SB 275: Health Care and Essential Workers: personal protective equipment.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-29
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 29, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 301, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 29, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 8.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Assembly Rule 69(d) suspended. (Ayes 57. Noes 15. Page 5408.) |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Joint Rule 61(b)(17) suspended. (Ayes 59. Noes 16. Page 5275.) |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (August 20). |
| Aug 18, 2020 | August 18 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 30, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (July 29). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Jun 29, 2020 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on L. & E. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 29). Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 17, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 13, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jan 6, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | July 9 set for first hearing.Testimony taken. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| May 2, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 1). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 19, 2019 | Set for hearing April 1. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | Unfinished Business SB275 Pan et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2020 | SB 275 Pan Senate Third Reading By Gonzalez | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 29, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
|
| Jun 29, 2020 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Labor and Employment] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB275 Pan | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 1, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 275
Author:(Pan and Leyva)
As Amended Ver:August 30, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires the Department of Public Health (CDPH) to establish a personal protective equipment (PPE) stockpile for health care workers and essential workers in the state and requires health care employers, as specified, to establish a PPE inventory that is sufficient for at least 45 days of surge consumption.
Major Provisions
State Stockpile
- Defines "essential worker" as primary and secondary school workers, workers at detention facilities, in-home support providers, childcare providers, government workers whose work with the public continues throughout the crisis, and workers in other positions as determined by the State Public Health Officer or the Director of Office of Emergency Services (OES).
- Defines "health care worker" as any worker who provides direct patient care and services directly supporting patient care, including, but not limited to, physicians, pharmacists, clinicians, nurses, aides, technicians, janitorial and housekeeping staff, food services workers, and nonmanagerial administrative staff.
- Defines "personal protective equipment" or "PPE" as protective equipment for eyes, face, head, and extremities, protective clothing, respiratory devices, and protective shields, and barriers.
- Requires CDPH and OES to establish, within one year of the effective date, a PPE stockpile for all health care workers and essential workers in the state, upon appropriation and as necessary.
- Requires CDPH to establish guidelines for procurement, management, and distribution of PPE and, in doing so, shall consider the recommendations of the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee and a number of additional factors, including, but not limited to, the various types of PPE required, the shelf life of that PPE, the amount of PPE that would be required for all health care workers and essential workers in the state during a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency, guidance on how to define essential workers, and geographical distribution of PPE storage.
- Establishes the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee, consisting of fifteen members appointed by the Director of OES, as specified, and required to make recommendations to CDPH and OES to assist in developing guidelines for procurement, management, and distribution of PPE.
Health Care Employer Inventory
- Defines "health care employer" as a person or organization that employs workers in the public or private sector to provide direct patient care in a general acute care hospital setting, a skilled nursing facility, a medical practice that is operated or maintained as part of an integrated health system or health facility, or a licensed dialysis clinic.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) and CDPH to adopt regulations setting requirements for determining 45-day surge capacity levels for health care employer inventories and provide that these regulations shall not establish policies or standards that are less protective or prescriptive than any federal, state, or local law on PPE standards.
- Provides that beginning on January 1, 2023, or 365 days after regulations setting health care employer inventory are adopted, whichever is later, health care employers must have an inventory of PPE sufficient for at least 45 days of surge consumption.
- Provides that a health care employer who violates the requirement to maintain an inventory of PPE is subject to a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation.
- Provides that a health care employer shall provide an inventory of its PPE to the Division of Occupational Safety and Health upon request and an employer who violates this provision is subject to a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation.
- Provides that health care employers, except for general acute care hospitals and skilled nursing facilities, may apply for a waiver if the facility has 25 or fewer employees and the employer agrees to close in-person operations during a public health emergency until sufficient PPE becomes available to return to in-person operations.
- Provides that if a health care employer's inventory falls below the mandated level of supply because it distributed PPE to health care workers during a state of emergency, the health care employer shall not be subject to a civil penalty for 30 days provided the health care employer replenishes its inventory to the mandated level within 30 days.
- Provides that DIR may exempt a health care employer from being assessed a civil penalty if it determines that supply chain limitations or issues beyond the employer’s control make meeting the mandated level of supplies infeasible and the healthcare employer has made a reasonable attempt to obtain PPE.
COMMENTS:
See Assembly Labor and Employment Committee analysis.
According to the Author:
"One of the hard-learned lessons of the COVID-19 pandemic is the need for a well-managed supply of personal protective equipment (PPE) to keep California's healthcare workforce and other essential workers safe. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed California's failure to adequately plan and prepare for a pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE, such as respirators, surgical masks, and gowns left healthcare workers vulnerable to infection and death in hospitals and nursing homes. The shortage of PPE also left other essential workers without necessary protection, with outbreaks occurring in settings such as grocery stores and prisons. Communities of color are overrepresented in essential jobs and have suffered high infection rates. By definition, a pandemic affects multiple countries, which makes it especially difficult to procure needed supplies in the midst of an emergency. The U.S. stockpile held only a fraction of the amount of PPE necessary to protect workers. While some domestic suppliers quickly ramped up manufacturing, shortages persist and have led to dramatic cost increases. In order to protect lives in a pandemic, California must establish strategic stockpiles and in-state PPE manufacturing capability to avoid price gouging when replenishing PPE supplies. SB 275 creates a reliable supply of PPE to ensure healthcare workers, essential workers, and the public at large are protected during the next health emergency."
Arguments in Support:
SEIU California, sponsor of the bill, argues "California and health care employers failed to prepare for a crisis of the magnitude of the COVID-19 pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE left health care workers vulnerable to infection and death, with some resorting to using handmade PPE like bandanas and trash bags. The lack of PPE also harms patients who come into contact with potentially exposed workers or through cross-contamination through the reuse of PPE…
The many attempts to obtain PPE during the crisis exposed significant flaws in PPE supply chains. Overseas suppliers diverted PPE to their own countries' needs or stopped production due to the effects of the pandemic. . . . Given the high cost of trying to procure PPE during an emergency, it is prudent and most cost-effective to prepare for a crisis before it happens. California needs a state-centered supply of PPE to protect workers and residents…
Unfortunately, because California was not prepared, we have had many health care and essential workers die from COVID-19. Many of these cases could have been prevented by merely providing workers with the protective equipment required by law. This bill takes the critical step of ensuring that all health care employers and essential workers have access to PPE. Simply put, this bill will save lives."
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Children's Hospital Association (CCHA) argues in opposition "[e]mergency preparedness rests with Health and Human Services. The bill proposes to split the responsibility for PPE levels between the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), for the state stockpile, and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), for health care employer inventory. This will likely lead to conflicting or inconsistent guidance. The DIR, through Cal/OSHA, currently enforces the most stringent employee health and safety regulations in the country. Those regulations dictate how PPE should be used and in what circumstances. However, CDPH is responsible for the state's emergency preparedness, including how much PPE should be maintained.
The bill correctly places the state's stockpile management and oversight under CDPH. For the same reasons, health care employer inventories should be overseen by CDPH because they are a critical aspect of emergency preparedness."
The California Association of Health Facilities has taken an oppose unless amended position with the following concerns:
- "Proposed fines are exorbitant and overly burdensome to long term care facilities. . . . The $25,000 fine is per violation is extremely punitive and unreasonable for facilities with majority Med-Cal residents. These significant fines would redirect needed funding away from patient care."
"Timeline is unrealistic due to the current pandemic. SB 275 requires a massive stockpile for both the state and facilities."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM RULES: 7-0-5
YES: Cooley, Carrillo, Flora, Grayson, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cunningham, Kamlager, Maienschein, Ramos, Wicks
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-4-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Megan Dahle, Fong, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 30, 2020
CONSULTANT: Justin Delacruz / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0003590
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 275 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 275
Author: Pan (D) and Leyva (D), et al.
Amended: 8/30/20
Vote: 21
PRIOR SENATE VOTES NOT RELEVANT
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Not available
SUBJECT: Health Care and Essential Workers: personal protective equipment
SOURCE: SEIU State Council
DIGEST:
This bill requires the Department of Public Health (DPH) and the Office of Emergency Services (OES) to establish a personal protective equipment (PPE) stockpile, and requires certain health care employers, including hospitals and skilled nursing facilities (SNFs), to maintain an inventory of PPE at least sufficient for 45 days of surge consumption, effective on January 1, 2023, or one year after regulations are adopted defining 45 days of surge consumption, whichever is later.
Assembly Amendments
delete the contents of the bill passed by the Senate, which had to do with the practice of psychology, and add the current contents of this bill relating to PPE.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates health facilities by the DPH, including general acute care hospitals and SNFs. [HSC §1250, et seq.]
- Establishes the California Emergency Services Act, which provides the Governor with broad powers to declare local and state emergencies, and to coordinate all emergency services functions for the mitigation of the effects of an emergency in California. [GOV §8550, et seq.]
- Establishes the OES, and requires OES to be responsible for the state’s emergency and disaster response services for natural, technological, or manmade disasters and emergencies, including responsibility for activities necessary to prevent, respond to, recover from, and mitigate the effect of emergencies and disasters to people and property. [GOV §8585]
- Establishes the California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973, to assure safe and healthful working conditions for all California workers. To this end, authorizes the enforcement of effective standards, the encouragement of employers to maintain safe and healthful working conditions and the furthering of research, training and education in the field of occupational safety and health. [LAB §6300, et seq.]
