SB 274: Mobilehome parks: tenancies.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-03
The Mobilehome Residency Law governs the terms and conditions of residency in mobilehome parks. The law requires, among other things, that the management of a mobilehome park comply with noticing and other specified requirements in order to terminate a tenancy in a mobilehome park because of a change of use of the mobilehome park.
This bill would require management to offer the previous homeowner a right of first refusal to a renewed tenancy in the park if the park is destroyed due to a fire or other natural disaster and management elects to rebuild the park in the same location. The bill would require the terms of the renewed tenancy to be substantially the same as the prior rental agreement, except for adjustments to reflect costs and expenses incurred to rebuild the park, as specified. The bill would require a previous owner to accept the offer within 60 days of receiving the offer, as specified. The bill would require management to accept applications on a first-come-first-served basis and would make the offers nontransferable.
The law provides that a homeowner may be charged a fee for an individual staying with the homeowner for more than 20 consecutive days or a total of 30 days in a calendar year. Existing law prohibits park management from charging a fee to an individual who lives alone and shares their occupancy with one other person, designated as a companion, provided that only one individual may be designated as a companion within a calendar year, except as specified.
This bill would, instead, allow an individual to designate up to 3 companions in a calendar year, but no more than one companion at a time, unless otherwise authorized by management.
Existing law authorizes management to require that management approve the purchaser of a mobilehome that will remain in the park and require that the selling homeowner, or his or her agent, give notice of the sale to management before the close of the sale. Existing law prohibits management from withholding approval from a purchaser who has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, except as otherwise provided. Existing law requires management to consider the amount and source of the purchasers gross monthly income or means of financial support when making this determination.
This bill would require a selling homeowner or their agent to provide notice to management of a sale of a mobilehome before the close of the sale. The bill would require management, upon receipt of that notice, to within 15 days provide a selling homeowner or prospective purchaser with the standards that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application and a list of all documentation needed to determine if the prospective purchaser will qualify for tenancy in the park. The bill would prohibit management from withholding approval from a prospective purchaser of a mobilehome unless management reasonably determines that the purchaser will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park, the purchaser does not have the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, or the purchaser commits fraud, deceit, or concealment of material facts during the application process.
This bill would allow the purchaser to provide, and require park management to consider, evidence of additional financial assets if an application is denied due to the inability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges, including savings accounts, certificates of deposit, stock portfolios, real property, and any other financial asset that can be liquidated or sold, when making that determination. The bill would authorize management to consider liabilities, as well as the additional financial assets, when determining whether the prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges. The bill would provide that management may be held liable to a selling homeowner for failing to comply with those provisions.
(a)A homeowner shall not be charged a fee for a guest who does not stay with the homeowner for more than a total of 20 consecutive days or a total of 30 days in a calendar year. A person who is a guest, as described in this subdivision, shall not be required to register with the management.
(b)A homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome and who wishes to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one other person, to be designated as the homeowners companion, may do so, and management shall not impose a fee for that person. For purposes of this subdivision, a homeowner may only designate one person at a time as a companion and shall not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management. Management may refuse to allow a homeowner to share their mobilehome with a companion under this subdivision if park residency is subject to age restrictions and the proposed companion is unable or unwilling to provide documentation that the proposed companion meets those age restrictions.
(c)A homeowner may share their mobilehome with any person over 18 years of age if that person is providing live-in health care, live-in supportive care, or supervision to the homeowner. Management shall not charge a fee for the live-in caregiver but may require written confirmation from a licensed health care professional of the homeowners need for the care or supervision, if the need is not readily apparent or already known to management.
(d)A senior homeowner who resides in a mobilehome park that has implemented rules or regulations limiting residency based on age requirements for housing for older persons, pursuant to Section 798.76, may share their mobilehome with any person over 18 years of age if this person is a parent, sibling, child, or grandchild of the senior homeowner and requires live-in health care, live-in supportive care, or supervision. Management shall not charge a fee for this parent, sibling, child, or grandchild, but may require written confirmation from a licensed health care professional of the need for the care or supervision, if the need is not readily apparent or already known to management. As used in this section, senior homeowner means a homeowner who is 55 years of age or older.
(e)A guest, companion, live-in caregiver, or family member under the care of a senior homeowner, as they are described in this section, shall have no rights of tenancy in the park, and any agreement between the homeowner and the guest, companion, live-in caregiver, or family member under the care of a senior homeowner shall not change the terms and conditions of the rental agreement between management and the homeowner.
(f)A violation of the mobilehome park rules and regulations by a guest, companion, live-in caregiver, or family member under the care of a senior homeowner, as they are described in this section, shall be deemed a violation of the rules and regulations by the homeowner and subject to subdivision (d) of Section 798.56.
(g)Nothing in this section shall be interpreted to create a duty on the part of management to manage, supervise, or provide care for a homeowners guest, companion, live-in caregiver, or family member under the care of a senior homeowner, during that persons stay in the mobilehome park.
SEC. 2.Section 798.62 is added to the Civil Code, to read:798.62.(a)If a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and management elects to rebuild the park at the same location, management shall offer a renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park to all previous homeowners in accordance with the following:
(1)The offer of renewed tenancy shall be on substantially the same terms as the previous homeowners rental agreement that was in existence at the time of the wildfire or other natural disaster. However, management may adjust terms in the previous rental agreement to reflect costs and expenses to rebuild the park that were incurred from the time of the disaster until management received a final certificate of occupancy for all spaces in the park. These costs and expenses may include, but are not limited to, costs associated with demolition, reconstruction, and environmental remediation, as well as taxes and interest expenses.
(2)Management shall provide the previous homeowner, upon request, a statement listing the costs and expenses incurred in rebuilding the park and how the costs and expenses relate to the adjustment of terms in the rental agreement.
(3)The offer shall include an application to accept the renewed tenancy, the terms of the renewed tenancy, the deposit required to secure the renewed tenancy, and a clear statement of when the offer expires.
(4)Management shall send each previous homeowner the offer by certified mail, at least 240 days before the park is reopened, to the last postal address for the previous homeowner known to management, which may be the previous homeowners former address within the park. If management has an email address or telephone number for the previous homeowner, management shall additionally attempt to notify the homeowner of the offer by those means.
(5)A previous homeowner may accept the offer by submitting, within 60 days from the date the homeowner receives the offer, the application and required deposit to secure the renewed tenancy to management and sign a rental agreement. If the previous homeowner fails to accept the offer within this time period, then the previous homeowners right to a renewed tenancy under this section is deemed forfeited.
(6)Management shall process applications for renewed tenancy on a first-come-first-served basis.
(7)The previous homeowner shall not transfer the right to a renewed tenancy.
(b)For purposes of this section, previous homeowner means a homeowner with a valid tenancy in a mobilehome park at the time of a wildfire or other natural disaster.
SEC. 3.Section 798.74 of the Civil Code is amended to read:798.74.(a)The management may require the right of prior approval of a prospective purchaser of a mobilehome that will remain in the park.
(b)(1)A selling homeowner or their agent shall give notice of a sale of a mobilehome that will remain in the park to management before the close of the sale.
(2)Management shall, within 15 days, provide the seller and the prospective purchaser both of the following, in writing, upon receiving the notice required in paragraph (1):
(A)The standards that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application, including the minimum reported credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency that management requires for approval.
(B)A list of all documentation that management will require to determine if the prospective purchaser will qualify for tenancy in the park.
(c)Management shall not withhold approval from a prospective purchase of a mobilehome unless any of the following apply:
(1)Management reasonably determines that, based upon the purchasers prior tenancies, they will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park.
(2)The purchaser does not have the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park.
(3)The purchaser has committed fraud, deceit, or concealment of material facts during the application process.
(d)In determining whether the prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the management may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. However, management shall not require the prospective purchaser to submit any of the following:
(1)Documentation beyond that disclosed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(2)Copies of any personal income tax returns.
(e)(1)Within 15 business days of receiving all of the information requested from the prospective purchaser, management shall notify the seller and the prospective purchaser, in writing, of either acceptance or rejection of the application. During this 15-day period, the prospective purchaser shall comply with managements request, if any, for a personal interview.
(2)(A)If management rejects the application, management shall state the reason for the rejection in accordance with subdivision (c). If the rejection is based upon an alleged lack of financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the prospective purchaser may elect to provide additional financial or asset information to management to demonstrate their financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park. For purposes of this paragraph, additional financial information includes, but is not limited to, the following:
(i)Savings accounts.
(ii)Certificates of deposit.
(iii)Stock portfolios.
(iv)Trust interests of which the purchaser is a beneficiary.
(v)Real property.
(vi)Similar financial assets that can be liquidated or sold.
(B)If the prospective purchaser elects to provide additional financial and asset information specified in subparagraph (A), management shall consider the information together with the prospective purchasers gross monthly income to determine whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park.
(C)If a prospective purchaser provides additional financial and asset information, management may also consider any liabilities of the prospective purchaser when making a final determination of the prospective purchasers ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park under this subdivision.
