SB 360: Mandated reporters: clergy.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 9, 2019 | July 9 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 30. Noes 3.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | April 22 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 5, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Apr 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 6, 2019 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 28, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 23. |
| Feb 20, 2019 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 23, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB360 Hill | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
Counsel: Sandy Uribe
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 360
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:July 2, 2019
SUMMARY: Narrows the existing exception for penitential communications within the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act (CANRA) to exclude penitential communications between clergy members or those between a clergy member and a person employed at the same place. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “penitential communication,” for purposes of the CANRA, as an oral communication made privately to a clergy member which is intended by the communicant to be an act of contrition or a matter of conscience and is intended by both parties to be confidential at the time the communication is made, and which is made in the manner and context that places the clergy member specifically and strictly under a level of confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine.
- States that penitential communication does not include any of the following activities unless they take place as part of the penitential communication:
- Providing spiritual direction;
- Religious counseling;
- Individual or group therapy;
- Activity related to human resources or personnel management
- Clergy assignment work;
- Communications between clergy, laity, or other members of the faith that occur outside of a penitential context; or,
- Activity related to church administration or management.
- Providing spiritual direction;
- Specifies that a written communication does not qualify as a penitential communication.
- Requires a clergy member to report any information related to known or suspected abuse or neglect obtained outside of a penitential communication, even if they clergy member has also received information regarding the same person or incident during a penitential communication.
- Excludes the following from the penitential communication exception:
- A penitential communication between a clergy member and another person that is employed at the same site or facility as the clergy member; and
- A penitential communication between a clergy member and another clergy member.
- A penitential communication between a clergy member and another person that is employed at the same site or facility as the clergy member; and
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Establishes the CANRA and states that the intent and purpose of the Act is to protect children from abuse and neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11164.)
- Defines "child" under CANRA to mean person under the age of 18 years. (Pen. Code, § 11165.)
- Defines "child abuse or neglect" under CANRA to include physical injury or death inflicted by other than accidental means upon a child by another person, sexual abuse as defined, neglect as defined, the willful harming or injuring of a child or the endangering of the person or health of a child as defined, and unlawful corporal punishment or injury as defined. (Pen. Code, § 11165.6.)
- Enumerates 46 categories of mandatory child abuse reporters. Specific occupations that are mandated reporters, including but are not limited to, teachers, athletic coaches, social workers, peace officers, firefighters, physicians, psychologists, psychiatrists, emergency medical technicians, licensed family therapists, child visitation monitors, and clergy members. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a).)
- Requires any mandated reporter who has knowledge of, or observes, a child in his or her professional capacity or within the scope of his or her employment whom he or she knows, or reasonably suspects, has been the victim of child abuse to report that incident immediately to a specified child protection agency by telephone, and further requires a written report be sent within 36 hours. (Pen. Code, §11166, subd. (a).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a mandated reporter to fail to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect as required by the CANRA. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).)
- Provides that a clergy member who acquires knowledge or a reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication is exempt from the mandated reporter reporting requirements. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).)
- Defines “clergy member” for purposes of the CANRA as “a priest, minister, rabbi, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization.” (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a)(32).)
- Defines “penitential communication” for purposes of the CANRA, as “a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).)
- Clarifies that a clergy member has a duty to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect when the clergy member acting in some other capacity that would otherwise make the clergy member a mandated reporter. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(2).)
- Defines “member of the clergy” for purposes of the clergy-penitent evidentiary privilege as “a priest, minister, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church or of a religious denomination or religious organization.” (Evid. Code, § 1030.)
- Defines “penitent” for purposes of the clergy-penitent evidentiary privilege as “a person who has made a penitential communication to a member of the clergy.” (Evid. Code, § 1031.)
- Defines “penitential communication” for purposes of the clergy-penitent evidentiary privilege, as “a communication made in confidence, in the presence of no third person so far as the penitent is aware, to a member of the clergy who, in the course of the discipline or practice of the clergy member’s church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications and, under the discipline or tenets of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Evid. Code, § 1032.)
- Provides that a penitent, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege. (Evid. Code, § 1033.)
- Provides that a clergy member, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege. (Evid. Code, § 1034.)
- States that the right of any person to claim a privilege is waived with respect to a communication protected by the privilege if any holder of the privilege, without coercion, has disclosed a significant part of the communication or has consented to disclosure made by anyone. (Evid. Code, § 912, subd. (a).)
- Provides that “Free exercise and enjoyment of religion without discrimination or preference are guaranteed. This liberty of conscience does not excuse acts that are licentious or inconsistent with the peace or safety of the State. The Legislature shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. A person is not incompetent to be a witness or juror because of his or her opinions on religious beliefs.” (Cal. Const., art. 1, § 4.)
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- States that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” (U.S. Const. Amend. I.)
- Provides that “No state shall make or enforce any law which shall abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the United States; nor shall any state deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” (U.S. Const. Amend. XIV.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “As mandated child abuse and neglect reporters, doctors, psychiatrists, therapists, and others have to break client privilege and report suspected child abuse and neglect, without exception. But clergy have been exempt from full reporting, if they believe the conversation was intended to be confidential.
“SB 360 would begin to close that loophole by requiring clergy to report suspected child abuse or neglect, if they acquire the knowledge or suspicion during a penitential communication with an employee at their facility or with another clergy member. SB 360 also narrows the definition of penitential communication. To qualify, the communication must be verbal, made privately to a clergy member, intended to be an act of contrition or matter of conscience, and in a context of strict confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine.
“When a child is being abused or neglected, they often don’t understand what is happening to them. We rely on adults who hear something or see something to say something, which is why doctors and therapists must report child abuse or neglect, no matter what. Faith leaders have been the only exception to this rule among mandated reporters. Instead of protecting children, some have been shielding abusers.
“It is time for California to put children first.” - Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act (CANRA): Existing law requires persons who work in 46 occupations to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect, including sexual abuse. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).) Failure to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine, or both. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).)
California law already requires a clergy member who learns of, or suspects, child abuse to report this conduct to law enforcement. This includes suspected child abuse committed by another clergy member or church employee. Clergy members are defined as “a priest, minister, rabbi, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization,” under the CANRA. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a)(32).)
Significantly, however, clergy members are provided an exemption from reporting under the CANRA if the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect is acquired during a “penitential communication.”, which is defined as “a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).)[1]
This bill would further clarify what is and is not a penitential communication. To qualify as a penitential communication, it must be: (1) an oral communication; (2) made privately to a clergy member; (3) intended by the communicant to be an act of contrition or a matter of conscience; (4) intended by both parties to be confidential at the time the communication is made; and, (5) made in the manner and context that places the clergy member specifically and strictly under a level of confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine. This bill would clarify that providing spiritual direction, religious counseling, or individual or group therapy is not a penitential communication. Nor is activity related to human resources or personnel management, clergy assignment work; communications between clergy, laity, or other members of the faith that occur outside of a penitential context; or, activity related to church administration or management. Finally, this bill expressly provides that a written communication does not qualify as a penitential communication.
Additionally, this bill would partially repeal the penitential-communication exemption under the CANRA to exclude the confessions of other clergy and those of persons employed at the same facility or location as the clergy member hearing the penitential communication.
- Confession in the Catholic Church and other Religions: The Catholic sacrament of penance or reconciliation, also called confession, is a means for members of the church to seeks God’s mercy and for restoring their relationship with God. Catholic church law, known as Canon Law, requires every Catholic to go to confession at least once a year. (Canon § 989.) Every Catholic parish has posted times set aside for confession. During this time, a priest will sit in a small booth, called a confessional, and hear the confessions of individuals, one at a time. There is a fixed screen between the confessor and the priest because Canon law requires that people have the opportunity to confess their sins anonymously.[2] (Canon 964 § 2.) Catholics are free to confess to any priest at any parish.