- Orders every employer to furnish a place of employment that is safe and healthful for the employees therein. [LAB §6400]
- Orders every employer to furnish and use safety devices, as well as adopt practices and methods, which reasonably render employment and a place of employment safe and healthful. Requires an employer to do everything reasonably necessary to protect the life, safety, and health of employees. [LAB §6401, 6403]
- Requires that an employer ensure that employees are instructed in the use of protective equipment in accordance with the manufacturer’s instructions and maintain required protective equipment in a safe, sanitary condition. [CCR Title 8 §3380]
- Requires employers to assess their workplace to determine if hazards are present or are likely to be present that would necessitate the use of PPE. Requires that an employer record which workplace was assessed, what person certified the assessment, and the date of the assessment. [CCR Title 8 §3380]
- Requires an employer who has determined that a workplace contains hazards to provide training for their employees including when PPE is necessary, what PPE is necessary, how to properly adjust and wear PPE, the limitations of PPE and the proper care, and useful life and proper disposal method for the PPE. Requires employers to ensure that all employees are trained before an employee undertakes hazardous work and to certify in writing that each employee has received and understood training in PPE. [CCR Title 8 §3380]
- Requires each of the following types of employer to provide all safeguards, including provision of PPE, respirators, training, and medical services, at no cost to the employee, at a reasonable time and place for the employee, and during the employee's working hours: [CCR Title 8 §5199]
- Hospitals;
- SNFs;
- Clinics, medical offices, and other outpatient medical facilities;
- Facilities where high hazard procedures are performed;
- Home health care;
- Long term health care facilities and hospices;
- Medical outreach services;
- Paramedic and emergency medical services including these services when provided by firefighters and other emergency responders; and,
- Medical transport.
This bill:
Health and Safety Code Provisions Related to the State Stockpile
- Defines “essential workers” as primary and secondary school workers, workers at detention facilities, in-home support providers, childcare providers, government workers whose work with the public continues throughout a crisis, and workers in other positions that the State Public Health Officer or the Director of OES deems vital to public health and safety, as well as economic and national security.
- Defines “health care worker” as any worker who provides direct patient care and services directly supporting patient care, including, but not limited, to physicians, pharmacists, clinicians, nurses, aides, technicians, janitorial and housekeeping staff, food services workers, and nonmanagerial administrative staff.
- Defines “PPE” as protective equipment for eyes, face, head, and extremities, protective clothing, respiratory devices, and protective shields and barriers, including, but not limited to, N95 and other filtering facepiece respirators, elastomeric air-purifying respirators with appropriate particulate filters or cartridges, powered air purifying respirators, disinfecting and sterilizing devices and supplies, medical gowns and apparel, face masks, surgical masks, face shields, gloves, shoe coverings, and the equipment identified by or otherwise necessary to comply specified regulations.
- Requires, within one year of the effective date of this bill, DPH and OES, in coordination with other state agencies, to establish a PPE stockpile, upon appropriation and as necessary.
- Requires DPH to establish guidelines for procurement, management, and distribution of PPE, and requires these guidelines, at a minimum, to take into account all of the following:
- The various types of PPE that may be required during a pandemic or other health emergency;
- The shelf life of each type of PPE that may be obtained from DPH and how to restock a portion of each type of PPE to ensure the procurements consist of unexpired PPE;
- The amount of each type of PPE that would be required for all health care workers and essential workers in the state during a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency;
- Lessons learned from previous pandemics and state emergencies, including but not limited to, supply procurement, management, and distribution;
- Guidance on how to define essential workers based upon different hazards;
- Geographical distribution of PPE storage;
- Guidance on how to establish policies and standards for PPE surge capacity to ensure that workers have access to an adequate supply of PPE during a pandemic or other health emergency;
- The policies and funding that would be required for the state to establish a PPE stockpile; and,
- How distribution from any procurement is to be prioritized in the event that there is insufficient PPE to meet the needs of health care providers or employers of essential workers, including consideration of specified factors, including location in a medically underserved area, or in a county with a high infection rate.
- Prohibits the development of the guidelines in 5) above from establishing policies or standards that are less protective or prescriptive than any federal, state, or local law on PPE standards.
- Establishes the PPE Advisory Committee to make recommendation to OES and DPH necessary to develop the guidelines in 5) above, and requires the PPE Advisory Committee to consist of the following:
- One representative each of the following associations: an association representing multiple types of hospitals and health systems; an association representing SNFs; association representing primary care clinics; and an association representing physicians;
- Two representatives of labor organizations that represent health care workers, and two representatives of labor organizations that represent essential workers;
- One representative from the PPE manufacturing industry;
- One consumer representative;
- One representative from an association representing counties; and,
- One representative each from DPH, OES, the Emergency Medical Services Authority, and the Department of Social Services.
Labor Code Provisions Related to Requirements on Certain Health Employers
- Defines a “health care employer” as a person or organization that employs workers in the public or private sector to provide direct patient care in a general acute care hospital setting, a SNF, a medical practice that is operated or maintained as part of an integrated health system or health facility, or a dialysis clinic. Excludes from this definition an independent medical practice that is owned and operated, or maintained as a clinic or office, by one or more licensed physicians and used as an office for the practice of their profession, within the scope of their license, regardless of the name used publicly to identify the place or establishment unless the medical practice is operated or maintained exclusively as part of an integrated health system or health facility or meets the requirements of a medical foundation, as specified.
- Requires a health care employer to maintain an inventory of unexpired PPE, at least sufficient for 45 days of surge consumption, for use in the event of a state of emergency declaration by the Governor, or a local emergency for a pandemic or other health emergency. Requires PPE in the inventory to be new and not previously worn or used. Requires the inventory to take effect on January 1, 2023, or one year after regulations specified in 12) below are adopted, whichever is later.
- Exempts health care employers from the requirement to maintain an inventory of 45 days of surge consumption if the health care employer provides services in a facility or other setting controlled or owned by another health care employer that is obligated to maintain a PPE inventory.
- Permits a health care employer, with the exception of hospitals, to apply to the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) for a waiver of some or all of the PPE requirements, if the facility has 25 or fewer employees and the employer agrees to close in-person operations during a public health emergency in which increased use of PPE is recommended by the public health officer until sufficient PPE becomes available to return to in-person operations.
- Requires DIR, by regulation and in consultation with DPH, to set forth requirements for determining 45-day surge capacity levels for health care employer inventory, including, but not limited to, the types and amount of PPE to be maintained by the health care employer based on the type and size of each health care employer as well as the composition of health care workers in its workforce. Requires the regulations to require each health care employer to maintain sufficient PPE for all health care workers. Requires the regulations to consider the recommendations of the PPE Advisory Committee.
- Prohibits the regulations in 12) above from establishing policies or standards that are less protective or prescriptive than any federal, state, or local law on PPE standards.
- Requires a health care employer to provide an inventory of its PPE to DIR upon request.
- Establishes a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation by an employer who violates the requirement to maintain the inventory of PPE, or the requirement to provide an inventory of its PPE to DIR.
- Exempts a health care employer from the civil penalty if the PPE inventory dips below the mandated level of supplies as a result of the distribution of PPE to health care workers during an emergency, if the employer replenishes its inventory to the mandated level within 30 days. Permits DIR to exempt a health care employer from the civil penalty if it determines that supply chain limitations make meeting the mandated level of supplies infeasible and a health care employer has made a reasonable attempt to obtain PPE, or if the health care employer makes a showing that meeting the mandated level of supplies is not possible due to issues beyond their control, such as if the equipment was ordered from a manufacturer or distributor but the order was not fulfilled, or if the equipment was damaged or stolen.
- Requires a health care employer, consistent with existing law, to supply appropriate PPE to its health care workers, ensure that its health care workers use the PPE supplied to them, and provide appropriate PPE to its health care workers upon their request. States that this provision is declaratory of existing law.
- Makes the provisions of this bill severable, such that if any provision of this act is held invalid, that invalidity does not affect other provisions that can be given effect without the invalid provision.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the COVID-19 pandemic exposed California’s failure to adequately plan and prepare for a pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE, such as respirators, surgical masks, and gowns, left health care workers vulnerable to infection and death in hospitals and nursing homes. Some workers relied on makeshift PPE, using materials like bandanas and trash bags to provide protection against infection. The lack of PPE also harms patients who come into contact with potentially exposed workers or by cross contamination from the reuse of PPE. According to DPH, as of August 24th, local health departments have reported 30,577 confirmed positive cases in health care workers and 145 deaths statewide. The Healthcare and Essential Workers Protection Act ensures that health care workers, first responders, school employees, child care workers and other essential workers have equitable access to PPE in the event of a pandemic or other health emergency. This bill achieves this by establishing a PPE stockpile at DPH for essential workers, and by requiring healthcare providers such as hospitals and nursing homes to maintain their own stockpile sufficient for 45 days of a pandemic emergency.
- August 2020 report on benefit of a state stockpile. Earlier this month, the UC Berkeley School of Public Health and the UC Berkeley Labor Center jointly published a paper entitled “Economic and Health Benefits of a PPE Stockpile.” According to the key findings of this report, procuring an adequate PPE stockpile in advance at non-pandemic prices would cost only 17% of the projected amount needed to procure it at current pandemic-inflated prices. Further, maintaining the stockpile would be cheaper than real-time purchases even if it was not needed for another 35 years, and even if we were fortunate enough to not need the stockpile for longer than that, it would be a highly financially prudent form of insurance. This report also found that health care access was severely affected in the early months of the COVID-19 pandemic, with 251,100 California health care workers receiving unemployment benefits, in part due to the lack of adequate PPE. The paper found that for every week earlier that this number of workers could return to work in the next pandemic if PPE were readily available at the start, the state could save approximately $93 million in unemployment insurance payments. Finally, the paper found that more than 50,000 health care and other essential workers in California have likely tested positive for COVID-19, and that the available research on COVID-19 to-date suggests that adequate and appropriate use of PPE can largely mitigate the spread of COVID-19 among healthcare workers. The report stated that it conservatively estimated that at least 20,860 essential worker-related COVID-19 cases may have been avoidable if proper PPE had been available, likely avoiding dozens of deaths.