(f)If the management collects a fee or charge from a prospective purchaser of a mobilehome in order to obtain a financial report or credit rating, the full amount of the fee or charge shall be credited toward payment of the first months rent for that mobilehome purchaser. If, for whatever reason, the prospective purchaser is rejected by the management, the management shall refund to the prospective purchaser the full amount of that fee or charge within 30 days from the date of rejection. If the prospective purchaser is approved by the management, but, for whatever reason, the prospective purchaser elects not to purchase the mobilehome, the management may retain the fee, or a portion thereof, to defray its administrative costs under this section.
(g)Management may be held liable by the selling homeowner for any and all damages proximately caused by managements failure to comply with this section.
(h)For purposes of this section:
(1)Charges means all charges authorized and imposed by management under Section 798.31.
(2)Consumer credit reporting agency has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 1785.3.
(3)Credit score has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 3, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 504, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 3, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 3). |
| Jun 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | Referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| May 13, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 31. Noes 5.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 7, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 6, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0. Page 905.) (April 30). |
| Apr 2, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 4, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB274 Dodd et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | SB 274 Dodd Senate Third Reading By Limón | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB274 Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 274 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 274
Amended: 8/19/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 31-5, 5/13/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Bates, Grove, Moorlach, Morrell, Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 74-0, 9/3/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Mobilehome parks: tenancies
SOURCE: Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League
DIGEST:
This bill (1) creates an opportunity for mobilehome residents to return when a mobilehome park is destroyed by natural disaster and subsequently gets rebuilt; (2) provides a required structure for a park’s determination of whether it must accept a prospective mobilehome buyer; and (3) provides mobilehome residents the opportunity to designate at least three “companions” in each calendar year with whom to share the mobilehome.
Assembly Amendments (1) eliminate any presumption of “financial ability to pay;” (2) allow parks to consider a prospective mobilehome purchaser’s liabilities, if it considers the prospective purchaser’s assets; (3) eliminate the automatic award of penalties for a park’s violation of the procedure for determining financial ability to pay; (4) require rebuilding parks to offer former residents an opportunity to return at least 240 days before the park reopens and gives former residents at least 60 days to consider the offer; and (5) allow parks to charge returning residents more to reflect the cost and expense of the rebuild.
Existing law:
- Provides that a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome and who wishes to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one other person may do so, and a fee shall not be imposed by management for that person. For purposes of this provision, a homeowner may only designate one person as their companion per calendar year, except in the case of the companion’s death. (Civ. Code § 798.34(a).)
- Gives mobilehome parks the authority to approve or deny the purchase of a mobilehome that will remain in the park, but that approval cannot be withheld unless:
- the purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park; or
- the management reasonably determines that, based on the purchaser’s prior tenancies, the purchaser will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
- Provides that, in determining whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, the management shall not require the prospective purchaser to submit copies of any personal income tax returns but may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
This bill:
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park, For purposes of this subdivision, a homeowner shall not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and management elects to rebuild the park at the same location, management shall offer previous homeowners the opportunity to return for a renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park, in accordance with the following:
- the offer shall be on substantially the same terms as the homeowner’s previous rental agreement that was in existence at the time of the wildfire or other natural disaster, except that the park may adjust the terms to reflect costs and expenses of rebuilding the park, as specified;
- the offer shall be made at least 240 days before the park reopens and the former residents shall have 60 days to accept the offer before it expires; and
- the offer shall not be transferable.
- Establishes specified procedures and standards for a park to determine whether or not a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, including:
- a requirement that the park provide the seller and prospective purchaser with advance notice of the standards the park customarily uses for approving or rejecting tenancies and the documentation the park will require of the prospective purchaser;
- a requirement that the park consider additional financial assets if the park initially rejects a potential purchaser based on inability to pay and the prospective purchaser elects to present evidence of additional financial assets, though if assets are considered, then the park may also consider the applicant’s liabilities; and
- that a park is liable to the selling homeowner for any damages proximately caused by a failure to comply with the standards and procedures.
Comments
The unique circumstances of mobilehomes
Mobilehomes situated in mobilehome parks present unique housing concerns. The homeowner owns the mobilehome, the park owns the land underneath, and, in spite of their names, mobilehomes are extremely difficult, if not impossible, to move. To address these unique circumstances, a special body of laws has developed, known collectively as the Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL). This bill addresses three aspects of the MRL.
- Provisions regarding companions
In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd, Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017), regarding the circumstances in which a mobilehome owner could invite others to live with them on an indefinite basis. The law struck a deliberate balance. On the one hand, many Californians are in need of a place to live and many homeowners could use the help of a cohabitant to cover expenses. On the other hand, allowing homeowners to sublet to an unlimited number of housemates would have strained the parks’ capacities and placed an unfair burden on park owners. SB 147’s compromise was to allow homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park.
The idea was to allow for long-term cohabitation. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year, with the only exception that the homeowner could name a subsequent companion in the same year if the first one died. The proponents of this bill state that, in practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. Companions move out for many different reasons: for example there may be a break-up, a change in job, an illness, tensions with the homeowner, or the companion may be unable to pay their portion of the expenses. Regardless of the reason, once the companion moves out, the homeowner is stuck with all of the expenses and unable to replace the companion, except in the case of the companion’s death, for the rest of the year.
To respond to this problem, this bill expands the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out. The author’s intention is that parks cannot charge a mobilehome anything for having a companion, regardless of whether the companion is the first, second, or third companion designated in the year.
- Provisions regarding return in the wake of a natural disaster
California’s recent, unprecedented spate of wildfires has struck the urban-wildland interface especially hard. Many mobilehome parks are located in these areas and many mobilehome parks have been destroyed as a result. Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident’s duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt. This bill creates a procedure, applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it, giving the former residents an opportunity to return to the park, should they elect to do so, on substantially the same terms, although a park would be permitted to adjust the terms to account for the costs and expenses associated with the rebuild.
In simplified terms, this bill’s “opportunity to return” provision would operate as follows. At least 240 days before reopening, a park choosing to rebuild would have to offer tenancies to the former residents on substantially similar terms as the tenancy that the former resident had when the natural disaster struck, thought the park may adjust the terms to reflect the cost of the rebuild. The park must make this offer by specified procedures intended to maximize the chances that the former residents will receive actual notice of the offer. The offer would expire 60 days after being made, unless accepted or rejected at a previous time.
- Provisions regarding financial ability to pay determinations
The unique nature of mobilehome properties creates complex dynamics when a homeowner is ready to sell the mobilehome and move out of the park. Theoretically, the homeowner could simply move the mobilehome out of the park. As a practical matter, this is rarely a physical possibility and frequently cost prohibitive. Consequently, in order to move out of the park, homeowners almost always have to sell their mobilehomes. Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, however, it is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
To further complicate matters, park management has potentially more at stake than just whether or not the prospective purchaser will pay the space rent and make a good member of the park community. If the selling homeowner is unable to sell the mobilehome, then that homeowner may have to abandon it to the park, either through a discounted sale or the imposition of a warehouse lien. The park can then turn around and sell the mobilehome itself, often at a tidy profit. This means that mobilehome park management has both a legitimate interest in screening prospective buyers for mobilehomes within their parks, as well as a potentially more nefarious interest in preventing sale of the mobilehome altogether.
The MRL deals with this tricky set of dynamics by giving mobilehome parks the right to approve or disapprove of prospective buyers seeking to purchase mobilehomes within their parks, but placing certain limitations on that right. Specifically, under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74.)
The trouble is that “financial ability to pay” is not defined anywhere in the MRL. With a strong incentive to block prospective purchasers, unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard. By demanding more and more documents or simply setting an absurdly high bar for what it means to have the financial ability to pay, these park managers can effectively sabotage any chance that the mobilehome gets sold, forcing the homeowner to abandon it to the park.
To address this problem, this bill sets forth a process for determining whether a prospective mobilehome purchaser has the financial ability to stay in the park. The park would retain the right to approve or reject a proposed buyer, but the park would have to let the prospective seller and purchaser know, in advance, what criteria it will apply and what documentation it will require. This procedure should ensure that park managers are not constantly moving the goalposts on prospective purchasers. If the park rejects the applicant, the park must provide written notice of the rejection and state its basis for the rejection. If the rejection is based on a lack of financial ability to pay, then the park must give the applicant the option to submit information about the applicant’s assets. If the applicant offers such asset information, the park must consider it, although the park may also take the applicant’s liabilities in to consideration as well. Finally, to make certain that parks comply with this process, this bill provides that parks are liable to the prospective purchaser and seller for any damages caused if the park fails to follow it.
The virtue of the process and standards set forth in this bill is twofold. First, it should somewhat reduce the ability of unscrupulous parks to abuse the vague “financial ability to pay” standard to force homeowners to abandon their mobilehome – often the one asset they have – to the parks. Second, by clarifying the standard and setting forth a clear and simple process for making the determination, this bill should cut down on legal disputes when homeowners seek approval from the park to sell their mobilehomes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League
Ventura County Board of Supervisors
One individual
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
For low-income seniors on fixed incomes, a lack of affordable housing can lead to loss of independence and higher costs to the public due to increased need for emergency healthcare or placement in nursing homes.
