SB 318: Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-03
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2019 | July 10 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 6. Noes 4.) |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on INS. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 13, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and INS. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 1200.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0. Page 1096.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0. Page 905.) (April 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on JUD. and APPR. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Insurance] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB318 Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 318
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
SUMMARY: Applies a number of existing consumer protection laws to bail and immigration bond transactions. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that translations of bail and immigration bond contracts be provided when the transactions include an extension of credit and are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Adds the securing or financing of a bail bond or immigration bond to the definition of “services” under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA).
- Adds individuals seeking to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer” under the CLRA.
- Adds money owed to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer debt” under the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Protection Act (RFDCPA).
- Adds agreements or contracts to secure or finance bail and immigration bonds to the definition of “loans or extension of credit” for the purpose of requiring the provision of a specified notice before completing the transaction.
- Specifies that the above changes are declaratory of existing law.
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the for-profit money bail system.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that translations of contracts for a range consumer transactions be provided when the transactions are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Establishes the CLRA to provide consumer protections against unfair competition, deceptive or unfair practices in the sale or lease of goods or services.
- Establishes the RFDCPA to prevent debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts.
- Requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract, and defines “consumer credit contract” for those purposes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, the commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate. To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives – while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake. SB 318 clarifies existing definitions on California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
- Bail. Once a person is arrested and booked into a jail, a court must decide whether the accused remains in custody or is released. The accused may be held in custody, released to await court dates on his or her “own recognizance,” or released on the condition of “bail” being met. Generally, bail is set to require a specific amount of money, usually in the form of a bail bond, to be paid to the courts in order to secure the appearance of the accused in court. Bail amounts are usually determined by a “schedule,” but the accused can have a bail hearing in front of a judge to determine the amount. If the accused does not wish to pay the full amount ordered by the court for release, or cannot afford the full amount, the accused may seek the services of a bail agent. The bail agent may post a bail bond for the accused as a guarantee for the person’s appearance at mandated court hearings and for release from custody.
- Bail Agents. In California, a bail agent is a person licensed and regulated by the Department of Insurance. A bail agent works with one or more bail surety companies, which essentially operate as an insurer backing the bail bond. In this instance, the bail agent takes responsibility for the accused making all court appearances and if the accused fails to appear, the bail agent will be the party responsible to pay the court the full amount of the bail bond.
Bail bonds may be negotiated in several ways. Most commonly, a bail agent charges eight or ten percent of the bail bond, commonly referred to as premium. This is the bail agent’s commission. The accused does not get any of this money back unless the bail agent chooses to rebate monies back to the accused. For example, on a $25,000 bail, the ten percent premium paid to the bail agent is $2,500. In turn, the bail agent must pay the surety a percentage of the $2,500 based on the bail agent's contract with the surety insurer involved. Collateral to secure the bail bond may take many forms, including a lien on house or a car. When all appearances are made and the case resolved, the money provided to the court for bail will go back to the party that paid – either the accused or the bail agent. If the accused fails to appear for any court appearance at any time, that money is forfeited to the court and a warrant is issued for the arrest of the person.
- Immigration Bond. An immigration bond is similar to a bail bond in that it provides a financial incentive for participants involved in the immigration system to attend required hearings or comply with agreements to depart the country.
- Previous Legislation. In 2018, California passed SB 10 which replaced money bail with a release or preventive detention approach founded on a risk assessment system [SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244]. However, this bill is the subject of a referendum to be placed on the November 2020 ballot. The implementation of SB 10 is suspended pending the outcome of the referendum.
- Suggested Amendments. The author should consider making the following amendments to the bill:
- Remove the provisions indicating that the changes made are “declaratory of existing law.” This language is an attempt to retroactively apply, by legislative enactment, these laws to contracts for bail and immigration bonds. There is an active debate in the legal and bail communities whether these laws apply to bail and immigration bond transactions as written. As a general matter, it is the province of the courts to sort out the application of existing law to an existing set of facts. Legislating on a retroactive basis can be an unwelcome intrusion in the prerogatives of the courts and is a suspect and uncertain endeavor in the best of circumstances. Undertaking that endeavor shortly before an election that may end the existing bail system may be hard to justify.
The elimination of this language leaves a bill that establishes bright line requirements that consumers seeking bail and immigration bonds benefit from these substantial consumer protections while presenting no new obstacles to advocates pursuing court decisions applying these laws to previous transactions.
- Remove language making legislative findings regarding the bail system and the application of these consumer protection laws to bail transactions.
The existing language could well have some influence over a court’s ruling on the application of existing statute to bail and immigration bond transactions. Again, this language can be removed without impairing the protections provided to consumers going forward.
- Insert language expressing Legislative intent that no actions taken on this bill are intended to influence litigation seeking to apply these consumer protections to bail and immigration bond transactions prior to the bill’s enactment.
This language is designed to provide assurance that this bill does not assist or impair attempts to seek a judicial determination regarding the application of these laws to bail and immigration bond transactions.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition, Sponsor
The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (LCCR), Co-Sponsor
#cut50
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Asian Law Alliance
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
California United for a Responsible Budget (CURB)
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA)
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS)
East Bay Community Law Center (“EBCLC”)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
JusticeLA
Re: Store Justice
Riverside Temple Beth El
Opposition
American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA)
Golden State Bail Agents Association (GSBAA)
Surety & Fidelity Association of America (SFAA)
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 318
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
SUMMARY: Applies a number of existing consumer protection laws to bail and immigration bond transactions. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that translations of bail and immigration bond contracts be provided when the transactions include an extension of credit and are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Adds the securing or financing of a bail bond or immigration bond to the definition of “services” under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA).
- Adds individuals seeking to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer” under the CLRA.
- Adds money owed to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer debt” under the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Protection Act (RFDCPA).
- Adds agreements or contracts to secure or finance bail and immigration bonds to the definition of “loans or extension of credit” for the purpose of requiring the provision of a specified notice before completing the transaction.
- Specifies that the above changes are declaratory of existing law.
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the for-profit money bail system.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that translations of contracts for a range consumer transactions be provided when the transactions are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Establishes the CLRA to provide consumer protections against unfair competition, deceptive or unfair practices in the sale or lease of goods or services.
- Establishes the RFDCPA to prevent debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts.
- Requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract, and defines “consumer credit contract” for those purposes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, the commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate. To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives – while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake. SB 318 clarifies existing definitions on California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
- Bail. Once a person is arrested and booked into a jail, a court must decide whether the accused remains in custody or is released. The accused may be held in custody, released to await court dates on his or her “own recognizance,” or released on the condition of “bail” being met. Generally, bail is set to require a specific amount of money, usually in the form of a bail bond, to be paid to the courts in order to secure the appearance of the accused in court. Bail amounts are usually determined by a “schedule,” but the accused can have a bail hearing in front of a judge to determine the amount. If the accused does not wish to pay the full amount ordered by the court for release, or cannot afford the full amount, the accused may seek the services of a bail agent. The bail agent may post a bail bond for the accused as a guarantee for the person’s appearance at mandated court hearings and for release from custody.
- Bail Agents. In California, a bail agent is a person licensed and regulated by the Department of Insurance. A bail agent works with one or more bail surety companies, which essentially operate as an insurer backing the bail bond. In this instance, the bail agent takes responsibility for the accused making all court appearances and if the accused fails to appear, the bail agent will be the party responsible to pay the court the full amount of the bail bond.
Bail bonds may be negotiated in several ways. Most commonly, a bail agent charges eight or ten percent of the bail bond, commonly referred to as premium. This is the bail agent’s commission. The accused does not get any of this money back unless the bail agent chooses to rebate monies back to the accused. For example, on a $25,000 bail, the ten percent premium paid to the bail agent is $2,500. In turn, the bail agent must pay the surety a percentage of the $2,500 based on the bail agent's contract with the surety insurer involved. Collateral to secure the bail bond may take many forms, including a lien on house or a car. When all appearances are made and the case resolved, the money provided to the court for bail will go back to the party that paid – either the accused or the bail agent. If the accused fails to appear for any court appearance at any time, that money is forfeited to the court and a warrant is issued for the arrest of the person.
- Immigration Bond. An immigration bond is similar to a bail bond in that it provides a financial incentive for participants involved in the immigration system to attend required hearings or comply with agreements to depart the country.
- Previous Legislation. In 2018, California passed SB 10 which replaced money bail with a release or preventive detention approach founded on a risk assessment system [SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244]. However, this bill is the subject of a referendum to be placed on the November 2020 ballot. The implementation of SB 10 is suspended pending the outcome of the referendum.
- Suggested Amendments. The author should consider making the following amendments to the bill:
- Remove the provisions indicating that the changes made are “declaratory of existing law.” This language is an attempt to retroactively apply, by legislative enactment, these laws to contracts for bail and immigration bonds. There is an active debate in the legal and bail communities whether these laws apply to bail and immigration bond transactions as written. As a general matter, it is the province of the courts to sort out the application of existing law to an existing set of facts. Legislating on a retroactive basis can be an unwelcome intrusion in the prerogatives of the courts and is a suspect and uncertain endeavor in the best of circumstances. Undertaking that endeavor shortly before an election that may end the existing bail system may be hard to justify.
