SB 304: Criminal procedure: prosecutorial jurisdiction in multi-jurisdictional elder abuse cases.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 206, Statutes of 2019. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 25). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 802.) (April 23). |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and APPR. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2019 | SB 304 Hill Senate Third Reading By Mullin | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Special Consent SB304 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 304
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Allows specified elder and dependent adult abuse offenses that occur in different jurisdictions to be consolidated in a single trial if all district attorneys in the counties with jurisdiction agree.
Major Provisions
- States that if more than one felonious theft, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, or identity theft occurs against an elder or dependent adult in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred.
- Specifies that the consolidation of charges is subject to a hearing and other procedures established for the joinder of multiple offenses, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial.
- Specifies that at the hearing, the prosecution shall present written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue, and that charged offenses from any jurisdiction where there is not a written agreement from the district attorney shall be returned to that jurisdiction.
- Specifies that in determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court shall consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
"Dependent adult and elder abuse is the fastest growing area of crime in the United States. California is the number one state in frequency of elder abuse cases, making up 11% of all cases within the United States. As the Baby Boomer generation ages, financial crimes against the elderly will only continue to increase. SB 304 will allow district attorneys to consolidate elderly and dependent adult financial fraud cases that span multiple counties into a single prosecution. Under this legislation, the burden is eased for victims by not requiring them to testify repeatedly in multiple locations as prosecutors try their case."
Arguments in Support:
According to the bill's co-sponsor, the San Mateo County District Attorney, "My office is currently prosecuting a case involving a defendant who, with unknown co-conspirators, traveled through multiple counties perpetrating a fraud scheme where the defendants pretended to be immigrants in need of help and swindled elderly victims out of tens of thousands of dollars in cash and jewelry. They appealed to the victims' vulnerability, diminishing capacity, and they at times invoked religion to ingratiate themselves with the victims. Our case involves three separate victims. Only one senior was victimized in San Mateo County. The other offenses occurred in Contra Costa and Alameda Counties. However, the fraud scheme perpetrated by the defendants was so unique and particularized that it was clearly all part of an ongoing conspiracy. The defendant was held to answer for all charges at the preliminary hearing and the case is awaiting trial.
"SB 304, by amending section 784.7 to add elder abuse, will be a much more direct and certain way to prosecute these important cases and would be our only option of the defendant acted alone and we could not charge conspiracy. Your bill will be extremely beneficial to law enforcement, especially because the perpetrators of elder financial abuse frequently travel to various jurisdictions, hit one city or county for a few days, and then move on to the next county. Furthermore, the evidence in the cases would be cross-admissible, so it makes sense from the perspective of judicial economy to prosecute them in the same jurisdiction. It would also make the judicial process less daunting for elderly victims, enabling them to only have to testify in one case and in one jurisdiction."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the California Public Defenders Association: "SB 304 would add another group of crimes, these involving multiple instances of elder and dependent adult abuse committed in different counties, to the already overlong list of crimes, mostly multiple instances of sex offenses, committed in different counties, to all, subject to a court hearing and certain criteria, may be brought in a single county.
"The jurisdictional statute involved, Penal Code section 784.7 has been expanded too rapidly to assess whether the benefits of consolidating in one county outweigh the problems to the prosecution and the defense, as well as victims, of bringing multiple prosecutions from different counties in only one of them. In less than five years PC section 784.7 has been expanded three times adding 6 crimes to the list. In 2014, effective January 1, 2015, SB 939 added three crimes to the list. In 2017, effective January 1, 2018, AB 368 added another crime to the list. And in 2018, effective January 1, 2019, A.B. 1746 added yet two more crimes.
"Before adding even more crimes, we all should pause and find out if the recent additions are helping or harming judicial economy, increasing or decreasing overall prosecution and defense expenses, how this is affecting convenience or hardship to victims and witnesses, and, most important, whether this is helping or harming public safety.
"Moreover, elder and dependent adult abuse crimes are often of a different nature than the sex offenses that make up most of the crimes already included in Penal Code section 784.7. For example, the former often involve financial, property, or health care issues, which sex offenses usually do not. That alone is enough reason to stop and assess first."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 38-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Mathis, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk, Santiago, Wicks
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 30, 2019
CONSULTANT: Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001159
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
Counsel: Matthew Fleming
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 304
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
SUMMARY: Allows specified elder and dependent adult abuse offenses that occur in different jurisdictions to be consolidated in a single trial if all district attorneys in the counties with jurisdiction agree. Specifically, this bill:
- States that if more than one felonious theft, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, or identity theft occurs against an elder or dependent adult in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred.
- Specifies that the consolidation of charges is subject to a hearing and other procedures established for the joinder of multiple offenses, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial.
- Specifies that at the hearing, the prosecution shall present written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue, and that charged offenses from any jurisdiction where there is not a written agreement from the district attorney shall be returned to that jurisdiction.
- Specifies that in determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court shall consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses.
EXISTING LAW:
- States that, except as otherwise provided by law, the jurisdiction of every public offense is in any competent court within the jurisdictional territory of which it is committed. (Pen. Code, § 777.)
- States that when a public offense is committed in part in one jurisdictional territory and in part in another, the jurisdiction of such offense is in any competent court within either jurisdiction. (Pen. Code, § 781.)
- States that when a public offense is committed on the boundary of two or more jurisdictional territories, or within 500 yards thereof, the jurisdiction of such offense is in any competent court within either jurisdictional territory. (Pen. Code, § 782.)
