SB 36: Pretrial release: risk assessment tools.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-08
Existing law, beginning October 1, 2019, and stayed pending voter approval under the powers of referendum pursuant to the California Constitution, requires Pretrial Assessment Services, as defined, to assess a person arrested or detained, as specified, according to a risk assessment instrument, as defined. Existing law requires Pretrial Assessment Services to release from confinement specified individuals based on that risk assessment, and, if the person is not released, to submit that assessment to the court for use in its pretrial release or detention decision.
This bill would require each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to validate the tool by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but no less frequently than once every 3 years, and to make specified information regarding the tool, including validation studies, publicly available. The bill would require the Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied those validation requirements and complied with those transparency requirements. The bill would require the Judicial Council, beginning on December 31, 2020, and on or before December 31 of each year thereafter, to publish a report on its internet website with data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release. The bill would require specified pretrial services agencies, the Department of Justice, courts, and local governments that elect to use risk assessment tools to work with the Judicial Council to provide the data necessary for this report. The bill would also require the Judicial Council, on or before July 1, 2022, to provide a report to the courts and the Legislature containing recommendations to mitigate bias and disparate effect in pretrial decisionmaking.
Existing law, beginning October 1, 2019, requires Pretrial Assessment Services, as defined, to assess a person arrested or detained, as specified, according to a risk assessment instrument, as defined. Existing law requires Pretrial Assessment Services to release from confinement specified individuals based on that risk assessment, and, if the person is not released, to submit that assessment to the court for use in its pretrial release or detention decision.
This bill would require each county to maintain specified data for each individual that undergoes an assessment using the risk assessment tool. By creating additional duties for counties, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Under Californias wealth-based bail and pretrial release system, thousands of individuals from lower economic backgrounds are held in county jails not because they have been convicted of a crime, but simply because they cannot afford to post money bail or pay a commercial bail bond company.
(2)The wealth-based bail system does not protect public safety because it is not based on public safety risk or flight risk.
(3)Many counties have begun to supplement the wealth-based system with a pretrial release system that focuses on public safety and ensuring court appearances.
(4)If used correctly, risk assessment tools that are validated by scientific research can be employed to screen individuals for their flight risk and risk to public safety. This affords individuals awaiting trial an opportunity to be released while providing conditions and supervision that will ensure court appearances and protection of public safety.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that California independently evaluate any risk assessment tool employed in a pretrial setting to measure its effectiveness in predicting flight and public safety risk and to measure the extent to which the results demonstrate bias or disparate effect based on gender, income level, race, or ethnicity.
(c)It is further the intent of the Legislature that policies and practices be adopted to reduce any disparate effect or bias that may result from the use of pretrial risk assessment tools.
SEC. 2.Chapter 1.7 (commencing with Section 1320.35) is added to Title 10 of Part 2 of the Penal Code, to read:1.7.Pretrial Risk Assessment Tool Validation1320.35.(a)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to understand and reduce biases based on gender, income level, race, or ethnicity in pretrial release decisionmaking.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Pretrial risk assessment tool means an instrument used to determine the risks associated with individuals in the pretrial context.
(2)Pretrial services agency means a local public agency that elects to perform pretrial risk assessments on individuals and provides the assessment information to a court.
(3)Release conditions framework means the guidelines used by the pretrail services agency and the court to categorize varying degrees of risk for purposes of recommending whether to release or detain a person, whether to impose pretrial release conditions on a person, and guidance regarding those conditions.
(4)Validate means using scientifically accepted methods to measure both of the following:
(A)The accuracy and reliability of the risk assessment tool in assessing (i) the risk that an assessed person will fail to appear in court as required and (ii) the risk to public safety due to the commission of a new criminal offense if the person is released before the adjudication of the current criminal offense for which they have been charged.
(B)Any disparate effect or bias in the risk assessment tool based on gender, race, or ethnicity.
(c)(1)Any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency shall be validated by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but no less frequently than once every three years. A pretrial services agency may coordinate with the Judicial Council to validate a pretrial risk assessment tool.
(2)A pretrial risk assessment tool shall be validated using the most recent data collected by the pretrial services agency within its jurisdiction, or, if that data is unavailable, using the most recent data collected by a pretrial services agency in a similar jurisdiction within California.
(d)(1)In order to increase transparency, a pretrial services agency shall, with regard to a pretrial risk assessment tool that it utilizes, make the following information publicly available:
(A)Line items, scoring, and weighting, as well as details on how each line item is scored, for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses.
(B)Validation studies for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses.
(2)A pretrial services agency shall, when selecting which pretrial risk assessment tool to utilize, ensure that the agency would be able to comply with paragraph (1) if that tool was selected.
(e)The Judicial Council shall maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied the validation requirement described in subdivision (c) and complied with the transparency requirements described in subdivision (d).
(f)Beginning on or before December 31, 2020, and on or before December 31 of each year thereafter, the Judicial Council shall publish on its internet website a report with data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release. The report shall, at a minimum, include:
(1)The following information on each county pretrial release program:
(A)The name of the pretrial risk assessment tool that is used to inform release decisions by the court.
(B)The release conditions framework used in the county.
(C)Whether a pretrial services agency is conducting interviews as part of the risk assessment.
(2)The following information by superior court in large and medium courts and otherwise aggregated by superior court size:
(A)Rates of release granted prearraignment and rates of release granted pretrial, aggregated by gender, race or ethnicity, ZIP Code of residency and offense type.
(B)The percent of released individuals who make their required court appearances, aggregated by offense type and whether they were released on bail or pursuant to a risk assessment. For those released pursuant to a risk assessment, this information shall be aggregated by risk level.
(C)The percent of released individuals who are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage, aggregated by offense type and whether they were released on bail or pursuant to a risk assessment. For those released pursuant to a risk assessment, this information shall be aggregated by risk level.
(D)The number of assessed individuals by age, ZIP Code of residency, gender, and race or ethnicity.
(E)The number of assessed individuals by risk level, ZIP Code of residency, booking charge level, and release decision.
(F)The number and percentage of assessed individuals who receive pretrial supervision by level of supervision.
(G)The number and percentage of assessed individuals, by supervision level, who fail to appear in court as required, are arrested for a new offense during the pretrial period, or have pretrial release revoked.
(3)The following information on each risk assessment tool:
(A)The percent of released individuals who attend all of their required court appearances and are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage, aggregated by risk level.
(B)Risk levels aggregated by race or ethnicity, gender, offense type, ZIP Code of residency, and release or detention decision.
(C)The predictive accuracy of the tool by gender, race or ethnicity, and offense type.
(D)The proportion of cases in which the release or detention recommendation derived from the risk assessment is different than the release or detention decision imposed by the judicial officer.
(4)If feasible, the Judicial Council shall provide information on any disparate effect in the tools based on income level.
(g)(1)Pretrial services agencies and courts shall provide the Judicial Council the requisite data, as determined by the Judicial Council, to meet the requirements of this section.
(2)The Department of Justice shall work with the Judicial Council to provide the data necessary to fulfill the requirements of this section.
(3)The Judicial Council shall not share any individual-level data with any outside entity unless it has entered into a contract for research purposes with the entity and privacy protections are established to anonymize the data.
(h)The requirements of subdivisions (f) and (g) shall apply to pretrial services agencies that perform risk assessments pursuant to a contractual agreement with the courts, including all of the following:
(1)Agencies funded pursuant to the Budget Act of 2019 as pretrial pilot projects.
(2)Agencies otherwise funded by the state to perform risk assessments.
