SB 294: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-11
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 13, 2020 | Stricken from file. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | In Senate. Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Vetoed by the Governor. |
| Sep 17, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | June 24 hearing: Heard for testimony only. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | April 8 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 29, 2019 | Set for hearing April 8. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 13, 2019 | Set for hearing March 27. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 6, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB294 Hill Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 5, 2019 | SB 294 Hill Senate Third Reading By Berman | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Special Consent SB294 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 8, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 294 |
VETO
Bill No: SB 294
Amended: 7/1/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/27/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0, 9/6/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/5/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
DIGEST:
This bill allows for a partial welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing, and increases the statewide cap on the value of property used for non-publicly financed affordable housing.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law (California Constitution, Article XIII).
- Allows the Legislature to exempt property used for charitable purposes, and owned by non-profit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes, such as universities, hospitals, and libraries (California Constitution, Article XIII, Sections Four and Five). The Legislature enacted this exemption, commonly known as the “welfare exemption.”
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or when ownership changes (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, as added by Proposition 13, 1978).
- Allows the welfare exemption for rental housing when the housing is financed by tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds; general obligation bonds; federal, state, or local grants; or federal low-income housing tax credits, pursuant to specific requirements. For projects with both low-income and market rate units, the owner can claim a partial exemption, equal to that percentage of the value of the property equal to the percentage that the number of units serving lower income households represents of the total number of residential units.
- Provides that non-publicly financed affordable housing, up to $20 million in value statewide, can claim a full exemption when:
- 90% of the households occupying the housing must be low-income persons, whose rent does not exceed specified limits for low-income persons;
- The property is managed solely by a charitable non-profit organization, specifically excluding limited partnerships, to be eligible for the exemption.
- Does not allow a partial exemption for non-publicly financed affordable housing similar to the one for publicly-finance affordable housing.
This bill:
- Revises the welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing to provide that the exemption applies when charities own non-publicly financed affordable housing where more than 50% of residents are low-income.
- Increases the cap on value from $20 million to $100 million.
- Becomes effective in the 2020-21 fiscal year.
- Creates a process for assessors to cancel taxes, interest, penalties, or escape assessments based on the bill’s changes.
- Sunsets its alterations after the 2030-31 fiscal year.
Background
Prior to 1999, rental housing owners could claim a welfare exemption from property tax for low-income housing if 20% of the property’s residents were low-income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city’s worst housing projects, they discovered that tax-exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance to housing that qualified them for the exemption from property tax. Responding to the investigation, the Legislature enacted AB 1559 (Wiggins, Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999), which repealed the occupancy test, instead requiring all owners to receive public financing in the forms listed above for the project to claim the welfare exemption, in addition to the above requirements. However, AB 1559 revoked the exemption for many worthy properties owned by charities that weren’t publicly financed, so the Legislature subsequently enacted AB 659 (Wiggins, Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000), which again allowed a full exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing property, subject to the above described requirements.
Since 2000, the value of housing has increased, compelling some non-profits to pay taxes on amounts that exceed the statutory cap, and discouraging other groups from acquiring rental housing in the hopes of preserving existing affordable units in their areas. In response, the Legislature enacted SB 996 (Hill, Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016), which:
- Quintupled the cap, and revised it to instead apply to the property’s value, not the tax paid, with the new threshold at $10 million of assessed value,
- Created a process for taxpayers to file a claim to cancel any outstanding taxes or escape assessments due on values that exceeded the previous cap, and
- Required property owners claiming the welfare exemption to provide specified information regarding the household income of and the rent charged to an occupant of an exempt unit.
However, charities must pay tax on any amount of value that exceeds the cap, which applies to all of its properties statewide, and the Saint Francis Center in San Mateo County continues to acquire affordable housing. Last year, the Legislature again increased the cap to $20 million in value (SB 1115, Hill, Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018), and provided a process for taxpayers to file a claim to have any outstanding taxes or escape assessments cancelled.
The Center recently acquired a property where all but a few residents meet the income eligibility requirements, but less than the 90% required, so the Center would have to evict one or more of the non-low income persons to meet the 90% requirement for the exemption, and a partial exemption does not apply because the property is not publicly financed.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual property tax losses, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in initial years and increasing in future years. Based on current information about affected properties, initial property tax revenue losses may be as high as $220,000. The Board of Equalization notes that revenue losses may increase in future years as nonprofit organizations acquire more properties that would otherwise be subject welfare exemption under current law. Any property tax revenue losses will lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending equal to roughly half of the local revenue losses.
- Potential, but likely modest, reimbursable costs for local county officials related to the assessment process.
AIDS Health Care Foundation
Mark Pope, San Mateo County Assessor-County Clerk-Recorder and Chief Elections Official
Saint Francis Center
San Mateo County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 10/18/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Four out of the five least affordable rental markets nationwide continue to be in California. Nonprofits that do not receive any tax credits from the state or federal government, and that provide non-publicly financed affordable housing to low income families, must pay property tax on affordable housing property with an assessed value of more than $20 million. Approximately 26 nonprofits in California fundraise privately to provide affordable housing in their communities and do not receive tax credits, possibly because they lack the staff to research and apply for the tax credits. In areas with very high rents and property values, like the Bay Area and Los Angeles, the property tax exemption cap limits the ability of these nonprofits to provide more affordable housing. These nonprofits own 75 properties that are subject to the cap, according to records county assessors filed with BOE. Only two of the organizations have exceeded the existing cap. SB 294 aids nonprofits and religious organizations by raising the cap for the property tax exemption on their affordable housing properties from an assessed value of $20 million to $250 million. Additionally, the bill lowers the percentage of low income residents required in a given property from 90% to 50% in order to be eligible for tax relief on a pro rata basis.”
GOVERNOR'S VETO MESSAGE:
I am returning Senate Bill 294 without my signature.
This bill would revise the current property tax welfare exemption for nonprofits that own and operate non-publicly financed affordable housing developments by increasing the current exemption for nonprofits from $20 million to $100 million and reducing the current low-income tenancy threshold from 90 percent to 50 percent for ten years. The bill would also allow outstanding unpaid property tax bills to be reduced or potentially forgiven on qualified properties.
While well intended, and specific to certain nonprofit entities that provide affordable housing, this bill makes changes to the property tax welfare exemption that could have significant long-term General Fund costs and reduced local revenue. In addition to tax exemptions under current law, properties that are in need of assistance to maintain long-term affordability have access to a range of state and local preservation financing programs.
Sustaining affordable housing in fiscally responsible manner for the long-term is a goal I share with the Legislature. Although this bill is not the solution, I am committed to working with the Legislature on bolstering existing programs and tailoring them to produce and preserve the State's much needed affordable housing stock.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/5/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
10/21/19 11:31:58
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 294 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 294
Amended: 7/1/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/27/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/5/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
DIGEST:
This bill allows for a partial welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing, and increases the statewide cap on the value of property used for non-publicly financed affordable housing.
Assembly Amendments reduce the increase in the cap on the statewide value of property eligible for the exemption from $250 to $100 million, and delete duplicative language requiring any partial exemption to be prorated.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law (California Constitution, Article XIII).
- Allows the Legislature to exempt property used for charitable purposes, and owned by non-profit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes, such as universities, hospitals, and libraries (California Constitution, Article XIII, Sections Four and Five). The Legislature enacted this exemption, commonly known as the “welfare exemption.”
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or when ownership changes (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, as added by Proposition 13, 1978).
- Allows the welfare exemption for rental housing when the housing is financed by tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds; general obligation bonds; federal, state, or local grants; or federal low-income housing tax credits, pursuant to specific requirements. For projects with both low-income and market rate units, the owner can claim a partial exemption, equal to that percentage of the value of the property equal to the percentage that the number of units serving lower income households represents of the total number of residential units.
- Provides that non-publicly financed affordable housing, up to $20 million in value statewide, can claim a full exemption when:
- 90% of the households occupying the housing must be low-income persons, whose rent does not exceed specified limits for low-income persons;
- The property is managed solely by a charitable non-profit organization, specifically excluding limited partnerships, to be eligible for the exemption.