This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. (Citations omitted.)
In support, the Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League writes:
The bill clarifies that a homeowner who lives alone could have, free of any fees, one companion and up to two other replacement companions in a calendar year should any one companion leave due to family circumstances, sickness or death.
The bill also protects homeowners who choose to sell their home from park owner interference in the sale by allowing a potential purchaser to demonstrate their ability to pay rent similar to other traditional affordable housing. Currently many homeowners and residents are finding themselves trying to meet a threshold greater than what lenders are requiring for a home loan.
Finally, given the devastation and displacement of homeowners caused by the fires and other natural disasters, the bill offers the right of first refusal to homeowners, and their park space, at their original lease terms, if a park owner chooses to rebuild the park.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 74-0, 9/3/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooper, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Medina, Rodriguez
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/3/19 18:08:36
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Dodd)
As Amended Ver:August 19, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes changes to the law governing mobilehome tenancy and residency related to companions and establishes rules regarding rebuilding mobilehome home parks after a natural disaster
Major Provisions
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in a mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park. A homeowner must not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and the park owner elects to rebuild the park at the same location, then:
- The park owner is required to make an offer of renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park to all homeowner at the time of the natural disaster. This offer must be made at least 240 days before re-opening of the park, and be at substantially the same terms as the previous rental agreement, adjusted to account for the cost to rebuild; and
- The homeowner has 60 days to accept the offer, leave a security deposit, and sign a rental agreement.
- Establishes specified procedures and standards for a park management to determine whether or not a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, including:
- A requirement that the park management provide the seller and prospective purchaser with advance notice of the standards the park uses for approving or rejecting tenancies and the documentation the park will require of the prospective purchaser;
- A requirement that the park management consider additional financial assets and liabilities if the park management initially rejects a potential purchaser based on inability to pay and the prospective purchaser elects to present evidence of additional financial assets.
COMMENTS:
Companionship: In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd), Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017, which allowed homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year. In practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. To respond to this problem, this bill expands the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out.
Right-of-Return: Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident's duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt. This bill creates a procedure to facilitate a right-of-return that is applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it. In that circumstance, the management must offer a renewed tenancy on "substantially the same terms," but can factor in the cost of rebuilding to the new rents. They must make this offer at least 240 days before the park is re-opened. The homeowner has 60 days to accept the offer, leave a security deposit, and sign a rental agreement. This process will create fairness to mobilehome owners who lost their home in a disaster, without removing the economic incentive of park owners to rebuild their park.
Proving Ability to Pay: Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, selling a mobilehome is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
Under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park. The trouble is that "financial ability to pay" is not defined anywhere in the Mobilehome Residency Law. Unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard to block potential buyers. To address this problem, the bill requires that management provide the standards that they normally use in determining tenancy, and a list of all documents that will be required by a prospective purchaser, any homeowner who provides notice that they are selling the property. The bill also allows a prospective purchaser the option of providing additional financial information to demonstrate an ability to pay. If such additional information was provided, management may also consider any of the prospective purchaser's financial liabilities.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. This bill clarifies when a mobilehome resident who lives alone can have a companion, after wildfires it allows tenants the first opportunity to move into a rebuilt mobilehome park, and allows for expansion of assets that park management may consider in determining ability to pay for a space in a mobilehome park."
Arguments in Support:
According to the Golden State Manufactured-Homes Owners League, "The bill helps to address the challenge facing displaced homeowners when their homes and parks burn down from devastating fires. Should a park owner decide to rebuild the park, homeowners would have the opportunity to return to the place they call home. Finally, the bill allows a purchaser of a mobilehome to demonstrate their ability to pay rent and other fees. Right now, the threshold is higher than what lenders require."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 31-5-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Grove, Moorlach, Morrell, Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas, Jones
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 8-0-0
YES: Chiu, Diep, Gabriel, Gloria, Kiley, Limón, Maienschein, Quirk-Silva
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 19, 2019
CONSULTANT: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0001397
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Dodd)
As Amended Ver:July 9, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes changes to the law governing mobilehome tenancy and residency related to companions and establishes rules regarding rebuilding mobilehome home parks after a natural disaster.
Major Provisions
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in a mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park. A homeowner must not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and the park owner elects to rebuild the park at the same location, then:
- The park owner is required to make an offer of renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park to all homeowner at the time of the natural disaster. This offer must be made at least 240 days before re-opening of the park, and be at substantially the same terms as the previous rental agreement, adjusted to account for the cost to rebuild; and
- The homeowner has 60 days to accept the offer, leave a security deposit, and sign a rental agreement.
- Establishes specified procedures and standards for a park management to determine whether or not a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, including:
- A requirement that the park management provide the seller and prospective purchaser with advance notice of the standards the park uses for approving or rejecting tenancies and the documentation the park will require of the prospective purchaser;
- A requirement that the park management consider additional financial assets and liabilities if the park management initially rejects a potential purchaser based on inability to pay and the prospective purchaser elects to present evidence of additional financial assets.
COMMENTS:
Companionship: In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd), Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017, which allowed homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year. In practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. To respond to this problem, this bill expands the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out.
Right-of-Return: Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident's duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt. This bill creates a procedure to facilitate a right-of-return that is applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it. In that circumstance, the management must offer a renewed tenancy on "substantially the same terms," but can factor in the cost of rebuilding to the new rents. They must make this offer at least 240 days before the park is re-opened. The homeowner has 60 days to accept the offer, leave a security deposit, and sign a rental agreement. This process will create fairness to mobilehome owners who lost their home in a disaster, without removing the economic incentive of park owners to rebuild their park.
Proving Ability to Pay: Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, selling a mobilehome is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
Under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park. The trouble is that "financial ability to pay" is not defined anywhere in the Mobilehome Residency Law. Unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard to block potential buyers. To address this problem, the bill requires that management provide the standards that they normally use in determining tenancy, and a list of all documents that will be required by a prospective purchaser, any homeowner who provides notice that they are selling the property. The bill also allows a prospective purchaser the option of providing additional financial information to demonstrate an ability to pay. If such additional information was provided, management may also consider any of the prospective purchaser's financial liabilities.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. This bill clarifies when a mobilehome resident who lives alone can have a companion, after wildfires it allows tenants the first opportunity to move into a rebuilt mobilehome park, and allows for expansion of assets that park management may consider in determining ability to pay for a space in a mobilehome park."
Arguments in Support:
According to the Golden State Manufactured-Homes Owners League, "The bill helps to address the challenge facing displaced homeowners when their homes and parks burn down from devastating fires. Should a park owner decide to rebuild the park, homeowners would have the opportunity to return to the place they call home. Finally, the bill allows a purchaser of a mobilehome to demonstrate their ability to pay rent and other fees. Right now, the threshold is higher than what lenders require."
Arguments in Opposition:
None.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 31-5-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Grove, Moorlach, Morrell, Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas, Jones
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 8-0-0
YES: Chiu, Diep, Gabriel, Gloria, Kiley, Limón, Maienschein, Quirk-Silva
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 9, 2019
CONSULTANT: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0001245
Date of Hearing: July 3, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 274
Author:(Dodd) – As Amended Ver:June 25, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 31-5
SUBJECT: Mobilehome parks: tenancies
SUMMARY: Makes changes to the law governing mobilehome tenancy and residency related to companions and establishes rules regarding rebuilding mobilehome home parks after a natural disaster. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in a mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park. A homeowner must not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and the park owner elects to rebuild the park at the same location, the owner is required to:
- Extend, for 60 days, an offer to the previous homeowner for a renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park on substantially the same terms as the homeowner’s previous rental agreement; and
- Include notice in the offer of renewed tenancy that the homeowner has 90 days to remove personal property from the homeowner’s park space, after which those possessions may be removed and destroyed by the park management.
- Establishes specified procedures and standards for a park management to determine whether or not a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, including:
- A requirement that the park management provide the seller and prospective purchaser with advance notice of the standards the park uses for approving or rejecting tenancies and the documentation the park will require of the prospective purchaser;
- A presumption that the prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other park charges if:
- The prospective purchaser’s average gross monthly income during the three months immediately preceding submission of the application is at least three times greater than the combined monthly rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park for the mobilehome space;
- The prospective purchaser has prequalified for loan financing for the mobilehome; or
- The prospective purchaser’s reported credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency meets or exceeds the minimum credit score that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application; and
- A requirement that the park management consider additional financial assets and liabilities if the park management initially rejects a potential purchaser based on inability to pay and the prospective purchaser elects to present evidence of additional financial assets.
- Requires a selling homeowner or their agent to give notice of a sale of a mobilehome that will remain in the park at the time an application for tenancy is requested for approval by park management.
- Provides that a park is liable to the seller and prospective purchaser for any damages proximately caused by a failure to comply with the standards and procedures set forth in (3), above.