- Taiwan model. According to a 2017 article published in Health Security entitled “Stockpile Model of Personal Protective Equipment in Taiwan,” the Taiwan Centers for Disease Control (CDC) has established a three-tier PPE stockpiling framework to maintain a minimum stockpile for the surge demand of PPE in the early stage of a pandemic. Following the SARS epidemic in 2003, in which the insufficient supply of medical masks resulted in fear and decreased willingness to work among frontline health care workers, a 3-tier stockpiling framework of PPE was established, in which the central government, local health authorities, and medical institutions were each required to maintain a minimum stockpile of PPE to ensure a sufficient supply for epidemic prevention and frontline health care personnel during the early phase of an epidemic. However, during nonepidemic periods, the use of PPE from the central government inventory was relatively limited, thus, most of the PPE remained unused and expired, and needed to be destroyed. To solve this issue, the Taiwan CDC developed a concept of stockpile replacement incorporated with a public-private partnership, including public sectors and private contractors, and employed the principles of logistics, supply chain management, and commercial marketing. In this model, the central authority is regarded as a large reservoir of stocks, and the local health authority and medical institutions are regarded as small reservoirs. The concept is to combine the replacement of the larger reservoir with the consumption of small reservoirs. The oldest stockpile of the large reservoir is regularly replaced and immediately replenished with the same amount of PPE. Meanwhile, the removed stock is circulated into small reservoirs for routine and emergency demand. Through various epidemic events, including H7N9 in 2013, and the avian flu epidemic in 2015, the stockpile was demonstrated to be a reliable and useful tool for domestic emergency response and international cooperation.
- Prior state stockpile initiated under Schwarzenegger Administration. In 2006, citing the threat of avian flu, then-Governor Schwarzenegger announced the state would invest in emergency and disaster preparedness. According to a Los Angeles Times article published on March 27, 2020, the state invested more than $200 million for three mobile hospitals and a related Health Surge Capacity Initiative to stockpile medicines and medical gear for use in outbreaks of infectious disease. In addition to the three 200-bed mobile hospitals, the state purchased 50 million N95 respirators, 2,400 portable ventilators, and kits to set up 21,000 additional patient beds wherever they were needed. However, according to the article, in 2011, in the midst of a recession and plunge in state revenues, the state cut off the money to store and maintain the stockpile of supplies and the mobile hospitals. Much of the medical equipment, including the ventilators, were given to local hospitals and health agencies, and the respirators that weren’t given away or used during wildfires were allowed to expire without being replaced. According to the LA Times, by the time COVID-19 arrived in California, there were 21 million expired N95 masks in the state stockpile. The state released these masks, but stated because they were past their expiration date, they were approved for use only in limited, low-risk circumstances, not for treating patients with COVID-19.
- Letter of concern. The California Hospital Association (CHA), in a letter removing its opposition, states that it shares and appreciates the goals of this bill to bolster the supply and reliability of PPE in California for health care and other essential workers. CHA states that it supports a state stockpile and the creation of a PPE Advisory Committee of relevant stakeholders to provide a thoughtful and deliberative process to inform appropriate requirements for both hospital inventories and the state stockpile. However, CHA is concerned that global PPE supply shortages persist, and that without appropriate flexibility, a stockpile mandate will exacerbate the strain on the existing supply chain and could drive prices even higher. CHA also points out that this pandemic is both a health and economic crisis, and that the cumulative net losses for California hospitals could exceed $22 billion, and argues that we cannot ignore the staggering financial hit to the health care system. CHA states that while this bill considers these issues and takes a more methodical approach to determining the requirements for hospitals to address future emergencies, it is hopeful these issues can be addressed via a stakeholder process.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
Unknown with latest amendments.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/31/20)
SEIU State Council (source)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Asian Americans Advancing Justice - California
Asian Pacific American Labor Alliance
Asian Pacific American Labor Alliance - Alameda County Chapter
Brea Congregational Church
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Health Professional Student Alliance
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Pan - Ethnic Health Network
California Physicians Alliance
California School Employees Association
California State Legislative Board, Smart Transportation Division
Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Harbor Christian Church
Innercity Struggle
LA Voice
Labor Council for Latin American Advancement- Los Angeles Chapter
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
Lumos Transforms
National Congress of Black Women
National Immigration Law Center
New Philadelphia AME Church
Orange Community of Christ
Orange County Poor Peoples Campaign
Peace Benevolence & Justice Ministry
Power California
Proyecto Pastoral
SEIU Asian Pacific Islanders Caucus
The Way Center of Truth, Inc.
Union of American Physicians and Dentists
Western Occupational & Environmental Medical Association
Worksafe
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/31/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by SEIU State Council, which states that the many attempts to obtain PPE during the crisis exposed significant flaws in PPE supply chains. Overseas suppliers diverted PPE to their own countries' needs or stopped production due to the effects of the pandemic. The national stockpile held only a fraction of the amount of PPE necessary to protect workers. While some domestic suppliers quickly ramped up manufacturing, shortages have persisted and led to dramatic cost increases with some markups reaching over 6,000%. Given the high cost of trying to procure PPE during an emergency, it is prudent and more cost-effective to prepare for a crisis before it happens. California needs a state-centered supply of PPE to protect workers and residents. SEIU states that this bill ensures that health care and essential workers have equitable access to PPE in the event of a pandemic or other health emergency by creating a new PPE stockpile at the state level, and by requiring health care providers to keep PPE stockpiles for all workers in a facility. SEIU states it is sponsoring this bill because of its members’ experience during this pandemic and their demand that we have enough PPE so that workers never go without the necessary protective equipment again. Unfortunately, because California was not prepared, many health care and essential workers have died from COVID-19. Many of these cases could have been prevented by providing workers with the PPE required by law. This bill takes the critical step of ensuring that all health care employers and essential workers have access to PPE.
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/31/20 21:54:28
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 275
Author:(Pan and Leyva)
As Amended Ver:August 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires the Department of Public Health (CDPH) to establish a personal protective equipment (PPE) stockpile for health care workers and essential workers in the state that is sufficient for a 45-day pandemic or other health emergency.
Major Provisions
- Provides that the Governor's Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) shall encourage in-state production of PPE.
- Requires CDPH to establish a stockpile of new and unused PPE for health care workers and essential workers in the state that is sufficient for a 45-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- Defines "essential worker" as primary and secondary school workers, workers at detention facilities, in-home support providers, childcare providers, government workers whose work with the public continues throughout the crisis, and workers in other positions as determined by CDPH.
- Defines "health care employer" as a licensed clinic, an office of physicians in a specified group practice, a clinic operated by a 501(c)(3) nonprofit corporation, as specified, an outpatient setting, a health facility, a county medical facility, a home health agency, medical offices that are part of an integrated system or hospital, a rural health clinic, or a federally qualified health center.
- Defines "health care worker" as any worker who provides direct patient care and services directly supporting patient care, including, but not limited to, physicians, pharmacists, clinicians, nurses, aides, technicians, janitorial and housekeeping staff, food services workers, and nonmanagerial administrative staff.
- Defines "personal protective equipment" or "PPE" as protective equipment for eyes, face, head, and extremities, protective clothing, respiratory devices, and protective shields, and barriers.
- Defines “safety net provider” as a health care employer that is a community clinic or free clinic, an intermittent clinic that is operated by a primary care community or free clinic, a tribal clinic operated by a federally recognized Indian tribe or tribal organization, an outpatient setting conducted, maintained, or operated by a federally recognized Indian tribe, tribal organization or urban Indian organization, a rural health clinic, or a federally qualified health center.
- Requires CDPH to create guidelines for the procurement of PPE for the stockpile and for the distribution of PPE from the stockpile.
- Provides that CDPH must procure the first 20% of the stockpile within three years after the effective date of this act and only if the Office of Emergency Services (OES) determines that PPE prices have returned to a normal level.
- Provides that for each year thereafter, CDPH must obtain an additional 20 percent of the stockpile until it has procured 100% of the stockpile.
- Requires that at least 25% of PPE in the stockpile must be manufactured in California and authorizes the Governor to waive this requirement for one year if they determine that the state cannot procure enough PPE to meet this requirement.
- Requires a health care employer, except for a safety net provider, to maintain an inventory of unexpired, unused PPE, according to the following schedule:
- On January 1, 2022, or 60 days after regulations setting health care employer inventory levels are adopted, an amount sufficient for 30 days of surge consumption.
- On January 1, 2023, or 365 days after regulations setting health care employer inventory levels are adopted, an amount sufficient for 45 days of surge consumption.
- Provides that starting six months after regulations setting health care employer inventory levels are adopted or by January 1, 2023, whichever is later, a safety net provider must either have an inventory of PPE that is sufficient for at least 30 days of surge consumption, or demonstrate to DIR that it has entered into a contract with a third-party that can ensure timely access to an inventory of PPE sufficient for at least 30 days of consumption.
- Provides that, on or before January 15, 2021, the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), in consultation with OES, must determine whether there is a significant supply limitation of PPE facing purchasers in California, and if there is such a limitation, revisit this determination every 30 days until there is not a significant supply limitation.
- Provides that if DIR determines there is not a significant supply limitation, beginning 60 days after this determination, general acute hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and skilled nursing facilities must maintain an inventory of PPE equal to at least six months of daily consumption.
- Provides that a health care employer who violates the requirement to maintain an inventory of PPE is subject to a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation, but limits the total amount of civil penalties that may be assessed against a safety net provider to $2,500 per calendar year.
- Provides that health care employers, except for general acute care hospitals, acute psychiatric hospitals, and skilled nursing facilities, may apply for a waiver if the facility has 25 or fewer employees and the employer agrees to close in-person operations during a public health emergency until sufficient PPE becomes available to return to in-person operations.