(3)Other agencies that perform risk assessments as long as sufficient funding is provided to the Judicial Council, the superior courts, and pretrial services agencies to ensure their ability to meet the data reporting requirements and standards set by the Judicial Council.
(i)(1)By July 1, 2022, the Judicial Council shall provide a report to the courts and the Legislature containing recommendations to mitigate bias and disparate effect in pretrial decisionmaking.
(2)A report to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)Under Californias wealth-based bail and pretrial release system, thousands of individuals from lower economic backgrounds are held in county jails not because they have been convicted of a crime, but simply because they cannot afford to post money bail or pay a commercial bail bond company.
(2)The wealth-based bail system does not protect public safety because it is not based on public safety risk or flight risk.
(3)Many counties have begun to replace the wealth-based system with a pretrial release system that focuses on public safety and ensuring court appearances.
(4)If used correctly, risk assessment tools that are validated by scientific research can be employed to screen individuals for their flight risk and risk to public safety. This affords individuals awaiting trial an opportunity to be released while providing conditions and supervision that will ensure court appearances and protection of public safety.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that California independently evaluate any risk assessment tool employed in a pretrial setting to ensure its effectiveness in mitigating flight and public safety risk while minimizing biases and disparate results based on race, ethnicity, gender, economic circumstances, and behavioral or developmental disability.
SEC. 2.Section 1320.35 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1320.35.(a)Each county that uses a risk assessment tool in a pretrial setting shall maintain data, including, but not limited to, information input into the risk assessment tool, outcomes from the risk assessment tool, and recommendations made by the risk assessment tool, for each individual that undergoes an assessment using the risk assessment tool.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this section to understand and reduce biases based on race, ethnicity, gender, economic circumstances, and behavioral or developmental disabilities in pretrial release decisionmaking.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 589, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 8, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 18, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (June 19). |
| Jun 11, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 4, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 9, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Mar 29, 2019 | Set for hearing April 8. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 13, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Set for hearing March 26. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB36 Hertzberg et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | SB 36 Hertzberg Senate Third Reading By Weber | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 11, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB36 Hertzberg et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 36 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 36
Author: Hertzberg (D) and Mitchell (D), et al.
Amended: 9/6/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/26/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0, 4/25/19
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Archuleta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/10/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Pretrial release: risk assessment tools
SOURCE: Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Californians for Safety and Justice
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
NextGen California
Service Employees International Union California
Western Center on Law and Poverty
DIGEST:
This bill requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to validate the tool on a regular basis and requires the Judicial Council to publish a yearly report on its Web site with specified data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release.
Assembly Amendments
:
- Specify that each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool shall validate the tool by January 1, 2021.
- Amend the frequency of the validation to occur no less than once every three years.
- Delete provisions in the bill related to the pretrial services agency maintaining specified data regarding a pretrial risk assessment tool and publishing such data on the agency’s Web site.
- Require the Judicial Council to publish a yearly report on its website with specified data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release.
- Require pretrial services agencies, the Department of Justice, courts and local governments that elect to use risk assessment tools to work with the Judicial Council to provide the data necessary for the report required under the bill.
- Require Judicial Council to provide a report to the courts and the Legislature containing recommendations to mitigate bias and disparate effect in pretrial decisionmaking.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the officer in charge of a jail, or the clerk of the superior court to approve and accept bail in the amount fixed by the arrest warrant, the bail schedule, or an order admitting to bail in case or surety bond, and to issue and sign an order for the release of the arrested person, and to set a time and place for the person’s appearance in court. (Pen. Code, 1269b, subd. (a).)
- Authorizes a court or other magistrate who could release a person from custody upon giving bail to release a person who has been arrested for, or charged with, any offense other than a capital offense, on the person’s own recognizance (OR). (Pen. Code, § 1270.)
- States that a person charged with a misdemeanor is entitled to an OR release unless the court makes a finding on the record, with public safety as the primary consideration, that an OR release will compromise public safety or will not reasonably assure the appearance of the defendant as required. If the court makes one of those findings, the court shall then set bail and specify the conditions, if any, under which the defendant shall be released. (Id.)
- Prohibits the release of a defendant on their OR for any violent felony until a hearing is held in open court and the prosecuting attorney is given notice and an opportunity to be heard on the matter. (Pen. Code, § 1319.)
- Specifies the conditions for a defendant's release on their OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.)
- Authorizes a court, with the concurrence of the board of supervisors, to employ an investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (a).)
- States that whenever a court has employed investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR, an investigative report shall be prepared in all cases involved in a violent felony listed in Penal Code Section 667.5(c), or a felony violation of driving under the influence and causing bodily injury to another person, recommending whether the defendant should be released on OR. The report shall include specified information.
This bill:
- States that it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting this bill to understand and reduce biases based on gender, income level, race or ethnicity in pretrial release decisionmaking.
- Provides the following definitions:
- “Pretrial risk assessment tool” means an instrument used to determine the risks associated with individuals in the pretrial context;
- “Pretrial services agency” means a local public agency that elects to perform pretrial risk assessments on individuals and provides the assessment information to a court;
- “Release conditions framework” means the guidelines used by the pretrial services agency and the court to categorize varying degrees of risk for purposes of recommending whether to release or detain a person, whether to impose pretrial release conditions on a person, and guidance regarding those condition; and,
- “Validate” means using scientifically accepted methods to measure the following:
- The accuracy and reliability of the risk assessment tool in assessing the risk that an assessed person will fail to appear in court as required and the risk to public safety due to the commission of a new criminal offense if the person is released before the adjudication of the current criminal offense for which they have been charged; and,
- Any disparate effect or bias in the risk assessment tool based on gender, race or ethnicity.
- Requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but no less frequently then once every three years and provides that a pretrial services agency may coordinate with the Judicial Council to validate a pretrial risk assessment tool.
- Provides that a pretrial risk assessment tool shall be validated using the most recent data collected by the pretrial services agency within its jurisdiction, or if that data is unavailable, using the most recent data collected by a pretrial services agency in a similar jurisdiction within California.
- States that in order to increase transparency, a pretrial services agency shall, with regard to a pretrial risk assessment tool that it utilizes, make the following information publicly available:
- Line items, scoring, and weighting, as well as details on how each line item is scored, for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses; and,
- Validation studies for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses.
- Requires a pretrial services agency, when selecting which pretrial risk assessment tool to utilize, to ensure that the agency would be able comply with the information that is it required to make publicly available if that tool was selected.
- Requires Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied the validation and transparency requirements pursuant to this bill.
- Requires Judicial Council, beginning on or before December 31, 2020, and on or before December 31 of each year thereafter, to publish on its Internet Web site a report with data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release.
- Provides that the report shall, at minimum, include:
- The following information on each county pretrial release program:
- The name of the pretrial risk assessment tool that is used to inform release decisions by the court;
- The release conditions framework used in the county; and,
- Whether a pretrial services agency is conducting interviews as part of the risk assessment.
- The following information by superior court in large and medium courts and otherwise aggregated by superior court size:
- Rates of release granted prearraignment and rates of release granted pretrial, aggregated by gender, race or ethnicity, ZIP Code of residency and offense type;
- The percent of released individuals who make their required court appearances, aggregated by offense type and whether they were released on bail or pursuant to a risk assessment. For those released pursuant to a risk assessment, this information shall be aggregated by risk level;
- The percent of released individuals who are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage, aggregated by offense type and whether they were released on bail or pursuant to a risk assessment. For those released pursuant to a risk assessment, this information shall be aggregated by risk level;
- The number of assessed individuals by age, ZIP Code of residency, gender, and race or ethnicity;
- The number of assessed individuals by risk level, ZIP Code of residency, booking charge level, and release decision;
- The number and percentage of assessed individuals who receive pretrial supervision by level of supervision; and,
- The number and percentage of assessed individuals, by supervision level, who fail to appear in court as required, are arrested for a new offense during the pretrial period, or have pretrial release revoked.