The elimination of this language leaves a bill that establishes bright line requirements that consumers seeking bail and immigration bonds benefit from these substantial consumer protections while presenting no new obstacles to advocates pursuing court decisions applying these laws to previous transactions.
- Remove language making legislative findings regarding the bail system and the application of these consumer protection laws to bail transactions.
The existing language could well have some influence over a court’s ruling on the application of existing statute to bail and immigration bond transactions. Again, this language can be removed without impairing the protections provided to consumers going forward.
- Insert language expressing Legislative intent that no actions taken on this bill are intended to influence litigation seeking to apply these consumer protections to bail and immigration bond transactions prior to the bill’s enactment.
This language is designed to provide assurance that this bill does not assist or impair attempts to seek a judicial determination regarding the application of these laws to bail and immigration bond transactions.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (LCCR), Co-Sponsor
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA)
Opposition
American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA)
Surety & Fidelity Association of America (SFAA)
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 318
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
SUMMARY: Applies a number of existing consumer protection laws to bail and immigration bond transactions. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires that translations of bail and immigration bond contracts be provided when the transactions include an extension of credit and are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Adds the securing or financing of a bail bond or immigration bond to the definition of “services” under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA).
- Adds individuals seeking to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer” under the CLRA.
- Adds money owed to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond to the definition of “consumer debt” under the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Protection Act (RFDCPA).
- Adds agreements or contracts to secure or finance bail and immigration bonds to the definition of “loans or extension of credit” for the purpose of requiring the provision of a specified notice before completing the transaction.
- Specifies that the above changes are declaratory of existing law.
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the for-profit money bail system.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires that translations of contracts for a range consumer transactions be provided when the transactions are primarily conducted in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean.
- Establishes the CLRA to provide consumer protections against unfair competition, deceptive or unfair practices in the sale or lease of goods or services.
- Establishes the RFDCPA to prevent debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts.
- Requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract, and defines “consumer credit contract” for those purposes.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, the commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate. To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives – while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake. SB 318 clarifies existing definitions on California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
- Bail. Once a person is arrested and booked into a jail, a court must decide whether the accused remains in custody or is released. The accused may be held in custody, released to await court dates on his or her “own recognizance,” or released on the condition of “bail” being met. Generally, bail is set to require a specific amount of money, usually in the form of a bail bond, to be paid to the courts in order to secure the appearance of the accused in court. Bail amounts are usually determined by a “schedule,” but the accused can have a bail hearing in front of a judge to determine the amount. If the accused does not wish to pay the full amount ordered by the court for release, or cannot afford the full amount, the accused may seek the services of a bail agent. The bail agent may post a bail bond for the accused as a guarantee for the person’s appearance at mandated court hearings and for release from custody.
- Bail Agents. In California, a bail agent is a person licensed and regulated by the Department of Insurance. A bail agent works with one or more bail surety companies, which essentially operate as an insurer backing the bail bond. In this instance, the bail agent takes responsibility for the accused making all court appearances and if the accused fails to appear, the bail agent will be the party responsible to pay the court the full amount of the bail bond.
Bail bonds may be negotiated in several ways. Most commonly, a bail agent charges eight or ten percent of the bail bond, commonly referred to as premium. This is the bail agent’s commission. The accused does not get any of this money back unless the bail agent chooses to rebate monies back to the accused. For example, on a $25,000 bail, the ten percent premium paid to the bail agent is $2,500. In turn, the bail agent must pay the surety a percentage of the $2,500 based on the bail agent's contract with the surety insurer involved. Collateral to secure the bail bond may take many forms, including a lien on house or a car. When all appearances are made and the case resolved, the money provided to the court for bail will go back to the party that paid – either the accused or the bail agent. If the accused fails to appear for any court appearance at any time, that money is forfeited to the court and a warrant is issued for the arrest of the person.
- Immigration Bond. An immigration bond is similar to a bail bond in that it provides a financial incentive for participants involved in the immigration system to attend required hearings or comply with agreements to depart the country.
- Previous Legislation. In 2018, California passed SB 10 which replaced money bail with a release or preventive detention approach founded on a risk assessment system [SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244]. However, this bill is the subject of a referendum to be placed on the November 2020 ballot. The implementation of SB 10 is suspended pending the outcome of the referendum.
- Suggested Amendments. The author should consider making the following amendments to the bill:
- Remove the provisions indicating that the changes made are “declaratory of existing law.” This language is an attempt to retroactively apply, by legislative enactment, these laws to contracts for bail and immigration bonds. There is an active debate in the legal and bail communities whether these laws apply to bail and immigration bond transactions as written. As a general matter, it is the province of the courts to sort out the application of existing law to an existing set of facts. Legislating on a retroactive basis can be an unwelcome intrusion in the prerogatives of the courts and is a suspect and uncertain endeavor in the best of circumstances. Undertaking that endeavor shortly before an election that may end the existing bail system may be hard to justify.
The elimination of this language leaves a bill that establishes bright line requirements that consumers seeking bail and immigration bonds benefit from these substantial consumer protections while presenting no new obstacles to advocates pursuing court decisions applying these laws to previous transactions.
- Remove language making legislative findings regarding the bail system and the application of these consumer protection laws to bail transactions.
The existing language could well have some influence over a court’s ruling on the application of existing statute to bail and immigration bond transactions. Again, this language can be removed without impairing the protections provided to consumers going forward.
- Insert language expressing Legislative intent that no actions taken on this bill are intended to influence litigation seeking to apply these consumer protections to bail and immigration bond transactions prior to the bill’s enactment.
This language is designed to provide assurance that this bill does not assist or impair attempts to seek a judicial determination regarding the application of these laws to bail and immigration bond transactions.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition, Sponsor
The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (LCCR), Co-Sponsor
#cut50
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Asian Law Alliance
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
California United for a Responsible Budget (CURB)
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA)
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety (CARS)
East Bay Community Law Center (“EBCLC”)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
JusticeLA
Re: Store Justice
Riverside Temple Beth El
Opposition
American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA)
Surety & Fidelity Association of America (SFAA)
Analysis Prepared by: Paul Riches / INS. / (916) 319-2086
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 318
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:May 17, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: CONSUMER PROTECTIONS: CONTRACTS AND AGREEMENTS TO FINANCE OR SECURE A BAIL BOND OR IMMIGRATION BOND
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD CONSUMER PROTECTIONS UNDER THE CONSUMER LEGAL REMEDIES ACT, THE CONTRACT TRANSLATION PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE, THE ROSENTHAL FAIR DEBT COLLECTION PRACTICES ACT, AND CONSUMER CREDIT CONTRACT PROVISIONS OF THE CIVIL CODE APPLY TO THE SECURING AND FINANCING OF BAIL AND IMMIGRATION BONDS?
- DOES EXISTING LAW ALREADY PROVIDE FOR THE APPLICATION OF THESE CONSUMER PROTECTIONS TO TRANSACTIONS TO SECURE OR FINANCE BAIL AND IMMIGRATIONS BONDS?
SYNOPSIS
Most defendants who are arrested on criminal charges are detained by the court prior to their trial to ensure that they appear in court. Several studies have demonstrated that pretrial detention results in worse legal outcomes, and can cause economic, physical, and mental hardship in those who are incarcerated. In many cases, defendants are given the option to secure pretrial release if they pay a sizable sum of money, typically far beyond the means of most defendants, as a deposit to be returned when they show up in court as scheduled. Because most defendants cannot afford these costs, they are left with a decision: remain detained until trial and suffer the consequences, or solicit the services of a bail bond agent. Bail bond agents arrange agreements with the court to release the defendant into their custody in exchange for a promise that the full amount of bail will be forfeited if the defendant does not show up for court. A bail bond transaction is, in reality, three separate transactions: one between the defendant and the bail bond agent to purchase the services of the agent; one between the bail bond agent and the court to arrange, pursuant to the defendant’s purchase, for release of the defendant into their custody; and one between the bail bond agent and a surety insurer which, for a percentage of the amount paid to the bail bond agent, insures the bail bond agent in the event that the defendant does not appear for court and the agent is held liable for the full bond. Bail bond agent licensure is regulated under the Insurance Code, but only in the context of the latter two transactions that actually seem to constitute insurance under the definitions of California law. The transaction between the defendant and the bail bond agent, on the other hand, appears to be the purchase of a service (i.e. the arranging of the defendant’s release with the court and custodial services). Because the defendant typically signs an indemnity agreement deeming them liable for the full amount of bail if they do not appear, the bail bond agent is not providing the defendant with insurance against that cost. Since the purchase of a service in California is regulated under various consumer protection statutes (e.g. protecting against misleading advertising, bad-faith business practices, and harassment and intimidation to facilitate debt collection), these provisions may also apply to the securing and financing of bail and immigration bond services.
