SB 325: Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-01
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 9, 2019 | July 9 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & P. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jun 13, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | April 29 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 10). |
| Mar 29, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Business and Professions] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB325 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 325
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
NOTE: This bill is double referred and passed the Assembly Committee on Health on June 25, 2019 on a 15-0 vote.
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) on or before July 1, 2020, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors and requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the procedures for the creation of any state board or category of licensed professional by the Legislature. (Government Code (GOV) §§ 9148-9148.8)
- Requires, prior to consideration by the Legislature of legislation creating a new state board or legislation creating a new category of licensed professional, a plan for the establishment and operation of the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional to be developed by the author or sponsor of the legislation. (GOV § 9148.4)
- Requires a plan for the creation of a new board or new category of licensed professional, to include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
- A description of the problem that the creation of the specific state board or new category of licensed professional would address, including the specific evidence of need for the state to address the problem. (GOV § 9148.4(a))
- The reasons why this proposed state board or new category of licensed professional was selected to address this problem, including the full range of alternatives considered and the reason why each of these alternatives was not selected. Alternatives that shall be considered include, but are not limited to, the following:
- No action taken to establish a state board or create a new category of licensed professional. (GOV § 9148.4(b)(1))
- The use of a current state board or agency or the existence of a current category of licensed professional to address the problem, including any necessary changes to the mandate or composition of the existing state board or agency or current category of licensed professional. (GOV § 9148.4(b)(2))
- The various levels of regulation or administration available to address the problem. (GOV § 9148.4(b)(3))
- Addressing the problem by federal or local agencies. (GOV § 9148.4(b)(4))
- The specific public benefit or harm that would result from the establishment of the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional, the specific manner in which the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional would achieve this benefit, and the specific standards of performance which shall be used in reviewing the subsequent operation of the board or category of licensed professional. (GOV § 9148.4(c))
- The specific source or sources of revenue and funding to be utilized by the proposed state board or new category of licensed professional in achieving its mandate. (GOV § 9148.4(d))
- The necessary data and other information required in this section shall be provided to the Legislature with the initial legislation and forwarded to the policy committees in which the bill will be heard. (GOV § 9148.4(e))
- Establishes the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency, and specifies that the is comprised of various licensing boards and other entities established for the purpose of ensuring that those private businesses and professions deemed to engage in activities which have potential impact upon the public health, safety, and welfare are adequately regulated in order to protect the people of California. (Business and Professions Code §§ 100-472.5)
- Requires Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to license residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities (RTFs) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. (Health and Safety Code (HSC) §11834.01-11834.50)
- Requires RTF licensees to provide at least one of the following: recovery, treatment, or detoxification services (HSC § 11834.26(a))
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations requiring records and procedures appropriate for the type of service provided, which may include: admission criteria; intake process; assessments; recovery, treatment, or detoxification planning; referral; documentation of provision of recovery, treatment, or detoxification services; discharge and continuing care planning; or indicators of recovery, treatment, or detoxification outcomes. (HSC §11834.26(b))
- Authorizes DHCS to implement a voluntary program certification procedure for alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services and to develop standards and regulations, after consultation with specified groups, for the alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services describing the minimal level of service quality required of the service providers to qualify for and obtain state certification. (HSC §11830.1)
- Grants DHCS the sole authority in state government to determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs under DHCS’s purview. (HSC §11833)
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with county alcohol and drug program administrators and other interested organizations and individuals, to develop program standards specified to each type of residential and nonresidential program to be used during its certification process. (HSC §11830.5)
- Requires substance use disorder (SUD) counselors that work in a facility licensed or certified by DHCS to be registered with or certified by a counselor certification organization (CO) recognized by DHCS. (HSC §11833)
- Prohibits a DHCS licensed or certified program, and specified individuals associated with or employed by those programs, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified. Permits DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties. (HSC §11831.6 and 11831.7)
THIS BILL:
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that:
- By July 1, 2022, all outpatient services for addiction treatment shall be provided by programs licensed by the DHCS or by individuals appropriately licensed by the DCA.
- After July 1, 2022, any offer or provision of addiction treatment services shall be provided in a licensed environment by qualified professionals.
- Requires the DCA, on or before July 1, 2020, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors and authorizes the DCA to contract with a public or private entity to conduct the review, as specified.
- Requires the DHCS, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program (outpatient substance use disorder (SUD) program) that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient SUD programs.
- Requires DHCS to include in its licensure standards for SUD programs, at a minimum, the following:
- References to the needs of youth up to 26 years of age, elderly individuals, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and nonbinary individuals, the disabled, and special populations with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those specified populations;
- Evidence-based standards that are equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- That any Drug Medi-Cal (DMC) certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s DMC Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver, to be deemed in compliance with the requirements in this bill as long as the DMC-ODS Waiver is in place and the program remains DMC certified by DHCS;
- An exemption for a provider that is employed by or provides services under a contract with a county that does not have a DMC-ODS Waiver and who would otherwise be subject to this chapter until January 1, 2023, or until the county obtains a DMC-ODS Waiver, whichever comes first;
- A prohibition against an outpatient SUD program banning the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requiring a program to keep accurate records, as specified; and
- Requiring licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Clarifies that the requirements of this bill do not constrict, limit, or affect the application of existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of licensing a program or individual practitioner.
- Permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the provisions in this bill.
- Makes other technical, and nonsubstantive changes.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee analysis of the April 11, 2019, version of this bill:
- Unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS’ Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD was $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the analysis, the number of outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services centers was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’ existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs.
- Potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands, General Fund) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Society of Addition Medicine and Shatterproof. According to the author, “Substance abuse costs our nation over $500 billion annually, but effective, evidence-based treatment helps reduce these costs. Treatment is also less expensive than common alternative outcomes, such as incarcerating addicted persons. But unscrupulous, unregulated treatment programs only serve to compound the problem. Outpatient programs do not currently require any licensing in the state of California. Today, if you wanted to open your own outpatient treatment facility, you could do so immediately – no license, training, or prior experience required. [This bill] seeks to address this disparity.”
Background. Existing law establishes a system of licensure of facilities under the DHCS, Department of Public Health, and Department of Social Services for the treatment behavioral and mental health disorders, including substance use disorder (SUD), commonly known as alcohol and drug dependency.
Alcohol and drug dependency are treatable conditions, requiring extensive treatment and customized care. As individual problems, needs, and resources vary from individual to individual, a variety of treatment strategies must also be available if the needs of citizens are to be met. The opioid epidemic and the expansion of individuals having insurance under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) has placed a growing burden on the existing SUD treatment community. Currently, California has approximately 36,000 registered or certified counselors working in more than 2,500 private and publicly funded drug and alcohol programs, ranging from residential rehabs to driving under the influence and outpatient programs.
This bill attempts to address two issues, the lack of uniform licensing of SUD treatment providers SUD treatment centers. The lack of standards of SUD treatment providers results from the fact that there are non-medical services that do not require professional licensure as a physician, psychologist, licensed marriage and family therapist, clinical social worker, licensed professional clinical counselor, or other licensed professional.
To address the first issue, this bill requires the DCA, by July 1, 2020, to review the necessity for licensure of SUD counselors, who are not currently licensed, but have voluntary certifications available that ensure competence to provide counseling for SUDs. However, there is currently no defined scope of practice for SUD counselors.
Currently DHCS delegates its authority to certify SUD counselors to three different certifying organizations to certify counselors. Each program develops its own classroom curriculum, training, supervisor, and work experience requirements meeting the department’s requirements of a minimum of 155 documented hours of formal classroom alcohol and other drug (AOD) education, a minimum of 160 documented hours of supervised AOD training and supervised on-site training by an AOD counselor who has been licensed or certified, 2,080 or more documented hours of paid or unpaid work experience providing counseling services in an AOD program, and a score of at least 70% on a written or oral examination approved by the certifying organization.
The following three National Commission for Certifying Agencies accredited organizations for the purpose of registering and certifying AOD counselors in California are:
- California Association for Alcohol and Drug Educators;
- California Association of DUI Treatment Programs Accredited Program: Certified Alcohol & Other Drug Counselor; and,
- California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals.
However, a 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes extensively examined the current process to become an SUD counselor, and noted some of the systemic flaws. California is one of only two states among the nation’s 15 largest that makes no attempt to review counselors’ criminal backgrounds. Even within California, SUD counselors are the only health-related profession not required to undergo these checks. According to the report, the ability to evade regulators represents a loophole. While the state’s three certifying organizations are required to check with their counterparts to see if a counselor has ever had their certification revoked, the regulation states this must be done only upon certification. Individuals registered to become counselors (registrants) may work for up to five years before they must become certified meaning that a counselor whose certification was previously revoked by another certifying agency could work as long as five years without prior revocations being detected.
Licensing or Certification of Programs and Facilities. RTFs licensed by DHCS, based on what is commonly referred to as the social model, provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. The Department of Public Health licenses medical model RTFs, known as chemical dependency recovery hospitals. The services provided by social model RTFs include group and individual counseling, educational sessions, and alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment planning. Social model RTFs are allowed to provide clients first aid and emergency care. RTFs can apply to DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified.
Existing law now requires DHCS to adopt American Society of Addiction Medicine treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs (SB 823 (Hill), Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018). DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities. As part of their licensing and certification functions, DHCS conducts reviews of licensed and certified programs every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute, regulations, and certification standards to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke a program’s license or certification for a violation of statute, regulations, and certification standards.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The California Society of Addition Medicine (co-sponsor) writes, “We believe that outpatient/aftercare is the critical component of SUD treatment. Yet, California has abdicated its responsibility to oversee and regulate these services. Indeed, California only provided voluntary Certification of out-patient services.”
“This abdication of State oversight has resulted in a wild west wherein there are no rules and third-party payers and family members have no idea of the kind or quality of treatment that folks suffering with SUD will receive when they enter a “program”. This situation would not be allowed to occur in the case of any other form of treatment for a chronic disease of condition.”