- Provides that a park withholding approval from a prospective purchaser when the purchaser has established financial ability to pay the combined rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, may be subject to a penalty of $2,000 in addition to any other consequential damages awarded to the selling homeowner as the prevailing party in any civil action.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome and who wishes to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one other person may do so, and a fee shall not be imposed by management for that person. For purposes of this provision, a homeowner may only designate one person as their companion per calendar year, except in the case of the companion’s death. (Civ. Code § 798.34(a).)
- Gives mobilehome parks the authority to approve or deny the purchase of a mobilehome that will remain in the park, but that approval cannot be withheld unless:
- The purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park; or
- The management reasonably determines that, based on the purchaser’s prior tenancies, the purchaser will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park. In determining whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, the management shall not require the prospective purchaser to submit copies of any personal income tax returns but may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
Purpose of the Bill: According to the author, “This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. This bill clarifies when a mobilehome resident who lives alone can have a companion, after wildfires it allows tenants the first opportunity to move into a rebuilt mobilehome park, and allows for expansion of assets that park management may consider in determining ability to pay for a space in a mobilehome park.”
Background: There are approximately 700,000 Californians living in about 400,000 mobilehomes dispersed over 4,100 mobilehome parks. Mobilehomes are not truly mobile, in that it is often cost prohibitive (up to $20,000) to relocate them. A mobilehome owner whose home is located in a mobilehome park does not own the land the unit sits on, and he or she must pay rent and fees for the land and any community spaces. As such, mobilehomes are considered chattel property and not real property. Purchasing a mobilehomes is often much less expensive than other forms of housing. As such, mobilehomes are an important source of housing statewide – particularly, affordable homeownership housing. However, like other forms of chattel property (like cars), they generally decrease in value over time. The Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL) extensively regulates the relationship between landlords and homeowners who occupy a mobilehome park.
Companionship: In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd, Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017), regarding the circumstances in which a mobilehome owner could invite others to live with them on an indefinite basis. The law struck a deliberate balance. On the one hand, many Californians are in need of a place to live and many homeowners could use the help of a cohabitant to cover expenses. On the other hand, allowing homeowners to sublet to an unlimited number of housemates would have strained the parks’ capacities and placed an unfair burden on park owners. SB 147’s compromise was to allow homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park.
The idea was to allow for long-term cohabitation. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year, with the only exception that the homeowner could name a subsequent companion in the same year if the first one died. The proponents of this bill state that, in practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. Companions move out for many different reasons: for example there may be a break-up, a change in job, an illness, tensions with the homeowner, or the companion may be unable to pay their portion of the expenses. Regardless of the reason, once the companion moves out, the homeowner is stuck with all of the expenses and unable to replace the companion, except in the case of the companion’s death, for the rest of the year.
To respond to this problem, this bill expands the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out. The author’s intention is that parks cannot charge a mobilehome anything for having a companion, regardless of whether the companion is the first, second, or third companion designated in the year.
Right-of-Return: California’s recent, unprecedented spate of wildfires has struck the urban-wildland interface especially hard. Many mobilehome parks are located in these areas and many mobilehome parks have been destroyed as a result. Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident’s duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt.
This bill creates a procedure to facilitate a right-of-return that is applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it. In that circumstance, the management must offer a renewed tenancy on “substantially the same terms” before offering tenancies to the general public. The park must make this offer by specified procedures intended to maximize the chances that the former residents will receive actual notice of the offer. The offer would expire 60 days after being made, unless accepted or rejected at a previous time. In the meantime, the park would be free to enter into tenancies with any other interested tenants, so long as the number of remaining vacancies is larger than the number of outstanding offers.
Though sympathetic to former residents who have lost their homes on account of a natural disaster, opponents of this bill point out that park owners may not be incentivized to rebuild if they know that they will be restricted to charging substantially the same rental rates as they were charging prior to the destruction of the park. This is particularly the case where the cost to rebuild the park exceeds projected revenues. In such circumstances, there would be no rebuilt housing at all, prolonging the crisis created by the original natural disaster. To address this concern, the Committee may wish to recommend enabling the previous terms to be adjusted to reflect costs required to rebuild the park, and that returning homeowners would, upon their request, receive a disclosure from the park owner that lists out the rebuilding cost and how that relates to the change in their terms.
Additionally, as currently written the procedures for right-of-return are lacking important details that would facilitate its functionality. These include timelines and parameters that provide clarity and certainty for both parties who are re-entering into their agreement. As such, the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Management must send the offer of renewed tenancy by certified mail at least 240 days prior to opening of the park. The offer must include the terms of renewal as well as the requested earnest money deposit to secure renewal;
- Homeowners shall have 60 days from receiving the offer to accept it, submit their earnest money deposit, and sign a lease. Applications for right to return must be taken on a first come first served basis. Non-response by the homeowner within 60 days will result in forfeiture of the right of return; and
- Specify that the right of return is non-transferable.
The most recent amendment to the bill added language at the behest of the Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association (WMA) requiring that the notice of an offer of a renewed tenancy must advise that the homeowner has 90 days from the date notice is sent to inspect and remove any personal property located on the homeowner’s park space damaged by the natural disaster, and after 90 days, all of the property remaining on the park space may be removed and destroyed by management. Upon further reflection, author and proponent of that language have asked for its removal. The language is intended to address a serious concern regarding the ability to clean up after a wildfire or natural disaster, particularly as it relates to the efforts of the Governor’s Office of Emergency Services (CalOES) and Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA). However, the current bill language only applies to the limited instances when the mobilehome park is being rebuilt, and is tied to the timeframe of that rebuild rather to the timeframe of the cleanup. As such, the Committee may wish to recommend removing this language. The author may wish to consider adding language to this bill that would address this important issue in a broader and more timely way.
Proving Ability to Pay: The unique nature of mobilehome properties creates complex dynamics when a homeowner is ready to sell the mobilehome and move out of the park. The cost to move a mobilehome is up to $20,000. Consequently, in order to move out of the park, homeowners almost always have to sell their mobilehomes. Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, however, it is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
To further complicate matters, park management has potentially more at stake than just whether or not the prospective purchaser will pay the space rent and make a good member of the park community. If the selling homeowner is unable to sell the mobilehome, then that homeowner may have to abandon it to the park, either through a discounted sale or the imposition of a warehouse lien. The park can then turn around and sell the mobilehome itself, often at a profit. This means that mobilehome park management has both a legitimate interest in screening prospective buyers for mobilehomes within their parks, as well as a potentially more nefarious interest in preventing sale of the mobilehome altogether.
The MRL deals with this tricky set of dynamics by giving mobilehome parks the right to approve or disapprove of prospective buyers seeking to purchase mobilehomes within their parks, but placing certain limitations on that right. Specifically, under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park.
The trouble is that “financial ability to pay” is not defined anywhere in the MRL. With a strong incentive to block prospective purchasers, unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard. By demanding more and more documents or simply setting a high bar for what it means to have the financial ability to pay, these park managers can effectively sabotage any chance that the mobilehome gets sold, forcing the homeowner to abandon it to the park.
To address this problem, the bill requires that management provide the standards that they normally use in determining tenancy, and a list of all documents that will be required by a prospective purchaser, any homeowner who provides notice that they are selling the property. However, the bill does not specify the timeframe for providing this information to the selling homeowner. To provide certainty on the timing, the Committee may wish to recommend adding a 15-day limit to management to provide the required information.
This bill also sets forth a process for determining whether a prospective mobilehome purchaser has the financial ability to stay in the park. This includes specifying that the purchaser would be determined to have the ability to pay if they had (1) an average income for the last three months that was more than three times the monthly space rent, utility charges, and fees for the park; (2) pre-qualified for a loan to purchase the mobilehome; or (3) has a credit score that meets or exceeds the standard that the park generally applies for approving tenancies. If the prospective purchaser did not qualify based on one of these presumptions, the park would have to give the prospective purchaser the option of providing additional financial information to demonstrate an ability to pay. If such additional information was provided, management may also consider any of the prospective purchaser’s financial liabilities.
The increased clarity of the standards regarding financial ability to pay could be beneficial, but there are equivalent challenges of having absolute standards. For example, income averages vary greatly across the state, so that a fixed standard could exclude lower income residents from qualifying in parts of the state with lower incomes but also lower costs of living. Additionally, as we have seen from the past financial crisis, lenders may be offering for prospective purchasers that might actually have the ability to pay. Finally, credit scores are a better predictor of payment on debt than ability to pay. Based on these concerns, the Committee may wish to recommend striking these standards and rely instead on the language included in the bill to increase transparency and establish a mobilehome owner’s ability to pay.
Current law states that management cannot withhold approval from a prospective purchaser if 1) they have the financial ability to pay, 2) the management cannot reasonably determines that, based on the purchaser’s prior tenancies, they will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park, or 3) the purchaser has not committed fraud, deceit, or concealment of material facts during the application process. Current law also enables the management or owner to be held liable for all resulting damages if their approval is withheld for any other reason. The existing bill expands the potential liabilities and penalties for management in these instances, predicated on the increased ability to definitively ascertain financial ability to pay. Should the Committee agree to strike the specific standards for determining ability to pay, as discussed above, the Committee should also consider removing these additional liabilities and penalties.
