SB 332: Wastewater treatment: recycled water.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 16, 2019 | May 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2. Page 798.) (April 23). |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 3). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 3. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and JUD. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 22. |
| Feb 19, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 332 (Hertzberg) - Wastewater treatment: recycled water
Version: April 30, 2019 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 2, JUD. 7 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Debra Cooper |
Bill Summary:
SB 332 would require wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers that discharge through ocean outfall to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50% by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95% by January 1, 2040 and would impose a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply.
Fiscal Impact:
- The State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) would be required to report to the Legislature every five years and would incur costs of about $175,000 every five years for increased workload to compile the report.
- Significant, unknown costs to the SWRCB for increased enforcement activity to confirm that wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers are in compliance and to impose penalties for any entities not in compliance.
- Unknown potential ratepayer costs to the General Fund and various special funds to the state as a ratepayer of water and wastewater to the extent those prices may be affected.
- Unknown potential revenue from moneys collected from penalties from wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers that are not in compliance.
Background:
Water recycling is reusing treated wastewater for direct beneficial or controlled purposes, such as for agricultural and landscape irrigation, industrial processes, toilet flushing, and replenishing groundwater basins. According to the US EPA, recycled water can satisfy most water demands, as long as it is adequately treated to ensure water quality appropriate for the use. On February 21, 2019, SWRCB adopted a resolution increasing the state’s water recycling goals to at least 1.5 million acre feet per year by 2020 and by at least 2.5 million acre feet per year by 2030. The most recent wastewater recycling survey showed that California had reused 714,000 acre feet of municipal recycled water in 2015.
SB 918 (Pavley, Chapter 700, Statutes of 2010) revised the state’s approach to regulating recycled water by requiring the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) to establish uniform statewide recycling criteria for each use of recycled water where the use involves the protection of public health. In 2014, all authority and responsibility for the state’s drinking water programs were transferred from CDPH to SWRCB, including the recycled water program. SB 918 requires to take action on three uses of recycled water: 1) it required the SWRCB, by December 31, 2013, to adopt uniform recycled water criteria for indirect potable reuse for groundwater recharge, 2) it required the SWRCB to develop and adopt uniform water recycling criteria for surface water augmentation, 3) it required SWRCB, by December 31, 2016, to investigate and report to the Legislature on the feasibility of developing uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse.
In 2017, AB 574 (Quirk) charged SWRCB with developing regulations for direct potable reuse by December 31, 2023. However, there is still no current requirement or timeline for SWRCB to develop treated drinking water augmentation regulations. The SWRCB recently adopted revisions to its Recycled Water Policy that, for the first time, require wastewater treatment plants and recycled water producers to report the volume of wastewater treated and discharged, specify level of treatment, and identify the volume of recycled water produced. The policy requires annual reporting of monthly volume of treated wastewater discharged to the environment, which will be used to estimate the amount of wastewater that may be available to recycle.
As authorized by the federal Clean Water Act (CWA), the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources – discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches – that discharge pollutants into waters of the United States. The NPDES Program is a federal program which has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through SWRCB and the nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards. In California, NPDES permits are also referred to as waste discharge requirements (WDRs) that regulate discharges to waters of the United States.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require wastewater treatment facilities that discharge through ocean outfall and affiliated water suppliers to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50% by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95% by January 1, 2040, and would impose a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply;
- Require holders of National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit a plan to the SWRCB by July 1, 2025, as specified;
- Require each holder of a NPDES permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit to the executive director of the SWRCB a report summarizing the actions accomplished to date and the actions remaining and proposed to meet the requirement, by January 1, 2027, and every January 1 every five years thereafter;
- Require each holder of a NPDES permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall and affiliated water suppliers, to update and submit to the executive director a plan to include any refinements or changes in the costs, actions, or financing necessary to achieve the requirements or a written statement that the plan is current and accurate, by January 1, 2030;
- Require SWRCB, by January 1, 2026, and by January 1 every five years thereafter, to a report to the Governor and the Legislature on the implementation of these provisions;
- Provide that failure to meet the plan or report submission deadlines for NPDES permit holders and affiliated water suppliers would result in a penalty of up to $10,000 (which would be available upon appropriation by the Legislature) and would make the permit holder and suppliers ineligible for a state loan or grant until the delinquent report has been submitted.
Related Legislation:
SB 606 (Hertzberg, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2018) requires SWRCB and the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to adopt water efficiency regulations, outlines requirements for water suppliers, specifies penalties for violations, and makes technical, conforming changes.
AB 574 (Quirk, Chapter 528, Statutes of 2017) required the SWRCB to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse by December 31, 2023.
SB 918 (Pavley, Chapter 700, Statutes of 2010) requires the Department of Public Health (the responsibility for recycled water has since been shifted to SWRCB) to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for indirect potable water reuse for groundwater recharge by December 31, 2013; to develop and adopt uniform water recycling criteria for surface water augmentation by December 31, 2016; and, to investigate and report on the feasibility of developing uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse.
