SB 326: Common interest developments.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 207, Statutes of 2019. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 32. Noes 5.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 10. Noes 2.) (July 2). |
| Jun 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (June 19). |
| Jun 12, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| May 24, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on H. & C.D. and JUD. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 28. Noes 8.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 1, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (April 30). |
| Apr 26, 2019 | Set for hearing April 30. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HOUSING. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on HOUSING. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Coms. on JUD. and HOUSING. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB326 Hill Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | SB 326 Hill Senate Third Reading By Chiu | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB326 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Housing |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Housing] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 326 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 326
Amended: 7/3/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 8-2, 4/30/19
AYES: Wiener, Caballero, Durazo, McGuire, Roth, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Morrell, Bates
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE FLOOR: 28-8, 5/9/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas, Chang
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-6, 8/12/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Common interest developments
DIGEST:
This bill makes two changes to the laws governing homeowners associations (HOAs). First, it establishes a mandatory inspection regime for exterior elevated elements (EEEs), such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings, within HOAs. Second it nullifies any provision in an HOA’s governing documents that purports to condition or limit the ability of the HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the developer or builder of the HOA.
Assembly Amendments (1) require HOA boards, during the mandatory meeting they must hold prior to filing a construction defects case, to discuss potential impacts on the association and members, including financial impacts; and (2) permit local governments or enforcement agencies to impose greater balcony safety requirements than those contained in the bill.
Existing law:
- Requires regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system on all buildings containing three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in common interest developments (CIDs). (Health & Saf. Code § 17973.)
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (“Davis-Stirling Act”), the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential CID and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members. (Civ. Code § 4000 et seq.)
- Provides the following definitions for purposes of the Davis-Stirling Act:
- “association” means a nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association created for the purpose of managing a CID (Civ. Code § 4080);
- “common area” means the entire CID except the separate interests therein (Civ. Code § 4095); and
- “exclusive use common area” means a portion of the common area designated by the declaration for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, of the owners of the separate interests and which is or will be appurtenant to the separate interest or interests (Civ. Code § 4145(a)).
- Provides that, unless the declaration states otherwise, any shutters, awnings, window boxes, doorsteps, stoops, porches, balconies, patios, exterior doors, doorframes, and hardware incident thereto, screens and windows or other fixtures designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest. (Civ. Code § 4145(b).)
- Provides that, unless otherwise provided in the declaration of a CID, the HOA is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area; the owners of each separate interest are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest; and the owner of each separate interest is responsible for maintaining the exclusive use common area appurtenant to that separate interest and the association is responsible for repairing and replacing the exclusive use common area. (Civ. Code § 4775.)
- Requires the board of directors of an association to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the CID, when the current replacement value of the major components meets a specified threshold. (Civ. Code § 5550.)
- Requires an HOA board of directors, at least 30 days before filing a civil action against the declarant or other developer for damage to property that the HOA is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify the members of the HOA in writing of:
- the time and place of a meeting to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action; and
- the options, including civil actions, that are available to address the problems. (Civ. Code § 6150(a).)
- Allows an HOA board of directors to give the notice specified in (6), above, within 30 days after filing a civil action if the association has reason to believe that the applicable statute of limitations will expire before the association files the civil action. (Civ. Code § 6150(b).)
This bill:
- Defines “exterior elevated elements” as those components of a building and their associated waterproofing system that:
- have a walking surface elevated more than six feet above ground level;
- extend beyond the exterior walls to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings; and
- are supported in whole or in part as well as the associated waterproofing system.
- Requires an HOA, at least once every nine years, to have a licensed structural engineer or architect conduct a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of a randomly generated and statistically significant sample, as defined, of the EEEs in buildings containing three or more multi-family dwelling units for which the association has maintenance or repair responsibility, to determine if they are in a generally safe condition and performing in accordance with specified standards.
- Defines “visual inspection” as inspection through the least intrusive method necessary to inspect load-bearing components, including visual observation only or visual observation in conjunction with, for example, the use of moisture meters, borescopes, or infrared technology.
- Provides that if, during the visual inspection, the inspector observes building conditions indicating that unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system, thereby creating the potential for damage to the load-bearing components, then the inspector may conduct a further inspection of a scope determined by the inspector’s best professional judgment.
- Directs the inspector, based upon the visual inspection, further inspection, and construction and materials expertise, to issue a written report containing the following information for each exterior elevated element inspected:
- its current physical condition, including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents;
- its expected future performance and remaining useful life; and
- recommendations of any necessary repair or replacement.
- Requires all inspection reports to be stamped or signed by the inspector, presented to the board, incorporated into the HOA’s triannual required reserve study, and maintained permanently as part of the HOA’s records.
- Requires an inspector to notify the HOA and local code enforcement, on specified timelines, of any EEE inspection that reveals an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants.
- Requires an HOA to take preventative measures when an EEE inspection reveals an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, including restricting access to an EEE until the local code enforcement agency inspects and approves repairs.
- Requires the first set of EEE inspections to be completed by January 1, 2025, for existing buildings, and to be completed not later than following the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for buildings for which a building permit application has been submitted on or after January 1, 2020.
- Authorizes an HOA board of directors, subject to compliance with existing statutory meeting notice requirements but not withstanding any provision of the HOA’s governing documents to the contrary, to make the determination of whether and when an association may commence legal action against the HOA’s declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Requires at a meeting of an HOA to consider filing a civil action against the developer of a CID, when discussing the impacts of the civil action the HOA shall discuss the potential impacts including any financial impacts, with its members.
- Provides that an HOA’s governing documents shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board’s authority to commence and pursue legal action against the declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Declares unenforceable, null, and void as against public policy any limitation or precondition on an HOA board of director’s authority to pursue legal action against a declarant, developer, or builder, unless that limitation or precondition is lawfully adopted by members of the association not affiliated with the declarant after the declarant has relinquished control of the board and no longer owns a majority of units in the association.
- Requires an HOA board, during the mandatory meeting they must hold prior to filing a construction defects case, to discuss potential impacts on the association and members, including financial impacts.
Comments
- Overview on EEE inspection regimes. On June 16, 2015, a fourth-floor balcony at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, California, collapsed. The collapse killed six people and injured seven more. A subsequent investigation revealed that years of exposure to moisture led to dry rot along the top of the balcony supports, causing them to give way.
In the wake of this tragedy, local and state agencies and the Legislature moved to address deficiencies in the laws around the construction, maintenance, and inspection of balconies, decks, and other EEEs. One month after the collapse, the Berkeley City Council approved a series of ordinances that require examination of all existing residential balconies in Berkeley and that tighten requirements on the materials and design of future structures.
At the state level, SB 465 (Hill, Chapter 372, Statutes of 2016) established greater oversight over the construction industry. For example, it required contractors convicted of crimes related to their work to report that information to the Contractors State Licensing Board (CSLB). SB 465 also required a working group formed by the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC) to study EEE failures in the state and to submit a report to the Legislature with findings and recommendations for statutory or other changes to the California Building Standards Code.
That working group found data supporting the conclusion that “deterioration of EEEs is a significant problem and illustrates that a post-occupancy inspection program is critical to reducing the risk of failure of existing EEEs.” The working group recommended that “post-occupancy inspection and the requirement for this post-occupancy inspection needs to be strengthened.” The report noted that “[l]egislation may be required to allow state agencies to implement such local inspection programs” and encouraged the Legislature “to write the enabling legislation in a way that allows the appropriate agencies to develop these programs rather than having the programs set forth in detail in the legislation.”
In 2017, SB 721 (Hill, Chapter 441, Statutes of 2017) responded to this call by requiring 15 percent of existing EEEs in multi-family buildings with three or more dwelling units to be inspected at least every six years to ensure that they are in a generally safe condition, adequate working order, and free from any hazardous conditions, as specified.
Though initially included in SB 721, late in the legislative process, HOAs were dropped from its scope. As a result, while multifamily dwellings with three or more units are subject to regular EEE inspections, there is presently no analogous requirement in the HOA context. This bill seeks to fill that gap.
- Overview on HOA governing document provisions that limit or condition commencement of lawsuits against the founder, developer, or builder of an HOA. As part of the creation of a new HOA, the developer typically begins laying the groundwork for the HOA’s future self-governance. This includes establishing the initial governing documents for the HOA, including the HOA’s “declaration” or covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CCRs). While the HOA developer is still selling off the separate properties within the HOA to homeowners, it is also common for the developer to serve, or appoint people to serve, on the HOA board of directors. In these ways, HOA developers exercise a great deal of control over how the HOA will operate going forward, even though, over time, the developer’s direct involvement with the HOA typically fades away.
The involvement of HOA developers in the creation of the HOA’s initial government documents and the appointment of early HOA board members can sometimes create conflicts of interest because the HOA and the developer’s interests are not necessarily aligned.
The second component to this bill addresses one such circumstance. In drafting the governing documents for the HOAs they are creating, developers sometimes add provisions that make it quite difficult for the HOA to sue the developer in the event that construction defects are discovered at the HOA.
While it could be argued that requiring a vote of the HOA members prevents the board of directors from spending the HOA’s money on legal disputes without the support of the members, the fact that these provisions are limited to construction defect claims against the developer suggests that more is afoot. Moreover, Civil Code Section 6150 already provides some protections against an overly litigious board bent on suing the developer: it requires an HOA board to hold a meeting of the members 30 days prior to filing a lawsuit, stating its reasoning and laying out the options available to the HOA.
This bill ensures that developers cannot reap the benefit of having taken advantage of their participation in the creation of the HOA in this way. This bill declares null and void any provision in the governing documents purporting to place limitations or preconditions on the HOA board’s ability to initiate a construction defect claim against the developer. It would also prevent board members appointed by or affiliated with the developer from participating in any board decision as to whether or not to pursue a construction defect claim against the developer.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
Consumer Attorneys of California
Executive Council of Homeowners
Eight individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/13/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-6, 8/12/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Choi, Fong, Kiley, Lackey, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow, Chen, Flora, Frazier, Kalra, Mathis, Mayes, Patterson, Robert Rivas
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/15/19 9:35:36
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 326
Author:(Hill)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes specified mandatory inspections for exterior elevated elements such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings in common interest developments (CIDs) and prohibits a homeowner association's (HOA's) governing documents from limiting the ability of an HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the founder, developer, or builder of the HOA.
Major Provisions
- Requires an HOA, of a condominium project with three or more units, at least once every nine years, to contract with a licensed structural engineer or architect for a visual inspection of a random and significantly significant sample of exterior elements of the HOA.
- Provides that if the inspector determines a risk to safety of the residents as a result of the inspection, the inspector shall provide a copy of the inspection report the HOA immediately upon completion of the report and to the local code enforcement agency within 15 days.
- Requires the HOA to take preventative measures immediately to prevent occupant access to exterior elevated elements until repairs have been inspected and approved by the enforcement
- Requires the first inspection to be completed on January 1, 2025, and every nine years after in coordination with the reserve study.
- Requires that for buildings for which a building permit application was submitted after January 1, 2020, the first inspection of the exterior elevated elements shall occur six years after the certificate of occupancy is issued.
- Authorizes an HOA to bring an action against a developer or builder of a CID for construction defect after providing notice to the members of the HOA.
- Provides that if the developer or builder sits on the HOA board then the decision to pursue legal proceedings for a construction defect shall be solely in the nonaffiliated board members.
- Provides that the governing documents of the HOA shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board's authority to pursue and claim, civil action, arbitration, or pre-litigation process against a developer or builder for construction defect.