- Provides that if a health care employer's inventory falls below the mandated level of supply because it distributed PPE to its health care workers during a state of emergency, the health care employer shall not be subject to the civil penalty for 30 days provided the health care employer replenishes its inventory to the mandated level within 30 days.
- Provides that DIR may exempt a health care employer from being assessed a civil penalty if it determines that supply chain limitations make meeting the mandated level of supplies infeasible and the healthcare employer has made a reasonable attempt to obtain PPE.
- Provides that each day a health care employer fails to provide PPE to its health care workers constitutes an independent violation and limits the total amount of civil penalties that may be assessed against a safety net provider for failing to provide PPE to $2,500 per calendar year.
- Requires DIR and CDPH to adopt regulations setting requirements for health care employer inventory, including capacity levels for safety net providers’ inventory.
- Establishes the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee (PPE Advisory Committee), appointed by the Secretary of Labor, to consist of twenty individuals who have experience in health care, public health, workers' rights, or emergency preparedness and to make recommendations to DIR and to CDPH relating to, among other things, surge capacity requirements for health care employers, the type and amount of PPE required for the state stockpile, and guidance on actions the state can take to create a state-run group purchasing organization by 2023.
- Requires that, on or before January 1, 2031, DIR and CDPH submit a report to the Legislature on the effectiveness of the health care employer inventory requirement, the effectiveness of the state stockpile, as well as to make recommendations that will improve health care worker safety and health care employer preparedness during a pandemic.
- Sunsets on January 1, 2035.
COMMENTS:
See Assembly Labor and Employment Committee analysis.
According to the Author:
"One of the hard-learned lessons of the COVID-19 pandemic is the need for a well-managed supply of personal protective equipment (PPE) to keep California's healthcare workforce and other essential workers safe. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed California's failure to adequately plan and prepare for a pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE, such as respirators, surgical masks, and gowns left healthcare workers vulnerable to infection and death in hospitals and nursing homes. The shortage of PPE also left other essential workers without necessary protection, with outbreaks occurring in settings such as grocery stores and prisons. Communities of color are overrepresented in essential jobs and have suffered high infection rates. By definition, a pandemic affects multiple countries, which makes it especially difficult to procure needed supplies in the midst of an emergency. The U.S. stockpile held only a fraction of the amount of PPE necessary to protect workers. While some domestic suppliers quickly ramped up manufacturing, shortages persist and have led to dramatic cost increases. In order to protect lives in a pandemic, California must establish strategic stockpiles and in-state PPE manufacturing capability to avoid price gouging when replenishing PPE supplies. SB 275 creates a reliable supply of PPE to ensure healthcare workers, essential workers, and the public at large are protected during the next health emergency."
Arguments in Support:
SEIU California, sponsor of the bill, argues "California and health care employers failed to prepare for a crisis of the magnitude of the COVID-19 pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE left health care workers vulnerable to infection and death, with some resorting to using handmade PPE like bandanas and trash bags. The lack of PPE also harms patients who come into contact with potentially exposed workers or through cross-contamination through the reuse of PPE…
The many attempts to obtain PPE during the crisis exposed significant flaws in PPE supply chains. Overseas suppliers diverted PPE to their own countries' needs or stopped production due to the effects of the pandemic. . . . Given the high cost of trying to procure PPE during an emergency, it is prudent and most cost-effective to prepare for a crisis before it happens. California needs a state-centered supply of PPE to protect workers and residents…
Unfortunately, because California was not prepared, we have had many health care and essential workers die from COVID-19. Many of these cases could have been prevented by merely providing workers with the protective equipment required by law. This bill takes the critical step of ensuring that all health care employers and essential workers have access to PPE. Simply put, this bill will save lives."
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Children's Hospital Association (CCHA) argues in opposition "[e]mergency preparedness rests with Health and Human Services. The bill proposes to split the responsibility for PPE levels between the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), for the state stockpile, and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), for health care employer inventory. This will likely lead to conflicting or inconsistent guidance. The DIR, through Cal/OSHA, currently enforces the most stringent employee health and safety regulations in the country. Those regulations dictate how PPE should be used and in what circumstances. However, CDPH is responsible for the state's emergency preparedness, including how much PPE should be maintained.
The bill correctly places the state's stockpile management and oversight under CDPH. For the same reasons, health care employer inventories should be overseen by CDPH because they are a critical aspect of emergency preparedness."
The California Association of Health Facilities has taken an oppose unless amended position with the following concerns:
- "Proposed fines are exorbitant and overly burdensome to long term care facilities. . . . The $25,000 fine is per violation is extremely punitive and unreasonable for facilities with majority Med-Cal residents. These significant fines would redirect needed funding away from patient care."
- "Timeline is unrealistic due to the current pandemic. SB 275 requires a massive stockpile for both the state and facilities."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
State stockpile:
Annual General Fund (GF) costs of approximately $140 million for five years for CDPH to establish a state stockpile. In total, the state stockpile will cost approximately $714 million, which includes $600 million for PPE for 1.8 million health care workers, $100 million for PPE for 1.7 million essential workers, and $14 million in warehouse, storage and other administrative costs. Costs will continue in later years, but those costs will depend on how often the PPE in the state stockpile must be replaced. State stockpile costs may be higher or lower depending on PPE prices in future years and other factors. See Comment #3 of Assembly Appropriations Committee Analysis for additional discussion around PPE stockpile cost assumptions.
Employer inventory:
- Annual GF costs of approximately $3.5 million for three years for the University of California (UC) system to establish 60-day surge capacity inventory by year three. In total, UC's inventory will cost approximately $10.5 million. Costs will continue in subsequent years, but those costs wil1 depend on how often UC must replace the PPE in its inventory.
- Significant GF costs, possibly in the hundreds of millions of dollars over three years, to reimburse skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) through the Medi-Cal program. The state provides reimbursements to SNFs for costs from new state mandates, and state costs would depend how much new PPE SNFs would need to purchase.
- Special fund costs in excess of $1.4 million in the first year and $332,000 annually thereafter for DIR related to rulemaking, training and implementation and enforcement costs as well as the costs related to running the PPE Advisory Committee and completing the required report. These costs will be significantly higher during health emergency conditions, likely exceeding $1.8 million each year during a pandemic or similar public health crisis.
Other costs:
Likely significant GF costs in excess of $250,000 for Go Biz to work with stakeholders to solicit donations and to develop policies aimed at encouraging in-state production of PPE. This bill does not require state funding to support any of these incentive programs.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM RULES: 7-0-5
YES: Cooley, Carrillo, Flora, Grayson, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cunningham, Kamlager, Maienschein, Ramos, Wicks
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 6-1-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 12-4-2
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Megan Dahle, Fong, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Justin Delacruz / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0003445
Date of Hearing: August 18, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 275
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | 6 - 1 | |
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) and health care employers to establish stockpiles of personal protective equipment (PPE). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires CDPH to establish a 90-day stockpile of PPE (state stockpile) for distribution to health care workers and essential workers during a pandemic or similar public health emergency. Major components of the state stockpile program include:
- CDPH must acquire 20% of the 90-day stockpile each year for five years and must purchase at least 25% of all types of PPE from a California-based manufacturer.
- CDPH may distribute PPE from the state stockpile only during a state of emergency or to sell to another entity.
- CDPH must develop guidelines on the type and quantity of PPE to stockpile and the process by which CDPH will prioritize and distribute PPE.
- Requires a health care employer, as defined, to establish a 90-day stockpile of PPE (employer stockpile) for health care workers during a pandemic or similar public health emergency. Major components of the employer stockpile include:
- A health care employer must build a 30-day stockpile by June 1, 2021, a 60-day stockpile by June 1, 2022, and a 90-day stockpile by June 1, 2023. A health care employer will be subject to a $25,000 civil penalty for each violation.
- An employer stockpile may dip below its mandated level without penalty if the employer distributes the PPE to health care workers during a pandemic or if the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) determines there are genuine supply limitations.
- DIR must establish regulations on the type and quantity of PPE an employer must stockpile.
- Establishes a new program within the Governor’s Office of Economic Development (GO Biz) to encourage the in-state production of PPE. This bill creates the Health Care Workforce Protection Account within the Made in California Fund to fund efforts to promote in-state PPE production through grants, loans, loan guarantees and other incentives. GO Biz may collect donations from businesses, nonprofits and individuals for this program.
- Establishes the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee (PPE Advisory Committee) with specified representatives. The PPE Advisory Committee must make recommendations to DIR on the type and amount of PPE needed by health care employer type. DIR must submit a report based on these recommendations to the Legislature by May 30, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT:
State stockpile:
Annual General Fund (GF) costs of approximately $140 million for five years for CDPH to establish a state stockpile. In total, the state stockpile will cost approximately $714 million, which includes $600 million for PPE for 1.8 million health care workers, $100 million for PPE for 1.7 million essential workers, and $14 million in warehouse, storage and other administrative costs. Costs will continue in later years, but those costs will depend on how often the PPE in the state stockpile must be replaced. State stockpile costs may be higher or lower depending on PPE prices in future years and other factors. See Comment #3 for additional discussion around PPE stockpile cost assumptions.
Employer stockpile:
- Annual GF costs of approximately $3.5 million for three years for the University of California (UC) system to establish a 90-day stockpile by June 1, 2023. In total, UC’s stockpile will cost approximately $10.5 million. Costs will continue in subsequent years, but those costs wil1 depend on how often UC must replace the PPE in its stockpile.
- Significant GF costs, possibly in the hundreds of millions of dollars over three years, to reimburse skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) through the Medi-Cal program. The state provides reimbursements to SNFs for costs from new state mandates, and state costs would depend how much new PPE SNFs would need to purchase.