This bill purports to clarify existing law and legislative intent by providing that consumer protections under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, and the contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code, apply to the securing and financing of bail and immigration bonds to arrange the pretrial release of a defendant. The bill specifies that it imposes no new laws, but rather clarifies existing definitions under these statutes as they apply to bail and immigration bond transactions. Though courts have not conclusively determined whether California consumer protections apply to these transactions, the definitions provided under these laws seem to allow a reasonable argument to be made that they should apply, so long as they are limited to the transaction between the defendant and the bond agent. Because such an argument can be reasonably made, case law seems to support the authority of a later Legislature to declare the intent of a law passed by an earlier Legislature, as it is not “unmistakably” altering the law to an “obviously absurd effect.” Proactively, this bill would thus apply these consumer protections to bail and immigration bond transactions, and retroactively, the court may consider this articulation of intent to be non-bonding guidance in adjudicating ongoing disputes.
The author has accepted amendments to remove contracts or agreements “securing” bail or immigration bonds from their clarifying language applying the contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code, as while these laws could reasonably be interpreted to apply to the financing of bail or immigration bond services, they do not seem to regulate contracts securing those services. The author has also agreed to rearrange the provisions to specify that financing of bail and immigration services is considered a “loan or extension of credit,” thereby subjecting associated contracts to those provisions. The proposed amendments are discussed in the analysis.
This bill is co-sponsored by the California Low-Income Consumers Coalition and the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights. The bill is supported by several legal aid, human rights, social justice, and civil liberties advocacy groups, who contend that the vulnerability of detained defendants subjects them to manipulation, abuse, and other malfeasance at the hands of bail and immigration bond agents. The bill is opposed by groups representing bail bond agencies and surety insurers, who contend that the bill imposes new laws retroactively, and that bail bond transactions are fundamentally insurance transactions that should not be subject to these consumer protection statutes.
SUMMARY: Clarifies that, pursuant to definitions in existing law, bail and immigration bond providers are subject to the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, the contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code, and the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Specifically, this bill:
- Clarifies that the term “contract” or “agreement,” as it is used in the contract translation provisions of the Civil Code, includes, but is not limited to, a contract or agreement to secure and finance a bail bond or immigration bond, as defined, for the release of a detained individual.
- Clarifies that “services,” as it is used in the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, includes, but is not limited to, the securing or financing of a bail bond or an immigration bond, as defined, for the release of a detained individual.
- Clarifies that “consumer,” as it is used in the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, includes, but is not limited to, an individual who, for the purposes of their release from detention or the release of another individual from detention, seeks or acquires services to finance or secure a bail bond or an immigration bond, as defined.
- Clarifies that “consumer debt,” as it is used in the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, includes, but is not limited to, money owing from a transaction for services to finance or secure a bail bond or an immigration bond, as defined, for the release of an individual from detention.
- Clarifies that “consumer credit contract,” as it is used in the consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code, includes, but is not limited to, an agreement or contract between an individual and another party to finance or secure a bail bond or an immigration bond, as defined, for the release of an individual from detention.
- Specifies that all provisions of this bill are declaratory of existing law.
- Makes findings and declarations relating to the unique vulnerabilities of individuals securing or financing bail and immigration bonds to predatory business practices, and that the provisions of this bill do not change existing law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires any person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean in the course of entering into a contract or agreement to deliver to the other party to the contract or agreement a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated prior to the execution thereof. (Civil Code Section 1632 (b); all subsequent statutory references are to the Civil Code, unless otherwise specified.)
- Defines “contract” or “agreement,” for the purposes of that provision, to mean the document creating the rights and obligations of the parties, including any subsequent document making substantial changes in the rights and obligations of the parties. (Section 1632 (g).)
- Specifies, under the title of the “Consumer Legal Remedies Act,” several unfair or deceptive acts or practices that are unlawful if undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or resulting in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. (Section 1770 (a).)
- Entitles any consumer who suffers any damage as a result of the use or employment of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful by the Consumer Legal Remedies Act to actual damages in excess of $1,000, an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices, restitution of property, punitive damages, and any other relief that the court deems proper. (Section 1780 (a).)
- Provides that the Consumer Legal Remedies Act shall be liberally construed and applied to promote its underlying purposes, which are to protect consumers against unfair and deceptive business practices and to provide efficient and economical procedures to secure such protection. (Section 1760.)
- Defines “services,” for the purposes of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, to mean work, labor, and services for other than a commercial or business use, including services furnished in connection with the sale or repair of goods. (Section 1761 (b).)
- Defines “consumer,” for the purposes of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, to mean an individual who seeks or acquires, by purchase or lease, any goods or services for personal, family, or household purposes. (Section 1761 (d).)
- Prohibits, under the title of the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, any debt collector from collecting or attempting to collect consumer debt by means of several unseemly practices including harassment, use of obscene or profane language, and threats to defame the debtor. (Sections 1788.10-1788.17.)
- Entitles any debtor who suffers a violation of the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act to actual damages to be paid by the debt collector who willing and knowingly violates the provisions of that Act as well as a penalty in such amount as the court may allow, which shall not be less than $100 nor greater than $1,000. (Section 1788.30 (a) - (b).)
- Defines “consumer debt” and “consumer credit,” for the purposes of the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, to mean money, property, or their equivalent, due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person by reason of a consumer credit transaction. (Section 1788.2 (f).)
- Defines “debt collection,” for the purposes of the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, to mean any act or practice in connection with the collection of consumer debts, and defines “debt collector” to mean any person who, in the ordinary course of business, regularly, on behalf of himself or herself or others, engages in debt collection. (Sections 1788.2 (b) & (c).)
- Specifies several requirements and conditions governing the construction of consumer credit contracts. (Section 1799.91-1799.104.)
- Defines “consumer credit contract,” for the purposes of those provisions, to mean any of the following obligations to pay money on a deferred payment basis, where the money, property, services or other consideration which is the subject matter of the contract is primarily for personal, family or household purposes: retail installment contracts, retail installment accounts, conditional sales contracts, loans or extensions of credit unsecured or secured by other than real property, loans or extensions of credit, or lease contracts. (Section 1799.90 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Most defendants who are arrested on criminal charges are detained by the court prior to their trial to ensure that they appear in court. Several studies have demonstrated that pretrial detention results in worse legal outcomes, and can cause economic, physical, and mental hardship in those who are incarcerated. In many cases, defendants are given the option to secure pretrial release if they pay a sizable sum of money, typically far beyond the means of most defendants, as a deposit to be returned when they show up in court as scheduled. Because most defendants cannot afford these costs, they are left with a decision: remain detained until trial and suffer the consequences, or solicit the services of a bail bond agent. Bail bond agents secure agreements with the court on behalf of defendants to release the defendant into their custody in exchange for a promise that the full amount of the bail will be forfeited if the defendant does not show up for court. This service is provided to the defendant upon the provision by the defendant or their representative of a percentage of the bail amount, or a payment plan to total to that amount, and an agreement to cover the full cost of bail in the event they do not show up for court.
A bail bond transaction is, in reality, three separate transactions: one between the defendant and the bail bond agency to purchase the services of the agency; one between the bail bond agency and the court to arrange, pursuant to the defendant’s purchase, for release of the defendant into their custody; and one between the bail bond agent and a surety insurer which, for a percentage of the amount paid to the bail bond agent, insures the bail bond agent in the event the defendant does not appear for court and the agent must pay the full bond to the court. Bail bond agent licensure is regulated under the Insurance Code, but only the latter two transactions actually seem to constitute insurance activities under California law. The transaction between the defendant and the bail bond agent, on the other hand, appears to be the purchase of a service (i.e. the arranging of release with the court and custodial services). Because the defendant typically signs an indemnity agreement deeming them liable for the full amount of bail if they do not appear, the bail bond agent is not providing them with insurance against that cost. Since the purchase of a service in California is regulated under various consumer protection statutes protecting against, e.g., misleading advertising, bad-faith business practices, and harassment and intimidation to facilitate debt collection, these provisions may also apply to the securing and financing of bail and immigration bond services.
This bill purports to clarify existing law and legislative intent by providing that consumer protections under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, and the contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code apply to the securing and financing of bail and immigration bonds to arrange the pretrial release of a defendant. The bill specifies that it imposes no new laws, but rather clarifies existing definitions under these statutes as they apply to bail and immigration bond transactions. Though courts have not conclusively determined whether California consumer protections apply to these transactions, the definitions provided under these laws seem to allow a reasonable argument to be made that they should apply to the activities at issue in this bill, so long as they are limited to the transaction between the defendant and the bond agent. Because such an argument reasonably can be made, case law seems to support the authority of a later Legislature to declare the intent of a law passed by an earlier Legislature, as it is not “unmistakably” altering the law to an “obviously absurd effect.” Proactively, this bill would thus apply these consumer protections to bail and immigration bond transactions, and retroactively, the court may consider this articulation of legislative intent to be non-bonding guidance in adjudicating ongoing disputes.