- Provides that any provision of the governing document that imposes a limitation or preconditions on the board's authority to pursue litigation for construction defect is valid if it was adopted solely when the developer of the HOA is no longer on the board and was adopted subject to the rules necessary to amend the government documents.
- Provides that the governing documents of the homeowners association shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board's authority to pursue and claim, civil action, arbitration, or pre-litigation process against a developer or builder for construction defect.
- Applies to all governing documents whether adopted before or after this bill takes effect and retroactively to claims initiated before the effective date of this bill, unless those claims have been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
- Requires at a meeting of an HOA to consider filing a civil action against the developer of a CID, when discussing the impacts of the civil action the HOA shall discuss the potential impacts including any financial impacts, with its members.
COMMENTS:
CIDs are required to complete a reserve study every three years which includes a visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the common interest development.
When CIDs are created the developer writes the governing documents of the HOA subject to the review and approval of the Department of Real Estate. While the HOA developer is still selling off the separate properties within the HOA to homeowners, it is also common for the developer to serve, or appoint people to serve, on the HOA board of directors. Some bylaws require that the members of the HOA vote to approve construction defect lawsuit against the developer. This bill declares null and void any provision in the governing documents purporting to place limitations or preconditions on the HOA board's ability to initiate a construction defect claim against the developer. It would also prevent board members appointed by or affiliated with the developer from participating in any board decision as to whether or not to pursue a construction defect claim against the developer. Civil Code Section 6150 already provides some protections against a board suing the developer: it requires an HOA board to hold a meeting of the members 30 days prior to filing a lawsuit, stating its reasoning and laying out the options available to the HOA.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "SB 326 builds upon last year's SB 721, which I authored to address balcony inspections and repairs for apartment buildings, following the deadly 2015 Berkeley balcony collapse that killed six and injured seven. SB 326 also requires that existing condominium buildings, governed by homeowners associations (HOAs), have inspections at least once every nine years on a small percentage of their balconies, stairwells, and other exterior elevated elements to ensure they are safe. And SB 326 also prevents builders from placing language in an HOA's covenants, conditions, and restrictions, or CC&Rs, that would limit the ability of the HOA Board of Directors to sue the developer if there are construction defects."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters of this bill write that the bill will prohibit developer of an HOA from including preconditions in the governing documents that prevent an HOA from recovering for construction defects. They also support efforts to maintain the safety of the balconies and external decks, balconies, stairways, walkways of a CID.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 28-8-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas, Chang
ASM HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT: 7-1-0
YES: Chiu, Diep, Gabriel, Gloria, Limón, Maienschein, Quirk-Silva
NO: Kiley
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-2-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085 FN: 0001220
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 326
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 24, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 28-8
SUBJECT: Common interest developments: building standards: litigation
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD BALCONIES AND OTHER EXTERIOR ELEVATED ELEMENTS WITHIN A COMMON INTEREST DEVELOPMENT BE SUBJECT TO A SPECIFIC INSPECTION REGIME?
- SHOULD THE GOVERNING DOCUMENTS OF HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATIONS, GENERALLY, BE PROHIBITED FROM CONTAINING LIMITATIONS ON THE ASSOCIATION’S RIGHT TO PURSUE LITIGATION FOR CONSTRUCTION DEFECT?
SYNOPSIS
In the wake of several high profile incidents involving the collapse of stairs and balconies at multi-unit housing dwellings, the Legislature sought to improve the inspection and maintenance of these exterior housing elements. Last year, the Legislature enacted SB 721 (Hill, Chap. 445, Stats. 2018) to regulate the maintenance and inspection of balconies within apartment complexes. This bill is a follow-up to that measure, and seeks to regulate the inspection of balconies and other exterior elements at properties managed by a homeowners association. Additionally, this measure seeks to eliminate the ability for a developer of a common interest development to interfere with the ability of homeowners association boards to seek redress for construction defects by drafting a common interest development’s governing documents in a manner that curtails the board’s ability to pursue litigation.
This bill is supported by a coalition of homeowners associations and the Consumer Attorneys of California, who argue in favor of the safety improvements that this bill will bring to housing across the state. The measure is opposed by a law firm representing developers. That firm, as well as the California Building Industry Association, who would support this bill with additional amendments, contend that the provisions of this bill related to litigation deny non-board members of a homeowners association the ability to adequately voice their opinion regarding the homeowners association’s decision to file lawsuits. Amendments agreed to in the Assembly Committee on Housing and Community Development removed most of the prior opposition to this bill. That Committee approved the bill on a bi-partisan 7 to 1 vote.
SUMMARY: Establishes an inspection regime for exterior elevated elements, including balconies, within common interest developments, and generally prohibits the governing documents of a homeowners association from limiting the board’s ability to bring construction defect litigation against the founder, developer, or builder of the development. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms for the purpose of the bill:
- “Associated waterproofing systems” include flashings, membranes, coatings, and sealants that protect the load-bearing components of exterior elevated elements from exposure to water;
- “Exterior elevated elements” mean the load-bearing components together with their associated waterproofing system;
- “Load-bearing components” mean those components that extend beyond the exterior walls of the building to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways, and their railings, that have a walking surface elevated more than six feet above ground level, that are designed for human occupancy or use, and that are supported in whole or in substantial part by wood or wood-based products;
- “Statistically significant sample” means a sufficient number of units inspected to provide 95 percent confidence that the results from the sample are reflective of the whole, with a margin of error of no greater than plus or minus 5 percent; and
- “Visual inspection” means inspection through the least intrusive method necessary to inspect load-bearing components, including visual observation only or visual observation in conjunction with, for example, the use of moisture meters, borescopes, or infrared technology.
- Requires, at least once every nine years, the board of a homeowners association to cause a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection to be conducted by a licensed structural engineer or architect of a random and statistically significant sample of exterior elevated elements for which the association has maintenance or repair responsibility to determine if the exterior elevated elements are in a generally safe condition and performing in accordance with applicable standards.
- Requires the inspector to perform the visual inspection based on a random list of the locations of each type of exterior element within the responsibility of the association, and provides that if during the visual inspection the inspector observes building conditions indicating that unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system, thereby creating the potential for damage to the load-bearing components, then the inspector may conduct a further inspection. Additionally, requires the inspector to exercise their best professional judgment in determining the necessity, scope, and breadth of any further inspection.
- Requires, based on the inspector’s visual inspections, further inspection, and construction and materials expertise, the inspector to provide the homeowners association with a written report containing the following:
- The identification of the building components comprising the load-bearing components and associated waterproofing system;
- The current physical condition of the load-bearing components and associated waterproofing system, including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents;
- The expected future performance and remaining useful life of the load-bearing components and associated waterproofing system; and
- Recommendations for any necessary repair or replacement of the load-bearing components and associated waterproofing system.
- Requires the inspector, if they advise that the exterior elevated element poses an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, to provide a copy of the inspection report to the association immediately upon completion of the report, and to the local code enforcement agency within 15 days of completion of the report. Requires, upon receiving the report, the association to take preventive measures immediately, including preventing occupant access to the exterior elevated element until repairs have been inspected and approved by the local enforcement agency. Authorizes local agencies to recover any associated enforcement costs.
- Requires the first inspection to be completed by January 1, 2025, and to continue thereafter.
- Requires a homeowners association to maintain the inspection reports for two cycles after the report is drafted.
- Provides that, notwithstanding 6), inspection of buildings for which a building permit application has been submitted on or after January 1, 2020, shall occur no later than six years following the issuance of a certificate of occupancy.
- Provides that the inspection regime provided in this bill only applies to buildings with three or more dwelling units.
- Provides that a homeowners association, local government, or local enforcement agency may enact requirements that are stricter than those provided in this bill.
- Authorizes the home owners association to bring an action against a developer or builder of a common interest development for construction defect after providing notice to the members of the association.
- Provides that if the developer or builder sits on the homeowners’ association board then the decision to pursue legal proceedings for a construction defect shall be solely in the nonaffiliated board members.
- Provides that the governing documents of the homeowners association shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board’s authority to pursue and claim, civil action, arbitration, or pre-litigation process against a developer or builder for construction defect.
- Provides that any provision of the governing document that imposes a limitation or preconditions on the board’s authority to pursue litigation for construction defect is valid if it was adopted solely when the developer of the homeowners association is no longer on the board and was adopted subject to the rules necessary to amend the government documents.
- Applies to all governing documents whether adopted before or after this bill takes effect and retroactively to claims initiated before the effective date of this bill, unless those claims have been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
- Requires, at a meeting of the homeowners association in which the filing of a civil action against the developer of a common interest development is considered, when discussing the impacts of the civil action the homeowners association to discuss the potential impacts, including any financial impacts, with its members.
- Provides that existing venues and procedures for construction defect litigation, including a developers right to inspect and remedy a property, apply to homeowners associations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential common interest development and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members. (Civil Code Section 4000 et seq.)
- Defines, for purposes of the Davis-Stirling Act, the following terms:
- “Association” means a nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association created for the purpose of managing a common interest development (Civil Code Section 4080);
- “Common Area” means the entire common interest development, except the separate interests therein (Civil Code Section 4095); and
- “Exclusive Use Common Area” means a portion of the common area designated by the declaration for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, of the owners of the separate interests and which is or will be appurtenant to the separate interest or interests (Civil Code Section 4145 (a)).
- Provides, unless otherwise specified in the declaration of a common interest development, that the development’s homeowners association is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area; that the owners of each separate interest are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest; and the owner of each separate interest is responsible for maintaining the exclusive use common area appurtenant to that separate interest and the association is responsible for repairing and replacing the exclusive use common area. (Civil Code Section 4775.)
- Requires the board of directors of a homeowners association to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the common interest development, if the current replacement value of the major components is equal to or greater than one-half of the gross budget of the association, excluding the association’s reserve account for that period. (Civil Code Section 5550.)
- Provides, unless otherwise specified in the declaration of a common interest development, that any shutters, awnings, window boxes, doorsteps, stoops, porches, balconies, patios, exterior doors, doorframes, and hardware incident thereto, screens and windows or other fixtures designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest. (Civil Code Section 4145 (b).)
- Requires the board of directors of a homeowners association, at least 30 days before filing a civil action against the declarant or other developer for damage to property that the homeowners association is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify the members of the association in writing of the time and place of a meeting to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action and the options, including civil actions, that are available to address the problems. (Civil Code Section 6150 (a).)
- Allows the board of directors of a homeowners association to give the notice specified in 6), above, within 30 days after filing a civil action if the association has reason to believe that the applicable statute of limitations will expire before the association files the civil action. (Civil Code Section 6150 (b).)
- Provides that in an action seeking recovery of damages arising out of, or related to deficiencies in, the residential construction, design, specifications, surveying, planning, supervision, testing, or observation of construction, the claimant’s claims or causes of action shall be limited to violations of established standards for the following:
- Water issues, including leaks;
- Structural issues;
- Soil issues;
- Fire protection issues;
- Plumbing and sewer issues;
- Electrical system issues; and
- Other general construction issues including sidewalks and hardways, stucco and exterior finishes, and products manufactured by third parties. (Civil Code Section 896.)
- Provides the statute of limitations for deficiencies is the following:
- For plumbing and sewer systems no action may be brought for a violation more than four years after close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (e));
- For electrical systems no action may be brought for a violation more than four years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (f));
- For exterior pathways, driveways, hardscape, sidewalls, sidewalks, and patios installed by the original builder no action may be brought for a violation more than four years from the close of escrow (Code of Civil Procedure Section 896 (g)(1));
- For inter-unit noise transmission standards no action may be brought for a violation more than one year from the original occupancy of the adjacent unit (Code of Civil Procedure Section 896 (g)(6));
- For irrigation systems and drainage no action may be brought for a violation more than one year from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(7));
- For wood posts no action may be brought for a violation more than two years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(8));
- For steel fences and adjacent components no action may be brought for a violation more than four years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(9));
- For paints and stains no action may be brought for a violation more than five years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(10));
- For landscaping systems no action may be brought for a violation more than two years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(12)); and
- For dryer ducts no action may be brought for a violation more than two years from the close of escrow (Civil Code Section 896 (g)(14)).
