SB 38: Sales and use taxes: consumer designation: all volunteer fire department.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-11
Existing law, the Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement (STAKE) Act, prohibits a person from selling or otherwise furnishing tobacco products, as defined, to a person under 21 years of age. Existing law authorizes specified enforcing agencies to assess civil penalties for violations of the STAKE Act.
This bill would prohibit a tobacco retailer from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale, a flavored tobacco product, as defined. The bill would authorize an enforcing agency to assess civil penalties under the STAKE Act for a violation of this prohibition. The bill would state the intent of the Legislature that these provisions not be construed to preempt or prohibit the adoption and implementation of local ordinances related to the prohibition on the sale of flavored tobacco products. The bill would state that its provisions are severable.
For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:
(a)Characterizing flavor means a distinguishable taste or aroma, or both, other than the taste or aroma of tobacco, imparted by a tobacco product or any byproduct produced by the tobacco product. Characterizing flavors include, but are not limited to, tastes or aromas relating to any fruit, chocolate, vanilla, honey, candy, cocoa, dessert, alcoholic beverage, menthol, mint, wintergreen, herb, or spice. A tobacco product shall not be determined to have a characterizing flavor solely because of the use of additives or flavorings or the provision of ingredient information. Rather, it is the presence of a distinguishable taste or aroma, or both, as described in the first sentence of this definition, that constitutes a characterizing flavor.
(b)Constituent means any ingredient, substance, chemical, or compound, other than tobacco, water, or reconstituted tobacco sheet, that is added by the manufacturer to a tobacco product during the processing, manufacture, or packing of the tobacco product.
(c)Enforcing agency means the State Department of Public Health, another state agency, including, but not limited to, the office of the Attorney General, or a local law enforcement agency, including, but not limited to, a city attorney, district attorney, or county counsel.
(d)Flavored tobacco product means any tobacco product that contains a constituent that imparts a characterizing flavor.
(e)Labeling means written, printed, pictorial, or graphic matter upon a tobacco product or any of its packaging.
(f)Packaging means a pack, box, carton, or container of any kind, or, if no other container, any wrapping, including cellophane, in which a tobacco product is sold or offered for sale to a consumer.
(g)Retail location means both of the following:
(1)A building from which tobacco products are sold at retail.
(2)A vending machine.
(h)Sale or sold means a sale as defined in Section 30006 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(i)Tobacco product means a tobacco product as defined in paragraph 8 of subdivision (a) of Section 104495 of the Health and Safety Code, as that provision may be amended from time to time.
(j)Tobacco retailer means a person who engages in this state in the sale of tobacco products directly to the public from a retail location. Tobacco retailer includes a person who operates vending machines from which tobacco products are sold in this state.
22996.(a)A tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailers agents or employees, shall not sell, offer for sale, or possess with the intent to sell or offer for sale, a flavored tobacco product.
(b)There shall be a rebuttable presumption that a tobacco product is a flavored tobacco product if a manufacturer or any of the manufacturers agents or employees, in the course of his or her agency or employment, has made a statement or claim directed to consumers or to the public that the tobacco product has or produces a characterizing flavor, including, but not limited to, text, color, images, or all, on the products labeling or packaging that are used to explicitly or implicitly communicate that the tobacco product has a characterizing flavor.
22997.An enforcing agency may assess civil penalties in the amounts set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 22958 for a violation of this division.
22998.This section does not preempt or otherwise prohibit the adoption of a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products than the restrictions imposed by this section. To the extent that there is an inconsistency between this section and a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products, the greater restriction on the access to tobacco products in the local standard shall prevail.
SEC. 2.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 78, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 11, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 8, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 5278.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 12, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Aug 11, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (August 11). |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 3130.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 22, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 21, 2020 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jan 16, 2020 | Set for hearing January 21. |
| Jan 15, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3099.) (January 15). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 9, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jan 9, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(c). |
| Jan 8, 2020 | Set for hearing January 15 in GOV. & F. pending receipt. |
| Jan 7, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 6, 2020 | From inactive file. |
| May 23, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Senator Hill. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | April 22 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Set for hearing April 22. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (March 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Set for hearing March 27. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | Unfinished Business SB38 Hill et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2020 | SB 38 Hill Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 11, 2020 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 27, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Senate 3rd Reading SB38 Hill et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 15, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 38 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 38
Author: Hill (D), et al.
Amended: 6/18/20
Vote: 21
PRIOR SENATE VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 1/15/20
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0, 1/23/20
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Atkins, Chang
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 8/30/20
(ROLL CALL NOT AVAILABLE)
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: consumer designation: all volunteer fire department
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends the designation of a qualifying volunteer fire department as a consumer, not a retailer, under the Sales and Use Tax Law, from January 1, 2021, to January 1, 2026.
Assembly Amendments
extend the designation of a qualifying volunteer fire department as a consumer, not a retailer, under the Sales and Use Tax Law, from January 1, 2021, to January 1, 2026, not repealing it entirely as the version the Senate approved; and add requirements for the purposes of complying with Revenue and Taxation Code §41. The amendments also make technical changes and add coauthors.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Imposes the sales tax on every retailer “engaged in business in this state” that sells tangible personal property, and requires them to register with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), as well as collect and remit appropriate tax at purchase and remit the amount to CDFTA.
- Provides that the sales tax applies whenever a retail sale occurs, which is generally any sale other than one for resale in the regular course of business.
- Sets the current sales and use tax rate at 7.25%., and additionally permits cities, counties, and specified special districts to increase the sales and use tax rate applicable within their jurisdictions.
- Requires retailers to obtain a seller’s permit, and report to CDTFA any sales tax collected from purchasers quarterly on a return.
- Treats nonprofits, public agencies, and charities generally the same way as any other retailer by not providing blanket exemptions from collecting and remitting the tax on their purchases or sales of taxable goods.
- Designates certain sellers as “consumers,” meaning that the law considers the tax paid when they purchase property, and the seller neither obtains a permit, nor collects and remits to CDTFA any tax from the purchaser at sale, including:
- Licensed medical and veterinary professionals dispensing specified products during the course of performing professional services,
- Qualified itinerant vendors,
- The Department of Transportation’s leases and sales of automobiles; and
- Nonprofit organizations that intermittently or irregularly sell food, nonalcoholic beverages, and other property made by the organization’s members.
- Designates all-volunteer fire departments as consumers, and not retailers, under the Sales and Use Tax Law for all its sales of tangible personal property, so long as its profits are solely and exclusively used to further the department’s purposes (SB 598, Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015). To qualify, a volunteer fire department must:
- Pay its members hourly or per incident, not with a regular salary,
- Have as its purpose the protection of life, property, and the environment within a designated geographic area from fires, disasters, and emergency incidents through education, prevention, training, and emergency response,
- Be organized as a tax exempt organization for state and federal purposes,
- Meet the definition of “volunteer fire department,” used in the welfare exemption from property tax.
- Provides that the designation does not apply when the volunteer fire department has gross receipts from the sales of property that exceeds $100,000 in each of the two preceding calendar years.
- Sunsets the designation of all-volunteer fire departments as consumers under the Sales and Use Tax Law on January 1, 2021.
This bill:
- Extends the current sunset date of January 1, 2021, on a volunteer fire department’s designation as a consumer under the Sales and Use Tax Law to January 1, 2026.
- Includes legislative findings and declarations to state the specific goals, purposes, and objectives of the consumer designation, and directs CDTFA to calculate the revenue loss due to the designation to help determine whether those specific goals, purposes, and objectives are met, and report the revenue loss to the Legislature.
Background
Many parts of California rely on volunteer fire departments to provide fire prevention and emergency response, especially in rural areas. These departments are mostly comprised of residents who voluntarily band together to provide these vital public services, and many have grown over time into present day fire districts. A volunteer fire department is currently eligible for the welfare exemption from property tax for property it owns that is used for departmental purposes. While some districts are funded and overseen by counties, many districts must solicit donations and sell items at fundraisers. However, selling property in California requires the seller to register with CDTFA, and collect and remit tax, which can be a burden for districts that must provide services with less administrative support than larger agencies.
The volunteer fire department seeking to eliminate the sunset date reports that most of their fundraising results from pancake breakfasts, or crab or pasta feeds. The department sells tickets to between 200 and 300 people for a price between $10 and $20. The department also sells t-shirts, hats, aprons, sweatshirts, and cups. Each event generated between $1,000 and $5,000.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, “SB 38 results in General Fund revenue loss of approximately $26,000 each year, and minor costs for CDTFA to provide revenue loss data to the Legislature.”