- The following information on each risk assessment tool:
- The percent of released individuals who attend all of their required court appearances and are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage, aggregated by risk level;
- Risk levels aggregated by race or ethnicity, gender, offense type, ZIP Code of residency, and release or detention decision;
- The predictive accuracy of the tool by gender, race or ethnicity, and offense type; and,
- The proportion of cases in which the release or detention recommendation derived from the risk assessment is different than the release or detention decision imposed by the judicial officer.
- Information on any disparate effect in the tools based on income level, if feasible.
- The following information on each county pretrial release program:
- States that pretrial services agencies and courts shall provide the Judicial Council the requisite data, as determined by the Judicial Council, to meet the requirements of this bill.
- Requires the Department of Justice to work with the Judicial Council to provide the data necessary to fulfill the requirements of this bill.
- Prohibits the Judicial Council from sharing any individual-level data with any outside entity unless it has entered into a contract for research purpose with the entity and privacy protections are established to anonymize the data.
- Specifies that the reporting and data-sharing requirements of this bill apply to pretrial services agencies that perform risk assessments pursuant to contractual agreements with the courts, including all of the following:
- Agencies funded pursuant to the Budget Act of 2019 as pretrial pilot projects;
- Agencies otherwise funded by the state to perform risk assessments; and,
- Other agencies that perform risk assessments as long as sufficient funding is provided to the Judicial Council, the superior courts, and pretrial services agencies to ensure their ability to meet the data reporting requirements and standards set by the Judicial Council.
- States that, by July 1, 2022, the Judicial Council shall provide a report to the courts and the Legislature containing recommendations to mitigate bias and disparate effect in pretrial decisionmaking.
Comments
According to the author of this bill, “Currently, 49 of 58 California counties use one of eight different pretrial risk assessment instruments to help determine the likelihood that an arrestee will commit a new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. Generally, these tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant’s trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor and absorbable one-time and annual costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to assist pretrial services agencies with risk assessment validation and to maintain a list of agencies that are compliant with validation and transparency requirements.
- Possibly minor reimbursable local costs to county pretrial services agencies to collect and maintain information about defendants being released on their own recognizance and to regularly validate their risk assessment tools for accuracy.
Anti-Recidivism Coalition (co-source)
Californians for Safety and Justice (co-source)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights (co-source)
NextGen California (co-source)
Service Employees International Union California (co-source)
Western Center on Law and Poverty (co-source)
California Public Defenders Association
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Disability Rights California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/10/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 9/10/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. /
9/10/19 22:08:22
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 36
Author:(Hertzberg and Mitchell)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to regularly validate the tool, and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available.
Major Provisions
- Requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but at least once every three years.
- Requires the Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial service agencies that have satisfied the validation requirement and complied with transparency requirements.
- Requires the Judicial Council beginning on December 31, 2020, and yearly thereafter to publish specified data on pretrial pilot projects funded under the Budget Act of 2019 and any agencies otherwise funded by the state to perform risk assessments.
- Requires the Judicial Council to provide a report to the courts and the Legislature containing recommendations to mitigate bias and disparate effects in pretrial decision making by July 1, 2022.
COMMENTS:
Risk Assessment Tools: Risk assessment tools are "empirically based tools that aim to estimate the likelihood of appearance in court with no new arrest, thereby providing information that can support objective and transparent decision-making" (See S. Desmarias & E. Lowder, Pretrial Risk Assessment Tools, A Primer for Judges, Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys, Feb. 2019, p. 3, < http://www.safetyandjusticechallenge.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Pretrial-Risk-Assessment-Primer-February-2019.pdf>). The goal of these pre-trial risk assessments tools is to provide objective, empirical evidence to inform decisions on pretrial release (Ibid). These tools assign a risk level to individuals based on questions asked to a defendant and/or obtained from the defendant's criminal history information. Pretrial risk assessment tools are meant to provide judges an additional decision-making tool, not supplant judicial decision making.
Automated risk assessments are becoming increasingly popular with courts around the country. According to the Judicial Council's Pretrial Detention Reform Workgroup, as of October 2017, 49 of California's 58 counties use a pretrial risk assessment tool. There are eight different types of risk assessment tools predominantly used among the counties. A few counties use county-specific risk assessment tools. The most commonly-used tools are Virginia Pretrial Risk Assessment Instrument (VPRAI) (17 counties), Ohio Risk Assessment System (ORAS-Pretrial) (17 counties), and COMPAS (4 counties) (See Pretrial Detention Reform-Recommendations to the Chief Justice, October 2017, Appendix G at pages 101-102, available at: https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/PDRReport-20171023.pdf>).
As stated on the Council of State Governments Justice Center website, "Risk and needs assessments are fundamental to reducing recidivism, but only when they perform as intended. It is imperative that agencies regularly evaluate their implementation of these tools and the predictive accuracy of the results, especially across race and gender groups" (https://csgjusticecenter.org/partner-with-us/improving-risk-and-needs-assessment-accuracy/).
There has been increased public scrutiny regarding the potential problems with risk assessments. For example, in 2016 ProPublica analyzed the risk assessment software known as COMPAS and concluded that the tool disproportionately incorrectly labels black defendants as higher risk of committing future crime (See Machine Bias, J. Angwin, J. Larson, S. Mattu & L Kirchner, May 23, 2016 https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing). Essentially, the concern is that while risk assessments appear to be neutral and unbiased because they are based on mathematical models, the algorithms may have systemic bias built directly into their designs: the algorithms predict future conduct based on historical data, which may reflect historical systemic bias.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "Currently, 49 of 58 California counties use one of eight different pretrial risk assessment instruments to help determine the likelihood that an arrestee will commit a new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. Generally, these tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant's trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Public Defenders Association (CPDA), "CPDA has significant concerns about the use of risk assessments instruments in pretrial release decisions, given their potential for perpetuating systemic bias based on race and socio-economic status. For this reason, CPDA supports the intent of this bill to collect data and outcomes from the use of these instruments and to provide transparency in their implementation. It is critically important that we not replace one flawed system of pretrial justice (money-based release) with another (release based on unvalidated and potentially biased algorithms). Given that the use of risk assessment instruments is already on the horizon, the data collection and validation process required by this bill may help determine whether the instruments used are furthering or hindering a more just system of pretrial release."
Arguments in Opposition:
None.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor and absorbable one-time and annual costs (General Fund) to Judicial Council to assist pretrial services agencies with risk assessment validation and to maintain a list of agencies that are compliant with validation and transparency requirements.
2) Possibly minor reimbursable local costs to county pretrial services agencies to collect and maintain information about defendants being released on their own recognizance and to regularly validate their risk assessment tools for accuracy.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-1
YES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk, Santiago, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Friedman, Fong, Gabriel, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Eduardo Garcia
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Sandy Uribe (Counsel) / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0002025
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 36
Author:(Hertzberg and Mitchell)
As Amended Ver:June 4, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to regularly validate the tool, and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available.
Major Provisions
- Requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but at least once every three years.
- Requires pretrial services agencies to collect specified data regarding any risk assessment tool that it uses.
