SB 328: Pupil attendance: school start time.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-13
Existing law requires the governing board of each school district to fix the length of the schoolday for the several grades and classes of the schools maintained by the school district in accordance with specified provisions of law.
This bill would require the schoolday for middle schools and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, to begin no earlier than 8:00 a.m. and 8:30 a.m. a.m., respectively, by July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school districts or charter schools respective collective bargaining agreement that is operative on January 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later, except for rural school districts. To the extent the bill imposes new duties on school districts and charter schools, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would encourage the State Department of Education to post specified information on its internet website, including research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time, and to advise school districts and charter schools of this posting.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)(1)The schoolday for middle schools and high schools, including middle schools and high schools operated as charter schools, shall begin no earlier than 8:30 a.m.
(2)The schoolday for middle schools, including middle schools operated as charter schools, shall begin no earlier than 8:00 a.m.
(b)For purposes of this section, schoolday does not include a zero period, or an extra period offered before the start of the regular schoolday. has the same meaning as defined by the school district or charter school for purposes of calculating average daily attendance in order to compute any apportionments of state funding. This section does not prohibit a school district or charter school from offering classes or activities to a limited number of pupils before the start of the schoolday that do not generate average daily attendance for purposes of computing any apportionments of state funding.
(c)This section shall be implemented by middle schools and high schools no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school districts or charter schools respective collective bargaining agreement that is operative on January 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
(d)This section shall not apply to rural school districts.
(e)The department is encouraged to post on its internet website available research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time and examples of successful strategies for managing the change to a later school start time, and to advise school districts and charter schools of this posting.
(f)The Legislature encourages school districts, charter schools, and community organizations to inform their communities, including parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders, about the health, safety, and academic impact of sleep deprivation on middle and high school pupils and the benefits of a later school start time, and to discuss local strategies to successfully implement the later school start time.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 4.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 13, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 868, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 13, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 20, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 10 a.m. |
| Sep 16, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 14, 2019 | August 14 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 30, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 22, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 24. Noes 9.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 8, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 24). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | April 10 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 8, 2019 | Set for hearing April 10. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 21. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | SB 328 Portantino Senate Third Reading By Gloria | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB328 Portantino et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 328
Author:(Portantino)
As Amended Ver:May 8, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. Prohibits middle schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits the schoolday for high schools, including high schools operated as charter schools, from beginning earlier than 8:30 a.m.
- Prohibits the schoolday for middle schools, including middle schools operated as charter schools, from beginning earlier than 8:00 a.m.
- Defines "schoolday" as having the same meaning as defined by the school district or charter school for purposes of calculating average daily attendance in order to compute any apportionments of state funding.
- Authorizes school districts and charter schools to offer classes or activities to a limited number of pupils before the start of the schoolday that do not generate average daily attendance for purposes of computing any apportionments of state funding.
- Requires that the specified start times be implemented by middle schools and high schools no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district's or charter school's respective collective bargaining agreement that is operative on January 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
- Exempts rural school districts from required start times.
COMMENTS:
According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average start time for middle and high schools in California was 8:07 a.m. in 2011-12. Under California's system of education governance, most aspects of the operation of schools are determined by locally elected governing boards. This bill raises fundamental questions about the balance of state and local control. Local governing boards and the governing bodies of charter schools currently have the authority to set school start times based both on the existing body of research, and the needs of students and the community. This bill could have unintended impacts on numerous programs, including: home-to-school transportation, before and after school programs, supervision of students, extracurricular activities (including athletics), and collective bargaining.
A number of studies over the last 15 years have investigated the impact of delayed school start times on student outcomes and adolescent sleep, with wide variation in conclusions and study design. More longitudinal research is needed to study if initial improvements due to delayed school start times persist. The widely-cited 2014 Policy Statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics, School Start Times for Adolescents, includes five recommendations. Of those recommendations for their primary audience, pediatricians, to consider, only two include language regarding delaying school start times. The remaining recommendations include information about sleep education and modifying adolescent sleep behavior.
If this bill is enacted, California would become the first state to adopt a late school start time statewide. According to the Start School Later, Inc. website, Indiana, Maryland, New Jersey and Pennsylvania have passed laws to study school start times. Several other states are hearing legislation this year to either study, create a pilot, or mandate specified school start times.
According to the Author:
"SB 328 is based on the recommendations of the American Academy of Pediatricians and the Centers for Disease Control. These organizations issued their recommendations after reviewing extensive academic research on the sleep science and biology of teens and concluding that our children's well-being deserves to be the primary focus when setting school start time. There is overwhelming evidence that moving high school and middle school start time later in the day increases academic performance and the public health of teenage students. It is appropriate and consistent for the State Legislature to enact minimum public health standards based on medical and biological research."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters cite research showing 1) the negative effects of sleep deprivation among adolescents and 2) that start times of 8:30 a.m. or later reverses those effects. They assert that adolescent sleep deprivation "is a public health issue that deserves a serious immediate response," and that starting school later is a "simple and obvious fix." Supporters also argue that adolescents' brains are "hard wired" to not sleep before 11:00 p.m., so simply going to bed earlier is not a solution. Finally, they argue that schools benefit from later start times, because experience has shown that the later time results in increased attendance (which increases school district revenue), reduced tardiness, improved academic performance, and a lower incidence of behavioral problems.
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Elk Grove Unified School District, "…the permissive nature of the California Education Code currently allows Local Education Agencies to set their own start times. The fact that today more than one in five school districts voluntarily meet SB 328's standards proves the bill is unnecessary for communities that would be well served by later start times. For communities and school agencies that would be burdened by a later school schedule, however, SB 328 would present tremendous difficulties with significant opportunity costs. And because school schedules have such a wide-ranging and significant impact on operations and expenses, a great number of districts would be hurt by this legislation for a number of different reasons. Determining school schedules is a decision that even more than most should reflect specific conditions and be decided locally, not from Sacramento."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the tens of millions of dollars statewide, for school districts and charter schools to make changes to school transportation. Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the millions of dollars annually statewide, to hire additional bus drivers.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the low millions of dollars statewide, for schools districts and charter schools to provide additional staff time for student supervision before and after school.
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, to school districts for collective bargaining workload.
The state may need to reimburse associated costs to schools or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 24-9-5
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Chang, Dodd, Galgiani, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Jones, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Rubio, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Caballero, Glazer, Grove, Leyva, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Borgeas, Durazo, Hurtado, Roth, Stern
ASM EDUCATION: 4-1-2
YES: Kiley, Kalra, McCarty, Weber
NO: O'Donnell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep, Smith
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-3-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 8, 2019
CONSULTANT: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0001664
Date of Hearing: August 14, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 328
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:May 8, 2019
Policy Committee: | Education | Vote: | 4 - 1 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits middle schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m. and high schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires its provisions to be implemented by middle schools and high schools by no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district’s collective bargaining agreement that is operative on July 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
- Exempts rural schools from its provisions.
- Specifies that its provisions do not prohibit a school district or charter school from offering classes or activities to a limited number of students before the start of the schoolday, as long as they do not generate average daily attendance funding from the state.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the tens of millions of dollars statewide, for school districts and charter schools to make changes to school transportation to accommodate start times imposed by this bill. Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the millions of dollars annually statewide, to hire additional bus drivers. These estimates assume about 10% of school districts and charter schools change their bus routes, buy a new bus and hire one additional bus driver as a result of this bill. These potential costs are described in more detail in comment #3.
- Ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the low millions of dollars statewide, for schools districts and charter schools to provide additional staff time for student supervision before and after school. This estimate assumes about 10% of schools will need to hire an additional staff member for supervision of students before and after school. These potential costs are described in in more detail in comment #4.
- One-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars, to school districts for additional workload associated with collectively bargaining work hours. This estimate assumes about 10% of school districts will have costs associated with collectively bargaining terms required by this bill. These potential costs are described in in more detail in comment #5.
If the Commission on State Mandates (CSM) determines this bill to be a reimbursable state-mandated local program, the state would need to reimburse associated costs to schools or provide funding through the K-12 Mandate Block Grant, described in more detail in comment #6.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Current law gives schools districts and charter schools discretion in determining school hours, as long as a certain number of instructional minutes are provided to students. To change existing school hours or implement an alternative schedule, current law requires the governing board of a school district to consult in good faith in an effort to reach agreement with the certificated and classified employees of the school, with the parents of students who would be affected by the change and with the community at large. It also requires the consultation to include at least one public hearing for which the board has given adequate notice to the employees and to the parents of students affected.
- How Many Schools Do Not Meet Bill’s Requirements Currently? This bill would require non-rural middle and high schools not already in compliance with its mandated start times to adjust their school schedules. To determine the number of schools that would need to change their start times, we must first determine how many middle and high schools are not currently in compliance and then determine how many of those schools are non rural. Using the latest available data on school start times is from the 2011-12 school year, and applying it to the number of schools serving middle and high school students, a total of about 3,000 schools have current start times that are before the bill’s start times. Using the federal definition of “rural,” 20% of California schools would be exempt. Therefore, this bill would require about 2,500 of the state’s 11,800 schools (or about 20%) to change their start times.