- States that when a public offense is committed in this State, on board a vessel navigating a river, bay, slough, lake, or canal, or lying therein, in the prosecution of its voyage, or on a railroad train or car, motor vehicle, common carrier transporting passengers or on an aircraft prosecuting its trip, the jurisdiction is in any competent court, through, on, or over the jurisdictional territory of which the vessel, train, car, motor vehicle, common carrier or aircraft passes in the course of its voyage or trip, or in the jurisdictional territory of which the voyage or trip terminates. (Pen. Code § 783.)
- States that when a public offense is committed in a park situated in more than one county, the jurisdiction over such an offense is in any competent court in any county in which any part of the park is situated. (Pen. Code § 783.5.)
- States that if one or more violations of specified sex offenses occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to the following conditions:
- Consolidation of the cases is subject to a joinder hearing, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial court;
- The prosecution presents written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue; and,
- Charged offenses from jurisdictions in which there is no written agreement from the district attorney must be returned to that county. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (a).)
- Consolidation of the cases is subject to a joinder hearing, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial court;
- States that if more than one violation of child abuse, domestic violence, or stalking, as specified, occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, and the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (b).)
- States that if more than one violation of human trafficking, pimping, or pandering occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to a hearing pursuant to a hearing, as specified, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial, if all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue. In determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court shall consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (c).)
- Permits consolidation of different offenses which do not relate to the same transaction or event where there is common element of substantial importance in their commission, such as the same class of crimes, and establishes a procedure therefor. (Pen. Code, § 954.)
- Provides that the court, in its discretion, may exclude evidence if its probative value is substantially outweighed by the probability that its admission will (a) necessitate undue consumption of time or (b) create substantial danger of undue prejudice, of confusing the issues, or of misleading the jury. (Evid. Code § 352.)
- Provides that evidence of a person’s character or a trait of his or her character (whether in the form of an opinion, evidence of reputation, or evidence of specific instances of his or her conduct) is inadmissible when offered to prove his or her conduct on a specified occasion. (Evid. Code § 1101.)
- Provides that in a criminal action in which the defendant is accused of an offense involving abuse of an elder or dependent person, evidence of the defendant’s commission of other abuse of an elder or dependent person is not subject to the prohibition on the use of evidence of a person’s character or a trait of his or her character (whether in the form of an opinion, evidence of reputation, or evidence of specific instances of his or her conduct). (Evid. Code § 1109, subd. (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “Dependent adult and elder abuse is the fastest growing area of crime in the United States. California is the number one state in frequency of elder abuse cases, making up 11% of all cases within the United States. As the Baby Boomer generation ages, financial crimes against the elderly will only continue to increase. SB 304 will allow district attorneys to consolidate elderly and dependent adult financial fraud cases that span multiple counties into a single prosecution. Under this legislation, the burden is eased for victims by not requiring them to testify repeatedly in multiple locations as prosecutors try their case.”
- Territorial Jurisdiction: The rule of jurisdiction is that “except as otherwise provided by law the jurisdiction of every public offense is in any competent court within the jurisdictional territory of which it is committed.” Ordinarily, the territorial jurisdiction of a superior court is the county in which it sits. When the Legislature creates an exception to the rule of jurisdiction, the statute is remedial and is construed liberally to achieve the legislative purpose of expanding criminal jurisdiction. (Price v. Superior Court (2001), 25 Cal. 4th 1046, 1055.)
- The Right to a Jury of Peers, “Vicinage”: Vicinage is the right to trial by a jury drawn from residents of the area where the offense was committed. Vicinage is not an absolute right guaranteed by the United States Constitution because it “does not serve the purpose of protecting a criminal defendant from government oppression and is not necessary to ensure a fair trial.” (Price, supra, 25 Cal. 4th 1046, 1065-1069.) According to the Supreme Court of California, the right to a trial by a jury of the vicinage – as guaranteed by the California Constitution – requires trial in a county that has a reasonable relationship to the offense or to other crimes committed by the defendant against the same victim. (Id. at p. 1075.) Therefore, the Legislature’s power to designate the place for trial of a criminal offense is limited by the requirement that there be a reasonable relationship or nexus between the place designated for trial and the commission of the offense. (Ibid.)
This bill would allow all felony-level, financial-type charges against elder or dependent adults to be consolidated into a single trial. It is possible that the provisions of this bill would challenged based on the right of vicinage, given that there does not appear to be a requirement that the consolidated crimes have a relationship to the place designated for trial or to other crimes committed by the defendant against the same victim. Nonetheless, the Legislature has created several exceptions to the general rule that a case must be tried in the jurisdiction where the offense was committed if a defendant commits multiple offenses in different jurisdictions, which appear to have survived legal challenges. These exceptions include sex crimes, domestic violence, child abuse, and human trafficking cases. The sex offense exemptions were challenged in court, and survived legal scrutiny. For sex offense cases in particular, the court ruled that the cases that can be joined do not have to be violations of the same offense. (People v. Nguyen (2010) 184 Cal.App.4th 1096.) Sex offenses currently subject to consolidation are of the same class of crimes and therefore any combination of the listed sex crimes may be properly joined. (Id. at 1113.) - Trial Consolidation: The benefits of trial consolidation include judicial economy and convenience to victims and witnesses who may have to testify in multiple trials. Attorneys and courts may save time resources as a result of consolidation. Specifically in the context of sex crimes and elder/dependent adult crimes, there exists an evidentiary rationale for the consolidation of a trial. In general, evidence of a person's character or a trait of his or her character (whether in the form of an opinion, evidence of reputation, or evidence of specific instances of his or her conduct) is inadmissible when offered to prove his or her conduct on a specified occasion. However, that evidentiary rule does not apply in sex crimes and elder/dependent adult crimes. Therefore, allowing the consolidation of these offenses may be beneficial to victims and witnesses who may otherwise be called to testify regarding the defendant’s character, or “propensity,” in multiple trials in different counties.