The Catholic Church absolutely prohibits priests from disclosing anything that is said in the confessional. (Canon 983 § 1.) This rule is known as the “seal of the confessional.” Under the Church’s cannon law, a priest who breaks the seal of the confessional is excommunicated. (Canon 1388 § 1.) This penalty is automatic. (Canon 1314.) The seal of the confessional is such an important tenet, that priests throughout history have been tortured and killed because they refuse to break the seal of the confessional. In fact, days ago the Vatican published a “note of the Apostolic Penitentiary on the importance of the internal forum and the inviolability of the sacramental seal,” which was approved by Pope Francis at the end of June. This document affirms “the absolute secrecy of everything said in confession and calling on priests to defend it at all costs, even at the cost of their lives.” (See Catholic News Service, July 1, 2019, Secrecy of Confession Must Never Be Violated, Vatican Says: <https://www.catholicsun.org/2019/07/01/secrecy-of-confession-must-never-be-violated-vatican-says/>.)
The Catholic Church is not the only religion to have a form of confidential confession and a confessional seal. Other religions include the Orthodox Church in America, the Lutheran Church, the Episcopal Church, and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. For example, as stated in the guidelines for clergy published by the Orthodox Church in America, “The secrecy of the Mystery of Penance is considered an unquestionable rule in the entire Orthodox Church.… Betrayal of the secrecy of confession will lead to canonical punishment of the priest.” (Orthodox Church in America, Guidelines for Clergy Compiled under the Guidance of the Holy Synod of the Orthodox Church in America (1998) at p. 14: <http://oca.org/PDF/official/clergyguidelines.pdf >.) The Episcopal Church also recognizes the Reconciliation of a Penitent as a sacramental right of the church. The Episcopal Dictionary teaches, “Under no circumstances may be information give be revealed by the priest, unless the penitent gives permission…. In some states, the priest may be asked by a court of law to divulge information but must refuse even though this may lead to imprisonment.” (The Episcopal Church, An Episcopal Dictionary of the Church: Seal of Confession, <https://www.episcopalchurch.org/library/glossary/seal-confession >.) The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints also mandates confession and church rules require that these confessional communications be kept confidential. (See e.g., discussion of confession in Scott v. Hammock (1994) 870 P.2d 947, 951.) Thus, while this bill might be seen a response to the Catholic Church’s attempts to cover up the sexual abuse of children by its priests, it implicates more than one religion. - Other States: All 50 states have a mandated reporter statute. A 2016 publication by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) on clergy members as mandated reporters reported that, as of August 2015, 28 states listed clergy members as mandated reporters. (Child Welfare Information Gateway (2016) Clergy as Mandated Reporters of Child Abuse and Neglect, US Department of Health and Human Services, Children’s Bureau, p. 1 <https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubPDFs/clergymandated.pdf>.) Another 18 states do not specifically list clergy members as mandated reporters, but instead require “any person” to report. (Ibid.) Of the 28 states that enumerated clergy members as mandated reporters, 24 of those states explicitly included an exemption for abuse discovered through penitential or pastoral communications. (Id. at p. 3.) Of the states with “any person” mandated reporter statutes, 7 explicitly provide a penitential communication exemption. (Ibid.) As of 2015, among states that list clergy as mandated reporters or enumerate “any person” as a mandated reporter, only six states deny the clergy-penitent privilege in cases of child abuse or neglect.[3] (Ibid.) Of note, Texas has explicitly abrogated all privileges, including not only the clergy-penitent privilege, but also the attorney-client privilege. (Id. at p. 15.)
This bill takes a very different approach from other states. As noted above, this bill would preserve the clergy-penitent privilege for most church members, and instead singles out the penitential communication of clergy and people working in the same church as the clergy member hearing the confession. No other state appears to make the privilege applicable based on the identity/profession of the person confessing. - First Amendment Issues: Requiring a clergy member to violate the confidentiality of the confessional raises constitutional issues. The first amendment provides, in pertinent part, that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” This “embraces two concepts—freedom to believe and freedom to act. The first is absolute, but in the nature of things, the second cannot be.” (Cantwell v. Connecticut (1940) 310 U.S. 296, 304.) In other words, while the freedom to believe is absolute, the freedom to act on those beliefs is not. The second clause is commonly referred to as the Free Exercise Clause. The Free Exercise Clause applies to the states through the due process clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. (Id. at pp. 303-304.)
This bill raises issues regarding the applicability of the Free Exercise Clause because it would require conduct that some religions prohibit, namely for clergy members to break the seal of the confessional.[4]
In Employment Division, Department of Human Resources of Oregon v. Smith (1990) 494 U.S. 872, the United States Supreme Court interpreted the Free Exercise Clause to mean that “the right of free exercise does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with a valid and neutral law of general applicability on the ground that the law proscribes (or prescribes) conduct that his religion proscribes (or prescribes.)” (Id. at p. 879.) Thus the inquiry for a Free Exercise Clause claim begins with the consideration of whether the law is one that is neutral and of general applicability. Depending on the answer to the question, a different standard of review applies.
When a law is found to be neutral and of general applicability, then a rational basis standard applies: the law need not be justified by a compelling government interest, even if it has the effect of burdening a religious practice. Under this test, regardless of how much a law burdens a religious practice, it will be found constitutional if it does not single out religious behavior for punishment and is not motivated by a desire to interfere with religion.
On the other hand, when the law is not general and neutral, then the government can prevail only if it satisfies strict scrutiny, showing that its restrictions on religion both serve a compelling interest and are narrowly tailored. (Church of Lukumi Babalu Aye v. City of Hialeah (1993) 508 U.S. 520, 531-532.)
In Smith, supra, 494 U.S. 872, members of a Native American church challenged a law regarding collecting unemployment benefits after they were fired from a drug rehabilitation center for using peyote. The State of Oregon denied them unemployment benefits because the reason for their dismissal was considered work-related “misconduct.” (Id. at p. 874.) The opinion noted, “The Court has never held that an individual's religious beliefs excuse him from compliance with an otherwise valid law prohibiting conduct that government is free to regulate.” (Id. at pp. 878-879.) The Court held that “Because respondents' ingestion of peyote was prohibited under Oregon law, and because that prohibition is constitutional, Oregon may, consistent with the Free Exercise Clause, deny respondents unemployment compensation when their dismissal results from use of the drug.” (Id. at p. 890.)
In contrast, in Hialeah, supra, 508 U.S. 520, the Court found city ordinances which prohibited the ritual slaughter of animals to violate the Free Exercise Clause. The City of Hialeah, Florida adopted the ordinances after the Santerias announced a plan to open a church, school, cultural center, and a museum. (Id. at p. 525-526.) The laws, among other things, punished a person who unnecessarily killed an animal in a ritual, and defined “sacrifice” as the unnecessary killing of an animal in a ritual not for the primary purpose of food consumption. The asserted need for the ordinances was to prevent animal cruelty. The Court determined the ordinances were not neutral because their objective was to prohibit the practice of the Santeria religion. (Id. at p. 534.) The court noted that there was a resolution passed which purported to prohibit acts or religion which were inconsistent with public morals, peace or safety. (Id. at pp. 534-535.) The Court found it significant that the ordinances “proscribed more religious conduct than necessary to achieve the stated end, and exempted other animal killing that undermined the government’s interest. In fact, the definition of sacrifice excluded almost all animal killings except for religious sacrifice. It even went so far as to exempt kosher slaughter. (Id. at p. 536.)