- School Transportation. A school is not required to provide transportation to a student unless it is required in a student’s Individualized Education Program (IEP). (The federal Individuals With Disabilities Education Act requires each child with a disability who attends public school to have an IEP, which is a document that includes information about the student’s disabilities and how service providers will help the student reach their full potential.) Some school districts, however, elect to provide transportation for non IEP students. In either case, school districts and charter schools may need to modify their bus schedules to adhere to the start times required in this bill. School districts commonly stagger their school start times to allow them to use fewer buses. For example, a district might start high school at 7:30 a.m., middle school at 8:00 a.m. and elementary school at 9:00 a.m. to allow one bus to drop off at multiple locations over time. This bill could result in districts needing to reconfigure their bus schedules, which could result in additional need for buses and bus drivers.
- Before and After School Supervision. This bill does not require schools to provide additional before or after school supervision, however, some schools may need to offer additional supervision in order to accommodate later school start times. For example, this bill could result in some families who are unable to take their children to school at a later time dropping their children off before school or result in families needing additional after school care for younger children whose older siblings can no longer supervise them due to a later release time.
- Work Hours and Collective Bargaining. Current law establishes collective bargaining rights for public school teachers, and gives teachers the right to elect an exclusive representative to bargain wages and working conditions with their local school boards. Various mandatory issues fall under this “scope of representation,” including hours of employment. To the extent that teacher preparation periods or professional development activities are impacted by this measure and there are related provisions included in a local contract, there could be additional workload on some school districts to negotiate and reach new agreements, which could result in additional local district costs.
- Reimbursable Mandates. The State Constitution requires the state to reimburse units of local government for all costs mandated by the state, with some exceptions. These costs may result from either legislative acts or administrative regulations that impose a new program or demand an increased level of service in an existing program. In the area of K-12 education, school districts are considered local governments. Although some state-mandated activities also apply to charter schools, the CSM deemed charter schools ineligible for reimbursement beginning in 2006.
Currently, school districts can either opt to use the tradition mandate claims process which is intended to provide reimbursements for a specific mandated activity or participate in the K-12 Mandates Block Grant program. The vast majority of school districts participate in the block grant, which was created by the state as part of the 2012-13 budget. The block grant is intended to address various concerns with the traditional mandate claims process, such as the disincentive for school districts to perform mandated tasks efficiently. The amount of funding available in the block grant annually is tied to the number of K-12 mandates the CSM has found to be reimbursable and the mandates’ statewide cost. (Typically, when the CSM has determined a claim filed by an school district to be reimbursable, it has developed a statewide cost estimate for performing the mandate and the state has added the estimated amount or a portion of the estimated amount to the block grant as part of its annual budget process.)
School districts that choose to participate in the block grant program receive per-student funding to cover the cost of state-mandated activities in lieu of submitting ongoing mandate claims for reimbursement. Charter schools may participate in the block grant, but they may not submit mandate claims or have the option of receiving reimbursement for mandated costs instead of block grant funds. School districts receive from the block grant a per-student funding rate for K-8 students of about $30 and about $60 provided for high school students. Charter schools receive half the K‑8 per-student funding rate of school districts, because about half of K-8 mandates apply to them. Similarly, about half of high school mandates apply to charter schools, but their grades 9‑12 rate is more than half the district rate, or about $40, because of the treatment of certain mandates.
- Schools Likely Would Take Actions to Reduce Costs Over the Longer Term. In the longer term, school districts and charter schools will likely make administrative changes to adjust to the start times imposed by this bill and reduce local costs. There likely will be tradeoffs associated with these decisions. For example, in reaction the increased cost of providing after school supervision that may result from this bill, a school district may take actions to modify elementary school start times to better match middle and high school start times. Another school district, in reaction to increased costs of providing additional buses to accommodate the new start times, may modify the start times at an their elementary schools to be earlier.
- Prior Legislation. SB 328 (Portantino), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was very similar to this bill, but was vetoed by the Governor, who stated:
This is a one-size-fits-all approach that is opposed by teachers and school boards. Several schools have already moved to later start times. Others prefer beginning the school day earlier. These are the types of decisions best handled in the local community.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 328
Author:(Portantino) – As Amended Ver:May 8, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 24-9
SUBJECT: Pupil attendance: school start time
SUMMARY: Prohibits high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. Prohibits middle schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits the schoolday for high schools, including high schools operated as charter schools, from beginning no earlier than 8:30 a.m.
- Prohibits the schoolday for middle schools, including middle schools operated as charter schools, from beginning no earlier than 8:00 a.m.
- Defines “schoolday” as having the same meaning as defined by the school district or charter school for purposes of calculating average daily attendance in order to compute any apportionments of state funding.
- Authorizes school districts or charter schools to offer classes or activities to a limited number of pupils before the start of the schoolday that do not generate average daily attendance for purposes of computing any apportionments of state funding.
- Requires that specified start times be implemented by middle schools and high schools no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district’s or charter school’s respective collective bargaining agreement that is operative on January 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
- Exempts rural school districts from specified start times.
- Encourages the California Department of Education (CDE) to post on its website available research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time, and examples of successful strategies for managing the change to a later school start time, and to advise school districts of this posting.
- States that the Legislature encourages school districts and community organizations to inform their communities, including parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders, about the health, safety, and academic impact of sleep deprivation on middle and high school pupils and the benefits of a later school start time, and to discuss local strategies to successfully implement the later school start time.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires the governing board of each school district to fix the length of the schoolday for the grades and classes of the schools maintained by the district. (Education Code (EC) Section 46100)
- Specifies that the minimum schoolday for purposes of average daily attendance for grades 4-12 is typically 240 minutes, except as otherwise provided for specialized programs. (EC Sections 46113, 46141)
- Requires school districts and county offices of education to offer 54,000 instructional minutes annually for grades 4-8 and to offer 64,800 instructional minutes annually for grades 9-12, except as otherwise provided. (EC Section 46200 et seq.)
- Authorizes the governing board of a school district that maintains a junior high school or high school to schedule classes in these schools so that each pupil attends classes for at least 1,200 minutes during any five-schoolday period or 2,400 minutes during any 10-schoolday period, and specifies that under that kind of schedule, authorizes any pupil to attend school for less than the total number of days in which the school is in session as long as the pupil attends the required number of minutes per five-schoolday period or per 10-schoolday period to accommodate career technical education and regional occupational center and program courses and block or other alternative school class schedules. (EC Section 46160)
- Requires the governing board of a school district, before implementing an alternative schedule in any school of the district, to consult in good faith in an effort to reach agreement with the certificated and classified employees of the school, with the parents of pupils who would be affected by the change, and with the community at large, and requires the consultation to include at least one public hearing for which the board has given adequate notice to the employees and to the parents of pupils affected. (EC Section 46162)
- Establishes collective bargaining rights for public school teachers, which gives teachers the right to elect an exclusive representative to bargain wages and working conditions with local school boards. Mandatory issues that fall under the “scope of representation” include wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment such as health and welfare benefits, leave, transfer, and reassignment policies, safety conditions, class size, procedures to be used for the evaluation of employees, organizational security, and grievance procedures. (Government Code Sections 3540, et seq., 3543.2(a)(1))
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee,
- Unknown Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure, likely in the low millions, for schools to provide additional staff time for supervision before school.
- Significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for school districts to provide home-to-school transportation services or purchase additional buses, and for local collective bargaining activities.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill. According to the author, “SB 328 is based on the recommendations of the American Academy of Pediatricians and the Centers for Disease Control. These organizations issued their recommendations after reviewing extensive academic research on the sleep science and biology of teens and concluding that our children’s well-being deserves to be the primary focus when setting school start time. There is overwhelming evidence that moving high school and middle school start time later in the day increases academic performance and the public health of teenage students. It is appropriate and consistent for the State Legislature to enact minimum public health standards based on medical and biological research.
The majority of middle and high schools in California begin at times that are contrary to the sleep-health-needs and developmental norms of adolescents. Currently, California has over 3 million middle school and high school students. The average school start time for these students is 8:07 a.m. These early start times are having detrimental and adverse effects on our student’s health, stifling academic performance and putting our children in serious risks. This small change of having high school start no earlier than 8:30 a.m. and middle school start no earlier than 8:00 a.m. will improve student health, safety, and educational development. As both the incidences of suicidal thoughts and car accidents are significantly reduced after school start times are shifted later SB 328 has the potential to save lives.”
Current school start times. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average start time for middle and high schools in California was 8:07 a.m. in 2011-12. The distribution of start times was as follows:
- Before 7:30 a.m., 3.5% of schools
- 7:30 to 7:59 a.m., 27.7% of schools
- 8:00 to 8:29 a.m., 47.6% of schools
- 8:30 a.m. or later, 21.2% of schools
These data reflect the distribution of start times among schools; the distribution among students was not reported and were collected through a survey by the U.S. Department of Education, which asked the question: "At what time do most of the students in this school begin the school day?" The survey did not distinguish between the regular school day and zero periods, as this bill does, nor does the survey distinguish between public middle, high, and combined schools. Therefore, the reported start times are likely to include zero periods from schools in which most students attend a zero period class, so they are not necessarily an accurate reflection of the start times for the regular school day. Nevertheless, these data suggest that about one-fifth of California's schools are already in compliance with this bill, about one-half would need to delay their start times by 30 minutes or less, about one-fourth would need to increase their start times by 31 to 60 minutes, and fewer than 5% would need to increase their start times by at least 60 minutes to be in compliance.