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/24/20)
California State Firefighters Association
Community Wildland Residents Association
Kings Mountain Volunteer Fire Brigade
La Honda Fire Brigade
San Marcos Hills Volunteer Fire Brigade
San Mateo County Board of Supervisors
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/24/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Prior to September 2015, California’s All-Volunteer Fire Departments (AVFDs) had to pay sales tax for fundraising activities like pancake breakfasts, barbeques and T-shirt sales. Fundraising income was cut down by critical dollars, diminishing the departments’ primary mission to protect Californian lives and property. SB 598 (Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015) exempts AVFDs from sales tax liability on income from fundraising activities. Additionally, the exemption does not apply if an all-volunteer fire department has receipts from the sale of tangible personal property of $100,000 or more. The law will sunset on January 1, 2021. As a primary source of revenue, these fundraisers allow AVFDs to make needed building improvements, and purchase lifesaving apparatuses. For example, La Honda’s All-Volunteer Fire Department used fundraising events to purchase a new $500,000 fire engine and a $30,000 fire station roof. AVFDs also continually need to purchase breathing apparatuses, fire fighter suits and other expensive equipment. California’s estimated 250 AVFDs and the lifesaving services they provide deserve a continued exemption on fundraisers. These organizations rely primarily on membership drives and fundraising activities to support their operational budgets and public mission.”
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
8/30/20 18:16:00
**** END ****
Date of Hearing: August 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 38
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 18, 2020
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 9 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends, from January 1, 2021, to January 1, 2026, the sunset date for the designation of all-volunteer fire departments (AVFDs) as consumers (instead of retailers) for the purposes of the sales and use tax (SUT). This bill also requires the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to estimate the revenue loss associated with this change in designation and to report this estimate to the Legislature annually beginning in 2023.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual General Fund revenue loss of approximately $26,000 each year.
- Minor costs for CDTFA to provide revenue loss data to the Legislature.
COMMENTS:
- The SUT, nonprofits and the consumer designation. Any retailer engaged in business in California must register with CDTFA and pay the state's sales tax, which applies to all retail sales of goods and merchandise except those sales specifically exempted by law. The retailer does not pay the SUT when purchasing goods for resale from a wholesaler or supplier.
State law designates some entities, including certain nonprofits such as AVFDs, as “consumers” for purposes of the SUT to ease administration and tax compliance. The practical impact of this designation, which typically applies only under very narrowly defined conditions, is that such an entity does not need to register with CDTFA as a seller, nor does it need to collect and remit sales tax when it sells goods to customers. Instead, the SUT is collected and remitted when the entity makes the initial purchase of goods for resale.
- Background on AVFD and the SUT. AVFDs protect lives and property within defined geographical areas from fires, disasters, and other emergency incidents through education, prevention, training, and emergency response. Volunteers are not paid a regular wage but may be compensated on an hourly or per-incident basis. AVFDs primarily serve rural areas and often operate on limited budgets funded through public finances, grants and charitable fundraising activities.
Prior to 2016, AVFDs had to remit sales and use tax from tangible personal property (TPP) sold through fundraising activities. SB 598 (Hill), Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015, designated AFVDs as consumers, and not retailers, of all TPP they sell if the profits are used solely and exclusively for fundraising purposes. This preferential treatment does not apply if an AVFD, in each of the two preceding calendar years, has gross receipts from the sale of TPP of $100,000 or more. This tax expenditure program will sunset on January 1, 2021
- Other bills related to AVFDs. A number of bills introduced this legislative session aim to address the financial health of volunteer fire departments and their firefighters. AB 1049 (Grayson), which provides an SUT exclusion for equipment purchased by an AVFD, and AB 1631 (Gray), which provided training resources to AVFDs, were both held on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 27, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 38
Author:(Hill) – As Amended Ver:June 18, 2020
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: consumer designation: all volunteer fire department
SUMMARY: Extends, from January 1, 2021, to January 1, 2026, the provisions of the Sales and Use Tax (SUT) Law that confer consumer status on certain all volunteer fire departments (AVFDs) that sell tangible personal property (TPP) for fundraising purposes. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that, for purposes of complying with Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, the Legislature finds and declares as follows:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this tax expenditure are to:
- Ensure that the entire gross amount of fundraisers continues to stay with AVFDs and helps provide critically needed equipment and services;
- Help AVFDs through this critical time; and,
- Ensure AVFDs can afford necessary equipment during fire season.
- For purposes of aiding the Legislature in determining whether this expenditure meets the goals, purposes, and objectives listed above, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) shall annually estimate the revenue loss associated with the tax expenditure; and,
- CDTFA shall report this information to the Legislature before each year beginning on or after January 1, 2023, and before January 1, 2026. The report shall comply with Government Code Section 9795.
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this tax expenditure are to:
- Provides that, notwithstanding existing law, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for lost SUT revenues.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling TPP, absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
- Imposes a complimentary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption of TPP generally purchased out-of-state and brought into California. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser; and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to an entity registered to collect California's use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the CDTFA.
- Designates the following entities as consumers, and not retailers, of specified TPP they use or furnish in the performance of their professional services:
- Licensed optometrists, physicians, pharmacists, and registered dispensing opticians (R&TC Section 6018);
- Licensed veterinarians (R&TC Section 6018);
- Licensed chiropractors (R&TC Section 6018.4);
- Specified garment cleaning establishments that received no more than 20% of their total gross receipts from the alteration of garments during the preceding calendar year (R&TC Section 6018.6);
- Licensed hearing aid dispensers (R&TC Section 6018.7); and,
- Producers of X-ray films or photographs used to diagnose human medical or dental conditions (R&TC Section 6020).
- Licensed optometrists, physicians, pharmacists, and registered dispensing opticians (R&TC Section 6018);
- Provides that an AVFD is considered the consumer, and not the retailer, of all TPP its sells, including hot prepared food products and clothing, if the profits are used solely and exclusively in furtherance of the AVFD's purposes. (R&TC Section 6018.10).
- Provides a property tax exemption for the property of a volunteer fire department that is used exclusively for volunteer fire department purposes, provided the department qualifies for exemption under R&TC Section 23701d or 23701f or under Internal Revenue Code Section 501(c)(3) or 501(c)(4). (R&TC Section 213.7).
- Requires any bill introduced on or after January 1, 2020, that authorizes a SUT exemption, to contain all of the following:
- Specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve;
- Detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets the goals, purposes, and objectives stated in the bill; and,
- Specified data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax expenditure is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding those specific goals, purposes, and objectives.
- Specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve;
FISCAL EFFECT: The annual SUT revenue loss would be approximately $48,207.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
Prior to September 2015, California's All-Volunteer Fire Departments (AVFDs) had to pay sales tax for fundraising activities like pancake breakfasts, barbeques and T-shirt sales. Fundraising income was cut down by critical dollars, diminishing the departments' primary mission to protect Californian lives and property. SB 598 (Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015) exempts AVFDs from sales tax liability on income from fundraising activities. Additionally, the exemption does not apply if an all-volunteer fire department has receipts from the sale of tangible personal property of $100,000 or more. The law will sunset on January 1, 2021.
As a primary source of revenue, these fundraisers allow AVFDs to make needed building improvements, and purchase lifesaving apparatuses. For example, La Honda's All-Volunteer Fire Department used fundraising events to purchase a new $500,000 fire engine and a $30,000 fire station roof. AVFDs also continually need to purchase breathing apparatuses, fire fighter suits and other expensive equipment.
California's estimated 250 AVFDs and the lifesaving services they provide deserve a continued exemption on fundraisers. These organizations rely primarily on membership drives and fundraising activities to support their operational budgets and public mission.
- This bill is supported by the California State Firefighters Association, which notes the following:
All-Volunteer Fire Departments (AVFDs) rely primarily on membership drives and fundraising events in order to support their large operational budgets and mission of public support. SB 598 (Hill) was a success in helping AVFDs better utilize scarce resources by exempting them from sales tax liability on income including but not limited to, hot prepared food products and clothing sold in fundraising activities.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- An overview of the SUT Law: The SUT represents the state's second largest source of General Fund (GF) revenues. Nevertheless, the past 70 years have seen a dramatic reduction in the state's reliance on the SUT and a corresponding increase in its reliance on personal income tax revenues. In Fiscal Year (FY) 2020-21, SUT revenues are estimated to comprise only 18.4% of the state's GF revenues, down from nearly 60% in FY 1950-51.
- What accounts for the state's reduced reliance on SUT revenues? The SUT Law was enacted in a very different era. In the 1930s, California's economy was largely dominated by manufacturing, and residents mostly bought and sold tangible goods. Thus, in establishing the base for a new consumption tax, it made sense to impose the tax on sales of TPP, defined as personal property that may be "seen, weighed, measured, felt, or touched." Over the past 80 years, however, California's economy has seen dramatic growth in the service and information sectors, resulting in a significant erosion of the SUT base. For example, the Commission on the 21st Century Economy noted that spending on taxable goods represented 34.6% of personal income in 2008, down from 55.4% in 1980. As a result, tax experts and economists from across the political spectrum argue that California should expand its SUT base.
It could be argued that, while well-intentioned, additional SUT exemptions further erode an already shrinking SUT base. This, in turn, increases fiscal pressures to maintain or even increase California's relatively high SUT rate. High rates arguably promote non-compliance and encourage out-of-state purchases, placing California retailers at a competitive disadvantage. High rates also risk impacting consumer decision-making, which runs counter to widely accepted principles of sound tax policy.
- How does the SUT Law generally apply to nonprofit organizations? The law does not generally exempt from the SUT sales by nonprofit organizations, persons engaged in charitable work, or those who enjoy certain income or property tax benefits. Therefore, nonprofit organizations' TPP sales are generally subject to tax to the same extent as any other retailer's sales. Generally, persons engaged in the business of selling TPP must obtain a seller's permit and report SUT on a CDTFA-prescribed return.