Author’s amendments. The author has accepted amendments to remove contracts or agreements “securing” bail or immigration bonds from their clarifying language applying the contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code, as while these laws could reasonably be interpreted to apply to the financing of bail or immigration bond services, they do not seem to regulate contracts securing those services. The author has also agreed to rearrange the provisions to specify that financing of bail and immigration services is considered a “loan or extension of credit,” thereby subjecting associated contracts to those provisions.
According to the author:
The commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate.
To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives - while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake.
SB 318 clarifies existing definitions in California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
Bail and immigration bonds. When a person is arrested on a criminal charge or detained for undocumented presence in the country, they are often incarcerated until trial in order to ensure that they do not flee prosecution. This practice is particularly prevalent in California, in which 59% of those accused of crimes are detained prior to trial, compared with 32% nationwide. (Sonya Tafoya, Pretrial Detention and Jail Capacity in California, Pub. Policy Inst. of California, July 2015.) In California, defendants are typically entitled to some form of pretrial release, but this release is often contingent on paying a sizable amount of money, far beyond the means of most defendants. Without these means, defendants suffer a range of issues resulting from their detention, regardless of whether or not they are actually guilty of the crime. Pretrial detention leads to higher rates of conviction, increased probability of jail time, longer sentences, and higher court fees, all possibly due to unconscious biases relating to a detained person. (Criminal Justice Reform Clinic, The Devil in the Details: Bail Bond Contracts in California, UCLA School of Law, May 2017, p.3.) Additionally, pretrial detention increases the likelihood that the defendant will plead guilty to the crime, whether or not they actually committed it, as a guilty plea could end their detention. During detention, those who are detained suffer the loss of income, and possibly loss of jobs, resulting from their inability to work, as well as the physical and mental health impacts of incarceration. These effects disproportionately impact people of color, as the likelihood of having bail denied in California is 25% higher for Black and Latino defendants compared to white defendants, and Black men average 35% higher assigned bail amounts than their white counterparts for the same crimes. (Ibid.) The United States is one of only two countries, along with the Philippines, that continues to maintain a money bail system.
To avoid these hardships, defendants often resort to commercial bail bond agents, who, for a percentage of the total bail amount, will arrange for the release of the defendant into their custody until trial. As of the spring of 2018, there were approximately 3,200 licensed bail agents and organizations in California. (Mel Gonzalez, Consumer Protection for Criminal Defendants: Regulating Commercial Bail in California (2018) 106 Calif. L. Rev. 1379, 1391.) This industry has grown exponentially over the past two decades, coinciding with increases in average bail amounts. From 2002 to 2012, the average bail amount for the most frequently committed felony offenses increased by 22% in California, and bail is a required condition of release in 70% of felony cases nationwide. (Id. at p.1394.) In 2018, California passed SB 10 which outlawed money bail as a condition for pretrial release. (SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chap. 244, Stats. 2018.) However, the provisions of this bill have not yet been implemented due to persistent legal challenges. In the meantime, the money bail system continues to provide defendants, whether guilty or innocent, with a difficult choice: remain detained until trial and suffer the resulting hardships and disadvantages, or secure and finance the services of a bail bond agent to arrange pretrial release, often with little information and virtually no leverage to negotiate the terms of the agreement.
A commercial bail bond transaction involves a complex system involving multiple contracts and parties. Determining the applicability of existing consumer protection laws to the securing and financing of bail bonds requires understanding the component parts of a commercial bail bond transaction. In reality, a commercial bail bond transaction consists of three separate agreements. The first is the agreement at issue in this bill between the bail bond agent and the defendant, in which an incarcerated defendant, or representative of that person, agrees to pay a fraction of the bail amount (typically 10%) in exchange for the defendant’s release from detention into the custody of the bail bond agency. Given the indigence of most defendants, this transaction often couples with a financing agreement for the defendant or family to afford the cost of procuring the services of the bail bond agent. The second agreement is one between the bail bond agency and the court, in which the bail bond agency procures an agreement for the release of the defendant into their custody without paying the full bail bond, but with a promise that the bond shall be provided, via an underwriting surety insurer, in the event that the defendant is not present to stand trial. The third agreement, consequently, is an arrangement between the bail bond agent and a surety insurer, typically a large insurance company that deals with many types of insurance, in which the insurer underwrites the cost of the bond in the event it must be forfeited. A 2018 law review by Mel Gonzales explains the nature of these transactions most succinctly:
For example, for a $50,000 bail, a defendant will pay $5,000 to a bail bond agent, who will then pay the insurance company $500 for an insurance policy that is supposed to cover the original $50,000 bail in case it is forfeited due to the defendant’s failure to appear in court. (Gonzalez, Consumer Protection for Criminal Defendants, supra, at p.1391.)
While it is tempting, for simplicity’s sake, to subject all of these transactions to the same laws of contracts and agreements, the fundamental differences between their functions differentiates the defendant-bail bond agent transaction from the other two.
The relationship between the bail bond agent and insurance company or court. Section 22 of the Insurance Code defines insurance as “a contract whereby one undertakes to indemnify another against loss, damage, or liability arising from a contingent or unknown event.” The function of both the bail bond agent-court and the bail bond agent-surety insurer transactions is one of insurance against the possibility that the defendant does not show up for court; that is, the bail bond agent is insuring the court that the defendant will show up, due at least in part to their custodial services, or else the bail will be forfeited, and the surety insurer is insuring the bail bond agent that the funds to pay out the forfeited bond will be available in the event the bail bond agent must compensate the court pursuant to that insurance agreement.
The relationship between the bail bond agent and the defendant. In contrast, the defendant is securing from the bail bond agent their services in procuring these aforementioned arrangements with the court and the insurer, respectively, as well as their custodial services. Rather than indemnifying against the possible forfeiture of bond by the consumer, bail bond agents typically require the bail to be paid in full (via collateral) to the agent in the event it must be forfeited. The defendant, then, is paying for the services employed by the bail bond agent that permit their release from pretrial detention without the need for the full bail amount, and is not paying to indemnify against the risk of forfeiting the full bail amount in the event they do not appear to stand trial. Indeed, while the sole regulation of bail agents is provided in the Insurance Code, all statute therein relates to the relationship between the bail agent and the state or the bail agent and the surety insurer (see Insurance Code Section 1800 et seq.).
When considering the transaction between the defendant and the bail agent independently, it seems reasonable that existing consumer protection laws should apply.
Consumer Legal Remedies Act. The Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), which prohibits several unfair or deceptive practices from being undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or resulting in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer, defines “services” to mean “work, labor, and services for other than a commercial or business use, including services furnished in connection with the sale or repair of goods.” (Civil Code Section 1761 (b).) The CLRA also defines “consumer” to mean “an individual who seeks or acquires, by purchase or lease, any goods or services for personal, family, or household purposes.” (Civil Code Section 1761 (d).) Under these definitions, it seems reasonable to consider the defendant, in the context of securing bail bond or immigration bond through a bail bond agency to be a consumer. In this case, the “work, labor, and services” would be the arrangement by the bail bond agent for the release of the defendant from pretrial detention into their custody, and the customer would be whoever acquires these services from the bail bond agent in exchange for paying the “premium” of a percentage of the full bail amount.
Opponents of the bill contend that there is not precedent to support the application of the CLRA to bail and immigration bonds. While this is true, the question has not been adjudicated either in favor or against such application. The bill’s opponents instead rely on case law indicating that the CLRA is not applicable to insurance transactions. A joint opposition letter from the Surety & Fidelity Association of America and the American Property Casualty Insurance Association argues:
The four sections of the Civil Code effected [sic] by SB318 have never been applied and should not be applied to insurance products, including bail bonds or immigration bonds. Insurance products have been legally defined outside the scope of a “good” or a “service” as the Consumer Legal Remedies Act uses those terms. [Fairbanks v. Sup.Ct. (Farmers New World Life Ins. Co.) (2009) 46 C4th 56, 60-61, 92 CR3d 279, 281-282 concluded life insurance is neither a “good’ nor a “service”]. The California Supreme Court has found that all types of insurance are outside of the scope of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act. [Civil Service Employees Ins. Co. v. Sup.Ct. (Schlichting) (1978) 22 C3d 362, 376, 149 CR 360, 368 (noting that Consumer Legal Remedies Act did not apply to insurer because “insurance is technically neither a ‘good’ nor a ‘service’ within the meaning of” the Consumer Remedies Act)]. The California federal courts have followed the California Supreme Court precedent concluding that insurance should not be considered “goods” or “services” under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act [Campion v. Old Republic Home Protection Co., Inc. (SD CA 2012) 861 F.Supp.2d 1139, 1144-1145]
However, as previously discussed, it does not seem that the specific transaction wherein the defendant secures bail or immigration bond through a bail bond agent to arrange their release can be appropriately construed as insurance, making the application of the case law provided seemingly inappropriate. While it seems based on these arguments that arrangements between bail bond agents and the court or arrangements between bail bond agents and surety insurers should not be subject to the CLRA, the same likely cannot be said for arrangements between bail bond agents and defendants or their representatives. Furthermore, the CLRA expressly provides that it is to be “liberally construed and applied to promote its underlying purposes, which are to protect consumers against unfair and deceptive business practices and to provide efficient and economical procedures to secure such protection.” (Civil Code Section 1760.) Based on this constructive guidance, and in the absence of case law to the contrary, it seems appropriate to apply the CLRA to the securing of bail or immigration bond from an agent, as it constitutes the provision of a service to a consumer under the definitions provided by the CLRA. This bill specifically clarifies the applicability of CLRA protections to “the securing or financing of a bail bond…or an immigration bond…for the release of a detained individual,” limiting its application to only that component of the bail bonding process. It thus does not appear unreasonable to contend that the CLRA applies to this transaction under existing law.
Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act. Likewise, the applicability of the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (RFDCPA) is limited to specific circumstances relating to the financing of bail and immigration bonds. Because many defendants lack the financial resources to cover the cost of the “premiums” demanded by bail agents but are nonetheless eager to be released from incarceration, defendants will often enter into payment plans to cover the costs owed for the services of the bail bond agency. These payment plans consist of a down payment of significantly less than the cost of the “premium,” followed by regular payments until the value of the “premium” is reached, which may result in efforts by the bail bond agency to collect money owed in the event of default. Such circumstances may also arise in the event the defendant fails to show up for court, in which case the full bail amount must be surrendered to the bail bond agency.
Determining applicability of the RFDCPA to bail and immigration bond financing and collection of breach of contract penalties is particularly important, as the bulk of abuse that defendants face in the period after their release occurs in the form of harassing tactics in attempts to collect payments. As summarized by Mel Gonzalez in a law review discussing the subject:
The harassment may come in the form of repeated phone calls by the agent at odd hours of the day. Or it may come in the form of bail agents calling friends, family members, and employers; engaging with the consumers via the internet; or perhaps disclosing sensitive information. The nature of the communication by bail agents to their consumers may border on abuse, including the use of obscene language and threats. Agents may also fail to disclose who they are, refuse to respect the consumer’s privacy, or his requests for particular forms of communication. Some agents may lie about the kind of authority they have, again relying on consumer’ lack of information and unique vulnerability. These kinds of conduct are specifically prohibited by the [RFDCPA] and would form the legal basis for plaintiffs brining suit against abusive bail companies. (Gonzalez, Consumer Protection for Criminal Defendants, supra at p.1418.)
The RFDCPA prohibits any “debt collector” from collecting or attempting to collect “consumer debt” by means of several unseemly practices including harassment, use of obscene or profane language, and threats to defame the debtor. (Civil Code Sections 1788.10-1788.17.) The RFDCPA defines “debt collector” to mean “any person who…on behalf of himself or herself or others, engages in…the collection of consumer debts,” (Civil Code Section 1788.2 (c)), and defines “consumer debt” and “consumer credit” to mean “money, property or their equivalent, due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person by reason of a consumer credit transaction” in which “property, services or money is acquired on credit…primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.” (Civil Code Section 1788.2 (e) - (f).) The California Court of Appeals clarified this definition, providing that “there is a consumer credit transaction when the consumer acquires something without paying for it.” (Gouskos v. Aptos Vill. Garage, Inc., (2001)94 Cal. App. 4th 754, 759.)
When a defendant enters into a payment plan to secure the services of the bail bond agency to arrange the defendant’s release and oversee custody, the defendant is acquiring some aspect of those services without paying, as the full cost of those services has not yet been provided. The definitions provided by the RFDCPA thus seem to apply to the financing of bail bond services and the collection of debts owed pursuant to those arrangements. The application of the RFDCPA to the collection of debts associated with the defendant’s failure to appear in court, though more complicated, nonetheless seems similarly appropriate. Upon the defendant’s failure to appear in court, the bail bond agency (via the underwriting surety) incurs the operational cost of forfeiting the full cost of the bond to the court. While the terms and conditions of bail bond agency contracts vary between agencies, they almost invariably require the defendant to reimburse the bail amount in full in the event it must be forfeited by the agency. Under these circumstances, the bail bond agency is paying out bond to satisfy their agreement with the court, secured on behalf of the defendant, that must be paid back as an incurred business expense relating to the agreement with that defendant. Consequently, the collection of such reimbursement appears to constitute debt collection under the definitions provided by the RFDCPA, and the underlying contract would likely be considered one specifying terms of a consumer credit transaction.
While no case law with precedential value in California has determined whether RFDCPA applies to these circumstances, instructive cases from Texas and Louisiana seem to indicate that a court would likely find that the RFDCPA likely extends to collection of debts, i.e. money owed pursuant to payment plans or pursuant to costs incurred by the bail agency through default on bond, by bail bond agencies. In Monroe v. Frank (936 S.W.2d 654 (1996)), the Fifth District Court of Appeals of Texas held that under the Texas Debt Collection Practices Act (TEX. REV. CIV. STAT. ANN. Art. 5069-11.01-11.12), Texas’s analogue to the RFDCPA, a bail bond agency was a debt collector under that law’s definition and was thus subject to its provisions, because the definition did not require debt collection to be the “principal business” of a debt collector nor did it require the debt collector to be collecting debts on behalf of another party. (Monroe v. Frank, supra at pp.660-661.) While the specific definition of “debt collector” differs between the Texas Debt Collection Practices Act and the RFDCPA, the definition of debt collector in the RFDCPA likewise neither requires that debt collection is the principal business of the person nor does it require that the person is not collecting debts on its own behalf, suggesting that consideration of a bail bond agency as a debt collector, provided the definition is not exclusive of its practices, may be appropriate. (Civil Code Section 1788.2 (c).)
In Louisiana, a federal case relating to the practices by a bail bond agency to collect expenses due to the failure of the defendant to appear in court determined that under the federal analogue of the RFDCPA, the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act, the expenses owed similarly constitute “debt.” (Barlow v. Safety Nat’l Cas. Corp. (2012) 856 F. Supp. 2d 828.) The federal Act defines “debt” to mean “any obligation of a consumer to pay money arising out of a transaction in which the money, property, insurance, or services which are the subject of the transaction are primarily for personal, family, or household purposes, whether or not such obligation has been reduced to judgment.” (15 U.S.C. Section 1692a (5).) The federal Act expressly announces its purpose as follows:
It is the purpose of this subchapter to eliminate abusive debt collection practices by debt collectors, to insure that those debt collectors who refrain from using abusive debt collection practices are not competitively disadvantaged, and to promote consistent State action to protect consumers against debt collection abuses. (15 U.S.C. Section 1692 (e).)
The court in Barlow held that indemnity owed to the bail bond agency on behalf of a defendant who did not appear in court constituted a “debt” under the Act and was thus subject to its provisions for debtor protection, especially in light of the intent of the law. The court summarized its decision on this matter as follows:
As the Eleventh Circuit has succinctly noted, the [Fair Debt Collection Practices Act] applies to payment obligations of a (1) consumer arising out of a (2) transaction in which the money, property, insurance, or services at issue are (3) primarily for personal, family, or household purposes. (See Oppenheim v. I.C. System, 627 F.3d 833 (11th Cir. 2010).) Here, Barlow entered into a consensual transaction for a bail bond insurance for her son: she paid AAA Bail Services, Inc. $475.00 for a bail premium to secure her son's release from jail. In connection with posting the bond, and as collateral, Barlow executed a promissory note for $3,500.00 and an indemnity agreement. In exchange, her son was released; when he failed to appear for his scheduled court date, the bond was forfeited, and Barlow became obligated to pay. Accordingly, Barlow's obligation to pay "aris[es] out of a transaction in which the...insurance or services which are the subject of the transaction are primarily for personal, family...purposes..." and therefore constitutes a "debt" within the meaning of ([15 U.S.C.] Section 1692a (5).) (Barlow v. Safety Nat’l Cas. Corp, supra at p.835.)
Again, while the federal Act is not identical to the RFDCPA, the intent of the law is the same as the RFDCPA, and the definition of “debt” under that law is similar to that of the RFDCPA. The application of federal prohibitions against unseemly debt collection practices act to the collection of debts owed due to indemnity for a defendant’s failure to appear in court thus has some instructive support in existing case law, suggesting the same would likely hold true for the RFDCPA.
