cal FIRE notes these costs would be reimbursed by the electrical corporations (ratepayers), presumably and after some time.
While this cost estimate is significant, it is important to place these costs in perspective. The annual revenue requirements of the state’s three largest electrical utilities total in the billions of dollars, collectively, and the Legislature authorized $165 million each year to Cal FIRE for healthy forest and fire prevention programs and projects that will improve forest health and reduce greenhouse gas emissions caused by uncontrolled wildfires, as well as $35 million to Cal FIRE annually to complete prescribed fire and other fuel reduction projects. If efforts required by this bill significantly reduce the risk of wildfire caused by utility equipment or improve utility safety, then it may be money well spent. If…
Coalition of California Utility Employees (source)
California Association of Professional Scientists
California State Association of Counties
County of San Bernardino
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “This bill ensures that an expert state agency, rather than a utility with a profit motive, decides what tree trimming should be done and verifies that the utility did it.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 9/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Frazier, Kiley
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U., & C. / (916) 651-4107
9/9/19 22:52:05
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 247
Author:(Dodd)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission's Wildfire Safety Division (CPUC) to audit vegetation management done by electrical corporations (IOUs) and establishes wage and qualification requirements for all individuals doing vegetation management for an IOU.
Major Provisions
- Requires the CPUC to audit vegetation management around electric lines after each IOU has completed a substantial portion of the work reflected in each IOU's wildfire mitigation plan (WMP), identify compliance failures by the IOU, and allow each IOU a reasonable time to address deficiencies identified in the audit.
- Directs the CPUC to issue a public report with the results of the audit within one year of the IOU's deadline to correct deficiencies, specifically describing any failure of an IOU to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements in its WMP.
- Requires that all individuals performing vegetation management for an IOU be qualified line clearance tree trimmers or trainees under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers as defined by the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR).
- Requires that all qualified line clearance tree trimmers be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman as determined by the Director of the DIR.
COMMENTS:
Historically, to avoid the constant interruptions in electric service that overgrown or fallen vegetation can cause, electric utilities have used various methods to control or remove vegetation in a safe and environmentally conscious manner. These are called rights-of-way vegetation management programs. The goal of these programs is to provide safe transmission and distribution services and to minimize disruptions caused by trees and other vegetation. Properly maintained rights-of-way are essential to providing safety for utility workers and customers. State vegetation and fire safety standards require clearances of four feet around power lines in high fire-threat areas with recommended minimum clearances of 12 feet or more at time of trim to ensure compliance year-round.
In response to the dramatically increasing wildfire threat the state faces, utilities are enhancing vegetation management practices to exceed state vegetation and fire safety standards in high fire-threat areas to prune overhanging branches and limbs directly above and around electric lines, and address specific tree species that have been involved in the majority of incidents of falling into electric lines and creating wildfire risk.
At this juncture, oversight of utility WMP implementation is of paramount concern. Although the CPUC recently approved the first round of annual WMPs per SB 901 (Dodd), Chapter626, Statutes of 2018, they report that there are currently no policies or standards in place on what a good WMP policy looks like. They also do not yet have an articulated long-term vision for how wildfire risk from utility infrastructure is going to be reduced over the long term, nor do they have boots on the ground investigators to inspect the IOU infrastructure and safety protocols. These policies and procedures are under development by the CPUC and funding was provided in the state budget along with the establishment of a new Wildfire Safety Division at the CPUC in AB 1054 (Holden).
Some utility vegetation management is done by utility employees but much of the work is contracted out to third parties. Aggressive vegetation management work has been triggered by the increasing threat of wildfires throughout the state and has exhausted the available workforce. Anecdotal reports are that companies are frantic for workers and are recruiting off the street and from states around the west. The author and sponsor report that this has resulted in the recruitment of anyone in the sight path of a tree contractor and lax oversight of safety training and practices. They additionally report that "because of the immigration status of many workers, many injuries go unreported and payment for this highly dangerous work is very low."
According to the Author:
Extreme weather has increased the number of catastrophic wildfires and the wildfire season length in California. California's most destructive wildfires burned in 2017 and 2018. According to CAL FIRE, 12 northern California wildfires in the October 2017 were caused by electric power and distribution lines, conductors and power poles. CAL FIRE cited trees or parts of trees falling onto power lines as specific causes of the fires.
To reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with the IOU's electric lines and equipment, the CPUC would audit each IOU's vegetation management work. The bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides whether the utility has done the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the risk of wildfires from contact with electric lines
Arguments in Support:
The Coalition of California Utility Employees writing in support of this bill opines that the current system of IOU vegetation management is "flawed and fails to reduce fire risk." They cite the need for someone other than the utility to determine whether the IOUs are doing the work needed to prevent fires. In support of the bill the California State Association of Counties states that "removing vegetation in contact with or nearby utility lines is effective in reducing potential ignitions. SB 247 would help improve current vegetation management near power lines; a critical element of protecting communities in or near fire prone areas.
Arguments in Opposition:
There is no reported opposition to the current version of this bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, based on a cost estimate provided by Calfire for a previous version of this bill, implementation of this bill by the Wildfire Safety Division would require 214 personnel years (PY) and cost $36.8 million in fiscal year 2020-21, $46.3 million in fiscal year 2021-22 and $44.7 million annually thereafter. These costs would be reimbursed by the electrical corporations (ratepayers) after some time.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Moorlach
ASM UTILITIES AND ENERGY: 14-0-1
YES: Holden, Patterson, Burke, Carrillo, Chen, Cunningham, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Mayes, Muratsuchi, Quirk, Reyes, Santiago, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Eduardo Garcia
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 11-0-0
YES: Friedman, Flora, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, Mathis, McCarty, Fong, Muratsuchi, Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kellie Smith / U. & E. / (916) 319-2083 FN: 0001753
Date of Hearing: August 21, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 247
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:August 12, 2019
Policy Committee: | Utilities and Energy | Vote: | 14 - 0 |
Natural Resources | 11 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (Calfire) to audit the work of each electrical corporation to implement its vegetation management plan as approved by the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) in the electrical corporation’s wildfire mitigation plan and to specify any failure to comply with the plan. The bill also requires Calfire, after time to allow the electrical corporation to correct and eliminate any deficiencies and no less than annually, to issue a report to the electrical corporation and the CPUC specifying any failure to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements of the wildlife mitigation plan.
The bill also requires all electrical line clearance tree trimmers be qualified for the position or trainees under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers, as specified, and that all qualified line clearance tree trimmers be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate.
Finally, the bill requires each electrical corporation to notify the CPUC by advice letter no less than 30 days prior to the time it projects it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill assigns new responsibilities to Calfire—to audit the work of each electrical corporation and report on that audit. Clearly, these new responsibilities entail new costs for Calfire.
Calfire, for its part, takes an expansive view of these new responsibilities. According to Calfire, implementation of this bill would require 214 personnel years (PY) and cost $36.8 million in fiscal year 2020-21, $46.3 million in fiscal year 2021-22 and $44.7 million annually thereafter. Calfire notes these costs would be reimbursed by the electrical corporations (ratepayers), presumably and after some time.
While this cost estimate is significant, it is important to place these costs in perspective. The annual revenue requirements of the state’s three largest electrical utilities total in the billions of dollars, collectively, and the Legislature authorized $165 million each year to Calfire for healthy forest and fire prevention programs and projects that will improve forest health and reduce greenhouse gas emissions caused by uncontrolled wildfires, as well as $35 million to Calfire annually to complete prescribed fire and other fuel reduction projects. If efforts required by this bill significantly reduce the risk of wildfire caused by utility equipment or improve utility safety, then it may be money well spent. If…
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Adequate vegetation management is critical to reducing the risk of trees and brush contacting electric lines and equipment. Part of CAL FIRE’s mission is to prevent fires…CAL FIRE is uniquely situated to ensure that the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with electric lines and equipment is sufficiently implemented…The bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides whether the utility has done the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the risk of wildfires from contact with electric lines.