Turning to the question of whether this proposed legislation is general and neutral one must consider what it requires. Under this bill, if a teacher, coach, or janitor confessed that he or she had abused a child, a priest has no duty to report the conduct to law enforcement. But if that teacher, coach or janitor happened to work at the Catholic parish where the priest also worked, the duty to report would be triggered. Additionally, the confession of any priest would always trigger the duty to report. This disparate treatment calls into question the neutrality of the proposed law. It also calls into question the proposed law’s general applicability. Why should some abusers be protected and not others?
The Court stated in Hialeah, supra, 508 U.S. 520, that factors relevant to the assessment of governmental neutrality include “the historical background of the decision under challenge, the specific series of events leading to the enactment or official policy in question, and the legislative or administrative history, including contemporaneous statements made by members of the decisionmaking body.” (Id. at p. 540.) The Free Exercise Clause bars even “subtle departures from neutrality” on matters of religion. (Id. at p. 534.)
Based on these factors, it can be argued that the proposed legislation is not neutral towards religion. The background sheet provided by the author to the committee states that the problem the bill seeks to remedy as follows:
Existing law gives clergy an exemption not given to the other 45 categories of mandatory child abuse and neglect reporters. That exemption has been distorted and manipulated to hide and enable child abusers within religious institutions.
Clergy, specifically clergy within the Catholic Church, promised to fix the cycle of secrets and abuse by instituting a “zero-tolerance” policy in 2002. Fifteen years later, the bombshell Pennsylvania Grand Jury Report and investigation of Cardinal McCarrick in Washington, DC showed in gruesome detail that those promises were not kept.
Institutions tend to make decisions based on self-preservation. This isn’t unique to faith institutions; it’s why we have governmental oversight of state institutions, local institutions, public and private institutions. And it is why we should no longer be complicit in a culture of secrecy by allowing, and entrusting, clergy to self-police themselves.
Additionally, several of the links to news articles provided in the committee background sheet pertain to child sexual abuse by religion institutions.[5] These references are suggestive that the law is not neutral, but rather, hostile towards a religious practice.
If the proposed legislation is found not to be neutral and of general applicability, then the government must show both that it has a compelling state interest and that the law is narrowly tailored. Protecting children from physical and sexual abuse is undeniably a compelling government interest. And yet, as noted above, nearly half the states maintain a penitential-communication exception to their mandated-reporting laws. Not one of those states singles out religious profession or employment as an exception to the exception. Arguably, eliminating the exception altogether, as some states have done, raises less constitutional concerns.
- Practical Concerns: In addition to constitutional concerns, this bill raises practical ones. As noted above, at least as pertains to the Catholic Church, the sacrament of confession can be received anonymously. In order to prosecute a priest for failure to report abuse learned of through a penitential communication, the prosecution would have to establish that the priest knew the penitent was another priest or a parish employee. In most situations, this would require an admission or revelation by the penitent that he or she confessed an instance of child abuse or neglect to the priest. That is not likely to happen because the person would be implicating himself or herself in criminal conduct. And while there is the possibility that a priest learns of abuse through the confession of a victim, under the provisions of this bill, the priest is not required to report information learned in that scenario.
Additionally, the question remains whether this bill would incentivize a clergy member to violate a religious oath in order to avoid incarceration. The failure of a mandated reporter to report a known or suspected child abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in a county jail, or by a fine of $1,000, or both. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).) In contrast, the penalty for a Catholic priest, for example, to break the seal of the confessional is excommunication. (Canon 1388 § 1.) It is difficult to imagine what priest would chose to be excommunicated rather than serve a maximum sentence of six months in a county jail.
For both of these reasons, this bill is unlikely to achieve its aims. - Argument in Support: According to the California Civil Liberties Advocacy, “The CCLA brought this concept before legislative offices as early as December 2018, including Senator Hill’s office. There has been confusion as to the CCLA’s stance and the rationale for supporting a bill that some perceive as attacking religious liberty. Our reasoning is based on the idea that the children of religious households should be afforded the equal protection of CANR, just as children whose abuse or neglect is not caused, facilitated, or kept secret by religious institutions. This is based on the “No Harm Principle,” discussed below….
“In Employment Division v. Smith, the late Justice Scalia, writing for the majority of the U.S. Supreme Court, held that an individual’s religious beliefs do not excuse them from compliance with an otherwise valid and neutral law prohibiting conduct that the state is free to regulate, and that, while the First Amendment protects the right of individuals to believe whatever they wish, it does not necessarily protect the right to act on those beliefs. The decision energized religious institutions and civil liberties groups alike to lobby Congress for what ultimately became the Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (RFRA). According to Americans United for Separation of Church State, the law was intended to protect the right of religious expression, ‘it was meant to be a shield, not a sword.’ Over the years, the RFRA has been broadly interpreted; for example, the U.S. Department of Justice released a memo on religious liberty guidance that effectively allows taxpayer-funded organizations, corporations, and individuals to use religion as a basis to discriminate against others. That particular issue is beyond the scope of SB 360, but it serves to illustrate our point that the reaction to the Supreme Court’s holding in Smith has been disproportionate. In 2018, Senator Kamala Harris introduced the Do No Harm Act, which would have made the RFRA inapplicable to laws or the implementation of laws that, among other things, ‘protect against child labor, abuse, or exploitation.’ The ‘No Harm Principle’ is based on the ideology that, while the government has no business interfering with individual beliefs, there must be a limit: when a religious actor’s conduct causes harm to another person. Thomas Jefferson once wrote that ‘[t]he legitimate powers of government extend to such acts only as are injurious to others. But it does me no injury for my neighbor to say there are twenty gods, or no god. It neither picks my pocket nor breaks my leg.’ In sum, the CCLA takes the position that the government may not regulate belief or conscience, but that bad actors should not be afforded the opportunity to hide behind the façade of “religious liberty” in order to escape criminal and civil liability for reprehensible conduct; thus, the No Harm Principle.
“According the U.S. Supreme Court, the purpose of the clergy-penitent privilege is to fulfill ‘the human need to disclose to a spiritual counselor, in total and absolute confidence, what are believed to be flawed acts or thoughts and to receive priestly consolation and guidance in return.’ The privilege should be protected but not to an unlimited degree. It is therefore interesting to note that the privilege in the United States did not exist at common law but was rather the product of statute enacted by state legislatures that was intended to be narrowly construed. In a throwback to the sanctuary laws of old England, predating the common law, many organizations conduct similar disciplinary investigations of violations of their own rules and beliefs, including criminal conduct, in order to render church discipline and prepare for litigation. And documented cases reveal that such communications are freely discussed, documented, and distributed among church leadership, in which clergy-penitent is often invoked. In other cases, priests have admonished victims to remain silent about abuse and “‘sweep it under the floor and get of rid it’ because “too many people would be hurt” if the victim were to disclose the abuse to others. ‘According to the Catholic Catechism, the act of confession is an intrinsically private communion between God and the sinner, with the priest as mediator.’ But it is clear that religious entities have failed to uphold their own principle—a principle protected under California law.
“It is important to note that SB 360 does not amend the California Evidence Code or have any effect on evidentiary privileges. SB 360 merely clarifies what clergy-penitent privilege is, for purposes of CANR, and excludes clergy and religious employees from the exemption. By narrowing the definition, as discussed above, religious institutions will no longer be able to excuse skirting CANR by broadly applying the exception to any matter where a clergy member may be present. Further, since much abuse is perpetrated by clergy members and religious employees, excluding such ones from the privilege will ensure that abusers are detected and afforded due process. However, beyond the initial report, the privilege is still intact for evidentiary purposes as SB 360 amends no part of the Evidence Code.