Staff Comments:
According to SWRCB data, the 65 wastewater treatment facilities subject to the provisions of this bill release approximately 1,174 million gallons per day of treated wastewater into the ocean, bays and estuaries. To comply with the bill’s provisions, facilities would, collectively, have to divert 587 million gallons per day of wastewater (approx. 650,000 acre-feet annually) to other beneficial uses or reduce inflow through water conservation and efficiency by 2030, and 1,115 million gallons per day (approx. 1,250,000 acre-feet annually) by 2040, in addition to what’s already being recycled.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 332 (Author:Hertzberg)
Version: February 19, 2019
Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
AMConsultant:
SUBJECT
Wastewater treatment: recycled water
DIGEST
This bill requires wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers that discharge through ocean outfall to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50 percent by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95 percent by January 1, 2040, and imposes a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply. The bill requires a holder of a national pollutant discharge elimination system (NPDES) permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit to the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) a plan to meet these requirements and a report containing specified information, and imposes a penalty of up to $10,000 for failure to submit the plan or report.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Californians know all too well how precious a resource water is, and the state has been trying to increase its recycling of water for years. Encouraging and facilitating the greater use of recycled water is supported by the California Constitution and existing state statutes and regulations. After several years of drought, the need to recycle water has become more apparent. This bill is intended to move California towards a future where very little water would be discharged through ocean outfalls.
The bill is sponsored by the National Resources Defense Council (NRDC) and the California Coastkeeper Alliance and is supported by various environmental organizations, including the Sierra Club of California. The bill is opposed by various sanitation and water districts, cities, and other organizations. The bill passed out of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on a vote of 5-2.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Declares, under the California Constitution, that because of the conditions prevailing in this state, the general welfare requires that the water resources of the state be put to beneficial use to the fullest extent of which they are capable, and that the waste or unreasonable use or unreasonable method of use of water be prevented, and that the conservation of such waters is to be exercised with a view to the reasonable and beneficial use thereof in the interest of the people and for the public welfare. (Cal. Const. Art. X, §2.)
- Establishes the Water Recycling Act of 1991, creating a statewide goal to recycle a total of 700,000 acre-feet of water per year by the year 2000 and 1,000,000 acre-feet of water per year by the year 2010, and declares that reclaimed or recycled water is considered a valuable resource. (Wat. Code § 13575 et. seq.)
- Requires the SWRCB to establish uniform statewide recycling criteria for each varying type of use of recycled water where the use involves the protection of public health. (Wat. Code § 13521.)
- Prohibits a person from recycling water or using recycled water for any purpose for which recycling criteria have been established until water recycling requirements have been adopted or a regional water quality control board determines that no requirements are necessary. (Wat. Code § 13524.)
- Updated water recycling goals to 1.5 million acre-feet per year in exceedance of 2002 levels by 2020 and by at least 2.5 million acre-feet per year by 2030 via resolution adopted by the SWRCB, and makes various findings regarding these goals. (Reso. No. 2018-005, State Wat. Resources Control Bd.[1])
- Makes legislative findings and declarations of the Legislature that the use of potable domestic water for nonpotable uses is a waste or an unreasonable use of the water within the meaning of Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution if recycled water is available, as specified. (Wat. Code § 13550.)
- Declares that the people of the state have a primary interest in the development of facilities to recycle water containing waste to supplement existing surface and underground water supplies and to assist in meeting the future water requirements of the state. (Wat. Code § 13510.)
- Requires the SWRCB and the nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards to implement the NPDES permit program as delegated to the states by the federal Clean Water Act. (Wat. Code § 13370 et. seq.; 33 U.S.C. §§ 1251 et. seq.)
This bill:
- Finds and declares that the discharge of treated wastewater from ocean outfalls, except in compliance with the provisions of the bill, is a waste and unreasonable use of water within the meaning of Section 2 of Article X of the California Constitution, and makes other findings and declarations of the Legislature.
- Requires each wastewater treatment facility that discharges through an ocean outfall and affiliated water suppliers to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50 percent by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95 percent by January 1, 2040, as compared to the average annual wastewater discharge baseline volume, by treating the water to be beneficially reused or by reducing inflow through water conservation and efficiency measures.
- Defines “ocean outfall” as a point source at the point where raw, partially treated, or treated wastewater may be discharged from a wastewater treatment facility or associated collection system to saline waters, including the ocean, bays, and estuaries.
- Defines “average annual wastewater discharge baseline volume” as the average annual volume of treated waste water discharging through a facility’s ocean outfall as determined by the SWRCB using monitoring data available for calendar years 2010 to 2020, inclusive.
- Imposes a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply.
- Requires a holder of an NPDES permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit to the executive director of the SWRCB, on or before July 1, 2022, a plan to meet the requirements either directly or by contract.
- The plan is required to contain all of the following information:
- An identification of all land acquisition and facilities necessary to provide for treatment, transport, and reuse of treated wastewater.