- Background. Existing statute addresses electrical utility wildfire risk in several ways. Generally, the law requires each electrical utility to construct, maintain and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire. Statute also specifies minimum vegetation clearance requirements for electrical equipment located in State Responsibility Areas (SRAs), that is, areas of the state where Calfire is the primary emergency response agency responsible for fire suppression and prevention. The law also requires each private electrical utility to annually submit a wildfire mitigation plan to the CPUC for review and approval, and that the plan must include information on the utility’s plans for vegetation management. Finally, the law also requires the CPUC and Calfire to formally cooperate on data sharing related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management and energy distribution systems, as well as fire ignition investigations.
Following the recent, horrific fire seasons, the electrical utilities are proposing, in their wildfire mitigation plans, and undertaking enhanced vegetation management activities. While the CPUC must review and approve the plans, there is concern no entity is ensuring the utilities are completing the work as they should. There is also concern that the increased demand for tree trimmers is leading to unqualified individuals conducting the dangerous and environmentally sensitive work.
This bill tasks Calfire—the state’s firefighting and fire prevention agency—with auditing the vegetation management work of the electrical utilities. And it specifies qualifications of those conducting tree trimming work. Both proposals seem reasonable, though the cost of implementation may be substantial.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 247
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:July 2, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation management
SUMMARY: Requires, on January 1, 2021, the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) to audit an Investor Owned Utility’s (IOU) work to complete the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan (WMP).
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, except as specified, any person that owns, controls, operates, or maintains any electrical transmission or distribution line in the State Responsibility Area (SRA) to maintain around and adjacent to any pole or tower that supports a switch, fuse, transformer, lightning arrester, line junction, or dead end or corner pole, a firebreak that consists of a clearing of not less than 10 feet in each direction from the outer circumference of such pole or tower.
- Requires any person that owns, controls, operates, or maintains any electrical transmission or distribution line in the SRA to maintain a clearance in all directions between all vegetation and all conductors as follows:
- For any line which is operating at 2,400 or more volts, but less than 72,000 volts, four feet;
- For any line which is operating at 72,000 or more volts, but less than 110,000 volts, six feet; and,
- For any line which is operating at 110,000 or more volts, 10 feet.
- For any line which is operating at 2,400 or more volts, but less than 72,000 volts, four feet;
- Requires dead trees, old decadent or rotten trees, trees weakened by decay or disease, and trees or portions thereof that are leaning toward the line that may contact the line from the side or may fall on the line to be felled, cut, or trimmed to remove the hazard.
- Authorizes owners of any electrical transmission or distribution line to traverse land as necessary, regardless of land ownership or permission from the owner, after providing notice and an opportunity to be heard to the land owner, to prune trees to maintain and to abate, by pruning or removal, any hazardous, dead, rotten, diseased, or structurally defective live trees.
- Declares the Legislature intends that the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) and CAL FIRE encourage the use of the concept "right tree right place" to reduce the need for utility vegetation management.
- Requires IOUs to construct, maintain, and operate their electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment and annually prepare and submit WMPs to the CPUC for review and approval. Requires CAL FIRE to consult with the CPUC on the review of WMPs.
- Requires each IOU WMP to specifically include plans for vegetation management.
- Requires the CPUC and CAL FIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data.
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable.
- Defines “qualified line clearance tree trimmer” as a person who has completed a minimum of 18 months of related training and on-the-job experience and is familiar with the special techniques and hazards involved in line clearance tree trimming operations.
- Defines “qualified line clearance tree trimmer trainee” as any worker regularly assigned to a line clearance tree trimming crew and undergoing on-the-job training who, in the course of such training, has demonstrated the ability to perform the assigned duties safely at that level of training.
THIS BILL:
- Effective January 1, 2021, requires:
- CAL FIRE to audit vegetation management done by IOUs as required in WMPs and to report IOU compliance failures to the IOU, which would have a reasonable time to address deficiencies identified in the audit.
- CAL FIRE to issue a report to the CPUC when audits are complete, but no less than annually, specifically describing any failure of an IOU to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements in its WMP.
- All individuals performing vegetation management to be qualified line clearance tree trimmers or trainees under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers as defined by the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR).
- All qualified line clearance tree trimmers to be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman as determined by the Director of the DIR.
- IOUs to notify the CPUC 30 days prior to the time when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management.
- Requires each IOU to reimburse CAL FIRE for its cost to carry out the requirements of this bill with respect to that IOU’s lines and other exposed energized overheard conductors and equipment.
- CAL FIRE to audit vegetation management done by IOUs as required in WMPs and to report IOU compliance failures to the IOU, which would have a reasonable time to address deficiencies identified in the audit.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, ongoing special fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars for CAL FIRE to oversee the vegetation management of IOUs, and ongoing special fund costs (CPUC Utilities Reimbursement Account) of around $500,000 annually for the CPUC to establish and oversee a two-way balancing account.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
Extreme weather has increased the number of catastrophic wildfires and the wildfire season length in California. California’s most destructive wildfires burned in 2017 and 2018. According to CAL FIRE, 12 northern California wildfires in October 2017 were caused by electric power and distribution lines, conductors and power poles. CAL FIRE cited trees or parts of trees falling onto power lines as specific causes of the fires. Adequate vegetation management is critical to reducing the risk of trees and brush contacting electric lines and equipment.
Part of CAL FIRE’s mission is to prevent fires. CAL FIRE’s fire prevention program includes wildland pre-fire engineering, vegetation management, fire planning, education, and law enforcement. CAL FIRE commonly conducts fire brush clearance and defensible space inspections to lessen the risk of wildfire to communities. CAL FIRE is uniquely situated to ensure that the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with electric lines and equipment is sufficiently implemented.
To reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with the IOU’s electric lines and equipment, CAL FIRE would audit each IOU’s vegetation management work. The bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides whether the utility has done the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the risk of wildfires from contact with electric lines.
- Background. In recent years, there has been an increase in the number of large and damaging wildfires caused by utility-owned lines and electric infrastructure. According to the Los Angeles Times, equipment owned by California’s three largest utilities ignited more than 2,000 fires in three and a half years. The common cause of utility ignitions is electrical lines making contact with vegetation and other line malfunctions that cause sparking. Over the last five years power lines accounted for 9% of wildfire ignitions, but 21% of the acreage burned. Four of the state’s 20 largest wildfire and seven of the state’s 20 most destructive wildfires were caused by power lines. In 2017, over 1.3 million acres burned in high-severity wildfires and over 10,000 structures were destroyed. In 2018, over 1.8 million acres burned and over 22,700 structures were destroyed. Over one hundred Californians have died from wildfires over the last two years. CAL FIRE keeps records of the largest and most destructive wildfires in the state’s history. Each year those records continue to be broken.
Fire has always been present in California landscapes either occurring by lightning strikes or used by Native American tribes to preserve certain useful plants and prevent larger fires. Low-intensity fires have clear ecological benefits, such as creating habitat and assisting in the regeneration of certain species of plants and trees. Low-intensity fire also reduces surface fuel, which decreases future wildfire intensity.
A century of suppressing low-intensity fires, logging of older growth and more fire-resistant trees, and a significant five-year drought has increased the size and severity of California’s fires. Climate change has also contributed to wildfire risk by reducing humidity and precipitation and increasing temperatures.
California’s forests have become overstocked and unhealthy. In the Stanislaus National Forest, a team of UC Berkeley researchers found a density of 400 trees per acre in 2013, compared with 60-90 trees per acre found in historical reports from 1911. In addition, the researchers found more undergrowth species, and a smaller average tree size than in 1911. From 2014 to 2018 over 147 million trees have died due to a combination of drought and bark beetles. New research by UC Berkeley states “these dead trees have created unprecedented levels of fuel, which could create dangerous wildfires in the near future that are beyond the predictive capacity of current fire models.”