- Provides that prior to filing an action for economic or property damages related to the standards provided in 8), a claimant must provide written notice via certified mail, overnight mail, or personal delivery to the builder and shall describe the claim in reasonable detail sufficient to determine the nature and location, to the extent known, of the claimed violation. (Civil Code Section 910.)
- Provides that within 30 days of a written request by a claimant or their legal representative, the builder shall provide copies of all relevant plans, specifications, mass or rough grading plans, final soils reports, Bureau of Real Estate public reports, and available engineering calculations, that pertain to a homeowner’s residence specifically or as part of a larger development tract. (Civil Code Section 912.)
- Requires a builder or their representative to acknowledge, in writing, receipt of the notice of the claim within 14 days after receipt of the notice of the claim. (Civil Code Section 913.)
- Requires regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system on all buildings containing three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in common interest developments. (Health & Safety Code Section 17973.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print the bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Seeking to address deficiencies in the existing law regarding common interest developments and exterior features that may pose significant life and safety risks to residents, this bill makes several changes to the law related to common interest developments. First, this bill requires the homeowners association of a common interest development to conduct regular, in-depth inspections of exterior elements including balconies, stairs, and awnings. Secondly, to ensure that homeowner association boards are able to properly seek redress for construction related issues, this bill clarifies the procedures the board must follow and notices the board must provide prior to commencing construction defect litigation. In support of the bill, the author states:
SB 326 requires that exterior elevated elements of multi-family dwellings that are common interest developments be inspected at least once every nine years. If the inspector encounters an immediate threat, they are required to report it to the local enforcement agency.
SB 326 also prohibits developers from inserting language in a community’s CC&Rs that abrogates or limits the rights of Boards of Directors to pursue litigation against a developer.
SB 326 does not prohibit home owners associations from adding vote requirements to their CC&Rs themselves. By keeping developers from inserting ‘poison pill’ requirements, this measure places that decision squarely in the hands of the homeowners.
Exterior elements at multi-unit dwellings have a troubling history of causing injuries. The author of this bill notes that without adequate inspection regimes, balconies and other exterior elements on multi-unit dwellings may be at risk of collapse. The author highlights a 2015 incident in which a balcony at an apartment complex in the City of Berkeley collapsed and killed six students. However, balconies are not the only issue. In 2015, a Folsom man was killed when the stairway at his apartment complex collapsed due to dry rot within the stair’s support system. (Branan & Chang, Dry rot suspected in fatal Folsom stairway collapse, Sacramento Bee (July 7, 2015) available at: https://www.sacbee.com/news/local/article26678224.html.) To address these issues, last year, the author of this measure successfully enacted legislation requiring minimum inspection requirements for the exterior elevated elements, including balconies and decks, of apartment buildings with three or more multifamily dwelling units. (SB 721 (Hill) Chap. 445, Stats. 2018.) However, that bill did not apply to multi-unit dwellings that are encompassed within common interest developments and governed by homeowners associations.
Common interest developments managed by homeowners associations have unique rules under the law. Presently, there are more than 52,000 common interest developments across California comprising over six million total housing units. Since the 1990s, approximately 60 percent of the new housing starts in California have been part of a common interest development. These developments are characterized by individualized ownership of one’s own dwelling space with common ownership of common property. Restrictions, covenants, and other agreements govern the use of the community spaces and enforce community wide restrictions on the individual’s dwelling unit, including an individual homeowners ability to make repairs or modifications to their property. Common interest developments include condominiums, community apartment projects, housing cooperatives, and planned unit developments, and are typically managed by a homeowners association consisting of the residents of the common interest development.
When a property owner purchases a property within a common interest development, they must agree to the covenants, conditions, and restrictions of the development and are contractually obligated to submit to oversight by the homeowners association. Typically, a property owner seeking to make significant modifications or improvements to their individual dwelling unit, particularly to the exterior of the unit, must seek approval from the homeowners association before proceedings with any changes to their individual unit. In turn, the board or governing body of the homeowners association assumes a leading role in providing services and improvements to common areas within the development. While these services are typically associated with the mowing of lawns and other landscape-related concerns, homeowners associations play a significant role in handling structural maintenance, particularly in common interest developments containing multi-unit dwellings like condominiums or townhouses.
Existing statutory and case law specifically require homeowners associations to maintain these shared spaces. In fact, existing law requires the homeowners association to conduct a visual inspection of all major building components falling within the responsibility of the homeowners association every three years to ensure that the association is maintaining adequate reserves for potential maintenance. Like all other property owners, should a homeowners association believe that damage to a building component is the result of defective or poor construction of the component, the homeowners association is entitled to file a lawsuit claiming a construction defect against the common interest development’s original builder.
Construction defect litigation and homeowners associations. California’s existing statutory scheme for litigating construction defect claims dates back to the early 2000s and is designed to provide for a pre-litigation dispute resolution process. (SB 800 (Burton) Chap. 722, Stats. 2002.) That statutory scheme created a defined list of minimum building standards for residential construction and provided that the failure to meet the standard was a defect. The existing law provides a claimant 10 years to file most claims, with numerous specific statutes of limitation provided for individual types of defects. Existing law also provides builders with the right to inspect and repair the alleged defects in a non-adversarial process, with the goal of reducing potential litigation.
In the event an individual homeowner seeks to file a construction defect claim, that homeowner need only follow the statutory notice and inspection process before filing a lawsuit. However, in the case of an association of homeowners within a common interest development, several additional variables and requirements come into play. Typically, when a common interest development is first created, the developer drafts the initial governing documents for the homeowners association, subject to the approval of the California Department of Real Estate. As a development is being constructed, and sold in phases, a developer will typically serve as a member of the homeowners association board, or appoint handpicked residents to serve on the board. Frequently, developers will draft provisions into the common interest development’s governing document, specifying that a vote of the homeowners association board is required before construction defect litigation can be commenced. Additionally, in some circumstances, the developer may include provisions limiting the homeowners association’s ability to commence such litigation against the developer in some circumstances. Thus, the author contends, existing law provides developers with significant ability to limit their liability for construction defects at common interest developments.
This bill. Seeking to increase adequacy and frequency of inspections of balconies and other exterior features found within common interest developments this bill enacts a mandatory inspection timelines for those features. The bill requires a comprehensive inspection of exterior elements every nine years. In the event the inspection determines there is an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, the inspector must notify the homeowners association and local building regulators. The homeowners association must then immediately take measures to prevent and remedy the threat.
Additionally, this bill seeks to close the apparent loophole whereby a developer can limit its exposure to construction defect liability lawsuits originating from the homeowners association. This bill would prohibit a homeowners association’s governing documents from limiting the board’s authority to commence legal proceedings against a declarant, developer, or builder of a common interest development. Although the bill provides provisions dictating how the board must inform homeowners within the association of the litigation, the bill prohibits preconditions on the board’s ability to initiate litigation. Additionally, the bill provides that notwithstanding the provisions enabling the homeowners association to pursue a construction defect action, the homeowners association must comply with the existing law’s requirements for notifying the developer of the defect and permitting them to resolve the issue out of court. Finally, this bill provides that the sections related to common interest development rules and covenants are retroactive.
This bill ensures that developers cannot use the governing structure of a homeowners association to escape liability. As noted above, the involvement of developers in the creation of the governing documents of common interest developments can result in potential conflicts of interest for the homeowners association board, particularly for decisions that are made when portions of the development remain under construction. Accordingly, this bill vests sole authority to commence litigation in the board and prohibits any developer-affiliated board members from voting in the action. This bill was previously opposed by the California Building Industry Association, who currently hold a support if amended position on the legislation. The California Building Industry Association believes that all homeowners in an association should be permitted to vote on whether to proceed to litigation regarding construction defects, not just the unaffiliated members of the board. The Association states:
We believe that the elimination of the homeowners’ voting rights will result in an imbalance between the Board’s power and the homeowners. The advocates for SB 326 claim that members of the HOA will be protected because the Board has a fiduciary duty to the association. We believe that characterizing HOA Boards as pure as the wind driven snow is naïve and contrary to the facts.
The California Building Industry Association’s position is not without merit. Over the last several years, this Committee has heard several bills seeking to reign in the power of homeowners association boards that arguably are no longer acting in the best interest of the association’s members at large. In fact, this Committee is slated to hear SB 323 (Wieckowski, 2019) to address this very matter later this month. Nonetheless, in arguing that homeowners association boards should not be the sole decision makers when determining whether litigation related construction defects is necessary, the California Business Industry Association cannot also contend that its intentions are “as pure as the wind driven snow.” Indeed, one of the Association’s primary motives in its prior opposition to this measure appeared to focus on retaining its ability to limit a homeowners association’s ability to pursue construction defect lawsuits.
As currently in print, the bill appears to reflect a degree of compromise between the parties. Amendments adopted in the Assembly Committee on Housing and Community Development ensure that this bill does not limit the developer’s right to inspect and remedy defects prior to litigation and provide all homeowners ample notice of potential litigation, thus ensuring that any homeowner wishing to avoid litigation can make their opinions known to the association board. Furthermore, the compromise version of this bill also ensures that the developer retains the right to litigate claims in any forum provided in the original convent for the development, including arbitration or other dispute resolution forums that are likely to favor the developer. Accordingly, the compromise developed in prior committees appears reasonable: developers clearly retain their rights under existing law, while homeowners associations are free to manage their association’s legal affairs without undue influence from parties that may be the subject of the legal issue. This Committee sees no reason to object to the prior compromise or propose any additional changes to the litigation and homeowner notice aspects of this bill.
At its core, this bill is designed to protect residents from potentially dangerous exterior elements on their property. Despite the bill’s righteous focus on conflicts potentially facing homeowners association boards in advance of litigation, at its core, this bill is focused on improving the safety of exterior elevated elements within properties governed by a homeowners association. As noted above, existing law already requires homeowners associations to conduct a visual inspect of these elements every three years. This bill would impose a more stringent inspection requirement, including examining structural waterproofing and the integrity of load bearing components, but requires such inspections to be conducted on a nine-year timeline. The bill imposes significant requirements on a homeowners association that discovers damage that poses an immediate threat in order to ensure that the association remedies the issue immediately before lives are threatened.
However, it should be noted that nine years is a significant period of time in which water damage or other issues may undermine the structural integrity of the exterior elements that this bill seeks to regulate. The coalition of homeowners associations that are supporting this bill note that existing law already requires the homeowners association to maintain, repair, and replace exterior features that fall within the association’s jurisdiction (Civil Code Section 4775(a)), and that individual homeowners may seek to enforce the obligations (Civil Code Section 5575 (a)). Nonetheless, it should be noted that although the members of the homeowners association board possess fiduciary duties to the association, they also retain significant discretion regarding what repairs are made in accordance with the business judgment rule. (See e.g. Frances T. v. Village Green Owners Association (1986) 42 Cal.3d 490.) Accordingly, if an inspection noted some evidence of damage to an exterior elevated element that did not rise to the level of an imminent threat to safety, the board would retain significant leeway as to when and if repairs would be necessary. While a nine-year inspection timeline appears reasonable for structures with no issues, the author may wish to implement a stricter inspection timeline for exterior elevated elements that show signs of damage that does not rise to the level of being an imminent danger. Such provisions would ensure that potential problems are monitored regardless of the priorities of any individual homeowners association board.