- Requires a pretrial services agency to make specified information regarding its pretrial risk assessment tool publicly available.
- Requires a pretrial services agency to publish a report on its internet website with specified aggregate data. The report must be published by July 1, 2021, and yearly thereafter.
- Requires the Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial service agencies that have satisfied the validation requirement and complied with transparency requirements.
COMMENTS:
Risk Assessment Tools: Risk assessment tools are "empirically based tools that aim to estimate the likelihood of appearance in court with no new arrest, thereby providing information that can support objective and transparent decision-making" (See S. Desmarias & E. Lowder, Pretrial Risk Assessment Tools, A Primer for Judges, Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys, Feb. 2019, p. 3, < http://www.safetyandjusticechallenge.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Pretrial-Risk-Assessment-Primer-February-2019.pdf>). The goal of these pre-trial risk assessments tools is to provide objective, empirical evidence to inform decisions on pretrial release (Ibid). These tools assign a risk level to individuals based on questions asked to a defendant and/or obtained from the defendant's criminal history information. Pretrial risk assessment tools are meant to provide judges an additional decision-making tool, not supplant judicial decision making.
Automated risk assessments are becoming increasingly popular with courts around the country. According to the Judicial Council's Pretrial Detention Reform Workgroup, as of October 2017, 49 of California's 58 counties use a pretrial risk assessment tool. There are eight different types of risk assessment tools predominantly used among the counties. A few counties use county-specific risk assessment tools. The most commonly-used tools are Virginia Pretrial Risk Assessment Instrument (VPRAI) (17 counties), Ohio Risk Assessment System (ORAS-Pretrial) (17 counties), and COMPAS (4 counties) (See Pretrial Detention Reform-Recommendations to the Chief Justice, October 2017, Appendix G at pages 101-102, available at: https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/PDRReport-20171023.pdf>).
As stated on the Council of State Governments Justice Center website, "Risk and needs assessments are fundamental to reducing recidivism, but only when they perform as intended. It is imperative that agencies regularly evaluate their implementation of these tools and the predictive accuracy of the results, especially across race and gender groups" (https://csgjusticecenter.org/partner-with-us/improving-risk-and-needs-assessment-accuracy/).
There has been increased public scrutiny regarding the potential problems with risk assessments. For example, in 2016 ProPublica analyzed the risk assessment software known as COMPAS and concluded that the tool disproportionately incorrectly labels black defendants as higher risk of committing future crime (See Machine Bias, J. Angwin, J. Larson, S. Mattu & L Kirchner, May 23, 2016 https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing). Essentially, the concern is that while risk assessments appear to be neutral and unbiased because they are based on mathematical models, the algorithms may have systemic bias built directly into their designs: the algorithms predict future conduct based on historical data, which may reflect historical systemic bias.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "Currently, 49 of 58 California counties use one of eight different pretrial risk assessment instruments to help determine the likelihood that an arrestee will commit a new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. Generally, these tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant's trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Public Defenders Association (CPDA), "CPDA has significant concerns about the use of risk assessments instruments in pretrial release decisions, given their potential for perpetuating systemic bias based on race and socio-economic status. For this reason, CPDA supports the intent of this bill to collect data and outcomes from the use of these instruments and to provide transparency in their implementation. It is critically important that we not replace one flawed system of pretrial justice (money-based release) with another (release based on unvalidated and potentially biased algorithms). Given that the use of risk assessment instruments is already on the horizon, the data collection and validation process required by this bill may help determine whether the instruments used are furthering or hindering a more just system of pretrial release."
Arguments in Opposition:
None submitted.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor and absorbable one-time and annual costs (GF) to Judicial Council to assist pretrial services agencies with risk assessment validation and to maintain a list of agencies that are compliant with validation and transparency requirements.
- Possibly minor reimbursable local costs to county pretrial services agencies to collect and maintain information about defendants being released on their own recognizance and to regularly validate their risk assessment tools for accuracy.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-1
YES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk, Santiago, Wicks
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Friedman, Fong, Gabriel, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Eduardo Garcia
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 4, 2019
CONSULTANT: Sandy Uribe (Counsel) / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001134
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 36
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 4, 2019
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool for purposes of determining pretrial release to regularly validate the tool and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires pretrial services agencies that use a pretrial risk assessment tool collect and retain information regarding individuals assessed for release, performance measures and release outcomes.
- Mandates any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated on a regular basis, but no less than once every three years.
- Requires a pretrial services agency make information regarding its pretrial risk assessment publically available and, beginning July 1, 2021, and on or before July 1 of each year thereafter, publish a report on its internet website with data related to outcomes and potential biases in pretrial release.
- Requires Judicial Council maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied the requirements of this bill and allows pretrial services agencies to coordinate with Judicial Council to validate their risk assessment tools.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor and absorbable one-time and annual costs (GF) to Judicial Council to assist pretrial services agencies with risk assessment validation and to maintain a list of agencies that are compliant with validation and transparency requirements.
- Possibly minor reimbursable local costs to county pretrial services agencies to collect and maintain information about defendants being released on their own recognizance and to regularly validate their risk assessment tools for accuracy.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
[Pretrial risk assessment] tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant’s trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy.
This bill would require pretrial services agencies to comply with certain data requirements and make certain information about the risk assessment tools publicly available. This bill also requires regular validation of risk assessment tools in order to ensure accuracy.
- Background on Pretrial Services. Pretrial services agencies may include probation, sheriff’s departments or other county offices responsible for assessing criminal defendants for possible own recognizance release and provide information upon sentencing. SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2018 requires pretrial defendants be assessed for release using risk assessment tools rather than posting money bail to secure release. A referendum of SB 10 will be on the ballot in November 2020. Existing law is unclear as to whether the Legislature may amend portions of a law pending a referendum vote. However, this bill does not amend the provisions enacted by SB 10. Rather, this bill requires existing pretrial services agencies to validate the risk assessment tools used to determine which defendants are suitable for release.
- Prior Legislation. SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2018, creates a risk-based non-monetary pre-arraignment and pretrial release system for people arrested for criminal offenses including preventative detention procedures for persons determined to be too high a risk to assure public safety if released.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 11, 2019
Counsel: Sandy Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 36
Author:(Hertzberg) – As Amended Ver:June 4, 2019
SUMMARY: Requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to regularly validate the tool, and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available. Specifically, this bill:
- States legislative intent to understand and reduce biases based on race, ethnicity, gender, age, economic circumstances, and behavioral or developmental disabilities in pretrial release decision making.
- Requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated by January 1, 2021, and on a regular basis thereafter, but at least once every three years.
- Defines “validated,” as specified.
- States that validation of a pretrial risk assessment tool shall use the most recent data collected by the agency within its jurisdiction. If that data is unavailable, the agency may use the most recent data collected by a similar pretrial services agency in a similar jurisdiction in the state.
- Allows a pretrial services agency to coordinate with the Judicial Council for purposes of validation.
- Mandates the Judicial Council to maintain a list of agencies that have complied with the validation requirement.
- Requires pretrial services agencies to collect the following data regarding any risk assessment tool that it uses:
- Input information, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
- The age, gender, ethnicity, and arrest offense for each individual assessed using the pretrial risk assessment tool; and
- The total number of individuals assessed.