The use of targeted mechanical vegetation management, prescribed fire, and managed wildfire reduces the accumulated high fuel loads, promoting healthier, more resilient forests, reducing the risk of high-severity wildfires.
SB 901 (Dodd), Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018, committed $1 billion for CAL FIRE’s Forest Health Grant Program and Fire Prevention Grant Program and dedicated fuel reduction crews over the next five years. The funds will be used to do significant fuel reduction work near communities and in forested watersheds, and many projects will include a biomass utilization component.
- Utility vegetation management. While high winds can send vegetation into utility lines from far distances, removing vegetation in contact with utility lines has been found effective in reducing fire starts. There are various Public Resources Code (PRC) sections requiring specified utility line vegetation management for poles and lines in the SRA. These requirements have been in place since 1976. CAL FIRE is required to enforce these requirements and has found utilities responsible for wildfire fires because of violations of these requirements. The CPUC’s General Order 95, rule 35 also places requirements on investor-owned utilities for vegetation management.
SB 1028 (Hill), Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016, required IOUs to annually prepare a WMP to the CPUC for review. In August 2017, CAL FIRE and the CPUC entered into a memorandum of understanding (MOU) to, among other things, create an interagency Fire Safety Working Group and improve enforcement and coordination on vegetation management activities. Part of that MOU stipulated that the CPUC reimburse CAL FIRE for one temporary position to assist the CPUC in reviewing WMPs. SB 901 amended the WMP requirement to add additional requirements including requiring CAL FIRE to consult on the review of each WMP.
According to the CPUC’s guidance on WMPs:
Generally speaking, the key and most costly aspects of the individual Wildfire Mitigation Plans consist of vegetation management; system hardening such as widespread electric line replacement with covered conductors designed to lower wildfire ignitions; new inspection programs; and “situational awareness” technology such as weather stations, high definition cameras, and use of computer modeling, weather and wind data and machine learning to predict where wildfires are most likely to strike. The individual Wildfire Mitigation Plan decisions focus on these issues because they are the ones on which parties provided the most input.
The Governor’s Budget included one person to evaluate the impacts and effectiveness of the WMPs. There was also a spring finance letter to provide CAL FIRE with $816,000 and two positions to review WMPs. This proposal was rejected. This bill would provide additional responsibilities to conduct an audit of the vegetation management requirements of a WMP. A utility’s vegetation management program outlining the ongoing activities related to tree inspection, pruning, and removal, and weed abatement in proximity to their distribution and transmission lines. CAL FIRE’s audit could determine whether the IOU is actually adhering to its own plan. Depending on whether this includes verification of the hundreds of thousands of trees inspected and trimmed, a spot check, or a financial audit of the work performed, it may require a significant increase in the inspectors at CAL FIRE. Currently, CAL FIRE is unable to meet its own goals for defensible space inspections. This is due, in part, to the use of personnel to conduct inspections that are also required to respond to wildfires.
- Personnel. Tree work includes the inspection and assessment of the vegetation and the trimming, pruning, felling, and removal of trees, shrubs and bushes. It involves climbing trees, using portable ladders, working at heights while using hand and portable power tools, working near energized overhead or downed power lines, feeding chippers, and other hazardous operations. Accidents related to tree work can result in severe traumatic injuries and deaths. Commonly reported accidents include falls, electrocutions, and those caused by falling objects. Most accidents can be prevented by recognizing and controlling hazards in advance, as well as training employees on safe work practices and effective use of personal protective equipment.
There does not appear to be regulated instruction or certification to become a tree trimmer. According to the DIR, “a qualified tree trimmer is an employee who, through related training and on-the-job experience, has demonstrated familiarity with the techniques and hazards involved in tree maintenance, and removal, and use of special equipment.” The agency does have safety standards for tree work, maintenance and removal, and also requires employers to implement an injury and illness prevention program. Employees are required to be trained and instructed in several areas including the hazards of the job, proper and safe use of all equipment, and the recognition and avoidance of electrical hazards.
The employer must document training to certify that the employee has satisfactorily completed the training program prior to performing the job assignment without the oversight and observation of a qualified person. The sponsor of this bill reports that trainees generally begin work on day three with the first two days in basic personnel and orientation activity.
The author reports that since 2013, more than 1,400 people have been killed performing this work in the United States, and many more have been injured.
Some utility vegetation management is done by utility employees, but much of the work is contracted out to third parties. Aggressive vegetation management work has been triggered by the increasing threat of wildfires throughout the state and has exhausted the available workforce. Anecdotal reports are that companies are frantic for workers and are recruiting off the street and from states around the west. The author and sponsor report that this has resulted in the recruitment of anyone in the sight path of a tree contractor and lax oversight of safety training and practices. They additionally report that “because of the immigration status of many workers, many injuries go unreported and payment for this highly dangerous work is very low.”
SB 247 requires specified qualifications, training, and wages for electrical line clearance tree trimmers. Tree inspections and assessments including deciding whether to exceed the CPUC’s recommended clearance guidelines are often done by certified arborists. Arborists can be certified by the International Society of Arboriculture (ISA). ISA has a specific certified utility specialist credential that demonstrates particular knowledge and experience in the field of electric utility vegetation management. According to the Utility Arborist Association, “Utility vegetation management is necessary because the wrong plant is growing in the wrong place. Trees that can grow to 80 feet are not compatible with power lines 25 feet above the ground. A smaller growing tree, however, could be grown under a distribution line for its entire life and never have to be pruned.” Embracing the concept of right tree, right place would help IOUs reduce the amount of tree trimming work needed, reducing costs and worker shortages.
- Amendment. The author and committee may wish to consider amending the bill to clarify that all of CAL FIRE’s costs to carry out the audit will be reimbursed by each IOU.
- Double referral. This bill was also referred to the Assembly Energy and Utility Committee where it passed out with a 14-0 vote.
- Related legislation.
AB 1054 (Holden) is the Governor’s proposal to establish a California Catastrophe Council, establish a Wildfire Safety Division within the CPUC, establish a California Wildfire Safety Advisory Board to advise the Division, modify the process for determining whether an IOU can recover its cost and expenses for arising from a wildfire, and establish a Wildfire Fund to address liability from utility-ignited wildfires. This bill was heard in Senate Energy, Utilities, and Communications Committee on July 5, 2019.
AB 1516 (Friedman) makes various changes to improve defensible space requirements, electrical transmission or distribution lines' vegetation clearance requirements, and the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) local government technical assistance requirements with the intent to improve the fire safety of California communities. This bill is awaiting hearing in the Senate Energy, Utilities, and Communications Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Professional Scientists
California State Association of Counties
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Opposition
None in file
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Jarred / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON UTILITIES AND ENERGY
Chris Holden, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 247
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:June 12, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation management
SUMMARY: Addresses issues related to vegetation management by electrical corporations (IOUs) to mitigate wildfire risks associated with electrical lines and vegetation. Specifically, this bill:
- Effective January 1, 2021, requires:
- The Department of Fire and Forestry and Fire Protection (CAL FIRE) to audit vegetation management done by IOUs as required in wildfire mitigation plans (WMPs) and to report IOU compliance failures to the IOU which would have a reasonable time to address deficiencies identified in the audit.
- CAL FIRE to issue a report to the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) when audits are complete, but no less than annually, specifically describing any failure of an IOU to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements in its WMP.
- All individuals performing vegetation management to be qualified line clearance tree trimmers or trainees under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers as defined by the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR).
- All qualified line clearance tree trimmers to be paid no less than the prevailing wage rate for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman as determined by the Director of the DIR.
- IOUs to notify the CPUC 30 days prior to the time when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management.
- Requires the CPUC to establish a two-way balancing account for each IOU to track all costs incurred by an IOU for vegetation management.
- Prohibits an IOU from diverting any funds from vegetation management and from earning a rate of return for costs incurred for vegetation management.