As proposed to be amended, this bill recognizes the role of local government and local regulatory agencies. Reflecting the diverse perspectives that various homeowners associations may hold toward maintenance of the property, as currently in print, this bill permits homeowners associations to adopt stricter rules than those provided by the bill. Although such flexibility is likely implicit in the law, the provision provides helpful clarity. However, the inclusion of such a provision casts uncertainty regarding the ability of local governments to impose stricter building inspection rules as their exclusion may be read to prohibit such actions. Accordingly, in order to preserve the power of local government and associated building safety regulators to maintain local control, the author has agreed to add the following subdivision to the proposed Section 5551 of the Civil Code:
(n) A local government or local enforcement agency may enact an ordinance or other rule imposing requirements greater than those imposed by this section.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by the Community Associations Institute, a coalition representing thousands of homeowners associations across California. In support of the bill they write:
Civil Code Section 985 et seq. provides a cause of action for associations to pursue for construction defect matters. However, most builders draft an association’s governing documents to include language restricting a board’s opportunity to pursue actions against the developer and effectively shortens the statute of limitations.
The bill eliminates the barriers imposed by builders to the rights of associations to recover for improper design and construction.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This bill is opposed by Plante Lebovic, LLP a law firm that represents, “real estate developers, home builders, and general contractors in complex construction, real estate, and business litigation.” They believe the bill needlessly strips individual homeowners of their rights to determine whether to pursue litigation and state:
As currently composed, SB 326 will deprive the majority of homeowners in a community of the opportunity to decide whether their home should be included in a lawsuit that could have a significant negative financial impact on them. At odds with the interests of the homeowners, plaintiff construction defect lawyers have a vested interest in making it as easy as possible to get common interest developments into construction defect litigation.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Community Associations Institute- California Legislative Action Committee
Consumer Attorneys of California
Support (if amended)
California Building Industry Association
Opposition
Plante Lebovic, LLP
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 326
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 12, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 28-8
SUBJECT: Common interest developments
SUMMARY: Establishes specified mandatory inspections for exterior elevated elements such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings in common interest developments (CIDs) and prohibits a homeowner association’s (HOA’s) governing documents from limiting the ability of an HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the founder, developer, or builder of the HOA. Specifically, this bill:
- Includes the following definitions:
- “Associated waterproofing systems” include flashings, membranes, coatings, and sealants that protect the load-bearing components of exterior elevated elements from exposure to water.
- “Exterior elevated elements” means the load-bearing components together with the associated waterproofing system.
- “Load bearing components” means those components beyond the exterior walls of the building to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, that have a walking surface six feet above the ground level and are designed for human occupancy or use, and are supported in whole or in substantial part by wood or wood-based products.
- “Statistically significant sample” means a sufficient number of units inspected to provide 95 percent confidence that the results from the sample are reflective of the whole with a margin of error of no greater than plus or minus 5 percent.
- “Visual inspection” means inspection through the least obtrusive method necessary to inspect load-bearing components, including visual observation only or visual observation in conjunction with the use of moisture meters, borescopes or infrared technology.
- Requires an HOA, of a condominium project with three or more units, at least once every nine years, to contract with a licensed structural engineer or architect for a visual inspection of a random and significantly significant sample of exterior elements of the HOA.
- Requires an inspection of the exterior elements of the HOA to determine whether or not they are generally in safe condition and performing in accordance with applicable standards.
- Requires the inspector to generate a random list of locations of each type of exterior elevated element that includes all exterior elevated elements that the HOA has maintained or repaired. The inspector shall provide the HOA the list.
- Requires the inspector to conduct a visual inspection based on the random list to determine if any unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system creating potential damage to the load bearing components.
- Provides that the inspector shall exercise their best professional judgement in determining the necessity for further inspection.
- Provides the inspector shall issue a written report containing the following information:
- An identification of the building components comprising the load bearing components and associated waterproofing system;
- The physical condition of load-bearing components and associated waterproofing systems including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents;
- The expected future performance and remaining useful life of the load bearing components and associated waterproofing system; and
- Recommendation for any necessary repair or replacement of load bearing components and associated waterproofing system.
- Requires the report submitted by the inspector shall be stamped and signed by the inspector and included in the HOAs reserves study.
- Provides that if the inspector determines a risk to safety of the residents as a result of the inspection, the inspector shall provide a copy of the inspection report the HOA immediately upon completion of the report and to the local code enforcement agency within 15 days.
- Requires the HOA to take preventative measures immediately to prevent occupant access to exterior elevated elements until repairs have been inspected and approved by the enforcement agency.
- Allows a local enforcement agency to recover enforcement costs from an HOA.
- Requires the first inspection to be completed on January 1, 2025 and every nine years after in coordination with the reserve study.
- Requires that for buildings for which a building permit application was submitted after January 1, 2020, the first inspection of the exterior elevated elements shall occur six years after the certificate of occupancy is issued.
- Allows an HOA to adopt rules or bylaws that impose requirements beyond what is in this Act.
- Authorizes an HOA to bring an action against a developer or builder of a CID for construction defect after providing notice to the members of the HOA.
- Provides that if the developer or builder sits on the HOA board then the decision to pursue legal proceedings for a construction defect shall be solely in the nonaffiliated board members.
- Provides that the governing documents of the HOA shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board’s authority to pursue and claim, civil action, arbitration, or pre-litigation process against a developer or builder for construction defect.
- Provides that any provision of the governing document that imposes a limitation or preconditions on the board’s authority to pursue litigation for construction defect is valid if it was adopted solely when the developer of the HOA is no longer on the board and was adopted subject to the rules necessary to amend the government documents.
- Applies to all governing documents whether adopted before or after this bill takes effect and retroactively to claims initiated before the effective date of this bill, unless those claims have been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
- Requires at a meeting of an HOA to consider filing a civil action against the developer of a CID, when discussing the impacts of the civil action the HOA shall discuss the potential impacts including any financial impacts, with its members.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, pursuant to SB 721 (Hill, Chapter 445, Statutes of 2018), regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways, and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system, on all buildings with three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in CIDs.
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential CID and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members.
- Provides that, unless otherwise provided in the declaration of a CID, the HOA is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area, as defined, while the individual members are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest (e.g., their individual unit).
- Requires an HOA board to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of all the major components the HOA is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the triannual inspection reserve study requirements of the CID, when the current replacement value of the major components meets a specified threshold.
- Requires an HOA board, at least 30 days prior to filing a civil against a developer or other declarant for damage to a property that the HOA is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify its members in writing of the time and place of a meeting to discuss the problems leading to the filing and options available to address the problems. An HOA board may give this notice within 30 days of filing a civil action if it has reason to believe the applicable statute of limitations will imminently expire.
FISCAL EFFECT: None.
COMMENTS:
Purpose of this bill: According to the author, “SB 326 builds upon last year’s SB 721, which I authored to address balcony inspections and repairs for apartment buildings, following the deadly 2015 Berkeley balcony collapse that killed six and injured seven. SB 326 also requires that existing condominium buildings, governed by homeowners associations (HOAs), have inspections at least once every nine years on a small percentage of their balconies, stairwells, and other exterior elevated elements to ensure they are safe. And SB 326 also prevents builders from placing language in an HOA’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions, or CC&Rs, that would limit the ability of the HOA Board of Directors to sue the developer if there are construction defects. This is not a hypothetical situation. A case is currently being litigated in San Francisco, where a routine water leak revealed that a main walkway on the third floor was about to collapse due to wood rot. When the HOA Board attempted to file a civil suit against the developer, they found requirements in their CC&Rs, placed there by the developer that required a full-member vote before they could legally seek damages. It took the Board months to conduct the member vote, and the statute of limitations on construction defect lawsuits nearly ran out.”
Common interest developments: There are over 52,000 CIDs in the state that comprise over six million housing units, or approximately one quarter of the state's housing stock. CIDs include condominiums, community apartment projects, housing cooperatives, and planned unit developments. They are characterized by a separate ownership of dwelling space coupled with an undivided interest in a common property, restricted by covenants and conditions that limit the use of common area and the separate ownership interests, and the management of common property and enforcement of restrictions by an association. CIDs are governed by the Davis-Stirling Act (the Act) as well as the governing documents of the association, including bylaws, declaration, and operating rules.
CIDs are required to complete a reserve study every three years which includes a visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the common interest development.
Background: SB 721 (Hill) Chapter 445, Statues of 2018, establishes minimum inspection requirements for the exterior elevated elements, including balconies and decks, of buildings with three or more multifamily dwelling units, as specified. The bill was introduced in response to the 2015 Berkeley balcony collapse. The balcony collapse incident, due to decayed wooden joists, killed six young adults and injured seven others, mostly Irish citizens, visiting California as part of a summer exchange program. The incident occurred at the Library Gardens apartment complex, located near the University of California, Berkeley campus. CIDs were not included in SB 721 because CIDs are already required to complete a review of the major components of the CID every three years. After working with representatives of the CID industry, the author introduced SB 326 which requires a review process that works in conjunction with the reserve study.
Construction defect litigation: When CIDs are created the developer writes the governing documents of the HOA subject to the review and approval of the Department of Real Estate. While the HOA developer is still selling off the separate properties within the HOA to homeowners, it is also common for the developer to serve, or appoint people to serve, on the HOA board of directors. Some bylaws require that the members of the HOA vote to approve construction defect lawsuit against the developer. This bill declares null and void any provision in the governing documents purporting to place limitations or preconditions on the HOA board’s ability to initiate a construction defect claim against the developer. It would also prevent board members appointed by or affiliated with the developer from participating in any board decision as to whether or not to pursue a construction defect claim against the developer.
Civil Code Section 6150 already provides some protections against a board suing the developer: it requires an HOA board to hold a meeting of the members 30 days prior to filing a lawsuit, stating its reasoning and laying out the options available to the HOA.
Arguments in support: Supporters of this bill write that the bill will prohibit developer of an HOA from including preconditions in the governing documents that prevent an HOA from recovering for construction defects. They also support efforts to maintain the safety of the balconies and external decks, balconies, stairways, walkways of a CID.
Arguments in opposition: The author has taken amendments to address concerns raised by the California Building Industry Association (BIA), however BIA has remaining concerns with the bill that keeps them opposed. BIA is concerned that the bill would prevent an HOA from participating in arbitration or alternative dispute resolution prior to initiating a construction defect lawsuit against a builder. The bill makes any provision of the governing documents that imposes any limitation or precondition on filing a construction defect lawsuit void and unenforceable. This provision is designed to void any requirement placed in the governing documents by a builder during the development of the HOA that requires the members of an HOA to vote on prior to suing a developer for construction defect. BIA is concerned that this could be interpreted to apply to arbitration or alternative dispute resolution. Those options are available to the HOA and would continue to be available if this bill were to go into effect. BIA has requested an amendment to specify those options are still available to the HOA.
Committee amendment:
The committee may wish to consider the following amendment to further clarify that the bill does not impact any requirement in an HOA’s governing documents to participate in arbitration or alternative dispute resolution.
e) Nothing in this section extends any applicable statute of limitation or repose to file or initiate any claim, civil action, arbitration, prelitigation process, or other legal proceeding. This section shall not affect the obligations of an association contained in Title 7 (commencing with Section 895) of Part 2 of Division 2. Subject to the provisions of subdivisions (a) and (b), this section shall not affect any other obligations of an association contained in Title 7 (commencing with Section 895) of Part 2, Division 2, or other provisions in the association’s CC&Rs related to arbitration or other alternative dispute resolution procedures.