- Performance measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The number of interviews and assessments conducted on eligible detained individuals;
- The number of assessed individuals, aggregated by risk level;
- The number of cases in which the detention or release recommendation by the agency conducting the assessment does not conform with the release or detention decision of the judicial officer;
- The rate at which the pretrial assessment staff conducting the assessments follows pretrial risk assessment criteria when recommending release or detention; and,
- The rate at which judicial officers follow the detention or release recommendation of pretrial risk assessment staff; and,
- The rate at which judicial officers make a pretrial detention decision that is more restrictive than the release recommendation of pretrial risk assessment staff.
- Outcome measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and released individuals who make all scheduled court appearances;
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and released individuals who are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage;
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and released individuals who are not arrested for a new offense during the pretrial stage;
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and supervised individuals whose supervision level or detention status corresponds with their assessed risk of pretrial misconduct;
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and released individuals who violated conditions of release that resulted in revocation of pretrial release; and,
- The percentage and raw number of assessed and released individuals who appear for scheduled court appearances, are not charged with any new offense during pretrial supervision, and did not receive a court remand.
- All of the following data:
- The number of individuals released, aggregated by release types, ordered during a specified timeframe;
- The number of supervised defendants divided by the number of pretrial officers or case managers;
- The time between the pretrial services agency’s assumption of supervision of an individual and the end of supervision of the individual; and,
- The proportion of pretrial defendants who are detained at any point throughout pretrial case processing.
- Input information, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
- Requires a pretrial services agency to make specified information regarding its pretrial risk assessment tool publicly available.
- Requires a pretrial services agency to publish a report on its internet website with specified aggregate data. The report must be published by July 1, 2021, and yearly thereafter.
- Requires the Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial service agencies that have satisfied the validation requirement and complied with transparency requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a court, with the concurrence of the board of supervisors, to employ an investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on their own recognizance (OR). (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (a).)
- States that whenever a court has employed investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR, an investigative report shall be prepared in all cases involved in a violent felony, as specified, or a felony violation of driving under the influence and causing bodily injury to another person, recommending whether the defendant should be released on OR. The report shall include specified information. (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (b).)
- Authorizes a court or other magistrate who could release a person from custody upon giving bail to release a person who has been arrested for, or charged with, any offense other than a capital offense, on the person's OR. (Pen. Code, § 1270.)
- States that a person charged with a misdemeanor is entitled to an OR release unless the court makes a finding on the record, with public safety as the primary consideration, that an OR release will compromise public safety or will not reasonably assure the appearance of the defendant as required. If the court makes one of those findings, the court shall then set bail and specify the conditions, if any, under which the defendant shall be released. (Id.)
- Prohibits the release of a defendant on their OR for any violent felony until a hearing is held in open court and the prosecuting attorney is given notice and an opportunity to be heard on the matter. (Pen. Code, § 1319.)
- Specifies the conditions for a defendant's release on OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “Currently, 49 of 58 California counties use one of eight different pretrial risk assessment instruments to help determine the likelihood that an arrestee will commit a new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. Generally, these tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant’s trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy.”
- Pretrial Services: According to the California Association of Pretrial Services Website, pretrial services agencies are important because they improve the court’s release and detention decision-making process. They also protect public safety by ensuring that only those defendants who can safely be released are released. Use of pretrial services agencies also increases the use of non-financial release alternatives, which reduces the percentage of pretrial detainees in the jail. Finally, pretrial services agencies can save taxpayer dollars by reducing the costs of jailing pretrial defendants (http://pretrialservicesca.org/about)
Services provided by pretrial services can include: jail screening and interviewing of all arrestees; investigation of the arrestee's ties to the community, past record, potential dangerousness to the community, past history of failures to appear, and the seriousness of the current criminal charges; preparation of a written report to the court and the presiding magistrate, summarizing the defendant's ties to the community and a recommendation for or against release; case monitoring of conditions of release and court date notification system for defendants; supervised release for selected defendants; social services referrals for defendants; and follow-up services to locate defendants who have failed to appear and return them to the court system without the unnecessary costs of an arrest. (http://pretrialservicesca.org/about) - Risk Assessment Tools: Risk assessment tools are “empirically based tools that aim to estimate the likelihood of appearance in court with no new arrest, thereby providing information that can support objective and transparent decision-making.” (See S. Desmarias & E. Lowder, Pretrial Risk Assessment Tools, A Primer for Judges, Prosecutors and Defense Attorneys, Feb. 2019, p. 3, < http://www.safetyandjusticechallenge.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/Pretrial-Risk-Assessment-Primer-February-2019.pdf>.) The goal of these pre-trial risk assessments tools is to provide objective, empirical evidence to inform decisions on pretrial release. (Ibid.) These tools assign a risk level to individuals based on questions asked to a defendant and/or obtained from the defendant’s criminal history information. Pretrial risk assessment tools are meant to provide judges an additional decision-making tool, not supplant judicial decision making.
Automated risk assessments are becoming increasingly popular with courts around the country. According to the Judicial Council’s Pretrial Detention Reform Workgroup, as of October 2017, 49 of California’s 58 counties use a pretrial risk assessment tool. There are eight different types of risk assessment tools predominantly used among the counties. A few counties use county-specific risk assessment tools. The most commonly-used tools are VPRAI (17 counties), ORAS-Pretrial (17 counties), and COMPAS (4 counties). (See Pretrial Detention Reform-Recommendations to the Chief Justice, October 2017, Appendix G at pages 101-102, available at: https://www.courts.ca.gov/documents/PDRReport-20171023.pdf>.)
As stated on the Council of State Governments Justice Center website, “Risk and needs assessments are fundamental to reducing recidivism, but only when they perform as intended. It is imperative that agencies regularly evaluate their implementation of these tools and the predictive accuracy of the results, especially across race and gender groups.” (https://csgjusticecenter.org/partner-with-us/improving-risk-and-needs-assessment-accuracy/)
There has been increased public scrutiny regarding the potential problems with risk assessments. For example, in 2016 ProPublica analyzed the risk assessment software known as COMPAS and concluded that the tool disproportionately incorrectly labels black defendants as higher risk of committing future crime. (See Machine Bias, J. Angwin, J. Larson, S. Mattu & L Kirchner, May 23, 2016 https://www.propublica.org/article/machine-bias-risk-assessments-in-criminal-sentencing ) Essentially, the concern is that while risk assessments appear to be neutral and unbiased because they are based on mathematical models, the algorithms may have systemic bias built directly into their designs: the algorithms predict future conduct based on historical data, which may reflect historical systemic bias. For example,
Arrest statistics, which are generated by historically biased patterns of criminal law enforcement, provide a prime example of how bias can be intertwined with the data. An excessive police presence in communities of color naturally fosters more contact between those communities and law enforcement. Greater police contact leads to more arrests, creating the impression that heavily policed communities are more prone to crime.
The problem is found not only in what the arrest data measure—crimes stemming from interactions between police and particular communities—but in what the data fail to measure: crimes that are committed by those who reside in communities that are not subjected to police scrutiny. At bottom, data informed by arrests are actually better indicators and predictors of police behavior—where they decide to patrol, who they interact with, and who gets arrested—than they are of the future behavior of individuals facing criminal charges. And, unfortunately, in jurisdictions where arrests play a role in the pretrial process as an indicator of one’s risk to public safety or flight, biased policing patterns and the resultant data will unfairly overstate the risk of those from overpoliced communities. (What Does Fairness Look Like? Conversations on Race, Risk Assessment Tools, and Pretrial Justice, Center on Race, Inequality and the Law at NYU Law and ACLU, October 2018, p. 12-13, available at: http://www.law.nyu.edu/sites/default/files/Final%20Report--ACLU-NYU%20CRIL%20Convening%20on%20Race%20Risk%20Assessment%20%20Fairness.pdf.)