- Does not allow a partial exemption for non-publicly financed affordable housing similar to the one for publicly-finance affordable housing.
This bill:
- Revises the welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing to provide that the exemption applies when charities own non-publicly financed affordable housing where more than 50% of residents are low-income.
- Increases the cap on value from $20 million to $100 million.
- Becomes effective in the 2020-21 fiscal year.
- Creates a process for assessors to cancel taxes, interest, penalties, or escape assessments based on the bill’s changes.
- Sunsets its alterations after the 2030-31 fiscal year.
Background
Prior to 1999, rental housing owners could claim a welfare exemption from property tax for low-income housing if 20% of the property’s residents were low-income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city’s worst housing projects, they discovered that tax-exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance to housing that qualified them for the exemption from property tax. Responding to the investigation, the Legislature enacted AB 1559 (Wiggins, Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999), which repealed the occupancy test, instead requiring all owners to receive public financing in the forms listed above for the project to claim the welfare exemption, in addition to the above requirements. However, AB 1559 revoked the exemption for many worthy properties owned by charities that weren’t publicly financed, so the Legislature subsequently enacted AB 659 (Wiggins, Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000), which again allowed a full exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing property, subject to the above described requirements.
Since 2000, the value of housing has increased, compelling some non-profits to pay taxes on amounts that exceed the statutory cap, and discouraging other groups from acquiring rental housing in the hopes of preserving existing affordable units in their areas. In response, the Legislature enacted SB 996 (Hill, Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016), which:
- Quintupled the cap, and revised it to instead apply to the property’s value, not the tax paid, with the new threshold at $10 million of assessed value,
- Created a process for taxpayers to file a claim to cancel any outstanding taxes or escape assessments due on values that exceeded the previous cap, and
- Required property owners claiming the welfare exemption to provide specified information regarding the household income of and the rent charged to an occupant of an exempt unit.
However, charities must pay tax on any amount of value that exceeds the cap, which applies to all of its properties statewide, and the Saint Francis Center in San Mateo County continues to acquire affordable housing. Last year, the Legislature again increased the cap to $20 million in value (SB 1115, Hill, Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018), and provided a process for taxpayers to file a claim to have any outstanding taxes or escape assessments cancelled.
The Center recently acquired a property where all but a few residents meet the income eligibility requirements, but less than the 90% required, so the Center would have to evict one or more of the non-low income persons to meet the 90% requirement for the exemption, and a partial exemption does not apply because the property is not publicly financed.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Annual property tax losses, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in initial years and increasing in future years. Based on current information about affected properties, initial property tax revenue losses may be as high as $220,000. The Board of Equalization notes that revenue losses may increase in future years as nonprofit organizations acquire more properties that would otherwise be subject welfare exemption under current law. Any property tax revenue losses will lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending equal to roughly half of the local revenue losses.
- Potential, but likely modest, reimbursable costs for local county officials related to the assessment process.
AIDS Health Care Foundation
Mark Pope, San Mateo County Assessor-County Clerk-Recorder and Chief Elections Official
Saint Francis Center
San Mateo County
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Four out of the five least affordable rental markets nationwide continue to be in California. Nonprofits that do not receive any tax credits from the state or federal government, and that provide non-publicly financed affordable housing to low income families, must pay property tax on affordable housing property with an assessed value of more than $20 million. Approximately 26 nonprofits in California fundraise privately to provide affordable housing in their communities and do not receive tax credits, possibly because they lack the staff to research and apply for the tax credits. In areas with very high rents and property values, like the Bay Area and Los Angeles, the property tax exemption cap limits the ability of these nonprofits to provide more affordable housing. These nonprofits own 75 properties that are subject to the cap, according to records county assessors filed with BOE. Only two of the organizations have exceeded the existing cap. SB 294 aids nonprofits and religious organizations by raising the cap for the property tax exemption on their affordable housing properties from an assessed value of $20 million to $250 million. Additionally, the bill lowers the percentage of low income residents required in a given property from 90% to 50% in order to be eligible for tax relief on a pro rata basis.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/5/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
9/5/19 15:50:36
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 294
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Increases the property tax exemption limitation from $20 million to $100 million in assessed value and decreases the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50% that applies to certain low-income rental housing owned by a nonprofit organization if the housing is not receiving government financing or tax credits.
Major Provisions
- Increases from $20 million to $100 million a cap that limits the total assessed value exemption amount allowed to non-publicly financed rental housing owned and operated by a nonprofit organization for low-income households at affordable rents.
- Decreases, for the 2020-21 through the 2030-31 fiscal years, the minimum occupancy threshold by low-income households before a pro-rata, occupancy-based exemption is permitted from 90% to 50%.
- Allows the cancellation of outstanding property taxes on low-income rental housing eligible for exemption pursuant to the above conditions.
COMMENTS:
Increasing the cap to $100 million: Increasing the exemption amount provides tax relief to the few nonprofit organizations able to privately raise funds to acquire and operate affordable rental housing without governmental assistance. The exemption limit has been periodically increased as the need arises.
Reducing the minimum occupancy threshold to 50%: Decreasing the minimum occupancy threshold permits nonprofits to allow pre-existing tenants who are, or become, non-income qualifying to continue residing in the units without disqualifying the entire property from exemption eligibility. Decreasing the minimum occupancy threshold addresses a recent 48-unit apartment purchase in San Mateo County where 90% of the pre-existing tenants were not income qualified, thus disqualifying the entire property.
Why do these requirements exist? The exemption limits and the minimum occupancy threshold applicable to certain nonprofit-owned rental housing were created following the discovery of exemption abuse by rental housing property owners who allegedly created shell nonprofit organizations to avoid paying property taxes. Additional safeguards and reforms to address low-income rental housing exemption abuses were also instituted and remain in place.
According to the Author:
This bill will aid nonprofits and religious organizations that provide affordable housing by expanding the property tax exemption to $100 million in assessed value annually. Additionally, charities will be able to get a pro-rated portion of their property taxes exempted as long as they have at least 50% low income tenants. Specifically, SB 294 will help two charities in our state from day 1 - one of which is in my district.
Arguments in Support:
The County of San Mateo states:
Given the severity of the affordable housing challenge and the astronomical rate of increases in property value over the last several years in our County, it is more important than ever to preserve and assist the efforts of nonprofits like the Saint Francis Center in Redwood City, which provide non-publicly financed affordable housing to extremely low-income residents without receiving tax credits from the state or federal government. Lowering the required percentage of low-income tenants and prorating the exemption based on low-income occupancy would help to alleviate displacement that can result when a charity purchases a building with existing tenants as was recently the case with the St. Francis Center.
Arguments in Opposition:
None
FISCAL COMMENTS:
- Annual property tax losses, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in initial years and increasing in future years. Based on current information about affected properties, initial property tax revenue losses may be as high as $220,000. The Board of Equalization notes that revenue losses may increase in future years as nonprofit organizations acquire more properties that would otherwise be subject to taxation under current law. Any property tax revenue losses will lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending equal to roughly half of the local revenue losses.
- Potential, but likely modest, reimbursable costs for local county officials related to the assessment process.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM REVENUE AND TAXATION: 9-0-2
YES: Burke, Brough, Chu, Mayes, Mullin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, McCarty, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gray, Melendez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 1, 2019
CONSULTANT: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098 FN: 0001631
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 294
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill increases, from the first $20 million in assessed value to the first $100 million in assessed value, the welfare exemption cap for certain nonprofit-owned low-income housing projects. This bill also temporarily reduces the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50% and cancels outstanding taxes on specified properties levied or imposed between January 1, 2019, and January 1, 2020.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual property tax losses, likely in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in initial years and increasing in future years. Based on current information about affected properties, initial property tax revenue losses may be as high as $220,000. The Board of Equalization notes that revenue losses may increase in future years as nonprofit organizations acquire more properties that would otherwise be subject welfare exemption under current law. Any property tax revenue losses will lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending equal to roughly half of the local revenue losses.