- Special fund costs of $1.4 million in the first year and $332,000 annually thereafter for DIR related to rulemaking, training and implementation and enforcement costs as well as the costs related to running the PPE Advisory Committee and completing the required report. These costs will be significantly higher during health emergency conditions, likely exceeding $1.8 million each year during a pandemic or similar public health crisis.
Other costs:
Likely significant GF costs in excess of $250,000 for Go Biz to work with stakeholders to solicit donations and to develop policies aimed at encouraging in-state production of PPE. This bill does not require state funding to support any of these incentive programs.
COMMENTS:
- Background. PPE is specialized clothing or equipment worn by health care workers to help prevent the spread of germs between patients. PPE is a broad term, but it often includes gloves, goggles or masks and respirators. According to the CDPH, PPE is crucial for health workers because they perform direct patient care and “routinely have prolonged, close direct contact with patients.”
The COVID-19 pandemic has significantly disrupted the market for PPE. Prior to the COVID-19 pandemic, hospitals accounted for approximately 55% of the PPE market. During the pandemic, media reports have highlighted the difficulty for hospitals to acquire adequate supplies.
- State procurement. On July 22, 2020, the Governor announced that the state would maintain a stockpile of 100 million N-95 respirators and 200 million surgical masks. As of that date, California had distributed 86.4 million N-95 respirators and 297 million surgical masks to health care workers, emergency responders, nursing home employees and farm and factory workers. Moreover, the state has a pending $315 million contract with BYD Manufacturing for an additional 120 million N-95 respirators and 300 million surgical masks.
- State stockpile costs and assumptions. This analysis makes a number of assumptions to arrive at its cost estimate:
- Affected workers. SB 275’s definitions of the types of workers covered by the state stockpile are broad and subject to CDPH’s discretion. For example, the definition of “essential worker” includes a government worker whose work with the public “continues throughout the crisis” as well as any other worker CDPH deems as “vital to public health and safety, as well as economic and national security.” This analysis assumes that any worker classified as a public safety employee would meet this definition. The below table provides additional details about the assumptions made by this analysis.
Workers Covered by SB 275 | # of Employees in 2019 |
Essential Workers: | |
Primary and secondary school workers | 826,393 |
Public safety workers | 282,224 |
IHSS providers | 520,000 |
Child care providers | 101,600 |
Total, Essential Workers: | 1,730,217 |
Health Care Workers | |
Ambulatory health care services (including doctor offices) | 883,230 |
Hospitals | 582,024 |
Nursing homes and residential care | 311,205 |
Total, Health Care Workers: | 1,776,459 |
Total, Affected Workers: | 3,506,676 |
- PPE prices. Given the disruption in PPE supply chains and the soaring demand for PPE during the COVID-19 pandemic, PPE prices will likely decline whenever the current public health crisis ends. This analysis assumes the same unit price for masks from the state’s July 20, 2020 contract with BYD Manufacturing. It is possible that the price of masks will fall over time as national manufacturing capacity increases and demand for PPE decreases.
- Role of existing stockpile. As noted above, the state has committed to establishing a stockpile of 100 million N-95 masks and 200 million surgical masks. This analysis does not assume this stockpile will be available for use by the time this bill’s provisions take effect. However, to the extent that some portion of this stockpile will be available to meet the requirements of this bill, costs could be lower than this analysis estimates.
- “Made in California” provisions. This bill also requires the state to purchase at least 25% of any type of PPE from a California-based manufacturer. This requirement will likely drive up PPE costs. In general, this type of restriction on state procurement limits the state’s bargaining power.
- Resale. This bill also authorizes CDPH to sell PPE. In theory, this would give CDPH a tool to recoup some costs if CDPH is able to replace PPE at a cheaper price. However, this analysis does not assume that CDPH sells any of its PPE. First, it is unclear why an entity would purchase old PPE during non-pandemic years when the PPE market is more stable. Second, CDPH is less likely to sell PPE during an urgent health crisis since the immediate concern will be to distribute PPE widely.
- A different perspective on costs. This bill aims to ensure an adequate supply of PPE during a pandemic or similar health crisis. Given the severity of the COVID-19 crisis and the inadequate supply of PPE for frontline workers, it is reasonable and, over the long term, possibly cost effective to develop stockpiles and distribution relationships to smooth over supply disruptions during a pandemic or health crisis. For example, an August 2020 UC Berkeley Labor Center report concludes that procuring an adequate PPE stockpile at non-pandemic prices would cost 17% of the amount needed to purchase the same amount at pandemic-level prices. In its analysis, the UC Berkeley Labor Center report argues that maintaining a stockpile would be cheaper over the long-term even if the stockpile was not needed for 35 years.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 29, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 275
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:July 27, 2020
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Health Care and Essential Workers Protection Act: personal protective equipment
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Public Health (CDPH) to establish a personal protective equipment (PPE) stockpile to ensure adequate supply of PPE for all health care workers and essential workers in the state that is sufficient for a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that as part of the Made in California Program, the Governor’s Office of Business and Economic Development (GO-Biz) shall encourage in-state production of PPE.
- Creates the Health Care Workforce Protection Account within the Made in California Fund and requires GO-Biz to use the funds to provide grants, loans, loan guarantees, and other incentives for projects that increase the capacity for the in-state manufacturing of PPE.
- Requires CDPH to establish a PPE stockpile to ensure an adequate supply of PPE for all health care workers and essential workers in the state that is at least sufficient for a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- Defines “essential worker” as primary and secondary school workers, workers at detention facilities, as defined in Section 9500 of the Penal Code, in-home support providers, childcare providers, government workers whose work with the public continues throughout the crisis, and workers in other positions that CDPH, in its sole discretion, deems vital to public health and safety, as well as economic and national security.
- Defines “health care employer” as a licensed clinic, an outpatient setting, a health facility, a county medical facility, a home health agency, a physician’s office with more than 25 physicians, a professional medical corporation with more than 25 physicians, a medical partnership with more than 25 physicians, a medical foundation with more than 25 physicians, a rural health clinic, a federally qualified health center, and any other entity that provides medical services in California.
- Defines “health care worker” as any worker employed to work at or by a provider to provide direct patient care and services directly supporting patient care, including, but not limited to, physicians, clinicians, nurses, aides, technicians, janitorial and housekeeping staff, food services workers, and nonmanagerial administrative staff.
- Defines “personal protective equipment” or “PPE” as protective equipment for eyes, face, head, and extremities, protective clothing, respiratory devices, and protective shields, and barriers provided and used wherever it is necessary by reason of hazards of processes or environment, biological hazards, chemical hazards, radiological hazards, or mechanical irritants encountered in a manner capable of causing injury or impairment in the function of any part of the body through absorption, inhalation or physical contact.
- Defines “provider” as a licensed clinic, an outpatient setting, a health facility, a county medical facility, a home health agency, a physician’s office, a professional medical corporation, a medical partnership, a medical foundation, a rural health clinic, a federally qualified health center, and any other entity that provides medical services in California.
- Requires CDPH to create guidelines for the procurement of PPE for the stockpile which must take into account all of the following:
- The various types of PPE that may be required during a pandemic or other health emergency.
- The shelf life of each type of PPE to be obtained for the stockpile and how to annually restock a portion of each type of PPE to ensure the stockpile consists of unexpired PPE.
- The amount of each type of PPE that would be required for all health care workers and essential workers in the state during a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- Provides that CDPH must procure 20 percent of the stockpile within one year and for each year thereafter until CDPH has procured 100 percent of the stockpile in five years.
- Requires that at least 25% of the each type of PPE in the state stockpile shall be manufactured in California and requires that distribution of the California-manufactured PPE must be made by resale.
- Provides that CDPH shall distribute PPE from the stockpile only under either of the following two circumstances:
- If the Governor declares a state of emergency, or a local emergency is declared, for which PPE will be required.
- To sell PPE from the stockpile, provided that the department acquired new PPE to offset any shortage resulting from the sale.
- Requires that CDPH establish guidelines regarding distribution of PPE from the stockpile, including the timing and amount of PPE distribution and the terms of sale should CDPH determine sale is appropriate.
- States that the guidelines must provide that in the event there is insufficient PPE to meet needs, distribution of PPE shall be prioritized for providers and employers of essential workers that meet any of the following qualifications:
- The provider or employer is in a location with a high share of low-income residents.
- The provider or employer is in a medically underserved area, as designated by the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration.
- The provider or employer disproportionately serves a medically underserved population, as designated by the United States Department of Health and Human Services, Health Resources and Services Administration.
- Requires CDPH to provide within three months of enactment the Department of Finance with an estimate of the cost to fully stock the stockpile and to maintain the stockpile for the subsequent five years.
- Requires a health care employer to maintain a stockpile of unexpired PPE for use in the event of a state of emergency declaration by the Governor according to the following schedule:
- On June 1, 2021, sufficient for a 30-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- On June 1, 2022, sufficient for a 60-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- On June 1, 2023, sufficient for a 90-day pandemic or other health emergency.
- Provides that a health care employer who violates the requirement to maintain a supply of unexpired PPE shall be assessed a civil penalty of up to $25,000 for each violation.
- Clarifies that if a health care employer provides services exclusively in a facility controlled by another health care employer who is obligated to maintain a PPE stockpile, the health care employer who controls the facility shall be required to maintain the required PPE for the health care employer providing services in that facility or setting.
- Provides that if a health care employer’s stockpile dips below the mandated level of supply as the result of distributing PPE to its health care workers during a state of emergency declared by the Governor or a declared local emergency for a pandemic, the health care employer shall not be subject to the civil penalty provided the health care employer makes reasonable efforts to replenish its stockpile to the mandated level.
- Provides that the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) may exempt a health care employer from being assessed a civil penalty if DIR determines that supply chain limitations make meeting the mandated level of supplies infeasible and the healthcare employer has made a reasonable attempt, in the discretion of DIR, to obtain PPE.