Because many risk assessment tools are proprietary, often we do not know what algorithms they are comprised of, or what weight is given to respective inputs.
The goal of this bill is to minimize disparate results and bias based on race, gender, age, economic circumstances, or disability status. This bill would require pretrial services agencies which use a pretrial risk assessment tool to validate it on a regular basis. This bill would also require that the agency collect, maintain, and publish data regarding individuals assessed by the tool, as well as specified performance measures and outcome measures.
However, this bill does not necessarily address transparency and oversight with regards to the algorithms and data sets that the risk assessment tools use to predict outcomes. The Legislature may want to consider whether algorithmic transparency should also be addressed.
- Arguments in Support:
- According to the Anti-Recidivism Coalition, a co-sponsor of this bill, “many counties have begun using pretrial risk assessment instruments as an aid in determining the likelihood that an arrestee will commit new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. By assessing an individual’s risk based on a set of several input factors, these instruments provide judges with additional information in making pretrial release decisions. Currently 49 of California’s 58 counties use one of eight different risk assessment instruments in their pretrial processes.
“However, despite the widespread adoption of these tools, there is currently no statewide requirement regarding the transparency of their inner workings, making them far less accountable to the communities they affect. Moreover, counties are under no obligation to maintain individualized data on the tools’ inputs and outputs, complicating any effort to honestly evaluate them and protect against discriminatory outcomes.
“California needs a strong statewide framework for ensuring the proper use of pretrial risk assessment tools and collecting data associated with their use. For these reasons and others, we are proud to co-sponsor SB 36.” - According to the California Public Defenders Association (CPDA), “CPDA has significant concerns about the use of risk assessments instruments in pretrial release decisions, given their potential for perpetuating systemic bias based on race and socio-economic status. For this reason, CPDA supports the intent of this bill to collect data and outcomes from the use of these instruments and to provide transparency in their implementation. It is critically important that we not replace one flawed system of pretrial justice (money-based release) with another (release based on unvalidated and potentially biased algorithms). Given that the use of risk assessment instruments is already on the horizon, the data collection and validation process required by this bill may help determine whether the instruments used are furthering or hindering a more just system of pretrial release.”
- According to the Anti-Recidivism Coalition, a co-sponsor of this bill, “many counties have begun using pretrial risk assessment instruments as an aid in determining the likelihood that an arrestee will commit new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. By assessing an individual’s risk based on a set of several input factors, these instruments provide judges with additional information in making pretrial release decisions. Currently 49 of California’s 58 counties use one of eight different risk assessment instruments in their pretrial processes.
- Related Legislation: SB 141 (Bates), would require the Board of Parole Hearings to consider the results of a comprehensive validated risk assessment for sex offenders in considering parole of an inmate with a prior conviction for a sexually violent offense. SB 141 will be heard in this committee today.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2018, creates a risk-based non-monetary prearraignment and pretrial release system for people arrested for criminal offenses including preventative detention procedures for person’s determined to be too high a risk to assure public safety if released.
- SB 1198 (Wilk), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have required the State-Authorized Risk Assessment Tool for Sex Offenders (SARATSO) Review Committee to sponsor research on related to recidivism and cessation from offending, as specified. SB 1198 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 789 (Rubio), Chapter 554, Statutes of 2017, allows a court to approve, without a hearing, own recognizance (OR) release under a court-operated or court-approved pretrial release program for arrestees of specified felony offenses with three or more prior failures to appear.
- SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2018, creates a risk-based non-monetary prearraignment and pretrial release system for people arrested for criminal offenses including preventative detention procedures for person’s determined to be too high a risk to assure public safety if released.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Anti-Recidivism Coalition (Co-Sponsor)
Californians for Safety and Justice (Co-Sponsor)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights (Co-Sponsor)
NextGen California (Co-Sponsor)
Service Employees International Union (Co-Sponsor)
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc. (Co-Sponsor)
Bay Area Regional Health Inequities Initiative
California Faculty Association
California Public Defenders Association
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Disability Rights California
League of Women Voters of California
Media Alliance
Showing Up for Racial Justice Bay Area
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 36 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 36
Author: Hertzberg (D) and Mitchell (D), et al.
Amended: 3/13/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 3/26/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Pretrial release: risk assessment tools
SOURCE: Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Californians for Safety and Justice
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
NextGen California
Service Employees International Union California
Western Center on Law and Poverty
DIGEST:
This bill requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to maintain specified data and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available.
Existing law:
- Authorizes the officer in charge of a jail, or the clerk of the superior court to approve and accept bail in the amount fixed by the arrest warrant, the bail schedule, or an order admitting to bail in case or surety bond, and to issue and sign an order for the release of the arrested person, and to set a time and place for the person’s appearance in court. (Pen. Code, 1269b, subd. (a).)
- Authorizes a court or other magistrate who could release a person from custody upon giving bail to release a person who has been arrested for, or charged with, any offense other than a capital offense, on the person’s own recognizance (OR). (Pen. Code, § 1270.)
- States that a person charged with a misdemeanor is entitled to an OR release unless the court makes a finding on the record, with public safety as the primary consideration, that an OR release will compromise public safety or will not reasonably assure the appearance of the defendant as required. If the court makes one of those findings, the court shall then set bail and specify the conditions, if any, under which the defendant shall be released. (Id.)
- Prohibits the release of a defendant on their OR for any violent felony until a hearing is held in open court and the prosecuting attorney is given notice and an opportunity to be heard on the matter. (Pen. Code, § 1319.)
- Specifies the conditions for a defendant's release on their OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.)
- Authorizes a court, with the concurrence of the board of supervisors, to employ an investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (a).)
- States that whenever a court has employed investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR, an investigative report shall be prepared in all cases involved in a violent felony listed in Penal Code Section 667.5(c), or a felony violation of driving under the influence and causing bodily injury to another person, recommending whether the defendant should be released on OR. The report shall include specified information.
This bill:
- Requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to collect and retain all of the following information regarding any pretrial risk assessment tool that it uses:
- Input information, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
- The age, gender, ethnicity, and arrest offense for each individual assessed using the pretrial risk assessment tool; and,
- The total number of individuals assessed.
- Performance measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The number of interviews and assessments conducted on eligible booked individuals;
- The number of assessed individuals, aggregated by risk level;
- The number of cases in which the detention or release recommendation by the agency conducting the assessment does not conform with the release or detention decision of the judicial officer;
- The rate at which the pretrial assessment staff conducting the assessments follows pretrial risk assessment criteria when recommending release or detention; and,
- The rate at which judicial officers follow the detention or release recommendation of pretrial risk assessment staff.
- Outcome measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The percentage of assessed individuals who make all scheduled court appearances.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who are not arrested for a new offense during the pretrial stage.
- The ratio of assessed and supervised individuals whose supervision level or detention status corresponds with their assessed risk of pretrial misconduct.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who violated conditions of release that resulted in revocation of pretrial release; and,
- The percentage of assessed and released individuals who appear for scheduled court appearances, are not charged with any new offense during pretrial supervision, and did not receive a court remand.
- All of the following additional data:
- The number of individuals released, aggregated by release types, ordered during a specified timeframe;
- The number of supervised defendants divided by the number of pretrial officers or case managers;
- The time between the pretrial services agency’s assumption of supervision of an individual and the end of supervision of the individual; and,
- The proportion of pretrial defendants who are detained at any point throughout pretrial case processing.