Local control. Under California’s system of education governance, most aspects of the operation of schools is determined by the locally elected governing board. This system recognizes the diversity of California’s communities, which differ in geography, size, and demographics. This bill raises fundamental questions about the balance of state and local control. Local governing boards and the governing bodies of charter schools currently have the authority to set school start times based both on the existing body of research, and the needs of students and the community. Many California schools already begin after 8:00 a.m. and 8:30 a.m., as noted, above. The Committee may wish to consider that if this bill is passed the autonomy of local governing boards and governing bodies of charter schools will be fundamentally changed by state statute.
Potential impact. This bill would require many school districts to push back their current start times to 8:30 a.m. or later for high school, and to 8:00 a.m. or later for middle school. The Committee may wish consider how that change, which for some schools would be almost an hour later, could have unintended impacts, including, but not limited to, impacts on each of the following:
- Home-to-school transportation. Although providing home-to-school transportation is no longer a requirement for local educational education agencies (LEAs) to provide, unless transportation is included in a student’s individualized education program, many LEAs continue to provide transportation to some or all of the students they serve. Further, several LEAs have worked with local transportation agencies to coordinate additional bus routes for students, and also relieve local traffic congestion at peak times of the day. The Rim of the World Unified School District (ROWUSD) bases its budget on a 95% average daily attendance, and relies heavily on home-to-school transportation to meet its budgeted goal for funding. In order to implement a start time of 8:30 a.m. at their high schools, ROWUSD calculates a one-time cost of over $3 million for buses, uniforms, chains, initial training and drug testing, with ongoing costs of approximately $1.4 million per year and would result in fiscal insolvency for the district. The Westside Union High School District has participated for over 40 years in the Antelope Valley Schools Transportation Agency in order to share transportation resources. If this bill is enacted, this LEA will need to either start schools serving students in kindergarten through sixth grade much earlier, or much later. The El Dorado Union High School District reports it will need to purchase at least seven busses to implement a delayed school start time. The Jurupa Unified School District calculates it will need to spend approximately $1 million to purchases 2 additional buses and 3 drivers to accommodate a delayed school start time.
- Before and after school programs. Before and after school programs are designed for multiple purposes: to provide a safe environment for students in the hours before and after school when there may be limited adult supervision, to provide enrichment activities (such as homework assistance, field trips), as well as provide child care for working families. Existing state and federal law establish various after school academic enrichment programs including the 21st Century High School After School Safety and Enrichment for Teens Program, the After School Education and Safety Program, and the federally funded 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program. While some of these programs may include a before school component, pushing school start time back to 8:30 a.m. does not seem likely to significantly decrease the need for after school programs, but it does seem likely to increase capacity demands on before school programs. Are there sufficient resources to meet those demands? If schools lack the necessary resources to expand before school programs, and parents – out of necessity – continue to drop their children off at school at the traditionally earlier times, will those students be appropriately supervised?
- Supervision. It is reasonable to expect that in a unified school district, after adjusting school start times for middle and high schools, elementary schools may need to start earlier and end earlier in order to accommodate the adjusted transportation and other logistics changes. LEAs will likely need to hire additional supervisory staff for the before and after school hours to ensure the safety of the youngest students, in addition to making changes to the operating hours of before and after school programs, creating new costs and potentially diverting funds from instructional activities. Many parents will likely not be able to adjust their work schedules, and will continue to drop off their students at the same time. The Hemet Unified School District reports they will not be able to simply “flip” an hour of coverage from the afternoon to the morning, due to the numerous events that take place after school. If activities and programs like after school programs, clubs and athletics end an hour later, their district will need the supervision coverage an hour longer in addition to adding the time in the morning.
- Extracurricular activities, including athletics. Pushing back the time school starts necessitates pushing back the time school ends. Could converting time in the afternoon that is currently used for extracurricular activities to in-class school time negatively impact extracurricular activities, including athletics? Later school start times would push back extracurricular activity start times, forcing students to complete homework and other studying activities further into the evening. Many LEAs report concerns regarding student safety moving athletics practices and games later in the day when there may not be daylight. Lighting of athletic fields will need to be added, or athletic practices will need to start before school to accommodate light and temperature considerations. Conversely, could requiring every high school to start at 8:30 a.m. or later, and middle school to start at 8:00 a.m. or later actually help athletics schedules? Are there positive benefits to keeping students who are not engaged in after school extracurricular activities in school longer? The body of research on this potential area of impact is very small.
- Block schedules. Block schedules in middle and high schools typically replace a more traditional schedule of six or seven 40-50 minute daily periods with longer class periods that meet fewer times each day and week. Some block schedules might last 120 minutes per period and meet a few times a week instead of every day. Some block schedules include periods of different length, providing longer classes for core academic subjects and shorter daily periods for electives, or opportunities for students to work off campus in internships. Block schedules are optional and customized locally at the LEA and school level. It is reasonable to expect that adjusting start times will require further modifications to block scheduling in ways potentially more complicated than a more traditional schedule.
- Collective bargaining. Existing law includes "hours of employment" within the scope of collective bargaining [Government Code §3543.2(a)(1)]. Accordingly, to the extent this bill requires schools to change their existing start times, collective bargaining contracts would be affected. This bill requires that specified start times be implemented by middle schools and high schools no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district’s or charter school’s respective collective bargaining agreement that is operative on January 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later. The Porterville Unified School District negotiated a collective bargaining agreement in 2018 with certificated employees in order to adjust school start and end times to fit the needs of their students. Should school start times be required to start at later times it would likely jeopardize the LEA’s ability to formulate a new schedule that provides supports, such as their Breakfast-in-the-Classroom initiative, developed with local stakeholder input.
Research on impact of delayed school start times. A number of studies over the last 15 years have investigated the impact of delayed school start times on student outcomes, with wide variation in conclusions and study design.
- Academic achievement. Very little consensus is found among researchers on the impacts of school start time on academic performance. The 2014 School Start Times for Adolescents policy statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics states, “Improvements in academic achievement associated with delayed start times have been somewhat less consistently demonstrated.” Further, a 2016 journal article in SLEEP, Longitudinal Outcomes of Start Time Delay on Sleep, Behavior, and Achievement in High School found, “No evidence to suggest that a change in school start times from earlier to later was associated with either improvement or decline in academic performance.” In a 2012 EducationNext article, Do Schools Begin Too Early? examined results from standardized test scores of middle school students in Wake County, North Carolina and found, “Delaying school start times by one hour, from roughly 7:30 to 8:30, increases standardized test scores by at least 2 percentile points in math and 1 percentile point in reading.”
The Seattle School District in the state of Washington delayed the start time for secondary schools from 7:50 to 8:45 a.m. in the 2016–2017 academic year. A 2018 research article in Science Advances titled, Sleepmore in Seattle: Later School Start Times are Associated with More Sleep and Better Performance in High School Students, summarized the findings of a study of the impact of the delayed start time. The study populations included sophomores of two public high schools in Seattle in which the authors of the article measured sleep-wake cycles using wrist activity devices during the spring of 2016 and the spring of 2017 and found, “delayed school start times are associated with higher grades, reduced sleepiness, and improved attendance and punctuality. Generalized linear models indicated that student performance, as measured by second-semester grades, was significantly higher.” The Committee may wish to consider that the article cited related to the Seattle study does not include longitudinal results for several years after the school start time was changed.
- Attendance and graduation rates. A 2017 article in the Journal of the National Sleep Health Foundation, Delayed High School Start Times Later than 8:30 a.m. and Impact on Graduation Rates and Attendance Rates, reported the findings of a study of 29 public high schools from eight school districts located throughout seven different states comparing data from the year the later school start time was implemented with two years prior – linked a start time of later than 8:30 a.m. to improved attendance and graduation rates. However, this study did not include an analysis of other internal or external factors to the school that could have influenced these findings such as changes to curriculum, student supports, and other interventions. According to a 2016 journal article in SLEEP, Longitudinal Outcomes of Start Time Delay on Sleep, Behavior, and Achievement in High School, which collected and analyzed data from a public high school in Glen Falls, New York, “Neither unexcused nor excused absences improved after the delay in start times was implemented—in fact, our data indicated a slight increase in absences post-transition.”
- Punctuality and tardiness. In the 2018 study of delayed school start times in Seattle (cited above) found, “…the later school starts led to an increase in punctuality and attendance that, remarkably, was only evident in the economically disadvantaged school.” Similarly, according to a 2016 journal article in SLEEP, Longitudinal outcomes of start time delay on sleep, behavior, and achievement in high school, “Delaying school start times had a small but robust effect on decreasing tardiness, particularly unexcused tardies that often result from oversleeping.”
- Amount of nighttime sleep. According to a 2014 research paper from the Center for Applied Research and Educational Improvement at the University of Minnesota, Examining the Impact of Later High School Start Times on the Health and Academic Performance of High School Students: A Multi-Site Study, which collected survey data and conducted interviews with students and parents from eight public high schools in five school districts in three states, “Results show that, on average, the teens who had high school start times of 8:35 a.m. or earlier averaged about 7.8 hours of sleep. In comparison, students at Jackson Hole High School, which changed its start time from 7:25 a.m. to 8:55 a.m., are now be averaging greater than 8 hours of sleep.” The 2015 article, School Start Time and Adolescent Sleep Patterns: Results from the U.S. National Comorbidity Survey—Adolescent Supplement, American Journal of Public Health, which surveyed over 9,000 students across the United States, “Adjusting for age, sex, school level, urbanicity, and student employment, each half-hour increase in start time before 8:01 a.m. was associated with 11.36 more minutes of weeknight sleep in an overall sample. From 8:01 a.m. onward, start time and sleep duration were not significantly associated.”