- Requires a health care employer to provide PPE to its health care workers upon their reasonable request and provides that each day a health care employer delays in doing so constitutes an independent violation.
- Requires DIR and CDPH to set requirements for health care employer stockpiles, including the types and amount of PPE to be maintained by the health care employer based on the type and size of each health care employer as well as the composition of health care workers in its workforce.
- Establishes the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee, appointed by the Secretary of Labor, to consist of eight individuals who have experience in health care, public health, workers’ rights, or emergency preparedness.
- Requires the Personal Protective Equipment Advisory Committee to make recommendations to DIR necessary for DIR to provide its report to the Legislature on or before May 30, 2021, which must include recommendations relating to, among other things, the type and amount of PPE needed by health employer type during a public health emergency to ensure compliance with public health and safety standards, and guidance on who shall maintain PPE if multiple health care employers are located at the same physical facility.
- Sunsets on January 1, 2025.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Made in California Program as a public and private collaboration within GO-Biz, the purpose of which is to encourage consumer product awareness and to foster purchses of high-quality products made in California.
- Requires an employer to furnish employment and a place of employment that is safe and healthful for its employees.
- Requires an employer to furnish and use safety devices and safeguards, and adopt and use practices, means, methods, operations, and processes which are reasonably adequate to render employment and the place of employment safe and healthful.
- Requires an employer to do everything reasonably necessary to protect the life, safety, and health of employees.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: The supply shortage of PPE during this global pandemic is well-documented. Governments, businesses and individuals all compete to acquire PPE, driving up prices. Due to this shortage, frontline essential and healthcare workers are required to ration, reuse, and improvise with PPE. According to CDPH, as of July 20, 2020, local health departments have reported 19,930 confirmed positive cases of COVID-19 among health care workers and 108 deaths statewide. This bill seeks to protect healthcare workers from further spread of COVID-19 as well as ensure adequate statewide supply of PPE for all essential workers to prepare for the future.
According to the author, “[o]ne of the hard-learned lessons of the COVID-19 pandemic is the need for a well-managed supply of personal protective equipment (PPE) to keep California’s healthcare workforce and other essential workers safe. The COVID-19 pandemic exposed California’s failure to adequately plan and prepare for a pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE, such as respirators, surgical masks, and gowns left healthcare workers vulnerable to infection and death in hospitals and nursing homes. The shortage of PPE also left other essential workers without necessary protection, with outbreaks occurring in settings such as grocery stores and prisons. Communities of color are overrepresented in essential jobs and have suffered high infection rates. By definition, a pandemic affects multiple countries, which makes it especially difficult to procure needed supplies in the midst of an emergency. The U.S. stockpile held only a fraction of the amount of PPE necessary to protect workers. While some domestic suppliers quickly ramped up manufacturing, shortages persist and have led to dramatic cost increases. In order to protect lives in a pandemic, California must establish strategic stockpiles and in-state PPE manufacturing capability to avoid price gouging when replenishing PPE supplies. SB 275 creates a reliable supply of PPE to ensure healthcare workers, essential workers, and the public at large are protected during the next health emergency.”
Arguments in Support
SEIU California, sponsor of the bill, argues “California and health care employers failed to prepare for a crisis of the magnitude of the COVID-19 pandemic. Inadequate supplies of unexpired PPE left health care workers vulnerable to infection and death, with some resorting to using handmade PPE like bandanas and trash bags. The lack of PPE also harms patients who come into contact with potentially exposed workers or through cross-contamination through the reuse of PPE.
The shortage of PPE in health care settings leaves other essential workers without the necessary protection. Outbreaks have occurred in numerous settings, including grocery stores and prisons, endangering workers and the public. Communities of color are overrepresented in essential jobs and have suffered correspondingly high infection rates, particularly working-age Latinos whose rates of infection are close to 20 percent higher than their share of the California population.
The many attempts to obtain PPE during the crisis exposed significant flaws in PPE supply chains. Overseas suppliers diverted PPE to their own countries’ needs or stopped production due to the effects of the pandemic. The national stockpile held only a fraction of the amount of PPE necessary to protect workers. While some domestic suppliers quickly ramped up manufacturing, shortages have persisted and led to dramatic cost increases with some markups reaching over 6,000%. Given the high cost of trying to procure PPE during an emergency, it is prudent and most cost-effective to prepare for a crisis before it happens. California needs a state-centered supply of PPE to protect workers and residents.
SEIU is sponsoring this bill because our members’ experience during this pandemic and their demand that we have enough PPE so that all workers never go without the necessary protective equipment again. Unfortunately, because California was not prepared, we have had many health care and essential workers die from COVID-19. Many of these cases could have been prevented by merely providing workers with the protective equipment required by law. This bill takes the critical step of ensuring that all health care employers and essential workers have access to PPE. Simply put, this bill will save lives.”
Arguments in Opposition
The California Orthopedic Association argues in opposition “This bill would put a significant burden on physician offices as PPE dates expire and the PPE would have to be regularly replaced. There would be an immense amount of waste generated by this bill as expired PPE are discarded.”
The California Hospital Association has taken an oppose unless amended position asserting “[w]e continue discussions with the bill’s sponsors with the goal of finding common ground that recognizes the importance of having sufficient PPE during a public health emergency while also recognizing the reality of supply chain constraints and balancing the requirements for inventory supply management.
CHA’s concerns are:
Emergency preparedness rests with Health and Human Services. The bill proposes to split the responsibility for PPE levels between the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), for the state stockpile, and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), for health care employer inventory. This will likely lead to conflicting or inconsistent guidance.
The timing of this bill’s requirements remains a concern. The bill proposes that the committee make its recommendations as to the type and amount of PPE needed by health care employers during a public health emergency. That report is due on May 30, 2021. However, health care employers are required to meet their stockpile obligations on June 1, 2021. Furthermore, CDPH is required to have a portion of its stockpile in place on January 1, 2022. . . . The current timeline is insufficient to allow full consideration of the report.
The 90-day pandemic level PPE for health care employers is too long and will likely result in unintended consequences. There is no one objective measure for what constitutes a 90-day pandemic level of PPE — yet. Requiring health care employers to maintain this level of PPE would draw resources away from other front-line workers who also need it. It would also draw resources away from patient care, as the current cost for PPE has increased by tenfold for some items. Hospitals are currently striving to maintain a 14-day supply.
Criteria for fines must be revised. We recognize that the emergency preparedness and employee safety issues this bill aims to address are consequential and that non-compliance should be addressed. We remain concerned the current language would discourage health care employers from sharing their PPE with another provider in need if that would cause their inventory to fall below the required level. This runs contrary to our “mutual aid” approach to emergencies.”
Related Legislation
AB 2537 (Rodriguez) of 2020 would require employers who employ workers who provide direct patient care in the hospital setting to maintain a stockpile of unexpired PPE in the amount equal to six months of normal consumption. This bill is pending in the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment (ACCE) Action
Asian Americans Advancing Justice - California
Asian Pacific American Labor Alliance
Asian Pacific Environmental Network
Brea Congregational Church
California Conference Board of The Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Health Professional Student Alliance
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Physicians Alliance
California State Council of Service Employees International Union (seiu California)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
Engineers and Scientists of California, Ifpte Local 20, Afl-cio
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Inlandboatmen's Union of The Pacific (IBU)
Innercity Struggle
LA Voice
Labor Council for Latin American Advancement- Los Angeles Chapter
Latino Coalition for A Healthy California
Lumos Transforms
National Congress of Black Women
National Immigration Law Center
New Philadelphia Ame
Newsong Church
Orange County Poor Peoples Campaign
Peace Benevolence & Justice Ministry
Power California
Professional and Technical Engineers, Ifpte Local 21, Afl-cio
Santa Clara County Democratic Party
Seiu Asian Pacific Islanders Caucus
The Way Center of Truth, INC.
Unite-here, Afl-cio
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
Worksafe
Support If Amended
California Dental Association
Oppose
California Children's Hospital Association
California Orthopedic Association
St. Paul's Senior Homes and Services
Oppose Unless Amended
California Ambulatory Surgery Association
California Association of Health Facilities
California Hospital Association/California Association of Hospitals and Health Systems
Developmental Services Network
Analysis Prepared by: Justin Delacruz / L. & E. /
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 275
Author:(Pan) – As Introduced Ver:February 13, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Psychologist: prohibition against sexual behavior
SUMMARY: Defines “sexual behavior” and states that an administrative law judge’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an order for license revocation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Board of Psychology (BOP) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to enforce and administer the Psychology Licensing Law. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2920)
- Requires that protection of the public to be the BOP’s highest priority in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (BPC § 2920.1)
- Requires any psychotherapist or employer of a psychotherapist who becomes aware through a client that the client had alleged sexual intercourse, sexual behavior, or sexual contact with a previous psychotherapist during the course of a prior treatment to provide a brochure to the client that delineates the rights of, and remedies for, clients who have been involved sexually with their psychotherapists. Requires the psychotherapist or employer to discuss the brochure with the client. (BPC § 728 (a))
- For purposes of the brochure, defines “sexual contact” as the touching of an intimate part of another person, and “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues. (BPC § 728 (c)(2))
- Authorizes the BOP to suspend or revoke the registration or license of any registrant or licensee found guilty of unprofessional conduct, which includes any act of sexual abuse, or sexual relations with a patient or former patient within two years following termination of therapy, or sexual misconduct that is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of a psychologist, psychological assistant, or registered psychologist. (BPC § 2960 (o))
- Requires any proposed decision or decision issued under the Psychology Licensing Law that contains any finding of fact that the licensee or registrant engaged in any act of sexual contact with a patient, or with a former patient within two years following termination of therapy, contain an order of revocation. The revocation shall not be stayed by the administrative law judge (ALJ). (BPC § 2960.1)
- Requires the BOP, in reaching a decision on a disciplinary action under the administrative adjudication provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), to consider and apply the “Disciplinary Guidelines and Uniform Standards related to Substance Abusing Licensees.” (Title 16, California Code of Regulations (CCR) § 1395.2 (a))
- Authorizes the BOP to deny an application for, or issue subject to terms and conditions, or suspend or revoke, or impose probationary conditions upon, a license or registration after a hearing held pursuant to the APA. (BPC § 2961)
- Authorizes the BOP to, within 100 days of receipt of an ALJ’s decision:
- Adopt the proposed decision in its entirety.