“The CCLA also argues that the exclusion of clergy and church employees is constitutionally sound under the holding in Roman Catholic Archbishop of Los Angeles v. Superior Court (hereinafter “Roman Catholic”), that a law which is neutral and of general applicability need not be justified by a compelling governmental interest even if the law has the incidental effect of burdening a particular religious practice. In deciding whether clergy-penitent privilege protected against disclosure of subpoenaed documents in a grand jury investigation, the plaintiff invoked both the ministerial exception doctrine and the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine.
“Under the First Amendment, the ministerial exception doctrine generally bars judicial inquiry into protected employment decisions and applies equally to ministers and a variety of nonordained employees with duties functionally equivalent to those of ministers. But the court in Roman Catholic held that ministerial exception did not apply to subpoenaed documents in a grand jury investigation involving priests who had sexually molested children because the case was criminal in nature and not related to employment matters. The ecclesiastical abstention doctrine is based on the determination that the Free Exercise Clause restricts the government's ability to intrude into ecclesiastical matters or to interfere with a church's governance of its own affairs. Likewise, the Roman Catholic court held that the ecclesiastical abstention doctrine, as an exception to the general rule that the right of free exercise, does not relieve an individual of the obligation to comply with valid and neutral laws of general applicability, did not apply to a religious institution that was required to disclose subpoenaed documents as part of grand jury investigation into allegations that church priests had sexually molested children, because the case did not involve an internal church dispute, but rather, a criminal investigation. Furthermore, the courts have generally held that to withstand strictures of establishment clause, government action must not foster excessive government entanglement with religion. But he Roman Catholic court equally held that the disclosure of the subpoenaed documents, as part of the grand jury investigation,, was not barred by the establishment clause of the federal Constitution because disclosure would not result in the government's excessive entanglement with questions of religious doctrine, because the core issue was whether children were molested by priests, which had no religious doctrine aspect.
“While those holdings primarily dealt with evidentiary privileges, it is reasonable to conclude that if clergy-penitent privilege cannot be invoked in responding to a criminal subpoena, then why should it be afforded greater protections in the context of mandatory reporting of child abuse and neglect, which itself is a matter with criminal implications.” - Arguments in Opposition:
- According to the California Catholic Conference, “The California Catholic Conference wholeheartedly agrees with the general principle that all youth should be protected from sexual abuse. To advance this principle, the Conference introduced amendments to clarify the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act (CANRA) by making it explicit that Catholic priests are mandatory reporters in every setting except when people come to them seeking God’s forgiveness in the confessional, a context where the Catholic faith (like many other religions) gives everyone the right to confess sins anonymously and confidentially.
“SB 360 recognizes there is a strong public interest in protecting the privacy right of every person to seek spiritual healing and forgiveness in a religious setting with clergy who have an absolute duty to keep those communications confidential. But even while specifically recognizing the privileged status of penitential communications, the additional amendment adding subdivision (d)(5) to the bill nevertheless denies this privacy right to some, including tens of thousands of lay employees of the Catholic Church in California, based solely upon their particular religious and employment status. There is no justification for this distinction or the resulting inequality.
“Not only does SB 360 fail to honor this privacy right for thousands of Californians, it does so without any evidence that this invasion of privacy will help protect children. The Conference recognizes the existence of accounts that in the past the Catholic Church did not do everything it could to bring abusers to face justice, but there is no evidence that we are aware of to suggest that there has ever been an issue with clergy failing to make mandatory child abuse reports as a result of information received during the Sacrament of Confession. There is therefore no basis to conclude that allowing a person to freely and openly speak to God and seek spiritual healing and forgiveness through a religious communication with clergy will somehow hinder the reporting of crimes and wrongdoings to authorities.
“SB 360 also may well fail to achieve its stated goal because Catholic clergy are never likely to have sufficient information to actually make the mandated report, because those seeking confession do so completely anonymously. There is no sign-in, no submission of identification, and so even if a priest received information from which to suspect abuse, he would have no actual names, locations, or other information to report. The Conference therefore offered amendments to SB 360 because it believes that a strong mandatory reporting law requires a bright line for implementation and enforcement. In its current form, SB 360 is therefore much more likely to chill the religious exercise of vulnerable people who would stop practicing their faith if they were uncertain whether they could trust their clergy, with no corresponding benefit to prevent abuse.
“Finally, but equally important, legislation like this has the potential to open the door for other governmental bodies to pass laws requiring the reporting of persons who seek assistance from the Church for violation of other laws, such as federal immigration laws. To be succinct, if the State of California can abrogate this well-established, constitutionally entrenched privilege, so can the Federal Government.
“Any law that does not keep this unique form of religious communications private and available to every person is impermissibly discriminatory and violates individuals’ rights to practice their religion freely. SB 360 is the extremely rare bill that on its face seeks to regulate religious rights of individuals based on their religious or employment status. Such laws are subject to strict scrutiny under the First Amendment, and are presumed unconstitutional unless the government can prove it cannot advance its interests in any other way. Given this infirmity, we believe that SB 360 would be enjoined before it ever takes effect, and that the law would eventually be struck down as unconstitutional. As such, passing SB 360 would not help protect children; it would only lead to expensive and protracted litigation.” - According to the California Missionary Baptist Convention, Churches in Action, and the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Fifth Quorum of the Seventy, North America West Area, “While gratefully acknowledging the good intentions animating SB 360, we oppose it for the following reasons.
“SB 360 Will Harm Child Abuse Victims. Past Legislatures have wisely understood that California’s existing clergy privilege helps protect child abuse victims. It does this in two ways. First, it provides perpetrators with a confidential space in which to disclose the abuse without fear that they will automatically be reported to law enforcement. While ideally all perpetrators would turn themselves into the police, that rarely happens as a first step. A strong clergy privilege helps induce perpetrators who would otherwise remain secret to disclose the abuse to clergy members. In our collective experience, once a perpetrator has made such a disclosure to a clergy member the perpetrator is nearly always open to measures that protect the victim from further abuse, such as by agreeing to move out of the home where the abuse is occurring or agreeing to disclose the abuse to a spouse or parent. Even without such permission, clergy members also take other measures that do not violate the clergy privilege but that protect the victim from further abuse and ensure that the perpetrator doesn’t commit additional abuse elsewhere (such as within the faith community). And once the perpetrator makes the initial disclosure of abuse, it is not uncommon for a clergy member to persuade the perpetrator to disclose the abuse to legal authorities as a condition of receiving forgiveness for the sin. In our long experience with these issues, the initial disclosure under conditions of legal confidentiality often opens the door spiritually, psychologically and emotionally for a report to law enforcement.
“Second, existing California law also protects child abuse victims by allowing the victims themselves to confidentially disclose abuse to clergy members. Child abuse victims—both those whose abuse has ended and those still being abused—are often terrified to speak of their abuse. They fear being interrogated by police. They fear what will happen to their families. They fear losing control—something the perpetrator has already taken from them. The current guarantee of confidentiality encourages safe, trusting communications with clergy members. Once that initial disclosure occurs, it is often easy to convince the victim to receive protection from further abuse (such as by being relocated to a safe home), to disclose the abuse to a safe parent or other trusted individual who can help, to receive professional counseling to begin the healing process, and even to report to law enforcement in a way that empowers the victim, rather than stripping the victim of control and making the person feel re-victimized. Child abuse is routinely reported under these circumstances.
“In its original form, SB 360 would have entirely revoked the clergy privilege for reporting purposes. That would have profoundly discouraged both perpetrators and victims from disclosing abuse. The net result would have been fewer victims getting the protection they desperately need and fewer perpetrators being reported to law enforcement.