- Mandates that the CPUC authorize IOU cost recovery for all reasonable vegetation management activity.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires IOUs to construct, maintain, and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment and annually prepare and submit a wildfire mitigation plans (WMPs) to the CPUC for review and approval (Public Utilities Code § 8386)
- Requires each IOU WMP to specifically include plans for vegetation management. (Public Utilities Code § 8386 [c][7])
- Requires the CPUC and CAL FIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data. (Public Utilities Code § 8386.5)
- Requires electrical transmission or distribution line owners in the State Responsibility Area (SRA) to maintain around and adjacent to any pole or tower which supports a switch, fuse, transformer, lightning arrester, line junction, or dead end or corner pole, a firebreak which consists of a clearing of not less than 10 feet in each direction from the outer circumference of such pole or tower. (Public Resources Code § 4292)
- Requires electrical transmission or distribution line owners in the SRA to maintain clearances in all directions between all vegetation and all conductors of varying voltages as specified. (Public Resources Code § 4293)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities Code § 451)
- Defines “qualified line clearance tree trimmer” as a person who has completed a minimum of 18 months of related training and on-the-job experience and is familiar with the special techniques and hazards involved in line clearance tree trimming operations. (Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 8 § 2700)
- Defines “qualified line clearance tree trimmer trainee” as any worker regularly assigned to a line clearance tree trimming crew and undergoing on-the-job training who, in the course of such training, has demonstrated the ability to perform the assigned duties safely at that level of training. (Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 8 § 2700)
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, ongoing special fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars for CAL Fire to oversee the vegetation management of IOUs, and ongoing special fund costs (CPUC Utilities Reimbursement Account) of around $500,000 annually for the CPUC to establish and oversee a two-way balancing account.
BACKGROUND:
Vegetation Management and Electric Utilities – Historically, to avoid the constant interruptions in electric service that overgrown or fallen vegetation can cause, electric utilities have used various methods to control or remove vegetation in a safe and environmentally conscious manner. These are called rights-of-way vegetation management programs. The goal of these programs is to provide safe transmission and distribution services and to minimize disruptions caused by trees and other vegetation. Properly maintained rights-of-way are essential to providing safety for utility workers and customers. State vegetation and fire safety standards require clearances of 4 feet around power lines in high fire-threat areas with recommended minimum clearances of 12 feet or more at time of trim to ensure compliance year-round.
In response to the dramatically increasing wildfire threat the state faces, utilities are enhancing vegetation management practices to exceed state vegetation and fire safety standards in high fire-threat areas to prune overhanging branches and limbs directly above and around power lines, and address specific tree species that have been involved in the majority of incidents of falling into power lines and creating wildfire risk.
Cost Recovery for Vegetation Management – Electric utilities generally receive authorization for funding for vegetation management in their general rate cases (GRCs) with new authorization every three years. The GRCs approve spending for broad categories of funding and occasionally for specific projects. Generally, spending for vegetation management is tracked in a one-way balancing account, which means that if the utility does not spend all the authorized funds, the unused funds are returned to ratepayers and the utility is not authorized to spend more than what has been budgeted. Additionally, utilities are generally prohibited from diverting funds to other spending areas or to profits. As required by Public Utilities Code Section 451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for recovery of costs that is deemed “just and reasonable.” The review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the primary purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator.
Balancing Accounts – Balancing accounts are approved by the CPUC and established by utilities to serve various ratemaking purposes. The primary purpose of balancing accounts is to ensure that a utility recovers its CPUC authorized revenue requirement from ratepayers for a given program or function, but no more or less. Since rates are always forward-looking and based on forecasted sales, actual collections by the utility from ratepayers can be more or less than what the CPUC had authorized it to collect. A balancing account tracks actual sales and reconciles actual revenues against authorized revenues. These accounts record the surplus or deficit amount to be applied to a future collection period. To ensure the utility spends a certain authorized amount on specified activities, one- or two-way balancing accounts are established. A one-way cost balancing account ensures that if a utility spends less on a particular program than the amount authorized, it credits the remaining budget back to ratepayers. Two-way balancing accounts authorize a utility to collect more or less than the authorized revenue requirement for a given program depending on actual costs, and are intended to ensure that the utility does not make or lose money due to uncertainties in the scope of work. The net balance in a balancing account is typically recovered from or refunded to ratepayers on an annual basis, but in some cases, the amortization of the balance may be more frequent. A two-way balancing account is often used for ongoing expenses as it allows for spending beyond what was budgeted.
Tree Trimming Work – Tree work includes trimming, pruning, felling, and removal of trees and bushes. It involves climbing trees, using portable ladders, working at heights while using hand and portable power tools, working near energized overhead or downed power lines, feeding chippers, and other hazardous operations. Accidents related to tree work can result in severe traumatic injuries and deaths. Commonly reported accidents include falls, electrocutions, and those caused by falling objects. Most accidents can be prevented by recognizing and controlling hazards in advance as well as training employees on safe work practices and effective use of personal protective equipment.
There does not appear to be regulated instruction or certification to become a tree trimmer. According to the DIR “a qualified tree trimmer is an employee who, through related training and on-the-job experience, has demonstrated familiarity with the techniques and hazards involved in tree maintenance, and removal, and use of special equipment.” The agency does have safety standards for tree work, maintenance and removal, and also requires employers to implement an injury and illness prevention program. Employees are required to be trained and instructed in several areas including the hazards of the job, proper and safe use of all equipment, and the recognition and avoidance of electrical hazards.
The employer must document training to certify that the employee has satisfactorily completed the training program prior to performing the job assignment without the oversight and observation of a qualified person. The sponsor of this bill reports that trainees generally begin work on day three with the first two days in basic personnel and orientation activity.
The author reports that since 2013, more than 1,400 people have been killed performing this work in the United States, and many more have been injured.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement. Extreme weather has increased the number of catastrophic wildfires and the wildfire season length in California. California’s most destructive wildfires burned in 2017 and 2018. According to CAL FIRE, 12 northern California wildfires in the October 2017 were caused by electric power and distribution lines, conductors and power poles. CAL FIRE cited trees or parts of trees falling onto power lines as specific causes of the fires. Adequate vegetation management is critical to reducing the risk of trees and brush contacting electric lines and equipment.
Part of CAL FIRE’s mission is to prevent fires. CAL FIRE’s fire prevention program includes wildland pre-fire engineering, vegetation management, fire planning, education and law enforcement. CAL FIRE commonly conducts fire brush clearance and defensible space inspections to lessen the risk of wildfire to communities. CAL FIRE is uniquely situated to ensure that the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with electric lines and equipment is sufficiently implemented.
To reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with the IOU’s electric lines and equipment, CAL FIRE would audit each IOU’s vegetation management work. The bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides whether the utility has done the vegetation management work necessary to reduce the risk of wildfires from contact with electric lines.
- Workforce Constraints. Some utility vegetation management is done by utility employees but much of the work is contracted out to third parties. Aggressive vegetation management work has been triggered by the increasing threat of wildfires throughout the state and has exhausted the available workforce. Anecdotal reports are that companies are frantic for workers and are recruiting off the street and from states around the west. The author and sponsor report that this has resulted in the recruitment of anyone in the sight path of a tree contractor and lax oversight of safety training and practices. They additionally report that “because of the immigration status of many workers, many injuries go unreported and payment for this highly dangerous work is very low.”
- Prevailing Wage Calculation. According to the DIR, the:
prevailing wage rate is the basic hourly rate paid on public works projects to a majority of workers engaged in a particular craft, classification or type of work within the locality and in the nearest labor market area (if a majority of such workers are paid at a single rate). If there is no single rate paid to a majority, then the single or modal rate being paid to the greater number of workers is prevailing.
The prevailing wage rates are historically determined by the DIR through surveys of actual wages in the field. This bill bypasses the survey and ties tree trimmer wages to the wages of a “first period apprentice electrical utility lineman.” This is atypical and there is no information as to the whether the position responsibilities and qualifications of the two positions are comparable. Proper wage for the work has long been valued. But mandating that one trade be tied to another when they have different skills and training requirements appears to be without precedent.