- Potential, but likely modest, reimbursable costs for local county officials related to the assessment process.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Property owned by nonprofit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes may be exempt from property taxation. This “welfare exemption” can also apply to nonprofit-owned low-income rental housing, and in these cases the exemption is based on the percentage of units serving low-income households. For these types of housing projects, the welfare exemption applies differently based on whether a project receives government assistance or not. Specifically, non-publicly financed housing project must devote 90% of its units for low-income housing, and only the first $20 million in assessed value is exempt (also known as the welfare exemption cap). In contrast, projects receiving government financing or low-income housing tax credits are not subject to the cap or the same occupancy tests.
- History of the welfare exemption cap. Following an investigation into abuses of the welfare exemption in the late 1990s, the Legislature established a welfare exemption cap equal to the first $2 million in assessed value. At the time, it was thought that properties receiving government financing or income tax credits would be subject to more oversight (which is why these projects are not subject to a cap), and the cap was created to limit the tax benefit for those creating shell nonprofit organizations in order to receive ample tax benefit.
More recently, the Legislature has increased the cap in response to specific nonprofits facing the cap. SB 996 (Hill), Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016, increased the cap from $2 million to $10 million and SB 1115 (Hill), Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018, increased the cap from $10 million to $20 million. These bills most directly affected the Saint Francis Center, a nonprofit located in the Bay Area that has been purchasing properties for the purposes of providing low-income housing.
- Purpose. The author provides the following statement:
SB 294 will aid nonprofits and religious organizations that provide affordable housing by expanding the property tax exemption to $100 million in assessed value annually. Additionally, charities will be able to get a pro-rated portion of their property taxes exempted as long as they have at least 50% low income tenants. Specifically, SB 294 will help two charities in our state from day 1 - one of which is in my district.
- Recent history. This bill, like previous legislative efforts to increase the welfare exemption cap, attempts to strike a balance between maintaining the goal and spirit of the cap and helping nonprofits and charities expand access to much-needed affordable housing. It was for this reason this committee amended SB 1115 (Hill) to replace a proposed total elimination of the welfare exemption cap with an increase to $20 million. At the time, based on conversations with supporters, this committee concluded that exempting up to $20 million in assessed value from property taxes would adequately cover affected properties.
This bill takes another bite at the apple and once again increases the cap. While SB 1115 applied to the Saint Francis Center’s $9.5 million purchase of a 25-unit apartment building, the new $20 million exemption did not cover Saint Francis’ purchase of a $22 million property that was in escrow at the time SB 1115 was moving through the legislative process. This bill increase the cap to $100 million, which will cover all known properties facing the cap as well as provide for additional breathing room for other nonprofits and charities seeking to purchase property for affordable housing.
- Minimum occupancy threshold. For projects subject to the $20 million cap, 90% of units must be affordable for lower income households. This bill reduces that occupancy threshold to 50% for exemption claims filed from 2020-21 through 2030-31. This will prevent the displacement of existing residents of a property recently purchased by the Saint Francis Center.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 294
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
FOR VOTE ONLY
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
SUMMARY: Increases the welfare exemption cap from $20 million to $100 million in assessed value and decreases the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50% that applies to certain low-income rental housing owned and operated by a non-profit organization that does not receive government financing or tax credits. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases from $20 million to $100 million the welfare exemption cap that limits the total assessed value exemption amount allowed to non-publicly financed rental housing owned and operated a non-profit organization for low-income households whose rent does not exceed specified amounts.
- Decreases, for exemption claims filed from the 2020-21 through the 2030-31 fiscal year, inclusive, the minimum occupancy threshold requirement in those properties subject to the welfare exemption cap from 90% to 50%.
- Requires any outstanding qualified ad valorem tax in excess of the "total exemption amount limitation" ($20 million in assessed value), and related interest or penalty, which was levied or imposed on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2020, to be canceled if a "qualified taxpayer" files a "qualified claim" on "qualified property".
- Prohibits, on and after January 1, 2020, an escape assessment from being levied on qualified property if that amount would be subject to cancellation.
- Defines a "qualified taxpayer" as a taxpayer subject to the total exemption amount limitation.
- Defines "total exemption amount limitation" as the exemption amount limitation with respect to a single property or multiple properties that is specified in Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214(g)(1)(C) as it read before January 1, 2020. This amount is $20 million in assessed value.
- Defines a "qualified claim" as a claim for exemption that was filed for a qualified property with the assessor on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2020, for which the assessor either (i) granted a partial exemption or (ii) denied the exemption because the minimum 90% occupancy threshold requirement was not met.
- Defines a "qualified property" as property used exclusively for rental housing and related facilities where 50% or more of the occupants of the property are lower income households whose rent does not exceed the rent prescribed by Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50053, and that qualifies for exemption under R&TC Section 214(g)(1)(C)(i)(I).
- Excludes from a "qualified property" property owned by a limited partnership in which the managing general partner is an eligible nonprofit organization.
- Makes findings and declarations that the cancellation of qualified outstanding ad valorem tax fulfills a statewide purpose because it addresses California's serious shortage of affordable housing by providing necessary tax relief for certain tax-exempt organizations so that these organizations can provide affordable housing for persons and families of low income.
- Provides that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs will be made as required by statute.
- Provides that no appropriation is made by this bill and that no reimbursement is required of any local agency for any property tax revenues lost.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Legislature to exempt from taxation, in whole or in part, property used exclusively for religious, hospital, or charitable purposes, as specified. (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 4(b).) The Legislature has implemented this "welfare exemption" in R&TC Section 214.
- Exempts low-income rental housing owned and operated by nonprofit organizations, including limited partnerships in which the managing general partner is an eligible nonprofit corporation, as specified. (R&TC Section 214(g).)
- Defines "low-income" as households at 80% of area median income (AMI) adjusted for family size. (R&TC Section 214(g)(2)(C)(i).)
- Grants a partial welfare exemption, equal to the percentage of units serving lower income households as defined in H&SC Section 50053, to property used exclusively for rental housing and operated by nonprofit organizations, as specified, under either of the following conditions:
- The project is publicly financed with tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds, general obligation bonds, grants, or low-income housing tax credits (LIHTCs); or,
- In the case of non-publicly financed affordable rental housing, 90% of units are affordable for lower income households with the nonprofit organization limited to an exemption of $20 million in assessed value on a statewide basis.
- Requires organizations seeking the welfare exemption to do the following:
- File an enforceable and verifiable agreement with a public agency or other restriction, as specified, that provides that the units designated for use by lower income households are continuously available to or occupied by lower income households; and,
- Certify that the funds that would have been used to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of, or reduce rents otherwise necessary for, the units occupied by lower income households.
- Requires, in the case of non-publicly financed low-income rental housing, a claim for the welfare exemption to be accompanied by a confidential affidavit, not subject to public disclosure, including a list of units occupied by lower income households for which the exemption is claimed, and the following non-personally identifiable information about the occupants (R&TC Section 259.14):
- The actual household income of the occupant;
- The maximum rent that may be charged to the occupant; and,
- The actual rent charged to the occupant.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the State Board of Equalization (BOE), the property tax revenue loss from reducing the occupancy threshold is unknown. However, based on average assessed values, the BOE estimates that the revenue impact per property that additionally qualifies would be $16,000. The revenue loss from increasing the exemption cap is pending.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
SB 294 will aid nonprofits and religious organizations that provide affordable housing by expanding the property tax exemption to $100 million in assessed value annually. Additionally, charities will be able to get a pro-rated portion of their property taxes exempted as long as they have at least 50% low income tenants. Specifically, SB 294 will help two charities in our state from day 1 - one of which is in my district.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- The low-income rental housing property tax exemption: To qualify for the welfare exemption, the rental property must be financed with tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds or general obligation bonds; local, state, or federal loans or grants; or low-income housing tax credits. Rental properties without government financing may also qualify for the exemption, but under more restrictive conditions. The rental property must be solely owned by a nonprofit organization (limited partnerships with a nonprofit organization serving as the managing general partner are ineligible) and lower income households must comprise 90% or more of its occupants before it can be eligible. Additionally, there is a statewide cap on the total amount of exempt property from which a nonprofit organization may benefit, limited to $20 million of assessed value with respect to a single property or multiple properties for any fiscal year. Counties annually provide information to the BOE to track this limitation statewide. The current cap impacts two organizations.