Arguments in Support: According to the Golden State Manufactured-Homes Owners League, “The bill helps to address the challenge facing displaced homeowners when their homes and parks burn down from devastating fires. Should a park owner decide to rebuild the park, homeowners would have the opportunity to return to the place they call home. Finally, the bill allows a purchaser of a mobilehome to demonstrate their ability to pay rent and other fees. Right now, the threshold is higher than what lenders require.”
Arguments in Opposition: According to WMA, regarding rebuilding after natural disasters, “When rebuilding these communities, many factors are taken into consideration including whether a return on investment can be attainted after: insurance reimbursement, loss of rent, disposal and cleanup of debris, rebuilding/replacing sewer and water infrastructure, etc. SB 274 seriously hampers this effort by requiring the management to offer a renewed lease on substantially the same terms as the previous homeowner's rental agreement and offers spaces in perpetuity, with no end date and no earnest deposit at any point in time.” With regards to financial ability to pay, Each community and region of the state are unique and landlords should be able to adjust standards in various regions accordingly. Mobilehome parks are already subject to just cause eviction and with the high cost of unlawful detainers, management must balance the risk of tenancy by adopting reasonable income requirements that fits their business model and their geographic location. WMA objects to language that could allow unjustified lawsuits against mobilehome park operators if they refuse approval of a mobilehome sale in their park based on legitimate financial concerns.”
Committee Amendments: To address the issues raised above, the Committee may wish to consider the following amendments:
- Regarding rebuilding after a natural disaster:
- Specify that, for park owners rebuilding after a wildfire or other natural disaster, the terms offered must be substantially the same except that they may be adjusted to reflect costs and expenses required to rebuild the park;
- Specify that returning homeowners would, upon their request, receive a disclosure from the park owner that lists out the rebuilding cost and how that relates to the change in their terms;
- Specify that management must send the offer of renewed tenancy by certified mail at least 240 days prior to opening of the park. The offer must include the terms of renewal as well as the requested earnest money deposit to secure renewal;
- Specify that homeowners have 60 days from receiving the offer to accept it, submit their earnest money deposit, and sign a lease. Applications for right to return must be taken on a first come first served basis. Non-response by the homeowner within 60 days will result in forfeiture of the right of return;
- Specify that the right of return is non-transferable;
- Remove the language regarding notice of and requirements to removing personal property;
- Regarding financial ability to pay:
- Add a 15-day limit to management to provide the standards they use to required information.
- Remove the specified thresholds for ability-to-pay, including an average income for the last three months was more than three times the monthly space rent, utility charges, and fees for the park; pre-qualified for a loan to purchase the mobilehome; or a credit score meets or exceeds the standard that the park generally applies for approving tenancies; and
- Remove the right of the selling homeowner to additional liabilities and penalties regarding denial based on ability to pay.
Related Legislation:
AB 3066 (Mark Stone), Chapter 774, Statutes of 2018: Established the Mobilehome Residency Law Protection Program, beginning July 1, 2020, within the Department of Housing and Community Development to help coordinate the resolution of complaints from homeowners relating to the Mobilehome Residency Law.
SB 147 (Dodd), Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017: Allowed a person living alone in a mobilehome to share the mobilehome with one other companion at no charge from the park. The bill limited each mobilehome to one companion per calendar year, except in the event of the companion’s death.
AB 2026 (Stone, 2014): Would have limited mobilehome parks to rejecting prospective purchasers based on financial grounds only, and would have deemed a loan approval or income of over three times the monthly rent and park fees sufficient proof of financial ability to pay, among other things. AB 2026 failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
SB 1107 (Correa), Chapter 170, Statutes of 2008: Allowed a mobilehome owner of any age to have a live-in caretaker at no additional charge from the park, upon presentation of a doctor’s note verifying the need for the caretaker.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League
Opposition
California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance
Park Owners (13)
Oppose Unless Amended
California Association of Realtors
Civil Justice Association of California
Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association
Analysis Prepared by: Steve Wertheim / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 274 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 274
Amended: 5/7/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Mobilehome parks: tenancies
DIGEST: This bill (1) creates an opportunity for mobilehome residents to return when a mobilehome park is destroyed by natural disaster and subsequently gets rebuilt; (2) provides standards a procedure for a park’s determination of whether it must accept a prospective mobilehome buyer based on “financial ability to pay;” and (3) provides mobilehome residents the opportunity to designate at least three “companions” in each calendar year with whom to share the mobilehome.
Existing law:
- Provides that a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome and who wishes to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one other person may do so, and a fee shall not be imposed by management for that person. For purposes of this provision, a homeowner may only designate one person as their companion per calendar year, except in the case of the companion’s death. (Civ. Code § 798.34(a).)
- Gives mobilehome parks the authority to approve or deny the purchase of a mobilehome that will remain in the park, but that approval cannot be withheld unless:
- the purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park; or
- the management reasonably determines that, based on the purchaser’s prior tenancies, the purchaser will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
- Provides that, in determining whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, the management shall not require the prospective purchaser to submit copies of any personal income tax returns but may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
This bill:
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park, For purposes of this subdivision, a homeowner shall not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and management elects to rebuild the park at the same location, management shall offer previous homeowners a 180-day right of first refusal for a renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park on the same terms as the homeowner’s previous rental agreement that was in existence at the time of the wildfire or other natural disaster before offering any tenancy in the rebuilt mobile park to the public.
- Establishes specified procedures and standards for a park to determine whether or not a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, including:
- a requirement that the park provide the seller and prospective purchaser with advance notice of the standards the park uses for approving or rejecting tenancies and the documentation the park will require of the prospective purchaser;
- a presumption that the prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other park charges if:
- the prospective purchaser’s average gross monthly income during the three months immediately preceding submission of the application is at least three times greater than the combined monthly rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park for the mobilehome space;
- the prospective purchaser has prequalified for loan financing for the mobilehome being purchased by them; or
- the prospective purchaser’s reported credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency meets or exceeds the minimum that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application; and
- a requirement that the park consider additional financial assets if the park initially rejects a potential purchaser based on inability to pay and the prospective purchaser elects to present evidence of additional financial assets.
- Provides that a park is liable to the seller and prospective purchaser for any damages proximately caused by a failure to comply with the standards and procedures set forth in (3), above.
- Provides that a park withholding approval from a prospective purchaser when the purchaser has established financial ability to pay the combined rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, may be subject to a penalty of $2,000 in addition to any other consequential damages awarded to the selling homeowner as the prevailing party in any civil action.
Comments
The unique circumstances of mobilehomes
Mobilehomes situated in mobilehome parks present unique housing concerns. The homeowner owns the mobilehome, the park owns the land underneath, and, in spite of their names, mobilehomes are extremely difficult, if not impossible, to move. To address these unique circumstances, a special body of laws has developed, known collectively as the Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL). This bill addresses three aspects of the MRL.
- Provisions regarding companions
In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd, Chapter 767, Statutes of 2017), regarding the circumstances in which a mobilehome owner could invite others to live with them on an indefinite basis. The law struck a deliberate balance. On the one hand, many Californians are in need of a place to live and many homeowners could use the help of a cohabitant to cover expenses. On the other hand, allowing homeowners to sublet to an unlimited number of housemates would have strained the parks’ capacities and placed an unfair burden on park owners. SB 147’s compromise was to allow homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park.
The idea was to allow for long-term cohabitation. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year, with the only exception that the homeowner could name a subsequent companion in the same year if the first one died. The proponents of this bill state that, in practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. Companions move out for many different reasons: for example there may be a break-up, a change in job, an illness, tensions with the homeowner, or the companion may be unable to pay their portion of the expenses. Regardless of the reason, once the companion moves out, the homeowner is stuck with all of the expenses and unable to replace the companion, except in the case of the companion’s death, for the rest of the year.
To respond to this problem, this bill expands the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out. The author’s intention is that parks cannot charge a mobilehome anything for having a companion, regardless of whether the companion is the first, second, or third companion designated in the year.
- Provisions regarding return in the wake of a natural disaster
California’s recent, unprecedented spate of wildfires has struck the urban-wildland interface especially hard. Many mobilehome parks are located in these areas and many mobilehome parks have been destroyed as a result. Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident’s duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt. This bill creates a procedure, applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it, giving the former residents an opportunity to return to the park on substantially the same terms, should they elect to do so.
In simplified terms, this bill’s “opportunity to return” provision would operate as follows. Before offering tenancies to the general public, a park choosing to rebuild would have to offer tenancies to the former residents on substantially similar terms as the tenancy that the former resident had when the natural disaster struck. The park must make this offer by specified procedures intended to maximize the chances that the former residents will receive actual notice of the offer. The offer would expire 180 days after being made, unless accepted or rejected at a previous time. In the meantime, the park would be free to enter into tenancies with any other interested tenants, so long as the number of remaining vacancies is larger than the number of outstanding offers.