“In fact, this lack of accountability is largely responsible or continued violations of the ACA and provisions of the of the federal parity laws. How can you enforce a low governing medical treatment absent oversight of those providing or purporting to provide treatment?”
“Lessons learned from the lack of state oversight over Mental Health Service Act programming on the local level tell us that a thoughtful, organized, evidence-based set of standards at the state level is an absolute necessity, for this reason, CSAM respectfully requests your support of [this bill].”
According to Shatterproof (co-sponsor), this bill “addresses a disparity among treatment programs being offered to the residents of California. While residential treatment programs are licensed and their programs regulated by DHCS, outpatient programs have no such requirements. Those seeking treatment, their families, and those paying for the treatment need to know that the State has a minimum set of standards that include evidence-based treatment and that the programs are required to comply with those standards.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
None on file
POLICY ISSUES:
- Definition for Outpatient Facilities. As written, this bill does not include a definition of outpatient facilities nor the services an outpatient facility may provide. It is unclear who the bill would apply to. However, one of the concerns raised by the author and sponsors is that the licensing requirements under this bill could prevent certain providers in rural areas from providing services. As a result, the conversations around what should be defined as an outpatient facility have focused on size of the practice. However, it is unclear why size should be the defining factor if there are standards that facilities should meet.
One way of specifying who should or should not be included would be to define a scope of services. For example, this bill could include recommendations from the SAMHSA report noted earlier, “Scopes of Practice and Career Ladder for Substance Use Disorder Counselling,” to determine whether there are low level services that should be excluded.
If this bill passes this Committee, the author may wish to continue to work with this Committee and the Committee on Health to determine definitions that clearly describe the types of facilities and providers to be licensed under this bill.
- Department of Health Care Services vs. Other Agencies. While the bill builds on existing requirements for residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities that are under the DHCS, it is unclear whether there is a more appropriate agency for the licensing program, such as the Department of Public Health, which is the certifying entity for the majority of healthcare facilities and currently certifies chemical dependency recovery hospitals, or the Department of Social Services, which licenses various counseling and behavioral health facilities.
- Sunrise Review. Sunrise review is the process by which the appropriate policies of the Legislature determine whether the creation of a new state board or a new license type is necessary, and requires proponents of the licensing scheme to submit a report to the appropriate policy committees of the Legislature justifying the need for the proposed level of regulation. This bill would instead delegate that authority to the Department of Consumer Affairs, which is not the typical entity for performing the review.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
- Individual Providers. This bill contains references to individual providers of outpatient alcohol or other drug treatment services that were not deleted when the bill was previously amended to remove individual licensure of drug counselors. If this bill passes this Committee, author may wish to delete the references to individual practitioners in the proposed requirements for outpatient treatment facility licensure.
- Death Reporting Consistency. According to the Assembly Committee on Health, the author may wish to amend the DHCS death investigation policy to include additional references to program clients in order to ensure consistency with other proposed amendments related to the death investigation policy.
- Timeline for the Department of Consumer Affairs Review. This bill requires the Department of Consumer Affairs to perform a “sunrise review” of the necessity for the licensure of individual substance use and recovery counselors by July 1, 2020. However, the department is not the typical entity that performs this type of review and does not currently have the infrastructure or funding to do so. As a result, a six month deadline may be too short. Therefore, if this bill passes this Committee, the author may wish to work with the department to determine the appropriate amount of time and amend the bill accordingly.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Society of Addiction Medicine (co-sponsor)
Shatterproof (co-sponsor)
Advocates for Responsible Treatment
Association of California Life & Health Insurance Companies
California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals
California District Attorneys Association
Consumer Attorneys of California
County Behavioral Health Directors Association
SEIU State Council
St. John's Well Child and Family Center
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Vincent Chee / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 325
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers.
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) on or before January 1, 2021, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors, as specified. Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires DCA, on or before January 1, 2020, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors. Permits DCA to contract with a public or private entity to conduct the review.
- Requires DCA to submit a report to the Legislature containing proposed licensing standards for independent practitioners providing alcohol or drug recovery or treatment services. Requires DCA in preparing the report to consider the data included in the review specified, and to consult with the County Behavioral Health Directors Association, the California Society of Addiction Medicine (CSAM), certifying organizations approved by DHCS to register and certify counselors and other interested organizations and individuals.
- Sunsets the requirement under 2) above on January 1, 2024.
- Requires the DHCS, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program (outpatient substance use disorder (SUD) program) that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient SUD programs.
- Requires DHCS to include in its licensure standards for SUD programs the following:
- Referencing the needs of youth up to 26 years of age, elderly individuals, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and nonbinary individuals, the disabled, and special populations with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those specified populations;
- Evidence-based standards that are equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- Providing for any Drug Medi-Cal (DMC) certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s DMC Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver, to be deemed in compliance with the requirements in this bill as long as the DMC-ODS Waiver is in place and the program remains DMC certified by DHCS;
- Exempting a provider that is employed by or provides services under a contract with a county that does not have a DMC-ODS Waiver and who would otherwise be subject to this chapter until January 1, 2023, or until the county obtains a DMC-ODS Waiver, whichever comes first;
- Prohibiting an outpatient SUD program from banning the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requiring a program to keep accurate records, as specified; and,
- Requiring licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Prohibits the requirements of this bill from constricting, limiting, or affecting the application of existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of licensing a program or individual practitioner, as specified.
- Permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the provisions in this bill.
- Makes other technical, and nonsubstantive changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the DCA to regulate private businesses and professions that engage in activities that have potential impact on the public health, safety, and welfare.
- Requires DCA, through its boards, bureaus and commissions, to establish minimum qualifications and levels of competency and to license, certify or register individuals desiring to engage in the occupations regulated by DCA after determining that individuals possess the requisite skills and qualifications necessary to provide safe and effective services to the public.
- Establishes DHCS for the purpose of preserving and improving the overall health and well-being of all Californians by ensuring access to affordable, integrated, high-quality health care, including medical, dental, mental health, substance use treatment services and long-term care.
- Requires DHCS to license residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities (RTFs) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services.
- Requires RTF licensees to provide at least one of the following: recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. Requires DHCS to adopt regulations requiring records and procedures appropriate for the type of service provided. Provides that the records and procedures can include all of the following: admission criteria; intake process; assessments; recovery, treatment, or detoxification planning; referral; documentation of provision of recovery, treatment, or detoxification services; discharge and continuing care planning; or, indicators of recovery, treatment, or detoxification outcomes.
- Grants DHCS the authority to implement a program certification procedure for outpatient alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services and to develop standards and regulations, after consultation with specified groups, for the alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services describing the minimal level of service quality required of the service providers to qualify for and obtain state certification. Requires certification and compliance with standards to be voluntary on the part of the programs.
- Grants DHCS the sole authority in state government to determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs under DHCS purview.
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with county alcohol and drug program administrators and other interested organizations and individuals, to develop program standards specific to each type of residential and nonresidential program to be used during its certification process. Requires program standards to include, but not be limited to, both of the following:
- Recognition and characterization of different approaches and solutions to the alcohol and drug problems that DHCS determines have sufficient merit for a separate standard; and,
- Reference to the needs of youth, the elderly, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, gays, lesbians, the disabled, and special populations, with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those special populations.
- Requires SUD counselors that work in a facility licensed or certified by DHCS to be registered with or certified by a counselor certification organization (CO) recognized by DHCS.
- Prohibits a DHCS licensed or certified program, and specified individuals associated with or employed by those programs, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified. Permits DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties.
- Prohibits, through regulation, “licensed professionals,” as defined, in good standing with their licensing agencies from being required to become certified by a CO in order to work at a facility licensed or certified by DHCS. Defines “licensed professional” as a physician licensed by the Medical Board of California; a psychologist licensed by the California Board of Psychology (CBP); a clinical social worker or marriage and family therapist licensed by the California Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS); or, an intern registered with the CBP or the BBS. Defines “in good standing” as the professional’s license being valid and not revoked, suspended, or otherwise terminated.
FISCAL EFFECT: The current version of the bill as amended June 13, 2019, has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee; however, according to the Senate Appropriations Committee, a previous version of this bill reflected, there are unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund (GF)) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS’ Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD was $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the fiscal analysis, the number of outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services centers was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’ existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs. In addition, there are potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands GF) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the National Institute on Drug Abuse states that addiction is a complex but treatable disease that affects brain function and behavior. California patients, their families, and those paying for treatment need assurance that all addiction treatment programs are delivering treatment that is effective, efficient, and has value. Individual treatment outcomes depend on the extent and nature of the patient’s problems, the appropriateness of treatment and related services used to address those problems, and the quality of interaction between the patient and their providers. Because the quality and appropriateness of addiction treatment is critical to the success of addiction treatment it is time that the state replaces its voluntary certification program with a licensure requirement. In addition to stopping drug abuse, the goal of treatment is to return people to productive functioning in the family, workplace, and community. Substance abuse costs our nation over $600 billion annually and treatment helps reduce these costs. Treatment is also much less expensive than its alternatives, such as incarcerating addicted persons. Those seeking treatment need to know that any provider they select meets evidence based treatment standards and that those standards are being enforced by the State.
- BACKGROUND. Alcohol and drug dependency are treatable conditions, requiring extensive treatment and customized care. As individual problems, needs, and resources vary from individual to individual, a variety of treatment strategies must also be available if the needs of citizens are to be met.
The increased demand for SUD treatment as a result of the opioid epidemic and the expansion of individuals having insurance under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) has placed a growing burden on the existing SUD treatment community. Currently, California has approximately 36,000 registered or certified counselors working in more than 2,500 private and publicly funded drug and alcohol programs, ranging from residential rehabs to driving under the influence and outpatient programs.- Current Certifying Organizations. Currently DHCS authorizes three (down from a high of more than a dozen) different certifying organizations to certify counselors. Each program develops its own classroom curriculum, training, supervisor, and work experience requirements meeting the department’s requirements of a minimum of 155 documented hours of formal classroom alcohol and other drug (AOD) education, a minimum of 160 documented hours of supervised AOD training and supervised on-site training by an AOD counselor who has been licensed or certified, 2,080 or more documented hours of paid or unpaid work experience providing counseling services in an AOD program, and a score of at least 70% on a written or oral examination approved by the certifying organization. The following three National Commission for Certifying Agencies accredited organizations for the purpose of registering and certifying AOD counselors in California are:
- California Association for Alcohol and Drug Educators;
- California Association of DUI Treatment Programs Accredited Program: Certified Alcohol & Other Drug Counselor; and,
- California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals.