- Background: Prior to 2000, nonprofit organizations that own rental housing could generally claim the welfare exemption merely on an "occupancy test" basis, which was 20% of the property's occupants were low income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city's worst housing projects, they discovered abuse of the welfare exemption that enabled owners of substandard housing properties to benefit from this property tax exemption. Allegations were made that substandard housing owners were partnering with nonprofit organizations in a limited partnership as a ruse to obtain the welfare exemption, or were creating their own nonprofit organizations for the sole purpose of holding their properties. In response, AB 1559 (Wiggins), Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999, repealed the occupancy test and instead required owners to receive government financing or income tax credits to qualify for the welfare exemption as such properties would at least be subject to some level of government oversight, presumably resulting in less fraud and higher quality housing for tenants. AB 1559 also imposed more stringent documentation standards to substantiate that the rental housing is dedicated to low-income housing.
- Why was the exemption cap created? The reforms set forth by AB 1559 inadvertently resulted in revocation of the welfare exemption from otherwise deserving nonprofit organizations that had been providing affordable rental housing without government support. In response, AB 659 (Wiggins), Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000, reinstated the welfare exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing with the restrictions provided for in existing law today. First, limited partnerships were banned. Second, the lower income occupancy test basis was restored, but increased from a 20% to 90% threshold. Third, the exemption cap was created. The intent of the cap was to limit the tax benefit bestowed on "bad actors" who might still qualify for the welfare exemption by creating shell nonprofit organizations.
- What does this bill do? This bill has three parts.
- Exemption cap: First, this bill increases the exemption cap from $20 million to $100 million in assessed value.
- Occupancy threshold: Second, this bill reduces the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50%, this will sunset after 10 years, and the threshold will return to 90%.
- Tax cancellation: Finally, this bill allows a county to cancel outstanding taxes on a rental housing property levied or imposed between January 1, 2019 and January 1, 2020 that meets these requirements. In application, this applies to San Mateo County, to low-income housing owned by the Saint Francis Center.
- The exemption cap is unique: No other property eligible for the welfare exemption is subject to any exemption cap limiting the amount of the exemption provided. Additionally, no other property eligible for other types of exemptions (e.g., church, college, and museum) is subject to any cap. The BOE annually collects information from county assessors to track the statewide cap. This assessor-reported information indicates that only two organizations are impacted by the cap.
- Have we been here before? Last year, this Committee passed SB 1115 (Hill) in a form which would have eliminated the exemption cap. Subsequently, in the Assembly Appropriations' Committee, SB 1115 was amended to instead increase the cap from $10 million to $20 million in assessed value. This amount was sufficient to cover the Saint Francis Center's $9.5 million purchase of a 25-unit apartment building giving rise to SB 1115. However, at that time, the Legislature was unaware that the Saint Francis Center was in escrow for a $22 million purchase of a 48-unit apartment. Previously, this information had not been pertinent given that SB 1115 initially eliminated the assessed value cap altogether.
- The minimum occupancy threshold reduction: This bill reduces the low-income household occupancy threshold in the case of a multi-family property from 90% to 50%. This reduction is intended to address the otherwise displacement of pre-existing tenants of the 48-unit apartment in the case of the Saint Francis Center's most recent acquisition. A few of the tenants living at the complex did not qualify as low-income households. While the low-income housing exemption is a pro-rata exemption based on the number of units occupied by eligible households, the minimum occupancy threshold is high at 90%. The Saint Francis Center did not want to displace those tenants from their homes. This bill reduces the minimum threshold from 90% to 50%, so that nonprofit organizations subject to the exemption cap need not evict tenants to qualify for the exemption. Instead, the nonprofit organization could opt to pay property taxes on those units. This bill sunsets the threshold reduction after 10 years and the threshold will return to 90%.
- Has the exemption cap been effective? Since its creation, few organizations have exceeded the cap. Most affordable housing projects receive government financing or tax credits. Those nonprofit organizations that have been impacted, or potentially impacted, have sought legislative intervention to increase the cap or to exclude the specific property from the cap. Committee staff notes that it appears the other safeguards (prohibiting limited partnerships and more stringent documentation) have proven effective. The exemption cap, however, has financially harmed those few nonprofits able to privately raise funds to provide housing and earn the support of their local community.
- Increasing the cap to $100 million: As property values continue to increase, more organizations may become impacted by the cap. Increasing the cap allows nonprofit organizations able to privately raise funds to acquire and operate more affordable housing units without fear of breaching the cap. This amount is sufficient to address all organizations currently impacted by the cap.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: This committee has recently adopted a new policy that tax expenditures, which include the expansion of an exemption such as this bill proposes, outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure seeks to achieve and data collection for evaluation purposes. Additionally, the policy requires an appropriate sunset date. This bill includes findings and declarations stating that it addresses California's serious shortage of affordable, decent, safe, and sanitary housing for low-income persons and families by providing necessary property tax relief for certain tax-exempt organizations so that these organizations can provide affordable housing for low-income persons and families. Additionally, this bill includes provisions to sunset the occupancy threshold changes and the exemption cap provision originally proposed at $250 million was reduced to $100 million to allow the Legislature to review the exemption on a periodic basis as needed. Data collection procedures currently exist through the BOE's statewide monitoring of the exemption cap.
- Previous legislation:
- SB 1115 (Hill), Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018, increased the exemption cap from $10 million to $20 million.
- SB 996 (Hill), Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016, effectively increased the cap from $2 million in assessed value ($20,000 in tax) to $10 million in assessed value ($100,000 in tax) and transitioned the measure of the cap from tax dollars to assessed value for administrative ease.
- SB 1284 (Lowenthal), Chapter 524, Statutes of 2008, excluded from the welfare exemption cap specified affordable housing properties acquired by a non-profit organization in Long Beach, as a result of mitigation efforts from the construction of the Century Freeway (I-105) in Los Angeles County.
- AB 659 (Wiggins), Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000, reinstated welfare exemption-eligibility for non-publicly financed low-income rental housing (excluding LPs) and created the welfare exemption cap applicable to this rental housing and established the 90% occupancy threshold.
- AB 1559 (Wiggins), Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999, revoked the welfare exemption eligibility from low-income housing if it did not receive governmental financial assistance. AB 1559 also imposed higher documentation standards to substantiate that a rental property is dedicated to low-income housing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Date of Hearing: June 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 294
Author:(Hill) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2019
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
SUMMARY: Increases the welfare exemption cap from $20 million to $250 million in assessed value and decreases the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50% that applies to certain low-income rental housing owned and operated by a non-profit organization that does not receive government financing or tax credits. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases from $20 million to $250 million the welfare exemption cap that limits the total assessed value exemption amount allowed to non-publicly financed rental housing owned and operated a non-profit organization for low-income households whose rent does not exceed specified amounts.
- Decreases, for exemption claims filed from the 2020-21 through the 2030-31 fiscal year, inclusive, the minimum occupancy threshold requirement in those properties subject to the welfare exemption cap from 90% to 50%.
- Requires any outstanding qualified ad valorem tax in excess of the "total exemption amount limitation" ($20 million in assessed value), and related interest or penalty, which was levied or imposed on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2020, to be canceled if a "qualified taxpayer" files a "qualified claim" on "qualified property".
- Prohibits, on and after January 1, 2020, an escape assessment from being levied on qualified property if that amount would be subject to cancellation.
- Defines a "qualified taxpayer" as a taxpayer subject to the total exemption amount limitation.
- Defines "total exemption amount limitation" as the exemption amount limitation with respect to a single property or multiple properties that is specified in Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 214(g)(1)(C) as it read before January 1, 2020. This amount is $20 million in assessed value.