The sponsor responds that the tie to the linemen wage is needed because “the current tree trimmer wage rate is very low because of the nature of the workforce. As an immigrant, frequently undocumented workforce, it has been very hard to even get them to report injuries for fear of being fired. They cannot be organized to take collective job action and as a result, they have no bargaining power. Consequently, the existing contracts have very low wage rates. We would not want those low rates to become the sanctioned prevailing wage rate.”
- Regulatory Oversight Lacking. This bill requires CAL FIRE to audit IOU work on vegetation management to ensure that the utility has fully “complied with the vegetation management requirements in the wildfire mitigation plan.”
At this juncture, oversight of utility WMP development and implementation is of paramount concern. Although the CPUC recently approved the first round of annual WMPs per SB 901, they report that there are currently no policies or standards in place on what a good WMP policy looks like. They also do not yet have an articulated long-term vision for how wildfire risk from utility infrastructure is going to be reduced over the long term, nor do they have boots on the ground investigators to inspect the IOU infrastructure and safety protocols. But these policies and procedures are under development and funding is pending in the state budget.
The electrical infrastructure of the IOUs run through local responsibility areas, state responsibility areas, and federal lands. The audit required by this bill would be limited to state responsibility areas which are within the jurisdiction of CAL FIRE. CAL FIRE also has a constrained workforce. As an example, a recent editorial of the San Diego Union Tribune reported that the agency had inspected just 12% of the properties in Sonoma, Napa and Lake counties for defensible space requirements. CAL FIRE didn’t come close to meeting its goal of inspecting 33% of homes every year.
This bill cherry picks one element of IOU wildfire mitigation work for audit in one specific geographic area of the state – only vegetation management done by the IOUs in the state responsibility areas – therefore bypassing local and federal lands where utility infrastructure passes and the infrastructure of all local publicly owned utilities (POU). Lacking is a comprehensive approach to oversight of the implementation of IOU wildfire mitigation plans or POU plans.
The Legislature should consider a comprehensive approach to checking the wildfire mitigation work of the IOUs and POUs. Pulling out one activity, for a subset of utilities, in one geographic area, does not seem efficient or thorough.
- Legislative Ratemaking. The Public Utilities Code provides the CPUC with full and complete authority to provide cost recovery to the regulated utilities, or not, if it finds costs to be just and reasonable. This bill adds language that mandates cost recovery in rates if the CPUC finds the costs reasonable, mandates the establishment of two-way tracking accounts by the IOU, and prohibits a utility from earning a rate of return on vegetation management work. These provisions could be construed as changing the CPUC’s current ratemaking authority, particularly whether the costs incurred by the utility are just and reasonable, and fall into the category of legislative ratemaking which has been historically avoided. The committee may wish to consider amending the bill to strike the mandatory cost recovery and two-way balancing account.
- Double Referral. This bill has been double-referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
- Related Legislation.
SB 901 (Dodd) Establishes a comprehensive framework to address and prevent catastrophic wildfires including prevention and planning by the state's electric utilities, management of the state's forests, chaparrals, and other lands to prevent and defend against wildfires, and standards to stabilize IOUs in the event of extensive liability resulting from claims under inverse condemnation. Status: Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018.
SB 1028 (Hill) Requires IOUs to file annual wildfire mitigation plans and requires the CPUC to review and comment on those plans. Also required POUs and electrical co-ops to determine their risk of catastrophic wildfire that can be caused by their electric lines and equipment and, if a risk exists, submit wildfire mitigation plans to their governing board for approval. Status: Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State Association of Counties
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Kellie Smith / U. & E. /
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 247 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 247
Amended: 4/29/19
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 11-1, 4/10/19
AYES: Hueso, Bradford, Chang, Dodd, Hertzberg, Hill, McGuire, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Wiener
NOES: Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/23/19
AYES: Stern, Jones, Allen, Borgeas, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation: management
SOURCE: Coalition of California Utility Employees
DIGEST:
This bill proposes several changes related to the vegetation management requirements of electrical corporations, including: (1) require the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (Cal FIRE) to audit the vegetation management of electrical corporations; (2) require specified training and qualifications for workforce conducting vegetation management; and (3) require that all costs associated with the electrical corporation’s vegetation management are recovered from ratepayers through a two-way balancing account.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Cal FIRE is responsible for fire protection in state responsibility areas, as well as the administration of the state's private and public forests. (Public Resources Code §700 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. (California Constitution, Article 12, §§3 and 4)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities §451)
- Requires each electrical corporation, local publicly owned electric utility, and electrical cooperative to construct, maintain, and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment. Requires each electrical corporation to annually prepare a wildfire mitigation plan and to submit its plan to the commission for review and approval, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §8386)
- Requires the CPUC and Cal FIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding (MOU) to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data. (Public Utilities Code §8386.5)
This bill:
- Requires an electrical corporation to notify Cal FIRE after it has completed all or a substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan approved by the CPUC. Requires Cal FIRE to audit the work performed by, or on behalf of, the electrical corporation.
- Requires Cal FIRE to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements and requires the electrical corporation to correct and eliminate any deficiency in the audit.
- Requires Cal FIRE to issue a report to the CPUC and the electrical corporation describing failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements.
- Requires specified qualifications and prevailing wages for all electrical line clearance tree trimmers performing work to comply with the vegetation management requirements in an electrical corporation’s wildfire mitigation plan.
- Requires an electrical corporation to notify the CPUC by advice letter not less than 30 days prior to the time when it projects that it will have spent, or incurred obligations to spend, its entire annual revenue requirement for vegetation management.
- Requires each electrical corporation to reimburse the Cal FIRE for its cost to carry out these functions with respect to that electrical corporation’s electrical lines and other exposed energized overhead conductors and equipment.
- Requires the CPUC to establish a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation for all costs incurred by the electrical corporation for vegetation management, prohibits the electrical corporation from diverting any revenue from the account to any activity other than vegetation management, and prohibits the electrical corporation from earning any profit on any revenue from the account.
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that an electrical corporation fully recovers all costs incurred to comply with the trim list requirements that would be adopted pursuant to this bill and all other reasonable vegetation management activity.
Background
Vegetation management and electric utilities. Electric utility companies trim and remove trees near high voltage power lines for public safety, fire prevention, and electric reliability. There are a number of laws and regulations governing vegetation management, including: California Public Resources Code Sections: 4293 Power Line Clearance Required; 4292 Power Line Hazard Reduction; 4291 Reduction of Fire Hazards around Buildings; and 4171 Public Nuisances. Additionally, there are a number of CPUC orders and California Code of Regulations, including General Order 95, California Code of Regulations Title 14, and others. Additionally, federal reliability rules require specified clearances between vegetation and transmission lines.
CPUC and Cal FIRE MOU. The CPUC has a MOU with the Cal FIRE, and has long worked with Cal FIRE on improving wildfire mitigation. Per statute, electric utilities must file wildfire mitigation plans with specified information. Investor-owned electric utilities have been required to develop wildfire mitigation plans since 2017, per SB 1028 (Hill, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016). SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) modified those existing requirements in a number of ways, including requiring a more nuanced and detailed list of information that the utilities must provide in their plans. In addition, the CPUC will review the plans, modify the plans when necessary, and eventually adopt plans. Statute also requires the CPUC to pursue enforcement actions for non-compliance with the plans.
Cost recovery for vegetation management. Electric utilities generally receive authorization for funding for vegetation management in their general rate cases (GRCs) with new authorization every three years. The GRCs approve spending for broad categories of funding and occasionally for specific projects. Generally, spending for vegetation management is tracked in a one-way balancing account, which means that if the utility does not spend all the authorized funds, the unused funds are returned to ratepayers and the utility is not authorized to spend more than what has been budgeted. Additionally, utilities are generally prohibited from diverting funds to other spending areas or to profits. As required by statute in Public Utilities Code Section 451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for recovery of costs that is deemed “just and reasonable.” The review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the primary purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator.