- Substance Abuse Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). In 2011, in response to the ACA as well as the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act expanding access and coverage for SUD treatment, SAMHSA convened key stakeholders to develop a model career ladder for SUD treatment workers. These stakeholders included representatives from higher education, the National Association of State Alcohol/Drug Abuse Directors, the State Association of Addiction Services, the International Certification and Reciprocity Consortium, the National Association of Addiction Professionals, and the Addiction Technology Transfer Center network. The recommendations were published in a document titled, “Scopes of Practice and Career Ladder for Substance Use Disorder Counselling,” which provides a framework and a guide for states to develop their own SUD scopes of practice and career ladders to meet the needs of their specific jurisdictions.
- Senate Report. A 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes extensively examined the current process to become an SUD counselor, and noted some of the systemic flaws. California is one of only two states among the nation’s 15 largest that makes no attempt to review counselors’ criminal backgrounds. Even within California, SUD counselors are the only health-related profession not required to undergo these checks. According to the report, the ability to evade regulators represents a loophole. While the state’s three certifying organizations are required to check with their counterparts to see if a counselor has ever had their certification revoked, the regulation states this must be done only upon certification. Individuals registered to become counselors (registrants) may work for up to five years before they must become certified meaning that a counselor whose certification was previously revoked by another certifying agency could work as long as five years without prior revocations being detected.
- Senate Health Committee informational hearing. On January 31, 2018, the Senate Health Committee held an informational hearing to examine the SUD treatment system with a focus on treatment and services provided in RTFs; insurance coverage; patient referrals; and, the state’s regulation and oversight of the system. The hearing provided an overview of recent issues that have affected the state regarding unscrupulous facility operators, and gave an opportunity for state regulators to highlight efforts they have undertaken to combat the exploitation of the SUD system. The goal of the hearing was to examine the issues and to seek strategies and policies that will prevent unscrupulous individuals from exploiting the various industries that are supposed to help treat those with SUDs, as well as to recognize federal and state protections for those with disabilities, and to ensure that policies are not enacted, either at the local or state level, that will limit the number of treatment options for those who need them.
- Licensed and certified programs. RTFs licensed by DHCS, based on what is commonly referred to as the social model, provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. (The Department of Public Health licenses medical model RTFs, known as chemical dependency recovery hospitals.) The services provided by social model RTFs include group and individual counseling, educational sessions, and alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment planning. Social model RTFs are allowed to provide clients first aid and emergency care, and since the passage of AB 848 (Stone), Chapter 744, Statutes of 2015, RTFs can apply to DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified. SB 823 (Hill), Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018, now requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs. DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities. As part of their licensing and certification functions, DHCS conducts reviews of licensed and certified programs every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute, regulations, and certification standards to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke a program’s license or certification for a violation of statute, regulations, and certification standards.
- DMC-ODS and ASAM. According to DHCS, the DMC-ODS is a five-year pilot program approved by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2015 under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver to test a new method for the organized delivery of health care services for Medi-Cal-eligible individuals with an SUD. Elements of the DMC-ODS include providing a continuum of care modeled after ASAM criteria for SUD treatment services; increased control and accountability; greater administrative oversight; utilization controls to improve care and efficient use of resources; evidence-based practices in SUD treatment; and, increased coordination with other systems of care. “Continuum of care” refers to a treatment system in which clients enter treatment at a level appropriate to their needs and then step up to more intense treatment, or down to less intense treatment, as needed. These levels should be thought of not as discrete levels of care but rather as points in a continuum of treatment services. ASAM criteria established five main levels in a continuum of care for SUD treatment:
- Level 0.5: Early intervention services;
- Level 1: Outpatient services;
- Level 2: Intensive outpatient/partial hospitalization services (Level 2 is subdivided into levels 2.1 and 2.5);
- Level 3: Residential/Inpatient services (Level 3 is subdivided into levels 3.1, 3.3, 3.5, and 3.7); and,
- Level 4: Medically managed intensive inpatient services.
- Current Certifying Organizations. Currently DHCS authorizes three (down from a high of more than a dozen) different certifying organizations to certify counselors. Each program develops its own classroom curriculum, training, supervisor, and work experience requirements meeting the department’s requirements of a minimum of 155 documented hours of formal classroom alcohol and other drug (AOD) education, a minimum of 160 documented hours of supervised AOD training and supervised on-site training by an AOD counselor who has been licensed or certified, 2,080 or more documented hours of paid or unpaid work experience providing counseling services in an AOD program, and a score of at least 70% on a written or oral examination approved by the certifying organization. The following three National Commission for Certifying Agencies accredited organizations for the purpose of registering and certifying AOD counselors in California are:
In addition to the levels of care described by ASAM, outpatient treatment can be broken down into four sequential stages that clients work through, regardless of the level of care at which they enter treatment: (1) treatment engagement; (2) early recovery; (3) maintenance; and, (4) community support.
After the initial approval of the five-year pilot program, which expires in 2020, counties could opt in to the DMC-ODS by submitting an implementation plan for approval by DHCS and CMS. After approval of a plan, a county contracts with DMC-certified providers or offers county-operated services to provide all services available through the DMC-ODS. Counties are also permitted to contract with managed care plans to offer services to beneficiaries. In addition to standard DMC benefits available to all Medi-Cal-eligible individuals who have an SUD diagnosis (which include narcotic treatment program services; outpatient drug-free treatment services; individual and group counseling; day care habilitative services; perinatal residential SUD services; and naltrexone treatment services), counties that opt into the program are required to provide: recovery services to support an individual’s recovery efforts, including counseling, education and job skills, and linkages to housing, transportation, and case management services; comprehensive assessment and periodic reassessment, referral services, and patient advocacy, such as linkages to physical and mental health care; and, physician consultation services, which are provided to DMC-certified physicians who seek expert advice on designing treatment plans for complex cases involving DMC-ODS beneficiaries.
According to the California HealthCare Foundation (CHCF), as of December 2018, 40 of California’s 58 counties had submitted implementation plans to participate in the DMC-ODS. The following 23 counties are now providing services: Alameda, Contra Costa, Imperial, Los Angeles, Marin, Merced, Monterey, Napa, Nevada, Orange, Placer, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, San Francisco, San Joaquin, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Santa Barbara, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Ventura, and Yolo. CHCF states that currently participating counties represent 75% of the state’s Medi-Cal population, and that once all 40 counties begin providing services, nearly 97% of Medi-Cal beneficiaries will have access to DMC-ODS services.
- SUPPORT. CSAM, sponsor of this bill states that outpatient/aftercare is the critical component of SUD treatment. Yet, California has abdicated its responsibility to oversee and regulate these services. Indeed, California only provides voluntary certification of out-patient services. This abdication of State oversight has resulted in a wild west wherein there are no rules and third-party payers and family members have no idea of the kind or quality of treatment that individuals suffering with SUD will receive when they enter a program. This situation would not be allowed to occur in the case of any other form of treatment for a chronic disease or condition. Shatterproof, also a sponsor states that this bill addresses a disparity among treatment programs being offered to the residents of California. While residential treatment programs are licensed and their programs regulated by DHCS, outpatient programs have no such requirements. Those seeking treatment, their families, and those paying for the treatment need to know that the State has a minimum set of standards that include evidence-based treatment and that the programs are required to comply with those standards. Shatterproof concludes SUD is at epidemic levels and legitimate, evidence-based treatment is a crucial component that addresses the personal, physical, and fiscal costs associated with addiction. We must assure those who need, and those who pay, for these services are getting effective treatment.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 1031 (Nazarian) would have enacted the Youth SUD Treatment and Recovery Program Act of 2019 and required DHCS to establish community-based nonresidential and residential treatment and recovery programs to intervene and treat the problems of alcohol and drug use among youth under 21 years of age. The bill also required DHCS to update its Medi-Cal billing codes to include specified services, based on whether those services are medically necessary. AB 1031 in pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- SB 10 (Beall) requires DHCS to amend its Medicaid State Plan to include a certified peer support specialist as a provider type for purposes of the Medi-Cal program, and to include peer support specialist services as a distinct service type for purposes of Medi-Cal, which may be provided to eligible Medi-Cal beneficiaries who are enrolled in either a Medi-Cal managed care plan or a mental health plan. Also requires DHCS to establish a certifying body and to establish curriculum and core competencies required for certification, including a process for an individual employed as a peer support specialist on January 1, 2020, to obtain certification under this bill. Establishes requirements for applicants for certification as a peer support specialist, and for continued certification. SB 10 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- SB 445 (Portantino) establishes the Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults Substance Use Disorder Treatment Act, and requires DHCS to convene an expert panel to advise DHCS solely on the development of youth SUD treatment quality standards, as specified. SB 445 is pending in Assembly Appropriations.
- AB 1031 (Nazarian) would have enacted the Youth SUD Treatment and Recovery Program Act of 2019 and required DHCS to establish community-based nonresidential and residential treatment and recovery programs to intervene and treat the problems of alcohol and drug use among youth under 21 years of age. The bill also required DHCS to update its Medi-Cal billing codes to include specified services, based on whether those services are medically necessary. AB 1031 in pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 2804 (Waldron) of 2018 would have stated legislative intent to establish one-year and five-year plans aimed at expanding the SUD treatment workforce in California to aid in the treatment of alcohol and drug abuse. AB 2804 was held in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 275 (Portantino) of 2018 was substantially similar to SB 445. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated: “not every problem with Medi-Cal needs or deserves a public stakeholder process, and DHCS regularly collaborates with stakeholders, including interested organizations, experts, partners, and colleagues”. Governor Brown stated he was confident DHCS would continue to do so.