Though sympathetic to former residents who have lost their homes on account of a natural disaster, opponents of this bill point out that park owners may not be incentivized to rebuild if they know that they will be restricted to charging substantially the same rental rates as they were charging prior to the destruction of the park.
Proponents of this bill respond that the substantially similar lease terms would only apply to the initial lease. In the absence of rent control, the park would be free to increase rent and make other changes to any subsequent leases. Where rent control did apply, parks would probably still be able to raise the rent on subsequent leases through application of rent control exceptions that generally allow for increases when justified by capital improvements.
- Provisions regarding financial ability to pay determinations
The unique nature of mobilehome properties creates complex dynamics when a homeowner is ready to sell the mobilehome and move out of the park. Theoretically, the homeowner could simply move the mobilehome out of the park. As a practical matter, this is rarely a physical possibility and frequently cost prohibitive. Consequently, in order to move out of the park, homeowners almost always have to sell their mobilehomes. Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, however, it is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
To further complicate matters, park management has potentially more at stake than just whether or not the prospective purchaser will pay the space rent and make a good member of the park community. If the selling homeowner is unable to sell the mobilehome, then that homeowner may have to abandon it to the park, either through a discounted sale or the imposition of a warehouse lien. The park can then turn around and sell the mobilehome itself, often at a tidy profit. This means that mobilehome park management has both a legitimate interest in screening prospective buyers for mobilehomes within their parks, as well as a potentially more nefarious interest in preventing sale of the mobilehome altogether.
The MRL deals with this tricky set of dynamics by giving mobilehome parks the right to approve or disapprove of prospective buyers seeking to purchase mobilehomes within their parks, but placing certain limitations on that right. Specifically, under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74.)
The trouble is that “financial ability to pay” is not defined anywhere in the MRL. With a strong incentive to block prospective purchasers, unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard. By demanding more and more documents or simply setting an absurdly high bar for what it means to have the financial ability to pay, these park managers can effectively sabotage any chance that the mobilehome gets sold, forcing the homeowner to abandon it to the park.
To address this problem, this bill sets forth a process for determining whether a prospective mobilehome purchaser has the financial ability to stay in the park. The park would retain the right to approve or reject a proposed buyer, but a prospective purchaser would be presumed to have the financial ability to pay under any of the following scenarios: (1) the prospective purchaser’s average income for the last three months was more than three times the monthly space rent, utility charges, and fees for the park; (2) the prospective purchaser has pre-qualified for a loan to purchase the mobilehome; or (3) the prospective purchaser’s credit score meets or exceeds the standard that the park generally applies for approving tenancies. If the prospective purchaser did not qualify based on one of these presumptions, the park would have to give the prospective purchaser the option of providing additional financial information to demonstrate an ability to pay.
To ensure that park managers are not constantly moving the goalposts on prospective purchasers, this bill also requires the parks to provide prospective purchasers and the homeowner seeking to sell, upon request, with a list of the documentation that the park will require of the prospective purchaser during the approval process as well as the standards that the park will apply. Finally, to make certain that parks comply with this process, this bill provides that parks are liable to the prospective purchaser and seller for any damages caused if the park fails to follow it.
The virtue of the process and standards set forth in this bill is twofold. First, it should greatly reduce the ability of unscrupulous parks to abuse the vague “financial ability to pay” standard to force homeowners to abandon their mobilehome – often the one asset they have – to the parks. Second, by clarifying the standard and setting forth a clear and simple process for making the determination, this bill should cut down on legal disputes when homeowners seek approval from the park to sell their mobilehomes. Viewed from the park owner and manager’s perspective, however, this simplification and clarification reduces the discretion they have to pick and choose who will move into the park, which they dislike. Opponents have also expressed dissatisfaction with this bill’s provisions creating a presumption of financial ability to pay based on specified factors. Presuming ability to pay based on pre-qualification for a loan, the opponents argue, means that financial institutions are making credit-worthiness determinations for the parks.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League
Ventura County Board of Supervisors
One individual
California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
For low-income seniors on fixed incomes, a lack of affordable housing can lead to loss of independence and higher costs to the public due to increased need for emergency healthcare or placement in nursing homes.
This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. (Citations omitted.)
In support, the Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League writes:
The bill clarifies that a homeowner who lives alone could have, free of any fees, one companion and up to two other replacement companions in a calendar year should any one companion leave due to family circumstances, sickness or death.
The bill also protects homeowners who choose to sell their home from park owner interference in the sale by allowing a potential purchaser to demonstrate their ability to pay rent similar to other traditional affordable housing. Currently many homeowners and residents are finding themselves trying to meet a threshold greater than what lenders are requiring for a home loan.
Finally, given the devastation and displacement of homeowners caused by the fires and other natural disasters, the bill offers the right of first refusal to homeowners, and their park space, at their original lease terms, if a park owner chooses to rebuild the park.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, the California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance writes:
[w]hile we understand the author’s intent and share sympathy with anyone who loses their home in a fire or other natural disaster, it is unreasonable to require a mobilehome parkowner to guarantee a home owner tenancy in a newly rebuilt park at the same rent. […] Ultimately, the parkowners and residents should be allowed to negotiate a right of first refusal as well as the terms.
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/8/19 15:36:32
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 274 (Author:Dodd)
Version: February 13, 2019
Hearing Date: April 30, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Mobilehome parks: tenancies
DIGEST
This bill: (1) creates an opportunity for mobilehome residents to return when a mobilehome park is destroyed by natural disaster and subsequently gets rebuilt; (2) gives prospective mobilehome buyers the option of submitting information about their financial assets to the park for consideration during the park’s determination of whether it must accept the prospective mobilehome buyer based on “financial ability to pay;” and (3) provides mobilehome residents the opportunity to designate at least three “companions” in each calendar year with whom to share the mobilehome.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
To address the unique issues raised by mobilehomes, a special body of law has developed, known collectively as the Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL). This bill would make three changes to the MRL. First, the bill would insert procedures into the MRL giving mobilehome residents an opportunity to return when natural disaster destroys their mobilehome park and it later gets rebuilt. Second, the bill would provide greater clarity around the meaning of financial ability to pay in the context of mobilehome sales within a park. Under the MRL, a park can veto such a sale, but only on limited grounds, including a determination that the prospective buyer lacks the financial ability to pay. This bill would allow prospective buyers to submit additional information about their financial ability to pay to support their application. Finally, existing law allows a homeowner living alone to share the mobilehome with one companion at a time with no additional charge from the park. This bill would allow the homeowner to name up to three such companions in any calendar year.
The bill is sponsored by the Golden State Manufactured Homeowners League. Opposition is from some mobilehome park owners and managers who, as to the bill in print, object primarily to the component relating to the opportunity to return after a natural disaster. They believe this aspect of the bill could dissuade parks from rebuilding, thus undercutting the goal of sustaining affordable housing options.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Provides that a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome and who wishes to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one other person may do so, and a fee shall not be imposed by management for that person. For purposes of this provision, a homeowner may only designate one person as their companion per calendar year, except in the case of the companion’s death. (Civ. Code § 798.34(a).)
- Gives mobilehome parks the authority to approve or deny the purchase of a mobilehome that will remain in the park, but that approval cannot be withheld unless:
- the purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park; or
- the management reasonably determines that, based on the purchaser’s prior tenancies, the purchaser will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
- Provides that, in determining whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, the management shall not require the prospective purchaser to submit copies of any personal income tax returns but may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. (Civ. Code § 798.74(a).)
This bill:
- Allows a homeowner who is living alone in the mobilehome to share occupancy of their mobilehome with one companion at a time, free of charge from the park, For purposes of this subdivision, a homeowner shall not designate more than three companions in total during any calendar year, unless otherwise authorized by management.
- Provides that if a mobilehome park is destroyed as a result of a wildfire or other natural disaster, and management elects to rebuild the park at the same location, management shall offer previous homeowners a 180-day right of first refusal for a renewed tenancy in the rebuilt mobilehome park on the same terms as the homeowner’s previous rental agreement that was in existence at the time of the wildfire or other natural disaster before offering any tenancy in the rebuilt mobile park to the public.
- Provides that, as part of a mobilehome park’s process for determining whether a prospective mobilehome purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent and charges of the park, the prospective purchaser may provide evidence of additional financial assets to the park and the park must consider any such submission making its determination.
COMMENTS
- The unique circumstances of mobilehomes
Mobilehomes situated in mobilehome parks present unique housing concerns. The homeowner owns the mobilehome, the park owns the land underneath, and, in spite of their names, mobilehomes are extremely difficult, if not impossible, to move.