There are also disadvantages to trial consolidation, including the potential prejudicial impact on the defendant because jurors may feel compelled to convict based on the sheer number of victims rather than the strength of the prosecution’s case. In other words, jurors can be swayed by the quantity of the evidence, rather than scrutinizing the quality of the evidence. As a result, some individual cases which may not even have gone to trial result in a conviction because the case is strengthened by the aggregate evidence of the other charges. In addition, convenience to some victims and witnesses may come at the cost of inconvenience to others. Law enforcement who live outside of the jurisdiction where the trial is held can be called away from their shift, meaning their department has to pay another officer overtime. In addition, elderly and dependent adult victims and witnesses are likely to have more difficulty with transportation from one part of the state to another. The rule in existing law that a case be tried in the county where the offense took place avoids these complications. - Argument in Support: According to the bill’s co-sponsor, the San Mateo County District Attorney, “My office is currently prosecuting a case involving a defendant who, with unknown co-conspirators, traveled through multiple counties perpetrating a fraud scheme where the defendants pretended to be immigrants in need of help and swindled elderly victims out of tens of thousands of dollars in cash and jewelry. They appealed to the victims’ vulnerability, diminishing capacity, and they at times invoked religion to ingratiate themselves with the victims. Our case involves three separate victims. Only one senior was victimized in San Mateo County. The other offenses occurred in Contra Costa and Alameda Counties. However, the fraud scheme perpetrated by the defendants was so unique and particularized that it was clearly all part of an ongoing conspiracy. The defendant was held to answer for all charges at the preliminary hearing and the case is awaiting trial.
“SB 304, by amending section 784.7 to add elder abuse, will be a much more direct and certain way to prosecute these important cases and would be our only option of the defendant acted alone and we could not charge conspiracy. Your bill will be extremely beneficial to law enforcement, especially because the perpetrators of elder financial abuse frequently travel to various jurisdictions, hit one city or county for a few days, and then move on to the next county. Furthermore, the evidence in the cases would be cross-admissible, so it makes sense from the perspective of judicial economy to prosecute them in the same jurisdiction. It would also make the judicial process less daunting for elderly victims, enabling them to only have to testify in one case and in one jurisdiction.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to the California Public Defenders Association: “SB 304 would add another group of crimes, these involving multiple instances of elder and dependent adult abuse committed in different counties, to the already overlong list of crimes, mostly multiple instances of sex offenses, committed in different counties, to all, subject to a court hearing and certain criteria, may be brought in a single county.
“The jurisdictional statute involved, Penal Code section 784.7 has been expanded too rapidly to assess whether the benefits of consolidating in one county outweigh the problems to the prosecution and the defense, as well as victims, of bringing multiple prosecutions from different counties in only one of them. In less than five years PC section 784.7 has been expanded three times adding 6 crimes to the list. In 2014, effective January 1, 2015, SB 939 added three crimes to the list. In 2017, effective January 1, 2018, AB 368 added another crime to the list. And in 2018, effective January 1, 2019, A.B. 1746 added yet two more crimes.
“Before adding even more crimes, we all should pause and find out if the recent additions are helping or harming judicial economy, increasing or decreasing overall prosecution and defense expenses, how this is affecting convenience or hardship to victims and witnesses, and, most important, whether this is helping or harming public safety.
“Moreover, elder and dependent adult abuse crimes are often of a different nature than the sex offenses that make up most of the crimes already included in Penal Code section 784.7. For example, the former often involve financial, property, or health care issues, which sex offenses usually do not. That alone is enough reason to stop and assess first.”
- Related Legislation: SB 496 (Moorlach), would provide that broker-dealers and investment advisers are mandated reporters of suspected financial abuse of an elder or dependent adult, and would allow these reporters to notify a trusted third party and delay disbursements or transactions. SB 496 is pending hearing in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1746 (Cervantes), Chapter 962, Statutes of 2018, added sexual battery and unlawful sexual intercourse to the list of offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial in any county where at least one of the offenses occurred, if the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses.
- AB 368 (Muratsuchi), Chapter 379, Statutes of 2017, added felony sexual intercourse, sodomy, oral copulation or sexual penetration with a child 10 years of age or younger occurring in two or more jurisdictions to the list of applicable offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial.
- SB 939 (Block), Chapter 246, Statutes of 2014, added felony human trafficking-related charges occurring in two or more jurisdictions to the list of applicable offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial.
- AB 2252 (Cohn), Chapter 194, Statutes of 2002, added specified felony sex crimes to the list of applicable offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial, required the prosecution to present evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue, and deleted the requirement that the consolidated offenses involve the same victim.
- AB 2734 (Pacheco), Chapter 302, Statutes of 1998, permitted jurisdiction for specified felony sex crimes occurring in two or more jurisdictions in any jurisdiction where at least one offense occurred, if the defendant and the victim were the same for all the offenses.
- AB 1746 (Cervantes), Chapter 962, Statutes of 2018, added sexual battery and unlawful sexual intercourse to the list of offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial in any county where at least one of the offenses occurred, if the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association (Co-Sponsor)
San Mateo County District Attorney's Office (Co-Sponsor)
AARP
California Elder Justice Coalition
California Long-Term Care Ombudsman Association
California State Sheriffs' Association
Crime Victims United of California
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Institute on Aging
Monterey County Department of Social Services
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
San Francisco City and County District Attorney
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
Ventura County District Attorney
Oppose
California Public Defenders Association
Analysis Prepared by: Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 304 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 304
Amended: 4/30/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/23/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Criminal procedure: prosecutorial jurisdiction in multi-jurisdictional elder abuse cases
SOURCE: California District Attorneys Association
San Mateo County District Attorney’s Office
DIGEST:
This bill allows felony financial crimes committed against elder and dependent adults that occur in different jurisdictions to be consolidated into a single trial in one of the jurisdictions where the crimes occurred.