- Defines a "qualified claim" as a claim for exemption that was filed for a qualified property with the assessor on and after January 1, 2019, and before January 1, 2020, for which the assessor either (i) granted a partial exemption or (ii) denied the exemption because the minimum 90% occupancy threshold requirement was not met.
- Defines a "qualified property" as property used exclusively for rental housing and related facilities where 50% or more of the occupants of the property are lower income households whose rent does not exceed the rent prescribed by Health and Safety Code (H&SC) Section 50053, and that qualifies for exemption under R&TC Section 214(g)(1)(C)(i)(I).
- Excludes from a "qualified property" property owned by a limited partnership in which the managing general partner is an eligible nonprofit organization.
- Makes findings and declarations that the cancellation of qualified outstanding ad valorem tax fulfills a statewide purpose because it addresses California's serious shortage of affordable housing by providing necessary tax relief for certain tax-exempt organizations so that these organizations can provide affordable housing for persons and families of low income.
- Provides that if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs will be made as required by statute.
- Provides that no appropriation is made by this bill and that no reimbursement is required of any local agency for any property tax revenues lost.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Legislature to exempt from taxation, in whole or in part, property used exclusively for religious, hospital, or charitable purposes, as specified. (California Constitution Article XIII, Section 4(b).) The Legislature has implemented this "welfare exemption" in R&TC Section 214.
- Exempts low-income rental housing owned and operated by nonprofit organizations, including limited partnerships in which the managing general partner is an eligible nonprofit corporation, as specified. (R&TC Section 214(g).)
- Defines "low-income" as households at 80% of area median income (AMI) adjusted for family size. (R&TC Section 214(g)(2)(C)(i).)
- Grants a partial welfare exemption, equal to the percentage of units serving lower income households as defined in H&SC Section 50053, to property used exclusively for rental housing and operated by nonprofit organizations, as specified, under either of the following conditions:
- The project is publicly financed with tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds, general obligation bonds, grants, or low-income housing tax credits (LIHTCs); or,
- In the case of non-publicly financed affordable rental housing, 90% of units are affordable for lower income households with the nonprofit organization limited to an exemption of $20 million in assessed value on a statewide basis.
- Requires organizations seeking the welfare exemption to do the following:
- File an enforceable and verifiable agreement with a public agency or other restriction, as specified, that provides that the units designated for use by lower income households are continuously available to or occupied by lower income households; and,
- Certify that the funds that would have been used to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of, or reduce rents otherwise necessary for, the units occupied by lower income households.
- Requires, in the case of non-publicly financed low-income rental housing, a claim for the welfare exemption to be accompanied by a confidential affidavit, not subject to public disclosure, including a list of units occupied by lower income households for which the exemption is claimed, and the following non-personally identifiable information about the occupants (R&TC Section 259.14):
- The actual household income of the occupant;
- The maximum rent that may be charged to the occupant; and,
- The actual rent charged to the occupant.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the State Board of Equalization (BOE), the property tax revenue loss from reducing the occupancy threshold is unknown. However, based on average assessed values, the BOE estimates that the revenue impact per property that additionally qualifies would be $16,000. The revenue loss from increasing the exemption cap is pending.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
SB 294 will aid nonprofits and religious organizations that provide affordable housing by expanding the property tax exemption to $250 million in assessed value annually. Additionally, charities will be able to get a pro-rated portion of their property taxes exempted as long as they have at least 50% low income tenants. Specifically, SB 294 will help two charities in our state from day 1 - one of which is in my district.
- The Saint Francis Center, which is the non-profit organization referenced above in the author's district, in support of this bill explains the following:
The St Francis Center [ . . . ] owns and operates 135 extremely and very-low income housing units. Over the years and in response to the huge need, we have purchased dilapidated buildings, completely remodeled them and have provided safe, dignified and affordable "homes" for our families. In the process of trying to purchase horrible properties, rehab them and turn them into beautiful places for families to live, we very quickly ran into the $20 million in assessed value currently allowed by law. In fact, one recent building purchase was $22 million and garnered 48 units for low-income families, but this building alone takes us out of tax exemption availability. Now, our tax bills are more than the meager rents that are generated. We are no longer able to honor our mission of trying to purchase and safe-guard housing because of the current tax limit. Though we serve in a very low-income community, we still serve in California, so property values are exorbitant and reaching the tax exemption limit was very easy to do.
- The California Assessors' Association has taken an oppose unless amended position relating to the desire for a sunset date provision.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- The low-income rental housing property tax exemption: To qualify for the welfare exemption, the rental property must be financed with tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds or general obligation bonds; local, state, or federal loans or grants; or low-income housing tax credits. Rental properties without government financing may also qualify for the exemption, but under more restrictive conditions. The rental property must be solely owned by a nonprofit organization (limited partnerships with a nonprofit organization serving as the managing general partner are ineligible) and lower income households must comprise 90% or more of its occupants before it can be eligible. Additionally, there is a statewide cap on the total amount of exempt property from which a nonprofit organization may benefit, limited to $20 million of assessed value with respect to a single property or multiple properties for any fiscal year. Counties annually provide information to the BOE to track this limitation statewide. The current cap impacts two organizations.
- Background: Prior to 2000, nonprofit organizations that own rental housing could generally claim the welfare exemption merely on an "occupancy test" basis, which was 20% of the property's occupants were low income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city's worst housing projects, they discovered abuse of the welfare exemption that enabled owners of substandard housing properties to benefit from this property tax exemption. Allegations were made that substandard housing owners were partnering with nonprofit organizations in a limited partnership as a ruse to obtain the welfare exemption, or were creating their own nonprofit organizations for the sole purpose of holding their properties. In response, AB 1559 (Wiggins), Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999, repealed the occupancy test and instead required owners to receive government financing or income tax credits to qualify for the welfare exemption as such properties would at least be subject to some level of government oversight, presumably resulting in less fraud and higher quality housing for tenants. AB 1559 also imposed more stringent documentation standards to substantiate that the rental housing is dedicated to low-income housing.
- Why was the exemption cap created? The reforms set forth by AB 1559 inadvertently resulted in revocation of the welfare exemption from otherwise deserving nonprofit organizations that had been providing affordable rental housing without government support. In response, AB 659 (Wiggins), Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000, reinstated the welfare exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing with the restrictions provided for in existing law today. First, limited partnerships were banned. Second, the lower income occupancy test basis was restored, but increased from a 20% to 90% threshold. Third, the exemption cap was created. The intent of the cap was to limit the tax benefit bestowed on "bad actors" who might still qualify for the welfare exemption by creating shell nonprofit organizations.
- What does this bill do? This bill has three parts.
- Exemption cap: First, this bill increases the exemption cap from $20 million to $250 million in assessed value.
- Occupancy threshold: Second, this bill reduces the minimum occupancy threshold from 90% to 50%, will sunset after 10 years, and the threshold will return to 90%.
- Tax cancellation: Finally, this bill allows a county to cancel outstanding taxes on a rental housing property levied or imposed between January 1, 2019 and January 1, 2020 that meets these requirements. In application, this applies to San Mateo County.
- The exemption cap is unique: No other property eligible for the welfare exemption is subject to any exemption cap limiting the amount of the exemption provided. Additionally, no other property eligible for other types of exemptions (e.g., church, college, and museum) is subject to any cap. The BOE annually collects information from county assessors to track the statewide cap. This assessor-reported information indicates that only two organizations are impacted by the cap.
- Have we been here before? Last year, this Committee passed SB 1115 (Hill) in a form which would have eliminated the exemption cap. Subsequently, in the Assembly Appropriations' Committee, SB 1115 was amended to instead increase the cap from $10 million to $20 million in assessed value. This amount was sufficient to cover the Saint Francis Center's $9.5 million purchase of a 25-unit apartment building giving rise to SB 1115. However, at that time, the Legislature was unaware that the Saint Francis Center was in escrow for a $22 million purchase of a 48-unit apartment. Previously, this information had not been pertinent given that SB 1115 initially eliminated the assessed value cap altogether.