- Identification and projection of all wastewater reductions due to implementation of conservation and efficiency measures in the facilities service area.
- An analysis of the costs to meet the requirements.
- A financing plan for meeting the requirements, including identifying any actions necessary to implement the financing plan, such as bond issuance or other borrowing, assessments, rate increases, fees, charges, or other financing mechanisms.
- A detailed schedule for the completion of all necessary actions.
- Supporting data and other documentation accompanying the plan.
- Requires an update to the plan to be submitted by January 1, 2026, including any refinements or changes in the costs, actions, or financing necessary to achieve the requirements or a written statement that the plan is current and accurate.
- Imposes a penalty for failure to submit the plan by the plan’s deadline of up to $10,000.
- Makes am NPDES permitholder and affiliated water suppliers ineligible for a state loan or grant for failure to submit the plan until the delinquent plan has been submitted.
- The plan is required to contain all of the following information:
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2024, and every January 1 every five years thereafter, a holder of an NPDES permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit to the executive director of the SWRCB a report summarizing the actions accomplished to date and the actions remaining and proposed to meet the requirements.
- Requires the report to include progress toward meeting the deadlines and to specifically include the detailed schedule for, and status of, all of the following:
- Evaluation of reuse and disposal options.
- Preparation of preliminary design reports.
- Preparation and submission of permit applications.
- Construction initiation.
- Construction progress milestones.
- Construction completion.
- Initiation of operation.
- Continuing operation and maintenance.
- Imposes a penalty for failure to submit the report by the plan’s deadline of up to $10,000.
- Makes a NPDES permitholder and affiliated water suppliers ineligible for a state loan or grant for failure to submit the report until the delinquent report has been submitted.
- Requires the report to include progress toward meeting the deadlines and to specifically include the detailed schedule for, and status of, all of the following:
- Requires the SWRCB to submit a report to the Governor and the Legislature on the implementation of these provisions, as specified.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
SB 332 sets a new course for California’s water future by declaring the discharge of treated wastewater into ocean outfalls as waste and unreasonable use of water. It will also set bold but necessary goals for the recycling and re-use of treated wastewater.
The sponsors of the bill, the NRDC and the California Coastkeeper Alliance, write:
California will continue to face water supply challenges as the state experiences oscillating wet years and periods of drought. SB 332 is a critical step to increasing local, reliable sources of water and decreasing reliance on imported water. By recognizing wastewater as a water resource – not a waste – this bill enforces the California Constitution and supports the state’s efforts to achieve a drought-resistant water future.
2. Enforcement mechanism
The bill requires wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers that discharge through ocean outfalls to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50 percent by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95 percent by January 1, 2040, and imposes a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply. The bill requires a holder of an NPDES permit authorizing the discharge of wastewater through an ocean outfall, in conjunction with affiliated water suppliers, to submit to the SWRCB a plan to meet these requirements and a report containing specified information, and imposes a penalty of up to $10,000 for failure to submit the plan or report. For a detailed analysis of current state law water recycling policy, please refer to the Senate Environmental Quality Committee analysis for this bill.[2]
In order to ensure compliance with the provisions of the bill, several penalties are imposed. First, there is a penalty for failure to meet the deadlines for achieving a reduction of the overall volume of a facility’s annual ocean outfall flow by at least 50 percent by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95 percent by January 1, 2040, of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction on overall volume discharged. There is also a penalty of up to $10,000 for failure to submit the required plan and report, and any required updates, by their due dates.
The author may wish to amend the bill to clarify what agency will be imposing the penalties and what processes and procedures are available for an appeal of an assessed penalty.
3. Concerns raised by opponents
Opponents consist of various water agencies, sanitation districts, and cities. Most, if not all, opponents recognize that the state needs to recycle water and want to be a partner in that process. However, they have concerns that the targets mandated by the bill may not be the best policy for achieving this goal and could have unintended effects on achieving other urgent goals of the state given the finite resources that are available. These concerns are heightened by the fact that failure to meet the targets could result in costly penalties. Opponents of this bill have raised many concerns and highlighted significant challenges to achieving the target reduction goals, including all of the following:
- potential insufficient year-round demand for and a lack of adequate storage for large quantities of recycled water;
- complex institutional relationships between wastewater treatment facilities, affiliated suppliers, and regulatory institutions;
- legal issues such as existing settlement requirements and riparian water rights;
- uncertainty as regulations regarding direct potable water reuse are not required to be issued by the SWRCB until 2023;
- the amount of energy needed to meet the targets;
- the enormous cost to facilities and potentially ratepayers;
- concerns posed by the need to manage large quantities of brine as a byproduct of large-scale advanced treatment for potable reuse;
- the need to scale new advanced treatment facilities to accommodate peak wet weather flows; and
- public and business acceptance of large new potable recycled water programs.