In contrast, a 2016 journal article in SLEEP, Longitudinal outcomes of start time delay on sleep, behavior, and achievement in high school, which studied the impact of later school start times in high school in both the year the later start time [Wave 1] was implemented and one year later [Wave 2], “In most examinations of sleep variables after start time changes are implemented, students slept in later in the morning and held bedtimes constant, leading to a net gain of sleep that sometimes exceeds the amount by which the start time was delayed. In our study, this did not occur: students did initially hold bedtimes roughly steady, and slept later, but by Wave 2, one year after the change in start times, bedtimes had delayed again. Although the sample reported 20 minutes longer total sleep time at Wave 1, these gains returned to baseline by Wave 2, and we detected no changes in sleepiness physical health, mental health, or sleep satisfaction compared to baseline levels [emphasis added].”
- Impact of sleep on other behaviors. Kyla L. Wahlstrom, Ph.D., in a 2017 article, Later Start Time for Teens Improve Grades, Mood, and Safety, states, “A seminal analysis of the data from the national Youth Risk Behavior Survey revealed that eight or more hours of sleep appear to be the tipping point in the at-risk behaviors of teenagers (McKnight-Eily et al., 2011). Cigarette, alcohol, and marijuana use declined by 8% to 14% when teens slept eight or more hours each night, with depressing and sexual activity also declining by 9% to 11%...In our study, we found the same patterns of benefit for the health of teens with a later start time. Among the 9,395 students in our study, those who slept eight or more hours each night were significantly less likely to: report symptoms of depression; fall asleep in class; drink caffeinated beverages; have a phone or computer in their bedroom; and do dangerous things without thinking.” Dr. Wahlstrom is also the author of the University of Minnesota study, cited above. A 2013 article in JAMA Pediatrics, Sleep-Deprived Young Drivers and the Risk for Crash, which examined data of adolescent teen drivers in Australia stated, “On average, those who reported sleeping six or fewer hours per night had an increased risk for crash compared with those who reported sleeping more than six hours.” The Committee may wish to consider that this study of Australian adolescents was not directly related to school start times.
Equity concerns for working and single parent families. It is nearly impossible for school boards to set their school start times at a time that is convenient for all parents and guardians because in any given community there is a variance of work schedules for parents and guardians. The Committee may wish to consider if it is plausible that pushing back school start times may disproportionately impact working families and single parent families who may not be able take their children to school later or easily arrange for child care. Is this an issue that will exist regardless of school start time?
Research on adolescent sleep. A number of research studies over the last 15 years have examined adolescent sleep, with wide variation in study design and conclusions.
- Circadian rhythms and sleep-wake homeostasis. According to the Education Commission of the States, Later Education Start Times in Adolescence: Time for Change, humans have a dual process for regulating sleep. The circadian rhythm is the internal clock, controlling the timing of most 24-hour behavioral and psychological rhythms. These daily rhythms include alertness and performance rhythms, hormone production, core body temperature and metabolism. The second process is sleep-wake homeostasis, effectively reminding the body that it needs to sleep after a certain time. The homeostatic process is a measure of sleep pressure; when one has been awake for a while, the pressure to go to sleep becomes greater.
“During puberty adolescents become sleepy later at night and need to sleep later in the morning as a result of shifts in biological rhythms. These biological changes are often combined with poor sleep habits (including irregular bedtimes and the presence of electronics in the bedroom) (Centers for disease Control and Prevention, CDC Features: Schools Start Too Early).” This phenomenon is known as ‘social jet-lag’.” “Proposed remedies for social jet-lag and associated sleep loss are individualized work schedules and later school start-times. According to a 2017 article, The Effects of Self-Selected Light-Dark Cycles and Social Constraints on Human Sleep and Circadian Timing: A Model Approach, in Scientific Reports, “While there have been some empirical case studies, there are currently no standard theory-based quantitative evaluations of the effects of such interventions on circadian rhythmicity and sleep timing.”
- How much sleep do adolescents need? The American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP) supports the American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommendation that teenagers aged 13 to 18 years should regularly sleep 8 to 10 hours per day for good health. However, other researchers including Ian Campbell, Ph.D., and Irwin Feinbert, M.D. of the University of California Davis disagree with the AAP’s recommendation stating in the David Enterprise on April 30, 2015, “[The AAP’s]…recommended sleep durations are not based on experimental data. There is no rigorous scientific evidence that supports this recommendation. Moreover, it is implausible that the amount of sleep that is biologically needed does not change between age 10 and 17 years.”
- Other factors. A 2017 article, Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine, Delaying Middle School and High School Start Times Promotes Student Health and Performance: An American Academy of Sleep Medicine Position Statement, states, “While an operational change in school start times does not automatically assure longer sleep durations, this change, coupled with inclusion of relevant and targeted educational materials regarding the importance of sleep into middle school and high school curricula, will help motivate students, teachers, and parents to prioritize sleep and implement healthy sleep practices. This includes a cool, dark, quiet sleep environment; adequate time for 8 to 10 hours of sleep per night; consistent bedtimes and wake times on weekdays and weekends; a regular bedtime routine to cue the body that sleep is imminent; and morning light exposure. Furthermore, the use of sleep-disrupting electronic devices near bedtime or during the night should be avoided, because light emitted from electronic devices, particularly blue wavelengths, can suppress the production of melatonin and contribute to difficulty falling asleep. These practices will benefit the student regardless of school start time.”
More longitudinal research is needed to study if initial improvements persist. Nearly every article related to school start times and adolescent sleep patterns includes a recommendation for additional research on this subject. In particular, more longitudinal studies are needed to determine the impact of later start times over time; more studies are needed to determine if any initial improvements exist across both academic, discipline, and other measures of student success:
- “It is clear that additional research is needed to further document the effects of changes in school start times over time, to examine specific factors that increase or decrease the likelihood of positive outcomes, and to assess the effect on families, the community, other stakeholders, and the educational system in general.” AAP Policy Statement, School Start times for Adolescents, 2014.
- “Few studies have assessed whether associations between school start time and sleep among adolescents differ by age or by sex, and the evidence has been mixed.” American Journal of Public Health, School Start Time and Adolescent Sleep Patterns: Results from the U.S. National Comorbidity Survey—Adolescent Supplement, 2015.
- “The two U.S. national studies that have reporting associations between school start time and adolescent sleep patterns did not investigate differences in urbanicity.” American Journal of Public Health, School Start Time and Adolescent Sleep Patterns: Results from the U.S. National Comorbidity Survey—Adolescent Supplement, 2015.
- “A recent review, highlights the fact that, although as many as 80 school districts may have already shifted school timing for adolescents and some positive benefits have been reported, there is a need for further systematic research to quantify the effectiveness of this intervention.” Scientific Reports, The Effects of Self-Selected Light-Dark Cycles and Social Constraints on Human Sleep and Circadian Timing: A Model Approach, 2017.
- “Although students have demonstrated potential benefits to delaying school start times, the existing evidence regarding the association between school start time and sleep also has limits. As noted by the American Academy of Pediatrics, there is a gap in knowledge regarding the factors that might modify the association of school start time with sleep outcomes.” American Journal of Public Health, School Start Time and Adolescent Sleep Patterns: Results from the U.S. National Comorbidity Survey—Adolescent Supplement, 2015.
- “At present, there is simply insufficient evidence to support the view that later school start times would be more helpful than other interventions. At a minimum, our knowledge of adolescent sleep informs us that there is insufficient evidence to justify the bed durations and school schedules currently recommended by the AAP.” Davis Enterprise, Opinion: Later School Start Times? Not So Fast, 2015.
- “The Seattle school start time delay of 55 minutes did not result in a gain of 55 minutes of sleep, suggesting that after a year—as opposed to an acute change lasting for 1 week—students may delay their bedtimes, indicating that there may be other factors that are keeping teens awake in the evenings of school days.” Sleepmore in Seattle: Later School Start Times are Associated with More Sleep and Better Performance in High School Students, Science Advances, 2018.
Recommendations from the AAP. The widely-cited 2014 Policy Statement from the American Academy of Pediatrics, School Start Times for Adolescents, includes five recommendations in the concluding remarks. In summary, those recommendations include:
- Pediatricians should educate adolescents and parents regarding the optimal sleep amount teenagers need to match physiologic sleep needs (8.5–9.5 hours).
- Health care professionals, especially those working in school-based clinics or acting in an advisory capacity to schools, should be aware of adolescent sleep needs, and should educate parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders about the biological and environmental factors, including early school start times, that contribute to widespread chronic sleep deprivation in America’s youth.
- Educational interventions for parents and adolescents as well as the general public should be developed and disseminated by the AAP and other child and sleep health advocacy groups.