Balancing accounts. Balancing accounts are approved by the CPUC and established by utilities to serve various ratemaking purposes. The primary purpose of balancing accounts is to ensure that a utility recovers its CPUC authorized revenue requirement from ratepayers for a given program or function, but no more or less. Since rates are always forward-looking and based on forecasted sales, actual collections by the utility from ratepayers can be more or less than what the CPUC had authorized it to collect. A balancing account tracks actual sales and reconciles actual revenues against authorized revenues. These accounts record the surplus or deficit amount to be applied to a future collection period. To ensure the utility spends a certain authorized amount on specified activities, one- or two-way balancing accounts are established. A one-way cost balancing account ensures that if a utility spends less on a particular program than the amount authorized, it credits the remaining budget back to ratepayers. Two-way balancing accounts authorize a utility to collect more or less than the authorized revenue requirement for a given program depending on actual costs, and are intended to ensure that the utility does not make or lose money due to uncertainties in the scope of work. The net balance in a balancing account is typically recovered from or refunded to ratepayers on an annual basis, but in some cases, the amortization of the balance may be more frequent. A two-way balancing account is often used for ongoing expenses as it allows for spending beyond what was budgeted.
Comments
SB 247. This bill expands Cal FIRE’s role and responsibilities to oversee vegetation management by electric investor-owned utilities. These new responsibilities would include auditing of the utility’s vegetation management. This bill also establishes specified requirements and certification needed of workers conducting related tree trimming and vegetation management. Lastly, this bill requires a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation’s vegetation management costs to allow for spending beyond what was budgeted by the utility.
CPUC v. Cal FIRE? As noted above, Cal FIRE and the CPUC currently have an existing MOU for wildfire mitigation-related activities. However, the scope of auditing that may be required by this bill could result in needing additional resources for either agency. Generally, the CPUC has an auditing function of utilities, but does not necessarily inspect electric lines directly and does not currently have the staff or resources to conduct these inspections. Cal FIRE also may lack some of the human or capital resources to undertake utility vegetation management inspections and tree trimming work. Cal FIRE also provides a significant portion of the utilities’ power lines and related equipment is not in a state responsibility area, which is where Cal FIRE’s statutory responsibilities are focused. In the recently released Budget Revision, the Governor has proposed significant funding for the CPUC to increase its oversight of the electric IOU’s wildfire mitigation plans ($41 million), including a proposal to have a “swat team” of inspectors. The debate as to whether CPUC or Cal FIRE should handle these responsibilities is one that may not be fully resolved.
Trained workforce? The requirements for the qualifications of the workers conducting the vegetation management as proposed in this bill could result in reduced ability by the utility to address all its vegetation management needs. The sponsor of the bill notes the work is dangerous where injuries and deaths happen far too often and necessitate the need for the specified trained workforce. The sponsor, Coalition of California Utility Employees, notes that some of the existing workforce may not report injuries due to their immigration status.
Impacts to ratepayers. Lastly, the requirement for a two-way balancing account could result in substantial increased costs to ratepayers as the utility could spend beyond what it has budgeted for vegetation management. The sponsor of this bill believes that the need to ensure the utility is adequately addressing its wildfire risk merits the need for a two-way balancing account, instead of a one-way account that would cap the amount to what the utility has budgeted.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including funding for mutual aid, fuel reduction and forestry policies, wildfire mitigation plans by electric utilities, and cost recovery by electric corporations of wildfire-related damages.
SB 1028 (Hill, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016) required electric CPUC-regulated utilities to file annual wildfire mitigation plans and requires the CPUC to review and comment on those plans.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Ongoing special fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars for Cal FIRE to oversee the vegetation management of electrical corporations.
- Ongoing special fund costs (PUC Utilities Reimbursement Account) of around $500,000 annually for CPUC to establish and oversee a two-way balancing account.
Coalition of California Utility Employees (source)
California State Association of Counties
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Part of Cal Fire’s mission is to prevent fires. Cal Fire’s fire prevention program includes wildland pre-fire engineering, vegetation management, fire planning, education and law enforcement. This bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides what tree trimming should be done and verifies that the utility did it.”
Prepared by: Nidia Bautista / E., U., & C. / (916) 651-4107
5/18/19 11:57:49
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 247 (Dodd) - Wildland fire prevention: vegetation management
Version: April 29, 2019 | Policy Vote: E., U., & C. 11 - 1, N.R. & W. 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Paul Jacobs |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFire) to oversee the vegetation management of electrical corporations. This bill also requires that all costs associated with the electrical corporation’s vegetation management are recovered from ratepayers through a specified mechanism called a two-way balancing account.
Fiscal Impact:
- Ongoing special fund costs in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars for CalFire to oversee the vegetation management of electrical corporations.
- Ongoing special fund costs (PUC Utilities Reimbursement Account) of around $500,000 annually for CPUC to establish and oversee a two-way balancing account.
Background:
CPUC-regulated utilities routinely submit requests for recovery of costs related to their operations, including expanding their infrastructure, paying for operation expenses, etc. Balancing accounts are approved by the CPUC and established to ensure that a utility recovers its CPUC authorized revenue requirement from ratepayers for a given program or function, but no more or less. Two-way balancing accounts authorize a utility to collect more or less than the authorized revenue requirement for a given program depending on actual costs, and are intended to ensure that the utility does not make or lose money due to uncertainties in the scope of work. A two-way balancing account is often used for ongoing expenses.
Electric utility companies trim and remove trees near high voltage power line for public safety, fire prevention, and electric reliability, and they generally receive authorization for funding. Generally, spending for vegetation management is tracked in a one-way balancing account, which means that if the utility does not spend all the authorized funds, the unused funds are returned to ratepayers. Additionally, utilities are generally prohibited from diverting funds to other spending areas or to profits.
Proposed Law:
This bill would expand CalFire’s role and responsibilities to oversee vegetation management by electric investor-owned utilities and would require a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation’s vegetation management costs.
Specific to CalFire’s expanded role, this bill would:
- Require an electrical corporation to notify CalFire after it has completed all or a substantial portion of the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan.
- Upon receiving notice from the electrical corporation, require CalFire to promptly audit the work performed by, or on behalf of, the electrical corporation and to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan.
- Require CalFire, after the time to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit expires, and no less than annually, to report to the electrical corporation and CPUC specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the vegetation management requirements in its wildfire mitigation plan and to make the report publicly available.
- Require each electrical corporation to reimburse CalFire for its cost to carry out these functions with respect to that electrical corporation’s electrical lines and other exposed energized overhead conductors and equipment.
Related Legislation:
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including funding for mutual aid, fuel reduction and forestry policies, wildfire mitigation plans by electric utilities, and cost recovery by electric corporations of wildfire-related damages.
Staff Comments:
According to CPUC, establishing a two-way balancing account for vegetation management spending of electric investor owned utilities necessitates additional staff resources estimated annually at $556,000 for an additional three positions.
Although CalFire already engages in improving fire safety for electrical corporations through vegetation management clearance inspections, fire incidence reporting, and involvement with changes to various CPUC general orders, this bill will require the department to perform additional workload related to collecting data, auditing, and reporting. This bill requires that any costs to CalFire for these activities shall be reimbursed by the electrical corporations.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 247 Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: | March 14, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | William Craven | ||
Subject: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation: management
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFIRE) and assigns CalFire responsibility for fire protection in state responsibility areas, as well as the administration of the state's private and public forests. (Public Resources Code §700 et seq.)