Some opponents have stated a “one-size fits all solution” fails to acknowledge the vast differences in resources, geography, and community need across the state. There are also concerns about how the average annual wastewater discharge baseline volume is measured pursuant to data available for calendar years 2010 to 2020 and that it discounts early efforts made to recycle and may actually benefit those who have not been aggressively recycling water.[3]
Some opponents have also raised concerns that the state encouraged investments by local jurisdictions to optimize use of local water resources and that the provisions of the bill would penalize these efforts. For example, Callegus Municipal Water District writes:
Calleguas is developing its $200 million Salinity Management Pipeline … designed to convey saline concentrate (brine) generated by brackish groundwater and advanced wastewater treatment facilities (potable reuse) to the ocean for disposal in accordance with an existing discharge permit. Brine concentrate discharges are a direct result of local agency efforts to optimize use of local water resources – the primary objective of SB 332 – and therefore should not be misconstrued as similar in nature to municipal wastewater discharges which have yet to be recovered and optimized for beneficial use.
The objective of SB 332 appears to target municipal wastewater treatment facility discharges. However, brine concentrate discharges are not separately distinguished and as a result the measure would impose unintentional reductions on such discharges, thus forcing brackish groundwater recovery projects to shut down. This oversight must be rectified in acknowledgement of the significant public investments in prudent, sustainable water management programs made by Calleguas, its retail purveyors, and other water agencies throughout the state: investments that have been strongly encouraged by the legislature and state agencies for decades.
In the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the author made a commitment to work with opponents on certain issues raised during that hearing. The author has indicated that he and the sponsors have been facilitating stakeholder meetings and are continuing to negotiate a workable solution to addresses those concerns and issues, but do not have a finalized solution at this time.
4. Statements of support and opposition
Supporters of the bill, a coalition of various environmental organizations, write:
California has well-established state policies that promote water conservation, efficiency, stormwater capture and the recycling of sanitary effluent. In 2009, with its Recycled Water Policy, the State Water Board made it a statewide goal to recycle 1.5 MAF of wastewater by 2020 and 2.5 MAF by 2030. In December of 2018, the State Water Board adopted its revised Recycled Water Policy with the goal to recycle all dry-weather ocean wastewater discharges statewide. SB 332 supports the goals of this Recycled Water Policy by setting aggressive, yet attainable water-saving goals. Specifically, SB 332 sets achievable milestones for wastewater facilities to reduce ocean wastewater discharges by 50 percent by 2030 and 95 percent by 2040. This bill ultimately helps provide a local, resilient water supply that is cheaper and less energy intensive than many other supply options, such as imported water or ocean desalination.
Some opponents of the bill, a coalition of sanitation and water agencies and special districts and cities, write:
As of today, the regulatory framework necessary for agencies to plan and implement projects to manage the massive volumes of water contemplated in SB 332 does not exist. Existing beneficial reuse options are limited and could not be utilized to manage such a vast quantity of water. Instead, every agency would necessarily need to implement large scale potable reuse projects. The State Water Board is charged with developing regulations for Direct Potable Reuse by 2023. Until that regulatory scheme has been developed it will be nearly impossible for agencies to plan for, let alone implement, projects to meet the mandate deadlines in SB 332. If the regulations are completed on schedule, agencies would then have a seven year window to plan, approve, execute and operate new infrastructure that would dramatically shift their day to day operations. To put this in perspective, some of the most ambitious recycling projects underway in the state currently have 20 to 30 year project schedules, and when fully operational will still not meet the discharge mandate proposed in the bill. Furthermore, no consideration is being given to these ambitious projects in the development of baseline discharge metrics, nor to other innovative project components such as stormwater capture and treatment.
5. Author’s amendments
The author has proposed amendments to address the concern raised in Comment 2 regarding the enforcement of the bill and to make technical, clarifying changes. The author has also proposed amendments to push back the due dates for the required plan and report in order to align the dates with the expected adoption of raw water augmentation regulations by the SWRCB, and to revise the definition of “average annual wastewater discharge baseline volume” to clarify the author’s intent and respond to some concerns raised by opponents.
The specific amendments are as follows:
Amendment 1
On page 4, at line 7, after “annual” insert:
dry weather
Amendment 2
On page 4, at line 8, after “of” insert:
dry weather,
Amendment 3
On page 4, at line 8, after “of” insert:
dry weather,
Amendment 4
On page 4, at line 21, after “annual” insert:
dry weather
Amendment 5
On page 4, at line 31, delete “2022,” and insert:
2025,
Amendment 6
On page 5, at line 12, delete “2026,” and insert:
2030,
Amendment 7
On page 5, at line 12, delete “2026,” and insert:
2030,
Amendment 8
On page 5, at line 19, delete “2024,” and insert:
2027,
Amendment 9
On page 5, at line 19, delete “July 1, 2025,” and insert:
January 1, 2026,
Amendment 10
On page 5, at line 37, delete “July”, and insert:
January
Amendment 11
On page 6, at line 14, after “a” insert:
plan or
Amendment 12
On page 6, at line 15, after “the” insert:
plan’s or
Amendment 11
On page 6, at line 14, insert the following:
(3) Civil liability under this subdivision shall be administratively imposed by the state board in accordance with Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 13323) of Chapter 5 of Division 7.