California law does, however, designate certain charitable organizations as consumers, rather than retailers, under the SUT Law. Statutorily, this is done on a case-by-case basis. For example, R&TC Section 6359.3 confers consumer status on nonprofit veterans' organizations with respect to United States flags sold, provided the profits are used exclusively in furtherance of the organization's purposes. R&TC Section 6360, in turn, confers consumer status on specified charities with respect to bracelets distributed to commemorate American prisoners of war. Once again, any profits must be used solely and exclusively in furtherance of the organization's purposes. As one last example, R&TC Section 6361.1 confers consumer status on qualified organizations that sell handcrafted items made by individuals with developmental disabilities or children with severe emotional disturbances. The price of each item sold must not exceed $20.
- AVFDs: There are numerous AVFDs throughout California. These entities, which primarily serve rural areas, protect lives and property by fighting fires and responding to other emergency incidents. These organizations often operate on limited budgets, with funds obtained through public financial support, fundraising activities, and grants.
SB 598 (Hill), Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015, provided that AVFDs shall be deemed consumers, and not retailers, of all TPP they sell if the profits are used solely and exclusively for fundraising purposes. This preferential treatment does not apply if an AVFD, in each of the two preceding calendar years, has gross receipts from the sale of TPP of $100,000 or more. Absent a statutory extension, this tax expenditure program is set to expire on January 1, 2021.
- What would this bill do? This bill would extend the sunset date for the current AVFD tax expenditure program from January 1, 2021, to January 1, 2026. This bill would also include data collection and reporting requirements to comply with R&TC Section 41.
- Policy on tax expenditures: Both R&TC Section 41 and Committee policy require any tax expenditure bill to outline specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax expenditure will achieve, along with detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax expenditure meets those stated goals, purposes, and objectives. A tax expenditure bill will not be eligible for a Committee vote unless it has complied with these requirements. This bill, in turn, has been amended to comply with R&TC Section 41.
In addition to the R&TC Section 41 requirements, this Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain an appropriate sunset provision to be eligible for a vote. According to the new policy, an "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean five years, except in the case of a tax expenditure measure providing relief to California veterans, in which case "appropriate sunset provision" shall mean 10 years. This bill has been amended to include a five-year sunset extension.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State Firefighters Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 38 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 38
Amended: 1/6/20
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 1/15/20
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: consumer designation: all volunteer fire department
DIGEST:
This bill repeals the sunset provision on the designation of a qualifying volunteer fire department as a consumer, not a retailer, under the Sales and Use Tax Law.
Senate Floor Amendments of 1/6/20 delete the prior version of the bill relating to flavored tobacco products and add the current language.
Existing law:
- Imposes the sales tax on every retailer “engaged in business in this state” that sells tangible personal property, and requires them to register with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), as well as collect and remit appropriate tax at purchase and remit the amount to CDFTA.
- Provides that the sales tax applies whenever a retail sale occurs, which is generally any sale other than one for resale in the regular course of business.
- Sets the current sales and use tax rate at 7.25%, and additionally permits cities, counties, and specified special districts to increase the sales and use tax rate applicable within their jurisdictions.
- Requires retailers to obtain a seller’s permit, and report to CDTFA any sales tax collected from purchasers quarterly on a return.
- Treats nonprofits, public agencies, and charities generally the same way as any other retailer by not providing blanket exemptions from collecting and remitting the tax on their purchases or sales of taxable goods.
- Designates certain sellers as “consumers,” meaning that the law considers the tax paid when they purchase property, and the seller neither obtains a permit, nor collects and remits to CDTFA any tax from the purchaser at sale, including:
- Licensed medical and veterinary professionals dispensing specified products during the course of performing professional services,
- Qualified itinerant vendors,
- The Department of Transportation’s leases and sales of automobiles, and
- Nonprofit organizations that intermittently or irregularly sell food, nonalcoholic beverages, and other property made by the organization’s members.
- Designates all-volunteer fire departments as consumers, and not retailers, under the Sales and Use Tax Law for all its sales of tangible personal property, so long as its profits are solely and exclusively used to further the department’s purposes (SB 598, Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015). To qualify, a volunteer fire department must:
- Pay its members hourly or per incident, not with a regular salary,
- Have as its purpose the protection of life, property, and the environment within a designated geographic area from fires, disasters, and emergency incidents through education, prevention, training, and emergency response,
- Be organized as a tax exempt organization for state and federal purposes,
- Meet the definition of “volunteer fire department,” used in the welfare exemption from property tax.
- Provides that the designation does not apply when the volunteer fire department has gross receipts from the sales of property that exceeds $100,000 in each of the two preceding calendar years.
- Sunsets the designation of all-volunteer fire departments as consumers under the Sales and Use Tax Law on January 1, 2021.
This bill repeals the sunset date of January 1, 2021, on a volunteer fire department’s designation as a retailer under the Sales and Use Tax Law.
Background
Many parts of California rely on volunteer fire departments to provide fire prevention and emergency response, especially in rural areas. These departments are mostly comprised of residents who voluntarily band together to provide these vital public services, and many have grown over time into present day fire districts. A volunteer fire department is currently eligible for the welfare exemption from property tax for property it owns that is used for departmental purposes. While some districts are funded and overseen by counties, many districts must solicit donations and sell items at fundraisers. However, selling property in California requires the seller to register with CDTFA, and collect and remit tax, which can be a burden for districts that must provide services with less administrative support than larger agencies.
The volunteer fire department seeking to eliminate the sunset date reports that most of their fundraising results from pancake breakfasts, or crab or pasta feeds. The department sells tickets to between 200 and 300 people for a price between $10 and $20. The department also sells t-shirts, hats, aprons, sweatshirts, and cups. Each event generated between $1,000 and $5,000.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California State Firefighters Association
La Honda Fire Brigade, Inc.
San Marcos Pass Volunteer Fire Department
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/22/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “Prior to September 2015, California’s All-Volunteer Fire Departments (AVFDs) had to pay sales tax for fundraising activities like pancake breakfasts, barbeques and T-shirt sales. Fundraising income was cut down by critical dollars, diminishing the departments’ primary mission to protect Californian lives and property. SB 598 (Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015) exempts AVFDs from sales tax liability on income from fundraising activities. Additionally, the exemption does not apply if an all-volunteer fire department has receipts from the sale of tangible personal property of $100,000 or more. The law will sunset on January 1, 2021. As a primary source of revenue, these fundraisers allow AVFDs to make needed building improvements, and purchase lifesaving apparatuses. For example, La Honda’s All-Volunteer Fire Department used fundraising events to purchase a new $500,000 fire engine and a $30,000 fire station roof. AVFDs also continually need to purchase breathing apparatuses, fire fighter suits and other expensive equipment. California’s estimated 250 AVFDs and the lifesaving services they provide deserve a continued exemption on fundraisers. These organizations rely primarily on membership drives and fundraising activities to support their operational budgets and public mission.”
Prepared by: Colin Grinnell / GOV. & F. / (916) 651-4119
1/23/20 8:24:29
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | SB 38 | Hearing Date: | 1/15/20 |
Author: | Hill | Tax Levy: | Yes |
Version: | 1/6/20 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Sales and use taxes: consumer designation: all volunteer fire departmenT.
Repeals the sunset provision on the designation of a qualifying volunteer fire department as a consumer, not a retailer, under the Sales and Use Tax Law.
Background
State law imposes the sales tax on every retailer “engaged in business in this state” that sells tangible personal property, and requires them to register with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), as well as collect and remit appropriate tax at purchase and remit the amount to CDFTA. Sales tax applies whenever a retail sale occurs, which is generally any sale other than one for resale in the regular course of business. The current rate is 7.25%. Additionally, cities, counties, and specified special districts may increase the sales and use tax, also known as district or transactions and use taxes.
Generally, retailers must obtain a seller’s permit, and report to CDTFA any sales tax collected from purchasers quarterly on a return. Nonprofits, public agencies, and charities are generally treated the same way as any other retailer, and do not have blanket exemptions from collecting and remitting the tax. However, state law designates certain sellers as “consumers,” meaning that the law considers the tax paid when they purchase property, and the seller neither obtains a permit, nor collects and remits to CDTFA any tax from the purchaser at sale.
“Consumers” include:
- Licensed medical and veterinary professionals dispensing specified products during the course of performing professional services,
- Qualified itinerant vendors,
- The Department of Transportation’s leases and sales of automobiles, and
- Nonprofit organizations that intermittently or irregularly sell food, nonalcoholic beverages, and other property made by the organization’s members.
Many parts of California rely on volunteer fire departments to provide fire prevention and emergency response, especially in rural areas. These departments are mostly comprised of residents who voluntarily band together to provide these vital public services, and many have grown over time into present day fire districts. A volunteer fire department is currently eligible for the welfare exemption from property tax for property it owns that is used for departmental
purposes. While some districts are funded and overseen by counties, many districts must solicit donations and sell items at fundraisers. However, selling property in California requires the seller to register with CDTFA, and collect and remit tax, which can be a burden for districts that must provide services with less administrative support than larger agencies.