- SB 823 (Hill) Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018, requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs.
- DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Committee on Business and Professions.
- AUTHOR’S AMENDMENTS. The author has proposed the following amendments to the bill:
- Adding a declaration stating it is the intent of the Legislature that on or before July 1, 2022, all outpatient services for addiction treatment be provided by programs licensed by DHCS or from individuals licensed appropriately by DCA, and that it is the intent of the Legislature that after July 1, 2022 any offer or provision of addiction treatments services be provided in a licensed environment, by qualified professionals;
- Delaying the effective date for the DCA sunrise review for drug counselors to July 1, 2020;
- Revising DHCS’s death investigation policy and reporting requirements to include the death of a “program client”;
- Adding the California Society of Addiction Medicine to the stakeholders DHCS must consult with in developing the program standards to be used during the licensure process;
- Clarifying language to the DMC-ODS exemption to provide that a non DMC-ODS Waiver county and an entity that contracts with a non-DMC-ODS Waiver county that provides services exclusively to clients of the non DMC-ODS Waiver county are exempt from this bill until January 1, 2023, or until the county obtains a DMC-ODS Waiver, whichever comes first;
- Establishing a penalty structure for licensed outpatient facilities, mirroring the penalties for licensed residential facilities in Health and Safety Code, and;
- Other nonsubstantive, technical amendments.
- COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. As currently written, this bill contains several references to individual providers of outpatient alcohol or other drug treatment services that were not deleted when the bill was previously amended to remove individual licensure of drug counselors and instead call for a sunrise review by the DCS. The Committee may wish to delete the references to individual practitioners in the proposed requirements for outpatient treatment facility licensure.
Additionally, the Committee may wish to further amend the DHCS death investigation policy to include additional references to program clients in order to ensure consistency with other proposed amendments related to the death investigation policy.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Society of Addiction Medicine (cosponsor)
Shatterproof (cosponsor)
Advocates for Responsible Treatment
California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals
Consumer Attorneys of California
County Behavioral Health Directors Association
SEIU State Council
Shatterproof
St. John Well Child and Family Center
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Judith Babcock / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 325
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 13, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 38-0
SUBJECT: Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers.
SUMMARY: Requires the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) on or before January 1, 2021, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors, as specified. Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires DCA, on or before January 1, 2020, to conduct a sunrise review for the licensing of alcohol or drug counselors. Permits DCA to contract with a public or private entity to conduct the review.
- Requires DCA to submit a report to the Legislature containing proposed licensing standards for independent practitioners providing alcohol or drug recovery or treatment services. Requires DCA in preparing the report to consider the data included in the review specified, and to consult with the County Behavioral Health Directors Association, the California Society of Addiction Medicine (CSAM), certifying organizations approved by DHCS to register and certify counselors and other interested organizations and individuals.
- Sunsets the requirement under 2) above on January 1, 2024.
- Requires the DHCS, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program (outpatient substance use disorder (SUD) program) that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient SUD programs.
- Requires DHCS to include in its licensure standards for SUD programs the following:
- Referencing the needs of youth up to 26 years of age, elderly individuals, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and nonbinary individuals, the disabled, and special populations with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those specified populations;
- Evidence-based standards that are equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- Providing for any Drug Medi-Cal (DMC) certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s DMC Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver, to be deemed in compliance with the requirements in this bill as long as the DMC-ODS Waiver is in place and the program remains DMC certified by DHCS;
- Exempting a provider that is employed by or provides services under a contract with a county that does not have a DMC-ODS Waiver and who would otherwise be subject to this chapter until January 1, 2023, or until the county obtains a DMC-ODS Waiver, whichever comes first;
- Prohibiting an outpatient SUD program from banning the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requiring a program to keep accurate records, as specified; and,
- Requiring licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Prohibits the requirements of this bill from constricting, limiting, or affecting the application of existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of licensing a program or individual practitioner, as specified.
- Permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body, as specified.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the provisions in this bill.
- Makes other technical, and nonsubstantive changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the DCA to regulate private businesses and professions that engage in activities that have potential impact on the public health, safety, and welfare.
- Requires DCA, through its boards, bureaus and commissions, to establish minimum qualifications and levels of competency and to license, certify or register individuals desiring to engage in the occupations regulated by DCA after determining that individuals possess the requisite skills and qualifications necessary to provide safe and effective services to the public.
- Establishes DHCS for the purpose of preserving and improving the overall health and well-being of all Californians by ensuring access to affordable, integrated, high-quality health care, including medical, dental, mental health, substance use treatment services and long-term care.
- Requires DHCS to license residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities (RTFs) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services.
- Requires RTF licensees to provide at least one of the following: recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. Requires DHCS to adopt regulations requiring records and procedures appropriate for the type of service provided. Provides that the records and procedures can include all of the following: admission criteria; intake process; assessments; recovery, treatment, or detoxification planning; referral; documentation of provision of recovery, treatment, or detoxification services; discharge and continuing care planning; or, indicators of recovery, treatment, or detoxification outcomes.
- Grants DHCS the authority to implement a program certification procedure for outpatient alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services and to develop standards and regulations, after consultation with specified groups, for the alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services describing the minimal level of service quality required of the service providers to qualify for and obtain state certification. Requires certification and compliance with standards to be voluntary on the part of the programs.
- Grants DHCS the sole authority in state government to determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs under DHCS purview.
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with county alcohol and drug program administrators and other interested organizations and individuals, to develop program standards specific to each type of residential and nonresidential program to be used during its certification process. Requires program standards to include, but not be limited to, both of the following:
- Recognition and characterization of different approaches and solutions to the alcohol and drug problems that DHCS determines have sufficient merit for a separate standard; and,
- Reference to the needs of youth, the elderly, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, gays, lesbians, the disabled, and special populations, with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those special populations.
- Requires SUD counselors that work in a facility licensed or certified by DHCS to be registered with or certified by a counselor certification organization (CO) recognized by DHCS.
- Prohibits a DHCS licensed or certified program, and specified individuals associated with or employed by those programs, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified. Permits DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties.
- Prohibits, through regulation, “licensed professionals,” as defined, in good standing with their licensing agencies from being required to become certified by a CO in order to work at a facility licensed or certified by DHCS. Defines “licensed professional” as a physician licensed by the Medical Board of California; a psychologist licensed by the California Board of Psychology (CBP); a clinical social worker or marriage and family therapist licensed by the California Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS); or, an intern registered with the CBP or the BBS. Defines “in good standing” as the professional’s license being valid and not revoked, suspended, or otherwise terminated.
FISCAL EFFECT: The current version of the bill as amended June 13, 2019, has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee; however, according to the Senate Appropriations Committee, a previous version of this bill reflected, there are unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund (GF)) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS’ Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD was $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the fiscal analysis, the number of outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services centers was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’ existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs. In addition, there are potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands GF) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the National Institute on Drug Abuse states that addiction is a complex but treatable disease that affects brain function and behavior. California patients, their families, and those paying for treatment need assurance that all addiction treatment programs are delivering treatment that is effective, efficient, and has value. Individual treatment outcomes depend on the extent and nature of the patient’s problems, the appropriateness of treatment and related services used to address those problems, and the quality of interaction between the patient and their providers. Because the quality and appropriateness of addiction treatment is critical to the success of addiction treatment it is time that the state replaces its voluntary certification program with a licensure requirement. In addition to stopping drug abuse, the goal of treatment is to return people to productive functioning in the family, workplace, and community. Substance abuse costs our nation over $600 billion annually and treatment helps reduce these costs. Treatment is also much less expensive than its alternatives, such as incarcerating addicted persons. Those seeking treatment need to know that any provider they select meets evidence based treatment standards and that those standards are being enforced by the State.
- BACKGROUND. Alcohol and drug dependency are treatable conditions, requiring extensive treatment and customized care. As individual problems, needs, and resources vary from individual to individual, a variety of treatment strategies must also be available if the needs of citizens are to be met.
The increased demand for SUD treatment as a result of the opioid epidemic and the expansion of individuals having insurance under the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) has placed a growing burden on the existing SUD treatment community. Currently, California has approximately 36,000 registered or certified counselors working in more than 2,500 private and publicly funded drug and alcohol programs, ranging from residential rehabs to driving under the influence and outpatient programs.- Current Certifying Organizations. Currently DHCS authorizes three (down from a high of more than a dozen) different certifying organizations to certify counselors. Each program develops its own classroom curriculum, training, supervisor, and work experience requirements meeting the department’s requirements of a minimum of 155 documented hours of formal classroom alcohol and other drug (AOD) education, a minimum of 160 documented hours of supervised AOD training and supervised on-site training by an AOD counselor who has been licensed or certified, 2,080 or more documented hours of paid or unpaid work experience providing counseling services in an AOD program, and a score of at least 70% on a written or oral examination approved by the certifying organization. The following three National Commission for Certifying Agencies accredited organizations for the purpose of registering and certifying AOD counselors in California are:
- California Association for Alcohol and Drug Educators;
- California Association of DUI Treatment Programs Accredited Program: Certified Alcohol & Other Drug Counselor; and,
- California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals.
- Substance Abuse Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA). In 2011, in response to the ACA as well as the Mental Health Parity and Addiction Equity Act expanding access and coverage for SUD treatment, SAMHSA convened key stakeholders to develop a model career ladder for SUD treatment workers. These stakeholders included representatives from higher education, the National Association of State Alcohol/Drug Abuse Directors, the State Association of Addiction Services, the International Certification and Reciprocity Consortium, the National Association of Addiction Professionals, and the Addiction Technology Transfer Center network. The recommendations were published in a document titled, “Scopes of Practice and Career Ladder for Substance Use Disorder Counselling,” which provides a framework and a guide for states to develop their own SUD scopes of practice and career ladders to meet the needs of their specific jurisdictions.