“SB 360 as amended is an improvement but still has serious defects. It protects only ‘penitential communications’ by the perpetrator to the clergy member that resemble the sacrament of penance in a handful of Christian faiths, rather than all confidential communications to clergy members regardless of faith. Only oral communications intended ‘to be an act of contrition’ or ‘conscience’ are protected. That would exclude protection for victims who wish to confidentially disclose abuse to clergy members, since victims typically do not disclose abuse as part of confessing sins (although, tragically, some victims believe the abuse is their fault). In contrast with communications to lawyers, which remain privileged, neither victim nor perpetrator could communicate by confidential letter. SB 360 would deny a young female victim and her mother from confidentially communicating with their clergy member about abuse because under the bill no other person can be present. Yet having someone accompany and support such a victim under conditions of clergy confidentiality is often essential for a disclosure to be made. And clergy members could not confidentially seek advice from other clergy members about how to help a victim or persuade perpetrators to turn themselves in without triggering the reporting duty.
“In short, we strongly believe SB 360, even as amended, will have the unintended effect of harming far more victims of abuse than it will help. The confidentiality of clergy communications is essential. It will undermine the extensive efforts we and other faith communities have undertaken for many years to protect child abuse victims and prevent perpetrators from abusing again.
“SB 360 (as Amended) Favors Some Religious Communities Over Others. As amended, SB 360 favors certain religious communities over others by extending the clergy privilege only to practices analogous to the sacrament of penance. Not all faith communities have sacramental confession or practice formal confession to clergy members, although they may have a deep tradition of confidentially communicating with clergy members about sin and personal trauma. Existing law properly recognizes the diversity of California faith communities and avoids constitutional problems (see, e.g., Scott v. Hammock, 870 P.2d 947 (Utah 1994) (narrow construction of clergy privilege to include only “penitential communications” would raise “serious” constitutional questions), by defining the clergy privilege to cover all confidential communications to clergy members.
“SB 360 Is Not Necessary to Punish Clergy Abuse Crimes. Lastly, sexual abuse of parishioners or anyone else by clergy members is a heinous crime. Aiding and abetting such acts is likewise criminal. These are serious felonies. Prosecutors already have plenty of tools under existing California law to severely punish clergy members who perpetrate child abuse or criminally conspire to facilitate it or cover it up. There is no evidence or reason to believe that the relatively minor (by comparison) misdemeanor penalties in the reporting statute will in fact provide further protections against criminal activity. Further, denying clergy members as a class the right to confess confidentially to their own clergy members (as SB 360 currently does) may itself raise grave constitutional problems. Existing California law wisely avoids this, and the other problems mentioned in this letter.”
- According to the California Catholic Conference, “The California Catholic Conference wholeheartedly agrees with the general principle that all youth should be protected from sexual abuse. To advance this principle, the Conference introduced amendments to clarify the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act (CANRA) by making it explicit that Catholic priests are mandatory reporters in every setting except when people come to them seeking God’s forgiveness in the confessional, a context where the Catholic faith (like many other religions) gives everyone the right to confess sins anonymously and confidentially.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1435 (Dickinson), Chapter 520, Statutes of 2012, made athletic coaches, athletic administrators, and athletic directors at public or private K-12 schools mandated reporters.
- AB 1713 (Campos), Chapter 517, Statutes of 2012, expanded the list of persons identified as mandated reporters to include commercial-film and photographic-print or image processors.
- AB 1817 (Atkins), Chapter 521, Statutes of 2012, expanded the list of persons identified as mandated reporters to include commercial computer technicians.
- AB 1564 (Lara), of the 2011-12 Legislative Session, would have made volunteers of public and private organizations, including non-profits, mandated reporters under CANRA, and revokes a non-profit's tax exempt status if an employee or volunteer fails to report an instance of known or suspected child abuse. AB 1564 was not heard in the Committee at the request of the author.
- SB 1264 (Vargas), Chapter 518, Statutes of 2012, made athletic coaches at public or private postsecondary institutions mandated reporters.
- SB 646 (Watson), Chapter 1444, Statutes of 1987, established CANRA, which requires specified persons who have knowledge of or observe a child in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, who the person knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse to report the known or suspected instance of child abuse to a child protective agency, as defined.
- AB 1435 (Dickinson), Chapter 520, Statutes of 2012, made athletic coaches, athletic administrators, and athletic directors at public or private K-12 schools mandated reporters.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California Family Resource Association
Child USA
Child-Friendly Faith Project
Consumer Attorneys of California
Crime Victims United of California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Restorative Justice International
Stop Child Abuse Advocates for Reform and Safety
The Child Abuse Prevention Center
Truth & Transparency Foundation
Opposition
California Catholic Conference
California Missionary Baptist Convention
Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints,
Fifth Quorum of the Seventy, North America West Area
Churches in Action
Diocese of Stockton
James A. Sonne, Stanford Law Professor, Religious Liberty Clinic
Knights of Columbus
Pacific Justice Institute
Syriac Orthodox Church of Antioch
Over 125,000 individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Sandy Uribe / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
The penitential communication exception is tied to the clergy-penitent privilege, codified in in Evidence Code sections 1030-1034, which precludes disclosure of evidence learned during a penitential communication during discover proceedings or at a trial. Other types of privileged communications, including attorney-client privilege, doctor-patient privilege, and psychotherapist-patient privilege, are also codified. (Evid. Code, § 900 et seq.) Because attorneys are not mandated reporters under California law, of the relationships/professions with recognized evidentiary privileges, only clergy members are granted an exemption under the mandated reporting statute.
The clergy-penitent privilege is a long established privilege rooted in religious doctrine and practice. (Jacob M. Yellin, The History and Current Status of the Clergy-Penitent Privilege (1983) 23 Santa Clara L. Rev. 95, 95.) The clergy-penitent privilege “reflects a public policy that values the sanctity of conversations between members of a particular faith and their religious advisors.” (Caroline Donze, Breaking the Seal of Confession: Examining the Constitutionality of the Clergy-Penitent Privilege in Mandatory Reporting Law (2018) 78 La. L. Rev. 267, 275.) The clergy-penitent privilege is unique among the privileges because the person on the receiving end of the communication, the clergy member, may claim protection from compelled disclosure under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, a defense that is not available to a doctor, attorney, or psychotherapist. (Id. at 272.) Another aspect of the clergy-penitent privilege that distinguishes it from the other privileges is the fact that “a communicant’s waiver of privilege may not be sufficient for clergy to justify revealing the details of a private confession.” (Ibid.) As will be discussed below, most clergy members are also barred by religious laws from disclosing anything that is said during confession. It should be noted that this bill does not in any way affect the evidentiary privilege to refuse to disclose a penitential communication codified in Evidence Code sections 1033 and 1034. ↑
Catholics also have the option of making a “face to face” confession, where the priest and the penitent sit facing each other a few feet away. ↑
Additionally, in Tennessee the Clergy/Penitent communication is not privileged concerning reports of child sexual abuse. “The privileged quality of communication between husband and wife and between any professional person and the professional person's patient or client, and any other privileged communication, except that between attorney and client, as such communication relates both to the competency of the witness and to the exclusion of confidential communications, shall not apply to any situation involving known or suspected child sexual abuse and shall not constitute grounds for failure to report as required by this part, failure to cooperate with the department in its activities pursuant to this part, or failure to give evidence in any judicial proceeding relating to child sexual abuse.” T.C.A §37-1-614 If the abuse is not sexual in nature, the clergy/penitent privilege as described in T.C.A §24-1-206 would still apply. ( ↑
Some individuals might also invoke the Free Exercise Clause on the grounds that it burdens or makes more difficult their religious observances. For example, a priest might argue that he is essentially prohibited from seeking forgiveness through the sacrament of penance because that confession is not confidential in comparison to that of other penitents. ↑
See e.g., Los Angeles Times, Los Angeles Archdiocese Priest Abuse Files <http://documents.latimes.com/los-angeles-archdiocese-priest-abuse-files/> and Seattle Times, Woman says Mormon Church Failed to Report Dad’s Sexual Abuse <https://www.seattletimes.com/nation-world/apxwoman-says-mormon-church-failed-to-report-dad-s-sexual-abuse/.> ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 360 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 360
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 4/2/19
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach, Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Mandated reporters: clergy
This bill amends the existing exception within the mandated reporter statute for penitential communications by altering the definition of penitential communication; requiring a clergy member to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect when information is obtained from any source other than a penitential communication, as specified; and excludes from the exception penitential communications between a clergy member and another person that is employed at the same site or facility, and penitential communications between clergy members.