In 2015, the Legislature designated all-volunteer fire departments as consumers, and not retailers, under the Sales and Use Tax Law for all its sales of tangible personal property, so long as its profits are solely and exclusively used to further the department’s purposes (SB 598, Hill). To qualify, a volunteer fire department must:
- Pay its members hourly or per incident, not with a regular salary,
- Have as its purpose the protection of life, property, and the environment within a designated geographic area from fires, disasters, and emergency incidents through education, prevention, training, and emergency response,
- Be organized as a tax exempt organization for state and federal purposes,
- Meet the definition of “volunteer fire department,” used in the welfare exemption from property tax.
SB 598’s provisions sunset on January 1, 2021, so a volunteer fire department will generally be treated as a retailer after that date. The author wants to remove the sunset, thereby making the consumer treatment permanent.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 38 removes the sunset provision on the designation of a qualifying volunteer fire department as a consumer, not a retailer, under the Sales and Use Tax Law.
State Revenue Impact
Pending.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Prior to September 2015, California’s All-Volunteer Fire Departments (AVFDs) had to pay sales tax for fundraising activities like pancake breakfasts, barbeques and T-shirt sales. Fundraising income was cut down by critical dollars, diminishing the departments’ primary mission to protect Californian lives and property. SB 598 (Hill, Chapter 248, Statutes of 2015) exempts AVFDs from sales tax liability on income from fundraising activities. Additionally, the exemption does not apply if an all-volunteer fire department has receipts from the sale of tangible personal property of $100,000 or more. The law will sunset on January 1, 2021. As a primary source of revenue, these fundraisers allow AVFDs to make needed building improvements, and purchase lifesaving apparatuses. For example, La Honda’s All-Volunteer Fire Department used fundraising events to purchase a new $500,000 fire engine and a $30,000 fire station roof. AVFDs also continually need to purchase breathing apparatuses, fire fighter suits and other expensive equipment. California’s estimated 250 AVFDs and the lifesaving services they provide deserve a continued exemption on fundraisers. These organizations rely primarily on membership drives and fundraising activities to support their operational budgets and public mission.”
2. Equal treatment. The Sales and Use Tax Law generally applies equal treatment regardless of whether a public or private entity buys or sells property, and usually imposes the same standards on retailers regardless of their size. Paying, collecting and remitting tax is a burden, but necessary to ensure adequate funding of public services, and promote equity between competitors. While volunteer fire districts argue that complying with current requirements diverts funds away from better uses, the same could be said for many other organizations. The Committee may wish to consider which characteristics, such as size, charitable purpose, or administrative burden, should qualify an organization for relief from the collection and remission requirements.
3. How does this work? Without consumer treatment, a volunteer fire department would have to obtain a seller’s permit from CDTFA if it wants to sell items at a fundraiser, as well as a resale certificate. If the department wants to hold a barbeque fundraiser, it would show the resale certificate to the supplier when purchasing hot dogs and hamburgers, and the supplier would not charge the department the sales tax at purchase. When the department sold the food at the fundraiser, it would collect tax from the purchaser in an amount of tax equal to the combined state and local rate for that jurisdiction times the purchase price, and remit the total tax amount from all its sales quarterly to CDTFA. The department would have to collect and remit the tax even if someone donated the hot dogs and hamburgers. Under SB 38, the department would continue to pay the supplier the tax instead as part of its purchase of hot dogs and hamburgers, and need not collect and remit tax from its sales at the barbeque fundraiser; instead, the food supplier would remit taxes due on the sale of those products to CDTFA.
4. Experience. The volunteer fire department seeking to eliminate the sunset date reports that most of their fundraising results from pancake breakfasts, or crab or pasta feeds. The department sells tickets to between 200 and 300 people for a price between $10 and $20. The department also sells t-shirts, hats, aprons, sweatshirts, and cups. Each event generated between $1,000 and $5,000.
Support and Opposition
(1/10/20)
Support: California State Firefighters Association; La Honda Fire Brigade, Inc.; San Marcos Pass Volunteer Fire Department.
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 38 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 38
Author: Hill (D), Glazer (D), McGuire (D) and Portantino (D), et al.
Amended: 5/17/19
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 8-1, 3/27/19
AYES: Pan, Stone, Durazo, Hurtado, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Rubio
NOES: Grove
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: Flavored tobacco products
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale a flavored tobacco product, as specified.
Existing law:
- Requires the Department of Public Health (DPH) to establish and develop a program to reduce the availability of “tobacco products,” as defined, to persons under 21 years of age through authorized enforcement activities, as specified, pursuant to the Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement Act (STAKE Act). [BPC §22952]
- Requires all persons engaging in the retail sale of tobacco products to check the identification of tobacco purchasers, to establish the age of the purchaser, if the purchaser reasonably appears to be under 21. [BPC §22956]
- Permits an enforcing agency, as specified, to assess civil penalties against any person, firm, or corporation that sells, gives, or in any way furnishes to another person who is under 21 any tobacco product, instrument, or paraphernalia that is designed for the smoking or ingestion of tobacco products, as specified, ranging from $400 to $6,000 for a first, second, third, fourth, or fifth violation within a five-year period. [BPC §22958]
- Defines “tobacco product” as a product containing, made, or derived from tobacco or nicotine that is intended for human consumption, as specified, including an electronic device that delivers nicotine or other vaporized liquids to the person inhaling from the device, and any component, part, or accessory of a tobacco product, whether or not sold separately. Prohibits any product approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for sale as a tobacco cessation product or for other therapeutic purposes, as specified, from being deemed a tobacco product. [BPC §22950.5]
This bill:
- Prohibits a tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale a flavored tobacco product.
- Deems a tobacco product as a flavored tobacco product if a manufacturer or any of the manufacturer’s agents or employees, in the course of his or her agency or employment, has made a statement or claim directed to consumers or to the public that the tobacco product has or produces a “characterizing flavor,” as defined, including, but not limited to, text, color, images, or all, on the product’s labeling or packaging that are used to explicitly or implicitly communicate that the tobacco product has a characterizing flavor.
- Excludes tobacco products designed for non-electronic hookah from the meaning of flavored tobacco products.
- Defines “characterizing flavor” as any distinguishable taste or aroma, or both, other than the taste or aroma of tobacco, imparted by a tobacco product or any byproduct produced by the tobacco product, including, but not limited to, tastes or aromas relating to any fruit, chocolate, vanilla, honey, candy, cocoa, dessert, alcoholic beverage, menthol, mint, wintergreen, herb, or spice. Prohibits a tobacco product from being determined to have a characterizing flavor solely because of the use of additives or flavorings or the provision of ingredient information.
- Permits an enforcement agency to assess civil penalties in the amounts specified in 3) of existing law above for a violation of this bill.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, youth usage of flavored tobacco products has surged recently. According to a report released by the FDA in November 2018, more than 3.6 million middle and high school students are using e-cigarettes. This is an increase of 1.5 million compared to 2017 and almost 13 times higher than the number of youth using e-cigarettes in 2011. The stunning growth between 2017 and 2018 amounted to a 78% increase in e-cigarette use by high school students and a 48% increase by middle school students. Flavored tobacco product poses a serious public health risk. Eighty percent of young people who have ever used tobacco started with a flavored product, which are a gateway to harder nicotine use, hooking users with kid-friendly flavors like cotton candy, bubble gum, and mango. This bill will address dramatic increases in youth tobacco use by prohibiting the retail sale of all flavored tobacco products. We have seen this before with big tobacco: false claims of safety, flavors used to hook users, and marketing obviously targeted to youth. This bill takes immediate action to prevent another generation from tobacco and nicotine addiction.
- Smoking prevalence. According to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly 90% of smokers in the U.S. started smoking by the age of 18, and 98% started by age 26. The CDC reports that if smoking continues at the current rate in the U.S., 5.6 million of today’s youth under the age of 18 (about one of every 13) will die early from a tobacco-related disease. Each day in the U.S., more than 3,200 youth aged 18 years or younger smoke their first cigarette, and an additional 2,100 youth and young adults become daily cigarette smokers. Flavorings in tobacco products can make them more appealing to youth. According to the CDC, in 2014, 73% of high school students and 56% of middle school students who used tobacco products in the past 30 days reported using a flavored tobacco product. From 2011 to 2016, cigarette smoking declined among middle and high school students. However, the use of electronic cigarettes increased among the same population during the same time: 4.3 % of middle school students reported in 2016 that they used electronic cigarettes, which was an increase from 0.6% in 2011, and 8% of high school students reported having used electronic cigarettes, which was an increase from 1.5%.
- Tobacco-related diseases. Every year, cigarette smoking causes more than 480,000 deaths in the U.S. The CDC reports that smoking causes more deaths each year than the following causes combined: HIV, illegal drug and alcohol use, motor vehicle crashes, and firearm-related incidents. Smoking also causes about 90% of all lung cancer deaths and about 80% of all deaths from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease. Estimates also show that smoking increases the risk of coronary heart disease and stroke by two to four times, as well as the risk of men and women developing lung cancer by 25 times. Smoking causes diminished overall health, increased absenteeism from work, and increased health care utilization and cost. The CDC reports that just one year after quitting smoking, the risk for heart attack drops sharply, and within two to five years, the risk for stroke may reduce to about that of a nonsmoker. Within five years of quitting smoking, risks for cancers of the mouth, throat, esophagus, and bladder drop by about half. The risk for lung cancer also drops by about half after ten years of having quit smoking.