- Senate Report. A 2013 report by the California Senate Office of Oversight and Outcomes extensively examined the current process to become an SUD counselor, and noted some of the systemic flaws. California is one of only two states among the nation’s 15 largest that makes no attempt to review counselors’ criminal backgrounds. Even within California, SUD counselors are the only health-related profession not required to undergo these checks. According to the report, the ability to evade regulators represents a loophole. While the state’s three certifying organizations are required to check with their counterparts to see if a counselor has ever had their certification revoked, the regulation states this must be done only upon certification. Individuals registered to become counselors (registrants) may work for up to five years before they must become certified meaning that a counselor whose certification was previously revoked by another certifying agency could work as long as five years without prior revocations being detected.
- Senate Health Committee informational hearing. On January 31, 2018, the Senate Health Committee held an informational hearing to examine the SUD treatment system with a focus on treatment and services provided in RTFs; insurance coverage; patient referrals; and, the state’s regulation and oversight of the system. The hearing provided an overview of recent issues that have affected the state regarding unscrupulous facility operators, and gave an opportunity for state regulators to highlight efforts they have undertaken to combat the exploitation of the SUD system. The goal of the hearing was to examine the issues and to seek strategies and policies that will prevent unscrupulous individuals from exploiting the various industries that are supposed to help treat those with SUDs, as well as to recognize federal and state protections for those with disabilities, and to ensure that policies are not enacted, either at the local or state level, that will limit the number of treatment options for those who need them.
- Licensed and certified programs. RTFs licensed by DHCS, based on what is commonly referred to as the social model, provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. (The Department of Public Health licenses medical model RTFs, known as chemical dependency recovery hospitals.) The services provided by social model RTFs include group and individual counseling, educational sessions, and alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment planning. Social model RTFs are allowed to provide clients first aid and emergency care, and since the passage of AB 848 (Stone), Chapter 744, Statutes of 2015, RTFs can apply to DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified. SB 823 (Hill), Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018, now requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs. DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities. As part of their licensing and certification functions, DHCS conducts reviews of licensed and certified programs every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute, regulations, and certification standards to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke a program’s license or certification for a violation of statute, regulations, and certification standards.
- DMC-ODS and ASAM. According to DHCS, the DMC-ODS is a five-year pilot program approved by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2015 under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver to test a new method for the organized delivery of health care services for Medi-Cal-eligible individuals with an SUD. Elements of the DMC-ODS include providing a continuum of care modeled after ASAM criteria for SUD treatment services; increased control and accountability; greater administrative oversight; utilization controls to improve care and efficient use of resources; evidence-based practices in SUD treatment; and, increased coordination with other systems of care. “Continuum of care” refers to a treatment system in which clients enter treatment at a level appropriate to their needs and then step up to more intense treatment, or down to less intense treatment, as needed. These levels should be thought of not as discrete levels of care but rather as points in a continuum of treatment services. ASAM criteria established five main levels in a continuum of care for SUD treatment:
- Level 0.5: Early intervention services;
- Level 1: Outpatient services;
- Level 2: Intensive outpatient/partial hospitalization services (Level 2 is subdivided into levels 2.1 and 2.5);
- Level 3: Residential/Inpatient services (Level 3 is subdivided into levels 3.1, 3.3, 3.5, and 3.7); and,
- Level 4: Medically managed intensive inpatient services.
- Current Certifying Organizations. Currently DHCS authorizes three (down from a high of more than a dozen) different certifying organizations to certify counselors. Each program develops its own classroom curriculum, training, supervisor, and work experience requirements meeting the department’s requirements of a minimum of 155 documented hours of formal classroom alcohol and other drug (AOD) education, a minimum of 160 documented hours of supervised AOD training and supervised on-site training by an AOD counselor who has been licensed or certified, 2,080 or more documented hours of paid or unpaid work experience providing counseling services in an AOD program, and a score of at least 70% on a written or oral examination approved by the certifying organization. The following three National Commission for Certifying Agencies accredited organizations for the purpose of registering and certifying AOD counselors in California are:
In addition to the levels of care described by ASAM, outpatient treatment can be broken down into four sequential stages that clients work through, regardless of the level of care at which they enter treatment: (1) treatment engagement; (2) early recovery; (3) maintenance; and, (4) community support.
After the initial approval of the five-year pilot program, which expires in 2020, counties could opt in to the DMC-ODS by submitting an implementation plan for approval by DHCS and CMS. After approval of a plan, a county contracts with DMC-certified providers or offers county-operated services to provide all services available through the DMC-ODS. Counties are also permitted to contract with managed care plans to offer services to beneficiaries. In addition to standard DMC benefits available to all Medi-Cal-eligible individuals who have an SUD diagnosis (which include narcotic treatment program services; outpatient drug-free treatment services; individual and group counseling; day care habilitative services; perinatal residential SUD services; and naltrexone treatment services), counties that opt into the program are required to provide: recovery services to support an individual’s recovery efforts, including counseling, education and job skills, and linkages to housing, transportation, and case management services; comprehensive assessment and periodic reassessment, referral services, and patient advocacy, such as linkages to physical and mental health care; and, physician consultation services, which are provided to DMC-certified physicians who seek expert advice on designing treatment plans for complex cases involving DMC-ODS beneficiaries.
According to the California HealthCare Foundation (CHCF), as of December 2018, 40 of California’s 58 counties had submitted implementation plans to participate in the DMC-ODS. The following 23 counties are now providing services: Alameda, Contra Costa, Imperial, Los Angeles, Marin, Merced, Monterey, Napa, Nevada, Orange, Placer, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, San Francisco, San Joaquin, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Santa Barbara, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Ventura, and Yolo. CHCF states that currently participating counties represent 75% of the state’s Medi-Cal population, and that once all 40 counties begin providing services, nearly 97% of Medi-Cal beneficiaries will have access to DMC-ODS services.
- SUPPORT. CSAM, sponsor of this bill states that outpatient/aftercare is the critical component of SUD treatment. Yet, California has abdicated its responsibility to oversee and regulate these services. Indeed, California only provides voluntary certification of out-patient services. This abdication of State oversight has resulted in a wild west wherein there are no rules and third-party payers and family members have no idea of the kind or quality of treatment that individuals suffering with SUD will receive when they enter a program. This situation would not be allowed to occur in the case of any other form of treatment for a chronic disease or condition. Shatterproof, also a sponsor states that this bill addresses a disparity among treatment programs being offered to the residents of California. While residential treatment programs are licensed and their programs regulated by DHCS, outpatient programs have no such requirements. Those seeking treatment, their families, and those paying for the treatment need to know that the State has a minimum set of standards that include evidence-based treatment and that the programs are required to comply with those standards. Shatterproof concludes SUD is at epidemic levels and legitimate, evidence-based treatment is a crucial component that addresses the personal, physical, and fiscal costs associated with addiction. We must assure those who need, and those who pay, for these services are getting effective treatment.
- RELATED LEGISLATION.
- AB 1031 (Nazarian) would have enacted the Youth SUD Treatment and Recovery Program Act of 2019 and required DHCS to establish community-based nonresidential and residential treatment and recovery programs to intervene and treat the problems of alcohol and drug use among youth under 21 years of age. The bill also required DHCS to update its Medi-Cal billing codes to include specified services, based on whether those services are medically necessary. AB 1031 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 10 (Beall) requires DHCS to amend its Medicaid State Plan to include a certified peer support specialist as a provider type for purposes of the Medi-Cal program, and to include peer support specialist services as a distinct service type for purposes of Medi-Cal, which may be provided to eligible Medi-Cal beneficiaries who are enrolled in either a Medi-Cal managed care plan or a mental health plan. Also requires DHCS to establish a certifying body and to establish curriculum and core competencies required for certification, including a process for an individual employed as a peer support specialist on January 1, 2020, to obtain certification under this bill. Establishes requirements for applicants for certification as a peer support specialist, and for continued certification. SB 10 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- SB 445 (Portantino) establishes the Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults Substance Use Disorder Treatment Act, and requires DHCS to convene an expert panel to advise DHCS solely on the development of youth SUD treatment quality standards, as specified. SB 445 is pending in Assembly Appropriations.
- AB 1031 (Nazarian) would have enacted the Youth SUD Treatment and Recovery Program Act of 2019 and required DHCS to establish community-based nonresidential and residential treatment and recovery programs to intervene and treat the problems of alcohol and drug use among youth under 21 years of age. The bill also required DHCS to update its Medi-Cal billing codes to include specified services, based on whether those services are medically necessary. AB 1031 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 2804 (Waldron) of 2018 would have stated legislative intent to establish one-year and five-year plans aimed at expanding the SUD treatment workforce in California to aid in the treatment of alcohol and drug abuse. AB 2804 was held in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 275 (Portantino) of 2018 was substantially similar to SB 445. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated: “not every problem with Medi-Cal needs or deserves a public stakeholder process, and DHCS regularly collaborates with stakeholders, including interested organizations, experts, partners, and colleagues”. Governor Brown stated he was confident DHCS would continue to do so.
- SB 823 (Hill) Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018, requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs.
- DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Committee on Business and Professions.
- AUTHOR’S AMENDMENTS. The author has proposed the following amendments to the bill:
- Adding a declaration stating it is the intent of the Legislature that on or before July 1, 2022, all outpatient services for addiction treatment be provided by programs licensed by DHCS or from individuals licensed appropriately by DCA, and that it is the intent of the Legislature that after July 1, 2022 any offer or provision of addiction treatments services be provided in a licensed environment, by qualified professionals;
- Delaying the effective date for the DCA sunrise review for drug counselors to July 1, 2020;
- Revising DHCS’s death investigation policy and reporting requirements to include the death of a “program client”;
- Adding the California Society of Addiction Medicine to the stakeholders DHCS must consult with in developing the program standards to be used during the licensure process;
- Clarifying language to the DMC-ODS exemption to provide that a non DMC-ODS Waiver county and an entity that contracts with a non-DMC-ODS Waiver county that provides services exclusively to clients of the non DMC-ODS Waiver county are exempt from this bill until January 1, 2023, or until the county obtains a DMC-ODS Waiver, whichever comes first;
- Establishing a penalty structure for licensed outpatient facilities, mirroring the penalties for licensed residential facilities in Health and Safety Code, and;
- Other nonsubstantive, technical amendments.