Double-referred: This bill was also referred to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary where it will be heard should it pass out of this committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Community Associations Institute
Consumer Attorneys of California
Opposition
California Building Industry Association
Plante Lebovic, LLP
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 326 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 326
Amended: 5/1/19
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Caballero, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE HOUSING COMMITTEE: 8-2, 4/30/19
AYES: Wiener, Caballero, Durazo, McGuire, Roth, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Morrell, Bates
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SUBJECT: Common interest developments
DIGEST:
This bill makes two changes to the laws governing homeowners associations (HOAs). First, it establishes a mandatory inspection regime for exterior elevated elements (EEEs), such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings, within HOAs. Second it nullifies any provision in an HOA’s governing documents that purports to condition or limit the ability of the HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the developer or builder of the HOA.
Existing law:
- Requires regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system on all buildings containing three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in common interest developments (CIDs). (Health & Saf. Code § 17973.)
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (“Davis-Stirling Act”), the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential CID and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members. (Civ. Code § 4000 et seq.)
- Provides the following definitions for purposes of the Davis-Stirling Act:
- “association” means a nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association created for the purpose of managing a CID (Civ. Code § 4080);
- “common area” means the entire CID except the separate interests therein (Civ. Code § 4095); and
- “exclusive use common area” means a portion of the common area designated by the declaration for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, of the owners of the separate interests and which is or will be appurtenant to the separate interest or interests (Civ. Code § 4145(a)).
- Provides that, unless the declaration states otherwise, any shutters, awnings, window boxes, doorsteps, stoops, porches, balconies, patios, exterior doors, doorframes, and hardware incident thereto, screens and windows or other fixtures designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest. (Civ. Code § 4145(b).)
- Provides that, unless otherwise provided in the declaration of a CID, the HOA is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area; the owners of each separate interest are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest; and the owner of each separate interest is responsible for maintaining the exclusive use common area appurtenant to that separate interest and the association is responsible for repairing and replacing the exclusive use common area. (Civ. Code § 4775.)
- Requires the board of directors of an association to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the CID, when the current replacement value of the major components meets a specified threshold. (Civ. Code § 5550.)
- Requires an HOA board of directors, at least 30 days before filing a civil action against the declarant or other developer for damage to property that the HOA is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify the members of the HOA in writing of:
- the time and place of a meeting to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action; and
- the options, including civil actions, that are available to address the problems. (Civ. Code § 6150(a).)
- Allows an HOA board of directors to give the notice specified in (6), above, within 30 days after filing a civil action if the association has reason to believe that the applicable statute of limitations will expire before the association files the civil action. (Civ. Code § 6150(b).)
This bill:
- Defines “exterior elevated elements” as those components of a building and their associated waterproofing system that:
- have a walking surface elevated more than six feet above ground level;
- extend beyond the exterior walls to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings; and
- are supported in whole or in part as well as the associated waterproofing system.
- Requires an HOA, at least once every nine years, to have a licensed structural engineer or architect conduct a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of a randomly generated and statistically significant sample, as defined, of the EEEs in buildings containing three or more multi-family dwelling units for which the association has maintenance or repair responsibility, to determine if they are in a generally safe condition and performing in accordance with specified standards.
- Defines “visual inspection” as inspection through the least intrusive method necessary to inspect load-bearing components, including visual observation only or visual observation in conjunction with, for example, the use of moisture meters, borescopes, or infrared technology.
- Provides that if, during the visual inspection, the inspector observes building conditions indicating that unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system, thereby creating the potential for damage to the load-bearing components, then the inspector may conduct a further inspection of a scope determined by the inspector’s best professional judgment.
- Directs the inspector, based upon the visual inspection, further inspection, and construction and materials expertise, to issue a written report containing the following information for each exterior elevated element inspected:
- its current physical condition, including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents;
- its expected future performance and remaining useful life; and
- recommendations of any necessary repair or replacement.
- Requires all inspection reports to be stamped or signed by the inspector, presented to the board, incorporated into the HOA’s triannual required reserve study, and maintained permanently as part of the HOA’s records.
- Requires an inspector to notify the HOA and local code enforcement, on specified timelines, of any EEE inspection that reveals an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants.
- Requires an HOA to take preventative measures when an EEE inspection reveals an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, including restricting access to an EEE until the local code enforcement agency inspects and approves repairs.
- Requires the first set of EEE inspections to be completed by January 1, 2025, for existing buildings, and to be completed not later than following the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for buildings for which a building permit application has been submitted on or after January 1, 2020.
- Authorizes an HOA board of directors, subject to compliance with existing statutory meeting notice requirements but not withstanding any provision of the HOA’s governing documents to the contrary, to make the determination of whether and when an association may commence legal action against the HOA’s declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Specifies that if the HOA’s board of directors includes members appointed by, or affiliated with, the developer or builder, the decision and authority to commence and pursue legal proceedings shall be vested solely in the nonaffiliated board members.
- Provides that an HOA’s governing documents shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board’s authority to commence and pursue legal action against the declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Declares unenforceable, null, and void as against public policy any limitation or precondition on an HOA board of director’s authority to pursue legal action against a declarant, developer, or builder, unless that limitation or precondition is lawfully adopted by members of the association not affiliated with the declarant after the declarant has relinquished control of the board and no longer owns a majority of units in the association.
- Provides that the bill’s nullification of the specified governing document provisions applies retroactively to all governing documents, whether recorded before or after the effective date of enactment, and applies retroactively to any claims initiated before the effective date of this section that have not yet been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
Comments
- Overview on EEE inspection regimes. On June 16, 2015, a fourth-floor balcony at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, California, collapsed. The collapse killed six people and injured seven more. A subsequent investigation revealed that years of exposure to moisture led to dry rot along the top of the balcony supports, causing them to give way.
In the wake of this tragedy, local and state agencies and the Legislature moved to address deficiencies in the laws around the construction, maintenance, and inspection of balconies, decks, and other EEEs. One month after the collapse, the Berkeley City Council approved a series of ordinances that require examination of all existing residential balconies in Berkeley and that tighten requirements on the materials and design of future structures.
At the state level, SB 465 (Hill, Chapter 372, Statutes of 2016) established greater oversight over the construction industry. For example, it required contractors convicted of crimes related to their work to report that information to the Contractors State Licensing Board (CSLB). SB 465 also required a working group formed by the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC) to study EEE failures in the state and to submit a report to the Legislature with findings and recommendations for statutory or other changes to the California Building Standards Code.
That working group found data supporting the conclusion that “deterioration of EEEs is a significant problem and illustrates that a post-occupancy inspection program is critical to reducing the risk of failure of existing EEEs.” The working group recommended that “post-occupancy inspection and the requirement for this post-occupancy inspection needs to be strengthened.” The report noted that “[l]egislation may be required to allow state agencies to implement such local inspection programs” and encouraged the Legislature “to write the enabling legislation in a way that allows the appropriate agencies to develop these programs rather than having the programs set forth in detail in the legislation.”
In 2017, SB 721 (Hill, Chapter 441, Statutes of 2017) responded to this call by requiring 15 percent of existing EEEs in multi-family buildings with three or more dwelling units to be inspected at least every six years to ensure that they are in a generally safe condition, adequate working order, and free from any hazardous conditions, as specified.
Though initially included in SB 721, late in the legislative process, HOAs were dropped from its scope. As a result, while multifamily dwellings with three or more units are subject to regular EEE inspections, there is presently no analogous requirement in the HOA context. This bill seeks to fill that gap.
- Overview on HOA governing document provisions that limit or condition commencement of lawsuits against the founder, developer, or builder of an HOA. As part of the creation of a new HOA, the developer typically begins laying the groundwork for the HOA’s future self-governance. This includes establishing the initial governing documents for the HOA, including the HOA’s “declaration” or covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CCRs). While the HOA developer is still selling off the separate properties within the HOA to homeowners, it is also common for the developer to serve, or appoint people to serve, on the HOA board of directors. In these ways, HOA developers exercise a great deal of control over how the HOA will operate going forward, even though, over time, the developer’s direct involvement with the HOA typically fades away.
The involvement of HOA developers in the creation of the HOA’s initial government documents and the appointment of early HOA board members can sometimes create conflicts of interest because the HOA and the developer’s interests are not necessarily aligned.
The second component to this bill addresses one such circumstance. In drafting the governing documents for the HOAs they are creating, developers sometimes add provisions that make it quite difficult for the HOA to sue the developer in the event that construction defects are discovered at the HOA.
While it could be argued that requiring a vote of the HOA members prevents the board of directors from spending the HOA’s money on legal disputes without the support of the members, the fact that these provisions are limited to construction defect claims against the developer suggests that more is afoot. Moreover, Civil Code Section 6150 already provides some protections against an overly litigious board bent on suing the developer: it requires an HOA board to hold a meeting of the members 30 days prior to filing a lawsuit, stating its reasoning and laying out the options available to the HOA.
This bill ensures that developers cannot reap the benefit of having taken advantage of their participation in the creation of the HOA in this way. This bill declares null and void any provision in the governing documents purporting to place limitations or preconditions on the HOA board’s ability to initiate a construction defect claim against the developer. It would also prevent board members appointed by or affiliated with the developer from participating in any board decision as to whether or not to pursue a construction defect claim against the developer.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
Consumer Attorneys of California
Eight individuals
California Building Industry Association
Prepared by: Timothy Griffiths / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/1/19 14:50:56
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HOUSING
Senator Scott Wiener, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 326 Hearing Date: 4/30/2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | 3/27/2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Erin Riches | ||
SUBJECT: Common interest developments
DIGEST: This bill establishes specified mandatory inspections for exterior elevated elements such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings in common interest developments (CIDs) and prohibits a homeowner association’s (HOA’s) governing documents from limiting the ability of an HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the founder, developer, or builder of the HOA.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, pursuant to SB 721 (Hill, Chapter 445, Statutes of 2018), regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways, and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system, on all buildings with three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in CIDs.
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential CID and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members.
- Provides that, unless otherwise provided in the declaration of a CID, the HOA is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area, as defined, while the individual members are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest (e.g., their individual unit).
- Requires an HOA board to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of all the major components the HOA is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the triannual inspection reserve study requirements of the CID, when the current replacement value of the major components meets a specified threshold.
- Requires an HOA board, at least 30 days prior to filing a civil against a developer or other declarant for damage to a property that the HOA is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify its members in writing of the time and place of a meeting to discuss the problems leading to the filing and options available to address the problems. An HOA board may give this notice within 30 days of filing a civil action if it has reason to believe the applicable statute of limitations will imminently expire.
This bill, as proposed to be amended (see “Judiciary Committee Amendments” in comment #8 below):
Definitions
- Defines “exterior elevated elements” (EEEs) as the components of a building that extend beyond the exterior walls to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways, and their railings, that have a walking surface elevated more than six feet above ground level, are designed for human occupancy or use, and that are supported in whole or in substantial part by wood or wood-based products, together with the associated waterproofing system.
- Defines “statistically significant sample” as a sufficient number of units inspected to provide 95% confidence that the results from the sample are reflective of the whole, with a margin of error no greater than plus or minus 5%.
Inspection requirement
- Requires an HOA board, at least once every nine years, to have a licensed structural engineer or architect (hereafter referred to as the inspector) conduct a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of a random and statistically significant sample of the EEEs for which the HOA has maintenance or repair responsibility. Requires this inspection to determine whether the EEEs are in a generally safe condition and performing in accordance to specified standards.