Contract translation and consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code must be limited to the financing of bail and immigration bonds to be consistent with existing law. Section 1632 of the Civil Code requires that any person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean in the course of entering into a contract or agreement deliver to the other party to the contract or agreement a translation of the document in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated prior to the execution of the agreement. (Civil Code Section 1632.) The provisions detailing this requirement define a “contract” or “agreement” to mean “the document creating the rights and obligations of the parties” including “any subsequent document making substantial changes in the rights and obligations of the partieis.” (Civil Code Section 1632 (g).) While a contract to secure or finance a bail or immigration bond would fall under this definition, the definition goes on to specify the certain types of contracts or agreements to which these provisions apply, including contracts or agreements relating to the purchase or lease of a motor vehicle, leases, subleases, and other rental contracts or agreements, reverse mortgages, contracts or agreements to obtain legal services, foreclosure consulting contracts, and “loans or extensions of credit secured other than by real property, or unsecured, for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.” (Civil Code Section 1632 (b) (1)-(7).)
The financing of bail or immigration bond for the purpose of arranging release from incarceration can, as previously discussed, be reasonably construed to be an extension of credit, and therefore subject to this provision under existing law. However, the same likely cannot be said for the securing of bail or immigration bonds, which does not fall under any of the categories of contracts or agreements to which this provision applies.
Author’s amendments. In order to maintain consistency with existing law, as this bill declares, the author has agreed to remove the inclusion of contracts or agreements “securing” bail or immigration bond, and instead limit the clarification of existing law to contracts for financing bail or immigration bond. The author has also agreed to strike the consideration of bail and immigration bond contracts as generally applicable under the definition of “contract or agreement,” and to instead specify that this provision is applicable to financing contracts for bail and immigration bonds based on their status as extensions of credit. The proposed amendment is as follows:
(2) (A) A loan or extension of credit secured other than by real property, or unsecured, for use primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.
(B) A “loan or extension of credit,” as described in this paragraph, includes, but is not limited to, a contract or agreement to finance a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of a detained individual. For purposes of this subdivision, “bail bond” shall have the same meaning as in Section 1800.4 of the Insurance Code, and “immigration bond” means a bond executed pursuant to Section 103.6 of Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations. This subparagraph is declaratory of existing law.
Similarly, the consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code define a “consumer credit contract” to mean “any of the following obligations to pay money on a deferred payment basis, where the money, property, services or other consideration which is the subject matter of the contract is primarily for personal, family, or household purposes.” (Civil Code Section 1799.90 (a).) The subsection specifies application to retail installment contracts, retail installment accounts, conditional sales contracts, lease contracts, and “loans or extensions of credit secured by other than real property, or unsecured, for use primarily for personal, family or household purposes.” (Ibid.) Consequently, like the contract translation provisions, existing law could be reasonably applied to contracts for financing bail or immigration bonds, but probably would not apply to contracts securing such bond.
For the same reasons as discussed for the previous amendment, the author has agreed to amend the bill to apply the consumer credit contract provisions of the Civil Code only to contracts for financing, rather than for financing or securing, bail or immigration bonds. The author has also similarly agreed to strike the consideration of bail and immigration bond contracts as generally applicable under the definition of “consumer credit contracts,” and to instead specify that these provisions are applicable to financing contracts for bail and immigration bonds based on their status as extensions of credit. The proposed amendment is as follows:
(D) (i) Loans or extensions of credit secured by other than real property, or unsecured, for use primarily for personal, family or household purposes.
(ii) “Loans or extensions of credit,” as described in this subparagraph, includes, but is not limited to, an agreement or contract between an individual and another party to finance a bail bond, as defined in Section 1800.4 of the Insurance Code, or an immigration bond pursuant to Section 103.8 of Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations, for the release of an individual from detention. This subdivision is declaratory of existing law.
It is within the authority of the Legislature to reasonably clarify the intent of legislation retrospectively. All letters of opposition received on this bill specify the retroactivity of this bill as a preeminent concern. They argue that because the bill imposes meaning on statute that did not previously exist, the bill is unconstitutional under Article I, Section 9 of the California Constitution, which prohibits ex post facto laws and laws impairing the obligation of contracts. According to the Golden State Bail Agents Association:
SB 318 seeks to retroactively apply consumer protection statutes to bail contracts. This would invalidate the contracts and create civil liability for contracts that were legal at the time they were entered into. Chaos would ensue in the criminal justice system as it would cause bail agencies to arrest and surrender all persons out on bond because the collateral and indemnity contracts securing those bonds would now be invalid.
The courts of this state have routinely rejected legislative declarations that statutory amendments were mere clarifications of existing law, in order to find that the amendments in fact affected substantive changes to the law, which then could not apply retroactively. See, e.g., Protect our Benefits v. City and County of San Francisco (2015) 235 Cal.App.4th 619, 636-37 (legislative declaration that law is clarification of voters’ intent rather than change to law may be rebutted and is not conclusive or binding on court).
This argument seems recursive, in that in order for the provisions of this bill to retroactively impose new laws, one must accept as a pretense that the provisions of the bill are not existing law. The argument that statutory amendments that are “mere clarifications of existing law” could not be applied retroactively if the affected substantive changes to the law appears to misapply the decision in the case cited, Protect our Benefits v. City and County of San Francisco, supra. In that case, San Francisco implemented an initiative amendment that conditioned payment of a supplemental cost of living allowance for retired city employees on the retirement fund being fully funded. While the court in Protect our Benefits v. SF ultimately held that the assertion the amendment was a clarification of existing law was not valid due to the obvious substantive change it imposed, it also indicated that clarifications of existing law by the Legislature are not without meaning. The decision held:
Was the 2011 amendment simply a clarification of the 2008 initiative measure? The task of answering that question, and with interpreting legislation in general, rests with the courts, not the legislative branch of government. (McClung v. Employment Development Dept. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 467, 472 [20 Cal. Rptr. 3d 428, 99 P.3d 1015].) When courts have not yet finally and conclusively interpreted a provision, “a declaration of a later Legislature as to what an earlier Legislature intended is entitled to consideration” and may be properly examined together with other factors to determine the legislative intent existing when the prior act was passed. (Id. at p. 473; see Western Security Bank v. Superior Court (1997) 15 Cal.4th 232, 244 [62 Cal. Rptr. 2d 243, 933 P.2d 507]; Eu v. Chacon(1976) 16 Cal.3d 465, 470 [128 Cal. Rptr. 1, 546 P.2d 289].) (Protect our Benefits v. City and County of San Francisco, supra, at pp.636-637.)
Because no case law with precedent value in California has adjudicated the application of these consumer protections to transactions for securing and financing bail or immigration bonds for the release of a defendant, a later Legislature may therefore declare as to the intent of an earlier Legislature, and that declaration is entitled to consideration in cases for which this application is at issue. As Protect our Benefits v. SF points out, however, the interpretation of legislation in general is a judicial function rather than a legislative one. Consequently, the ultimate decision as to whether the retrospective declaration of Legislative intent is consistent with the proper interpretation of that law rests with the courts. The decision in Protect our Benefits v. SF qualifies the authority for the Legislature to retrospectively clarify intent, stating that “such a declaration…’is neither binding nor conclusive.’” (Id. at p.637, quoting McClung v. Employment Development Dept. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 467, 473.)
It is self-evident that the Legislature cannot dramatically alter existing law through a “clarification of intent,” as was reiterated by Protect our Benefits v. SF:
A declaration that a statutory amendment merely clarified the law ‘cannot be given an obviously absurd effect, and the court cannot accept the Legislative statement that an unmistakable change in the statute is nothing more than a clarification and restatement of its original terms. [Citation.] Even if we accept the City's assertion that the “clarification” language of section A8.526-3(d) is entitled to a presumption of validity [Citation], that presumption has been rebutted in this case. (Ibid.)
Based on arguments articulated previously, even if the possibility exists that this is a change in existing law, it is not “obviously” or “unmistakably” so, and this bill would be similarly entitled to a presumption of validity. (See, e.g., Tobe v. City of Santa Ana, supra.) Protect our Benefits v. SF suggests that the substantive provisions of this bill could be applied proactively, and their retroactive application would not be binding, but nonetheless would be available for judicial consideration in ongoing litigation or future litigation related to the bill. It thus seems unlikely that the passage of this bill would result in “chaos…in the criminal justice system” as anticipated by its opponents.
There is little support for claims suggesting Equal Protection or federal preemption issues with this bill. Opponents of the bill raised the possibility that the application of California’s consumer protection laws to the bail and immigration bond industry could violate the right to equal protection under the law guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment of the United States Constitution. (U.S. Const., art. I, sec. 7.) A law firm representing “several surety companies that write bail and immigration bonds” argues:
The proposed legislation violates equal protection clauses of the United States and California Constitutions. It singles out bail and immigration bonds for compliance with the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, while leaving out all other insurance companies and insurance transactions dealing with consumers.
This claim seems spurious for several reasons. First, as was previously discussed, while there are components of the bail or immigration bond process that can be considered insurance, justifying regulation under the Insurance Code, the transaction between the consumer and the bail bond agent is not one relating to the provision of insurance, but rather to the provision of a service. Consequently, that the CLRA does not apply to other types of insurance does not seem relevant here, since the transaction in question is categorically distinct.