- COMMITTEE AMENDMENTS. As currently written, this bill contains several references to individual providers of outpatient alcohol or other drug treatment services that were not deleted when the bill was previously amended to remove individual licensure of drug counselors and instead call for a sunrise review by the DCS. The Committee may wish to delete the references to individual practitioners in the proposed requirements for outpatient treatment facility licensure.
Additionally, the Committee may wish to further amend the DHCS death investigation policy to include additional references to program clients in order to ensure consistency with other proposed amendments related to the death investigation policy.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Society of Addiction Medicine (cosponsor)
Shatterproof (cosponsor)
Advocates for Responsible Treatment
California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals
Consumer Attorneys of California
County Behavioral Health Directors Association
SEIU State Council
Shatterproof
St. John Well Child and Family Center
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Judith Babcock / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 325 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 325
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/10/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Grove, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 6-0, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
SUBJECT: Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers
SOURCE: California Society of Addiction Medicine
Shatterproof
DIGEST:
This bill requires the Department of Health Care Services, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program or an individual practitioner that provides those services to the public, as specified; and makes other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
Existing law:
- Requires the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to license residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities (RTFs) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. [HSC §11834.01, et seq.]
- Requires RTF licensees to provide at least one of the following: recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. Requires DHCS to adopt regulations requiring records and procedures appropriate for the type of service provided. Provides that the records and procedures can include all of the following: admission criteria; intake process; assessments; recovery, treatment, or detoxification planning; referral; documentation of provision of recovery, treatment, or detoxification services; discharge and continuing care planning; or indicators of recovery, treatment, or detoxification outcomes. [HSC §11834.26]
- Grants DHCS the authority to implement a program certification procedure for alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services and to develop standards and regulations, after consultation with specified groups, for the alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services describing the minimal level of service quality required of the service providers to qualify for and obtain state certification. Requires certification and compliance with standards to be voluntary on the part of the programs. [HSC §11830.1]
- Grants DHCS the sole authority in state government to determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs under DHCS’s purview. [HSC §11833]
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with county alcohol and drug program administrators and other interested organizations and individuals, to develop program standards specified to each type of residential and nonresidential program to be used during its certification process. Requires program standards to include, but not be limited to, both of the following:
- Recognition and characterization of different approaches and solutions to the alcohol and drug problems that DHCS determines have sufficient merit for a separate standard; and,
- Reference to the needs of youth, the elderly, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, gays, lesbians, the disabled, and special populations, with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those special populations. [HSC §11830.5]
- Requires substance use disorder (SUD) counselors that work in a facility licensed or certified by DHCS to be registered with or certified by a counselor certification organization (CO) recognized by DHCS. [HSC §11833]
- Prohibits a DHCS licensed or certified program, and specified individuals associated with or employed by those programs, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified. Permits DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties. [HSC §11831.6 and 11831.7]
- Prohibits, through regulation, “licensed professionals,” as defined, in good standing with their licensing agencies from being required to become certified by a CO in order to work at a facility licensed or certified by DHCS. Defines “licensed professional” as a physician licensed by the Medical Board of California; a psychologist licensed by the California Board of Psychology (CBP); a clinical social worker or marriage and family therapist licensed by the California Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS); or an intern registered with the CBP or the BBS. Defines “in good standing” as the professional’s license being valid and not revoked, suspended, or otherwise terminated. [Title 9 CCR §13015]
This bill:
- Requires DHCS, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program (outpatient SUD program) or an individual practitioner, who is registered with or certified by a CO approved by DHCS, that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient SUD programs.
- Adds criteria, in addition to the requirements in 5) above in existing law, for DHCS to include the following standards for licensure:
- Evidence-based standards that are equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- Certification by specified national certifying organizations for individual practitioners who are also registered or certified by a CO recognized by DHCS for registering or certifying SUD counselors;
- Requiring any Drug Medi-Cal (DMC) certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s DMC Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver, to be deemed in compliance with the requirements in this bill as long as the DMC-ODS is in place and the program remains DMC certified by DHCS;
- Prohibiting an outpatient SUD program from banning the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requiring a program to keep accurate records, as specified; and,
- Requiring licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Prohibits the requirements of this bill from constricting, limiting, or affecting the application of existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Prohibits the requirement for licensure in this bill to apply to SUD treatment services provided in a driving-under-the-influence (DUI) program, in an educational environment, by a U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) Substance Abuse Professional evaluating individuals in private or public employment that are subject to USDOT regulations, as specified, or in a licensed hospital or clinic.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of administering the provisions in this bill and licensing a program or individual practitioner, as specified.
- Changes existing law to require, instead of permit, DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties, for violations of giving or receiving remuneration in exchange for referring a person to recovery or treatment services as specified in existing law.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the provision in this bill.
- Makes other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the National Institute on Drug Abuse states that addiction is a complex but treatable disease that affects brain function and behavior. California patients, their families, and those paying for treatment need assurance that all addiction treatment programs are delivering treatment that is effective, efficient, and has value. Individual treatment outcomes depend on the extent and nature of the patient’s problems, the appropriateness of treatment and related services used to address those problems, and the quality of interaction between the patient and his or her treatment providers. Because the quality and appropriateness of addiction treatment is critical to the success of addiction treatment, it is time that the state replaces its voluntary certification program with a licensure requirement. In addition to stopping drug abuse, the goal of treatment is to return people to productive functioning in the family, workplace, and community. Substance abuse costs our nation over $600 billion annually and treatment helps reduce these costs. Treatment is also much less expensive than its alternatives, such as incarcerating addicted persons. Those seeking treatment need to know that any provider they select meets an evidence-based treatment standard and that those standards are being enforced by the state.
- Licensed and certified programs. RTFs licensed by DHCS, based on what is commonly referred to as the social model, provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. (The Department of Public Health licenses medical model RTFs, known as chemical dependency recovery hospitals.) The services provided by social model RTFs include group and individual counseling, educational sessions, and alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment planning. Social model RTFs are allowed to provide clients first aid and emergency care, and since the passage of AB 848 (Stone, Chapter 744, Statutes of 2015) RTFs can apply to DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified. SB 823 (Hill, Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018) now requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs. DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities. As part of their licensing and certification functions, DHCS conducts reviews of licensed and certified programs every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute, regulations, and certification standards to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke a program’s license or certification for a violation of statute, regulations, and certification standards.
- Reports about “patient brokering.” Several news articles (“How Some Southern California drug rehab centers exploit addiction,” Orange County Register, May 21, 2017; “A Choice for Recovering Addicts: Relapse or Homelessness, New York Times, May 30, 2015; “California’s Rehab System is in Crisis … ” CityWatch Los Angeles, June 23, 2016; and “Special Report: Two states with an ocean view, and an ethical cloud,” Addiction Professional, March 18, 2013) highlight the issue of “patient brokering,” whereby unscrupulous individuals (sometimes called “interventionists”) lure clients seeking SUD treatment services, buy insurance policies for the clients or offer to pay their deductibles, and “sell” them to facility operators that do not provide any type of treatment services or regular monitoring (typically unregulated sober living homes and outpatient facilities that are not certified by DHCS), all the while billing the insurance plan. Some individuals involved in this practice have been quoted in news articles as acknowledging that the practice may be wrong; however, they also claim that the practice is so ubiquitous in California that they would have no clients at all if they did not engage. As a result, some facility operators keep interventionists on retainer, often for $5000 to $10,000 a month, regardless of how many clients an interventionist refers to them, in order to remain in business. After clients’ insurance coverage is exhausted, unscrupulous facility operators have been allegedly dumping them in the streets where they continue their addictions. In many news articles, the issue is largely attributed to facilities that do not require state licensure or oversight, including what New York refers to as “three-quarter houses,” which are New York’s equivalent to California’s recovery residences.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD were $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the analysis, the number of non-certified outpatient SUD programs was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’s existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs.
- Potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands, General Fund) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
California Society of Addiction Medicine (co-source)
Shatterproof (co-source)
California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals
Consumer Attorneys of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Society of Addiction Medicine, Shatterproof, and other supporters, largely treatment providers, argue that the unregulated system in the state has caused devastation as treatment providers abuse clients, operate with no consequences for incompetent care, and drain payment from both the public and private payment systems through fraud and deceit. Supporters argue that this lack of oversight does not exist currently for any other medical condition. Supporters state that thousands of dollars have been paid out for poor or non-existent services with no requirements for staff, outcomes reporting, or even health and safety standards. Supporters argue that currently if a certified provider is found to not be abiding by certification standards, they can simply choose not to continue to be voluntarily certified.
Prepared by: Reyes Diaz / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
5/20/19 12:19:15
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 325 (Hill) - Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers
Version: April 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
Senate Bill 325 would require, effective January 1, 2021, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program or an individual practitioner that provides those services and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS’ Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD was $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the analysis, the number of outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services centers was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’ existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs.
- Potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands, General Fund) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
Committee Amendments:
The committee amendments would clarify that DHCS can charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of administering the program or practitioner under the bill’s provisions.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 325 (Hill) - Substance abuse recovery or treatment providers
Version: April 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 29, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
Senate Bill 325 would require, effective January 1, 2021, the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program or an individual practitioner that provides those services and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, significant ongoing costs (likely low millions General Fund) for DHCS to hire and train new staff to ensure compliance of SUD treatment facility laws, regulations, and standards. The DHCS’ Substance Use Disorder Compliance Division (SUDCD) has two sections, the Licensing and Certification Section and the Complaints Section. The Licensing and Certification Section currently has 24 analysts, and the Complaints Section has a total of 20 analysts. In 2017-18, actual expenditures for SUDCD was $14.1 million. As of January 11, 2019, DHCS identified 1,930 active residential treatment and/or certified facilities. At the time of the analysis, the number of outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services centers was unknown. The staff estimate mirrors costs from DHCS’ existing expenditures in its licensing of RTFs.