- The minimum occupancy threshold reduction: This bill reduces the low-income household occupancy threshold in the case of a multi-family property from 90% to 50%. This reduction is intended to address the otherwise displacement of pre-existing tenants of the 48-unit apartment in the case of the Saint Francis Center's most recent acquisition. A few of the tenants living at the complex did not qualify as low-income households. While the low-income housing exemption is a pro-rata exemption based on the number of units occupied by eligible households, the minimum occupancy threshold is high at 90%. The Saint Francis Center did not want to displace those tenants from their homes. This bill reduces the minimum threshold from 90% to 50%, so that nonprofit organizations subject to the exemption cap need not evict tenants to qualify for the exemption. Instead, the nonprofit organization could opt to pay property taxes on those units. This bill sunsets the threshold reduction after 10 years and the threshold will return to 90%.
- Unclear threshold language: The BOE states that this bill's occupancy threshold provisions assume that the exemption for exemption-cap impacted properties is not prorated and is unclear. Committee staff concurs and is working with the author to clarify this language.
- Has the exemption cap been effective? Since its creation, few organizations have exceeded the cap. Most affordable housing projects receive government financing or tax credits. Those nonprofit organizations that have been impacted, or potentially impacted, have sought legislative intervention to increase the cap or to exclude the specific property from the cap. Committee staff notes that it appears the other safeguards (prohibiting limited partnerships and more stringent documentation) have proven effective. The exemption cap, however, has financially harmed those few nonprofits able to privately raise funds to provide housing and earn the support of their local community.
- Increasing the cap to $250 million: As property values continue to increase, more organizations may become impacted by the cap. Increasing the cap allows nonprofit organizations able to privately raise funds to acquire and operate more affordable housing units without fear of breaching the cap. To allow the Legislature to periodically review this issue as needed, the author has agreed to reduce the cap from $250 million to $100 million in assessed value. This amount is sufficient to address all organizations currently impacted by the cap.
- Committee's tax expenditure policy: This committee has recently adopted a new policy that tax expenditures, which include the expansion of an exemption such as this bill proposes, outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure seeks to achieve and data collection for evaluation purposes. Additionally, the policy requires an appropriate sunset date. This bill includes findings and declarations stating that it addresses California's serious shortage of affordable, decent, safe, and sanitary housing for low-income persons and families by providing necessary property tax relief for certain tax-exempt organizations so that these organizations can provide affordable housing for low-income persons and families. Additionally, this bill includes provisions to sunset the occupancy threshold changes and the author has agreed to reduce the exemption cap provision from $250 million to $100 million. Data collection procedures currently exist through the BOE's statewide monitoring of the exemption cap.
- Previous legislation:
- SB 1115 (Hill), Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018, increased the exemption cap from $10 million to $20 million.
- SB 996 (Hill), Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016, effectively increased the cap from $2 million in assessed value ($20,000 in tax) to $10 million in assessed value ($100,000 in tax) and transitioned the measure of the cap from tax dollars to assessed value for administrative ease.
- SB 1284 (Lowenthal), Chapter 524, Statutes of 2008, excluded from the welfare exemption cap specified affordable housing properties acquired by a non-profit organization in Long Beach, as a result of mitigation efforts from the construction of the Century Freeway (I-105) in Los Angeles County.
- AB 659 (Wiggins), Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000, reinstated welfare exemption-eligibility for non-publicly financed low-income rental housing (excluding LPs) and created the welfare exemption cap applicable to this rental housing and established the 90% occupancy threshold.
- AB 1559 (Wiggins), Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999, revoked the welfare exemption eligibility from low-income housing if it did not receive governmental financial assistance. AB 1559 also imposed higher documentation standards to substantiate that a rental property is dedicated to low-income housing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION
Support
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
Assessor-County Clerk-Recorder & Elections, County of San Mateo
County of San Mateo Board of Supervisors
St. Francis Center
Oppose
California Assessors' Association (Unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 294 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 294
Introduced: 2/14/19
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/27/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
DIGEST:
This bill allows for a partial welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing, and increases the statewide cap on the value of property used for non-publicly financed affordable housing.
Existing law:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law (California Constitution, Article XIII).
- Allows the Legislature to exempt property used for charitable purposes, and owned by non-profit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes, such as universities, hospitals, and libraries (California Constitution, Article XIII, Sections Four and Five). The Legislature enacted this exemption, commonly known as the “welfare exemption.”
- Limits the maximum amount of any ad valorem tax on real property at 1% of full cash value, and directs assessors to only reappraise property when newly constructed, or when ownership changes (California Constitution, Article XIIIA, as added by Proposition 13, 1978).
- Allows the welfare exemption for rental housing when the housing is financed by tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds; general obligation bonds; federal, state, or local grants; or federal low-income housing tax credits, pursuant to specific requirements. For projects with both low-income and market rate units, the owner can claim a partial exemption, equal to that percentage of the value of the property equal to the percentage that the number of units serving lower income households represents of the total number of residential units.
- Provides that non-publicly financed affordable housing, up to $20 million in value statewide, can claim a full exemption when:
- 90% of the households occupying the housing must be low-income persons, whose rent does not exceed specified limits for low-income persons;
- The property is managed solely by a charitable non-profit organization, specifically excluding limited partnerships, to be eligible for the exemption.
- Does not allow a partial exemption for non-publicly financed affordable housing similar to the one for publicly-finance affordable housing.
This bill:
- Revises the welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing to:
- Provide that the exemption applies when charities own non-publicly financed affordable housing where more than 50% of residents are low-income, and
- Prorate the exemption amount based on the percentage of lower income households that occupy the property.
- Increases the cap on value from $20 million to $250 million.
- Becomes effective in the 2020-21 fiscal year.
- Creates a process for assessors to cancel taxes, interest, penalties, or escape assessments based on the bill’s changes.
- Sunsets its alterations after the 2030-31 fiscal year.
Background
Prior to 1999, rental housing owners could claim a welfare exemption from property tax for low-income housing if 20% of the property’s residents were low-income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city’s worst housing projects, they discovered that tax-exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance to housing that qualified them for the exemption from property tax. Responding to the investigation, the Legislature enacted AB 1559 (Wiggins, Chapter 927, Statutes of 1999), which repealed the occupancy test, instead requiring all owners to receive public financing in the forms listed above for the project to claim the welfare exemption, in addition to the above requirements. However, AB 1559 revoked the exemption for many worthy properties owned by charities that weren’t publicly financed, so the Legislature subsequently enacted AB 659 (Wiggins, Chapter 601, Statutes of 2000), which again allowed a full exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing property, subject to the above described requirements.
Since 2000, the value of housing has increased, compelling some non-profits to pay taxes on amounts that exceed the statutory cap, and discouraging other groups from acquiring rental housing in the hopes of preserving existing affordable units in their areas. In response, the Legislature enacted SB 996 (Hill, Chapter 836, Statutes of 2016), which:
- Quintupled the cap, and revised it to instead apply to the property’s value, not the tax paid, with the new threshold at $10 million of assessed value,
- Created a process for taxpayers to file a claim to cancel any outstanding taxes or escape assessments due on values that exceeded the previous cap, and
- Required property owners claiming the welfare exemption to provide specified information regarding the household income of and the rent charged to an occupant of an exempt unit.
However, charities must pay tax on any amount of value that exceeds the cap, which applies to all of its properties statewide, and the Saint Francis Center in San Mateo County continues to acquire affordable housing. Last year, the Legislature again increased the cap to $20 million in value (SB 1115, Hill, Chapter 694, Statutes of 2018), and provided a process for taxpayers to file a claim to have any outstanding taxes or escape assessments cancelled.