- Establishes that the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. (California Constitution, Article 12, §§3 and 4)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities Code §451)
- Requires each electrical corporation, local publicly owned electric utility, and electrical cooperative to construct, maintain, and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment. Requires each electrical corporation to annually prepare a wildfire mitigation plan and to submit its plan to the CPUC for review and approval, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §8386)
- Requires the CPUC and CalFIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data. (Public Utilities Code §8386.5)
PROPOSED LAW
Summary: This bill requires the CalFIRE to oversee the vegetation management of electrical corporations, including identifying the list of trees to trim. This bill also requires that all costs associated with the electrical corporation’s vegetation management are recovered from ratepayers through a specified mechanism called a two-way balancing account.
This bill:
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2021, CalFIRE to provide a “trim list” to each electrical corporation identifying all trees and other vegetation in the vicinity of electrical lines or equipment owned by the electrical corporation requiring removal or trimming, including the extent of trimming required.
- Requires CalFIRE to provide an updated trim list to the electrical corporation no longer than one week after the identification of additional required vegetation management.
- Requires the electrical corporation to notify CalFIRE after it has completed all or a substantial portion of the trimming or removal in the trim list. Upon receiving notice from the electrical corporation, this bill requires CalFIRE to promptly audit the work performed by, or on behalf of, the electrical corporation and to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the trim list.
- Provides that an electrical corporation would have a reasonable time to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit.
- Requires CalFIRE, after the time to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit expires, and no less than annually, to report to the electrical corporation and the CPUC specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the trim list and to make the report publicly available.
- Requires all electrical line clearance tree trimmers to be under the direct supervision and instruction of qualified line clearance tree trimmers as provided in High-Voltage Safety Orders of the Department of Industrial Relations.
- Requires that all qualified line clearance tree trimmers to be paid no less than the prevailing wage for a first period apprentice electrical utility lineman as determined by the Director of Industrial Relations.
- Requires each electrical corporation to reimburse CalFire for its costs to carry out these functions with respect to that electrical corporation’s electrical lines and other exposed energized overhead conductors and equipment. States that the willful or negligent failure to perform any of these electrical corporation obligations would be a misdemeanor.
- Requires the CPUC to establish a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation for all costs incurred by the electrical corporation for vegetation management, prohibits the electrical corporation from diverting any revenue from the account to any activity other than vegetation management, and prohibits the electrical corporation from earning any profit on any revenue from the account.
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that an electrical corporation fully recovers all costs incurred to comply with the trim list requirements that would be adopted pursuant to this bill and all other reasonable vegetation management activity.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, CalFire has documented that 12 northern California wildlifres in October, 2017 were caused by electric power and distribution lines or other utility equipment. CalFire cited trees or parts of trees falling into power lines as specific causes of the fires. Because of CalFire’s work on fire prevention, the author believes that the utility tree trimming effort should be shifted to CalFire from the utilities. The author also noted that the tree trimming work is dangerous and requires people to work in the air with power equipment near energized electric lines. Injuries and deaths happen far too often, and injuries may not be reported because of the immigration status of the workers. Provisions in this bill would require training and wages adequate to attract and retain a workforce.
The sponsor, the Coalition of California Utility Employees, notes that under existing law, the CPUC gives utilities a fixed budget to perform vegetation management work, and the utility decides what trees to trim or remove. It supports shifting this work to CalFire as well as follow-up audits. The proposed new funding mechanism would allow utilities to get rate based funds to do the tree trimming work that is determined by CalFire to be necessary, while prohibiting any diversion of those funds to other purposes.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
The Rural County Representatives of California argue that shifting the oversight of utilities’ vegetation management to CalFire diverts resources that are better allocated to fuel reduction projects and defensible space inspections. RCRC argues that the bill should be narrowed so that CalFire’s utility vegetation management responsibilities start and end when CalFire observes unfinished work during its ordinary course of operations.
COMMENTS
While much of the bill is within the jurisdiction of other committees, there are aspects of this bill that affect CalFire that are within the jurisdiction of this committee.
In discussions with the sponsor and author, staff is recommending changes that would leave the development and implementation of the “trim list” to the utilities. CalFire would retain its role as proposed in the bill to conduct audits of the work completed by the utilities. Through an existing MOU process, CalFire and the CPUC would consult on the vegetation management plans through an existing provision of law.
There are a couple of reasons for these suggestions:
- First, CalFire does not have the human or capital resources to undertake utility vegetation management inspections and tree trimming work. (Amendment 1). A technical amendment is proposed to delete a reference to the “trim list” and to substitute the wildfire mitigation plans required on an annual basis in current law. (Amendment 2).
- Second, a significant portion of the utilities’ power lines and related equipment is not in a state responsibility area, which is where CalFire’s statutory responsibilities are focused.
- Third, CalFire has a role in investigating fires that may have been caused by utility lines or other equipment, and the suggested staff amendment is consistent with that approach in that CalFire would now have an oversight and audit role in fire prevention activities undertaken by the utilities and greater information on what activities the utilities are undertaking to reduce fire risks.
The last amendment was agreed to in the Senate Energy Utilities and Telecommunications Committee to be adopted in this committee because of timing. (Amendment 3).
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
Delete 4742 (a)
AMENDMENT 2
Page 4, line 15, delete “in the trim list” and substitute “in its wildfire mitigation plans as required by section 8386 (a) of the Public Utilities Code.” Similarly, delete “trim list” and substitute “wildfire mitigation plan” on page 4, line 19; page 4, line 27; and page 4, line 30.
AMENDMENT 3
Page 5, line 15, replace existing (d) by adding: An electrical corporation shall notify the commission by advice letter not less than 30 days prior to the time when it projects that it will have spent or incurred obligations to spend its entire annual revenue requirement established by the commission. Also re-letter existing (d) as a new (e).
SUPPORT
Coalition of California Utility Employees (Sponsor)
California Association of Professional Scientists
OPPOSITION
Rural County Representatives of California – unless amended
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 247 Hearing Date: 4/10/2019
Author: | Dodd | ||
Version: | 3/14/2019 As Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Nidia Bautista | ||
SUBJECT: Wildland fire prevention: vegetation: management
DIGEST: This bill would require the Department of Forestry and Fire Protection (CalFIRE) to oversee the vegetation management of electrical corporations, including identifying the list of trees to trim. This bill would also require that all costs associated with the electrical corporation’s vegetation management are recovered from ratepayers through a two-way balancing account.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the CalFIRE is responsible for fire protection in state responsibility areas, as well as the administration of the state's private and public forests. (Public Resources Code §700 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) has regulatory authority over public utilities, including electrical corporations. (California Constitution, Article 12, §§ 3 and 4)
- Authorizes the CPUC to fix the rates and charges for every public utility and requires that those rates and charges be just and reasonable. (Public Utilities §451)
- Requires each electrical corporation, local publicly owned electric utility, and electrical cooperative to construct, maintain, and operate its electrical lines and equipment in a manner that will minimize the risk of catastrophic wildfire posed by those electrical lines and equipment. Requires each electrical corporation to annually prepare a wildfire mitigation plan and to submit its plan to the commission for review and approval, as specified. (Public Utilities Code §8386)
- Requires the CPUC and CalFIRE to enter into a memorandum of understanding to cooperatively develop consistent approaches and share data related to fire prevention, safety, vegetation management, and energy distribution systems and to share results from various fire prevention activities, including relevant inspections and fire ignition data. (Public Utilities Code §8386.5)
This bill:
- Requires, beginning January 1, 2021, CalFIRE to provide a “trim list” to each electrical corporation identifying all trees and other vegetation in the vicinity of electrical lines or equipment owned by the electrical corporation requiring removal or trimming, including the extent of trimming required.
- Requires CalFIRE to provide an updated trim list to the electrical corporation no longer than one week after the identification of additional required vegetation management.
- Requires the electrical corporation to notify CalFIRE after it has completed all or a substantial portion of the trimming or removal in the trim list. Upon receiving notice from the electrical corporation, this bill requires CalFIRE to promptly audit the work performed by, or on behalf of, the electrical corporation and to specify any failure of the electrical corporation to fully comply with the trim list.