- Pediatricians and other pediatric health care providers (for example: school physicians, school nurses) should provide scientific information, evidence-based rationales, guidance, and support to educate school administrators, parent-teacher associations, and school boards about the benefits of instituting a delay in start times as a potentially highly cost-effective countermeasure to adolescent sleep deprivation and sleepiness.
- Pediatricians should routinely provide education and support to adolescents and families regarding the significance of sleep and healthy sleep habits as an important component of anticipatory guidance and well-child care.
The Committee may wish to consider that of the five recommendations for their primary audience, pediatricians, to consider, only two include language regarding delaying school start times. The remaining recommendations include information about sleep education and modifying adolescent sleep behavior.
Other states. If this bill is enacted, California would become the first state to adopt a late school start time statewide. According to the Start School Later, Inc. website, Indiana, Maryland, New Jersey and Pennsylvania have passed laws to study school start times. Several other states are hearing legislation this year to either study, create a pilot, or mandate specified school start times. The New York Times reported on September 7, 2018, “The Boston Public School system voted to change its start times in late 2017 but backed away from that switch after facing criticism.” The criticism from parents and students largely focused on corresponding new, earlier start times for elementary schools throughout the district changed in compensation for the later start times for high schools.
Arguments in support. Supporters cite research showing (1) the negative effects of sleep deprivation among adolescents and (2) that start times of 8:30 a.m. or later reverses those effects. They assert that adolescent sleep deprivation "is a public health issue that deserves a serious immediate response," and that starting school later is a "simple and obvious fix." Supporters also argue that adolescents' brains are "hard wired" to not sleep before 11:00 p.m., so simply going to bed earlier is not a solution. Finally, they argue that schools benefit from later start times, because experience has shown that the later time results in increased attendance (which increases school district revenue), reduced tardiness, improved academic performance, and a lower incidence of behavioral problems.
Arguments in opposition. According to the Elk Grove Unified School District, “…the permissive nature of the California Education Code currently allows Local Education Agencies to set their own start times. The fact that today more than one in five school districts voluntarily meet SB 328’s standards proves the bill is unnecessary for communities that would be well served by later start times.
For communities and school agencies that would be burdened by a later school schedule, however, SB 328 would present tremendous difficulties with significant opportunity costs. And because school schedules have such a wide-ranging and significant impact on operations and expenses, a great number of districts would be hurt by this legislation for a number of different reasons. Determining school schedules is a decision that even more than most should reflect specific conditions and be decided locally, not from Sacramento.”
Related legislation. AB 760 (Cooper) of this Session requires, commencing with the 2019–20 fiscal year, the amount of funds received for specified pupil transportation programs to be adjusted by a specified cost-of-living calculation, and requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to compute an add-on to the total sum of a county superintendent of schools’, school district’s, or charter school’s base, supplemental, and concentration grants in accordance with a certain formula to incrementally equalize pupil transportation program funding to 90% of the approved cost expenditures of the county superintendent of schools’, school district’s, and charter school’s pupil transportation programs.
SB 328 (Portantino) of the 2017-18 Session was very similar to this bill, but was vetoed by the Governor, with the following message:
This is a one-size-fits-all approach that is opposed by teachers and school boards. Several schools have already moved to later start times. Others prefer beginning the school day earlier. These are the types of decisions best handled in the local community.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
Brown Alpert Medical School
California District Attorneys Association
California Medical Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Sleep Society
California State PTA
Center for Human Sleep Science UC Berkeley
Congresswoman Zoe Lofgren
Educate. Advocate.
Edvoice
F.Lux Software LLC
First District PTA
Fourth District PTA
Fresno Unified School District
High School Parent Engagement Group
Kaiser Permanente
Loyola University Maryland
Lucile Packard Children's Hospital Stanford Children's Health
Mental Health America of California
Ninth District PTA
Pasadena Unified School District Board of Education
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Renaissance School Of Medicine
San Diego Unified School District Board of Education
Sleep Research Society
South Pasadena Unified School District
Start School Later
Start School Later California Chapter
Start School Later, San Diego County
Opposition
Alameda County Transportation Commission
Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District (AC Transit)
Association of California School Administrators
California Association of School Business Officials (CASBO)
California Association of School Transportation Officials (CASTO)
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California School Boards Association
California Teachers Association
Charter Schools Development Center
Clovis Unified School District
Compton Unified School District
Elk Grove Unified School District
Irvine Unified School District
Kern County Superintendent of Schools
Natomas Unified School District
Oakland Unified School District
Office Of The Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Orange County Department Of Education
Rim of The World Unified School District
Riverside County Office of Education
San Bernardino County District Advocates for Better Schools (SANDABS)
Small School Districts Association
Torrance Unified School District
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
West Covina Unified School District
2 individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Marguerite Ries / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 328 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 328
Author: Portantino (D), et al.
Amended: 5/8/19
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 4-2, 4/24/19
AYES: Wilk, Chang, McGuire, Pan
NOES: Leyva, Glazer
NO VOTE RECORDED: Durazo
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates
SUBJECT: Pupil attendance: school start time
Start School Later, California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits middle schools, including those operated as charter school, from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m., and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m.
Existing law:
- Requires the governing board of each school district to fix the length of the schoolday for the several grades and classes of the schools maintained by the district. (Education Code § 46100)
- Specifies that the minimum schoolday for purposes of average daily attendance for grades 4-12 is typically 240 minutes, except as otherwise provided for specialized programs. (EC § 46113, §46141)
- Requires, generally, school districts and county offices of education to offer 54,000 instructional minutes annually for grades 4-8 and to offer 64,800 instructional minutes annually for grades 9-12, except as otherwise provided. (EC § 46200 et seq.)
- Authorizes the governing board of a school district that maintains a junior high school or high school to schedule classes in these schools so that each pupil attends classes for at least 1,200 minutes during any five-schoolday period or 2,400 minutes during any 10-schoolday period and specifies that under that kind of schedule, any pupil may be authorized to attend school for less than the total number of days in which the school is in session as long as the pupil attends the required number of minutes per five-schoolday period or per 10-schoolday period to accommodate career technical education and regional occupational center and program courses and block or other alternative school class schedules. (EC § 46160)
- Requires the governing board of a school district, before implementing an alternative schedule in any school of the district, to consult in good faith in an effort to reach agreement with the certificated and classified employees of the school, with the parents of pupils who would be affected by the change, and with the community at large, and requires the consultation to include at least one public hearing for which the board has given adequate notice to the employees and to the parents of pupils affected. (EC § 46162)
- Establishes collective bargaining rights for public school teachers, which gives teachers the right to elect an exclusive representative to bargain wages and working conditions with local school boards. Mandatory issues that fall under the “scope of representation” include wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment such as health and welfare benefits, leave, transfer, and reassignment policies, safety conditions, class size, procedures to be used for the evaluation of employees, organizational security, and grievance procedures. (Government Code § 3540, et seq., § 3543.2(a)(1))
This bill prohibits middle schools, including those operated as charter school, from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m., and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits middle schools, including those operated as charter school, from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m., and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m.
- Specifies that “schoolday” has the same meaning as defined by the school district or charter school for purposes of calculating average daily attendance in order to compute any apportionments of state funding.
- Specifies that its provisions do not prohibit a school district or charter school from offering classes or activities to a limited number of pupils before the start of the schoolday that do not generate average daily attendance for purposes of computing any apportionments of state funding.
- Requires its provisions to be implemented by middle schools and high schools by no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district’s collective bargaining agreement that is operative on July 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
- Exempts rural school districts from its provisions.
- Encourages the California Department of Education to post on its Internet Web site available research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time and examples of successful strategies for managing the change to a later school start time, and to advise school districts of this posting.
- States the Legislature encourages school districts and community organizations to inform their communities, including parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders, about the health, safety, and academic impact of sleep deprivation on middle and high school pupils and the benefits of a later school start time, and to discuss local strategies to successfully implement the later school start time.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “The leaders of local school districts are or should be well-aware that requiring students – especially adolescents – to wake, travel to school, and learn during early morning hours is contrary to the developmental needs and biological sleep cycles of growing minds and bodies. Yet, only a handful of districts have been proactive in doing what is right for students by making the change back to traditional school hours, which prior to the 1980s had most school opening between 8:30 and 9 a.m. Today, most middle and high schools begin at or way before 8 a.m. According to the most recent data available, the average start time among California-based public schools is 8:07 a.m.”
- Existing start times. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average start time for middle and high schools in California was 8:07 a.m. in 2011-12. The distribution of start times was as follows:
- Before 7:30 a.m., 3.5 percent of schools
- 7:30 to 7:59 a.m., 27.7 percent of schools
- 8:00 to 8:29 a.m., 47.6 percent of schools
- 8:30 a.m. or later, 21.2 percent of schools
These data reflect the distribution of start times among schools; the distribution among students was not reported. In addition, these data were collected through a survey by the U. S. Department of Education, which asked the question: "At what time do most of the students in this school begin the school day?" The survey did not distinguish between the regular school day and zero periods, as this bill does. Therefore, the reported start times are likely to include zero periods from schools in which most students attend a zero period class, so they are not necessarily an accurate reflection of the start times for the regular school day. Nevertheless, these data suggest that about one-fifth of California's schools are already in compliance with this bill, about one-half would need to delay their start times by 30 minutes or less, about one-fourth would need to increase their start times by 31 to 60 minutes, and fewer than 5 percent would need to increase their start times by at least 60 minutes to be in compliance.