Amendment 12
On page 6, at line 14, deleted “(3)” and insert:
(4)
SUPPORT
Natural Resources Defense Council (sponsor)
California Coastkeeper Alliance (co-sponsor)
California League of Conservation Voters
Clean Water Action
Clean Water Supply, American Rivers
Ceres
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Environment California
Environmental Water Caucus
Endangered Habitats League
Friends of the River
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
Institute for Fisheries Resources
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Monterey Coastkeeper
Orange County Coastkeeper
Pacific Coast Federation of Fisherman’s Associations
Planning and Conservation League
Residents for Responsible Desalination
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Sierra Club California
Southern California Watershed Alliance
Surfrider Foundation
The Otter Project
Yuba River Waterkeeper
OPPOSITION
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Sanitation Agencies
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Special Districts Association
Calleguas Municipal Water District
Carpinteria Sanitary District
City of Camarillo
City of Livermore
City of Roseville
Crockett Community Services District
Dublin San Ramon Services District
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Irvine Ranch Water District
Las Gallinas Valley Sanitary District
League of California Cities
Leucadia Wastewater District
Napa Sanitation District
North Marin Water District
Olivenhain Municipal Water District
Rodeo Sanitary District
Santa Clara Valley Water District
Stege Sanitary District
Union Sanitary District
Vallecitos Water District
WaterReuse California
Western States Petroleum Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 606 (Hertzberg, Ch. 14, Stats. 2018) required the state board and the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to adopt water efficiency regulations, outlined requirements for water suppliers, and provided penalties for violations.
AB 574 (Quirk, Ch. 528, Stats. 2017) required the state board to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse by December 31, 2023.
SB 918 (Pavley, Ch. 700, Stats. 2010) required the State Department of Public Health to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for indirect potable water reuse for groundwater recharge by December 31, 2013, and for surface water augmentation by December 31, 2016.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
**************
Available at https://www.waterboards.ca.gov/board_decisions/adopted_orders/resolutions/2018/rs2018_0057.pdf. The resolution adopted amendments to the Water Quality Control Policy for Recycled Water, which will take effect once approved by the Office of Administrative Law. ↑
Cal. Sen. Env. Quality Committee, Analysis of SB 332 (Hertzberg, 2019), available at http://lis.calegis.net/LISWeb/faces/bills/billxmlxsl.xhtml;jsessionid=ez0xJBVivvhO-HDZfQ7RjNoLBNIGndRHo2QvYV2iXdvtTcw8BiGO!1316832588# (as of Apr. 15, 2019). ↑
For example, the Orange County Groundwater Replenishment System began its water recycling program in 2008. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 332
Author: | Hertzberg and Wiener | ||
Version: | 2/19/2019 | Hearing Date: | 4/3/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Wastewater treatment: recycled water
DIGEST: Requires wastewater treatment facilities and affiliated water suppliers that discharge through ocean outfall to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50% by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95% by January 1, 2040 and imposes a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the Water Recycling Act of 1991, creating a statewide goal to recycle a total of 700,000 acre-feet of water per year by the year 2000 and 1,000,000 acre-feet of water per year by the year 2010.
- Makes findings regarding the State Water Resources Control Board's (SWRCB) updated water recycling goals adopted by resolution, which update the above goals to 1.5 million acre feet per year in exceedance of 2002 levels by 2020 and by at least 2.5 million acre feet per year by 2030.
- Requires the SWRCB to establish uniform statewide recycling criteria for each varying type of use of recycled water where the use involves the protection of public health.
- States that no person shall recycle water or use recycled water for any purpose for which recycling criteria have been established until water recycling requirements have been established or a regional water quality control board determines that no requirements are necessary.
- Makes legislative findings that the use of potable domestic water (drinking water) for nonpotable uses, including, but not limited to, cemeteries, golf courses, parks, highway landscaped areas, and industrial and irrigation uses, is a waste or an unreasonable use of the water within the California Constitution if recycled water is available which meets certain conditions.
- Declares that the people of the state have a primary interest in the development of facilities to recycle water containing waste to supplement existing surface and underground water supplies and to assist in meeting the future water requirements of the state.
- Declares that it is the intent of the Legislature that the state undertake all possible steps to encourage the development of water recycling facilities so that recycled water may be made available to help meet the growing water requirements of the state.
This bill:
- Makes legislative findings that it is a waste and an unreasonable use of water within the California Constitution to discharge treated wastewater from ocean outfalls, except in compliance with this bill.
- Defines “ocean outfall” as a point source at the point where raw, partially treated, or treated wastewater may be discharged from a wastewater treatment facility or associated collection system to saline waters, including ocean, bays or estuaries.
- Requires wastewater treatment facilities that discharge through ocean outfall and affiliated water suppliers to reduce the overall volume of the facility’s annual flow by at least 50% by January 1, 2030, and by at least 95% by January 1, 2040. Imposes a penalty of $2,000 per acre-foot of water above the required reduction for failure to comply.