Existing law:
- States that, except as otherwise provided by law, the jurisdiction of every public offense is in any competent court within the jurisdictional territory of which it is committed. (Pen. Code, § 777.)
- States that when a public offense is committed in part in one jurisdictional territory and in part in another, the jurisdiction of such offense is in any competent court within either jurisdiction. (Pen. Code, § 781.)
- Allows property crimes occurring in one jurisdictional territory where property is taken to another jurisdictional territory and an arrest is made there, to be prosecuted in either jurisdiction. (Pen. Code, § 786.)
- Permits consolidation of different offenses which do not relate to same transaction or event where there is common element of substantial importance in their commission, such as the same class of crimes. (Pen. Code, § 954.)
- Provides that if one or more violations of specified sex offenses occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to the following conditions (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (a)):
- Consolidation of the cases is subject to a joinder hearing, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial court;
- The prosecution presents written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue; and,
- Charged offenses from jurisdictions in which there is no written agreement from the district attorney must be returned to that county.
- States that if more than one violation of child abuse, domestic violence, or stalking, as specified, occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, and the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (b).)
- Provides that if more than one violation of human trafficking, pimping, or pandering occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to a hearing pursuant to Section 954, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial, if all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue. In determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court shall consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (c).)
This bill:
- Allows felony financial crimes committed against elder and dependent adults that occur in different jurisdictions to be consolidated into a single trial if all district attorneys in the counties with jurisdiction agree in writing.
- Requires, in determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court to consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses.
Comments
According to the author of this bill:
SB 304 adds elder abuse to the list of existing crimes that are currently permitted to have district attorneys prosecute multiple offenses spanning multiple jurisdictions in one county. Cases of sexual assault (against adults or children), child abuse, domestic violence, stalking, human trafficking and pimping or pandering all already have this ability. The prosecution currently and will continue to have to present written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction agree to the venue. The Legislature has recognized that victims of these crimes are vulnerable and need special attention and care. Elderly victims should be treated similarly.
By virtue of U.S. demographics, elder abuse is the fastest growing area of crime in the United States. As the Baby Boomer generation ages, the “Gray Tsunami” of crimes against the elderly increases. Throughout California, elder abuse is becoming more prevalent. At times, perpetrators commit crimes against elder adults in one jurisdiction, and then move to other nearby jurisdictions to evade detection and prosecution. SB 304 amends Penal Code Section 784.7 to include elder and dependent adult abuse among the classes of crimes where offenses in multiple jurisdictions may be consolidated and prosecuted in a single jurisdiction.
All of the crimes encompassed in section 784.7 of the PSC share a commonality: the Legislature has recognized victims of those crimes as vulnerable and in need of special attention and care. They are glaringly omitted, however, from the protections afforded to other vulnerable victims by section 784.7. Penal Code Section 368(a) states that crimes against “elders, adults whose physical or mental disabilities or other limitations restrict their ability to carry out normal activities or to protect their rights, and adults admitted as inpatients to a 24-hour health facility deserve special consideration and protection.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- State prison: Unknown, potential increase in state costs for new commitments to state prison that otherwise would not have resulted in incarceration or as lengthy of a total sentence. The proposed FY 2019-20 per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $83,064 annually, with an annual marginal rate per inmate of over $12,000. (General Fund)
- Courts: Unknown, potential cost savings to the courts in a reduction of separate cases to adjudicate if charges across multiple counties are consolidated into one case. (General Fund*)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
California District Attorneys Association (co-source)
San Mateo County District Attorney’s Office (co-source)
AARP
California Elder Justice Coalition
California Long Term Care Ombudsman Association
California State Sheriffs’ Association
City and County of San Francisco District Attorney’s Office
Crime Victims United of California
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Institute on Aging
Monterey County Department of Social Services
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
California Public Defenders Association
ARGUMENT IN SUPPORT: According to the San Mateo County District Attorney, the sponsor of this bill:
My office is currently prosecuting a case involving a defendant who, with unknown co-conspirators, traveled through multiple counties perpetrating a fraud scheme where the defendants pretended to be immigrants in need of help and swindled elderly victims out of tens of thousands of dollars in cash and jewelry. They appealed to the victims’ vulnerability, diminishing capacity, and they at times invoked religion to ingratiate themselves with the victims. Our case involves three separate victims. Only one senior was victimized in San Mateo County. The other offenses occurred in Contra Costa and Alameda Counties. However, the fraud scheme perpetrated by the defendants was so unique and particularized that it was clearly all part of an ongoing conspiracy. The defendant was held to answer for all charges at the preliminary hearing and the case is awaiting trial.