- Provides that an electrical corporation would have a reasonable time to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit.
- Requires the CalFIRE, after the time to correct and eliminate any deficiency specified in the audit expires, and no less than annually, to report to the electrical corporation and the CPUC specifically describing any failure of the electrical corporation to substantially comply with the trim list and to make the report publicly available.
- Requires each electrical corporation to reimburse the CalFIRE for its cost to carry out these functions with respect to that electrical corporation’s electrical lines and other exposed energized overhead conductors and equipment. States that the willful or negligent failure to perform any of these electrical corporation obligations would be a misdemeanor.
- Requires the CPUC to establish a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation for all costs incurred by the electrical corporation for vegetation management, prohibit the electrical corporation from diverting any revenue from the account to any activity other than vegetation management, and prohibits the electrical corporation from earning any profit on any revenue from the account.
- Requires the CPUC to ensure that an electrical corporation fully recovers all costs incurred to comply with the trim list requirements that would be adopted pursuant to this bill and all other reasonable vegetation management activity.
Background
CPUC-regulated utilities - cost recovery of expenses. CPUC-regulated utilities routinely submit requests for recovery of costs related to their operations, including expanding their infrastructure, paying for operation expenses, etc. The primary vehicle for recovery of a utility’s costs is through the general rate case (GRC). The GRC usually occurs every three years and authorizes a utility to collect a specified amount from its customers to cover the anticipated operational expenses during the three years of the authorized amount in the GRC. As required by statute in Public Utilities Code §451, the CPUC may only approve a utility’s request for recovery of costs that is deemed “just and reasonable.” The review of utility expenses to ensure they are just and reasonable is the primary purpose of the CPUC’s existence and the main task of the agency as an economic regulator.
Balancing accounts. Balancing accounts are approved by the CPUC and established by utilities to serve various ratemaking purposes. The primary purpose of balancing accounts is to ensure that a utility recovers its CPUC authorized revenue requirement from ratepayers for a given program or function, but no more or less. Since rates are always forward-looking and based on forecasted sales, actual collections by the utility from ratepayers can be more or less than what the CPUC had authorized it to collect. A balancing account tracks actual sales and reconciles actual revenues against authorized revenues. These accounts record the surplus or deficit amount to be applied to a future collection period. To ensure the utility spends a certain authorized amount on specified activities, one- or two-way balancing accounts are established. A one-way cost balancing account ensures that if a utility spends less on a particular program than the amount authorized, it credits the remaining budget back to ratepayers. Two-way balancing accounts authorize a utility to collect more or less than the authorized revenue requirement for a given program depending on actual costs, and are intended to ensure that the utility does not make or lose money due to uncertainties in the scope of work. The net balance in a balancing account is typically recovered from or refunded to ratepayers on an annual basis, but in some cases, the amortization of the balance may be more frequent. A two-way balancing account is often used for ongoing expenses.
Vegetation management and electric utilities. Electric utility companies trim and remove trees near high voltage power line for public safety, fire prevention, and electric reliability. There are a number of laws and regulations governing vegetation management, including: California Public Resources Code Sections: 4293 Power Line Clearance Required; 4292 Power Line Hazard Reduction; 4291 Reduction of Fire Hazards around Buildings; and 4171 Public Nuisances. Additionally, there are a number of CPUC orders and California Code of Regulations, including General Order 95, California Code of Regulations Title 14, and others. Additionally, federal reliability rules require specified clearances between vegetation and transmission lines.
Cost recovery for vegetation management. Electric utilities generally receive authorization for funding for vegetation management in their GRCs with new authorization every three years. The GRCs approve spending for broad categories of funding and occasionally for specific projects. Generally, spending for vegetation management is tracked in a one-way balancing account, which means that if the utility does not spend all the authorized funds, the unused funds are returned to ratepayers. Additionally, utilities are generally prohibited from diverting funds to other spending areas or to profits.
This bill. This bill would expand CalFIRE’s role and responsibilities to oversee vegetation management by electric investor-owned utilities. These new responsibilities include developing a “trim list” identifying all trees and other vegetation to be removed or trimmed, auditing each electrical corporation’s vegetation management work and inform the electrical corporation of any failure to fully comply with CalFIRE’s list, report to CPUC describing any failure of the electrical corporation. This bill also establishes requirements about the skills certification needed to conduct tree trimming. Lastly, this bill would require a two-way balancing account for each electrical corporation’s vegetation management costs.
Areas of concern. Currently, electric utilities identify their trim list, in some cases, they also maintain an extensive inventory of the trees in or near their right-of-ways and inspect trees, prune and remove vegetation in close proximity to electric distribution or transmission lines. This bill proposes to have CalFIRE oversee and take on the tasks related to vegetation management in terms of scoping the work and auditing it after the vegetation has been trimmed by the utility. Although well-intentioned as an effort to improve the efforts of electric utilities to mitigate against wildfires, this bill also raises a number of concerns. Specifically, concerns raised by this bill, include: the potential for redundancy, capacity and expertise of CalFIRE, costs to ratepayers, interplay with current efforts (including wildfire mitigation plans), and the potential increased liability on CalFIRE. Although this bill proposes to have CalFIRE oversee the electric utility’s vegetation management, many of these functions will need to continue to be executed by the electric corporation. As such, it is very possible there could be some unintended redundancy (and potential costs) between the utility and CalFIRE. Additionally, the California Farm Bureau Federation and Rural County Representatives of California raise concerns that these new responsibilities will distract CalFIRE from its other duties. However, the proponents of this bill have suggested CalFIRE can contract out for these functions, including with the contractors that the utilities currently use. The increase of responsibilities proposed for CalFIRE are likely to result in increased liability for the agency, as they would be the final arbiter of whether to trim a tree. As such, it is quite possible that should there be a fire caused by a tree making contact with an electric line then CalFIRE may be likely to share in the liability for the damages. Lastly, the requirement for a two-way balancing account could result in substantial increased costs to ratepayers. This provision merits further investigation to ensure a two-way balancing account is merited, when a one-way balancing account is generally authorized. As such, the author and committee may wish to amend this bill to require the CPUC to determine whether a two-way balancing account is necessary.
Double referral. Should this bill be approved by this committee, it will be re-referred to the Senate Committees on Natural Resources and Water for their consideration.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 901 (Dodd, Chapter 626, Statutes of 2018) addressed numerous issues concerning wildfire prevention, response and recovery, including funding for mutual aid, fuel reduction and forestry policies, wildfire mitigation plans by electric utilities, and cost recovery by electric corporations of wildfire-related damages.
SB 1028 (Hill, Chapter 598, Statutes of 2016) required electric CPUC-regulated utilities to file annual wildfire mitigation plans and requires the CPUC to review and comment on those plans.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT:
Coalition of California Utility Employees (Sponsor)
OPPOSITION:
Rural County Representatives of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
Part of Cal Fire’s mission is to prevent fires. Cal Fire’s fire prevention program includes wildland pre-fire engineering, vegetation management, fire planning, education and law enforcement. Instead of each electrical corporation deciding what trees should be trimmed, this bill would require CalFIRE to provide each electrical corporation with a list of all trees and other vegetation to be removed or trimmed, including the extent to which the vegetation must be trimmed, to ensure compliance with CPUC and any other legal requirements and reduce the level of wildfire risk from contact with the electrical corporation’s electric lines and equipment. CalFIRE would audit each electrical corporation’s vegetation management work to ensure compliance with CalFIRE’s list. This bill ensures that an expert state agency rather than a utility with a profit motive decides what tree trimming should be done and verifies that the utility did it.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, the Rural County Representatives of California(RCRC) express concerns with the expansion of responsibilities this bill proposes to add to CalFIRE and the impact these changes would have on CalFIRE’s existing responsibilities. RCRC notes their desire to have utilities continue to oversee their vegetation management responsibilities and narrow CalFIRE’s scope of work and identify trees to trim only as part of their operations.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):