Existing law:
- Establishes the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act and states that the intent and purpose of the Act is to protect children from abuse and neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11164.)
- Defines the occupations that are mandated reporters which includes but is not limited to teachers, athletic coaches, social workers, peace officers, firefighters, physicians, psychologists, psychiatrists, emergency medical technicians, licensed family therapists, child visitation monitors, and clergy members. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a).)
- Requires a mandated reporter to make a report whenever the mandated reporter, in his or her professional capacity or within the scope of his or her employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the mandated reporter knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect. Requires the mandated reporter to make an initial report by telephone to the agency immediately or as soon as is practicably possible, and to prepare and send, fax, or electronically transmit a written follow up report within 36 hours of receiving the information concerning the incident. Provides that the mandated reporter may include with the report any non-privileged documentary evidence the mandated reporter possesses relating to the incident. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).)
- Provides that a mandated reporter who fails to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect as required by this section is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months confinement in a county jail or by a fine of $1,000 or by both that imprisonment and fine. Provides that the intentional concealment of a mandated reporter’s failure to report an incident known by the mandated reporter to be abuse or severe neglect is a continuing offense. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).)
- Provides that a clergy member who acquires knowledge or a reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication is exempt from the mandated reporter reporting requirements. Defines “penitential communication” as a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).)
- Clarifies that a clergy member has a duty to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect when the clergy member acting in some other capacity that would otherwise make the clergy member a mandated reporter. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(2).)
- Defines “member of the clergy” as a priest, minister, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church or of a religious denomination or religious organization. (Evid. Code, § 1030.)
- Defines “penitent” as a person who has made a penitential communication to a member of the clergy. (Evid. Code, § 1031.)
- Defines “penitential communication” as a communication made in confidence, in the presence of no third person so far as the penitent is aware, to a member of the clergy who, in the course of the discipline or practice of the clergy member’s church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications and, under the discipline or tenets of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret. (Evid. Code, § 1032.)
- Provides that a penitent, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege, subject to Evidence Code section 912. (Evid. Code, § 1033.)
- Provides that a member of the clergy, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege. (Evid. Code, § 1034.)
- Provides that the right of any person to claim a privilege is waived with respect to a communication protected by the privilege if any holder of the privilege, without coercion, has disclosed a significant part of the communication or has consented to disclosure made by anyone. (Evid. Code, § 912, subd. (a).)
This bill:
- Provides that the requirement that a clergy member report whenever the clergy member, in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the clergy member knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect does not apply to knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect obtained by a clergy member during a penitential communication.
- Defines “penitential communication” as a communication that meets all of the following requirements:
- Is communicated orally.
- Is made privately to a clergy member.
- Is intended by the communicant to be an act of contrition or a matter of conscience.
- Is intended by both parties to be confidential at the time the communication was made.
- Is made in a manner and context that places the clergy member specifically and strictly under a level of confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine.
- Specifies that “penitential communication” does not mean any of the following activities, unless such activities take place as part of a penitential communication as defined above: providing spiritual direction; religious counseling; individual or group therapy; activity related to human resources or personnel management; clergy assignment work; communications between clergy, laity, or other members of the faith that occur outside of a penitential context; or activity relating to church administration or management.
- Provides that a written communication shall not qualify as a penitential communication.
- Provides that the clergy exception from mandated reporting does not modify or limit the duty of a clergy member to report known or suspected child abuse when a clergy member receives information about abuse or neglect from any source other than a penitential communication. Requires a clergy member to report any information obtained outside of a penitential communication even if the clergy member has also received information relating to abuse or neglect regarding the same person or incident during a penitential communication.
- Provides that the clergy exception from mandated reporting does not apply to a penitential communication between a clergy member and another person that is employed at the same site or facility as the clergy member, or a penitential communication between a clergy member and another clergy member.
Background
Mandated Reporting. Existing law requires members of 46 occupations to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).) Failure to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine, or both. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).) Clergy members, defined as “a priest, minister, rabbi, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization,” are included in the list of mandated reporters. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a)(32).) Notably, clergy members are provided an exemption from reporting under the mandated reporter statute if the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect is acquired during a penitential communication. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).) Existing law defines penitential communication as “a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Id.)
This bill amends the existing exception within the mandated reporter statute for penitential communications. Specifically, this bill changes the definition of penitential communication to mean a communication that is communicated orally; made privately to a clergy member; intended by the communicant to be an act of contrition or a matter of conscience; intended by both parties to be confidential at the time the communication was made; and made in a manner and context that places the clergy member specifically and strictly under a level of confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine. This bill specifies that penitential communication does not mean any of the following activities, unless such activities take place as part of a penitential communication as defined above: providing spiritual direction; religious counseling; individual or group therapy; activity related to human resources or personnel management; clergy assignment work; communications between clergy, laity, or other members of the faith that occur outside of a penitential context; or activity relating to church administration or management.
This bill further provides that the clergy exception from mandated reporting does not modify or limit the duty of a clergy member to report known or suspected child abuse when a clergy member receives information about abuse or neglect from any source other than a penitential communication. This bill requires a clergy member to report any information obtained outside of a penitential communication even if the clergy member has also received information relating to abuse or neglect regarding the same person or incident during a penitential communication. Finally, this bill provides that the clergy exception from mandated reporting does not apply to a penitential communication between a clergy member and another person that is employed at the same site or facility as the clergy member, or to a penitential communication between a clergy member and another clergy member.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Court: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against clergy defendants who do not report child abuse or neglect discovered during penitential communications. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the governor’s proposed FY 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund- Trial Court Trust Fund)
- Prosecution & Incarceration: Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
Child USA
Consumer Attorneys of California
Crime Victims United of California
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Restorative Justice Initiative
Stop Child Abuse Advocates for Reform Society
1 individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
California Catholic Conference
Pacific Justice Institute- Center for Public Policy
Prepared by: Stephanie Jordan / PUB. S. /
5/20/19 11:26:23
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 360 (Hill) - Mandated reporters: clergy
Version: February 20, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Bill Summary:
SB 360 would narrow the penitential communication exception for clergy for purposes of mandatory reporting of known or reasonably-suspicioned child abuse or neglect.
Fiscal Impact:
- Court: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against clergy defendants who do not report child abuse or neglect discovered during penitential communications. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the governor's proposed FY 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Prosecution & incarceration: Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Committee Amendments:
Create a narrow exemption for penitential communications, which would be an oral communication, made privately to a clergy member, intended by the communicant to be an act of contrition or a matter of conscience, intended by both parties to be confidential at the time of the communication was made, and made in a manner and context that places the cleric specifically and strictly under a level of confidentiality that is considered inviolate by church doctrine. Specified activities would not be included as penitential communications, nor would any communication by a coworker of the clergy person who works at the same location or any communication between clergy members regardless of the location of work.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 360 (Hill) - Mandated reporters: clergy
Version: February 20, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: April 22, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
SB 360 would remove the penitential communication exception for clergy for purposes of mandatory reporting of known or reasonably-suspicioned child abuse or neglect.