SB 304, by amending section 784.7 to add elder abuse, will be a much more direct and certain way to prosecute these important cases and would be our only option of the defendant acted alone and we could not charge conspiracy. Your bill will be extremely beneficial to law enforcement, especially because the perpetrators of elder financial abuse frequently travel to various jurisdictions, hit one city or county for a few days, and then move on to the next county. Furthermore, the evidence in the cases would be cross-admissible, so it makes sense from the perspective of judicial economy to prosecute them in the same jurisdiction. It would also make the judicial process less daunting for elderly victims, enabling them to only have to testify in one case and in one jurisdiction
ARGUMENT IN OPPOSITION: According to the California Public Defenders Association:
The jurisdictional statute involved, Penal Code section 784.7 has been expanded too rapidly to assess whether the benefits of doing so outweighs the problems to both the prosecution and the defense, as well as victims, of bringing multiple prosecutions from different counties in only one of them. In 2014, effective January 1, 2015, SB 939 added three crimes to the list. In 2017, effective January 1, 2018, AB 368 added another crime to the list. And in 2018, effective January 1, 2019, A.B. 1746 added yet two more crimes.
Before even more crimes are added, we all should pause and find out if the recent additions are helping or harming judicial economy, increasing or decreasing overall prosecution and defense expenses, how this is affecting convenience or hardship to victims and witnesses, and, most important, whether this is helping or harming public safety.
Moreover, elder and dependent adult abuse crimes are often of a different nature than the sex offenses that make up most of the crimes already included in Penal Code section 784.7. For example, the former often involve financial, property, or health care issues, which sex offenses usually do not. That alone is enough reason to stop and assess first.
Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. /
5/18/19 10:54:47
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 304 (Hill) - Criminal procedure: prosecutorial jurisdiction in multi-jurisdictional elder abuse cases
Version: April 30, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 304 would allow specified felony financial elder abuse offenses that allegedly happened in multiple counties to be consolidated into a single trial in any county where at least one of the offenses allegedly occurred.
Fiscal Impact:
- State prison: Unknown, potential increase in state costs for new commitments to state prison that otherwise would not have resulted in incarceration or as lengthy of a total sentence. The proposed FY 2019-20 per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $83,064 annually, with an annual marginal rate per inmate of over $12,000. (General Fund)
- Courts: Unknown, potential cost savings to the courts in a reduction of separate cases to adjudicate if charges across multiple counties are consolidated into one case. (General Fund*)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
The general rule in California is that the district attorney prosecutes an offense in the jurisdiction where the crime occurred. If part of the commission of the crime occurs in one county but the crime is completed in another county, the proper jurisdiction is in either of the counties. There are, however, a number of exceptions to the rule that the territorial jurisdiction of the case is where the offense occurred. These exceptions include certain sex crimes, domestic violence, child abuse, and human trafficking cases. For these offenses, existing law provides that when more than one violation of certain specified offenses occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, jurisdiction for any of those offenses and any other properly joinable offenses may be in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred if all district attorneys in the counties with jurisdiction over any of the offenses agree to the venue.
With respect to the crime of felony financial elder abuse, a non-caretaker who commits theft, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, or identity theft, as specified, with respect to the property or personal identifying information of an elder or a dependent adult that exceeds $950 in value, and who knows or reasonably should know that the victim is an elder or a dependent adult, is punishable by imprisonment pursuant to the 2011 Realignment Legislation for two, three, or four years and/or a base fine of up to $10,000. A caretaker who commits felony financial elder abuse as described above is subject to the same punishment.
Proposed Law:
This bill would allow charges of felony financial elder abuse that allegedly occurred in multiple counties to be tried in one county, along with properly-joinable offenses, where at least one of the offenses allegedly occurred, subject to a hearing in the jurisdiction of the proposed trial and written evidence presented that all of the district attorneys of the counties with jurisdiction over the offenses agree to the venue. In determining if consolidation is proper, the court would be required to consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses.
Related Legislation:
AB 2734 (Pacheco, Ch. 302, Stats. 1998) permitted jurisdiction for specified felony sex crimes occurring in two or more jurisdictions in any jurisdiction where at least one offense occurred, if the defendant and the victim were the same for all the offenses. AB 2252 (Cohn, Ch. 194, Stats. 2002), SB 939 (Block, Ch. 246, Stats. 2014), AB 368 (Muratsuchi, Ch. 379, Stats. 2017), and AB 1746 (Cervantes, Ch. 962, Stats. 2018) each added various felony sex crime charges that were alleged to happen in multiple jurisdictions to the list of offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial in a jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses allegedly occurred. AB 2252 also deleted the requirement that the consolidated charges involve the same victim for specified charges.
Staff Comments:
The fiscal impact of this bill cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors, including, but not limited to, judicial and prosecutorial discretion, the criminal history of the defendant, and the factors unique to each case. For example, in one county, a court may sentence a defendant found guilty of, or a district attorney may agree to a plea deal for, a financial elder abuse crime that results in the avoidance of a commitment to state prison (e.g., when the sentence includes a period of probation). In another county, because of differing judicial or prosecutorial philosophies or other reasons, that same defendant found guilty of the same crime would have no other practical alternative to a sentence to state prison. If cases from counties with differing sentencing practices were consolidated into one case in a county with stricter sentencing practice, it could result in additional counts of convictions (e.g., by rejecting plea deals that would lead to the dismissal of certain counts in exchange for the conviction of others) and additional and/or longer prison sentences. Consequently, by allowing the consolidation of financial elder abuse crimes that allegedly occurred in multiple counties into a single case, this bill could result in an increase in detention costs to the state prison system.