- Input information, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
- Provides the following definitions:
- “Pretrial risk assessment tool” means an instrument used to determine the risks associated with individuals in the pretrial context;
- “Pretrial services agency” means an agency or organization designated by the county to conduct pretrial risk assessments and provide other pretrial services to defendants; and,
- “Validated” means that the overall input criteria and each individual input criterion for a risk assessment tool have been evaluated, calibrated, and normalized using statistical methods to optimize accuracy and have been demonstrated by scientific research to be accurate and reliable in assessing the risk of a person failing to appear in court as required or the risk to public safety due to the commission of a new criminal offense if the person is released before adjudication of their current criminal offense and to minimize bias.
- Requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated on a regular basis, but no less frequently then once every six months and provides that a pretrial services agency may coordinate with the Judicial Council to validate a pretrial risk assessment tool.
- States that in order to increase transparency, a pretrial services agency shall, with regard to a pretrial risk assessment tool that it utilizes, make the following information publicly available:
- Line items, scoring, and weighting, as well as details on how each line item is scored, for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses; and,
- Validation studies for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses.
- Requires a pretrial services agency to, when selecting which pretrial risk assessment tool to utilize, consider if the agency would be able to comply with the information that is it required to make publicly available if that tool was selected.
- Requires Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied the validation requirements and transparency requirements pursuant to this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
Anti-Recidivism Coalition (co-source)
Californians for Safety and Justice (co-source)
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights (co-source)
NextGen California (co-source)
Service Employees International Union California (co-source)
Western Center on Law and Poverty (co-source)
California Public Defenders Association
Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
Disability Rights California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
None received
Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. /
4/10/19 15:28:24
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 36 Hearing Date: March 26, 2019
Author: | Hertzberg | ||
Version: | March 13, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Pretrial Release: Risk Assessment Tools
HISTORY
Source: Anti-Recidivism Coalition
Californians for Safety and Justice
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
NextGen California
Service Employees International Union (SEIU) California
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Prior Legislation: SB 10 (Hertzberg), Ch. 244, Stats. 2018
AB 42 (Bonta), failed passage on Assembly Floor, 2017
AB 789 (Rubio), Ch. 554, Stats. 2017
AB 805 (Jones-Sawyer), Ch. 17, Stats. 2013
SB 210 (Hancock), failed passage on Assembly Floor, 2012
SB 1180 (Hancock), failed passage on Senate Floor, 2012
Support: California Public Defenders Association; Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice; Disability Rights California; National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Opposition: None known
PURPOSE
This bill requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to maintain specified data and to make specified information regarding the tool publicly available.
Existing law authorizes the officer in charge of a jail, or the clerk of the superior court to approve and accept bail in the amount fixed by the arrest warrant, the bail schedule, or an order admitting to bail in case or surety bond, and to issue and sign an order for the release of the arrested person, and to set a time and place for the person’s appearance in court. (Pen. Code, 1269b, subd. (a).)
Existing law authorizes a court or other magistrate who could release a person from custody upon giving bail to release a person who has been arrested for, or charged with, any offense other than a capital offense, on the person’s own recognizance (OR). (Pen. Code, § 1270.)
Existing law states that a person charged with a misdemeanor is entitled to an OR release unless the court makes a finding on the record, with public safety as the primary consideration, that an OR release will compromise public safety or will not reasonably assure the appearance of the defendant as required. If the court makes one of those findings, the court shall then set bail and specify the conditions, if any, under which the defendant shall be released. (Id.)
Existing law prohibits the release of a defendant on their OR for any violent felony until a hearing is held in open court and the prosecuting attorney is given notice and an opportunity to be heard on the matter. (Pen. Code, § 1319.)
Existing law specifies the following conditions for a defendant's release on their OR:
- The defendant’s promise to appear at all times and places, as ordered by the court or magistrate and as ordered by any court in which, or any magistrate before whom the charge is subsequently pending;
- The defendant’s promise to obey all reasonable conditions imposed by the court or magistrate;
- The defendant’s promise not to depart this state without leave of the court;
- Agreement by the defendant to waive extradition if the defendant fails to appear as required and is apprehended outside of the State of California; and,
- The acknowledgment of the defendant that he or she has been informed of the consequences and penalties applicable to violation of the conditions of release. (Pen. Code, § 1318.)
Existing law authorizes a court, with the concurrence of the board of supervisors, to employ an investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR. (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (a).)
Existing law states that whenever a court has employed investigative staff for the purpose of recommending whether a defendant should be released on OR, an investigative report shall be prepared in all cases involved in a violent felony listed in Penal Code Section 667.5(c), or a felony violation of driving under the influence and causing bodily injury to another person, recommending whether the defendant should be released on OR. The report shall include all of the following:
- Written verification of any outstanding warrants against the defendant;
- Written verification of any prior incidents where the defendant has failed to make a court appearance;
- Written verification of the criminal record of the defendant; and,
- Written verification of the residence of the defendant during the past year. (Pen. Code, § 1318.1, subd. (b).)
This bill requires each pretrial services agency that uses a pretrial risk assessment tool to collect and retain all of the following information regarding any pretrial risk assessment tool that it uses:
- Input information, including, but not limited to, both of the following:
- The age, gender, ethnicity, and arrest offense for each individual assessed using the pretrial risk assessment tool; and,
- The total number of individuals assessed.
- Performance measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The number of interviews and assessments conducted on eligible booked individuals;
- The number of assessed individuals, aggregated by risk level;
- The number of cases in which the detention or release recommendation by the agency conducting the assessment does not conform with the release or detention decision of the judicial officer;
- The rate at which the pretrial assessment staff conducting the assessments follows pretrial risk assessment criteria when recommending release or detention; and,
- The rate at which judicial officers follow the detention or release recommendation of pretrial risk assessment staff.
- Outcome measures, including, but not limited to, all of the following:
- The percentage of assessed individuals who make all scheduled court appearances.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who are not charged with a new offense during the pretrial stage.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who are not arrested for a new offense during the pretrial stage.
- The ratio of assessed and supervised individuals whose supervision level or detention status corresponds with their assessed risk of pretrial misconduct.
- The percentage of assessed individuals who violated conditions of release that resulted in revocation of pretrial release; and,
- The percentage of assessed and released individuals who appear for scheduled court appearances, are not charged with any new offense during pretrial supervision, and did not receive a court remand.
- All of the following additional data:
- The number of individuals released, aggregated by release types, ordered during a specified timeframe;
- The number of supervised defendants divided by the number of pretrial officers or case managers;
- The time between the pretrial services agency’s assumption of supervision of an individual and the end of supervision of the individual; and,
- The proportion of pretrial defendants who are detained at any point throughout pretrial case processing.
This bill provides the following definitions for the purposes of this bill:
- “Pretrial risk assessment tool” means an instrument used to determine the risks associated with individuals in the pretrial context;
- “Pretrial services agency” means an agency or organization designated by the county to conduct pretrial risk assessments and provide other pretrial services to defendants; and,
- “Validated” means that the overall input criteria and each individual input criterion for a risk assessment tool have been evaluated, calibrated, and normalized using statistical methods to optimize accuracy and have been demonstrated by scientific research to be accurate and reliable in assessing the risk of a person failing to appear in court as required or the risk to public safety due to the commission of a new criminal offense if the person is released before adjudication of their current criminal offense and to minimize bias.
This bill requires any pretrial risk assessment tool used by a pretrial services agency to be validated on a regular basis, but no less frequently then once every six months and provides that a pretrial services agency may coordinate with the Judicial Council to validate a pretrial risk assessment tool.