To address these unique circumstances, a special body of laws has developed, known collectively as the Mobilehome Residency Law (MRL). This bill addresses three aspects of the MRL: provisions regarding sharing a mobilehome with a companion; provisions regarding what happens when a mobilehome is destroyed by a natural disaster and subsequently rebuilt, and provisions regarding parks’ procedures for approving or denying the sale of mobilehomes in the park to prospective purchasers. Each is discussed, in turn, below.
a. Provisions regarding companions
In 2017, California enacted SB 147 (Dodd, Ch. 767, Stats. 2017), regarding the circumstances in which a mobilehome owner could invite others to live with them on an indefinite basis. The law struck a deliberate balance. On the one hand, many Californians are in need of a place to live and many homeowners could use the help of a cohabitant to cover expenses. On the other hand, allowing homeowners to sublet to an unlimited number of housemates would have strained the parks’ capacities and placed an unfair burden on park owners. SB 147’s compromise was to allow homeowners living alone to invite just one other person at a time to live with them – a companion – at no additional charge from the park.
The idea was to allow for long-term cohabitation. To prevent perpetual turnover, SB 147 limited homeowners to naming just one companion per calendar year, with the only exception that the homeowner could name a subsequent companion in the same year if the first one died. The proponents of this bill state that, in practice, this restriction has turned out to be overly restrictive. Companions move out for many different reasons: for example there may be a break-up, a change in job, an illness, tensions with the homeowner, or the companion may be unable to pay their portion of the expenses. Regardless of the reason, once the companion moves out, the homeowner is stuck with all of the expenses and unable to replace the companion, except in the case of the companion’s death, for the rest of the year.
To respond to this problem, this bill would expand the number of companions that a mobilehome owner could have in a calendar year from one to three. This number would still prevent the possibility of constant turnover, without forcing mobilehome owners living alone to wait a year to replace a companion who has moved out.
The author’s intention is that parks cannot charge a mobilehome anything for having a companion, regardless of whether the companion is the first, second, or third companion designated in the year. To prevent any possible interpretation of the bill to the contrary, the author proposes to amend the bill in Committee to further clarify that point.
b. Provisions regarding return in the wake of a natural disaster
California’s recent, unprecedented spate of wildfires has struck the urban-wildland interface especially hard. Many mobilehome parks are located in these areas and many mobilehome parks have been destroyed as a result. Under existing California law, the destruction of the mobilehome park renders the lease agreement void: the park resident’s duty to pay rent is extinguished, but so is any right to return, even if the park gets rebuilt.
This bill would create a procedure, applicable only when a natural disaster destroys a mobilehome park and the park owner decides to rebuild it, giving the former residents an opportunity to return to the park on substantially the same terms, should they elect to do so.
As it appears in print, the bill’s “opportunity to return” provision simply states that, before offering tenancies to the general public, the park must offer tenancies to the former residents and wait 180 days to hear back. Left unaddressed is how the notice would be communicated to the former residents. In addition, the bill in print can be criticized for forcing park owners to wait 180 days even in circumstances where there are more available spaces than former residents who might return or where it is clear that the resident has no intention to return. Finally, the bill does not address sales of mobilehome units themselves, which might well be done by the mobilehome park itself, and which could be used, absent rules to the contrary, as a way to prevent former residents from exercising their option to return through targeted pricing.
To address these narrow concerns, the author proposes to offer amendments in Committee that would: (1) specify how notice of the opportunity to return is to be communicated to the former residents; and (2) allow parks to offer tenancies to the general public at any time, so long as the number of remaining spaces available does not exceed the number of potential returnees. The author may wish to consider additional amendments going forward, that would shorten the time that former residents have to exercise their option to return and prevent parks from discriminating against returning residents in the pricing of any mobilehome sales.
Opponents of the bill express a broader concern, however. Park owners may not be incentivized to rebuild parks if they know that they will be restricted to charging substantially the same rental rates as they were charging prior to the destruction of the park. As the California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance puts it:
In a circumstance where a park is destroyed by a fire or other natural disaster, the parkowner will likely face substantial financial hardships to rebuild the park. […] While many parks will be insured to cover lost income and new construction costs, there is no predicting if insurance will cover the full cost to rebuild the park. [...] Also residents will be moving back into a brand-new park, with new utilities, a club house, and other facilities making the park a more attractive place to live and worthy of increased rent.
Since the purpose behind the bill is to try to maintain pre- and post-disaster affordable housing in the form of mobilehome residences, this criticism of the bill may be significant. The idea of giving residents displaced by natural disaster the opportunity to return is attractive. Yet, if the imposition of an option to return on the same lease terms might lead some parks not to rebuild at all, that impact could run contrary to the bill’s purpose.
c. Provisions regarding financial ability to pay determinations
The unique nature of mobilehome properties creates complex dynamics when a homeowner is ready to sell the mobilehome and move out of the park. Theoretically, the homeowner could simply move the mobilehome out of the park. As a practical matter, this is rarely a physical possibility and frequently cost prohibitive. Consequently, in order to move out of the park, homeowners almost always have to sell their mobilehomes. Unlike selling residential property in other contexts, however, it is not just a matter of finding a willing buyer. In the mobilehome context there is another interested party, park management, from whom the new owner will be renting the space on which the mobilehome sits. Understandably, therefore, the park wants some say in the selection of the buyer.
To further complicate matters, park management has potentially more at stake than just whether or not the prospective purchaser will pay the space rent and make a good member of the park community. If the selling homeowner is unable to sell the mobilehome, then that homeowner may have to abandon it to the park, either through a discounted sale or the imposition of a warehouse lien. The park can then turn around and sell the mobilehome itself, often at a tidy profit. This means that mobilehome park management has both a legitimate interest in screening prospective buyers for mobilehomes within their parks, as well as a potentially more nefarious interest in preventing sale of the mobilehome altogether.
The MRL deals with this tricky set of dynamics by giving mobilehome parks the right to approve or disapprove of prospective buyers seeking to purchase mobilehomes within their parks, but placing certain limitations on that right. Specifically, under existing law, mobilehome parks can exercise veto power over prospective buyers, but they are only supposed to do so when there is evidence, based on past tenancies, that the prospective buyer is likely to break park rules or when the prospective purchaser lacks the financial ability to pay the monthly space rent, utilities, and any other costs of staying at the park. (Civ. Code § 798.74.)
The trouble is that “financial ability to pay” is not defined anywhere in the MRL. With a strong incentive to block prospective purchasers, unscrupulous park managers can take advantage of this vague standard. By demanding more and more documents or simply setting an absurdly high bar for what it means to have the financial ability to pay, these park managers can effectively sabotage any chance that the mobilehome gets sold, forcing the homeowner to abandon it to the park.
To address this problem, this bill, as the author proposes to amend it, would set forth a process for determining whether a prospective mobilehome purchaser has the financial ability to pay to stay in the park. The park would retain the right to approve or reject a proposed buyer, but a prospective purchaser would be presumed to have the financial ability to pay under any of the following scenarios: (1) the prospective purchaser’s average income for the last three months was more than three times the monthly space rent, utility charges, and fees for the park; (2) the prospective purchaser has pre-qualified for a loan to purchase the mobilehome; or (3) the prospective purchaser’s credit score meets or exceeds the standard that the park generally applies for approving tenancies. If the prospective purchaser did not qualify based on one of these presumptions, the park would have to give the prospective purchaser the option of providing additional financial information to demonstrate an ability to pay.
To ensure that park managers are not constantly moving the goalposts on prospective purchasers, the bill would also require the parks to provide prospective purchasers and the homeowner seeking to sell, upon request, with a list of the documentation that the park will require of the prospective purchaser during the approval process as well as the standards that the park will apply.
Finally, to make certain that parks comply with this process, the bill provides that parks are liable to the prospective purchaser and seller for any damages caused if the park fails to follow it.
The virtue of the process and standards set forth in the bill is twofold. First, it should greatly reduce the ability of unscrupulous parks to abuse the vague “financial ability to pay” standard to force homeowners to abandon their mobilehome – often the one asset they have – to the parks. Second, by clarifying the standard and setting forth a clear and simple process for making the determination, the bill should cut down on legal disputes when homeowners seek approval from the park to sell their mobilehomes. Viewed from the park owner and manager’s perspective, however, this simplification and clarification reduces the discretion they have to pick and choose who will move into the park, which they may dislike.
In response, the proponents of the bill note that the financial ability to pay standard was always intended to limit parks’ discretion to stand in the way of mobilehome sales for arbitrary or self-serving reasons. The existing standard is simply too vague to achieve that purpose, especially in the hands of unscrupulous park operators with an incentive to block sales in order to seize ownership of the mobilehome themselves.
2. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill that would:
- clarify that parks may not charge homeowners for any companion, whether the first, second, or third one designated in any calendar year;
- elaborate on the procedures associated with the option for return provided to mobilehome residents displaced by destruction of a park in a natural disaster;
- create a default standard for determining financial ability to pay in the context of a park’s authority to approve or deny the sale of a mobilehome that will remain within the park to a prospective purchaser; and
- specify the procedures through which parks make a determination of whether to approve or deny the sale of a mobilehome that will remain within the park to a prospective purchaser.