California is subject to a federal court order to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5 percent of design capacity. The state has undertaken efforts to implement a durable remedy to reduce and avoid prison overcrowding. On April 24, 2019, 117,831 inmates were detained in the state’s thirty-five adult institutions and camps, 6,488 were housed in in-state contract beds, and 845 inmates were held in an out-of-state facility. The prison population changes daily as new inmates are admitted and others are released, but, on that date, the state’s prison population was approximately 134.3 percent of design capacity. By potentially increasing the inmate population in in-state institutions, this bill could make it more difficult for the state to comply with the court order.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 304 Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | April 3, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Criminal Procedure: Prosecutorial Jurisdiction in Multi-Jurisdictional Elder Abuse Cases
HISTORY
Source: San Mateo County District Attorney’s Office (Co-sponsor)
California District Attorneys Association (Co-sponsor)
Prior Legislation: AB 1746 (Cervantes), Ch. 962, Stats. 2018
AB 368 (Muratsuchi), Ch. 379, Stats. 2017
SB 939 (Block), Ch. 246, Stats. 2014
AB 1278 (Lieber), Ch. 258, Stats. 2008
AB 2252 (Cohn), Ch. 194, Stats. 2002
AB 2734 (Pacheco), Ch. 302, Stats. 1998
Support: AARP; California Elder Justice Coalition; California Long Term Care Ombudsman Association; California State Sheriffs’ Association; City and County of San Francisco District Attorney’s Office; Crime Victims United of California; Housing and Economic Rights Advocates; Institute on Aging; Monterey County Department of Social Services
Opposition: California Public Defenders Association
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to allow elder and dependent adult abuse cases that occur in different jurisdictions to be consolidated in a single trial if all district attorneys in the counties with jurisdiction agree.
Existing law states that, except as otherwise provided by law, the jurisdiction of every public offense is in any competent court within the jurisdictional territory of which it is committed. (Pen. Code, § 777.)
Existing law states that when a public offense is committed in part in one jurisdictional territory and in part in another, the jurisdiction of such offense is in any competent court within either jurisdiction. (Pen. Code, § 781.)
Existing law allows property crimes occurring in one jurisdictional territory where property is taken to another jurisdictional territory and an arrest is made there, to be prosecuted in either jurisdiction. (Pen. Code, § 786.)
Existing law permits consolidation of different offenses which do not relate to same transaction or event where there is common element of substantial importance in their commission, such as the same class of crimes. (Pen. Code, § 954.)
Existing law provides that if one or more violations of specified sex offenses occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to the following conditions (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (a)):
- Consolidation of the cases is subject to a joinder hearing, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial court;
- The prosecution presents written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue; and,
- Charged offenses from jurisdictions in which there is no written agreement from the district attorney must be returned to that county.
Existing law states that if more than one violation of child abuse, domestic violence, or stalking, as specified, occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, and the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (b).)
Existing law provides that if more than one violation of human trafficking, pimping, or pandering occurs in more than one jurisdictional territory, the jurisdiction of any of those offenses, and for any offenses properly joinable with that offense, is in any jurisdiction where at least one of the offenses occurred, subject to a hearing pursuant to Section 954, within the jurisdiction of the proposed trial, if all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction of the offenses agree to the venue. In determining whether all counts in the complaint should be joined in one county for prosecution, the court shall consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses. (Pen. Code, § 784.7, subd. (c).)
This bill creates similar authority for consolidation of cases involving elder or dependent adult abuse.
COMMENTS
- Need for this Bill
According to the author of this bill:
SB 304 adds elder abuse to the list of existing crimes that are currently permitted to have district attorneys prosecute multiple offenses spanning multiple jurisdictions in one county. Cases of sexual assault (against adults or children), child abuse, domestic violence, stalking, human trafficking and pimping or pandering all already have this ability. The prosecution currently and will continue to have to present written evidence that all district attorneys in counties with jurisdiction agree to the venue. The Legislature has recognized that victims of these crimes are vulnerable and need special attention and care. Elderly victims should be treated similarly.
By virtue of U.S. demographics, elder abuse is the fastest growing area of crime in the United States. As the Baby Boomer generation ages, the “Gray Tsunami” of crimes against the elderly increases. Throughout California, elder abuse is becoming more prevalent. At times, perpetrators commit crimes against elder adults in one jurisdiction, and then move to other nearby jurisdictions to evade detection and prosecution. SB 304 amends Penal Code Section 784.7 to include elder and dependent adult abuse among the classes of crimes where offenses in multiple jurisdictions may be consolidated and prosecuted in a single jurisdiction.
All of the crimes encompassed in section 784.7 of the PSC share a commonality: the Legislature has recognized victims of those crimes as vulnerable and in need of special attention and care. They are glaringly omitted, however, from the protections afforded to other vulnerable victims by section 784.7. Penal Code Section 368(a) states that crimes against “elders, adults whose physical or mental disabilities or other limitations restrict their ability to carry out normal activities or to protect their rights, and adults admitted as inpatients to a 24-hour health facility deserve special consideration and protection.”
- Consolidation of Cases from Different Jurisdictions
The general rule in California is that the district attorney prosecutes an offense in the jurisdiction where the crime occurred. If part of the commission of the crime occurs in one county but the crime is completed in another county, the proper jurisdiction is in either of the counties.
The Legislature has created several exceptions to the rule that the territorial jurisdiction of the case is where the offense occurred. These exceptions include sex crimes, domestic violence, child abuse, and human trafficking cases. For sex offense cases, the court has ruled that the cases that can be joined do not have to be violations of the same offense. (People v. Nguyen (2010) 184 Cal.App.4th 1096.) Rather, the sex offenses currently listed in Penal Code section 784.7 are of the same class of crimes and therefore any combination of the listed sex crimes may be properly joined. (Id. at 1113.)