- Potential one-time costs (mid-tens of thousands, General Fund) for DHCS staff to draft regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
Background:
The DHCS is the sole licensing authority for over 2,300 SUD programs, including narcotic treatment programs, Driving Under the Influence (DUI) programs, and alcohol and other drug treatment programs. The DHCS licenses recovery or treatment facilities (RTF) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. The DHCS must determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within licensed or certified alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs.
The DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities.
RTFs licensed by the DHCS provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. Since the passage of AB 848 (Stone, Chapter 744, Statutes of 2015), RTFs can apply to the DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified. SB 823 (Hill, Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018) also requires DHCS to adopt American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs. The DHCS currently licenses about 1,020 RTFs. As part of their licensing functions, the DHCS conducts reviews of licensed RTFs at least once every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute and regulations to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke an RTF’s license for a violation of statute or regulations.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require, effective January 1, 2021, the Department of Health Care Services to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program or individual practitioner that provides those services and is not licensed. The bill also includes the following provisions:
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient substance use disorder (SUD) programs.
- Adds the additional following criteria to be included in program licensure standards:
- Youth include those up to age 26 years of age;
- Evidence-based standards equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- Certification by specified national certifying organizations for individual practitioners who are also registered or certified by a CO recognized by DHCS for registering or certifying SUD counselors;
- Compliance of any Drug Medi-Cal certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s Drug Medi-Cal Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver as the DMC-ODS Waiver is in place and the program remains Drug Medi-Cal certified;
- Requirement that an outpatient SUD program allow the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requirement that a program keep accurate records, as specified; and,
- Requirement for licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Provides that the bill does not constrict, limit, or affect existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Exempts SUD treatment services provided in a driving under the influence (DUI) program, in an educational environment, by a U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) Substance Abuse Professional evaluating an employee who has violated USDOT regulations, as specified, or in a licensed hospital or clinic, from the bill’s licensing provisions.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of licensing a program or individual practitioner, as specified.
- Permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body, as specified.
- Changes existing law to require, instead of authorize, DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties, for violations of giving or receiving remuneration in exchange for referring a person to recovery or treatment services as specified in existing law.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the bill’s provisions.
Related Legislation:
- SB 589 (Bates) would prohibit a certified alcohol or other drug program, recovery residence, as defined, or third party that provides any form of advertising or marketing to one or more of those entities, from making false or misleading statements or receiving remuneration or anything of value for referring a person to a recovery or treatment service, as specified. The bill is on this committee’s suspense file.
- AB 615 (Brough) would make a willful violation of the prohibition against referrals for remuneration a crime punishable by a fine of not more than $10,000, imprisonment in a county jail for 16 months, or two or three years, or both fine and imprisonment. AB 615 failed passage in the Assembly Public Safety Committee and was granted reconsideration.
- AB 940 (Melendez) would prohibit a recovery residence, as specified, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking recovery and treatment services, and would require DHCS to impose a minimum fine of $50,000 for each violation. AB 940 is in the Assembly Health Committee.
- SB 1290 (Bates, 2018) would have established the Commission on Substance Abuse and Recovery, and would have made it unlawful for specified persons to offer or pay a commission, benefit, bonus, rebate, kickback, or bribe; solicit or receive a commission, benefit, bonus, rebate, kickback, or bribe. SB 1290 was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
- SB 992 (Hernandez, Chapter 784, Statutes of 2018) requires programs licensed or certified by DHCS to disclose certain business relationships, as specified, including with a recovery residence, and makes changes to current law for licensed RTFs to improve client treatment and provide DHCS more oversight authority over RTFs.
- SB 1228 (Lara, Chapter 792, Statutes of 2018) prohibits certain persons, programs, or entities, including a licensed RTF and persons employed by, or working for, that program, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
BILL NO: SB 325
AUTHOR: | Hill | ||
VERSION: | March 28, 2019 | ||
HEARING DATE: | April 10, 2019 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Reyes Diaz | ||
SUBJECT: Substance abuse recovery and treatment providers
SUMMARY:
Requires the Department of Health Care Services, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program or an individual practitioner that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified. Makes other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
Existing law:
- Requires Department of Health Care Services (DHCS) to license residential alcoholism or drug abuse recovery or treatment facilities (RTFs) that provide 24-hour residential non-medical services to adults who are recovering from problems related to alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug misuse or abuse, and who need alcohol, drug, or alcohol and drug recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. [HSC §11834.01, et seq.]
- Requires RTF licensees to provide at least one of the following: recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. Requires DHCS to adopt regulations requiring records and procedures appropriate for the type of service provided. Provides that the records and procedures can include all of the following: admission criteria; intake process; assessments; recovery, treatment, or detoxification planning; referral; documentation of provision of recovery, treatment, or detoxification services; discharge and continuing care planning; or indicators of recovery, treatment, or detoxification outcomes. [HSC §11834.26]
- Grants DHCS the authority to implement a program certification procedure for alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services and to develop standards and regulations, after consultation with specified groups, for the alcohol and other drug treatment recovery services describing the minimal level of service quality required of the service providers to qualify for and obtain state certification. Requires certification and compliance with standards to be voluntary on the part of the programs. [HSC §11830.1]
- Grants DHCS the sole authority in state government to determine the qualifications, including the appropriate skills, education, training, and experience of personnel working within alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment programs under DHCS’s purview. [HSC §11833]
- Requires DHCS, in consultation with county alcohol and drug program administrators and other interested organizations and individuals, to develop program standards specified to each type of residential and nonresidential program to be used during its certification process. Requires program standards to include, but not be limited to, both of the following:
- Recognition and characterization of different approaches and solutions to the alcohol and drug problems that DHCS determines have sufficient merit for a separate standard; and,
- Reference to the needs of youth, the elderly, women, pregnant women, mothers and their children, gays, lesbians, the disabled, and special populations, with recognition of innovative solutions to the problems of those special populations. [HSC §11830.5]
- Requires substance use disorder (SUD) counselors that work in a facility licensed or certified by DHCS to be registered with or certified by a counselor certification organization (CO) recognized by DHCS. [HSC §11833]
- Prohibits a DHCS licensed or certified program, and specified individuals associated with or employed by those programs, from giving or receiving remuneration or anything of value for the referral of a person who is seeking alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment services, as specified. Permits DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties. [HSC §11831.6 and 11831.7]
- Prohibits, through regulation, “licensed professionals,” as defined, in good standing with their licensing agencies from being required to become certified by a CO in order to work at a facility licensed or certified by DHCS. Defines “licensed professional” as a physician licensed by the Medical Board of California; a psychologist licensed by the California Board of Psychology (CBP); a clinical social worker or marriage and family therapist licensed by the California Board of Behavioral Sciences (BBS); or an intern registered with the CBP or the BBS. Defines “in good standing” as the professional’s license being valid and not revoked, suspended, or otherwise terminated. [Title 9 CCR §13015]
This bill:
- Requires DHCS, beginning January 1, 2021, to license an outpatient alcohol or other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program (outpatient SUD program) or an individual practitioner that provides those services to the public and is not otherwise licensed, as specified.
- Changes all references to “certification standards” in existing law to “licensure standards” in regard to outpatient SUD programs.
- Adds criteria, in addition to the requirements in 5) above in existing law, for DHCS to include in licensure standards that include:
- Evidence-based standards that are equivalent to the American Society of Addiction Medicine (ASAM) treatment criteria, as specified;
- Certification by specified national certifying organizations for individual practitioners who are also registered or certified by a CO recognized by DHCS for registering or certifying SUD counselors;
- Requiring any Drug Medi-Cal (DMC) certified treatment program operating under DHCS’s DMC Organized Delivery System (DMC-ODS) Waiver, under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver, to be deemed in compliance with the requirements in this bill as long as the DMC-ODS is in place and the program remains DMC certified by DHCS;
- Prohibiting an outpatient SUD program from banning the use of medication-assisted treatment by any enrollee of its program, as specified;
- Requiring a program to keep accurate records, as specified; and,
- Requiring licensure standards to be implemented in a way that provides for sufficient time for programs and individual providers to comply without significant displacement of program clients.
- Prohibits the requirements of this bill from constricting, limiting, or affecting the application of existing law related to the Medical Practice Act, the Nursing Practice Act, the Psychology Licensing Law, the Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Act, the Clinical Social Worker Practice Act, or the Licensed Professional Clinical Counselor Act.
- Prohibits the requirement for licensure in this bill to apply to SUD treatment services provided in a driving under the influence (DUI) program, in an educational environment, by a U.S. Department of Transportation (USDOT) Substance Abuse Professional evaluating an employee who has violated USDOT regulations, as specified, or in a licensed hospital or clinic.
- Requires DHCS to charge a fee not to exceed the reasonable regulatory costs of licensing a program or individual practitioner, as specified.
- Permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body, as specified.
- Changes existing law to require, instead of permit, DHCS to investigate allegations of violations and take action, such as revocation of licensure or certification, or assessment of penalties, for violations of giving or receiving remuneration in exchange for referring a person to recovery or treatment services as specified in existing law.
- Requires DHCS to adopt regulations by December 31, 2021, to implement the provision in this bill.
- Makes other technical, nonsubstantive changes.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the National Institute on Drug Abuse states that addiction is a complex but treatable disease that affects brain function and behavior. California patients, their families, and those paying for treatment need assurance that all addiction treatment programs are delivering treatment that is effective, efficient, and has value. Individual treatment outcomes depend on the extent and nature of the patient’s problems, the appropriateness of treatment and related services used to address those problems, and the quality of interaction between the patient and his or her treatment providers. Because the quality and appropriateness of addiction treatment is critical to the success of addiction treatment, it is time that the state replaces its voluntary certification program with a licensure requirement. In addition to stopping drug abuse, the goal of treatment is to return people to productive functioning in the family, workplace, and community. Substance abuse costs our nation over $600 billion annually and treatment helps reduce these costs. Treatment is also much less expensive than its alternatives, such as incarcerating addicted persons. Those seeking treatment need to know that any provider they select meets an evidence-based treatment standard and that those standards are being enforced by the state.