- Requires holders of National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permits to submit a plan to the SWRCB by July 1, 2022, that includes:
- Identification of all land acquisition and facilities necessary to provide treatment, transport, and reuse of treated wastewater;
- Identification and projection of all wastewater reductions due to implementation of conservation and efficiency measures in the facilities service area;
- An analysis of the costs to meet the requirements of this plan;
- A financing plan for meeting the requirements of the bill; and
- Schedule for the completion of all necessary actions.
- Requires such NPDES permit holders, by January 2024, and every January 1 every five years after, to submit a report to the SWRCB summarizing the actions accomplished to date and remaining actions. Imposes a penalty of up to $10,000 on permit holders for failure to submit the above referenced plan and/or subsequent report. Further specifies that such permit holders are ineligible for state loan or grant until the delinquent report has been submitted.
- Requires the SWRCB, by July 1, 2025, and by July 1 every five years after, to submit a report to the Governor and the Legislature on the implementation of this bill.
Background
- Recycled water. Water recycling is reusing treated wastewater for direct beneficial or controlled purposes, such as for agricultural and landscape irrigation, industrial processes, toilet flushing, and replenishing groundwater basins. According to the US EPA, recycled water can satisfy most water demands, as long as it is adequately treated to ensure water quality appropriate for the use. In addition to providing a dependable, locally controlled water supply, water recycling can provide environmental benefits. By providing an additional source of water, water recycling can decrease the diversion of water from sensitive ecosystems. Other benefits include decreasing wastewater discharges and reducing and preventing pollution.
- State water recycling policy. On February 21, 2019, SWRCB adopted a resolution increasing the state’s water recycling goals to at least 1.5 million acre feet per year by 2020 and by at least 2.5 million acre feet per year by 2030. The most recent wastewater recycling survey showed that California had reused 714,000 acre feet of municipal recycled water in 2015. State law recognizes that the use of recycled water for indirect potable reuse is critical to achieving the SWRCB’s goals for increased use of recycled water for the state. State law also declares that the achievement of the state’s goals depends on the timely development of uniform statewide recycling criteria for indirect and direct potable water reuse.
- Existing state standards for water recycling. SB 918 (Pavley, Chapter 700, Statutes of 2010) revised the state’s approach to regulating recycled water by requiring The Department of Public Health (DPH) to establish uniform statewide recycling criteria for each use of recycled water where the use involves the protection of public health. In 2014, all authority and responsibility for the state’s drinking water programs were transferred from DPH to SWRCB, including the recycled water program.
SB 918 requires SWRCB (formerly required DPH) to take action on three uses of recycled water. First, it required the SWRCB, by December 31, 2013, to adopt uniform recycled water criteria for indirect potable reuse for groundwater recharge. The SWRCB has developed uniform regulations authorizing the use of highly treated wastewater for groundwater recharge, if specified requirements are met, including a requirement that the treated wastewater must have a residence time in the ground of at least two months, before reaching drinking water intake pumps. These regulations went into effect on June 18, 2014. Second, SB 918 required the SWRCB to develop and adopt uniform water recycling criteria for surface water augmentation. These regulations were adopted in early 2018.
Finally, SB 918, and later SB 322 (Hueso, Chapter 637, Statutes of 2013), required SWRCB, by December 31, 2016, to investigate and report to the Legislature on the feasibility of developing uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse. Statute required SWRCB to examine specific information, including the availability and reliability of recycled water treatment technologies necessary to ensure the protection of public health; barriers and treatment processes that may be appropriate at wastewater and water treatment facilities; available information on health effects; mechanisms that should be employed to protect public health if problems are found in recycled water that is being served to the public as a potable water supply; and, monitoring needed to ensure protection of public health. SWRCB released the required report on direct potable reuse of recycled water in December, 2016. SWRCB found that direct potable reuse is feasible but that additional research and study was necessary before treated drinking water augmentation could be considered.
In 2017, AB 574 (Quirk) charged SWRCB with developing regulations for direct potable reuse by December 31, 2023. However, as noted above, there is still no current requirement or timeline for SWRCB to develop treated drinking water augmentation regulations.
The SWRCB recently adopted revisions to its Recycled Water Policy that, for the first time, require wastewater treatment plants and recycled water producers to report the volume of wastewater treated and discharged, specify level of treatment, and identify the volume of recycled water produced. The policy requires annual reporting of monthly volume of treated wastewater discharged to the environment, which will be used to estimate the amount of wastewater that may be available to recycle.
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES): As authorized by the federal Clean Water Act (CWA), the NPDES Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources that discharge pollutants into waters of the United States. Point sources are discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches. Examples of pollutants include, but are not limited to, rock, sand, dirt, and agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste.
The NPDES Program is a federal program which has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through SWRCB and the nine Regional Water Quality Control Boards. In California, NPDES permits are also referred to as waste discharge requirements (WDRs) that regulate discharges to waters of the United States.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 332 sets a new course for California’s water future by declaring the discharge of treated wastewater into ocean outfalls as waste and unreasonable use of water. It will also set bold but necessary goals for the recycling and re-use of treated wastewater.