Fiscal Impact:
- Court: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against clergy defendants who do not report child abuse or neglect discovered during penitential communications. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the governor's proposed FY 2019-20 budget seeks to appropriate $52.5 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Prosecution & incarceration: Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Public Safety:
Existing law requires members of 46 occupations to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).) Failure to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine, or both. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).) Clergy members, defined as “a priest, minister, rabbi, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization,” are included in the list of mandated reporters. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a)(32).) Notably, clergy members are provided an exemption from reporting under the mandated reporter statute if the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect is acquired during a penitential communication. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).) Existing law defines penitential communication as “a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Id.)
Proposed Law:
This bill would mandate clergy to report to a law enforcement agency if the clergyperson acquired the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication.
Staff Comments:
The fiscal impact of this bill cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors, including, but not limited to, judicial and prosecutorial discretion, the criminal history of a defendant, and the factors unique to each case. As the crime expanded upon by this bill—that is, the failure of clergy to report the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect acquired during a penitential communication—is punishable as a misdemeanor with the potential for incarceration, certain rights to the defendants are attached to the proceedings, including the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings. Consequently, to the extent that the court adjudicates a dozen or more of these new crimes, on average, that otherwise would not have been filed or resulted in a criminal action but for the alleged violation of the failure to report, court costs of this bill would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 360 Hearing Date: April 2, 2019
Author: | Hill | ||
Version: | February 20, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SJ | ||
Subject: Mandated Reporters: Clergy
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: None known
Support: California Civil Liberties Advocacy; Child USA; Consumer Attorneys of California; Crime Victims United of California; National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter; Restorative Justice Initiative; Stop Child Abuse Advocates for Reform Society; 1 individual
Opposition: California Catholic Conference; Pacific Justice Institute- Center for Public Policy
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to require a clergy member to report whenever the clergy member, in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the clergy member knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect, including when the clergy member acquires the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication.
Existing law establishes the Child Abuse and Neglect Reporting Act and states that the intent and purpose of the Act is to protect children from abuse and neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11164.)
Existing law defines the occupations that are mandated reporters which includes but is not limited to teachers, athletic coaches, social workers, peace officers, firefighters, physicians, psychologists, psychiatrists, emergency medical technicians, licensed family therapists, child visitation monitors, and clergy members. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires a mandated reporter to make a report whenever the mandated reporter, in his or her professional capacity or within the scope of his or her employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the mandated reporter knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect. Requires the mandated reporter to make an initial report by telephone to the agency immediately or as soon as is practicably possible, and to prepare and send, fax, or electronically transmit a written follow up report within 36 hours of receiving the information concerning the incident. Provides that the mandated reporter may include with the report any non-privileged documentary evidence the mandated reporter possesses relating to the incident. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).)
Existing law provides that a mandated reporter who fails to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect as required by this section is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months confinement in a county jail or by a fine of $1,000 or by both that imprisonment and fine. Provides that the intentional concealment of a mandated reporter’s failure to report an incident known by the mandated reporter to be abuse or severe neglect is a continuing offense. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).)
Existing law provides that a clergy member who acquires knowledge or a reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication is exempt from the mandated reporter reporting requirements. Defines “penitential communication” as a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).)
Existing law clarifies that a clergy member has a duty to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect when the clergy member acting in some other capacity that would otherwise make the clergy member a mandated reporter. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(2).)
Existing law defines “member of the clergy” as a priest, minister, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church or of a religious denomination or religious organization. (Evid. Code, § 1030.)
Existing law defines “penitent” as a person who has made a penitential communication to a member of the clergy. (Evid. Code, § 1031.)
Existing law defines “penitential communication” as a communication made in confidence, in the presence of no third person so far as the penitent is aware, to a member of the clergy who, in the course of the discipline or practice of the clergy member’s church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications and, under the discipline or tenets of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret. (Evid. Code, § 1032.)
Existing law provides that a penitent, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose, and to prevent another from disclosing, a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege, subject to Evidence Code section 912. (Evid. Code, § 1033.)
Existing law provides that a member of the clergy, whether or not a party, has a privilege to refuse to disclose a penitential communication if he or she claims the privilege. (Evid. Code, § 1034.)
Existing law provides that the right of any person to claim a privilege is waived with respect to a communication protected by the privilege if any holder of the privilege, without coercion, has disclosed a significant part of the communication or has consented to disclosure made by anyone. (Evid. Code, § 912, subd. (a).)
This bill requires a clergy member to report whenever the clergy member, in their professional capacity or within the scope of their employment, has knowledge of or observes a child whom the clergy member knows or reasonably suspects has been the victim of child abuse or neglect, including when the clergy member acquires the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect during a penitential communication.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author:
All 50 states have statutes mandating that certain groups report suspected child abuse or neglect. This is no accident: there has long been a consensus that child abuse and neglect is categorically different than other crimes. Child victims don’t understand what is happening to them. Worse still, adult abusers often make children feel responsible for their abuse, resulting in guilt, shame, and a fear of reporting. When children are the victims, our country has decided the rules should be different.
Unfortunately, California has not applied those rules equitably to all mandated reporters. California gives clergy – priests, rabbis, ministers, religious practitioners, or similar functionaries of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization – an exemption not granted to any of the other 45 mandated reporters listed in statute. Even spousal privilege and doctor-patient privilege are nullified in cases of child abuse or neglect.
Additionally, recent investigations by 14 attorneys general, the federal government, and other countries have revealed that the clergy-penitent privilege has been abused on a large scale, resulting in the unreported and systemic abuse of thousands of children across multiple denominations and faiths.
In 1973, the U.S. Congress rejected a proposal to codify the clergy-penitent privilege in the Federal Evidence Code, choosing instead to leave the decision up to individual states. Connecticut, Indiana, Mississippi, Nebraska, New Hampshire, New Jersey, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, Tennessee, Texas, and West Virginia already have statutes similar to this bill proposal.
- Mandated Reporting
Existing law requires members of 46 occupations to report known or suspected child abuse or neglect. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (a).) Failure to report an incident of known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail, a fine, or both. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (c).) Clergy members, defined as “a priest, minister, rabbi, religious practitioner, or similar functionary of a church, temple, or recognized denomination or organization,” are included in the list of mandated reporters. (Pen. Code, § 11165.7, subd. (a)(32).) Notably, clergy members are provided an exemption from reporting under the mandated reporter statute if the knowledge or reasonable suspicion of child abuse or neglect is acquired during a penitential communication. (Pen. Code, § 11166, subd. (d)(1).) Existing law defines penitential communication as “a communication, intended to be in confidence, including, but not limited to, a sacramental confession, made to a clergy member who, in the course of the discipline or practice of his or her church, denomination, or organization, is authorized or accustomed to hear those communications, and under the discipline, tenets, customs, or practices of his or her church, denomination, or organization, has a duty to keep those communications secret.” (Id.)
This bill would repeal the provisions of law related to the clergy exemption from reporting known or reasonably suspected child abuse or neglect. In doing so, a clergy member who failed to report child abuse or neglect when the clergy member acquired the knowledge during a penitential communication would be subject to the same criminal liability as other mandated reporters.