The Center recently acquired a property where all but a few residents meet the income eligibility requirements, but less than the 90% required, so the Center would have to evict one or more of the non-low income persons to meet the 90% requirement for the exemption, and a partial exemption does not apply because the property is not publicly financed. The author wants to revise the criteria for non-publicly financed affordable housing to ensure that the Center can claim a partial exemption for its newly-acquired project consistent with publicly-financed affordable housing, and again increase the statewide cap.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Board of Equalization (BOE) indicates that it would incur minor and absorbable administrative costs to update claim forms, Property Tax Rule 140, and it’s Assessors’ Handbook. BOE indicates that, based on county assessor data, two organizations currently own housing that exceeds the current $20 million valuation limit. BOE is still developing the corresponding property tax revenue loss that would result under the bill raising that valuation limit. However, the decline in revenue would increase over time, as (1) assessed values of organizations’ current holdings exceed $20 million over time (resulting from the annual inflation factor of up to 2 percent), and (2) to the extent organizations acquire or construct additional property that would be subject to the current $20 million cap. Lower local property tax revenues lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors). BOE also estimates that, with respect to bill’s provision that would reducing the low-income household requirement, the revenue loss per new qualifying property would be $16,000 per newly qualified property. The annual number of such properties that would newly qualify is unknown. Under the California Constitution, this bill’s imposing of new duties on local county officials related to the real property tax assessment process could be subject to reimbursement by the State. The magnitude of these potential costs is unknown.
AIDS Health Care Foundation
Mark Pope, San Mateo County Assessor-County Clerk-Recorder and Chief Elections Official
Saint Francis Center
San Mateo County
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
California Assessors Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Four out of the five least affordable rental markets nationwide continue to be in California. Nonprofits that do not receive any tax credits from the state or federal government, and that provide non-publicly financed affordable housing to low income families, must pay property tax on affordable housing property with an assessed value of more than $20 million. Approximately 26 nonprofits in California fundraise privately to provide affordable housing in their communities and do not receive tax credits, possibly because they lack the staff to research and apply for the tax credits. In areas with very high rents and property values, like the Bay Area and Los Angeles, the property tax exemption cap limits the ability of these nonprofits to provide more affordable housing. These nonprofits own 75 properties that are subject to the cap, according to records county assessors filed with BOE. Only two of the organizations have exceeded the existing cap. SB 294 aids nonprofits and religious organizations by raising the cap for the property tax exemption on their affordable housing properties from an assessed value of $20 million to $250 million. Additionally, the bill lowers the percentage of low income residents required in a given property from 90% to 50% in order to be eligible for tax relief on a pro rata basis.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Assessors Association, “SB 294 creates several areas of concern for Assessors relating to the administration of these exemptions. In addition, we have concerns that the bill removes constraints put in place by legislation that was intended to dissuade fraud and intentionally re-enacted the occupancy threshold of 90% after an original threshold of 20% had been removed. We believe that a sunset provision should be added to allow review of the administrative issues and evaluate our concerns about fraudulent practices.”
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
5/18/19 12:53:16
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 294 (Hill) - Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
Version: February 14, 2019 | Policy Vote: GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: April 8, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SB 294 would (1) increase the assessed value exemption limitation of property used for non-publicly financed affordable housing, and (2) decrease the required percentage of occupants that are lower income households to qualify for the exemption.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Board of Equalization (BOE) indicates that it would incur minor and absorbable administrative costs to update claim forms, Property Tax Rule 140, and it’s Assessors’ Handbook.
- BOE indicates that, based on county assessor data, two organizations currently own housing that exceeds the current $20 million valuation limit. BOE is still developing the corresponding property tax revenue loss that would result under the bill raising that valuation limit. However, the decline in revenue would increase over time, as (1) assessed values of organizations’ current holdings exceed $20 million over time (resulting from the annual inflation factor of up to 2 percent), and (2) to the extent organizations acquire or construct additional property that would be subject to the current $20 million cap. Lower local property tax revenues lead to increased General Fund Proposition 98 spending by up to roughly 50 percent (the exact amount depends on the specific amount of the annual Proposition 98 guarantee, which in turns depends upon a variety of economic, demographic and budgetary factors).
- BOE also estimates that, with respect to bill’s provision that would reducing the low-income household requirement, the revenue loss per new qualifying property would be $16,000 per newly qualified property. The annual number of such properties that would newly qualify is unknown.
- Under the California Constitution, this bill’s imposing of new duties on local county officials related to the real property tax assessment process could be subject to reimbursement by the State. The magnitude of these potential costs is unknown.
Background:
All property in California is taxable unless explicitly exempted. Specifically, the Legislature may exempt property owned by nonprofit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes, such as universities, hospitals, and libraries (known as the “welfare exemption”). This exemption currently results in $3 billion in annual foregone local property tax revenues.
The welfare exemption includes property used exclusively for rental housing, if (1) specified financing mechanisms provide the financing, (2) the property is restricted for low-income housing, and rents do not exceed specified levels, and (3) the property owner certifies that funds that would have been used to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of the units or reduce rents.
For projects with both low-income and market rate units, the owner can claim a partial exemption, equal to that percentage of the value of the property equal to the percentage that the number of units serving lower income households represents of the total number of residential units.
Prior to 1999, rental housing owners could claim a welfare exemption from property tax for low-income housing if 20 percent of the property’s residents were low-income. After an investigation determined that tax-exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance to housing that qualified them for the exemption from property tax, the Legislature enacted AB 1559 (Wiggins, 1999), which repealed the occupancy test. Instead, owners were required to receive public financing in the forms listed above for the project to claim the welfare exemption, in addition to the above requirements. However, AB 1559 revoked the exemption for many worthy properties owned by charities that weren’t publicly financed; subsequently, Legislature enacted AB 659 (Wiggins, 2000), which again allowed a full exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing property, subject to several requirements, including: (1) 90 percent of the households occupying the housing must be low-income persons, whose rent does not exceed specified limits for low-income persons, and (2) a cap in the exemption amount of $20,000 (translating to $2 million in assessed valuation) in tax for all properties the taxpayer owns in the state,
As assessed valuation in the State generally rose in the ensuing years, (1) some non-profits were required to pay taxes on property amounts that exceeded the $2 million cap, and (2) other groups were discouraged from constructing or acquiring rental housing, especially those regions of the state with higher property values. Other reforms adopted as part of the package, such as making the exemption contingent upon deed restrictions binding rents, and limiting the exemption solely to non-profit organizations owning the units, appear to have succeeded. Consequently, the cap could hinder nonprofit organizations that own, or want to purchase, affordable housing in their communities, and can be especially burdensome for organizations operating statewide. Additionally, no other organizations claiming the welfare exemption (such as hospitals, churches, and universities) are subject to a similar cap. In response, the Legislature enacted SB 996 (Hill, 2016), which among other things raised the cap from $2 million to $10 million. In 2018, the Legislature increased the cap yet again to $20 million in assessed value (SB 1115, Hill)
Proposed Law:
This bill would revise the welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing to provide that (1) the exemption would apply when charities own non-publicly financed affordable housing where more than 50 percent of residents are low-income, (2) the exemption amount would be prorated based on the percentage of lower income households that occupy the property, and (3) the cap on value would be increased from $20 million to $250 million.
The bill would (1) provide a process for assessors to cancel taxes, interest, penalties, or escape assessments based on the bill’s changes, and (2) sunset in 2030-31.
Staff Comments:
BOE monitors the statewide assessed valuation cap; it receives annual welfare exemption filings filed with assessors, to ensure that owners don’t abuse the public financing requirement by creating shell non-profit organizations. In 2015, BOE reported that few non-profit organizations that own low-income rental housing exceeded the cap, which the Legislature quintupled that year. Again, BOE reports that two organizations in the state own housing that exceeds the current $20 million limit. However, the cap could deter non-profit organizations that currently own property subject to the cap, but want to purchase additional affordable housing, as the exemption currently would not be applicable above the $20 million valuation limit.