The benefits of consolidation include judicial economy and convenience to victims and witnesses who may have to testify in multiple trials, however there are drawbacks. This includes the potential prejudicial impact on the defendant because jurors may feel compelled to convict based on the number of victims rather than the strength of the prosecution’s case. Convenience to some victims and witnesses may also come at the cost of inconvenience to others who live outside of the jurisdiction where the trial is held, which could include law enforcement officers from different counties that investigated each crime. So while consolidation may avoid multiple short trials, the single consolidated trial would likely be much longer. Additionally, not all of those individual cases may have gone to trial due to weakness in evidence or lack prosecutorial resources, but when all of the cases are consolidated into one trial, there is a chance that a charge with weak evidence can still result in a conviction because it is strengthened by the aggregate evidence in the other charges leading to a different outcome than would have occurred if the charge was tried separately.
In recent years, additional exceptions to the rule that requires offenses to be prosecuted in the jurisdiction where the crime occurred were enacted. AB 1746 (Cervantes), Chapter 962, Statutes of 2018, added sexual battery and unlawful sexual intercourse to the list of offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial in any county where at least one of the offenses occurred, if the defendant and the victim are the same for all of the offenses. AB 368 (Muratsuchi), Chapter 379, Statutes of 2017, added felony sexual intercourse, sodomy, oral copulation or sexual penetration with a child 10 years of age or younger occurring in two or more jurisdictions to the list of applicable offenses that may be consolidated in a single trial. SB 939 (Block), Chapter 246, Statutes of 2014 and AB 1278 (Lieber), Chapter 258, Statutes of 2008, authorized felony human trafficking-related charges occurring in two or more jurisdictions to be consolidated in a single trial.
This bill creates another exception allowing for consolidation of crimes against elder or dependent adults into a single trial. Existing law provides for enhanced penalties for specified crimes such as theft, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, and identity theft committed against elderly or dependent persons. (Pen. Code § 368, subd. (d).) The law also punishes willfully causing or permitting an elder or dependent adult to suffer or inflicting unjustifiable physical pain or mental suffering; or as a caretaker willfully causes or permits injury or the health to be endangered. (Pen. Code § 368, subds. (b)-(c).) If the crime is committed under circumstances or conditions likely to cause great bodily injury or death, the punishment is a felony. If the crime is committed under circumstances or conditions not likely to cause produce great bodily harm or death, the punishment is a misdemeanor. (Id.) If great bodily injury is incurred, the defendant must be sentenced to an additional 3 years if the victim is under 70 years of age, or 5 years if the victim is 70 or older. If the offense causes death of the victim, the defendant must be sentenced to an additional 5 years if the victim was under 70 years old and 7 years if the victim was 70 or older. (Id.) Existing law also provides that false imprisonment of an elder or dependent adult is punishable as a felony. (Pen. Code § 368, subd. (f).)
This bill would allow any of the offenses listed in Penal Code section 368 to be consolidated into a single trial in a jurisdiction where one of the offenses took place if all of the district attorneys in the other jurisdictions agree. In making this determination, the court would have to consider the location and complexity of the likely evidence, where the majority of the offenses occurred, the rights of the defendant and the people, and the convenience of, or hardship to, the victim or victims and witnesses. The burden is placed on the defendant to prove that there is a substantial danger of prejudice requiring that the charges be separately tried. (Frank v. Superior Court (1989) 48 Cal. 3d 632, 640.) As discussed above, the crimes that are currently allowed to be consolidated are specified sex crimes, domestic violence, child abuse, and human trafficking cases. The crimes of domestic violence and child abuse require all of the cases to involve the same defendant and same victim.
While some crimes listed in Penal Code section 368 involve harm or mental suffering of an elder or dependent adult, it also includes financial crimes. This is a departure from the types of crimes that are currently allowed to be consolidated under Penal code section 784.7.
- Evidentiary Considerations
This bill amends existing Penal Code section 784.7. When that section was first enacted, it created a multicounty venue for trial of offenses involving sexual or child abuse by the same defendant against the same victim. (AB 2734 (Pacheco), Ch. 302, Stats. 1998.) A few years later, the Legislature removed the "same victim or victims" requirement for sex cases. The purpose was to limit the number of court appearances for victims in serial sexual assault cases involving multiple counties. (AB 2252 (Cohn), Ch. 194, Stats. 2002.) The rationale was that if a defendant was charged with multiple sex crimes involving different victims in a number of different counties, the ability to introduce propensity evidence under Evidence Code Section 1108 makes it very likely that multiple victims will testify in any county that chooses to prosecute the defendant.
Similar to sex crimes, existing law allows the introduction of propensity evidence in elder or dependent adult abuse cases. (Evid. Code, § 1109, subd. (a)(2).) Additionally, the testimony of unrelated victims might be relevant under Evidence Code section 1101, subdivision (b), which allows evidence of uncharged crimes to prove motive, opportunity, intent, preparation, plan, knowledge, identity, absence of mistake or accident. Evidence code section 1101, subdivision (b)is not limited to specific crimes.
Arguably, allowing the consolidation of these offenses would be beneficial to victims and witnesses who may otherwise be called to testify in multiple trials in different counties. However, section 784.7 includes a much narrower list of offenses than Evidence Code sections 1108 and 1109. Also, with respect to child abuse and domestic abuse, section 784.7 only allows consolidation where the victim and defendant are the same for all of the cases.
- Right to Jury Trial
The U.S. Constitution guarantees criminal defendants the right to be tried “by an impartial jury of the state and district wherein the crime shall have been committed, which district shall have been previously ascertained by law . . ..” (U.S. Const., 6th Amend.) The California Supreme Court has held that “[t]he Legislature may determine the venue for trial except to the extent the vicinage or due process provisions of the state or federal Constitution circumscribe that authority.” (Price v. Superior Court (2001) 25 Cal. 4th 1046, 1056.)