- Reduce or otherwise mitigate the proposed penalty and adopt the balance of the proposed decision.
- Make technical or other minor changes in the proposed decision and adopt it as the decision. Action by the agency under this paragraph is limited to a clarifying change or a change of a similar nature that does not affect the factual or legal basis of the proposed decision.
- Reject the proposed decision and refer the case to the same ALJ if reasonably available, otherwise to another ALJ, to take additional evidence.
- Reject the proposed decision, and decide the case upon the record, including the transcript, or upon an agreed statement of the parties, with or without taking additional evidence. (Government Code (GOV) § 11517)
THIS BILL:
- Changes references from “patient” to “client.”
- Adds “sexual behavior” with a client or former client, as specified, to the violations that trigger an order for license revocation, upon an ALJ’s finding of fact.
- States that the order for a license revocation due to a finding of sexual contact or sexual behavior may be stayed by the BOP.
- Defines “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the California Board of Psychology. According to the Author, “The Board believes that sexual behavior in the psychotherapist-client relationship by the licensed professional is one of the most flagrant ethical violations possible, as it violates the duty of care inherent in a therapeutic relationship, abuses the trust of the client, and can create harmful, long-lasting emotional and psychological effects.
[This bill] would make this clear under the law that these sexual behaviors with a client are sexual misconduct.”
Background. Board of Psychology. California recognized psychology as a vocation with the Certification Act of 1958, which provided only title protection to psychologists. In 1967, the Legislature statutorily defined the profession of psychology and required licensure to practice. BOP regulates licensed psychologists, registered psychological assistants, and registered psychologists. It is funded by license, application, and examination fees, and receives no revenue from California’s General Fund. BOP consists of nine members (five licensed psychologists and four public members) who are appointed to four-year terms.
DCA produces a consumer brochure entitled Professional Therapy Never Includes Sex, which the law requires a psychotherapist to provide to and discuss with a client if the psychotherapist learns of inappropriate contact between the client and a previous psychotherapist. This brochure was updated last year (AB 2968, Levine (Chapter 778, Statutes of 2018)), to define and include “sexual behavior” between a client and a previous psychotherapist. The present bill, SB 275, uses a slightly different definition of “sexual behavior,” adding that such behavior must be made by the psychotherapist “for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse.” BOP indicates the reason for greater specificity is that the brochure’s definition is to instigate a discussion, while SB 275 establishes the basis for discipline.
This bill further adds that if an ALJ makes a finding of fact that a licensee engaged in any act of sexual behavior, the BOP may stay the order for a license revocation. This restates BOP’s existing authority under the APA to reject an ALJ’s determination with or without additional evidence. Current law does not authorize an ALJ to recommend license revocation for sexual behavior under the BOP’s enforcement parameters. However, the BOP is authorized to deviate from the disciplinary guidelines when the BOP determines, “in its sole discretion” that the facts of the particular case warrant such a deviation.
BOP indicates that this bill is necessary because it is otherwise “hamstrung” absent explicit authority to revoke licenses for lesser offenses. However, this is not entirely accurate; the BOP could have revoked licenses for sexual behavior prior to this bill’s enactment as long as the BOP acted pursuant to the APA.
This bill reinforces the BOP’s commitment to consumer protection and formally declares that an ALJ’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an ALJ’s order for license revocation.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 2968 (Levine, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2018) updated the informational brochure “Professional Therapy Never Includes Sex” to include sexual behavior and requires a psychotherapist (or their employer) who becomes aware that a patient had alleged sexual behavior with a previous psychotherapist to provide and discuss with the client the above described informational brochure.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The Board of Psychology writes in support, “The [BOP] sponsored [this bill] due to the Board’s experiences adjudicating cases involving inappropriate sexual conduct that did not meet the current definition of sexual contact and therefore did not require the ALJ to recommend revoking the license. Examples of sexual behaviors that the [BOP] has seen in disciplinary cases that did not reach the level of sexual contact include:
• Kissing a client,
• Touching or exposing oneself inappropriately,
• Sending flirtatious, sexually suggestive or sexually explicit texts (sexting), Messages or emails to a client,
• sending clients photos that include nudity, genitals, or sexually suggestive poses, and
• Buying romantic/sexual gifts for a client.
These cases left the [BOP] hamstrung in achieving appropriate discipline for sexual behavior antithetical to the psychotherapist-client relationship, making it exceedingly difficult for the [BOP] to achieve disciplinary terms that matched the egregiousness of the acts. By way of [this bill], the [BOP] seeks to ensure that sexual behavior with a client, even if it has not resulted in intercourse or sexual contact, is considered a violation that merits the highest level of discipline.”
POLICY ISSUES:
Policy currently exists insofar as therapists are licensed by the State and are currently regulated not only by a series of ethical codes but by legal statutes contained within the Business and Professions Code as well as the Penal Code. Section 726 of the Business and Professions Code provides that the commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct, or relations with a patient constitutes unprofessional conduct and is grounds for disciplinary action against any licensed psychologist.
Business and Professions Code Section 729, subdivision (a), states that a psychotherapist who “engages in an act of sexual intercourse, sodomy, oral copulation, or sexual contact with a patient or client” is guilty of sexual exploitation which is a criminal offense. “Sexual contact” is defined as “sexual intercourse or the touching of an intimate part of the patient for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, or abuse.” Section 729, subdivision (b) clearly states that “in no instance shall consent of the patient . . . be a defense.”
The professional licensing board which governs psychotherapists is the California Board of Psychology, Department of Consumer Affairs. Business and Professions Code, Section 2960 empowers the Board to suspend, revoke, or place on probation, a licensed therapist for unprofessional conduct which includes any active sexual abuse, or sexual relations with a patient (or former patient within two years following termination of therapy) or other sexual misconduct which is substantially related to the qualifications or duties of a psychologist.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
Board of Psychology (Sponsor)
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Danielle Sires / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 275 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 275
Introduced: 2/13/19
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/1/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Psychologist: prohibition against sexual behavior
SOURCE: California Board of Psychology
DIGEST:
This bill defines “sexual behavior” and states that an administrative law judge’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an order for license revocation.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Psychology (BOP) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to enforce and administer the Psychology Licensing Law. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2920)
- Requires that protection of the public to be the BOP’s highest priority in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (BPC § 2920.1)
- Requires any psychotherapist or employer of a psychotherapist who becomes aware through a client that the client had alleged sexual intercourse, sexual behavior, or sexual contact with a previous psychotherapist during the course of a prior treatment to provide a brochure to the client that delineates the rights of, and remedies for, clients who have been involved sexually with their psychotherapists. Requires the psychotherapist or employer to discuss the brochure with the client. (BPC § 728 (a))
- Defines, for purposes of the brochure, “sexual contact” as the touching of an intimate part of another person, and “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues. (BPC § 728 (c)(2))
- Authorizes the BOP to suspend or revoke the registration or license of any registrant or licensee found guilty of unprofessional conduct, which includes any act of sexual abuse, or sexual relations with a patient or former patient within two years following termination of therapy, or sexual misconduct that is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of a psychologist, psychological assistant, or registered psychologist. (BPC § 2960 (o))
- Requires any proposed decision or decision issued under the Psychology Licensing Law that contains any finding of fact that the licensee or registrant engaged in any act of sexual contact with a patient, or with a former patient within two years following termination of therapy, contain an order of revocation. The revocation shall not be stayed by the administrative law judge (ALJ). (BPC § 2960.1)
- Authorizes the BOP to deny an application for, or issue subject to terms and conditions, or suspend or revoke, or impose probationary conditions upon, a license or registration after a hearing held pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act (APA). (BPC § 2961)
This bill:
- Changes references from “patient” to “client.”
- Adds “sexual behavior” with a client or former client, as specified, to the violations that trigger an order for license revocation, upon an ALJ’s finding of fact.
- States that the order for a license revocation due to a finding of sexual contact or sexual behavior may be stayed by the BOP.
- Defines “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues.
Background
California recognized psychology as a vocation with the Certification Act of 1958, which provided only title protection to psychologists. In 1967, the Legislature statutorily defined the profession of psychology and required licensure to practice. BOP regulates licensed psychologists, registered psychological assistants, and registered psychologists. It is funded by license, application, and examination fees, and receives no revenue from California’s General Fund. BOP consists of nine members, five licensed psychologists and four public members, who are appointed to four-year terms.
DCA produces a consumer brochure entitled “Professional Therapy Never Includes Sex”, which the law requires a psychotherapist to provide to and discuss with a client if the psychotherapist learns of inappropriate contact between the client and a previous psychotherapist. This brochure was updated last year (AB 2968, Levine, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2018) to define and include “sexual behavior” between a client and a previous psychotherapist. The present bill, SB 275, uses a slightly different definition of “sexual behavior,” adding that such behavior must be made by the psychotherapist “for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse.” BOP indicates the reason for greater specificity is that the brochure’s definition is to instigate a discussion, while SB 275 establishes the basis for discipline.