This bill states that in order to increase transparency, a pretrial services agency shall, with regard to a pretrial risk assessment tool that it utilizes, make the following information publicly available:
- Line items, scoring, and weighting, as well as details on how each line item is scored, for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses; and,
- Validation studies for each pretrial risk assessment tool that the agency uses.
This bill requires a pretrial services agency to, when selecting which pretrial risk assessment tool to utilize, consider if the agency would be able to comply with the information that is it required to make publicly available if that tool was selected.
This bill requires Judicial Council to maintain a list of pretrial services agencies that have satisfied the validation requirements and transparency requirements pursuant to this bill.
This bill states that it is the intent of the Legislature in enacting the provisions of this bill to understand and reduce biases based on race, ethnicity, gender, economic circumstances, and behavioral or developmental disabilities in pretrial release decision making.
This bill makes various Legislative findings and declarations related to the pretrial release system and risk assessment tools.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
Currently, 49 of 58 California counties use one of eight different pretrial risk assessment instruments to help determine the likelihood that an arrestee will commit a new offense prior to trial, or miss his or her next court date. Generally, these tools use large data sets regarding past trends to predict future outcomes, and assist judges in making release or detention decisions prior to a defendant’s trial. However, despite their widespread use, these tools lack the transparency necessary for honest evaluation and elimination of disparate outcomes, and counties are under no obligation to collect the data necessary to ensure their accuracy.
2. Own Recognizance Release
In cases where the defendant is likely to return to court and where the safety of the public or specific persons will not be put at risk, a court can release the person on their own recognizance (OR). This includes both felonies and misdemeanors. An OR release is essentially release without payment of bail pending trial or other resolution of a criminal case.
In order to be released on OR,
[T]he defendant signs a release agreement promising to appear at all required court hearings in lieu of posting bail. Before granting an OR release, the judge must evaluate the defendants flight risk by considering the defendants ties to the community, whether the defendant has a past record of failures to appear in court, and the possible sentence the defendant faces if convicted. The judge must also evaluate risk to public safety by considering any threats that have been made by the defendant, as well as any record of violent acts.
In counties with active pretrial programs, the judge may consider pretrial reports and recommendations based on interviews and evaluations that assess the defendant’s public safety and flight risk. For example, in Marin County, the county probation department contracts with an independent agency that provides pretrial services. Using an evidence-based pretrial risk-assessment tool, agency staff evaluates eligible defendants along three dimensions: criminal history, employment and residential stability, and drug use. Following a verification process and an evaluation of danger to self or others, the agency prepares a recommendation along with a report. After approval by the probation department, the report is submitted to the court. In addition to supplying the court with recommendations and reports, these programs may also offer a range of conditional release options. These release options may include release on electronic monitoring, release with alcohol monitoring, or release to home detention. If pretrial release is not granted and bail is fixed by the court, realignment legislation also permits the sheriff to authorize the pretrial release of inmates. Under the legislation, a county board of supervisors must first designate the sheriff as the county’s correctional administrator and may then authorize the correctional administrator to place pretrial jail inmates who do not pose a significant threat to public safety in an electronic monitoring program when specified conditions are met.
In some instances, an unsentenced jail inmate who has not posted bail may be released due to jail overcrowding. At implementation of realignment, 17 counties were operating under court orders that limit the number of inmates they can hold at one or more of their county facilities. Statewide, in the year before realignment, the average annual jail population was 71,060, and releases due to lack of capacity numbered 6,800 per month for unsentenced inmates and 3,900 per month for sentenced offenders.
(Tafoya, Assessing the Impact of Bail on California's Jail Population, Public Policy Institute of California (June 2013), p. 8 (citations omitted).) If a judge determines that a person should not be released on OR, then the judge can set bail with the bail schedule as a guide.
3. Pretrial Services
According to the California Association of Pretrial Services website, pretrial services agencies are important because they improve the court’s release and detention decision-making process. They also protect public safety by ensuring that only those defendants who can safely be released are released. Use of pretrial services agencies also increases the use of non-financial release alternatives, which reduces the percentage of pretrial detainees in the jail. Finally, pretrial services agencies can save taxpayer dollars by reducing the costs of jailing pretrial defendants. (See < http://pretrialservicesca.org/home-page/pretrial-services/ > [as of Mar. 13, 2019].)
Services provided by pretrial services can include: jail screening and interviewing of all arrestees; investigation of the arrestee's ties to the community, past record, potential dangerousness to the community, past history of failures to appear, and the seriousness of the current criminal charges; preparation of a written report to the court and the presiding magistrate, summarizing the defendant's ties to the community and a recommendation for or against release; case monitoring of conditions of release and court date notification system for defendants; supervised release for selected defendants; social services referrals for defendants; and follow-up services to locate defendants who have failed to appear and return them to the court system without the unnecessary costs of an arrest. (Id.)
The majority of pretrial services in California is provided by county probation departments. Other agencies that provide pretrial services include the county courts, sheriffs’ departments and non-profit organizations. (Alameda County Probation Department, Pre-Trial Program Transition <http://www.acgov.org/board/bos_calendar/documents/DocsAgendaReg_3_8_18/GENERAL%20ADMINISTRATION/Regular%20Calendar/Final%20ACPD%20Pre_Trial%20Program%20Transition.pdf> [as of Mar. 15, 2019].)
This bill would require pretrial services agencies to comply with requirements such as collecting and maintaining specified data and making certain information publicly available. This bill also requires regular validation of risk assessment tools in order to ensure accuracy.
4. Status of Bail Reform in California
In 2018, the Legislature passed and the Governor signed into law SB 10 (Hertzberg), Chapter 244, Statutes of 2018. SB 10 would, beginning October 1, 2019, eliminate the use of cash bail and bail bonds for pretrial release and expand the use of risk-based pretrial release. After SB 10 was signed into law, a referendum to overturn SB 10 qualified for the November 2020 statewide ballot which in effect halts the implementation of the law until the referendum is decided. (McGough, The fate of California’s cash bail industry will now be decided on the 2020 ballot, Sacramento Bee (Jan. 17, 2019) <https://www.sacbee.com/news/state/california/article224682595.html> [as of Mar. 5, 2019].)
Separately, a state appellate court ruled that a judge must consider an individual’s ability to pay bail as well as consider alternatives to bail that could ensure public safety and the individual’s appearance in court. This case is currently pending review at the California Supreme Court. (In re Humphrey, review granted May 24, 2018, S247278.)
This bill does not amend the provisions enacted by SB 10. Rather, this bill requires existing pretrial services agencies to comply with its provisions.
5. Argument in Support
According to Western Center on Law and Poverty:
Currently, 49 out of California’s 58 counties use one of eight different risk assessment instruments in their pretrial processes. Regardless of the outcome of the 2020 referendum on SB 10, we expect the adoption of risk assessment tools to be used in pretrial detention decisions will increase throughout 2019, as court decisions continue to indicate the need to eliminate money bail. [Fn. omitted.] This is why it is important to establish statewide standards to ensure these processes are fair, just and unbiased.
A 2017 study by a workgroup commissioned by the California Supreme Court recommended abolishing money bail by statute and replacing it with validated risk assessment tools. Despite this recommendation and the widespread adoption of these tools, there is still currently no statewide standard, nor any requirement regarding the transparency of their inner workings, making them far less accountable to their communities. Moreover, counties are under no obligation to maintain individualized data on the tools’ inputs and outputs, complicating any effort to honestly evaluate them and protect against discriminatory outcomes.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):