- FDA actions. The FDA has issued several statements over the past couple of years focusing on youth access to tobacco products. Specifically, the FDA is concerned about youth access to electronic smoking devices (ESDs), as the youth use rate has reached epidemic status. According to the FDA, the most recent data shows more than 3.6 million middle and high school students across the nation were current (past 30 day) ESD users in 2018, which is an increase of 1.5 million children since the previous year. The data also showed that youth who used ESDs were also using them more frequently and were using flavored products more often than in 2017. In various statements, the FDA commissioner signaled that most flavored tobacco products would be banned from retail locations. However, in March 2019, the FDA commissioner issued a statement announcing that manufacturers and retailers were being put on notice that they could be subject to FDA enforcement for selling certain flavored ESD products without authorization. The FDA announced it would prioritize enforcement to focus on protecting youth from becoming addicted to nicotine, which includes the retail sale of ESDs that are offered in ways that pose a greater risk for minors’ access to the products, such as retail and online sales without heightened age verification, and products that appeal to kids or that resemble non-ESD products like USB devices. In September 2018, the FDA commissioner issued a statement stating that the FDA would not tolerate a whole generation of young people becoming addicted to nicotine as a tradeoff for enabling adults to have unfettered access to the same products. As a result, the FDA initiated a Youth Tobacco Prevention Plan that focuses on preventing youth access to tobacco products, curbing the marketing of tobacco products aimed at youth, and educating teens about the dangers of using any tobacco products. In the September 2018 statement, the FDA announced issuing 12 warning letters to companies that continued to advertise and sell products to youth. Earlier the same year the FDA had also issued 56 warning letters and six civil monetary penalties to retailers as part of its enforcement action to limit access of tobacco products to youth. The FDA also sent letters to five ESD manufacturers whose products were sold to kids during the FDA’s ramped up enforcement period. The five ESD manufacturers collectively represent more than 97% of the current market for ESDs—JUUL, Vuse, MarkTen, blu e-cigs, and Logic. The FDA requested that these companies provide robust plans on how they will address the widespread use of their products by minors or face increased enforcement.
JUUL announced in November 2018 that it was taking action to curb youth access, such as selling flavored JUUL pods on its Web site only, using an enhanced online age verification system, shutting down its Facebook and Instagram accounts, and using its Twitter account for non-promotional communication only, and developing a next-generation device with access restrictions at the user level.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates a revenue loss of $292 million ($237 million in excise tax and $54.5 million in sales tax revenue) in fiscal year (FY) 2020-21. Absent the amount of tax revenue remitted, CDTFA anticipates a gross domestic product increase of $288 million, and employment impact gains of 1,685 jobs (537 within the industry, and 1,148 indirect jobs). CDTFA notes few data sources are available to document consumer responses to banning flavored products, so consumer impacts are highly uncertain. While the bill does not affect tax rates related to excise tax revenues, studies suggest a corresponding decrease in consumer purchases of products, as the bill’s proposed banned flavors include menthol, mint, and others.
- DPH estimates unknown and significant ongoing costs (hundreds of thousands to low millions) to investigate and take enforcement action. The range reflects multiple enforcing agencies’ actions, and the bill’s proposed enforcement requirement would be broader than DPH’s current responsibility, discussed below.
Staff estimates that the original revenue loss estimate would need to be revised to reflect a narrower scope of products that will be affected by the ban, specifically those that did not have a patent prior to 2000. At the time of the analysis, the fiscal estimate reflects an unknown, significant, and ongoing revenue loss, potentially in the high tens of millions to low hundreds of millions.
Alameda County Tobacco Control Coalition
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Americans for Nonsmokers’ Rights
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of Northern California Oncologists
Breathe California
California Chapter of the American College of Cardiology
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
California Dental Association
California Medical Association
California Optometric Association
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California Public Interest Research Group
California Society of Addiction Medicine
California State PTA
City of Emeryville
City of Oakland
City of Palo Alto
City of San Leandro
City of San Pablo
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Santa Clara
Families Uniting Locally to Solve Tobacco Proliferation
Fight Back Leadership Coalition
Flavors Hook Kids—Livermore
Health Access California
Kaiser Permanente
Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital Stanford
Medical Oncology Association of Southern California
National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners, SF Bay Area Chapter
Public Health Institute
San Francisco Bay Area Physicians for Social Responsibility
Sierra Club California
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
The Cancer Journey
USC Health, Emotion, and Addiction Laboratory
USC Institute for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention Research
USC Tobacco Center on Regulatory Science
Hundreds of individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/21/19)
American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network
American Heart Association
American Lung Association
American Petroleum and Convenience Store Association
California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
Cigar Association of America, Inc.
JT International USA Inc.
JUUL Labs
Logic Technology Development, LLC
PrimeTime International Distributing Inc.
The R Street Institute
Swedish Match North America
Vapor Technology Association
Hundreds of individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The supporters of this bill, largely health advocates, health professionals, and local governments, argue that tobacco products remain the leading cause of preventable illness, disability, and death in the nation. Supporters argue that the effects of tobacco are even more concerning in youth, whose brains are still developing, and that products are increasingly marketed to youth with enticing flavors and product design. Supporters cite recent studies that found youth users of ESDs rose by 78% between 2017 and 2018, and that 440,000 youth in the state are expected to die prematurely as a result of tobacco use. The supporters also note targeted marketing of certain tobacco products to communities of color, low-income individuals, and the LGBTQ community, citing that the tobacco industry aggressively markets menthol-flavored products to African Americans. Approximately 85% of African Americans who smoke use menthol cigarettes, and African-American men have the highest death rates from lung cancer when compared to other demographic groups. Further, supporters state that an alarming 80% of youths who have ever used tobacco started with a flavored product. The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians states that smokeless tobacco is responsible for serious illnesses, like cancer of the mouth, esophagus, lip, pancreas, and tongue, in addition to contributing to heart disease and stroke.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network, American Heart Association, and American Lung Association (the Coalition) state that due to the hostile amendments inserted into the bill in the Senate Appropriations Committee, they regret to inform that they are withdrawing co-sponsorship and moving to an oppose position. The Coalition states that exempting hookah products sets a terrible precedent and undermines the foundation of the original legislation to protect youth, low income, and minority communities from flavored tobacco. The Coalition argues that water pipe smoke, like cigarette smoke, contains significant amounts of cancer-causing ingredients, such as arsenic, cobalt, chromium, lead, and carbon monoxide. In addition, smoke from a water pipe contains carbon monoxide in amounts equal to or greater than smoke from cigarettes. Research has shown that water pipe smoking has the same negative effect on lung function as cigarette smoking. Water pipe smokers can be exposed to sufficient doses of nicotine to lead to addiction. Additional research found that using a water pipe was equivalent to smoking two to 10 cigarettes per day. Water pipe smoke produces similarly increased blood nicotine levels and increases in heart rate as cigarette use. Smokers of water pipes may be exposed to even more smoke than cigarette smokers because water pipe smoking sessions last longer. One study found that during a typical water pipe smoking session, a user may inhale 90,000 milliliters of smoke compared with 500-600 milliliters of smoke during a cigarette smoking session. The Cigar Association of America, Inc. (CAA) states that it is adamantly opposed to youth usage of cigars and pipe tobacco, but it does not believe this bill is necessary to reach the goal of further preventing youth access to tobacco products. CAA argues that given the aggressive regulatory actions being pursued at the federal level, it believes that a state-specific flavorings ban is problematic because it would run the risk of being in conflict with federal policy and that the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act expressly preempts states from enacting any requirement different from or in addition to federal requirements. JUUL Labs argues that this bill would impede adult smoker from accessing flavored products. JUUL Labs states that recent data show 40-56% of adult smokers who purchased and used JUUL products fully switched from combustible cigarettes within 90 days of use. JUUL states it also is concerned about the increase in youth use of its products and has taken dramatic and aggressive steps of any manufacturers in the industry to prevent underage use. The Vapor Technology Association argues that vapor products are considered to be dramatically safer than cigarettes and the focus should be on regulatory efforts on curbing combustible tobacco.
Prepared by: Reyes Diaz / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
5/21/19 15:23:43
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 38 (Hill) - Flavored tobacco products
Version: December 3, 2018 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 8 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
SB 38 would prohibit a tobacco retailer, or any of the retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale, a flavored tobacco product, as defined. The bill would authorize an enforcing agency to assess specified civil penalties, and would provide that the bill does not preempt or prohibit adoption of a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates a revenue loss of $292 million ($237 million in excise tax and $54.5 million in sales tax revenue) in fiscal year (FY) 2020-21. Absent the amount of tax revenue remitted, CDTFA anticipates a gross domestic product increase of $288 million, and employment impact gains of 1,685 jobs (537 within the industry, and 1,148 indirect jobs). CDTFA notes few data sources are available to document consumer responses to banning flavored products, so consumer impacts are highly uncertain. While the bill does not affect tax rates related to excise tax revenues, studies suggest a corresponding decrease in consumer purchases of products, as the bill’s proposed banned flavors include menthol, mint, and others. Please see Staff Comments for more detail on the assumptions and methodology of the estimate.