Inspection process
- Requires the inspector, prior to conducting the first visual inspection, to generate a random list of the locations of each type of EEE, including all EEEs for which the HOA has maintenance or repair responsibility. Requires the list to be provided to the HOA for future use.
- Allows the inspector, if they observe building conditions during the visual inspection indicating that unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system, thereby creating the potential for damage to the load-bearing components, to conduct a further inspection of a scope determined by the inspector’s best judgment.
- Requires the inspector, based on their visual inspections, further inspection, and construction and materials expertise, to issue a written report including the following information for each EEE inspected:
- Its current physical condition, including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents.
- Its expected future performance and remaining useful life.
- Recommendations of any necessary repair or replacement.
- Requires the inspector’s report to be stamped or signed by the inspector, presented to the HOA board, and incorporated into the HOA’s triannual inspection reserve study, and maintained for two inspection cycles as part of the HOA’s records.
Inspection follow-up
- Requires the inspector, upon finding that an EEE poses an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, to provide a copy of the inspection report to the HOA immediately, and to the local code enforcement agency within 15 days. Requires the HOA to take preventive measures immediately upon receipt of the report, including preventing occupant access to the EEE until repairs have been inspected and approved by the local enforcement agency. Provides that local enforcement agencies shall have the ability to recover enforcement costs associated with the requirements of this bill.
- Requires the first inspection to be completed by January 1, 2025 for existing buildings, and every nine years thereafter in coordination with the HOA’s triannual inspection reserve study. Requires inspections of buildings for which a building permit application has been submitted on or after January 1, 2020, for buildings with three or more multifamily units, to occur no later than six years following the issuance of a certificate of occupancy.
HOA governing documents
- Allows an HOA board to enact rules or bylaws imposing inspection and follow-up requirements greater than those imposed by this bill.
Litigation
- Requires an HOA board to make the determination of whether and when an HOA may commence a legal proceeding against the developer or builder of the CID. Provides that if the board includes members appointed by, or affiliated with, the declarant, developer, or builder, the decision and authority to commence and pursue legal proceedings shall be vested solely in the non-affiliated board members.
- Prohibits an HOA’s governing documents from imposing preconditions or limits on the HOA board’s authority to commence and pursue any legal proceeding against the developer or builder for construction defects. Provides that any such provision shall be unenforceable, null, and void, except as specified. Applies this provision retroactively to all governing documents, whether recorded before or after the effective date of this bill, and applies retroactively to claims initiated before the effective date of this bill, except if those claims have been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
COMMENTS
- Purpose of the bill. The author states that this bill builds upon SB 721 from last year, which addressed balcony inspections and repairs for existing multifamily, landlord-owned dwellings, following the deadly 2015 Berkeley balcony collapse that killed six and injured seven. Balcony collapses have killed people throughout the state in recent years. In addition to the Berkeley balcony collapse, a stairwell at an apartment building in Folsom collapsed in 2015, killing a Cal Poly student who was visiting a friend. Both the Berkeley and Folsom incidents were found to be a result of poor initial construction and a lack of proper follow-up inspections. This bill requires existing apartment and condominium buildings governed by HOAs to be inspected at least once every nine years to ensure that balconies, stairwells, and other exterior elevated elements are safe. It also prevents builders from placing language in an HOA’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) that would limit the ability of the HOA board of directors to sue the developer if there are defects in the initial construction.
- CID background. A CID is a form of real estate in which each homeowner has an exclusive interest in a unit or lot and a shared or undivided interest in common-area property. Condominiums, planned unit developments, stock cooperatives, community apartments, and many resident-owned mobilehome parks all fall under the umbrella of CIDs. There are more than 50,000 CIDs in California comprising over 4.8 million housing units, or approximately one-quarter of the state’s housing stock. CIDs are governed by HOAs. The Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act provides the legal framework under which CIDs are established and operate. In addition to the requirements of the Act, each CID is governed according to the recorded declarations, bylaws, and operating rules of the HOA, collectively referred to as the governing documents.
- Legislative history: balcony bills. In 2015, during an event at an apartment in the Library Gardens apartment complex, located near the University of California, Berkeley campus, a balcony collapsed, killing six young adults and injuring seven others. Ultimately, the Contractors State License Board (CSLB) revoked the license of the general contractor responsible for building the apartment complex. In response to the collapse, SB 465 (Hill, 2016) established additional oversight for contractors and required the CSLB to establish a working group to study EEE failures and report to the Legislature on its findings and possible recommendations for statutory or other changes to the California Building Standards Code. In 2017, the California Building Standards Commission approved emergency regulations to accelerate the adoption of higher construction standards.
SB 721 (Hill, 2018) requires existing EEEs in buildings with three or more multifamily units, excluding CIDs, to be inspected at least every nine years by licensed individuals in order to determine that EEEs and their associated waterproofing elements are in a general safe condition, adequate working order, and free from any hazardous conditions. SB 721 also requires repairs to be made within a designated timeframe and provides penalties for building owners who fail to complete required repairs.
- Next steps: CIDs. Although SB 721 originally included CIDs, these provisions were removed in the Assembly late in the bill’s two-year process. Existing law requires HOAs to conduct “a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection” of common areas at least once every three years, and to fund repair, replacement, restoration, or maintenance as specified. The Community Associations Institute (CAI), which represents HOAs, states that it opposed SB 721 because it would have resulted in significant costs to CIDs but that it committed to work with the author to find a process CIDs could incorporate into existing requirements. This bill does so by providing for inspections that coincide with CID’s existing cycle for triannual inspection reserve study. CAI supports this bill.
- Comparison to SB 721. This bill is similar to, though not exactly the same as, last year’s bill. Differences include:
- Inspection scope. While SB 721 requires each inspection cycle to include 15% of each type of EEE in a building, this bill calls for a “statistically significant sample” each cycle. This bill defines “statistically significant sample” as a sufficient number of units inspected to provide 95% confidence that the results from the sample are reflective of the whole, with a margin of error no greater than plus or minus 5%. According to the author, this definition is intended to address concerns that a fixed percentage could lead to oversampling or undersampling.
- Inspection process and follow-up. This bill is generally modeled on SB 721 in imposing a mandatory, post-occupancy inspection regime for EEEs. Both bills require the hiring of a qualified outside inspector (though this is defined differently in each bill) to conduct visual inspections and to produce reports that must be submitted to the building owner or HOA board, as appropriate. However, while SB 721 imposes fines on building owners who do not get repairs completed in a timely manner, this bill requires HOAs to immediately take preventive measures, such as preventing occupant access to the EEE in question, until repairs have been inspected and approved by the local enforcement agency.
- HOA governing documents in relation to litigation. As noted earlier, SB 721 excludes CIDs, while this bill establishes an inspection regime specifically for CIDs. As part of the creation of an HOA, a developer typically establishes the initial governing documents and often serves, or appoints people to serve, on the HOA board. This involvement can create conflicts of interest because the interests of the HOA and the developer are not always aligned. To address this concern, this bill nullifies any provisions in an HOA’s governing documents that limit or condition the HOA’s ability to commence litigation against the founder, developer, or builder of an HOA.
- Aren’t HOAs already required to do regular inspections? Existing law requires HOAs to conduct, at least once every three years, “a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection” of accessible areas that the HOA is responsible for maintaining as part of its triannual inspection reserve study. However, there is no requirement for the inspector to have particular expertise in structural or architectural engineering. This bill aims to address that concern by imposing a more specific inspection regime.
- Opposition concerns. The California Building Industry Association (CBIA) states that this bill imposes obstacles on constructing high density, multifamily housing by prohibiting those who purchase a unit in a CID from being informed of the burdens and costs placed on homeowners and from voting on decisions made by the HOA board to enter into litigation. Note that some of CBIA’s concerns are addressed in the amendments approved in Judiciary Committee (see #8 below).
- Judiciary Committee Amendments. The Judiciary Committee approved a number of amendments on April 23rd, which will be taken in this committee due to timing issues. The amendments, which are included in the “This bill” description above, in summary do the following:
- Delete the first section of the bill, which required the developer of an HOA to provide a complete set of architectural and structural plans and specifications to the HOA for each building containing EEEs.
- Provide a definition of “statistically significant.”
- Require notification of the local code enforcement agency when the inspection reveals conditions that constitute an immediate safety threat to HOA occupants.
- Clarify that the bill’s provisions regarding nullification of specified provisions within an HOA’s governing documents do not apply to claims that are time-barred or that have reached final resolution on their merits.
- Double referral. This bill was passed by the Senate Judiciary Committee on a 7-2 vote on April 23rd.
Related Legislation:
SB 721 (Hill, Chapter 445, Statutes of 2018) — established inspection and repair requirements for EEEs, including decks and balconies for buildings with three or more multifamily units; established reporting and repair requirements if repairs are needed, including specific timelines for carrying out the repairs; specified who can complete the inspections and repairs; and provides for civil penalties for building owner violations.
SB 465 (Hill and Hancock, Chapter 372, Statutes of 2016) — among other things, required the CSLB to convene a working group to study recent EEE failures in California. Required the working group to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2018 on its findings and any recommendations for statutory changes or changes to the state building code.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
POSITIONS: (Communicated to the committee before noon on Wednesday,
April 24, 2019.)
SUPPORT:
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
OPPOSITION:
California Building Industry Association
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 326 (Author:Hill)
Version: March 27, 2019
Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Common interest developments
DIGEST
This bill makes two changes to the laws governing homeowners associations (HOAs). First, it establishes a mandatory inspection regime for exterior elevated elements (EEEs), such as balconies, decks, walkways, stairways, and railings, within HOAs. Second it nullifies any provision in an HOA’s governing documents that purports to condition or limit the ability of the HOA to bring construction defect litigation against the developer or builder of the HOA.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The condition of EEEs is vital to the safety of those who use them, as the deaths of six people in a 2015 balcony collapse in Berkeley, California, tragically demonstrated. To help prevent structural failures like that one from recurring, in 2017, California enacted SB 721 (Hill, Ch. 441, Stats. 2017), which mandated the inspection of EEEs at regular intervals on multifamily dwellings. However, late in SB 721’s path through the legislative process, HOAs were dropped from the scope of that bill. This bill now seeks to impose an EEE inspection regime on HOAs that is similar, though not identical to, SB 721’s inspection regime for multifamily dwellings. Separately, this bill would nullify any provision in an HOA governing document that purports to set preconditions or otherwise limit the authority of an HOA’s board of directors to initiate legal action against the developer of the HOA for construction defects. This would prevent HOA developers from making it more difficult or impossible for HOAs to hold those developers accountable for construction defects.
The bill is author-sponsored. It is supported by an organization representing HOAs and an organization representing consumer attorneys. Opposition is from the builders who believe that the bill is unnecessary and worry it could expose them to significant increases in litigation.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Requires regular inspection of elevated decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system on all buildings containing three or more multifamily dwelling units, excluding buildings in common interest developments (CIDs). (Health & Saf. Code § 17973.)
- Establishes, through the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (“Davis-Stirling Act”), the rules and regulations governing the operation of a residential CID and the respective rights and duties of an HOA and its members. (Civ. Code § 4000 et seq.)
- Provides the following definitions for purposes of the Davis-Stirling Act:
- “association” means a nonprofit corporation or unincorporated association created for the purpose of managing a CID (Civ. Code § 4080);
- “common area” means the entire CID except the separate interests therein (Civ. Code § 4095); and
- “exclusive use common area” means a portion of the common area designated by the declaration for the exclusive use of one or more, but fewer than all, of the owners of the separate interests and which is or will be appurtenant to the separate interest or interests (Civ. Code § 4145(a)).