The specific amendments are as follows:
Amendment 1
On page 3, in line 39, strike out “shall, before offering”, strike out line 40, on page 4, strike out line 1, in line 2, strike out “refusal for” and insert:
shall offer
Amendment 2
On page 4, strike out line 3, in line 4, strike out “tenancy” and insert:
park to all previous homeowners. The offer for the renewed tenancy shall be
Amendment 3
On page 4, in line 4, after “on” insert:
substantially
Amendment 4
On page 4, in line 4, strike out “homeowner’s”
Amendment 5
On page 4, in line 4, after “previous” insert:
homeowner’s
Amendment 6
On page 4, in line 6, after the period insert:
The offer shall clearly state when it expires.
Amendment 7
On page 4, strike out lines 7 to 9, inclusive, and insert:
(b) Management shall make the offer by mailing it to the last postal address for the previous homeowner known to management, which may be the previous homeowner’s former address within the park. If management has an email address or telephone number for the previous homeowner, management shall additionally attempt to notify the homeowner of the offer by those means.
(c) The offer of a renewed tenancy shall run until rejected by the previous homeowner in writing, or at least 180 days after management complies with subdivision (b), whichever comes first.
(d) Management shall not enter into any other tenancy agreements for the rebuilt park unless the number of available tenancies in the rebuilt park exceeds the number of outstanding renewal tenancy offers made pursuant to subdivision (a) that have not expired or been rejected.
Amendment 8
On page 4, in line 10, strike out “(c)” and insert:
(e)
Amendment 9
On page 4, in line 15, after the first “a” insert:
prospective
Amendment 10
On page 4, strike out lines 16 to 21, inclusive, and in line 22, strike out “regulations of the”
Amendment 11
On page 4, between lines 22 and 23, insert:
(b)(1) A selling homeowner or their agent shall give notice of a sale of a mobilehome that will remain in the park to management before the close of the sale.
(2) Management shall provide the seller and the prospective purchaser both of the following, in writing, upon receiving the notice required in paragraph (1):
(A) The standards that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application, including the minimum reported credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency that management requires for approval.
(B) A list of all documentation that management will require to determine if the prospective purchaser will qualify for tenancy in the park.
(c) Management shall not withhold approval from a prospective purchase of a mobilehome unless any of the following apply:
(1) Management reasonably determines that, based upon the purchaser’s prior tenancies, they will not comply with the rules and regulations of the park.
(2) The purchaser does not have the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park.
(3) The purchaser has committed fraud, deceit, or concealment of material facts during the application process.
(d) It shall be presumed that a prospective purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) if any of the following are satisfied:
(1) The prospective purchaser’s average gross monthly income during the three months immediately preceding submission of the application is at least three times greater than the combined monthly rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park for the mobilehome space.
(2) The prospective purchaser has prequalified for loan financing for the mobilehome being purchased by them.
(3) The prospective purchaser’s reported credit score from a consumer credit reporting agency meets or exceeds the minimum that management customarily utilizes to approve a tenancy application.
Amendment 12
On page 4, in line 23, strike out “(b)(1)” and insert:
(e)
Amendment 13
On page 4, in line 23, after the first “the” insert:
prospective
Amendment 14
On page 4, in line 24, strike out “park,” and insert:
park pursuant to paragraph(2) of subdivision (c),
Amendment 15
On page 4, in line 24, after “management” insert:
may require the prospective purchaser to document the amount and source of their gross monthly income or means of financial support. However, management
Amendment 16
On page 4, in line 25, after “the” insert:
prospective
Amendment 17
On page 4, in line 25, strike out “copies” and insert:
any of the following:
(1) Documentation beyond that disclosed pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (b).
(2) Copies
Amendment 18
On page 4, in line 26, strike out “returns in order to obtain approval for residency in the”, strike out lines 27 to 29, inclusive, and insert:
returns.
Amendment 19
On page 4, strike out lines 30 to 33, inclusive, and insert:
(f)(1) Within 15 business days of receiving all of the information requested from the prospective purchaser, management shall notify the seller and the prospective purchaser, in writing, of either acceptance or rejection of the application. During this 15-day period, the prospective purchaser shall comply with the management’s request, if any, for a personal interview.
(2)(A) If management rejects the application, management shall state the reason for the rejection in accordance with subdivision (c). If the rejection is based upon an alleged lack of financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park, as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), the prospective purchaser may elect to provide additional financial or asset information to management to demonstrate their financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park. For purposes of this paragraph, “additional financial information” includes, but is not limited to, the following:
Amendment 20
On page 4, in line 34, strike out “(A)” and insert:
(1)
Amendment 21
On page 4, in line 35, strike out “(B)” and insert:
(2)
Amendment 22
On page 4, in line 36, strike out “(C)” and insert:
(3)
Amendment 23
On page 4, in line 37, strike out “(D)” and insert:
(4)
Amendment 24
On page 4, in line 38, strike out “(E)” and insert:
(5)
Amendment 25
On page 4, in line 39, strike out “(F)” and insert:
(6)
Amendment 26
On page 5, strike out lines 1 to 25, inclusive, and insert:
(B) If the prospective purchaser elects to provide additional financial and asset information specified in subparagraph (A), management shall consider the information together with the prospective purchaser’s gross monthly income to determine whether the purchaser has the financial ability to pay the rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park.
Amendment 27
On page 5, in line 27, strike out “(e)” and insert:
(g)
Amendment 28
On page 5, below line 38, insert:
(h)(1) Management may be held liable by the selling homeowner, prospective purchaser, or both, for any and all damages proximately caused by management’s failure to comply with this section.
(2) If it is proven that management withheld approval from a prospective purchaser when the purchaser has established financial ability to pay the combined rent, estimated utilities, and other charges of the park pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), and the purchaser was not rejected pursuant to paragraph (1) or (3) of subdivision (c), management shall be presumed to be in willful violation of this section and the damaged selling homeowner shall be entitled to an award of the penalty amount set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 798.86, in addition to any other consequential damages awarded to the selling homeowner as the prevailing party in any civil action.
(i) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Charges” means all charges authorized and imposed by management under Section 798.31.
(2) “Consumer credit reporting agency” has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 1785.3.
(3) “Credit score” has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1.
3. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
The effect of the Baby Boom population on housing needs is exacerbating the scarcity of affordable housing in California. Statewide, the number of impoverished residents aged 65 and older increased by 85 percent, to roughly 520,000 between 1999 and 2014, more than double the rate of population growth among the elderly (Sacramento Bee: Poverty Rate Jumps Among California Seniors-March 26, 2016). For low-income seniors on fixed incomes, a lack of affordable housing can lead to loss of independence and higher costs to the public due to increased need for emergency healthcare or placement in nursing homes (California Housing Partnership Corporations: Update on California’s Affordable Housing Crisis-April 2015).
This bill seeks to protect this important source of affordable housing by increasing protections for mobilehome residents and those who desire to reside in a mobilehome park. This bill clarifies when a mobilehome resident who lives alone can have a companion, after wildfires it allows tenants the first opportunity to move into a rebuilt mobilehome park, and allows for expansion of assets that park management may consider in determining ability to pay for a space in a mobilehome park.
In support, the Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League writes:
The bill clarifies that a homeowner who lives alone could have, free of any fees, one companion and up to two other replacement companions in a calendar year should any one companion leave due to family circumstances, sickness or death.
The bill also protects homeowners who choose to sell their home from park owner interference in the sale by allowing a potential purchaser to demonstrate their ability to pay rent similar to other traditional affordable housing. Currently many homeowners and residents are finding themselves trying to meet a threshold greater than what lenders are requiring for a home loan.
Finally, given the devastation and displacement of homeowners caused by the fires and other natural disasters, the bill offers the right of first refusal to homeowners, and their park space, at their original lease terms, if a park owner chooses to rebuild the park.
4. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance writes:
[w]hile we understand the author’s intent and share sympathy with anyone who loses their home in a fire or other natural disaster, it is unreasonable to require a mobilehome parkowner to guarantee a home owner tenancy in a newly rebuilt park at the same rent. […] Ultimately, the parkowners and residents should be allowed to negotiate a right of first refusal as well as the terms.
SUPPORT
Golden State Manufactured-Home Owners League
Ventura County Board of Supervisors
One individual
OPPOSITION
California Mobilehome Parkowners Alliance
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 147 (Dodd, Ch. 767, Stats. 2017) allowed a person living alone in a mobilehome to share the mobilehome with one other companion at no charge from the park. The bill limited each mobilehome to one companion per calendar year, except in the event of the companion’s death.
AB 2026 (Stone, 2014) would have limited mobilehome parks to rejecting prospective purchasers based on financial grounds only, and would have deemed a loan approval or income of over three times the monthly rent and park fees sufficient proof of financial ability to pay, among other things. AB 2026 failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
SB 1107 (Correa, Ch. 170, Stats. 2008) allowed a mobilehome owner of any age to have a live-in caretaker at no additional charge from the park, upon presentation of a doctor’s note verifying the need for the caretaker.
AB 624 (Lieber, 2003) would have restricted mobilehome parks’ authority to reject a prospective purchaser on the basis of lack of financial ability to pay, if the prospective purchaser could demonstrative income that is three times the sum of the monthly rent, utilities, and fees plus the loan payment on the mobilehome. AB 624 failed passage on the Assembly Floor.
**************
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):