“California’s wastewater has historically been treated solely as waste – used once, treated, and then disposed of through offshore dumping. As a result, approximately 400 billion gallons of treated water are wastefully discharged into the ocean or California estuaries annually. California’s ‘pump and dump’ approach to water management is increasingly at odds with the state’s hydrologic reality. As climate change creates hotter, drier conditions and reduces the storage capacity of the Sierra snowpack, the need to prevent water waste is more critical than ever. Climate realities have proven that California can no longer rely on a water transfer infrastructure to meet the needs of a growing population. In order to adapt to growing water scarcity and climate extremes, California must develop a long-term, locally managed water conservation mindset.”
- Reasonable Targets and Timeframes? This bill sets forth the target of reducing treated wastewater discharges from facilities into the ocean by 50% in 2030 and 95% by 2040. Setting ambitious goals can be a driver of innovation and technology in order to achieve environmental and public health benefits. In this case, the bill’s mandated target is designed to provide greater supplies of clean, safe drinking water to all Californians in wet or dry years and to have the ability to have surplus water to store in groundwater aquifers and surface storage reservoirs.
According to SWRCB data, the 65 wastewater treatment facilities subject to the provisions of this bill release approximately 1,174 million gallons per day of treated wastewater into the ocean, bays and estuaries. To comply with the bill’s provisions, facilities would, collectively, have to divert 587 million gallons per day of wastewater (approx. 650,000 acre-feet annually) to other beneficial uses or reduce inflow through water conservation and efficiency by 2030, and 1,115 million gallons per day (approx. 1,250,000 acre-feet annually) by 2040, in addition to what’s already being recycled.
Proponents argue that the bill gives wastewater and water agencies flexibility in how to reduce their ocean discharge. Compliance, they maintain, can be achieved through a combination of solutions, including low-cost conservation and efficiency measures. Wastewater facilities, however, maintain that such measures are not adequate to manage such a vast quantity of water and that every facility subject to the bill would necessarily need to implement large-scale potable reuse projects, estimated to cost more than $20 billion, for which a regulatory framework does not currently exist (i.e., raw water augmentation regulations not due until 2023).
Supporters counter that facilities can begin now to plan and design the distribution system to distribute recycle water to groundwater basins, reservoirs, and water treatment facilities and note that even without the raw augmentation regulation in place, SWRCB has the authority to approve projects on a case by case basis. This approach was taken by the Orange County Groundwater Replenishment System – now the world’s largest water purification system for indirect potable use.
Accounting for Early Recycling Efforts. There have been concerns raised that the bill’s baseline definition (i.e., average annual wastewater discharge baseline volume) that would determine a facility’s diversion requirement penalizes early recycling efforts/investments made by some facilities that predate the baseline determination. For example, since the Orange County Groundwater Replenishment System, referenced above, began in January 2008 (prior to the baseline accounting period in the bill), neither the Orange County Water District nor the Orange County Sanitation District, who spearheaded these recycling efforts, would be able to count these early efforts towards their diversion requirement.
Assorted Other Challenges. Wastewater treatment facility stakeholders have identified a number of other significant challenges to achieving the bill’s targets, including: a potential lack of adequate storage for large quantities of recycled water; potential insufficient year round demand for additional large quantities of recycled water; complex institutional relationships and legal authorities among water and wastewater agencies; high energy use; and other technical concerns posed by the need to manage large quantities of brine as a byproduct of large-scale advanced treatment for potable reuse; the need to scale new advanced treatment facilities to accommodate peak wet weather flows; and public and business acceptance of large new potable recycled water programs.
Encouraging and facilitating the greater use of recycled water is supported by the California Constitution, existing state statutes and regulations. The bold new water recycling targets mandated in this bill will not be easily achievable and could come with significant costs. The underlying policy question is whether this level of additional water recycling warrants the increased costs and how these costs should be prioritized with other urgent drinking water projects given finite resources.
SB 332 is a work in progress and, as such, staff is not recommending a complete series of substantive amendments because doing so would be premature.
Should the Committee decide to move this bill forward, it may wish to consider directing the author to work with Committee staff and stakeholders to address a number of issues raised in the analysis and by stakeholders, including: developing more achievable/workable discharge reduction targets and timeframes, acknowledging the importance of the state adopting the raw water augmentation standards in 2023; providing recognition of early adopters of recycled water; clarifying that NPDES permittees will still be able to discharge a sufficient volume to dispose of brine and meet permit water quality limits; and clarifying that the bill would not require the treatment and reuse of all wet weather flows.
Double Referral:
If this measure is approved by the Environmental Quality Committee, the motion must include the action to refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 606 (Hertzberg, Chapter 14, Statutes of 2018) requires SWRCB and the Department of Water Resources (DWR) to adopt water efficiency regulations, outlines requirements for water suppliers, specifies penalties for violations, and makes technical, conforming changes.