- How Other States have Approached Clergy as Mandated Reporters
All 50 states have a mandated reporter statute. A 2015 publication by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) on clergy members as mandated reporters reported that 28 states listed clergy members as mandated reporters. (HHS, Clergy as Mandated Reporters of Child Abuse and Neglect (2015) <https://www.childwelfare.gov/pubPDFs/clergymandated.pdf> [as of Mar. 27, 2019].) Another 16 states did not specifically list clergy members as mandated reporters, but instead enumerated “any person” as a mandated reporter. (Id.) Of the 28 states that enumerated clergy members as mandated reporters, 24 of those states explicitly included an exemption for abuse discovered through penitential or pastoral communications. (Id.) Of the 16 states with “any person” mandated reporter statutes, 7 explicitly provide a penitential communication exemption. (Id.) As of 2015, among states that list clergy as mandated reporters or enumerate “any person” as a mandated reporter, only 6 states deny the clergy-penitent privilege in cases of child abuse or neglect. (Id.) Of note, even in states that deny clergy-penitent privilege in cases of child abuse or neglect, the ability to compel testimony from clergy who learned of abuse during a penitential communication may be limited. (See e.g,. N.H.R.S.A. § 169-C:32 and § 516:35 [New Hampshire’s mandated reporter statute includes “priest, minister, or rabbi or any other person having reason to suspect that a child has been abused or neglected” but § 516:35 provides that a “priest, rabbi or ordained or licensed minister of any church or a duly accredited Christian Science practitioner shall not be required to disclose a confession or confidence made to him in his professional character as spiritual adviser, unless the person confessing or confiding waives the privilege”].)
Recently there have been efforts to add clergy members to the list of mandated reporters in states that do not already include them in their reporting statutes. (See <https://www.wkbw.com/news/i-team/priests-other-clergy-would-be-mandatory-child-abuse-reporters-under-proposed-new-york-law>; <https://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/clergy-child-abuse-sex-reporting_us_5c49eb19e4b013f47a6bf77c> [as of Mar. 27, 2019].) In light of the ongoing revelations of child sex abuse within various churches, the clergy exemption from reporting child abuse when the knowledge regarding the abuse was learned through a penitential communication is being more heavily scrutinized. (See <https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/29/opinion/catholic-priest-abuse-reporting.html>; <https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2012/03/should-clergy-report-confessions-of-child-abuse/254053/> [as of Mar. 27, 2019].)
- First Amendment Concerns
Requiring clergy members to report child abuse learned during a penitential communication may raise First Amendment concerns. The clergy exemption from the mandated reporting of child abuse when learned through a penitential communication is tied to the clergy-penitent privilege, codified in California law in Evidence Code sections 1030-1034. Other types of privileged communications, including attorney-client privilege, doctor-patient privilege, and psychotherapist-patient privilege, are codified. (Evid. Code, § 900 et seq.) Notably, only clergy members are granted an exemption under the mandated reporting statute.
The clergy-penitent privilege is a long established privilege rooted in religious doctrine and practice. (Jacob M. Yellin, The History and Current Status of the Clergy-Penitent Privilege (1983) 23 Santa Clara L. Rev. 95, 95.) The clergy-penitent privilege “reflects a public policy that values the sanctity of conversations between members of a particular faith and their religious advisors.” (Caroline Donze, Breaking the Seal of Confession: Examining the Constitutionality of the Clergy-Penitent Privilege in Mandatory Reporting Law (2018) 78 La. L. Rev. 267, 275.) The clergy-penitent privilege is unique among the privileges because the person on the receiving end of the communication, the clergy member, may claim protection from compelled disclosure under the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, a defense that is not available to a doctor, attorney, or psychotherapist. (Id. at 272.) Another aspect of the clergy-penitent privilege that sets it apart from the other privileges is the fact that “a communicant’s waiver of privilege may not be sufficient for clergy, specifically those of the Catholic faith, to justify revealing the details of a private confession.” (Ibid.) In the case of a Catholic priest, he faces excommunication from the Church if he discloses a communication made to him during Confession. (Samuel G. Brooks, Confession and Mandatory Child Abuse Reporting: A New Take on the Constitutionality of Abrogating the Priest-Penitent Privilege (2009) 24 BYU J. Pub. L.117, 120 (2009).
The constitutionality of a state’s mandated report statute that requires clergy members to report child abuse but that does not provide an exemption for penitential communications remains an evolving legal question. The Free Exercise Clause “embraces two concepts—freedom to believe and freedom to act. The first is absolute, but in the nature of things, the second cannot be.” Cantwell v. Connecticut (1940) 310 U.S. 296, 304. Prior to its decision in Employment Division v. Smith, the U.S. Supreme Court employed a test balancing the interest asserted by the government against the claim of religious liberty asserted by the affected person when evaluating a claim of a Free Exercise Clause violation. (Sherbert v. Verner (1963) 374 U.S. 398.) In Sherbert, the court held that the government regulation would be valid only if the government had a compelling interest and no alternative forms of regulation would serve that interest. (Id. at 403, 406-409.)
The analysis changed following Employment Division v. Smith, (1990) 494 U.S. 872. In that case, the U.S. Supreme Court held that “if prohibiting the exercise of religion…is not the object [of the regulation]…but merely the incidental effect of a generally applicable and otherwise valid provision, the First Amendment has not been offended.” (Id. at 878.) The court explained: “We have never held that an individual’s religious beliefs excuse him from compliance with an otherwise valid law prohibiting conduct that the State is free to regulate.” (Id. at 878-879.) In response to Smith, a more stringent standard for reviewing laws based on violations of the Free Exercise Clause—reviving the Sherbert test—was codified in the federal Restoration of Religious Freedom Act (RFRA). However, RFRA was struck down by the U.S. Supreme Court with respect to its applicability to the states in 1997, and California has not codified its own RFRA since that time. (City of Boerne v. Flores (1997) 521 U.S. 507.)
Some legal scholars have argued that in states that do not have their own RFRA, “mandatory reporting legislation abrogating the clergy-penitent privilege easily survives a Free Exercise challenge under Smith” and that “eliminating the privilege actually enhances the general applicability of mandatory reporting laws.” (Donze, supra at 288.) Arguably, a mandated reporter statute that includes clergy members but does not provide for the penitential communication exemption would survive even under a strict scrutiny analysis.
The analysis of a challenge to a mandated reporter statute that includes clergy members but does not provide for the penitential communication exemption as a violation of the California Constitution’s Free Exercise Clause would differ to some extent from one relying on the Free Exercise Clause of the U.S. Constitution due to the unique language found in the state’s Clause. The California Constitution provides:
“Free exercise and enjoyment of religion without discrimination or preference are guaranteed. This liberty of conscience does not excuse acts that are licentious or inconsistent with the peace or safety of the State. The Legislature shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion. A person is not incompetent to be a witness or juror because of his or her opinions on religious beliefs.” (Cal. Const., art. 1, § 4 (emphasis added).)
Arguably, the free exercise of religion in this case—that is, refusing to disclose penitential communications in child abuse cases—is “inconsistent with the peace and safety of the state.”
- Argument in Support
California Civil Liberties Advocacy writes:
By removing the exemption for clergy-penitent privilege, California law will ensure that incidences of child abuse and neglect no longer go unreported. Religious institutions have had decades to address this matter internally and they have utterly failed to do so….Abusers will no longer be protected by the “sanctuary” provided by religious institutions and abuse survivors will no longer be silenced by clerics who admonish them not to disclose the matter to anyone else. If enacted, SB 360 will rightfully restore the civil liberties of society’s most vulnerable, and ensures that children receive the equal protection of the law.
- Argument in Opposition
The California Catholic Conference writes:
We oppose SB 360 because it crosses a constitutionally protected element of our religious faith: penitential communications.
There is no question that protecting children and young people must be held accountable for their crimes but disregarding fundamental religious freedom rights is unnecessary and inappropriate. The sanctity of religious communications can be protected and respected and criminals brought to justice for their crimes. These two public priorities are not mutually exclusive.
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):