- Science of adolescent sleep. According to the author, “The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association (AMA) and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) are among the organizations and experts that have reported on the harm being done to the physical and emotional health of adolescents due to the sleep deprivation caused by such developmentally-misaligned school hours. Similarly, researchers report that academic success and school attendance is greatly improved by later starting school days. The recommendation made the American Academy of Pediatrics – and supported by the AMA, CDC, and others – states that no middle or high school should begin before 8:30 a.m. Other organizations add that no elementary school should begin before 8 a.m.”
A specific example of a research study supporting these contentions is Examining the Impact of Later High School Start Times on the Health and Academic Performance of High School Students: A Multi-Site Study, conducted by the Center for Applied Research and Educational Improvement (CAREI) in the College of Education and Human Development at the University of Minnesota. In its final report, CAREI’s major findings stated that “The results from this three-year research study, conducted with over 9,000 students in eight public high school in three states, reveal that high schools that start at 8:30 AM or later allow for more than 60 percent of students to obtain at least eight hours of sleep per school night. Teens getting less than eight hours of sleep reported significantly higher depression symptoms, greater use of caffeine, and are at a greater risk for making choices for substance abuse. Academic performance outcomes, including grades earned in core subject areas of math, English, science, and social studies, plus performance on state and national achievement tests, attendance rates, and reduced tardiness show significantly positive improvement with the later start times of 8:30 AM or later. Finally, the number of car crashes for teen drivers from 16 to 18 years of age was significantly reduced by 70 percent when a school shifted start times from 7:35 AM to 8:55 AM.”
- Home-to-school transportation (HTST) funding. As noted by the Legislative Analyst’s Office report: Review of School Transportation in California, “Because HTST allocations were locked in during the early 1980s, they fail to reflect districts’ current characteristics or level of transportation services. As a result, funding allocations now vary across similar districts for no apparent reason. Available data indicate that one–quarter of districts receive an HTST allocation sufficient to cover less than 30 percent of their costs, whereas another one–quarter of districts receive an HTST allocation that covers more than 60 percent of their costs… In addition to the disparities in funding among districts receiving HTST allocations, some local education agencies are excluded entirely from receiving any allocation. Most notably, all of the state’s approximately 1,100 charter schools (serving more than 450,000 students) do not receive HTST funding because charter schools were not authorized until the early 1990s. In addition, at least 20 school districts (serving more than 26,000 students) reported some transportation expenditures in 2011–12 but received no HTST funding. (These districts likely did not participate in the HTST program during the early 1980s, and therefore have been excluded ever since.)
“Additionally, in contrast to some other states, California does not require districts to transport students who live far from school. Instead, state law allows the district governing board to provide pupil transportation ‘whenever in the judgment of the board the transportation is advisable and good reasons exist therefor.’ Generally, the state grants districts discretion over which students they will transport and how many school bus routes they will operate. The only students required to be transported are students with disabilities, students attending federally sanctioned schools, and homeless students.”
An economic analysis conducted by the RAND Corporation, “Later School Start Times in the U.S.,” states that “it is estimated that the largest cost of later school start time in the U.S. would incur from changes in school bus schedules from the current three-tier to a one-or two-tier school bus systems. Specifically, in order to reduce the total number of school buses, many school districts stack start times according to the three school levels, elementary, middle and high school, generally with middle and high schools starting first. Often high-school starts first because of safety concerns arising from having younger children walking to school or waiting for buses early in the morning when it is potentially still dark outside. That is, schools that currently provide transportation for students would likely have to reduce the bus tiers and invest and operate more buses amid a delay in school start time. Previously, these costs have been estimated to be approximately $150 per student per year, or about $1.950 over a student’s school career.”
- Other potential unintended impacts. This bill requires many school districts to push back their current start times to 8:00 a.m. or later for middle schools and 8:30 a.m. or later for high schools, which for some schools would be almost an hour later and could have unintended impacts, including, but not limited to, impacts on each of the following:
- Equity concerns for working and single parent families. It is nearly impossible for school boards to set their school start times at a time that is convenient for all parents and guardians because in any given community there is a variance of work schedules for parents and guardians. However, pushing back school start times may disproportionately impact working families and single parent families who may not be able to take their children to school later or easily arrange for child care. Is this an issue that will exist regardless of school start time?
Moreover, for some families, older students may be called upon to help care for younger children who will still be getting out earlier in the day. For other students, they might have afterschool jobs to help support their family or themselves.
- Extracurricular activities, including athletics. Pushing back the time school starts necessitates pushing back the time school ends. Could shifting time in the afternoon that is currently free for extracurricular activities to in-class school time negatively impact extracurricular activities, including athletics?
- Before and afterschool programs. Existing state and federal law establish various after school academic enrichment programs including the 21st Century High School After School Safety and Enrichment for Teens Program, the After School Education and Safety Program, and the federally funded 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program. While some of these programs may include a before school component, pushing school start time back to 8:00 a.m. for middle schools and 8:30 a.m. for high school does not seem likely to significantly decrease the need for afterschool programs, but it does seem likely to increase capacity demands on before school programs.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 328 (Portantino, 2017-18) was substantially similar to this bill, but was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated, “This is a one-size-fits-all approach that is opposed by teachers and school boards. Several schools have already moved to later start times. Others prefer beginning the school day earlier. These are the types of decisions best handled in the local community.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure, likely in the low millions, for schools to provide additional staff time for supervision before school.
- Significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for school districts to provide home-to-school transportation services or purchase additional buses, and for local collective bargaining activities.
California State PTA (co-source)
Start School Later, California (co-source)
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
California Medical Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Sleep Society
Center for Sleep Science at the University of California, Berkeley
Educate.Advocate.
f.lux softwere LLC
First District PTA
Fourth District PTA
Fresno Unified School District
High School Parent Engagement Group
Kaiser Permanente
Mental Health Alliance of California
Ninth District PTA
Pediatric Sleep Medicine Program at Rady Children’s Hospital and UCSD
Sleep Research Society
South Pasadena Unified School District
Start School Later, Inc.
Start School Later, San Diego County
Several individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/15/19)
Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District
California Association of School Business Officials
California Association of School Transportation Officials
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California School Boards Association
California Teachers Association
Charter Schools Development Center
Clovis Unified School District
Compton Unified School District
Kern County Superintendent of Schools
Oakland Unified School District
Office of the Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Orange County Department of Education
Rim of the World Unified School District
San Bernardino County District Advocated for Better Schools
Small School Districts Association
Torrance Unified School District
Prepared by: Brandon Darnell / ED. /
5/18/19 12:02:10
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 328 (Portantino) - Pupil attendance: school start time
Version: May 8, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 4 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill prohibits high schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. and middle schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m., which would be required to be implemented no later than July 1, 2022 or the date on which a collective bargaining agreement expires. The bill’s provisions would not apply to rural school districts.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure, likely in the low millions, for schools to provide additional staff time for supervision before school.
- Significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for school districts to provide home-to-school transportation services or purchase additional buses, and for local collective bargaining activities.
Background:
Existing law specifies that the minimum schoolday for purposes of average daily attendance for grades 4-12 is typically 240 minutes, except as otherwise provided for specialized programs. Further, it generally requires school districts and county offices of education to offer 54,000 instructional minutes annually for grades 4-8 and to offer 64,800 instructional minutes annually for grades 9-12, except as otherwise provided.
Existing law authorizes the governing board of a school district that maintains a junior high school or high school to schedule classes in these schools so that each pupil attends classes for at least 1,200 minutes during any five-schoolday period or 2,400 minutes during any 10-schoolday period and specifies that under that kind of schedule, any pupil may be authorized to attend school for less than the total number of days in which the school is in session as long as the pupil attends the required number of minutes per five-schoolday period or per 10-schoolday period to accommodate career technical education and regional occupational center and program courses and block or other alternative school class schedules. Existing law also requires the governing board of a school district, before implementing an alternative schedule in any school of the district, to consult in good faith in an effort to reach agreement with the certificated and classified employees of the school, with the parents of pupils who would be affected by the change, and with the community at large, and requires the consultation to include at least one public hearing for which the board has given adequate notice to the employees and to the parents of pupils affected.
Further, existing law establishes collective bargaining rights for public school teachers, which gives teachers the right to elect an exclusive representative to bargain wages and working conditions with local school boards. Mandatory issues that fall under the “scope of representation” include wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment such as health and welfare benefits, leave, transfer, and reassignment policies, safety conditions, class size, procedures to be used for the evaluation of employees, organizational security, and grievance procedures.
Proposed Law:
This bill prohibits high schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. and middle schools from beginning their schoolday before 8:00 a.m which shall be implemented no later than July 1, 2022. The bill’s provisions would not apply to rural school districts.
This bill provides that for purposes of this provision, “schoolday” has the same meaning as defined for purposes of calculating average daily attendance in order to compute any apportionments of state funding under this code. This bill also provide that this does not prohibit a school district or charter school from offering classes or activities to a limited number of pupils before the start of the schoolday that do not generate average daily attendance for purposes of this state funding apportionments.
This bill encourages the California Department of Education to post on its Internet Web site available research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time and examples of successful strategies for managing the change to a later school start time, and to advise school districts of this posting.