- The Department of Public Health (CDPH) estimates unknown and significant ongoing costs (hundreds of thousands to low millions) to investigate and take enforcement action. The range reflects multiple enforcing agencies’ actions, and the bill’s proposed enforcement requirement would be broader than CDPH’s current responsibility, discussed below.
Staff estimates that the original revenue loss estimate would need to be revised to reflect a narrower scope of products that will be affected by the ban, specifically those that did not have a patent prior to 2000. At the time of the analysis, the fiscal estimate reflects an unknown, significant, and ongoing revenue loss, potentially in the high tens of millions to low hundreds of millions.
Committee Amendments:
The committee amendments would define “tobacco product” as a product that does not have a patent issued prior to January 1, 2000, is a menthol flavored product, and is as defined in existing law, except for hookah.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 38 (Hill, et al.) - Flavored tobacco products.
Version: December 3, 2018 | Policy Vote: Health 8-1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: April 22, 2019 | Consultant: Samantha Lui |
Bill Summary:
SB 38 would prohibit a tobacco retailer, or any of the retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale, a flavored tobacco product, as defined. The bill would authorize an enforcing agency to assess specified civil penalties, and would provide that the bill does not preempt or prohibit adoption of a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates a revenue loss of $292 million ($237 million in excise tax and $54.5 million in sales tax revenue) in fiscal year (FY) 2020-21. Absent the amount of tax revenue remitted, CDTFA anticipates a gross domestic product increase of $288 million, and employment impact gains of 1,685 jobs (537 within the industry, and 1,148 indirect jobs). CDTFA notes few data sources are available to document consumer responses to banning flavored products, so consumer impacts are highly uncertain. While the bill does not affect tax rates related to excise tax revenues, studies suggest a corresponding decrease in consumer purchases of products, as the bill’s proposed banned flavors include menthol, mint, and others. Please see Staff Comments for more detail on the assumptions and methodology of the estimate.
- The DOJ reports no fiscal impact.
- The Department of Public Health (CDPH) estimates unknown and significant ongoing costs (hundreds of thousands to low millions) to investigate and take enforcement action. The range reflects multiple enforcing agencies’ actions, and the bill’s proposed enforcement requirement would be broader than CDPH’s current responsibility, discussed below.
- Staff notes unknown but potentially significant cost-avoidance and long-term savings to state public health systems and public health (cardiovascular and respiratory health-related illnesses), to the extent tobacco use is reduced and prevented in youths, and smoking cessation attempts are successful for some.
Background:
SBX2 5 (Leno, Chapter 7, Statutes of 2016) recasts and broadens the definition of “tobacco product” to include electronic smoking devices (ESDs), and extends current restrictions and prohibitions against the use of tobacco products to ESDs. SBX2 7 (Chapter 8, Statutes of 2016) increases the minimum legal age to purchase or consume tobacco from 18 to 21. Current law defines “tobacco product” as any of the following:
- A product containing, made, or derived from tobacco or nicotine that is intended for human consumption, whether smoked, heated, chewed, absorbed, dissolved, inhaled, snorted, sniffed, or ingested by any other means, including, but not limited to, cigarettes, cigars, little cigars, chewing tobacco, pipe tobacco, or snuff.
- An electronic device that delivers nicotine or other vaporized liquids to the person inhaling from the device, including, but not limited to, an electronic cigarette, cigar, pipe, or hookah.
- Any component, part, or accessory of a tobacco product, whether or not sold separately.
A tobacco product does not include a nicotine replacement product approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration.
The Governor’s 2019 January Budget summary outlines how revenues from the tax on cigarettes and other products are distributed:
- 10 cents of per pack tax to the General Fund.
- 50 cents of the per pack tax, and an equivalent rate levied on non-cigarette tobacco products, goes to the Children and Families First Trust Fund, as specified by Proposition 10.
- 25 cents of the per pack tax, and rate equivalent to 87 cents on non-cigarette tobacco products and e-cigarettes, to the Cigarette and Tobacco Products Surtax Fund, as specified by Proposition 99.
- 2 cents of the per-pack tax to the Breast Cancer Fund.
- $2 of the per-pack tax, and an equivalent rate on non-cigarette tobacco products and e-cigarettes, to the California Healthcare, Research and Prevention Tobacco Tax Act of 2016 for Proposition 56 distributions.
According to CDPH and CDTFA’s retailer database, there are over 31,056 tobacco retailers in California, including vape shops. The CDPH enforces the Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement (STAKE) Act, which prohibits sales of tobacco products to individuals under 21 years of age.
Proposed Law:
This bill includes the following provisions:
Prohibits sale of flavored tobacco. The bill prohibits a tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale, a flavored tobacco product, as defined.
Requires a rebuttal presumption that a tobacco product is a flavored tobacco product if a manufacturer or any of the manufacturer’s agents or employees, in the course of his or her agency or employment, has made a statement or claim directed to consumers or to the public that the tobacco product has or produces a characterizing flavor, including, but not limited to, text, color, images, or all, on the product’s labeling or packaging that are used to explicitly or implicitly communicate that the tobacco product has a characterizing flavor.
Civil penalties. The bill authorizes an enforcing agency, as defined, to assess civil penalties, according to an existing civil penalty schedule, as follows:
- $400 to $600 for the first violation;
- $900 to $1,000 for the second violation within a five-year period;
- $1,200 to $1,800 for a third violation within a five-year period;
- $3,000 to $4,000 for a fourth violation within a five-year period; or,
- $5,000 to $6,000 for a fifth violation within a five-year period.
The bill defines enforcing agencies to include the Department of Public Health (CDPH), another state agency including but not limited to the office of the Attorney General, or a local law enforcement agency, including but not limited to a city attorney, district attorney, or county counsel.
Local standards. The bill does not preempt or otherwise prohibit the adoption of a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products than the restrictions imposed by this section. To the extent that there is an inconsistency between the bill and a local standard that imposes greater restrictions on the access to tobacco products, the greater restriction on the access to tobacco products in the local standard must prevail.
Definitions. The bill defines terms, including but not limited to:
- “Tobacco product” means a tobacco product as defined in existing law.
- “Tobacco retailer” means a person who engages in this state in the sale of tobacco products directly to the public from a retail location, and includes a person who operates vending machines from which tobacco products are sold in this state.
- Retail location” means a building from which tobacco products are sold at retail and a retail vending machine.
- “Flavored tobacco product” means any tobacco product that contains a constituent that imparts a characterizing flavor.
- “Characterizing flavor” means a distinguishable taste or aroma, or both, other than the taste or aroma of tobacco, imparted by a tobacco product or any byproduct produced by the tobacco product. Characterizing flavors include, but are not limited to, tastes or aromas relating to any fruit, chocolate, vanilla, honey, candy, cocoa, dessert, alcoholic beverage, menthol, mint, wintergreen, herb, or spice. A tobacco product must not be determined to have a characterizing flavor solely because of the use of additives or flavorings or the provision of ingredient information.
Severability. The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
Related Legislation:
- SB 39 (Hill, Glazer, and Portantino) requires sellers, distributors, and nonsale distributors to deliver tobacco products in conspicuously marked containers and to obtain the signature of a person 21 years of age or older before delivering a tobacco product. SB 39 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 739 (McCarty and Wood) is substantially similar to this bill. AB 739 is pending in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee.
- AB 1625 (Robert Rivas) requires the Attorney General to establish and maintain his list of tobacco product brand styles that lack a characterizing flavor, as defined. AB 739 is pending in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee.
- SB 835 (Glazer, 2018) and SB 836 (Glazer, 2018) would have implemented a ban on smoking and disposing of tobacco products, as defined, at state parks and beaches, and establishes a violation and infraction schedule. Governor Brown vetoed the bills, stating: “We have many rules telling us what we can't do and these are wide open spaces.”
Staff Comments:
The CDTFA outlined several factors in their estimate development, and notes that the estimate does not break out tobacco products by type. The estimate was calculated by converting estimated sales of tobacco product revenue, as specified, and California sales of e-cigarettes, which converted to wholesale sales by applying an average retailer margin. Cigarettes are expected to decline about three percent per year, starting in FY 2019-20, following a long-term trend. Tobacco products, other than ESDs, are expected to increase 5.6 percent per year, the average for the past three years. Based on an industry study, ESDs are assumed to grow 15 percent per year. Cigarette and tobacco product prices were projected to change based on three-year averages of wholesale prices by the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Richard Pan, Chair
BILL NO: SB 38
AUTHOR: | Hill, Glazer, McGuire, and Portantino | ||
VERSION: | December 3, 2018 | ||
HEARING DATE: | March 27, 2018 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Reyes Diaz | ||
SUBJECT: Flavored tobacco products.
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale a flavored tobacco product.