Venue refers to the territorial jurisdiction in which a case may be brought to trial, in other words, the location where the trial is held. Vicinage is the right to trial by a jury drawn from residents of the area in which the charged offense allegedly was committed.
In Price v. Superior Court, supra, the California Supreme Court explained these concepts as applied to criminal prosecutions:
The concepts of venue and vicinage are closely related, as a jury pool ordinarily is selected from the area in which the trial is to be held. The concepts have different origins and purposes, however. Venue is historically significant from a national perspective because, as discussed below, the pre-Revolutionary practice of transporting colonists who were charged with crimes in the colonies to either England or other English colonies for trial was among the principal complaints of the colonists against England. Objections to that practice led to the inclusion of Article III, Section 2 in the United States Constitution. That provision limits the place of trial in federal criminal proceedings to the state in which the crime was committed. Most California venue statutes serve a similar purpose in reducing the potential burden on a defendant who might otherwise be required to stand trial in a distant location that is not reasonably related to the alleged criminal conduct.
. . . [T]he general rule of territorial jurisdiction over felonies is that stated in section 777: “except as otherwise provided by law the jurisdiction of every public offense is in any competent court within the jurisdictional territory of which it is committed.” Ordinarily the jurisdictional territory of a superior court is the county in which it sits. (Pen. Code, § 691, subd. (b).) Venue or territorial jurisdiction establishes the proper place for trial, but is not an aspect of the fundamental subject matter jurisdiction of the court and does not affect the power of a court to try a case.
When the Legislature creates an exception to the rule of section 777, the venue statute is remedial and for that reason is construed liberally to achieve the legislative purpose of expanding criminal jurisdiction. Section 784.7 is such an exception and the legislative purpose is clear. (People v. Price, supra, 25 Cal.4th at pp. 1054-1056, internal citations omitted.)
As to the right of vicinage, the Supreme Court explained:
Because a vicinage guarantee does not serve the purpose of protecting a criminal defendant from government oppression and is not necessary to ensure a fair trial, it is not a necessary feature of the right to jury trial. For that reason we conclude that the vicinage clause of the Sixth Amendment is not applicable to the states through the Fourteenth Amendment. (Price v. Superior Court, supra, 25 Cal. 4th p. at 1065.)
Rather, the Court explained, the right of vicinage in California is derived from the right to a jury trial guaranteed in the California Constitution and is effectively limited to a requirement that there be a reasonable nexus between the crime and the county of trial:
The right to a trial by a jury of the vicinage, as guaranteed by the California Constitution, is not violated by trial in county having a reasonable relationship to the offense or to other crimes committed by the defendant against the same victim. We do not hold here that a crime may be tried anywhere. The Legislature’s power to designate the place for trial of a criminal offense is limited by the requirement that there be a reasonable relationship or nexus between the place designated for trial and the commission of the offense. Repeated abuse of the same child or spouse in more than one county creates that nexus. The venue authorized by Penal Code section 784.7 is not arbitrary. It is reasonable for the Legislature to conclude that this pattern of conduct is akin to a continuing offense and to conclude that the victim and other witnesses should not be burdened with having to testify in multiple trials in different counties. (Price v. Superior Court, supra, 25 Cal.4th. at p. 1075.)
- Argument in Support
According to the San Mateo County District Attorney, the sponsor of this bill:
My office is currently prosecuting a case involving a defendant who, with unknown co-conspirators, traveled through multiple counties perpetrating a fraud scheme where the defendants pretended to be immigrants in need of help and swindled elderly victims out of tens of thousands of dollars in cash and jewelry. They appealed to the victims’ vulnerability, diminishing capacity, and they at times invoked religion to ingratiate themselves with the victims. Our case involves three separate victims. Only one senior was victimized in San Mateo County. The other offenses occurred in Contra Costa and Alameda Counties. However, the fraud scheme perpetrated by the defendants was so unique and particularized that it was clearly all part of an ongoing conspiracy. The defendant was held to answer for all charges at the preliminary hearing and the case is awaiting trial.
SB 304, by amending section 784.7 to add elder abuse, will be a much more direct and certain way to prosecute these important cases and would be our only option of the defendant acted alone and we could not charge conspiracy. Your bill will be extremely beneficial to law enforcement, especially because the perpetrators of elder financial abuse frequently travel to various jurisdictions, hit one city or county for a few days, and then move on to the next county. Furthermore, the evidence in the cases would be cross-admissible, so it makes sense from the perspective of judicial economy to prosecute them in the same jurisdiction. It would also make the judicial process less daunting for elderly victims, enabling them to only have to testify in one case and in one jurisdiction.
- Argument in Opposition
According to the California Public Defenders Association:
The jurisdictional statute involved, Penal Code section 784.7 has been expanded too rapidly to assess whether the benefits of doing so outweighs the problems to both the prosecution and the defense, as well as victims, of bringing multiple prosecutions from different counties in only one of them. In 2014, effective January 1, 2015, SB 939 added three crimes to the list. In 2017, effective January 1, 2018, AB 368 added another crime to the list. And in 2018, effective January 1, 2019, A.B. 1746 added yet two more crimes.
Before even more crimes are added, we all should pause and find out if the recent additions are helping or harming judicial economy, increasing or decreasing overall prosecution and defense expenses, how this is affecting convenience or hardship to victims and witnesses, and, most important, whether this is helping or harming public safety.
Moreover, elder and dependent adult abuse crimes are often of a different nature than the sex offenses that make up most of the crimes already included in Penal Code section 784.7. For example, the former often involve financial, property, or health care issues, which sex offenses usually do not. That alone is enough reason to stop and assess first.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):