This bill specifies that the Legislature encourages school districts and community organizations to inform their communities, including parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders, about the health, safety, and academic impact of sleep deprivation on middle and high school pupils and the benefits of a later school start time, and to discuss local strategies to successfully implement the later school start time.
Staff Comments:
Existing law authorizes school boards to set their own start times, and some already set their start time at 8:30 a.m. or later. By establishing a statutory prohibition against starting high school before 8:30 a.m. and middle schools before 8:00 a.m., this bill could have the following cost implications:
- This measure could impact families who may not be able take their children to school later or easily arrange for child care. It could either increase the demand for before school programs offered by a school district or create pressure for the district to provide additional staff time for supervision, assuming schools would need to open their doors (e.g., cafeteria or library) by a specific time to accommodate students that need to be dropped off. Assuming additional staff time of one hour per day for 20 percent of the elementary, middle and junior high schools in the state, this bill would drive Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressure in the low millions.
- School districts that continue to provide home-to-school transportation services for students may need to modify their schedules to adhere to the prescribed start time. However, districts with limited staff or buses, particularly small districts or districts with staggered schedules may have difficulties with this. For example, a district that currently has staggered start times of 7:30 a.m. for a high school, 8:00 a.m. for a middle school, and then elementary schools starting 8:30 a.m., the start times may need to be pushed back an hour with the high school starting at 9:00 a.m. or 9:30 a.m. But if the district were to have each of the schools start at 8:30 a.m., it would not be able to do so without additional staff or buses. To the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that these activities are claimable, there could be additional Proposition 98 General Fund costs which are likely to be significant. The cost for just 150 buses statewide would be approximately $10 million. However, these activities would stem from the bill’s prohibition and not a requirement, so they may not be interpreted to be a mandate. In that case, school districts would have to absorb the costs within existing resources.
- Under existing law, working hours are specifically included within the scope of representation for purposes of teachers’ collective bargaining rights. However, it does not appear that the bill’s prohibition against starting school before 8:00 a.m. or 8:30 a.m. would have bargaining implications on the “regular school day.” To the extent that teacher preparation periods or professional development activities are impacted by this measure and there are related provisions included in a local contract, there could be additional workload on school districts to negotiate and reach new agreements which could result in additional local district costs. If the Commission on State Mandates determines that these bargaining activities are imposed by this measure, the costs could be reimbursable by the state. But again, these activities would result from the bill’s prohibition and not a requirement, so they may not be interpreted to be a mandate and would have to be absorbed within existing resources.
- Pushing back the school start time would also push back the time that school would end. This would then affect the time that is available after school for extracurricular activities and athletics. This may impact the availability of school district facilities and grounds that are leased, including activities that fall under the Civic Center Act. To the extent the bill leads to a decrease in space available for leasing opportunities, there could be a minor loss in revenue for districts.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 328 Hearing Date: April 24, 2019
Author: | Portantino | ||
Version: | March 25, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Brandon Darnell | ||
Subject: Pupil attendance: school start time.
SUMMARY
This bill prohibits middle schools and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
1) Requires the governing board of each school district to fix the length of the schoolday for the several grades and classes of the schools maintained by the district. (Education Code § 46100)
2) Specifies that the minimum schoolday for purposes of average daily attendance for grades 4-12 is typically 240 minutes, except as otherwise provided for specialized programs. (EC § 46113, §46141)
3) Requires, generally, school districts and county offices of education to offer 54,000 instructional minutes annually for grades 4-8 and to offer 64,800 instructional minutes annually for grades 9-12, except as otherwise provided. (EC § 46200 et seq.)
4) Authorizes the governing board of a school district that maintains a junior high school or high school to schedule classes in these schools so that each pupil attends classes for at least 1,200 minutes during any five-schoolday period or 2,400 minutes during any 10-schoolday period and specifies that under that kind of schedule, any pupil may be authorized to attend school for less than the total number of days in which the school is in session as long as the pupil attends the required number of minutes per five-schoolday period or per 10-schoolday period to accommodate career technical education and regional occupational center and program courses and block or other alternative school class schedules. (EC § 46160)
5) Requires the governing board of a school district, before implementing an alternative schedule in any school of the district, to consult in good faith in an effort to reach agreement with the certificated and classified employees of the school, with the parents of pupils who would be affected by the change, and with the community at large, and requires the consultation to include at least one public hearing for which the board has given adequate notice to the employees and to the parents of pupils affected. (EC § 46162)
6) Establishes collective bargaining rights for public school teachers, which gives teachers the right to elect an exclusive representative to bargain wages and working conditions with local school boards. Mandatory issues that fall under the “scope of representation” include wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment such as health and welfare benefits, leave, transfer, and reassignment policies, safety conditions, class size, procedures to be used for the evaluation of employees, organizational security, and grievance procedures. (Government Code § 3540, et seq., § 3543.2(a)(1))
ANALYSIS
This bill prohibits middle schools and high schools, including those operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m. Specifically, this bill:
1) Prohibits middle schools and high schools, including middle schools and high schools operated as charter schools, from beginning their schoolday before 8:30 a.m.
2) Specifies that “schoolday” does not include a “zero period,” or an extra period offered before the start of the regular schoolday.
3) Requires the 8:30 a.m. or later start time to be implemented by middle schools and high schools by no later than July 1, 2022, or the date on which a school district’s collective bargaining agreement that is operative on July 1, 2020, expires, whichever is later.
4) Exempts rural school districts from its provisions.
5) Encourages the California Department of Education to post on its Internet Web site available research on the impact of sleep deprivation on adolescents and the benefits of a later school start time and examples of successful strategies for managing the change to a later school start time, and to advise school districts of this posting.
6) States the Legislature encourages school districts and community organizations to inform their communities, including parents, teenagers, educators, athletic coaches, and other stakeholders, about the health, safety, and academic impact of sleep deprivation on middle and high school pupils and the benefits of a later school start time, and to discuss local strategies to successfully implement the later school start time.
STAFF COMMENTS
1) Need for the bill. According to the author, “The leaders of local school districts are or should be well-aware that requiring students – especially adolescents – to wake, travel to school, and learn during early morning hours is contrary to the developmental needs and biological sleep cycles of growing minds and bodies. Yet, only a handful of districts have been proactive in doing what is right for students by making the change back to traditional school hours, which prior to the 1980s had most school opening between 8:30 and 9 a.m. Today, most middle and high schools begin at or way before 8 a.m. According to the most recent data available, the average start time among California-based public schools is 8:07 a.m.”
2) Existing start times. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the average start time for middle and high schools in California was 8:07 a.m. in 2011-12. The distribution of start times was as follows:
• Before 7:30 a.m., 3.5 percent of schools
• 7:30 to 7:59 a.m., 27.7 percent of schools
• 8:00 to 8:29 a.m., 47.6 percent of schools
• 8:30 a.m. or later, 21.2 percent of schools
These data reflect the distribution of start times among schools; the distribution among students was not reported. In addition, these data were collected through a survey by the U. S. Department of Education, which asked the question: "At what time do most of the students in this school begin the school day?" The survey did not distinguish between the regular school day and zero periods, as this bill does. Therefore, the reported start times are likely to include zero periods from schools in which most students attend a zero period class, so they are not necessarily an accurate reflection of the start times for the regular school day. Nevertheless, these data suggest that about one-fifth of California's schools are already in compliance with this bill, about one-half would need to delay their start times by 30 minutes or less, about one-fourth would need to increase their start times by 31 to 60 minutes, and fewer than 5 percent would need to increase their start times by at least 60 minutes to be in compliance.
2) Science of adolescent sleep. According to the author, “The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Medical Association (AMA) and the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) are among the organizations and experts that have reported on the harm being done to the physical and emotional health of adolescents due to the sleep deprivation caused by such developmentally-misaligned school hours. Similarly, researchers report that academic success and school attendance is greatly improved by later starting school days. The recommendation made the American Academy of Pediatrics – and supported by the AMA, CDC, and others – states that no middle or high school should begin before 8:30 a.m. Other organizations add that no elementary school should begin before 8 a.m.”
A specific example of a research study supporting these contentions is Examining the Impact of Later High School Start Times on the Health and Academic Performance of High School Students: A Multi-Site Study, conducted by the Center for Applied Research and Educational Improvement (CAREI) in the College of Education and Human Development at the University of Minnesota. In its final report, CAREI’s major findings stated that “The results from this three-year research study, conducted with over 9,000 students in eight public high school in three states, reveal that high schools that start at 8:30 AM or later allow for more than 60 percent of students to obtain at least eight hours of sleep per school night. Teens getting less than eight hours of sleep reported significantly higher depression symptoms, greater use of caffeine, and are at a greater risk for making choices for substance abuse. Academic performance outcomes, including grades earned in core subject areas of math, English, science, and social studies, plus performance on state and national achievement tests, attendance rates, and reduced tardiness show significantly positive improvement with the later start times of 8:30 AM or later. Finally, the number of car crashes for teen drivers from 16 to 18 years of age was significantly reduced by 70 percent when a school shifted start times from 7:35 AM to 8:55 AM.”