Even if we accepted that this transaction is one of insurance, the differential application of laws to distinct types of insurance does not violate the constitutional guarantee of equal protection, or else we would not have, e.g., distinct laws governing auto insurance and health insurance. Finally, if we accept as true that 1) the defendant-bail bond agent transaction is one of insurance and 2) that an equal protection claim could be raised on the grounds that different types of insurance are being treated differently, there still would be no equal protection issue, given that neither “industry” nor “variety of insurance” is a protected class. The standard for determining the constitutionality of this law would thus be determined on a “rational basis” standard, wherein the disparate treatment of subclasses must be justifiable by a rational basis. The rational basis for this law, namely to provide protections for vulnerable defendants contracting with bail and immigration bond agents, is fairly clear, and because the bail and immigration bonding process is unique from, say, repairing a car or providing for healthcare, disparate treatment appears to be completely appropriate.
The opponents of the bill also raise a concern that, due to the inclusion of securing or financing immigration bonds in the protections discussed above, the proposed legislation “impermissibly intrudes on the exclusive jurisdiction of the Federal government to regulate immigration.” However, the bill does not deal in any way with immigration itself, but rather with the agencies that provide the service of arranging release of detained immigrants. The transaction for securing and financing these services is entirely independent of the process of immigration, with the exception of the fact that release is arranged with an immigration court rather than another type of court. If it were true that the jurisdiction of the court with which the agreement for release were arranged dictated the ability to regulate those transactions, bail bond agents licensed by California would not be able to post bond for defendants detained in federal criminal courts. Therefore, this argument also appears to be without merit.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is co-sponsored by the California Low-Income Consumer Coalition and the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area, and is supported by a coalition of legal aid, civil liberties, human rights, and social justice organizations including the American Civil Liberties Union, the Anti-Recidivism Coalition, and the Ella Baker Center for Human Rights. Supporters contend that though existing consumer protection laws should, under existing law, apply to the securing and financing of bail and immigration bond in order to arrange release from detention, bail and immigration bond agents frequently behave as though they do not, necessitating clarification that they are included in obligations and protections provided. Supporters contend that in the bail and immigration bond industry, advertising is often misleading, harassment is rampant, and contracts are often produced in bad faith.
The California Low-Income Consumer Coalition, a coalition of 13 legal aid providers across California, argues:
SB 318 would restate and clarify existing law to help protect consumers from unfair and deceptive conduct that bail and immigration bond companies across California routinely engage in. These companies too frequently operate as if the consumer protection laws that apply to virtually all other businesses in the state do not apply to them. They harass and humiliate the families of detained individuals, deceive those families about their terms of service, and fail to disclose key information about the credit they extend. When confronted with the fact that they are violating state consumer protection laws like the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act or the Consumer Legal Remedies Act, bail and immigration band companies, after overcoming their surprise that someone has challenged their conduct, attempt to claim that California’s fundamental consumer protection laws simply do not apply to them. That claim is specious, and this bill will make sure that courts know that existing California law does indeed apply to these companies.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by law firms and organizations representing bail bond agencies and surety insurers, who argue that existing law does not, in fact, provide for the application of consumer protections to transactions between defendants and bail bond agencies, primarily because these transactions fall under the scope of insurance. They thus argue that, because existing law does not already include provisions of this bill, the bill is unlawfully enacting new law retroactively.
A coalition letter submitted by the Surety & Fidelity Association of America and the American Property Casualty Insurance Association argues:
The bill states that it intends to clarify that bail and immigration bonds are subject to the consumer protection laws under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act and the Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and that these laws have always applied to these bonds. However, these bonds have never been regulated in this manner and this bill would significantly change the regulatory regime governing bail and immigration bonds. Senate Bill 318 could result in significant unintended consequences that would adversely affect jails, courts, and accused defendants now out on bail. If the bill is applied retroactively and the indemnity agreements and premium payment plans are deemed void, then many bondsmen will likely exercise their right to immediately return the accused to jail. This would cause significant strain on courts and jails, as well as to the accused and their family.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
SUPPORT
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition (co-sponsor)
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (co-sponsor)
#CUT50
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Asian Law Alliance
Bet Tzedek Legal Services (Los Angeles)
California United for a Responsible Budget (CURB)
Centro Legal de La Raza
Consumers for Auto Reliability & Safety
The Dream Corps
East Bay Community Law Center
Elder Law & Advocacy (San Diego)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
The Justice & Diversity Center (San Francisco)
JusticeLA
Law Foundation of Silicon Valley
Legal Aid Society of San Bernardino
Public Counsel (Los Angeles)
Public Law Center of Orange County
Re:store Justice
Riverside Legal Aid
Riverside Temple Beth El
Santa Clara University, Alexander Community Law Center
UC Irvine Consumer Law Clinic
Watsonville Law Center
OPPOSITION
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
The Surety & Fidelity Association of America
Golden State Bail Agents Association, Inc.
Roxborough, Pomerance, Nye & Adreani, LLP
Analysis Prepared by: Landon Klein / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 318 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 318
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/30/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Allen, Caballero, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond
SOURCE: Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and Consumer Credit Contract notice provisions apply to bail bond and immigration bonds.
Existing law:
- Makes, under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, unlawful certain acts identified as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by a person in a transaction for the sale or lease of goods or services to a consumer, and defines “services” and “consumer” for purposes of those provisions. (Civ. Code § 1761.)
- Requires a person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean, before entering into specified contracts or agreements, to deliver to the other party a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated. (Civ. Code § 1632.)
- Prohibits, pursuant to the Rosenthal Debt Collection Practices Act, debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts. (Civ. Code § 1788.2.)
- Requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract, and defines “consumer credit contract” for those purposes. (Civ. Code § 1799.90 through §1799.104)
This bill:
- Defines “bail bond” and “immigration bond” for purposes of this bill.
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the for-profit money bail system.
- Makes it clear that provisions in existing law that require a person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean, before entering into specified contracts or agreements, to deliver to the other party a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated, are applicable to a contract or agreement to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of a detained individual.
- Makes clear that “services” under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act includes the securing or financing of a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of an individual from detention and defines “consumer” to include an individual who, for the purpose of their release or another person’s release from detention, seeks or acquires services to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
- Includes money owing from a transaction for services to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of a detained individual within the definition of “consumer debt” for purposes of the Rosenthal Debt Collection Practices Act, which is an act that prohibits debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts.
- Makes clear that an agreement or contract between an individual and another party to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of an individual from detention is included in the definition of “consumer credit contract” for purposes of existing law that requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract.
Background
Under California law there are several statutes that are designed to protect consumers. This includes statutes designed to ensure that a company that negotiates a contract in a language other than English actually provides the consumer with a copy of the contract in the language in which the transaction was negotiated. The author points the Senate Judiciary Committee to examples of where immigration bond companies and bail bond companies do not follow the consumer protection laws on the books and then argue in court that these laws do not apply to them. This bill does not change existing law. This bill simply restates existing law that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and Consumer Credit Contract notice provisions apply to bail bond and immigration bonds. This bill is sponsored by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area and is supported by several groups that fight for equity for people of color, immigrants, and consumers. There is no known opposition to the bill.
Comments
The author writes:
The commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate. To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives – while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake.
SB 318 clarifies existing definitions on California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
In support, the Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety writes:
People who are incarcerated have their liberty at stake, tend to be low-income, and experience difficulty navigating our justice system – especially when presented with documents in a language that is foreign to them. Thus, it is particularly important to ensure that they are at least provided crucial documents in a language they have the opportunity to read and understand. Otherwise, the contracts are nothing more than an open invitation for “gotcha” tactics that prey on vulnerable people.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Insurance reports costs of $29,000 in FY 2019-20, $126,000 in FY 2020-21, and minimal ongoing costs for its legal department to review all bail contracts for accuracy of translation. (Various funds*)
- Unknown workload cost pressures to the courts to the extent that providing that bail and immigration bonds are subject to the specified consumer protection provisions leads to additional enforcement actions and/or requests for injunctive relief. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Governor's proposed 2019-20 Budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
*General Fund and Insurance Fund
**Trial Court Trust Fund
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (source)
#cut50
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Asian Law Alliance
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
East Bay Community Law Center
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
Initiate Justice
JusticeLA
Re:Store Justice
Riverside Temple Beth El
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
None received
Prepared by: Margie Estrada / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/20/19 13:34:19
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 318 (Hertzberg) - Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond
Version: March 25, 2019 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Bill Summary:
SB 318 would provide that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and consumer credit contract notice provisions, and specified contract translation provisions apply to bail bonds and immigration bonds.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Insurance reports costs of $29,000 in FY 2019-20, $126,000 in FY 2020-21, and minimal ongoing costs for its legal department to review all bail contracts for accuracy of translation. (Various funds*)
- Unknown workload cost pressures to the courts to the extent that providing that bail and immigration bonds are subject to the specified consumer protection provisions leads to additional enforcement actions and/or requests for injunctive relief. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the governor's proposed 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
*General Fund and Insurance Fund
**Trial Court Trust Fund
Author Amendments:
Provide that the bill is declaratory of existing law.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 318 (Hertzberg) - Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond
Version: March 25, 2019 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 318 would provide that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and consumer credit contract notice provisions, and specified contract translation provisions apply to bail bonds and immigration bonds.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Insurance reports costs of $29,000 in FY 2019-20, $126,000 in FY 2020-21, and minimal ongoing costs for its legal department to review all bail contracts for accuracy of translation. (Various funds*)
- Unknown workload cost pressures to the courts to the extent that providing that bail and immigration bonds are subject to the specified consumer protection provisions leads to additional enforcement actions and/or requests for injunctive relief. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the governor's proposed 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
*General Fund and Insurance Fund
**Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
The Consumers Legal Remedies Act makes unlawful certain acts identified as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by a person in a transaction for the sale or lease of goods or services to a consumer. For the purposes of this act, “services” is defined as work, labor, and services for other than a commercial or business use, including services furnished in connection with the sale or repair of goods. Additional, “consumer” for purposes of the act is defined as an individual who seeks or acquires, by purchase or lease, any goods or services for personal, family, or household purposes. (Civ. Code, § 1761.)