AB 574 (Quirk, Chapter 528, Statutes of 2017) required the SWRCB to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse by December 31, 2023.
SB 918 (Pavley, Chapter 700, Statutes of 2010) requires the Department of Public Health (the responsibility for recycled water has since been shifted to SWRCB) to adopt uniform water recycling criteria for indirect potable water reuse for groundwater recharge by December 31, 2013; to develop and adopt uniform water recycling criteria for surface water augmentation by December 31, 2016; and, to investigate and report on the feasibility of developing uniform water recycling criteria for direct potable reuse.
SOURCE:
Natural Resources Defense Council (Sponsor)
California Coastkeeper Alliance (Co-Sponsor)
SUPPORT:
Ceres
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Environmental Water Caucus
Friends of the River
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Monterey Coastkeeper
Orange County Coastkeeper
Planning and Conservation League
Residents for Responsible Desalination
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Sierra Club California
Southern California Watershed Alliance
The Otter Project
Yuba River Waterkeeper
OPPOSITION:
Association of California Water Agencies
California Association of Sanitation Agencies
California Municipal Utilities Association
California Special Districts Association
Carpinteria Sanitary District
City of Camarillo
Crockett Community Services District
Dublin San Ramon Services District
Las Gallinas Valley Sanitary District
Leucadia Wastewater District
Napa Sanitation District
North Main Water District
Olivenhain Municipal Water District
Rodeo Sanitary District
Stege Sanitary District
Union Sanitary District
Vallecitos Water District
WaterReuse California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to the Natural Resources Defense Council and California Coastkeeper Alliance, “California has well-established state policies that promote water conservation, efficiency, capturing stormwater and the recycling of sanitary effluent. In 2009, with its Recycled Water Policy, the State Water Board made it a statewide goal to recycle 1.5 MAF of wastewater by 2020 and 2.5 MAF by 2030. Unfortunately, California is not on track to meet these goals. Current policies have largely been pursued as independent objectives rather than as part of an integrated statewide strategy to increase the beneficial use of our developed supplies of water by reducing the ocean discharge of sanitary effluent. In December of 2018, the State Water Board adopted its revised Recycled Water Policy with the goal to recycle all dry-weather ocean wastewater discharges statewide.
“SB 332 supports the goals of this Recycled Water Policy by setting aggressive, yet attainable water-saving goals. Specifically, SB 332 sets achievable milestones for wastewater facilities to reduce ocean wastewater discharges by 50 percent by 2030 and 95 percent by 2040. This bill ultimately helps provide a local, resilient water supply that is cheaper and less energy intensive than many other supply options, such as imported water or ocean desalination.
“Reusing treated wastewater also has the potential to help increase flows in our rivers and streams. By bolstering local water supply in coastal regions, we can facilitate retaining and returning flows to the state’s rivers, which is essential to restoring the Delta, as well as the state’s once-thriving populations of salmon and steelhead. Reusing water in coastal communities can ensure that less water is pumped from the Delta, dammed in reservoirs, and diverted from our rivers.
“Cities are already taking the lead and moving in this direction. Last month, the City of Los Angeles announced a bold plan to recycle 100 percent of wastewater currently being discharged to the ocean through the Hyperion Wastewater Treatment Plant – the largest treatment plan west of the Mississippi River – by 2035. This is a major step to expand water recycling and reduce reliance on imported water.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to the California Association of Sanitation Agencies, the California Special Districts Association, the California Municipal Utilities Association, and the Association of California Water Agencies, “The provisions proposed in SB 332 could significantly disrupt existing efforts to promote recycled water production and use, as well as innovative reuse projects currently being planned and implemented.
“California has a significant number of wastewater ocean and bay dischargers, and they vary dramatically in terms of treatment capacity, discharge, and the amount of recycling that occurs. Each watershed, region, treatment facility, and outfall is different, and the capability to beneficially reuse wastewater varies widely as well. Reliable and feasible end uses for recycled water are not always available and depend on factors other than simply the discharger’s technical ability to supply recycled water.
“For this reason, a mandate on every ocean and bay discharger in the state is simply unworkable. In many circumstances, regional demand may not exist to reuse 95 percent of an agency’s ocean discharge. In addition, recharge and reuse options may be unavailable or infeasible for a variety of reasons, such as geographical or legal constraints in the watershed. Furthermore, distribution can require complex arrangements between water recyclers and water purveyors, brine management may present significant issues in some areas, and public acceptance of beneficial reuse of wastewater remains an obstacle. These challenges exist and require a regional approach to the management of recycled water supplies.
“There are numerous technical realities in the wastewater treatment and management processes that have not been considered in SB 332. The bill lacks consideration of major operational issues surrounding brine management, wet weather influent management, existing regulatory constraints relative to minimum flows, and other real and substantive conflicts with how wastewater agencies function in their communities. These technical issues are vast, far reaching, and vary based on the regional watershed and individual permitting levels.”
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):