- Provides that, unless the declaration states otherwise, any shutters, awnings, window boxes, doorsteps, stoops, porches, balconies, patios, exterior doors, doorframes, and hardware incident thereto, screens and windows or other fixtures designed to serve a single separate interest, but located outside the boundaries of the separate interest, are exclusive use common areas allocated exclusively to that separate interest. (Civ. Code § 4145(b).)
- Provides that, unless otherwise provided in the declaration of a CID, the HOA is responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining the common area; the owners of each separate interest are responsible for repairing, replacing, and maintaining their separate interest; and the owner of each separate interest is responsible for maintaining the exclusive use common area appurtenant to that separate interest and the association is responsible for repairing and replacing the exclusive use common area. (Civ. Code § 4775.)
- Requires the board of directors of an association to cause to be conducted, at least once every three years, a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of the accessible areas of the major components that the association is obligated to repair, replace, restore, or maintain as part of a study of the reserve account requirements of the CID, when the current replacement value of the major components meets a specified threshold. (Civ. Code § 5550.)
- Requires an HOA board of directors, at least 30 days before filing a civil action against the declarant or other developer for damage to property that the HOA is obligated to maintain or repair, to notify the members of the HOA in writing of:
- the time and place of a meeting to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action; and
- the options, including civil actions, that are available to address the problems. (Civ. Code § 6150(a).)
- Allows an HOA board of directors to give the notice specified in (6), above, within 30 days after filing a civil action if the association has reason to believe that the applicable statute of limitations will expire before the association files the civil action. (Civ. Code § 6150(b).)
This bill:
- Defines “exterior elevated elements” as those components of a building that extend beyond the exterior walls to deliver structural loads to the building from decks, balconies, stairways, walkways and their railings, together with the associated waterproofing system.
- Requires the developer of an HOA to provide a complete set of architectural and structural plans and specifications to the HOA for each building containing EEEs.
- Requires an HOA, at least once every nine years, to have a licensed structural engineer or architect conduct a reasonably competent and diligent visual inspection of a randomly generated and statistically significant sample of the EEEs for which the association has maintenance or repair responsibility, to determine if they are in a generally safe condition and performing in accordance with specified standards.
- Defines “visual inspection” as inspection through the least intrusive method necessary to inspect load-bearing components, including visual observation only or visual observation in conjunction with, for example, the use of moisture meters, borescopes, or infrared technology.
- Provides that if, during the visual inspection, the inspector observes building conditions indicating that unintended water or water vapor has passed into the associated waterproofing system, thereby creating the potential for damage to the load-bearing components, then the inspector may conduct a further inspection of a scope determined by the inspector’s best professional judgment.
- Directs the inspector, based upon the inspector’s review of the architectural and structural plans, visual inspections, further inspection, and construction and materials expertise, to issue a written report containing the following information for each exterior elevated element inspected:
- its current physical condition, including whether the condition presents an immediate threat to the health and safety of the residents;
- its expected future performance and remaining useful life; and
- recommendations of any necessary repair or replacement.
- Requires all inspection reports to be stamped or signed by the inspector, presented to the board, incorporated into the HOA’s triannual required reserve study, and maintained permanently as part of the HOA’s records.
- Requires the first set of EEE inspections to be completed by January 1, 2025, for existing buildings, and to be completed not later than following the issuance of a certificate of occupancy for buildings for which a building permit application has been submitted on or after January 1, 2020.
- Authorizes an HOA board of directors, subject to compliance with existing statutory meeting notice requirements but not withstanding any provision of the HOA’s governing documents to the contrary, to make the determination of whether and when an association may commence legal action against the HOA’s declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Specifies that if the HOA’s board of directors includes members appointed by, or affiliated with, the developer or builder, the decision and authority to commence and pursue legal proceedings shall be vested solely in the nonaffiliated board members.
- Provides that an HOA’s governing documents shall not impose any preconditions or limitations on the board’s authority to commence and pursue legal action against the declarant, developer, or builder for construction defects.
- Declares unenforceable, null, and void as against public policy any limitation or precondition on an HOA board of director’s authority to pursue legal action against a declarant, developer, or builder, unless that limitation or precondition is lawfully adopted by members of the association not affiliated with the declarant after the declarant has relinquished control of the board and no longer owns a majority of units in the association.
- Provides that the bill’s nullification of the specified governing document provisions applies retroactively to all governing documents, whether recorded before or after the effective date of enactment, and applies retroactively to any claims initiated before the effective date of this section.
COMMENTS
- Background on HOAs in California
CIDs, often referred to as homeowners associations or HOAs, are self-governing groups of dwellings that share common spaces and amenities. They come in a wide variety of physical layouts: condominium complexes, apartment buildings, and neighborhoods of detached, single-family residences, for example. Some consist of thousands of units. Others are made up of just a handful. Dwellings within common housing developments currently account for approximately a quarter of the state’s overall housing stock, meaning that the laws overseeing such developments have a large impact on the population. In California, HOAs are primarily governed by the Davis-Stirling Act. (Civ. Code §§ 4000-6150.)
- Background on EEE inspection regimes
On June 16, 2015, a fourth-floor balcony at the Library Gardens apartment complex in Berkeley, California, collapsed. The collapse killed six people and injured seven more. A subsequent investigation revealed that years of exposure to moisture led to dry rot along the top of the balcony supports, causing them to give way.
In the wake of this tragedy, local and state agencies and the Legislature moved to address deficiencies in the laws around the construction, maintenance, and inspection of balconies, decks, and other EEEs. One month after the collapse, the Berkeley City Council approved a series of ordinances that require examination of all existing residential balconies in Berkeley and that tighten requirements on the materials and design of future structures.
At the state level, SB 465 (Hill, Ch. 372, Stats. 2016) established greater oversight over the construction industry. For example, it required contractors convicted of crimes related to their work to report that information to the Contractors State Licensing Board (CSLB). SB 465 also required a working group formed by the California Building Standards Commission (CBSC) to study EEE failures in the state and to submit a report to the Legislature with findings and recommendations for statutory or other changes to the California Building Standards Code.
That working group found data supporting the conclusion that “deterioration of EEEs is a significant problem and illustrates that a post-occupancy inspection program is critical to reducing the risk of failure of existing EEEs.” The working group recommended that “post-occupancy inspection and the requirement for this post-occupancy inspection needs to be strengthened.” The report noted that “[l]egislation may be required to allow state agencies to implement such local inspection programs” and encouraged the Legislature “to write the enabling legislation in a way that allows the appropriate agencies to develop these programs rather than having the programs set forth in detail in the legislation.”
In 2017, SB 721 (Hill, Ch. 441, Stats. 2017) responded to this call by requiring 15 percent of existing EEEs in multi-family buildings with three or more dwelling units to be inspected at least every six years to ensure that they are in a generally safe condition, adequate working order, and free from any hazardous conditions, as specified.
- Inspection of EEEs in the HOA context
Though initially included in SB 721, late in the legislative process, HOAs were dropped from its scope. As a result, while multifamily dwellings with three or more units are subject to regular EEE inspections, there is presently no analogous requirement in the HOA context. This bill seeks to fill that gap.
In its general imposition of a mandatory, post-occupancy inspection regime for EEEs, this bill is modeled on SB 721, and several details of the bill are similar. Both regimes require the hiring of a qualified outside inspector (though the qualifications requirements vary slightly between the bills) to conduct visual inspections, as defined, and to produce reports that must be submitted to the building owner, or, in the HOA context, to the HOA board.
However, other aspects of this bill are significantly different from SB 721. For instance, while SB 721 required inspections to take place every six years, this bill only requires them every nine. Similarly, while SB 721 requires each inspection cycle to include 15 percent of each type of EEE in a building, this bill calls for inspection of a “statistically significant sample” each cycle.
Perhaps most importantly, though, SB 721 included a mechanism for follow up from any inspection that resulted in a finding that repairs are needed. Under SB 721, when the inspector advises that the condition of an inspected EEE poses an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, the inspector must provide a copy of the inspection report to the local enforcement agency responsible for upholding building codes and the building owner is required to undertake preventive measures immediately. Even in the case of repairs that are needed but less urgent, SB 721 requires building owners to apply for a permit to make the repairs within 120 days. Moreover, SB 721 imposed fines on building owners who did not get the repairs done in a timely fashion. In these ways, SB 721 included mechanisms that ensured that its inspection regime did not just result in identification of problems, but also fixing them.
By contrast, this bill does not contain any follow up mechanism, provides for no notification to the local enforcement agency of immediate threats to the safety of occupants, and imposes no consequences if no action is taken in response to an inspection report that finds an EEE in need of repair. Instead, the bill simply states that “continued and ongoing maintenance of the load-bearing components and associated waterproofing systems in a safe, functional, and sanitary condition shall be the responsibility of the association as required by the association’s governing documents.” In opposing the bill, the California Builders Association characterizes the bill’s EEE inspection regime as “unnecessary and less protective of consumers than existing law.”
While the HOA context is unique in many respects, it may be worth inquiring whether the unique aspects of the HOA context fully justify all of the differences between SB 721 and this bill. For example, wood rots just as quickly whether it is part of an HOA or a multifamily building outside of an HOA, so it may be worth inquiring how a nine-year interval between inspections is appropriate in one context, while six-year intervals are required in the other. Proponents of the bill assert that the longer interval is justified in the HOA context because HOAs facilities are subject to triannual visual inspections as part of the reserve study required by Civil Code Section 5550. This is true, but while the reserve study must be “competent and diligent,” no particular expertise in structural or architectural engineering is required, as they would be under this bill’s inspection regime.
With regard to follow-up provisions requiring corrective action to be done within a certain time when an inspection reveals that an EEE is in need of repair, the proponent argue that, in the HOA context, the potential need to raise funds through special assessments to cover the cost of the EEE repairs means that imposing timelines on an HOA is not appropriate. Similarly, proponents assert that an HOA’s fiduciary duties to its members will motivate it to make repairs without the threat of fines. On the other hand, it can be inquired whether that explanation is sufficient to justify the absence of any consequence for failure to take corrective action and the absence of any notification to local code enforcement, particularly in those cases where the inspection has revealed an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants. In response to these concerns, the author proposes to offer amendments in Committee that would require notification to local code enforcement whenever the EEE inspection reveals a situation that poses an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants. The proposed amendment would also require the HOA to take immediate preventative measures to prevent use of the dangerous EEE until the local code enforcement agency inspects and approves the work done to repair the EEE.
4. How many inspections are needed for a statistically significant sample?
The bill requires HOAs to have a licensed structural engineer or architect conduct a “statistically significant” number of inspections every nine years. Generally, the term “statistically significant” refers to a sample size sufficiently large to provide confidence that the results returned from the sample are reflective of the whole, and not merely the result of random variation. Whether any given sample size is statistically significant depends upon the outcome of the inspections, however, as well as the level of confidence desired.
SB 721 (Hill, Ch. 441, Stats. 2017) utilized a standard sample size of 15 percent of each type of EEE. The proponents of this bill argue that the use of a fixed percentage like that could result in oversampling, something that would increase costs to the HOAs without any associated benefit. A fixed percentage could also lead to undersampling in a scenario in which the first few inspections reveal a high frequency of EEEs in need of repair. The concept of statistical significance would seem to address both of these concerns, but further definition of the term, including the level of confidence required, may be necessary in order to avoid legal disputes about what sample size is needed to be compliant under the bill. To address this issue, the author proposes to offer amendments in Committee that would further define “statistically significant sample.”