The revenue loss resulting from the bill’s assessed valuation cap increase to $250 million would emerge and grow (1) if organizations acquire more property subject to the cap, or (2) if assessed values over time exceed $20 million due to the application of the annual inflation factor (up to 2 percent). As an example, assuming the full two percent inflation factor, property assessed at $20 million would grow to $30 million in about 22 years. The resulting loss in property tax revenue relative to current law would be about $100,000, half of which could result in increased Proposition 98 General Fund spending.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 294 | Hearing Date: | 3/27/19 |
Author: | Hill | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/14/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Property taxation: welfare exemption: low income housing
Allows for a partial exemption for non-publicly financed affordable housing, and increases the statewide cap on the value of property used for non-publicly financed affordable housing.
Background
The California Constitution provides that all property is taxable unless explicitly exempted by the Constitution or federal law, but also allows the Legislature to exempt property used exclusively for charitable purposes so long as it is owned by non-profit entities organized and operated for charitable purposes, such as universities, hospitals, and libraries. The Legislature enacted this exemption, commonly known as the “welfare exemption.” The welfare exemption has a similar policy genesis as tax exempt status for charitable groups: revenues paid in tax to the government divert needed resources away from the organizations’ good works. According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, local agencies statewide forego $3 billion annually in property tax revenues from welfare exempt properties.
The welfare exemption includes property used for rental housing, if:
- Tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds; general obligation bonds; federal, state, or local grants; or federal low-income housing tax credits finance the housing,
- The property is enforceably restricted for low-income housing, and rents do not exceed those prescribed in deed restrictions, and
- The property owner certifies that funds that would have been used to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of the units or reduce rents.
For projects with both low-income and market rate units, the owner can claim a partial exemption, equal to that percentage of the value of the property equal to the percentage that the number of units serving lower income households represents of the total number of residential units.
Prior to 1999, rental housing owners could claim a welfare exemption from property tax for low-income housing if 20% of the property’s residents were low-income. After the Los Angeles Housing Project investigated some of the city’s worst housing projects, they discovered that tax-exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance to housing that qualified them for the exemption from property tax. Responding to the investigation, the Legislature enacted AB 1559 (Wiggins, 1999), which repealed the occupancy test, instead requiring all owners to receive public financing in the forms listed above for the project to claim the welfare exemption, in addition to the above requirements. However, AB 1559 revoked the exemption for many worthy properties owned by charities that weren’t publicly financed, so the Legislature subsequently enacted AB 659 (Wiggins, 2000), which again allowed a full exemption for non-publicly financed rental housing property, subject to several requirements:
- 90% of the households occupying the housing must be low-income persons, whose rent does not exceed specified limits for low-income persons;
- A cap in the exemption amount of $20,000 in tax for all properties the taxpayer owns in the state; and
- A requirement that the property be managed solely by a charitable non-profit organization, specifically excluding limited partnerships, to be eligible for the exemption.
Since 2000, the value of housing has increased, compelling some non-profits to pay taxes on amounts that exceed the $20,000 cap, and discouraging other groups from acquiring rental housing in the hopes of preserving existing affordable units in their areas. In response, the Legislature enacted SB 996 (Hill, 2016), which:
- Quintupled the cap, and revised it to instead apply to the property’s value, not the tax paid, with the new threshold at $10 million of assessed value,
- Created a process for taxpayers to file a claim to cancel any outstanding taxes or escape assessments due on values that exceeded the previous cap, and
- Required property owners claiming the welfare exemption to provide specified information regarding the household income of and the rent charged to an occupant of an exempt unit.
However, charities must pay tax on any amount of value that exceeds the $10 million cap, which applies to all of its properties statewide, and the Saint Francis Center in San Mateo County continues to acquire affordable housing. Last year, the Legislature again increased the cap to $20 million in value (SB 1115, Hill), effective January 1, 2019, and provided a process for taxpayers to file a claim to have any outstanding taxes or escape assessments cancelled.
The Center recently acquired a property where all but a few residents meet the income eligibility requirements, but less than the 90% required, so the The Center would have to evict one or more of the non-low income persons to meet the 90% requirement for the exemption, and a partial exemption does not apply because the property is not publicly financed. The author wants to revise the criteria for non-publicly financed affordable housing to ensure that the Center can claim a partial exemption for its newly-acquired project consistent with publicly-financed affordable housing, and again increase the statewide cap.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 294 revises the welfare exemption from property tax for non-publicly financed affordable housing to provide that:
- The exemption applies when charities own non-publicly financed affordable housing where more than 50% of residents are low-income,
- Prorates the exemption amount based on the percentage of lower income households that occupy the property,
- Increases the cap on value from $20 million to $250 million.
The bill becomes effective in the 2020-21 fiscal year. The measure also provides a process for assessors to cancel taxes, interest, penalties, or escape assessments based on the bill’s changes, and sunsets its alterations after the 2030-31 fiscal year.
State Revenue Impact
According to the Board of Equalization (BOE), for every property that would qualify as a result of the bill’s changes, the annual property tax revenue loss would be $26,000.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Four out of the five least affordable rental markets nationwide continue to be in California. Nonprofits that do not receive any tax credits from the state or federal government, and that provide non-publicly financed affordable housing to low income families, must pay property tax on affordable housing property with an assessed value of more than $20 million. Approximately 26 nonprofits in California fundraise privately to provide affordable housing in their communities and do not receive tax credits, possibly because they lack the staff to research and apply for the tax credits. In areas with very high rents and property values, like the Bay Area and Los Angeles, the property tax exemption cap limits the ability of these nonprofits to provide more affordable housing. These nonprofits own 75 properties that are subject to the cap, according to records county assessors filed with BOE. Only two of the organizations have exceeded the existing cap. SB 294 aids nonprofits and religious organizations by raising the cap for the property tax exemption on their affordable housing properties from an assessed value of $20 million to $250 million. Additionally, the bill lowers the percentage of low income residents required in a given property from 90% to 50% in order to be eligible for tax relief on a pro rata basis.”
2. As time goes by. When the Legislature set the $20,000 cap in 2000, it was part of a series of reforms that responded to an investigation that showed tax exempt property owners were not providing basic maintenance for its housing projects. Other reforms adopted as part of the package, such as making the exemption contingent upon deed restrictions binding rents, and limiting the exemption solely to non-profit organizations owning the units, should have chased out any potential bad actors over the past nineteen years. BOE monitors the statewide cap, as it receives annual welfare exemption filings filed with assessors, to ensure that owners don’t abuse the public financing requirement by creating shell non-profit organizations. In 2015, BOE reported that few non-profit organizations that own low-income rental housing have exceeded the cap, which the Legislature quintupled that year. BOE reports that two organizations in the state own housing that exceeds the current $20 million limit. However, the cap deters non-profit organizations that currently own property subject to the cap, but want to purchase additional affordable housing, as the exemption wouldn’t apply above the $20 million valuation limit. Additionally, the Legislature already disconnected the cap for the Long Beach Affordable Housing Coalition’s purchase of specified properties in Los Angeles County (SB 1284, Lowenthal, 2008). Lastly, no other organizations claiming the welfare exemption are subject to a similar cap, such as hospitals and universities. When the Committee approved SB 1115 last year, the measure included a provision eliminating the cap; however, the measure was subsequently amended to instead it increase it to the current threshold.
3. Information. When the Legislature quintupled the cap in 2015, it required any non-profit organization qualifying for the exemption to provide additional information with their annual claim. The measure required the non-profit organization to annually provide non-personally identifiable information about the occupants which includes the actual household income of the occupant, the maximum rent that may be charged to the occupant, and the actual rent charged to the occupant. As a result, assessors now have more information to ensure that the welfare exemption from property tax for affordable housing is correctly administered.
4. Mandate. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local governments for the costs of new or expanded state mandated local programs. Because SB 294 changes the manner in which assessors value real property, and creates a claim process, Legislative Counsel says that it imposes a new state mandate. The measure states that should the Commission on State Mandates determine that the bill imposes a reimbursable mandate, reimbursement must be made pursuant to existing statutory provisions. Additionally, the bill provides that the state shall not reimburse local agencies for any property tax revenue losses resulting from its expanded welfare exemption.
Support and Opposition
(3/22/18)
Support: AIDS Healthcare Foundation, Saint Francis Center, San Mateo County.
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):