Existing law:
- Requires the Department of Public Health (DPH) to establish and develop a program to reduce the availability of “tobacco products,” as defined, to persons under 21 years of age through authorized enforcement activities, as specified, pursuant to the Stop Tobacco Access to Kids Enforcement Act (STAKE Act). [BPC §22952]
- Requires all persons engaging in the retail sale of tobacco products to check the identification of tobacco purchasers, to establish the age of the purchaser, if the purchaser reasonably appears to be under 21. [BPC §22956]
- Permits an enforcing agency, as specified, to assess civil penalties against any person, firm, or corporation that sells, gives, or in any way furnishes to another person who is under 21 any tobacco product, instrument, or paraphernalia that is designed for the smoking or ingestion of tobacco products, as specified, ranging from $400 to $6,000 for a first, second, third, fourth, or fifth violation within a five-year period. [BPC §22958]
- Defines “tobacco product” as a product containing, made, or derived from tobacco or nicotine that is intended for human consumption, as specified, including an electronic device that delivers nicotine or other vaporized liquids to the person inhaling from the device, and any component, part, or accessory of a tobacco product, whether or not sold separately. Prohibits any product approved by the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) for sale as a tobacco cessation product or for other therapeutic purposes, as specified, from being deemed a tobacco product. [BPC §22950.5]
This bill:
- Prohibits a tobacco retailer, or any of the tobacco retailer’s agents or employees, from selling, offering for sale, or possessing with the intent to sell or offer for sale a flavored tobacco product.
- Deems a tobacco product as a flavored tobacco product if a manufacturer or any of the manufacturer’s agents or employees, in the course of his or her agency or employment, has made a statement or claim directed to consumers or to the public that the tobacco product has or produces a “characterizing flavor,” as defined, including, but not limited to, text, color, images, or all, on the product’s labeling or packaging that are used to explicitly or implicitly communicate that the tobacco product has a characterizing flavor.
- Defines “characterizing flavor” as a distinguishable taste or aroma, or both, other than the taste or aroma of tobacco, imparted by a tobacco product or any byproduct produced by the tobacco product, including, but not limited to, tastes or aromas relating to any fruit, chocolate, vanilla, honey, candy, cocoa, dessert, alcoholic beverage, menthol, mint, wintergreen, herb, or spice. Prohibits a tobacco product from being determined to have a characterizing flavor solely because of the use of additives or flavorings or the provision of ingredient information.
- Permits an enforcement agency to assess civil penalties in the amounts specified in 3) of existing law above for a violation of this bill.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, youth usage of flavored tobacco products has surged recently. According to a report released by the FDA in November 2018, more than 3.6 million middle and high school students are using e-cigarettes. This is an increase of 1.5 million compared to 2017 and almost 13 times higher than the number of youth using e-cigarettes in 2011. The stunning growth between 2017 and 2018 amounted to a 78% increase in e-cigarette use by high school students and a 48% increase by middle school students. Flavored tobacco product poses a serious public health risk. Eighty percent of young people who have ever used tobacco started with a flavored product, which are a gateway to harder nicotine use, hooking users with kid-friendly flavors like cotton candy, bubble gum, and mango. This bill will address dramatic increases in youth tobacco use by prohibiting the retail sale of all flavored tobacco products. We have seen this before with big tobacco: false claims of safety, flavors used to hook users, and marketing obviously targeted to youth. This bill takes immediate action to prevent another generation from tobacco and nicotine addiction.
- Smoking prevalence. According to the federal Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), nearly 90% of smokers in the U.S. started smoking by the age of 18, and 98% started by age 26. The CDC reports that if smoking continues at the current rate in the U.S., 5.6 million of today’s youth under the age of 18 (about one of every 13) will die early from a tobacco-related disease. Each day in the U.S., more than 3,200 youth aged 18 years or younger smoke their first cigarette, and an additional 2,100 youth and young adults become daily cigarette smokers. Flavorings in tobacco products can make them more appealing to youth. According to the CDC, in 2014, 73% of high school students and 56% of middle school students who used tobacco products in the past 30 days reported using a flavored tobacco product. From 2011 to 2016, cigarette smoking declined among middle and high school students. However, the use of electronic cigarettes increased among the same population during the same time: 4.3 % of middle school students reported in 2016 that they used electronic cigarettes, which was an increase from 0.6% in 2011, and 8% of high school students reported having used electronic cigarettes, which was an increase from 1.5%.
- Tobacco-related diseases. Every year, cigarette smoking causes more than 480,000 deaths in the U.S. The CDC reports that smoking causes more deaths each year than the following causes combined: HIV, illegal drug and alcohol use, motor vehicle crashes, and firearm-related incidents. Smoking also causes about 90% of all lung cancer deaths and about 80% of all deaths from Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD). Estimates also show that smoking increases the risk of coronary heart disease and stroke by two to four times, as well as the risk of men and women developing lung cancer by 25 times. Smoking causes diminished overall health, increased absenteeism from work, and increased health care utilization and cost. The CDC reports that just one year after quitting smoking, the risk for heart attack drops sharply, and within two to five years, the risk for stroke may reduce to about that of a nonsmoker. Within five years of quitting smoking, risks for cancers of the mouth, throat, esophagus, and bladder drop by about half. The risk for lung cancer also drops by about half after ten years of having quit smoking.
- DPH report. According to a 2018 report by DPH, California Tobacco Facts and Figures, the smoking rate declined by 51.9% between 1988 and 2016, from 23.7% to 11.4%. California has the second lowest adult smoking rate among the 50 states plus the District of Columbia, second only to Utah. Almost 9% of adults use other tobacco products, such as cigars, little cigars, pipe, hookah, and electronic smoking devices, which includes e-cigarettes, vape pens, tanks, and mods. In California, 64% of smokers start by the age of 18, and 96% start by age 26. According to DPH, in 2010, 36.8% of high school students had smoked a whole cigarette by age 13 or 14, and in 2012, illegal tobacco sales to minors rose to 8.7% from 5.6% in 2011. Among adult users of other tobacco products (such as electronic smoking devices, or ESDs) in California, 70.3% reported using flavored products in the past six months, and eight out of ten young adults 18 to 24 that currently use ESDs reported flavor usage. The report states that one of the reasons for the high rate of flavored use among young adults may be due to the popularity of ESDs. California data indicates that ESD use rate is approximately 10% for young adults ages 18 to 24. DPH states that flavored tobacco products are driving youth experimentation, as more than 80% of youth who ever used a tobacco product reported that their first product was flavored. While teen cigarette smoking in 2016 was low (4.3%), overall tobacco use among teens is stagnant: 13.6% compared to a smoking rate of 13.8% in 2010. However, the proliferation of tobacco product categories (cigarettes; chew and snus tobacco; cigarillos and little cigars; hookah; and a variety of ESDs), flavored products, and the evolution of tobacco marketing appear to be fueling teens switching from traditional cigarettes to a new generation of products. The DPH report further noted that in 1997, 21.7% of retailers sold tobacco products to minors, just above the federally mandated target of 20%. The rate in 2017 was 5.7%, a significant decrease from 10.3% in 2016. However, tobacco-only stores continue to have the highest retailer violation rate (12%) when compared to other retailers (4.9%).
- FDA actions. The FDA has issued several statements over the past couple of years focusing on youth access to tobacco products. Specifically, the FDA is concerned about youth access to ESDs, as the youth use rate has reached epidemic status. According to the FDA, the most recent data shows more than 3.6 million middle and high school students across the nation were current (past 30 day) ESD users in 2018, which is an increase of 1.5 million children since the previous year. The data also showed that youth who used ESDs were also using them more frequently and were using flavored products more often than in 2017. In various statements, the FDA commissioner signaled that most flavored tobacco products would be banned from retail locations. However, in March 2019, the FDA commissioner issued a statement announcing that manufacturers and retailers were being put on notice that they could be subject to FDA enforcement for selling certain flavored ESD products without authorization. The FDA announced it would prioritize enforcement to focus on protecting youth from becoming addicted to nicotine, which includes the retail sale of ESDs that are offered in ways that pose a greater risk for minors’ access to the products, such as retail and online sales without heightened age verification, and products that appeal to kids or that resemble non-ESD products like USB devices. In September 2018, the FDA commissioner issued a statement stating that the FDA would not tolerate a whole generation of young people becoming addicted to nicotine as a tradeoff for enabling adults to have unfettered access to the same products. As a result, the FDA initiated a Youth Tobacco Prevention Plan that focuses on preventing youth access to tobacco products, curbing the marketing of tobacco products aimed at youth, and educating teens about the dangers of using any tobacco products. In the September 2018 statement, the FDA announced issuing 12 warning letters to companies that continued to advertise and sell products to youth. Earlier the same year the FDA had also issued 56 warning letters and six civil monetary penalties to retailers as part of its enforcement action to limit access of tobacco products to youth. The FDA also sent letters to five ESD manufacturers whose products were sold to kids during the FDA’s ramped up enforcement period. The five ESD manufacturers collectively represent more than 97% of the current market for ESDs—JUUL, Vuse, MarkTen, blu e-cigs, and Logic. The FDA requested that these companies provide robust plans on how they will address the widespread use of their products by minors or face increased enforcement.