This bill further adds that if an ALJ makes a finding of fact that a licensee engaged in any act of sexual behavior, the BOP may stay the order for a license revocation. This restates BOP’s existing authority under the APA to reject an ALJ’s determination with or without additional evidence. Current law does not authorize an ALJ to recommend license revocation for sexual behavior under the BOP’s enforcement parameters. However, the BOP is authorized to deviate from the disciplinary guidelines when the BOP determines, “in its sole discretion” that the facts of the particular case warrant such a deviation.
BOP indicates that this bill is necessary because it is otherwise “hamstrung” absent explicit authority to revoke licenses for lesser offenses. However, this is not entirely accurate; the BOP could have revoked licenses for sexual behavior prior to this bill’s enactment as long as the BOP acted pursuant to the APA.
This bill reinforces the BOP’s commitment to consumer protection and formally declares that an ALJ’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an ALJ’s order for license revocation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Board of Psychology (source)
OPPOSITION: (Verified 4/22/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The BOP writes, “The [BOP] sponsored SB 275 due to the Board’s experiences adjudicating cases involving inappropriate sexual conduct that did not meet the current definition of sexual contact and therefore did not require the ALJ to recommend revoking the license. Examples of sexual behaviors that the [BOP] has seen in disciplinary cases that did not reach the level of sexual contact include:
- Kissing a client,
- Touching or exposing oneself inappropriately,
- Sending flirtatious, sexually suggestive or sexually explicit texts (sexting), Messages or emails to a client,
- sending clients photos that include nudity, genitals, or sexually suggestive poses, and
- Buying romantic/sexual gifts for a client.
“These cases left the [BOP] hamstrung in achieving appropriate discipline for sexual behavior antithetical to the psychotherapist-client relationship, making it exceedingly difficult for the [BOP] to achieve disciplinary terms that matched the egregiousness of the acts. By way of SB 275, the [BOP] seeks to ensure that sexual behavior with a client, even if it has not resulted in intercourse or sexual contact, is considered a violation that merits the highest level of discipline.”
Prepared by: Sarah Huchel / B., P. & E.D. /
4/24/19 15:10:36
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 275 Hearing Date: April 1, 2019
Author: | Pan | ||
Version: | February 13, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Huchel | ||
Subject: Psychologist: prohibition against sexual behavior
SUMMARY:
Defines “sexual behavior” and states that an administrative law judge’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an order for license revocation.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Board of Psychology (BOP) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to enforce and administer the Psychology Licensing Law. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2920)
- Requires that protection of the public to be the BOP’s highest priority in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (BPC § 2920.1)
- Requires any psychotherapist or employer of a psychotherapist who becomes aware through a client that the client had alleged sexual intercourse, sexual behavior, or sexual contact with a previous psychotherapist during the course of a prior treatment to provide a brochure to the client that delineates the rights of, and remedies for, clients who have been involved sexually with their psychotherapists. Requires the psychotherapist or employer to discuss the brochure with the client. (BPC § 728 (a))
- For purposes of the brochure, defines “sexual contact” as the touching of an intimate part of another person, and “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues. (BPC § 728 (c)(2))
- Authorizes the BOP to suspend or revoke the registration or license of any registrant or licensee found guilty of unprofessional conduct, which includes any act of sexual abuse, or sexual relations with a patient or former patient within two years following termination of therapy, or sexual misconduct that is substantially related to the qualifications, functions, or duties of a psychologist, psychological assistant, or registered psychologist. (BPC § 2960 (o))
- Requires any proposed decision or decision issued under the Psychology Licensing Law that contains any finding of fact that the licensee or registrant engaged in any act of sexual contact with a patient, or with a former patient within two years following termination of therapy, contain an order of revocation. The revocation shall not be stayed by the administrative law judge (ALJ). (BPC § 2960.1)
- Requires the BOP, in reaching a decision on a disciplinary action under the administrative adjudication provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), to consider and apply the “Disciplinary Guidelines and Uniform Standards related to Substance Abusing Licensees.” (Title 16, California Code of Regulations (CCR) § 1395.2 (a))
- Authorizes the BOP to deny an application for, or issue subject to terms and conditions, or suspend or revoke, or impose probationary conditions upon, a license or registration after a hearing held pursuant to the APA. (BPC § 2961)
- Authorizes the BOP to, within 100 days of receipt of an ALJ’s decision:
- Adopt the proposed decision in its entirety.
- Reduce or otherwise mitigate the proposed penalty and adopt the balance of the proposed decision.
- Make technical or other minor changes in the proposed decision and adopt it as the decision. Action by the agency under this paragraph is limited to a clarifying change or a change of a similar nature that does not affect the factual or legal basis of the proposed decision.
- Reject the proposed decision and refer the case to the same ALJ if reasonably available, otherwise to another ALJ, to take additional evidence.
- Reject the proposed decision, and decide the case upon the record, including the transcript, or upon an agreed statement of the parties, with or without taking additional evidence. (Government Code (GOV) § 11517)
This bill:
- Changes references from “patient” to “client.”
- Adds “sexual behavior” with a client or former client, as specified, to the violations that trigger an order for license revocation, upon an ALJ’s finding of fact.
- States that the order for a license revocation due to a finding of sexual contact or sexual behavior may be stayed by the BOP.
- Defines “sexual behavior” as inappropriate contact or communication of a sexual nature for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse. “Sexual behavior” does not include the provision of appropriate therapeutic interventions relating to sexual issues.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the BOP. According to the Author’s office, “The [BOP] believes that sexual behavior in the psychotherapist-client relationship by the licensed professional is one of the most flagrant ethical violations possible, as it violates the duty of care inherent in a therapeutic relationship, abuses the trust of the client, and can create harmful, long-lasting emotional and psychological effects.
“The [BOP] would like to add ‘sexual behavior’ to Section 2960.1 of the [BPC] due to the [BOP’s] experiences adjudicating cases involving inappropriate sexual conduct that did not meet the current definition of sexual contact. These cases left the [BOP] hamstrung in achieving appropriate discipline for sexual behavior antithetical to the psychotherapist-client relationship, making it exceedingly difficult for the [BOP] to achieve disciplinary terms that matched the egregiousness of the acts. Through SB 275, the [BOP] wants to ensure that sexual behavior with a client, even if it has not resulted in intercourse or sexual contact, is an egregious ethical violation that merits the highest level of discipline.”
- BOP Background. California recognized psychology as a vocation with the Certification Act of 1958, which provided only title protection to psychologists. In 1967, the Legislature statutorily defined the profession of psychology and required licensure to practice. BOP regulates licensed psychologists, registered psychological assistants, and registered psychologists. It is funded by license, application, and examination fees, and receives no revenue from California’s General Fund. BOP consists of nine members (five licensed psychologists and four public members) who are appointed to four-year terms.
- Comments. DCA produces a consumer brochure entitled Professional Therapy Never Includes Sex, which the law requires a psychotherapist to provide to and discuss with a client if the psychotherapist learns of inappropriate contact between the client and a previous psychotherapist. This brochure was updated last year (AB 2968, Levine (Chapter 778, Statutes of 2018)), to define and include “sexual behavior” between a client and a previous psychotherapist. The present bill, SB 275, uses a slightly different definition of “sexual behavior,” adding that such behavior must be made by the psychotherapist “for the purpose of sexual arousal, gratification, exploitation, or abuse.” BOP indicates the reason for greater specificity is that the brochure’s definition is to instigate a discussion, while SB 275 establishes the basis for discipline.
This bill further adds that if an ALJ makes a finding of fact that a licensee engaged in any act of sexual behavior, the BOP may stay the order for a license revocation. This restates BOP’s existing authority under the APA to reject an ALJ’s determination with or without additional evidence. Current law does not authorize an ALJ to recommend license revocation for sexual behavior under the BOP’s enforcement parameters. However, the BOP is authorized to deviate from the disciplinary guidelines when the BOP determines, “in its sole discretion” that the facts of the particular case warrant such a deviation.
BOP indicates that this bill is necessary because it is otherwise “hamstrung” absent explicit authority to revoke licenses for lesser offenses. However, this is not entirely accurate; the BOP could have revoked licenses for sexual behavior prior to this bill’s enactment as long as the BOP acted pursuant to the APA.
This bill reinforces the BOP’s commitment to consumer protection and formally declares that an ALJ’s finding of fact that sexual behavior occurred between a psychotherapist and client shall trigger an ALJ’s order for license revocation.
- Prior Related Legislation. AB 2968 (Levine, Chapter 778, Statutes of 2018) updated the informational brochure “Professional Therapy Never Includes Sex” to include sexual behavior and requires a psychotherapist (or their employer) who becomes aware that a patient had alleged sexual behavior with a previous psychotherapist to provide and discuss with the client the above described informational brochure.
- Arguments in Support. The BOP writes, “The [BOP] sponsored SB 275 due to the Board’s experiences adjudicating cases involving inappropriate sexual conduct that did not meet the current definition of sexual contact and therefore did not require the ALJ to recommend revoking the license. Examples of sexual behaviors that the [BOP] has seen in disciplinary cases that did not reach the level of sexual contact include:
- Kissing a client,
- Touching or exposing oneself inappropriately,
- Sending flirtatious, sexually suggestive or sexually explicit texts (sexting), Messages or emails to a client,
- sending clients photos that include nudity, genitals, or sexually suggestive poses, and
- Buying romantic/sexual gifts for a client.
“These cases left the [BOP] hamstrung in achieving appropriate discipline for sexual behavior antithetical to the psychotherapist-client relationship, making it exceedingly difficult for the [BOP] to achieve disciplinary terms that matched the egregiousness of the acts. By way of SB 275, the [BOP] seeks to ensure that sexual behavior with a client, even if it has not resulted in intercourse or sexual contact, is considered a violation that merits the highest level of discipline.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Board of Psychology (Sponsor)
Opposition:
None on file.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):