The Rosenthal Fair Debt Collection Practices Act prohibits debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts. It defines “consumer debt” and “consumer credit” for purposes of that act as money, property or their equivalent, due or owing or alleged to be due or owing from a natural person by reason of a consumer credit transaction. (Civ. Code, § 1788.2.)
Additionally, existing law requires a person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean, before entering into specified contracts or agreements, to deliver to the other party a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated. (Civ. Code, § 1632.)
Every bail licensee shall promptly file with the Insurance Commissioner a copy, or a reference to copies already filed and which the licensee will use, of all forms or documents which the licensee intends to use regularly or frequently in connection with bail transactions. These include the following:
- The document to be delivered to the arrestee or other person containing the information required by Insurance Code section 2083.
- The form of any receipt for or agreement relating to collateral used pursuant to Insurance Code section 2083, subdivision (m).
- The document to be delivered to the arrestee or other person containing the information required by Insurance Code section 2083.1.
- The form of guarantor's agreement referred to in Insurance Code section 2084.
- The form of original communication referred to in Insurance Code section 2097, subdivision (a).
- The form of original application referred to in Insurance Code section 2097, subdivision (b)
- Any other form or document. (Cal. Code Regs., tit. 10, §2095, subd. (k).)
Proposed Law:
This bill would provide that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, consumer credit contact notice provisions, and specified contract translation provisions are applicable to bail bonds and immigration bonds for the release of a detained individual.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 318 (Author:Hertzberg)
Version: March 25, 2019
Hearing Date: April 30, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: MEC
SUBJECT
Consumer protections: contracts and agreements to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond
DIGEST
This bill clarifies that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and Consumer Credit Contact notice provisions apply to bail bond and immigration bonds.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under California law there are several statutes that are designed to protect consumers. This includes statutes designed to ensure that a company that negotiates a contract in a language other than English actually provides the consumer with a copy of the contract in the language in which the transaction was negotiated. The author points the Committee to examples of where immigration bond companies and bail bond companies do not follow the consumer protection laws on the books and then argue in court that these laws do not apply to them. This bill does not change existing law. This bill simply restates existing law that the California Consumer Legal Remedies Act, Contract Translation Act, Rosenthal Fair Debt Collections Practices Act, and Consumer Credit Contact notice provisions apply to bail bond and immigration bonds. This bill is sponsored by the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area and is supported by several groups that fight for equity for people of color, immigrants, and consumers. There is no known opposition to the bill.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- The Consumers Legal Remedies Act, makes unlawful certain acts identified as unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by a person in a transaction for the sale or lease of goods or services to a consumer, and defines “services” and “consumer” for purposes of those provisions. (Civ. Code § 1761.)
- Requires a person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean, before entering into specified contracts or agreements, to deliver to the other party a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated. (Civ. Code § 1632.)
- The Rosenthal Debt Collection Practices Act prohibits debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts. (Civ. Code § 1788.2.)
- Requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract, and defines “consumer credit contract” for those purposes. (Civ. Code § 1799.90 through §1799.104)
This bill:
- Defines “bail bond” and “immigration bond” for purposes of this bill.
- Makes findings and declarations regarding the for-profit money bail system.
- Makes it clear that provisions in existing law that require a person engaged in a trade or business who negotiates primarily in Spanish, Chinese, Tagalog, Vietnamese, or Korean, before entering into specified contracts or agreements, to deliver to the other party a translation of the contract or agreement in the language in which the contract or agreement was negotiated, are applicable to a contract or agreement to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of a detained individual.
- Makes clear that “services” under the Consumers Legal Remedies Act includes the financing or securing of a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of an individual from detention and defines “consumer” to include an individual who, for the purpose of their release or another person’s release from detention, seeks or acquires services to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond.
- Includes money owing from a transaction for services to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of a detained individual within the definitions of “consumer debt” and “consumer credit” for purposes of the Rosenthal Debt Collection Practices Act, which is an act that prohibits debt collectors from engaging in unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the collection of consumer debts.
- Makes clear that an agreement or contract between an individual and another party to finance or secure a bail bond or immigration bond for the release of an individual from detention is included in the definition of “consumer credit contract” for purposes of existing law that requires a creditor to deliver to a person a specified notice before the person is obligated on a consumer credit contract.
COMMENTS
- Impetus for the bill
According to the author:
The commercial bail and immigration bond industry profiteers off low-income Californians by taking advantage of the failures and financial complexity of the money bail system. They currently operate as if existing consumer protection laws do not apply to them despite the fact that they routinely engage in activities that these laws aim to regulate. To secure a commercial bail bond or immigration bond company’s services, consumers are required to sign legally complex, confusing, and often unfair contracts that are difficult to understand. Further, consumers are required to sign these contracts during some of the most stressful moments of their lives – while their own or a loved one’s liberty is at stake.
SB 318 clarifies existing definitions on California’s consumer financial protection statutes to ensure that these businesses, and the products they offer, can no longer evade meaningful regulation.
2. Taking advantage of consumers
The American Civil Liberties Union of California, in support of this bill, explains that many “consumers cannot afford to pay the premiums up front, and when faced with the imminent loss of liberty, they enter into financing agreements to pay them off over time. The debt from financed bail bond contracts often follows consumers for years after the underlying case has been resolved in the courts, resulting in predatory debt collection practices and significant damage to consumer credit reports.” The author and supporters of the bill note that immigration bond companies and commercial bail bond companies operate as if consumer protection laws do not apply to them even though they engage in the activities that the consumer protection laws regulate.[1]
Under California law there are several statutes that are designed to protect consumers. This includes statutes designed to ensure that a company that negotiates a contract in a language other than English actually provides the consumer with a copy of the contract in the language in which the transaction was negotiated. The author points the Committee to examples of where immigration bond companies and bail bond companies do not follow the consumer protection laws on the books and then argue in court that these laws do not apply to them. This bill should not be necessary, as it is a restatement of existing law. However, writing into the codes that immigration bonds and bail bonds are covered within these consumer protection laws will help stop the cash bail industry bad-actors from arguing that the statutes do not apply to them.
The Committee received a letter from “an individual and consumer who has directly suffered as a result of the bail bond industry’s current practices.” She explained that through “free legal assistance from the Bail Clinic at Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area” she was able to resolve the matter. She noted that the Lawyer’s Committee identified violations of consumer protection law. The individual also notes the following:
As it stands, bail and immigration bond companies operate as if current consumer protection laws do not apply to them. This bill will make clear that these laws do apply to them and will help protect consumers like me from the egregious and predatory practices these businesses use.
In support, the Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety writes:
People who are incarcerated have their liberty at stake, tend to be low-income, and experience difficulty navigating our justice system – especially when presented with documents in a language that is foreign to them. Thus, it is particularly important to ensure that they are at least provided crucial documents in a language they have the opportunity to read and understand. Otherwise, the contracts are nothing more than an open invitation for “gotcha” tactics that prey on vulnerable people.
SUPPORT
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area (Sponsor)
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Asian Law Alliance
Californians United for a Responsible Budget
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
East Bay Community Law Center
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Homeboy Industries
Initiate Justice
JusticeLA
Re:Store Justice
Riverside Temple Beth El
Evelin Urbina Diaz, an individual
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation: None known
**************
See UCLA School of Law Criminal Justice Reform Clinic, The Devil in the Details: Bail Bond Contracts in California (May 2017), available at https://static.prisonpolicy.org/scans/UCLA_Devil%20_in_the_Details.pdf (as of 4/26/19). ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):