JUUL announced in November 2018 that it was taking action to curb youth access, such as selling flavored JUUL pods on its Website only, using an enhanced online age verification system, shutting down its Facebook and Instagram accounts, and using its Twitter account for non-promotional communication only, and developing a next-generation device with access restrictions at the user level.
- Related legislation. SB 8 (Glazer) makes it an infraction punishable by a fine of up to $25 for a person to smoke, as defined, on a state coastal beach or in a unit of the state park system, as defined, or to dispose of used cigar or cigarette waste on a state coastal beach or in a unit of the state park system unless the disposal is made in an appropriate waste receptacle. SB 8 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 39 (Hill, Glazer, and Portantino) requires sellers, distributors, and nonsale distributors to deliver tobacco products only in conspicuously marked containers, as specified, and to obtain the signature of a person 21 years of age or older before delivering a tobacco product. SB 39 is set for hearing in this Committee on March 27, 2019.
AB 739 (McCarty and Wood) is substantially similar to this bill. AB 739 is pending in the Assembly Rules Committee.
AB 1625 (Robert Rivas) would require the Attorney General to establish and maintain his list of tobacco product brand styles that lack a characterizing flavor, as defined. AB 1625 is pending in the Assembly Rules Committee.
AB 1718 (Levine) is identical to SB 8. AB 1718 is pending in the Assembly Water, Parks, and Wildlife Committee.
- Prior legislation. SB 835 (Glazer of 2018) would have implemented a ban on smoking and disposing of tobacco products, as defined, at state parks and establishes an infraction punishable by a fine of up to $25 for a violation. SB 835 was vetoed by the Governor who stated that he had vetoed similar measures in each of the last two years, and the third time is not always a charm. The Governor stated his opinion on the matter had not changed, and we have many rules telling us what we can't do and these are wide open spaces.
SB 836 (Glazer of 2018) would have prohibited smoking of cigarettes, cigars, pipes and other tobacco-products in state coastal beaches, as specified, and establish that a violation is an infraction with a fine of up to $25. SB 836 was vetoed by the Governor, who issued the same veto message as for SB 835.
SCR 143 (Pan of 2018) would have encouraged major motion picture studios to give a Restricted (R) rating to any new film designed for viewing by children and adolescents that shows or implies smoking or tobacco use. SCR 143 failed passage in the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 1097 (Levine of 2018) was substantially similar to SB 835. AB 1097 was vetoed by the Governor, who issued the same veto message as SB 835.
SB 386 (Glazer of 2017) would have prohibited the smoking of cigarettes, cigars, pipes, and other tobacco products at state parks and state coastal beaches, as specified, and established that a violation is an infraction with a fine of up to $100. SB 386 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated that such a far-reaching prohibition in every state park and on every state beach is too broad. In addition, the fine prescribed in SB 386 for lighting one cigarette is excessive. If people can't smoke even on a deserted beach, where can they? There must be some limit to the coercive power of government.
AB 725 (Levine of 2017) would have prohibited smoking of tobacco products on state coastal beaches and at state parks, as specified, and established that a violation is an infraction with a fine of up to $50. AB 725 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated that such a far-reaching prohibition in every state park and on every state beach is too broad. In addition, the fine prescribed in AB 725 for lighting one cigarette is excessive. If people can't smoke even on a deserted beach, where can they? There must be some limit to the coercive power of government.
SB 1333 (Block of 2016) would have prohibited the smoking of tobacco products on state coastal beaches and at state parks, as specified, and established that a violation is an infraction with a fine of up to $250. SB 1333 was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated the complete prohibition in all parks and beaches is too broad, and a more measured and less punitive approach might be warranted.
SBX2 5 (Leno, Chapter 7, Statutes of 2016) recasts and broadens the definition of “tobacco product” to include ESDs, and extends current restrictions and prohibitions against the use of tobacco products to ESDs.
SBX2 7 (Hernandez, Chapter 8, Statutes of 2016) increases the minimum legal age to purchase or consume tobacco from 18 to 21. Removes penalty provisions for those under 21 in possession of tobacco and exempts military personnel from the age increase.
ABX2 7 (Stone, Chapter 4, Statutes of 2016) extends the workplace-smoking ban and closes loopholes, among other things, to address secondhand smoke.
SB 977 (Pan, Chapter 537, Statutes of 2016) prohibits a person from smoking a tobacco product, as defined, within 250 feet of a youth sports event, as defined. Broadens the definition of “smoke or smoking” in existing law.
SB 591 (Pan of 2015) would have imposed an additional cigarette tax at a rate of $2.00 per package of 20 cigarettes, and a corresponding rate for a cigarette tax stamp. SB 591 was placed on the Inactive File on the Senate Floor and no further action was taken.
AB 768 (Thurmond, Chapter 779, Statutes of 2015) prohibits, commencing December 1, 2016, the use or possession of smokeless tobacco products, as defined, on the playing field of a baseball stadium during a professional baseball game or practice.
SB 648 (Corbett of 2013) would have extended the restrictions and prohibitions against the smoking of tobacco products to include restrictions or prohibitions against ESDs in various places, including, but not limited to, places of employment, school campuses, public buildings, day care facilities, retail food facilities, and health facilities. SB 648 failed passage in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 768 (De León of 2013) was substantially similar to SB 591. SB 768 was held on the Senate Appropriations suspense file.
AB 1142 (Bloom of 2013) would have prohibited smoking at state parks and beaches, as specified, and established that a violation is an infraction with a fine of up to $250. AB 1142 failed passage in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee.
- Support. The sponsors and other supporters of this bill, largely health advocates, health professionals, and local governments, argue that tobacco products remain the leading cause of preventable illness, disability, and death in the nation. Supporters argue that the effects of tobacco are even more concerning in youth, whose brains are still developing, and that products are increasingly marketed to youth with enticing flavors and product design. Supporters cite recent studies that found youth users of ESDs rose by 78% between 2017 and 2018, and that 440,000 youth in the state are expected to die prematurely as a result of tobacco use. The sponsors and other supporters also note targeted marketing of certain tobacco products to communities of color, low-income individuals, and the LGBTQ community, citing that the tobacco industry aggressively markets menthol-flavored products to African Americans. Approximately 85% of African Americans who smoke use menthol cigarettes, and African-American men have the highest death rates from lung cancer when compared to other demographic groups. Further, supporters state that an alarming 80% of youths who have ever used tobacco started with a flavored product. The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians states that smokeless tobacco is responsible for serious illnesses, like cancer of the mouth, esophagus, lip, pancreas, and tongue, in addition to contributing to heart disease and stroke.
- Oppose unless amended. Swedish Match states that this bill would take smokeless tobacco products off the shelves, and that the FDA has recognized some flavors in tobacco products are not likely to appeal to youth. Swedish Match argues that some products, like smokeless tobacco products, are less harmful than other products and should be available to adult consumers, citing that smokeless tobacco was not among the American Cancer Society’s recent 17 identified risk factors for cancer.
- Opposition. The Cigar Association of America, Inc. (CAA) states that it is adamantly opposed to youth usage of cigars and pipe tobacco, but it does not believe this bill is necessary to reach the goal of further preventing youth access to tobacco products. CAA argues that given the aggressive regulatory actions being pursued at the federal level, it believes that a state-specific flavorings ban is problematic because it would run the risk of being in conflict with federal policy and that the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act expressly preempts states from enacting any requirement different from or in addition to federal requirements. JUUL Labs argues that this bill would impede adult smoker from accessing flavored products. JUUL Labs states that recent data show 40-56% of adult smokers who purchased and used JUUL products fully switched from combustible cigarettes within 90 days of use. JUUL states it also is concerned about the increase in youth use of its products and has taken dramatic and aggressive steps of any manufacturers in the industry to prevent underage use. The Vapor Technology Association argues that vapor products are considered to be dramatically safer than cigarettes and the focus should be on regulatory efforts on curbing combustible tobacco.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: American Cancer Society Cancer Action Network (co-sponsor)
American Heart Association (co-sponsor)
American Lung Association (co-sponsor)
Alameda County Tobacco Control Coalition
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of Northern California Oncologists
California Chapter of the American College of Cardiology
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
California Dental Association
California Medical Association
California Optometric Association
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California Society of Addiction Medicine
California State PTA
The Cancer Journey
City of Palo Alto
City of San Leandro
City of San Pablo
County Health Executives Association of California
County of Santa Clara
Families Uniting Locally to Solve Tobacco Proliferation
Flavors Hook Kids—Livermore
Health Access California
Kaiser Permanente
Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital Stanford
National Association of Pediatric Nurse Practitioners, SF Bay Area Chapter
Public Health Institute
R Street Institute
San Francisco Bay Area Physicians for Social Responsibility
Sierra Club California
USC Health, Emotion, and Addiction Laboratory
USC Institute for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention Research
USC Tobacco Center on Regulatory Science
Hundreds of individuals
Oppose: California Fuels and Convenience Alliance
Cigar Association of America, Inc.
JUUL Labs
The R Street Institute
Swedish Match North America (unless amended)
Vapor Technology Association
Hundreds of individuals
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):