- Licensed and certified programs. RTFs licensed by DHCS, based on what is commonly referred to as the social model, provide recovery, treatment, or detoxification services. (The Department of Public Health licenses medical model RTFs, known as chemical dependency recovery hospitals.) The services provided by social model RTFs include group and individual counseling, educational sessions, and alcoholism or drug abuse recovery and treatment planning. Social model RTFs are allowed to provide clients first aid and emergency care, and since the passage of AB 848 (Stone, Chapter 744, Statutes of 2015) RTFs can apply to DHCS for an additional license to provide incidental medical services by a licensed physician and surgeon or other health care practitioner, as specified. SB 823 (Hill, Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018) now requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs. DHCS also offers a voluntary facility certification to those programs that provide the following services: day treatment, outpatient, and nonresidential detoxification. The certification is granted to programs that exceed minimum levels of service quality and are in substantial compliance with state program certification standards. Certification is available to both residential and nonresidential programs. The majority of facilities licensed by DHCS are also certified. DHCS also provides program certification for facilities that are licensed by the Department of Social Services that serve adolescents. DHCS licenses about 1,000 RTFs and certifies approximately 900 facilities. As part of their licensing and certification functions, DHCS conducts reviews of licensed and certified programs every two years, or as necessary; checks for compliance with statute, regulations, and certification standards to ensure the health and safety of clients; investigates all complaints; and has the authority to suspend or revoke a program’s license or certification for a violation of statute, regulations, and certification standards.
- DMC-ODS and ASAM. According to DHCS, the DMC-ODS is a five-year pilot program approved by the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2015 under the Section 1115 Bridge to Reform Demonstration Waiver to test a new method for the organized delivery of health care services for Medi-Cal-eligible individuals with an SUD. Elements of the DMC-ODS include providing a continuum of care modeled after ASAM criteria for SUD treatment services; increased control and accountability; greater administrative oversight; utilization controls to improve care and efficient use of resources; evidence-based practices in SUD treatment; and, increased coordination with other systems of care. “Continuum of care” refers to a treatment system in which clients enter treatment at a level appropriate to their needs and then step up to more intense treatment, or down to less intense treatment, as needed. These levels should be thought of not as discrete levels of care but rather as points in a continuum of treatment services. ASAM criteria established five main levels in a continuum of care for SUD treatment:
- Level 0.5: Early intervention services;
- Level 1: Outpatient services;
- Level 2: Intensive outpatient/partial hospitalization services (Level 2 is subdivided into levels 2.1 and 2.5);
- Level 3: Residential/Inpatient services (Level 3 is subdivided into levels 3.1, 3.3, 3.5, and 3.7); and,
- Level 4: Medically managed intensive inpatient services.
In addition to the levels of care described by ASAM, outpatient treatment can be broken down into four sequential stages that clients work through, regardless of the level of care at which they enter treatment: 1) treatment engagement; 2) early recovery; 3) maintenance; and 4) community support.
After the initial approval of the five-year pilot program, which expires in 2020, counties could opt in to the DMC-ODS by submitting an implementation plan for approval by DHCS and CMS. After approval of a plan, a county contracts with DMC-certified providers or offers county-operated services to provide all services available through the DMC-ODS. Counties are also permitted to contract with managed care plans to offer services to beneficiaries. In addition to standard DMC benefits available to all Medi-Cal-eligible individuals who have an SUD diagnosis (which include narcotic treatment program services; outpatient drug-free treatment services; individual and group counseling; day care habilitative services; perinatal residential SUD services; and naltrexone treatment services), counties that opt into the program are required to provide, among other requirements: recovery services to support an individual’s recovery efforts, including counseling, education and job skills, and linkages to housing, transportation, and case management services; comprehensive assessment and periodic reassessment, referral services, and patient advocacy, such as linkages to physical and mental health care; and, physician consultation services, which are provided to DMC-certified physicians who seek expert advice on designing treatment plans for complex cases involving DMC-ODS beneficiaries.
According to the California Health Care Foundation (CHCF), as of December 2018, 40 of California’s 58 counties had submitted implementation plans to participate in the DMC-ODS. The following 22 counties are now providing services: Alameda, Contra Costa, Imperial, Los Angeles, Marin, Merced, Monterey, Napa, Nevada, Orange, Placer, Riverside, San Bernardino, San Diego, San Francisco, San Joaquin, San Luis Obispo, San Mateo, Santa Barbara, Santa Clara, Santa Cruz, Ventura, and Yolo. CHCF states that currently participating counties represent 75% of the state’s Medi-Cal population, and that once all 40 counties begin providing services, nearly 97% of Medi-Cal beneficiaries will have access to DMC-ODS services.
- Reports about “patient brokering.” Several news articles (“How Some Southern California drug rehab centers exploit addiction,” Orange County Register, May 21, 2017; “A Choice for Recovering Addicts: Relapse or Homelessness, New York Times, May 30, 2015; “California’s Rehab System is in Crisis … ” CityWatch Los Angeles, June 23, 2016; and “Special Report: Two states with an ocean view, and an ethical cloud,” Addiction Professional, March 18, 2013) highlight the issue of “patient brokering,” whereby unscrupulous individuals (sometimes called “interventionists”) lure clients seeking SUD treatment services, buy insurance policies for the clients or offer to pay their deductibles, and “sell” them to facility operators that do not provide any type of treatment services or regular monitoring (typically unregulated sober living homes and outpatient facilities that are not certified by DHCS), all the while billing the insurance plan. Some individuals involved in this practice have been quoted in news articles as acknowledging that the practice may be wrong; however, they also claim that the practice is so ubiquitous in California that they would have no clients at all if they did not engage. As a result, some facility operators keep interventionists on retainer, often for $5000 to $10,000 a month, regardless of how many clients an interventionist refers to them, in order to remain in business. After clients’ insurance coverage is exhausted, unscrupulous facility operators have been allegedly dumping them in the streets where they continue their addictions. In many news articles, the issue is largely attributed to facilities that do not require state licensure or oversight, including what New York refers to as “three-quarter houses,” which are New York’s equivalent to California’s recovery residences.
- Senate Health Committee informational hearing. On January 31, 2018, the Senate Health Committee held an informational hearing to examine the SUD treatment system with a focus on treatment and services provided in RTFs; insurance coverage; patient referrals; and the state’s regulation and oversight of the system. The hearing provided an overview of recent issues that have affected the state regarding unscrupulous facility operators, and gave an opportunity for state regulators to highlight efforts they have undertaken to combat the exploitation of the SUD system. The goal of the hearing was to examine the issues and to seek strategies and policies that will prevent unscrupulous individuals from exploiting the various industries that are supposed to help treat those with SUDs, as well as to recognize federal and state protections for those with disabilities, and to ensure that policies are not enacted, either at the local or state level, that will limit the number of treatment options for those who need them.
- Related legislation. AB 1031 (Nazarian) enacts the Youth SUD Treatment and Recovery Program Act of 2019 and requires DHCS to establish community-based nonresidential and residential treatment and recovery programs to intervene and treat the problems of alcohol and drug use among youth under 21 years of age. Requires DHCS to update its Medi-Cal billing codes to include specified services, based on whether those services are medically necessary. AB 1031 was heard in the Assembly Health Committee on April 2, 2019, and passed out by a vote of 15-0.
SB 445 (Portantino) establishes the Children, Adolescents, and Young Adults Substance Use Disorder Treatment Act, and requires DHCS to convene an expert panel to advise DHCS solely on the development of youth SUD treatment quality standards, as specified. SB 445 is set to be heard in this Committee on April 10, 2019.
- Prior legislation. SB 275 (Portantino of 2018) was identical to SB 445. SB 275 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated not every problem with Medi-Cal needs or deserves a public stakeholder process, and DHCS regularly collaborates with stakeholders, including interested organizations, experts, partners, and colleagues. Governor Brown stated he was confident DHCS would continue to do so.
SB 823 (Hill, Chapter 781, Statutes of 2018) requires DHCS to adopt ASAM treatment criteria, as specified, as the minimum standard of care for licensed RTFs.
- Support. The sponsors of this bill and other supporters, largely treatment providers, argue that the unregulated system in the state has caused devastation as treatment providers abuse clients, operate with no consequences for incompetent care, and drain payment from both the public and private payment systems through fraud and deceit. Supporters argue that this lack of oversight does not exist currently for any other medical condition. Supporters state that thousands of dollars have been paid out for poor or non-existent services with no requirements for staff, outcomes reporting, or even health and safety standards. Supporters argue that currently if a certified provider is found to not be abiding by certification standards, they can simply choose not to continue to be voluntarily certified.
- Policy comment. This bill permits DHCS to grant a provisional license to entities that have an accreditation by a national alcohol or drug program accrediting body. However, there is no timeframe indicated by which a provisionally licensed entity would need to receive full licensure. Additionally, in past informational hearings by this Committee, treatment providers that have an additional accreditation by a national organization have expressed that national accreditation often does not mean a higher level of oversight or assurance that accredited entities are actually providing quality services. The Committee may wish to consider if granting provisional licensure to entities that are nationally accredited meets the goals of this bill to provide quality treatment to those with SUDs.
- Technical amendments. The author may wish to consider the following technical amendments to provide clarity to various provisions in this bill:
- Add the term “outpatient” when referring to “alcohol and other substance use disorder recovery or treatment services program” to distinguish these entities from currently licensed RTFs;
- Replace references to “standards,” which were relevant to voluntary certification, with “regulations” to ensure DHCS can properly enforce rules for licensed outpatient programs;
- Revise the terms “gays” and “lesbians” to “lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and nonbinary individuals”;
- Specify that individual practitioners who aren’t currently licensed are those who are currently registered or certified as SUD counselors by a DHCS-approved CO;
- Replace “medically assisted treatment” with “medication-assisted treatment”;
- Replace “enrollee” with “client” to maintain consistency in existing law; and,
- Specify that the USDOT provides DUI evaluation to individuals in private or public employment that are subject to USDOT regulations and not to USDOT employees.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Society of Addiction Medicine (co-sponsor)
Shatterproof (co-sponsor)
California Consortium of Addiction Programs and Professionals
Consumer Attorneys of California
Oppose: None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):