By moving the start time back to 8:30 a.m. or later for middle schools and high schools, this bill could improve attendance rates and reduce tardiness. A study involving 29 high schools and 30,000 students over seven states, Delayed High School Start Times later than 8:30 a.m. and Impact on Graduation Rates and Attendance Rates, concluded that “Attendance rates and graduation rates significantly improved in schools with delayed start times of 8:30 a.m. or later. School officials need to take special notice that this investigation also raised questions about whether later start times are a mechanism for closing the achievement gap due to improved graduation rates.”
3) Local control and local circumstances. In recent years, the state has transitioned to the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) and the utilization of Local Control and Accountability Plans to empower local school boards with the ability to tailor important educational decisions to the unique circumstances of their schools and communities. As stated above, under existing law, school boards can currently set their start time at 8:30 a.m. or even later. The committee may wish to consider if mandating a statewide prohibition against starting middle school or high school before 8:30 a.m. is consistent with the intent of the LCFF.
4) Home-to-school transportation (HTST) funding. As noted by the Legislative Analyst’s Office report: Review of School Transportation in California, “Because HTST allocations were locked in during the early 1980s, they fail to reflect districts’ current characteristics or level of transportation services. As a result, funding allocations now vary across similar districts for no apparent reason. Available data indicate that one–quarter of districts receive an HTST allocation sufficient to cover less than 30 percent of their costs, whereas another one–quarter of districts receive an HTST allocation that covers more than 60 percent of their costs… In addition to the disparities in funding among districts receiving HTST allocations, some local education agencies are excluded entirely from receiving any allocation. Most notably, all of the state’s approximately 1,100 charter schools (serving more than 450,000 students) do not receive HTST funding because charter schools were not authorized until the early 1990s. In addition, at least 20 school districts (serving more than 26,000 students) reported some transportation expenditures in 2011–12 but received no HTST funding. (These districts likely did not participate in the HTST program during the early 1980s, and therefore have been excluded ever since.)”
“Additionally, in contrast to some other states, California does not require districts to transport students who live far from school. Instead, state law allows the district governing board to provide pupil transportation ‘whenever in the judgment of the board the transportation is advisable and good reasons exist therefor.’ Generally, the state grants districts discretion over which students they will transport and how many school bus routes they will operate. The only students required to be transported are students with disabilities, students attending federally sanctioned schools, and homeless students.
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis for SB 328 (Portantino, 2017-18), which analyzed a very similar version to this bill, the fiscal impact of later school start times includes “significant local costs for school districts to provide home-to-school transportation services and for local collective bargaining activities. These activities would result from the bill’s prohibition and not a requirement, which is not reimbursable. Costs would have to be absorbed within existing school resources. Some schools districts stagger the start time of their K-12 schools in order to utilize the same school buses for student pick-up and drop-off. School districts that continue to provide home-to-school transportation services may need to purchase additional buses. The cost for just 150 buses statewide would be approximately $10 million. Furthermore, under existing law, working hours are specifically included within the scope of representation for purposes of teachers’ collective bargaining rights. To the extent that teacher preparation periods or professional development activities are impacted by this measure and there are related provisions included in a local contract, there could be additional workload on school districts to negotiate and reach new agreements which could result in additional local school district costs.”
According to the California Association of School Business Officials, this bill “would make it difficult for school districts that choose to provide home-to-school transportation to maintain their current capacities without increased costs. For example, a school district who buses 10,000 students in 72 schools, would need an additional 142 buses, costing the district $8.9 million.”
An economic analysis conducted by the RAND Corporation, “Later School Start Times in the U.S.,” states that “it is estimated that the largest cost of later school start time in the U.S. would incur from changes in school bus schedules from the current three-tier to a one-or two-tier school bus systems. Specifically, in order to reduce the total number of school buses, many school districts stack start times according to the three school levels, elementary, middle and high school, generally with middle and high schools starting first. Often high-school starts first because of safety concerns arising from having younger children walking to school or waiting for buses early in the morning when it is potentially still dark outside. That is, schools that currently provide transportation for students would likely have to reduce the bus tiers and invest and operate more buses amid a delay in school start time. Previously, these costs have been estimated to be approximately $150 per student per year, or about $1.950 over a student’s school career.”
In light of these concerns, staff recommends that the bill amended to apply only to high schools.
5) Other potential unintended impacts. This bill requires many school districts to push back their current start times to 8:30 a.m. or later, which for some schools would be almost an hour later and could have unintended impacts, including, but not limited to, impacts on each of the following:
a) Equity concerns for working and single parent families. It is nearly impossible for school boards to set their school start times at a time that is convenient for all parents and guardians because in any given community there is a variance of work schedules for parents and guardians. However, the committee may wish to consider whether pushing back school start times will disproportionately impact working families and single parent families who may not be able to take their children to school later or easily arrange for child care? Is this an issue that will exist regardless of school start time?
Moreover, for some families, older students may be called upon to help care for younger children who will still be getting out earlier in the day. For other students, they might have afterschool jobs to help support their family or themselves. The committee may wish to consider the potential impact of later start times on these students and families, as well.
b) Extracurricular activities, including athletics. Pushing back the time school starts necessitates pushing back the time school ends. Could shifting time in the afternoon that is currently free for extracurricular activities to in-class school time negatively impact extracurricular activities, including athletics? For example, in the Winter months, would schools that lack lighting on their fields be forced to install potentially expensive field lighting in order to ensure that students can practice their sport?
Conversely, by taking a statewide approach could requiring every school to start at 8:30 a.m. or later actually help athletics schedules?
c) Before and afterschool programs. Existing state and federal law establish various after school academic enrichment programs including the 21st Century High School After School Safety and Enrichment for Teens Program, the After School Education and Safety Program, and the federally funded 21st Century Community Learning Centers Program. While some of these programs may include a before school component, pushing school start time back to 8:30 a.m. does not seem likely to significantly decrease the need for afterschool programs, but it does seem likely to increase capacity demands on before school programs. Are there sufficient resources to meet those demands? If schools lack the necessary resources to expand before school programs, and parents – out of necessity – continue to drop their children off at school at the traditionally earlier times, will those students be appropriately supervised?
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee analysis for SB 328 (Portantino, 2017-18), which analyzed a very similar version to this bill, the fiscal impact of later school start times includes “unknown Proposition 98/GF cost pressures, likely in the low millions, for schools to provide additional staff time for supervision before school, assuming schools need to open their doors by a specific time to accommodate pupils that need to be dropped off.”
Conversely, are there positive benefits to keeping students who are not engaged in after school extracurricular activities in school longer?
6) Charter schools and private schools. The Charter Schools exempts charter schools from the vast majority of laws that govern school districts, including significant topics such as curriculum requirements and teacher tenure and dismissal procedures. Charter schools were granted this exemption in order to be laboratories of innovation, which could then be infused into traditional public schools. But charter schools are not exempt from all laws that govern school districts, and in recent years the Legislature has included charter schools in many pieces of legislation.
This bill applies to charter schools but it does not apply to private schools. Unlike most traditional public schools, in which parents typically enroll their children in their assigned neighborhood school, parents voluntarily enroll their children in charter schools and private schools. The committee may wish to consider whether it would be more appropriate to allow charter schools, if they so choose, to be a public alternative with start times before 8:30 a.m. After all, private schools, which would be free to continue to start before 8:30 a.m., often are only available to those families that can afford the tuition.
7) What is rural? This bill exempts rural school districts from its requirements, but does not provide a definition for what qualifies as a rural school district, nor does existing law provide a definition. If the bill moves forward, the author may wish to clarify the meaning of rural school districts for purposes of the exemption.
8) Related and previous legislation. AB 760 (Cooper, 2019) requires, commencing with the 2019–20 fiscal year, the amount of funds received for specified pupil transportation programs to be adjusted by a specified cost-of-living calculation, and requires the Superintendent of Public Instruction to compute an add-on to the total sum of a county superintendent of schools’, school district’s, or charter school’s base, supplemental, and concentration grants in accordance with a certain formula to incrementally equalize pupil transportation program funding to 90 percent of the approved cost expenditures of the county superintendent of schools’, school district’s, and charter school’s pupil transportation programs.
SB 328 (Portantino, 2017-18) was identical to this bill, but was vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated:
“This is a one-size-fits-all approach that is opposed by teachers and school boards. Several schools have already moved to later start times. Others prefer beginning the school day earlier. These are the types of decisions best handled in the local community.”
SUPPORT
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
American Academy of Sleep Medicine
California Medical Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Sleep Society
California State PTA
Center for Sleep Science at the University of California, Berkeley
Educate.Advocate.
First District PTA
Fourth District PTA
Fresno Unified School District
f.lux softwere LLC
High School Parent Engagement Group
Kaiser Permanente
Mental Health Alliance of California
Ninth District PTA
Pediatric Sleep Medicine Program at Rady Children’s Hospital and UCSD
South Pasadena Unified School District
Start School Later, Inc.
Several individuals
OPPOSITION
Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District (AC Transit)
California Association of School Business Officials
California Association of School Transportation Officials
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California School Boards Association
California Teachers Association
Charter Schools Development Center
Clovis Unified School District
Compton Unified School District
Kern County Superintendent of Schools
Oakland Unified School District
Office of the Riverside County Superintendent of Schools
Orange County Department of Education
Rim of the World Unified School District
San Bernardino County District Advocated for Better Schools (SANDABS)
Torrence Unified School District
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):