- Background on creation of HOA governing documents
As part of the creation of a new HOA, the developer typically begins laying the groundwork for the HOA’s future self-governance. This includes establishing the initial governing documents for the HOA, including the HOA’s “declaration” or covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CCRs). While the HOA developer is still selling off the separate properties within the HOA to homeowners, it is also common for the developer to serve, or appoint people to serve, on the HOA board of directors. In these ways, HOA developers exercise a great deal of control over how the HOA will operate going forward, even though, over time, the developer’s direct involvement with the HOA typically fades away.
- Nullification of HOA governing document provisions that limit or condition commencement of lawsuits against the founder, developer, or builder of an HOA
The involvement of HOA developers in the creation of the HOA’s initial government documents and the appointment of early HOA board members can sometimes create conflicts of interest because the HOA and the developer’s interests are not necessarily aligned.
The second component to this bill addresses one such circumstance. In drafting the governing documents for the HOAs they are creating, developers sometimes add provisions that make it quite difficult for the HOA to sue the developer in the event that construction defects are discovered at the HOA. The author provides two illustrative examples of such clauses:
In the event that any claim or other actions brought by the Association under California Civil Code section 895 et. seq., (or any successor statutes or laws) involving allegations of construction defects relating to the Association Common Areas or Common Facilities is not resolved pursuant to the non-adversarial procedures set forth in Civil Code sections 910-938 (or any successor statutes or laws), the Association shall not initiate further action or procedures against the Declarant pursuant to Section 13.08, below (Arbitration of Disputes) without first obtaining the consent of a Majority of a Quorum of the Members.
--------
In the event the Board decides to commence binding arbitration proceedings under the Limited Warranty or decides to commence any other legal proceedings against any of the Declarant Parties […] relating to construction defect Disputes, the Secretary shall call a special meeting of the Corporation. In addition to the information required by Section 6000 to be specified in the notice of such meeting, the notice shall also specify the following: (a) the estimated costs to repair the defects; (b) how the necessary repairs will be funded; (c) the name of the attorney whom the Corporation is contemplating retaining and an estimate of the attorney’s fees, consultant’s fees and any other costs to be incurred to prosecute such proceedings; (d) how such fees and costs will be funded; (e) each Member’s duty to disclose to prospective purchasers the alleged defects; and (f) the potential impact the proceedings may have on the marketability and availability of financing for Condominiums in the Project. Such notice shall be sent to all Members of the Corporation. The decision of the Board to commence any other legal proceedings against any of the Declarant Parties relating to a construction defect Dispute must be approved by not less than fifty-one percent (51%) of the voting power of the Corporation residing in Members other than the Declarant.
While it could be argued that requiring a vote of the HOA members prevents the board of directors from spending the HOA’s money on legal disputes without the support of the members, the fact that these provisions are limited to construction defect claims against the developer suggests that more is afoot. Moreover, Civil Code Section 6150 already provides some protections against an overly litigious board bent on suing the developer: it requires an HOA board to hold a meeting of the members 30 days prior to filing a lawsuit, stating its reasoning and laying out the options available to the HOA.
This bill would ensure that developers cannot reap the benefit of having taken advantage of their participation in the creation of the HOA in this way. The bill would declare null and void any provision in the governing documents purporting to place limitations or preconditions on the HOA board’s ability to initiate a construction defect claim against the developer. It would also prevent board members appointed by or affiliated with the developer from participating in any board decision as to whether or not to pursue a construction defect claim against the developer.
Proponents of the bill point out that it would be consistent with a recent Supreme Court of Massachusetts ruling that invalidated governing document provisions designed to inoculate the developer against construction defect claims. That court found such provisions to be void as against public policy, writing:
[i]t is overreaching for a developer to impose a condition precedent that, for all practical purposes, makes it extraordinarily difficult or even impossible for the [Board of Directors] to initiate any litigation against the developers regarding the common areas and facilities of a condominium. Such a provision has all the same flaws as a waiver of liability provision — which we would find void as contravening public policy — but without the transparency of such a provision. (Trustees of the Cambridge Point Condominium Trust v. Cambridge Point, LLC (2018) 478 Mass. 697, 709.)
The California Building Industry Association opposes this aspect of the bill, arguing that it goes too far:
we see no good reason for prohibiting a homeowner from being informed of the action the board is contemplating and its potential consequences to the homeowner. The claim process may require the homeowner to take time out of their day to allow inspections of their home, participate in depositions, testify as a witness and expose them to other burdens that they have a right to know about before the decision is made to proceed with litigation. Not obtaining the informed consent of these homeowners will result in hiding facts and burdens from the affected consumer and promotes uninformed decision making.
As mentioned, however, Civil Code Section 6150 already requires an HOA board to give notice and hold a meeting explaining its reasoning and plans for undertaking litigation of this type. In addition, this bill does not prohibit HOAs from placing limitations or restrictions on the initiation of lawsuits against the developer, so long as the developer does not participate, directly or indirectly, in the decision to do so.
As it appears in print, the bill would apply retroactively, not just to any governing documents sitting around out there, but also to pending construction defect claims. Even if it makes policy sense for the bill to nullify these self-serving provisions within existing HOA governing documents generally, this general rule becomes more problematic when applied to pending claims. Historically, this Committee has sought to avoid interfering with or altering the outcome of pending litigation. Nonetheless, as the Massachusetts Supreme Court’s decision suggests, these provisions raise such concern that the courts might well find them void as against public policy regardless of whether this bill passes. The Committee might find retroactive application to pending claims appropriate under that narrow circumstance.
At the same time, the language in the bill is written so broadly that it could be interpreted to allow for the revival of lapsed claims or claims that have already been resolved on their merits. That this is not the bill’s intent and the author proposes to offer an amendment in Committee that would limit the bill’s retroactivity to claims that are not time-barred and that have not been resolved on their merits.
7. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill. In order to facilitate the transition of the bill to the Senate Housing Committee, which will consider the bill next, these amendments will be processed in that committee. The amendments would, among other things:
- provide a definition of “statistically significant”;
- require notification of the local code enforcement when the inspection reveals conditions that constitute an immediate safety threat to HOA occupants; and
- clarify that the bill’s provisions regarding nullification of specified provisions within an HOA’s governing documents do not apply to claims that are time-barred or that have reached final resolution on their merits.
The specific amendments are as follows:
Amendment 1
On page 2, in line 1, strike out “Section 4770 is added to the Civil Code, to read:” and strike out lines 2 to 13, inclusive.
Amendment 2
On page 2, in line 14, strike out “SEC. 2.”
Amendment 3
On page 3, in line 10, after “loads” insert:
to the building
Amendment 4
On page 3, in lines 10 and 11 strike out “the exterior elevated element to the building, including, but not limited to,”
Amendment 5
On page 3, in line 12, strike out “railings.” and insert:
railings that have a walking surface elevated more than six feet above ground level, that are designed for human occupancy or use, and that are supported in whole or in substantial part by wood or wood-based products.
(4) “Statistically significant sample” means a sufficient number of units inspected to provide 95 percent confidence that the results from the sample are reflective of the whole, with a margin of error of no greater than plus or minus 5 percent.
Amendment 6
On page 3, in line 13, strike out “(4)” and insert:
(5)
Amendment 7
On page 3, in lines 22 and 23, strike out “load-bearing components and associated waterproofing systems” and insert:
exterior elevated elements
Amendment 8
On page 3, strike out lines 29 and 30.
Amendment 9
On page 3, in line 31, strike out “The inspector”
Amendment 10
On page 3, in line 33, strike out “at the condominium project”
Amendment 11
On page 4, in lines 5 and 6, strike out “review of the architectural and structural plans,”
Amendment 12
On page 4, after line 23, insert:
(g) (1) If, after inspection of any exterior elevated element, the inspector advises that the exterior elevated element poses an immediate threat to the safety of the occupants, the inspector shall provide a copy of the inspection report to the to the association immediately upon completion of the report, and to the local code enforcement agency within 15 days of completion of the report. Upon receiving the report, the association shall take preventive measures immediately, including preventing occupant access to the exterior elevated element until repairs have been inspected and approved by the local enforcement agency.
(2) Local enforcement agencies shall have the ability to recover enforcement costs associated with the requirements of this section.
Amendment 13
On page 4, in line 24, strike out “(g)” and insert:
(h)
Amendment 14
On page 4, in line 28, strike out “h” and insert:
(i)
Amendment 15
On page 4, in line 31, strike out “permanently” and after “maintained” insert:
for two inspection cycles
Amendment 16
On page 4, in line 33, strike out “(i)” and insert:
(j)
Amendment 17
On page 5, in line 1, strike out “(j)” and insert:
(k)
Amendment 18
On page 5, after line 5, insert:
(l) This section shall only apply to buildings containing three or more multifamily dwelling units.
(m) The association board may enact rules or bylaws imposing requirements greater than those imposed by this section.
Amendment 19
On page 5, in line 6, strike out “3.” and insert:
2.
Amendment 20
On page 6, in line 9, strike out “any”
Amendment 21
On page 6, in line 10, strike out “section.” and insert:
section, except if those claims have been resolved through an executed settlement, a final arbitration decision, or a final judicial decision on the merits.
8. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
A SB 326 builds upon SB 721 from 2017, which addressed balcony inspections and repairs for existing, multi-family, landlord-owned dwellings, following the deadly 2015 Berkeley balcony collapse that killed six and injured seven.
SB 326 establishes inspection requirements for the exterior elevated elements of existing, multi-family common interest developments, like homeowners associations.
SB 326 also prevents builders from placing language in an HOA’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions, or CC&Rs, that would limit the ability of the HOA Board of Directors to sue the developer if there are defects in the initial construction.
The opposition to this bill contends that it is anti-consumer. I firmly disagree. This bill simply extends the consumer protections from SB 721 to residents of common interest dwellings.
The opposition to this bill also claims it is anti-democracy. Again, I firmly disagree. An HOA Board of Directors is democratically elected to represent the best interests of their members, just as we are in this body. Developers have no business limiting their fiduciary obligation to act in the best interests of the community.
In support, Community Associations Institute – California Legislative Action Committee writes:
In 2018, CAI-CLAC opposed SB 721 because the requirements proposed in it pertaining to Common Interest Developments (CIDs) would have resulted in significant costs. The CID language was deleted from the bill in the Assembly and we agreed to work together to find a process CIDS could incorporate into existing requirements with a specific focus on elevated elements, like balconies. The language in SB 326 does just that by allowing for an inspection every 9 years that coincides with the existing cycle for reserve fund inspections. This will allow community members to fund necessary repairs over time and decrease the incidence of special assessments.
9. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Building Association writes to express its belief that: (1) the bill’s requirements will force disclosure of copyrighted material in architectural and structural plans; (2) the bill’s nullification of restrictions on an HOA board’s ability to sue developers for construction defects undermines the democratic self-governance process within HOAs; and (3) that the bill’s EEE inspection is unnecessary in light of the existing construction defect laws. Details on these concerns are discussed in the corresponding Comments, above.
SUPPORT
Community Associations Institute - California Legislative Action Committee
Consumer Attorneys of California
Eight individuals
OPPOSITION
California Building Industry Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 721 (Hill, Ch. 441, Stats. 2017) established inspection and repair requirements for EEEs as defined, including decks and balconies for buildings with three or more multifamily dwelling units. The bill established reporting and repair requirements if repairs are needed, including specific timelines for carrying out the repairs and specified who can complete the inspections and repairs. It also provided for civil penalties against building owners for violations.
SB 465 (Hill, Ch. 372, Stats. 2016) established greater oversight over the construction industry and required the CBSC working group tasked with studying recent EEE failures, the Exterior Elevated Element (EEE) working group to submit a report to the Legislature containing any findings and possible recommendations for statutory changes or changes to the California Building Standards Code by January 1, 2018.
**************
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):